EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 13, 2022

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 34 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Marcel Münch

executive
#1

Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for being with us on today's investor and analyst conference call, where we'll discuss EnBW's Q1, 2022 figures, and welcome to it. Our CFO, Thomas Kusterer, will as usual walk you through the presentation for today, and after that, we look forward to hearing your comments and questions. I'll hand things straight over to Thomas so he can take you through the relevant slides and figures. Thomas, over to you.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#2

Marcel, many thanks. Ladies and gentlemen, a warm welcome from me as well. Only seven weeks have passed since I last addressed you on the call about our 2021 results. The war in Ukraine, still ongoing, is an enormous tragedy and keeps appalling us. Given the human suffering, the need and necessity to deliver humanitarian assistance remains paramount. At EnBW, we continue to stand by the people in and from Ukraine through a comprehensive assistance package — immediate and long-term, financial as well as practical. I can only repeat what I said previously. We fully back the measures the German government has taken. Clearly, this exceptional situation affects our operating business as a provider of System Critical Infrastructure. As I have noted many times in recent days, we recognize our special responsibility as a large German utility to secure supply in our country. As you are very much aware, EnBW's business model centers predominantly on highly stable activities. That stems from our integrated approach along the entire value chain and our diversified lineup. In 2021, roughly 70% of our earnings came from low-risk businesses. Another factor reducing our overall risk is our prudent, forward-looking hedging strategy.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#3

For the current year, we've hedged 100% of the electricity generation volumes we expect, and a substantial portion is already covered for 2023 and the following year as well. Given our systems expertise, we bear a particular responsibility to contribute substantially toward an energy supply in Germany that is climate friendly, secure, and affordable. In the very first days of the Ukraine war, we established a task force that coordinates every area of EnBW relevant to energy supply, both inside the company and with partners across industry, associations, authorities, and, naturally, politics. That cooperation is functioning very well. As we stated on our call in late March, coal-related energy generation made up less than 5% of our group's earnings in 2021. Our earnings contribution from gas sales and from electricity generation using natural gas likewise came to only about 5%. Since then, our teams have achieved significant progress in cutting our exposure to Russian gas and coal, while taking high sustainability and affordability criteria into account. On the coal business, as noted on our call in March, we had already started broadening our procurement base for hard coal at the end of last year. Since that time, we have considerably ramped up sourcing of non-Russian coal.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#4

Right now, we have a lot of confidence that we've secured sufficient hard coal through the end of winter 2022 to 2023, and at this point we are completely ready for the embargo the EU Commission imposed on coal supply from Russia starting in August. In the prior year, just 14% of the coal we procured came from non-Russian countries, whereas a few years back, most of our coal had been sourced from Colombia and South Africa. That demonstrates procurement changes are achievable in a comparatively brief period, since so many supply options exist around the world. Moving on to the gas business. We are likewise continuing to further diversify our gas procurement portfolio. Our LNG activities, in particular, are expanding nicely. EnBW brings many years of experience in LNG trading. At the end of March 2022, we signed an MoU with Hanseatic Energy Hub covering at least 3 billion cubic meters of natural gas, equivalent to 33 TWh per annum, through the LNG terminal in Stade. Beyond that, we are pursuing a number of additional projects. Even with the volatility currently seen in the market, EnBW remains well-positioned in today's environment, thanks to its integrated business model. I'm now glad to walk you through our Q1 figures, which show this once again.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#5

We'll begin by briefly reviewing adjusted EBITDA and adjusted Group net profit, which you can see on slide 3. During the first three months of this year, adjusted EBITDA rose sharply — by roughly 46% — to EUR 1,185 million, versus the same period in 2021. Favorable wind conditions and a substantial improvement in wholesale market prices were the primary factors behind that gain. In a moment I'll give you more detail on the segment results. Adjusted Group net profit attributable to the shareholders of EnBW AG climbed 45% to EUR 464 million in the first quarter, compared with Q1 2021. That rise in net profit stemmed mainly from the significant increase in EBITDA and was only slightly affected by the decline in the financial results. The latter largely resulted from high expenses tied to marking securities to market as of the reporting date. Now let's take a closer look at our three business segments, beginning with Smart Infrastructure for Customers on the slides that follow. In this segment, adjusted EBITDA fell by around 16% to EUR 103 million in the first quarter of 2022 compared with the prior year period. High procurement costs were the chief cause of that earnings decline.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#6

We anticipate that this impact will partly unwind over the remainder of the year. On slide number 5, the System Critical Infrastructure segment accounted for roughly 30% of our total earnings in Q1 2022. Adjusted EBITDA fell by approximately 5% to EUR 353 million versus the corresponding period a year earlier. Significantly higher expenses for grid reserve in our electricity transmission grid are the primary factor behind this trend. To guarantee security of supply, the extraordinary market conditions demanded considerably longer operating hours of reserve plants at elevated fuel and CO2 costs, and higher grid revenues offset this only in part. Turning to slide 6, let me discuss Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, our biggest business segment in Q1 2022, which delivered close to 70% of our overall results. Adjusted EBITDA more than doubled to EUR 821 million in the first quarter of 2022 compared with the equivalent period in 2021. Within renewable energies, the first of the two sub-segments, adjusted EBITDA rose sharply by 41% to EUR 292 million. Favorable wind conditions in onshore and offshore — both of which had been especially poor in 2021 — were the main factor, along with, in certain instances, selling power above the fixed EEG tariff.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#7

Moving to the second sub-segment, thermal generation and trading, adjusted EBITDA came in at EUR 529 million — that's an increase of more than threefold. Two factors drove this earnings trend: generation volumes sold at prices significantly higher than a year earlier, along with temporary valuation effects. That leads me to slide 7 and how our retained cash flow developed. Retained cash flow rose by almost 22%, reaching EUR 883 million, primarily on the back of higher EBITDA. The principal offsetting items versus the prior year were a reduction in provisions — largely from reversing a provision for onerous contracts tied to power purchase agreements — plus a non-cash effect, mainly from gas storage valuation. Let me walk you through net debt for the first quarter of 2022 on slide 8. Net debt stood at EUR 8.7 billion as of March 31, essentially matching the level at the close of 2021. Across Q1, working capital grew by roughly EUR 800 million, reflecting three effects combined. First, working capital went up because of higher receivables linked to redispatch, which get passed on to other transmission system operators. Then there was the buildup of inventories, chiefly carbon allowances for generation at our power plant in 2021.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#8

Conversely, the bank account tied to the German Renewable Energy Act went up by roughly EUR 700 million. Net investments came to approximately EUR 400 million, mostly due to projects contained in the grid development plans, along with expansion and renovation work on the transmission grid. In addition, projects within our renewable business completed our solar parks, Alttrebbin and Gottesgabe, and obtained a lease option on Scotland's east coast to build a 2.9 GW offshore wind farm jointly with bp. The reduction in the equity credit for outstanding subordinated bonds resulted from repaying two bonds, with nominal values of EUR 725 million and $300 million respectively, at the start of January 2022. Finally, pension provisions declined owing to the higher discount rate, which rose from 1.15% at the close of 2021 to 1.8% as of 31st March 2022. That leads me to our outlook on slide 9. As previously mentioned, our 2022 earnings guidance for the group overall, and for each individual business segment, is still unchanged. It should be noted, however, that the war in Ukraine, together with generally high market volatility, has raised the degree of uncertainty surrounding statements about future developments.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#9

So we keep watching conditions closely and assessing what might affect our business. For Smart Infrastructure for Customers, our expectation is adjusted EBITDA ranging from EUR 350 million to EUR 425 million in the current year. That works out to a rise somewhere between 2% and 24%. On the whole, we anticipate stronger operating earnings driven by expansion in our new business areas. In the older end customer businesses, though, there is still uncertainty about whether new customers will sign up for basic service at higher volumes, given the currently elevated additional procurement costs. It's also possible we'll need to book larger bad debt allowances. When it comes to System Critical Infrastructure, we're looking at adjusted EBITDA for this year somewhere between EUR 1.225 billion and EUR 1.325 billion, a range of -3% to +5% versus the prior year, so roughly flat against the 2021 level. Grid use revenue should climb thanks to returns from greater investment activity on projects covered by the electricity and gas grid development plan. On the other hand, expenses for grid reserve and balancing energy have been rising since the end of 2021, and there's a risk that trend carries into 2022, which would weigh on operating earnings this year.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#10

For 2022, adjusted EBITDA within Sustainable Generation Infrastructure is set to rise even more. Our projection for adjusted EBITDA is a range of EUR 1.65 billion to EUR 1.75 billion, which works out to growth somewhere between 7% and 14%. Operating earnings should receive roughly EUR 900 million from renewables. Following 2021's weak wind conditions, our assumptions for wind yields — and therefore the volumes we generate — rest on the long-term average. We also anticipate that additional renewable generation capacity coming online will lift earnings. On top of that, higher wholesale market prices and spreads should drive an earnings increase from our thermal power plant portfolio in 2022. Looking at group level, we forecast earnings rising by +2% to +7% in 2022, landing between EUR 3.025 billion and EUR 3.175 billion. On that note, let me add that given how the market currently stands, our coal-fired power plants are operating at full capacity. As a result, based on today's situation, we do not anticipate lowering our CO2 intensity in 2022 relative to last year. At this juncture, I want to assure you that our commitment to sustainability goals remains full. Our aim is for CO2 intensity in 2025 to sit 15%-30% under the 2018 baseline.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#11

The baseline figure stood at 553 g/kWh. For EnBW, sustainability along with security of supply remain the foremost priorities. What we are concentrating on in this area is faster build-out of renewables and high-capacity grids, scaling up electric mobility, and speeding up progress around hydrogen. Meeting these conditions is what makes a carbon-free energy supply possible over the long term, all while keeping the balance between security of supply and sustainability. With that said, I'll pass things to the operator so we can begin our Q&A session.

Operator

operator
#12

Ladies and gentlemen, we're going to start the question-and-answer portion at this point. If you'd like to pose a question, you can press star and then one on your touchtone phone. Should you want to take yourself out of the queue, just press star and then two. In case you're on speaker equipment today, please pick up the handset before you make those selections. Anybody with a question can press star and then one right now. Give us a moment for the first question, please. Our first question comes from Andrew Kuske at Credit Suisse. Please go ahead.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#13

Yes. Hello, Thomas. Hello, Marcel.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#14

Hello.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#15

Hi there. Yeah, I’d like to begin with a fairly broad question. I mean, I’ve obviously been listening to a few other German utility conference calls, as I’m sure most people have. The German energy security law came up a lot on those calls. What I took from them was that the law could, in the event Russian gas stops flowing, make existing contracts effectively invalid, and it would let you, as a gas supplier, go into the market and then pass the costs of buying there through to your end customers. So my question to you is really whether I’ve got that right. Is there any further information you can give us on how the German energy security law might operate, or when you actually expect it to take effect, or, you know, do you perhaps know any additional details on that? Maybe just in connection with that, I wanted to check on the VNG contract. On your first slide, you mentioned that VNG has two direct import contracts totaling around 100 terawatt-hours. Then one of those expires this year. You have only 65 terawatt-hours contracted beyond 2023.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#16

So my first question about that is the 65 terawatt hour contract — when does it actually expire? And second, how are you replacing the 35 terawatt hours you're losing when that first contract expires? Thank you.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#17

I'll begin with your second question. Yes, that 35 terawatt hour contract runs out at the end of this year, and we'll replace it through market purchases. Everything is back to back. If we have no additional volumes of any kind, we won't enter the market to serve customers. It's really more a matter of whether we can secure those volumes elsewhere — whether at wholesale market price, from other countries, or through LNG. On your first question, inside the VNG complex, the 65 terawatt hour long-term contract expires by 2013. It is genuinely a long-term contract that runs for the next 8 years. As for the energy security law, your understanding matches mine exactly. Unfortunately I can't offer any further insight, because that is precisely how we see it. That was a fair summary of our reading of the law. When will it take effect? I don't know yet. What I have heard, though, is that it should become effective within the next two to three weeks, so quite soon.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#18

Alright.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#19

Andrew, is that at least enough to address what you asked?

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#20

Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I mean, that's good. I mean, that's kind of a very similar answer to what I've been getting from the other German companies who've said very much the same sort of thing that, you know, they can't really add much more detail.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#21

Yes.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#22

There are just some things that aren't clear to me — how certain arrangements would function, you know, international contracts, given that this is German law. How would that actually play out? And if you did manage to source gas from Norway instead of from Russia, would that gas also fall under the German law? I'm simply not sure. You know, I'd really like to get some clarity on those kinds of points. But can I just ask — you mentioned the 35 terawatt hours that you're trying to replace. Have you had any actual success in replacing that, or is it turning out to be more or less impossible to replace those gas volumes?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#23

So VNG is actually talking with a number of suppliers — Norway is one example — about replacing those volumes. Whether that gets done, and on what terms, well, that remains to be seen. Yeah. Talks are underway right now.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#24

All right, good. I have just two questions about generation, if I may, and then I'll be done.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#25

Alright.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#26

I just had a question about your guidance for the generation segment. I mean, clearly, EBITDA reached EUR 825 million in the first quarter, and the low end of your guidance is just twice that figure. You know, I mean, okay, I realize Q2 and Q3 likely won't be as strong as Q1 and Q4, but it still feels somewhat conservative to set your guidance that low. I'm just wondering whether there are any risks, you know, beyond the obvious volatility of the Russia and Ukraine situation, that leave you cautious regarding German generation EBITDA for the full year. Perhaps slightly related to that as well. Many German companies are discussing a change to their hedging strategy on the generation side, you know, with markets in a sort of backwardation now, and they may be thinking about leaving larger volumes open going forward. Are you also considering that?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#27

On your final question, Andrew, our hedging approach is something we continually monitor. That said, right now we don't believe it makes sense to take on significantly more market risk over the coming years. Again, we'll keep assessing that on an ongoing basis. As things stand, we really don't see a fundamental need to alter our hedging strategy. As for our generation result at year-end, on the surface it could look conservative. But as I mentioned, our power plants are operating at full capacity, and there is always a risk that these stations could shut down unexpectedly, and if that happens, you must purchase electricity at elevated prices. That is the reason we are somewhat cautious, and certain risks exist that we have to factor in. So we expect to remain, at least for now, inside the bandwidth we gave for this business segment.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#28

All right.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#29

Yeah.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#30

Great. I'll pause at this point for now. Thank you, Thomas. Thank you, Marcel.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#31

Welcome. Yeah.

Operator

operator
#32

Just a quick reminder — if you'd like to ask a question, hit star and then 1. Up next, we have Orlando Finzi from MAG on the line. Go right ahead.

Orlando Finzi

analyst
#33

Good afternoon, Thomas Kusterer and Marcel Münch, and thanks a lot. Maybe just a couple of questions from a slightly different angle. Clearly the Russian risk is the dominant one here, but I think we need to wait and see how it actually plays out. Predicting what the effects could be feels quite difficult. In terms of the impact on, I suppose, energy consumers first of all, are you at all worried about bad debts on the customer side? And related, I guess, to the understandable wish to speed up renewables, certainly at the national level — and I'm sure you'll be doing your utmost there as well, since it's part of your strategy — do you have any concerns about the supply chain for deploying that CapEx? You know, and I guess this ties back to the situation here, where the macro environment feels more stressed for a while. I'd be very interested in your thoughts on those points. Thank you.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#34

Orlando Finzi, I appreciate the questions, and it's really nice to have you with us on the call. On the renewables side, I'll begin with your third question. Looking at the supply chain, we are indeed currently seeing price increases for certain commodities—steel, aluminum, and copper in particular—along with some price rises in principal products. So yes, there are concerns about higher prices as well as delivery delays. That said, at present we don't see a significant effect on our projects overall. That's the first point, and second, we also see upside for renewables business plans stemming from the increase—the general rise in wholesale market prices. In addition, PPA prices have gone up as well over the last couple of months. It isn't simple to claim this would negatively affect the profitability of the underlying projects. Once more, supply chain is a worry, and we keep monitoring it constantly. On your second question—please correct me if I misunderstood it. You were asking about how the current situation, particularly gas and electricity prices, affects customers. Was that in fact the question, Orlando?

Orlando Finzi

analyst
#35

Right, absolutely. Whenever there’s an issue with non-payment or, you know, bad debt effectively to

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#36

Yes. That’s definitely something we’re watching. During the presentation I believe I mentioned that because price increases are coming, we could find ourselves facing higher bad debt allowances. So that risk does exist. What we’re seeing right now — and you may have caught our press release earlier this week — is that our gas prices are going up starting in July. A lot of other suppliers have already done the same, since it’s fairly obvious that at some point we have to pass along the higher gas and electricity costs to our customers. That’s something we really need to keep a close eye on. Your first question dealt with the broader gas situation. I think that was more of a comment, and I can only agree with what you said. The overall picture is definitely difficult to forecast, particularly the effects we could be facing. Once again, I believe we’re well prepared, and with the energy security law and the additional measures our government has taken, I think we ought to be able to manage the situation going forward. Orlando, does that answer your question?

Orlando Finzi

analyst
#37

Right, that makes sense. Let me just verify something there, if I can. Clearly, there's a force majeure event or a halt, plus some interruption to the gas flow. We'll need to see how that plays out. Purely from the regulatory side, I just want confirmation that regulation brings no volume impact. Should the volume of gas being moved fall—if that volume declines—there's no direct effect. My understanding is that there's no direct impact from it. I just wanted to confirm that with you.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#38

I mean, what you're referring to there is what we call the Gasmangellage situation — that translates to a gas shortage situation. Were we to find ourselves in that kind of situation, Germany has a clear legal framework governing it. Once we reach that point, there won't be a market any longer. When that moment arrives, the regulator will handle distributing whatever volumes remain. A gas shortage situation would arise if, say, we stopped receiving any gas flows from Russia. That would constitute such a situation. In that scenario, naturally, we do have a shortage, and distribution would fall to the regulator, Bundesnetzagentur, meaning we could invoke our force majeure clauses right away. At that moment there's no risk to us, if what you're getting at is any sort of financial risk with respect to EnBW. Yes, that is how it would play out in such a situation.

Orlando Finzi

analyst
#39

Let me just confirm that with you, Thomas — thanks. As for the regulated earnings on the assets, there's no impact there.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#40

No. All right, I agree with you. No, nothing hits the regulated earnings within the regulated business. My apologies — I hadn't quite grasped what you were asking. Yeah.

Orlando Finzi

analyst
#41

Nope, yet the two parts are solid responses. I appreciate it.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#42

Thanks for joining us.

Operator

operator
#43

Our next follow-up question comes from Andrew Kuske's line. Go right ahead.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#44

Yes, hi once more. I simply wanted to revisit what you said about the PPAs. You mentioned there's a possibility of getting PPAs signed at elevated prices. What I'm really wondering is whether that reflects how customers generally act in the PPA market. In other words, do they look at today's market and say, "Power prices are really high right now, so I don't want to lock in a PPA at a high power price. I'll hold off until they perhaps decline next year," or something along those lines, and sign the PPA then? Or are they fine with stepping in now and signing a PPA at a high price? Or maybe you're actually having to restructure the PPAs so customers can adjust them more in case power prices fall from the significant level they're at? That's my first question. My second question is just a check on the LNG terminals under construction. I mean, you brought up Stade, I believe RWE has discussed Brunsbüttel, and Uniper has discussed Wilhelmshaven. Are there any others, or is it only those three LNG terminals that are proposed for construction in Germany?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#45

Regarding your first question, Andrew, I believe many companies right now share that view, and it could very well prove correct — namely that over the long term, our prices will sit above the levels observed, say, at the start of 2021 or midway through 2021. That is precisely why PPA prices, including long-term ones, are climbing. I think that makes sense. So that is what the market is showing us at present. As I mentioned a moment ago, I would concur that in the long term, power prices will be higher than the levels seen six months ago. That is my view.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#46

Sorry, Thomas, could I just come back on that point? Are you saying that whenever folks are considering entering into PPAs with you, they aren't really looking at — and you aren't setting your PPAs based on — power prices as things stand right now, but rather at the levels seen back in mid-2021.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#47

What we're saying is essentially what we observed prior to the crisis getting underway.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#48

Got it.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#49

Prior to that, we had witnessed a significant rise in supply chain prices. Actually, that was precisely the point I was attempting to convey earlier. When we examine the supply chain disruptions, when we observe the cost increases, material costs and so on, and then we look at, on the other side, the PPA and power prices, we can't instantly conclude that these projects' profitability is declining because of the price increase. Since on the other side, we do see power prices rising too, along with long-term PPAs.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#50

Right. Okay.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#51

Right. On your LNG terminal question — Stade, Brunsbüttel, Wilhelmshaven — those are the three under discussion right now. A fourth could come up. There's talk about Rostock over in eastern Germany, but those three or four are what's being evaluated at present. Yes.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#52

What portion of the German gas would they be replacing? Are they, as far as you know, more or less fully up and running? In other words, would that cover all of the imports from Russia, or just half of them?

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#53

My view is that they’re able to, though the figure is 10 terawatt-hours for each 10 BCM, which works out to 100 terawatt-hours per terminal.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#54

Alright.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#55

The figure we're discussing is roughly 200 to 300 TWh.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#56

Thanks.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#57

Roughly 500 is where the Russian gas supply stands.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#58

All right, that's excellent. Thanks a lot. It takes the place of the majority of the gas coming from Russia, in my view.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#59

Correct.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#60

That's good news.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#61

At least that part is good news, yeah.

Andrew Kuske

analyst
#62

Yes. Excellent. Thanks very much.

Thomas Kusterer

executive
#63

No problem at all.

Operator

operator
#64

That’s all the questions we have right now. I’ll turn it back over to Marcel Münch for some closing remarks.

Marcel Münch

executive
#65

Thanks, Thomas, for what you shared and for your remarks — and I appreciate everyone joining us on today's call. We're looking forward to having you with us once more when we share our Q2 2022 numbers on the upcoming earnings call, scheduled for August 12. Take care, and goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.