EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 11, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and thanks for holding. I'm Emma, the Chorus Call operator on this line. We're glad to have you with us for EnBW's Investor and Analyst Conference Call covering the first 9 months of 2022. During the recorded presentation today, everyone will be in listen-only mode. After the presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. Should you wish to pose a question, you can do that by pressing *, then 1. For operator assistance, please press the * key, then 0. I'll now pass the call to Marcel Münch, Senior Vice President of Finance, M&A, and Investor Relations. Please go ahead.
Marcel Münch
executiveGood day, everyone, and welcome. We appreciate your presence on this call with investors and analysts regarding EnBW's results covering the opening nine months of 2022. Shortly, our CFO, Thomas Kusterer, is going to walk you through the most recent developments affecting our operations and the conditions in which we're working, and he'll take you through the numbers for those first nine months of 2022. After that, as usual, we're eager to hear your remarks and questions. So let's get started — I'll pass things straight to Thomas for the presentation. Thomas, the floor is yours.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveMarcel, many thanks. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome as well from my side. I'd like to begin by giving you an overview of the key events in Q3 and over recent weeks, which you'll find on slide two. During the first nine months of this year, adjusted EBITDA came in at the same level as the prior year. Curtailment of Russian gas supplies at subsidiaries—and the resulting elevated replacement costs for the gas volumes that went missing—along with higher expenses for network security of supply measures, weighed on results. Those effects were largely compensated by greater earnings contributions from renewable energies and trading activities. Beyond the war in Ukraine, we are confronted with several other uncertainties in the current environment. A possible gas shortage, the high market volatility, and the structure of the windfall profit levy, which remains unclear. Against this backdrop, we are lowering our full-year guidance at group level by up to roughly 10%. More details will follow at the end of the presentation. Still, I want to emphasize that overall uncertainty surrounding statements about future developments is currently greater than usual. Therefore, we continuously monitor and assess the conditions with regard to the potential impact on EnBW Group. In particular, since the war against Ukraine began, liquidity movements have been elevated but have remained well within the scenarios analyzed.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWe took substantial, proactive steps to reinforce our liquidity — adding bank lines, issuing commercial paper, and managing our hedging position actively. By September 13, our liquidity stood in a comfortable place, with cash and cash equivalents of EUR 3.1 billion plus available credit lines at group level exceeding EUR 7 billion. Then, with our debut U.S. private placement in November, we widened our investor base once more, following the first promissory note we issued in July of this year at a volume of EUR 500 million. The U.S. private placement transaction, totaling $850 million, covers amounts denominated in euros, U.S. dollars, and pounds sterling, with maturities running from 3 to 12 years. As for the maturity of the transaction volume, the maturities are 10 or 12 years. This long-term financing fits our investment projects in grids and renewables perfectly. Conditions in the energy markets remain tight. That is why, on October 19, the German cabinet approved the draft of a further amendment to the Atomic Energy Act, which creates the basis for extending, in a limited way, operation of the three remaining nuclear power plants — Emsland, Isar Two, and Neckarwestheim Two — through April 15, 2023.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveUsing new nuclear fuel rods isn't allowed. To put it another way, we can only use fuel rods that are already on hand. At our Neckarwestheim Two plant, besides the nuclear fuel rods sitting in the reactor core, there are additional partly used fuel rods kept in a storage pool. As an optimization step, those existing fuel rods are going to be reassembled inside the reactor core. That lets us keep the plant running through mid-April 2023, which makes an important contribution to security of supply and grid stability over these winters. Finally, as all of you know well, our subsidiary VNG filed in early September for stabilization measures under Section 29 of the Energy Security Act, aiming to preserve financial flexibility and accelerate negotiations on covering replacement costs for 2 gas supply contracts for Russian gas as of that time. After that, both rating agencies came out with a note on EnBW. Moody's issued an issuer comment on the group's Ba1 rating and left the rating evaluation unchanged, whereas S&P affirmed the rating at A- but cut the outlook to negative. According to S&P, the rating outlook could be moved back to stable once there is clarity on VNG's full-year losses and adequate visibility into the German gas market.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLadies and gentlemen, allow me to restate once more that our dedication to preserving strong investment grade ratings has not wavered at all. Now let's move on to the numbers for the opening nine months of 2022, which you'll find on slide three. I'd like to begin by taking a quick look at adjusted EBITDA along with adjusted group net profit. Adjusted EBITDA came in at EUR 1,968 million for the first nine months of 2022, essentially flat versus the same period a year earlier. What this tells us is that we succeeded in offsetting, at least in part, the major headwinds encountered within portions of our portfolio regarding operating earnings. As I just noted, these effects weighed negatively: curtailment of Russian gas supplies at subsidiaries, which produced elevated replacement costs for the gas volumes that went missing, plus increased expenses for grid reserve. Higher earnings contributions from renewable energies and trading activities offset this development to a large extent. We'll dig into the specifics shortly. That said, adjusted group net profit attributable to the shareholders of EnBW AG almost halved, reaching EUR 397 million in the first nine months of 2022. IFRS 9 effects are chiefly responsible for this decline in net profit.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAhead of discussing how our operating segments are developing, I want to brief you on the most recent news concerning our subsidiary VNG — that takes us to slide four. A settlement was reached on October 10 between VNG and WIEH, a subsidiary of the former Gazprom Germania that now operates under the name SEFE; under that settlement, WIEH bears the entire expense of replacement procurement for 2022. In addition, the contract for a supply of 65 terawatt-hours per annum — which originally would have run until 2030 — is to be terminated with effect from the end of 2022. Note that VNG had not sold any gas volumes stemming from this contract at fixed prices beyond 2022. Starting at the beginning of 2023, VNG will carry no further exposure under this purchase contract. Settling the Veha contract represented a major step for VNG and substantially lowered the risks arising from gas replacement procurement. A second supply contract VNG holds with Russia's Gazprom Export, covering 35 TWh, likewise expires at the end of 2022. Because VNG is itself the importer under that contract, however, and had sold some gas to its customers at fixed prices for 2022, replacement procurement costs keep being incurred by VNG. Our results for the first 9 months of 2022 reflected a total charge of almost EUR 1.2 billion for replacement procurement costs already incurred until the end of September, plus an assumption regarding VNG's residual contribution to the costs through year-end.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFor Q4 2022, the leftover replacement procurement expenses of nearly EUR 600 million are reflected within our non-operating results. There are two key points to keep in mind here. First, those estimates rested on market forward prices as of September 13, 2022. Since then, those prices have fallen considerably, which lowers the anticipated negative impact by a three-digit million EUR amount. Second, we anticipate that the residual costs will largely reverse once an agreement is reached with the federal government to compensate VNG for the canceled gas levy. The key takeaway is that starting from the beginning of 2023, VNG will carry no risk at all under either of the two purchase contracts. Regarding the 35 terawatt contract with Gazprom Export, discussions with the federal government and the relevant ministries are moving along very well. We are confident that a satisfactory agreement for both sides will be reached in the near future, one that will at least partially compensate VNG for the expenses it has incurred to ensure security of supply. As you can certainly appreciate, we are not yet able to comment on the details, since this agreement is subject to pending official and court proceedings.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveTo be clear, as we see things today, we don't expect the government to take any equity stake in VNG. Ladies and gentlemen, let's now examine our three business segments closely, beginning with Smart Infrastructure for Customers on slide five. Adjusted EBITDA for this segment in the first nine months of 2022 came in at the same level as the prior year period, at EUR 321 million. The steep year-on-year rise in procurement costs for electricity and gas was offset by positive earnings contributions from newly acquired subsidiaries at SENEC, our home storage provider. Adjusted EBITDA for our System Critical Infrastructure segment on slide six made up nearly half of our operating earnings overall. Versus the previous year's period, it rose slightly by 3% to EUR 944 million. That reflects the sharp increase in the number of deployments and in market prices. We see a significant rise in expenses for pre-reserve measures, including redispatch, to maintain security of supply. Conversely, congestion revenues were higher thanks to a larger electricity price differential between Germany and the neighboring countries, France as well as Switzerland. On slide 7, let me turn to sustainable generation infrastructure. Adjusted EBITDA in this segment rose slightly by 3% to EUR 878 million in the reporting period compared to the previous year.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLet's take a closer look at how the two components of this business segment performed, beginning with renewable energies. Adjusted EBITDA there climbed sharply, up over 50% to EUR 839 million, and three effects mainly drove that. To begin with, new solar farms that EnBW brought into service added to earnings. Second, we gained from higher market prices. And finally, wind yields came in above the prior year's level, which, in a historical comparison, had been well below average. Turning to thermal generation and trading, adjusted EBITDA fell sharply, down 88% to EUR 39 million against the prior year period. Curtailment and the suspension of gas supplies stemming from the Russia-Ukraine war, along with a negative valuation effect on derivative financial instruments, weighed heavily on earnings in this part of the business segment. Those factors were partly offset by higher market prices and a positive contribution to earnings from trading activities. Now let's take a brief look at how our retained cash flow developed on slide 8. Retained cash flow for us increased sharply, by almost 70%, to EUR 1,506 million. Non-cash items include, among other things, the valuation of raw materials, consumables and supplies, mostly gas and storage. The dividend paid to EnBW shareholders for the financial year 2021 came to EUR 1.10 per share.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOnce you adjust for the IFRS 9 valuation effect, that works out to a dividend payout ratio of 36%. That takes me to net debt development, which is on slide 9. Net debt stood at roughly EUR 9.4 billion as of September 13, around EUR 600 million higher than where it was at the end of 2021. Working capital rose by EUR 2.3 billion, driven by growth in inventories and a decrease in net margin payments received from the close of 2021. Net investment came in at approximately EUR 1.5 billion. Nearly EUR 1 billion of that went to investment in our grid infrastructure. This mostly reflects projects under grid development plans along with expansion and renewal of the distribution grid. Beyond that, we put some EUR 477 million into our renewables business to finish our Weesow-Willmersdorf and Gottesgabe solar parks and to lock in the lease option off Scotland's east coast for a 2.9-gigawatt offshore wind farm developed jointly with BP. Conversely, we sold 49.9% of the 600-megawatt solar portfolio, which also contains the new large-scale solar farms, Weesow-Willmersdorf, Gottesgabe. Roughly EUR 217 million went toward investments in our segment Smart Infrastructure for Customers, mainly for rolling out our e-mobility fast-charging infrastructure.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAt the start of January 2022, we repaid two subordinated bonds — one with a nominal value of EUR 725 million and the other with a nominal value of $300 million — and that pushed our net debt up by roughly EUR 500 million. Meanwhile, pension provisions fell considerably, by approximately EUR 2.4 billion, because the relevant discount rate rose substantially, from 1.15% at the end of 2021 to 3.75% as of September 30. Liquid funds coming from the Renewable Energy Sources Act were up by EUR 955 million relative to year-end 2021. Because those funds are restricted and cannot be used to repay debt of EnBW Group, we also present net debt adjusted for this effect. Adjusted net debt rose by 15% during the first nine months, from EUR 10.4 billion to EUR 11.9 billion. Allow me to walk you through our revised outlook for the full year 2022 on slide 10. As I said at the outset, uncertainty has grown — specifically the war in Ukraine, high market volatility and a possible gas shortage, along with the structure of the windfall profit levy, which remains unclear. Given that backdrop, we lowered our full year guidance at group level by up to 10%, and we now expect adjusted EBITDA for the full year to come in between EUR 2.7 billion and EUR 2.9 billion.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLooking at the segment level, our earnings guidance for Smart Infrastructure for Customers is staying as it was. For System Critical Infrastructure, we anticipate segment results coming in well below the forecast range we set out in the Integrated Annual Report 2021, and they will also land under the prior year's level, because we expect expenses for grid reserve to rise further — including redispatch to keep supply secure — in the fourth quarter of 2022. Subsequent years will see this offset, though it will still weigh on earnings in 2022. Finally, we also anticipate Sustainable Generation Infrastructure coming in under its initial forecast range, with the outcome ultimately hinging on the final solution at VNG — which is still being discussed with the federal government — and on how the announced windfall profit levy is ultimately structured. That said, I want to emphasize that in the face of all the market environment's challenges, our business model is once again proving how robust it is. We firmly expect to close out this year very well, notwithstanding the negative effects just mentioned. The unexpected impact of reduced gas supplies from Russia is confined to 2022 and will be behind us starting in 2023. So we believe we are excellently positioned for the future, with our integrated lineup spanning the entire energy value chain, and that our business model is enjoying significant tailwind from the accelerated transition of the energy system in Germany.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHaving said that, I'd now like to pass things over to the operator so we can begin the Q&A portion.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, we're going to start the question-and-answer portion now. Should you wish to pose a question, press * and then 1 on your phone's keypad. To take yourself out of the queue, press * and then 2. If speaker equipment is what you're on today, kindly lift the handset before you make your selection. Anybody with a question can press * and then 1 right now. Please hold a moment for the first question. Our first question comes from Calum Emslie at Fidelity. Go ahead, please.
Calum Emslie
analystHello, and good afternoon. Many thanks for the presentation. I have a few questions, though let me start with the first one. As we look toward next year and the sale of TransnetBW, I was hoping you could provide some sense of the possible cash inflow from it. I have come across press articles that point to an EV of EUR 2 billion, yet I believe the recent S&P report indicates a cash inflow of EUR 2 to 3 billion. Could you comment on that, or on how net debt would be affected by that potential transaction, and perhaps give some indication regarding timing as well? On my second question, net debt, could you give us any indication of what you are looking at for year-end, and perhaps how much of that working capital increase you expect to reverse? I noticed there was talk about gas fills and so on, and I guess the question is whether that is going to continue into Q4 or whether we should see some reversal by year-end. Yes, and just finally, could you give us a breakdown of the private placement tranches that you did, basically, or an indication, say, of how much you did in each currency, and what coupon you paid for each currency and maturity, if possible?
Calum Emslie
analystAppreciate it.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHi, Calum. I'll begin by addressing your question about TransnetBW. First off, the process itself is tracking very much in line with the timeline we had anticipated. We expect to be able to close the transaction by year-end or in Q1, and there is healthy competition around this asset. That's our timing. On cash flow and cash inflow, I'm sorry to say that we aren't providing any indication at this point, since we're right in the middle of the sales process. I hope you'll appreciate that. On net debt, by year-end we expect the net debt level to be between EUR 12.5 billion and EUR 13 billion. On the working capital level, working capital is extremely high at the moment. There are two main reasons. First, our gas storage is at levels of almost 100%. Second, if you look at our hard coal inventories, we currently hold significant hard coal inventory at our power stations to ensure security of supply through this winter. I would assume — very much depending on the weather and on how cold this winter turns out to be over the next six months — that these levels will come down slightly for Q4.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveMy assumption, honestly, is that working capital is going to drop quite a bit in Q1, since we're assuming gas storage levels will be well under where they sit now, and that our hard coal inventory will also come down at this point. On the U.S. private placement, just quickly: roughly 50% is in euros, with the remainder split between U.S. dollars and pound sterling. I hope that goes some way toward answering your question, Calum.
Calum Emslie
analystYeah, for the most part. I was just thinking — I mean, I suppose, if I could maybe ask a follow-up question about that.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAbsolutely.
Calum Emslie
analystSince you chose the private placement market, and I believe you haven't mentioned the coupon level or any indicative levels, should we take it that this is cheaper than what you think you could have funded in the bond market? Or was there another reason for going for the
Thomas Kusterer
executiveNo, I'd say that's actually a fair underlying assumption. That's what we do at present. We're examining various instruments, and we go into whichever market looks most preferable to us as a company. Fair assumption.
Calum Emslie
analystGreat, thanks. That’s really helpful. I’ll let somebody else take a turn.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks. Appreciate it, Calum.
Operator
operatorJust a reminder, that’s star followed by one to ask a question. Our next question comes from Andrew Moulder at CreditSights. Go ahead, please.
Andrew Moulder
analystThanks. Hello, Thomas. Hello, Marcel. Colin really covered a good number of the questions I had in mind, but perhaps I can just build on a few of them. Regarding the TransnetBW sale, I know one item S&P may be somewhat worried about with EnBW is how large your minorities are. Clearly, if you dispose of 50% of TransnetBW, your minorities are going to be considerably bigger. I mean, do you think your rating might potentially come under pressure should you go ahead and sell TransnetBW? I mean, clearly you're lowering the share of regulated income and at the same time raising the minorities. I'd just maybe like a small comment on that. I also wanted to get clarity on the net debt figure. You mentioned EUR 12.5 billion to EUR 13 billion. Is that before or after the EEG adjustment? Maybe now a few other questions. I wanted to try to grasp exactly where we stand. You mentioned the windfall profit levy, and I realize it's uncertain, but maybe you could just bring me up to date on what the most recent proposals are that have been put forward. I mean, is it purely a kind of power price cap on the inframarginal technologies, for which I've seen numbers of perhaps EUR 180 per megawatt hour.
Andrew Moulder
analystI've also come across numbers around EUR 100 per megawatt hour. Could you maybe say something about where things stand on that? Will there be a price cap on gas as well? How would that operate? And then, sorry, on the windfall profits, I've heard as well that some kind of decision is expected at the legislative level on the eighteenth of November, which might give us some clarity. Do you think that's a sensible date, or would you say it's optimistic? Sorry, one last question, just on the VNG effect: you had EUR 1.2 billion in adjusted EBITDA, which I believe you said reflected the cost incurred through the third quarter plus an estimate of what you'd incur in the fourth quarter. You had a further EUR 600 million in the non-operating result. I don't really follow why you're placing it in two separate categories, and I don't really understand why you're saying the effect is only EUR 1.2 billion when to me it looks like a EUR 1.8 billion effect. Could you perhaps explain precisely why those two numbers are there and why you've categorized them in that way? I'll leave it there for now, I think.
Andrew Moulder
analystMuch appreciated.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHey, Andrew. Really nice to hear from you.
Andrew Moulder
analystAppreciate it, Thomas.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, I’ll begin with your last question, the one about VNG. Yes, we have booked EUR 1.2 billion in our operating result. As you noted, that covers everything we incurred through the end of September, plus the underlying assumptions for what we would have incurred under the gas levy. If you remember, the gas levy would also have covered only 90% of the cost for the fourth quarter. Within this EUR 1.2 billion, we assume that we will receive reimbursement from the state for the fourth quarter. It is all the GM. It is the gas from Gazprom Export, everything in the third quarter, including EUR 200 million for VHR, which we agreed with the government, and an underlying assumption about what we might incur for Q4. The EUR 600 million is actually the maximum risk we face if we receive no compensation of any kind for the fourth quarter. But we need to reflect on that, because it is based on forward price levels as of September thirtieth, and prices have fallen significantly since then. We can already reduce the EUR 600 million by a couple of hundred million. The remainder, we assume, will be covered by the hopefully soon-to-come agreement with the government regarding compensation for 35 TWh of gas from the Gazprom Export contract.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveIs that what you were asking?
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah, it feels a little counterintuitive to me, since I didn't assume that with the gas levy being canceled, your EUR 1.2 billion would have assumed that you actually received compensation when, in fact, you're not getting compensation at the moment. But I understand where it's coming from now.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo, we made that split on purpose, since our base case is that the biggest exposure or the biggest charge tied to VNG by year-end is going to come to EUR 1.2 billion. That's very clear. On top of that, we aren't factoring in any stake being taken in VNG by this government. Agreements are close to being finalized, though it's still too early to say anything more precise there, Andrew.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright, thank you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI'll begin with your first question about TransnetBW. What you asked, at least as I understand it, was about our rating and whether that rating might come under pressure because we're increasingly considering minority stakes in our business. No, Andrew, since we already manage our rating on a pro rata basis, that is already part of our underlying assumption. It is already reflected in our ratings. You know. Does that answer your question?
Andrew Moulder
analystI'm not certain, honestly. What I mean is, I don't really know whether the additional minority stakes you'll end up with once TransnetBW is sold are already captured in the ratings S&P is assigning to you?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYeah. Actually, we’re already examining figures on a pro rata basis. We’re already reviewing numbers that reflect minority stakes, and S&P knows completely about the TransnetBW sale.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWe don’t anticipate that the TransnetBW sale will put any further pressure on our ratings.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn your second question, about that EUR 12.5 billion to EUR 13 billion guidance for net debt — since that figure includes the EEG account, the adjusted net debt number comes to EUR 15 billion.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, thanks.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks for that. Your last question concerned the windfall profits and the way the mechanism will be structured. Yes, Andrew — unlike the approach at the European level, where it's 180 EUR per megawatt hour for every technology, what we see currently in Germany is caps on power prices that differ by technology. That said, it applies only to inframarginal technologies, meaning hard coal and gas won't fall under this windfall profit levy. This is fairly comparable to the EU-level scheme, though the caps here are technology-specific, and the precise cap level hasn't been settled yet — discussions are still ongoing. Even so, we expect some clarity will emerge. You mentioned the eighteenth of November — I've heard the same. To be honest, I really don't know whether clarity will actually be available at that time.
Andrew Moulder
analystRight. That cap applies to the inframarginal generation technologies. Gas prices won't have a cap on them, will they?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRight, exactly. Regarding gas and hard coal — there's no cap on either one. Neither gas nor hard coal has a cap.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright. So there's no limit on gas sold into the general market — whether it's going to your consumers, to businesses, or anything along those lines?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYeah. There’s absolutely no cap on gas or hard coal.
Andrew Moulder
analystRight, okay.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOur portfolio spans nuclear and lignite, and in our particular case it leans mostly toward renewable energies.
Andrew Moulder
analystSo you figure the pricing will vary depending on which technology it is?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRight, that's exactly how the government is viewing it at the moment.
Andrew Moulder
analystPerhaps just a quick question about that. Do you anticipate any kind of limit on the nuclear output — the additional 3 months that you'll be running?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYeah. Yeah, for sure. Since nuclear falls under the windfall profit levy, from where we sit today we really need to see what that actually translates to in profit terms for these three months. A lot hinges on where the cap is set.
Andrew Moulder
analystRight. Okay. Sorry — just on nuclear, will it definitely be running for those 3 months, or is a decision still pending at the start of December?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveNo, there's no additional decision that has to be made. That's clear. Those three power stations can keep operating through the fifteenth of April next year.
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah, sorry. I mean, I was aware they had permission to operate, but I figured the government would make a call in early December about whether running them would be mandatory.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveNo. That point has been cleared up in the meantime. There's no additional decision that has to be made, and none will be made by the government, on the question of whether the power stations are permitted to operate or not.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right, that's fine. If you don't mind, I've got just one additional question to ask, then.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOf course.
Andrew Moulder
analystRegarding the gas contracts, there are 100 terawatt-hours at VNG that come to an end at the close of 2022.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveUnderstood.
Andrew Moulder
analystAnd what occurs after that point? Is there replacement gas available that VNG could continue providing to its customers? Or will VNG's volumes decline by, say, 50 or 60 terawatt-hours during 2023?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo in fact, we're substituting those volumes within the wholesale market. We're examining additional contracts — Norway, say, and possibly LNG down the road. That said, it's quite possible that we'll have fewer volumes on hand for our customers starting next year.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveFor clear reasons, we no longer hold any long-term agreements of any sort for Russian gas — and that's the 100 terawatt-hours you're asking about.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, so you’re not able to offer any clarity on the way compensation will actually be paid. I mean, it looks fairly certain that no government stake will be taken in VNG, but still — to me that would look like a pretty tidy answer. They take a 10% stake, which provides, you know, EUR 200 million, EUR 300 million, EUR 600 million of compensation by means of an equity injection — but that is definitely not what will happen?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveActually, that is certainly not going to occur. The state has no intention of becoming a shareholder or acquiring shareholdings within VNG. We will find another solution. My hope is that in the next days—not weeks—we can give you greater clarity on that.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right, that would be appreciated. Great. Thank you, Thomas.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI'm confident it will. Thank you, Andrew.
Operator
operatorWe’ll take the next question from James Sparrow at BNP Paribas. Please go ahead.
James Sparrow
analystGood afternoon, everybody, and thank you for the call. Andrew, I appreciate you covering all my questions. I really just have one more follow-up. On the transfer itself, you mentioned completing it by the end of this year or Q1 next year. Does that mean actually agreeing the transaction or actually closing the transaction? I'm thinking about receipt of proceeds, whatever they might be. Are you expecting those to come in, let's call it Q1? I'm thinking purely around liquidity grounds. Yeah, that's all. Thanks.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveJames, just to keep it brief, our assumption is that every bit of the cash inflows comes in next year. That is the base-case assumption. I believe it also fits with the process we're in right now. In fact, that's how we planned it at the start. Does that address your question?
James Sparrow
analystSure, that works. I tend to view it more through the lens of liquidity, considering that.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYeah.
James Sparrow
analystRegarding the comment you made about breaking.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveGot it completely. Yep.
James Sparrow
analystYes. Wonderful. Thanks very much.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks for joining us.
Operator
operatorThe next question comes from Orlando Finzi at M&G Investments. Your line is open.
Orlando Finzi
analystHi, good afternoon, Thomas and Marcel. Thanks for the call. Can I just check a few sort of little list of questions if I can? If I could just sort of throw them, and maybe we just whiz through them. You mentioned on the price cap, obviously, devil's in the detail of the implementation. I just guess what I'm curious there is how reassured you are, given interactions and I guess how sort of front foot government's been on this that the details can be worked out, and there won't be any sort of collateral damage from that. Separate question on VNG. Andrew touched on the sort of portfolio going forward. I'm just sort of curious, and maybe this isn't something you can answer, but in terms of the state not taking a shareholding, what drives that decision? Why that's different than Uniper? Is there something obvious we can just be aware of, in maybe the situation was less, you know, fragile than Uniper. Just to understand it would be helpful. I guess just on credit ratings, you mentioned a very strong commitment, Thomas, to strong investment-grade credit ratings, and that's really appreciated, obviously. I just wonder with that, given the pressures you're under this year, and obviously the energy price isn't solved yet, isn't fixed, we have to live through it and see how what sort of shape it has.
Orlando Finzi
analystIs there anything else along those lines? If additional credit support is needed, is your primary shareholder able to assist, or are the shareholders in a position to help — or does it work the other way around, given what the energy crisis has cost, with them actually pressing you for dividends? I'm just curious how that dynamic plays out. Perhaps one final question, just to put it out there. We've all seen, of course, the announcement from RWE regarding its 2030 target to exit lignite. Specifically on your coal lignite assets, when do you expect to provide an update on those — on conversion, replacement, or closure? Is there a natural point at which you'll be able to tell us more about that? Thank you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHi, Orlando. I’ll begin with the last question you raised about our coal assets. We’ll provide an update on that next year. We need a bit more clarity on certain aspects. Personally, I would expect that we’ll shut our coal power stations sooner than what we have indicated up to now. Now, on your question about price caps. I believe we’re seeing solid progress with the government regarding how the overall framework is designed. There are a few concerns on our side, one of them being that the government may be considering what amounts to retrospective applications beginning September first. We need to be very careful about that. It always comes down to investors’, let’s say, trust in frameworks. You need to be careful. As for cap levels, much has already been done, and we’ve been working with the government to make sure we’ve been heard on what is required so that the merit order remains intact and the market itself continues to function even with these price caps. I think we’re making good progress toward a sensible solution. I would also hope the same applies to administrative processes, because what we should avoid is a great deal of bureaucracy and a kind of bureaucratic monster.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat is a worry, though I believe a solution will be found in this case as well. On VNG — with respect to VNG, yes, in my view, what we see right now and what stands out plainly is that the government will hold no equity stake in VNG. The point is to compensate VNG for having safeguarded supply security in the gas market. VNG passed no kind of higher price levels on to its customers with respect to replacement procurement costs. What we are discussing is compensation for not passing elevated price levels along to customers. As I said a moment ago, in doing so it safeguarded supply security in the German gas market. On your last question, regarding ratings, yes, indeed. I mean, we have just cut our guidance by up to 10% for year-end. Even so, we remain inside the guidance required for our solid investment grade ratings. On the second part of that question, of course, as ever, I mean our shareholder base is extremely stable. It is a long-term shareholder base, and if and when needed, we will receive any support from that shareholder base. It is not needed at present, to be very clear. I hope that answered your question, Orlando.
Orlando Finzi
analystYeah, that's really, really useful, thank you. Nice work steering through a tough situation up to this point. Yeah.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveMuch appreciated, Orlando — thank you very much.
Operator
operatorOur next question is a follow-up from Calum Emslie at Fidelity. Go right ahead.
Calum Emslie
analystHello, and thanks. I'd like to ask a follow-up about nuclear, and I suppose it's a question with two parts. First, if you did have to operate past April, how straightforward would securing the necessary fuel rods be? In other words, is that genuinely feasible in a physical sense? I realize it is — legally, of course, it's supposed to conclude in April, and so on and so forth. Then, thinking ahead, more conceptually, how are EnBW and, indeed, Germany as a whole viewing the capacity margin — that is, the volume of electricity generation at your disposal going into roughly winter 2023? We've all seen EDF's nuclear projections. As we know, the capacity margin isn't strong in many other European nations. It would seem strange that — unless you're anticipating, is Germany or EnBW expecting that you'll receive substantial quantities of Russian gas again in 2023, or that essentially you'll have to continue operating coal plants at maximum output, perhaps for the coming two or three winters or thereabouts? Could you give us some insight into how you're approaching this and, perhaps, where nuclear fits within that picture?
Calum Emslie
analystAppreciate it.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveCalum, I mean, the political will here is quite evident, and a political choice has been made to genuinely shut down the three nuclear power plants by the middle of April next year. As you just mentioned, beyond that date everything is conceptual or theoretical. From where I sit, I would not presume that those power stations will operate past mid-April. We are not permitted to purchase any new fuel rods, so this decision, I think, is fairly stable. It's a valid point regarding power generation for the coming winter. We do not anticipate receiving gas from Russia next year. That said, your last remark about hard coal, I think, is highly relevant. I would expect our hard coal power stations to operate at full capacity through the next winter, meaning winter 2023 to 2024. That is hopefully actually enough to guarantee security of supply in Germany. There's nothing further I can contribute to the discussion at this moment, I'm afraid. I hope I was able to at least partly answer your question, Calum.
Calum Emslie
analystYes. No, that helps. Thanks. Right.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveGlad to have you with us.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Alessandro La Scalia at BlackRock. Please go ahead.
Alessandro La Scalia
analystYes, hi everyone, and thank you, Thomas and Marcel, for the presentation. Yeah, I have a few questions, mainly to get some clarification on a couple of points you raised during it. The first concerns your guidance. If I have it right, when you compare what H1 carried in terms of total annual costs tied to the Russian gas shortfall, you are now piling on roughly EUR 600 to 700 million, or perhaps more, in costs. Yet the impact on your guidance at the EBITDA level comes to only EUR 200 million. What I mean is, you are reaffirming your guidance for H1, and you state that it sits essentially a good EUR 200 million under the 2021 level. I am simply trying to work out how that happens — why did your guidance not fall by more? My other question concerns your net debt outlook for 2022. If I have it right, you are basically telling us that you will add EUR 3 billion to net debt during Q4. I am not fully certain I follow where that figure would originate. That is also taking into account that, as I would imagine, some of your extra gas storage costs will be, you know, reversed once the gas gets injected, and that is going to occur at some point over the winter as well.
Alessandro La Scalia
analystI'd like to get your view on what you're assuming there. Perhaps this is the last question, and it concerns 2023. Again, one thing I find quite striking is that in the end, notwithstanding everything that occurred, notwithstanding this EUR 1.2 billion hit you will absorb — and are already absorbing at the EBITDA level — your EBITDA for 2022 is once more just EUR 200 million below 2021. That appears to suggest that absent that item, you would have enjoyed an extraordinarily strong year. Should we draw some inference from that regarding your 2023 results? I realize that, I mean, we aren't exactly comparing like with like. There are several moving parts. Maybe the question is whether you would expect to return to a more normal growth rate, you know, in 2023? I mean, I won't be asking you for guidance on 2023, but once more, it would be useful to grasp, in your view, what the key moving parts are when it comes to operational performance next year. Thank you very much.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHello, Alessandro. Let me actually begin with your first question, and maybe I can also fold your last question into the answer I give. Your math is indeed completely correct. We raised the charge related to VNG by EUR 700 million, and we cut our guidance by approximately EUR 200 million, which makes it very clear how robust our overall business model is and that the portfolio effect you see here has paid off. We had positive earnings elsewhere, mainly in renewable energies and in trading. That is in fact offsetting the extra losses we incurred between the second quarter and the end of the year. That is why we only need to lower our guidance by the roughly EUR 200 million figure you mentioned. On forward-looking statements, as you already noted, we would certainly not give any guidance for next year. But what we did say, and I think this is obvious, is that the EUR 1.2 billion is a one-off. To some extent, we would assume that the positive tailwinds we are seeing in the markets right now will last a bit longer than just 2022. That is all I can offer you as guidance, let's say, for the time being.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn net debt, yes, that's an increase of approximately EUR 3 billion, tied to gas storage and an underlying assumption about gas storage levels by year-end, as well as prices. The same applies to our hard coal inventory. Incidentally, we're still building up our hard coal inventory right now. Yeah, the primary drivers behind that EUR 3 billion are gas storage and coal inventories at year-end. Alessandro, does that address your questions, or do you have any follow-up?
Alessandro La Scalia
analystYeah, that’s right.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYes.
Alessandro La Scalia
analystNo, no—it does. Again, I get your caution about peering into 2023, but it looks like it's going to be interesting.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI believe that's correct.
Alessandro La Scalia
analystRight, and thank you again for clarifying that — of course, if you picture yourselves still in that stage of adding storage in October, then that balance will most likely rise in economic terms during Q4. Thanks a lot.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat's right. Appreciate the question, Alessandro.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes as a follow-up from Andrew Moulder at CreditSights. Go right ahead.
Andrew Moulder
analystYes. Hello once more. I suspect you figured I'd already asked so many questions that there was no way I could come up with another one. Right, I simply wanted to verify a few items. You mentioned the private placement, I believe somewhere in your reply to the first question. I was just curious — clearly you have a hybrid whose first call date falls in 2024, and honestly, what we've witnessed during this year is that the hybrid market has basically shut. So I wondered whether, if refinancing a hybrid became necessary, you might look at doing it through the private placement market, since you appear to be fairly drawn to that market right now. Second question. I wanted to raise once more the subject of the technologies and the varying prices attached to each technology and so forth. I was just wondering how that would function in the case of something like pumped storage in Germany. You know, obviously pumped storage tends to be deployed when prices are really high, and doing so is very economic for them, very profitable. Yet if you begin imposing a price cap on that, there's a possible risk that pumped storage plants would end up being used almost like run-of-river plants, operated during baseload times, and would not be there when they were actually needed.
Andrew Moulder
analystI'm just curious about how the German government is approaching that. That's my last question. Clearly, there's a new CEO in place, and I'm wondering whether a major strategic update is coming next year, because I assume he'll want to review the business and sort of assess its priorities. Should we expect some kind of strategy update next year? Thank you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, turning to your follow-up questions, I'll begin with our U.S. private placement and what you said about hybrid. Pardon me, but I won't comment on which instruments we'll use. I mean, this is 2024 — that's a long way off, and we'll see what the right market for this product actually is at that point. On pumped storage, I should have included it on the exclusion list earlier. It isn't. Coal, gas, and pumped storage as well are excluded from the caps. That's contrary, by the way, to run-of-river, which falls under the price cap — so it's in the windfall profit levy. As for our new CEO starting effectively next week, yes, I'd assume as well that we'll receive some strategy guidance next year. Within EnBW, we normally hold a strategy supervisory board meeting around mid-year, so my assumption is next year will be the same. For sure we'll see — we'll get an update, and Theo will give some update on our strategy. That's at least what I'm assuming. Does that answer you, Andrew?
Andrew Moulder
analystYes. Yes, that answers it. Perhaps I could ask just one additional question.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOf course.
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah, that's something I do every time.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, as you know, we really appreciate that.
Andrew Moulder
analystHonestly, you know, quite a few clients I talk to are actually pretty at ease about the gas situation this winter. I'm just curious, what are, sort of, EnBW's expectations looking toward next winter? I mean, you know, with VNG, obviously you're deeply involved in the German gas market. Do you think there will be genuine worry regarding gas supplies for next winter, instead of this winter? How do you expect that situation to develop?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHonestly, to be completely fair, I'd say next year looks challenging where gas is concerned. Naturally, a great deal hinges on the winter we're already in. Should this winter prove mild and we come through it with gas storage at higher levels, then I believe it's very much achievable. If storage levels end up low, filling them to the level we saw this year is going to be a challenge. I mean, we do have the new FSRUs — the floating storage regasification units — coming in. Assuming they arrive on time, there's a reasonable likelihood that it's achievable. That said, from where we sit, it is clearly a challenge — very clearly.
Andrew Moulder
analystEven assuming the German population and economy somehow succeed in cutting demand by the 20% they're aiming for, do you still see next winter being difficult?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHonestly, my worry isn't really the 20% — it's actually the weather, more than anything. The reason is that what really determines gas consumption is the effect that comes from the weather.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright, that's fair enough. Thanks a lot, Thomas. Appreciate it, Marcel.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYou’re welcome.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the question queue. I'd now like to return the floor to Marcel Münch for some closing remarks.
Andrew Moulder
analystThomas?
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Thomas, for your responses and remarks, and I appreciate everyone on the call taking the time today. At this point, we'd like to wish each of you a pleasant and calm holiday season, and we look forward to having you join us again when we present our full-year 2022 results on our next conference call, March 27. Until then, take care, and goodbye.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of this conference call. You can hang up your phones now. Many thanks for being with us, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.