EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 27, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Marcel Münch
executiveRegarding EnBW's annual results for 2022 — and sorry, I'll begin once more, since I believe the introduction was missed — welcome, ladies and gentlemen. We appreciate your presence on today's Investor and Analyst Conference Call concerning EnBW's 2022 results. It's a pleasure to welcome our new CEO, Andreas Schell, together with our CFO, Thomas Kusterer. This event concerns not just the presentation of a business year's figures but also a matter of far-reaching importance: our considerably more ambitious climate targets, which we announced this morning together with our results. In a minute, Andreas will open with all the relevant facts about our SBTi-approved targets and our accelerated coal exit. Thomas will then give you details on developments in our business and the environment in which we operate. After that, as always, we look forward to your comments and questions. And without further ado, I'll hand things over directly to Andreas. The floor is yours.
Andreas Schell
executiveThank you, Marcel. Ladies and gentlemen, I’d also like to offer you a warm welcome. As Marcel mentioned, I became EnBW’s CEO one month ago, and I’ve been genuinely impressed by how dedicated and experienced the EnBW team is; that gives me an excellent foundation to build on. And of course, I’m also eager for the discussion we’ll have today. Let me begin with what I see as the key topics. Our 2020 operating result, with adjusted EBITDA of around EUR 3.3 billion, is comfortably above guidance. It also surpasses the roughly EUR 3 billion posted a year earlier. That is a very pleasing outcome given the substantial headwinds in 2022. Such a positive performance would not have been achievable without our highly resilient business model and a well-diversified portfolio spanning the whole value chain, which provided stability, particularly amid volatile markets and periods of major uncertainty. And, certainly, not least, the impressive dedication of the entire EnBW team drove this success. As you know, sustainability sits at the core of our business and serves as a compass for our strategic direction. In 2020, we published our climate neutrality goal for the first time. And now we have set even more ambitious climate action targets for ourselves, which we published this morning.
Andreas Schell
executiveOur own emissions are on a trajectory consistent with 1.5 degrees, and SBTi has approved that. On top of that, we set an SBTi-approved reduction goal covering indirect emissions in Scope 3. SBTi has also confirmed that every one of our climate targets lines up with the Paris Agreement. We now plan to move the coal phaseout date forward to '28. Delivering on these targets naturally demands a faster expansion of renewables and grids, something the German government is promoting. With that in mind, we made significant choices on several large-scale projects, and those choices support our goal of accelerating the energy transition. I'll point to just 3 of them. First, we began construction on 3 fuel switch projects that move from coal to natural gas, with a combined capacity of 1.5 gigawatts; these new plants will offset the intermittency of renewable generation. Second, last week we reached the final investment decision on our 960-megawatt offshore wind farm He Dreiht. Third, our team is advancing the SuedLink transmission line, which is vital for security of supply because it carries power from wind offshore installations in the north of the Baltic Sea down to the south of Germany.
Andreas Schell
executiveLet me give you a handful of key figures on how we're speeding up our climate transition plan. Our own emissions are now Paris aligned with a 1.5 degree pathway, and that has been approved by SBTi, and we intend to move the coal phaseout forward to 2028 — that's 7 years earlier than our previous target. So we want to be coal-free a full 10 years before the formal legal deadline. That means we're accelerating our route to climate neutrality in 2035, and we expect to hit key milestones well ahead of what was previously planned. As early as 2027, we will cut our own emissions by around 50%, which pulls that target forward by roughly 3 years. By 2030 we will lower our own emissions by around 70%, and that marks a new milestone on our decarbonization timeline. And by 2035 we will bring our own emissions down by 83%, which pins down our climate neutrality goal. Ladies and gentlemen, what matters for a successful energy transition is a triangle. That triangle consists of growing renewable energies and grid infrastructure, together with the ramp-up of low carbon dioxide dispatchable power generation. Only when significant progress happens across all 3 of these fields at the same time, not one after another, will we be in a position to deliver the energy transition in Germany within the time frame under consideration.
Andreas Schell
executiveWith that in mind, it's worth stressing that getting to an energy supply with zero carbon dioxide emissions depends on having the right economic and political framework in place. At EnBW, we will do our part for that broader objective by directing by far the biggest portion of our investment into exactly these areas. To speed up the shift toward a climate-neutral future, EnBW keeps investing at full speed in sustainable infrastructure that is also critical to the system. For the 2021 to 2025 period, net investments of around EUR 14 billion are now planned, which is EUR 2 billion more than our earlier target. Let's look at some specifics of our climate transition plan on the next slide. Developments over the past years have sharply underscored how vulnerable energy supply can be. As I already said, phasing out coal significantly earlier is only feasible if we first build up dispatchable generation capacity. Our fuel switch plans at 3 locations are the phenomenon for security of supply. At these sites, natural gas will replace coal at first, and hydrogen in the medium term. The accelerated phaseout of our remaining coal power plants, with a generation capacity of around 2,000 megawatts, will be completed in 2028 rather than 2035.
Andreas Schell
executiveThat lets us cut our own carbon dioxide emissions by 70% in 2030, rather than the 50% target we previously had for this year. When it comes to the coal-fired power plants that remain, we are preparing exit plans for each individual site. At partly owned sites, we will enter talks aimed at concrete solutions. The coal phase out — these will be carried out in a socially responsible way, meaning together with our employee representatives and in dialogue with our local partners. Gas transmission and distribution grids will be hydrogen ready by 2030. And in 2035, our plan is to switch to carbon-neutral gases. Moving to the next slide, let's look more closely at our fuel switch projects. Last year, we took the final investment decision for 3 major fuel switch projects in Baden-Württemberg, with an overall capacity of 1.5 gigawatts and a planned investment volume of EUR 1.6 billion. Conversion work is already underway at our sites in Heilbronn, Altbach/Deizisau and Stuttgart-Münster, and completion is expected in 2026. These 3 projects are a key element in implementing the energy transition in the southern part of Germany. Building up carbon dioxide reduced dispatchable power is necessary to ensure security of supply, especially in light of the earlier coal exit and until hydrogen is available at large scale.
Andreas Schell
executiveAdditional carbon dioxide cuts are possible through the use of climate-neutral gases — or, over the longer term, hydrogen — for generating electricity. From the mid-2030s, we anticipate being able to run on climate-neutral gases. At the EU level, natural gas is acknowledged as a significant bridging technology on the path toward carbon dioxide neutrality. Including gas in the taxonomy reflects this. Our 3 fuel switch plants satisfy the European Union Commission's taxonomy criteria for natural gas-fired plants and are therefore reported as taxonomy aligned. On Slide 6, with reference to the triangle already mentioned, I'd like to share the most relevant details about our offshore wind farm He Dreiht. For EnBW, as an experienced developer and operator of offshoring firms, our next offshore wind farm He Dreiht is a key milestone in the significant expansion of our renewables. As you may recall, in 2017, He Dreiht was the very first zero subsidy bit placed in an offshore auction worldwide. The FID now taken therefore marks confirmation of excellent teamwork over more than 6 years, culminating in the implementation of this very important project. He Dreiht will be situated in the North Sea roughly 90 kilometers northwest of the island of Borkum and 110 kilometers west of Heligoland.
Andreas Schell
executiveWe already have our Hohe See and Albatros offshore wind farms running close by, so He Dreiht stands to gain from that proximity as well as from our current service hub and the coastal city of Emden. The project will use 64 Vestas turbines, each with 15 megawatts of capacity, placing it among the most powerful currently in operation and bringing total capacity to 960 megawatts. Around EUR 2.4 billion is the investment volume for this offshore wind farm. Commercial operation is scheduled for late 2025. At that point He Dreiht will deliver green electricity to roughly 1.1 million households. Before construction begins, we will bring first-class partners on board by selling a minority stake of 49.9% to a consortium made up of Alliance Capital Partners, AIP and Norges Bank. During construction, EnBW will handle the technical, administrative and commercial implementation. Once completed, EnBW will take care of technical and commercial management along with maintenance and servicing. EnBW has also signed long-term PPAs to date; the comprehensive PPA portfolio of 335 megawatts was concluded with financially solid offtakers, Fraport, Evonik, Salzgitter and Bosch. In addition, in December 2022, we secured EUR 600 million in long-term financing from the European Investment Bank, one of the world's largest financiers of climate action and environmental sustainability.
Andreas Schell
executiveLadies and gentlemen, at this point I’ll turn things over to Thomas, who will walk you through the financial specifics for our fiscal year 2022. Thomas?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThank you, Andreas, and hello as well from my side. Turning to Slide 7, I'd like to begin with the big picture of where we are today, before we get into the specifics for fiscal year 2022. As Andreas mentioned at the start of the presentation, we delivered a strong financial performance in 2022. Adjusted EBITDA rose by 11% to EUR 3.3 billion, with roughly EUR 2.2 billion of that coming from low-risk businesses along with regulated FiTs and renewables. Retained cash flow climbed by 42%, while net debt grew by just a moderate 5%, which works out to a high debt repayment potential of 23% at year-end 2022. The biggest drag on our 2022 figures came from the curtailment of Russian gas supplies at our subsidiary VNG, and that is reflected in our adjusted EBITDA number. As you may know, VNG held 2 supply contracts for Russian gas. Counterparties failing to fulfil their supply obligations, along with supply restrictions, affected these contracts. And ultimately, there was the suspension of supplies through the Nord Stream 1 pipeline. Because VNG had already sold gas volumes at fixed prices through the end of 2022, it was forced to procure gas on the energy markets at significantly higher prices.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn October 10, VNG and WIEH — the subsidiary of the former Gazprom Germania, which now operates as Sefe — reached a settlement regarding the contract for the supply of 65 terawatt hours per year. We have paid the full cost of the replacement procurement in 2022. At the same time, the contract that originally ran until 2030 was terminated at the end of 2022. At the beginning of December 2022, VNG resolved the residual risk for its contract with Gazprom export covering 35 terawatt hours per annum. As partial compensation for the expenses incurred, VNG received an amount in the mid-triple-digit million euro range from the government in Germany. In return, VNG withdrew its application for stabilization measures which are no longer necessary. The contract with Gazprom export expired at the end of 2022. The overall negative impact for EnBW for replacement costs at VNG, for missing gas volumes in 2022 amounted to a total of EUR 1.1 billion. In December, a resolution to increase VNG's equity by a maximum of EUR 850 million was adopted. EnBW and OEW paid in their pro rata share of this increase. The second largest shareholder of VNG consisting of 8 municipalities in Eastern Germany has until May 31, 2023, to exercise in whole or part its subscription rights to further VNG shares.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLiquidity was another key focus area in 2022, especially from the moment the war in Ukraine began. EnBW saw elevated liquidity movements, yet these stayed comfortably inside the risk scenarios we had analyzed. By moving into new markets and deploying new financial instruments, we strengthened our liquidity position considerably and proactively. Through issuing our first promissory notes over the summer and completing the first U.S. private placement in November, we successfully broadened our investor base. We also added bank lines, issued commercial paper and actively managed our hedging position. All in all, we have substantially expanded and diversified the financing instruments available to us. At the close of 2022, we held a strong consolidated cash balance of EUR 5.2 billion in cash, plus further liquidity sources, amounting to EUR 7.2 billion of undrawn credit lines in total, to ride out any potential resurgence of market volatility. Ladies and gentlemen, as we look forward, we anticipate a significant rise in operating earnings this year and forecast adjusted EBITDA of between EUR 4.7 billion and EUR 5.2 billion. Our regulated business gives us not only an attractive risk return profile but also secures a high share of stable earnings. In addition, within our competitive business area, sales and generation, we hedge our margins as much as 3 years ahead.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRegarding 2023, our hedging position is complete, giving us a very solid foundation for earnings growth that year. And finally — certainly not least — the elevated replacement procurement costs incurred at VNG, our subsidiary, for missing gas volumes represented a one-off item during 2022. Let's turn now to a closer examination of the 2022 figure. I'd like to begin by reviewing operating earnings on Slide 8. Adjusted EBITDA came in at EUR 3.286 billion for financial year 2022, roughly 11% higher than in 2021. In 2022, the portion of adjusted EBITDA attributable to taxonomy-aligned activities is set to surpass EUR 2.4 billion, or 73%, versus under EUR 1.9 billion the year before. That gain stemmed mainly from stronger earnings in renewable energies, which are entirely taxonomy aligned. Now let's go deeper into our operating segments, beginning on Slide 9. Adjusted EBITDA for smart infrastructure for customers rose significantly in 2022. This favorable trend was driven especially by improved earnings with business customers at subsidiaries and by our solar home storage business, SENEC. Temperatures milder than anticipated, together with energy saving measures, led to reduced sales volumes, and the corresponding sale of excess volume made a positive contribution to earnings. In addition, SENEC achieved a high growth rate in 2022, driven particularly by greater sales volumes, which climbed by 40%.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn Slide 10, adjusted EBITDA for our segment's system-critical infrastructure fell 17% versus a year earlier, to EUR 1.046 billion. The decline came mostly from greater spending on credit reserve measures, such as re-dispatch and reserve power plants, needed to keep the system stable. Because of the energy crisis, both the number of deployments and market prices rose sharply. Still, the effect on the fourth quarter of 2022 ended up smaller than what the updated guidance of November 2022 had assumed, largely because weather was warmer than average late in the year. Congestion revenues were also higher, thanks to the large electricity price gap between Germany and its neighbors, France and Switzerland. Moving to Slide 11, let me discuss sustainable generation infrastructure. In this segment, adjusted EBITDA rose by almost 30% to EUR 1.935 billion in financial year 2022, compared with the prior year. The chief reasons we beat our forecast were negative valuation effects that came in lower than expected and stronger overall earnings from trading activities. In addition, the windfall profit levy legislation passed in December matches our original assumptions, which rested on technology-specific price caps. Proceeds from selling electricity produced from renewable energies, nuclear power, mineral oil, waste and lignite will be skimmed off between December 1, 2022, and June 30, 2023, to fund relief for end customers.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveNow let's take a closer look at what the 2 parts of this segment delivered, beginning with renewables. Adjusted EBITDA there climbed by nearly 40%, crossing EUR 1 billion for the first time. We reached EUR 1.107 billion on the back of 3 main factors: first, market prices were higher; second, wind yields came in above the prior year, which by historical standards had been well under average; and third, EnBW commissioned new solar farms, which helped lift earnings. In thermal generation and trading, 2022's extraordinary market conditions — high commodity prices and volatility — produced sizable offsetting effects, with the positive ones prevailing. Curtailments and the suspension of gas supplies stemming from the war in Ukraine, along with negative valuation effects on derivative financial instruments, persisted through year-end and weighed on earnings. As mentioned earlier, the adverse impact from VNG by itself came to EUR 1.1 billion. Still, higher market prices and a positive contribution from trading activities offset those effects. Against financial year 2021, adjusted EBITDA in thermal generation and trading rose 11% to approximately EUR 828 million, and as in the grid area, security of supply mattered a great deal, with our power plant fleet making an important contribution to it.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat leads me straight to the electricity volumes we generated in 2022, covered on Slide 12, which also take in long-term purchase agreements and, in particular, power plants we own. EnBW's own output of 42 terawatt hours came in at pretty much the same level as the prior year's. Versus 2021, generation from renewables rose thanks to more favorable wind conditions and higher photovoltaic generation from the addition of further solar products. Hydropower generation, by contrast, was significantly lower than the year before because of low water levels. Overall generation volumes from the thermal plants declined. Output from coal-fired power plants went up slightly, whereas generation from gas-fired power stations fell significantly. Coal accounted for 40% of total electricity generated, while renewables made up almost 28%. That brings me to carbon intensity, a key performance indicator we watch closely. In the wake of the Ukraine war, our thermal generation units — especially those in the southwest of Germany — were needed to maintain security of supply, not only in Germany but also in France, where a large number of nuclear power plants were unavailable. Because priority was given to raising gas storage levels in the second half of 2022, more coal had to be used for generating electricity instead of gas.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo all of that fed through into a modest increase in our specific CO2 intensity, which rose 2.6% to 491 grams per kilowatt hour. That sits at the bottom of the range we had forecast for 2022, which was an increase of 0% to 15%. Measured against the base year 2018, CO2 intensity came down by 11.5% in 2022. For 2025, our aim is a reduction of 15% to 30% in CO2 intensity relative to 2018. So we remain on track to hit that 2025 target. Renewables capacity grew to 5.4 gigawatts in 2022, up from 5.1 gigawatts a year earlier, driven largely by the commissioning of Gottesgabe and Alttrebbin, our large-scale solar farms. As of the end of 2022, that amounts to roughly 42% of total generation capacity. That takes me to Slide 13 and our investments in financial year 2022. As I mentioned on last year's conference calls, the bulk of our investment went into expanding electricity transmission networks and renewables, so the emphasis was firmly on the energy transition. Investments totaled close to EUR 3.2 billion, which is a 12% rise year-over-year. System-critical infrastructure made up 60% of that. Within this segment, EUR 1.9 billion of investment let us push forward with expanding our electricity and gas transmission and distribution grids.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSo through this, we’re contributing substantially to modernizing and growing Germany’s grid-based energy infrastructure — the backbone of the energy transition. Beyond that, we put roughly EUR 860 million into sustainable generation infrastructure, with EUR 632 million of that tied to renewable energies, chiefly the solar farms I mentioned earlier and offshore wind. At the start of 2022, alongside our partner BP, we secured the rights to build a 2.9 gigawatts offshore wind farm off Scotland’s coast. That gives us, together with BP, a project pipeline of 5.9 gigawatts of offshore wind, with FID expected in 2026. And those wind farms are set to come online between 2028 and 2030. As Andreas noted earlier, in 2022 we also raised our investment in He Dreiht, our offshore wind farm. Within Thermal Generation & Trading, EUR 228 million went in, mostly to push our fuel switch projects forward. Spending on smart infrastructure for customers came to approximately EUR 341 million, and our main focus there is broadening our high-performance charging network for e-mobility. Over only a few years, we’ve built out a sizable high-performance charging infrastructure. EnBW holds more than 800 charging locations, which means we run by far Germany’s largest fast-charging network.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveIn 2022, divestments totaled roughly EUR 386 million. A 49.9% minority stake in a portfolio of 16 solar farms, with combined capacity of 597 megawatts, was sold to a German insurance group. We also exited the U.S. offshore wind power business. When we look at the taxonomy alignment of our CapEx, investments into EnBW's equity-accounted entities are included as well. Of this expanded CapEx, about 83% was taxonomy aligned, which means an increase of more than 12% points versus 2021. Turning to Slide 14, I'd like to comment on how our retained cash flow developed. Retained cash flow in 2022 rose by almost EUR 750 million, or 42%, compared with 2021. Three factors drove this improvement: an increase in our adjusted EBITDA, particularly in our Renewables business and trading activities, as well as in our customer business as described earlier; company's cash relevant earnings in our nonoperating result; and last but not least, provisions and accruals we booked as part of our operating results to cater for potential risks, especially in our customer segment and electricity distribution grids. That brings me to the development of net debt on Slide 15. Because Renewable Energy Act account balances are only held in escrow by the transmission system operator, we are not allowed to be -- they are not allowed to be used for operating purposes.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveStarting with this operating date, those account balances are no longer part of net debt. We've restated the prior year figures to match. Net debt as of December 31, 2022, came to roughly EUR 10.8 billion, about EUR 500 million higher than where it stood at the end of 2021. Working capital also rose by around EUR 2 billion over the same period, driven mostly by higher inventories. Net cash investments totaled just under EUR 2.8 billion. When we repaid 2 subordinated bonds in early January 2022 — nominal values of EUR 725 million and USD 300 million, respectively — net debt went up by approximately EUR 500 million, because we lost 50% equity credit. Meanwhile, pension provisions fell sharply, by roughly EUR 2.4 billion, largely because the relevant discount rate climbed substantially from 1.15% to 3.7% as of December 31, 2022. As you know, we steer our credit profile with the KPI debt repayment potential, meaning the ratio of retained cash flow to net debt. That metric closely mirrors the matrix rating agencies use, so it fits very well for managing both our investments and our net debt. Consequently, debt repayment potential of more than 23% in the 2022 reporting year sits well above the prior year's 17%.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn Slide 16 you can see that adjusted group net profit attributable to shareholders of EnBW AG fell 19% to EUR 973 million. The main driver here is a decline in our financial results, largely from a loss on marketing securities to market following the negative capital market trends of last year. Over the long term, our aim is to pay out no more than between 40% and 60% of adjusted group net profit, and subject to approval at the Annual General Meeting on May 3, our dividend proposal stands at EUR 1.10 per dividend bearing share, level with the prior year. That works out to a payout ratio of 31%. With this dividend proposal, additional funds stay in the company to finance our future growth and further strengthen our equity base. Ladies and gentlemen, let me wrap up with our guidance for financial year 2023 on Slide 17. In the segment smart infrastructure for customers, we expect adjusted EBITDA of between EUR 400 million and EUR 500 million. For the time being, we expect volatility to decrease and the market to return to more normal levels. Beyond that, we anticipate increased competition in the commodity business with consumer and business customers.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWhen it comes to our new business areas, we're projecting earnings that are stable to slightly higher. Within the system-critical infrastructure segment, we anticipate a substantial rise in adjusted EBITDA. We expect that figure to land between EUR 1.6 billion and EUR 1.9 billion. The drag from 2022 related to grid reserve and re-dispatch won't be a factor in 2023. Credit revenue should also climb modestly, driven by larger investments in projects covered by the electricity and gas grid development plans. For the sustainable generation infrastructure segment, we're looking for adjusted EBITDA to rise to somewhere between EUR 2.9 billion and EUR 3.2 billion by the end of 2023. First, the Renewable Energies business should come in flat versus the prior year at more than EUR 1 billion. Second, 2 effects will contribute slightly positively to earnings. Generation volumes, especially from runoff river, were well under the long-term average in financial year 2022, and we anticipate greater volumes in 2023; we also foresee a modest expansion of our renewable generation capacity this year. Conversely, some effects push the other way: a price level that is declining relative to 2022, and the windfall profit level, which might hurt the profitability of our renewables business should prices rise again.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveNext, we anticipate a substantial rise in earnings for 2023 within Thermal Generation and Trading. Part of the reason is that the negative one-off impact at our subsidiary VNG from last year will not recur. At the same time, we foresee a moderately adverse effect stemming from the windfall profit levy as well as from normalization in the wholesale market. With that in mind, our guidance for the full year at group level for the present financial year calls for a significant earnings increase ranging between EUR 4.7 billion and EUR 5.2 billion. This earnings growth will let us carry out the energy transition with greater speed and success. Concretely, that means stepping up expansion of renewables and of our grid infrastructure, where our investment will be even larger than previously. With that, I'd like to pass things to Marcel so we can begin our Q&A session.
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Thomas, and thank you, Andreas. Ladies and gentlemen, we'll begin the Q&A portion now. <<operator_script>> Andrew Moulder is with us — Andrew, would you like to proceed with your questions? Andrew, it appears your microphone is still set to mute. Okay, he's dropped off now. Let's try Orlando Finzi. Orlando, can you hear us? Once more, I believe your line remains muted. Orlando, if you're able to hear me. I think your microphone is still switched to mute. Now we ought to be able to hear you. Hello, Orlando? It looks like Orlando is having a technical issue with his microphones. So let's go back to Andrew. Andrew, can you hear us?
Andrew Moulder
analystAppreciate the strong results. I just want to make sure I understand the guidance you provided. It really looks to me like the reason it's up so much next year is essentially that you don't have the VNG one-off this year. I mean, fine, grids will be better since you've had to pay some costs this year. But the large increase in the generation segment really stems from not having VNG, that one-off, the EUR 1.1 billion. If you could confirm that, that would help. And then just a couple of other questions. You mentioned these hydrogen-ready plants. A lot of utilities are talking about hydrogen-ready plants. But I'm not really sure I grasp the economics of hydrogen-ready plants. I mean, what kind of power price do you actually need in order to make a plant that's generating using hydrogen an economic proposition? I'd just like a bit more clarity on that. I don't know whether you can give me some sort of levelized cost of electricity or something else along those lines. Just to give me a feel for whether those things are actually economic. And then I also just wanted to ask you about He Dreiht.
Andrew Moulder
analystYou mentioned divesting that 49%, yet I noticed that neither in your press release nor in what you've said today did you actually address the price you got for it. So I wonder whether you might be able to share that with me. Also, I'm not 100% persuaded that now is really the optimal moment to be selling it. I mean, the parties buying into the project will be carrying some risk until construction is finished. You still have quite a lot of merchant exposure as well. Had you held off until commissioning, there would be no construction risk. You might have 600 megawatts of sold PPAs in place, meaning less merchant risk on price there. And from whoever is buying into the project, you could probably secure a far better price than is available now. So I'm simply not convinced that now is the best time to sell. And perhaps you could give me your sense of that? And my last question, I guess this one is perhaps more for Andreas. As I recall, originally you had a target of reaching EUR 3.2 billion of EBITDA for 2025. I mean, you've already hit that, and you're going to be -- maybe up at EUR 5 billion or possibly even more next year.
Andrew Moulder
analystAnd so a fresh strategic plan is now in place, and clearly, with Andreas joining too, chief executives usually review the company's strategy and determine if anything ought to be approached in another way. So is a complete strategic review necessary? And if it is, when would that happen? I'll leave it there.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, thanks a lot for those questions. On the first one, I can really only confirm what you just mentioned regarding the earnings increase in our Power Generation segment. It's indeed because of the 2 topics you raised: it's VNG, and it's lower re-dispatch and security-of-supply expenses in our Networks business. So I can fully confirm what you said. That's where the increase comes from. On the second question, hydrogen, let me try to take that one. That's a tough one, because as of today, using hydrogen isn't economically viable, and I think we can all just agree on that. It depends very much on how the hydrogen market develops in the future. And we assume that by 2035, so the middle of the next decade, we'll have sufficient hydrogen available for these power plants at economically sensible prices. But that's certainly something that remains to be seen. And it's too early to really look into that. I mean, honestly, it needs to be at the price level you currently have for LNG. That's basically what it would mean. So there's a long way to go, certainly, before we reach those price levels for hydrogen.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOn He Dreiht, that 49.9% stake sale — and it won't come as a shock when I tell you we aren't revealing the purchase prices. On timing, from where we sit, we actually nailed it with this sale. Sure, the investors will be carrying the investment and construction risk. But the market has changed across the last couple of years and grown more mature. We don't see any meaningful premium between now and the end of construction out there. So for us, bringing a partner in who shares construction risk on one side, and also shares the CapEx during construction, made total sense — selling it as of today. Turning to the PPAs — their levels, amounts and volumes — those 335 megawatts were a deliberate choice, actually, not to push it higher right now, because our trading team is convinced better times are coming, even better times than what we managed to close the PPAs at, in the near future. So step by step, across the next couple of years, we'll raise that level to at least 450, potentially beyond 450 megawatts, since we'd also like some market exposure even over the mid and long term for He Dreiht.
Andrew Moulder
analystLet me just return briefly to He Dreiht. I wanted to verify that those PPAs are essentially buy-as-generated, meaning no volume is written into them. And also, with inflation and costs having risen as we've seen, could you confirm that every cost for building He Dreiht is completely locked in?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYes, we've actually locked in every cost for He Dreiht, to begin with. And then, secondly — what was your second question again? Help me out?
Andrew Moulder
analystRegarding the PPAs, is it volume risk that you're taking on, or is it more just...
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYes, Andrew — sorry about that. What I can confirm is that, when it comes to the PPAs, we aren't carrying any volume risk of any kind. The volume risk is actually going to sit with the offtake.
Andrew Moulder
analystWhat about the questions on strategy?
Andreas Schell
executiveYes. Well, thank you, Andrew. Shortly after I arrived here, it became quite clear that EnBW is in a strong position today. And looking at 2025, that clearly falls inside the paradigm — inside the frame — of our midterm planning horizon. That is why we feel quite confident regarding our outlook toward 2025. But to address your question, it is also very evident that 2022 has delivered such a massive impact on the energy industry. So it is very clear, given the turn we are about to take, that we will examine our strategy. Work on that has already begun. And I believe we can say that following internal discussions and conclusion, we will update you as we proceed through the rest of this year.
Andrew Moulder
analystAll right, that sounds fine. Mind if I slip in just one additional question? There was one item you didn’t bring up at all during your presentation — Transnet. Could you maybe offer a comment on how things are progressing there?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, absolutely. It’s functioning — it’s coming along nicely, just as we had anticipated. We’re midway through that process. And Andrew, you’re familiar with how we operate: once we reach a final agreement, we’ll share additional details. But in fact, it’s exactly as we expected.
Marcel Münch
executiveI believe Orlando is back with us once more. Let's try that again and see whether the microphone works this time.
Orlando Finzi
analystGreat, and I'm sorry about that. I'm using my mobile rather than the computer, and for some reason that's working. But many thanks for the results and for the updated climate strategy. And I just — clearly, there is a great deal to take in from what you've announced today. But I'd simply like to — I suppose, to ask, regarding the ambition to shut coal generation by 2028. Clearly, there's greater reliance on gas. And as we know, natural gas supply right now is not fixed and is not adequate. How much does your closing of coal depend on developments taking place in the supply of natural gas, of LNG? I just want to grasp that relationship and how you've factored that situation into your decision-making.
Andreas Schell
executiveThank you so much, Orlando. To address that, we have to consider what lies ahead as well. This morning we also noted that the outcome hinges on it, and our investments are going toward building out renewable energy sources — and we're confident that by 2028 those sources will account for a significantly larger portion of energy supply. So at that point, the power we must generate through dispatchable means — through fuel switch power plants, for example — will keep shrinking further and further. Our assessment, consequently, is that we can manage and secure the natural gas supply. We've verified this through an internal study. That's the reason — that's why we chose not to focus on the soonest possible date for exiting coal, but rather on the date that makes sense from where we stand, and that is how we arrived at 2028. The aim, then, is to rely on as little dispatchable power as we can and, as a result, use less natural gas.
Orlando Finzi
analystThat's quite clear. Then, just so I understand on that point, in what way does this approach also fit with the government and the stance it takes on energy? Is there a significant dependence there, or are there choices still to be made? And then, as a separate — apologies, a separate question, when I look at the CapEx increase that this implies, there's clearly a possibility of pressure on credit metrics. And I just — perhaps, Thomas, just to understand how you're thinking about it, again, you've obviously been very clear on credit ratings in the past. And just to understand, with this new — the new step up, so to speak, to the challenge of a climate transition, how confident are you in being able to maintain the same? Thank you.
Andreas Schell
executiveThis fits really nicely with what our government expects for how Germany's energy capacity will be built up going forward. Estimates put the need at roughly 50 gigawatts of gas-fired power plants by 2040 or 2045, along with 15 to 20 gigawatts of such plants after 2030. So with the 3 fuel switch projects we've already announced, we're making solid progress on that path. And I believe our government will view this quite favorably.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAnd Orlando, on the credit matrix — well, you've basically made the point yourself. My position on where our ratings sit has always been very clear, and it remains the same. What we're aiming for is solid investment grade ratings. If you look at our credit ratings from both S&P and Moody's, you'll see that, and we're quite comfortable at that level. That's how we run the business — keeping ourselves at that level not only now but into the future too. So it's very clear. And it is achievable, in fact. That was really the second half of what you were asking, if I may put it that way, Orlando. Can we actually pull it off with the CapEx coming up? Without question. We've also seen our underlying retained cash flow go up. So we're comfortable that we can actually satisfy every metric required to remain inside the current ratings grid.
Marcel Münch
executiveBefore I hand things to Andrew, let me check once more whether anyone else would like to ask something. No one does at this point. Andrew, the floor is yours — I believe you have a few follow-ups.
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah, just a couple of quick basic questions. On net debt, Thomas, you mentioned restating it since the liquid funds for the year count are ring-fenced. That's fine. But what happens if it goes the other direction and you actually owe money to the EEG? Would that still be counted as net debt? Maybe you could just comment on that. I'm only thinking a bit about EDF and the CSPE, which does move in both directions, positively and negatively. I assume the EEG behaves the same way, but maybe I'm wrong and it doesn't. So if you could just comment on that. And the second thing, I wanted to ask about VNG and the capital increase. So if I understand correctly, you've already put the extra capital into VNG. And I think you said the partners in VNG have until May to put their money in. So should I assume you've put in the whole EUR 850 million and you're waiting for them to decide? Because presumably, VNG needs EUR 850 million whether they put the money in or not. So where would the extra money come from if they choose not to put it in?
Andrew Moulder
analystAnd I apologize, one more question along those lines. In what way would I see all of that showing up in your accounts? Since clearly, VNG is fully consolidated. So I'm not really certain I'll see anything at all in your accounts until your third parties put money in, and at that point your cash is going to rise.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYes. Let me begin with the VNG question, actually. What we did was we contributed an additional EUR 850 million. But we paid our share, which is a EUR 630 million capital increase, and OEW paid EUR 40 million. So what remains outstanding is actually the portion belonging to the 8 municipalities from Eastern Germany, and their share is still outstanding. And the question is really whether we would take up their subscription rights if and when they either would not participate in the capital increase or would only participate in a limited way, actually. And as things stand, that is not the case, because for the time being we do not foresee that VNG requires the additional CapEx if it were not to take part in the capital increase, so that's where we start. And you can see it in rising dividends actually going forward, because obviously our share has gone up — at least as of today, if we do not see any kind of subscription, our share has increased, so you can see that there. And actually, we would also expect that dividends going forward from VNG are going to rise, because, I mean, we still have an extremely solid business case in place with VNG, and we would expect that the earnings contribution from VNG is going to increase over the next couple of years.
Andrew Moulder
analystPardon me, but has that capital increase impact already been factored into your 2022 figures?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveSure, sure, yes, yes, yes, yes — apologies. I actually didn’t grasp that question. It’s in there. It’s already — it’s part of our 2022 accounts. In fact, we paid in December. On your net debt question, with respect to the Renewable Energies Act: for the moment it’s positive. Were it to go negative, the state would in fact cover it. So we really don’t have any obligation of that kind here. It wouldn’t raise our overall net debt position.
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Andrew. I believe Orlando is back with some follow-up questions, if I'm not wrong. Orlando?
Orlando Finzi
analystI’d like to ask about the new climate strategy, which is really encouraging. I just want to get a sense, when it was being put together, of where the pressure points were and how confident you are in the targets. Can you — obviously, the ambition is very high and commendable. But I just want to understand the complexities involved in trying to construct that. Is there any kind of insight from that process that you can share with us?
Andreas Schell
executiveAbsolutely, happy to do that. We began this last year, and I genuinely believe EnBW has the experience and expertise internally to tackle that kind of question. Bear in mind that we're the only energy utility still left in Germany positioned essentially across the whole value chain — that covers power generation and trading, plus grids, plus customers. So having that perspective matters a great deal to us. What we've done, then, is examine our own models and produce a forecast of utilization and, with it, the potential power generation in the later years, while also factoring in trading prices, or the prices projected for trading. We then essentially brought the art of the possible together with reality and reached the conclusion that 2028 was the right year for us. Obviously, we now need to keep talking with some of our partners wherever we jointly own power generation plants. Those conversations are already underway, and it's quite clear how things will proceed. Further details of our plans will be announced.
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Orlando. I hope that answers what you were asking.
Orlando Finzi
analystYes, that does. That’s really useful. Thanks.
Marcel Münch
executiveSo let me check whether there are any further questions. At this point I don't see any hands raised, but let's wait another second on that. All right. That doesn't appear to be -- no, here, we have someone. There we go now. So let's go to Richard Alderman, please. That doesn't seem to be working. So Richard, perhaps we'll give it another try in a minute or 2. Let's go to Calum Emslie, please. There appears to be a technical issue as well. Calum, can you hear us? No, that doesn't seem to be working. Let's try James Sparrow, please. James, can you hear us? Turn on your microphone. Hello, James. This seems really unfortunate, Calum and James, we have both of you in the webcast at this point, but neither of you is -- we can't hear either of you here in the room. That seems really unfortunate. So let's -- we have Richard once more, Richard, let's give it a try with you. Richard, your microphone appears to be switched on, but unfortunately, we're unable to hear you here in the room. Look, if you're having trouble raising or switching on a microphone, I know I had said that you shouldn't use the chat, but we might as well reverse that.
Marcel Münch
executiveOkay, so if you drop your question in the chat, we ought to be able to tackle it right now. We're trying to stay flexible here and respond to the many questions you have on this call. So we'll give you a few seconds to type your questions in, and then we'll try to handle them that way. All right. I believe we have a question from a little earlier, but it came from James, and I think we answered it, about Transnet. And — okay, there we have the question Richard raised. So let me repeat it. Can you please tell me whether you need to see the coal foundation reactivated in 2023 in order to hit the 2028 deadline? And do you have an outstanding cost or costing that needs approval? Well, I think what lies behind that question is whether we had implicitly assumed a coal foundation would be put in place in Germany as part of our ambitions to become — or to exit coal in 2028. And Thomas, would you like to take that?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYes, absolutely. Richard, thanks a lot for that question. And I’m sorry, actually, that we’re having some technical problems here. No, we did not assume that any coal foundation would be set up, either for hard coal or for lignite. So no, that isn’t among the assumptions underlying our coal exit by 2028.
Marcel Münch
executiveThanks, Thomas. So let me check whether there are additional questions coming in through the chat, or whether Orlando would like to take another shot — we may as well do that, since Orlando, it has worked on your end.
Orlando Finzi
analystHonestly, it might actually work better on a mobile device than on the office computer, funny enough. That's just my own experience, though — it's a very clever technology. Can I just check something — obviously, I guess we're all quite relieved that the energy crisis has played out the way it has so far, which is probably better than anyone feared. But obviously, it isn't solved as we head toward next winter, where, obviously, a huge amount of effort has been made and is still ongoing to try to avoid crisis. But can I just ask, from an EnBW perspective, how are you prepared in case there is greatly increased volatility again? How do you think it might impact you or not, given you have the knowledge now? Of course, given you don't have the same exposure to gas contracts that you did in 2022. But just to check on that, because clearly, the problem, if you like, isn't fixed yet. So we live with it and have to deal with it, and it's uncertainty.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveUncertainty definitely remains, Orlando, and I completely agree with that. My view is that the energy crisis hasn't finished yet, particularly if you look toward next winter. That said, from the standpoint of earnings, we really shouldn't take a negative hit from it. What it comes down to is more a matter of supply security for the coming winter. As of today I'm optimistic, because gas storage volumes remain very high. So I believe we could reach gas storage at 100% by the start of winter. We also have to make sure sufficient coal is available to us. Inventory is on hand, and we're ensuring there's enough coal to carry us through the winter. So on earnings I'm not especially worried. Volatility will persist and could rise again. As for the remaining supply security, with the LNG terminal now coming online, we ought to be able to manage it. Does that address your question, Orlando?
Orlando Finzi
analystYeah, that's really helpful. And perhaps I can just build on what was asked there. Clearly, given the plan to shut the coal plant in 2028, you obviously have to keep it available until then. How do you — when it comes to getting the balance right on the amount of coal stock, the coal stockpile for generation, and then also thinking about winding it down, how would you achieve that balance? How do you strike it? Is that hard? Or is it reasonably manageable?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveIf we tried to close our coal plants right away, that would be tough. Not if you're looking at 2028, for a range of different reasons. To begin with, by that date we ought to have our 3 gas-fired plants available as well — by 2026, to be exact — and that certainly helps. And those plants would still be connected to the grid — in the market — come 2028. We should then be in a position to plan properly and use down the coal inventories at each site before shutting things down. And it's possible those plants could also be placed into grid reserve; that remains to be seen. So that doesn't worry us. I think we'll therefore have the necessary levels — coal levels — in place to draw them down by 2028, or indeed to make sure there's sufficient coal for grid reserve. So no, that's not a concern for us. Definitely not.
Marcel Münch
executiveCalum has another question in the chat now — I believe he ran into trouble using his microphone or unmuting it. Thomas, I'll direct this one right to you: could you say something about the press reports that the German government is considering nationalizing the electricity TSOs? Have we taken part in those discussions? Do we have a view on whether Germany ought to combine all the TSOs into one functional group? And would we be willing to hold only a minority stake in that?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRight. I mean, we aren't part of those kinds of conversations. Word has reached us that such talks are, up to a point, still going on — though honestly I'm not certain about the scale or how serious they really are. What we see right now, and what appeared in the press, is that the German government is at present discussing raising its stake in TenneT. As of today it has no effect on us, and none either on our process of selling down 49.9% of our TSO business, TransnetBW. So for the time being we're relaxed about it, and we honestly don't see any need to get any further involved in those kinds of discussions. Yes.
Marcel Münch
executiveCalum, I realize you can't respond to us directly, but hopefully we can get to what you asked. Now, I don't know if anyone else would like to ask something, either through the chat or by joining the webcast. Just so everyone has a chance to bring up any points. Andrew is here with us again — Andrew, let's give it one last try and see whether the microphone is working on your side.
Andrew Moulder
analystActually, one thing just struck me. You mentioned VNG being more profitable and larger dividends down the road. But clearly, you called off those Russian contracts, which happened at the end of 2022. So given today's market conditions, I would assume replacing that Russian gas would have cost you far more than the contracts you originally held. So will we truly see VNG's profits rise, and why?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveTo frame it that way — those 2 contracts we held for Russian gas. First off, we aren't nearly as hugely profitable as you may imagine. Second, yes, they made money, naturally, but not on the scale you'd probably suppose. For starters, the regulated side makes up the larger share of VNG's business. Also, the price level on the gas market right now differs from what it was in prior years. So all in all, we genuinely see a strong opportunity for VNG moving ahead as well, even though it won't have the advantage of those 2 Russian gas contracts.
Marcel Münch
executiveThank you, Andrew. As far as I can tell, no further questions have come in through the chat, and nobody else has raised a hand, so I believe we're getting close to wrapping up this call. So thank you, Andreas. Thank you, Thomas, for the answers and comments you gave. And thank you to everyone joining us on the webcast for making the time, and also for your patience and for the effort you put in to try to overcome the technological challenges. It's a real pleasure to have you with us in the stream, and we very much look forward to welcoming you back when we present our figures for the first quarter 2023 on our next conference call on May 12. Until then, all the best and goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.