EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 11, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Marcel Münch
executiveGood day, everyone, and welcome from me too. We appreciate your presence on today's call with investors and analysts regarding EnBW's results covering the first 6 months of 2023. In just a moment, our CFO, Thomas Kusterer, will walk you through the specifics of how our business has developed along with our outlook. Following that, as is customary, we're eager to hear your comments and questions. So without further delay, I'll pass things straight over to Thomas. The floor is yours.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks, Marcel, and hello everyone, a warm welcome from my side as well. Earlier today, we released our numbers for the first 6 months 2023. As we already announced, adjusted EBITDA at group level rose by 65% to EUR 3.5 billion during the first 6 months of this year, as stated on August 4. In this connection, it's worth noting that we've chosen to reclassify asset-related temporary valuation effects out of adjusted EBITDA and into a nonoperating EBITDA, effective from now on, so that the economic success of our segment Sustainable Generation Infrastructure is better reflected. I'll come back to that shortly. Turning to the rest of 2023, we confirm our forecast for financial year 2023 of adjusted EBITDA between EUR 4.7 billion and EUR 5.2 billion. As we see it today, we anticipate a result toward the upper end of the bandwidth, despite the impact stemming from the reclassification of valuation effects. The liquidity position of EnBW Group, at close to EUR 6 billion, remains very comfortable as of June 30, 2023. On top of that, we still have undrawn credit facilities totaling more than EUR 6 billion available to us. That's the brief summary of the financial situation. Ladies and gentlemen, allow me to go on with some developments that have occurred since our previous investor and analyst conference call.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAs the sole fully integrated utility operating in Germany, we keep pushing hard to advance the energy transition overall. That also opens up considerable investment possibilities for us, and through 2025 we anticipate gross CapEx of roughly EUR 14 billion spanning every business area. With that in mind, our attention stays fixed on the energy transition's three sides at once: growing renewables, expanding grid infrastructure, and scaling up low-CO2 dispatchable generation. Given how electricity generation is shifting, the large-scale build-out of grid infrastructure is an essential piece. In February 2022, EnBW said it would examine ways to bring in long-term investment partners holding a minority stake of as much as 49.9% in TransnetBW, 1 of the 4 electricity transmission grid operators in Germany, to help grow our overall balanced portfolio. By the end of May, we disclosed that a 24.95% stake in TransnetBW is being sold to a consortium made up of over 30 banks, insurance companies and pension funds from Baden-Württemberg. In addition, KfW Bank, which is owned by the German state, holds an option to buy a further 24.95% stake under the same conditions as the consortium's offer. Talks with KfW continue.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveWe anticipate reaching the final investment decision once the summer break in Berlin is over. The deal should close within the next few months. In Q2, we also hit important milestones on He Dreiht, our 960 megawatts offshore wind farm, to speed up renewables expansion. Before construction began, we agreed to divest a 49.9% minority stake to a consortium made up of Allianz Capital Partners, AIP and Norges Bank. In addition, EnBW signed 4 long-term power purchase agreements totaling 335 megawatts with financially very strong off-takers: Fraport, Evonik, Salzgitter and Bosch. Finally, we obtained 2 long-term loans to fund our portion of the construction budget. Back in December 2022, we arranged a EUR 600 million long-term financing from the European Investment Bank, one of the world's largest financiers of climate action and environmental sustainability. Then in April this year, we signed a EUR 500 million loan with a consortium of 3 banks, backed by the Danish export credit insurer, EIFO. As a result, He Dreiht is already fully funded. Beyond that, in May we decided to invest roughly EUR 280 million to expand our pumped storage power plant in Forbach. That project represents the third element of the energy transition triangle: low-CO2 dispatchable power generation.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThe current site is going to be upgraded and converted into a pumped storage power plant with high capacity, so that it delivers dispatchable capacity along with storage reservoirs capable of quickly supplying electricity whenever it's needed. That makes the plant an ideal match for growing our renewable capacity, and it will help create stability. Work gets underway later in 2023, and we expect it to be finished by the end of 2027. Finally, a few remarks about how our CO2 intensity is developing; in our integrated annual report 2022 we had projected a 10% reduction in the best case and a 5% increase in the worst case relative to 2022. During the first half of 2023, we observed the energy market environment stabilizing increasingly, with market prices and spreads now below what we originally expected for 2023. Our hard-fought procurement volumes over the first 6 months fell by 44% versus the prior year. Along with the damage-related outage at -- of our power plant in Heilbronn, weaker market prices and spreads brought about a reduction in electricity generation from our core power products. On that basis, we now anticipate CO2 intensity for the full year 2023 will decline by 10% to 25% relative to 2022.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLadies and gentlemen, at this point let's take a closer look at the numbers for the first 6 months of 2023. I'd like to begin with operating earnings, which you'll find on Slide 3. As we said at the outset, starting with the first half of 2023, we chose to reclassify temporary valuation effects tied to assets out of adjusted EBITDA and into nonoperating EBITDA, so that the economic success of our Sustainable Generation Infrastructure segment is reflected even more accurately. Under our hedging strategy, we hedge the generation margin as much as 3 years ahead against commodity price fluctuations. Per IFRS 9, valuation effects stemming from these hedging transactions connected to our generation assets have to be recognized at fair value. What that means is that when market prices fall relative to the hedge level, a profit must be recorded, or a loss when prices rise. Such temporary effects reverse once the product that was hedged has been delivered — for example, once a megawatt of electricity has been produced. For 2023 year-to-date, that means EUR 1.7 billion of unrealized earnings now appear within our nonoperating results. Meanwhile, we restated the results for the first 6 months of 2022, moving unrealized losses of roughly EUR 700 million into nonoperating EBITDA.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat, in turn, raised adjusted EBITDA for the same period a year earlier by an identical amount. Even with this reclassification, we delivered a very strong financial performance during the first 6 months of 2023, posting adjusted EBITDA of EUR 3.5 billion. That represents growth of roughly 65% against the restated figures for last year. The rise in adjusted EBITDA came mainly from higher hedge prices, together with the fact that last year's 6 months figures took a negative hit from the curtailment of Russian gas supplies and the resulting cost of replacing shortfall in gas volumes at our subsidiary, VNG. On the back of that adjusted EBITDA development, adjusted group net profit likewise climbed significantly, by almost EUR 850 million versus the corresponding period in 2022. Let's now dive deeper into our operating segments on Slide 4. Adjusted EBITDA in Smart Infrastructure for Customers came in significantly below the prior year level, at EUR 21 million. The substantial decline is attributable largely to charges of about EUR 250 million related to the deconsolidation of a gas supply company as well as the associated write-down on receivables. Moreover, as anticipated, gas volume -- gas sales volumes reduced meaningfully due to milder weather and savings behavior.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLower seasonality in procurement prices relative to the prior year played a big part in easing this. I should note as well that, given the current market conditions, churn rates for electricity and gas sales came in under last year's level. On Slide 5, adjusted EBITDA for our System Critical Infrastructure segment rose 70% versus the prior year, reaching roughly EUR 1 billion. Two effects largely drove that increase: first, significant revenue growth stemming from higher investments in grid expansion; and second, because revenue caps are higher, grid usage charges this year already incorporate the expenses anticipated for grid reserve and re-dispatch to keep supply secure. Moving to Slide 6, let me discuss Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, the segment where earnings grew most substantially relative to 2022. Adjusted EBITDA climbed significantly to EUR 2.607 billion across the first 6 months of 2023, up from the prior year period. Let's examine in more detail how the 2 components of this business segment performed, beginning with Renewable Energies. Adjusted EBITDA there rose slightly, by 3.2%, to EUR 565 million. During the first half of 2023, we observed a favorable earnings trend from run-of-river electricity generation.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveIn addition, we managed to boost the installed capacity of our renewable projects by roughly 200 megawatts. Several wind and solar farms in France and Germany have been brought into commission. The favorable earnings development from those added capacities was nearly cancelled out by the effect of declining prices in the direct marketing of volumes produced from wind and photovoltaics. Conversely, adjusted EBITDA in Thermal Generation and Trading rose sharply during the first 6 months of 2023 versus 2022, arriving at a level of EUR 2.042 billion. The main reason is that we succeeded in locking in earnings at higher price levels in 2022 by hedging our generation margin as much as 3 years ahead, an approach we have kept unchanged even through periods of pronounced market volatility. Contracts get closed on a back-to-back basis, factoring in the expected generation volumes of our power plant portfolio. As a integrated utility, we gain from a natural hedge of own generation and sales activities, which offsets price movements in volatile times and a changing environment. Thanks to our energy management activities, higher electricity price levels exert a positive impact on EnBW's earnings when the output is hedged gradually.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRegarding 2023, we were already fully hedged by the close of last year. With that hedging approach in place, the spot market likewise presents chances for our trading team to trade around the assets when volatility occurs. Adjusted EBITDA in our Thermal Generation and Trading segment was also helped by the fact that the comparable prior-year periods carried substantial negative effects stemming from gas supply curtailments caused by the Russian-Ukraine war. Since every supply contract with Russian counterparties had been terminated by the end of 2022, that negative impact is no longer present. Lastly, electricity output at the nuclear power station Neckarwestheim II was lower than a year earlier, as the final shutdown occurred on April 15, 2023. On Slide 7, a few remarks about how our retained cash flow developed in the first 6 months 2023. Beginning with significantly higher adjusted EBITDA of almost EUR 3.5 billion, we recorded a cash outflow of EUR 418 million for income taxes and of EUR 187 million for contributions covering pension and nuclear liabilities. Funds from operations reached close to EUR 2.9 billion, which was also significantly above last year. After accounting for higher declared dividends of EUR 639 million, retained cash flow came to EUR 2.238 billion and therefore surpassed the corresponding period 2022 by roughly EUR 800 million.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveTurning to Slide 8, I'd like to walk you through how net debt developed. In the first 6 months of 2023, retained cash flow was mostly offset by 2 factors: a rise in net debt tied to relevant working capital of roughly EUR 1.8 billion — driven largely by a lower positive margin balance, plus higher receivables stemming from the rollout of the electricity and gas price breaks, which is fairly temporary in nature — and net investments of about EUR 1.6 billion. Within System Critical Infrastructure, we put around EUR 770 million into expanding capacity, renewing the distribution grid, and executing the electricity network development plan. Over EUR 600 million went into Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, including almost EUR 440 million for renewables — chiefly our offshore wind farm, He Dreiht, in the German North Sea, on which the final investment decision was made in March. The remainder was mostly allocated to our fuel switch projects in Baden-Württemberg. On top of that, the discount rate used to calculate our pension provisions edged down from 3.7% to 3.6%, lifting pension provisions by EUR 78 million. Adding all of these effects together, net debt stood at EUR 11.95 billion as of June 30, 2023 — roughly EUR 1 billion higher than at the end of December 2022.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveLadies and gentlemen, I'd like to wrap up today's presentation by turning to Slide 9 and our outlook for 2023. Drawing on prior and anticipated developments, we reaffirm our guidance for group-level adjusted EBITDA in 2023 of between EUR 4.7 billion and EUR 5.2 billion. That said, as we already noted, from where we stand today we anticipate landing at the top end of that forecast range. With that in mind, we now expect to come in below the segment guidance of between EUR 400 million and EUR 500 million for intelligent infrastructure for customers, driven by the charges stemming from the deconsolidation of a gas supply company and the related write-down on receivables. Beyond that, we still anticipate declining volatilities and a normalizing market in the B2B and B2C commodity business as competition intensifies. Conversely, stable to slightly higher earnings from expansion in our new business areas are producing an offsetting effect. Within System Critical Infrastructure, we continue to anticipate a substantial rise versus last year, with adjusted EBITDA of between EUR 1.6 billion and EUR 1.9 billion. The adverse impacts seen in 2022 related to grid reserve and re-dispatch no longer carry over into 2023, given that the empirical values from 2022 have now been incorporated into the 2023 revenue cap.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAdditionally, grid revenues are set to rise marginally, driven by greater investments in projects tied to the electricity and gas grid development plan. Finally, in Sustainable Generation Infrastructure, we anticipate surpassing the segment guidance of EUR 2.9 billion to EUR 3.2 billion, thanks to a substantial earnings increase in Thermal Generation and Trading. That favorable earnings trend in this segment stems chiefly from elevated hedge prices and spreads. That said, given how unusually seasonal earnings distribution has been in recent years and with our nuclear plant Neckarwestheim II now fully shut down, we expect adjusted EBITDA for the second half of 2023 to come in below the first 6 months' level. Considering the very strong overall results in the first half of 2023, we remain vigilant and are closely watching developments both in energy markets broadly and across our business areas as we enter fall and the approaching winter period 2023-'24. With that, I'll turn things over to the operator to begin the Q&A session.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Andrew Moulder.
Andrew Moulder
analystI held back for a moment about letting someone else take the first question. But given that I'm on the line, I wanted to clarify a bit what you mean when you discuss net debt and when you're examining the movement in net debt related to working capital. I notice you have a slide in the deck, Slide 14, that actually displays a EUR 4.1 billion swing in working capital along with a couple of other items. So I don't fully follow why those don't show up in your net debt. I suppose you're arguing that certain items will be recovered, and therefore they won't affect net debt over the long term. But could you walk me through the reasoning there a little? And also, just so I'm clear on what you're doing with EBITDA regarding unrealized earnings, are you genuinely saying that it's really the mark-to-market derivative impact that you're now stripping out of EBITDA and shifting into nonoperating earnings? And lastly, I really wanted to ask — since we've heard a lot from the renewables companies, RWE, Ørsted and so on, I'm just curious what your view is on the profitability of offshore wind.
Andrew Moulder
analystSo when I look at your portfolio — and sure, He Dreiht is in there. But the following 2, I believe, involve BP, a joint venture in the Irish Sea and one in Scotland as well. What's the view on how profitable those projects will be? I mean, my sense is you paid a fairly hefty amount for those in a lease round, or at least the one your Irish team did. Is your expectation still that they're profitable? What steps are you taking to lock in costs on those projects? How is BP approaching it, this partnership with you? So if you could also just comment, please, on offshore wind profitability in general. And I suppose, what happens should those projects not proceed? Are you continuing to look for other active projects in the U.K.? That's all for now.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, good to hear from you. I'll begin with your third question, on offshore wind. Yes, what we're seeing right now is that competition is heating up. We saw that in the German auction. That said, when I look at our pipeline — and you're right that we have the procurement fully secured here — we don't have any issues at all when it comes to rising price levels. Of course, the situation differs for our project in the U.K. That one is still in the design phase, so it's still early days. And we are seeing price levels rise there. On the other hand, first of all, we still believe we've secured the most attractive sites. And at the same time, we're also seeing energy prices — electricity prices — going up. And we still have the option, at some point in time, to either enter into a CfD or actually go to the market. So as we see it today, that's our view, and from what I understand, it's also BP's view. We still have profitable projects on hand here, and we would expect that we'll be able to get these projects built and connected to the grid by the end of this decade.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveStill, it's early days, though. This project remains in its design phase. As I said at the outset, competition overall is picking up. And we've observed that 2 oil majors succeeded in the German auctions. In fact, there are more options still to come. And as you're aware, offshore wind isn't our only focus. We do have a broad portfolio along with investment opportunities across various areas. So overall, we're not worried. And in fact, we continue to believe offshore wind is moving ahead. It will be a profitable business, since offshore wind is something we do need. So going forward, we'll find a balance between cost and returns in this business segment as well. That covers your third question. I hope that answers what you asked. On EBITDA, yes, you're absolutely right. What we're discussing here is unrealized earnings or losses. It concerns the standalone valuation of derivatives. So effectively, under IFRS 9, you're looking at just one leg of the hedge. And the economic value of this transaction becomes visible upon delivery. Delivery of electricity — that's typically what we're hedging. So we believe it's more accurate and more transparent to place those effects in the nonoperating result going forward rather than in the adjusted EBITDA.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveIt wasn't relevant or material until the end of 2021. That's the reason we included it in the prior year within our operating results. But given the high prices and the volatility, it does make sense going forward to account for it in nonoperating earnings. And your first question was, if I understood it correctly, actually, why we didn't reflect that in our working capital? Was that what you were asking?
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah, just — I mean, when you discussed your net debt, you were referring to the shift in net debt tied to relevant working capital. But looking at your Slide 14, I can see that the overall movement in working capital comes to roughly EUR 4.1 billion. And I was just wondering why those other 2 items aren't being included in the fountain.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI've got it. Regarding how we present net debt, yes, that's completely clear, Andrew — every movement in cash, every change that has a cash impact, sits inside our net debt figure, and valuation effects do not.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, so that's pretty much identical to what you're already doing with EBITDA, right?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYeah, almost—not entirely, because the way we present net debt is that we include everything affecting cash rather than valuation. That's the approach behind our net debt figures. And the adjustments we've made to operating results are purely a valuation effect. That's the reason those adjustments aren't part of our net debt numbers.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, let me return to Slide 14, which sort of illustrates the gap between the EUR 1.8 billion you describe as relevant and the EUR 4.1 billion total. Surely you still need funds on hand to cover any shortfalls — at least when it comes to temporary financing arrangements for the EEG fund, and for cash-relevant derivatives as well. Isn't that right?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI'll pass things along to Marcel, since he's far more immersed in this subject than I am.
Marcel Münch
executiveAndrew, first off, many thanks for bringing that up, since it's extremely pertinent what Thomas already mentioned, and allow me to emphasize that point once more. The net debt number you observe takes in every cash position we hold and, clearly, every debt position too, correct, no matter whether those are cash effects tied to adjusted EBITDA or to nonoperating EBITDA, all right? So every cash movement shows up in net debt. That said, as Thomas noted, our adjusted EBITDA now leaves out valuation effects. Those are temporary by nature and they reverse in later periods. That said, once more, some of these valuation effects connect to margin movements, since we've hedged positions and we either receive or pay margins. So these margins do carry a cash impact, and they sit inside our net debt. Yet because we begin from an adjusted EBITDA that excludes valuation effects, we cannot put the entire delta in working capital into our net debt range. That's the first aspect. And the second aspect, also laid out on Page 14, and you're aware of it, is that we exclude the EEG funds from the net debt position we present, since those funds are effectively ring-fenced and cannot be used for operating purposes.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright. Fine. Yeah, I'm generalizing.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI hope that made clear what you...
Andrew Moulder
analystRight, I understand the overall picture. I’ll review it carefully and then get back to you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveBeyond that, you’re welcome to reach out to us at any point.
Andrew Moulder
analystYes, I will. Yes, absolutely.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> It looks like there are no more questions at this point. I'll now turn things back over to Marcel Munch for some closing remarks.
Marcel Münch
executiveYes. Thomas, thank you for your answers and comments. And thank you to everyone on the call for making the time. We look forward to welcoming all of you back when we present our figures for the first 9 months of 2023 on our next conference call, which is scheduled for November 30. Until then, we wish all of you the best. Have a good weekend now, and goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.