EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG (EBK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 12, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and welcome to EnBW's Investor and Analyst Conference Call covering the results for the first nine months of 2024. This is Sergeant, the Chorus Call operator speaking. Please be aware that everyone attending is in listen-only mode and that this conference is being recorded. A Q&A session will come after the presentation. To register a question, you may press star and one on your phone at any point. Should you need operator assistance, just press star and zero. Recording this conference for publication or broadcast is not permitted. Right now, I'm pleased to introduce Lenka Zikmundova, Head of Investor Relations. Over to you.
Lenka Zikmundová
executiveAppreciate that, Sergeant. Good afternoon, everyone. Glad to have you on our call covering the first nine months of this year. As always, our Deputy CEO and CFO, Thomas Kusterer, is here with me, and he'll take you through the presentation. After that, we'll open the lines for your questions. So with that, Thomas, over to you for the update on the first nine months of 2024.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThank you, Lenka, and a warm welcome to everyone. As always, we appreciate your interest in our company. Today, we are pleased to report a solid financial performance in the first nine months of 2024. As expected, with the market normalization, declining power prices continue to feed through. But thanks to our robust integrated setup, we were able to deliver a solid result across the group. With adjusted EBITDA at EUR 3.7 billion and adjusted net profit at EUR 1.3 billion, we reiterate our full-year EBITDA guidance for 2024 for all segments, as well as at group level. We also continue to deliver on our strategy towards the green transition of the energy system. This has been rewarded recently by MSCI, which upgraded our sustainability rating into the ESG leader category, in particular for our environmental achievements, granting us a double E score. This upgrade reflects our continued successful transformation. Needless to say, we remain dedicated to further strengthening our company's position in terms of sustainability and to further improve in the relevant ESG ratings. In October, we reached an important milestone in diversifying our funding sources and issued two green senior bonds with a total volume of EUR 1 billion on the Australian capital market under a new AMTN program.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThis milestone deal represents the first ever kangaroo bond issue by any German utility in Australia, and it gives us entry to an appealing market with fresh investors. The debut EUR 1 billion dual tranche is already being used as a funding source for 2025. Just before the issuance, Moody's confirmed EnBW's Baa1 rating with a stable outlook. Moving on to operational progress, EnBW remains on track with its green growth projects. At present we have roughly 1.5 GW of renewable energy projects in construction. Among them is our flagship offshore wind farm at He Dreiht, where all 64 foundations are now installed. In addition, to reach the highest possible level of noise reduction for protecting life below water, a double-walled noise mitigation template was designed specifically for this project. As you'll remember, He Dreiht is set to begin operations in late 2025, and the project is fully on track. In September, we successfully secured seven solar projects in a German public solar tender. Those projects, totaling 184 MW of capacity, managed through this tender to secure a revenue stream for roughly 90 megawatts over 20 years. There's also good news on the recent progress of SuedLink, a major electricity transmission project in Germany.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThen there's a different stretch of that important DC line being built in our home area, Baden-Württemberg. Only a few weeks back, the first fire — what people call hot commissioning — got underway at one of the three hydrogen-ready plants we have, so the new gas-fired turbine could be fine-tuned and tested. Full official commissioning is scheduled for 2025. That said, let me return to the financials. As I noted earlier, during the first nine months of 2024 our business kept performing as expected, even with market conditions more normalized, posting group-adjusted EBITDA of EUR 3.7 billion. Low-risk operations — our grids plus the renewable business — made up EUR 2.6 billion of adjusted EBITDA, which equals 71% of total earnings for the first nine months of this year, versus 57% during the same stretch of 2023. Now let's move to our business segments, beginning on slide 4 with sustainable generation infrastructure, where adjusted EBITDA came in at almost EUR 2 billion. Let's zoom in a bit on renewables. Adjusted EBITDA reached EUR 876 million. The cause of the year-over-year decline is unchanged from prior months. It stems from realized electricity prices staying persistently lower, chiefly at pumped storage, which results in a reduced margin.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveEarnings were bound to fall off following the unusually high power prices seen a year earlier, and stronger offshore wind conditions plus greater run-of-river output could only partly make up for that. In thermal generation and trading, adjusted EBITDA came in at EUR 1.1 billion, also shaped by much weaker power and commodity prices and by less volatility when operating our gas storage assets. To give that number some perspective, the third quarter is normally the weakest one for EBITDA contribution from power generation across the entire year. So the outcome lines up quite well with what we had anticipated. On hedge levels, we are fully hedged for this year, above 90% for 2025, between 50% and 80% for 2026, and already as much as 40% for 2027. Turning to the system-critical infrastructure segment, which covers our electricity and gas transmission and distribution grids: adjusted EBITDA there reached EUR 1.8 billion over the first nine months. That is a rise of 24% versus last year, driven by greater income from investments in our grid businesses throughout the group and by lower spending on grid reserve and redispatch. Those gains were partly countered by higher personnel costs in both our transmission and distribution grid operations.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveMoving to segment three, smart infrastructure for customers, where adjusted EBITDA rose modestly to EUR 233 million. What matters most here is how one of the effects has diminished. The prior year took a hit, chiefly from deconsolidating our subsidiary BMP Greengas and, to a smaller degree, from incidents at SENEC, our solar home storage subsidiary. During the first nine months of this year, the counteracting factors were heavier burdens from restructuring the product portfolio at SENEC — among them the battery module replacement and marketing expenses — plus weaker sales volumes in our B2B gas business. Now on to our investments. Capital spending for the first nine months of 2024 came to almost EUR 3.9 billion, a substantial rise of almost 40% versus the prior-year figure. Nearly 90% of those expenditures were taxonomy-aligned, and 85% went to growth projects tied to the energy transition, with the remainder being investments in retrofitting existing assets. Over 40% of our gross investments went into sustainable generation infrastructure — mainly developing and building our offshore activities in Germany and the U.K., along with our three hydrogen-ready gas power plants. A bit more than 44% of our CapEx was directed into system-critical infrastructure, centered on expanding and modernizing our electricity transmission and distribution grids.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThe rest of the investments were directed toward smart infrastructure for customers, largely tied to expanding our e-mobility charging infrastructure further. Divestments and co-financing contributions from partners — especially for our offshore wind farm here at He Dreiht and our transmission grid operator, TransnetBW — matched the prior year's level. The relatively high divestments in the previous year stemmed from the sale of a minority interest in He Dreiht during the third quarter of 2023. Now let's briefly review our retained cash flow on page eight. Across the first nine months, retained cash flow reached almost EUR 1.5 billion, consistent with how adjusted EBITDA developed. On top of that, the year-on-year decline was driven by higher dividends paid, along with non-cash items reflected in prior year's adjusted EBITDA. Ladies and gentlemen, as shown on page nine, net debt rose by 14% to EUR 13.3 billion, primarily driven by our significant net cash investments totaling EUR 3.4 billion. Key counterbalancing factors were the green hybrid issuance at the start of this year, with 50% classified as equity, and a reduction in pension provisions of roughly EUR 200 million, resulting from higher discount rates.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveJust remember that our investments—especially in the grid—are weighted more heavily toward the end of the year, so net debt will reflect a further rise in gross investments during the fourth quarter. In addition, redeeming the green hybrid on November 5th will affect net debt by EUR 250 million. Consequently, by year-end we expect net debt to be higher than the Q3 level, and our debt repayment potential should align with our guidance of 13%-16% retained cash flow in relation to net debt. Lastly, turning to guidance for the fiscal year 2024: as noted earlier, we confirm our full-year guidance. Given resilient performance across the first nine months, we feel very comfortable with the guidance both for the segments and at group level. That concludes my presentation, and I now look forward to your questions.
Lenka Zikmundová
executiveThanks, Thomas. And now, ladies and gentlemen, we’ll begin the Q&A portion of EnBW’s call. Sergeant, please go ahead.
Operator
operatorIf you'd like to ask a question, you can press star and one on your touchtone phone. A tone will sound to let you know you've joined the queue. Should you want to drop out of the question queue, just press star and two. If you're on the phone with a question, we ask that you disable loudspeaker mode and also mute the volume from the webcast while you ask it. At this point, anyone with a question can press star and one. Our first question comes from Alessandra Mac Donald at BlackRock. Please go ahead.
Alessandra Mac Donald
analystHi, Thomas and Lenka. Thanks for the presentation today. If I may, I have three questions. The first one concerns the impact of the elections. I was just wondering about the EUR 3 billion capital increase that should be forthcoming in 2025 — does this funding come from the federal level or from the state level? I'm just trying to understand whether there is any risk that the funds will not be forthcoming. Then the second question is about the reduction in margins from pumped storage. I just wanted a little bit more color. If you could just explain a bit more what happened there. And then on the retail side, the reduction in volume, so there was a reduction in volumes of energy, if I understand correctly. So I'm just trying to understand the growth going forward. What is it driven by? Is it increasing margins that you expect, or was the growth the effect of the absence of negative one-offs? And that's it from me. Thank you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHello, Alessandra. I appreciate you joining and posing your questions. On your first one about how the elections might matter — there's no direct effect at all on the capital increase. As you know, the state of Baden-Württemberg is our shareholder base, rather than the federal level, along with municipalities here in Baden-Württemberg. So nothing touches us from what you might call the challenging situation at the federal level right now. On your second question — and tell me if I didn't quite catch it — it concerned pumped storage. Is that correct? And you were asking why earnings declined, is that right?
Alessandra Mac Donald
analystYes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thanks.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat's essentially because volatility has dropped quite a bit, particularly if you look at the spreads between peak and off-peak. So that reflects markets normalizing with less volatility. That's what you'd typically expect. Yeah. And regarding your third question, could you help me with your third question again, please.
Alessandra Mac Donald
analystRegarding the amounts of energy sold — I’m simply trying to get a handle on what’s driving energy supply. I understand you had some negatives last year, and now those negatives are gone, so there’s growth. But since the volumes of energy sold are lower, should I expect marginality to rise going forward or not? So will that growth come entirely from the absence of negative one-offs?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveRight, exactly. What drives the growth ahead is that those negative one-offs won't be there. A year ago, they came mostly from BMP Greengas, our subsidiary. This year we had some one-offs tied to SENEC. So those are one-offs that you shouldn't expect in the years ahead. And really, the reason we cut volumes in the B2B gas business is that we judged the margins available there didn't match the overall risk profile. That's a smaller factor, though. It's more the one-off effects you just mentioned. Looking ahead, we do expect sales to rise and growth in our customer segment.
Alessandra Mac Donald
analystSo are you saying you expect an increase, or that you don't expect one?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveYes. We do. We do.
Alessandra Mac Donald
analystAll right, all right, all right. Thanks. Thanks a lot.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThanks for joining us.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Andrew Moulder of CreditSights. You may proceed.
Andrew Moulder
analystHello, Thomas. Hello, Lenka. Hello, Alessandra — she beat me to it there. Yeah, actually, may I just pick up on one of the questions she raised? Since she asked about the capital increase.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveI wasn't 100% sure that this was definitely going to move forward. I mean, my impression was that you were kind of talking it over and examining alternatives and different possibilities. But based on your response, I now take it that a EUR 3 billion capital increase is definitely going to take place, I guess, next year. Is that correct? It isn't certain. Still, there's actually a high likelihood that we will see this capital increase during the next year. At present we are in close contact with both of our main shareholders, the state of Baden-Württemberg, and the municipalities. And as things look today, there's a high likelihood that we will go down that road next year.
Andrew Moulder
analystOkay, alright. May I just pose a few additional questions to you? Really just a couple regarding renewables. Concerning PPAs for renewables, on the Fortum conference call they mentioned pay-as-produced PPAs and said demand for that structure was declining, with people not willing to sign up for them. I'm curious whether you are observing the same trend. And if signing pay-as-produced PPAs isn't possible, what steps are you taking to mitigate risk on your end given the fluctuations in renewable output? Then my second renewables question: I've come across several reports suggesting BP intends to scale back its offshore renewables operations. Naturally, you hold a couple of lease areas won in the U.K. through joint ventures with BP. So I was wondering what your thinking is on those? I mean, if BP were to reduce their positions there, do you hold preemptive rights over them? Would you continue to move forward with them? Because I believe they were rather costly at the time. Could you perhaps offer a few comments about those joint ventures you have?
Andrew Moulder
analystI appreciate that.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAndrew, absolutely. I'll begin with your second question about the BP joint venture. We're in close contact with BP, and we don't foresee any effect from their plan to scale back their renewables business overall, since it doesn't touch our GB. If they do take any action, my understanding at least is that it would be at a broader or global level rather than at the GB level. So, from what we hear from them in our GB, the project is progressing well, and we see no impact at the operational level or in our conversations with senior management at BP. So there's no impact on this project whatsoever. On Fortum, I'm not sure exactly which markets they were referring to. At least here in the German market, we don't see that. We also offer PPAs, pay-as-produced, and we continue to see significant demand here. So not in our German market, at least not — that's not what we're seeing currently. And in any of the other offshore markets — I mean, in the Netherlands or Europe, doing PPAs there? We have no exposure of that kind there.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveOur exposure is limited to the German market—both offshore and onshore—and eventually at some point in the U.K., but for now it's only in Germany and, to some extent, actually, in France, though we don't see it in France either.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright. Good, and perhaps just one additional question. Alessandra inquired about the retail business. Could you maybe elaborate a bit on your outlook for retail going forward? Because it kind of strikes me that given the electrification we're seeing in Europe, I would have thought retail businesses would be growth businesses. I mean, do you view that as a major growth business going forward? Maybe not next year, but in five years' time, as I say, with the electrification we're seeing because of the energy transition.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveHonestly, there are two parts to my response on that. First, in the B2B retail segment, you could actually witness a shift away from the purely commodity-type operation toward something more complicated, and going forward that could genuinely work in our favor. Second, regarding our own particular operation — the customer-facing one — we're also examining the e-mobility charging infrastructure segment. Within that space, we anticipate considerable expansion over the coming years. So it comes down to a B2C commodity operation that is stable to growing, plus rising earnings from our charging infrastructure segment. Does that address what you asked?
Andrew Moulder
analystYeah, it does. That’s great. Thank you. Thanks, Thomas. All right.
Operator
operatorJust a quick reminder — if you’d like to ask a question, hit star and one on your phone. We’ve got a follow-up question from Alessandra Mac Donald at BlackRock. Go ahead, please.
Alessandra Mac Donald
analystHello, Thomas. I have a couple of questions, if that's alright. First, on personnel costs, I believe you said they went up — was that due to new hires, or was inflation the reason? And then, could you remind me how the derivative-related changes in your working capital actually function? Thank you.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveAlessandra, on the personnel expenses, it's both things. On one hand there's the tariff increase, and on the other hand it's also driven by growth in headcount. I mean, since we're investing heavily, we also need to add personnel. So it's both. There are extra expenses from tariff increases and from the additional personnel. On the working capital question, Alessandra — sorry, we have a bad line here. I didn't fully catch your second question about working capital. No worries. No worries. Sorry about that. I was looking at the working capital reported, and I think I don't have the slides in front of me, but you had a relatively large absorption due to the derivatives, if I remember correctly, and I was just wondering if you could remind me how those work, so when do you see an absorption and when is it then reversed? Okay. I mean, the derivatives relate to our trading business, and it very much depends on the valuation of these derivatives, and that actually very much depends on the wholesale market prices. And so we cannot give any kind of prediction, actually, for year-end how this is going to evolve.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThat’s one of the swings we do carry on our balance sheet, and it isn’t something we control. To put it plainly, though, all of that nets out once deliveries occur. So it’s purely the valuation effect, and there isn’t any kind of economic — there’s no economic value or risk sitting behind it. Does that kind of answer your question?
Alessandra Mac Donald
analystYeah, yeah, yeah. Thanks. Thanks, Thomas.
Thomas Kusterer
executivePerfect.
Operator
operatorThere's a follow-up question coming from Andrew Moulder at CreditSights. Please go ahead.
Andrew Moulder
analystYes. Thanks a lot. Just one quick question — you mentioned testing the hydrogen-ready power plant. I'm just curious what fuel you're actually testing it with, and if you're using a hydrogen blend, what kind of results are you seeing? I mean, when it comes to efficiency and when it comes to emissions, how is that going?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveNo, actually, how things stand right now — I mean, those units are hydrogen-ready. What that means is we have the ability to switch over to hydrogen, but at present they actually run on natural gas. So this has nothing to do with blending in hydrogen in any way. It's straight natural gas, in fact.
Andrew Moulder
analystSo how does that actually test a plant that's hydrogen-ready, then?
Thomas Kusterer
executiveBeing hydrogen-ready simply means that, should you choose to, you have the option of switching over to hydrogen. To do that, certain adjustments at the plant are required, but the whole setup is designed so that we can take hydrogen on board down the road. That said, it isn't something required for commissioning as things stand today. So it's a task that will need to be handled later on.
Andrew Moulder
analystAlright, thank you, Thomas.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveGlad to help.
Operator
operatorIf you'd like to ask something, just hit star and one on your phone once more. At this point, we don't have any further questions. I'll hand the conference back to Lenka Zikmundova now for any closing comments.
Lenka Zikmundová
executiveThank you. And again, I really appreciate it. To everyone who joined us on this call—thanks for tuning in. We appreciate the questions. And should anything else come up, please feel free to get in touch with our investor relations team. Take care, and enjoy the remainder of your day.
Thomas Kusterer
executiveThank you, and goodbye.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings us to the end of today's conference. We appreciate your choosing Chorus Call, and many thanks for joining us on the call. At this point you're welcome to disconnect your lines. Goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnBW Energie Baden-Württemberg AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.