Energizer Holdings, Inc. (ENR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 5, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jackie Burwitz
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. On this call, we'll go over what we achieved in Q1 of fiscal 2020. Please note this session is being recorded and can be replayed through the Investor Relations area on energizerholdings.com. You'll also find a slide deck on that site that gives more information about our performance and what we expect for the next year. Joining me are Alan Hoskins, our Chief Executive Officer; Mark LaVigne, President and Chief Operating Officer; and Tim Gorman, Chief Financial Officer. Today we might share thoughts regarding what we anticipate for upcoming initiatives, such as operating and financial results. Those types of remarks are forward-looking, representing how we currently see things that haven't happened yet. We'll also touch on non-GAAP financial metrics. You can see how those non-GAAP figures line up with comparable GAAP figures in the reconciliation included in the press release that came out earlier today, which is posted on our site. Any discussion of our segment and market share on this call covers the markets in which we operate and relies on approximations drawing on Energizer's own internal information, third-party industry research, and reasonable adjustments we consider appropriate. Unless noted otherwise, everything we share applies to the 13-week stretch that concluded in November. When we mention particular quarters or years, we mean our fiscal ones, and when we talk about the legacy and/or base business, we mean Energizer's operations before the Battery and Auto Care acquisition closed. I'd encourage investors to look at the risk factors described in our Form 10-K, 10-Q, and other SEC filings to understand the main elements that impact our business. Those risks could lead actual outcomes to vary significantly from what our forward-looking statements suggest. We're not committing to revise these forward-looking statements later. With all that said, I'll hand things over to Alan.
Alan Hoskins
executiveThank you, Jackie, and hello everybody. Prior to getting started, I want to express appreciation to everyone who took part in our Investor Day back in November; the curiosity shown toward Energizer means a lot, and our team truly cherishes the chance to sit down with so many of you and lay out where we're headed. Having the ability to introduce additional members of our leadership group and offer deeper perspective on the reasons we feel such enthusiasm regarding Energizer's future is something we deeply appreciate. During Investor Day, we explained how Energizer sits in a strong spot to become an industry leader as a diversified worldwide household products business spanning Batteries, Lights, and Auto Care, while also creating meaningful shareholder value. Our financial targets by the close of 2022 involve producing above $700 million in adjusted EBITDA along with greater than $400 million of adjusted free cash flow, which we would use to make strategic investments in the company. Reaching that means concentrating on the very strategies that have worked well for us from the moment of separation. Those are: innovate first, run with excellence, and push productivity throughout every business we operate. Thanks to these strategies, we can generate steady organic growth that outpaces our categories, put money into innovation as well as A&P, and secure more than $100 million of synergies by the time our acquisition reaches its third anniversary. Carrying out these strategies moves us toward building a robust, integrated enterprise holding a leading position across Batteries, Lights, and Auto Care. 2020 marks the initial complete year along the road toward hitting those financial targets we laid out at Investor Day. Results for our first quarter matched what we had anticipated, and we are confirming our output figures for the entire fiscal year. Tim will go deeper into the financial specifics for both the quarter and the full year afterward on this call, but I'd like to offer a few high-level remarks. Our organic net sales in batteries came in above what we expected, against the guidance calling for a decline in the mid-single digits that we gave on the fourth quarter call. I want to praise our colleagues for the way they executed through the holiday selling period, which included handling the shift of holiday display activity that arrived earlier than usual, moving out of the first quarter and into the prior year's fourth quarter. Turning to the rest of the year, we hold strong conviction in our forecast of 1% to 2% organic growth for 2020, since our team has locked in new distribution and widened shelf space with customers we already serve. When it comes to our Auto Care business, net sales performance in the first quarter landed in-line with what we projected, and that period is traditionally the year's smallest sales quarter. With the peak selling season drawing near, we sit in a solid position to hit our organic sales goals through broader distribution, fresh product innovation, higher A&P spending, and dependable high customer fill rates coming out of our Dayton facility. Mark will get into greater detail shortly, but we hit a number of significant integration milestones while experiencing very little disruption. The payoff from these efforts should show up over the balance of the year. The way we'll succeed in this fiscal year, and across the next several years, comes down to a few things. We deliver steady organic growth by being the partner our customers prefer. We put money into an innovation pipeline within A&P so that consumers switch to our brands no matter where they buy. And we capture the gains from major synergies as we build one strong combined company. In the end, this combination helps us produce robust EBITDA and free cash flow growth, which lets Energizer speed up earnings, cut debt, and keep paying a meaningful dividend. We're thrilled by the opportunities in front of us, and we stay committed to carrying out the plans already in motion so we meet our commitments in 2020 and create value for every one of our shareholders. Having said that, I'd like to hand the call to Mark so he can update us on our categories, business trends, and integration efforts.
Mark LaVigne
executiveThanks, Alan, and good morning, everyone. During the previous quarter, I noted that for fiscal 2020 our goals involve creating forward movement throughout our operations, and at the same time carrying out our integration initiatives exceptionally well. To start, let's review the overall battery category's positive trends. Before I get into the quarter's particular figures, I'd like to point out several dynamics that matter and should be remembered. Among them are the hurricane events from the comparable period 1 year earlier, Black Friday arriving later in the current year, and a certain amount of pantry stocking that took place because of Hurricane Dorian. Every one of these contributes to the category trends we're currently seeing; beyond those elements, on the value side, price hikes in the U.S. along with multiple international markets caused some movement between the category's premium and value segments. Keeping all this in view, across the latest 13-week stretch that concluded in November, worldwide battery value declined 1.1%, largely because of lapping the prior year's hurricane volume and Black Friday coming later than it typically does. If you set aside the effect of those things, worldwide battery category value would have risen by close to 1%, thanks to premium segment pricing in the U.S.; and Latin America, plus expansion in the price segment. To reinforce that idea, when you examine the 13-week figures ending in December, here in the U.S. we observed category value growth of 2%. During the November period, Energizer's value share across measured channels fell 1.8 points, the result of multiple influences: a competitor's launch of a new product, softer POS trends in the U.S. stemming from premium price increases, and more private label activity. Every one of those trends is fairly in line with what's occurred previously after competitive launches and price increases. Once these elements worked their way through the marketplace, we've watched trends start to steady and move back toward historical norms. Within the U.S. During the period that wrapped up in November, our e-commerce channel grew 9%, and both Energizer and Rayovac outperformed the category and gained share, together landing at a 32 share. Rayovac remains the fastest-growing brand online, since we're applying the same expertise that grew the Energizer brand. Overall, conditions in the U.S. commercial market held firm, as the category saw reduced promotional activity and a higher average unit price across the quarter; with that said, let's move on to our battery results. You may recall that in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2019, several large customers pulled holiday shipments forward, which drove stronger growth in that fourth quarter. Because of that, we expected first quarter net sales to decline at a mid-single digit rate; even so, net sales came in above expectations, falling at a low single digit rate, as we kept delivering strong results in non-measured channels within the U.S. We're continuing the worldwide introduction of the new Energizer visual identity, which gives prominent placement to our iconic brand characters, the Energizer Bunny and Mr. Energizer. Our new packaging has rolled out worldwide in retail, and shoppers keep reacting well to it, which fuels growth for both our brands and our retail partners. Looking ahead to the rest of the year, distribution gains remain a key focus for our teams. Actually, we've just landed some significant distribution agreements with several retailers in the U.S., and those ought to begin adding results in Q3 and Q4. Such wins underscore the confidence we have in our guidance, which projects organic growth of 1% to 2% for 2020. Turning now to the auto segment: on the whole, category value continues to climb in each of our four sub-segments, with value increasing 4.5% during the November reporting period, driven by appearance, chemicals and refrigerants, all three of which gained 10%. Performance chemicals and air fresheners each posted a 2% increase. During that same period, consumer takeaway improved for the Armor All and A/C Pro brands, reflecting solid execution along with the lift from favorable weather in September. On a year-over-year basis, the auto business we acquired saw a modest dip this quarter, but that was due to how shipments fell between Q1 and Q2. For our consolidated auto business, we expect a robust peak season across the second and third quarters. We have that confidence because of wider distribution, more spending on advertising and promotion, and fresh innovative items — among them Armor All extreme shield protectant and wipes, the A/C Pro extreme digital gauge, and STP intake valve cleaner. Those investments, along with fill rates close to 100% at our Dayton facility, make us confident that we'll give our customers and consumers outstanding products and service and achieve net sales growth of about 3.5%. We're also wrapping up our strategy for taking Auto Care into markets outside the U.S., and the aim there is to double net sales over the next three years, starting in fiscal year 2021. Last, let's talk about where things stand with integration; our integration plans keep moving forward with substantial progress. Synergies from the project came to $9 million for the quarter, and we anticipate delivering the rest of the $45 million to $50 million target before this fiscal year wraps up. We're tracking well toward hitting our overall synergy goal of more than $100 million by the time we've owned the business for three full years. Teams across our organization finished a number of major IT implementations at various sites during the quarter, and the business experienced only minimal disruption. Through this effort, we'll be able to bring our operations and support functions even closer together and make them more efficient. Thanks to these rollouts and the dedication of teams worldwide, we've now completed 90% of the transition services work with Spectrum Brands, and we intend to wrap up the rest of those agreements by the close of this year. The Varta divestiture is complete, and the other European businesses that came to us from Spectrum have been brought entirely onto our platform. Our multiyear program to simplify and improve the structure of our integrated supply chain is still moving forward as planned. This effort is going to cut down on complexity and generate bigger efficiencies across manufacturing, packaging, and distribution, which lets us serve customers better in every one of our categories. When it comes to batteries specifically, we're currently moving our North American Battery and Lights distribution together into one Indiana location, and we're also merging specialty battery output at our facility in portage Wisconsin. Over in Auto Care, we kept moving forward with a phased method of bringing manufacturing together at the Dayton Ohio site, along with establishing a consolidated distribution center. So far, these initiatives have been carried out exceptionally well and leave us strongly positioned as we head into the season. I'd like once more to recognize our colleagues throughout the business, who operate as one unified team and have accomplished a fantastic job forming a robust combined company. As we've said previously, we'll put synergies beyond our $100 million goal to work building capabilities and adding resources so we can create a multi-year innovation portfolio that we benchmark against our leading brands; to wrap up, our attention is on securing distribution and visibility for our brands, putting money into our brands and innovation, and carrying out the integration plan. This combination, we believe, sets us up very nicely to generate substantial long-term shareholder value. To hear more about the quarter's financial results, I'll hand things over to Tim.
Tim Gorman
executiveThank you, Mark, and hello everybody on this call. The press release contains our results, and my remarks can be followed in the slide deck posted on our website. My comments will center on what drove net sales and gross margin; during 2020 we anticipate finishing a number of significant milestones toward achieving our long-term financial goals. The initiatives Alan and Mark described are moving forward, and the headway made so far supports our confidence in restating the full-year guidance we gave before, which includes worldwide net sales rising 9% to 10%, with organic growth of 1% to 2% in combined battery and 3.5% growth in combined Auto Care; adjusted EBITDA between $610 million and $640 million; adjusted free cash flow between $310 million and $340 million; and adjusted earnings per share between $3.00 and $3.20. Quarterly net sales rose 29% to $737 million, lifted by the added net sales from businesses we acquired. Worldwide organic net sales fell 3.4%, better than the mid-single digit decrease we told you to expect on the fourth quarter call. Versus the year-ago period, organic net sales felt the effects of the items we described last quarter: softer point-of-sale trends caused by pricing moves; a competitor's product launch in batteries; and reduced replenishment volumes tied to Hurricane Dorian, which together accounted for 280 basis points of the decrease. Moving holiday shipments out of the first quarter and into the fourth quarter produced a negative effect of 240 basis points, while better pricing offset 180 basis points of the organic sales decline. Organic net sales dropped 5% in the Americas, whereas international net sales came in essentially flat versus the prior year. The following sale components bridge from the 2019 net sales base of $2.49 billion to our full-year net sales outlook. Added net sales from businesses we acquired will contribute $205 million to $210 million; we have largely cycled past the year-over-year comparability challenges the acquisitions created, except that the second quarter will include one additional month of incremental acquired Auto Care sales. Auto Care should grow roughly $50 million, matching the 3.5% organic growth we expect. That figure assumes a normal weather pattern during peak season, international distributor sales going back to usual order patterns, and roughly 2% category growth. Lastly, anticipated growth from battery and lights will add incremental net sales to the outlook of 1% to 2% organic growth. Shifting to gross profit, the gross margin rate for the first quarter came in at 41.8%, driven mainly by including the acquired businesses, whose margins are lower than those of our legacy business, plus further effects from incremental tariffs, channel mix and unfavorable overhead absorption stemming from reduced production volume. Foreign currency had a small unfavorable effect, which was less bad than anticipated. Furthermore, gains from battery price increases and synergies partly offset those negative effects. As you may remember, we closed out the previous year with a 42.1% gross margin rate during Q4. Moving from Q4 into this quarter, we’re seeing gains from pricing of roughly 70 basis points, plus synergies, though those are being offset by negative effects from unfavorable fixed overhead absorption, additional tariffs, and channel mix. The synergies Mark mentioned that we expect will play a key role in the gross margin outlook, along with better fixed cost absorption as we increase production to support growth in batteries, which is being driven by distribution gains and a strong peak selling season in Auto Care. For the full year, our gross margin outlook anticipates an improvement of 10 basis points to 40 basis points compared with last year. Given how our gross margin performed in Q1, we’re expecting an improvement of 200 basis points to 240 basis points across the rest of the year. These are the elements behind that improvement. Synergies add 140 basis points to 160 basis points, favorable commodity costs contribute 40 basis points to 50 basis points, and favorable fixed cost absorption contributes 80 basis points to 100 basis points. Working against these anticipated positive effects on our gross margin rate are additional tariffs and foreign currency headwinds. On the Q4 call, we talked about how currencies, tariffs, and Brexit could affect our business. With the events that have since taken place in the UK and the Phase 1 trade deal with China, we’ve updated our expected impact from tariffs and Brexit on 2020 results. We now estimate an incremental impact of roughly $8 million from tariffs in 2020 and no impact from Brexit during this fiscal year. Currency movements are more difficult to forecast. In the quarter, the U.S. dollar weakened against several of our major currency exposures. Although the negative effect on Q1 results was smaller than anticipated, we still faced a net sales headwind of $2.5 million, along with an unfavorable effect on net operating profit. Using current rates, including our hedge positions, we’ve factored a negative full-year impact of approximately $10 million into our outlook. Once we have greater visibility into how stable recent trends are, we’ll look at adjusting this outlook. The better outlook for currency, tariffs, and the timing of Brexit’s impact gives us room to raise our investment in A&P by $5 million to support our brands and innovation. Consequently, we now expect a full-year increase of 15% to 20% in dollar terms compared with 2019. Our plan spreads these investments across the year, based on the seasonality of Batteries and Auto Care. Now to capital allocation: in the quarter, we used free cash flow to pay down roughly $40 million in debt. We also refinanced $365 million of our Term Loan B into a newly established Term Loan A. The favorable rates on the new Term Loan A will save around $2 million in annual interest. After that quarter ended, we finalized the divestiture of the Varta consumer business. From Varta AG and Spectrum, the first proceeds we got totaled roughly $345 million. We're directing that money toward paying down the term loan debt. A true-up to those initial proceeds will be determined by the final closing balance sheet, and we anticipate a final settlement taking place during the coming six months. Once the term loan debt was accounted for and paid down in early January, our net debt-to-EBITDA multiple sits at approximately 4.7 times right now. The other pieces of our guidance have been reaffirmed and appear in the appendix of our slide presentation. Before I hand the call back to Alan, I'd like to restate how confident we are in the full-year outlook, which covers top line organic growth, margin expansion, greater investments in our brands and innovation, and lastly, achieving integration synergies through optimizing our manufacturing and distribution network; at this point, I'd like to give the call back to Alan for his closing remarks.
Alan Hoskins
executiveThanks, Tim. As all three of us have explained, what we achieved during Q1 backs up the guidance we're looking toward for 2020. It's been more than 12 months now since we completed those acquisitions. Energizer today is a stronger business, thanks to the extra know-how and capabilities that came with the teams we brought on, plus fresh markets where we can put money to work for growth, and a wider lineup of top brands and categories in which brands truly count. We feel a lot of enthusiasm about what lies ahead for the rest of 2020 and in future years, as we move forward in building a company with greater capabilities — one that can meet our strategic and financial goals over the long term. So with that, I'll hand things over to the operator, who will open up the line for questions.
Wendy Nicholson
analystMorning, and thanks for taking this. I've actually got 2 things. First, regarding the new distribution, could you make clear if that's fully secured and basically guaranteed, since I understand it's meant to be fueling the pickup in growth over the course of the year? So is there any downside there, or is everything basically locked and loaded? Then my second one concerns the pricing environment — could you speak to how confident you are about the price increases you took? Clearly commodities are more favorable, so do you see any downside to that price? Might you have to step up promotional activity, and so on and so forth? Thanks.
Mark LaVigne
executiveHi, Wendy. This is Mark. I'll take the first one. Alan can address pricing afterward; when it comes to distribution, the wins we referenced are locked and loaded and included in our plans; right now we're in the planning phase with customers, so the phasing and timing of when those roll out and when the loads will hit is still somewhat in flux, but as far as space in the distribution goes, that's all locked in.
Alan Hoskins
executiveSo, Wendy, regarding pricing, you should assume that will stay in place; we aren't expecting any shift there. What I believe you'll observe is a spread that has opened up between the premium brands and the value-priced ones; our expectation is that this is short-term, consistent with past patterns; it will ease and go back to normal as time passes. When it comes to promotions, our attention is mainly on the U.S. The promotional landscape remains quite steady. In fact, in the latest quarter, average unit prices paid by consumers rose once more.
Wendy Nicholson
analystUnderstood, that's useful. Thanks. Then, just one final question regarding the second quarter, simply to assist everyone from a modeling standpoint, I know you mentioned significant gross margin growth in the second half, but for the second quarter, could you provide any indication about which way gross margin is headed, still under pressure? Or when ought we to begin seeing the advantages, and so forth, and so forth?
Mark LaVigne
executiveYes. Wendy, the enhancement in gross margin will begin to become apparent for you in the second quarter. Once more, you know, what will cause that are synergies, gross margin growth as absorption gets better.
Bill Chappell
analystThanks, good morning.
Mark LaVigne
executiveGood morning, Bill.
Alan Hoskins
executiveMorning, Bill.
Bill Chappell
analystStarting off, back on battery growth — the organic side for this year. Do you figure on organic growth in all three of the coming quarters, with the main attention on Q4, as we try to get a handle on whether that retailer pull forward shows up again this year, whether that's a hard comparison — clearly, the hurricane makes for a hard comparison — or whether shelf-space wins did more than cancel out both of those?
Mark LaVigne
executiveBill, baked into that 1% to 2% organic growth for the battery business this year, it will probably deliver organic growth from Q2 through Q4. The timing and the size of that organic growth may move around based on when things land, you know, from one month to the next, but on the whole, you know, organic growth is what we look for from Q2 through Q4.
Bill Chappell
analystAll right, thank you; and as a quick follow-up, I believe I recall an expected hit of $20 million to $30 million from tariffs, though my understanding was that most of those tariffs fell under Auto Care and related to the December tariffs that ultimately were never put into effect. So could you perhaps bring us up to date on how tariffs will affect things this year?
Tim Gorman
executiveSure, so, Bill, during the prior quarter we noted that tariff effects would come to $12 million incremental, while the Brexit cost would total $2 million. As I just mentioned — you’re correct, the December came off. None of the tariffs that already existed were affected by the Phase 1 deal, and therefore, that December impact was approximately $4 million.
Bill Chappell
analystSo, I mean, for the entire year, is there an updated total? Sorry.
Tim Gorman
executiveWhat we mentioned during the previous quarter was that, had you factored in tariffs, Brexit, and currency effects, the figure would have come to about $0.25; that has since fallen to approximately $0.18, and the gap comes from the additional A&P investment we are putting in.
Bill Chappell
analystUnderstood. Many thanks.
Jason English
analystHello there, everyone, and good morning.
Alan Hoskins
executiveMorning to you.
Jason English
analystI appreciate you letting me join. I'd like to revisit the topic of gross margins, since the quarter-over-quarter change in GMs caught me off guard. You provided a helpful bridge from Q4 to Q1, and I'm grateful for that, but in past years, that bridge from Q4 to Q1 involved a meaningful increase. Typically, we see a substantial sequential gain as we enter the first quarter. It sounds like maybe — perhaps because of how production was timed and the idle capacity or underutilization — there was a headwind, but could you shed some light on that? Also, can you tell us whether this was a one-off? Or will this become the standard seasonal pattern shaping your gross margins across the year? Or ought we to anticipate a return to the historical high points?
Tim Gorman
executiveYes. So, Jason, as you know, one factor was clearly the timing of holiday shipments that we flagged during Q4; that affected production volumes as we came into Q1, and we anticipated margin pressure from that shift, plus the further effects of channel mix and added tariffs. So, as you know, going forward, my expectation is that it will get better as the volumes — as organic growth gets better. When you look ahead to later years, you clearly need to factor in how acquired businesses affect our business; so, my expectation is that as we go forward, you know, depending on how the timing of holiday shipments plays out, we won't return to the — what the legacy gross margin rates were, but you'll observe a fairly typical pattern in our business. Once again, you need to factor in Auto Care and that business's seasonality too.
Jason English
analystYeah, absolutely. I realize it has altered not just how large your big margins are, but also shifted their shape somewhat.
Tim Gorman
executiveRight.
Jason English
analystSo, taking that thought further, if some of the softness we're seeing comes from sales and leverage being pulled ahead into Q4, ought we to prepare for a rather difficult fourth quarter — perhaps we'll be up against that pull-forward on sales, along with the margin leverage, once Q4 arrives?
Mark LaVigne
executiveJason, right after Bill's question, we said we're expecting organic growth in Q4; part of the reasoning is that we're assuming the timing shift that happened over the past year carries into this year. So if any shifting takes place, that said, the new distribution is also a factor, and it will drive organic growth too, and we anticipate that landing significantly around the August-September window.
Kevin Grundy
analystThanks, good morning everyone.
Alan Hoskins
executiveGood morning.
Kevin Grundy
analystLet's turn to synergies — you appear to have solid line of sight on that $65 million you guided to for fiscal 2020. Could you walk us through where the main synergy capture is coming from? How do you keep business risk in check while capturing those synergies? And then, as you work through them in an environment that's still volatile — commodities, FX, and so on — what flexibility might the company have to speed up the pace of synergy capture beyond that $65 million this year?
Tim Gorman
executiveYes, Kevin, we do have good line of sight to that cumulative $65 million. It breaks down as $45 million to $50 million incremental in 2020, which laps the $18 million we realized last year. So a pretty strong governance process is in place to manage those risks you're outlining, and as we move forward and move through the integration, we're confident in our ability. I think we called out one big factor — getting the European business onto our IT platform — and that occurred in the first quarter, so we've moved from the Varta business. And so we have many milestones coming up this year. And again, we're extremely confident in our ability to deliver.
Mark LaVigne
executiveAbsolutely, Kevin — when it comes to business risk, we keep a very tight grip on that, and honestly, it sits at the center of every conversation we have: what's going on with the businesses while we put these changes in place to capture those synergies. So minimizing business risk comes first. Getting the synergies is priority number two, and priority number three is when those synergies land. We believe we've established a solid rhythm, but should business risk ever emerge, we'll rearrange things to guarantee we aren't introducing any business risk — that's the top and most critical consideration; and as we laid out during our Investor Day, we have a really strong grasp of how to stage these activities, which we proved both in 2013 and with the 2015 separation. We have a lot of confidence in that.
Kevin Grundy
analystAll right, that's useful. My quick follow-up concerns the Auto Care business, which you anticipate will get back to growth during this year. Could you update us on how things stand with the retailers in that area, where clearly there was some tension previously under a different owner? Then secondly, just the visibility into the distribution you expect to build as we move toward the key March and June quarters? I'll hand it over, thanks.
Alan Hoskins
executiveKevin, clearly we can see the sets, and those are going to be placed over the coming, you know, 30 days, 45 days with retailers, so our visibility into that is quite good, and we do have some additional space. Well, the job now is making certain that space performs for us. Our retailer relationships are in great shape. I believe the ties the team we brought in with the Global Auto Care business had were genuinely robust. We've simply worked to strengthen those further and demonstrate what Energizer can deliver for this business too; we've held a number of top-to-top, you know, innovation summits at which we laid out our plans for the business, from an innovation angle as well as a branding angle, and they're enthusiastic about what they're hearing and what they're seeing from us, but ultimately, we must prove it to them and we will prove it to them in this Q2, Q3, and after that, we're going to build on that moving forward, but the relationships are solid, and because of that, you know, we would anticipate that to keep that business on its upward trajectory.
Steve Strycula
analystMorning, everyone. I’ll start with a question about operational assortment, then follow up quickly on the financial side. Alan, regarding assortment, roughly 6 to 7 months have passed since a national private label roll-out happened and since a major rival introduced a premium item. I’d like a bit more detail on the new distribution wins you can see ahead for calendar 2020. Are those mainly from the branded side? From the premium side? Across the board? Could you give us additional color and a sense of where those new distribution wins originate? After that, I have one more question.
Alan Hoskins
executiveWe are using the whole portfolio. In battery, what I’d say is that we’re using the portfolio to gain distribution with new customers, and also to get expanded space with customers we might already have. Naturally, at this point, with where we sit in planning, our policy means we don’t discuss particular customers, but these are already committed, and we’re currently working through how the sets will look and the timing of product moving into their DCs and stores. Mark?
Mark LaVigne
executiveAs you may recall, during our conversations with several of you back in November and December, we mentioned our expectation that we could win back a portion of the ground we had given up as a result of that competitive launch, and our teams have managed to accomplish exactly that. That was already factored into what we set as our goal and our plans for 2020. The exact timing keeps moving slightly, but you will begin to observe a portion of this new distribution arriving during March and April, and then once more further along in the year.
Alan Hoskins
executiveAnd it’s all branded to answer the first part of your question.
Steve Strycula
analystAll right, that's quite useful. Now for the numbers question — looking at EBITDA guidance from 2019 to 2020, going from the endpoint to the midpoint, that works out to roughly an $80 million step up, or gain compared with the prior year. I understand around $50 million of that comes from incremental synergies, but could you help us understand a bit better how much might be attributable to the acquisitions during the four months last year when you didn't own them? And how much comes from the ENR base business? That would really help, thank you.
Alan Hoskins
executiveSure. The acquisitions added roughly $40 million in incremental EBITDA. As you mentioned, synergies play a major role, and the remainder comes from the legacy business — and included within that is the distribution we discussed, along with regaining space and new space as well.
Lauren Lieberman
analystGreat, thanks. Good morning.
Alan Hoskins
executiveGood morning.
Lauren Lieberman
analystTo build on what was asked regarding Batteries distribution, I'm interested in how private label factors in when you approach retailers with your broader lineup now — clearly that's product you aren't manufacturing — and whether you're seeing willingness from retailers to replace private label so Rayovac can serve as the opening price point option, and perhaps that isn't even how you're framing it, but I'd love to hear your thoughts?
Alan Hoskins
executiveI'd say that's really the big-picture strategic matter, and it represents what made this acquisition worthwhile. When we walk in, we've clearly held conversations for a long time about bringing energy to the category's premium tier, yet buying the Rayovac brand lets us stretch our U.S. reach in a specific manner. Of course, Eveready gave us that too, but in some markets Rayovac carries far more weight, which lets us start talks at the opening price point and carry that conversation right up through the category's premium tier. So there is receptiveness to this. My sense is this will be a discussion spanning a long period. Retailers each have their own playbooks; they've got their own approaches regarding private label and what they'll agree to or refuse. Yet once you begin landing some wins and perhaps shift private label over to the Rayovac brand, and then retailers review the numbers showing what it delivers for their category, that becomes a genuinely persuasive narrative for them, though everything must align with their strategy for their stores and their shopper, which is what our teams work on every day.
Lauren Lieberman
analystAll right, excellent. Then my next question kind of goes to the opposite side, the premium side. I'm just wondering what sorts of things you might be doing to build more awareness around lithium, and what can be done right at the shelf, since clearly with the optimum launch, the thinking is, you know, pushing price points higher, but that's a product that's on its way out. So yes, and anything that — is there anything within your discussions with retailers at shelf that also involves how the shelf itself has been set up, and in-store education regarding what separates offerings within the premium side of the category?
Alan Hoskins
executiveThat is absolutely something our teams are focused on, and that means putting forward these shopper based solutions as something our teams excel at; the real issue is communicating what lithium can do not just to the customer, but afterward to the consumer too, and the lithium product carries distinct advantages. It's the top battery available in the market right now, and ensuring we reach consumers to get that message across, along with getting across the advantages tied to particular uses, matters, and it's something we handle and are working on each day to get the word out both inside stores, but then also from, you know, a digital advertising angle too.
Mark LaVigne
executiveWe’re using both above the line and below the line support — that means television, digital, the price change we put in place on shelf, plus in-store visibility — and it’s paying off. Around the world, lithium is rising: during the most recent 13 week period, it was up 7%, nearly 8%.
Faiza Alwy
analystMorning, everyone. First off, I want to revisit the topic of distribution. Could you share a bit more detail about which channels are driving those gains? More specifically, will this show up in the scanned data that comes out every 2 weeks? Then for my second question: it appears you have some room to maneuver when it comes to EBITDA and EPS, and this quarter you opted to boost reinvestments and put more into A&P relative to the guidance. So I'm interested in how you view the right level of A&P spending. And if you get additional upside from items such as FX and so on, should we assume those amounts will keep being funneled back into the business? Thanks.
Mark LaVigne
executiveFaiza, this is Mark. I'll take the first part, then hand it to Tim for the second. We'd really like to discuss the specifics behind those distribution gains, and I know it's frustrating when we hold back that level of detail. This is something we're actively working on alongside our customers. We do have a standard policy of not commenting on customers, and we genuinely want to unveil this distribution together with our customers in store, and with their shoppers too; so we don't want to get ahead of that process. Those distribution gains are clearly factored into the reaffirmation of guidance we gave today. What I'd tell you is that you'll start to see that distribution gain actually take place during the March, April timeframe at certain retailers, and after that, you'll see it over the summer at certain other ones. As it rolls out, you'll begin to see it. We're still working through the phasing and planning, but it is baked into our reaffirmation today. We're excited about it, and we're excited about what it will do for our business.
Tim Gorman
executiveAnd Mark, you'll find it in both measured and non-measured, and it shows up in — mostly within the U.S., though outside the country as well.
Mark LaVigne
executiveThat's right.
Alan Hoskins
executiveAnd regarding your question about A&P, Faiza — we actually had a chance to put more money into A&P, particularly by boosting what we spend on the Auto Care business. So, as we've mentioned before, there's a need to put dollars behind those brands and to bring innovation forward; we're seizing that chance now, and going forward we'll keep assessing what the proper amount of A&P should be, but some upfront spending will be necessary at the start to restore the Auto Care business to its previous level.
Mark LaVigne
executiveAnd then, Tim, whatever extra we end up with past that synergy figure, that’s going straight back into the business.
Tim Gorman
executiveThat's right.
Faiza Alwy
analystAll right, thanks.
Rob Ottenstein
analystExcellent, many thanks. Some of this came up in earlier remarks, and I was hoping you might expand a bit on what's taking place with mix — both product and channel — and perhaps offer some added color regarding how your business is growing relative to one another across the Energizer brand, Rayovac, and private label, plus what you expect going forward? Then, could we also hear a bit about channel mix and how it's affecting your margin structure? Clearly, e-commerce is expanding more quickly — what does the margin profile look like there, and what about international? Thanks.
Alan Hoskins
executiveSure. So when it comes to channel mix — as you've observed in POS trends within measured channels, declines have been occurring. Growth in unmeasured channels is making up for that. Consequently, what you're seeing is somewhat of a mix effect tied to unmeasured channels expanding while measured ones do not. That dynamic showed up late in Q4, then continued into Q1, together with the absorption effect we mentioned during prepared remarks. Over the rest of the year, that mix should begin to flip, thanks to certain distribution gains we cited before.
Rob Ottenstein
analystAnd when it comes to margin impact — or, you know, how would you compare the margin profile of your measured business versus your unmeasured business?
Alan Hoskins
executiveYeah, we don't get into discussing margins for specific channels. In particular, you asked about Amazon — we just don't go into margin profiles for individual customers or channels.
Analyst
analystHey, everyone. Appreciate you taking the question. John < > here, filling in for Olivia. I've got a really fast one regarding your China exposure, what with the coronavirus, on both the manufacturing side and the sales side, and whether you could perhaps expand a bit on if there might be any effect on the supply chain or on your capacity in any way? Then my second question would be — I don't know about other parts of the country, but so far this winter the northeast has had some really mild weather, and I'm curious whether you've seen that show up in the Auto Care line?
Alan Hoskins
executiveYes, so I'll — this is Alan. I'll handle the first one, John, and then Mark will take the second. So, the health and well-being of our colleagues came first for us, and we're glad to say that in Asia, everyone is doing fine. Looking at it from a business standpoint, there's nothing major to report at this time. I think everything hinges on how things develop over the coming two to three weeks; that might change, but as of right now, we don't expect any significant problems. I'll tell you that over the past two weeks, our global supply chain has been doing quite a bit of work on contingency planning should any action become necessary, but at this moment, we're in a good spot.
Mark LaVigne
executiveTurning to what was asked about Auto Care, as observed across the 13-week period that closed in November, the September month in particular showed category growth that was fairly robust, and weather was the reason. What really counts for our business is the weather during Q2 and Q3, and if you remember, cold and rainy conditions persisted last year across a large part of the spring and the early summer season, and a return to more normalized weather patterns is what we expect. Clearly, should it turn particularly hot early, our business benefits. Depending on when that weather arrives, some shifting between Q2 and Q3 may occur. A great deal of our Auto Care business is weather dependent, so the peak season begins when spring hits.
Analyst
analystAlright, thanks guys.
Alan Hoskins
executiveThank you.
William Reuter
analystHey there. I've got just one question, I suppose. When we look at the way you're paying down debt, you set a goal for the close of 2020 — could you remind us what you anticipate at the close of fiscal year 2021, and also whether any M&A prospects are emerging that might alter that debt-reduction trajectory?
Mark LaVigne
executiveSure. We had indicated an expectation of landing somewhere between 4.2 and 4.4 in 2020, and then approximately half a turn of improvement going into 2021.
Alan Hoskins
executiveWhen it comes to M&A, we're still going to consider bolt-on acquisitions. That's something where we clearly keep leverage levels in mind, especially given where those levels sit today. But as far as giving a forward-looking view on M&A, that's hard to do. We keep evaluating it, though what we're concentrated on at the moment is bringing down debt, and if some opportunity were to arise, we would certainly factor that in or run the analysis.
Mark LaVigne
executiveWe’re going to continue to take a balanced approach to capital allocation.
William Reuter
analystThat tracks. Thanks very much.
Carla Casella
analystHello. You mentioned a handful of significant victories within the battery category — do any of those come with trade-offs, whether lost accounts or shortened product lifecycles, and could you frame that in terms of the older business compared with the Spectrum business you picked up?
Mark LaVigne
executiveOur approach has been to treat the battery operation as one whole, and across that entire battery operation our growth came in at 1% to 2%, since how well the brands connect really varies by the individual retailer or the individual customer, so what we aim for is to view it as one full operation and one full portfolio. Naturally, any given year unfolds in ways you don't anticipate. You get pluses and minuses as the year goes on. We anticipated these distribution victories as we entered this year — that we would take back that space — along with the competitive launch, because we observed the story in the category trends and we had a highly persuasive story to present to the retailers. Broadly speaking, we remain quite confident in that 1% to 2% organic growth. Everything we currently know is incorporated into the guidance we gave today, which essentially captures organic growth spanning Q2 through Q4.
Carla Casella
analystAll right, excellent, thanks.
Karru Martinson
analystMorning. I'd like to dig a bit deeper into how the battery mix has been shifting. Specifically, I'm curious how the hearing aid operation is doing for you, given that it's been such a significant portion of spectrum's battery unit when it comes to contributing margin?
Mark LaVigne
executiveThere's been some conversion you can observe within hearing aids, but what you're seeing at present is more hearing aid devices, or they're adopting rechargeable batteries; they also involve some distribution loss, which happened prior to our acquisition of that business. We continue working through that. It was a solid margin business in a healthy market, and it's a lesser part of our overall business, though it was that way for spectrum, yet you're still witnessing very strong trends across the specialty segment as a whole. Hearing aid fits within that, but what you're observing on the lithium side is attractive growth rates, and we managed to capitalize well thanks to our broadened portfolio.
Alan Hoskins
executiveAmong the retailers, specialty is among the more profitable areas. On a value basis, Energizer currently holds a 55 share worldwide across a minimum of 13 weeks. We're dominant in that space, and as Mark pointed out, hearing aid, if you consider it, is in fact a comparatively smaller portion of overall specialty, at 17%. The watch electronic category, where we hold dominance, accounts for approximately three quarters of worldwide sales in brick and mortar.
Karru Martinson
analystThanks a lot, everyone. I appreciate it.
Andrea Teixeira
analystThank you. Good morning. Could you give me some help understanding the synergies from the first quarter? You reported 9 million, but is that mostly tied to gross margin? And if we figure roughly 7 million went to gross margin, then those synergies gave you about 120 basis points of help on gross margin. So I was attempting to bridge the gap and figure out what the core business margin was for the legacy Energizer business, and how that compares with the acquired batteries and autos? And just to clarify the follow-up question from the prepared remarks — you brought up competitive activity, and if I understood correctly, that includes private-label players as well. So is that taking place on discount, or again in the drug channel, as we keep seeing in the track channel, and are you building a normalization of this trend into guidance? Thank you, appreciate it.
Alan Hoskins
executiveYes. I'll handle the last one, and Tim will put together his view on the first question. On private label, no, there hasn't been any meaningful change. As we said last quarter, and as we anticipated this quarter, there was activity at one large U.S. retailer involving some promotional and distribution activity related to private label, but that was expected. Beyond that, we aren't seeing anything different. It does differ by channel, market, and category — more developed obviously in Lights, less so in Battery, and even less so in Auto Care — but worldwide we aren't seeing major shifts. Currently, private label value shares still stand at about 18.8%. The increase we saw in the most recent 13 weeks, again, came from that one U.S. retailer. Tim?
Tim Gorman
executiveRegarding those synergies, we highlighted the 9 million figure, and like we mentioned during Investor Day, the composition of that amount will break down as roughly 65% coming from COGS, with the remainder split between SG&A and R&D. So that's already reflected in what we delivered for Q1. Once again, the affected line items are exactly the ones we identified — you have the absorption effect, plus the mix effect that happened in Q1. We aren't separating out the legacy operation from the other — going forward it's a single merged business, and this quarter marks the final time we'll be comping against the acquisition.
Andrea Teixeira
analystThanks.
Alan Hoskins
executiveWe appreciate your presence on today's call, along with your ongoing interest in Energizer. Thanks, operator.
Operator
operatorThat brings this call to an end. We appreciate your joining us for the presentation today. You’re welcome to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Energizer Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Energizer Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Energizer Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.