Energizer Holdings, Inc. (ENR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 5, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Staples Household Products earnings 67 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jacqueline Burwitz

executive
#1

Hello, and thanks for being with us today. On this call, we'll go over our third quarter fiscal year 2020 results. A replay of this call can be accessed through the Investor Relations area of our site, energizerholdings.com. You'll also find a slide deck on our website that covers specifics of the quarter's results. Joining me this morning are Alan Hoskins, our Chief Executive Officer; Mark LaVigne, President and Chief Operating Officer; and Tim Gorman, Chief Financial Officer. Throughout this call, we'll share forward-looking statements regarding the company's future business and financial performance; these reflect management's current expectations and carry risks and uncertainties that could lead actual results to differ materially from what we've stated in those forward-looking statements. We won't be updating these forward-looking statements. Factors that might cause actual results to differ materially from these statements appear in today's presentation slides and in the reports we file with the SEC. We'll also be referencing non-GAAP financial measures. A reconciliation of non-GAAP financial measures to comparable GAAP measures appears in the press release issued earlier today, which you can find on our website. Information about our category and market share discussed on this call relates to the markets where we compete and comes from Energizer's internal data, industry analysis data, and estimates we believe to be reasonable. Unless otherwise noted, all comparisons are to the same period in the prior year. With that, I'd like to hand the call over to Alan.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#2

Thank you, Jackie, and hello to everybody on this call. I want to start by expressing gratitude to our teammates across the globe who showed steadfast dedication through the hardest conditions any of us has encountered. Although the pandemic is still a worldwide danger, the focus and nimbleness of this team helped protect the health and safety of our people and powered Energizer's impressive results in the third quarter. We keep working within an unpredictable landscape, with only partial visibility into how long the pandemic will last, how severe it will be, and what it will do to the economy; even so, so far our team has moved quickly and with clear intent, positioning us as well as possible given what we do know. And as we look forward, our long-range plans are still in place and keep generating robust results on both the top and bottom lines. In the quarter, organic net sales rose 3.4%, driven by solid battery results and organic expansion in Auto Care. The strength in batteries came mainly from distribution gains in North America, price increases, and higher demand for batteries in the U.S. brought about by COVID-19. Auto Care's growth mirrored better trends during the quarter as consumers drove their vehicles more, and we gained from favorable weather. All quarter long, our people in manufacturing plants and distribution centers did an outstanding job meeting the higher demand by consistently delivering high fill rates overall, and our retail operations teams did the same, carrying out our in-store plans with excellence. Even with pressure from currency and added costs tied to COVID-19, adjusted earnings per share climbed 35% to $0.50, driven by the gains from organic sales growth and ongoing synergy capture. Beyond that, we produced robust adjusted free cash flow, which further shows how stable our business is. In the quarter, we kept advancing our long-range goals, such as carrying out our integration plans to deliver more than $100 million in synergies by the close of calendar year 2021. We are drawing on the strength of our wide portfolio to win new and expanded distribution in the U.S. and a number of international markets, putting investment into our Auto Care business to build a strong innovation pipeline, supported by fresh, high-impact creative that bolsters our brands and connects with consumers, and rolling out our plan to grow the Auto Care business in international markets. We anticipate fiscal 2020 will mark our fifth straight year of organic growth, thanks to new distribution, greater demand for batteries in the U.S. due to COVID-19, and better pricing. Net sales growth ought to land between 9% and 10%, with organic growth of 1% to 1.5%. Furthermore, we anticipate adjusted earnings per share of $2.45 to $2.55 and adjusted free cash flow above $300 million. Looking toward what's ahead, we think the long-range plans we laid out with you at Investor Day have helped us navigate the pandemic and will keep helping us in the new normal to come. The categories we compete in hold up well during difficult periods and offer chances to grow, given shifting consumer needs. We have faith that our team members will turn tough circumstances into strengths, and because of that, Energizer will come out of this pandemic in an even better position. With that said, I'll hand things over to Mark.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#3

Thank you, Alan, and good morning to all of you. Our colleagues' handling of the pandemic's first phase is something we take immense pride in. This was genuinely a team-wide effort, with coworkers across the globe acting quickly, staying focused and nimble, and performing at a very high standard throughout the toughest crisis this group has ever faced; every conceivable test was thrown at us, yet we still produced solid financial results while — even more crucially — keeping one another out of harm's way. As of today, our plants are more secure, our worldwide supply network is better able to absorb shocks, and our systems and processes have grown sturdier. Consequently, we are providing a high level of service to our customers, even with the difficulties created by the pandemic. We headed into Q4 understanding consumer habits in this new landscape quite clearly, since economies had started reopening, and our product segments have held up against the strain of the last 6 months. We are keeping an eye on the recent surge in COVID-19 infections, particularly within the U.S. And exactly as we did when the pandemic first emerged, we will adjust our operations when necessary, so that we keep delivering for our customers and consumers. Before we get into batteries, I want to walk through how we plan to look at our categories going forward. It's no secret that retail has been changing for a long time. COVID-19 is accelerating shifts in the way shoppers buy and in the way retailers respond. E-commerce, Click and Collect, and Home Delivery are all growing quickly, and together they're moving us toward a truly omnichannel retail environment. So starting now, we'll report category performance on a combined basis, because we believe that gives a clearer picture. That means our category discussion today, and in the future, will bring together brick-and-mortar and U.S. omnichannel results from a number of large retailers and pure play e-commerce within the U.S. Now let's turn to the battery category. During the 13-week stretch that ended in May, covering the peak of the shelter-in-place mandates, battery category value climbed 28.4% globally and 37% in the U.S. That sudden demand surge when the pandemic began was substantial in the U.S. Although these patterns have eased since May came to a close, they are still far above where they have historically sat. Our continued study of U.S. consumer behavior reveals higher battery usage as people keep spending more time in their homes. Beyond the U.S., the picture was historically quite different. To put it in general terms, many markets outside the U.S. imposed tougher stay-at-home rules, and as a result our category took a hit, especially in channels and markets we don't measure. Let me go a little deeper. Outside America in the developed world, supermarkets — which we do measure — grew rapidly, since they ranked among the handful of channels deemed essential, while channels we don't measure, like Home Center and mom-and-pop outlets, were forced to close. In developing countries such as the Philippines and Malaysia, stay-at-home orders came down quickly, with virtually no warning, and essentially froze those nations. In those markets, the category posted significant declines stemming from the steps governments took to address COVID-19. As for pricing overall, average unit prices went up while promotions were reduced during the quarter, since retailers were rightly concentrated on keeping their stores running, their shelves filled and the shoppers protected. Now to how we performed in the quarter. Although our global share position fell 2.8 points, it kept getting better on a sequential basis. We anticipate that this trend will speed up in the fourth quarter as we capture the gain from resets carried out at a number of U.S. customers. That covers widening where our brands are available in the club channel, a place where we had been underrepresented, plus boosting visibility through preferred positioning in other channels. Past that point, the gains we've seen in share will soon start to reflect the fact that we're now up against the resets that major U.S. retailers made a year ago. On top of that, some of the channel movement that occurred during the earliest phase of the pandemic should revert to more typical patterns. Overall, our organic growth came in strong, driven by distribution gains and increased U.S. demand for our products tied to COVID-19, with conditions abroad in our international markets partly working against that. As we look at the remainder of the calendar year, we're in a solid position thanks to those U.S. distribution gains, and we're already getting ready for the holiday season ahead. So that addresses the tweaks we've made to our advertising and promotion spending, which are meant to keep pace with how shoppers' purchasing habits are shifting, and that includes putting more dollars into digital. Also, while the guidance we've given doesn't factor in any hurricane effects, we're in a strong position to take care of our customers when storms hit. Now let's move on to Auto Care. Compared with the prior quarter, category trends here in the U.S. are up quite a bit. During the 13 weeks that concluded in May, the category's value rose 4.3%. What's behind these better trends in the category is that people are choosing to drive rather than fly when they take their summer vacations, as the U.S. When the economy started back up, people turned to DIY projects since many car care shops had either shut down or cut back on services after being labeled nonessential. On top of that, everyone was focused on keeping their cars clean and disinfected because of the pandemic, and warmer weather came back, which let drivers take care of maintaining and washing their vehicles — all of this pushed up demand for refrigerants. Our share dropped 1.2 points during the quarter, since growth came from categories such as waxes, polishes and vehicle wash, areas where Energizer has a weaker position. This quarter, our appearance products saw robust demand, particularly Armor All wipes. Innovation is delivering for us too. Five of the top 10 new items are ours, among them a number of new Armor All offerings: Armor All Extreme Protectant, Armor All Snow Foam Wash, and Armor All Wheel and Tire Cleaner. Beyond that, we expanded distribution in the U.S., Europe, and Australia, picking up additional channels and customers. As for the final months of the summer selling season, we're cautiously optimistic, given that these favorable trends have continued through our fourth quarter so far. Even so, rising case counts in the U.S. might restrain growth should stricter shelter-in-place orders be reinstated. Over a longer horizon, we stay optimistic regarding the category's fundamentals, given that consumers are moving from do-it-for-me toward do-it-yourself, holding on to their vehicles for more years and putting on more miles. Another possible tailwind is consumers paying greater attention to keeping their cars clean. We're putting substantial investment behind our brands through fresh creative and innovation plus a dedicated push to reshape the pipeline and reinvigorate the brands; we've started carrying out our international expansion plans, which should produce solid growth across the coming several years. Pairing brand investment, product investment and geographic expansion is the correct strategy for growing the Auto Care business sustainably over the long term. Let me now move to our integration efforts. Despite the pandemic, our team members continue performing exceptionally well on our integration efforts, with almost no impact on customers, because they've found inventive ways to use technology and stay sharply focused on the work in front of them. Several projects have just been completed, while others remain underway. These include bringing our auto manufacturing together at the Dayton, Ohio site, sending all Auto Care products from a brand-new distribution center, opening a fresh facility for distributing batteries and lights, and moving the acquired battery and Auto Care operations over to Energizer's SAP system — a process set to finish by the close of the calendar year. During this quarter, we achieved $15 million in synergy savings, and we remain on course to hit the incremental synergies of $45 million to $50 million that we previously disclosed for this year. Our progress feels excellent, and we anticipate that by the time the calendar year ends, our integration efforts will be largely finished, keeping us in position to deliver over $100 million in synergies by the close of 2021. Any synergies past that figure are anticipated to be put back into supporting our leading brand and accelerating the multiyear innovation portfolio in Auto Care; in short, the focus and agility we've shown over the past 7 months have brought us to this point and will propel us ahead. We respond fast when the operating environment shifts, ensuring that what we spend on A&P tracks changes in consumer behavior. That way we connect with consumers wherever they are and turn into the brands they look for, notice, and choose, no matter which channel. This requires strengthening how resilient our global product supply chain is so disruptions stay minimal, while keeping service at a best-in-class level for our customers. Because of how we're set up, we're prepared to keep performing at a high standard, providing what our customers and consumers need, while also advancing our long-range plans. We've made it through the first phase of the pandemic, and we're committed to emerging from this crisis in a stronger position than when it began. Now I'll hand things to Tim so he can walk through the quarter.

Tim Gorman

executive
#4

Thank you, Mark, and good morning to all of you. Our third quarter was a solid one, delivering adjusted earnings per share of $0.50, which rose 35%, along with adjusted EBITDA of $135 million, an increase of 6%. Those figures speak to outstanding execution during the period, plus the upside from battery demand that came in above what we expected thanks to COVID-19, better momentum in Auto Care sales, and the realization of planned synergy savings. Offsetting these gains were added expenses tied to COVID-19 and negative currency effects, which together amounted to roughly $0.19 per share. I'll walk through a handful of quarterly highlights and our outlook, but we've also made more detailed slides available on our website. Net sales for the quarter climbed 1.7%, reaching $658 million. Organic net sales rose 3.4%, powered by distribution gains, robust demand for batteries and Auto Care within the U.S., and pricing, though softness in international markets stemming from the pandemic worked against those gains. In the Americas, organic net sales were up 7%, whereas the International segment fell 6%. That International drop mirrors how lockdowns affected unmeasured channels, such as developing in distributor markets and DIY in modern markets. Once those markets and channels started reopening later in the quarter, sales did bounce back quickly. Our adjusted gross margin rate for the third quarter rose 80 basis points, hitting 40.8%. Synergies, favorable raw material costs, and pricing were the main forces behind that improvement. Partly offsetting these were foreign currency headwinds and added operating costs from COVID-19, which together dragged gross margins down by $18 million, or 210 basis points. The added COVID expenses consisted mainly of airfreight, personal protection equipment, and unfavorable absorption. SG&A, once acquisition and integration costs are excluded, fell by about $6 million to 16.2% of net sales, a decline of 120 basis points, with synergies as the primary factor as we wrapped up the majority of Transition Service Agreements with Spectrum and saw lower T&E because of travel restrictions. Now to adjusted free cash flow: we brought in $136 million for the quarter and roughly $244 million year-to-date. Free cash flow this quarter came in $100 million above the same period a year ago. As we noted on the second quarter call, back in April we took multiple actions to shore up our liquidity given the uncertainty during the pandemic's early stages. Thanks to how strongly the business has performed, we've been lucky to keep our expanded liquidity largely unused, finishing the quarter with around $600 million in cash on hand. Roughly 60% of that cash sat in the U.S. We also capitalized on the low interest rate environment by issuing $600 million of senior notes at 4.75% due in 2028. Those proceeds went toward tendering and redeeming the $600 million of 5.5% senior notes due in 2025, which cut annual cash interest by approximately $4.5 million and pushed out the maturity by 3 years. Once we reach the close of this calendar year, we'll take another look at whether the extra cash we're holding in the U.S. should go toward speeding up debt reduction, and that decision will hinge on how we see the pandemic. Right now, with part of the fiscal year behind us, the near term looks clearer than it did. As Alan said, we're giving a full year 2020 outlook. Net sales growth is expected to land between 9% and 10%, and that figure includes organic growth of 1% to 1.5%. For adjusted earnings per share, we're looking at $2.45 to $2.55. Adjusted EBITDA should come in between $575 million and $585 million. Last, adjusted free cash flow is expected to be greater than $300 million. That sits under what we told you back in February, and there are 4 main reasons: roughly $15 million to $18 million in extra cost of products sold tied to COVID-19; $7 million to $8 million less in SG&A, since travel restrictions brought T&E down; about $9 million to $10 million more in interest expense from added liquidity; and roughly $14 million from a bigger hit due to unfavorable currencies. Taken together, those items produced a decrease of about $0.35 to $0.40 per share, and that's baked into the outlook we have now. This reflects how we see the full year today, with 3 quarters finished and some visibility into how the fourth quarter is beginning. Even so, a great deal of uncertainty persists, given the pandemic and what it's doing to retail and to our business around the world. Looking further out, we stay dedicated to a balanced capital allocation strategy, one that stresses bringing debt down; we'll keep doing what's within our control, such as integrating and optimizing the businesses we acquired. Through these hard times brought on by the pandemic, our team has shown it can perform at a high level. We're still on course to hit the long-term financial goals we presented at our Investor Day, among them more than $700 million of EBITDA and $400 million of free cash flow. At this point, I'd like to hand the call back to Alan for his closing remarks.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#5

Thanks, Tim. The future may be unpredictable and shifting, but we have faith in how capable and nimble our team is to steer us through it well. Looking after the health and safety of the people we work with, along with serving what our customers and consumers need, stays at the top of our list. As quarter four gets underway, we can see a path to wrapping up the year strongly and keeping enough liquidity on hand to get through whatever uncertainty comes our way. The underlying long-term strength of the categories we operate in hasn't changed, and we feel good about the steps we're taking to hit the long-term goals we've laid out and to create meaningful value for every stakeholder. With that said, I'll hand things over to the operator now, who will open up the line for questions.

Wendy Nicholson

analyst
#6

I'm having some difficulty wrapping my head around this, and I'm trying to work through these figures — the guidance for Q4, clearly, is landing under what people had anticipated. I get the additional expenses tied to PP&E, I suppose, but those just look like large amounts to me. So first, regarding that FX pressure, do you plan to adjust prices in order to counter it? Or is it simply a hit to the P&L that we're stuck with? Second, the extra interest expense tied to the added liquidity — that's a sizable figure. Do you believe you actually require that much liquidity? Is it wise to take on all of that debt? Or given your cash flow, do you plan to pay it down? And then, my final question relates again to the guidance. You mentioned there's added demand for products right now. Yet your organic sales guidance remains unchanged from what it was when the fiscal year started. So my question is, do you believe there's extra inventory sitting in consumers' pantries? Or why isn't this added demand producing an increase, so to speak, in your organic sales growth target? I realize that's quite a bit; so whatever you can offer on these points would be helpful.

Tim Gorman

executive
#7

Yes. So Wendy, perhaps we begin with the top line and then move downward from there. Yes. As Mark mentioned, we keep seeing solid demand as Q4 gets underway. When it comes to that demand, it is creating some added expenses. Thus a significant portion of the added COVID costs is airfreight. We are shipping product by air due to the faster demand we're experiencing, especially in batteries within the U.S., to get the product where it's needed. We don't view that as a lasting expense, but for the time being, during the pandemic, we're doing whatever is necessary to keep business continuity. On FX, when it comes to raising prices, you typically do that in situations where currencies have a more significant effect. Lately, we've observed a shift in the currency path as the dollar has weakened. So there could be some possible upside as we move through Q4. We have made, and it is reflected in Q4, our guidance, the greater investment in A&P that we've discussed. And then we're realizing the advantages of lower travel within SG&A. And that, in the same way, is reflected in the guidance; concerning the interest, we decided to boost our liquidity when we went into the pandemic. Some uncertainty is still present. So as I said during prepared remarks, we will assess that once the calendar year ends. My take is that this represents an expense incurred to keep that liquidity on hand until we can be sure it's no longer necessary. Consequently, during the third quarter up to this point, we succeeded in holding onto the cash position we carried throughout that period. To put it roughly, we stood at $600 million at the moment we boosted liquidity, and we've kept it at that level all the way to the quarter's close. This is a judgment call on our part; and you should recognize that as we navigate the pandemic, many elements are in flux. That, then, is what our guidance captures.

Wendy Nicholson

analyst
#8

That's reasonable. So that's what drove the extra amount — I'm figuring that once supply chains return to their usual state, those airfreight expenses will disappear. Yet when we think ahead to Fiscal '21, my assumption is also that the money saved on T&E will return, since folks will likely resume traveling. Still, do you have any idea, as we consider '21, of what the lasting increase in COVID-related expenses might be? My guess is that greater PP&E will stick around for quite a while. Do you have a feel for what we ought to factor into the model for '21?

Tim Gorman

executive
#9

Yes. Wendy, regarding '21, that's something we're assessing at the moment. I'd want to determine which portion of it is lasting. My expectation is that a large majority of it won't be lasting. You're correct that the rise in airfreight ought to shrink. As for the PP&E — some part of that will probably persist past that point. And regarding the interest, once we make the decision at the close of the calendar quarter, should we reduce debt, that will be eliminated starting in the second quarter. So as for the COVID expense, we had a lower figure in Q2. We identified about $1 million this quarter, and I mean that it's included in COGS, it's about $9 million in the third quarter; and we identified about $5 million to $8 million in Q4. Then interest expense, about $4.5 million per quarter for however long we maintain that greater liquidity.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#10

So, first, sort of building on what Wendy asked. Do you have any thinking around how much of an FX headwind there would be for '21 if rates stay where they are?

Tim Gorman

executive
#11

Bill, right now, since I don't have the full '21 outlook in front of me, I'd rather not get into '21 questions, except that — I can mention commodities. For this year, we're completely locked. For next year, on commodities, we're about 60% locked.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#12

Understood. Moving on to what you said regarding market share and the gains made lately. I believe we're nearing the point where we annualize that shift from Eveready to store brands, which happened roughly 12 months back. Curious whether you've noticed any additional developments there? Or possibly more curiosity around Rayovac as the downturn carries on over the coming months — just what's the thinking among your retail partners regarding what they want? Or maybe you haven't observed any trading down whatsoever, and they're still leaning toward the premium labels?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#13

Bill, regarding anniversarying those share figures, the declines we talked about in the script — stemming from both the competitor's introduction and the store-brand rollout you brought up — we're pretty much at that point right now. So essentially we're marking the one-year anniversary as we speak. On top of that, we clearly have all the fresh distribution lined up. So when it comes to share, I believe you'll definitely witness an acceleration once we move past Q4 and into Q1. That's going to give us a boost that I'm aware folks have been anticipating for some time. We keep on utilizing Rayovac, once more, as we head into this period of economic uncertainty. It's a tool at our disposal that we lacked previously when talking with our retail partners. As a result, we can deploy it wherever there's a desire to ensure that shoppers seeking more value-oriented options find us available too. That might come instead of store brands or alongside them, and it truly hinges on what each retailer prefers in terms of how they wish to manage the battery aisle. But clearly it positions us well to fulfill whatever requirements they might have. During periods such as this, you genuinely observe consumers shifting toward brands they have confidence in, and trusted brands are something you'll hear mentioned by many consumer packaged goods businesses nowadays; luckily, we possess a wide array of them including Energizer, Eveready and Rayovac, which enable us to address numerous distinct needs across various retailers. So we are noticing curiosity, though clearly Energizer remains our flagship and will stay that way going forward.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#14

So then, I suppose when it comes to the share gains you're referring to, they mostly come from somewhere other than Rayovac for the core Energizer business, right?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#15

Right.

Dara Mohsenian

analyst
#16

Could you talk about how the EBITDA miss this year compared with what you originally guided affects your longer-term goal of more than $700 million in EBITDA for fiscal '22? Clearly, as we talked about, a portion of those pressures is definitely shorter-lived, tied to COVID costs, though part of it looks like it's more persistent. So I just wanted to get a sense of how this hits your longer-term targets.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#17

Sure. Tim, I'll handle the longer-term piece, and then perhaps you can add a bit on the EBITDA. Dara, we're still on course to hit the long-term financial objectives we presented at Investor Day. The way I'd frame it is that in the near term, we're simply continuing to carry out the items within our control. Consider that to be integration along with the optimization of the businesses we acquired, plus our ongoing emphasis on our 3 core strategies. And then Tim, anything else you'd like to say regarding the EBITDA?

Tim Gorman

executive
#18

Yes. Dara, when it comes to the major elements, such as synergies, I believe we're still on schedule. We're surpassing what was expected and putting money back into the business. Certain short-term effects, for example the added COVID expense, will ultimately disappear. And another pattern we've observed involves some of the channel and market shifts tied to the present timeframe; thus, as we move past this, we'd anticipate things starting to return to normal in '21. So, regarding what Alan said, we're still on track right now when it comes to the long-term goals we set out.

Dara Mohsenian

analyst
#19

All right, that's useful. So from your vantage point — clearly, demand has picked up in the U.S. category, the battery category. Would you say that's largely because people are actually using more batteries? Has there been any pantry stocking? Any thoughts on whether we might see consumers draw down their pantries going forward?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#20

Dara, at this stage I wouldn't say we're too worried about pantry loading, simply given how persistent battery demand has been throughout this pandemic, and we keep conducting consumer research. What we hear back is quite persuasive that consumers truly are going through far more batteries than was once the case, since they're spending more time at home. And that, we've certainly — watched that show up in the POS trends. As we discussed on a global basis, it rose about 28%, and then 37% in the U.S. It's beginning to moderate now that shelter-in-place orders are being removed and folks are leaving their homes more often. Yet even looking solely at the 1-month data for June, it was up approximately 23% in the U.S., and that's now being offset abroad by the effect of shutdown orders, which is quite different. So you're witnessing that offset when you look at our consolidated results. But net-net, if you told us we'd navigate the pandemic and deliver organic growth from a battery standpoint of 5.3%, those are really strong results. Obviously, within the U.S. the results were stronger, and those got offset by some of the negative trends internationally. But we feel it was a really strong quarter for batteries. We do see the trends continuing. They will moderate as you get through the pandemic and people resume more normalized activities. But for now, battery business is strong and consumers are using a lot of batteries.

Kevin Grundy

analyst
#21

Kevin, I'd like to revisit the guidance if I may, and in particular I'm trying to connect where things stood back in February — how you viewed the situation then versus how you see it today. At that point, EPS was $2.45 to $2.55 — sorry, $2.45 to $2.55 — while it had been $3 to $3.20 previously, which means a decline of $0.60 at the midpoint. Then, to use round figures, COVID-related costs add another $0.20, plus FX of 15, so we're left with approximately $0.25. I do value the detail you're providing as you attempt to size COVID, but I simply want to confirm I've got the major moving pieces right, since the top line perhaps isn't landing the way you anticipated — at least on a geographic basis, or even by category — yet overall it looks reasonably solid. So if you could, walk me through that gap — the additional $0.25 — whether it's mix, supply chain expenses, other investment areas beyond COVID, and our FX?

Tim Gorman

executive
#22

Yes, Kevin, that's roughly right, and here's how the $0.25 breaks down: we deliberately chose to raise our A&P spending, which accounts for about $0.06 of that $0.25, with a strong emphasis on digital investment given the shifting dynamics underway. A further $0.06 relates to taxes and the earnings mix we have, reflecting the shifts taking place. What remains is a margin effect; and once more, we're observing channel and market shifts happening throughout COVID that are dragging things down, along with certain related costs. Even though category trends remain robust — Mark mentioned 5.3% for batteries in the quarter and 2.4% for Auto Care — for Auto Care and International, COVID affected the expectations we had established back in February, especially regarding Auto Care. Also, we were up against a soft comparison from the prior year. And although 2.4% growth is decent for the quarter, we had expected more. So that's what makes up the difference to the $0.25 — roughly $0.12 in margin, COVID's effect on the top line and margin, and then part of COVID's effect on channel and market dynamics.

Kevin Grundy

analyst
#23

All right, that helps. Then I want to ask Alan or Mark about Auto Care specifically. Earlier this year you were aiming for 3% to 5%, and then the pandemic arrived. What does that target look like today? I realize you're seeing some improvement quarter over quarter. Mark, I believe you mentioned you're optimistic about gaining some shelf space through certain resets. So where do you anticipate landing now compared with that 3% to 5%? It also doesn't seem as though your longer-term outlook on the business has turned negative, but perhaps you could share thoughts on the longer-term picture, and I'll hand it over.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#24

Thank you, Kevin. I can tell you're cutting out a bit, but I believe I got the gist regarding Auto Care growth and its current appearance. Clearly, given what the international business has been and the difficulties of operating through the crisis, managing organic growth of 2.4% in spite of that is truly encouraging for Auto Care. We're witnessing genuine momentum in the U.S. within the Auto Care category; and when you examined that category as we moved through the most recent quarter, during March, on an aggregated basis for the subcategories where we compete, it had fallen roughly 4.7%. During April, the decline was 1.7%. Then during May, it rose 18%; and those patterns have genuinely persisted as we progressed through the summer. So the signals are quite encouraging. In fact, looking at the appearance sub segment, 50% of appearance buyers during this past quarter were new to the category; so many new consumers are entering the category, and obviously our aim is to keep driving growth ahead of the category; we still have work to do in that business, both to keep rejuvenating the innovation pipeline and to keep spending money behind new creative and more A&P. But overall, I'm quite pleased with the trends we're seeing; we do expect them to persist in the U.S., and weather matters greatly in the refrigerant business too; so however the weather unfolds across August and September, that will affect results. But once more, I don't want to discuss '21 guidance for that business. Yet when I consider category trends, consider our innovation pipeline, our line reviews that will be set next year, which will drive next year's organic growth have been favorable, and people are genuinely pleased with how we're bringing innovation and being a category leader the way we have in battery. And the international growth plan keeps moving forward along with the integration. Therefore, I'd mention that additional details will arrive in November, when we discuss how Auto Care is expanding, yet I remain genuinely happy with what happened during this quarter, considering all the challenges we needed to handle, and we truly aim to speed that up once we reach '21.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#25

I think you've covered it well, Mark.

Lauren Lieberman

analyst
#26

I had actually intended to ask about Auto, same as Kevin. But here's a follow-up I might add: is there anything you're doing to tweak your marketing strategies across the channels where you advertise — the messaging and so forth — in light of shifts in how consumers behave, which, as you mentioned, ought to help the Auto category? But anything more specific regarding how you can target and really push more usage and adoption to spark buying behaviors toward a greater share of their time on the card?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#27

Yeah. Lauren, there are 2 elements to that. I mean, first, we're examining consumer behaviors and the way they're evolving because of this pandemic, and ensuring we apply that consumer insight to fuel our innovation pipeline too. And then, as you mentioned, regarding the way consumers shop the category, we're moving our spend — from an A&P perspective, and also from a trade investment perspective. You're seeing us pursue far more digital conversion tactics involving search and instacarts, and then on the media side — for want of a term, old media versus new media — reallocating between TV and moving further into streaming, video, gaming, and social media. On the trade investment side, there were certain restrictions on the kinds of promotional activities. With some retailers, we'd move those dollars away from their in-store activities toward omnichannel investments, to ensure we were putting those dollars there to help that grow. I'd say, just as a rough order of magnitude between digital and traditional, we were perhaps at a 60 to 40 split; and today we're likely leaning closer to a 50 to 50 split. So we keep moving further toward digital as this crisis has developed, and that's something we were already well along the path of doing when we went into it. And I'd say the one thing we truly did was speed that up somewhat more because of what we were seeing.

Lauren Lieberman

analyst
#28

All right, that's helpful. I have one more question about the COVID-related expenses, and I'm sorry if this was already covered. You brought up airfreight, not only things like PPE. So regarding airfreight, how much longer do you expect that to last? My assumption is that once demand settles into a more sustainable run rate, a portion of these COVID costs should begin to decline, even if you aren't ready to commit to that happening within the next 3 months. Beyond that point, though, it ought to ease. So if there's anything you can share to break down the composition of those COVID costs, so that however we decide to model COVID going forward, we can do it that way...

Tim Gorman

executive
#29

Yes, and once more, Lauren, we identified 3 categories. The total amount sitting in COGS came to approximately $9 million, with airfreight accounting for about $5 million of it. That stemmed from the global effects of COVID, along with very strong battery demand, which pushed us to bring batteries into the U.S. As you suggested, I don't anticipate this becoming an ongoing problem. We've factored the cost into the Q4 outlook. Once we reach '21, we'll evaluate what we expect. PPE came to about $1 million, and the rest, as we noted, was absorption. A few of our facilities were temporarily closed and we had to adjust labor levels, which affected the absorption rates for the batteries we were selling. So once again, under normal conditions, I wouldn't expect those to persist.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#30

And Lauren, regarding the airfreight component, there are a few points worth remembering. First, consider simply the ripple effects from the worldwide disruption—looking at the supply chain from beginning to end, several of our vendors are indeed affected. Consequently, you must make up ground at various stages along the route. Beyond that, demand's makeup differs from our projections. It's located in other regions across the globe. Because of that, once we entered the year, we needed to relocate certain inventory items away from the spots we'd originally intended. Thus, it involves multiple dimensions. Then, when the crisis ends, many of these conditions should settle back as our vendors achieve steadier operations and demand eases toward conventional patterns rather than the ones we've experienced. So essentially, two factors are behind this. Yet, echoing Tim's remark, I certainly wouldn't anticipate this turning into the standard.

Tim Gorman

executive
#31

Right. And what we actually highlighted as the 2 things that mattered most while steering our way through the pandemic were: first, keeping our colleagues healthy and safe — that came before anything else. The other was keeping the business running without interruption. And the price of guaranteeing that continuity turned out to be taking on the airfreight, since absent that, no sale would have happened; so yes, we recognize it costs more, but it was the step required to hold those service levels up where they were.

Lauren Lieberman

analyst
#32

Right. Turning to what's working in your favor — you brought up reduced travel and entertainment costs, something clearly on everyone's radar. That said, what have you discovered in that area that strikes you as something you could keep doing, such as alternative approaches to getting work done, recognizing you're able to handle more tasks off-site, and so forth. So when we consider airfreight and how certain of those expenses might ease possibly in '21, is it fair to expect some of the positive developments to endure?

Tim Gorman

executive
#33

Yes, Lauren, I believe that — please continue, Alan.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#34

Tim, what I was going to say is that we're working with the task force to assess everything we've implemented during COVID that falls under continuous improvement and can be integrated into how we run things moving forward. Putting numbers to those is still underway; we'll keep examining them; but I believe your question is reasonable. Although there were items such as that airfreight we used to guarantee continuity and fill rates for our customers, there are also beneficial outcomes emerging from this situation that we'll keep putting into practice. And we'll share more about that when we give guidance for '21. Tim?

Tim Gorman

executive
#35

Absolutely. To build on what Alan mentioned, I believe we, in common with a lot of businesses, are looking at how we work in the wake of the pandemic. Clearly, in-person commercial travel is something we can't do without; however, as far as everything else goes, is there a smarter approach to getting those activities done without physically being present. And much like other organizations, our team members are discovering that remote operations can be extremely productive; my expectation is that things will go back to how they were, yet at the same time there will be a reassessment of — is every single trip you used to take really necessary.

Faiza Alwy

analyst
#36

Mark, I believe you said you've been conducting consumer research on battery usage. Could you expand a bit on what that research is showing? What's behind the increased battery usage, especially in the U.S.? And why does it run higher here than in other markets?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#37

Faiza, this matches what we discussed during the prior call. Let's start with the U.S. Consumers are spending far more time at home, and they're using their devices more — gaming controllers, home electronics that need to work for office purposes. Those devices simply get far more use. They're being used more often. Because of that, you see the demand in the U.S.; things look a bit different across international markets. It varies from one market to another. Part of it comes down to how strict the shutdowns have been. It's the count of devices per household in certain international markets. Consumer shopping behaviors matter too. Do they purchase in bigger quantities in the U.S. the way they do in certain international markets? But really, when you look at developed international markets, the trends resemble what you'd find in the U.S. They simply aren't as elevated as what you'd observe, and in developed being and then sort of our distributor market subset, it's really — that's where — in the script, we described it as a starkly different story. That's genuinely the best description. The shutdowns were more severe. Retail shops weren't open nearly as pervasively, and businesses were deemed much more essential in a tighter way than in the U.S. So product availability just isn't there either; because of that, consumers pulled back far more than they did; and disposable income in many of those markets isn't what it is in developed markets either.

Faiza Alwy

analyst
#38

All right, and now a quick follow-up regarding Auto Care. I believe you said there was a bit of a shortfall compared with your earlier outlook for Auto Care, and it appears mostly tied to overseas markets. So I'd like you to elaborate on what's causing that, if you would. Is it again simply the retail conditions you just described? Also, I'm curious whether you believe you've missed out on refrigerant sales, considering how seasonal that business is.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#39

Regarding markets outside the U.S., I think you've hit it. That's genuinely where the gap showed up. Back in January and February, when we discussed 3.5%, that assumed a typical international selling season. Of course, that got disrupted — plenty of the retailers who stock these products abroad had closed. Consequently, those amounted to nothing but missed sales. So internationally, there was a disruption. The U.S., to be sure, has shown some solid momentum. March proved difficult, yet afterward things genuinely began improving, and that has helped counterbalance a portion of the overseas volume. On refrigerants, we don't break out figures that precisely, though the season has been stronger for them, especially considering it began poorly — both because of how many miles people drove and because folks simply weren't in their vehicles nearly as often during March and April — and the weather failed to cooperate across March and April as well. But truly, from May through June, with the heat much of the U.S. experienced, refrigerant trends looked quite striking. So from a refrigerant perspective, I'd say that business held up rather well and recovered somewhat versus what last year showed.

Tim Gorman

executive
#40

And regarding what Mark mentioned about markets outside the US, the one bright spot is that as we reached the quarter's final stretch and restrictions lifted, sales did bounce back. That's an encouraging signal we drew from the quarter.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#41

The guidance has me somewhat puzzled. Stepping back and taking in everything you've described, what comes through is really powerful momentum in Auto. You just said things are getting better internationally on the battery side, and in the U.S. battery business you're seeing pricing, with demand rising. Plus you feel that's sticky. More distribution gains are coming your way. Your A&P is climbing. So that presumably should provide a lift. Pantry deloading isn't something that worries you. So I'm somewhat puzzled as to why the organic top line growth guidance looks so subdued?

Tim Gorman

executive
#42

Well, Rob, looking at where we stand, organic growth came in at 1% year-to-date. Let me remind you that during last year's fourth quarter, our organic growth rate hit 9%. And when you take the 1% to 1.5% figure for the full year, that works out to a bit above 2% organic growth during the fourth quarter. So delivering a robust year-over-year result in the fourth quarter, and I think sustaining that through the pandemic to land at 1% to 1.5% organic growth for the full year, counts as a robust performance. What we lack, and we're also up against hurricane volume from a year ago that isn't present in the current outlook — clearly, a storm recently came up the East Coast, yet that storm contributed fairly little in terms of volume tied to it, given how fast it traveled north. Power outages exist right now. So we'll keep watching that, but hurricane activity isn't factored in. So that could be somewhat offsetting once you run the quarter-over-quarter comp.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#43

And I believe a portion of this stems from the degree of ambiguity we're simply facing regarding the broader economic situation. I mean, clearly we're observing a rise in cases across the U.S., and you're looking at global markets where certain ones are performing well while others aren't performing as strongly. It's genuinely the unpredictability of how things will ultimately shape up. There's fiscal support from the government that could either happen or not happen. You've got the financial impacts that people are experiencing. So I'd say we prefer to remain sensibly careful regarding the outlook we're providing for the fiscal year, since we simply don't have the business conditions shifting so drastically. And take March and April, for instance — we're definitely optimistic about what we're witnessing in the Auto Care segment at this moment; however, should we be forced into a strict lockdown, we've already observed the impact that can have on category patterns. So I'd say — taking into account every element we know about, we believe this is the correct decision. Of course, should the patterns we're discussing persist, then that means — we might be in a position to surpass those figures, yet we definitely want to stay careful regarding how much we attempt to forecast what lies ahead in a progressively more uncertain climate.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#44

All right. That helps a lot, and I appreciate it. I believe you touched briefly on how market share for batteries played out around the world. Could you go deeper on the U.S. and perhaps break that out between online and offline when it comes to market share?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#45

Like we said during the prepared remarks, our intention is to keep viewing this holistically inside the category. You're going to keep seeing favorable share trends across the next several reporting periods, purely because of certain distribution gains that are now visible in store. I'd add that additional distribution gains remain available across the rest of the year, and those are underway too. A lot of them sit in unmeasured and somewhat in measured; yet from a measured perspective, that's going to keep showing up consistently, and I'll talk more generally regarding online, offline. Online, we remain the branded share leader. You're watching a lot of retailers put emphasis on their omnichannel offerings and their platforms, and we're leaning in alongside them too. If you consider the digital space broadly within batteries, you're looking at the 20% to 25% range of what moved through digital. I'd say Amazon accounts for roughly 15% of that — and that 15% of that, 15% with total omnichannel sitting at 20% to 25%. Our share position online isn't as strong as it is offline, but clearly, we've redoubled our efforts to ensure we keep making sure those share positions mirror one another. Yet even inside a given retailer — going retailer to retailer, our share positions differ, retailer to retailer. Still, rest assured, we're pushing to maximize our share the right way, both online and offline retailer by retailer.

Olivia Tong

analyst
#46

A few quick follow-ups on that. To start, regarding the distribution gains that are on the way — could you share what kind of share increase you expect those to deliver? And on the e-commerce side, with the digital marketing work you've described, what exactly are you doing in e-commerce to keep building your presence and push your share up a bit more, closer to where your brick-and-mortar share sits?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#47

Olivia, one point I want to be sure we stress is that placing too much weight on share is risky — it can encourage the wrong kind of behavior when you're running the business. So chasing share for its own sake isn't what we do. What we focus on is generating solid, lasting, profitable distribution, and that's what we've accomplished across the balance of this fiscal year. Right now you're seeing many resets completed at measured retailers. Because of that, share trends will show up. I won't forecast where share lands down the road. That will simply reveal itself in the numbers, and also as channel shifting either slows or speeds up, depending on what the pandemic is doing. So the landscape keeps moving, but I'm at ease saying share figures will stay positive through this fiscal and calendar year and will probably pick up pace as you go along. When it comes to e-commerce, our approach hasn't changed; we concentrate on content; we concentrate on search; we make certain we're engaging consumers digitally; we make certain we carry out those conversion efforts so that purchases happen when consumers look for batteries online. Plenty of tactical work, but we also keep putting money into the brands and into the products; it isn't different from what we've already been doing. There's likely just more of it, and clearly it has paid off for us before; it's paying off for us in Auto Care too, where our growth rates — especially in the appearance subcategory — run at nearly triple the growth rates you'd see for the category. So we're making certain our digital team highlights not only batteries but Auto Care and lights too, and we're seeing enormous growth figures across all 3 businesses online.

Andrea Teixeira

analyst
#48

My question concerns A&P. If you wouldn't mind elaborating on that $0.06 above the earlier guidance. You mentioned digital, but how much do you figure is needed to make up ground on the promotional activity you brought up before, especially relative to the 9% comp from last year's fourth quarter? Also, do you anticipate putting some promotional dollars behind Rayovac so it's better positioned versus private label and can help the shopper dealing with the recession, which would be careless < >. As a follow-up, on exit rates, you noted June's growth came in under May's performance. Could you describe how trends have carried on since June? And then just — anything worth flagging in particular markets where reopening has moved the other way? So did you observe a comparable uptick in consumption, sorry, pardon? Or is behavior more normalized in your view?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#49

The way I'd frame it — there are a lot of questions packed in there, Andrea. On A&P spend, our message has been steady at between 5% and 6%. That matches how we're guiding for this fiscal year, and we'll finish inside that range; clearly we have to tweak along the way how those funds get allocated and invested and confirm we're getting the right return. That said, we've spotted a chance to put money behind Auto Care, especially given some of those category trends. I'd rather not discuss upcoming promotional activity for any of our brands. Still, on A&P, 5% and 6%, Rayovac represents a key piece of our — of the category within our portfolio. We will ensure we invest. Typically that tends to be somewhat more tactical spending rather than campaign-style spending on A&P. Regarding trends in the battery category, they remain strong. Again, these are U.S. figures, and we've warned people that international dynamics differ. It rose 37%, as we noted in the prepared remarks. Looking at the single month of June, it was 23%. So growth is still solid, just moderating from prior levels. For international markets, it truly hinges on which market you're in. You're seeing a fairly quick bounce back as consumers head out and into stores. Yet you're also seeing renewed shelter-in-place orders in certain places. Just yesterday, Manila issued a fairly restrictive shelter-in-place order. We have cities such as Melbourne in Australia issuing some shelter-in-place orders. So things shift quite rapidly. We have leaders across the globe reacting to that and making sure; but no, certainly, as consumers internationally can get out to stores, we'd anticipate normalized demand levels. My guess is that for every market, the issue becomes a matter of timing — when does it happen, and after that, what duration does it run? That said, our confidence in the overseas strategy is quite high. All we require is for the rules to permit folks to go out and make purchases.

William Reuter

analyst
#50

So when we look at the deleveraging course you're currently following, we're somewhat behind where I believe we expected to be 2 years back. It's not as though anyone could have anticipated COVID, but leverage is still a bit high. Have you reached a stage where you'd look at M&A possibilities, considering how strong the business's free cash flow is? Or would you rather bring leverage down from here before you'd seriously consider pursuing those kinds of opportunities?

Tim Gorman

executive
#51

So I think — go ahead, Alan.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#52

My apologies. What I meant to say was that I'd give 2 quick responses, and then Tim could add to them. So, in brief, clearly, over the longer term, our commitment to a balanced strategy when it comes to capital allocation hasn't changed. And our main emphasis will keep being on reducing debt. As far as M&A goes, briefly, we'll keep evaluating possibilities, though those would be bolt-ons within battery or Auto. And then, Tim, anything you'd like to add?

Tim Gorman

executive
#53

Nope. That's exactly right.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#54

I'd simply like to express our thanks for being with us on today's call, and we're grateful for your interest in Energizer. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#55

That brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate everyone joining the presentation today. You're welcome to leave the line now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Energizer Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Energizer Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Energizer Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.