Energizer Holdings, Inc. (ENR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 12, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Staples Household Products earnings 61 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jacqueline Burwitz

executive
#1

Hello, and thanks for being with us today. On this call, we'll cover how we performed in Q4 and fiscal 2020, plus what we expect for fiscal '21. A replay of this call can be accessed through the Investor Relations area of our site, energizerholdings.com. You'll also find a slide deck on our site that gives specifics on the quarter's results; joining me this morning are Alan Hoskins, our Chief Executive Officer; Mark LaVigne, President and Chief Operating Officer; Tim Gorman, Chief Financial Officer; and John Drabik, Senior VP, Corporate Controller. Regarding forward-looking statements, risk factors, and GAAP to non-GAAP reconciliations, please see the press release and slide presentation we put out earlier today, both accessible on our website, along with the risk factors contained in our SEC filings. Any discussion of our category and market share on this call pertains to the markets in which we operate and draws on Energizer's internal data, industry analysis, and estimates that we consider reasonable. Except where noted, every comparison is made against the equivalent period a year ago. I'll now hand things over to Alan.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#2

Thank you, Jackie, and good morning to all of you. I'm certain you noticed in the press release we issued today that there are numerous subjects for us to cover during this call. First, I'll speak about how we performed during the quarter and the year in broad terms, then I'll share some detail regarding my upcoming retirement and Mark's selection to become Energizer's next CEO. When the pandemic first hit, we made a commitment to 2 principles: safeguarding the health and safety of our team members and satisfying what our customers and consumers require. During a year full of extraordinary difficulties, we depended on a phenomenal team to adjust on the fly so that business operations could continue and so that we could position ourselves for what lies ahead. Although we made certain that our brands and products remained accessible to customers and consumers at the times and places they required them, the expense involved exceeded what we had anticipated, and that shows up in our financial results for both the quarter and the year; specifically, 3 factors have affected our business from the moment the pandemic began: elevated COVID costs stemming from our work to satisfy the heightened demand from our customers and consumers; a shifting sales mix caused by the pandemic, spanning markets, channels and products; and greater interest expense from the defensive steps we took regarding our balance sheet. Demand, especially for batteries across the U.S. and numerous developed markets abroad, stayed high and lasted a long time beginning in the middle of March. Given how long this unusually strong demand continued and how much it varied from one market to another, we met the surges in demand during the spring and summer, while simultaneously taking further steps to make sure we would be ready for the holiday season that lies ahead. Consequently, the expense of serving that greater demand ended up above our projections. Even so, from the moment the pandemic started, we chose to satisfy the demand, since we believe the worth of our relationships with customers greatly exceeds these near-term costs. As Mark will explain thoroughly shortly, our results have genuinely come from a team effort and have encompassed a wide range of actions, among them a modest acquisition, gains in supply chain operating efficiency, plant reconfigurations and genuine collaboration with our suppliers. Given what we currently know and our outlook for the future regarding demand levels, cost and product mix, we anticipate that our first quarter 2021 results will show the last of the incremental cost, with very little cost afterward even if demand stays at its present level. That said, we acknowledge that a great deal of uncertainty remains as a result of the pandemic and the way it affects the retail landscape and our business around the world. We also observed a change in our business mix spanning markets, channels and products, caused partly by consumer behavior reacting to the pandemic. In the end, this produced a net negative effect on our margins during the fourth quarter of 2020 and the full year, especially in the fourth quarter. We think part of this change is temporary, as Tim will explain, but we've factored into our 2021 guidance the business mix shifts we expect to persist into the following year, assuming nothing materially disrupts our markets, customers, or operations. Also, interest expense weighed on our results for the year, since we took a defensive stance on our balance sheet given the uncertainty we faced earlier in the year. Lately, we've moved aggressively to seize chances to reduce debt and refinance what we owe at reduced interest rates. Despite the difficulties the pandemic created, the year produced a number of notable achievements that, in our view, show how resilient our organization is and confirm the confidence we hold about this business going forward. Every major initiative tied to integrating our Battery and Auto Care acquisitions is either progressing well or finished; during 2020, we realized $51 million of synergies, and the 2021 outlook Tim will present incorporates the full-year run rate of the benefits our shareholders should expect from more than $100 million in synergies; we kept our top line momentum going, with organic net sales rising 6.1% in the quarter and 2.5% for the year. Across the most recent 3 months, we've witnessed robust category growth and share gains in both our Battery and Auto Care businesses. Specifically, our Auto Care business posted exceptionally strong results for the quarter and the full year, driven by solid operating fundamentals, compelling innovation, and favorable weather patterns. Although partly attributable to onetime items, working capital management, and the timing of inventory movements, which will reverse once we rebuild our safety stock, we substantially exceeded our free cash flow target, our #1 priority, reaching $405 million, which is up $149 million compared with the prior year; that cash flow let us pay down more than $100 million of debt as 2021 began. And we're still well positioned to keep lowering debt and follow a balanced approach to capital allocation. Lastly, our colleagues' efforts worldwide have been extraordinary, and I've witnessed more commitment over the past year toward keeping colleagues safe and keeping the business running than I could ever have envisioned. I genuinely value the hard work so many colleagues have contributed as we keep operating through the pandemic; to sum up, 2020 was a difficult year, and we're focused on 2021 and our plans to generate organic sales growth, margin expansion as the year goes on, synergy realization, and EBITDA growth. Before handing the call to Mark, I want to take a moment to discuss the CEO succession plan we announced this morning. After nearly 40 years at Energizer, including the past 5 years as CEO, I announced that I've decided to retire effective January 1, 2021, and Mark will become our new company CEO. Mark's move into this role comes after 2 years of thorough succession work alongside our Board. Having given it careful consideration, I feel the moment has arrived to hand the reins to a new generation of leadership. The spectrum businesses are almost fully integrated, we've responded to the difficulties created by the pandemic, and we're positioned to largely remove the added costs that came with serving higher demand, so the groundwork for Energizer's coming stage of expansion is firmly in place. No individual is better suited to guide Energizer through what comes next than Mark. He played a key part in shaping and carrying out our strategic initiatives, and he has led our integrated operating model while concentrating on expanding our platform and market positions across categories. I am extremely confident he will be an outstanding CEO for Energizer. For a seamless handover, I will stay on as a Director and an Adviser to the company through the close of September 2021. Serving almost a 40-year career within the Energizer family has been an honor and a privilege, and acting as its Chief Executive Officer for the past 5 years has been a pleasure. We've made bold moves to reshape the company from one built on a single category into one driven by a mission to reach industry leadership as a diversified global household products company spanning batteries, lights and auto care. I could not be more proud of everything this organization has achieved, and I want to express my thanks to the Energizer colleagues for their dedication, their commitment to excellence and their passion for winning. With that, I'll hand things over to Mark, who will give a detailed review of the business and the actions we've taken to set us on a path toward meaningful growth in 2021 and beyond.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#3

Thank you, Alan, and good morning to all of you. Taking on the CEO position is something I consider a genuine privilege, and I feel quite humbled by it. Speaking for Energizer's team members worldwide, I'd like to express appreciation to Alan for the way he has led this company and for what he has contributed, and on a personal level, for the strong partnership we've shared and will keep sharing, since we'll be working together closely during the months ahead to make sure this transition goes smoothly. Looking forward, the strategies we've set for the long term stay unchanged. We've implemented programs aimed at tackling the difficulties of late, and we're setting up the business so it can extend what it has already achieved, reinforce its leading position in the markets at its core, and generate value for those who hold our stock. Before I get into the numbers, I'd also like to express my gratitude to our team members everywhere, who keep showing day after day how resilient they are. The determination and effort they bring are extraordinarily impressive; even more significant, though, is how dedicated they are to looking after one another's health and to fulfilling what our customers need — that genuinely inspires me. Let me say a few words about the Battery and Auto Care segments, then move on to how we performed. Demand in the battery segment stayed robust, especially in North America and modern markets. On a global basis, category value rose by more than 15% during the 3 months that ended in August, which reflects a degree of easing compared with the prior quarter. Although our value share dipped a little, it came back sequentially over the most recent 3 months, thanks to new distribution that was set during the summer in the U.S. Looking at the U.S. for the 4 weeks ending October 18, the category was up by more than 7%, and we picked up a little over 3 share points. The Auto Care segment likewise kept posting very robust growth as it recovered from the spring lockdown period. That produced category value growth of 17% for the 3 months ended in August, while the appearance subsegment rose by more than 27%. Our innovation, paired with our skill at building brands, wider distribution, and sustained strong operational execution, generated momentum for our brands, which led to share gains in a category posting double-digit growth rates. Now to our financial results. The top line momentum across our businesses stayed exceptionally strong. Even though we picked up share in both Batteries and Auto Care and posted strong organic sales growth, it does not please us that we couldn't convert that into growth in earnings. What we see in our bottom line reflects the effect of shifts in our sales mix, along with greater costs stemming from our work to satisfy higher demand, especially within our Battery business. Let's go through how the sales mix changes affected us. As you might remember, we entered our fiscal year with weaker-than-expected results in Batteries after the price increases taken during 2019, plus some competitive activity. After that, as the year progressed, the pandemic brought lockdowns around the globe, which pushed our business away from higher-margin markets — some of which faced longer and harsher lockdowns — and toward lower margin markets. Beyond that, we observed shifts in how people shopped as they made their way through the pandemic, moving to various channels and frequently purchasing bigger pack sizes to keep up with rising usage. When we look at the entire year, the mix of reduced volume of higher-margin sales during Q1, followed by a move toward lower margin markets, channels and products later in the year, weighed on our gross margin; we think a lot of these elements have already turned around or will turn around across 2021. Higher costs also played a role in our margin compression, especially during Q4, as we kept pushing to satisfy as much of the greater demand as possible. As you're aware, we normally expect low single-digit growth in the Battery category, with brief stretches of stronger demand around holidays and disasters. Because of the pandemic, we saw heightened and extended demand in certain geographies. This was made more challenging as we were getting ready for the approaching holiday season. At that moment, we confronted a choice: either walk away from customers when they needed us, or stretch ourselves to deliver no matter what. For us, that decision was painful yet abundantly clear; we carried out a set of temporary measures to make sure we could serve our customers, boosting our internal production, aggressively procuring raw materials and finished goods, often at elevated prices and in some instances, absorbing tariffs and adding airfreight and co-packing capacity. A lot of these measures fall outside our typical low-cost operating model. Beyond that, we acquired a new manufacturing facility, which we expect will help us handle demand in Q1 of '21 and will deliver advantages well into the future too. These efforts led to extra costs of $29 million for the fiscal year. Taken together, the mix shift and the choice to satisfy our customers and consumers affected our gross margin by 200 basis points in 2020. Going forward, current trends indicate consumers are starting to go back to prepandemic shopping behaviors, and a portion of the mix shift is returning to historical levels. Even so, we are actively running the business on the assumption that some share of these mix shifts will persist in the short to medium term. We feel confident that our broad distribution puts us in a strong position to offset any enduring changes in the mix profile. Regarding the incremental cost, we've taken action to largely remove them by the close of Q1 of fiscal '21. To be more specific, we pinpointed 2 areas of focus to allow us to satisfy the greater demand at a cost closer to our historical model. First, we upgraded our manufacturing network to address near-term needs and back our long-term plan; and second, we restructured our global product supply teams. In Batteries, we expanded capacity in the U.S. With more lines added at both our Fennimore and Asheboro sites, and on the international side, a modernization effort wrapped up at the Singapore plant in June, giving us extra capacity. After that, in October, we bought an alkaline facility located in Indonesia. Our expectation is that these moves will substantially boost our cost-competitive capacity and let us cut back on how much product we source from third parties. Because we're building on facilities we already have, we think only minimal incremental fixed costs get added to our network, which gives us flexibility when demand shifts without leaving unnecessary costs stranded. The benefits are already showing up in the 3-month period from July through September: roughly 10% of the batteries packed in the North American market moved by airfreight, while in October that figure had fallen to 6%. Come November, it's tracking at 3%, and by December, our plans have airfreight usage going back to prepandemic levels. Over in Auto Care, even though this business did extremely well over the past year, we still see opportunities there. Specifically, we've added shifts and are operating our Dayton facility at much higher utilization rates. Over the coming months, we will — we expect to bring in additional lines at our production facilities to make our wipes products.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#4

At first, these lines will assist in meeting the tremendous demand we're experiencing for that product. Once demand settles, we anticipate being able to move some outsourced products back in-house, while also backing our International Auto Care expansion initiatives. We're likewise simplifying and enhancing the way our worldwide product supply teams function; specifically, we're putting money into our demand and supply groups, including better technology so they can forecast and navigate far greater volatility than what we've seen in the past. Beyond that, we're simplifying our end-to-end supply chain approach with a single point of accountability by category, covering everything from manufacturing through customer delivery. The steps I've just described should eliminate nearly all of the added costs by the close of the first quarter of fiscal '21, and we foresee achieving additional cost savings as time goes on. We think the final outcome will be a supply chain that's more diversified, resilient, and agile from end to end, running with a lower cost structure than existed prior to the pandemic. We're also speeding up our spending on enterprise analytics to enable better and faster decisions. Now that most of the IT integration work is finished, we're moving into the next stage of improving our systems and processes, which is meant to provide much greater visibility and understanding of our business results. Much like with supply chain, we expect the final outcome of this initiative will strengthen our capacity to examine and model our business and, in the end, give us better predictability regarding cost to serve and new consumer trends. On the whole, we'll keep concentrating on what we've done time and again in recent years: locating places where we can take costs out of our business and boost margins. As we move forward with integrating our recent acquisitions, we spotted further chances to streamline and simplify our organization. We think these efforts will let us boost our overall margins, while still keeping the flexibility to put money into growth, which emerge in our categories. Before I hand the call to Tim, I'd also like to speak about our outlook, including giving an update on the long-term targets for fiscal 2022; given our fiscal 2020 results and the expectations for 2021 that appeared in our earnings release, we're now projecting growth from a lower base than previously expected. Consequently, we no longer expect to hit our prepandemic targets of $700 million in EBITDA and $400 million in free cash flow in 2022. That said, we anticipate delivering growth past 2021 founded on the financial algorithm that support the long-term targets we gave earlier, which Tim will explain in a moment. Looking forward, we stay dedicated to our strategic priorities, which were essential to achieving 5 consecutive years of organic growth. Looking ahead, it's obvious we have to keep our revenue trajectory strong while also pushing hard on efficiency, so we can eliminate those short-term added expenses and get back to the lean operating structure we've traditionally had. In periods such as this one, there's real value in getting back to fundamental execution and concentrating on the things that generate lasting shareholder value. The foundation for achieving that value begins with carrying out our fiscal 2021 plan perfectly, and that's exactly what we're dedicated to doing. So with that, I'll hand things over to Tim now.

Tim Gorman

executive
#5

Thanks, Mark, and welcome everyone joining us. In addition to the earnings release distributed this morning, there's a slide deck on our website highlighting several additional key financial metrics. First, I want to review our three main earnings measures for the quarter: earnings per share, EBITDA and free cash flow. Changes in sales mix spanning our markets, channels and products, along with elevated COVID-related costs, hurt our fourth-quarter results, yielding adjusted earnings per share of $0.59 and adjusted EBITDA of $140 million. An increase in the tax rate further reduced earnings per share. Both adjusted EBITDA and earnings per share landed under the outlook we had given previously. Adjusted free cash flow, by contrast, reached $161 million and beat expectations by a wide margin. The main reason was sizable working capital benefits stemming from the demand spikes that Alan and Mark talked about earlier. Now some more detail on what drove these results. To begin, organic revenue rose 6.1%, reflecting positive outcomes in every one of our categories, fueled by distribution gains and robust replenishment tied to stronger demand, especially in North America. Those gains were partly offset by a year-over-year drop in measured storm-related sales and higher cost to serve from continued elevated demand in batteries. Because battery demand was so high and that strained how well we could fill orders, we absorbed higher costs to serve, and we think that will be a drag on Q1 2021, although we expect those expenses to decline in subsequent quarters as a result of the steps Mark outlined previously. We've already talked a lot about growing battery demand, but I also want to point out that following the March and April lockdowns, demand rose in our Auto Care business as well, because shoppers became more intent on maintaining their vehicles' cleanliness and shifted toward doing it themselves. We beat the category as customers responded to our brands and innovation. As a result, our Auto Care business posted an 18.6% increase in organic sales for the quarter. At the company-wide level, gross margin declined by 370 basis points, landing at 38.4%. That reflects $19 million in additional COVID-related costs along with currency headwinds and an unfavorable sales mix, though anticipated synergies of $9.4 million provided partial offset. A&P increased by $12.8 million, reaching 5.3% of sales, as we continue putting money behind our brands and innovation. SG&A, once you set aside acquisition and integration costs, came down by about $4 million to 15.6% of net sales — a 150 basis point improvement driven by synergies and reduced travel. Despite generating solid top line growth, we missed the September guidance we provided for both EBITDA and EPS, and there were 3 reasons for that. To start, we saw $6 million in additional COVID-related expenses because of increased demand — mostly customer fines and penalties — and that took a toll on both sales and gross margin. Then there was another $4 million in higher costs for product we source from third parties, tariffs included. And finally, our SG&A savings came in below our own forecast, in part due to $6 million connected to factoring costs, legal fees, and compensation expenses. The uptick in factoring activity also affected where our free cash flow landed for the year. Taken together, these factors account for a $16 million decline in EBITDA and, once you layer in a higher tax rate, about $0.20 per share in earnings. During this quarter, the debt markets were favorable, allowing us to refinance our senior notes from 2025 and 2026, which had a principal amount of $1.35 billion. These refinancings had a positive net present value, lowered our yearly interest rates, resulting in roughly $17.5 million in annual savings, and extended the maturity of those borrowings by about three years. Because of these actions, we reported a loss on debt extinguishment of $90.7 million, or $1.01 per share; now let's turn to our 2021 outlook. As we continue to deal with the pandemic's fallout, we've set some assumptions to steer our operating and financial planning projections. These cover how long the pandemic lasts, how severe it is, and its worldwide macroeconomic impact. Specifically, for fiscal 2021 we aren't factoring in any major interruptions to our manufacturing plants, distribution centers or customers around the world. Our expectation is that competition in retail will remain intense and that commodity costs will stay favorable. Should any of these assumptions shift, the results we anticipate could take a substantial hit. Now for the specifics on our key metrics: we're projecting net sales growth between 2% and 4%, with Batteries expected to land at the lower end of that range and Auto Care at the upper end; gross margin should come in roughly flat, and that includes about $15 million in COVID costs during the first quarter, with only minimal COVID costs in the quarters that follow; adjusted earnings per share between $2.95 and $3.25; adjusted EBITDA between $600 million and $630 million; and adjusted free cash flow between $325 million and $350 million, as working capital gets back to more normal levels. We're mainly expecting things to get better because of a few factors: we think revenue will keep climbing, COVID-related expenses should come down, we'll start realizing more of the synergies we've been working toward, and interest costs will be lower thanks to carrying less debt on average plus the refinancing moves we made in 2020. On the currency side, we're looking at a modest boost in 2021, and commodities should be roughly neutral, maybe a touch favorable. Working against some of that, though, is the margin squeeze we dealt with in 2020 — we think part of it carries over into 2021, since certain shifts across markets, channels and products aren't going away. We'd also like to give a brief refresher on how sales flowed by quarter during 2020. During last year's first quarter, we experienced lower sales, especially for Battery. Then, because demand has stayed high across numerous markets, we expect a large portion of 2021's net sales growth to land in this quarter. Demand for Battery and Auto Care jumped due to COVID lockdowns, with that jump starting near the close of Q2 and continuing all the way through Q4. Our expectation is that net sales growth will keep going until we lap those Battery spikes. Once that happens, we foresee modest declines in net sales compared with the prior year as demand moves closer to a more typical level, especially in North America; given our present assumptions, we expect to keep incurring incremental COVID expenses during Q1, with a favorable comparison against comparable COVID costs in Q3 and Q4 of 2021. As 2021 unfolds, we would anticipate a steady uptick in gross margin rates. Shifting to capital allocation. Our commitment to a balanced strategy for capital allocation remains intact for the long haul. For the time being, our priority will stay on deleveraging. Thanks to robust free cash flows during Q4, we've already retired $100 million of debt in October. We closed out 2020 with net debt to credit defined EBITDA under 5x, and we anticipate continuing to produce solid cash flow that can bring leverage down by as much as 0.5 turn annually. We also intend to keep investing in our businesses so we can reach a sixth straight year of organic sales growth, finish bolt-on acquisitions in Battery and Auto Care, and simultaneously give cash back to shareholders via our dividend and opportunistic share buybacks. Today, we shared that our Board has declared our quarterly dividend and given the green light to a fresh share repurchase authorization covering 7.5 million shares. When we look at 2021, our outlook assumes we capture the complete benefit of over $100 million in synergies we expect to achieve. Beyond fiscal 2021, our plan is to bring back guidance based on the same financial framework that underpinned our long-term targets prior to the arrival of the pandemic. To put it plainly: we aim to expand the top line more quickly than the categories we compete in — which, in ordinary conditions, would mean growth ranging from flat to low single digits — while also improving gross margins and SG&A, which together would deliver consistent low to mid-single-digit gains in EBITDA and EPS. After conditions return to normal, we would expect free cash flow to return to its historical level of 11% to 13% of net sales. Lastly, we still expect to complement shareholder returns with a dividend. At this point, I'd like to hand the call back to Alan for his closing remarks.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#6

Thanks, Tim. Like I mentioned before, COVID-19 brought a lot of difficulties throughout the fiscal year. Even so, we think the strategies we've presented today will get us back on track toward achieving significant growth in fiscal 2021. During this fiscal year, our attention will go toward fueling top line growth by way of innovation, putting money into and reinforcing our brands for the long term, and boosting productivity so we can simplify and standardize the business and bring costs down. With that said, I'd like to hand things over now to the operator, who will open up the line for questions.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#7

Alan, well done. Working alongside you has been a pleasure. Mark, my congratulations to you as well as we carry on down this road.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#8

Thank you, Bill.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#9

I suppose, before we examine what might be the single largest factor behind your view that you won't reach that $700 million in EBITDA in 2022, I'm just attempting to grasp it. It appears many of these shifts across the last few quarters were transitory. And as we head toward 2022, ideally, matters ought to normalize. So please help me out if there's one primary reason and why — why reaching it isn't possible.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#10

Of course. Bill, I can take you through part of the reasoning behind our position; we held numerous lengthy discussions on this and genuinely stepped back to reconsider. Right now we find ourselves amid tremendous upheaval in the marketplace. Putting together a plan for '21 proved somewhat difficult, yet we believed our grasp of the building blocks was sufficient to give the outlook we provided today. However, once you step back and consider the macro backdrop involving the pandemic — its length and how severe it is, plus the effect on markets globally, and how a vaccine could influence where any of those items head. Then, I believe, you examine the economic consequences from a fallout perspective, any government stimulus that might or might not be rolled out, whether within the U.S. or globally, and afterward the resulting effects you'd observe those having on our categories. Considerable uncertainty surrounds every one of those items. And the farther ahead you look, the harder it becomes to predict what the effects would be and how our business would be shaped at that point. So taking everything together — and then secondly, we have enormous top-line growth. Consumers everywhere are seeking out our brands. We've captured the synergies. Yet we must also acknowledge that we took on substantial transitory costs, which our business needs to resolve. Those costs can't be accepted, and we must act and have acted to aggressively remove them. And from there, I think you consider rebuilding growth from a lower base than what we originally anticipated. There's a lesser factor, I'd say, at play here, and that's the International Auto Care growth plan. It's still moving forward — it will still expand and expand at a healthy pace, though it has decelerated somewhat owing to certain disruptions surrounding the pandemic. We factored in all of those elements, and we simply believed it was wise to concentrate on delivering '21. We intend to return to fundamentals. We intend to ensure we deliver precisely what we just described regarding '21 and then keep advancing with the financial algorithm we rolled out a couple of years ago.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#11

All right. So it isn't automatically out of the question. It's simply that with only 2 years remaining, there's no benefit to establishing an enormous base.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#12

I'd say that's a reasonable point.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#13

Okay, I follow. Then for my second point, I'm just attempting to get a handle on what was said regarding the way the mix moved during this quarter in Batteries, with more multi types — that part makes sense to me. What I'm really trying to figure out, though, is why this counts as new rather than something that existed from when we began in March, or in what way it had an incremental effect. And also, perhaps, did it land more heavily on the Rayovac side? Or did it lean more toward the Energizer side? Or does it show up pretty much everywhere?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#14

What I'd say is that the majority of the effects we laid out apply throughout the category. Beyond that, the shift in mix within our batt business has genuinely been driven by a market mix shift — meaning that once certain higher-margin markets got shut down, demand came in below what we had anticipated. A portion of that demand moved into higher or lower margin markets where shutdowns had less of an impact; our view is that this is the piece that will reverse soonest, as some markets reopen and even certain shutdowns that took place in Europe lately have proven less restrictive than they were at the start. On top of that, there's the channel and pack size dynamic, where consumers move to different channels for shopping and additionally purchase bigger pack sizes since they're going through more batteries. That is an item we believe — and it has already begun to revert, both in terms of channel shifting back and a bit of pack size reversion. Consequently, we figure roughly half of that will carry over into fiscal '21 when it comes to the channel and pack size. After that, we'll keep working to ensure the margin impact is reduced as we move into '22. That said, we have factored in a headwind of about a 50 basis point because of some of those shiftings in '21.

Jason English

analyst
#15

I'd like to add my congratulations to the two of you, and particularly to you, Alan. Your career at Energizer has been lengthy and distinguished. Congratulations on that.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#16

Thanks, Jason.

Jason English

analyst
#17

I have two questions. The first one is really straightforward. What's your free cash flow guidance for the coming year? I'm not entirely clear on what adjusted free cash flow means. Could you just tell me what you expect for actual cash flow — free cash flow for '21.

Tim Gorman

executive
#18

Sure. Operating cash flow is going to decline. The way we define adjusted free cash flow, we exclude the cash flow tied to acquisitions and integration. We anticipate roughly $20 million of noncash items in that figure. And on the whole, it comes to approximately $60 million. So the $325 million to $350 million we cite essentially mirrors working capital getting back to a normalized state; in other words, $325 million to $350 million, with total working capital reverting to normal. Beyond that, during this year we benefited from a onetime recovery of roughly $30 million in the early part of the year, and that won't happen again.

Jason English

analyst
#19

So we subtract $20 million from that to arrive at something like actual usable free cash flow? Free cash flow we can deploy? Did I get that correct?

Tim Gorman

executive
#20

Correct.

Jason English

analyst
#21

All right, understood. And Mark, I realize it's still quite soon, and you've only just taken on this new leadership position. Even so, I'd welcome a few initial impressions about what you might want to approach differently when it comes to the strategic path for this business. I'm confident you already have certain thoughts in mind. You've clearly occupied a role with considerable sway. So a dramatic overhaul is hard for me to picture, yet I'm certain you'll seek opportunities to leave your own stamp on the company. Could you share a few of those early impressions on that subject?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#22

Of course, Jason. I'd say it's a bit soon to really nail down any particular new course we might choose. Naturally, we'll keep pursuing the 3 strategic priorities already in place: lead with innovation, operate with excellence and drive productivity. Those stay the same. For '21, I'd describe our focus as pretty straightforward. It's to sustain the top line momentum already achieved, to keep putting money behind our brands, to keep pushing innovation within our categories, since consumers keep responding well to it. On the organizational side, the emphasis has to be on 2 things. We must remove from the system the costs we took on during '20 and repair the margin profile that deteriorated throughout '20. We also must boost our visibility from a financial standpoint so we can sharpen visibility and our analytics, which lets us make better decisions, and then, honestly, just improve how we communicate externally so we can offer clearer sight into where we believe the shape of the P&L is heading. If those items get done, I'd call '21 a success. I also think we carry forward the momentum Alan set in motion with the company immediately following separation, and we aim to keep building on it. Down the road, certain things will surely look different, but I'm not prepared to nail those down until I've spent a bit more time in the seat and had further conversations about them.

Lauren Lieberman

analyst
#23

I'm curious — I realize that focusing on the past isn't particularly enjoyable, yet in this case it's likely the right thing to do. Looking back at how your worldwide supply chain was structured, the capacity you had available, again, everything before the pandemic, what options existed, correct? A pandemic plus that spike in demand wasn't in your business plan for good reason, nor should it have been. So looking back now, are there simply things on the operational side that ought to have been arranged differently from the start? Had you not yet adapted to the notion that battery demand had reached a low point and was beginning to recover in a structural manner? If we could essentially remove the COVID spike, did this situation expose weaknesses in the earlier setup, the earlier plan? I'd be interested to hear about that.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#24

That's an excellent question, Lauren. Obviously, with hindsight, given everything we now understand about the pandemic, every one of us would have made different plans going into it; even so, I think our supply chain performed very effectively throughout this pandemic. Here's what I think it accomplished — we had for a long time pushed the organization to become more flexible and agile. That's something we've advocated for years. As we entered the pandemic, keep in mind that our battery demand curve tends to be reasonably stable and steady, with bumps around holidays and then surge capacity when disasters hit. We've planned for that and handled it successfully for a long time. During the pandemic, what you observed was that it stayed prolonged and elevated over a lengthy stretch. Because we operate very efficiently from a capacity perspective throughout the year, clearly, the longer demand remained elevated, the more of a problem that would become given our existing constraints. We anticipated that. Consequently, I'm genuinely impressed by what the organization has managed to accomplish, since we basically asked the organization to navigate the pandemic, keep executing the integration, and midway through it redesign your supply chain — and they managed all 3. We installed lines in Fennimore. We installed lines in Asheboro. We installed more efficient lines in Singapore, and we acquired a new facility in Indonesia. That reshapes our capacity to be more flexible and agile, and it does so without raising our cost structure in the system. So overall, the temporary expenses we dealt with across the past 6 or 7 months are not something we can accept. But we faced that directly, we resolved it, and they won't keep going after we finish Q1 — and pulling that off within 6 or 7 months while the pandemic was still raging says a lot about what this organization can achieve. So the supply chain, I'd say, was performing well, and going forward it will perform even better.

Kevin Grundy

analyst
#25

Thanks, and Alan and Mark, I'd also like to congratulate the two of you. I have a couple of questions. Mark, for the first one, picking up on a few things that came up earlier on this call — in particular, enterprise systems and what they mean for your guidance. You mentioned this already, and if I understood correctly, the point was that having these new systems up and running should improve your capacity to model the business. You're obviously going to feel worried and let down, and that makes sense. With only one month remaining before the quarter closes, the profit guidance, or the actual profit results, came in below expectations. So where does that leave you right now in that process — and I know conditions are unpredictable — specifically regarding your systems and enterprise analytics work? When will that effort wrap up? And obviously the next thing to ask would be: based on what you've got today, how much confidence can you express about the fiscal '21 guidance as it currently stands? Is there reason for investors to worry about whether you can hit it? I also have another question after that.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#26

Every one of those is a reasonable question, Kevin. When I consider our position with enterprise analytics, our company, once we finished those integrations, turned into something more complicated. There were additional sizable and important markets across the globe. There was also a wider-ranging assortment of products, plus brands that needed tracking and monitoring. The initial task involved moving each of those acquired businesses onto one common platform and placing all personnel inside a single setting, something we managed to accomplish during '20; the logical next phase is to begin tweaking those systems so they produce data more quickly and in a fashion that's more dependable. The work is genuinely well along on that front. We've conducted numerous deep dives during the past 6 months into those systems, examining how we might modify them and which changes are required. We're definitely not fully there yet, and this will remain a continuing effort as we progress through '21. However, regarding visibility, processes, and systems, we've already observed gains; we will keep seeing gains each quarter across '21. I'd say the shift to the final state will occur at the close of '21, yet definitely, consistent enhancement along the way; we acknowledge the misses we've experienced previously, and we treat those with great seriousness. They frustrate us. Consequently, you may be certain, we applied considerable diligence to what we just shared today and ensured we felt quite at ease with the figures we released today, acknowledging that our past record has been uneven. The sole method to alter that is simply to keep achieving the figures we promise and demonstrate to you that matters will get better.

Kevin Grundy

analyst
#27

Understood. Let me ask Tim a quick follow-up about the guidance. I'm just considering the main factors behind the EBITDA bridge from fiscal '20 to '21, and Mark mentioned specifically that there's a real effort to remove some of those costs from the system. But from what I can tell, there doesn't appear to be much expectation of that actually occurring. My thinking here is that you can run through the figures and apply a sensible incremental margin to what you anticipate achieving on the top line. Synergies will be significant again this year, and your track record on delivering them has been solid so far. FX and commodities aren't playing a major role. Then, once you factor in the COVID costs you identified in the first quarter, that essentially gets you to where you need to be. That math basically lands you at what you're projecting for the year, which raises the question: why would more of those COVID costs be leaving the P&L over the remainder of the year? So perhaps you could address that, or maybe clarify where my thinking might be off regarding how you view the next 12 months?

Tim Gorman

executive
#28

Yes. Kevin, we identified approximately $29 million in COVID costs for this year, and what we've included for next year — all of it landing in the first quarter — is $15 million; that works out to a decline of roughly $14 million in those costs year-over-year. So those costs are indeed coming out, and the trends, as we said, are favorable on that front. Our present expectation is that by the time the first quarter ends, they'll be basically gone. That's factored into the EBITDA outlook we gave. The main reason you aren't seeing more is simply that we expect gross margin to be flat compared with last year, including the $15 million in COVID costs during Q1.

Andrea Teixeira

analyst
#29

Congratulations to you both, Alan and Mark. My question again concerns the margin side. To build on your earlier comment, when we look back at the guidance from before COVID, you've just adjusted that out, and there were also the synergies we had in the Auto business. So I'd like to bridge this: what's the new implied, all things equal, more normalized base of profitability? It sounds like a lot hinges on either getting price back, more competitive pricing, or channel. I was just wondering how we ought to think about this longer term. Should we take 2021 adjusted for COVID, then apply that over the long run, and perhaps assume the synergies you could extract were all embedded in your 2021?

Tim Gorman

executive
#30

Yes. So Andrea, as far as '21 goes, the COVID effect comes to roughly 50 basis points. That puts you at about 41 1 excluding COVID. Then the rest of the erosion we saw in '20, including the COVID costs, currency acted as a headwind. The final piece we mentioned on this call was the mix impact. We therefore anticipate those mix impacts persisting into '21, which explains why you aren't seeing a higher gross margin rate in 2021. Yet going forward, we expect normalization and the rate to improve as we progress. Mark, I don't know whether there's anything else you'd like to add.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#31

That's everything.

Andrea Teixeira

analyst
#32

Right, I'm just having trouble with this — since you'll be lapping that mix shift, correct? Unless what you're telling us is that it gets worse throughout fiscal 2021 — clearly, you've still got the first quarter left to deal with, right, the first, and in all likelihood, the first half of the fiscal year, but after that you'll be lapping it. So unless you're saying something like folks will keep stocking up even more through the channels? Or what you're observing is simply people trading down even inside your mix, within the brands? Is that a reasonable assumption, or...

Mark LaVigne

executive
#33

No, here's how we're looking at gross margin for '21, and once more, I don't — providing '22 gross margin guidance isn't something we want to back into; but when you consider gross margin, from the guide we gave at the start of '20 through the actuals of '20, we had $29 million of direct COVID costs, and $15 million of that carries forward into '21. Regarding the mix shift, we stated that half of it, in our view, carries into '21. You'll have both market customer channels, with some combination reverting back. Past '21, we'll evaluate that as we move through '21. But we already see, from a direct cost and a direct mix standpoint, half of each returning in '21. So as we move through '21, we'll get a better handle on any long-term changes. But as of now, we don't expect any. And there are plenty of actions we're taking to make sure we have improving gross margins past '21.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#34

A few items. To start, could you update us on the status of service levels with those retailers that triggered the penalties? And is it your expectation that this carries over into calendar 2021?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#35

From a fill rate perspective, I'd describe our position as significantly improved compared with the stretch that led to the fines we discussed today. Around mid-September through mid-October, we did hit what I'd call a bit of a squeeze when it came to service levels; however, as we stand right now going into the holiday season, those service levels are quite robust.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#36

Great. Then next, could you give us some color on how the mix across channels is changing? Does this represent a move toward e-commerce? And perhaps you could help us understand how that channel mix looked in the prior year versus the current one, so we can see the individual pieces more clearly?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#37

Robert, here's how I'd put it: taking '19 as your reference point, what happened in '20 was, clearly, a big surge in e-commerce, spanning both pure-play digital and the omnichannel options that retailers provide; that grew substantially. At a certain moment in that year, digital accounted for roughly 21%, or more than 21%, of the Battery category. Since then it has fallen to 16%, and afterward to 13%, depending on which retailers are included in or excluded from that figure. Still, that tells you in a directional sense where the change happened and where things are heading. The simplest way I can frame it is that shoppers genuinely wanted to make fewer trips, and those trips were larger when they went to retailers. What you therefore observed was certain smaller retailers struggling while bigger retailers gained. So it really amounted to consumers saying, I'd rather not visit the store at all. I'll use a digital platform instead. Or if I do go, I'll load up, and I'll choose a large store with a wider selection. Some of that is now reversing — I mean, as the pandemic progressed, you did see more specialized retailers gain, especially in the auto channel, where foot traffic improved because it was a compact shopping experience that consumers knew they could get into and out of faster. So there genuinely has been a dynamic of consumers moving around in terms of which stores they patronize. Consequently, we see part of that carrying over into '21, especially given that the pandemic is showing a bit of a resurgence right now, though we expect it to settle down. Our assumption is, say, Q3, Q4 as we sort of make our way through the year.

Rob Ottenstein

analyst
#38

Excellent. And as a last point, in what way are you weighing the balance between what you charge and your portion of the market? You're gaining a solid portion of the market. The brands are robust. Overall, demand from consumers is robust. In what way are you considering, hey, perhaps push prices up to counter a portion of the elevated costs?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#39

Well, I would say — please, Alan.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#40

Absolutely, Robert — that's something we review routinely, and we weigh all sorts of considerations when judging if a price adjustment makes sense in the market. Right now, our view is that it doesn't, though we'll keep watching it. Still, when it comes to pricing broadly, what we're seeing around the world is that retail pricing conditions are holding steady. As for what retailers are paying, we believe we're sitting in a fairly solid spot at this point. As you'd expect, we'll take an initial step alongside our retail partners to strip out inefficiencies and expenses within our own operations, and that's exactly what Mark described earlier during the prepared remarks.

Faiza Alwy

analyst
#41

I'm not sure whether I overlooked this, but could you break down Battery sales between International markets and the U.S. for us? Also, I'd really like to hear your thinking on that for 2021. I know you mentioned a 2% sales growth figure for batteries. How should we think about that split between the U.S. and International?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#42

Looking at the International market side, what we observed is, clearly, fairly steep declines as we made our way through the pandemic, and certain shutdown measures proved more extreme than others. Over recent months, once those restrictions had lapped, a rebound has appeared. In the aggregate, they aren't fully back to where they stood before, but they're certainly much improved compared with what I'd call the May-June-July period.

Tim Gorman

executive
#43

Correct, Faiza. Like we mentioned, several markets took a heavy hit from the pandemic. When you look at Q4, International came in only marginally above flat, while the Americas posted robust growth, powered by North America. For the entire year, that pattern largely held. In Q3, as we shared in our report, International had actually declined, whereas the Americas were up almost 9%. So International definitely felt the effects. As Mark pointed out, over the course of '21, we anticipate that International will return to its usual historical patterns.

Olivia Tong

analyst
#44

To start, Alan, congratulations on retiring; and Mark, congratulations as well — I suppose welcome to this new position. What I wanted to ask about is EBITDA. My sense is that we're not in an ordinary environment, and when the $700 million goal was established, nobody was expecting COVID. At the same time, that plan also didn't count on stronger demand, more shelf space, and, as I see it, a fairly steady macro climate. So judging by your updated growth objectives, it appears reaching that initial goal wouldn't happen until 2024; yet your fiscal '21 EBITDA objective sits just $10 million away from where you aimed before the pandemic; so then, what has shifted to cause one more year of postponement from that $600 million to $630 million figure, assuming you believe airfreighting returns to usual levels within the coming months and the battery mix goes back to how it was? You've mentioned a few times, it seems, that by the second half of '21 most of these items return to something closer to normal. So any elaboration on that would be appreciated.

Mark LaVigne

executive
#45

Olivia, what mainly explains this choice, I'd say, is simply how unclear the macro environment is and what the pandemic's lingering consequences will be; and with — as you look further ahead, it clearly gets more difficult to forecast those consequences; and given the costs we took on in '20, our priority is making them transitory, clearing them out, while also acknowledging that we're expanding from a smaller base. So to reach the very same levels we'd have needed to hit in '22, the growth rates would need to rise quite sharply. Naturally, we'll put in the effort to make that happen, but we preferred not to publish figures with a substantial degree of uncertainty surrounding them. And of course, once things move past 2022, we concluded it made sense to simply return to the financial algorithm. That approach worked well for us starting at separation, so let's execute '21. As you noted, if we deliver on '21 and hit what we've laid out, we're back on track. After that, we can give '22 guidance once we reach the close of '21.

Carla Casella

analyst
#46

I'd like to ask about the mix you mentioned. Could you explain what contributed most to pushing the margin lower on the mix shift side? And I apologize, but does that figure include customer penalties when you refer to mix shift, or are those listed separately?

Mark LaVigne

executive
#47

Regarding gross margin, let's break out direct COVID costs of $29 million, which takes in the fines and penalties. On the mix shift, representing about another 100 basis points of gross margin decline, we have not broken down the shift among markets, channels and pack sizes. Still, I'd say that if you walked through it, you could roughly put a third, a third, a third against each one, and you'd land pretty close to that impact.

Alan Hoskins

executive
#48

We appreciate you being with us on today's call, and once more, thank you for your ongoing interest in Energizer. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#49

That brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate your joining us for today's presentation. You're welcome to disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Energizer Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Energizer Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Energizer Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.