Energizer Holdings, Inc. (ENR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 14, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jon Poldan
executiveHello everyone, and thanks for joining us for Energizer's conference call covering the fourth quarter of fiscal 2023. Here with me are Mark LaVigne, our President and Chief Executive Officer, along with John Drabik, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. If you'd like to hear this call again, a replay will be posted in the Investor Relations area of energizerholdings.com. We've also put a slide deck on our site that lays out the quarter's financial results in detail. Throughout this call, we'll be sharing forward-looking statements regarding the company's future business and financial performance, along with other topics. Such statements reflect management's present expectations and carry risks and uncertainties that could lead actual results to differ materially; we take on no obligation to revise these forward-looking statements. Additional factors that might cause actual results to diverge materially from what these statements suggest appear in the reports we submit to the SEC. Our presentation also touches on non-GAAP financial measures. You can find a reconciliation of those non-GAAP financial measures against comparable GAAP measures in the press release we issued earlier today, which is posted on our website. Any information about our categories and estimated market share covered in this call applies to the categories in which we compete and draws on Energizer's internal data, industry analysis, and estimates we consider reasonable. Data on the battery category covers retail sales in both brick-and-mortar and e-commerce. Except where stated otherwise, everything we say about the quarter and the year refers to Energizer's fiscal year, and any comparison to the prior year refers to the equivalent period in fiscal 2022. With that said, I'll hand things over to Mark.
Mark LaVigne
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being here on our call to discuss the close of our fiscal year. Now that fiscal 2023 is wrapping up, I'd like to begin by going over the goals we set when the year began: getting gross margin back on track, returning to solid free cash flow production, and reducing our debt. Throughout the year, we've made strong headway on all three fronts, and that includes a gross margin gain of 170 basis points compared with last year, $340 million in free cash flow, and $225 million of debt reduction; in addition, we posted adjusted earnings per share and adjusted EBITDA that landed inside the guidance ranges we originally provided, even with the effects of stubborn inflation and macroeconomic headwinds. I want to express my gratitude to our teams around the world, because these outcomes reflect their commitment, their execution, and their attention to the basics. Looking forward, a number of factors are shaping our thinking for 2024. To begin with, we have a macroeconomic environment in which higher interest rates, the restart of student loan payments, and the expiration of emergency pandemic benefits represent only some of the forces weighing on how consumers feel. That change in consumer confidence has been made worse by ongoing inflation, which pushes shoppers to be more careful and to shift what their households buy between discretionary and nondiscretionary items. When it comes to how our categories are affected, let's begin with batteries. To grasp how the pandemic and wider inflationary patterns have affected both value and volume, it's essential to examine the category over a longer horizon. Globally, the battery category saw a surge in volume growth during the pandemic, when people spent more time at home and with their devices. As people move closer to their pre-pandemic habits, volume came back down from the high points reached in 2020 and 2021. On top of that, inflation throughout the store, along with a number of price hikes in the battery category, contributed to the drop in volume. Now that we've started to lap those effects, we've observed a resumption of category volume growth in the U.S. over recent periods. The upshot is a category that is 5% bigger now than before the pandemic, at approximately 20 billion cells compared with 19 billion cells in 2019. Since 2015, global category volume has posted a compounded annual growth rate of about 1.5%. During that same span, U.S. category volume has risen by roughly 1% each year. Device ownership is what gives the category its strength and stability, and it serves as the main driver of consumption. Since 2015, the count of devices per U.S. household has grown by over 5%. The way smartphones have become part of everyday life has opened up a world of connected devices, with more than 50% of those using primary batteries, including connected home products like security cameras, doorbells, and smart tags, as well as health devices such as blood pressure monitors and pain relief devices. The device pipeline ahead is strong as well. We expect worldwide consumer devices to keep expanding, and many will still use primary batteries, just as they do now. Over the long run, our view for the category stays at flat to low single-digit volume growth, backed by these healthy category fundamentals. Turning to Auto Care. Auto Care continues to be an appealing space for growth, underpinned by strong category dynamics. Miles driven are above pre-pandemic levels, more than 6% higher than 2019. The carpark's age and size are rising too. Vehicles in the U.S. have been getting older on average, and that average now sits above 12 years, while the fleet has added more than 3 million vehicles in the past year. As cars keep aging and consumers contend with economic pressures, a growing number say they handle car care on their own rather than choosing do-it-for-me options. With that as the broader backdrop across our categories, this is how we view FY '24. Our plan rests on carrying forward our strategic priorities: continued margin recovery, generating free cash flow and paying down debt. Those goals make sure we can put money into our business and hit the financial algorithm, and both create meaningful value for our shareholders. Project Momentum is a major driver; having realized $50 million in fiscal '23, we will add another $80 million to $100 million in savings across the next 2 years, giving us the flexibility to operate in this environment. Through this downturn, we intend to speed up investments, concentrating on innovation and brand building to fuel consumer engagement and build long-term consumer preference; in batteries, we will stay disciplined as we weigh pricing and promotion strategies against the need to engage consumers, deliver top line and capitalize on the improving volume trends. In balancing these factors, our main focus is on the overall health of the category and on further strengthening the earnings power of the business. In a healthy category with improving earnings, we will not chase share at the cost of those 2 objectives; in Auto Care, we take pride in the growth we have delivered. Top line has risen by more than $90 million since 2020. That equals a 6% compounded annual growth rate and aligns with our low to mid-single-digit growth expectations over the long term. Looking forward, we have an exciting slate of innovation coming this year, and we will keep investing behind new product development and launches. Fiscal '23 was a pivotal year for Auto Care. We made tremendous progress restoring profitability, lifting operating margins by almost 500 basis points versus last year, while keeping the top line stable. This emphasis on pricing, innovation and cost control will drive additional margin improvement through fiscal 2024. Now let me hand the call to John, who will share more details on our financial performance and fiscal 2024 guidance.
John Drabik
executiveThanks, Mark. Before I move on to what we expect for 2024, I'll walk through a fuller recap of both the quarter and the entire fiscal year. Just a quick note that a slide deck covering our main financial metrics is available on our site. Once again, the organization turned in a strong fourth quarter, capping off a year during which pricing and the savings delivered by Project Momentum helped counter persistent macro headwinds, and we landed adjusted earnings per share and EBITDA inside the ranges we originally guided. Revenue as reported rose 2.6%, while organic revenue was higher by 2%. On the organic side, we got 150 basis points from pricing in both battery and auto. On top of that, volume contributed roughly 100 basis points, driven by batteries shipping ahead of the holidays for holiday sales, though that was partially offset by softer nontracked channels, some channel movement toward value products, and the fact that we lost battery distribution in several markets outside the U.S. For the quarter, adjusted gross margin rose 380 basis points to 40%, with pricing, continued Project Momentum gains, and lower transportation costs all helping. Adjusted SG&A was 14.2% of net sales versus 15.1% in the same period last year. The improvement this year largely came from Project Momentum savings. A&P was 4.1% of sales, an increase of 60 basis points and in line with our plan to concentrate A&P spending in the first and third quarters; adjusted EBITDA came to $185.4 million and adjusted earnings per share were $1.20. We also produced $78 million of free cash flow during the quarter and reduced debt by $25 million. As we said in this morning's press release, we took a onetime noncash charge of $50 million tied to a partial buyout of U.S. pension liabilities in the quarter. For the entire year, organic revenue was down 1%. The reason is that our price increases were largely offset by reduced volumes, which came from higher retail prices and the wider economic environment. Beyond that, volumes also dropped due to our deliberate withdrawal from lower-margin business and the battery distribution we lost in international markets. Adjusted gross margin improved by 170 basis points, since pricing moves and Project Momentum savings were partially offset by increased input costs. Adjusted EBITDA reached $597.3 million, and earnings per share came in at $3.09, both of which benefited from significant gross margin improvement and the gains delivered by Project Momentum. Now looking at the coming fiscal year, our expectation is that we'll be operating in an environment where input costs have stopped rising but remain elevated. Shoppers continue to feel pressure on their budgets, so how we price and promote across our categories remains a deliberate strategic priority. Given that, our outlook is for organic revenue to come in anywhere from unchanged to a decline in the low single digits, while FX at today's rates should be a slight drag. As input costs begin to move favorably, and with a full year's worth of savings on freight rates plus ongoing momentum gains, we should more than cover what we spend on focused promotions, which points to gross margin expanding by about 100 basis points to land at 40% for the entire year. Looking at dollars, we expect A&P and SG&A to be roughly flat versus fiscal year '23. Because of paying down debt along with a debt capital structure that is largely fixed, our expectation is that interest expense will be favorable by $8 million to $10 million across the full year; additionally, we are projecting a 22% to 23% tax rate for the year. Mainly via improvement in gross margin and by continuing to leverage project momentum for savings, we expect earnings growth next year, which produces an outlook for adjusted EBITDA between $600 million and $620 million and earnings per share between $3.10 and $3.30. Project Momentum is anticipated to deliver a 2024 benefit of $55 million to $65 million and has been factored into the outlook ranges we provided today. Looking ahead over the coming two fiscal years, we anticipate that Project Momentum will generate between $80 million and $100 million in savings. Roughly 70% of that benefit should show up in gross margin, while the remaining portion will be recorded across the other lines of the P&L. Given the investments we continue to make in our core operations, along with Project Momentum and our digital transformation, our expectation is that 2024 capital expenditures will land in the range of $95 million to $105 million. We also expect that sustained robust cash flow, supported by working capital management, will be enough to fund both capital expenditures and the onetime costs tied to Momentum, while still producing free cash flow in line with our target of 10% to 12% of net sales — though this year it will likely come in at the lower end of that range. Let me add some more detail about the first quarter, since we've been anticipating a rough beginning to the year. Even though volume in the category keeps getting better, we think the first half will take a hit from the holiday shipment timing shift we saw earlier, which benefits the value segment, along with softer results in nontracked channels. So for Q1, our expectation is organic sales declining 6% to 8%, with improvement later in the year. Gross margin ought to come in at about the same level as the year-ago quarters. And because of the drop in net sales, mostly, we're looking at adjusted EPS between $0.50 and $0.60 per share for the first quarter. To wrap up, I'll share a few thoughts about how our debt is set up and where we're directing capital. Right now, 91% of what we owe carries a fixed rate, averaging 4.8%, and we don't face any significant repayments until 2027. Going forward, trimming that debt and bringing down leverage remains our top priority for using capital, and we're aiming to finish 2024 with leverage under 5x. In our view, steadily generating free cash flow stands among the biggest drivers of our business right now. By channeling that cash back to shareholders via the quarterly dividend while also reducing what we owe, Energizer investors get an attractive chance at reliable returns plus the possibility of their holdings gaining value; with that, I'll hand things back to Mark for his closing thoughts.
Mark LaVigne
executiveAs we kicked off this year, we started a transformation spanning multiple years, one that is going to make our operations more efficient, lift our financial results and in the end determine what Energizer's future looks like. Across the past 12 months, our progress has been considerable, and during fiscal 2024, our strategic priorities will remain the same: bringing gross margin back up, generating top-tier free cash flow and cutting debt, which in the end will drive sustainable earnings growth along with shareholder value over the long term. At this point I'll hand things back to the operator so we can begin the question-and-answer portion.
Bill Chappell
analystMark, I'd like a bit more detail on how things stand in the battery segment, in the U.S. as well as abroad. Let me see if I've got this right — my sense is you feel that consumer demand has been pretty steady for a few years now. What I want to pin down is where promotional activity sits, particularly in the U.S., but overseas too: do we have to return to where things stood in 2019? Or does spurring even more demand require going above those 2019 levels? Are promotional levels among competitors coming in differently than you'd anticipated? Will, can you give us more detail on the overall landscape, and what either you or the entire category needs to accomplish to get back to that yearly volume growth of 0 to low single digits?
Mark LaVigne
executiveAbsolutely, Will. There are several questions bundled into that one. Let me begin this way — I'll go over how we assembled '24 from a framework perspective, and then John might be able to take you through a few details regarding how we're shaping the year. What I mean is it truly starts with the manner in which we handle the plan for the year, which means remaining aligned with the strategic priorities we established in '23. Margin improvement remains a goal for us, and that ties into what you were asking about promotions. For fiscal '24, our guidance reflects a 100 basis point gain. We also aim to produce free cash flow again, making it two years straight, in line with what we've historically delivered. Debt reduction stays a priority too, and we intend to finish fiscal '24 under 5x. Looking at it through the lens of strategic priorities, the outlook we've given hits every one of those targets. Now, pulling back to the broader picture you raised, considering consumers overall and then our specific categories. When you take a broad look at consumers, not just within our segment, they are definitely under strain. The data we're seeing doesn't point in a single direction. My take on why it's mixed is that consumers remain highly involved in categories, yet their priorities keep shifting, so they move among many different ones. What follows from that is people putting off purchases, and sometimes trading down — whether from premium to value or simply choosing a smaller pack size — along with some switching between brands. Every one of those behaviors stems from short-term priorities and needs that consumers are dealing with in an environment that's putting fairly significant pressure on them. Once you go deeper, though, and look specifically at our categories, they're holding up well. On the battery side, what we've witnessed is a gradual retreat from the unusually high baseline established during the pandemic, when demand surged. Pricing and elasticity are also making themselves felt. Across roughly the last two quarters, volumes have settled into something of a plateau, and watching that pattern flatten out has been encouraging. Auto Care behaves similarly, though it may lean a bit more toward discretionary spending. So if you combine the strategic priorities we're pursuing in our business with category trends that are stable and a shopper who's watching their wallet, everything really hinges on pricing and promotion — which is precisely what you were asking about. And discipline in both pricing and promotion matters enormously to what we're trying to do. It mattered enormously when we restored gross margins. It will matter enormously as we keep protecting gross margins; and then on the promotion front, the thing we keep challenging ourselves with is that we promote in order to bridge consumers toward a higher price point and keep them connected to our brands. We don't promote in order to condition them for, say, permanently lower prices. So we'll keep leaning toward the first approach, not the second. And that's how we constructed the '24 plan to ensure we can keep delivering the results we presented today. John, would you like to walk through the specifics of '24?
John Drabik
executiveYeah. So perhaps I'll just touch on a few of the planning assumptions we've got. Let me begin with the full year, then get into Q1, since I realize that's part of what we released this morning. On the top line, we're looking at flat to down low single digits across the full year. And like Mark mentioned, in battery, category volumes have come back; for the remainder of the year we're forecasting those to be roughly flat. Within the category, we're forecasting auto volumes to be modestly positive. Given that backdrop, we anticipate putting some of the gross margin recovery we've achieved back into pricing and promotional activity. That applies both online and in-store. And then, as we've noted, on top of all that, we'll be starting the year facing some headwinds, since we saw some holiday volume shift into last year's fourth quarter, and we don't expect to comp that again this year. Turning to gross margin, where improvement continues, we're looking for 100 basis points across the full year. Project Momentum has been a tremendous efficiency source for us. We anticipate that it keeps driving improvements, on the order of 120 to 140 basis points; raw material input costs have sort of swung back in our favor. We see that contributing roughly an 80 basis point improvement next year. Transportation rate savings remain a benefit in our view, and we get a full year of those this year, so another 70 basis points of improvement should show up. Following 2 years of significant pricing, we expect some of that pricing and promotion to be reinvested, and that's probably going to be a headwind of about 100 to 150 basis points. And then, with lots of inflationary impacts on conversion costs, utilities and wages, that should be another 50 basis point drag. As I sort of discussed in the prepared remarks, SG&A should be roughly flat. That's really Project Momentum offsetting some inflationary costs we're seeing, along with digital transformation investment. On A&P, we want to grow our A&P dollars and probably land more in that 5% range for the year. On interest, given our debt pay down and the fact that 90% of our debt is fixed rate, we expect interest expense to be about $8 million to $10 million better next year. And then the tax rate will rise a bit. It's going to land between 22% and 23% next year. So that should be a slight drag on our EPS. All in, EBITDA in that $600 million to $620 million range and EPS of $3 to $3.10 — or sorry, $3.10 to $3.30. And for the Q1 outlook, we expect our first quarter to open the year down, with the top line around 6% to 8%, and really — half of that decline ties to the holiday volume shift in the fourth quarter we just completed. Like we said earlier, performance remains softer across certain channels we don't track; beyond that, there's been a modest movement toward channels that lean into value-oriented options, which affects our share somewhat and also brings some trade-down effect; for the first quarter, we anticipate gross margin will come in slightly ahead of where it landed a year ago. Taking everything together, EPS should land somewhere between $0.50 and $0.60.
Mark LaVigne
executiveWe threw a lot of answer there, Bill, any areas we didn't answer?
Bill Chappell
analystNo. I believe my model for the coming year is now complete. Great. One brief additional question. You mentioned softness in the nontracked channel, which I take to mean the DIY channel. Is that a matter of harder year-over-year comparisons? Or share that's been lost? Or is some other factor at play? Or is it simply how those retailers are behaving at the moment when it comes to store traffic?
Mark LaVigne
executiveMy view is that it reflects a broader store traffic pattern across nontracked channels, based on whatever data you happen to receive. That means DIY and online, where you are seeing growth. So here's how I'd frame it: brick-and-mortar, traditional brick-and-mortar is down slightly in volume; online is up; nontracked, home center included, is down.
Lauren Lieberman
analystSo one thing I'd like to ask — when you consider and discuss the trade-down and bargain-hunting patterns showing up among shoppers, especially since your lineup is wider today than it was roughly 5 years back, how does that factor in? What options do you have with Rayovac? What can you do regarding your merchandising sets? Is the current state fluid enough that you could lean on that wider lineup a bit more to put yourself in a good spot as shopper behavior shifts? That's sort of my first one. Then my second one concerns pricing. In tracked channels, pricing is trending downward while volumes climb, and the slide appears to show that same pattern. So I'm just wondering what more you might share, perhaps about the promo discussion — where we are now relative to maybe 2019 in terms of normalized promotional levels, and where you think that will ultimately land.
Mark LaVigne
executiveThanks, Lauren. Regarding that last item, Bill raised it too. As far as promotional levels go, we don't anticipate a scenario in which we'd go above the promotional levels seen in 2019. On what you asked about value brands — the quick response is yes. Our portfolio is complete. We hold a number of value brands capable of meeting a need, especially during the kind of period consumers are going through right now. Doing that is a bit simpler online, since it's somewhat simpler to slot in than within a brick-and-mortar setting. Still, it's something we are leveraging; we're having a few promising conversations with retailers about it. And that's one we'll keep leveraging for as long as the macro environment stays as it is today. Did I leave anything out on that, Lauren?
Lauren Lieberman
analystNo, I believe that's excellent. Now, may I pivot briefly to auto and consider the long-term margin objectives for that segment — perhaps what you're comfortable disclosing regarding where gross margins stand in that business at present and where you believe they could reach?
Mark LaVigne
executiveOn that point, Lauren, allow me to pull back and reflect on what this organization has gone through over the past couple of years. The initial challenge involved a pandemic that put your capacity to handle supply chain interruptions to the test. That demanded deeper insights, forward-looking management of bottlenecks, and simply more resilience; at that moment we chose not just to resolve the immediate problems, but we also put money into strengthening that operational excellence going forward and truly boosting the visibility throughout our supply chain. Enormous strides have been made there. Afterward, regarding Auto Care and inflation, we took a hit, especially within Auto Care from elevated inflation, and that necessitated pricing actions. We introduced Project Momentum to remove costs from our supply chain. You've observed some easing in certain inflation rates, and we have genuinely committed ourselves to our pricing and revenue management teams, so that as we stand here now, what we can see across our network is far superior to how it was before the pandemic. Our fill rates meet or exceed the targets we set. Our margins keep getting better; we achieved enormous gains in Auto Care, rising almost 500 basis points, as we mentioned during the prepared remarks. So past the financial outcomes, from the standpoint of managing supply chain margins, there's the organizational capability we've developed to address these matters more immediately than previously possible. When it comes to Auto Care, we've witnessed strong fundamental macro trends through the 3 primary elements that fuel volume demand in that category. And we have thoroughly recommitted and redirected our attention toward margin levels, which we keep — which we anticipate will keep getting better this year. The initial goal involves returning that business to its pre-pandemic position, and afterward, to keep enhancing the margins. Yet we will always strive to boost margins and expand that business in the future.
Nik Modi
analystI was hoping you could share a bit more insight into a few of those international distribution losses you mentioned. Is it simply a rival going extremely heavy on promotions? Any additional context on that would be useful. And then, when you consider the first quarter, clearly the holiday period matters a great deal, at minimum for the battery segment, given what's happening with devices and so on. What sort of assumptions about how the holiday period unfolds are you building into your guidance?
Mark LaVigne
executiveRegarding the international distribution, once again, our top priority during last year and this year has been bringing margins back to our business, and doing that means raising prices; in certain markets overseas, we pushed hard on price. That led to some distribution being lost. It wasn't really about promotions. It was purely a conversation about price where we stayed very disciplined, and that resulted in some distribution losses. We continue to feel that is definitely the correct strategy. From a pricing perspective, we would make the identical choices if we could start over, since we had to bring our margins back, which lets us put money into the business again and eventually win that distribution back through sound category management, something we always keep our focus on. Then, the second question, Nik. On the holiday, at this point, our retailers have given us terrific support as we head into it. We are planning to succeed. I believe there will be a degree of caution, from both our side and the retailers' side, concerning how the early part of the holiday period turns out, what consumption looks like, and that is what will shape the replenishment conversations as you move deeper into the holiday. So I would say there was a bit of caution when we put together our plan for Q1, and we've picked up on a little caution from retailers since they had sufficient inventory, because they want to observe how things develop. But that will resolve itself as you get nearer to Christmas.
Nik Modi
analystGreat, that's really useful. The guidance disclosure, plus the release and the presentation, were all very helpful too — I just wanted to share that feedback.
Andrea Teixeira
analystYou said half of the 6% to 8% sales drop in the first quarter comes from the holiday sales shift, right — so a pull forward. And the remaining portion — yes, so is that remaining portion more about consumption? Or is it partly — could you bridge that remaining half, whether it's the distribution loss you just mentioned for international? Or is it really consumption at this stage that moved, as you put it, into the nontracked channels? And I was also wondering whether you can bridge that from an e-commerce angle, if you're seeing that kind of tracking toward more promo at your main e-commerce partner.
Mark LaVigne
executiveLet me begin with the digital side, and then John can walk through some of the sales differentials. What I'd say is — as you watch consumers move online, there's a natural share shift for us, from brick-and-mortar to online. Our online share isn't tied the way it is in some of our brick-and-mortar retailers. So that's driving some of the shifting dynamics. As of right now, I'd say promotional levels are somewhat above last year, though below what we saw in '19. My sense is promotional levels will stay around those levels. And going back to the earlier question, I don't expect them to go past 2019. What matters with promotion right now, I think, is bridging consumers to those higher price points and continuing to sort of train them up the value scale as you work your way through what is a tougher macro environment for them. And John, on the breakdown.
John Drabik
executiveIndeed, Andrea, your point is accurate. That movement of holiday volume into Q4 accounts for 50% of the decrease. As for the remaining gap, the other factors are roughly balanced in their contribution. Still, I would characterize 50% of that gap as consumption, and it truly sits within the nontracked channels we discussed, meaning foot traffic and similar things. Then, as Mark just noted, we have observed a movement toward — when we discuss those channels showing a preference for value offerings, that likewise carries a share effect on us, plus a certain amount of trade down, which impacts the top line.
Andrea Teixeira
analystNo, that helps a lot. And if I could just fit in one clarification — so suppose we include the first quarter, correct, that 6% to 8% drop, meaning minus 7% at the midpoint. And after that, for the rest of the fiscal year, I take it you meant flat volumes, right? That suggests battery volumes will be flat next year. So that suggests a bit of a — well, to start with, those volumes will turn around over the remaining part of the fiscal year. And then, secondly, there's some pricing. Is it fair to say that in your embedded outlook for the 9 months left in the year, you'll see organic sales inflecting along with volumes inflecting?
John Drabik
executiveYes. So we think volume for the category should stay fairly stable across the remainder of the year. We do expect our own results to remain probably under pressure in the second quarter even. But really, once you move into the third and fourth quarters, we think the top line should show some improvement from that point.
Andrea Teixeira
analystAnd when it comes to price, your approach has been steady and rigorous regarding promotions, so you don't expect price to swing negative as we move into the coming year, is that right?
John Drabik
executiveWell, our comment was that on price broadly, I wouldn't say there are any widespread hikes we'd be discussing. Nothing additional on the price front is flowing through. And heading into '24, we've essentially cycled through all of it; thus, we expect to put some of the gains we've made in margin back to work in both price and promo efforts. So as I indicated regarding gross margin, you likely picked up that a bit more than 100 basis points of unfavorable price impact exists for the year.
Dara Mohsenian
analystJust to make sure I have this right, I believe I heard you say Project Momentum will deliver an additional $80 million to $100 million in savings. Is that accurate?
Mark LaVigne
executiveThat's right. It will come across the next 2 years.
Dara Mohsenian
analystAll right. When you look at that more than $50 million for this year, what is behind the better-than-expected result compared with the target you set initially? And then secondly, out of that additional $80 million to $100 million, what portion is expected to be realized in fiscal '24 as opposed to fiscal '25?
Mark LaVigne
executiveFor fiscal '24, the savings figure is $55 million to $65 million. What caused the improvement? We touched on this somewhat during the prior quarter's call, when we noted that having a third year in the plan let us take on certain projects on the operational network side that a 2-year window had made somewhat difficult for us, yet those projects produced larger savings; so it comes down to a handful of additional projects we can finish within that 3-year span. On top of that, we have managed to implement certain organizational changes tied to digital transformation, and that is generating part of the savings in SG&A; however, across the entire 3-year program, the total is $130 million to $150 million.
Dara Mohsenian
analystGreat. That helps. Now, regarding what batteries cost, one thing that has really defined this segment is that prices have tended to climb steadily across time, and I get why that isn't happening in the fiscal year ahead given where consumers and retailers stand. That said, could you walk us through, in a conceptual way, what you anticipate for battery category pricing once this year is behind us, and perhaps set that alongside what things looked like in fiscal '24?
Mark LaVigne
executiveFor many categories, '24 comes across as something of a reset period — a matter of returning to the basics of managing a category. What our company is centered on, I'd say, is keeping up investment behind the brands and behind products, across both batteries and Auto Care, and letting that spending create openings for pricing down the road. Within batteries, the pattern hasn't really been an approach of raising prices annually; instead, it has consistently been that every few years, increases occur. My expectation is that this carries on, though I do believe we must keep reestablishing our baseline at where we are now. In my view, consumers need to locate those price points. Normalizing promotional activity has to keep going. After that, you put money into brands, you put money into innovation, and that will fuel conversations about pricing moving forward.
Rob Ottenstein
analystI realize you've addressed this in a few different spots already, but the volume outlook still leaves us somewhat puzzled. I believe you said the holiday volume faced a tough comparison, yet what I have in front of me shows a 5% decline for December of last year — so I'm not sure whether that figure is right, but I'm trying to reconcile it. Also, could you provide some sense of how shipments break out versus takeaway in the U.S. and internationally for batteries, and where those stand, especially relative to what your guidance assumes for the quarter? And whether any unusual destocking is occurring in a particular country or category. Then, connected to that, any perspective on what consumers are holding at home in their pantries when it comes to batteries.
John Drabik
executiveAll right, I'll take the holiday point first, just to make things clear. For this holiday, our shipments landed in Q4 of '23, and that represents roughly 50% of the headwind we're facing as we enter Q1. So on the holiday side, what matters is really the sequential quarter, not the year-over-year comparison. I think your second question related somewhat to retail inventories. We've sold in ahead of the holidays, and I'd characterize the inventories we're observing as fairly in line. We do need to watch how sell-through performs over the coming month, honestly, but we believe we're sitting in a reasonably good position there.
Mark LaVigne
executiveNow, regarding the consumer side, I'd mention that whenever we've regularly done consumer research, for a stretch of time, they were consistently purchasing to satisfy immediate requirements; and at present their customers are putting off certain purchases, which matches what we observe among consumers broadly; they're likewise drawing on what they already have at home to cover present needs. Still, I wouldn't describe consumer inventory as plentiful. If anything, it's shrinking as shoppers make prioritization choices in the current climate. So I wouldn't — there isn't a headwind coming from consumer inventory levels. If anything, it might serve as somewhat of a tailwind once the macro environment improves a little.
Hale Holden
analystI've got 2 things I'd like to ask about next. Regarding what you said on category growth, when you look at how devices might expand across the coming 2 years, I'm curious whether that would lean more toward the health care area — blood pressure monitors, glucose monitors, and so on — or whether you expect it to come from another place.
Mark LaVigne
executiveI'd rank home automation alongside health care automation, and the devices arising from each of those, as roughly 1A and 1B when it comes to where those devices ought to originate.
Hale Holden
analystThanks. Then for my follow-up, regarding what you said about the move toward online, where your share was smaller — does that apply just to the nontracked type of home stores? Or did it span the whole domestic market?
Mark LaVigne
executiveIt spans the entire online market. That's right.
William Reuter
analystI've got two. First, regarding those headwinds you mentioned for the first quarter — you discussed DIY somewhat, and then the timing shift came up. I didn't catch any mention of seasonal sets with retail partners declining versus a year ago. Did anything change in terms of distribution volume, maybe specifically for the holiday period? Any shift in how much shelf space gets allocated to the products?
Mark LaVigne
executiveNo, there isn't. What we observe in the U.S. is steady compared with a year ago; when it comes to international markets, we noted certain distribution losses, and that clearly would have an effect on holiday. However, within the U.S., holiday sets are mostly in line with last year.
William Reuter
analystAlright. And then, second thing from me: you brought up that there could be some movement toward nontracked channels — or actually, that your share in nontracked channels runs slightly lower. Has anything shifted when it comes to what consumers are doing with private label? You touched on having Rayovac plus a few cheaper choices that you can use to sort of plug those holes. But is anything happening on the private label side?
Mark LaVigne
executiveGlobally, private label as a whole has gained roughly 0.7 share points. In the U.S. you're seeing a bigger gain than that, though it's concentrated among particular retailers and also online, since you've been working through some of that channel movement taking place there. Across international markets, on the whole, it's declining; in Europe it's declining. Within APAC it's rising somewhat. Yet on the whole, it's declining. So I'd describe private label as sitting inside the manageable historical range for category penetration that you've observed over the years.
Brian McNamara
analystI want to pick up where Andrea left off. Looking at the top line, Q1 begins at minus 6% to 8% against your easiest comparison. Your full-year guidance is flat to low singles. What is behind that gain, and in particular the volume gain in the second half?
Mark LaVigne
executiveBroadly speaking, what we're building in is that, as you know, half of what shifts out of Q1 lands in Q4 of this year. On volume, our expectation is flat versus last year, more or less across all four quarters. And I'd say simply solid category dynamics plus distribution should produce that improvement once we reach Q2 and Q3.
Brian McNamara
analystWhen you look at that volume outlook, are there any particular dynamics at play between the batteries side and Auto Care?
John Drabik
executiveIt's pretty consistent.
Mark LaVigne
executiveThe two are in line with each other. On the top line, what you'll observe from us is a modest amount of growth for Auto Care across the year, while batteries are going to lag behind that.
Brian McNamara
analystThen, for my second question: should the move toward value-priced battery options continue, would that alter how you approach promotions this year?
Mark LaVigne
executiveWhen we look at promotion, I believe the key is avoiding the trap of applying a lasting fix to what may only be a short-term issue. My view is that you keep putting money behind your brands. You keep running promotions; we have value brands available to offer; yet in the end, consumers are going to move past this period into a stronger one. Our goal is to ensure we hold onto them within the premium portion of the category. That's because it gives us the better margin picture. And that will be ongoing. The question becomes how do we close the distance using both our value brands and our promotional approaches, so we keep navigating our way through this broader economic climate that shoppers are facing.
Mark LaVigne
executiveAppreciate all of you for being on this call and for the continued interest in Energizer. I hope the remainder of your day goes really well.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate you joining us for today's presentation. You're welcome to disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Energizer Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Energizer Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Energizer Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.