EnerSys (ENS) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
June 2, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Dave Shaffer
executiveAppreciate that, Sarah. Hello everyone, and thanks for being here on our call covering the fourth quarter along with the full year results. Joining me this morning is Mike Schmidtlein, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer. Yesterday evening we put slides up on our site, and we'll be pointing to those throughout today's call. Should you have missed that material, it's available under the webcast tab within the Investors portion of our site, www.enersys.com. I'll turn things over to Mike to address details about forward-looking statements.
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveThanks, Dave, and hello everybody. I want to remind you that during this call we'll be sharing some forward-looking statements. Those are rooted in what management currently anticipates and how we see upcoming events and operating results, and they come with risks as well as shifting conditions. There are several factors that could cause what actually happens to be quite different from those forward-looking statements. These statements of ours speak only as of today's presentation date. If you'd like to review the factors that might impact our future results, such as our earnings estimates, please look at the forward-looking statements contained in Item 7, management's discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations, which appears in our annual report on Form 10-K covering the fiscal year that ended March 31, 2020, as filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Beyond that, we'll also be discussing some non-GAAP financial measures. To understand how the comparable GAAP financial information differs from the non-GAAP information, please refer to our company's Form 8-K, which contains our press release dated June 1, 2020, and can be found on our website at www.enersys.com. At this point, I'll hand things back over to you, Dave.
Dave Shaffer
executiveThank you, Mike. For the first several minutes of today's call, I want to walk everyone through what the coronavirus is doing to our operations and the steps we're taking to meet that test. Even with all the difficulties this pandemic has created, we've kept our attention squarely on keeping employees around the globe healthy and safe. Our people are working from home wherever that's feasible, and each plant runs in full accordance with every relevant health and safety standard, rule, and regulation. Watching how our workforce has responded and adapted throughout this crisis fills me with tremendous pride. Spirits remain elevated, and the teams keep banding together to deliver for our customers. Later on in this call, I'll share more on our strategy as we move forward in this COVID setting. Let's turn to Slide 3. The single biggest COVID-driven hit to EnerSys came in April, when our electric forklift and Class 8 over-the-road OEM truck customers were forced to shut down, which struck order rates immediately and severely. Those customers' plants have reopened since then, but a great many aren't running at full capacity because of market demand or interruptions in their supply chains. Our May sales look considerably better than April, yet because we can't be sure of the full size and shape of the truck OEM recovery, providing forward-looking guidance isn't something we can do right now. We've experienced only small supply chain interruptions, and our biggest plants worldwide have kept running, since our products are vital to numerous critical infrastructure markets, among them communications, information technology, defense, energy and transportation systems. Let's turn to Slide 4. Given the headwinds the COVID outbreak generated during this quarter, we were happy to report fourth quarter 2020 adjusted earnings of $1.11 per diluted share, which lines up largely with what was in our April 21 press release. China's economic activity took the worst hit during our fourth quarter, with our 2 plants closed for several weeks and order demand slowing markedly. In Europe and North America, the coronavirus's impact was mostly felt near the close of our fourth quarter. As mentioned before, orders in EMEA had already been softening from our traditional motive power OEM customers prior to COVID, and in the third fiscal quarter we also saw a low-priced competitor return to the EMEA market. Despite all of that, EMEA demand for high-margin motive power TPPL products remains robust. Mike will go into greater detail on the quarterly results during his part of the call. Please turn to Slide 5. I'd like to bring you up to date now on a few of our key markets. Energy Systems Americas saw strong order intake in Q4, powered by several factors tied to the nationwide build-out of 5G. T-Mobile finished buying Sprint, and that move helped push through orders that were already in place while also bringing in fresh ones, since T-Mobile keeps ramping up 5G aggressively by drawing on the wider spectrum the merged businesses now hold. EnerSys' batteries, Purcell cabinets, and Alpha electronics all stand to gain from this. Regulators also required that DISH be separated out and build its own 5G network as the fourth nationwide carrier, something we see as a favorable development for EnerSys later on. Both AT&T and Verizon came out ahead in recent 5G spectrum auctions, and they're likely to bid strongly this fall when the high-speed C-band spectrum goes up for auction, which will pave the way for millimeter wave and the fastest 5G speeds available; with one of our bigger customers in this area, we keep collaborating closely on a next-generation line powering system. Taken together, telecom customers appear dedicated to their raised capital expenditure budgets for calendar year 2020. In fiscal 2021, telecom batteries, power systems, and closures and services ought to feel the upside from this pattern, especially as nationwide 5G deployment begins and fiscal '22 speeds up. Work-from-home steps tied to COVID have put pressure on every broadband network, with over 1 million new broadband subscribers added during the first quarter of this calendar year, which pushes broadband providers to keep putting money into their networks so capacity grows. Our view is that outside plant powering products from Alpha will have to keep pace. Last, the picture for wireless quad play efforts stays favorable for EnerSys. We keep working on broadband power electronics, among them our new DOCSIS 3.1 compliant outdoor UPS. Thanks to Alpha's gateway product, a 5G small cell can link to more than 1 million miles of existing hybrid fiber coaxial networks that broadband providers have installed, providing instant power, backup, and access to the MSO's backbone fiber network for data backhaul. And finally, the data center battery replacement markets have slowed a bit lately because of COVID site-access limits. Even so, demand for cloud computing services and capacity has risen owing to COVID-driven virtual workflows. Please turn to Slide 6. Shifting to the motive power side of our business; we're glad to report that our capacity is fully back after the September fire at our plant in Richmond, Kentucky. You might have seen that a large competitor filed for bankruptcy for the third time. Because we recovered quickly and got back to full capacity, we've been able to serve customers worried about Exide's capacity to supply. As mentioned before, the main effect on our motive power OEM and charger business comes from our OEM customers' closures and production ramps. Healthy battery demand from our national accounts retailers, particularly in e-commerce and home improvement, has partly offset that. Demand for thin plate pure lead, or TPPL, products kept rising through the quarter. Our push to boost production, which includes buying NorthStar, will fuel additional TPPL growth. In the Americas legacy, TPPL sales rose 14% versus the prior year. The force behind that expansion was NexSys TPPL, whose share of motive power Americas sales climbed twofold, reaching nearly 10% over the course of the year. That achievement stands out all the more given that throughout fiscal 2020, EnerSys faced limits on TPPL capacity. Thanks to this increase, we captured a substantial portion of the TPPL market even though the lead acid market on the whole remained essentially unchanged, and we anticipate further share gains going forward. In Asia, motive power had a sluggish fourth quarter, made worse by the coronavirus's effects, especially in China. Now that the pandemic is easing, conditions across Asia are recovering. During our October Investor Day, we noted that we keep building EnerSys' share within the transportation sector by capitalizing on our TPPL technology platform. We closed the fourth quarter carrying a solid transportation backlog, mostly because of constraints on our TPPL output. Although COVID has thrown our Class 8 OEM business into disarray, we can counter that reduced volume through greater activity in Class 8 replacement markets. Beyond that, we are expanding among premium battery automotive aftermarket distributors and retailers, among them new accounts like AutoZone.
Dave Shaffer
executiveBeyond offering an excellent product, what has driven our achievement is that we're once again engaging ODYSSEY accounts we previously couldn't pursue at scale owing to supply limitations. Within EMEA transportation, demand for the ODYSSEY brand remains very strong thanks to its outstanding performance attributes. Now turning to a different thrilling area of our operations. We're happy about the ongoing traction within the defense segment. More specifically, we're quite enthusiastic regarding a number of recent contract awards plus growing market share gains involving Armasafe and thermal lithium batteries. Since the Investor Day held in late 2019, EnerSys has secured more than $50 million in funded munitions awards spanning multiple programs. Most of those programs have leveraged our industry-leading thermal battery technology, which delivers lighter weight and longer operating times for uses in air and missile defense, air-to-ground weapons and hypersonics. Among the standout program wins are the PAC-3 MSE and the next-generator interceptor with Lockheed Martin, along with the AIM-9X air-to-air missile with Raytheon. All of these programs sit within the U.S. Army's big 6 funding priorities and match EnerSys' enabling technology to the demanding future needs of the U.S. Department of Defense. Kindly turn to Slide 7. I'll now give further updates on the ongoing headway we're making with our strategic initiatives, which matter more and are more pertinent than ever. As you're aware, in October, we completed the acquisition of NorthStar Battery, which fit perfectly with our strategy to boost sales of premium products by positioning EnerSys to speed up our sales of higher-margin TPPL. Integration of NorthStar has proceeded very smoothly, further validating our rationale for the deal. Beyond its current production capacity, a major reason behind the NorthStar acquisition was that the newer of its 2 factories had extra floor space ready right away for our new TPPL high-speed production line, letting us sidestep the cost and disruption tied to placing it into our Warrensburg facility. Installation of the new high-speed line was going very well until technicians and engineers from our U.K. supplier were called back home in April because of COVID concerns. We estimate this will push commissioning back by about 2 months to August of 2020. Throughout the quarter, we achieved meaningful progress toward reducing business cost via our initiatives. We cut inventory by $27 million in March, improving across every category, while still sustaining strong cash flow. The headway we're making in EOS, or EnerSys Operating System, also assisted us in lessening the COVID impact as our plants managed to flex most of their controllable variances in April. COVID has strengthened our capacity to accomplish more with less. Lastly, though COVID-19 has posed difficulties across many parts of our business, we're glad to report it has not impacted the scope and pace of our product development. When the pandemic took hold, our product development groups promptly set up a way to keep information moving smoothly among every development unit worldwide, along with the hardware and modeling approaches we'd built before, so those teams could keep working on actual hardware even from off-site locations. For the material handling sector, we intend to bring our lithium-ion offerings to market in Q2, and a variant of that platform will become available for residential energy storage a quarter after that. Telecommunications lithium-ion, uninterruptible power supplies, and bigger energy storage systems are all queued up to roll out one after another. This year brought a string of obstacles — a telecom downturn that hit broadly, the ongoing effects of our ERP rollout, a fire at our Richmond site, and a global pandemic — yet we keep carrying out our strategic plan: gaining share in motive power with our NexSys iON and PURE products; growing in thrilling, high potential markets such as transportation, defense and 5G; folding in 2 key acquisitions, Alpha and NorthStar; and achieving amazing momentum on our product modernization road map. Going forward, COVID-19's worldwide reach will bring EnerSys both difficulties and chances, particularly during the first half of fiscal year 2021. With stay-at-home mandates being removed across the globe, numerous forklift and heavy truck OEM clients of ours are only now bringing their factories in Europe and the U.S. back up to speed following shutdowns that lasted weeks. Meanwhile, our communications clients are shifting priorities for many of their investments toward more pressing network demands, which frequently calls for extra EnerSys power and backup technology. Although we anticipate that significant communications projects, 5G among them, will see certain delays tied to the pandemic, their significance only increases as a growing number of people work, communicate and purchase goods and services over the internet. As an industry leader that has consistently come out of economic slumps stronger and better situated to compete, we welcome the challenge and will seize the opportunities that lie in front of us. Our solid balance sheet, strategic worldwide footprint and standing for product excellence put us in a good position to handle the unknowns that lie ahead, as we stay dedicated to our approach of providing highly integrated energy systems that meet the critical power requirements of diversified industrial markets across the globe. Having said that, I'll invite Mike now to share additional details about our fourth quarter and full year results. So let me now — hand the call to Mike.
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveAppreciate that, Dave. For those of you joining via our webcast, my remarks start on Slide 8. We posted $782 million in net sales during the fourth quarter, which represents a 2% decrease compared with the prior-year period. Volume was down 3%, currency created a 2% headwind, and acquisitions contributed a 3% benefit that partially offset those factors. Turning to our regions, Americas fourth quarter net sales climbed 6%, reaching $537 million. EMEA net sales declined 13%, landing at $199 million, while Asia fell 25% during the fourth quarter to $46 million, a drop driven by the COVID pandemic. Within the Americas, volume added 4% and acquisitions added 3%, with a 1% currency decline partially offsetting those gains. For EMEA, acquisitions contributed 4%, though volume decreased 14%, and currency created a 3% drag. In Asia, volume dropped 20%, currency fell 4%, and price was down 1%, because COVID hit that region the hardest in our fourth quarter. Now looking at product lines: motive power net sales were up 2% compared with a year ago, reaching $353 million, whereas reserve power was down 5%, at $429 million. Reserve power dealt with an 8% decrease in volume, a 1% decrease in price, and a 2% decrease in currency, with 6% from acquisitions making up for it. Motive power had a 1% price increase, minus a 2% foreign currency decrease, and volume rose 3%. Let's move to Slide 9 now. Sequentially, fourth quarter net sales rose 2% versus the third quarter of fiscal 2020, helped by a 2% volume improvement and a 1% price improvement, partly offset by a 1% currency decline. Geographically, the Americas gained 7% as motive power bounced back from the fire in Richmond, Kentucky. EMEA fell 2%, and Asia dropped 22%, since the spread of the COVID virus hit our Asian region especially hard. By product line, reserve power fell 4%, while motive power rose 12%. Let me now offer a few remarks on our adjusted consolidated earnings performance. As you're aware, we use certain non-GAAP measures when analyzing how our company is operating, specifically excluding highlighted items. The operating earnings figures I'm about to discuss, as well as the diluted earnings per share comments I'll make afterward, leave out every highlighted item. If you want specifics on those highlighted items, our company's Form 8-K is the place to look — it contains our press release dated June 1, 2020. Now let's move to Slide 10. On a year-over-year basis, adjusted consolidated earnings for the fourth quarter dropped by about $12 million, landing at $71 million, while the operating margin declined 130 basis points. Cost reductions in commodities could not fully counterbalance the drop in volume, plus increases in manufacturing and trade costs. Looking sequentially, operating earnings in our fourth quarter rose 80 basis points, reaching 9.1%. Operating expenses, excluding highlighted items, came to 16.4% of sales in the fourth quarter, versus 15.7% a year earlier. When you look at Q4 on a GAAP basis, we excluded certain items from operating expenses. Our pretax charges came to $53 million, and those were mostly tied to impairments of intangible assets at $44 million, plus $2 million for restructuring, and $5 million for Alpha and NorthStar amortization charges. If you set those charges aside, the operating earnings percentage for our Americas business segment came in at 11.9%, and that was 20 basis points below the 12.1% we posted in the fourth quarter of last year. On a brighter note, though, gross profit dollars rose by $3 million. If you look at it quarter by quarter, in the Americas our fourth-quarter operating earnings margin improved by 200 basis points from the 9.9% we reported in Q3, and the main driver there was that we bounced back from the Richmond fire. In dollar terms, Americas operating earnings were up $14 million quarter over quarter. Over in EMEA, the operating earnings rate came in at 4%, which is lower than the 10.2% we saw a year ago and also below the 6.6% from the previous quarter. Compared with last year, EMEA operating earnings dollars were down $15 million, largely because of lower volume, and versus the prior quarter they were off by almost $6 million. Compared to last year's results, the drop was mostly due to not having a motive power competitor in the prior-year period, and on a sequential basis the decrease comes from reduced telecom revenue plus increased costs for lead and manufacturing. Turning to Asia, operating earnings percentage for this year's fourth quarter rose 30 basis points, landing at a 1.8% operating loss versus last year's fourth-quarter loss of 2.1%, though that figure declined from the 1.1% income posted in the previous quarter. Asia's OE dollars are in line with the same period a year ago, yet they fell close to $2 million quarter over quarter as a result of the virus. Let's turn to Slide 11. Turning to what we laid out on Slide 10, adjusted operating earnings for the fourth quarter came to $71 million, which is down 15% compared with the prior year. Adjusted consolidated net earnings reached $47.5 million, a figure $15 million below the prior year. The main driver behind the drop in adjusted net earnings is a higher tax rate, together with the Asia and EMEA effects already discussed. As for the business interruption claim tied to the Richmond fire, the recovery we originally anticipated landing in the fourth quarter has slipped, partly because of remote work mandates affecting the people handling the claim; so far we have collected $5 million... During the opening quarter of fiscal 2021, those payments represent roughly 60% of what we claimed, and we're actively pursuing complete reimbursement for our business interruption loss. At 18%, our adjusted effective income tax rate for Q4 came in above both the 13% recorded a year earlier and the 16% from the preceding quarter. Most of that movement stemmed from discrete tax items. For the entire fiscal 2019 period, the tax rate stood at 17%, whereas in fiscal '20 it landed slightly under 18%, which still fell inside the guidance range we had set for fiscal 2020. On weaker net earnings, that figure fell 22%, reaching $1.11. Looking ahead to the first quarter of fiscal 2021, our expectation is that shares outstanding will remain near 42.9 million, which is essentially unchanged from the level we saw in Q4. As a reminder, we still have authorization remaining for close to $50 million worth of buybacks, but we have no plans to repurchase anything in the near term, aside from potentially the modest annual buybacks we conduct to offset dilution caused by the employee stock plan. The dividend that was announced recently will remain at its current level. If you'd like to review our year-to-date figures, they can be found on Slides 12 and 13, but I don't intend to go through them in any detail. Appendix 1 at the conclusion of our webcast is also available for you to check. In Q4 of fiscal year, Alpha generated $115 million in revenue along with adjusted operating income of $6 million—a margin of 4.9%. As Dave mentioned, our confidence remains high regarding Alpha and the entire energy systems segment, including enclosures, despite the fact that Q4 revenue was softer. Overall, taking into account interest, taxes, and dilution from shares issued to the seller, Alpha contributed 2% accretion, excluding $4 million in after-tax amortization related to intangible assets stemming from purchase accounting. NorthStar reported an adjusted operating loss of $4 million against $29 million in revenue, which reduced quarterly EPS by $0.11 after accounting for interest and taxes. Our legacy business slipped a bit on softer volume. That mostly shows the big headwinds we're facing in enclosures worldwide, which fell 25% during the quarter and 35% across the year. We believe that drop in enclosures won't last, since 5G ought to drive demand back up.
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveAbsent that kind of headwind from enclosures, our primary energy storage segment held steady in constant currency, and profitability gained 30 basis points. Things are moving forward with the Alpha deal as anticipated, with synergies coming in line with what we expected. The rationale behind buying that company hasn't changed; even so, Alpha's top line fell compared with a year earlier, driven by how some large broadband and telecom clients are currently spending, a situation that will probably get better before long. The NorthStar purchase is likewise proceeding according to plan, particularly since we're putting money into unlocking the value we identified in that deal. As we mentioned on earlier calls, as these acquisitions get folded in, separating the businesses we bought from the legacy EnerSys operation grows more difficult. Because of that, this quarter marks the final time we intend to share this breakdown during the call. Let's go back to Slide 14 now. Our balance sheet is still solid and puts us in a good position to handle today's economic conditions. We're holding close to $327 million in cash, and the leverage ratio under our credit agreement sits at 2.25x. Operating cash flow for fiscal 2020 came to more than $253 million. We spent $101 million on capital expenditures, which matches what we had projected for the year. For fiscal 2021, we now anticipate CapEx at just 50% of what fiscal 2020 saw, even though we remain dedicated to our key investment initiatives — namely developing lithium batteries and integrating NorthStar, which includes bringing our high-speed line online and shifting NorthStar products serving the European market to our plant in France. The bulk of the high-speed line spending is behind us; we look for our leverage ratio to stay at or under 2.5x during fiscal 2021. April brought positive cash generation, as we had expected, and collections on receivables stayed robust, with DSO holding flat versus March. We're confident that the cost-cutting and cash-preserving actions already implemented will deliver savings north of $40 million in EBITDA and close to $200 million in cash across fiscal 2021. We expect the gross profit rate to slip somewhat during the first half of fiscal 2021, since weaker revenue and reduced utilization at certain plants will probably offset gains from cheaper commodities and energy. On tariffs, we look for a cash and earnings recovery of as much as $5 million tied to exemptions already granted, likely during the first half of fiscal '21. Turning to guidance, we're hopeful about resuming it in the back half of this fiscal year. As Dave explained, although we expect softer demand in motive and transportation markets, other markets are holding steady or could grow. We think the steps we've taken put us in position not just to endure this difficulty, but to come out of it stronger, just as happened 10 years ago; we believe possible market share gains could offset an overall drop in demand, and we take encouragement from the fact that through the previous downturn, we cut leverage and grew our market share. I'll now hand the call back over to Dave.
Dave Shaffer
executiveThanks, Mike. Sarah, we can now open the line for questions.
Noah Kaye
analystTo kick things off, perhaps we could dig into the patterns you laid out on Slide 3 — specifically what you saw during April and May. Could you guide us through that and, where you can, put numbers to how severe the drop was in motive and how a rebound began in May? Also, it sounds like across certain reserve markets, telecom especially, you suggested things might be performing above the rates you saw as you left your fiscal fourth quarter. So once more, whatever you can offer to help us size the bottom and frame a revenue run rate would be useful.
Dave Shaffer
executiveYes. The trough for orders, I'd say, arrived near Easter. That appeared to be the point where things stopped falling. Since then they've climbed back quite consistently and in a fairly predictable way each week; and clearly that pattern carried on through May. We anticipate the same as we move into June. Nearly every one — perhaps every one — of our major OEM customers has now reopened. They've come back at varying production levels, though. A few restarted at — the figure I heard that was smallest was 50%. For most of them, what I heard was roughly 70%; and regarding how they finish this month, the reports are mixed — there's a spread. Still, my expectation is that the bulk will wrap up this month somewhere in the 70% to 100% band. A number of the larger ones anticipate being completely back at 100% before this month ends; so normalcy is returning in that portion of the business. It was something of a jolt, clearly, when orders decelerated so abruptly right at the start of April; yet as Mike mentioned, we've been fighting hard in other areas of the business. As I noted in my prepared remarks, orders arriving straight from retailers have proven quite resilient, particularly within home improvement. In my view that has helped offset part of that slump. As we've discussed, there are really 3 categories of electric trucks. First is Class 1 — the large sit-down rider forklift trucks; those carry fairly sizable batteries; next comes Class 2, the newer aisle trucks, and Class 3 covers the walkie trucks. Then Class 8, as you're aware, refers to the over-the-road big rigs. That last group is where the ODYSSEY-branded product comes in. So Class 1 represents a significant market; and once more, I believe as we close out June we'll be healthier, definitely improved from where we've been. I can't promise we'll reach 100% across every category. Class 2 is feeling reasonably good. When it comes to Class 3, my visibility is honestly pretty limited. Class 8 makes me somewhat uneasy. Those Class 8 units, as you're aware, had been somewhat overbuilt before COVID hit. So things were already moving slowly there, but what's encouraging regarding those lines is that we're shifting away from that specific SKU that typically goes to, say, a large Daimler plant. We're moving away from that SKU toward batteries for companies such as AT&T or T-Mo. That's what's great about — it isn't — there's no way to just flip a switch. You can't make that change overnight, but our plants have performed well. I take real pride in how they've managed to adjust, and they're genuinely battling through this circumstance. Absenteeism is somewhat problematic for everyone. People are — they get somewhat anxious about showing up, but I doubt we're different from anybody else, and that circumstance has gotten significantly better too. So at this point it feels — it feels far better at this point than it did several weeks back. And by the time June ends, I believe it will feel even better. That's — that appears to be the direction we're headed. Plus the Exide bankruptcy is definitely going to create its own problems too. A number of their customers will be seeking some supply assurance. So as we mentioned, there are plenty of puts and takes, but we ought to exit June in a much stronger position. And ideally, at that stage, I believe if this had come, on our financial calendar, merely a few weeks earlier, we'd likely be able to provide guidance. But we're just — Mike and I are fairly cautious people and we simply require a few more weeks to watch how June plays out. Does that more or less capture where things stand?
Noah Kaye
analystSure, that definitely helps. Now, regarding the other half of my question, which concerns reserves — would it be reasonable to say, simply going by what you've shared, that telecom is currently up by a double-digit percentage compared with how things stood in Q4? Is that roughly the correct way to frame it directionally?
Dave Shaffer
executiveYeah — I won't commit to an exact figure for where Q1 will land, but the battery segment is clearly performing well, since people are actively reinforcing their networks. On the equipment side, things remain — I'd say we currently have a handful of sizable projects underway. And the largest efforts we're engaged in at present involve 5G. As I mentioned during my prepared remarks, we believe a portion of the COVID-related disruption — and I'm not attempting to — it remains incredibly thrilling; and as I said, it matters more now than it ever has. However, there's been — certain timelines have been pushed back by 1 or 2 months. So — when it comes to telecom equipment, it's — we're aware it's on the way. We receive the forecast; we observe it and sense it from the customers. Yet the battery segment has unquestionably gotten much better on the telco side, and we anticipate the equipment portion will soon catch up.
Noah Kaye
analystAll right. That sounds good. And before I pass the baton, could I squeeze in one more? You brought up what you're expecting on the gross profit side — the gross margin percentages — and you touched on a few of the actions being taken. Mike, I believe in your prepared comments you noted that you're focused on preserving a couple hundred million dollars in cash. So, first, how should we frame the decremental EBIT margins overall, given where you currently stand and what you're working toward managing? And second, beyond CapEx, could you share additional detail on what else you're pulling levers on to reach that couple hundred million dollars in cash savings?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveAll right — I'll take the second half of what you asked first. The two largest components, relative to what you described, came to approximately $50 million of CapEx. And the second one: we believe we can reduce inventory by as much as $100 million, both because volumes might be somewhat lower and because — keep in mind — we won't be transporting the same quantity over the ocean as we did 12 months back, now that NorthStar is in place, and our progress on that front keeps improving; so inventory accounted for that second component. Additional elements were factored in as well. No pay raise was given by us this year, and a handful of other, smaller things roll up to that $200 million. So — as for the margins, the gross profit margin is what my remark referred to, though clearly that ought to carry through. Yet our gross profit margin, measured against a 25% to 26% level, will likely see 100 to 200 basis points of erosion. And EBIT will likely land roughly 100 points lower, I believe, than the usual expectations you'd have had. That's about the best description I can offer. What looms larger is the top line, and the top line turns into far more of an open question, I think, purely because of certain virus mandates and factories that may or may not be reopening. Predicting when those things will occur, or whether further new restrictions could arise, is simply difficult.
Brian Drab
analystBrian Drab from William Blair here. I want to pick up on what Mike was saying about gross margin being lower — I believe your figure was 100 to 200 basis points. Could you clarify exactly which time frame that refers to?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveThe first half is what I had in mind.
Brian Drab
analystYeah. So for the back half of the year, what kind of boost do you expect from lead prices falling 18% to 20%? I realize you've done some hedging there, but to me that looks like — it's nearly a third of your cost of goods, so that ought to matter a lot 6 months out, maybe even — I'm not sure whether it's $0.20, $0.25, $0.30 every quarter. And then the freight reduction — the freight savings you just brought up, how significant is that for gross margin 6 months out when you put the two together?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveBrian, lead costs by themselves can swing 200 to 300 basis points. So assuming nothing else changes, if spot prices at today's levels roughly hold for the coming 60 days, our third quarter at minimum should gain 200 basis points from lead alone. As you noted, we continue hedging, though at rates lower than what you may have observed from us previously. On freight costs, we ought to pocket somewhat more across the board, simply given the volumes shipped. My sense is everybody anticipates freight rates will come down, not just from weaker demand, but also since fuel prices have fallen. So with luck, that's a twofold gain for us, and freight is a sizable item in our business. So that might deliver an additional 50-plus basis point lift; and on tariffs, I did say we got some exclusions, or let me clarify what I meant; we obtained an exclusion, mainly for our Alpha-made products, received in the last — the fiscal year that closed March 2020. We haven't gotten those funds back yet from customs. As a result, we're holding off on recognizing that benefit or recovery until the cash arrives, but it's roughly a $5 million benefit that we hope to see during the first half of this year.
Brian Drab
analystAll right. And regarding NorthStar, have you observed the freight-related synergies as of yet? Or does that fall under synergies overall? Or will that only become visible in the figures down the road this year? And could you be more specific about when we'll see it?
Dave Shaffer
executiveYes. Brian, I'd say the bulk of that still lies in front of us. We've had a small amount of hold-ups. Take, for instance, one of our major clients in that area, Daimler — we need to secure certain ISO-type approvals at our factory in France before we can ship. Everybody wants it; they're after a shorter supply chain; we're after a short supply chain too. It's merely a handful of these obstacles we must get past; that's one item. And then the most significant problem, as we noted, is that there's been some slight hold-up in starting up and commissioning a few pieces of our new equipment, since our suppliers were European. So that's deferring some of those savings owing to tooling problems and the fact that we're — we need to tool up various SKUs across different factories. So overall, I'd say COVID has shifted a great deal of those savings further into the back half of the year, no question.
Brian Drab
analystAll right. Then I'll pose just a single additional question at this point. But — stay with me on this one, since I believe it could help all of us get a clearer picture. In May, the demand level you observed — set aside April — how did May stack up against February and March? Could you offer any indication — I'm simply attempting to determine where things stand compared to — set aside the worst period of COVID. During May, have you returned to something approaching typical volumes, or are you still a long way off from that?
Dave Shaffer
executiveNo. What I'd say is that we are moving back toward normal. I wouldn't claim we've arrived there just yet, though it's very, very much better than April, without question; and yes, you're correct, April is simply the month I'm choosing to disregard. But yes, things are improving — my hope is to finish June at something resembling normal. So in cases where certain OEM customers of ours perhaps haven't returned, we can ideally make up those portions elsewhere in the business.
John Franzreb
analystWhen it comes to cost savings, what figure do you anticipate extracting during 2021? And within that total, what portion is fixed as opposed to variable?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveGive me a second, John. I need to pull up my reference. So the pay freeze we discussed applies more or less uniformly, though that — I'd classify the bulk of it under the fixed category. There have been several other — we carry a huge quantity of temp staff across the entire fleet that we leveraged for flexing, especially within EMEA, where bringing on full-time staff is such a costly undertaking. So as we trimmed those workers, we managed to accomplish that far more economically, and that piece definitely falls under variable; yet when you consider simply items such as the travel bans we've experienced, sales gatherings, client journeys, there's been a pretty sizeable chunk of that, which would appear within selling and other operating expenses, things we'd typically regard as fixed costs, but here, they'd turn into more of a variable nature; so I suppose in response to your inquiry, I'd put it at roughly an even 50 to 50 split between the fixed and variable costs we've managed to cut on that, let's say, $40 million figure.
John Franzreb
analystOkay. All right. Now, when it comes to Exide and that other rival, could you give some insight into how pricing looks in Europe, and perhaps a bit of detail on North America as well? Exide has gone into and come out of bankruptcy on a couple of occasions. Previously, it hasn't appeared that you had any interest in those assets. I can't picture you having interest in them at this point. But I'm more interested in the pricing landscape and how you see that unfolding across both continents?
Dave Shaffer
executiveYes. The interesting thing regarding this bankruptcy, John, is that they split the company into the U.S. side and the Europe side. In Europe, I'd say it will be business as usual. I don't see any changes or effects coming. Regarding the U.S., their situation — particularly with the demand conditions we have right now, I simply don't believe it should produce a meaningful impact either way, that would be my best guidance at this moment. It's quite difficult to predict. I don't want to comment too much. Clearly, this is a delicate matter at present since they're in the middle of that process; so — but on the whole, I'd say I don't anticipate it having too meaningful an effect on the pricing environment itself in either region.
John Franzreb
analystAll right. I suppose this is my final question, and I'm certain I overlooked something here; but what amount remains unpaid on the insurance claims? Also, should we anticipate that everything gets finalized before the June quarter ends?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveSure. As we said in the past, the combined figure for our claims, covering both property and casualty plus business interruption, came in at slightly below $50 million. Therefore, the — my belief is that we're likely — we stood at — cash received up to now totals roughly $26 million; thus, let's call it somewhere beyond 50% regarding the claim at this point. Naturally, the insurer needs to examine the claim; their perspective might differ on this; and as we noted in our prepared comments, the reality is that a number of our staff members are operating remotely, not just at the site where supporting documentation must be obtained, but at additional sites too. Plus the consultants we brought on, the consultants retained by the insurance company, the insurance company itself, and everyone is operating remotely. Consequently, the expectation that we might get this matter finalized during the fourth quarter, sort of, disappeared by the middle of March. Yet I remain optimistic. Today is June 2 and this month concludes in roughly 33, 34 days. So I realize additional headway will be made since we've already achieved that headway, but the extent of further completion we can predict is unclear. My sense is we sped up our claim process compared with what apparently other parties do when facing these kinds of losses. Thus, we're likely attempting to push things a bit quicker than usual, and we're doing so during a period when that is somewhat challenging, but progress will definitely be made in Q1. I cannot guarantee we'll be finished in Q1.
John Franzreb
analystUnderstood. And then, Dave, one final item, if that's all right — at what point do you expect the team will be reassembled and made ready?
Dave Shaffer
executiveWell, a great deal hinges on Governor Wolf. My aim, I'd say, is likely to begin near June 21, perhaps, and after that we hit the July 4 holiday. So definitely, once the July 4 holiday is behind us. John, honestly, it hasn't been — Mike's group, I believe, has endured the greatest strain. They've been working to wrap up the year and the quarter, and sadly that process remains heavily paper-based. So that group, I take real pride in them. Over the past several weeks they gave it everything. Beyond that, though, <<inaudible>> maintained lab operations. So aside from a number of the lab technicians plus bringing some of those engineers back into the labs, there isn't — I don't sense a gun to our head. We simply want to handle it smoothly, and we want everybody to feel good about it. And so — yet I'd say, beginning in late June, likely emerging after July 4 and, naturally, we'll need to comply with every distancing and protective equipment guideline as set forth by the State of Pennsylvania. But it will take place over the next few weeks.
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveAnd John, just to remind you — I'm mentioning this since I'm currently at the Warrensburg factory, and that's where I've spent the past 2 months. Around here, things are more or less as usual. A modest portion of our office employees are doing their work off-site. Still, for the most part, the parking lot has plenty of cars, and I'd say existence has stayed fairly ordinary across many of our plants.
John Franzreb
analystAll right. Don't let your guard down too much, Mike.
Mike Webber
analystGreg isn't here — it's Mike joining the call instead. Several of the things I planned to ask have come up already, though I did want to circle back to a few of your cost items; and I'm aware somebody raised the topic of lead pricing a little earlier and you spoke somewhat generally about your capacity to hedge there. What I'd like to know is whether you can be more granular about just how aggressive you're able to be at these levels to capitalize on weaker pricing, in terms, I suppose, of both capacity and risk? What sort of markers would guide your thinking about pushing hard here and securing additional pricing at fatter margins?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveWell, with hedging — the positions you put on as the spot rate falls tend to hurt more than the situation where lead is rising and you haven't hedged. The reason is that with lead climbing and no hedge in place, you can at minimum cite the spot price as backing for your price hikes; whereas with lead falling and you're buying lead under a forward contract signed 90 days before, justifying that is tougher. Let me begin though, Mike, by noting that the bulk of our European region operates under contractual requirements in which this is simply passed along via a formula; so their job amounts to running the calculation and entering the figure. Consequently, while we never nail the timing of when costs land in our P&L relative to revenue, and our customers are able to schedule their buying somewhat so that, at the edges, they capture a slightly better bargain — if they expect lead to rise in the next period, they'll buy more ahead of the increase, and if they expect lead to drop soon, they'll buy less; across the Americas, things lean far more toward a published price list with discounts applied to it for motive power, while reserve power is handled more contractually, where pricing tends to be somewhat stickier. And — yet you must stay mindful of your competitors' moves; and ordinarily you'd anticipate the same logic <<inaudible>> that we're in. And — the single caveat I'd offer is this: should the pricing rationale across the competitive landscape somehow fall apart, that's the one thing that ought to concern you.
Mike Webber
analystUnderstood. At moments like this, when things get a bit softer, we shouldn't think of it as a small lever you folks can just pull, right? It's not really something your framework allows you to adjust very much?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveAs I mentioned, in the Americas, pricing usually sees fewer adjustments, maybe in both directions; when it comes to EMEA, it simply follows whatever the formula is built on.
Mike Webber
analystUnderstood. All right, that's useful. During one of your earlier questions, you also brought up longer-term margins and a few of the adjustments you're making to labor, especially overseas, plus the pressures that come with hiring permanent staff instead of, I assume, independent contractors. Is that mostly an EMEA matter rather than Asia Pacific, simply because of the heavier taxes and regulatory obstacles in that region? And should we treat those adjustments as lasting? Or might we think that in Asia Pacific they're more of a medium-term change, something on the order of a few quarters, a year, or 2, whereas in EMEA it could be something more structural?
Mike Schmidtlein
executiveYes. I'd say contract workers are far more common in EMEA; you've got a permanent group that has stayed for a decade or longer, alongside a temp group whose turnover runs somewhat higher, and what you give up for potentially greater turnover at lower seniority levels is that you avoid the sizable severance expense when you have to flex the business. In Asia, that idea of temp workers isn't traditionally seen, because their demand for or ability to locate other jobs is permitted — has not permitted temp labor to really take hold, if you will. That said, don't undervalue severance expenses in Asia; they're quite generous compared with what you pay the employee. Severance there can run quite high. But at this point, I'd say our Asian plants have mostly <<inaudible>> we've let the temporary labor go. We largely believe our staffing levels are where they need to be for the foreseeable future; and the bulk of that took place in late March and early April.
Dave Shaffer
executiveAppreciate that, Sarah. I'd also like to express my gratitude to all of you for joining and for setting aside your time to be on today's call. We're eager to share more updates about how we're progressing when we hold our first quarter 2021 call in August. Wishing everyone a wonderful day. Take care.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that wraps up the call for today. We appreciate you joining us. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete EnerSys transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to EnerSys earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in EnerSys or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.