F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 21, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Matthew Lazzaro
executiveThanks. Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call; during this conference call of F.N.B. Corporation and the reports it files with the Securities and Exchange Commission, forward-looking statements and non-GAAP financial measures are frequently included. Our reported results prepared in accordance with GAAP should be viewed alongside non-GAAP financial measures, not as a replacement for them. You can find reconciliations of GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, compared with the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures, in our presentation materials and in our earnings release. Those non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures are contained in our earnings release, related presentation materials and in our reports and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available on our corporate website, so please refer to them. This call can be replayed until January 28, and a webcast link is going to be posted to the About Us, Investor Relations and Shareholder Services section of our corporate website. Now I'll hand the call over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thank you for being on today's call about our earnings. Joining me are Vince Calabrese, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer, and Gary Guerrieri, our Chief Credit Officer. Asset quality will be handled by Gary, and the financials will be walked through by Vince. As for me, I'll begin by sharing highlights from how we did in 2019, then reflect on our accomplishments during the past year, and close by talking through the strategic goals we've established for 2020. Once that's done, we'll take your questions. Let me start by pointing out several important metrics from 2019. We're thrilled to share that net income hit a record $386 million, and operating EPS also reached a record $1.18. Those profit levels gave us positive operating leverage and strong internal capital generation, which drove capital ratios up and increased tangible book value per share by 13%. That growth makes us happy, because our dividend payout ratio for the full year was 41%, with close to $160 million in cash dividends returned to shareholders. Even with interest rates swinging around in 2019, FNB brought in total revenue of $1.2 billion. The way our portfolios are growing hasn't slowed down. Loans have been increasing at an average of 5%, while deposits are up 6%. That production came from all across the footprint, and we saw especially strong results from our legacy markets, plus we're gaining real traction in the Mid-Atlantic and Southeast expansion markets for FNB. It was an excellent year for our fee-based operations, with operating noninterest income rising 10%, and a lot of our units sold — posting record-breaking revenue numbers. To give you some examples: capital markets jumped 56%, mortgage banking income rose 44%, and wealth management plus insurance revenues together were up 6%. Inside the capital markets businesses, the money we've put into people and products is paying off, and that's being driven by our strategies for expanding geographically, along with really solid execution throughout the footprint. If we look back at 2019, I want to spend a few minutes discussing how far we came on the major goals we described earlier in the 2018 annual report letter. Our aims were to produce better returns on tangible common equity than our peers, generate capital internally, and increase tangible book value per share. Once again, our 2019 return on average tangible common equity came in at 17%, which led the peer group, while tangible book value rose 13%, a pace that remains ahead of others in the industry. All of this reinforces the commitment we have held for a long time to return value to shareholders. For 2019, the strength of our financial results produced a 35% total shareholder return, which put FNB in the top quartile against our peers. While generating those superior returns, we also aimed to safeguard our appealing dividend and give capital back to shareholders. That objective has been met, since tangible common equity finished December at 7.58%, the highest it has been in almost 20 years. Going forward, we have now exceeded the targets we set forth and gained additional room to optimize how capital is deployed once CECL is in place. Those stated goals underpin what our organization is ultimately trying to achieve: expanding revenue by growing our loan and deposit portfolios in a prudent manner, while continuing to uphold our outstanding credit quality and risk-management culture. We delivered another robust year, marked by loan and deposit expansion in the mid-single-digit range and additional gains across numerous asset-quality measures, all while enhancing how our funding is composed. To illustrate, noninterest-bearing deposits rose by almost $400 million, exceeding 6%, and this continues to be a key priority throughout our organization. On top of that, we've concentrated on bringing in new households and strengthening ties with current customers; over the year, our overall deposit growth was a solid 6%. If you set aside an intentional reduction of $600 million in brokered time deposits, then total deposits climbed by close to $2 billion, which is over 8%. Turning to our efforts to broaden and expand fee-based operations—specifically capital markets, mortgage banking, wealth management, and insurance—during 2019, every one of these areas outperformed what we had anticipated, with income from capital markets and mortgage banking each rising by more than 40%, and that directly fueled a 10% rise in total noninterest income, an increase of $25 million, reaching a record $300 million. Beyond that, we aim to keep advancing toward operating as a data-driven bank and to further refine how we deliver through our branches; our attention has been on technology and risk-management foundations, investing carefully and enhancing platforms within the retail bank while boosting both efficiency and the customer experience. Across 2019, we shuttered 25 branches, and we're still carrying out our well-established Ready program. During the earlier part of the year, we shared our intention to build de novo sites in the D.C. Metro area's Northern Virginia region and in Charleston, South Carolina. These expansion initiatives in strategically chosen geographies bolster our retail approach and corporate banking activities across a range of appealing markets. As a demonstration of how well we've executed our growth plan, we now hold a firm position with top 10 deposit market share in 5 of the 7 major markets that have populations exceeding 1 million. Finally, we keep striving to enhance efficiency and control expenses; proof of this is our efficiency ratio, which improved by 30 basis points, moving to 54.5% between 2018 and 2019, even with interest rate pressure in a tough rate climate and substantial, ongoing capital investment in technology. Our approach has been validated across multiple cycles, as shown by the dependable results and ongoing dedication to bettering many crucial asset-quality metrics that Gary will elaborate on. These achievements collectively produced a highly successful 2019, and we'll leverage that strong momentum going into 2020; with that, I'll turn it over to Gary for his thoughts on credit quality. Gary?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThanks, Vince, and hello everyone. We closed out 2019 with a solid Q4, since our main credit measures remained at healthy levels in line with our expectations, and we still feel quite positive about the position of our portfolio going into 2020. As you're all aware, the new CECL accounting rule became effective on January 1, 2020, which alters the way reserves are calculated under that standard and also marks the end of the prior approach for accounting for loans acquired via a business combination. My prepared comments this morning are mostly about the GAAP credit numbers for the whole loan book, on an all-in basis. Beyond that, I'll briefly cover results from both the originated side and the acquired side, touching on a handful of notable points from each of those two portfolios. Moving to the aggregate portfolio, December closed with GAAP delinquency at 94 basis points — up 3 bps from the prior quarter's record-low reading. The broader trend is still favorable, as this quarter came in 13 basis points better than the same period a year ago. Nonperforming loans and OREO moved along much the same lines. They were up just a handful of basis points compared with an exceptionally healthy third quarter, landing at 55 basis points, and on a year-over-year basis they got 6 basis points better. The positive longer-term direction comes from work we keep doing to clear criticized assets off the books, which leaves the portfolio in a stronger position, and during the fourth quarter we got a lot done on that front. One thing to keep in mind: starting in the first quarter of 2020, loans that came through an acquisition will show up as nonaccrual once interest stops accruing, which lines up with the move away from the old purchase accounting standard toward CECL. Right now, most of those acquired credits sit in the 90-plus past-due bucket. Setting aside how these items are recorded on our books, our team stays committed to the approach we've been taking — actively and carefully managing those assets that aren't performing up to standard. Turning to how our loan losses have performed, our GAAP net charge-offs stayed at healthy levels, coming in at $5.3 million during the quarter, which works out to 9 basis points on an annualized basis, and finishing out the year at $28.3 million, or 12 basis points. With the provision amounting to $7.5 million in the quarter and $44.6 million across the full year, we more than covered both our charge-offs and the growth in our loan book during those windows. Vince Calabrese is going to offer a bit more color on the reserve as well as CECL when he gives his prepared remarks. Now I want to spend a moment on the originated and acquired portfolios so we can look at how they stack up versus the previous quarter. When December closed, delinquencies in the originated book sat at 71 basis points — a 5 basis point rise from the prior quarter — and NPLs plus OREO moved up 3 basis points, landing at 59 basis points. Fourth quarter originated net charge-offs came in at a solid 10 basis points annualized, finishing December at $5.3 million, while the full year figure reached $20.7 million, equal to 11 basis points. Our acquired portfolio continues to perform in line with what we expected, and contractual delinquency trends are steadily getting better — they have fallen $47 million versus a year earlier, a 40% decrease. With another strong year now behind us, we feel good about where the portfolio stands and about the steady, reliable credit results we've posted across every book of business. The consistency and stability we've shown over the long term demonstrate how disciplined we are in the processes behind our credit and lending decisions, and none of that would be achievable without the seasoned bankers we have throughout our entire footprint. As we head into the new year and the shifts that come with the CECL accounting standard, we stay dedicated to upholding our fundamental credit principles so we can balance growth goals against the asset mix and risk profile we want at this later point in the economic cycle. Reflecting on the past year, we're extremely pleased with how the portfolio performed for the full 12 months, and we look forward to the business opportunities that lie ahead in 2020. At this point I'll hand the call to Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, to share his remarks.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks, Gary, and good morning. During today's call, I'll go over the financial results we posted for the fourth quarter, and then I'll walk through our guidance for 2020. On Slide 4, you can see that operating EPS for the fourth quarter came to $0.30, which brought operating EPS for the full year 2019 to $1.18 — that's up 4% compared with 2018. As Vince said earlier, the TCE ratio stands at 7.58%, which is the highest it has been in almost 20 years. Tangible book value per share also reached its peak over that same stretch, coming in at $7.53 per share. What these figures show is how focused we are on delivering meaningful shareholder value while keeping asset quality favorable. Let's begin by reviewing the balance sheet for the fourth quarter, which is on Slide 6. Average loan growth on a linked-quarter basis came to $504 million, or 9% annualized, driven by commercial growth of 10% and consumer growth of 7%. If we look at spot year-end balances compared with 2018, total loans are up more than $1.1 billion, or 5%. Spot commercial growth of 7% was led by a $752 million rise in C&I balances, while commercial real estate also had good origination activity, though that was affected by continuing paydowns in that area. Spot consumer growth of 2% came from increases of 8% in residential mortgages and 3% in direct installment loans, partly offset by lower home equity line of credit balances. Moving on within Slide 6. Average deposits on a linked-quarter basis grew 12% annualized. Annualized growth of 41% in interest-bearing deposits and 8% in noninterest-bearing deposits was partly offset by an expected decrease in time deposits, including a decline of nearly $500 million in brokered CD balances. Shifting from time to interest-bearing deposits gives us more flexibility to manage costs when rates are changing. Now to the income statement on Slide 7. Net interest income came in at $226.4 million, down 1.5% from last quarter, as the net interest margin compressed 10 basis points to 3.07%. We recognize that the impact of the interest rate environment is not something only we are facing. The rate cut that happened early in the quarter clearly affected variable rate loan yields and the net interest margin. More specifically, with 1-month LIBOR falling another 25 basis points during the fourth quarter, the net interest margin declined a bit more than we had expected. Relative to the third quarter, 1-month LIBOR dropped 23 basis points in October by itself, which put pressure on asset yields starting at the beginning of the quarter. We managed to partly offset some of that decline, since interest-bearing deposit costs improved 6 basis points on an average basis and 11 basis points on a spot basis. Although deposit costs were slow to follow LIBOR downward in October compared with variable rate loan yields, we are confident that our deposit rates at the end of December will help support the net interest margin as we move through 2020. Beyond that, we have consumer promotional deposits repricing in February, and we expect the anticipated decrease in interest-bearing deposit costs to support gradual net interest margin expansion. For the upcoming quarter, we're anticipating a net interest margin that's fairly steady, and after that, we look for the margin to expand gradually over the remainder of the year. Slides 8 and 9 lay out the specifics on noninterest income and expense. Mortgage banking, capital markets, trust income, and operating noninterest income overall all keep delivering robust results. As Vince mentioned before, our record fee-based results for 2019 leave us very happy. We beat what we had anticipated by a wide margin and, just as important, offset the rate fluctuations that came our way. In the fourth quarter, noninterest income came to $74 million, which is 7% below the prior quarter, largely because of the service charge refunds we flagged on the side; if you look at it on an operating basis, noninterest income fell 2% from a record level in the third quarter, since strong capital markets and mortgage banking income were offset by smaller gains on sales of real estate and weaker results from our SBIC investment. Moving to Slide 9, noninterest expense stayed roughly level versus the third quarter. On a core basis, if you strip out the $3.2 million item tied to the renewable energy investment tax credit from the prior quarter, noninterest expenses climbed 2%, driven by more spending on outside professional services, strategic technology investments in software and equipment, and routine merit raises plus incentive payout accruals reflecting the strong 2019 performance. Keeping expenses in check stays a top priority, and we're quite happy that core expenses came in roughly flat against 2018. Finally, I want to restate the expected capital impact from CECL adoption for 2020 that we previously disclosed. During the last quarter, we gave an estimated day 1 increase to our allowance for credit losses of 25% to 35% for the originated loan portfolio, with the associated capital impacts projected to fall between 11 and 15 basis points of TCE and between 14 and 20 basis points of CET1 regulatory capital on a fully phased-in basis. Keep in mind that the CECL transition on the acquired portfolio produces a balance sheet gross up of loans and allowance without any capital impact. After the day 1 CECL allowance is set on the acquired portfolio, the remaining credit and noncredit marks of $115 million to $135 million on those loans get accreted into interest income prospectively across what's left of the portfolio's life. Recognizing this accretion works much like what we do today, except the remaining marks or discounts stay at the loan level rather than at loan pools. We anticipate the overall allowance coverage ratio will land at 1.25% to 1.35% based on 12/31 numbers. Now let's turn to guidance for 2020: mid-single-digit growth in spot loans and deposits for the full year. I should point out that our 2020 rate outlook assumes a stable yield curve with no further Fed moves in 2020 and 1-month LIBOR rates holding at where they stood at the end of December. Every comparison is year-over-year against 2019 reported results as the base year. We anticipate that net interest income, along with noninterest income and noninterest expense, will each rise by a low single-digit percentage. We expect provision expense to fall somewhere between $55 million and $65 million, and that figure takes into account the effect of CECL; our effective tax rate should land between 18% and 19%, and this reflects a certain amount of income tax credits that we have seen during the past few years. Having said that, I will now hand things over to Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks, Vince. In January of last year, we went over the key elements of our long-range plan, and I'd like to give you an update. All through 2019, we kept concentrating our work on refining both our digital and brick-and-mortar delivery methods to make the customer experience better, while also putting money into our infrastructure and technology. In the quarter ahead, we plan to roll out a brand-new interactive site built with improved capabilities. With the debut of our new proprietary website, we're creating an interactive digital experience that offers one-stop shopping. We're enthusiastic about the fresh features and a simplified process for opening accounts for our customers. Our continued spending on innovation matters greatly to our company's long-range goals and makes sure our teams have what they need to go beyond customer expectations and, in turn, drive future revenue growth. During the last several years, we've had success bringing in top-notch talent as we keep raising our profile, particularly in our markets in North and South Carolina. We're happy with how good our team is in the field and with the rising contributions coming from those regions. Before I hand the call to the operator, I'd like to express my thanks to our whole team for their tremendous effort and commitment in making 2019 a success; we're in a strong position for a terrific 2020, and we'll keep serving our constituencies, staying actively involved with the communities, investing in our devoted employees and delivering more shareholder value.
Frank Schiraldi
analystI'd like to begin by asking about that really impressive demand growth we saw this quarter. Could you walk us through what made that possible? I understand your intention had been to lower the planned decrease in brokered CD levels — but what enabled demand to expand the way it did? Did promotions play a role at all? And how are you thinking about 2020? Do you expect that same kind of mix shift to carry into next year?
Vince Delie
executiveA variety of initiatives on our part have fueled growth in demand deposits. As we've mentioned previously, every quarter this year has brought fairly solid gains. Our team receives incentive compensation tied directly to expanding that category. Within the consumer scorecard, it ranks among the main categories, and it rewards output rather than activity — meaning balance sheet growth. That's one lever we pull. Data analytics and leads are used to back that effort. In the municipal space we run a fairly strong calling program, and our corporate bankers do the same from a treasury management angle, so commercial demand deposit balances are rising nicely, purely because those services are being used. We discuss the other fee-income categories often, yet treasury management fee income has grown substantially throughout the company, especially across the Southeast, the Mid-Atlantic, and the newer markets we've moved into. All of that has contributed and keeps contributing, and the growth has remained solid. This stood as one of the pillars we concentrated on to offset margin compression this year; we highlighted it in the annual report letter, and it was a company-wide priority. Everyone executed really well on that front. Still, many different areas received our attention to generate that result, Frank — there was no single silver bullet.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAll right. So then — but for 2020, is it your view that this kind of trend keeps going...
Vince Delie
executiveYes, that's our view.
Frank Schiraldi
analystIs demand growing more strongly?
Vince Delie
executiveYes, we do. Shifting that mix will remain our focus going forward, and we'll keep pushing deposit costs lower so the hit to margin gets offset. Vince — like Vince said when discussing guidance, a stable yield curve that's steeper should let margin tick up a bit as the year goes on, in our view. By zeroing in on that mix across our funding base, we're aiming to hopefully beat that. Our folks are highly adept at pursuing those deposits, and a range of tools gets used by us to help them capture that market share. That ought to stay a priority and ought to keep working in our favor.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAll right. Then regarding operating leverage, I simply want to confirm my reasoning is right. You clearly provided guidance along with several line items, so those can be entered into our models; but I'm curious whether — during 2019, positive operating leverage was achieved versus the prior year. Based on where you finished the year, and where margin stood in 4Q compared with the start of the year, it appears to me that achieving positive operating leverage year-over-year in 2020 will be quite a difficult request; so is the approach instead that you'll — you just — the aim is to bring the efficiency ratio for 2020 below 4Q levels? Or do you believe positive operating leverage year-over-year can be delivered once more?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo. Positive operating leverage is certainly included in the guidance, Frank, for 2020. I'd say, as you might anticipate, reaching that point for '20 was harder than for '19 because of the rate environment all of us have gone through. Yet under our plan, we never approach the board without positive operating leverage. So revenue rises more quickly than expenses, perhaps not by much, but it does outpace expenses; and we're able to control that expense side as we go. During '19 we had initiatives to remove a substantial portion of expenses, and that's simply part of operating the company. We also have comparable efforts underway in 2020 to make sure positive operating leverage is achieved. And should we receive any surprises in the yield curve in terms of added steepness, that clearly benefits costs past what's built into the plan. But no, positive operating leverage is what's in our guidance.
Frank Schiraldi
analystregarding the comparison with the same period a year earlier, for Q4.
Vince Calabrese
executiveVincent J. Calabrese, answer: correct, compared with a year ago.
Jared Shaw
analystMaybe we could begin with the margin. You seem to be indicating that Q1 ought to hold steady, with a slow climb after that, and you expect the one-month LIBOR to mirror what happens at year-end. Yet on the one-month rate, we've already fallen 13 basis points versus year-end. So I suppose my question is: how does that shape the outlook for asset yields in Q1? And then, thinking about the remainder of the year, I obviously hear your point regarding funding, but would you anticipate any gain in asset yields coming from ongoing remix? Or is it truly the case that — does the margin's slow improvement really come mainly from funding?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo, let me offer a few points. On LIBOR, the yield curve embedded in our plan puts one-month LIBOR at 1.75% by the close of the fiscal year ending June 30. As you noted, today's rate sits below that. So we do anticipate a bit of modest pressure in Q1 — not as large as what the fourth quarter delivered — and from there it rises steadily. Looking at the 10-year rate assumed in our plan, it reaches 2% by year-end. Once more, this mostly draws on Bloomberg economists' surveys, and you have a 2-year at roughly 1.69% by year-end. So I believe that offers a sense of what's assumed. And should LIBOR return — as you're aware, the one-month LIBOR is highly volatile. It has risen considerably from this level and subsequently fallen back. So near term, pressure persists. Yet, as I noted in my remarks, opportunity remains on the interest-bearing deposit cost side. I pointed to the 6 basis points of average decline. Measured on a spot basis, it's 11 lower. And looking toward Q1, we ought to bring the average cost down by another 5 to 10 basis points during that quarter. That clearly would help keep the margin fairly steady in Q1. I think that — every element contributes, as you said. Commercial growth stands as the biggest piece of our growth. Those loans are mostly linked to one-month LIBOR, and you capture the upside as rates rise there. So all the moving pieces are essentially what's assumed, consistent with the guidance we've given on loan and deposit growth; so — but plainly, with one-month LIBOR at its current level, it creates a little pressure during that first quarter.
Jared Shaw
analystAnd so, when it comes to purchase accounting accretion, what should we be expecting for 2020?
Vince Calabrese
executiveWell, the figure sits within the band we provided back in October regarding CECL, meaning $115 million to $135 million, which will be accreted on an individual loan basis moving forward; so that applies across some average life span, be it 3 or 4 years, yet it truly depends on each loan separately. Thus, when prepayments arrive, you'll see the advantage of quicker accretion. Should prepayments be slower, accretion will be slower too. But that's essentially the pool, once we've shifted into CECL mode, that will be accreted over time.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right, and how about looking at it purely from the interest rate marks side?
Vince Calabrese
executiveJared, everything's reflected at this point — that figure captures it entirely; so both the overall marks and the discounts still outstanding sit inside that pool of $115 million to $135 million.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right, understood. Turning now to the fee income area. Clearly, mortgage banking had a fantastic quarter. What do you anticipate there, I suppose, when it comes to your 2020 outlook? My assumption is that this will decline, and we'll see growth in the other lines that offsets it carrying on through the year?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah. Regarding the noninterest income guidance, I'd mention a few points. The total low single digits figure rests on reduced gains from real estate sales; we had some gains this year. We managed to shift certain properties off the balance sheet at a gain. And then reduced capital markets revenue following a record year in '19 that gained from rate volatility aiding the costs. So those are basically the 2 main elements behind that low single digits. And then the remaining elements are basically expanding. Service charges in the low single digits. The other category is basically mid to high. A number of our nonbanking businesses fall into that, at roughly double-digits growth. Mortgage banking is basically mid-single digits growth anticipated in 2020 compared with 2019. So not as robust as '19 versus '18, yet still a fairly solid level in those mid-single digits.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right, and last thing from my end. In the Carolinas, are you beginning to notice any initial chances stemming from a few of the bigger transactions that have happened — SunTrust, BB&T, plus the First Horizon and IBKC deal possibilities — for bringing on more staff or picking up customers?
Vince Delie
executiveOn the customer front, we've definitely observed a shift in how customers are behaving. What I mean is, we're being given chances to sit down and talk through possibilities. In the past, I believe some of those prime borrowers wouldn't have made themselves available for that, but the uncertainty, I think, has opened doors to at least engage, and that's a good thing. With those 2 mergers, I don't believe we've reached a stage yet where customers are experiencing pain, since assignments haven't truly been finalized. Systems haven't been integrated. They're still working through all of that. So we remain in a stretch of uncertainty. Naturally, though, I think any upheaval present in the market — since we're fully staffed and we sort of have our position in the market and we're firmly established — I think chances are going to appear, especially given the caliber of the individuals we've managed to bring aboard; when it comes to employees, we've consistently had openings to recruit from bigger institutions; we've said so many times. We've been fairly effective at swapping out a number of the bankers and truly improving in some cases with individuals who've spent many years in the market, who arrive from bigger organizations; that will keep being true regardless of whether there's upheaval. Still, that certainly benefits us too. We'll find chances to meet and talk with individuals. We're almost at full staffing. Only a small number of roles remain unfilled across the Southeast, but should the chance arise to bring on a high-performing banker, we would definitely act on that chance.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAs Vince said, Jared, the possibilities tied to that specific merger are going to keep coming as the combined company is brought together. Over roughly the past 9 to 12 months, we've also recorded fresh business opportunities that arose from that transition. In other words, we've brought in some new customers who are already booked because they were worried about how big that entity is and who would be managing their credit relationship; so the impact has been favorable, and we anticipate additional gains.
Mike Young
analystI'd like to begin with the topic of capital. The TCE and the TA ratio have at last exceeded 7.5%. My understanding is that you've been discussing the possibility of returning some capital, maybe through share buybacks, once we've finished dealing with CECL. Does that view still hold? And in this kind of climate, what capital levels are you aiming for?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. As all of you are aware, I'd put it this way — for a number of years we've put in a great deal of effort to get the dividend payout ratio to where it's acceptable. And throughout this year, we've been pleased to see that pleasant strengthening in both the TCE ratio and tangible book value. On the subject of repurchasing shares, as I mentioned, the complete effect of CECL will be visible to us by the time the first quarter ends. So at present, buybacks will more or less stay in that opportunistic style — for instance, buying back stock for — shares required for incentive plan needs, and matters of that sort, in the near term, on an opportunistic basis — contingent on how the stock is valued. Like we've stated previously, we won't merely accumulate capital just to accumulate it. Given the strong earnings forecast, we believe a solid chance exists to buy back stock in a more programmatic way, and to fine-tune the capital position as the year progresses and once CECL is essentially behind us on the books. In our view, the stock sits well under intrinsic value, and we'll keep a close watch on the economics and earn back as the year unfolds. So based on how all of that appears, my expectation is that we'll turn somewhat more active after we've gotten through that CECL stretch.
Mike Young
analystAll right. Is there a particular capital ratio you keep an eye on when you consider how to deploy capital?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo. I'd say the TCE ratio matters a lot to us. Getting above 7.5 — the 7% to 7.5% we've discussed is a range for operations, and sitting above it is a positive. Still, no fixed goal exists. We won't run it, correct, toward 7.5% each quarter, though at that point we're at ease. That then leaves us able to buy back stock whenever it looks like a sensible moment.
Mike Young
analystAll right, and I simply hoped to get some clarity based on what was asked earlier. You said the plan that was handed over contained positive operating leverage. And even if the macro backdrop, or loan growth, or whatever else happened to decelerate, all of you remain dedicated to producing that compared with a year earlier?
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect — that is one element of the way we operate this business.
Vince Delie
executiveYes.
Broderick Preston
analystI just want to check on a percentage — apologies if this was covered, but how much of our loan book is linked to LIBOR? And to be more precise, 1-month LIBOR?
Vince Calabrese
executiveCertainly. 1-month LIBOR accounts for $8 billion, which equals 34.3% of total loans; separately, prime accounts for another $2.8 billion, or 12.2%. So whenever the Fed moves, those are essentially the 2 pools that shift.
Broderick Preston
analystAll right, that's helpful. And these loans usually reprice on what schedule? Does that happen every 30 days?
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect. It happens at various points across the month.
Vince Delie
executiveMost of them are on a 1-month reset.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. So various days through the month.
Vince Delie
executiveYes.
Broderick Preston
analystOkay. I just wanted to turn to the average balance sheet. You saw some fairly solid average loan growth. I believe it came in at 8% on a linked-quarter annualized basis, though compared with period end, it was just 4%. It seems there may have been some paydowns late in the quarter, perhaps in consumer and indirect. Would that be accurate?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNothing unusual.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYeah, there's nothing out of the ordinary there, Brody. What I mean is, a few short-term tax instruments mature as the year wraps up, and those actually get settled in that final week of the year. So that creates a bit of an effect. On top of that, 1 or 2 CRE deals of ours shifted over into the secondary market. So that produced a modest effect as well, right as the year came to a close.
Broderick Preston
analystOkay, that's fine. Still, on the whole, would you say you're fairly at ease with those kinds of targets for balance sheet growth in the mid-single-digit range?
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat's right.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes.
Broderick Preston
analystOkay. I'd like to revisit the deposit strength for a moment. I realize noninterest-bearing balances are influenced by many — I suppose many various factors. But looking at it geographically, could you discuss what was behind the strength we saw this quarter?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, our legacy markets keep delivering strong results. We've recorded multiple wins throughout the footprint; there were meaningful wins in the Southeast and the Mid-Atlantic, and those truly contributed, on the commercial side, with large treasury management clients. And broadly speaking, honestly, it comes down to a process that is managed extremely well from the top down. We've also talked about our technology investment. S&P Global gives our mobile app very high marks. We've consistently put money into infrastructure for digital analytics and to give our sales teams better information. We track digital scorecards every day that we provide to retail staff. Branch employees and commercial bankers also have scorecards. So we've devoted considerable time and effort to ensuring that process is run very effectively, and our products and services are competitive and compare favorably with some of the biggest competitors nationwide. That's really the reason we've driven that demand deposit growth; and I realize FNB, based on the name, doesn't come across as a technologically advanced bank, but we've put a lot of — allocated a lot of our resources, in terms of both personnel and capital expenditure, toward giving our people strong products and services and the capacity to compete; and then tracking that performance has consistently been a key driver of our success here. So...
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnd the markets we've entered, there's a lot of competition in the...
Vince Delie
executiveYeah, the markets we've moved into are far more vibrant than the ones we currently operate in. What I mean is, they're expanding — you've got population increases, you've got new businesses being started. When we made the acquisition announcement, we laid out that thesis; from an M&A standpoint, we conducted a thorough analysis of those markets we were entering, and our view was that we had what it takes to compete successfully, and I believe the past several years have demonstrated exactly that. And we're hoping to keep enjoying the upside from broadening our geographic footprint. As we work our way through the cycle, I think this sets up a really favorable operating backdrop for us.
Broderick Preston
analystAll right, that's great. A few additional questions from my side. I was hoping you could explain what was behind the service charge refund we saw this quarter?
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure. What happened is we went back and reviewed some transactions tied to customer activity from before '19, and we concluded that certain service charges ought to be returned to customers. This fits within our broader product offerings. Internally, we keep pushing ourselves. We look at how customers behave and how they respond, simply to confirm we're making the right kinds of moves when it comes to service charges. So this is genuinely a onetime item. Going forward, it won't have any impact on the run rate.
Broderick Preston
analystAll right. Then turning to the South — regarding those South Carolina markets, when Len was brought on at Investor Day, you all offered fairly upbeat remarks about some early wins after he came aboard. I just wanted to ask about how the pipelines are shaping up in that region.
Vince Delie
executiveThose pipelines are quite robust. We have brought in some truly capable people. Down in that region, Len, Elizabeth, and the rest of the team have excelled at drawing in talent. As a result, we hold a very positive outlook on Charleston as we head into the coming year, especially given that a substantial set of branches will be open and serving our customers by mid-year; that ought to work strongly in our favor; moreover, the commercial pipeline sits above $100 million and has remained at that level. So our confidence there is high.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. They hit the ground running really.
Vince Delie
executiveThey have truly performed admirably.
Broderick Preston
analystOkay. Then, if I may, just one additional question. I was hoping to hear, or perhaps have you restate, your perspective regarding possible M&A activity going forward as we head into 2020 and 2021.
Vince Delie
executiveSure. Looking ahead, I'd say we aren't — once more, our attention remains on running the business we have built. Our markets are excellent; we intend to capitalize on our standing within them. Disruption surrounds us in many forms. Meaningful chances exist for us to expand organically, in my view. Over recent years, I believe we have succeeded in producing favorable operating leverage while staying extremely disciplined about expenses, yet still uncovering avenues for growth, including de novo expansion and technology investments; that will remain our approach, and several of those investments have been strong ones. The website should launch soon, and I expect a very favorable reception; a demo was shown to a small group of you. Many thrilling developments lie ahead, I believe. Clearly, the rate environment isn't one we would choose or had forecast. What we predicted was the reverse. Even so, we have consistently navigated such periods and emerged on the far side with solid credit quality, growth in fee income, and a changed deposit mix, which assisted us much as it did this year, and without that margin benefit we could never have anticipated reaching our current position this year. Nevertheless, we united as a team, and we reduced expenses. Our attention went to fee income. In the field, we supervised the teams somewhat more closely to make sure they generated demand deposit growth, and we reached the far side with a favorable result. I anticipate the same during 2020.
Russell Gunther
analystTo build on what you said about growth, I have two things. First, I'd like you to verify that the projection for loan growth is based on a figure taken at the close of the period. Second, could you share your thoughts on which lending categories you anticipate will propel that expansion, and which geographic areas might provide the greatest momentum?
Vince Delie
executiveI'll hand it over to Vince to address the guidance question. It's based on period end, correct?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYep, that's the end of the period. Yes.
Vince Delie
executiveAll right, so looking at growth, I'd say we've concentrated on several areas and seen strong results, especially around D.C., where our commercial and industrial efforts in Maryland and D.C. have performed well and consistently. We've been pushing teams toward larger deals — not a specific vertical, but bigger chances where we can bring in more business, and that worked out very well this year, with syndication fees, derivative opportunities, and treasury management fee income all up considerably. My expectation is that carries into next year. We've barely gotten started. On the CRE side, we're looking at quite a few sizable projects. We're selective about which ones we pursue, since we continue to believe credit quality comes first, and we have to remain disciplined about our credit appetite, not drift — not let ourselves be pulled into drifting. Those, I'd say, are 2 areas of focus. Manufacturing has softened somewhat; it makes up a smaller share of our portfolio now than it used to, but my expectation — my personal expectation — is that it turns back around during the back half of this year, mostly driven by the trade agreements being signed and a few other encouraging signals; still, there's definitely been a modest pullback there. Those are the things that will fuel growth. I'd also say we're improving in the new markets; we've gotten those people trained. We've invested heavily in putting everyone through credit training and through our foundations training. Those bankers especially are far more capable and better positioned to bring in small business opportunities. We're expecting SBA to improve this year. Their pipeline is substantial. So that's really more of a fee income story, though it still sits on the credit side. We're also expecting small business broadly, throughout the footprint, to do better. We've adjusted some things there. So there are multiple areas where growth can come from. And as you'll recall, among regional banks our size, we're one of just a few with this kind of geographic dispersion and concentration in those appealing markets; being in Charlotte, Raleigh, the Piedmont Triad, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Washington D.C. means we can chase a big pool of prospects and hit our growth targets while keeping our risk appetite unchanged. So there's no shortage of opportunities for us to pursue, and there's considerable disruption throughout that whole region; that's the loan-side growth strategy.
Russell Gunther
analystNo, that's fantastic detail, Vince. I appreciate it; and as a follow-up, my final question, guys, would be, I suppose, just at a high level, does the growth outlook take into account a decrease in those elevated paydowns that acted as a headwind for '19, or does it assume that situation remains about the same? I'd just be curious about what's assumed.
Vince Delie
executive'19 — it wasn't actually payoffs in '19, it was predetermined sales. We sold a big mortgage portfolio. I believe it was $400 million, correct?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, <<inaudible>>
Vince Delie
executiveThere were certain moves we made deliberately, and they made solid financial sense as we headed into a CECL setting. So we remain disciplined and concentrated on sound decision-making. If you think about the year before, we offloaded quite a few troubled assets we had picked up. We pushed out more than $300 million, and we divested Regency Finance; as a result, we built a situation — you noticed the charge-offs this quarter, and our credit quality was pristine. So I'd say, considering how we stand as we enter the cycle, we ought to keep gaining from strong, steady credit quality too; but those were self-inflicted headwinds; and having spent 30 years in this business, I sincerely believe we cannot simply grab for growth, we must stay disciplined; that's the pitfall everyone gets caught in. And that's the reason we grew geographically so aggressively, so we'd be able to realize our investment thesis while not altering the risk profile at all.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveRussell, let me add one more point. When it comes to CRE, our expectation is that secondary market activity will keep going for the rest of the year. It has eased off from that tepid — extremely robust clip seen in 2018 and the early part of '19; even so, that activity is still happening, and we anticipate it will also carry on through 2020.
Collyn Gilbert
analystOne final short item. Regarding growth in loans, Vince, I realize you talked about the mortgage banking picture and your remarks on fees. Still, I'm wondering what your thinking is concerning the balance for residential mortgage expansion in what you expect for 2020?
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat falls around the middle single-digit area — likely the middle to upper single digits, I'd put it — which is roughly what's incorporated within the mid-single-digit figure overall. And we might complete one more sale during the back half of the year, comparable to the one we completed this year. When it comes to CECL, should you hold jumbo mortgage loans, with just one product in the household, and across some defined timeframe, if expanding that relationship proves impossible, we'd look at doing something along those lines once more later in the year. So that's also roughly incorporated within the overall mid-single-digit guidance.
Collyn Gilbert
analystAll right. And now that you're operating in these stronger markets, so to speak, what does the breakdown look like between refinancing and purchase activity across your residential mortgage business as a whole?
Vince Calabrese
executiveWell, it shifted around a fair amount over the course of this year, which is what you'd anticipate, considering how interest rates moved. During the fourth quarter, purchases accounted for 54%. That figure stood at 68% during the preceding quarter. So there was a bit more refinancing volume flowing through, simply because of the rate environment at the time. So, I'd say typically, we sit closer to that 70% to 80% range when it comes to purchase activity under something like normal conditions.
Brian Martin
analystTwo items from me, and most points have already been addressed, but regarding the loan growth that's baked in, Vince — I realize it sits at mid-single digits. When you consider C&I, since that's one piece of the margin and the benefit, could C&I expansion this year and your projections come in somewhat above that mid-single-digit level and provide a little extra help on the margin? Is that roughly your thinking? Or would it be fair to assume it's simply more single-digit growth, matching the actual guide?
Vince Delie
executiveI'd say it matches the guide. Yes. I don't — yes, we — and our hope is that we exceed the guide, but as we sit today, that's our best estimate; so...
Brian Martin
analystAll right. And regarding the pipeline right now, Vince, I believe you may have mentioned this and I just didn't catch it, but where does that stand at present within the commercial pipeline?
Vince Delie
executiveI didn't provide — correct, I didn't provide overall pipeline details. I did note that Charleston remained at or above $100 million in the commercial pipeline, so it's still quite strong.
Brian Martin
analystCan you offer any thoughts on either the—
Vince Delie
executiveThe sole point I’ll make—actually, the sole point I’ll share with you is this: regarding production, we discussed production, however an unfunded portion exists within how we compute production, since we grant individuals credit for commitments, some percentage of credit. Yet if you examine the production originating from the Southeast, as an illustration, I believe it has risen, what, 40% compared with the same period a year earlier, Vince, correct?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, that seems correct.
Vince Delie
executiveWe've seen some healthy, steady expansion when it comes to how many transactions we've recorded. At this point, certain efforts are bearing fruit, and the portfolio is progressing. Still, activity in the Southeast over this last year was extremely robust. We anticipate that carrying on. And on the whole, the pipelines look fairly similar to their typical level at this point in time. That's why we feel confident enough to project growth in the mid-single-digit range.
Brian Martin
analystAll right, that's useful. The only other item I had concerns the expense guidance. I suppose, could you address — whether it's operation ready or simply what you've included for branch reductions during this year? Is some amount built into this year regarding fewer branches, or what's the right way to think about it?
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure. A few points come to mind. Our low single digits guidance for 2020 captures investments across a number of strategic initiatives we've discussed, the clicks-to-bricks approach, the website Vince mentioned. So investment continues. That's simply part of operating this company, as you're aware. Each year we put money into things like a new branch teller platform and de novo expansion, so all those efforts are incorporated within the higher expense figure. At the same time, we maintain ongoing discipline around expense management to fund those investments and produce positive operating leverage. Once more, that's within our control. On the cost-management initiative front, that involves ready — keeping up our examination of how to optimize the retail network, which means carrying on the usual ready activities done annually, plus ongoing vendor renegotiations, facility optimization, how cash is handled in the vaults, and so forth. There's an extensive list of initiatives across the company that we're pursuing.
Brian Martin
analystAll right. So a few of those are included in what you laid out, and that's basically the way we should be looking at it? Would you say that's accurate?
Vince Calabrese
executiveRight. For this year, the branches absolutely hold further chances to optimize.
Mike Young
analystVince, I wanted to check something. We had a stretch when rates kept climbing, right? Folks were securing longer terms and pushing out maturities when it came to funding, and then, clearly, things flipped the other way during the past year. Now that we're in a stretch where rates seem steadier, do you plan to make any structural changes to the balance sheet to capitalize on what's hopefully a calmer stretch, I suppose?
Vince Delie
executiveMichael, we're constantly evaluating things. We took advantage of the opportunity and added some funding last year — at quite attractive rates when it was sensible to do so, and we secured some of that funding. Our treasury team and our ALCO team are always reviewing possibilities. That said, no major overhauls are planned; we'll keep examining the asset side of the balance sheet. Under CECL, where chances exist to perhaps open up additional capacity for commercial loan growth, we'll keep exploring that as well. It's simply part of how we handle the balance sheet on a continuous basis. So whenever solid opportunities arise to act on either side of the balance sheet, we'll take them.
Vince Delie
executiveAlright, I appreciate it. I'm grateful for every one of those excellent questions, and I want to thank our shareholders for standing behind us all year long. In my view, it was an outstanding year, and we can't wait for 2020 as we keep building on that momentum. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up our call. We appreciate everyone joining the presentation today. You're welcome to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.