F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 23, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Matthew Lazzaro
executiveThanks a lot. Morning, everybody, and thanks for joining our earnings call. This conference call from F.N.B. Corporation, along with the reports we file with the Securities and Exchange Commission, frequently includes forward-looking statements as well as non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP financial measures ought to be considered alongside our reported results rather than as a substitute for them, which are prepared in accordance with GAAP. You can find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, compared against the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures, in our presentation materials and in our earnings release. Please take a look at those non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures found in our earnings release, the related presentation materials, and the reports and registration statements we file with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available on our corporate website. A replay of this call can be accessed until April 30, and a link to the webcast will be posted in the About Us, Investor Relations and Shareholder Services section of our corporate website. At this point, I'll hand things over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveGood morning, and thanks for joining our earnings call. There are 3 main subjects I want to cover today. To start, I'll give you an update on the way we're steering the company through the COVID-19 pandemic, while also taking care of our employees, customers, communities and shareholders. After that, I want to make a few brief remarks regarding our first quarter financial results. Then, to close, I'll return to a number of important strategic initiatives and programs. Thanks to FNB's preexisting pandemic preparedness plan, along with the pandemic exercises we routinely conduct, we were able to remain ahead of this worsening crisis. In 2018, our leadership participated in an exercise simulating a pandemic, collaborating with the business continuity group to draft an official plan for responding to such an outbreak. Sustainability was given close attention during that work and ultimately emerged as the foundation of the comprehensive strategy we now have. Beyond that, our ongoing commitment to investing in technology and digital channels proved critical, enabling us to provide banking options that were convenient for customers unable to leave their homes. Those same technology investments allowed us to build and launch an automated system that processed close to 15,000 SBA Paycheck Protection Program business applications in just 1 week. As a result of our work, we approved and processed 75% of those applications during the first round of funding, which amounted to $2.1 billion in loans. We expect to process the rest of the applications in the second round of funding. As I noted earlier, when Phase 1 of FNB's technology initiative known as clicks-to-bricks got underway, we had already rolled out online appointment setting, and we were able to make specialized COVID-19 content and offerings quickly available in our solution centers. We drew on the strength of our well-established communication channels for customers and employees alike, keeping both groups up to date on any developments. The way our employees have responded to this crisis has been outstanding. The way they've supported each other, our clients, and the areas where we operate during this extraordinary period has been genuinely uplifting — they've shown professionalism, empathy, optimism, and toughness. Making sure our staff stay healthy, safe, and financially secure remains a top priority as we seek ways to address any consequences for their wellness or that of the people they love. As one example, our colleagues at FNB received up to 15 days of paid time off, and we expanded the paid caregiver leave initiative we already had in place. Also, to ease possible money troubles caused by the coronavirus, FNB gave a one-time assistance payment to frontline essential staff and those in our operations divisions — the folks who ensure customers continue receiving crucial financial services. We also leveraged our IT setup, putting arrangements in place so staff could work from home wherever that was practical. Right now, around 2,200 team members are working remotely, representing approximately 50% of our employees and largely nonretail roles. That capacity likewise shows the results of what we've put into technology and IT infrastructure. When it comes to supporting the communities we serve, the FNB Foundation made a pledge of $1 million toward relief efforts tied to COVID-19, with that money going to food banks and to supply critical medical equipment. A large number of our team members started connecting with customers and community members in order to offer help. Over at our Pittsburgh headquarters, the vendor management group at FNB has put our vetting process to work helping Allegheny County, moving quickly to investigate new suppliers that offer medical supplies and services in the fight against COVID-19. Turning to our retail branches, we've emphasized drive up services and shut our lobbies, shifting to an appointment-only approach, which our clicks-to-bricks platform supports through its appointment setting functionality. It probably comes as no surprise that the enormous dedication shown by our leadership team and our employees to keep things running in such a tough environment demanded a continuous 24/7 push. I want to praise our employees for what they've done to carry out and follow our safety protocols while keeping operations going. Now that I've covered those key priorities and actions, let me shift to a brief look at how we performed in the first quarter. Given that everything happened amid a turbulent quarter, the fundamental strength of our core operations remains intact. We believe in maintaining a steady approach to risk management regardless of where we are in the economic cycle, and in serving as our clients' primary source of capital. FNB, in common with numerous banks, will face a challenging economic backdrop, but our guiding principles—along with the steps we've taken to reinforce our balance sheet and lower our risk exposure—ought to leave FNB favorably situated as we navigate the present crisis. Turning to the quarter's numbers, GAAP EPS came in at $0.14, which encompassed a $0.15 hit to the bottom line stemming from significant items, chiefly tied to COVID-19 as well as the adoption and implementation of CECL and the reserve build that followed under these macroeconomic conditions. Revenue climbed past $300 million, marking a strong top line, fueled by robust expansion in loans and deposits along with favorable performance in our fee-based operations. Commercial loan averages rose by $225 million, a 6% gain, as momentum built in late March, especially within C&I, which jumped 17%. I should mention that expected liquidity draws had only a minimal effect on average balances. Average deposits were up 5% relative to the first quarter of 2019, with noninterest-bearing deposits rising 7%, which enhanced our funding mix. Net interest margin widened to 3.14%, aided by vigorous loan growth, a 7 basis point gain in total cost of funds, and increased accretion compared with the previous quarter. On the noninterest income side, the underlying trends came in strong. Capital markets revenues reached $11 million, which marked another first-quarter record. Insurance and mortgage banking income likewise showed solid underlying performance. Because of the major swing in the interest rate environment, our noninterest income figure includes $7.7 million of impairment on mortgage servicing rights. If you set aside changes in MSR valuations, mortgage banking income came to $6.7 million, an increase of more than 50% compared with the first quarter of 2019, with substantial pipelines moving ahead. On a core basis, our expenses were flat relative to the fourth quarter, and maintaining tight control over spending will remain a top priority for us as we move beyond this crisis. Vince and Gary are going to share more about how CECL is being implemented, along with further specifics on the financials, when they speak. So with that, I'll hand the call to Gary.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAppreciate that, Vince, and hello everyone. At the point we wrapped up Q1 of 2020, the credit portfolio remained in a decent spot despite the worldwide challenges created by COVID-19. Something else worth highlighting about the quarter was that we put the CECL accounting standard into effect, which — as I noted in what I shared with you last quarter — brings about additional changes in the way credit quality metrics are reported. Beyond that, I'll describe the steps we're pursuing to monitor the book and address risks as they come up, while continuing to meet the borrowing needs of our customers and the communities in which we operate. Let's move on now to how we performed in the first quarter. By the end of Q1, on March 31, our delinquency rate stood at 1.13%. That's up 19 basis points quarter over quarter. The increase came from a brief spike in early stage delinquencies, and by now most of those have been resolved. When we look at NPLs plus OREO, that figure hit 64 basis points, which is 9 basis points above the prior quarter. This isn't evidence of worsening credit quality. What drove it was a shift in how we report nonaccruals, moving from the old PCI pool accounting method to CECL. Net charge-offs remained low at $5.7 million for the quarter, equal to 10 basis points on an annualized basis. During the quarter, provision expense came in at $48 million. Of that total, $38 million was connected to building reserves because of unfavorable macroeconomic circumstances stemming from COVID-19. We finished with a reserve of 1.44%, and that figure stands 15 basis points higher than the 1.29% CECL reserve we recorded on day 1. At quarter end, this gave us NPL coverage of 256%. Also worth pointing out: when you factor in unamortized loan discounts, the reserve we held at period end equals 66% of the charge-offs in our 2018 DFAST severely adverse scenario. In responding to the COVID-19 crisis, our teams have put in tremendous effort across the past several weeks — sitting down with borrowers, examining credits, monitoring performance metrics, and running government-backed lending programs. Going into this crisis, our credit book was strong, and that largely reflects the core credit principles I've talked about with you previously: steady underwriting, staying ahead of risk, a hands-on and assertive approach to workouts, and a mix of assets that's balanced across all the areas we serve. Over the past few years we've done a great deal to keep our risk profile low, so that our portfolio could hold up through different economic cycles and tough conditions like the ones we're facing right now. In the past four years, we've unloaded roughly $700 million worth of loans as a deliberate move to reduce risk on our balance sheet. A big chunk of those were riskier loans we'd acquired and managed to get off our books while actually making money on them. On top of that, we've long kept our lending to industries that are especially vulnerable—things like travel and leisure, food and accommodation, and energy—at a minimum. When you add up those three sectors, they make up just 3.8% of our loan portfolio. On the relief side, our credit teams were able to move quickly to review and approve deferral plans for eligible borrowers, which currently represents about 6% of the loan portfolio. As an SBA preferred lender, we've also worked consistently to assist small business clients in securing PPP loans, which carry a full SBA guarantee. We monitor the volume and key performance indicators for these programs daily through a dedicated set of COVID-19-specific reports. Our credit systems take a comprehensive approach, letting us monitor utilization rates each day, plus deferral activity, PPP loan volume, and assessments of how borrowers are affected. All of that gets segmented further, allowing us to keep an eye on our credit portfolio across line of business, loan product, geography, and industry. In addition to broader analytics, we've leveraged our current allowance and DFAST frameworks to conduct scenario analysis and stress testing on chosen loan portfolios. Each of these measures will help us navigate the tough circumstances the industry currently confronts. Before we go further, I want to take a moment to recognize the extraordinary work and dedication shown by our bankers and the staff who support credit operations, as they've worked hard to serve the borrowing needs of our customers and communities during this challenging time. Our credit and banking teams' leadership and expertise will continue to be something we count on to steer us through these difficult conditions, exactly as we managed in earlier downturns. With that, I'll turn things over to Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, who will share his comments.
Vince Calabrese
executiveGary, appreciate that, and hello everybody on this call. My remarks will address what we delivered in quarter one along with a status report on conditions as they stand. Turning to Slide 9, GAAP earnings per share for the quarter came to $0.14, and that figure contains $0.15 tied to significant items. Our TCE ratio closed out March at 7.36%, a level that includes 16 basis points from adopting CECL plus an additional 15 basis points attributable to $48 million in after-tax items. You'll find these significant items detailed in the reconciliation tables, and the largest component was a $38 million reserve build linked to COVID-19 taken during quarter one. A pandemic-driven recessionary scenario served as our framework when assessing macroeconomic projections. Let's begin by walking through the balance sheet, which appears on Slide 14. Compared to the prior quarter, our average loans grew by $278 million, which works out to 5% on an annualized basis. That came from a 6% rise in commercial and a 2% rise in consumer. Within the commercial figure, under 1 percentage point annualized stemmed from COVID-19 related growth in commercial line utilization during March. Moving along to the balance sheet slide: sequentially, average deposits were essentially unchanged, since typical seasonal withdrawals weighed on the averages. Looking at it versus a year earlier, average deposits climbed $1.2 billion, or 5.2%. As far as overall liquidity goes, we feel good about where we stand today, and that includes the advantage of tapping the debt capital markets when an opportunity arose on February 20 to bring in $300 million of holding company liquidity at highly favorable spreads. We also carried out part of the buyback plan we'd announced earlier, repurchasing 2.4 million shares before March 12 — that's 0.7% of the shares we have outstanding. Now let's look at the income statement, which is on Slide 15. Net interest income came in at $233 million, which is $6.2 million, or 2.7%, higher than what we saw last quarter. Our net interest margin widened by 7 basis points, reaching 3.14%, and the reasons behind that include healthy growth in average loans, a reduced cost of funds, and increased discount accretion now that we're operating under CECL. In the first quarter, that added discount accretion helped make up for the squeeze on yields from variable rate loans caused by the big drop in the short end of the curve. Turning to how we fund the balance sheet: our overall cost of funds came in at 1.01%, down 7 basis points from 1.08%. That decline reflects cheaper borrowing, a different mix of funding sources, and interest-bearing deposit costs that fell 10 basis points. If you look at Slides 16 and 17, you'll find the breakdown for noninterest income and noninterest expense. Capital markets, mortgage banking, insurance and trust all continue to perform strongly, and so does operating noninterest income overall. Vince mentioned this earlier, and it still holds: our fee-based businesses keep delivering positive contributions, which broadens where our revenue comes from and cushions us against swings in interest rates. Turning to Q1, our noninterest income came in at $68.5 million, which represents a 7.4% decline versus the prior quarter, largely driven by a $7.7 million MSR impairment tied to the drop in interest rates. Excluding that impairment, noninterest income would have been up $2.2 million, or 3%, and capital markets posted a record $11.1 million, a 29% increase over Q4, fueled by strong origination volume. Now let's go to Slide 17. Looking at it on a run rate basis, noninterest expense was flat compared with fourth quarter levels. Excluding those, we had $2 million related to COVID-19, $8.3 million for consolidating branches, and $5.6 million from changes to retirement provisions for new grants in our long-term incentive program — those don't alter what the grants cost overall, but they do move around when that expense gets recognized. Bank shares and franchise taxes were up $1.7 million, reflecting a $1.2 million state tax credit that was recognized in the prior quarter plus higher bank capital levels at the end of 2019, while other gains and losses mostly offset each other. Our efficiency ratio was 59% compared with 56%, as the other unusual or outsized items added more than 3 percentage points to the current quarter's efficiency ratio. About our guidance: the outlook we shared in January is no longer valid. COVID-19 has hurt the broader economy, and nobody knows how long it will take to recover. That said, we want to be transparent about what we expect in the near term. So on Slide 18, we're providing our current directional outlook for the second quarter of 2020, based on what we know right now. Given how rapidly things are shifting for all of us, it could change. We expect net interest income in the second quarter to decline by a mid-single-digit percentage compared with the first quarter, since the net interest margin will reflect a full quarter of today's interest rate levels. On the loan side, we're looking at average balances climbing somewhere in the mid- to high-single digit range. That reflects spot balances that came in stronger as of March 31, plus $2.1 billion in PPP loans from the program's first round, which we expect to fund over the course of this quarter. Once the program's second round kicks in, those numbers would go higher still, since we're trying to reach every customer who wants to participate. On expenses, we expect them to hold steady relative to the $178 million core level we saw this quarter. As for core fees, the trends we saw in a solid first quarter should continue, though service charges will probably decline given how COVID-19 has affected certain products and services. We're also expecting the effective tax rate to come in around 20%. With that, I'll turn things back over to Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveAppreciate that, Vince. There are a number of initiatives I want to highlight that really stand out as we look ahead. Back in January, we rolled out a brand-new interactive site built with better capabilities, giving people a single destination for shopping and a digital interactive experience, plus online scheduling of appointments, a smoother process for opening accounts, and interactive teller machines placed across our footprint — those are just some of the things our clicks-to-bricks digital strategy makes possible. Add in our roughly 40 ITMs and 550 ATMs, along with our strong, award-winning mobile app, and we're in a great spot to keep serving customers across multiple channels and to meet what they need amid social distancing and economic difficulty; we've put substantial investment into mobile and online, which matters enormously when physical channels face restricted operations. During the final 2 weeks of March, mobile deposits climbed over 40% versus the same stretch a year earlier and versus pre COVID-19 first quarter levels. FNB will keep expanding digital capabilities as we had already planned. To shield customers and communities from economic harm, FNB ranked among the earliest banks to create a structured deferral program, and we announced multiple steps to assist customers facing financial hardship who were directly affected by COVID-19. On top of that, we set up an outreach effort and switched on an outbound calling push to reach thousands of customers across every business unit while the crisis unfolded, making sure their needs got met. We're also still taking part in the Paycheck Protection Program I mentioned earlier and lift — and assess additional COVID-19 related federal government relief programs to judge whether they fit our customers and communities. On outlook, liquidity and overall capital position: we routinely conduct stress tests covering many economic situations, among them severely adverse scenarios whose economic conditions resemble today's. In those scenarios, our regulatory capital ratios stay above the threshold, and we can hold suitable liquidity levels, which shows we're able to keep supporting all of our constituencies when financial conditions are stressful. As we get clearer insight into this shifting health pandemic and the tough economic environment it has produced, we'll keep bringing you updates on key business drivers and expectations. To wrap up, I want to say how proud I feel about our team's work through this extremely hard period to find new and creative ways of connecting with people in need; this is an unprecedented moment for our country and our industry. Our mission has always been improving quality of life in the communities we serve. Now, more than ever, we have to join forces to help those hit by this public health crisis. So I want to say once more: thank you to our employees and everyone on the front line in our communities who is making a difference as we get through this together.
Jared Shaw
analystMaybe we could begin with the margin. Walk us through the different pieces as you think about the second quarter. I'd guess that since PPP is expanding so strongly, that would offset some of the pressure in Q2. On PPP, I'm wondering whether those fees are being counted, or if you plan to count them through NII? And then, what is the blended fee rate on that $2.1 billion you're holding?
Vince Delie
executiveOf course. Jared, let me share a few thoughts. So, in a sense, walking through the outlook for net interest income going forward. Like we talked about before, when 1-month LIBOR and prime move, that really impacts both our net interest income and our margin. Looking at the average LIBOR we had during the past two quarters, plus what we're projecting for this one: it came in at 1.84% for Q4, then 1.68% during Q1, and we figure it'll average around 0.70% in Q2. On our books, we've got $8.5 billion of loans tied to LIBOR, plus another $2.9 billion in loans linked to prime. So that drop we're expecting obviously hits those portfolios — though to offset it, as we've mentioned, we keep bringing down what we pay on interest-bearing deposits. For the second quarter, we expect another drop of 33 basis points compared with the first quarter. Then, as you pointed out, we'll get benefits from the PPP program since we're funding it this quarter. Now, on that $2.1 billion, our estimated average fee rate comes to about 3% once you work through the tiers. The spread works out to 65 basis points. So the overall margin on those loans lands somewhere around 2% to 2.25%. As for how we'll handle the accounting, each loan gets entered individually into the loan system. That means it amortizes over two years. After those loans get forgiven and completely repaid, the rest of the fees would be recognized as interest income right at that point. And one more thing I'd mention—the accretion we saw this quarter, running through under CECL versus how it worked before CECL, came to roughly $17 million. That's an increase of around $7 million compared with the fourth quarter. So that helped out in Q1. I don't think it'll stay quite that high in Q2, though I can't say for sure, since prepayment activity drives it. Also, CECL accounting brings in additional factors, with prepayments playing a major role. So I'd still look for it to add something notable in Q2, just probably below that $17 million level. Looking back at last year's third and fourth quarters, accretion gave us 10 to 12 basis points. That's probably a reasonable run rate, though it may move around based on how much prepayment activity we see during the quarter.
Vince Calabrese
executiveJared, a few more things regarding the PPP program. From those 15,000 applications we received, the typical loan we've originated comes to roughly $180,000. That puts us toward the smaller end when it comes to size. More small businesses are moving through that pipeline; 25% of them remain pending. Altogether, that's around $650 million we've processed and which stands ready for processing in round 2 as soon as the funds become available. Beyond that, we'd anticipate some further fundings, and in the interest of transparency, we've already funded roughly 90% of the $2.1 billion; those are closed and on the books.
Jared Shaw
analystRegarding the loan growth this quarter, did I hear you correctly? Did you say just 1% of the growth came from increased line utilization? Or was it that line utilization rose 1%?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo, it was 1% on average, correct? So line utilization happened later in March than we would have had. So on average, the — it's 1% of that 5% growth that I mentioned, the average balance growth.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveJared, I can build on what Vince said. Before COVID hit, our usage rate sat at roughly 42%, slightly above 42%. It reached a high of just below 47% as companies stockpiled some cash. Now we've dropped back to 43.8% already. So at this stage, it's essentially returning near a typical level.
Vince Calabrese
executiveHowever, we genuinely lack a substantial volume of big corporate exposure that was mainly drawn down either to add liquidity onto their balance sheets or to support commercial paper programs; there isn't a huge quantity of that within our portfolio; as a result, the liquidity draws came in considerably below what other companies would have disclosed.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right, that's helpful; and lastly from my side — apologies; regarding the deferrals, you mentioned 6% of total loans sit in deferral. Is there any clustering you're noticing by loan type or by region?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAt this moment, we're around 5%. Given the pipeline, we anticipate being near 6%, or slightly above 6%, reflecting what's in that pipeline. As for those deferrals, they're showing up in the sectors you'd anticipate; restaurant, travel, tourism. From our standpoint those books are quite small, since we've made a strategic choice, really not needing to concentrate on lending into that area, as we've discussed previously, so it's fairly clustered in that segment.
Vince Calabrese
executiveWhen you examine how deferrals are spread out, Gary, the pattern is fairly uniform among the various loan types, measured as a share of portfolio size. Specifically, the range sits near 2.5% — from 2% up to 2.9%. That's essentially the level we're at, so it holds steady. No single segment is showing a sudden surge.
Frank Schiraldi
analystI'm just wondering — could you share anything further, Gary, when it comes to stress testing? And say we consider the baseline outlook, how do loss expectations compare with the prior cycle, 08'-09' at the Legacy Bank, though I suppose, all of it — leaving Florida out of the picture from that period?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveRight. Frank, here's what I'd tell you: we've been extremely proactive, and in a strategic way we've derisked the balance sheet across the past several years, as I said before, and we're emerging from some quite strong charge-off levels throughout the past 18 months. Of course, the world has shifted. We anticipate that the consistency in underwriting that we discuss with all of you constantly on the front end will matter significantly as we move ahead here. When it comes to charge-offs, every bank will see credit deterioration, just as happens in any downturn; and at this stage this one is fairly severe. During our most recent stress test, we stayed well capitalized and anticipate being able to carry out our business plan completely from a charge-off standpoint under those adverse scenarios. And if the forecasted economic conditions under the CECL methodology turn out worse, then COVID-19 conditions are currently what we used as of the March 27 date; so we're incorporating some highly current COVID information into our modeling. We would anticipate that any potential reserve build would come from normal levels, driven by movements from this point in time. So looking at losses, we won't be projecting losses as we move ahead. But we do anticipate the portfolio will perform as strongly as it can through this cycle we're facing right now, given the consistency we've described in the underwriting.
Vince Delie
executiveRight. Frank, on Page 13 of the deck, you'll find a chart showing how FNB has done, looking at net charge-offs as a share of average loans going back through history. Gary, perhaps you'd like to say something about that. I should note that it leaves out Regency as well as the Florida portfolio we sold off.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAbsolutely. Think back to the 2009 and 2010 great recession that every one of us lived through several years back. If you turn to Page 13, FNB's results across that downturn are laid out. Essentially, what you're looking at is the core bank. At that moment, it left out — and it still leaves out — Florida and Regency, since those portfolios have been removed from the company's balance sheet at this point. The steady underwriting approach we followed in those days is still what we use now. And our expectation is that this will let us come out ahead of the broader industry as the current cycle plays out.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAll right. And now, circling back to the guidance on margin and NII for 2Q, Vince — is any accretion baked into the NII expectations there? Or, I'm not sure, have you given yourself a wide enough band? Just wondering.
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo, that would take in what I mentioned before, roughly 10 to 12 basis points. When you consider the run rates from the third and fourth quarter, which came before CECL, my expectation is that next quarter looks more like a normal run rate, correct? That said, it does depend on prepayments. Should prepayments come in elevated once more, we'd have additional. So I'd call that a sensible figure, Frank. And honestly, I won't have clarity until the quarter unfolds. But that 10 to 12 is certainly present for the second quarter; it's built into what we've given you. And one more clarification: we referenced the $2.1 billion tied to PPP activity; that sits on the books for 2 months of the quarter. So rather than $2.1 billion, you've got 2/3 of it, purely from a modeling perspective. And that likewise flows into the number within the target.
Frank Schiraldi
analystWhat I assume wouldn't be counted, though, is a scenario where those loans sit on our balance sheet for just 2 months — and, well, I figure that lands near the end of the quarter. So nothing related to that 3% getting accelerated, since a portion of these amounts will ultimately be forgiven — none of that shows up in 2Q, correct?
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect. Correct; what does get captured is simply the standard accretion over that 2-year window; most likely — that forgiveness procedure will probably carry you all the way to June 30. A process is going to be involved.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveMy guess is that would carry you past June 30, Frank. So you're likely looking at the third-quarter event, beginning with those forgiveness items working their way through.
Vince Calabrese
executiveRight, Frank — there's no speeding up of that fee baked into what I've got. It's simply the usual build over a 2-year stretch.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAnd then, last thing from me — when you put together this guidance, how are you thinking about LIBOR? Do you basically assume it just stays where it is from this point on?
Vince Calabrese
executiveAs I said in my comments earlier, roughly 70 basis points is the figure we have in mind. I believe at present we're sitting in the high 50s. So averaging 70 for the quarter — we came into the quarter somewhat above that. That's the assumption reflected in our figures.
Mike Young
analystTo get us started, Gary, I'd like to focus on that extra COVID-19 reserve you established during this quarter. Could you walk us through the sorts of assumptions behind it — the macroeconomic ones, plus any weightings or management overlays — that got you to that figure?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAbsolutely. Let me walk you through the broad picture. Our scenario is a pandemic-driven recession, one in which the economy takes a serious hit early on; things get somewhat better as the year goes on, and then we face ongoing economic softness all the way through 2021. Our analysis doesn't factor in any of the government stimulus programs. So none of that provides any benefit. Just as we've always done with the DFAST scenarios we keep running, we look at and factor in roughly 12 variables, and among those variables are several I can mention — the Dow, housing, consumer confidence levels, GDP and unemployment are a few of them; but that's essentially what powers our models and the portfolio analysis we've carried out.
Mike Young
analystI'd figure that was timestamped around the end of March, so perhaps commissions have gotten a bit worse after that. Should we remain on roughly the same path, that could mean a larger reserve build is needed possibly in the next quarter, depending on where things land?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveWell, these scenarios keep being run by us. Ours were run as recently as the past couple of days. This is according to the update. Once more, our model was run around the March 27 timeframe. And according to our latest run using the updated data, there really isn't a material difference, though slightly, but nothing material given just the simulated models we're running.
Mike Young
analystAll right. And Gary, I believe you've really nailed it on this slide, laying out all those industries that are sensitive to COVID, and so on. Is there anything in particular we ought to keep a close eye on that you feel carries greater near-term risk compared with the rest, whether that's thinner liquidity, less cash, or collateral getting hit harder?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYeah. From where I sit, looking at it by industry, obviously restaurants have taken a heavy hit. Hotels have taken a heavy hit. Energy finds itself in a difficult position at the moment, and it's getting hit too. Those are a few of the segments — hotels and energy in particular — we actually hold a modest restaurant book, and we have some really solid clients in it. We halted lending in the hotel segment 4.5 years back. That was a strategic call, and it has turned out to be an excellent one. We hold certain assets, as we've mentioned before, that came out of the acquisitions. We've reduced risk in that portfolio and haven't been lending into it at all. When it comes to energy, well, the slide deck makes clear, we aren't an energy lender. We have a handful of customers who are quite strong and — along with a few publicly traded names there that keep performing well. But those are the sectors I'd be worried about first, given that we're at an early point here. And given all the uncertainty everybody is still dealing with, they could turn more troublesome more quickly. Once again, from a strategic view, we've set ourselves up and made choices across time to keep those portfolios extremely small; and I believe that will pay off for us as we work our way through this cycle.
Vince Delie
executiveSo, I believe a few years back we shared information about what we had on the books tied to energy, isn't that right, Gary? That was during a period of decline. My recollection is roughly 3, possibly 4 years ago. That amount has been reduced by 50%; so — I mean, it seems fairly clear we haven't been doing much in those sectors. I think you ought to address what we have in retail too, since when you consider how things are running right now, I mean, a lot of retailers are struggling. And if you examine how our portfolio breaks down on the retail side, certain portions of retail will keep doing well, correct? Take grocery — there's quite a few of them, I mean.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAbsolutely. And Vince, I'd say that's a significant thing to bring up too, since obviously worries exist around that. Something crucial to note: those three categories—fuel stops, food stores, and car-related businesses—account for two-thirds of what we hold in retail C&I. So that's a substantial share. Quite a few of those sectors have kept operating because they're classified as essential. As a result, we're feeling reasonably confident about where our retail portfolio stands going into this, and about how it navigates a rough patch from an economic perspective.
Casey Haire
analystSo I suppose my first question concerns the second quarter guide and how it ties to the balance sheet. Should we simply take it that earning assets follow loan growth in this case? The reason I ask is that the securities book stayed roughly flat while deposits declined. I'm just attempting to gauge what sort of balance sheet we ought to anticipate in the second quarter.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah. It'll likely come in somewhat lighter than that, since with the investment portfolio, we really did shrink it over the quarter, purely because of reinvestment. My recollection is that we brought it down by nearly $200 million — $191 million across the first quarter. So my estimate is that the cash flow from it totals $1.6 billion across 12 months. Thus I'd anticipate that it gradually declines a bit from that level, once more, driven by prepayments. What I mean is we are putting some money to work, but we aren't fully reinvesting that cash flow. As a result, earning assets would come in somewhat below that.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveOne thing worth keeping in mind is that those balances — the depository balances — follow a seasonal pattern for us; specifically, we tend to see them as outflows. Right. So over time, they'll build up.
Casey Haire
analystRight, got it. Now regarding loan growth — $2.1 billion, that works out to 7% of the earning asset base for the first quarter. And I realize you saw some line draws near the end of the quarter. So on a core loan growth basis, you're carrying positive momentum into the second quarter. But what should we expect for — and it sounds like utilization has declined. So my question really is, what does the core loan book look like? What's the outlook for core FNB loans excluding PPP in the second quarter?
Vince Delie
executiveYeah. At this point in the game, it's somewhat difficult to say. We have a strong, stable customer base, in my view. Not much movement is happening. At this stage, I don't believe anyone is particularly anxious to make a move. So my expectation would be that — the balances we hold today should remain fairly solid. The pipeline, I believe, is still quite healthy. That said, as I mentioned, things are somewhat frozen since you're unable to actually go visit prospects. I do know we're capturing business in the market for multiple reasons. Relative to what I've observed, our PPP execution was exceptionally strong. Among our existing customers alone, we achieved an 80% capture rate. When we first made it available to new customers, roughly 10% were new. So execution has been solid, and the feedback has been quite positive; therefore, once everything begins to calm down later in the year, I'd anticipate activity to pick up speed. Anything else — Gary, do you want to add something?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYeah, Casey, we're going to do that — and over the past month to month and a half, we've been seeing solid, consistent business coming from the clients we serve. What I mean is, they're continuing to put money in, particularly when it comes to certain investments they'd already mapped out. Some of them have paused those for the time being, but through roughly the last 1.5 months, we've been witnessing fairly healthy lending activity as things stand right now.
Vince Delie
executiveAnd clearly, you've got to be cautious, since we're right in the middle of a crisis, and we get how that might affect borrowers' financial results. So we're taking a careful approach. Still, I'd say we're in a fairly good spot as we get through this crisis and come out the other side.
Casey Haire
analystGot it. Also, the TCE ratio came in at 7.40% for the quarter. I realize PPP might weigh on it somewhat, and it holds a 0 risk weighting, but your leverage on that measure is a bit higher than most. What's your tolerance? How far down are you prepared to let that ratio drop?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, growing it is what we're aiming for. That's what our plan was before the crisis hit. I'd say — once more — our capital standing versus the risk embedded in the portfolio looks solid. As we've noted, we've run stress tests on our capital position across many scenarios, among them the pandemic scenario Gary brought up. So my confidence there is fairly high. Going forward, I'd anticipate seeing fee income's benefit speed up, genuinely assisting us in the third quarter when it comes to building capital, since I believe you'll witness an acceleration, and ideally, plus forgiveness on those loans as borrowers meet the conditions that are going to be set out. I mean, those conditions aren't published yet, but they will be set out. So I think all of that leaves us in a fairly strong spot from a TCE standpoint and from a tangible book value per share standpoint. Vince, anything you'd like to add? Or did I leave something out?
Vince Calabrese
executiveRight. Let me just tack on a few points there. What I'd say is, if you set aside the PPP effects, our expectation is that this ratio would have been rising purely on a quarter-over-quarter basis — which lines up with what you were saying about it building. So that's worth keeping in mind. It sort of got buried. That $2.1 billion in temporary impact pushes us to just below 7%. Given everything Vince laid out and how solid the balance sheet is, we're at ease with that. And then depending on what plays out with Phase 2 on the funding side, that would step us down further from that point. But $2 billion takes you from roughly 7.36% down to 6.95%. So that works out to around 21 basis points for each $1 billion of those loans. And once again, these are temporary. As you're aware, they have zero effect on regulatory ratios, though the TCE ratio does take a hit. So we're fine with that interim level, and then we'd look to build back up from there as those loans come off the books.
Casey Haire
analystAll right, this will be my final question. Gary, I apologize if I overlooked this in your — during your prepared remarks, but regarding the forbearance and the modifications, could you give us some color on whether that — at 6%, has it — has it topped out, similar to how the line draws topped out and then declined? I'm just attempting to understand the pace of forbearance.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes. To be clear, Casey, we're sitting at roughly 5% at the moment. And when we factor in the pipeline, we expect it will reach slightly above 6%. At this point it has decelerated significantly. We do anticipate a continued trickle there, but from a commercial borrower standpoint it has decelerated significantly. We're still moving through a portion of the mortgage portfolio as of today, but that too has decelerated as we sit here.
Russell Gunther
analystJust a few more items to pick up on. Gary, for your part, I value how detailed that was. I wanted to revisit the exposure tied to COVID-19 sensitivity, which you flagged in restaurants, hotels, and energy. From an underwriting angle, is there anything you can offer regarding where LTVs and debt service coverage currently sit? Then my second question: you brought up an internal stress test that the company is running. I'm just wondering what kinds of loss rates you'd be using inside those 3 at-risk buckets?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes. When it comes to those industries, looking at it from an LTV perspective, broadly speaking, what you'll typically find is 70%, the low 70% range for LTVs in those areas; and across our portfolio that should hold pretty consistently. What was the other part of your question, Russell?
Russell Gunther
analystGary, could you give us any specifics about the internal stress testing you brought up in your remarks, including the loss rates you're assuming for certain portfolios that carry more risk?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAll right. Vince will address that.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, Russell, I'd just like to mention that we made a point of releasing that 66% figure. To repeat what Gary had written down: when you factor in the unamortized loan discounts, the reserve we held at the close of the period on March 31 equals 66% of the severely adverse charge-offs across 9 quarters, based on the most recent stress test we ran. That context matters — it shows a substantial reserve set against those charge-offs. We haven't shared every detail on the various loss rate components. Still, I can say we applied it very aggressively under that severely adverse scenario, and we've done so on each occasion we've run it.
Collyn Gilbert
analystTo stay on the credit topic briefly — Gary, you said you're currently seeing something like 6% in deferrals? I believe that works out to roughly $1.4 billion. Of those deferred amounts, can you tell me how much falls within the approximately $3.5 billion of COVID-sensitive loans you put on Slide 11?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveSure. Regarding deferred loans in the retail IRE portfolio, the figure comes to $470 million altogether. Food and accommodation accounts for roughly $75 million; now let me locate the lodging number. Lodging stands at approximately $175 million, while retail is right around $145 million.
Collyn Gilbert
analystAll right, and beyond that, I'd imagine it's simply a matter of finer, more detailed figures.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYou've got it, Collyn.
Collyn Gilbert
analystGot it. That's useful. I also wanted to get some clarity from you, Vince, regarding that announcement, just so I know I have the figures straight. When we look at the real accretion dollar figure you recorded this quarter, what was it, if we set it against the $9.6 million recorded during the fourth quarter?
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat's right. The figure came to $17 million — $17.1 million.
Collyn Gilbert
analystAll right. All right. Then looking at it from a core NIM standpoint, does that suggest that perhaps core NIM dropped roughly 4 bps during the first quarter — is that correct? So core NIM would land at approximately 2.90?
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect. If you took that out, I mean, it's sort of all baked in there, correct, as we move ahead under CECL. So that $17 million, I'm attempting to recall — hold on one moment. Yes, I suppose that's roughly 3 to — what is it, 5 to 6 basis points would be — $8.8 million equals 3 basis points of margin, so. Yes, it's approximately 5 basis points or so.
Collyn Gilbert
analystAll right, understood. All right, and so finally, regarding the conversation around loan growth. And attempting to square, Gary, your remark regarding the pipeline and the fact that you still have certain customer activities continuing to move through. Yet certainly, plenty of activity has likewise essentially stopped dead. But then merely considering, I suppose, capital markets, it seems that you — well, clearly you enjoyed a strong quarter in capital markets during this period. And it appears the expectation there, according to your guidance, is that those levels ought to persist into the current quarter. So I am merely attempting to grasp, I suppose, whether you are observing a visible pipeline there that would lead you to state that? Or merely attempting to square perhaps the notion that activity would begin to decelerate rather substantially there. So I am merely attempting to grasp why you still have — please continue.
Vince Delie
executiveYes. I believe one must examine fee income as a whole, Collyn, since the mortgage bank is — its pipeline is enormous; thus when they recorded the large impairment, I do not foresee — I am uncertain what will occur with interest rates. I have no desire to forecast; yet I would anticipate that their fee income during the following quarter would be considerably greater. And then you have the SBA business apart from the PPP program, which had a fairly robust pipeline heading into this circumstance. And then there is plenty of activity. The initial 2 months of March were quite good from an origination standpoint for us throughout the geographies; therefore I would anticipate that capital markets activity would persist into the following quarter. I cannot forecast at what level, yet I would anticipate it to persist since there are numerous companies that would prefer to fix their debt, and there are several deals we were working through from a syndications standpoint. So once more, there is plenty of uncertainty. We are attempting to do our utmost with the forecasting, yet we were looking quite good heading into this. We shall see what occurs as everything settles out.
Broderick Preston
analystI'd like to return to the topic of PPP fee income — specifically how we recognize that PPP income. My goal is to get a clearer picture of the reason it would, as I understand it, be deferred into 3Q, since looking at it through accrual accounting, the bulk of the activity happened early in the second quarter, and then you have that 8-week period, which lands us around the first weeks of June. So my thinking is that you'd have a pretty good idea, at least for round one, of what's been utilized by June and therefore what will be forgiven. So why not accrue for that during 2Q instead of 3Q?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, there's a process involved. The guidelines on forgiveness — how that process will actually function — still have to be released, Brody. So you won't truly have certainty that each and every loan will receive that forgiveness. They carry a 100% guarantee, so on the risk side, you're protected. However, from a loan accounting perspective, you can't actually recognize the unamortized or unaccreted fee until that loan has been forgiven and paid off; therefore, because you lack certainty that all 100% of them will be forgiven as they move through the SBA process that has yet to be defined, that's the reason. And we will accrete a portion of it, but the entire amount truly only arrives once the loan is genuinely paid off, and at that point you'd recognize it.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnd because of how big the client we're working with is, well, the most recent group we financed came in below $100,000. So my sense is the delay will be larger. There are additional small businesses we've onboarded in this process. Compared to a lot of others in the market, our average is considerably lower. That means the question of when they get their paperwork ready so it can enter the forgiveness queue under a process that still isn't available to us remains a major unknown. So from our standpoint, things will probably move somewhat more slowly, since these customers aren't as sophisticated, correct? Which means it could take them somewhat more time.
Vince Delie
executiveAlso, Brody, an 8-week window is included in that calculation, correct? That means the initial step is waiting until those 8 weeks have passed, and after that you must comply with whatever procedure the SBA establishes regarding how it will operate. Consequently, that carries you past June 30 and into the third quarter.
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect, and that’s the reason — indeed, they align the charge with each individual loan, one loan at a time, and then, I suppose, fold it into the yield, so it’s going to appear.
Broderick Preston
analystAlright, that's useful. Then I just wanted to circle back. Gary, you mentioned that deferrals currently make up 5% of loans, and with what's in the pipeline, you expect that to reach roughly 6%. So that works out to around $1.4 billion. I believe, based on the slide deck, you're beginning with 90-day deferrals for those customers, correct? FASB and the regulators have kind of allowed for up to a 180-day deferral period. For most of these loans, do you anticipate going that route? Or are you seeing — if you could provide some detail on what kind of borrower is utilizing the deferrals? Is there a blend of borrowers who genuinely require it and perhaps some who are fairly strong and simply want additional liquidity?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThat is what we're seeing; and what I can share with you, Brody, is that a meaningful portion of the — a meaningful percentage of the commercial borrowers to whom we've extended interest-only payment options, essentially deferring just the principal or a complete deferral, we lean very heavily toward the interest-only side of that; so more than 70% of the time, borrowers are opting to pay interest and only defer principal; so I believe that reflects the quality of the borrower and the portfolio seeking deferrals here. I think what they want is — to conserve cash, and deferrals are offered. So they're making appropriate use of that. Regarding the 180 days, we will assist borrowers who require it with another 90 days. So we'll continue working with those borrowers going forward. My expectation is that the restaurant industry would be one needing an additional 90 days, and possibly the hotel industry too. So mainly, I think their focus will be concentrated there.
Broderick Preston
analystAll right; that's helpful detail. And I suppose why I'm bringing this up is simply that I'm attempting to figure out if you'd anticipate a meaningful rise in that accrued interest receivable line item, which, just given that 70% of your commercial borrowers keep — are requesting IO. My assumption is that you don't anticipate that accrued interest receivable will shift materially upward?
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnd a portion of it will also get capitalized into the loan.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes. Yes. No, we do not.
Broderick Preston
analystAll right. It's just — I suppose what I'm getting at is, with certain of those borrowers, for instance where interest is being accrued or perhaps you aren't actually collecting it, that amount gets added to the loan balance, possibly later on, but my assumption is that in the meantime it would go into accrued interest receivable, is that right?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNot in the case where you capitalize it. When capitalization happens, it turns into a portion of the loan balance.
Broderick Preston
analystOkay.
Vince Delie
executiveEssentially, it's funding...
Gary Guerrieri
executiveCorrect.
Vince Delie
executiveRight. The customer provides the funds, and that amount gets tacked onto the tail end of the loan, so interest builds on a larger balance across a stretch of time.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThat's right.
Vince Delie
executiveThat's what's happening.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveEven though it's minor, you're correct.
Vince Delie
executiveIt's more minor, but — it's a minor portion, yet somewhat greater. Right.
Broderick Preston
analystAll right. And you had — you said that the 60 — that right now the reserve would represent 66% of the 2018 DFAST under the severe loss scenario. So that severe loss works out to roughly $520 million, maybe just running the numbers. Does that loss cover 1 year, or does it extend across several years within that stress test?
Vince Delie
executiveIt covers 9 quarters. That's how stress testing is conducted. That cumulative loss spans a 9-quarter period.
Broderick Preston
analystSo from what you're saying, and considering where the PPNR run rate stands, it seems like there'd be no need to touch the reserve at all, since PPNR would be more than enough to absorb the losses. Would that be a fair way to put it?
Vince Delie
executiveBrody, I'm not certain I'm tracking what you mean. Could you say that again?
Broderick Preston
analystYes. So at that level, across that stretch, your PPNR is more than sufficient to absorb those losses, provided you build for them each quarter, so you wouldn't really have to reach into the reserve, right?
Vince Delie
executiveOh, now I follow your point. Yes. Well, how the economy unfolds is what it hinges on.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThe way it unfolds.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveHere's hoping.
Vince Delie
executiveYeah.
Broderick Preston
analystCorrect. Correct. So Vince, you brought up a fascinating figure — mobile deposits rising 40% over the past 2 weeks. I realize things are changing quickly, but that is a sizable number. So I was hoping to get a clearer picture. Has something occurred over the past month or so that has shifted your thinking regarding your footprint? Is there any geography where customer behavior has caught you off guard when it comes to mobile adoption in this period? Or maybe you hadn't thought about closing branches before, and now that's something you're considering?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, a lot of branches have been closed by us. As a matter of fact, 16 were closed ahead of this. If we hadn't already started down that road, chances are we would have kept them operating. What I'm seeing — and it's curious — is that we still get roughly 66% of typical branch volume when it comes to transactions. So the read I take from that is that although folks are prepared to use remote capture, and this is remote capture from start to finish. That might be small businesses. Rather than visiting a branch, they use their device at their office; it's mobile, people on their mobile device, as I said, and we raised the limits so more checks could go through. My expectation, and what we've observed, is that quite a few customers who might have been older and weren't using our online and mobile offerings are now enrolling in them. So we're guiding them through the process at the branches; thus I'd anticipate faster uptake of those products. The count of branches has been brought down considerably by us. I believe we're reaching a stage where redirecting those branches is positive; and if we keep trimming at this pace without some kind of capital investment in the delivery channel, our capacity to grow will start to degrade. So we — and we're examining that. By that I mean we'll need to be strategic regarding closures. It may be necessary to construct a new facility and remove 2 in a market where a consolidation can be handled, but that calls for CapEx spending; that's where we stand, I believe, in the evolution of branch closures.
Broderick Preston
analystAll right, and then a few very fast ones that I've got on...
Vince Delie
executiveAnother item I should bring up is that we likewise experienced a notable rise in ITM transactions, clearly. So we have roughly 40 ITMs, the interactive teller machine, through which you can really talk with a person, cash a check down to a penny; they've been — usage of those has gone up over the last several weeks. Once again, as consumers grow more at ease with these devices and the equipment, I think that's a positive sign for what's ahead when it comes to utilization, which might result in greater efficiency in the branches from an HR standpoint. So there are additional ways to view it. But that's a good question, and I appreciate it.
Broderick Preston
analystYes. Then a final question from my side regarding capital. Am I right to assume that share repurchases have been paused? Apologies if that was already covered — I must have missed it.
Vince Calabrese
executiveRepurchases have indeed been paused. As Vince noted during his prepared remarks, roughly $25 million in stock was acquired before everything went into floating, after which we halted the program in order to preserve capital.
Brian Martin
analystI think most of what I wanted to ask has already been addressed, but let me go back to the PPP for a moment — Gary, or actually, Vince, my apologies. When you mention the 3% rate and the $2.1 billion, I just want to make sure I follow what you mean regarding the timing of when that benefit shows up, or how you're approaching it, especially since there isn't much disclosure around it or around how you plan to handle it. If you apply 3% and that comes to $60 million, and you recognize it across the next couple of quarters, or whatever approach you're taking, could you give some indication of how that $60 million — just the fee portion, not the spread portion — would flow through, from a high-level view, based on how you're thinking today? What portion of the benefit lands in the second and third quarter — or rather, in the third and fourth quarter?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. It would be recognized across the 2 years, Brian, unless something changes — once forgiveness happens, then you'd record whatever remains. The accounting is done loan by loan. So essentially, the number you mentioned, around 60, which is what the math produces, simply gets recognized evenly across that 2-year period, which represents the life of the loans — the stated life, I should clarify. And as we said before, based on how we expect the process to unfold, forgiveness won't occur until the third quarter arrives, when the loans get paid off. At that point, whatever remains on each loan that gets forgiven would be recorded as income during the third quarter; so I mentioned roughly 2-point — 2.25% all-in yields that we'd have, which is what was essentially assumed for the second quarter.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. Alright, that's useful. Then, regarding — I suppose, when it comes to the balance sheet and capital, I mean Gary, you mentioned the loans that were sold, the assets disposed of during the past 2 years. Is there anything, I suppose, you'd be considering, I suppose, is that something you folks are contemplating at present, any further asset sales moving forward? Or is that not truly something on your mind right now?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes. Brian, we continuously examine the balance sheet, and we have nothing at all positioned that we'd have any desire to sell right now; having said that, we always review the mortgage portfolio. So if anything existed, it would merely be a standard kind of mortgage pool being sold, but nothing beyond that.
Vince Calabrese
executivePlus, it wouldn’t be easy. What I mean is, those portfolios were sold by us when conditions were stronger. So I believe — and in most instances, we managed to exit those exposures at a premium. And I think back, I look back on those calls. I’m aware there was enormous pressure on us to increase revenue, but Gary made the strategic choice to leave certain classes — asset classes. A big part of those loans that got sold was hospitality, and many times they were past credits; so we — I believe we’ve taken a significant chunk out of the apple when it comes to risk management. And if you look back, exiting Regency, stepping away from certain mortgage products that we chose to sell, examining the credit portfolios, the acquired portfolios that were heavily concentrated in hospitality and other areas where we had no appetite, we bundled them up and sold them. And we sold them at a moment when a gain on the sale was possible because there was greater certainty then. Credit spreads were tighter. I hope that responds.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAbsolutely. Another point I’d mention in that regard, Brian, is the workout group we have. Across the past 2 to 2.5 years, we’ve made it substantially stronger, and they’ve been accomplishing a great deal when it comes to getting assets we don’t want to keep off our books. That is still happening now, so it’s delivering benefits for us too. It’s also one of the company’s central priorities, and it will remain so.
Brian Martin
analystThat's all. Alright. No, that's useful; and in my view it appears to be an excellent decision. So my final item was regarding the fee income section. Only two questions. Did I catch that correctly — I realize service charges declined during this quarter, but your expectation is that they will fall even more. And simply if you provided any detail on, just considering the market conditions, roughly how you are viewing the strength of the trust business at present, whether that too is experiencing pressure, and you already witnessed a portion of that. Are you observing any of it?
Vince Calabrese
executiveThe latter portion, and I will return to the forecast.
Vince Delie
executiveGo ahead.
Vince Calabrese
executiveOkay, all right. Yes, I can — I suppose the way I'd put it is that the guidance we've provided simply assumes core noninterest income holds steady compared with where it stood, apart from softer service charges. What I mean is, we do anticipate — we have observed a rise in waivers, though it isn't a large figure, under $1 million, over roughly the initial 4 weeks of this. So that creates a bit of drag. On top of that, activity has simply been lower. Thus the remark was that deposit transaction service charges are expected to come in weaker. So that will work against what the other businesses are delivering. We continue to anticipate robust contributions. If you look at the noninterest income slide included in the deck, we could observe the year-over-year move relative to the fourth quarter, and trust, insurance, securities commissions, capital markets were all quite strong. The percentage growth against both the fourth quarter and the first quarter a year ago has risen quite attractively. And we've put money into those businesses; we've kept expanding the teams in them; so I believe those contributions are — have mattered a great deal in offsetting the interest rate effects. And regarding mortgage, absent an MSR impact this quarter, our expectation is that the figure would sort of return to a normal, good, solid level during the second quarter.
Vince Delie
executiveYet when we look at it through the lens of earnings, if what you mean is that net asset values are falling as a result of the broader market's downturn, my expectation would be that this isn't significant or material, correct? So from an earnings standpoint, I'd say it won't be material.
Vince Delie
executiveOkay, to start, I want to express my gratitude to everyone for the insightful questions. I hope the details proved useful to you. We made an effort to give extra data regarding the credit portfolio, so that all of you might gain a clearer grasp of the way we operated our model, the approach we applied in running that model, and the places our exposures might possibly lie. I believe we're in a fairly solid position; and I value the careful analysis and inquiries from each of you, and I simply hope everyone remains safe, and we'll aim to meet you again. Thus, in the upcoming quarter, ideally, we'll gain greater clarity regarding our economic situation. So, many thanks. Stay well.
Operator
operatorThat brings an end to our call. We appreciate everyone joining us for this presentation. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.