F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 17, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Matthew Lazzaro
executiveThanks, and good morning, everyone — glad you could join us for this earnings call. This call from FNB Corporation, along with the documents it submits to the Securities and Exchange Commission, frequently includes forward-looking statements as well as non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP financial measures ought to be considered alongside, rather than as a substitute for, the results we report that are put together in line with GAAP. You'll find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, mapped to the closest comparable GAAP financial measures, in our presentation materials and in the earnings release. We ask that you look at the non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures found in the earnings release, the related presentation materials, and the reports and registration statements we file with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available on our corporate Website. A replay of this call will be accessible through July 24, and a link to the webcast will be posted in the About Us, Investor Relations section of our corporate Website. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveHello everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call this morning. With me today are Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, and Gary Guerrieri, our Chief Credit Officer. During this call, I'll give you an overview of second quarter results and an update on FNB's involvement in the paycheck protection program. Gary will cover asset quality and offer more detail on our loan portfolios. Vince will speak to our financial results and discuss relevant trends. After that, I'll share an update on our digital platforms and physical operations, and then talk about our organization's $250 million commitment and the ongoing initiatives aimed at addressing economic and social inequity in our community. This year, both as a company and personally, we've faced substantial challenges and change. Our thoughts go out to everyone affected by the pandemic and the unrest in our community. I take pride in the way our company has come together to support our customers and the neighborhoods where we operate. There's a determination to work together, to emerge stronger and united, and a drive for a more successful future for all of our constituents. FNB's second quarter results rose considerably. Operating earnings per share grew 63% to $0.26, which included an additional 17 million, or $0.04 per share, of COVID-19 reserve build during the quarter, and PPNR climbed to 130 million. Core revenue trends stayed solid through a difficult interest rate environment, with total revenues up 6% annualized to $306 million. And total assets grew nearly $3 billion, finishing June at $38 billion. Versus the first quarter, loans and deposits rose $2.3 billion and $3.6 billion, or 10% and 15% respectively. On a linked quarter basis, double-digit second quarter loan and deposit growth was backed by organic commercial production and by originating nearly 20,000 PPP loans totaling $2.6 billion. Our fee based businesses did exceptionally well, with capital markets and mortgage banking setting revenue records of $13 million and $17 million respectively. Our efficiency ratio came in at 53.7%, and operating expenses were well controlled, down 3% from the first quarter. Even with disruption across our footprint because of COVID-19, we've still seen good commercial loan origination activity across most of the footprint. That speaks to our teams, who keep serving our clients and meeting their borrowing needs while navigating a challenging operating environment. A stronger balance sheet and ample liquidity allowed FNB to support our clients' capital needs. We continue to apply our consistent underwriting standard, aligned with our strategy and overall risk profile, as we assess business opportunities in the current climate; on a linked quarter basis, total average loans grew 9%, largely driven by a 14% increase in commercial loans. Commercial line balances contracted relative to historical levels, as we saw much lower line utilization of 36%. The utilization rate fell as PPP funds were used by many existing clients to support working capital needs, and economic activity declined during the period. On the commercial lending side, we also saw an effect from big corporate clients who used the greater liquidity available in the bond market to pay down their bank credit facilities. Our average deposits rose 11%, reflecting strong organic growth and customer relationships, and we also saw a significant influx of deposits tied to PPP funding through government stimulus programs. As part of our business strategy, we've concentrated on lowering wholesale borrowings by bringing in more depositors and deepening the relationships we already have. Because of that, we managed to completely remove our overnight borrowing position and substitute it with customer deposits. Non-interest bearing deposits climbed 2.1 billion, or 33%, compared with the prior quarter end. If you look at spot balances as of June 30, our loan to deposit ratio stood at 92%, counting the funded PPP loans, which puts us in a better position given the current rate environment. Expanding non-interest bearing deposits has long been a key component of our strategy, and we've reliably achieved organic growth across a range of interest rate environments, which has further reinforced our overall funding mix. In fact, transaction deposits are up 4 billion, or 20%, from March 31, and they now make up 85% of total deposits, a figure that stacks up very well against 79% five years ago; since the Fed has taken near term rate hikes off the table, we have an opportunity to offset net interest income headwinds by continuing to bring deposit costs down. As we've said before, growing our fee based businesses is critical to diversifying where our revenue comes from and to easing pressure on net interest income during a prolonged low rate period. With interest rate expectations now pointing to lower for longer, it matters that we keep building on our recent momentum in capital markets, mortgage banking, wealth management and insurance. This quarter's record mortgage banking income of 17 million is a better reflection of the underlying fundamentals and results excluding MSR impairment, as the mortgage banking business posted a new quarterly production record of 869 million. Now, regarding our involvement in the paycheck protection program, I want to start by acknowledging our teams for the way they supported our customers and communities through these extraordinary circumstances. Our employees have worked tirelessly to make sure businesses got critical funding at a time when regions in our footprint faced extended shutdowns, especially in our Metro markets in Pennsylvania and the Mid- Atlantic, and when many borrowers came to FNB from larger banks so we could meet their needs. Through the PPP origination process, every borrower opened an FNB account, which helps our push to bring in new households. Going forward, we're optimistic that borrowers will be able to put these funds to use as businesses across the footprint reopen. As an organization, we used our existing technology infrastructure and expertise to adapt quickly and serve our customers in a difficult, remote environment, and together with substantial financial aid and employee volunteerism in our communities, our efforts have assisted tens of thousands of small businesses during the pandemic and helped preserve hundreds of thousands of jobs. Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, FNB has maintained steady totals for both overall and audited transactions, giving clients a smooth shift from in-person visits to online and mobile channels. That became achievable thanks to the major funding we've directed toward our digital and online platforms across the past decade; in fact, the appointment booking tool on our newly launched Website, which debuted in January, allowed FNB to keep serving customers safely inside our branches during the crisis; we expanded from 26 appointments per month in January to 2700 appointments in April. The swift move toward remote service sped up improvements to our digital strategy that were already in progress and reduced inconvenience for our customers. Because the operating environment keeps shifting constantly, we will maintain our inventive approach to serve our customers better. I'll now provide a few updates on our operations and delivery chain. Alongside the rise in online appointment booking, our Website drew millions more daily visitors. As we strengthen ties with customers through our digital capabilities, we are also creating substantial opportunities by aligning the in-person and digital customer experience, we can take customers who use just one product and expand the relationship to encompass products like savings, credit cards, private banking, mortgage, wealth management and insurance. Ultimately, it delivers enormous benefit to the customer to hold several product relationships inside FNB on one platform linked via digital capabilities. On the whole, the surge in digital and remote banking volume showcases our flexible integrated multi-channel strategy. Customers have been more engaged in FNB's mobile and online channels, with monthly average users rising by 50,000 in each category, relative to the average for 2019. Although our customer adoption rates for online and mobile have sped up, our customers have still voiced a strong wish to do business inside our branches. As an essential business, FNB must stay available and accessible. Our business continuity team, working with other units such as data science, human resources and retail banking, built a monitoring system that lets us assess data tied to the healthcare crisis on a location-by-location basis. On July 13, 2020, we reopened most of our branch lobbies to customers while following the strictest safety measures, such as social distancing and cleaning protocols, as we start advancing to the next phase of operation. With that, I'll hand the call to Gary to discuss asset quality.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThanks, Vince, and hello everyone. While the worldwide COVID-19 outbreak continues to change, our credit portfolio kept up a satisfactory performance all through Q2. Amid this tough economic environment, our credit measures stayed steady, and I'll take you through that more thoroughly using both GAAP and non-GAAP figures, setting aside the loan volume we funded via the PPP program. I'll also share some news about the status of our loan deferrals and what we're doing to manage our book, particularly for those borrowers tied to industries sensitive to COVID. Let's move on to the quarterly results now. Looking at GAAP figures, delinquencies ended Q2 at 92 basis points. That's a drop of 21 bps versus the previous quarter, since early-stage delinquencies are coming back to more typical levels. Had PPP loans been left out, delinquency for the quarter would have landed at 1.02%, which is 11 bps lower than the prior quarter. As of June, NPLS and OREO stood at 72 basis points — up 8 basis points from the linked quarter — and on a non-GAAP basis, stripping out PPP, that figure was 80 bps. The main reason for this shift was a handful of credits that had been rated before and then got hit harder by the COVID situation, so during the quarter we made the proactive decision to put them on non-accrual. Looking at our overall NPLS as of June, you'll see that 48% of those borrowers are still making payments on schedule <<inaudible>>. Net charge-offs held at a solid 8.5 million for the quarter, or 13 basis points annualized, which brings us to 12 basis points for the year to date. Provision expense reached $30 million this quarter, and that figure includes an extra build for macroeconomic conditions related to COVID-19. To give some context on the economic-driven build from Q1, our COVID-related provision across the first half of the year added up to $55 million. Looking at where our reserves ended up, the figure came in at 1.4%. If you take PPP volume out of the picture, the non-GAAP ending ACL was 1.54%, which is a 10 basis point bump from the quarter before, and that gave us NPL coverage of 215%. Once you factor in the unamortized loan discounts from acquisitions, though, coverage without PPP volume reaches 1.87%. Run things under the preliminary severely adverse default scenario, and the reserve position as it stands now, unamortized loan discounts included, would absorb 78% of stressed losses. With the pandemic still weighing on the global economy, the way we're managing the book through COVID hasn't changed from what I laid out on last quarter's call. We keep doing detailed borrower-by-borrower examinations across our commercial books, so we can monitor the key performance indicators for companies in industries that are sensitive to economic conditions, or that have been affected in other ways by the pandemic. Through these continuing, targeted portfolio reviews, our credit teams are able to spot emerging risks fast and deal with them proactively, whether they arise at the level of a borrower's industry or across the portfolio as a whole. On top of that, we are still running a set of scenario analyses and stress test models under the allowance and DFAST frameworks we already have in place, while we navigate this difficult environment. As for borrowers who sought payment deferrals, 10% of our loan portfolio, excluding PPP loans, was approved during that initial deferment request window. Prior to the pandemic, 98.4% of those deferments were current and in good standing. Of the other 39 million, 12 million have already been placed on non-accrual. At this point, requests for first-time deferrals have essentially disappeared, and thus far only a modest volume of second payment-deferral requests has come in; even so, we continue to monitor our credit portfolio closely and remain vigilant, which allows us to detect borrowers who may face greater strain amid these uncertain economic conditions. That method enables us to spot and address risk within the portfolio swiftly while continuing to meet our customers' credit needs. The portfolio remains diversified and well balanced across a range of product lines, geographies and industries. Turning to Slide 10, you can see that our lending to highly sensitive sectors remains modest—just 3.8% of the overall portfolio. That figure includes every borrower in travel and leisure, food services, and energy. Among those borrowers, the share receiving payment deferrals still stands at 38%. On top of that, we've kept a close watch on our retail secured IRE portfolio, which lets us gauge the new pressures building in this asset class, understand what kinds of operations the tenants run, and see how well they're shielded from particular economic stress as essential businesses. The average loan-to-value across this portfolio, weighted for size, remains solid at 65%. To put it briefly, we are continuing to oversee our credit book amid these tough economic conditions, drawing on solid credit basics and the risk management approaches we keep refining as COVID continues to unfold. Despite these hurdles, our portfolio stands in a satisfactory place going into the back half of the year. Acknowledging the considerable uncertainty in the economy ahead of us, we keep leaning on the capabilities of our seasoned banking professionals to steer through these circumstances as we progress into the year's final six months. I'd like to acknowledge how hard our teams have been pushing as we continue to navigate these difficult conditions. At this point, I'll hand things over to our Chief Financial Officer, Vince Calabrese, so he can share his comments.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks, Gary. Good morning, everyone. I'll go over our second quarter results, the trends we're seeing in the operating environment, and then cover how we're managing capital along with where we stand right now. I want to point out that we came into this year with tangible common equity at the strongest level we've seen in close to twenty years, and we feel good about where our capital sits today. If you look at Slide 5, GAAP EPS came in at $0.25 for the second quarter, and that includes $0.05 tied to significant or outsize items. Those items consisted of 17.1 million in COVID-19 reserve bills and 2 million of expenses related to COVID-19. The CCE ratio finished June at 697, which reflects these items plus a 52 basis point temporary impact from the 2.5 billion in net PPP loan balances as of June 30. Excluding the PPP balances, the CCE ratio would have come in at 749. On top of that, our CET1 estimate at quarter end was 9.4%, versus 9.1 at March 31 and 9.4 at the close of 2019, since PPP loans receive a 0% risk weighting for risk-based capital purposes. Pre-tax pre-provision earnings rose to 130 million, which gives us more than sufficient earnings power, and earlier this week we declared our third quarter dividend of $0.12. With a dividend payout ratio of 48% in the second quarter, we remain well under the historical levels of prior payout ratios. I'll get into our capital management approach in greater detail later on. Moving to the balance sheet on Slide 14, the main story is the effect of 2.5 billion in net PPP loans. <<inaudible>> 9.5% of total loans and leases at June 30. PPP was the biggest factor behind the linked quarter average increase of 2.1 billion, or 9%, along with solid organic activity across most of the commercial <<inaudible>>. Commercial line utilization at the end of June was 36%, under historical levels and down from the mid-40s spot utilization rate at the close of the first quarter, as we obviously saw some customer borrowing shift toward the PPP and our large corporate borrowers tap capital markets to pay down their bank debt. Average consumer loans were basically unchanged, as direct installment loans grew 65 million, or 14% annualized, and residential mortgage rose 6% annualized, two bright spots that keep performing well. Gains in direct installment and mortgage loans were offset by the ongoing decline in indirect auto loans and consumer lines, two loan classes hit hard by the pandemic. Continuing down Slide 14, average deposits grew 2.7 billion, or 11%, on a linked quarter basis, <<inaudible>> by 2.9 billion, or 15%, in transaction deposit growth. Transaction deposits made up 85% of total deposits as our client CD management continued, and transaction deposit balances got a lift from stimulus programs and PPP-related customer inflows. Non-interest bearing, interest bearing demand, and savings account balances each rose significantly, up 1.8 billion, 854 million, and 226 million respectively. Now let's focus on the income statement on Slide 15. Relative to the first quarter, net interest income came to 228 million, down 4.7 million, or 2%, since growth in loans and deposits largely counterbalanced the effect of reduced rates. The net interest margin contracted by 26 basis points to 88, largely because of a whole quarter's impact from the , cutting the target Fed funds range to 0 to 25 basis points. In addition, average 1-month LIBOR dropped to 36 basis points, down from 141 the previous quarter. Total yield on average earning assets fell 58 basis points from 354, mirroring diminished yields on variable and adjustable rate loans caused by the lower interest rate climate and the effect of PPP balances. Total cost of funds declined to 67 basis points from 101, as costs on interest bearing deposits were brought down to 37 basis points. Slides 16 and 17 give specifics on non-interest income and expense versus the first quarter. Non-interest income reached 77.6 million, up 9.1 million, or 13.3%, with mortgage banking operations rising 17.6 million on a reported basis, or 10.2 million when excluding MSR impairments of 300,000 and 7.7 million, respectively. Mortgage production hit a fresh quarterly record of 869 million, up 306 million, or 55%, from the earlier quarter, with big contributions from North Carolina and the Mid Atlantic region. Capital markets likewise reached a new record of 12.5 million, climbing 1.4 million, or 12.6%, on strong contributions from interest rates derivative activity throughout the footprint. As anticipated, service charges fell 6.2 million, or 20.5%, because of markedly weaker transaction volumes in the COVID-19 setting. Moving to Slide 17, non-interest expense was 175.9 million, a rise of 19 million, or 9.7%, including 2 million of expenses tied to COVID-19 in the second quarter of 2020, and 15.9 million of outsize unusual or significant expenses that occurred in the first quarter. On an operating basis, expenses dropped 5.1 million, or 2.9%, versus the first quarter of 2020, since we achieved lower variable expenses, such as travel and business development, plus greater FAS 91 benefits, given how many loans were originated in the second quarter. Furthermore, we recorded an impairment of 4.1 million from a second quarter renewable energy investment tax credit transaction. Related tax credits were recognized during the quarter as a benefit to income tax. The efficiency ratio improved markedly to 53.7% from 59%. Beginning with recent trends on Slide 18, we keep watching daily shifts in external factors, among them multiple aspects of possible economic recovery, changes in government programs, and regulatory changes to current programs. That said, we are offering our present directional outlook for the third quarter based on what we know today, which is subject to change as we all know; we expect period end loans to rise by low single digits from June 30, assuming no forgiveness of PPP loans given the SBA's current expected timing for processing forgiveness applications. Although we anticipate a decrease in deposits at the levels seen in the second quarter of 2020 based on an expectation, as customers deployed more of the funds they received from government programs, we do anticipate ongoing organic expansion in transaction deposits; for the third quarter, we expect net interest income to show the complete effects of a lower one month LIBOR rate on variable rate loans, partly offset by a full quarter advantage from higher commercial loan balances and a continued decrease in the cost of interest bearing deposits. We anticipate favorable trends in capital markets and mortgage banking, though below the record levels of this quarter. We expect service charges to rise if the recent transaction volume trends persist. We expect expenses to be stable to up slightly from the second quarter. Finally, we expect the effective tax rate to be around 17% for the full year 2020; for the rest of my comments, I would like to talk about our risk based capital position and overall management philosophy given the current environment, starting on Slide 20. We continue to be very comfortable with our capital ratios as they stand today, as the benefit of entering this crisis from a position of strength. As shown in the new capital slides we have added to the deck, we have ample internal capital generation cushions for all of our capital ratios in relation to well capitalized thresholds. For instance, for the total risk based capital ratio far below 11%, total capital would have to drop by $258 million, 7.9% of total capital of $3.3 billion.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThe amount our risk weighted assets went up by was 2.3 billion, representing 8.5% of the 27.5 billion total for risk weighted assets <> that 258 million figure is in after tax dollars. Beyond where our capital stands, we hold a conservative leaning in the way we establish reserves, particularly considering the steady underwriting approach that's been followed for more than ten years. We have CET1 amounting to $2.6 billion, plus an allowance for credit losses totaling 365 million and a remaining PCD discount of 77 million, giving us a sizable foundation to soak up credit losses. For context, those reserves together with the remaining discount on loans acquired earlier would span 62 quarters of net charge offs, which ran at an average of 7.1 million each quarter during the first half of 2020. That's without factoring in the 2.6 billion in GDP volume. Yet another angle: compare this against the severely adverse charge offs from our most recent stress test. Once more, taking 442 million in reserves plus the remaining discount, we're covering 75% of the 586 million in charge offs that the severely adverse scenario projects across a nine quarter stretch. For context on that 586, it stands against 64 million across nine quarters based on first half 2020 net charge offs, or 9.2x what we're seeing now. When it comes to whether the dividend can be sustained, the Federal Reserve and the OCC have authority over us. Looking at it from the Fed's angle, we're currently paying out 39 million in common dividends along with 2 million in preferred dividends, making 41 million each quarter in total. The Fed's four quarter tests presently indicate more than $153 million remaining after distributing the third quarter dividends just declared. From the OCC's side, substantial cushions exist to back the $46 million the bank is expected to pay up to the holding company. <> indicates a cushion of 913 million against net undivided profits of 517 million against net profits for the present year, and when combined with retained net profits from the two prior years, cushions sit above well capitalized thresholds by anywhere from 228 basis points to 384 basis points. Besides examining our capital position, PPNR generation deserves attention. Our year-to-date PPNR of 236 million does more than enough to support the added reserve build across the year's first six months. We produced plenty of capital to cover preferred and common dividends, and our CET1 ratio matched where we finished 2019, at 9.4%. Earlier this week, we declared our third quarter dividend of $0.12, and given the earnings seen through the first half of 2020, you can observe the ability to keep returning capital to shareholders. All in all, our approach to capital management rests on conservative and steady underwriting and credit management through all sorts of economic cycles, reinforced by strong, thorough enterprise risk management, which includes highly active credit monitoring processes; with that, I'll hand the call back over to Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveThank you, Vince. When I think about all that we've navigated during these past several months, the way our team has stepped up to help our customers and the communities we're part of has truly been remarkable. The recent events that brought attention to ongoing disparities in this nation have reinforced how essential our role is in standing behind those who are vulnerable and have historically been left without adequate service. Within our organization, we keep a sharp focus on fostering inclusion, and that's shown by the $250 million pledge we made recently to tackle economic and social inequity in low and moderate income and predominantly minority communities. As we keep putting these investments to work, our shareholders stand to gain, since we've carried on with disciplined oversight of risk, liquidity and capital actions to strengthen our company's position. In the quarter, FNB produced close to 500 million in paycheck protection program loans and low to moderate income lending in rural neighborhoods, which helped thousands of small businesses and their employees. What drove this success was our bankers reaching out proactively to more than 100 organizations and non-profit entities that engage directly with these communities. That's one illustration of how directing our resources in this manner generates solid business outcomes. I'd urge everyone to find out more about our continuing initiatives and our dedication to diversity and inclusion by following the links included on the slides in today's presentation. As we prepare to enter the next stage of COVID-19 recovery, our response will stay centered on four key pillars designed to serve each of our constituencies. Those pillars consist of employee protection and assistance, operational response and preparedness, customer and community support, and risk management along with the actions we take to protect shareholder value amid the severe difficulties we face. Even under these extraordinary circumstances, our employees have unfailingly provided a superior experience to our customers. In June, Forbes and AdvisoryHQ respectively ranked FNB among the best banks in Ohio and North Carolina, which speaks to how consistently our customer-centric culture is applied throughout our footprint. Once again, the Cleveland Plain Dealer named the company a top workplace in northeastern Ohio, marking the sixth consecutive year; that honor, which rests entirely on employee feedback, added to a roster of close to 30 similar awards we've earned over the past decade. Every bit of this has come about because of our devoted employees. To wrap up, I want once more to express my gratitude to my fellow team members, because throughout this period they've shown precisely why they remain our most valuable asset. Our commitment to building a superior culture feeds straight into a better customer experience, stronger financial performance and higher returns for our shareholders. With that, I'll hand the call to the operator so we can open it up for questions.
Casey Haire
analystLet me begin with something procedural. There's a lot I've picked up for us; so what about the purchase accounting, Vince, for this quarter and what lies ahead?
Vince Calabrese
executiveFrom the CECL method, the remaining discounts contributed 13.2 million of accretion. As you might recall, that figure stood at 17 million during the first quarter. It's therefore somewhat lower, though it remains a fairly solid, healthy amount.
Casey Haire
analystAll right, excellent. Then, Gary, regarding credit quality, the fact that defaults sit at 10% suggests the new requests have dropped off sharply. My understanding is that you all had a three month program, so I'd think they'd either be getting extended or reverting to normal — based on what you're seeing and hearing, how do you think that 10% will move over the coming quarter, meaning this quarter?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveCasey, on that point, we did run 90 days, and things really picked up in late April — mid to late April through May. In June it leveled off quite a bit. There was a really tiny amount of activity during June. So here's what happened: a large number of our clients had already made their March payment and then made the April payment, and we sort of pushed them deeper into recovery; as things stand now, we've seen only roughly 50 commercial requests for second deferrals, plus around 250 on the retail side. So right now it's been quite light, and the bankers are engaged closely with those clients, speaking with them frequently. We do anticipate that picking up as we move through the remainder of July and into August and September, somewhat, but as of now, it's very light.
Casey Haire
analystAll right, but when you report in October, do you anticipate those deferrals staying at 10%, or do you figure many of them will revert to normal?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYeah, we anticipate many of those deferrals reverting to normal payments, and we'll disclose that moving forward since a lot of those clients won't require a second deferral; from where we sit right now, a significant number won't require it. And I believe what you'll observe is heavier deferrals for second requests arriving in the hotel space and in that restaurant space, given the greater pressure they face. Another item I'll bring up again is that entering this situation, right at using the end of the year, 98.4% of these clients who took the deferrals are in perfectly good standing; so, as mentioned, it was a very small number in my report that weren't operating in the normal course of business. Of course, this shutdown has affected a lot of clients. And a lot of clients were preserving liquidity and being cautious. But hopefully that answers the question for you holistically.
Casey Haire
analystYeah, yeah. Thank you. About that reserve build — it was less pronounced this quarter. So when did you actually — which projections did you use, and how current was the forecast behind your reserve calculation? And since the reserve came in lower this quarter, do you think you and deferrals are getting some favorable signals? Has the reserve build — the hard part — basically wrapped up? I know that's tough to pin down, it changes every day; but looking at where deferrals are heading and your smaller reserve build, it appears you folks are — the toughest portion is done; so any thoughts on that would help.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveLet me take the model question first, Casey. The recessionary scenario we're still working with came out in the middle of June. It assumes an unemployment rate averaging 11% over the forecast period, and annualized GDP on a year-over-year basis doesn't go positive until the middle half of 2021. So it's a reasonably solid recessionary scenario, and that's what we've built into the model. Now for the second part of what you asked — it comes down to our focus and our steady philosophy when it comes to underwriting and credit culture, specifically around which asset classes we want in the book, along with the positioning and mix of the portfolio. I'm fairly confident that, over the course of the cycle, our book will outperform in a general sense, the way it did in the previous one. That being said, as you pointed out, there's a great deal of uncertainty in the economy right now, and should the economy weaken further from where it stands, the portfolio would face greater stress. In light of where we stand and how we've performed so far, along with the composition of our portfolio — the smaller portfolios spread across higher asset classes — we'll keep evaluating those positions as the third quarter unfolds. A few more things to add here: keep in mind that in Q1, we picked up the March 27 forecast at a time when others possibly didn't. So at that moment, we made use of that freshest piece of information in connection with our forecasted models. We put together a total of $55 million across those first six months. One more thing worth mentioning: our exposure is basically zero when it comes to credit cards and student loans, and our energy book is quite small. As everyone is aware, those areas are difficult from a reserve perspective in conditions like these. On top of that, we saw a fairly large drop in line utilization within direct auto, along with some decreases in the small business portfolio, and together those released roughly $10 billion in extra reserves for us over the quarter, which was another helpful factor. Lastly, if you consider the macroeconomic backdrop and hold it steady, with our portfolio performing in a comparable way going forward, we would not anticipate any meaningful further build from a macroeconomic forecast standpoint. We'll keep handling that in line with whatever direction the economy takes going forward.
Vince Delie
executiveCasey, one thing I'd tack on — and I believe we touched on this already — is that once you set the PPP aside, reserve coverage came in at 154. On the acquired loans, we still carry $77 million of discount remaining, and under CECL accounting that figure stays flat <<inaudible>>, meaning it's there to soak up losses, which takes 154 up to 187. Then, as shown in our slides, we hold an additional $14 million set aside for unfunded lines, worth roughly another 7 basis points; so since year-end, we've built up a solid amount in the reserves, as Gary mentioned.
Casey Haire
analystGot it. And Vince, perhaps just one final item — the overall capital ratio, I couldn't find it in either the release or the deck. Was it sitting at 630?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYou mean the total risk-based capital ratio?
Casey Haire
analystThat's right.
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo, we didn't — we haven't put that out there, Casey. Our CET1 sits at 9.4; we'll have that figure available before this call wraps up. It's simply not on hand right now.
Frank Schiraldi
analystFollowing up about credit — as you both note, when the acquired book gets included in the reserve ratio, it appears to stack up fine against where competitors sit, yet digging into the individual categories, on the surface some of them look slightly slimmer than I'd have figured; so could you perhaps offer a bit more detail or color regarding, say, the retail CRE book, where reserves, I believe, remain only a hair below 1%?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveLooking at that portfolio, Frank, credit problems within it are currently quite scarce; our sponsors throughout it leave us feeling quite confident; and given that part of it leans retail, as we've discussed, our underwriting for that book over recent years has concentrated on stronger cash flow streams and mandated debt service coverages. One element present there is an exceptionally small amount of delinquency as of today — naturally, things shift. That said, delinquency within it stands at 60 basis points, with hardly any rated credit at this stage. From our standpoint, then, that book was underwritten quite well. And per what I noted earlier, LTVs throughout it come in right at 65%. At this point, therefore, our position in that portfolio is solid. So we genuinely feel confident about it and about collaborating with those clients. Currently, what we're observing is rental streams beginning to climb as the economy reopens. We'll keep watching that as things progress, though ideally positive momentum will keep showing up there too.
Frank Schiraldi
analystSo when it comes to downgrades, or deferrals that end up pushing downgrades, moving credit into classified or criticized status — or those deferrals just delaying that — what's your approach? Do you handle each one as it arrives, and I'm curious whether you think that once these deferrals roll off, there might be migration that leads to additional reserve builds.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveIn that initial round, credits tied to industries that weren't sensitive generally got shifted by a notch. Other credits sitting in a really strong position, where we were being conservative — those specific ones stayed put. Now in this second phase, each second deferral is going to call for a one notch downgrade, and in most cases possibly two, down to a substandard rating. So that portfolio will keep being worked in that manner, and we'll handle those ratings based on whatever risk exists in each individual credit situation.
Vince Calabrese
executiveFrank, let me address that within the commercial portfolio—I want to make sure I'm hearing you correctly on the commercial portfolio side, and I'm not certain whether you're crossing over. But similar to that, we have very active risk rating reviews that never stop. So we've got a highly aggressive management system in place to make sure that when we look at financials and examine credit and covenant compliance, the right risk rating gets assigned to those credits. So the migration on risk ratings, if that's what you're asking about, is happening right now—I mean, it's been happening. When those deferrals came in, it might have been slightly early, right, because the bulk of the impact for our commercial customers, based on what I'm hearing, was occurring in April, late March into April and May. And most of the industries have kind of rebounded back well past where they stood at the depths of April. So that's a continuing process. And we have a pretty rigorous process in place to review this rating.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveFrank, what Vince brought up is really worth noting. From the perspective of regulators, we have a reputation for being quite forceful when it comes to how we assign risk ratings. What drives us is this: whenever a banker has any involvement with a credit, regardless of the type, be it the time for an annual review, the moment for renewing a line of credit, or even just a phone call, that banker must evaluate the circumstances and lower the risk rating as often as each month. That kind of forward-leaning practice, I believe, has existed for a long stretch of years.
Frank Schiraldi
analystRight, thanks. I've got a quick one about expenses, if that's okay — you folks provided a bit of guidance regarding what to expect for the third quarter. Could you walk us through a few puts and takes on how we get there from where we are this quarter? I realize the tax credit would have pushed expenses higher this quarter. So I'm just attempting to get a feel for — if I look at, if I strip out the COVID related expense, I believe I land at roughly 174 for the expense space this quarter; so is that basically the starting point you're referring to when you say steady to slightly up? And would that serve as a decent run rate perhaps past 3Q, if you could give us any indication there? Thanks.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. On the slide, we noted the 4.1 million in impairments, and then moving the opposite direction, since you didn't observe much change in that other non-interest expense line. We saw lower business development, lower OREO — prior to OREO we had lower miscellaneous losses and miscellaneous; so those roughly offset one another. As you can tell, it was 21.9 in the first quarter and 21.9 in the second quarter. So looking ahead to the third quarter, I mean, the comments I gave during my prepared remarks, roughly the mid 170s. I'd say somewhere in the range of 175 to 177-ish or so. That figure includes commissions on mortgage activity, which has been extremely heavy. So that flows through to that line item; and we'll see a portion of that come through in the third quarter; so, I mean, it's really right around — I think last quarter I referenced something like a 178, and I think we'd come in below that. We landed at 176 on a total basis, 174 as you mentioned, so; it's around there, Frank — 175, 177, that sort of thing used as a run rate for the third quarter. Regarding the fourth quarter, we aren't really offering any further direction there, but nothing unusual is on the horizon that would affect that.
Mike Young
analystI want to ask a fast second question, beginning with credit. You show on Slide 9 what looks like the peak historical charge off rate reaching back to the prior crisis, yet clearly you did well in x-Florida. Gary, is that roughly the correct lens for charge offs in this instance? Are you at ease with that, or do you believe that because of how severe the shock is, plus how long this crisis might run, it might end up being worse now?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveMichael, I feel just as confident about the way the portfolio is going to perform through a cycle like this one. Consider our models, as we discussed regarding stress testing, what we are doing, every model we run across the portfolio, and the $55 million build over the first six months of the year. Were you to add that to normalized charge offs, you would be looking at charge offs annualized at roughly the 45 basis point range at that stress level. The models back that up, and to me it feels pretty good. Of course, at some point the economy needs to stabilize, and the volatility has to go away. Still, right now, from that standpoint, it feels good.
Mike Young
analystAlright, so to pull all of this together — if we removed charge-off rates comparable to that, and then supposed that broader economic circumstances perhaps leveled out when it comes to the CECL allowance picture, then you'd simply be reflecting downgrades along with those charge offs we already talked about. That's roughly the way we ought to view credit and provisioning moving ahead.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveI'd call that reasonable.
Vince Delie
executiveAnd providing for growth.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveProviding for growth.
Mike Young
analystAbsolutely. That's what we'd been hoping to hear. Let me pivot to a different topic, Vince — regarding the PPP loans and their related fees. Did any of those fees get recognized this quarter through accelerated amortization? And going forward, how do you see that playing out?
Vince Delie
executiveRight. I'd say the forgiveness process hasn't gotten underway at this point. The SBA is still figuring out the mechanism by which they'll accept forgiveness applications. We're prepared for it whenever that happens, but at this moment we aren't in a position to kick that process off. So the fee recognition that occurred was essentially just normal accretion of those fees, since the bulk of these loans carry two-year terms. A small number of them had five-year terms. One way to think about it: the yield for Q2 came in at 3.15, which reflects the coupon plus accretion of a piece of the fee. So no acceleration has shown up there yet. Honestly, it's difficult to forecast — nobody really has a clear picture. In our discussions internally, we've tossed around the idea that perhaps 15% forgiveness arrives in Q4. You likely get none during the third quarter, simply because they aren't ready yet; they get 90 days to respond, which pushes everything into the fourth quarter. So for my modeling purposes, we've assumed 15% in Q4. Perhaps three quarters of it lands by the end of March, then maybe 90% by the end of June, with some remainder after that — though these are just reference points, since nobody truly knows. We do anticipate receiving some degree of forgiveness, which would occur in the fourth quarter, and then the fee impact going forward depends on how large that turns out to be. Those are the main points regarding the PPP balances. And on the third quarter, I should mention as well: the average balance was 1.9 billion. For Q3, the average balance will be roughly 2.5 net, because we didn't carry all of it through the entirety of Q2.
Vince Calabrese
executiveOne more item, Vince — I want to give a shout-out to our IT group and to Sam Kirsch over in digital channels. We have created a pretty sturdy platform that lets customers submit their documentation, and it guides them through the forgiveness procedure, which keeps evolving. It is quite advanced, yet the experience is quite pleasant. After that, Gary brought on a group of individuals and has put together a team whose job is to serve as liaisons for customers, assisting in making the forgiveness procedure move along. So we continue to hold out hope for a simpler procedure for those smaller loans — I'm aware there's discussion about immediate forgiveness for amounts below 150 — that would be an enormous help, but we do have systems ready to assist in making forgiveness happen for our customers. One more item I want to mention: if you examine the balances, our total loan balances — once you take out the PPP loans — would have declined a little, at 1%, I believe, 1%, 1.5% in total; it's a rather tricky calculation, because we have smaller customers. If you look at how widely those PPP loans were distributed, our loans tend to be smaller in relative terms. Usually those borrowers would take money through the PPP program, reduce their working capital facilities, correct? Since the rate differences are pretty substantial, and then draw again on their lines if they feel confident they can do so. So I think when we consider the shift from PPP into our own revolver balances or line balances for small business customers, that accounts for part of the drop in the portfolio. The general level of activity throughout the company, as I said in my prepared remarks, was quite solid. And there remain businesses worth financing out there. There are organizations we would definitely deem worthy of extending credit to. And there are other sectors that are struggling, and we aren't heavily involved in them, as you can tell from the portfolio breakdown included in our disclosures. We don't have much activity in quite a few of those spaces. So I feel somewhat more positive regarding activity going forward. Naturally, we have not yet witnessed the consequences that I believe will emerge from a credit standpoint in the third and fourth quarter; up to now, things appear fine for us. In any case, I wanted to pass that along to you — a bit of extra commentary.
Mike Young
analystYes. I appreciate the extra detail there, Vince. Then perhaps one final item from me regarding the net interest margin; it appears you still have room to lower deposit funding costs each year — could you possibly discuss the timing and the opportunity around that? Also, is there any lingering roll down and loan yields from here?
Vince Calabrese
executiveWell, regarding the liability side, I mean, I believe if opportunities exist within the deposit base, I know we've seen meaningful deposit growth even beyond the PPP. The growth tied to PPP balances arriving — our demand deposits rose considerably, we've been trending upward over the last few years; so that has persisted. I think opportunities are present there to reduce our overall costs; and I'll let Vince address the asset side of the equation when it comes to margins; but on the liability side, there is room for us to keep improving on that side.
Vince Delie
executiveI'll offer just a few remarks. Looking at how we did during the quarter: net interest income came down by 4.7 million, and that's because one-month LIBOR fell 105 basis points, moving from 141 basis points down to 36 basis points. On 8.5 billion, that works out to a $22 million drop in interest income. Considering that $22.3 million hit, the net result isn't bad. Then, as I said at the start of this call, accretion came in somewhat lower, going from 17 to 13, so comparing Q2 with Q1 you felt some effect from that. Turning to average earning assets — those grew 2 billion, and the funding for that came mostly from a billion eight in non-interest bearing deposits, a business that keeps expanding. Clearly the programs brought extra inflow, but our DDAs have grown annually. So regarding what interest bearing deposits cost, as shown on the slide, we managed to lower that by 37 basis points, which helped cushion the LIBOR hit. That let us counter a sizable portion of it, which is a good thing. If you consider the entry point into Q3 on a spot basis, interest bearing deposit costs were 61 basis points while the quarterly average stood at 72 — that gives you an 11 basis point head start as you enter Q3, and there are still buckets of deposits we've identified and are examining, and we keep expecting to push those rates lower still. So more effect is certainly coming. On the asset side, I'd note LIBOR sits at 18 basis points. It had fallen to 16 basis points. That's a couple. So I'll accept a couple of basis points, though I don't see anything out of the ordinary carrying into Q3 from Q2 apart from mix — the mix of loans you originate. Nothing much past that, and spreads have stayed fairly steady over recent months.
Jared Shaw
analystHey everyone, Jared speaking. I've got one question, I suppose, regarding the reserve build. Concerning that $17 million of additional build stemming from the macro forecasts — Gary, is that simply running the model using the macro assumptions you described, with the result just coming through, or do qualitative overlays and some of those other items you mentioned play a role, offsetting what the model would otherwise produce for the macroeconomic expectation on the reserve?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveNo, Jared, it would incorporate some overlays in our standard modeling approach. So overlays and qualitatives are part of it.
Jared Shaw
analystAlright. So, in the event that the macro model worsens during Q3, ought we to think there might be further overlays that could counterbalance the straightforward effect of that shift, or is that not a given?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThis will stay in flux. What the forward view will look like at that moment is something I'm unable to predict. Given where things stand right now, we're pleased with how our portfolio is positioned. We'll keep watching it and steer it as the macroeconomic backdrop evolves down the road.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right. Vince, during your remarks earlier, you brought up the idea of looking at business opportunities, and moving ahead, could you share a bit more detail on what that might involve?
Vince Delie
executiveSure. What I'd say is that particular pockets exist, and here's one illustration: we recently closed on a rather sizable credit in the REIT — hard as it may be to believe, the borrower is a developer whose tenants are 99% occupied, a $25 million transaction where an insurance company wanted out of its retail exposure, and the loan to value stands at 55%, while debt service coverage comes in at 2.2x or higher. So deals of that kind are available for you to pursue. The tenant roster is mostly composed of big investment grade banks. Our parcel on the property holds four banks. And a grocery store is included that has a very <<inaudible>> long-term lease. What I mean is, every one of these leases runs long-term. There are chances to conduct business. What I mean is, we simply must be unbelievably picky regarding what we pursue; also, we recently secured a sizable credit facility for an AA-rated higher education institution. So activity continues to happen, with billions of dollars in reserves; so we simply must monitor our actions closely. And I'm aware that our people are highly attuned to the right opportunities to pursue; we possess the capital and liquidity to keep moving ahead, and the cautious character of our underwriting places us today in a position to keep operating, and that's what we've stated from the start. That's how our business model works. We aren't as showy when times are expanding but rather steady when the downturn arrives. And I believe that produces stability for lending from where we sit and keeps business activities going. So, let me tell you about our employees <<inaudible>> I delivered prepared comments, but these individuals have put in endless hours throughout the PPP program, handling the credit risk, and I could keep going and going and going. What I mean is, I'm incredibly impressed by everything they've managed to accomplish. And regarding our pipeline, when you examine our production for the last quarter, it was quite similar to the prior quarter, the post-COVID quarter we were measuring against. So once more, they aren't merely parked at home, which was my fear might occur. They're putting in tremendous effort. I tip my hat to our employees, who are passionate about their customers, who care, and who are extremely eager to guarantee we make it through this and make it through it soundly. So plenty of activity is happening.
Jared Shaw
analystSo going forward, that's what we ought to be modeling, not bank M&A — right?
Vince Calabrese
executiveAs of now, over the past three years, we've made clear that our attention hasn't been there, and I don't believe now is the right moment to turn our attention there. As a nation, we've got to fix our economic situation, and we need a clearer sense of what lies ahead. A great deal of uncertainty exists going forward; yet one thing I have no doubt about is how good our people are and our capacity to steer through it; we demonstrated that previously, during the last crisis it was this same management team. And a lot of the bankers are unchanged too. So I have a lot of confidence that we'll come out of this, and once we're on the far side, we'll be well positioned to choose our next move — possibly M&A, after we've gotten through this, that's a real option for us, considering how strong the company is. So as things stand today, I think we'll use that option further down the line. Another point I want to raise, Jared: we're opening our PPP program to non-clients in our newer markets, since we believed some of the bigger institutions couldn't deliver. During PPP's first round, our staff originated $2.1 billion. Of the applications we took in, we managed to convert 83% and fund 83%. At most of the large banks, that figure was in the low 20s or 30% range. So we gained a lot of clients, or prospects who have since become clients, which will create future opportunities for our bankers, since these companies now count us as part of their capital structure. So once we get past this, I'm optimistic on that front too. We now have relationships with no fewer than 2,000 middle market prospects; so we'll watch how it all unfolds further down the line, but our employees executed very well, and that's why we're where we are.
Russell Gunther
analystAs a quick follow-up to what we discussed about deferrals before — my takeaway is that you're taking a comprehensive lens on this exposure, meaning that 98% which was current and in good standing when the pandemic hit. That said, do you view those borrowers as riskier because they're presently in a forbearance program, and if that's the case, has it been factored into the reserve as it stands?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes, that's correct. Russell, when the pandemic arrived and the economy got hit along with every shock felt by everyone in the business community, a large share of those borrowers chose to be careful. A number of them pulled on their lines. Line draws rose to roughly 46%, 47%. They were after liquidity; they sought deferral, and more than 75% of our commercial deferrals opted to keep paying interest rather than defer it. So they made those interest payments by their own choice. The industries under more pressure went with C&I deferrals, as we've discussed. Those books are fairly small. Hotels and restaurants have taken a heavy hit. Given the volatility — opening, reopening, shutting down again — and uncertainty over what lies ahead, I'd anticipate clients in those sectors seeking a second round of deferral options. With all that said, deferrals within the restaurant segment have been surprisingly low, and I believe the figure is around 32%, which caught us off guard by not being larger. So risk ratings have been addressed. They are still being addressed. Further requests will lead to additional downgrades, and in our view we currently hold the right risk classifications for the credits throughout the portfolio.
Russell Gunther
analystThanks for that, Gary. Also, sorry if this was covered already, but was there any disclosure from you folks regarding the levels of criticized and classified assets for this quarter? I don't think I came across it in the release.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThat wasn't included, though I'm certain it will appear in the Q.
Russell Gunther
analystCould you just speak directionally to whether there's meaningful migration happening?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThey've risen modestly.
Russell Gunther
analystAlright. Thank you, Gary. And then, regarding when charge-offs might occur, regardless of how big they are, there are clearly plenty of unknowns around stimulus and forbearance. But I suppose I'm asking about your own expectations on the timing side — specifically, when might we start to observe charge-offs climbing, given that you still posted quite a strong first half of the year?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYeah. Russell, I can tell you that this effect is going to show up during Q4 and carrying into 2021. There could be a slight effect toward the end of Q3, but my own expectation would be Q4 and carrying into 2021.
Russell Gunther
analystAll right. Thanks, Gary. And the final question from me, folks. You gave us a few general parameters regarding the PPNR outlook for Q3, plus you narrowed the expense guidance range for us. So, we're grateful for that. Still, in an effort to connect everything, do you believe you can hold PPNR at this level quarter over quarter, given the pluses and minuses in that PPNR outlook?
Vince Calabrese
executiveRussell, I believe we've handed you every driver, correct? So, I think that means laying out the pieces in motion. Take net interest income as an example — walk through a few of those components. One-month LIBOR stands at 18 basis points as of today. Its second-quarter average was 36. If you reduce that to a range of 5 billion to 8.5 billion, that works out to roughly 3.8 million per quarter in net interest income, purely from the LIBOR change, all right? Then there's purchase accounting — I noted $13 million — I'd still anticipate a solid figure in Q3, likely somewhat under that, yet still a decent level, and I'd expect it to remain in double digits at minimum. So that's one component of net interest income. Next, the PPP loans — you'll have the entire $2.5 billion. Those add to net interest income and add to margin. The longer they stay funded with DDA, so. And as I said before, we'll keep bringing down the cost of interest bearing deposits. So that obviously delivers a favorable effect. But on balance, net interest income, I'd anticipate a slight decline. Fee income ought to remain quite strong. The guidance, as I noted, we'd anticipate service charges rebounding, and they'd been declining in that 40% to 50% year-over-year range for transaction volumes, and now that's more like 20% to 25%. So I'd anticipate that component, non-interest income, rising somewhat. I mean, mortgage at $16 million, $17 million is an all-time high. I wouldn't anticipate it staying that strong, but I'd certainly anticipate it remaining in double digits, and we'll see plenty of pipelines high, with lots of activity still going on. This is a busy stretch for that business. Then the capital markets piece — that figure, we've posted a few new records in succession. I'd anticipate it being very strong once more in Q3. I can't forecast another record, but I expect it to be very strong relative to what's baked in. Also, regarding the other main segments that declined—the wealth and insurance operations—my expectation is that they'll recover somewhat. So overall, non-interest income will mirror all of those factors. Again, many elements are in motion there. As for service charges, we'll just have to wait and see how things develop. The latest uptick in transaction activity remains below prior levels, though the gap has narrowed, which should provide some support. Turning to costs, you're aware that our company keeps a tight rein on spending, just as we've always done. On an operating core basis, expenses have stayed extremely level. That, I believe, should be a positive factor overall. As for where PPNR ultimately lands, we'll find out, but my expectation remains that it will be quite robust. Looking at the first six months, at $236 million year-to-date, we clearly anticipate another very solid showing in the third quarter. So I realize I'm not providing a figure, but I'm attempting to lay out all the various drivers and help you understand what we're observing and what the outlook looks like from our vantage point right now. Let me return to what Casey asked earlier: the total risk-based capital estimate comes to roughly 11.9. I believe a slide in here shows last quarter at 11.6; it stood at 11.8 when the year ended, and 11.6 at the close of March. So the projected figure is 11.9 for our position at the end of June.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThere was growth in tangible book value per share, correct? <<inaudible>> an increase during the quarter.
Collyn Gilbert
analystStarting off quickly with you, Vince Calabrese, I have a question about how PPP affected things. Regarding the interest income piece during 2Q that came from PPP, my rough math puts it at about 16 million. Could you confirm that figure? And on the PPP side as well, what was the benefit to OpEx? You hinted at it, but I mean the deferred loan origination cost tied to PPP loans, again during the second quarter.
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure. On that 1.09 billion, total interest income for the quarter came to roughly $15 million. That works out to a 3.15 yield, and you'll arrive at those two components, the 1.09 billion, and then as I mentioned, the $2.5 billion on average, we would have some sort of — no forgiveness as of yet in the third quarter. And that 3.15 figure includes accretion from the portion of fees I brought up earlier. Then the FAS 91 deferred origination costs rose 3.7 million going from the first quarter into the second quarter, and the reason for that is — PPP is clearly the largest factor there; so that provides a bit of help on the expense side, and then that sort of lands in — your accretion arrives net of that, which is the yield adjustment across the remaining life plus the fees, but clearly there's a net positive since fees exceed cost. So that was the delta for the quarter, around 3.7.
Collyn Gilbert
analystAll right, that's useful. And finally, Gary, thanks for the detail on a few of those credit actions, particularly the retail CRE. I'm just wondering whether you might share something similar, perhaps comparable credit figures for the hotel portfolio. Sure, it's a modest share of the total book, I realize that, 1.5% or thereabouts. But when I look at the reserve against it, which stands at 1.56, where exactly do you feel at ease — what is it about that book that makes you confident that reserve level is appropriate?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes; regarding that portfolio, Collyn, if you examine how it has performed, a sizable portion of it — above $100 million, or roughly 40% or more — consists of what I'd describe as our handful of anchor clients in that segment. We've never operated as a hotel lender except for a select group of highly seasoned, well-capitalized hotel operators with long track records who have accumulated substantial capital. So a meaningful part of that business is extremely solid. Most of what remains originated through acquisitions. As you may remember, following those acquisitions the portfolio climbed beyond $530 million to $550 million. We've brought it down to $350 million. We haven't extended credit in this area for more than four years now. Delinquency in that book — obviously, certain of the weaker, smaller hotels, and by that I mean small mom-and-pop operations that came to us through acquisitions, received brief support from government stimulus and deferral programs. Even so, delinquency sits at 15 basis points, and we've genuinely reduced risk in that portfolio over recent years, as I noted. Will it absorb some losses? Certainly. We recognize that, and we'll resolve what we can together with our clients, and we'll likely see some rise in non-accrual assets within that book too. I definitely anticipate that going forward. That said, on the whole, I'm comfortable with where it stands, we've shed the higher-risk assets and we'll need to handle a few. I hope that gives you a bit of insight.
Brody Preston
analystJust a fast one. Can you walk me through the reason that $77 million PCD discount is excluded from the reserve after CECL?
Vince Delie
executiveRegarding the loan portfolio's discount. When you work through CECL accounting, acquired loans come into the loan balance at gross, and the discount simply gets accreted in — that's how the accounting rules function. It essentially operates on the marks remaining on the acquired loan before CECL. You'd retained gains, or leftover marks, sitting there since you weren't able to recognize them in income until the pool was eliminated or nearly eliminated.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveIt was stranded capital.
Vince Delie
executiveStranded there, right.
Brody Preston
analystOkay, got it, I appreciate that. That 1.54 reserve ratio excluding PPP — CECL is meant to cover losses expected over a lifetime. So I'm not sure whether you could help us understand what that roughly suggests in your modeling regarding, I suppose, the near-term high point for NPAs?
Vince Delie
executiveWhen it comes to how high NPAs might go, Brody, I won't just throw out guesses here. That's a tough thing to predict. There's just so much uncertainty out there right now, when you consider where all of this is headed. Honestly, I doubt any of us truly has the answer. Looking at the economy as it stands now and its direction, what I'd say is that you will see NPAs rise as we move through this period throughout the industry. But as for naming some peak figure, I'm not comfortable putting one out there.
Brody Preston
analystAll right, okay. Then I suppose we could shift over to PPP. Considering what it costs to service those PPP loans, plus the fact that forgiveness takes a longer stretch to work through — has your team thought about offloading these loans to a third party, the way a few smaller banks have done?
Vince Calabrese
executiveWell, we have gotten calls about that, and those potential buyers are looking to essentially capture all the income without paying for it. So that simply doesn't pencil out. We've examined it. In our view, holding it on the balance sheet makes more sense, particularly given the price points being discussed.
Vince Delie
executiveGetting it started was the toughest piece. Once you've done that, though, my feeling is that having it will pay off for us. To begin with, our clients benefited, and they've shown a lot of gratitude. It strengthens their loyalty. Selling it now, in my view, wouldn't be received well; and beyond that, we managed to create an automated workflow that kept things highly efficient. Only a handful of banks possessed a fully digital process from start to finish; we brought bankers in at various stages. 1000 bankers were in touch with clients, yet the process they used was completely digital and paperless for onboarding. The same pattern will play out for us with forgiveness; we put a great deal of internal investment into the resources needed to pull that off; that sets our company apart, and we'll have a very polished online system that guides the client through forgiveness one step at a time and lets them upload documents in digital form; as a result, we can handle it somewhat more efficiently. A smaller bank could find it hard. They would likely need to farm out parts of it, or perhaps the whole thing. At that stage, they might want to escape the weight of working through those loans. Keep in mind that for most smaller banks, this represented a bigger share of their overall assets. On our end, it's a sizable portfolio that we're able to handle using the resources at our disposal. On top of that, I noted that thousands of people who weren't customers, whom our bankers had been pursuing and who got in touch saying hey, my PPP loans are stuck at my big bank, would you be open to handling them for us, now have relationships with us. We said yes to those requests. There's one more thing I should add that I left out. I brought it up in my prepared remarks. Our people contacted 100 community groups and non-profits serving low to moderate-income communities throughout our footprint. This happened before it turned into a hot issue, and we managed to originate $0.5 billion in PPP loans in those low to moderate income and rural communities, where keeping jobs matters so much. So what we accomplished made me quite proud, and I believe we did an excellent job underwriting them, making sure the borrowers on the other side are solid, and we'll see it through; that's how we approach it, our broader philosophy.
Brody Preston
analystTurning back to the margin and liquidity — you saw a fairly large jump in cash, around $370 million. I just wanted to get a sense of how much of that came from PPP, if any? And then, what should we expect for cash balances going forward?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah. The deposits that came in, which were greater than the loans, and the loan-to-deposit ratio dropping to 92%, basically accounts for all of it. Like Vince said in his comments, we shifted from overnight borrowings to putting a few hundred million to work, as he noted, and that really isn't sitting on our balance sheet, and as things stand right now that's basically at zero. So once deposits eventually get put to use, that figure will move up and down accordingly. And in the interim, PPP plays such a major role in these numbers. We keep bringing on new relationships and new talent and winning business. And like Vince said, 25% of the PPP customers had been prospects. They weren't customers before, so that's a group of clients we're going to be actively and —
Vince Delie
executiveAdditionally, they establish accounts with the institution since funding for the loan was required; a portion simply transferred extra deposits or broadened their ties. Consequently, if you examine—we genuinely monitored the PPP disbursements, and we've implemented a mechanism, though it's not completely precise, which we created during origination to observe money movement and transfer patterns—what we've observed is growth in the count of accounts within that customer group. Thus, in some cases, deposit amounts surpass the total PPP loan provided; that has benefited us. I mean, examining deposits as a whole, our increase is significantly above the PPP totals, and a number of those funds were redirected to settle pre-existing obligations. So from a deposit standpoint, things appear quite favorable. I mean, I feel quite confident regarding our funding foundation and our capacity to attract households.
Vince Calabrese
executiveOur teams are working to expand those relationships to Vince's point.
Vince Delie
executivePlus, this happened while a pandemic was going on. So, taking into account social and civil unrest, and as I mentioned, our team has performed amazingly well. I couldn't feel more proud.
William Wallace
analystJust one brief question about modeling. Regarding the PPP, under the current written rules, how much of the loan volume do you expect to be forgiven?
Vince Calabrese
executiveOverall, my belief is that most of it gets forgiven. It should land somewhere in the 90s, though we can't say for sure. As Vince noted, there's discussion of automatic forgiveness for loans under 150,000. Whether that comes to pass, I don't know. That would clear things out. Our average, I believe, was...
Vince Delie
executiveIt was <<inaudible>>.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThe average is $129,000.
Vince Delie
executiveI'd say as well that our performance was fairly solid. Once clients were brought in, we had a chance to guide them through what the forgiveness requirements would involve. And from what I can tell, our team, given the requirements on our end, there was a lender certification we mandated, meaning they had to confirm specific details and hold conversations; that's the reason we had 1000 bankers, drawn from various business lines, engaged with the client. That should support the forgiveness process, and it should help us reach a greater share of forgiveness.
Vince Calabrese
executiveSo Willy, to go back over what I mentioned before, the way we see it at the moment, what we're projecting comes straight from that forms figure — 15% during Q4, then 75% of all forgiveness wrapped up by the close of March, and 90% by the time June ends, which is roughly the minimum we have in mind.
William Wallace
analystAll right, thank you so much. Then here's a broad question for you, Vince D; during your prepared comments you cited certain figures indicating a fairly substantial rise in how much your customer base uses the digital network. Over the years you folks had been quite diligent and thoughtful regarding your branch network, and you've gradually been consolidating it. What I'm curious about is whether this greater digital network utilization alters how you'd think about choices involving the branch network — if you wouldn't mind addressing that, and I'll drop off.
Vince Delie
executiveYeah. I'm grateful for that question. That's an excellent question. I believe that clearly, under current circumstances, there's been, shall we say, a faster educational journey for clients. Adoption across those digital channels rose enormously for us. Our focus has always been the client interface; we've always held the view that, since our budget isn't unlimited, what we could control was how simple it is for a consumer to engage with us, and that's genuinely where our attention went — the interface. I think our people did a remarkable job on our Web site. If you haven't visited it, I'd suggest going on and having a look at our Web site. It's built so that buying products and services or viewing educational content is very easy and intuitive. Being able to offer that is going to shift things — the educational journey that happened because of COVID-19 will definitely drive users toward that platform. We had a process. We shut many branches — I mean we consolidated; I don't even recall the figures, but broadly 15 to 20 each year across the last five years have been consolidated, partly via M&A, partly opportunistically given shifting client preferences. My expectation is that this will keep going, yet I'll say that during this whole period a number of clients wrote me a letter, emailed me, halted me on the street and inquired: when will your lobbies be open? Small business customers still prefer visiting the branch, and they want to head there and make their deposits at the branch, since in many cases they continue using cash; coin and currency, and they must come in. When clients face problems, they like to drop in. So I think it's going to be — an article just ran in the S&P, it showcased our concept branch. My view is there will be fewer branches. How the branch is designed and how we present content on products and services will shift, yet a need will always exist. There may be fewer of them. And we'll keep examining that in order to drive efficiency. Basically, we decided to put money into the front-end system, and into being able to deliver products and services in a full, well-rounded way — with attention on the interface, plus making certain our branches, or the branch system, are tuned and set up properly so they can handle conversations and the content. That direction, as I view it, will keep going, and it's going to give us a chance to run things with greater efficiency down the road. In any case, that's —
Brian Martin
analystHi, everyone. Nearly everything I wanted to ask has already been covered. Only a few small items remain. Vince, regarding what you mentioned about service charge income, I realize it fell this quarter, but you anticipated some recovery. If I recall, you noted a drop of roughly 40%, and now it's just 20% lower — is that the right way to view it?
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat's right, Brian.
Brian Martin
analystAlright, I just wanted to confirm I understood that correctly. Then regarding the accretion figure, I suppose the question is what period we ought to consider for getting back that remaining roughly $77 million, Vince — taking into account some of the dropdown during this quarter, would most of it be realized by maybe the close of next year, or is that a fair way to look at it?
Vince Calabrese
executiveI'd say the large majority would be, over roughly a span of two years, 2 to 3 years. Probably that's a reasonable way to put it. By the time next year wraps up, my thinking is you'd see the bulk of it flowing through. It really depends on prepayments, correct — so if more loans get prepaid or move into various refined government programs or similar, then more of that would arrive. Still, a two to three year sort of window, Brian, is probably reasonable.
Brian Martin
analystAll right. Then the final item from my side, folks. Regarding how PPP affected margin, I suppose for this quarter, I suppose broadly speaking, I suppose what's your take on that?
Vince Calabrese
executiveWell, truthfully it boosts the margin. I mean, assuming you examine — I brought up the yield being 3.15, with funding through essentially deposits at 3 basis points; therefore our spread comes to roughly 3.12. When you calculate it, that contributes 10 to 15 basis points. I'd say the margins over that brief stretch. So it will depend on how long those stick around in terms of them flowing through and how long we haven't funded with demand deposits, correct? So eventually the customers will begin drawing on those funds, and after that your mix of funding sources will shift, but what I can state with certainty is what happened in the second quarter and it was a 3.12 spread, which as you can observe, when you calculate it, clearly boosts the margin we reported. Thank you.
Vince Delie
executiveAlright, I want to express my gratitude to all of you for those questions, and I genuinely value the time you have dedicated to being with us and your interest in FNB. Please remain safe, and we are eager to get together with you again in the next quarter. Take care.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings the conference to a close. We appreciate your joining today's presentation. Minato central lines
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.