F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 20, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lisa Constantine
executiveThanks. Morning everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call. This conference call from F.N.B. Corporation, along with the reports it submits to the Securities and Exchange Commission, frequently includes forward-looking statements and non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP financial measures ought to be considered alongside our reported results prepared under GAAP, not as a substitute for them. You can find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, comparing them to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures, in our presentation materials as well as our earnings release. Please take a look at these non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures in our related materials, reports, and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are accessible on our website. A replay will be offered until Thursday, January 27, and the webcast replay is going to be posted in the About Us, Investor Relations section of our corporate website. At this point I'll hand the call over to Vincent Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the call for our fourth-quarter results. With me here today are Vincent Calabrese, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer, and Gary Guerrieri, our Chief Credit Officer. For the fourth quarter, FNB reported earnings per share of $0.30, which lifted our total for the full year to $1.23 — the best EPS figure we've posted since the company was restructured back in 2004. Beyond that strong EPS result, the fourth quarter stood out for vigorous loan growth, the debut of the Noble eStore, and the digital introduction of our improved physicians first program. That full service offering is aimed at meeting both the personal and commercial needs of physicians, dentists and veterinarians. Let's walk through all of these wins, and we'll start with the increase in loans. If you strip out PPP forgiveness, spot loan growth came in at $610 million, which works out to 10% annualized, versus the third quarter of 2021. That strong lending expansion supported a 13% annualized quarter-over-quarter gain in net interest income, leaving out PPP and purchase accounting accretion, and it provides significant momentum as we head into 2022 earnings; beyond reaching the initial full year loan growth guidance we gave last January, we have now posted 3 straight quarters of solid loan growth, which amounts to a $1.3 billion year-over-year increase, or 6% excluding PPP, relative to the December 31, 2020 balance. For the quarter, commercial loans expanded at a 10.6% annualized pace. Strong production across our footprint drove that result, demonstrating what our strategy of geographic diversification is worth. Thanks to this organic growth in loans, total assets reached $40 billion at year end, and once the Howard Bank acquisition closes in a couple of days, the balance sheet will be roughly $42 billion on a pro forma basis. In early November, we added our eStore shopping tool to the FNB mobile app, part of a set of innovative upgrades that expand what customers can do when banking digitally. We also completed a successful overhaul of our mobile banking platform, introducing additional capabilities and broadening the range of loan applications available online — covering FNB credit cards, mortgage products, home equity line credit, home equity installment loans and small business loans. Through this platform, a digital-only bank has been established, allowing customers to handle everyday transactions, buy products and services, and set up virtual appointments with our bankers. S&P Global Market Intelligence recently gave our comprehensive mobile offering recognition, describing FNB Direct as among the most competitive mobile banking apps in the industry. According to their analysis, our mobile app offers more features than any of our peers and matches what JPMorgan and Bank of America provide. Beyond that, our digital approach and our clicks-to-bricks model earned recognition as the best in their class, and we took home a prestigious national honor for what our mobile banking offers. We also brought the eStore into the fold, and refreshed our mobile app with a cleaner, more modern layout plus quick paths to the features customers reach for most — richer payment options, tools for shopping and opening accounts, and chat on mobile. Customers responded positively to that refresh, which shows up in an app store score of 4.8 stars, a figure that leads the industry. We continue to bring more products and services onto our digital platform, which lets us serve customers better and expand our market share by attracting them through an approach that is both scalable and efficient. Not long ago, we introduced an upgraded, all-digital version of the program we call physicians first, now available through our newly launched store. This broad collection of offerings, all accessible online, was built to serve the particular requirements of doctors, dentists, veterinarians and various other healthcare professionals, and it spans commercial lending, deposit offerings, consumer credit and wealth management. Our footprint is home to over 250,000 physicians, dentists and veterinarians, and on top of that, more than $4 billion in fresh medical student debt arises every year, so the opportunity before us to improve financial results for people employed in healthcare is massive. Over the past year, our physician loans grew 68%, even as we invested in staff and product development. Because of the momentum our current program has, along with what we've invested in our digital capabilities, there's a major opportunity to deepen relationships we already have and bring in new customers in the health care industry. Finally, I wanted to mention the Howard Bank acquisition. We are down to the final days before we close on January 22 and complete the systems integration on February 5. We've collaborated closely with the Howard team and anticipate a smooth transition. Howard's talented employees have really impressed us, and we're keeping more frontline employees than we initially anticipated. In fact, retention overall across our footprint has been strong, and we're eager for them to become part of FNB in this dynamic market. Things are progressing nicely with the acquisition, and we're still on schedule to achieve the cost savings we outlined back in July. Our asset quality has outperformed what we originally expected. Just like we've done with earlier acquisitions, we'll introduce our broader product lineup to the newly acquired customers, which should drive additional noninterest income growth in both Baltimore and Washington, D.C. Both the one-time expenses and the credit mark, day 2 included, ought to land better than our original projections. At this point, I'll pass things to Gary, who will walk through our overall credit quality. Gary?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThanks, Vince, and hello, everyone. We wrapped up the year with ongoing favorable results throughout every one of our portfolios as we finished another prosperous year and came into 2022 from a place of strength. In the quarter, credit quality improved further, with delinquency and NPLs dropping, as did the amount of our rated credits. On top of that, both our fourth quarter and full year net charge-offs have hit levels that are historically low. Let's go over a few of the highlights now, then a quick update regarding the pending Howard Bank acquisition, and finally some closing thoughts about what we expect in 2022. Delinquency levels, once PPP balances are excluded, finished December at a very solid 62 basis points, which is better by 9 bps on a linked-quarter basis. NPLs and OREO likewise got better in the period, finishing December at 39 basis points, a drop of 10 basis points versus the prior quarter, with lower nonaccrual levels of $22 million fueling that improvement. Looking year over year, our nonaccruals have fallen almost 50% against December 2020, which equals an $82 million reduction. This mostly mirrors steps we took late in 2020 to put our loan portfolio in a better spot for the year to come, when we proactively removed risk during a difficult macroeconomic backdrop. Net charge-offs in the quarter came in very low at $1.4 million, or 2 basis points annualized, while net charge-offs for the full year 2021 added up to $14 million and registered a solid 6 basis points, a level that is historically low. We booked the $2.3 million net benefit in the provision in the quarter after continued strengthening in our credit quality position and the earlier 2020 moves to position the portfolio, plus a broad improvement in economic factors that helped our forecast models; this left us with a GAAP reserve position that fell 3 basis points to 1.38%, while the x PPP reserve dropped 5 bps to 1.4%, still directionally in line with our credit results. Our NPL coverage position improved further, finishing December at a very solid 392%, following the reductions just noted in NPLs and rated credits during the quarter. Our total ending reserve position, including acquired unamortized discounts, comes to 1.5%. Now I'd like to give you a few quick updates on the pending Howard acquisition. Since the announcement, our credit teams have been closely tracking and monitoring the Howard portfolio, which is our usual practice. Right now, we continue to be pleased with the credit performance and the anticipated day 1 positioning of this book, which is doing better than we first expected. After close, we don't anticipate any effect on our loan risk profile or credit quality performance, since the Howard book stays well diversified and will barely affect our credit concentrations. Wrapping up yet one more strong year, one characterized by ongoing favorable credit performance, we feel quite good about where our portfolio stands as we head into 2022. Given the worldwide difficulties and unpredictable economic landscape we encountered during 2020, taking initiative on risk management along with regular evaluation of our credit portfolio let us place ourselves advantageously going into 2021 — clear evidence of how carefully and consistently we handle our credit book. We stay watchful and focused on any risks that may arise, whether in the wider economy or in the markets where we and our customers do business. As macro conditions keep shifting — things like economic circumstances, inflationary pressure and the changing character of the virus — we will keep overseeing our book through this extremely competitive setting, with our fundamental credit principles at the forefront. This bedrock of sound, steady underwriting, risk oversight and prudent choosing of top-quality lending possibilities keeps powering our growth aims as we anticipate further business chances in 2022. At this point I'll hand the call to Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, to share his comments.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks, Gary. Turning to our financial results, over the last twelve months we turned in an outstanding performance, beating what we had projected for the entire year on both the bottom line and a pre-provision net revenue basis. We posted mid-single-digit loan growth; leaving out PPP, that came to 5.7% growth year-over-year on a spot basis. We came in above our revenue projections for the whole year, posting a record $1.23 billion, powered by our ongoing strategic emphasis on a diversified contribution from fee income. Operating expenses stayed well controlled, and operating pre-provision net revenue, or PPNR, finished the year at $508 million. Given our strong credit quality trends and better economic conditions, our provision for loan losses came in at essentially 0 and $0.6 million for the full year. By successfully executing our strategies, we managed to raise our operating net income available to common stockholders by 27%, to $400 million, or $1.24 per share. Let's go through the fourth quarter financials, beginning with the highlights on Slide 5. Fourth quarter operating EPS came to $0.30, which is an increase of $0.02 from the year ago quarter. Tangible book value per share rose 9% year-over-year, to $8.59. Leaving out PPP, which better reflects underlying loan growth, period-end total loans rose $610 million, or 10.1% annualized on a linked-quarter basis, including growth of $421 million in commercial loans and $188 million in consumer loans. Commercial loan production hit a record $1.5 billion, diversified across our geographic footprint. Line of credit utilization rose for the third consecutive quarter, to 35.8%, which is below the prepandemic level of 40% to 45%. Consumer lending had its second highest production quarter, and we also saw record linked quarter growth for small business loans. Let's move on to the balance sheet on Slide 7. Average earning assets now sit above $35 billion, and securities rose 4.8% linked-quarter because of pre-investing for the upcoming Howard acquisition and putting excess cash to use, with spot cash balances down 15%. Reported average loans and leases stayed flat at $24.7 billion, with loan growth offset by a $620 million reduction in average PPP balances. Average deposits came to $31.7 billion, up 2.7% linked-quarter, with year-over-year growth in all 8 of our primary MSA markets. That growth keeps producing a favorable funding mix, as customers prefer low-cost savings accounts and keep higher checking account balances. We expect organic growth to continue, and as rates rise, we expect balance growth in lower beta deposit products to shift toward higher beta products. Turning to Slide 8. Net interest income came to $223.3 million, down $9.1 million, or 3.9%, from the prior quarter total of $232.4 million, reflecting a $15.4 million decreased contribution from PPP, given forgiveness activity, which was partially offset by an increase in average earning assets, a more favorable funding mix and lower deposit costs. Reported net interest margin fell 17 basis points, to 2.55%. Earnings on assets produced a yield that fell by 19 basis points, landing at 2.80%, which mirrors smaller PPP contributions along with a rise of $498 million, or 15.6%, in average cash balances. For the fourth quarter, the combined effect of PPP purchase accounting accretion and larger cash balances brought net interest margin down by 14 basis points, versus a 2 basis point gain during the earlier quarter. Once those items are set aside, net interest margin held steady, as a 3 basis point drop in the cost of funds canceled out diminished yields on variable rate loans. Turning now to noninterest income and expense: noninterest income came to $79 million. That figure dropped $9.9 million, or 11.1%, from the record set the previous quarter, yet our fee-based businesses keep delivering wide-ranging contributions. Capital markets income reached $9.5 million, aided by a healthy contribution from spot activity, loan syndications, debt capital markets and international banking; our capital markets team's performance has really impressed us, with international banking and loan syndication climbing 117% and 42%, respectively. Thanks to our recent build-out of debt capital markets capabilities, revenue tripled in the fourth quarter, and it has swiftly grown into yet another $1 million-plus revenue business for us. Service charges rose $0.7 million on seasonally stronger customer activity. Mortgage banking operations income fell $2.3 million, or 27.8%, because of a seasonal decline in the held-for-sale pipeline and weaker secondary market revenue. SBA volumes and average transaction sizes remain robust, with $2.1 million of premium income recorded in other noninterest income — the third quarter in a row above $2 million. Noninterest expense as reported was tightly managed, dropping $2.6 million, or 1.4%, from the prior quarter to $181.6 million. Driving that decrease were salaries and employee benefits, down $0.8 million, or 0.8%, largely tied to elevated production and performance-related commissions and incentives during the earlier quarter. Bank shares and franchise taxes fell $1.9 million, or 52.8%, after state tax credits were recognized in the fourth quarter of 2021. The efficiency ratio came in at 58.1% versus 55.4%, mirroring reduced PPP income and the drop in noninterest income from last quarter's record levels mentioned earlier. All in all, a robust quarter capped 2021 and leaves us positioned quite favorably for 2022; let's now go to 2022 guidance on Page 12. We anticipate that the loan growth momentum from 2021 will carry forward. Loans should rise somewhere between the low double digits and low teens, counting the Howard Bank acquisition benefit, with organic growth underneath landing in the mid- to high single digits on a year-over-year spot basis. This year, deposits gained from the PPP program and other government stimulus, which we anticipate will start to run off during 2022. Assuming that runoff is baked into our projections, deposits ought to expand mid- to high single digits on a spot basis, Howard included. Moving on to the income statement now, and this captures Howard Bank along with every assumption we've made; for net interest income, our expectation is a full-year figure somewhere in the range of $965 million to $1.005 billion, while the first quarter should land between $226 million and $230 million. Under the guidance we're using as a baseline, 2 rate hikes are baked in — one arriving in June, the second in September — though given how much interest rate futures have been swinging lately, we've kicked off some sensitivity analysis. For noninterest income, the projection across the whole year sits at $320 million to $340 million, and for the first quarter we're looking at the high $70 million to $80 million range. When it comes to noninterest expense on an operating basis, the expectation is $760 million to $780 million across the full year and $190 million to $195 million in the first quarter, reflecting typical seasonality plus what Howard adds. Those figures leave out the onetime costs tied to buying Howard Bank. We anticipate doing better than what we initially modeled. Credit quality should stay positive all through 2022, with the provision guided to $20 million to $40 million. That excludes the day 2 CECL provision related to Howard, and it's under $20 million in the first quarter, plus it hinges on how much net loan growth we see over the course of the year. And finally, for the full year the effective tax rate ought to fall between 17.5% to 18.5%. With that, I'll hand the call back over to Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveAppreciate it, Vince. FNB enjoyed a tremendous 2021, giving us plenty of wins to recognize. Let me walk through a handful of the key milestones. Our revenue hit an all-time high, which fueled robust earnings, with EPS reaching its peak level since the 2004 restructuring of the company. Loans, once you set aside PPP, rose $1.3 billion compared with the prior year, and total assets climbed to a record $40 billion. Fee income came in at a record above $330 million, a 12% rise versus the prior year, and it now makes up 27% of overall revenue. Our team delivered over $20 million in run rate cost savings, which completed the $60 million, 3-year target for total cost savings. With credit quality, liquidity and capital all strong, our company sits in a solid spot to carry out what we're offering in 2022. We upgraded our digital technologies so we can serve customers better, placing us at the industry's forefront, and we backed our communities in getting through the pandemic by facilitating $3.6 billion of PPP loans. We kept up our work extending loans and investment to low-to-moderate income communities as well, and earned an outstanding CRA rate. Thanks to our exceptional financial performance, we produced value for shareholders, with tangible book value up 9% versus the prior year and a 15% operating return on tangible common equity; on top of that, our company gave back roughly $200 million of capital via dividends and the share repurchase program. None of this happens without the commitment of our FNB employees, who stay focused on serving their clients and driving shareholder value daily. Navigating this past year was tough, yet our employees kept delivering exceptional performance. Looking ahead to 2022, we're well positioned thanks to our ongoing loan growth momentum, investments in differentiated technology, an asset-sensitive balance sheet, solid asset quality and improving capital flexibility. I'm eager to work alongside our employees in 2022, driving performance and superior return. With that, I'll hand the call to the operator for questions.
Mike Young
analystActually, I'd like to kick things off with something more strategic, and it's directed at Vince. Once digital banking rolls out — the app as well as the online marketplace — what does that change strategically for all of you? Will you be putting more marketing spend to work and attempting to capture share there? Or is what we should expect simply greater operational efficiency in the retail bank? How are you thinking about this, perhaps from both a strategic and a financial standpoint going forward?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, I'd say it brings — it genuinely brings something to each of those. I believe we can run more efficiently as we build out the digital work streams inside the company, since that factors into it too. What I mean is, the external — the piece facing customers matters because I think it genuinely allows us to scale considerably in markets that hold potential where our market share may not be top or our penetration may not be deep. So when it comes to having those digital channels — I think from the time our eStore launched, we essentially redid its format and brought it back out, then introduced a loan product. We began last year, and after that we brought in different loan products in phases. So consumer loans showed up online in August and September, and credit card arrived in January, while mortgages arrived in the — the mortgage product itself arrived in May. We've performed quite well when it comes to applications. What I mean is, we — across that stretch, we managed to originate close to 3,000 applications through the online channel for those loan products. And we're not even underway yet; no digital advertising has been done by us. We've barely done anything with media content or commercials, though that will ramp up. So the plan we had was to construct the interface and keep working to refine it, since the following phase here is building an omnichannel application. I've discussed this for quite a while — a place where customers come in and put together 1 application covering 5 or 6 products at once; that's on the way — before this year ends, we ought to have it essentially ready. Development work on it has been underway for a while. Meanwhile, we began standing up the different loan products. We had a complete suite of deposit products available. And incidentally, on deposits we've been at it quite a while, meaning a couple of years, and we accepted 20,000 applications in the deposit area last year. If you consider what's taken place — if you consider what's happening throughout the — actually, let me correct that, our website received 20,000 hits; they weren't really applications. Those were people who began interacting with the solutions center. After we made that specific eStore offering, or platform — whatever you'd like to call it — mobile-friendly, it surged 56%. So during December, across the entire month, we recorded 31,400 interactions that would be put to use for — not every one of them resulted in an application, but they began the process or review for content on products and services. What we're doing is taking that data, those interactions, and wherever we're able to recognize a customer who has self-identified, we can generate a lead and then send it back through our retail delivery channel and the commercial bank and the way we follow up on it. So that's roughly the strategy, but it has genuinely begun to gain traction, and I believe it's going to contribute to our capacity to grow loans. I believe it has contributed. I believe it has assisted us this year in particular categories, especially mortgage, with more than 60% of the applications during the year arriving via that channel. So in any case, that's — that's what has us excited, and I believe it will give us a terrific chance to squeeze out efficiency as we streamline the process of bringing these customers aboard and working out the digital work streams inside the company, removing a great deal of manual processes. And on the other side, it will assist us in scaling. And we have not advertised or invested much money in promoting that; we will. This year, we have a plan to do so. So it's baked into the expense guidance that Vince gave you.
Vince Calabrese
executiveOne more piece is that the nonbanking operations are also conducting their business via the digital bank — wealth, insurance, private banking. So opportunities exist in that area to make the most of the investments we have made really throughout the businesses.
Mike Young
analystAll right. I appreciate how you connected that to the financial guide. Perhaps I could ask a follow-up about the 2022 financial guidance, Vincent Calabrese. Just — when we consider rate hikes, you have to have incorporated some into what you estimate for the year, but supposing there were a third one, have you examined the sensitivity, whether in dollars or on a NIM basis, to what one additional rate hike beyond those you already assume would mean?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. Indeed we have. With things shifting so rapidly, we've run some sensitivity analysis covering various scenarios. So yes, we quantified it. Essentially, our ranges for 2022 would rise by roughly 3% should a rate hike occur in March. Therefore, putting 1 March alongside the June and September already included in the guidance produces a 3% increase to the range of $965 million to $1.005 billion.
Mike Young
analystAll right, that's very useful. And one final thing, if I can squeeze it in. Regarding Howard, you're extremely close to getting that deal done. Should we be factoring in any pro forma balance sheet moves that you plan to make, or that have already happened — maybe reducing its size and getting some kind of NIM boost, or anything along those lines, as we build our model?
Vince Calabrese
executiveFrom where we stand right now, Michael, the biggest piece would be their roughly $200 million of borrowings plus somewhere around $100 million of wholesale deposits — the borrowings we'd retire, and the wholesale deposits would gradually taper off throughout the year. Broadly speaking, that's the key initial step, and beyond that there's nothing like an exit portfolio on the loan side the way we did with certain transactions previously; credit quality there has been quite pleasing to us. So truly, just those 2 items as things look today.
Mike Young
analystThat's great.
Vince Calabrese
executiveMike, I should also point out that the steps I just referred to are factored into our guidance.
Frank Schiraldi
analystTo kick things off, I suppose I'd like to follow up on what was asked about rate hikes. As far as I know, you don't give us any figures on the deposit betas being applied. Still, I was curious whether you might shed some light on the way you project this over the initial handful — my assumption would be that deposit pricing barely budges at first and possibly rises later on. Do you simply apply a linear approach, can you tell us? Or is each one factored in separately?
Vince Calabrese
executiveI'd describe it as a process of modeling that's fairly dynamic. As things stand right now, my sense is that we'll absorb a few of the Fed's actions, and after that some effect on deposit rates begins to appear, and the way I'd frame it is that roughly 20% of the Fed's movement might show up in deposit rates by the time the year ends, then gradually shift toward something like the historical 40% to 50%; however, when it comes to '22, it's more around that 20% mark.
Frank Schiraldi
analystUnderstood. All right. So that's the assumption reflected in the outlook you've provided; and now regarding costs for the coming year. I'm curious whether you could address how much of a role inflation is playing in that. And I might have missed this, so I apologize if that's the case. I recall Vince mentioning the $20 million of cost savings that have been achieved across the last 3 years. I'm just curious whether there was anything comparable for this year and at the...
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah. I'd offer a few remarks on that. What I mean is, the story for Q4, as you're aware, landed in line with what we anticipated and consistent with the guidance we provided. Each line item on nonutilities essentially held steady versus the third quarter. Looking ahead to 2022, we've effectively included some degree of an inflation element within our noninterest expense forecast for the year. What I mean is it falls within the single — roughly mid-single digits, I'd put it, when viewed in terms of millions of dollars, yet that has been incorporated into the guidance we've given. And then the latter portion, Frank, what was that latter portion once more?
Frank Schiraldi
analystCost saves.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, on that cost save figure — like you mentioned, it came to $20 million annually across 3 years. During those 3 years, we've done a great deal of branch consolidation. So for this year, what we've voted on is $10 million altogether in cost saves, and that figure is included in the guidance as well. And one thing I should point out, I think it matters, is that if you consider it from the perspective of operating leverage, PPP is, as everyone knows, sort of working its way through, with a small tail remaining in the first half of the year. Yet when you examine how the company's underlying operations are performing, well, we posted positive operating leverage ex PPP in Q4. Then going into 2022, every quarter brings positive operating leverage, and we expect that to grow. And clearly, as rate moves arrive, that provides an additional boost. Still, per the guidance we've given, each quarter has positive operating leverage that builds across the year. So I wanted to mention that as well.
Timur Braziler
analystTimur Braziler here, covering for Jared. Loan growth has been really strong — that's 3 quarters in a row now. When we last talked, I believe you all felt great about how December was shaping up. So with such a solid December and such strong production, I'm wondering whether some of that got pulled forward out of the first quarter. Then, thinking about your '22 guidance, the mid- to high single digits — if the momentum we're seeing right now keeps up, might that turn out to be conservative? Or is there something else you expect in '22 that could slow that loan growth rate down somewhat?
Vince Delie
executiveYes. I'd say the guidance we provided is pretty consistent. Looking back at our historical growth path, it lines up fairly well with where we've grown in the past. So when we assess what the marketplace can offer, we obviously don't have certainty. We depend on pipeline economic data and input from the field. to figure out what we believe we can deliver. Historically, I'd say we've landed in the mid- to upper single-digit range, and really leaned toward the upper single-digit range, and with everything happening in the economy around stimulus — the economy is still experiencing stimulus effects — there's a chance we outperform, but we can't we must go by what we know today. And our pipelines are good. We don't typically discuss pipeline specifics, but I'd say it's pretty good broadly, especially in the South East and the Mid-Atlantic region; so we've been performing well there, and that's really benefited us — that expansion has been a help. The technology investment; certainly, if that begins to truly gain traction and adoption rises, we might see considerable growth in certain categories, with the consumer loan category gaining some growth in small business possibly; so that is — that might add to it. But our guidance, I believe, is rooted in the company's historical growth. And I think applying that guidance is reasonable. I also think you raised the first quarter. I'm not sure if you meant this year's first quarter, when we were softer, and then we had 3 strong orders in the back half of the year, or if you mean going into next year, this quarter.
Timur Braziler
analystYeah. What I was asking about was Q4 output — whether some of it had been moved up out of Q1 of '22.
Vince Delie
executiveNo. Since I used to be a commercial banker, I can't schedule this stuff, and I joke about it constantly — folks ask why these bankers can't predict the moment a deal will close. When a transaction closes isn't up to us. Countless variables are involved. Naturally, bankers are eager to get paid. And our incentive compensation plans are built around — they receive payment based on whatever they close in a given quarter. So a bit of a push-and-pull exists between clients and the corporate banker. Ultimately, though, the client has the upper hand, and an M&A deal slips. Anything imaginable can occur. They chose to postpone CapEx spending until the following year; and suddenly your incentive comp is gone, correct? You wind up shoved into March; so that's genuinely outside our control. I don't believe anyone — nothing motivates people to sandbag given how our plans are designed. So my guess is that the production flow is genuine and typical, and our personnel or how our personnel behave isn't affecting it.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, that's helpful context. Then perhaps this one's for Gary. When you look at the provision guidance for '22 against what you've said about asset quality expectations, sort of at the time the deal — when the Howard deal was announced today — might that turn out to be conservative, and likewise perhaps some portion of that day 2 allowance has been reversed out over the course of the year. I suppose maybe just walk through the puts and takes of additional reserve releases, stronger Howard performance, and then providing for incremental growth, and how that flows through to the provision in '22.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYeah. I think the key element there is that, more and more, it comes down to continued solid performance across the book of business we manage. And we do anticipate that continuing to track quite well; but the other key factor is the loan growth we're capable of delivering — that loan growth is truly what will drive that provision expense near that guide. So based on how robust that growth turns out to be, from that mid- to high single digit level, it could push it higher as we go forward. Speaking of Howard, we're quite pleased with how that portfolio has performed. And the day 1 credit mark along with the day 2 provision on that book are going to come in better than expected, as was mentioned earlier; so all in all, everything is heading in a good direction there; it's going to be driven by those factors as we make our way through the year.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right. If I may, one more question. When I look at the balance sheet, it appears that a portion of the shift away from cash and into securities happened late in the quarter. Vince, I believe you mentioned that the margin has some spring-loading as we head into the first quarter of '22. Could you walk through how that works, what was bought late in the quarter for the securities book, and how you see that affecting the margin?
Vince Calabrese
executiveCertainly. Yes. The slide mentions that the average cash balance rose from 3.2 to 3.7 during the fourth quarter; on a spot basis, it dropped by $0.5 billion. So we closed the year at $3 billion, and we will carry excess cash. When we consider what our '22 guidance assumes, we project that figure will decline by roughly half from now until year-end. Regarding the investment portfolio, we put a little more than $900 million into it during the fourth quarter, which is roughly twice the portfolio's cash flows. A significant share of that was preinvesting ahead of the Howard acquisition; therefore, on a net basis, the portfolio increased by $179 million. In the fourth quarter, our reinvestment rate was approximately $134 million. For comparison, in the third quarter it stood at $113 million. That is 21 basis points above the rate at which we were investing during the third quarter. Carrying that forward to this year, in the first quarter, during January, we have invested $300 million that we have put to work so far in January at $154 million. So that is another 21 basis points above where we stood in the fourth quarter. Also, it had a fairly low duration of 3.7; so when we look at the close of the quarter, there are many moving pieces with Howard coming in; we see securities at quarter-end at roughly $7 billion, $7.1 billion at the end of March, up from the $6.8 billion to $6.9 billion we essentially finished the year with.
Daniel Tamayo
analystSo, hopefully this wraps up the discussion on the NII guidance. You mentioned how excess cash plays a role, and you also mentioned how deposit pricing plays a role. I was just wondering about timing when it comes to any floors or similar items, specifically regarding the added benefit from more hikes as we move through this year and into the next one — how does the balance sheet stand for, say, the first hike compared with later hikes?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. What I'd say is that the floors we do have are actually quite low; we have $12.5 billion of loans indexed to what LIBOR order time, and under $400 million, roughly $350 million, carry floors on them at a present benefit of 63 basis points; so essentially, you get 2 Fed moves before that $356 million for the move, though that represents only a small piece of the overall portfolio. Just as a reminder, regarding the total portfolio, I mean, we had $9.9 billion in total loans at the end of the year tied to 1-month LIBOR, plus another $2.5 billion tied to products. So combining the 2, that's 50% of the loan portfolio tied to those short-term indices; and at the 4 levels, we didn't get the benefit on the way down. So that's part of why there's such a large balance there that kind of has to work back through.
Daniel Tamayo
analystAll right, that's great. Moving to the noninterest income side — clearly, mortgage banking is going to take a hit now that the refi cycle has wrapped up. That said, I'm curious how you view the remaining noninterest income base and what a rising rate backdrop might mean for those line items.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAs we've mentioned before, the money we put to work across the past few strategic planning cycles into these fee-based businesses has served us quite well, especially when rates were declining. Looking at each piece: service charge really just tracks customer activity, while the wealth management segment is up 16% year-over-year on trust and securities commission. So we expect that to keep delivering solid growth this year. The insurance business has been expanding at a healthy pace. Turning to cap markets — though it's off from a lifetime record of 12.5% in the third quarter, $9.5 million is still a very solid figure. We'll be looking for that to grow as we move ahead. What's also additive is that with Howard joining, the breadth of products and services we offer that they don't have comes into play. That gives us a chance to bring their client base a much wider array of products and services, capital markets and banking included. So we're really eager to have them join the company and to work with those customers; it's all factored in. In other words, the rate environment we laid out is built into our guidance. So it's all accounted for.
Vince Delie
executiveYeah. From a realistic standpoint, we'd anticipate a decline in mortgage banking fee income — those margins have tightened relative to that cycle's high point. Yet balancing that out, when rates are climbing, SBA gain on sale improves; that line of business is beginning to gain traction for us. Our debt capital markets platform, which Vince referenced and which we rolled out over the last year, has already brought in $1 million in revenue. So that's going to be a boost as we head into next year. Also, certain transactions will fall within this year — I said next year, though what I meant was 2022. There are deals we're already involved in, so we'll see some upside on the fee income side from those. On syndication, the pipeline remains fairly robust. That operation has expanded quite well throughout the footprint, and we're beginning to witness bigger opportunities across the Southeast and the Atlantic region, plus Pittsburgh and Cleveland and our established markets. Then, when we consider additional ways to expand fee income, especially in treasury management, rolling out products and services, and the Howard acquisition, we believe there are sufficient other businesses within our diversified model to counter the decreases that arise from economic conditions. That's roughly how we structured it; our hope is that this proves correct for us, and that we'll hit the guidance we've provided. There are numerous moving pieces. I apologize, Vince, I simply wanted to add...
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo, that's a really good point.
Vince Delie
executiveQuite a bit to make sure that we have that diversification.
Vince Calabrese
executiveRegarding the mortgage business, let me also mention that when we consider what our 2022 guidance contains, my expectation is that the level in the fourth quarter, roughly $6 million, is likely where a bottom appears. One reason I say this is that if you check what the market anticipates for mortgage applications, well, that figure has dropped 25% to 30%. For our company, though, purchased loans make up 75% of what we do. And on the purchase side, expectations — at least those from Fannie Mae — showed an increase of 8% to 10%. So given the business model we operate in mortgage and with 75% coming from purchase activity, that seems promising. Consequently, assuming nothing else changes, I would anticipate that number building from this point as 2022 progresses, and our guidance reflects that as well.
Michael Perito
analystI've already gotten answers to the majority of what I wanted to ask, so just 2 fast ones. First, regarding growth in loans. Clearly, looking back across the past few quarters, the advantage of a diversified platform is plain to see. Yet CRE expansion has come in somewhat slower. Apologies if I missed commentary on that, but I was simply wondering, when you consider the diversity of the pipeline as we head into next year, any views on where that mid- to high single-digit core growth is going to originate? Will the mix resemble what we saw in the back half of this year? Or do you believe there's room for, or perhaps additional buckets that could add more, given the pipeline?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, in CRE there's been quite a bit of activity, I'd say. I've personally been part of conversations with a number of borrowers. So we're still evaluating some projects that are fairly sizable, and we had certain projects we closed that will fund over the next year or so. That business unit, I'd anticipate, will contribute a bit more next year. Overall, though, when we examine our pipelines, the Carolinas continue to have a very strong pipeline. Charleston, I think, has been terrific for us. Raleigh and Charlotte both delivered solid growth, and Charlotte has a pipeline of projects coming together for this year. Over in the Mid-Atlantic, thanks to the Howard acquisition, the bank should land at number six in deposit share, with a pretty meaningful lending presence in that market as well as in Washington, D.C. So I feel quite good about our chances of hitting those growth targets. As I've mentioned previously, I'd credit our expansion strategy for that, plus the fact that we managed to bring on board a large group of lucky share physicians, and having fairly dynamic MSAs throughout the Southeast and Mid-Atlantic genuinely works in our favor. We're sitting in a solid spot if the economy manages to stay intact, and ideally it keeps holding together, which could hand us some gains during this year.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveMichael, there was something that had some effect on Q4 when it comes to the CRE side. As we've discussed before, we had multifamily projects that are simply somewhat lumpy. Six projects worth $150 million shifted into the secondary market. So from a footing perspective, that created a bit of a challenge in that specific book of business. And that's going to keep happening, since it's a significant part of what we do, particularly in the Southeast, as Vince pointed out. So with those exits, we'll keep seeing some lumpiness there.
Michael Perito
analystUnderstood, that helps. Last thing from me, then. Clearly, it's encouraging to see headlines about regulatory uncertainty in the markets regarding pending deals; so it's encouraging to see Howard wrapping up soon and on schedule. I'm just wondering whether you could give us a refreshed view on roughly 2022 and on where M&A stands in terms of appetite, and on how you see — how you're looking at the broader market and whether you expect additional opportunities or whether today's pipeline is less strong?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, we — like I've mentioned previously, our true focus is deploying capital as effectively as we can. So Howard basically fit the bill. It was available, strip out cost, and there's a solid team. Its size was reasonable. Not overly large, simple to absorb. It truly gave us the chance to set the company up from a cost standpoint as we head into a climate where everybody worries about inflation and wage pressure; so the outcome was great, both the timing and the fact that you're exiting PPP. So those balances will come onto our books, and the timing lined up nicely with rolling out our eStore and the improvements to our digital offering. That let us bring those products to those customers. So I'd call that an illustration of an M&A opportunity we viewed favorably, correct? We examined it. Our — the Fed and the OCC approved us, I believe, 32 days after application. So as we see it, no delays occurred. Perhaps the deal's relative size, along with our outstanding rating, plus the fact that we'd just finished our outstanding CRA rating and had just wrapped up some exams, might have made the regulators somewhat more at ease, yet we got it done and I take great pride in that. I believe our ties with the regulators are solid, and we pay attention and we act. And I think that explains how our deal got cleared. And we're extremely cautious when it comes to underwriting, re-underwriting the credits, and calculating the provision for reserves across those portfolios, and that provides a lot of reassurance. That said, I keep repeating to everyone that what excites us most is the investment we've put into digital — into our digital technology, the things happening within the company that aren't visible to you in terms of automation and AI, the data analytics team, the data hub we've built, the infrastructure we've developed in-house, which has genuinely assisted us not only in winning customers and pulling together information to serve our customers with products and services, but also in achieving greater efficiency across the company, in tracking an expanding set of metrics that help us push performance. So every bit of that is incredibly, incredibly thrilling to me. So considering where this company sits right now, we completed that major growth push and entered 2 really vibrant regions of the nation, and that ought to give us sizable chances for many years ahead; therefore what we're concentrating on is capturing more market share within those areas. And should an opportunity arise on the M&A side, and it makes sense and aligns with that approach, certainly we'll examine it. However, it must benefit shareholders, not anything that damages us or the shareholders either way, and that's all. So thanks. I'm grateful for the question.
Russell Gunther
analystFollowing up about the growth discussion — I'm wondering whether you might give a bit more detail regarding what you believe must occur for us to reach the top end of that range. That means moving from the middle to the upper part of single digits. Would that be C&I utilization still getting better, plus the single-family portfolio at the current put? I'd just like to know what you see as the forces behind that gap.
Vince Delie
executiveWell, my view is that it's going to require a mix of execution across every one of those areas; and my sense is that our 10% growth came with almost no assistance from expansion in working capital facilities. I'm aware that I've looked at other earnings reports, and growth in line utilization has shown up at other companies. For us, that really hasn't happened. What I mean is, we were up 1%, which is a negligible contribution. So although that does play a role, my thinking is that the more activity you get in working capital utilization, the more it signals there are chances to finance other things as well. So clearly, those 2 are linked together. That said, we have excellent chances in the middle market throughout the footprint, thanks to the eStore rollout and the fact that we can now digitally onboard small business customers — a terrific opportunity to do that far more efficiently and cost effectively across our footprint. So potential exists there. Potential exists in consumer, potential exists in mortgage through our physicians first program, which we introduced and which I referenced; so yes, my view is that we have many channels available to generate that growth. So my sense is that our pipeline looks fairly solid as we head into the year. So we're feeling fairly good.
Russell Gunther
analystThat's excellent. Then the final item from my side follows up regarding the cost reductions. You brought up the $10 million. Does that come from ongoing branch consolidation, or are there other sources? Simply from all the typical...
Vince Delie
executiveThere's a team focused on expenses, and we refer to the person leading it as our actual CEO, since he's the expense driver — so he'd be Chief Expense Officer. So we have someone reporting on those events, and Adam performs wonderfully. We examine each individual line item; next we review each sizable contract we hold, we check numerous statistics concerning the branch network, and we dedicate considerable time. A full team of truly data analytics folks examines transaction counts and similar metrics. Then we also run an initiative in our operations division under Udemy app to assess automation and how intelligent software gets utilized, helping automate and remove duplicative processes along with manual processes. So everything there connects into lowering expenses. Then we also have a group examining occupancy costs on a continual basis. I mean, they review that nonstop. We permit no FTEs. I mean, we scrutinize each job posting, each backfill role across the company, and we make people conduct an analysis tied to transaction volume, some kind of bearing ratio, to justify even a replacement. The company has operated — we've been quite lucky given the turnover seen at lots of companies. Our vacancy rate has stayed inside historical norms. So we haven't witnessed a mass exodus. Employees depart occasionally, yet it's remained fairly steady. We've experienced no difficulty hiring staff. So I believe those are every action we take to control costs; it was an entire process surrounding it. And I believe we've been — we've performed quite well; and like Adam and that group do, they worked really effectively, have done a fantastic job keeping us aligned.
Executive
executiveThat top workplace honor was a boost as well.
Vince Delie
executiveYeah. I mean, we've taken home best workplace honors across multiple years. We just earned it for year 10, and 1 publication in Pittsburgh covering basically every market over the past decade; we've collected awards, and when that happens, the staff feels involved in what's going on, and engagement is incredibly high. Our engagement scores were off the charts when we brought in a third party to survey the workforce. So I'd say the culture here is really solid; it's a culture of collaboration. People truly enjoy one another. It shows up in the outcomes we deliver, even if some of us are a bit crazy, I think that the rest of the company history. They like showing up, putting in the effort, and winning; and I think when your culture looks like that, sure, you're not impenetrable, but it's a great spot to be. Anyway, that's what drives our performance and our results. Every one of those factors plays a role.
Samuel Varga
analystLet me pose two quick things about the securities portfolio. Can you tell us what share of those securities carry a floating rate?
Vince Calabrese
executiveI'll need to follow up with you on that. Even though there's hardly anything there, if anything at all, I can track down the answer while we're speaking, so feel free to move on to your next question. There's barely anything of that sort — we have none.
Samuel Varga
analystThen, as a sort of additional question related to that. Would you share how long the available-for-sale segment of the securities book runs.
Vince Calabrese
executiveGive me a moment on that. Scott, if you'd like to — Scott or Bob, just send me a message, perhaps you've got it, just locate it.
Samuel Varga
analystMaybe I’ll pose one more question, and perhaps by then that figure will be available.
Vince Calabrese
executive3%.
Samuel Varga
analystHow long is it?
Vince Calabrese
executiveIt comes to 3%, that's right, on what we have available for sale.
Samuel Varga
analystBuilding on the topic of gaining market share, is there any hiring program you have in mind, like bringing over whole teams or something similar? Could you share some details?
Vince Delie
executiveSure. Over the past 12 months, we've brought on a significant number of individuals. Our usual practice is to recruit from bigger organizations within the commercial banking space. For instance, we recently brought in someone from JPMorgan located here in Pittsburgh, and that person is now heading up the teams in Pittsburgh. We've also brought on several bankers from different firms in the Southeast; quite a few of our bankers, at some stage in their careers, worked at either Wells or BofA in the Southeast. The whole Charleston team — I believe at various points, we can execute a lift out since we've brought on many individuals from Wells and BB&T and elsewhere. And I believe that reflects our culture as well. That's the reason we can substitute for physicians, I think — people see our offerings as comprehensive if you're a corporate banker, the incentive compensation structures are equitable and offer potential for growth. Plus, you have a robust array of products ranging from debt capital markets through to nearly all commercial treasury management offerings, which are on — we've earned branch accolades in the Treasury Management International award. So if you join as a commercial banker, you're set up well. I mean, you're arriving in, across many of these markets; we hold a large deposit share but a comparatively small commercial share; so the whole market — so if anyone listening on this call wants to be employed here, feel free to reach out to me; but among all the organizations I've been part of, I've never been with a company where the leadership of the wholesale bank. I mean, the culture is so collaborative in spirit. I just — words can't really capture it. I mean, at other big firms, individuals are competing across different product divisions. In our case, the incentive compensation structures are built so that people collaborate, and they truly do collaborate to succeed. They simply aim to win in the market and deliver the best possible results for their clients and for our shareholders. So the culture is excellent, and as I mentioned, we've had no trouble attracting talent from any — from the biggest bank in the United States right down to smaller organizations. So that's my take.
Samuel Varga
analystGot it. Then, if I may slip in one final question: are there any plans going forward to bring down overdraft levels?
Vince Delie
executiveHonestly, we got out in front on that one; a product was launched by us last year. A press release went out about it, which you can locate; we have a total — there's an electronic checking offering we introduced as part of our digital lineup; with it, overdrafting isn't possible, and no overdraft fees get charged to you; and that product ranks third — I believe behind — previously it held the number two spot among the most in-demand or best-selling products in the whole company across the past 8 or 9 months. It might have fallen to 1/3 since our student checking campaign, student checking drives it higher, yet it sits within our top 3 offerings. That's the reason our noninterest income guide factors in a leveling off of fees in the consumer segment, despite growth we're observing elsewhere; so an impact will be felt. Our guidance already accounts for it. That's one action taken by us, plus we've implemented numerous other adjustments and intend to alter additional pieces of the fee structure inside the consumer bank. So...
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, we are looking into how the competition is shaping up.
Vince Delie
executiveRight. Being a market leader isn't possible for us in that space. Our only option is to take a step back and observe what's going on, but that single product was ours, and the feedback it got was very favorable, and now it's certified once again, and things have gone really well.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnd then, just to make the timing clear: on 12/31, AFS sits at 3.4, while the overall figure comes to 3.6 — which puts HTM at 3.7. So those numbers are quite close to one another. But I want to fix something I mentioned before: the 3.4 belongs to the AFS portfolio.
Brian Martin
analystAlright, so this is the final thing I have for you, maybe two things. It's about capital. Is there any shift in how you're viewing where you'll put your capital to work? Vince, I realize you've already touched on the M&A picture somewhat, but what about buybacks — how are you weighing that, given the room you have?
Vince Calabrese
executiveAbsolutely, Brian. Our CET1 sits at 9.9%, as you're able to see in the slide deck, and it has remained quite steady. It was 9.9% during the prior quarter and 9.8% twelve months back; thus, we've discussed roughly a 10% goal in that regard. So the level we're at makes us happy. And despite the robust loan growth of 10% that Vince referenced, keeping CET1 unchanged reveals the amount of earnings we are producing and then holding onto. Looking ahead, our guide assumes the capital ratio will gradually climb from this point, since we're still exchanging ordinary loans for PPP loans, correct, which carry a 0 risk weighting. So — yet I continue to anticipate, based on our projection for the CET1 ratio to rise, as I said, a steady increase from now until the close of the year. After that, we'll simply act opportunistically regarding buybacks. I mean, our primary aim is to put it toward loan growth. So if loan growth comes in stronger at the upper end, we'd like to direct the capital toward backing that loan growth. However, we will be opportunistic with share purchases as we progress through 2022. We completed none in the fourth quarter, given the timing surrounding Howard and the regulatory approval and matters of that nature. But we'll keep watching it and simply handle capital in a manner that's completely in line with shareholder interests; yet loan growth will be, more or less, the initial lever we'll seek to use it for.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. All right. And Vince, within the guidance, maybe you already covered this and I missed it since I dialed in a bit late, but regarding the excess liquidity — I think if you could just discuss where the core margin landed in 1Q, and then the outlook you've assumed for a 26 basis point drag from excess liquidity across the year, given the loan growth forecast?
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure. The excess cash averaged $3.7 billion during the fourth quarter, which produced the drag shown on that slide. Our 2022 expectation is that figure declines by half, reaching roughly $1.5 billion by year-end. In a similar way, PPP related deposits are included in our guide, and we project those to fall by about $1.3 billion. They've proven stickier than our estimates throughout this process, but that's incorporated in our guidance. So essentially, the cash level moves from a $3.7 billion average and then progresses to $1.5 billion by the end of the year. I can't calculate that in my head that fast. But that's essentially what sits beneath it. So that effect will diminish as the year progresses.
Brian Martin
analystYes. Okay. All right. Then I just have one point I want to clarify regarding the guidance. With respect to Howard's impact, considering when the deal closes — I'm referring to the effect on NII, actually not NII, rather the fees and expenses and similar items — is the assumption that it closes next week? Or was that essentially incorporated as though it were a year-end close? I simply want to confirm what is reflected in the guidance you've provided.
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo. For 11 months, it's included.
Brian Martin
analystAll right, that matches my understanding. I simply wanted to make sure. Thanks, Vince. I appreciate your taking the questions.
Vince Delie
executiveAll right. Thanks to everyone. Thanks for asking them. Excellent questions, quite thorough, and I'm glad we could respond. With any luck, we addressed every question people had. I'd like to praise our leadership team along with the employees. Whenever I had the chance, I'd devote a great deal of time to sitting down with folks in the field and engaging across various markets. And morale over this whole stretch of the last 2 years has been outstanding, and the leadership has been extremely solid. And truly, that is what generates our success; so I want to praise everyone for all the effort and the commitment and the motivation to succeed. So please continue that; and thank you, and thanks for the questions, and thanks to our shareholders for your ongoing backing.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it. That brings this call to a close. Thanks for joining us for today's presentation. You're free to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.