F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 19, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lisa Constantine
executiveThanks, and good morning everyone — welcome to the call. This F.N.B Corporation conference call, along with the reports we file with the Securities and Exchange Commission, frequently includes forward-looking statements and non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP figures ought to be considered alongside, rather than as a substitute for, the results we report under GAAP. You'll find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, and to the closest comparable GAAP financial measures, in both our presentation materials and the earnings release. Please take a look at those non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures in the related materials, reports, and registration statements we've filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are also available on our corporate website. A replay of today's call can be accessed through Tuesday, April 26, and the webcast link will be posted in the About Us Investor Relations section of our corporate website. With that, I'll hand the call over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveThank you, and good morning everyone — glad to have you on our Q1 earnings call. Joining me are Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, and Gary Guerrieri, our Chief Credit Officer. FNB entered 2022 with solid underlying results, and Howard Bank is now completely integrated. We're pleased that the deal metrics associated with Howard came in at or above what we planned, which benefited our capital ratios. Through Howard, we added $1.8 billion in loans to the balance sheet, bringing total assets up to $42 billion. On a combined basis, FNB actually posted robust growth in its Mid-Atlantic loan pipeline — 13% higher year-over-year and 61% higher linked quarter. We anticipate continued expansion in the Mid-Atlantic region, supported by the outstanding staff members and new customers who came aboard FNB. Beyond that, we expect a revenue boost from FNB's stronger product lineup as we extend those services to the customer base already present in that market. This month, earlier on, FNB's Board of Directors gave the green light to a fresh repurchase program covering 150 million shares, which provides us with greater flexibility to manage capital effectively and deliver benefits to our shareholders. FNB posted first quarter GAAP earnings per share of $0.15, and $0.26 on an operating basis. Revenue increased 3.4% linked-quarter, driven by net interest income rising 5%. Thanks to the strategic moves we made to position our balance sheet and take advantage of the current interest rate cycle, we remain well positioned to grow net interest income. That covers things like a better deposit mix and putting money into a short-term securities portfolio. We're still in good shape, with $16 billion of assets tied to short-term rate indices. When you set PPPs aside, loans were up $2 billion, or 8.2%. Howard added to that growth, but commercial loan production on its own topped $1 billion, a 30% year-over-year increase. Going forward, pipelines have recovered thanks to our strong fourth-quarter growth and are 23% higher quarter-over-quarter. That makes us more confident in our full-year guidance of mid-to-high single-digit organic loan growth. Our fee income businesses had another solid quarter at $78 million, basically flat versus the prior quarter. Wealth management continued to deliver record results. Revenue rose $1.1 million from the prior quarter — almost 30% annualized — mainly on record organic sales activity. Mortgage banking income climbed 700,000 quarter over quarter to 7 million amid considerable interest rate volatility. Although higher mortgage rates should cut refinance activity, we believe our diversified geographic footprint and steady dedication to the home purchase and new construction market will let us beat the industry. In fact, purchase money mortgage accounted for nearly 80% of our originations this quarter. Technology investment at FNB has also let us bring in more mortgage clients efficiently, since 66% of our mortgage applications came through our online e-Store. While we keep expanding the balance sheet, we stay watchful about today's macro backdrop—elevated inflation, supply chain turmoil, and geopolitical instability. In light of present conditions, we've taken a proactive approach to evaluating risks and putting plans into action. Our credit team continuously monitors the sectors that rising interest rates might affect. Given higher prices for food, oil, gas, and commodities, plus interruptions in supply chains, we will continue assessing environmental risks and adjusting our approach as necessary—so that results remain steady even as we meet the needs of our key stakeholders. I'll now turn the call over to Gary, who will discuss overall credit performance and the steps his team has taken to position our portfolio.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThank you, Vince, and good morning to everyone. First-quarter results were again solid, and we're quite happy with how favorably our credit portfolio remains positioned, as our key asset quality metrics show. This quarter also saw us finish the Howard Bank acquisition successfully, and I'm glad to say it came in a bit better than we had anticipated and had no material effect on the credit portfolio overall. I'll give a little more detail on that transaction, including the Day 1 and Day 2 effects on reserve levels, and I'll get to that later in my prepared remarks. Let's begin by going over our GAAP asset quality results for the quarter. As I noted before, we came into 2022 with the credit portfolio in a strong position, and now that the newly acquired Howard loan book is included in our total consolidated results, we saw only modest upticks in delinquency and NPL levels relative to our very low year-end figures. Delinquency finished March at a very solid 66 basis points, an increase of five bps that came entirely from Howard; excluding that acquired loan book, delinquency would actually have edged down from the prior quarter. NPLs and OREO likewise showed a modest linked-quarter rise against very low year-end results, with the GAAP level climbing two basis points to finish March at 40 bps, again attributable to absorbing Howard's portfolio. For the quarter, net charge-offs came in at a very modest $1.9 million, which works out to three basis points on an annualized basis, and we continue to operate at levels that are low by historical standards, just as we have over the last several quarters. This quarter we booked provision expense of $18 million, and that figure includes the $19.1 million initial provision on non-PCD loans associated with the Howard acquisition. Adding the Day 1 PCD gross up of $10 million, our reserve position at quarter end stands at 371 million, equal to 1.38% of loans. The PCD loans we acquired were relatively small, accounting for slightly more than 10% of the Howard loan book. If you set aside the Howard deal along with the associated provision and gross-up activity, our reserves would have come down somewhat compared with December, and that's consistent with the positive credit quality trends we've been observing. Our coverage of nonperforming loans is still solid at 365%. Regarding Howard's loan portfolio, we're quite pleased with how well the book was converted and with the ongoing tracking and monitoring our teams are performing, which helps us manage risk more effectively during this transition period. Leading up to conversion, Howard's credit book did somewhat better than we had anticipated, and both our loan risk profile and credit concentrations remain satisfactory. We look forward to further lending opportunities and access to a broader customer base across our Mid-Atlantic footprint, which supports our overall loan growth objectives and gives us deeper opportunities for our other fee-based services. I want to congratulate the team on their tireless work to close the transaction and grow our presence in this highly desirable market. I'd now like to briefly discuss recent global and macroeconomic developments that we've been watching, including the possible effect on our borrowers and the markets where we operate. With ongoing inflation, high input costs, supply chain disruptions, labor shortages, and geopolitical influences posing persistent challenges, we're concentrating on these elements in our underwriting and credit discussions so we can tackle and reduce these risks early. While we haven't observed any material effect on our credit portfolio so far, we're staying vigilant and have adjusted our credit decisioning approach to account for how these various factors might affect a borrower's EBITDA and margin levels—covering fluctuating operational and supply costs as well as potential interest rate sensitivities that could drive up borrowing costs. Even so, we've taken an active approach with interest rate instruments, letting borrowers lock in their borrowing costs and become less exposed to the rising rate environment. To wrap up, our portfolio's position and the successful purchase of Howard Bank continue to please us greatly. And we've kept our attention on the year ahead, managing our expanding credit book through an economic environment that could soften. Upholding our strong credit culture remains our top priority, and we are well equipped and continue to act proactively so that emerging risks in our loan portfolio are spotted quickly and handled better. Our credit discipline rests on steady underwriting, oversight of tenant risk, and a selective approach to strong lending opportunities — all of which have worked in our favor and set us up for the coming year. At this point I'll hand things over to our Chief Financial Officer, Vince Calabrese, for his comments.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks, Gary. As Vince said, we're really enthusiastic about the Howard deal and what it can do to keep our fee-based revenues growing. Once the merger closed, deposits were $1.8 billion on both sides, and 43% of those deposits sat in non-interest bearing accounts. On significant items, the first quarter included $28.6 million of merger-related expenses, $19.1 million of initial provision for non — PCD loans, and $4.2 million tied to branch consolidation costs. In connection with the acquisition, FNB issued slightly more than 34 million common shares at $12.99 in exchange for 18.9 million Howard common shares. From here on, Howard shows up in all of our reported numbers, guidance included, since it's now part of FNB. With that, let's go to slide five and walk through the first quarter financials, beginning with the highlights. Reported EPS for the first quarter came to $0.15, and $0.26 on an operating basis once you adjust for the Howard-related items and branch consolidation costs I just mentioned. But if you exclude PPP and Howard loans as of the acquisition date, which better reflects underlying loan growth, period end total loans rose $259.7 million, or 4.3% annualized on a linked-quarter basis, including a $81.7 million increase in commercial loans and leases and $178 million in consumer loans. Average loans, excluding PPP and Howard, were up $440 million, or 7.4% annualized. Let's move on to the balance sheet on Slide 7. First quarter average securities hit $7.0 billion, up $469 million from the prior quarter, as we stepped up investing activity to take advantage of the higher interest rate environment. That securities growth, together with the loan growth, drove a 3.9% rise in total average earning assets. Average deposits excluding Howard were $31.7 billion, up 7.8% year-over-year. That reflects continued organic growth in households and account balances, partly offset by a decline in time deposits as customers preferred moving funds into liquid accounts. On Slide 8, net interest income was $234.1 million, up $10.8 million, or 4.8%, from the prior quarter, mainly on growth in average earning assets and early benefits from the higher interest rate environment, partly offset by the $4.2 million lower contribution from PPP. Our net interest margin rose six basis points to 261, reflecting the early stages of benefiting from upward movement in interest rates. The combined impact of PPP, purchase accounting accretion, and higher cash balances reduced net interest margin by 13 basis points this quarter, similar to the 14 basis point reduction last quarter. Now let's look at non-interest income and expense. Non-interest income was $78.3 million, essentially flat versus the prior quarter. We've talked before about our strategy of investing in diversified fee-based businesses, and this quarter again shows why it matters. For instance, insurance commissions and fees rose $2.3 million linked-quarter, offsetting a $2.4 million decrease in capital markets as it came back down from elevated fourth quarter levels. We believe our diversified fee income strategy will pay off as we move through the economic cycle. Non-interest expense as reported rose $45.8 million, or 25.2%, from the prior quarter. On an operating basis, non-interest expense went up $13.9 million, or 7.7%, to $194.6 million, leaving out merger-related expenses and branch consolidation costs from both the current and prior quarters. Salaries and employee benefits, on an operating basis, rose $8.1 million, or 7.8%, quarter over quarter, mainly because of normal seasonal long-term compensation expense of $6.2 million in the first quarter of 2022 and seasonally higher employer payroll taxes. The quarter's total also includes a little over two months of salaries and benefits for the Howard employees who joined F.N.B. Occupancy and equipment rose $3.1 million, or 10.1%, largely from higher seasonal utility costs. Bank shares and franchise taxes rose $2.3 million because of state tax credits recognized in the prior quarter. The efficiency ratio came in at 60.7% versus 58.7. The higher efficiency ratio stemmed from nearly $20 million less in triple fee and purchase accounting accretion income than a year ago. Excluding PPP and PAA, our efficiency ratio would have improved by roughly 220 basis points year over year; we expect this quarter's efficiency ratio to improve going forward, helped by expected rate hikes and revenue and expense synergies tied to Howard. Tangible book value per share fell from the prior quarter to $8.09, mainly because of a $202 million, or $0.57 per share, accumulated other comprehensive loss as of March 31, 2022, reflecting higher interest rates' effect on the fair value of AFS securities. That compares with a $52 million, or $0.19, negative impact at the end of the prior quarter. Unrealized losses in the AFS portfolio that grew due to rising rates should return to capital over time as securities mature or prepay. In the first quarter of 2022, the company bought back 2.2 million shares of common stock at a weighted average price of $13.25, for $29.8 million in total. To date, FNB has repurchased 111 million under the program approved in September 2019. Earlier this month, our Board approved a new 150 million-share repurchase program, continuing to give FNB a tool for optimizing capital management and enhancing overall shareholder returns; now let's turn to guidance on Page 12. We expect loans to grow in the low double digits to low teens, with underlying organic growth in the mid-to-high single digits on a year-over-year spot basis. Total deposits are projected to grow high single digits on a year-over-year spot basis. Full-year net interest income should land between $1.0 billion and $1.04 billion, with the second quarter between $249 million and $253 million. Our base guidance currently assumes 125 basis points of rate increases for the rest of the year, including a 50 basis point increase in May. Full-year non-interest income is expected to be between $315 million and $330 million, with the second quarter around $80 million. Our updated guidance for the entire year is somewhat lower than anticipated, and that's because of market-related fee income. We're not changing our outlook for non-interest expense for the whole year: it remains in the range of $760 million to $780 million on an operating basis, and for the second quarter it's $190 million to $195 million. That excludes the one-time costs tied to the Howard Bank acquisition. We expect positive credit quality to persist through 2022, with provision guidance of $20 million to $40 million. That figure leaves out the initial $19.1 million of provision connected to Howard, and it depends on how net loan growth actually plays out during the year. Finally, the effective tax rate for the full year should land between 17.5% and 18.5%, assuming corporate income tax rates stay unchanged and depending on the amount of investment tax credit activity; with that, I'll hand the call back to Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks, Vince. We've put a lot of effort into creating a strongly differentiated brand, and that includes our commercial lending and wholesale banking operations. Our knowledgeable team, together with investments in products and technology, produces a commercial banking experience that stands out for its exceptional convenience and sophistication. Our commercial business spans everything from large corporate clients to small business lending, including highly specialized industry verticals, which creates a chance for FNB to go beyond what most clients need. So far in 2022, Forbes has named FNB one of America's Best Bank and World's Best Banks, and we've received 17 branch excellence and Best Brand Awards. Energage also recognized us as a top workplace USA for a second consecutive year; these honors add to a long list of accolades FNB has earned for its differentiated culture and business model, which centers on doing what is right for clients, communities, and employees, and ultimately benefits our shareholders. For instance, in April 2022 FNB is raising our closing costs assistant grant to 5000, furthering our commitment to borrowers in low-to-moderate-income communities; we also improved our mortgage product offerings through Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to give additional access to homeowners whose income is at or below the area median income for their markets. Our aim is to make sure all stakeholders benefit from the products and services we offer. Our first-quarter results give us a solid foundation to keep building momentum throughout 2022. As always, our performance is a testament to our team, and I thank each employee for their dedication and contribution. With that, I'll hand the call over to the Operator for questions.
Frank Schiraldi
analystMorning. Vince, you mentioned that you remain quite confident about this year's loan growth expectations, and I think you also said the pipeline right now is up 23% from the prior quarter. I'd like to dig into that — is this the commercial pipeline? And can you expand on what's driving that increase? Is it a sign that supply chain problems are easing? Or is it more of a seasonal pattern? I'm curious whether you could give a bit more context on why the pipeline jumped so much quarter over quarter.
Vince Delie
executiveSure, I can speak to that. My sense is it's fairly broad-based. When you examine how our pipeline is spread out, there's a small chart right here for our unsafe (ph) that illustrates the trend. Nearly every region — and the company has recorded linked-quarter pipeline growth — is visible there. Recall that during the fourth quarter we had quite a robust period — it was a record quarter for production on our side. What usually occurs is that bankers get occupied closing transactions, so the pipeline contracts somewhat. After that we return to prospecting or handling borrowers' requests, and the pipeline expands once more, which I believe is what you're seeing here. Another element is that the first quarter tends to be seasonally slower. You don't yet have the financial results from your corporate borrowers that you can act on. Usually, companies haven't worked out their CapEx plans up to this point. So this is the moment when you begin to see the pipeline pick up. We're quite happy with how the Mid-Atlantic region has grown. The Mid-Atlantic is up 13% year-over-year and 61% quarter-over-quarter. So that Howard acquisition gave you a big boost. There's a lot of critical mass and scale, deeper market penetration, and some excellent bankers we brought on who appear to be fairly pleased with our system. So we're really enthusiastic about the opportunities in that region. And as I mentioned on the call, we also believe that. Looking at non-interest income, our fee-based operations give us a huge chance to reach deeper into that customer base, with meaningful fee potential in wealth and the <<inaudible>> market. That, I believe, ought to benefit us there. So it's a major factor. Charlotte has grown 33% compared with a year earlier and 52% quarter over quarter. Quite a lot is happening across the Southeast. I recently passed some time — a week — in Charleston and Raleigh, and each of those markets is doing very well. We've devoted considerable time to working with clients, and I believe those markets are responding positively to our brand; we're fairly well established there, with regional headquarters set up in Greensboro, Charlotte, Raleigh, and Charleston, South Carolina, featuring prominent signage and a solid delivery channel. So deals are beginning to come together in those places. We've also grown through a de novo approach into Asheville, North Carolina. It's been about two years now, so that's starting to build momentum for us. In addition to Greenville, South Carolina — we were situated on the outskirts of Greenville — we have plans to expand more aggressively into that market, which gives us a fair number of commercial opportunities, especially C&I opportunities. And small business banking had historically lagged for us from a growth standpoint, since we were consolidating portfolios with each acquisition we made; that has stabilized and has actually begun to grow nicely for us throughout the footprint, so we are getting a bit of a lift from our small business lending activity, which gives you the landscape. In my view, Frank, it has more to do with looking at how much of our credit lines customers actually draw on — Chris Chan and I were going over those figures just now. The pattern is a sharp decline in usage, meaning outstanding balances declined once COVID hit, right as the pandemic began. After that initial pandemic quarter in 2020, commercial clients' borrowing activity fell away substantially. So many of those businesses turned to cash; they received stimulus or benefited from stimulus and brought their balances down, and then a series of events took place that were unpredictable, but supply chain disruption, all sorts of things happened; that slowed their capacity to grow or expand, and I think we are beginning to see a pickup if you dug into that utilization where, even though we have not seen much of a broad increase in utilization rates across all the portfolios, once you start to drill down into it, we are seeing growth in the middle market now; we are starting to see things pick up; so that tells me we are working through those supply chain issues. Regarding the conflict in Ukraine, it's likely a concern for companies, but from an operational perspective, I believe they're beginning to return to normal. In any case, as I mentioned in my comments, we continue to be quite cautious. We're still watching credit conditions closely, since there are worries about additional supply chain disruption and about oil and gas prices climbing and impacting particular industries. So we're keeping a close watch on that, yet overall, we haven't observed any significant weakness anywhere in the portfolio; credit quality, in fact, is holding up. I hope that addresses your question. I tried to be as comprehensive as possible.
Frank Schiraldi
analystThat's been a big help, thanks. And I suppose, just to follow up on that — given how solid, given how confident you sound about the loan growth outlook, is there any chance at all to increase the buyback? I'm just curious whether, with bank stocks having come down somewhat since the levels where you repurchased shares in the first quarter, we ought to be thinking about maybe stepping that up a bit. Should we be looking at that any differently than we did heading into 1Q?
Vince Delie
executiveI'd say our loan growth guidance isn't unreasonable. We're looking at mid to high single-digit growth, so there is a bit of room for us to fund that growth using capital we generate on our own along with repurchasing shares; that's the reason the Board gave the buyback program its approval. We want to keep options available so we can keep driving shareholder value and support the stock price if we see it move downward; and the company has done admirably across the last few years, so there's plenty of confidence among the Board in bringing forward a buyback program. If you look at how the company has performed financially, it's been very strong even through some very challenging times, and the steps that Gary and the credit team have taken with our commercial bankers; we really set ourselves up well and came through in pretty good shape, and that gives them a lot of confidence on the buyback. And if you look at the capital ratios, and I can't remember, Chris, we're at 10% <<inaudible>>. In any case, from a regulatory capital standpoint, we look good. I think we're in a good spot, Frank, so the options are there for it.
Frank Schiraldi
analystOkay, that's fine. Thanks a lot, Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveIt sounds as though he's riding a horse.
Daniel Tamayo
analystGood morning, guys.
Vince Delie
executiveHey there. How are you?
Vince Calabrese
executiveMorning.
Daniel Tamayo
analystWe're doing well, thanks. Perhaps I could start with the mortgage-banking outlook. You offered helpful detail on the ongoing expectation that this would—I should say—beat the industry as we move ahead. But could you maybe give a bit more detail on how you're thinking about how we ought to think about sizing that revenue stream as we go forward, or do you still expect it to grow from here, or stay flat, or from a broader perspective, how do you see revenue moving from this point?
Vince Delie
executiveI'll have Vince take that one; in <<inaudible>>, but as I've said before, I'll tell you the pipeline has moved, as we've noted. We're very well positioned throughout the Southeast and the Mid-Atlantic and some rather dynamic housing markets. So we have a chance to gain more heavily from purchase-money mortgage origination. I believe our pipeline right now stands at roughly 90%. So purchase money. So we did make that shift, and it provides some support, which is why I said in my prepared comments that we ought to beat the industry. We're less reliant on refinance activity, and we're spread out across broad geographies in some very appealing markets. And roughly 50% of the franchise sits in very stable, more stable markets, which gives us some stability and lets us keep a lower growth trajectory. And then half of it sits in more dynamic, higher growth markets, where we're seeing more housing starts and a lot of activity. But go ahead, Ben. I don't know whether you'd like to give them a bit more color on the top line; and what were our expectations?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. No, I'd say that during the quarter, the results showed we were slightly above a low point from the prior quarter, and we had expected it to be low. The mix of purchase versus refi, as Vince noted, puts us in a good spot to concentrate on purchase; for this quarter we're at 77%, and now it's risen while refi last quarter dropped to 5% of the total; so in a sense the way our business is structured leaves us very well positioned, and purchase-side activity has remained quite robust; but I suppose if you reduce it to mortgage banking income, that depends on how much you sell and how much your portfolio as well, depending on what kind of originations they are. We've certainly observed some shift toward customers wanting ARMs of seven, six months — it's no longer one. And in 10-year and six months. So we've begun to see some movement in that direction; so that's up close in the portfolio. So you'd have a poorer portfolio, higher net interest income, and somewhat less gain on sale from that. I guess if you reduce it all to the essentials, I would expect mortgage banking to rise from here compared with the first quarter; we're entering the seasonal second and third quarters that tend to be high, but around the level to a little bit higher from here is the best way to describe it. And it's really going to depend on the mix of those originations; but they're still very healthy, applications are very strong, and the purchase market continues to be strong. So that helps support the activity there.
Vince Delie
executiveOn the flip side, there's a good deal going on in consumer lending compared with mortgage lending. Beyond the mortgage bank itself, our pipelines have jumped. At the moment we have one of the strongest pipelines we've ever had, so the increase has been meaningful. A lot of demand had been pent up. I'm not sure — there was the capacity to carry out many of the construction projects, so I believe demand has surged throughout our footprint, and that's essentially in every geography. So all of this means — the reason I raised that point is that in the end it may prompt people to take a consumer loan that's secured by real estate and then roll it into a bigger — into a larger mortgage loan, and it gets paid off. In any case, that's — there's a good deal of activity. So we feel fairly good about where we sit when it comes to repurchase money opportunities and growth in certain segments of our business.
Daniel Tamayo
analystThat's really thorough — thank you for laying it all out. Maybe I can switch gears here and ask about net interest income: clearly the rate outlook looks quite different now than it did a quarter ago, and your updated guidance reflects that. How should we think about — or how are you thinking about — how the bank's sensitivity to rates changes from the spike we just saw all the way to what you're projecting by year-end? Does that have any impact? Do you anticipate any gap when it comes to loan betas — specifically what you can reprice on the lending side — and could you also remind us whether you still expect deposit betas to land in that 40% to 50% range by year-end?
Vince Calabrese
executiveLet me address that in a couple of ways regarding what the guidance assumes — you can see what we've included, another 125 basis points <<inaudible>>. Should we see more than that, there would clearly be upside to the range. I realize everyone is incorporating their own rate projections. So there is plainly some upside to the range, depending on where things ultimately land. Regarding those measures, they remain fairly robust. Historically, nearly half of our total loans are linked to those two metrics at three months or shorter, and to prime as well. That comes to $13 billion dollars, or 48% of total loans, so rising rates work in our favor there. Our cash position is also helping: we still hold roughly $3 billion — $3.2 billion — which was earning 50 and now earns 40, and we'd anticipate that increasing by the time the Fed acts, adding another 50 basis points to reach 50, so that's a benefit. Even though those funds haven’t been lent out yet, you’re seeing a gain from them as well. Then there’s the investment portfolio — during the latest quarter we were able to capitalize on elevated rates by allocating additional capital there and expanding that portfolio. That is helping the overall margin; and PPP has nearly disappeared. Setting PPP aside, our loan yields actually rose five basis points, with those operations continuing along the same lines, and regarding deposit betas — once more, none of us truly knows how — the amount of liquidity within the banking system is clearly still something all of us are weighing. As we keep traveling further along this road of Federal Reserve actions, I believe we'll experience added pressure—particularly given what type of commercial depository we are and how early we sit in that process. Based on our current observations and expectations, our projection really centers on the quarter when the rate increases flow through, affecting total deposit cost by about 25% on a total deposit basis. By year-end, interest-bearing deposits come in at approximately 40%. That is essentially what we are forecasting at present.
Daniel Tamayo
analystGreat, that covers everything from my side. Appreciate all of that.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks.
Mike Young
analystHey, can you hear me?
Vince Delie
executiveWe can now.
Mike Young
analystAll right, my apologies for that. We're dealing with a few technical problems this morning, and I'm sorry.
Vince Delie
executiveThe first time around, it sounded as though you were riding a horse. There was just a clicking sound on our end, but we're happy to have you with us on the call.
Mike Young
analystYeah. Perhaps it's the specter of cellphone past, I'm not sure. But my apologies.
Vince Delie
executiveThat's always the way. Please go ahead.
Mike Young
analystIt did a really good job. Vince, I'd like to walk through the fee income part. Obviously, this quarter had plenty of big swings — the MSR value adjustment can drive large movements, with insurance going up while capital markets went down. It sounds like the outlook is for a slight weakening, but is that mostly tied to mortgages, or are you noticing some things in other business lines that you expect to be a bit softer as the year goes on?
Vince Delie
executiveYou've got red on combined across several areas. Comparing mortgage banking fee income to last year will clearly be a hard task, since the prior figure was so robust. Still, our approach to developing fee-based operations has been to ensure that whenever certain ones underperform at peak levels, the breadth of what we offer can compensate. As you noted, the guidance we provided reflects some of that reallocation. Take capital markets — certainly, looking purely at derivatives, interest rate and hedging, many customers and clients naturally took advantage of hedging offerings back when rates were exceptionally low. That segment has softened somewhat. Conversely, within capital markets we rolled out a platform for debt capital markets. Activity and prospects look promising there, so we anticipate a fairly strong year in that area. We've put money into our international banking platform and introduced additional products, and we look for growth in that space. Growth in SBA has been quite robust, and we anticipate that continuing. Our SBA platform—which we reduced in size, subsequently rebuilt, and folded more thoroughly into calling efforts throughout the company rather than keeping it separate—is beginning to gain momentum. Those factors ought to offset the mortgage and derivative operations. Of course, net asset values are something we depend on too. If the market holds steady, we ought to gain from that as well, since we're experiencing considerable organic growth. In DC and Baltimore we're quite opportunistic with that Howard portfolio, and because they lacked a product offering, we're beginning to see some solid opportunities there. Then in the Carolinas — Charleston, Asheville, and Greenville are roll-up rate markets for us, with the private banking involved respectively — and we're starting to see some activity.
Mike Young
analystSo Howard is going to be additive, purely on the base.
Vince Delie
executiveOh, yes. So if you brought on quite a few households, a nice little commercial bank that fits well with us culturally. So the people there did a nice job and we were able to take cost out but still keep the vast majority in the front line people. So we've added to our teams and those folks are doing really well.
Vince Calabrese
executiveTheir product lineup wasn't the same as ours, and the fee-side test results matter a lot, considering how strong that customer base is — it truly spans wealth management, capital markets, insurance, and mortgage across the board, so opportunities exist in each of the different fee-based revenue categories. And that will be additive.
Vince Delie
executiveSure, there are obstacles, but we aren’t sitting around fussing. Mortgage banking will be harder this year, and capital markets will be harder too, especially around hedging. Still, I think the guidance we provided is something we feel good about, thanks to how well we can generate income in those other areas.
Vince Calabrese
executiveI think that matters as well, correct? So for the quarter we posted 78, and for the upcoming quarter our guidance sits at roughly 80, then 315 to 330; so clearly we see diversification across the fee-based categories, and we're at ease with those guidance ranges you mentioned, which are above the per-quarter level.
Mike Young
analystAll right, great. Just to follow up on what was asked earlier, when we look at those cash balances, the 10-year rate has climbed quite a bit — so are you thinking about laddering some of that into securities and expanding the balance sheet? Or are you leaning more toward a remix, simply funding loan growth with the cash? That would mean we should expect somewhat less balance sheet growth, but stronger margins.
Vince Calabrese
executiveWith the opportunities rates present, we've certainly deployed more money during the first quarter; we put $600 million into the portfolio, roughly $200 million above cash flows. Looking at it, the average balance rose by nearly $0.5 billion; so you take advantage of rates moving — yet we remained within our strategy of duration of about 3.5 to 4. We haven't wanted to extend today, and as we sit here right now, for the current quarter at least, our expectation would be to reinvest the cash flows coming in; and rates are — we were — in the fourth quarter we reinvested around 1.34, in the first quarter up to 1.90, again with the 3.5 duration. One thing that's important for us too is that with interest rates moving, our securities portfolio is 50/50 AFS versus held-to-maturity; so, and it's on the short side. So I think the AOCI hit we took was much smaller than others, depending on how they structure their portfolio. That helps us manage as far as the impact on book equity, but also helps us manage and create opportunities with a billion dollars of cash flow coming that should continue to move. We will be opportunistic and — that makes sense. We will put — we will grow the portfolio itself, but we've done a good amount here. But we'll just watch very closely and look for those opportunities as we have been doing.
Mike Young
analystAll right, thanks.
Timur Braziler
analystGood morning, everyone. Timur Braziler here, sitting in for Jared. To start off, I want to follow up on the NII guidance, comparing this quarter's guidance with the prior quarter's. Last quarter it looked quite comparable, with two rate hikes assumed and, I believe, 3% sensitivity in case a third hike came; now the assumption is five hikes, one of which has already happened, plus an expectation of 50 basis points in May. That the guidance isn't higher is a bit of a surprise to me. Did something else in how that guidance is calculated change and offset part of that sensitivity to the added hikes, or perhaps the present mix together with Howard — if you could lay that out, I'd appreciate it.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThe spot where I'd call us conservative would be the betas, since I genuinely can't predict how that plays out once Howard joins and as we look forward from today. We'll find out. As I mentioned, there's plenty of liquidity in the banking system. Banks, I believe, will be deliberate about raising rates as needed, but you're carrying a lot of cash on the balance sheet. That's likely the one area where we're being somewhat conservative on the betas, though nobody can say for sure; we raised the guide considerably versus the guide from the first quarter. With what's included here — and I'm aware some analysts have additional hikes built into their forecasts — so, as I said before, should we get beyond 125 basis points from here, which the futures market, I'm not sure where <<inaudible>>? It's above that; it's above that. Above that. So more than that means additional upside as well; those are the two points I'll comment on.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right. Then on the power side, perhaps for Gary, could you give an outlook for purchase accounting dollars beginning here in Q2?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYeah — please go ahead, Vince. My apologies.
Vince Calabrese
executiveI didn't quite catch what you asked.
Vince Delie
executiveOnly the outlook and expectation regarding accretion — purchase accounting accretion.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAll right. So you're looking to <<inaudible>>
Vince Delie
executiveOnce the PCD gross up is applied, the total net acceptable discount came to just about $10 million. So going forward, we'd figure on roughly 600,000, or slightly above 0.5 million per quarter, depending on prepay.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat one's only meant for Howard.
Vince Delie
executiveRight, this is Howard's. Hi Gary, is there anything else you can share about Howard, and about the group as a whole?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes, Vince, I can give everyone an update. As I said in my remarks, the portfolio performed better than we had anticipated. We were quite happy with what we learned as we dug further into the transaction regarding certain clients on whom we initially lacked some information—we ended up feeling very comfortable with a number of them and were able to raise those ratings up to pass ratings. That was a tremendous help from a market standpoint, and also in terms of how the portfolio did over the quarter. The portfolio was very well underwritten—in fact, it was the best-underwritten portfolio we have seen—and we expect it to keep performing very, very well going forward. As you saw in the metrics, the changes in the metrics were very minimal. Broadly speaking, they are significantly higher than that, and from a ratings perspective, the portfolio rated very well, very closely to FNB's, and we are very pleased overall with it.
Vince Calabrese
executiveApologies — one quick point on accretion. In the first quarter, total purchase accounting accretion came to roughly 3 million pre- — Howard, correct? That figure should be expected to decline on a quarterly basis, as it has been doing. Then you factor in the Howard piece, which is $600,000 per quarter, as we discussed. So on a net-net basis, it will land somewhere in the range of $3 million to $3.5 million each quarter across the next several quarters — that includes all of the Howard amount plus what we had previously.
Timur Braziler
analystUnderstood. Alright, that helps. Thanks. And I have one additional follow-up. It's great to see the pipeline being rebuilt. I'm just curious—when you look ahead at expected loan growth for this year, will the mix look similar to what we saw in the back half of '21, or given some of these new digital initiatives, should we anticipate more loan production coming from the consumer side rather than the commercial side?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, as we begin the year, we're seeing fairly strong production coming out of consumer bank overall, and I'd attribute that to a couple of factors. Part of it is simply economic—macroeconomic. Part of it is embedding the e-Store into our mobile application and our online offerings. Essentially, what we did with those products was put them in front of the client repeatedly through those digital channels, so they can act on it quite easily, schedule an appointment, and go see someone at a branch. For instance, it's been added to our online user base, and we've grown online users 10% year-over-year. We now have over 900,000 enrolled users; our mobile banking is up 12%. The share of mortgage applications we've pushed through our e-Store has reached 60% of production, which is up from 59. We've invested quite heavily in a number of areas. But if you look at total e-Store visits that I mentioned, that's up 56% year-over-year; so for us that's a very sensible way to advertise our products and services, particularly when macroeconomic factors fluctuate. People need to borrow money for renovation or renovation; so that appears to be working for us. The data analytics tools we've put in place and the leads we're able to generate, some analysis we do on pools of data in our data hub—that has helped us immensely. We can find opportunities within the systemic way. We can find opportunities within the portfolio and then capitalize on them by reaching out to those customers proactively; and if you look at all of those statistics together, there's quite a bit going on there, and it's driving that activity. On the commercial side, I think we're well positioned. We have very, very good bankers across the footprint—high-quality bankers; we don't have many carpetbaggers, just plenty of bankers—I ran corporate banking groups for a long time. There are lots of bankers who move around from bank to bank to bank. We don't have much of that; we have pretty sound, respected bankers in each of the markets. They've not been going around 50 times. We may have attracted them. Your career opportunities. We really depend pretty heavily on their skill set. Salesmanship being one of a series of skills that we expect. So I think we're starting to see the benefits of all of this. Anyway.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat's — production in the first quarter was very strong resignation levels, very strong.
Vince Delie
executiveWe saw robust origination activity.
Timur Braziler
analystExcellent — thanks for that detail; it’s very helpful.
Vince Delie
executiveOkay. Thanks very much.
Tyler Marks
analystHello, good morning; Tyler Marks here, sitting in for Casey. To follow up on Frank's question regarding appetite for share buybacks, how far beneath your target fee — the C1 ratio of 10% — are you actually willing to go?
Vince Calabrese
executiveWhat I'd say is that's genuinely the target we manage toward. This quarter we're at 10.0, a year ago we were at 10.0, and I believe 9.9 in the quarter before that; so that really is the level we treat as our floor to manage to. Given the earnings generation capabilities along with the expectation for higher rates, obviously that produces more earnings, which builds toward our guidance; so we'll use that as a governor, and we'll — we depended on how much loan activity there is. If loan activity were lower for some reason, we'd be more accurate here; but if you look at what we did with the first program, we bought back $111 million at a very attractive price, as I mentioned. We were opportunistic when the opportunity presented itself and the markets were dipping, and this will take our stock to a very attractive value. So we will keep being opportunistic. And we were down to $30 million or so, so we're aligned to approve a new level to give us that flexibility to manage capital. So 10 really is the governor we're using; we think that's a good level for us, for our profile as a company. And as we move up above that, we'll opportunistically do share buybacks.
Tyler Marks
analystAll right, got it. And then what are you doing about the secular pressures we're seeing with the overdraft fee? And does your fee guide assume any of that impact within service charges?
Vince Delie
executiveSorry, could you say that again?
Tyler Marks
analystWhat steps are you taking in response to the secular pressures showing up in overdraft fees, and does your fee guide factor any of that effect into service charges?
Vince Delie
executiveI didn't catch "secular pressure" — I was trying to figure out what that referred to. So I did hear it — I understand what you mean. To start with, we had — we launched a product that carries bank-on certification, which we recommend to clients, especially those worried they might overdraw or run into an overdraft problem, and it simply will not allow it; so with the product we provide, you cannot overdraw the account. If an overdraft occurs because of some POS transaction or some posting issue, the customer gets it refunded, so we have this product that we launched. For us it's a Top 4 product — in fact it's the third most popular checking account product. So it has already affected overdraft fees for us; and we've made quite a few changes to our overdraft practices over the years and intend to keep making those changes; and I believe we said, when we launched the guide for the year on the income, that we expected that category to decline as the year went on. So that's one more area. Put that together with the mortgage and other capital markets area I mentioned — there will be headwind pressure that we have to overcome and make up for. That's another category. I don't have a precise figure for you, it isn't at my fingertips, but it's a fairly meaningful decline that we anticipated because of that pressure. And more changes to our practices are on the way, but it's reflected in the guides we gave you at the start of the year.
Vince Calabrese
executiveOne more thing I'd mention: those consumer fees run roughly $6 million to $7 million each quarter.
Vince Delie
executiveRight.
Vince Calabrese
executivePutting it in perspective.
Tyler Marks
analystUnderstood. Thanks so much.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThank you.
Vince Delie
executiveTake care.
Michael Perito
analystYeah, thanks. I just have one final clarification question for you. I was curious whether you could comment — you mentioned Howard doing well and some of the appetite around the buyback, maybe by putting the whole capital deployment picture together for us as we move forward. It seems the fundamental outlook is fairly bullish for you guys, with margins moving higher and growth pipelines filled. The expense guide was unchanged. I mean, how do you view the new buyback program versus incremental M&A as you look out over the next 12 to 18 months, just in terms of capital deployment priorities, as you see it? That'd be great. Thanks.
Vince Delie
executiveWe've devoted considerable effort to modeling and assessing every one of these options, and from a return-on-capital standpoint we compare loan growth with buybacks, and we apply that same lens to M&A. What guides our choices is whatever serves the company and its shareholders best going forward, so we aim to strike that balance. My view is that if loan growth fails to show up, or if there aren't accretive M&A opportunities delivering returns well above our cost of capital, then having the capacity to repurchase shares gives us one more lever for essentially handing capital back to shareholders. We view that as a fallback, and from there we assess the alternative. I wouldn't dismiss any possibility, though I'm also not suggesting anything is on the horizon. I'm merely saying we are quite disciplined about how we put capital to work, considering how it affects tangible book value dilution, the earn-back period, and everything along those lines.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnd the main priority—loan growth is the main priority for capital's future.
Vince Delie
executiveExactly right.
Vince Calabrese
executiveSo really <<inaudible>> loan growth is robust, and that's where our capital will go. If it's closed the way Vince mentioned, then we'll be looking at buybacks and getting more active with the buyback.
Michael Perito
analystUnderstood. Just so we're clear, then — assuming your growth guidance is met as anticipated and no further M&A materializes during this year, you'd expect buybacks to be used to some degree, given the market as it stands?
Vince Delie
executiveYes.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah.
Michael Perito
analystUnderstood, excellent. Thanks, everyone.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks, Michael.
Russell Gunther
analystHey there, good morning, everyone.
Vince Calabrese
executiveHello, Russell.
Vince Delie
executiveMorning, Russ.
Russell Gunther
analystGood morning. To get a broader picture and better grasp how you see the operating environment from a growth standpoint: on one hand, we've discussed how pipelines are frequently mentioned and that's boosting confidence in that mid to high single-digit range. On the other, given the possibility of a softer environment, there's some caution from a credit watch perspective — just the things you're watching there; so does that mid-single-digit guidance assume a stable operating environment — a growth environment — or are you factoring in the chance of some software growth in the back half of the year, recessionary pressures, just to help me frame it, that would be great. Thank you.
Vince Delie
executiveMy view is that mid-single-digits captures the situation as it exists right now, factoring in the things we flagged as potential trouble spots. I'm not trying to scare anyone; as I mentioned, no softness has shown up so far, but these are the kinds of areas where any careful observer would conclude, look, we've got several challenges heading our way that we need to be ready to handle, correct? So that might end up causing the US economy to slow and demand for loans to drop; and the commercial segment would feel it first. I've come across several economics reports suggesting consumer spending might fall off during the second half of this year—that's a topic people are discussing. Certain economists argue that consumers are holding up better than anticipated; time will tell how that unfolds. When you consider the current situation—and all we really know is what's occurring at our own bank and inside our portfolios, correct? As I noted, the consumer portfolio pipeline has reached record highs. The mortgage business has moved quite sharply toward purchase money. During Q1, the commercial side decelerated. We faced the Ukraine war, certain supply-chain interruptions, and a really strong Q4 pipeline that got closed — the closed cap that went back into production — plus some seasonal softness. So what we expect, and what's baked into our guidance, is a slower start to the year, with activity picking up much as it did a year ago. We sat in the same position last year, with slightly stronger growth in Q1 than last year, and the consumer bank had nowhere close to the production and pipelines we're carrying now. I hope that covers it for you. I want to stay careful about how much growth we can expect as the year unfolds. With Gary—who is highly capable—alongside the team, Tom Fisher, and everyone here, we're keeping a close eye on developments and will keep tracking them, since we have no wish to expand headlong into a downturn. That's the reason our guidance looks the way it does. All of it is already accounted for. We thought it through seriously and put substantial effort into the modeling. We built it from the ground up, portfolio by portfolio, and that's how we got to where we are.
Russell Gunther
analystAppreciate that, Vince. That's exactly the sort of detail I was hoping to get a clearer picture of, so thanks for weighing in.
Vince Delie
executiveI understand why it comes across as confusing, since on one side we're telling you, look, we're going to hit loan growth in the mid to high single digits; and on the other side, we're telling you we're quite worried about some developments in the economic backdrop that might affect that growth during the back half of the year. So I'd say — I'd say with the geographic diversification and the quality of the credit portfolio skill, or bank skills, we're able to reach our guidance.
Russell Gunther
analystThanks for the detail. That's all I had, everyone. Appreciate it.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThank you.
Brody Preston
analystHey, good morning, everyone.
Vince Delie
executiveHi, Brody.
Brody Preston
analystI only wanted to follow up. Appreciate all the detail you gave on the securities book earlier. My question is just to confirm — Vince, did you say $134 million each quarter in cash flows is what you're putting back to work? And then, can you give us some sense of how the new yields compare with what's coming off, given that re-pricing cadence?
Vince Calabrese
executiveRegarding the twelve-month cash flow we projected at $1 billion, which is coming off a yield of 174 — if you look at where we're deploying capital, thus far this quarter we've put $150 million to work in April at yields nearer to 3%. New purchases remain in that roughly 3.5 to 4 duration band, slightly toward the higher end of it, but still inside that <<inaudible>>; those are the moving pieces there, Brody, if that answers your question.
Brody Preston
analystUnderstood — that's useful, thanks. I did want to ask about when the increases you're all modeling are scheduled. I realize the 50 is in May, but past that point, from a timing standpoint, where does the extra 75 come from?
Vince Delie
executiveIt's pretty much one for meeting Brody after that.
Brody Preston
analystUnderstood, thanks Chris. I did have a single follow-up question regarding the capital markets business. Could you refresh my memory? I realize there is a great deal that factors into it, but would you remind me what the primary revenue drivers are inside capital markets?
Vince Delie
executiveSure. We have syndications. We handle both large CRE and C&I syndication; we also run a sizable derivatives practice, which I mentioned earlier and which is mainly focused on interest rate derivatives, though within that area we can also do commodity-based derivatives. On top of that there's international banking, which we fold into capital markets for reporting simplicity, since in the international space we provide hedging products as well as spot transactions. And then there's what I refer to as the debt capital markets platform, where we take part in bond economics for public bond offerings — that business got started last year. I believe that covers essentially all of it; these are the main areas generating most of the revenue in capital markets; and syndications here are lumpy, correct? Because you land large syndications, and when you've structured it right you earn a heavier fee than you would on a best efforts arrangement. The debt capital markets side is lumpy as well, since when you're in a larger deal and we might be picking up syndications, the income comes because we're part of distribution and we're now getting bond economics, because the company has issued public debt or is included in the syndicate. In any case, those are the businesses we put on.
Brody Preston
analystUnderstood, and thanks. I’ve got just a couple more questions here. The first concerns expenses. Could you perhaps help us understand what might lead you to land either at the low end or at the high end of the expense guidance — specifically, are there particular items that come to mind that would push it in one direction or the other?
Vince Calabrese
executiveAs you know, we keep a very close grip on costs across the company, and that discipline has been in place for many years. In the 2022 guidance we gave, as we said back in January, there was a target of $10 million in cost savings. Given the timing within the quarter, the cost savings from Howard are still to be realized, and some of that has already come through — we're on track with what we laid out early on. Commissions tied to production are always one of the drivers, so they can swing based on business activity across the different businesses. So that's a swing item; it could shift quarter-to-quarter and move you within that range. But we'll keep managing expenses tightly the way we always have, and I think the full-year range is a pretty tight one, so really the key drivers for us — and we've discussed before RPA continuing to pursue ways to automate our processes and making that just continuous every day, and there's more opportunity to set things up to get done quicker. There's opportunity there as well. But again, for the guidance it's a pretty tight range.
Brody Preston
analystThen for my final question, Vince, I have a quick follow-up. I appreciate the detail you provided on deposit betas, which they are modeling. I believe you said 40% was the interest-bearing figure in that context; that is fairly consistent with the prior cycle. So I suppose what I wanted to ask is — regarding what you did on the interest-bearing deposit beta side during the last cycle — I guess I wanted to hear your thoughts on what is causing the beta to come in near the prior cycle. I think many people at first, simply because of the improvements across the industry when it comes to liquidity, lower loan-to-deposit ratios, moving off cash, higher securities balances, were thinking that perhaps betas might lag the last cycle at least on a percentage basis. But the assumption you are making suggests you expect them to be in line. So could you share any detail on why you anticipate that?
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure. What we said on the prior call was that we’d aimed for roughly 50%, which is perhaps the historical level, and conditions are notably different when it comes to system liquidity. So to start with, we’re already below that, at 40, and as I noted earlier, we’re again taking a conservative stance on the Betas. We’ll manage them so as to optimize earnings for the Company as a whole and won’t be more aggressive than necessary. So, as I said before, I believe there is some conservatism built into that. Yet even at 40, we are inside of — I think that’s what we stated last quarter. So we’re at 40. And I think the speed of the shifts, how rapid they are, the sizable magnitude, 50 basis point moves, is simply something we must manage closely. And customers become more alert as things unfold. So it’s just — it’s just for all of us to note that; but I’d simply say the 40s, inside the 50s, so it already reaches the bottom line, and then there’s conservatism with that status.
Brody Preston
analystUnderstood. Thanks a lot for fielding my questions and for making room for us all this morning, everyone. I appreciate it.
Vince Calabrese
executiveOkay. Thank you.
Vince Delie
executiveThank you.
Brian Martin
analystHey, guys. Thanks for taking the questions — just a couple of follow-ups here. On the yields for new loans, Vince, could you — for commercial loans, could you just talk about where those stand — where they're coming in today?
Vince Calabrese
executiveFor new loans overall, I'd say they came in at 309 during the quarter, versus 291 last quarter. So clearly a nice move up. The overall spot portfolio rate, ex-PPP, which sounded like $180 million, went up 10 basis points to 322; so those are all-in figures there.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. Alright, that helps. Then just a few more housekeeping items. Regarding the line of credit leases and line utilization — it didn't seem like that rose much this quarter. Is that accurate, or is it roughly the same as last quarter, with the expectation being that it will move higher, or is that basically what I'm hearing?
Vince Delie
executiveWith the debt capital markets platform, I believe we completed some bigger transactions that were unfunded. So in that sense — we earned the income. So at some point we'd expect those to fund, correct? So we carried over larger commitments with lower borrowings against them. That's one part of it. The other part is, as I've mentioned, if we look closely at the different segments, we saw certain areas beginning to grow and expand — small business, middle market banking on the C&I side saw expansion — and then we brought on some large construction yields and those large corporate transactions, which held us steady or actually pushed it back a bit, essentially flat, but slightly lower. If you removed those from the picture, we saw utilization expand. I don't have the precise figures for you, but that's what we observed.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood.
Vince Calabrese
executiveOne more thing I'd mention: broadly speaking, when you compare year over year, it really didn't climb past 3 points going from the first quarter of last year to the first quarter of this year. After that, it's held fairly steady relative to where it stood at year-end, in that mid 30s.
Vince Delie
executiveMy expectation is that it keeps climbing as time goes on. Historically, that figure sat in the 42% to 44% range, and at some point we anticipate it returning to that level.
Brian Martin
analystAll right, and then just a final couple — regarding the Howard expense savings, is the second quarter largely a clean quarter, given the back-office consolidation that happened this quarter, I suppose? So how should we be thinking about that clean expense quarter?
Vince Delie
executiveYes, so as we said in the announcement, we expect the cost saves to be greater than 50%, and we're well on track to get the 85% phase-in that we discussed during 2022. I mean, Howard really didn't add that many expenses this quarter. I mean, we're talking a number of less than mid-single-digit million. So I think we have a pretty good handle on the expenses, and we're all watching out for the rest of the year.
Vince Calabrese
executiveBrian, my guess is it would be more like Q3 before you’re really clean or you try to force it. I mean, Q2, sure.
Vince Delie
executiveAt the moment we're operating out of two branches because some renovations are underway. Should those wrap up over the summer, we expect to see the final piece of the tail emerge.
Brian Martin
analystAll right, that helps; and then regarding the prudence you mentioned around certain items, just the reserve coverage with some of the noise this quarter involving Howard — I mean, given your credit quality outlook, which seems quite solid, though with some caution, where do you see that reserve? How might the level, the reserve coverage, trend over the coming couple of quarters?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveOn the reserve, I mean, we've stayed very prudent throughout the pandemic and didn't make any big releases, as you know. With the headwinds we're seeing out there — inflation, supply chain, transportation costs, higher interest rates — those things, as we've discussed, we're cautious about, and they can affect borrowers sitting at the lower end of the liquidity range or the higher end of the leverage range. We were flat this quarter at 138 even with Howard included. We feel comfortable with that level at present, and we'll keep watching how it all unfolds going forward — it's only 3 basis points of charge-offs. Another factor that will matter there is loan growth. We've discussed that quite a bit today, and it has its effect. So I'd say that we're looking at, right now, the guide of 20 to 40, and it will likely land at the low end of that guide given how strong the book is at present. It certainly can, but I'd expect that with all the headwinds, we'll stay cautious on those items as we go forward.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. Thanks, Gary. And then just one final thing, Vince Calabrese — I guess just, last quarter you mentioned the liquidity levels, maybe reducing that by half come year-end. I think you're at a similar level on liquidity at the moment, I guess, is that still what you expect, or is this how you're viewing things?
Vince Calabrese
executiveHard to say. Deposits continue to grow, PPP <> another $180 million of forgiveness, and that flows into the coffers as well, so I'd think that's probably too low at this point, and we'll see how the year unfolds, Brian, but we've already begun moving down, and we've said that for six quarters now; so those deposits are growing quickly. I'd think we'd begin to slowly bring that number down, but the pace of it is just hard to say with certainty.
Brian Martin
analystYes, sure. Alright, thanks for fielding our questions, folks.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks.
Vince Delie
executiveThank you, Brian.
Brody Preston
analystHi everyone, apologies for jumping back in this way. Only a single quick item. Can you remind me what amount remains in PPP fees from here on? I realize the portfolio has gotten smaller. I simply want to be certain I grasp what's still left for you.
Vince Delie
executive$3.5 million.
Brody Preston
analystAwesome. Thank you very much.
Vince Delie
executiveOkay, first off, thanks for all the thoughtful questions. A few of them I thought were great. Glad we could answer them. If we didn't get to you or didn't get to your question, please give us a call; we posted fairly extensive data, and we'll walk you through it; but thank you; we appreciate your support and look forward to — we've got a lot of work to do. It was a good solid quarter, but there's still a lot in front of us and we plan on executing. So I want to thank the employees for a great start; and we'll keep working on your behalf; so thank you very much for joining me on the call, all of us. Take care, guys.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings the conference to a close. We appreciate your joining today's presentation. You're welcome to disconnect your lines now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.