F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 20, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lisa Hajdu
executiveThanks. Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call. This conference call from F.N.B. Corporation, along with the report it submits to the Securities and Exchange Commission, frequently includes forward-looking statements as well as non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP financial measures ought to be considered alongside our reported results prepared under GAAP, not as a substitute for them. You can find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, matched against the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures, within our presentation materials and our earnings release. We encourage you to review those non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures that appear in our related materials, reports, and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available on our corporate website. A replay of this call can be accessed through Friday, April 29th. The webcast link will be made available under the About Us Investor Relations section of our corporate website. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks. I appreciate everyone joining our first-quarter earnings call. With me are Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, and Gary Guerrieri, our Chief Credit Officer. F.N.B. posted first-quarter net income available to common stockholders of $144.5 million, or $0.40 per diluted common share. On an operating basis, EPS rose 54% compared with the first quarter of 2022. Operating free provision net revenue was up 68% versus the year-ago quarter, as we delivered positive operating leverage of 21%. F.N.B.'s strong financial results came from steady execution of the strategic initiatives we had already laid out. To illustrate, we sought to broaden income and draw on multiple sources to sustain performance. In this quarter, F.N.B. recorded wealth management revenue of $18 million on a linked-quarter basis, a record, which helped keep non-interest income stable. We also aim to serve as our customers' primary operating bank. Thanks to deep customer relationships and a granular deposit base, we kept average deposit balances steady. Our approach of applying consistent and prudent underwriting standards no matter the macroeconomic backdrop helped FNB increase average loans 3.6% from the quarter while not sacrificing asset quality. The first quarter also brought favorable momentum across several key performance metrics, among them return on tangible common equity of 20%, return on average assets of 1.4%, and a tangible common equity ratio of 7.5%, among the highest levels in the company's history. We are happy with the results for this quarter and think they confirm the execution of our strategy described above, particularly our conservative and diligent balance sheet management, with ample capital and liquidity to endure the adversity in the industry in a more challenging economic environment. The recent bank failures, however idiosyncratic they may be, have highlighted how important liquidity is for keeping a diversified and granular deposit base, conservative and prudent balance sheet management, solid capital levels, and sound risk management policies and governance. Such practices have always been central to F.N.B.'s long-term strategy and are embedded in our enterprise risk management program, which encompasses regular liquidity stress test analysis, capital stress testing, CECL reserve model analysis, and diligent proactive credit monitoring. As I have said before on multiple calls, I mean, we build close relationships with our customers and stay focused on being their primary operating bank. Beyond prioritizing high-touch service, we have made strategic investments in our digital technology, treasury management platform, and payment solution capabilities, which enables our customer privacy. The first-quarter deposit levels through the industry disruption demonstrate the success of our focus on growing client relationships, with deposits finishing the quarter at $34.2 billion, a slight decline of 1.7% from the prior quarter, outperforming the HA deposit data for small and large banks. Between March eighth, when the industry volatility began, and quarter end, our deposit balances were essentially flat, declining 0.7%, mainly because of seasonal outflows from normal wholesale and retail customer activity. We also benefit from having a wide variety of depositors across our various customer categories, and consumer account balances make up the biggest portion of overall deposits, at 41%. Roughly 1 million accounts fall within the consumer segment, and the median balance for a consumer deposit at the close of the quarter stood at about $5,000. On top of that, starting on March eighth, we saw a net gain in account count spanning every customer segment. This puts FNB in a favorable spot as deposit inflows return to typical levels and customers spread their funds among multiple banks. Thanks to how granular our deposit base is, FNB closed the quarter with roughly 76% of deposits that were either FDIC-insured or collateralized, a figure above the peer median for the 50 banks in the KBW Bank Index it mirror edges. Should the need arise, we likewise hold available liquidity sufficient to cover as much as 170% of our uninsured and non-collateralized deposit balances as of March 31, which leaves FNB in an exceptionally strong liquidity position. When it comes to duration and risk, F.N.B.'s approach to its investment portfolio is conservative by nature as well. We target an average duration of 3 to 5 years and have kept a fairly balanced mix between Available-for-Sale and Held-to-Maturity over time. When the banking industry disruption first hit, F.N.B. management put our contingency funding plan into action. Our team responded quickly, putting in diligent work across the weekend to make sure our board of directors received briefings, employees felt reassured about our stability, and customer-facing staff started proactive outreach to clients with talking points about the strength of our balance sheet, covering F.N.B.'s capital and liquidity position both relative to peers and on a standalone basis. Beyond that, we strengthened our liquidity by adding close to $1 billion in cash to the balance sheet. Across the financial crisis, the pandemic, and now this banking industry disruption, F.N.B. has won our customers' trust. We are committed to honoring that trust, since we have positioned the company to beat the industry across a broad range of possible economic and industry scenarios. Credit remains one of our strengths as well. I am delighted to report yet again a solid credit position, with low delinquency at 60 basis. I will now hand the call over to Gary, who will provide further detail on our asset quality and our steady management of credit risk. Gary?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveAppreciate that, Vince, and hello everyone. We wrapped up the quarter with the credit portfolio sitting in good shape, and asset quality measures continuing to sit near lows we haven't seen much of historically. Looking at how the period came out, total delinquency ended at 60 basis points, while NPLs and OREO came in at 38 basis points, and net charge-offs landed at 18 basis points. Criticized loans ticked up slightly to 19 basis points from the previous quarter, yet they fell 55 basis points year over year and are still at levels that are historically quite low. I'll take a closer look at the GAAP asset quality items for this quarter, and then I'll offer my thoughts on how we approach credit strategy to steer the loan portfolio through different points in the economic cycle. Now let's turn to our credit results. Delinquency on a total basis dropped 11 basis points in the quarter, which leaves it at the low levels relative to history that we've recorded in earlier quarters. NPLs and OREO were down 1 basis point versus the prior quarter, and 55% of our NPLs are currently making payments as contractually required. Net charge-offs totaled $13.2 million for the quarter, equal to 18 basis points annualized, and 11 basis points of that came from drawing on specific reserves set aside previously. For the quarter, we set aside $14.9 million in total provision expense, which covered loan growth and charge-offs lacking a previously established specific reserve. Model builds tied to CECL came in at a moderate level, around $4 million. During the quarter, our ending funded reserve increased by $1.7 million, reaching $403 million — a solid 1.32% of loans, which speaks to the strong position we hold relative to peers. Once acquired unamortized loan discounts are factored in, that reserve figure comes to 1.49%, and our coverage of NPLs remains strong at 356%. Our commitment to consistent underwriting and credit risk management stays firm, so that we keep a balanced, well-positioned portfolio across economic cycles. We make a point of examining and stress testing our portfolios regularly, and we did that again this quarter. During that process, we took a close look at commercial real estate loans set to mature in 2023 and 2024. The results made us happy: no risk ratings had to be adjusted. That outcome wasn't a surprise, since our commercial real estate book is diversified, our sponsors are solid, and our LTVs are low. Turning to office, delinquencies are still quite small, at 27 basis points, while criticized loans sit under 10%. The average size of our 25 largest office exposures is $28 million, and loans below $5 million make up 43% of that group. Our approach to this portfolio involves aggressive oversight, loan by loan, which is built into the thorough assessments we conduct on a routine basis. To wrap up, the quarter went well, reflecting both the resilience and advantageous standing of our credit book as we keep producing varied lending expansion across appealing regions. We keep a close watch on broader economic developments along with each specific market inside our territory, and proactive, forceful risk management will remain central to how we handle credit, an approach that has proven valuable during periods of weaker economic conditions. At this point, Vince Calabrese, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer, will provide his remarks during this call.
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveThanks, Gerry. Good morning, everybody. I'll spend today on our first-quarter financial results, give you some context around what we did with the balance sheet while the banking system was disrupted in March, and share updated guidance for the rest of 2023. Net income available to common shareholders for Q1 came to $144.5 million, equal to $0.40 per share, reflecting record revenue contributions, expenses that were seasonally higher, and asset quality that continued to perform solidly. Total earning assets hit a record, finishing the quarter at $39.3 billion, up $352 million from the prior quarter, as loans and leases rose $418 million, which is 5.6% annualized. Commercial loans were up $222 million, or 4.7% annualized, thanks to our strategy of growing high-quality loans across a diverse geographic footprint continuing to work well. Commercial production came in a bit lighter than in Q4, which is normal seasonality, but attrition got better and loan pipelines rose on a linked-quarter basis following the strong production we saw last quarter. Consumer loans rose $196 million from the prior quarter, or 7.3% annualized, as residential mortgage growth of $292 million was partly offset by declines in average direct home equity installment loan balances, consumer lines of credit, and indirect auto loans. With rates where they are, organic residential mortgage growth shows customers still favoring adjustable rate mortgages, along with our Physicians First mortgage program continuing to succeed, and we are presently holding both in portfolio. The investment portfolio held steady at $7.3 billion, 46% of which is available for sale. If you include the fair value marks on our AFS and HTM portfolios, our CET1 ratio sits above the peer median computed the same way, and we stay well capitalized. The duration of our securities portfolio was 4.5 years at March 31st, and 3.9 years once cash is included. Total deposits finished the quarter at $34.2 billion. That $580 million linked-quarter decrease, or 1.7%, was mostly normal Q1 seasonality; actually, deposits have been fairly flat since March 8th, edging down just 0.7% from ordinary outflows tied to wholesale and retail customer activity. Vince noted earlier that our median consumer deposit balance was $5,000 at the end of March. Looking across the whole deposit portfolio, the average account balance comes to roughly $30,000, far under Silicon Valley Bank's $1.1 million average and Signature Bank's $508,000; we're also below our peer median as of year-end. Deposit mix did move this quarter, with time deposits up $1.1 billion as customers shifted funds out of money market accounts to capture better CD rates. At March 31st, non-interest-bearing deposits made up a still-strong 33% of total deposits, a modest dip from 34% at year-end. Our loan-to-deposit ratio stayed at a comfortable level, finishing the quarter under 90%. Because of the disruption in the banking industry, we chose to strengthen on-balance sheet liquidity by adding roughly $1 billion of short- and long-term borrowings combined, which lifted our excess cash position to $1.3 billion at quarter end. On the income statement side, we posted record quarterly revenue of $416 million. That was fueled by net interest income of $337 million, which rose $1.8 million from the prior quarter, or 0.5%. Net interest margin widened by 3 basis points, as earning asset yields climbed 39 basis points — loan yields were up 42 basis points — while our cost of funds rose 38 basis points. Obviously, keeping deposit costs in check in this rate setting remains a major priority for us. Spot interest-bearing deposit costs finished the quarter at 171, and the quarterly average was 150, which speaks to the continued hard work our team is putting in. Cumulative deposit rates overall came in at 21.8% at quarter end, inside the 22% guidance we gave previously. Now on to non-interest income and expense: non-interest income came to $79.4 million, down just 1.5% versus last year's Q4. Wealth management hit a record $18 million, up $2.4 million quarter over quarter. That was mostly divided between securities commissions and fees, lifted by robust annuity revenue, and trust services, mainly from solid organic growth seasonality. Greater production and contingent revenues produced a $30.3 million, or 73%, quarter-over-quarter gain in insurance commissions and fees, and mortgage banking operations income rose $2.1 million from the prior quarter, mirroring a 5% rise in sold mortgage volume along with better gain on sale margins. Capital markets income fell $3.2 million because of fewer syndications and swap fees compared with the exceptionally strong levels seen in Q4 of 2022. Service charges declined $2.9 million this quarter, mostly due to the anticipated drop in overdraft and non-sufficient fund charges stemming from the fee program changes we announced earlier, in light of today's competitive environment. Operating non-interest expense was $218 million, up 11% from Q4, mainly from typical seasonality, plus a full quarter of the Union expense base and the effect of the FDIC insurance assessment rate increase we previously announced. Salaries and employee benefits were up $17 million, with roughly $12 million tied to normal seasonal compensation activity, including $6.7 million of long-term compensation and seasonally elevated employer-paid payroll taxes. The other $5 million of the increase comes mostly from lower salary deferrals given reduced loan origination volumes and the added Union expense base from the acquisition. Despite these expense items, our efficiency ratio stayed at a healthy 50.6%. Capital ratios at quarter end came in at levels we expect to be at or above the peer median. Tangible book value per common share stood at $8.66 as of March 31st, up $0.39 per share, or 4.7%, from December 31st, driven largely by stronger earnings and a smaller AOCI impact, which cut tangible book value at the end of the current quarter by $0.87 per share versus $0.99 at year-end. As Vince noted, our TCE ratio sits at 7.5%, among the highest in the company's history. To show how solid this level is even with all the disruption in the industry, our TCE, once you adjust for unrealized losses on HTM, came to 6.9%, and that figure sits 50 basis points above the median among our peers when you use their reported year-end levels. Now let's move on to what we're targeting financially for 2023, and we'll begin with the balance sheet. Looking at full-year spot, we kept the same guidance we gave before, which calls for loans rising mid-single digits compared with a year earlier. We expect total deposits to finish 2023 around the same spot level they stood at on December 31, 2022, though we do anticipate that the mix of deposits will keep shifting because of where rates stand right now. For the whole year, Net Interest Income should land somewhere between $1.315 billion and $1.365 billion, and for Q2 it should come in at $325 million-$335 million. What we're guiding to right now bakes in a 25 basis point hike in May, followed by no changes for the rest of the year. The small trim to guidance versus last quarter mostly stems from our view that deposit betas will be higher, given the conditions the banking industry currently faces. Should rates decline during this year, which is what the forward curve presently anticipates, we might see a modest amount of upside to the NII figure we're forecasting. For non-interest income across the full year, the range we expect is $305 million to $320 million, a slight bump up that mirrors how we beat our earlier guidance in Q1. Q2 should land in the mid $70 million range, with ongoing gains from our strategy of diversified revenue. On an operating basis, the full-year guidance for non-interest expense is $835 million-$855 million. This change reflects the elevated Q1 expense levels, while the other 9 months ought to line up with what we guided previously. For Q2, non-interest expense should fall between $205 million-$210 million. Provision guidance for the full year stays at $65 million-$85 million, and it hinges on net loan growth along with possible CECL model related bills stemming from a weaker macroeconomic backdrop. As for the effective tax rate, it ought to be in the 20% to 21% range across the full year, and that excludes any investment tax credit activity that might take place. I'll hand the call back over to Vince. Insurance commissions and fees rose $3.3 million, or 73%, from the prior quarter.
Vince Delie
executiveThe way we run our business conservatively has put F.N.B. in a position to keep delivering dependable results even while our sector faces disruptions. At the close of Q1, our capital standing was robust and our deposit base remained steady, and we have every confidence that this groundwork sets us up to take advantage of opportunities over the coming months. There is a direct link between how F.N.B. performs financially and our ability to preserve an outstanding culture; our distinctive culture is something we take pride in, along with the recognition we have earned for leading our industry in the experiences we provide to employees and clients. During 2023, F.N.B. received selection as a Celent Model Bank for omni-channel retail delivery, recognizing our proprietary eStore. Forbes named us one of America's best banks. Energage recognized us as a Top Workplaces USA. For the 12th consecutive year, we won a Greenwich Excellence Award for client service. Recognition also keeps coming for how we embrace diversity and inclusion — as one of America's greatest workplaces for LGBTQ Plus, as a Best of the Best company from three diversity publications, and as a Women's Choice Award winner for women and millennial women. These honors were earned by FNB thanks to the effort and commitment of our staff, who embrace the same dedication to our values and mission that we hold. We appreciate our team for building a setting that delivers shareholder value while also treating each other with respect and achieving success as one. Mistake I made up here.
Lisa Hajdu
executiveI think it's because you're human and not an AI machine.
Vince Delie
executiveBe an AI machine.
Lisa Hajdu
executiveAll right. That one's great. Is there anything you would like to re-record?
Frank Schiraldi
analystGood morning. Vince, you brought up either that negative carry or the extra liquidity sitting on the balance sheet. I'm just curious how large that negative carry actually is, and whether it's mainly what's pushing the NII guidance lower, or if the mix shift matters more. My sense is things are now accelerating somewhat as you move into time.
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveFrank, that negative carry is honestly around 10, perhaps 10, 15 basis points. It isn't all that meaningful, since we do earn something on our excess cash position. That figure remains at $1.3 billion. On that, we're earning 4.90%. As I recall, the borrowers we took down came in at roughly 40 or so; so it isn't a large negative carry. It's more a matter of mix shift and other things steadily rolling, with deposit rates where they currently sit.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAll right. I'm a bit curious — I'm not sure whether that level of detail is available to you right now — but when you consider the shift in mix that's built into your guidance, what does that imply about non-interest-bearing balances as a share of total deposits by year-end?
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveIt declines a little from here through the end of the year; it's not meaningful. That's a major area of emphasis for the company, as you're aware. Bringing in operating accounts has always been at the center of our approach to acquiring accounts and our lending approach. Those ongoing initiatives keep adding new accounts. Through this period of disruption, we've actually added accounts on a net basis. In percentage terms, we discuss customer primacy. What that refers to is being the main operating bank, or the disbursement bank, for consumers and businesses. If you look at the detail within the consumer book, which we referenced during the call in the prepared remarks.
Frank Schiraldi
analystRight.
Vince Delie
executiveThat one is quite stubborn, honestly. You know, options for getting a better return on $5,000 are limited. I'm not sure it packs enough of a punch to make folks shift their funds from place to place. For us, that's typically their main operating account. You know, they'll leave cash sitting there to handle items coming in for payment, and that's where direct deposit gets credited. Over on the business side, like we've mentioned before, when you look at how 17% of our deposits are concentrated in the commercial segment, a solid chunk of that is linked straight to services. You know, compensating balances where you pick up an earnings credit that sits in a non-interest bearing bucket and once again, tends to be sticky since customers would rather use balances to cover services than pay fees in cash. You know, all of that is baked into that non-interest DDA category; we feel pretty good about having a strong, steady base and at the very least, we feel we'll do better than others who might be leaning on more transaction , more fleeting balances. I think it demonstrates essentially, if you look back over time, you can spot it in how we perform compared with other banks in that category.
Frank Schiraldi
analystOkay, got it, and thanks for that. So for my final follow-up, I want to direct something to Gary regarding credit. In the slide deck you provided, there's discussion of average LTVs — if I recall correctly, that figure sits in the low sixties for the office book in particular. My assumption is that this mostly reflects values at the time the loans were originated. What I'd like to know is, given the thorough portfolio review you've conducted, what insights has that process yielded? If you're able to share, what has it revealed about how values have shifted across some of your markets with respect to the underlying properties, expressed in percentage terms? Thanks.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveFrank, we've gone back and revisited a number of valuations on those kinds of properties, and what we're generally finding is markdowns running from about 15% up to the high teens and even into the 20s. There was a single asset dealing with some occupancy problems, and that one went as high as the 30s. Still, up to now, that's the band we've been seeing. Among the ones we've needed to refresh, it's been more or less universal.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAlright, that's good. I'm grateful for it. Thank you.
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveFrank, I want to get some clarity regarding the negative carry issue. It slipped my mind that a certain share of what we drew down involved two-year money at roughly 4.40%, more or less on an all-in basis within the extra liquidity, which essentially carried no negative carry on an all-in flat basis.
Frank Schiraldi
analystOkay. Thank you.
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveThanks.
Daniel Tamayo
analystThank you. Morning, everybody. To start with, regarding the guidance on operating expense, could you provide some sense of why the overall outlook moved up, since my general assumption was that a reduced outlook ought to result in lower incentive compensation?
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveYes, Danny, I can address that. For the quarter, expenses on an operating basis totaled $218 million. Back in January, our range was $210 million-$215 million. So that's $3 million higher than the top of that range. Just lower deferrals on loan origination costs, caused by reduced consumer loan volumes compared with our plan, accounted for half of that variance; that represented roughly half of the $3 million gap. The remainder was essentially a few one-time items. When you look at our Q2 guidance, $205 million-$210 million, that's measured against a $218 million figure. This aligns with the original guidance we provided in January. Actually, the 9 months, as I noted during my prepared remarks, remains the same as what we previously stated. It's simply a mix of reduced FAS 91 deferrals, which is half, plus certain one-time items. Going ahead, as the year unfolds, commission incentive comp is variable, correct? It will rise or fall based on how much revenue we generate. That's a swing item, or a variable expense, that will shift based on when it ultimately; it's simply that it came in $3 million above the top of the range, so it isn't all that meaningful. Looking forward, we will handle expenses carefully, just as we always do.
Daniel Tamayo
analystThanks for that. My apologies — I overlooked what you said during the prepared remarks regarding the stable versus the earlier guidance for the remainder of the year, so I appreciate it. Now, perhaps a few questions for Gary on credit, starting with the first one. On the office portfolio, I'm grateful for all the extra detail. I was just curious whether you could break it down — I realize you said it's distributed throughout the footprint — but which properties are involved, and in which cities, or is it urban versus suburban? Is there any method by which we could obtain additional specifics about the sort of city where those offices are located?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveWell, what I'd say is, Daniel, most of the bigger office facilities sit in the metro cities. As we noted in the remarks, 43% — nearly half of that book — is below $5 million; those tend to be dispersed mostly throughout suburban markets. Regarding the appraisals, one property with leasing problems in Pittsburgh was written down; another in the Carolinas was written down. It's more or less across the board.
Vince Delie
executiveGary, just to be clear, as you mentioned, the overwhelming bulk of our CRE exposure is suburban in character. I realize you referred to metro markets, but we generally don't provide long-term financing for big office facilities, aside from our own. What I'm saying is we don't do that, we're not involved in that line of work, correct?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveNope. Since the mean comes to $28 million, well, that figure for the top 25 — $28 million — kind of tells the story on its own.
Vince Delie
executiveCorrect.
Daniel Tamayo
analystRegarding the kinds of assets and their geographic placement — we hold a minimal amount of office space located in urban, major downtown areas. Just a tiny sliver.
Vince Delie
executiveThe loan-to-value ratios we use are quite cautious. A share of the portfolio that sits in construction, once fully funded, generally has leases securing it. We avoid speculative projects almost entirely, doing very few. Leases serve as the backing for that. On the construction portions of the portfolio, LTVs will run somewhat higher than what exists in our book, since we prefer not to carry sizable exposures. We underwrite these with the expectation of a permanent takeout. I want everyone to clearly grasp that within the composition of the figures shown on our slide for non-owner occupied CRE: $25 million to $28 million.
Daniel Tamayo
analystOkay. Terrific.
Vince Delie
executiveRight.
Daniel Tamayo
analystThanks for that, Vince and Gary.
Vince Delie
executiveYep.
Daniel Tamayo
analystAnd then finally, as a quick follow-up — this isn't about office specifically, but more about the broader macro picture, I suppose. Reserves declined during the quarter, and that caught me a bit off guard. I'm just wondering what you think drove that decrease, and then what your view is on the macro outlook generally, I guess, compared with where things stood a quarter ago.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveYeah, so actually, the dollar amount of reserves wasn't lower. Reserves went from 133 to 132, meaning a drop of 1 basis point. They're still sitting at $403 million. As you know, we tapped some of those specific reserves I brought up during the prepared remarks, and that accounts for the 1 basis point. We basically view it as flattish. You know, when you...
Daniel Tamayo
analystYes.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveOnce you factor in the unamortized loan discounts totaling $149 million, our reserve position, when measured against peers, is quite robust. All right.
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveWhen I compare us to others, I believe we're running 20 to 25 basis points higher. If you examine the coverage level we hold and set that against what peers have, it amounts to a meaningful cushion beyond what those other companies have kept in their reserves.
Daniel Tamayo
analystGot it. That makes sense. Okay, I really appreciate all the detail. That's all I have. Thanks, everyone.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveYes, thank you.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks, Dan.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveThanks.
Timur Braziler
analystHello, and good morning. Timur Braziler here, stepping in for Jared. Perhaps we can pick up where the previous questions about the allowance ratio left off. As you mentioned, it's significantly higher than what our peers show. How much of the reserve for a possible recession has already been factored into your figures? And if the macro backdrop turns more punishing, would that buffer of 25 basis points still apply while everyone else plays catch-up, or is part of it already reflected in your more careful baseline?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveYes, Timur. From the moment we were 6 months into COVID, our stance has been a careful one. Our strong feeling was that this would remain a problem for a long while. Unlike other institutions, which freed up large amounts of reserves during that period, we chose not to; our perspective was that we should keep those reserves given what we anticipated ahead. Now we're entering what looks like a naturally weaker economic period. Those reserves have stayed in place. They sit comfortably inside our quantitative and qualitative boundaries. This is something we analyze every single month. In fact, we recalculate the reserve weekly, according to how the portfolio shifts from one week to the next. When you consider that situation, we're pleased with our current standing, and we will keep managing it in that same manner.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, that's helpful. So Gary, I've got one more for you, and it picks up where we were on the office book. If I'm remembering right, you gave us 13% maturing in 23 and 11% in 24. For the loans that are approaching that maturity or refi point, what rate would they be moving to? And how much confidence do you have that the occupancy and the trends underneath can handle the higher interest rate they'd be moving to?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveYes, during the quarter we went through each of the bigger credits very carefully. As I said in my remarks, there were no downgrades on those credits. They're handled by us routinely, one loan at a time. So that latest review, with no downgrades in it, factored in those maturity walls and the capacity to reset, generally around 7%. That's something we've already accounted for in those specific situations. I should add too that LTVs are mostly in the 60s. Of course, a portion of that will feel some pressure when leases roll off. Across that book the sponsorship is very strong, and, as I mentioned, given the latest review, which showed no downgrade, we see it as quite manageable.
Timur Braziler
analystGreat.
Vince Delie
executiveHey, Gary. Gary, regarding that question about how our reserves stack up against peers. One thing I think is worth pointing out: our ratios for criticized and classified loans tend to sit above those of other banks, and that's due to how aggressively we grade. That doesn't automatically mean net charge-offs follow. If you examine a long stretch of time, F.N.B. compared with the peers, we usually run higher, yet charge-offs come in lower across the cycle. What drives that is our credit folks being extremely aggressive and proactive when it comes to downgrading credits, and that produces a bigger reserve position. Within the portfolio, the gradation truly makes a difference. It's possible for other institutions to lag in assessing risk, and until a crisis is at its very tail end, they won't see reserves at the same level. You know, this ought to be seen as a positive rather than a negative. I simply want to ensure that's clear to everyone. Am I on task here, Gary?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveYou're right, Vincent, I'm on the same page with all of that. What I'd add is that when it comes to handling risk ratings, we take a very forceful approach, just like you pointed out. This portfolio is absolutely at the top of our list, and that's been the case for a good while now.
Timur Braziler
analystNo, that's helpful context, and I appreciate it. Perhaps this one is for Vince Calabrese; looking at slide 15, which covers interest rate sensitivity, it appears the impact from both the 100 basis point increase and the 100 basis point decrease has grown. I'm simply curious about what drives NII to gain in either an upward or a downward scenario.
Vince Delie
executiveWould you like to take that one?
Scott D. Free
executiveAlright, this is Scott Freed speaking, our Treasurer. As you're aware, the inverted yield curve has brought about a rather unusual situation: since deposit rates have at last begun rising in the down scenario, we will now begin seeing the advantage of shifting those balances somewhat more quickly than up.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, understood. So for my final question, do you have any views on the buyback? Banks are pretty inconsistent when it comes to either keeping it going or hitting pause. You folks were busy with it during Q1. I'd just like to know whether you can share any detail on what got repurchased after March 8th, and then how you see the buyback shaping up from here.
Scott D. Free
executiveLet me begin by noting that when you compare our capital standing against that of peers, we look distinctive thanks to the modest AOCI hit and the way we've managed our investment portfolio conservatively. Thanks to Scott, who is seated here with us. That, in my view, leaves us situated differently. As you know, on CET1, we've already reached the level we set as our target, correct? We anticipate that capital appreciation will keep lifting those capital ratios higher. That hands us somewhat greater flexibility than what others have. That said, we remain quite guarded given the climate we find ourselves in. You know, I can't really predict how events will unfold over the remaining months of the year. I'm somewhat hesitant since my sense is that we're entering a recessionary stretch, and we're observing a slowdown across the economy in a number of sectors. The signals we're receiving are mixed, yet in light of all that, our approach will be to move ahead with a great deal of caution. The capacity to act is there should we want to, and should it prove advantageous for the shareholders. Vince, I'm not sure whether you'd like to offer anything further on that, but.
Vincent J. Calabrese
executiveNo, I'd simply put it this way — that 10% goal we've discussed remains, in our view, quite suitable, though you have to weigh the risk profile of the balance sheet. As we go along, as Vince mentioned, we do anticipate it will steadily climb from this point. There's room for us, after all. We'll approach buybacks with care. We bought back in the 13th. Once we feel at ease with conditions, we'd obviously want to be buying back in the 11th. There's certainly appetite, I believe, for getting some of that put to work over the course of the year. It really just comes down to timing.
Vince Delie
executiveTo be clear, no buybacks during the quarter took place after the market turmoil began. All of it occurred prior to that point.
Scott D. Free
executiveRight.
Vince Delie
executiveOnce more, luckily for us, our situation differs from that of other companies. We have choices available. We'll take great care in how we carry those choices out, you know, but the ability to do so is there on our end. Other companies lack that. That's the reason the responses you're hearing don't all match.
Timur Braziler
analystOkay, that's helpful. Thanks a lot. I appreciate the detailed explanation.
Vince Delie
executiveSure.
Scott D. Free
executiveOne more point I'd tack on there, Timur, regarding how sensitive our assets are, just building on Scott's remarks. If you examine the figures, we're sitting quite near neutral. Those figures, whether up or down, don't carry the weight they might have carried 9 or 12 months back; there is that small gain for us, be it positive or negative, but you're roughly beginning to converge toward a fairly neutral spot.
Michael Perito
analystHi there, morning everyone, and thanks for fielding my questions. Most of what I wanted to ask has already been covered. I suppose I have one broader question regarding expansion in loans. You've all discussed credit quite a bit, but what about how things look on the funding side? In other words, could any situation arise that would change how willing you are to pursue additional loan growth? Clearly, following what's happened recently, certificates of deposit have grown sharply throughout the sector. I'd expect that trend to persist to some degree, though perhaps not with the same intensity we witnessed during the final 30 days of the quarter. Could there be a circumstance in which funding — assuming it stays at roughly today's beta increase and elevated CD costs — would alter your willingness to originate fresh loans?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, considering the markets we operate in, I'd describe our guidance as fairly cautious. When you examine our deposit composition, our liquidity standing, and the makeup of those deposits, we possess numerous ways to generate liquidity that still produce a situation where booking loans adds value. I doubt we'll face the same pressure others may encounter. I believe your assessment of the broader industry is accurate, yet that's precisely what sets us apart once more. Our tendency toward caution, the reality that this company has been structured around the deposit base it holds, along with our disciplined approach to credit underwriting, allows us to keep lending throughout the cycle in a highly selective manner. Demand could decline, sure, and fewer competitors will be seeking to originate. During the previous cycle, we witnessed exactly that. Within the markets we've entered, we might get the chance to gain share against quite a few rivals. I don't foresee a situation requiring us to retreat. I've shared with our staff that they ought to feel fortunate to be employed here, especially those working in lending. Although it can be tough when times are good, since we lean conservative, our capacity to maintain lending operations across the cycle is genuine, and Gary's approach to credit is genuine as well; we remain inside a tight range, never attempting to expand beyond our means when conditions are overheated or to assume excessive risk. In periods such as this one, we're present in the market backing our clients and capturing more share. For a commercial banker, I'd call that paradise. I can't claim the same holds for everybody. When you survey the wide array of banks, each one sits in a distinct situation. Compared with reaching our guidance, F.N.B. occupies a highly solid position.
Michael Perito
analystThat's useful, Vince. Thank you. And without getting ahead of ourselves, as you consider that relative strength — and once we get past these next couple quarters, and perhaps we finally have a clearer sense of whether a recession is coming or things settle down, whatever happens — how does that carry over? I mean, I believe one factor putting you in this spot is simply the variety across your franchise's lines of business. You've got geography. And M&A, of course, has long played a major role in building that variety. With dislocation like this, you're in a fairly strong position. Over a longer horizon, what kinds of opportunities do you think could arise for F.N.B.
Vince Delie
executiveGiven the situation, I'm certain there will be a transformation across the industry and its landscape. Pressure is going to be felt by other players. While we navigate this cycle, our attention stays squarely on risk management, keeping liquidity at healthy levels, and setting the right price for our funding. Growth isn't the priority right now — margin matters more as we make our way through this stretch of the economic cycle. Once we're past it, I expect opportunities will emerge. What those look like, I can't say. That said, I can tell you we've done an outstanding job as well. The team has really excelled at creating operations from scratch. Take a look at our non-interest income, which did quite nicely during this year, and as Vince noted in the prepared remarks, the wealth management business stands out, plus we've seen solid results in insurance. Our collection of fee-generating businesses is highly granular and diversified, and for the most part it has been built organically. We'll keep concentrating on expanding what these groups are capable of in order to grow fee income, which acts as an annuity-style boost to earnings. Our digital strategy will remain a priority for us. The recognition we earned for the eStore strikes me as quite significant. The biggest banks globally threw their hats in the ring for this recognition, and we came out on top. Our approach isn't like everyone else's, you know. Adding more capabilities to it and reaching deeper into both our existing customers and potential ones across the seven states where we do business — those are good states to be in — that's what we're really concentrating on. That's where our attention stays going forward, I believe. I've already covered our M&A approach; it's come up in past conversations. For the time being, I think we're simply hitting the brakes and holding off until things become clearer. My sense is that we'll emerge from this stronger than before, which means plenty of chances will open up for us later on.
Michael Perito
analystOK. Yeah, that's logical. I'm grateful that the two of you took part in today's call. Thanks a lot.
Vince Delie
executiveSure. Thank you, Mike. I appreciate that.
Scott D. Free
executiveThank you, Mike.
Russell Gunther
analystMorning, everyone.
Vince Delie
executiveHi there, Russell.
Russell Gunther
analystI just wanted to-
Vince Delie
executiveMorning.
Russell Gunther
analystHi, a fast follow-up here. During the quarter, you discussed the liquidity measures you took along with excess cash. Could you remind us what your target level is, whether that's measured as cash to assets, and did that bogey shift at any point within the quarter, even if only for the short term?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, our management of that cash position has been pretty fluid across roughly the past 18 months. I'd say we pulled in around an additional $1 billion of liquidity — we brought that in because of uncertainty in the environment and because of how conservative we are. That's $1 billion we otherwise wouldn't have drawn, correct? In this environment, we felt it was both the smart move and the conservative move. Looking at what we've put in place, our total wholesale funding right now sits at about $3 billion, and roughly one-third of that is two years, one-third is one year, and the remaining third is within six months. We sort of assembled a ladder, and over time we use it to fund what we generate organically on the lending side. That billion, I mean, really serves as a reference point you could work from.
Russell Gunther
analystThat's useful, Vince. Thanks. I want to ask a follow-up regarding the NII guidance. You referenced that modest decline stemming from greater deposit beta expectations. Have you fellows calculated what you anticipate the deposit beta will be across the cycle? Has it gone up? Would you like to give a target for it?
Vince Delie
executiveOur target for each quarter is there in the slide. What I'd say is that, at this point, thus far, just as a reminder to everyone, exactly as shown on the slide, the cumulative beta on our total deposits came to 21.8% when the quarter closed. We had given guidance of 22%, so that's quite near it. It stood at 16.3%, if you recall, when the year ended. Looking forward, we expect roughly a mid-20s figure for total deposit basis when Q2 wraps up. Although the close of the year seems quite distant, our present view, and I'll describe it as a view for year 1, would be approximately the low 30s on total deposits in terms of cumulative data by the conclusion of this year.
Russell Gunther
analystExcellent. Alright, Vince, thanks for that. One final item from my side. Gary, over the last two to three years, your team has taken a cautious approach and reduced risk in the portfolio through a couple of different methods. Looking ahead at the conditions in front of us, do you foresee any chance or desire to pull back risk even more?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveWell, Russell, when we examine the portfolio right now, obviously softer economic conditions lie ahead; at this moment we aren't contemplating any meaningful further de-risking, since we're happy with where the portfolio stands. Of course, we remain very wary about the office sector, just as we have for a good while, and we keep going through that book loan by loan. In the ordinary course of business, we might possibly sell one or two assets or a small piece of them, but nothing is currently in the pipeline.
Russell Gunther
analystOK. Appreciate it, Gary, and thanks to everyone for letting me ask.
Vince Delie
executiveSure, thanks a lot.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveAbsolutely. Appreciate it.
Brian Martin
analystHey, morning, everyone. Most of what I had has already been covered, I think, but there are one or two items. Vince Calabrese, perhaps, regarding the margin — could you discuss what the March margin came in at, and sort of the measures you mentioned around liquidity, and what that means as a starting point, so to speak, going into the next quarter?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. Brian, the margin for March came in at 3.49%. That serves as our entry point as we head into the second quarter.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. All right, so essentially the pluses and minuses moving forward, I suppose, when you're looking at 2022, sort of given the guidance you've provided.
Scott D. Free
executiveOne thing that I think is also worth noting is that because of the surplus cash we're holding, correct? That extra liquidity we took on, $1 billion, that clearly has an impact on that ratio, right? As you know, Net Interest Income declines somewhat. That ratio is impacted by that sort of surplus liquidity situation, you know, as long as it remains. My apologies. What was the second thing you asked, Brian?
Brian Martin
analystYeah, no, I was only trying to suggest we consider that, you know, that margin, if, you know, the step, you know, the step into the following quarter, 3.49% is sort of where you begin. Just as it relates to the guidance. I mean, I suppose, do you expect the margin percentage to stay fairly flat going forward? I know you mentioned that with rates lower, there could be a modest pickup, but just in the near term, you know, the coming quarter or two?
Scott D. Free
executiveI think you were only discussing net interest income. I mean, it declines somewhat from here and then would grow in the Q3 and Q4, sort of reflecting our earning asset growth, as we head into the third and Q4. I mean, the margins move around a great deal and given the noise on the balance sheet, it's simply more difficult to address the margin component, Brian. The net interest income.
Brian Martin
analystYeah.
Scott D. Free
executiveI think
Brian Martin
analystAll right. Regarding that surplus cash, Vince, what exactly is the approach here? What sort of timeline are you considering? Are you simply intending to hold onto it for a while? Is some portion going to flow out, or what's your current thinking on that?
Scott D. Free
executiveYeah, that's precisely the point I was making. One-third of it sits at roughly 6 months or under, another third at 1 year, and the remaining third at 2 years. Most likely we'll simply allow that — you know, prepaying isn't something we're going to do. We'll just let it be absorbed in the natural course as time passes.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. All right, I didn't catch that, so. Fine. So then regarding the pipelines, both the ones for pipelines and for loans during the quarter — I didn't hear what was mentioned about the commercial side. Perhaps Vince said it, in terms of their status or simply the direction they're moving.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveIn my view, the pipelines have softened somewhat compared with how they typically looked in the past. That said, I don't believe we're being as aggressive when it comes to knocking on doors, and demand seems to have declined somewhat, fairly uniformly, pretty much everywhere. What I can say is the near-term pipelines appear fairly healthy. That's our 90-day figure. Our measurement is 90 days, and then anything past 90 days. The portion past 90 days appears somewhat weaker. The 90-day pipeline appears somewhat stronger. A greater share of fundings is coming through within that pipeline, meaning there's less garbage in it. I believe folks are somewhat more dialed in. I... It, it's a, it's a mixed picture when I look across every one of the markets. Some markets in Carolina are down. Others have stronger pipelines. South Carolina appears fairly healthy. Charlotte appears healthy in the near term and is likely growing its longer-term pipeline. Cleveland and Pittsburgh are performing fine. It's somewhat inconsistent everywhere, which tells me there's considerable hesitancy among the customer base. It isn't us. It isn't because of insufficient effort when it comes to calling. I believe it has more to do with what the client is doing, and there's reduced demand from our current customers for CapEx spending at this point in the cycle, which is likely beneficial. Right. A bit more prudence within the portfolio. What we're additionally observing is that utilization rates haven't moved. Nobody posed that question, so I'll bring it up. In my view, essentially, when we examine the C&I book — and Gary, feel free to jump in if you want — but I think many of our customers haven't been accumulating inventories; instead they've been drawing down inventory, and moving their short-term assets into cash as we enter a slower economic stretch. We're beginning to notice declines in line balances. I believe following the turmoil that hit the banking sector, quite a few companies found it gave them greater awareness of their situation, and they took cash and essentially reduced revolver debt since they're paying an interest rate far above what they're earning. A great deal of that has happened during recent months, and forecasting through year-end is somewhat difficult. My expectation is that we'll land in line with our guide. You know, reaching that point is not going to come easily, is it? Right. For my part, I would.
Vince Delie
executiveSure, I’d share the customer’s view on bringing inventory levels down. That’s basically what we’re observing everywhere. Of course, they accumulated extra stock while supply chain problems were going on. Some of that has already been worked through, and, you know, given caution looking ahead from, you know, an economic perspective, and a possible slowdown there. Their inventory positions are a major focus for them, and I’d anticipate that continuing to decline as we move ahead.
Brian Martin
analystGreat. I appreciate all the detail. Regarding those new origination yields, I’m not sure whether it’s Gary or someone else who should answer, but where do those stand right now on the loan side?
Vince Delie
executiveI believe—
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveYou know. Go ahead. No, go ahead, Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveYou got the specific numbers. I mean, I have generalities.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveLet me offer a big-picture remark here, and then you can add whatever detail you'd like. Loans newly originated in Q1 carried a rate of 6.31%. By way of contrast, during Q4 that figure stood at 5.70%. That covers everything. All newly issued loans.
Brian Martin
analystBrian, thanks — understood, that clears it up. Gary, near the beginning of this call you brought up the criticized level. Was it that it rose slightly during the quarter? My recollection is you described a decline compared with a year ago — or do I have the direction backwards regarding what happened with criticized assets?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveBrian, quarter over quarter it came in 19 basis points higher, while on a year-over-year basis it fell 55 basis points, and all of that occurred alongside a balance sheet that was $5 billion bigger. From where we sit, criticized levels remain close to record lows even now — $631 million.
Brian Martin
analystAll right. Regarding that rise, was there any particular factor behind it, or is it simply, you know, a mix of various items? Anything at all you'd highlight, considering everything—all those credit-related disclosures you've provided?
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveYes. Not particularly. It was fairly broad-based.
Brian Martin
analystOkay.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveNo, nothing specific.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. Alright, the final item I had concerns capital markets revenue. I believe you mentioned syndications were somewhat down. Do you have any views on — I suppose what we'd anticipate is that you'll notice some fluctuation there, yet it ought to move upward over the course of the year.
Vince Delie
executiveYes. If you examine what our results looked like during this quarter, that's fairly in line with — it's essentially our standard level of performance, correct?
Brian Martin
analystOkay.
Vince Delie
executiveYou know, I think all of that is really going to hinge on how things ultimately play out going forward. I mean, clearly when it comes to the structural side of syndications, if we're the lead, if we allow ourselves to lead, that's gonna be tied to CapEx need, M&A activity. There are a lot of factors that play into generating fees in that category. I'd anticipate certain things surfacing over the next few quarters that should help that area, because we do have a pretty sizable hauling effort on the syndication side. I'd also anticipate derivatives. You know, as we work through the cycle and you observe a number of companies using up their old fixed rate program, I'd anticipate seeing them re-upping, especially given the inversion in the yield curve. I mean, there's hope that we can sustain or grow those numbers. I think that's reflected in our guide. You know, I actually thought they did pretty well in the Q1, which is typically seasonally lower.
Brian Martin
analystYeah.
Vince Delie
executiveI believe we're in good shape. When it comes to wealth, our performance is exceptionally strong when it comes to generating new net asset values. Net asset values are rising, and compliance is strong, especially in the southeast and in the Mid-Atlantic. My expectation is that this will keep going, since we've added to our staffing in that region over the past several years and have achieved improved penetration. I anticipate that this will perform somewhat better than prior years as far as organic growth is concerned. Over time, that ought to benefit us. On the mortgage side, there's a fair amount of uncertainty regarding our direction from a gain on sale standpoint, given where rates stand. As you know, once again, we're newcomers to a lot of these markets. We now have excellent people, excellent originators, and we're distributed over a fairly large geography with diversification, holding a comparatively smaller share in many markets. We ought to be in a position to maintain that; we feel fairly confident about our guidance there.
Brian Martin
analystYeah. No, that's.
Vince Delie
executiveRight.
Brian Martin
analystGot it. Alright, I appreciate you fielding our questions, and I'm grateful for the extra detail you provided regarding the office book as well as the series book. That really helps.
Vince Delie
executiveYeah. Thanks.
Gary L. Guerrieri
executiveAppreciate it, Brian.
Vince Delie
executiveAny more questions? All right, that wraps up the Q&A. I'd like to express my gratitude to everyone for joining in. Thanks for the insightful questions — extremely, extremely thorough — and I hope we managed to address them. As you know, we released a substantial amount, and I'd suggest going through the disclosures we issued. In my view, our team did a fantastic job distributing that information to the market. I want to thank you, as well as our employees here and the shareholders for their support. We're going to perform well as we navigate through this on a relative basis. I'm confident of that because we truly have an outstanding team in place. Thanks for being part of this. Take care. See you all.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's call to a close. We appreciate your joining this presentation. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.