F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 20, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lisa Constantine
executiveThanks. Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call. This conference call from F.N.B. Corporation, along with the documents we've filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, includes forward-looking statements as well as non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP financial measures ought to be considered alongside our reported results under GAAP, not as a replacement for them. You'll find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, and to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures, in our presentation material and our earnings release. We encourage you to review those non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures in the related materials, reports, and registration statements we've filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available on our corporate website. A replay of this call will be accessible through Thursday, July 27th, and the webcast link will be posted in the About Us Investor Relations section of our corporate website. I'll now hand the call over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveThanks for joining us for the earnings call on our second quarter. With me are our Chief Financial Officer, Vince Calabrese, and Gary Guerrieri, who serves as our Chief Credit Officer. On both an operating and reported basis, I believe we posted net income available to common stockholders of $140.4 million, which works out to $0.39 per diluted common share; that takes our operating earnings per share for the first half of the year to $0.79, which is up 39% from the same stretch in 2022. Operating pre-provision net revenue rose 51% year-to-date, which pushed our efficiency ratio down to 50% and lifted operating return on tangible common equity to 19.1%. Average total loans grew 2.1% from the prior quarter, reaching more than $31 billion. Solid production gave commercial loan balances a boost, mainly in Pittsburg, Harrisburg, and the North and South Carolina markets. Average deposits came to more than $34 billion, down 1.3% versus the first quarter, mostly because of seasonal deposit outflows tied to tax related payments and how the inflationary macroeconomic environment affected our clients. Even with deposit competition speeding up because of the recent banking disruption, noninterest-bearing deposits as a share of total deposits stood at 32% on June 30, which is relatively stable. At quarter end, the loan-to-deposit ratio came in at 92.7%. That solid deposit composition resulted from our emphasis on building connections with customers and acting as their main financial institution. Across the last few years, we have improved what we offer in terms of products and our digital tools, added great bankers to our workforce, and deliberately grown into new markets so we can deliver top-tier experiences to our customers—experiences that create ease, confidence, and a dependable deposit base. As an illustration of this, we just introduced the Common App, Common Account application, within our eStore that has won awards, and our goal there is to become the first bank providing one universal application covering the bulk of our offerings, which lets customers submit requests for several products at the same time. Thanks to cutting-edge tools like AI and machine learning, our eStore Common App makes applying faster and safer, and its strong data features let us suggest products tailored to what each customer specifically needs. With so many fields filled in ahead of time, the Common Application cuts down on what customers have to type and greatly shortens how long it takes to finish applying for several products. All consumer lending products are part of the Common Application's initial rollout, which went live last month. By the close of 2023, consumer deposit products will join it, with business products arriving soon afterward during the opening half of 2024. Our simplified workflow drove online applications up by more than 170% this June versus the same month last year, and we anticipate that figure will keep climbing as we push the feature more aggressively. Beyond digital channels, we've kept putting money into our fee-based services. Right now we're broadening our award-winning Treasury Management platform, with strategic goals of fueling organic growth, boosting revenue, and bringing in low-cost deposits. Just in this quarter, clients on our newly introduced Integrated Payable Solutions finished roughly $1 billion worth of payments, while also benefiting from check outsourcing and reduced fraud risk. We've likewise used integrated payables to keep building our commercial card revenue, which has grown at a 19% compound annual rate across the last three years, and it keeps increasing as we penetrate more deeply among commercial and small business clients. Such investments across our broad range of products and services keep helping FMB add noninterest-bearing deposit accounts and further diversify the fee-based income streams we rely on, giving customers services of high value. FMB keeps raising its market share in a steady way. The 12% spot loan growth year-over-year recorded this quarter was reached while we stuck to underwriting guidelines that are both consistent and conservative. Our culture still treats risk management as a core element. At this point I'll hand the call to Gary so he can speak in greater detail about asset quality and credit risks. Gary?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThanks, Vince, and good morning to all of you. We closed out the quarter with asset quality metrics that are still close to record-low levels. Results for the period show that total delinquency finished the quarter at 75 basis points, while NPLs and OREO came in at 47 basis points, and net charge-offs registered 11 basis points. Criticized loans declined by one basis point versus the prior quarter, and classified assets fell 16 basis points. I'll go into greater detail on those asset quality highlights for the quarter, then give you an update on the office portfolio. Let's turn now to our credit results. Total delinquency rose 15 basis points during the quarter, and NPLs and OREO as a percentage of total loans climbed nine basis points from the preceding quarter. That rise in NPLs and OREO was mostly tied to one $32 million C&I loan, placed on non-performing status. As of quarter end, we had reserved for roughly 40% of our exposure. This credit emerged right at the close of the quarter, stemming from a developing issue between our borrower and their main business partner. Net charge-offs for the quarter came to $8.7 million, equal to 11 basis points annualized, with eight basis points reflecting the use of specific reserves set up earlier. Total provision expense for the quarter was $18.5 million, covering loan growth in the specific reserve just mentioned, offset by releases tied to the decline in classified loans. Our ending funded reserve grew $9.3 million during the quarter, and now sits at $413 million, a solid 1.32% of loans, which reflects our strong standing relative to peers. Once acquired unamortized loan discounts are included, our reserve reaches 1.48%, and our NPL coverage position remains strong at 325%, inclusive of the unamortized loan discounts. We stay dedicated to consistent underwriting and robust credit risk management so we can keep a balanced, well-positioned portfolio through economic cycles. We proactively review and stress test portfolios continually, including this quarter, when we ran a full company-wide stress test in line with prior years; we were happy with how the results came out, since it confirms that our diversified portfolio and proactive credit risk management allow us to weather a range of economic downturn scenarios. Turning to the office portfolio, delinquency is still very low at 26 basis points, and criticized loans are still under 10%, with no negative migration this quarter; every commercial real estate loan secured by office properties that matured during the quarter was renewed, with no downgrades needed. We have proactively managed this portfolio on a loan-by-loan basis, and will keep doing so, as part of the in-depth reviews we conduct regularly. To wrap up, asset quality metrics are still near historical lows, and we continue to produce diversified loan growth in attractive markets. We keep a close watch on macroeconomic trends and the individual markets within our footprint, and we'll keep managing risk proactively and aggressively as part of our core credit philosophy, which has served us well across economic cycles. At this point, I'll hand things over to Vince Calabrese, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer, so he can share his comments.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAppreciate that, Gary, and good morning to everyone. My focus today will be the financial results from the second quarter, along with updates to guidance for the rest of 2023. For the second quarter, net income available to common shareholders came to $140.4 million, which works out to $0.39 per diluted common share, on both an operating and reported basis. That brings our operating earnings year-to-date to $0.79 per share. Looking at spot balances, loans and leases finished the quarter at $31 billion, an increase of $681 million, or 2.2% on a linked-quarter basis. Within that, consumer loans rose $517 million, helped by solid seasonal activity from the Physicians First mortgage program. Commercial loans and leases were up $164 million, or 0.8%, and loan spreads improved relative to where they stood in the first quarter. Our investment portfolio came down modestly to $7.2 billion, since we shifted cash toward supporting loan growth. The securities portfolio overall is still split about evenly between AFS and HTM, with 47% sitting in available for sale, and a duration of 4.5 years as of quarter end. Total deposits closed the quarter at $33.8 billion, down $365 million linked quarter, or 1.1%, mostly reflecting seasonal deposit outflows, tax-related payments, and the effects of the inflationary macroeconomic backdrop. Deposit mix kept shifting during the quarter, with customers moving $586 million into time deposits, which partly offset declines of $273 million in interest-bearing demand deposits and $383 million in noninterest-bearing demand deposits. At June 30th, noninterest-bearing demand deposits made up 32% of total deposits, versus 33% at March 31st. Although the disruptions in the banking industry clearly sped up deposit competition, we continue to expect the mix of noninterest-bearing demand to total deposits to stay above where it was before COVID. Our loan-to-deposit ratio rose to 92.7% in the quarter, which reflects robust loan growth along with the seasonal impact of tax payments on deposits. Revenue came in at $410 million, supported by net interest income of $329 million and steady noninterest income, with benefits from our diversified fee businesses. The second quarter's net interest margin was 3.37%, and we expect the quarterly decline to moderate, with the month of June at 3.34%. Yields on earning assets rose 26 basis points to 4.94%, driven by better yields on loans, investment securities, and interest-bearing deposits with banks. Meanwhile, the cost of funds climbed 46 basis points to 1.64%, as the cost of interest-bearing deposits rose 47 basis points to 1.97%. We keep managing total deposit costs actively, and they finished the quarter at 1.47%, which brings the total cumulative deposit data to 27%. We anticipate ending 2023 in the mid-30s. Moving to noninterest income and expense, noninterest income was $80.3 million, up 1% from a solid first quarter. Service charges grew $1.4 million, or 4%, on the strength of Treasury Management services and interchange fees, which offset the overdraft practice changes F.N.B implemented in the first quarter of 2023. Dividends on non-marketable securities rose $1.4 million, or 33%, driven by higher FHLB dividends tied to additional borrowings. Revenue from insurance commissions and fees fell by $1.8 million, which works out to 23%, reflecting typical seasonal patterns along with robust production overall during the first quarter. Strong contributions kept coming from our wealth management operation, which posted combined revenue of $17.7 million — a 12% gain compared with the same period a year earlier. Noninterest expense came to $212 million, down $8 million, or just under 4%, versus the prior quarter. Salaries and employee benefits dropped $6.3 million, mostly because of seasonal compensation recorded in the first quarter, partly offset by standard yearly merit raises in the second quarter, plus larger commissions stemming from better than anticipated contributions out of our mortgage banking and fee-based businesses. The efficiency ratio came in at 50.0%, reflecting robust revenue and expenses that were well managed. Capital ratios stayed solid across the quarter, with our CET1 ratio sitting at the 10% target we aim for. TCE finished the quarter at 7.47%, and after adjusting for our health and maturity investment marks, that figure was 6.8%, which we anticipate will stay above peer median levels. During the quarter we also bought back 2.3 million shares, paying a weighted average price of $10.80. Tangible book value per common share stood at $8.79 as of June 30th, up $0.13 per share from March 31st, driven mainly by the higher earnings level, which offset a bigger hit from AOCI — that reduced tangible book value by $0.99 per share, versus $0.87 at the close of the previous quarter. Now let's turn to the 2023 financial objectives, beginning with the balance sheet. On a full year spot basis, we're keeping our earlier guide for loans, which should rise mid-single digits year-over-year. For total deposit balance, the revised expectation is to finish 2023 down low single digits against the December 31st, 2022 spot balances. We look for year-end levels to be roughly flat versus the June 30th figure of $33.8 billion, since seasonality ought to turn into a tailwind during the second half of 2023. Net interest income for the full year should land somewhere between $1.28 and $1.32 billion, and for the third quarter of 2023, between $313 million and $323 million. Our guidance right now bakes in a 25 basis point rate hike next week, followed by no changes for the rest of the year. The reduction in guidance relative to last quarter stems mostly from what we expect on deposit betas, which are being pushed higher by intense competition for deposits and a continuing mix-shift toward time deposits. We continue to anticipate that the ratio of noninterest-bearing demand to total deposits will stay above pre-COVID levels. Noninterest income for the full year should come in between $315 million and $325 million, with the third quarter landing around $80 million. This upward revision reflects the advantage of our diversified fee-based income strategy. On an operating basis, full year guidance for noninterest expense should fall at the high end of our earlier range of $835 million to $855 million, primarily because of elevated commissions linked to better than expected fee income. Third quarter noninterest expense should be somewhere between $210 million and $215 million. Our projection for provisions across the entire year is still $65 million to $85 million, and it hinges on how much net loan growth we see plus possible CECL model-related charges stemming from a software macroeconomic backdrop. And finally, for the whole year, the effective tax rate ought to land somewhere in the range of 20% to 21%, and that figure leaves out any investment tax credit activity that might take place. So with all that said, I'll hand things back over to Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveThank you, Vince. F.N.B. delivered yet another strong quarter. What sets our financial results apart is a creative lineup of products and services, prudent management of the balance sheet, and a corporate culture built around risk management. None of this would be possible without our skilled and committed team members. This approach allows us to support our clients across economic cycles in ways rivals simply cannot; we recently earned recognition on Forbes' 2023 Global 2000 and America's Best in State Banks, with that second honor driven by customer input that highlights how much our staff contribute to our results. Our capital standing stays robust, with CET1 sitting at our goal operating level of 10%, while still funding loan expansion and share buyback activity during the quarter. Tangible book value per share keeps climbing, reaching $8.79 this quarter, an 8.6% increase year-over-year. Looking ahead to the back half of the year, we are positioned unlike anyone else to take advantage of disruption and are ready to keep generating shareholder value.
Daniel Tamayo
analystMorning, everyone. Appreciate you fielding my question. So, to start with the balances in noninterest-bearing deposits — I'm not certain whether I caught what you said. Was there a specific figure you built into the guidance regarding where those stand by year-end? And I realize you said they'd finish higher than the pre-COVID level. I'm curious whether you could give a bit more granularity on roughly where you expect them to settle; plus, regarding the quarter itself, any color on how the mix shift progressed — did it decelerate as the quarter went on, was there a pattern worth noting? Thanks.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah. Regarding noninterest-bearing deposits, no particular goal existed for us as a share of deposits. We noted we stood at 32, having fallen from 32, and before COVID we ran around 26%, and we aren't anticipating a near-term drift all the way down to that level — meaning we'd expect to stay above it. In my view, the aim would be a 30 handle, assuming we're able to hold a 30 handle, since we must keep progressing. We do get seasonal municipal deposits that tend to accumulate from now through the October, November stretch, which would influence that noninterest-bearing line. It's also a major priority for this company; it has been for 15, 16 years when it comes to expanding noninterest-bearing deposits — retail, commercial, municipal, plus small business <<inaudible>>, and we're eager to see that support us here.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveRight, and the shift is different now, isn't it? So the latter portion of what you asked concerned what will take place as we continue ahead regarding how deposits are mixed.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, that shift in mix toward CDs — it's still been quite substantial, though it's certainly eased up. On the retail side, I'd say requests to match competitors' rates have come down a lot compared with a few quarters back. Over on the commercial side, things remain very active, as you'd anticipate, with every bank reaching out to every other bank's customers. Still, I believe we've done a really good job holding onto our customers and picking up others because of the disruption in the marketplace.
Vince Delie
executiveAnd I realize we sound like a broken record on this point, but one big factor I believe will make our results compare quite favorably against peers when it comes to noninterest-bearing deposits specifically is this: as I've noted on many prior calls, we've chosen to center our approach on client primacy — being the main bank our customers rely on. What backs that deposit base, especially the noninterest-bearing portion, is compensating balances that cover Treasury Management Services, plus embedded balances tied to the flow, consumer, and small business accounts. So, in my view, our team has performed quite well at sustaining that, and that's the thing really carrying our noninterest-bearing deposit base.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnother point I'd mention as well, as something of a proof point regarding the mix shifts that took place in the quarter, it was definitely slowing if you moved through the quarter. When we look at the margin, the margin, with everything that all the banks did, purposes included in March, from March to April, our margin declined nine basis points to a 3.40 level, and then from April to May we were down three basis points, and three from May to June. So clearly, there's been a slowing impact to the margin statistics that also flows through the net interest income.
Daniel Tamayo
analystThat's fantastic detail, and I appreciate it. Perhaps shifting topics for my next question, regarding costs. I'm just wondering, if we make it through the year near the upper end of the guidance, that suggests a quarterly run rate of roughly 2.13, and correct me if I'm mistaken there; so I'd like to know whether you see any chances to bring expenses down going forward, considering the revenue pressure.
Vince Calabrese
executiveWell, we set a cost savings goal annually. This quarter marks our fourth or fifth year with substantial cost savings objectives, and for this year it's $9 million, and we'll maintain that as we move into the new year. I mean, we operate with a 50% efficiency ratio, so it isn't as though there's extra cost available to cut; yet we keep working daily to control costs, whether through renegotiating agreements — one major factor flowing through expenses is simply inflation's effects, contracts containing CPI provisions that have sort of activated in prior quarters. We're proactively approaching those suppliers to explore renegotiating those agreements and secure something beneficial for us given where CPI has stood at times; we've seen some considerable hikes there. Process improvement is a major priority across the company, so opportunities keep existing there; so it's daily, Danny, that we handle the expense side. We stay disciplined, and we keep seeking methods to sort of optimize our facilities, space optimization, which is simply an ongoing focus; so that's something additional sort of integrated into our daily operations.
Timur Braziler
analystHello, good morning. Timur Braziler here, sitting in for Jared. I wanted to pick up on what was said about deposits, specifically that prepared comment about a beta in the mid-30s by the end of the year. That strikes me as a fairly cautious figure. After all, beta went up by percentage points during this quarter. If you're building in one additional hike, does that mean — given how strong your deposit performance has been up to now — that you'd expect some degree of delay after the final rate increase? Or is it fair to think that, once the Fed finishes, assuming no further mix shift, the cost will likewise begin to ease?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, I'd say our teams keep on <<inaudible>> of change when it comes to handling deposit costs, and in a particularly tough environment, the balancing act since the failures has required quite a lot of effort across our entire company, both on the commercial side and the retail side, with the Fed still pushing rates up. With one additional move that everyone anticipates in February — February next week — I don't believe it simply ends there. As I said a bit earlier, competition remains intense when it comes to commercial deposits, and we've clearly done very well at keeping our customers and holding onto deposits. So I think there's likely some continuation of that, and if it does occur, it ought to run for a while. But the beta, at 27 — we initially guided in April to the mid-20s, which was a couple of times higher than 25, so we essentially used the middle of that range. Given what we know today and our forecast and how we're handling it, the mid-30s is above the low 30s we sort of estimated back in April; still, I'd call that a number that seems sensible to us, and we can improve on it. That would be great.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, excellent. Let's shift over to loan growth, perhaps. I have two things to ask. First, the residential expansion along with the Physician First initiative keeps performing at an extremely strong pace. Residential now makes up nearly 20% of our loan portfolio. So, part A: who exactly is originating mortgages at this point? Is it purchase activity? Is it some kind of refinancing? How much additional runway exists in residential? And second, looking forward, what mix shift or loan growth composition do you anticipate?
Vince Delie
executiveWell, to start with, the borrowers within the Physicians First program represent some of the strongest credit profiles we have, correct? They're typically well established physicians who are upgrading their home. Purchase money accounts for most of the business we conduct. So the overwhelming majority — not only in Physicians First, but throughout our entire footprint — has historically leaned toward purchase money. That has been our approach. Going forward, I'd anticipate that we've somewhat altered our focus. As a result, we're generating more saleable product. The Physicians First loans are generally balance sheet oriented. So the remainder of the book has been shifting, and we've been moving further toward generating saleable product, which ought to assist us in managing the balance sheet. Looking ahead, regarding the concentrations, we're completely aware and able to make adjustments; that might involve sales and other channels, but we also keep an eye on concentrations. Yet I believe overall, extremely high quality borrowers, especially purchase money; and the objective here is to ensure we circle back, or at the front end of origination; that's the reason we built the eStore — to provide multiple products and services to that group, especially wealth management. We have brokerage, insurance, fee based, high quality fee-based businesses. And then we consider, we ultimately also capture opportunities on the business side with the practices, offering Treasury Management Services and loan products to help facilitate the build out for acquisition of practice.
Vince Calabrese
executivePush those forward as time goes on.
Vince Delie
executiveThose will also propel them forward over time. With that in mind, that essentially sums up how we're approaching mortgage expansion — our aim, I'd say, has been locating originators who truly concentrate on and are wired into the new home purchase segment, rather than depending on recent refinance volume to generate production. That's the way we've viewed this for quite a while.
Vince Calabrese
executiveTo put it another way, purchases accounted for 97% of originations, meaning refinancing activity was minimal. Once rates decline, that segment will recover, but at this moment, essentially everything is purchase-driven.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, and then my final one is probably for Gary. At the moment, we're in a stretch where everyone anticipates some kind of credit event occurring late in 2023 or during '24. So I'm curious: when you do your routine assessment of the loan book, does that expectation of a credit event alter anything, or is it essentially the same as always when you look at those loans? Are you attempting to act more proactively? I realize you're examining each loan, every theory loan maturing in 2023 and 2024. Is there any piece of wanting to take a more forward-leaning approach, perhaps setting aside a bigger allowance given the wider mood out there, or does essentially nothing shift?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes, two more. What I'd say is that for us, essentially nothing shifts. Risk management is something we pursue very aggressively, and a change in the economy won't alter our program; thus we'll keep handling the book portfolio loan by loan in certain instances, as we've discussed regarding the office book and the problems occurring in that area right now; yet there's no genuine difference when it comes to how we manage risk. We simply keep staying in front of it, which matters from where we sit.
Frank Schiraldi
analystFrank, good morning to you. For me, a few items regarding capital. Vince, my understanding is that you mentioned being essentially at your CET1 goal ratio. I'm curious — my assumption would be that factoring in the AFS book, because of how large this bank is, that issue is probably a smaller worry for you folks compared with certain bigger institutions that could face revisions to capital regulations. Still, I wanted to ask about your priorities in this area, whether we might observe that CET1 ratio declining somewhat as a result of expansion. And your team was somewhat more forceful with repurchasing shares than my model had assumed. I'm just curious how you're viewing this now. At this stage, is it simply a matter of taking opportunities when they arise with buybacks?
Vince Calabrese
executiveVince, yes, that's how I'd put it, Frank. What I mean is, we've set 10% as an operating target. At present we sit exactly at 10.0, and managing to precisely 10.0 each quarter isn't our plan. Still, because earnings were robust this quarter, and considering the price at which the stock was trading, we took advantage of opportunities, which is exactly the term you used — that's the important part. So yes, we seized those opportunities, and we'll keep seizing them as the year progresses. If you examine it, there's a slide we included here that shows the CET1 ratio and TCE ratio, first as reported and then incorporating the marks; and I believe you're able to observe the CET1 ratio, at least as of March, correct, we stood at 10.0, with peers at 10.1. Once AFS is included, our figure is 9.3 against 8.9, and after adding both AFS and HTM it's 8.6 against 8.3; so every one of those represents a comfortable level and beats peers. In the same way, regarding the TCE ratio, on slide 7, the effect is visible there. So, taking into account the risk profile and the balance sheet, that 10% still leaves us quite comfortable. Robust earnings production backed our asset expansion and afterward allowed us to seize opportunities. Based on our present forecast, we anticipate steadily accumulating CET1 during the back half of the year. The funds will go toward supporting loan growth first, which is our consistent practice; and afterward, should opportunities arise or should loan growth come in somewhat slower than our model assumes, we'll be more precise.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAll right, that sounds good. Now, as a follow-up regarding deposits — you brought up how municipal deposit dollars behave seasonally. For modeling, could you remind us how large those flows have typically been historically, plus the anticipated costs, perhaps in relation to the remainder of the book?
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure. On a piece-by-piece basis, the typical movement is somewhere between $300 million and $500 million, declining during Q1 and then rising around October through November. We haven't given specific cost figures for those; we have discussed our pricing levels. There are certain promotional CD rates we put in place in May that are currently available — roughly 5% on a 13-month CD, and 4.75% on a 10-month CD. Since May began, we've brought in approximately $400 million in CDs; around two-thirds of that represents entirely new money for the company, and a number of municipal customers will also make use of those rates.
Vince Delie
executiveFor virtually all of them — correct — we serve as their main Treasury Management supplier. What we're doing isn't merely letting them bring in hot money alongside us. That means the odds are lower that they'll shift over to those pricier offerings. And when seasonal patterns hit, especially around ad valorem tax collection and other seasonal work, Treasury Management fees rise right now. Because of that, they usually keep more demand deposits on hand to offset the expense of that heavier operational load. So quite a few dynamics are at play in that portfolio. It isn't simply cash moving in and out toward high yielding.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAll right. So my guess is a portion of that arrives as noninterest bearing. I'm just wondering whether it will actually move that noninterest-bearing pattern enough for us to notice it in the coming quarter, though perhaps not.
Vince Delie
executiveMy sense is the effect won't be dramatic; still, it's difficult to predict, given earnings credit rates and the kind of return they could obtain, whether the people overseeing those balances at those entities choose to deploy free balances or make a little by investing. That's included in the picture, but I simply wanted to clarify that we aren't merely absorbing the expenses tied to high yielding buyers — that isn't our practice.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnd the bulk of the money I referenced will really come through GDA side.
Vince Delie
executiveRight.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThe tax gets gathered, and the rates go up; therefore that will be settled by way of the line for noninterest-bearing paring. Let me just make that clear.
Michael Perito
analystMorning, everyone, and thanks for fielding my questions. To kick things off — and I realize this may be roughly a quarter ahead of schedule — could you share a bit more detail regarding the incremental CD growth and what duration looks like there? And as you look ahead, when does that shift from being a headwind into a tailwind? Also, given the uncharted territory you're operating in, if your rate forecast turns out right and the environment cools, would you expect to roll some of that forward at lower levels? Obviously, on the competitive side, CD rates today are likely the fiercest they've been in recent memory, but I'm just curious how you're weighing that dynamic against the margin as we look toward next year from here?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, Mike, that's precisely our framing. Right now the CD portfolio carries an average term of 10 months. The 2 specials I referenced are a 13 months CD and a 7 months CD. So quite short. The thinking is that, as you noted, competition is intense at present, yet should rates begin declining mid-year, in the second half of next year, we'd have a chance to reprice those downward; so that's precisely the strategy.
Michael Perito
analystUnderstood. So next, when you consider everything that's been shaking up this sector, my own belief is that one factor behind how effectively you've come through it is simply how varied your franchise is, across business lines and regions. Some truly big, highly regarded competitors aren't here anymore. From a strategy standpoint, is anything on your roadmap that could be either fresh or accelerated, where openings exist, perhaps in private banking or in certain of those smaller niche commercial segments where those institutions held big market share, that you're evaluating and that we ought to keep in mind when considering growth chances in ‘24 and ‘25?
Vince Delie
executiveI don't believe there's a particular business line belonging to other banks that would draw our interest. Had we wanted that, we'd have gone after it ages ago, correct. We've consistently stated that we were distinct; we got lumped in with those institutions sitting in our approximate size bracket, at minimum a few years back. Thus they were peers, part of our peer set, and analysts used them as benchmarks against us. Their approach, in my view, differed enormously from ours. We've said this as time passed — check the earlier earnings transcripts — I've repeated it many times. Our inclination is to concentrate on forging connections in the middle market, serving consumers, sort of midstream consumers. There is a private banking operation here. There's also the Physicians First program, aimed at higher income consumers; yet we serve the wide range of consumer and small business. And that genuinely is what we've centered on. We put emphasis on funding product capabilities that let us widen returns on capital we put to work with consumers and businesses. That may not sound like a particularly glamorous model, but our approach to risk has been diversification across geographies. We've stated that again and again. Gary devotes a great deal of time — his team, Tom Fisher, Gary, the entire group — to examining risk concentrations so the portfolio retains granularity. Then, if you examine earnings transcripts from even prior to all of this occurring, I stated we're a highly robust consumer franchise whose deposit base is granular. Our deposit mix was extremely advantageous. And honestly, I believe that's truly critical to how a bank gets valued. If you're assessing what an actual institution is worth, in my view you should examine its deposit base. So, I don't foresee us genuinely shifting. I do believe that with the exit, they operate in our lines of business too, correct. Thus those players leaving, from a competition standpoint, will be to our advantage. I think on the wealth side, making loans to high net worth individuals, commercial lending in particular markets, we'll be positioned to gain from the disruption.
Michael Perito
analystIs there also a chance to bring on more bankers?
Vince Delie
executiveWithout a doubt. When it comes to bringing folks aboard, drawing talent has never been a problem for us. In fact, individuals contact us constantly, which wasn't how things used to work. My sense is that remaining disciplined and staying the course genuinely places us well; that's the reason I mentioned it during my remarks — as we progress through this cycle, we need to compete more effectively. We need to bring capital capacity to bear, along with a terrific lineup of products; and I believe, as I've stated previously and will repeat, that the money we've put into technology, and where we're directing our attention internally, is exactly right. It's enhancing how customers can buy several products and services from us very efficiently; so we keep our eyes on the eStore, and that explains why consumer applications have climbed to the level they have. I believe that once we introduce deposits in November onto that platform, it will genuinely assist us in acquiring a new consumer. Buying several products and services and opening depository accounts will become really simple, all through a single platform with a single application. So that's the piece I find most thrilling, I think, going forward; it's applying AI and the digital tools we've implemented to create a better experience for the clients. Anyway, that's —
Michael Perito
analystThat's genuinely useful context, so thanks, everyone. One final item from my side: I wanted to ask whether you'd be open to offering a few thoughts, Vince, on what comes next for bank M&A. It's fairly clear additional consolidation will follow in the wake of what's happened. I'm just wondering what you're observing in the market — things look quite sluggish, with regulatory obstacles right now — and perhaps you could also weigh in on what that coming round of consolidation might represent for F.N.B as an opportunity, if anything at all.
Vince Delie
executiveOn one of the calls I remarked that being an investment banker isn't something I'd want. Right now, everyone is paralyzed. I won't offer any sarcastic remarks. That said, I'd note that at some future point it could be a favorable moment to work as an investment banker, since plenty of banks are facing difficulties for many different reasons. As this cycle unfolds, my sense is that once we reach the far side of it, there will be opportunities worth examining. I don't believe we've arrived there yet. If we were to pursue M&A — and I'm not saying that we are — our attention is directed inward at present, and we've adhered to the dependable, proven approach of pursuing in-market transactions where cost savings can be captured that immediately add to earnings, with only minimal dilution of tangible book value and returns on capital comfortably exceeding our cost of capital. That has always been our position; it's what the board anticipates. We maintain strong discipline on that front. Our results demonstrate that we've remained faithful to that approach. In my view, today's M&A environment remains quite difficult. Many banks would presumably be interested in selling, yet I'm not certain a transaction can be made to work mathematically or financially. So our primary focus has been expanding our e-Delivery channel — the eStore I referenced — and then supplementing that channel throughout our seven-state footprint by installing ATMs and ITMs. We believe that represents a superior, highly cost-efficient route for us, connecting our physical delivery network through the ATMs — branded ATMs — and then delivering our digital offerings to that customer base. We've enjoyed solid results with that effort, so we'll keep concentrating on that de novo approach along with ATM deployment, and keep bringing in consumers and small business activity. In any case, that's where I stand on M&A. No sarcastic headlines this time.
Russell Gunther
analystRussell, good morning. Regarding what Gary mentioned before, it would help if you could walk us through a few of the inputs behind that company-wide stress test done this quarter. My understanding is that this happens at the same point each year. Getting the broad strokes on those assumptions would be interesting, especially declines in CRE prices — anything more you can add there.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveYes, Russell, from the standpoint of assumptions, this is essentially our usual stress test review. Looking at results, charge-offs landed somewhat below the level seen in the previous review. As for the economic forecast, there's a bit more provision tied to it. When it comes to the ACL, it absorbed those possible losses at a rate above 50%, under a worst case nine-quarter scenario. So it's a routine review that we perform quite regularly, and the outcome exceeded our expectations and also topped the earlier review.
Russell Gunther
analystThat's useful, Gary. Thanks. Let me shift topics for my final question, which is about the securities portfolio. Is there any desire to restructure part of it? And if there is, what kind of earn back would you folks be prepared to accept?
Vince Calabrese
executiveI'd say that, looking back over time, we've examined that possibility, and it amounts to a zero sum gain. So we're happy with the portfolio we hold, and cash flows come in at a fairly healthy level. Nearly $900 million across the coming 12 months, roughly 12% of the portfolio. That's rolling off at 241, while at present we're putting money back to work at around the $540 million level. So considering how the portfolio is structured, I believe our team — Scott and his team — has done a very good job building a portfolio so that you don't face meaningful extension risk or attraction risk. And given where things stand today, there's an opportunity to generate cash flow each month. For the second quarter, we reinvested roughly two thirds of the cash flows, $135 million or so, back into the portfolio. The portfolio did get a bit smaller, and we need some of those funds to support loan growth if it's there, but during the quarter, we invested $529 million, as of today. Now it's $540 million. In the prior quarter, the first quarter, it stood at $510 million, so we'll keep investing there when attractive opportunities arise. Looking forward, the broad plan is to keep the portfolio roughly at the same level it had at the end of June as we move ahead. Again, we invest when we can be opportunistic. Thus far, we've managed to put $82 million to work at $540 million for a duration of three years. So I think the portfolio's strategy rests on a good, sound portfolio, and I think that strategy makes a great deal of sense for us.
Manuel Navas
analystMorning. To build on what was just discussed, could you share additional detail regarding your current position on borrowing, along with how decisions get made and the process itself? I'm aware you had staggered things somewhat and provided an update during the prior quarter. I'd simply like to know where things stand regarding borrowing right now, plus the cash held on the balance sheet.
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure. The way things look at this moment, we're still carrying roughly $1.2 billion in what I'd describe as surplus cash. That was added around March because of the disruption we saw in the market. As I mentioned, this impacted our net interest margin figures, which declined during the March to April period I referenced. However, when it comes to the actual dollars of NII, it roughly balances out. This is something we discuss on a routine basis. At present, our plan is to hold onto that $1.2 billion, correct, Scott?
Manuel Navas
analystOkay. If we return to the topic of loan growth briefly, it appears the focus is on the consumer side, since purchase volume is declining and you're engaging more in gain on sale activity. Consumer growth could drop somewhat over the latter half of the year, partly due to seasonality. So what are the patterns regarding an outlook, and what's your current view on the commercial side?
Vince Delie
executiveYes, I believe you described the mortgage book accurately. What I mean is, we anticipate it will taper off somewhat as the year winds down. Yet I do believe commercial is rising, with pipelines increasing roughly 12% overall. There's strong activity in the Carolinas, somewhat slower than in prior years, but still quite solid. This is where our geographic diversification truly benefits us, correct? Since I think the mid-Atlantic is sluggish, DC and Baltimore are somewhat slower. Pittsburgh remains, Pittsburgh has simply continued steadily. Cleveland and Pittsburgh, and then the South is still seeing, we are seeing higher pipelines, but as I mentioned, I think it's somewhat slower than it used to be previously. But it's significant enough to give us chances to meet our guide, which is why we reaffirmed our guide for the year. So we're at the midpoint now, so we feel somewhat more confident about where we'll finish up than before; so in any case, that's roughly the picture. From a C&I standpoint, I think there's likely a bit more activity on the C&I side. Clearly, CREs are somewhat slower. Once more, we aren't involved in large office space, urban large office, we're not truly involved there. So what we're observing is somewhat different, but others might have pursued it. But that's our situation.
Manuel Navas
analystHow big is the Physician First portfolio right now, and could you possibly give us any updates on cross-sell success or anything along those lines?
Vince Delie
executiveSure — I don't have any statistics with me that I can pass along. That portfolio keeps expanding. In total, it was above $750 million. The precise figure isn't in front of me, but —
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, it's around like $1.5 billion of Physicians First portfolio.
Vince Delie
executiveThat figure is worldwide. What I'm talking about is the amount we generated through our program compared with the amount kept on our balance sheet. The portion kept on our balance sheet is bigger.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat's just outside of —
Vince Delie
executiveYes, that's the entire revision when it comes to mortgages, not only Physicians and the Physicians First program. So a total of $1.5 billion would make up the portfolio. Roughly $750 million to $800 million would be originated via our dedicated program. But again, I think that as we go forward, the focus is going to be on product that's more saleable. We ought to be able to reduce balances as a result. And those customers — honestly, we've only just begun to scratch the surface regarding how we pursue our sell opportunity, so solid statistics aren't something I can give you. We're at a very early stage, especially when it comes to aggregating those products within the eStore. And once November arrives and depository products get added, here's what will happen: when a mortgage loan is originated by someone, even via the Physicians First program, they'll be able to buy insurance along with depository and other consumer loan products on one platform, at one time, with one application. Insurance won't arrive until a bit later, but by November, deposits and loans will be there end to end.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, look, when it comes to the loans for Physicians that were originated this year, what I'm saying is that over 90% of them went out the door with more than one product through our dealing, so.
Manuel Navas
analystExcellent. So I suppose the final thing I want to ask is that when we look at NII, and considering your rate assumptions, it can shift very rapidly. Yet with the guidance for NII and NIM, should we expect NII to reach its low point around the start of next year? What are your general views on that, since this is somewhat of a hypothetical for next year?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, I'd put it this way — the margin and NII likely hit their low point somewhere between the fourth quarter and the first quarter, roughly according to our present projections and our current thinking. After that, we'll begin to increase from there. Clearly, the expansion of earning assets that we have is a crucial element in that, and it assists them in growing, along with those other matters. And I'd add that the fourth-to-first timing I mentioned rests on what we're seeing right now, and as you noted, that can shift rapidly. So that's roughly the point where we'd expect things to reach their low point.
Brian Martin
analystHi there, good morning everyone. A lot of what I had was already covered regarding the loans and the margin, but I have one additional question about the margin, Vince. Is it fair to say that the speed of march indicates the pressure from funding costs is easing, meaning the effect of rates on the margin moving forward ought to keep getting smaller? So if you're projecting into the quarter, then in Q1 the rate at which the margin declines ought to be — it would be somewhat larger this quarter, perhaps somewhat smaller in Q1 and then gradually tapering off — is that the right way to view it based on what you expect for rates?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, I'd say — I referenced the 3 basis points a month over the last couple of months, so what's incorporated into our guidance would likely fall in that range of, I'm not sure, 3 to 4 a month; we'll probably experience a pace that's quite a bit slower than the 19 basis points it dropped by between Q1 and Q2; so that's what our guidance reflects. And then reaching a bottom in that Q4 to Q1, Brian, and then beginning to gradually build from there.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. Alright. Now regarding the liquidity component and, more broadly, deposit growth, I realize you mentioned that perhaps noninterest-bearing balances are somewhat reduced, yet concerning the decline, and you brought up how this quarter has seasonal patterns for deposits. What is your view going forward on deposits? I mean, assuming you continue, you sustain that liquidity according to your projections, those deposits ought to pick up somewhat seasonally during this quarter. Right, I understand you sort of provided the full-year guidance, but simply considering deposits in aggregate, rather than only the noninterest-bearing category.
Vince Calabrese
executiveRight, what we said is essentially unchanged through year-end merely because of municipal deposits and the movement going through that, and I believe our, if you examine our figures, well, every peer hasn't reported yet, however our reduction in deposits relative to the H8 data, I believe, looks quite strong. And I think the shifts in noninterest-bearing from certain items I've seen are definitely toward the stronger side in the earlier quarter when measured against those that have come out thus far, so.
Brian Martin
analystYeah. Alright. And what's your view regarding the liquidity, when you might actually consider deploying it to support loan growth instead of simply keeping it parked for a while? What does the outlook for that liquidity look like?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah, honestly at this point, Brian, we're just going to keep it right where it sits. I mean, we're making 5.15 on it, correct, Scott? Well, 25 basis points, that's not much; so holding onto it really isn't creating a cost for us, and with the current environment, no specific date has been set. I ask Scott about this constantly. Eventually we'll begin putting it to work, but at the moment we're going to keep that $1.2 billion as is; and as I mentioned, from an NII perspective, it isn't doing us any harm.
Brian Martin
analystRight, you have to. All right; and maybe regarding those last two items, it sounds like pipelines have picked up somewhat along with loan growth, yet things are still perhaps a bit lukewarm when it comes to the conversional side, and the buyback, I suppose, is something where this kind of repurchase pace at the current level might be able to keep going in the near term. If earnings support it and you're ready to deploy the capital, perhaps somewhat less if you have that conservative credit quality following the stress test, is that a fair way to view the buyback moving ahead, definitely anticipating you folks will be opportunistic?
Vince Calabrese
executiveThat's probably the key phrase, I believe. It is truly opportunistic. And should loan growth come in somewhat below our forecast, we might act more aggressively. On capacity, we still have a lot remaining under the $140 million authorization we have, and it could still be utilized by. So we'll stay opportunistic; and we handle that; we'll need to ensure shareholder interests, and we'll keep doing so.
Brian Martin
analystAll right, and this might be the final item. Gary, I believe during the prior quarter you said that following completion of the stress test, you could consider carrying out certain selective dispositions on the office side. I suppose, any news on that front? I suppose if you've sort of worked through everything. Has your view shifted at all there? Is there still a chance that could happen?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveBrian, at present we have nothing in our Q. So truly, there is nothing lined up for a sale in a later year. Taking action is always one option available to us; therefore, we'll keep examining that as the year progresses. I'll check whether anything ought to be placed into that category prior to the year's end. However, nothing at this time.
Vince Delie
executiveI want to express my appreciation to everyone for the questions and for the interest shown in F.N.B, plus thank our shareholders for sticking with us; the second half of the year is something we're excited about. There are, I believe, some excellent chances ahead for us to execute and deliver strong results; and I also want to thank our employees, who are so committed and consistently carry us through tough periods, and good periods, since we have very engaged and devoted staff. And I wished to express my gratitude to them too for all their efforts. Well, that's everything from me. Thanks to all of you.
Operator
operatorThis call is finished. We appreciate your participation in today's presentation. You are welcome to leave the line now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.