F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 19, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 68 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Lisa Constantine

executive
#1

Thanks. Morning everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call. This conference call from F.N.B. Corporation, along with the documents we've filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, is going to include forward-looking statements and non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP financial measures ought to be considered alongside, not instead of, the results we report under GAAP. You'll find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP financial measures, mapped to the closest comparable GAAP measures, in both our presentation materials and our earnings release. I'd ask you to review those non-GAAP and forward-looking disclosures that appear in our related materials, reports, and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which you can access on our corporate website. A replay of this call will be up until Thursday, October 26, and a link to the webcast will be posted in the About Us, Investor Relations section of our corporate website. At this point I'll hand things over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.

Vince Delie

executive
#2

Thank you, all, and good day to everyone joining this quarterly earnings discussion. Joining me on this call are our Chief Financial Officer, Vince Calabrese, along with Gary Guerrieri, who serves as our Chief Credit Officer. During the third quarter, F.N.B. reported net income available to common shareholders totaling $143 million, equivalent to $0.40 per diluted common share. Earnings per share rose 3% over the quarter. These figures demonstrate that F.N.B.'s long-term strategies are actively at work — approaches centered on risk management, prioritizing clients, generating organic growth, and expanding fee-based income. Our efficiency ratio for Q3 stood at 51.7%, and measured on a purely relative basis, we anticipate it will remain within the upper quartile. Beyond that, our operating leverage for the year so far is 8%. On a year-over-year basis, tangible book value per share increased 12.5%, hitting $9.02, and that's despite the impact of a higher industry figure. Return on tangible common equity came in at a solid 18.2% once again. As we've noted previously, given how strong our capital and liquidity position is, along with our commitment to underwriting guidelines that are consistent and conservative, F.N.B. is well positioned to steadily grow market share in this volatile environment. We closed the third quarter with total deposits of $34.6 billion, which is a 2.3% increase over the second quarter, and the mix remained fairly stable, with noninterest-bearing deposits making up 31%. During Q3, our linked deposit expansion outpaced the Fed's H8 deposit figures yet again, continuing a trend of beating the industry on a quarterly basis and reflecting both the resilience of our granular deposit base and our diversified geographic footprint, along with our ambition to serve as our clients' primary bank. Indeed, FDIC deposit market share figures that came out in September revealed F.N.B. holds a top-5 position in almost half of the MSAs where we have operations, and a top-3 spot in close to 30%. Despite intensifying deposit competition throughout banking, F.N.B.'s spot deposits have declined by under 0.5% since the close of 2022, underscoring the trusted role we play as our customers' primary operating end. During this quarter, the increase in deposits was essentially matched one-to-one by a 2.5% rise in loans compared with the prior quarter, and that loan expansion also clearly surpassed the H8 figures. A 2.4% gain in commercial loans was helped by the strongest quarterly production we have seen so far this year, and that activity was distributed throughout our entire footprint. From the end of 2022 through now, we have delivered 6.3% spot loan growth while also raising our CET1 ratio to 10.2%. Our tangible common equity to tangible asset ratio keeps climbing as well, reaching 7.54% in this quarter, despite the pressure of elevated rates. On top of that, a strong liquidity stance and funding costs that beat our peers give us flexibility on the balance sheet and let us meet our clients' capital requirements. The ratio of loans to deposits is still at a comfortable 92.9%. We're still putting money into the skills and tools that help us win more of the market and stay ahead of rival firms, especially when it comes to the digital products we provide to retail and business clients. Through our eStore, which has earned industry awards, we give customers a distinctive experience that improves both satisfaction and how many products they take up. Most recently, we introduced the eStore common application, which creates a single universal account form that spans the majority of our consumer lending offerings, letting someone apply for multiple products in one go via a greatly streamlined journey. Within just a few months, we're going to bring our consumer deposit offerings onto that same common application, and that should make onboarding faster for customers across multiple products while giving a meaningful lift to adoption of the common application. With our best-in-class digital capabilities and the strength of our balance sheet as a competitive edge, we'll pursue acquiring and expanding customer relationships throughout the 7-state region where we operate. This quarter, we took a full charge-off on the commercial and industrial loan that came up on our second quarter earnings call. Gary is going to share further details in his presentation. Setting aside that one charge-off, total net charge-offs would have come in at just 7 basis points, and total delinquency was 63 basis points. A careful emphasis on risk management balances out our growth strategies; we keep a close watch on macroeconomic and market-specific trends to handle risk, which is central to our credit philosophy and has treated us well during softer economic periods; we stay committed to steady underwriting and credit risk management so our portfolio remains balanced and well-positioned through economic cycles, letting us serve customers across business cycles in ways our competitors cannot. At this point I'll hand the call to Gary, who will give you more information about our credit performance.

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Vince, and greetings to everyone. We closed out both the quarter and the year-to-date period with asset quality measures remaining at sound levels. On a total basis, delinquency decreased by 12 basis points over the quarter, ending at 63 bps, and NPLs along with OREO came down 10 basis points, landing at a strong 36 bps. Criticized loans saw an 18 basis point reduction, while net charge-offs hit 47 basis points in the quarter and 26 basis points for the year-to-date stretch. Excluding the one-off credit item Vince referenced, net charge-offs registered 7 and 12 basis points across the quarter and year-to-date period, in that order. I'll finish my remarks by covering how our credit risk management approaches are evolving, plus the CRE portfolio. During our Q2 earnings call, we mentioned that we had placed one $31.9 million C&I loan on nonaccrual. Because of alleged fraud and additional findings that came to light as our investigation continued, along with bankruptcy filings that followed from both our borrower and its main supplier, we charged off that outstanding balance. We will continue monitoring the bankruptcy proceedings closely and pursue every avenue aggressively to recover some portion of the charge-off. Provision expense for the quarter totaled $25.6 million, which addressed loan growth along with the charge-off just described, after accounting for the $13 million specific reserve we had set aside for it at the end of the previous quarter. During the quarter, our ending funded reserve decreased by $12.1 million, landing at $401 million — a healthy 1.25% of loans — which shows where we stand versus our peers. If you factor in acquired unamortized loan discounts, that reserve figure comes to 1.39%, while our NPL coverage stays robust at 394%, again counting those unamortized loan discounts. Our dedication to steady underwriting and managing credit risk hasn't wavered, so we can keep the portfolio balanced and well-positioned no matter what the economy does, and each quarter we keep running full stress tests across the loan portfolio; the results from the latest exercise left us encouraged, since they affirm that having a diversified loan portfolio lets us weather a range of economic downturn scenarios. On the nonowner-occupied CRE side, delinquency came in at 31 basis points and NPLs at 20 basis points — both quite low. That tells us our disciplined underwriting and solid sponsorship are holding up even as rates rise. To wrap up, asset quality finished the quarter at healthy levels, and we're still producing loan growth that's diversified across appealing markets. We keep a close watch on macro conditions and the specific markets within our footprint, and we'll stay aggressive about managing risk. That's been central to our credit philosophy, and it's worked well for us through a range of economic cycles. At this point I'll hand things over to Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, who will share his comments.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#4

Appreciate it, Gary, and hello everyone. My remarks today will cover how we performed financially in quarter three, plus revised guidance for quarter four. For Q3, net income attributable to common shareholders came to $143.3 million, equal to $0.40 per share, which lifts our earnings per share for the first nine months to $1.18. These results reflect work by our commercial leasing group, which originates renewable energy financing transactions as part of its business model, and during this quarter they completed a sizable solar transaction involving an associated investment tax credit. Loans and leases stood at $32 billion when the quarter closed, up $796 million, or 2.5% on a linked-quarter basis, powered by our successful strategy of expanding high-quality loans throughout our varied footprint. Commercial loans rose $470 million, or 2.4%, spread across our 7-state geography, with significant contributions from the Pittsburgh, Mid-Atlantic and North Carolina markets. Consumer loans finished Q3 at $12 billion, up $326 million, or 2.8% versus the prior quarter, led by residential mortgage growth. Our investment portfolio was unchanged at $7.1 billion, split relatively evenly between AFS and HTM. The duration of the securities portfolio as of September 30 came in at 4.4, comparable to the prior quarter. Total deposits at the end of September reached $34.6 billion, a solid linked-quarter gain of $790 million, or 2.3%, driven by organic deposit growth along with seasonal inflows of municipal deposits. Our ability to gather deposits keeps beating the industry, as shown by Federal Reserve H8 deposit data, under which our deposit growth ran almost 220 basis points above for the quarter and 320 basis points above from year-end 2022. The shift in deposit mix decelerated somewhat in this quarter as customers shifted toward time deposits and interest-bearing demand deposits, which increased $458 million and $712 million, respectively, more than compensating for the $210 million drop in noninterest-bearing deposits. Because time deposits have expanded, we have deliberately maintained a short portfolio, with a weighted average maturity of 11 months, so that whenever rates decline, we can reprice those balances lower. At September 30, noninterest-bearing deposits made up 31% of total deposits, versus 32% on June 30 and 34% at year-end. With our granular, stable deposit base, we expect to keep beating the industry with an attractive ratio of noninterest-bearing deposits to total deposits, even should interest rates stay higher for longer. Our loan-to-deposit ratio is still at a comfortable 92.9%, unchanged from June 30. Revenue came to $408 million, supported by $327 million of net interest income and growth in noninterest income, which demonstrates our diversified fee income strategy. Net interest margin for Q3 was 3.26%, down 11 basis points, a smaller decline than the 19 basis points we saw in the prior quarter. Earning asset yields rose 17 basis points to 5.11%, reflecting better yields on loans and investment securities. Our overall funding cost rose 29 basis points, reaching $193, driven by interest-bearing deposit costs climbing 39 basis points to 2.36%, partly counterbalanced by what noninterest-bearing deposits contributed; we keep managing deposit expenses proactively, finishing the quarter at 1.75% and lifting the cumulative deposit beta to 31%. We expect that cumulative beta will finish 2023 in the mid-30s. Now for noninterest income and expense. Noninterest income came to $81.6 million, up 2% versus the second quarter, with capital markets income rising $1.2 million, led by International Banking thanks to strong contributions from swap fees, syndications, and debt capital markets income. Mortgage banking operations income fell $1 million because of negative fair value marks stemming from the sharp jump in mortgage rates during the third quarter, which more than outweighed a 46% rise in total saleable mortgage production compared with last quarter. Noninterest expense reached $218 million, which is $6.2 million or 3% higher than last quarter. Net occupancy and equipment expense grew $3.5 million, mostly reflecting technology investments and the inflationary macroeconomic backdrop. Marketing expenses rose $1.5 million owing to the timing of digital marketing campaigns, which aided deposit growth and brought in additional households. The efficiency ratio came in at a solid 51.7%, a slight increase from 50% last quarter. Across the first 9 months of 2023, the efficiency ratio was 50.8%, versus 54.7% during the same period in 2022. Even while fueling robust loan growth, our capital ratios stayed strong throughout the quarter. Our TCE ended the quarter at 7.54%, and after adjusting for held-to-maturity investment marks it would be 6.7%. Our CET1 ratio of 10.2% matches the peer median, and we stay well capitalized even after factoring in fair value marks across our AFS and HTM portfolios. Tangible book value per common share stood at $9.02 as of September 30, up $0.23 per share from June 30, mainly because a higher level of retained earnings more than offset the greater impact of AOCI, which cut current quarter end tangible book value per common share by $1.06. Year-over-year, tangible book value per common share climbed a full dollar, or 12.5%, which shows our dedication to generating capital internally. Let's turn now to fourth quarter financial objectives, beginning with the balance sheet. On a full year spot basis, we raised our earlier guidance for loans to grow mid- to high single digits year-over-year, since we're using this time to invest in our capabilities so we can gain market share across our diverse geographic footprint. Total projected deposit balances are revised upward to end 2023 relatively flat against year-end 2022 spot balances. Fourth quarter net interest income should land between $315 million and $325 million, assuming no further interest rate hikes for the remainder of the year. For the fourth quarter, we anticipate noninterest income of roughly $80 million, which aligns with what we guided to across the first 3 quarters of this year, as our diversified fee-based business strategy keeps delivering benefits. On noninterest expense, our fourth quarter outlook falls in the range of $215 million to $220 million, reflecting both higher investment spending and the pressures of the inflationary macroeconomic backdrop. Turning to full year provision guidance, we've narrowed it to a tighter band of $70 million to $80 million, and it will hinge on net loan growth along with charge-off activity during the fourth quarter. Finally, the full year effective tax rate is projected to land between 17.5% and 18%, while for the fourth quarter the effective tax rate should come in somewhere between 17.8% and 18.2%, reflecting the benefits of investment tax credits produced through financing transactions in our commercial leasing business during the quarter. With that, I'll hand the call back over to Vince.

Vince Delie

executive
#5

I want to say thank you — the results we delivered for this quarter came about because every one of our team members put in hard work. At F.N.B., our culture is built on people collaborating as a team so we can hit our objectives together. Independent input from our own staff keeps bringing us national recognition for that inclusive culture, and that comes on top of the several honors we picked up earlier in the year recognizing innovation, leadership in our family-friendly benefits and compensation programs — we also added more national culture excellence awards, which underscore how dedicated we are to diversity and to appreciation, wellness and development for employees. Our firm conviction is that an excellent culture with a workforce that is engaged produces outstanding results and rising shareholder value. This quarter's numbers make us happy, since we kept beating the industry by reporting growth in loans and deposits, stayed true to our cautious approach to managing risk, and at the same time made our capital and liquidity position stronger. With performance this solid, F.N.B. stands ready to serve our consumer and business clients, offering a wide range of products and services, a robust balance sheet, and a dedication to creating success for every one of our stakeholders. Thank you.

Daniel Tamayo

analyst
#6

Could you share your latest thinking on when you expect the margin to reach its low point? Also, do you have additional information about what September looked like regarding margin and yields, and similar items?

Vince Delie

executive
#7

Danny, I suppose I have a few remarks about that. Considering all that the industries endured during this year, it's obvious the high point occurred in the first quarter. When you examine our net interest income for the third quarter, we saw a decrease of just $2.6 million from NIM compression, which, as I noted, eased to 11% after a drop of 19 basis points in the prior quarter. Since May, the monthly reduction in NIM has typically been roughly 3 to 4 basis points each month; thus it has been declining, yet fairly consistent inside that band. Our guidance for the fourth quarter, between $315 million and $325 million, includes no rate hikes, as I stated, alongside the margin decrease, roughly comparable to what occurred in the third quarter—that is approximately what is incorporated into our forecast.

Daniel Tamayo

analyst
#8

All right, that's useful. Thanks for that. Now shifting to the topic of loan growth — I'm interested in how you view the potential for loan growth in the coming year should the economy lose momentum, since it's been maintained at a fairly robust pace throughout 2023, especially physicians first within the residential mortgage book. But I'd just like to hear your higher-level thinking on whether that level of loan growth can be kept up?

Vince Delie

executive
#9

Yeah. To start, I'd say our position is quite strong when compared with a lot of competitors, especially the smaller banks dealing with capital and liquidity challenges; that leaves us able to have F.N.B. step forward — essentially we can play offense, and we can pursue additional opportunities confidently. As we progress through 2024, we could meet our clients' capital needs. No guidance was provided for '24, so specific figures aren't something I can address; but as I look ahead to next year, loan demand is going to be uneven for everyone, and for us to succeed, we'll need to remain highly disciplined about growing our market share in the markets we've entered, where solid GDP-driven growth is still continuing. That should be one factor working in our favor. Beyond that, considering how large and broad the company is now compared with years past, there are multiple markets where we can chase opportunities. So as we head into '24, how the economy turns out will determine things, and finding creditworthy borrowers we'd actually want to bank will be tougher, correct? Under those conditions, competition will intensify. So having the right personnel distributed across those regions should benefit us compared with a competitor that's heavily concentrated in, for instance, Pennsylvania or Ohio. So I believe all of that works to our advantage. On top of that, we've put substantial investment into certain platforms that will keep generating fee income; thus beyond loan growth, we actually did quite well on the fee income side despite the pressures we encountered. However, we've put money into our digital platform, which ought to assist us in small business and in bringing in deposits as we enter this quarter and the common app is completely finished. We've invested considerably in treasury management systems, and our payment processing capabilities plus the lockbox capability we continue to provide clients have been enhanced over roughly the past 12 months. In Capital Markets, we've developed our capacity to take part in bond offerings via our debt capital markets platform, and that keeps producing good results for us while letting us move up market, engage in lower-risk transactions, and still satisfy the return thresholds we hold internally. Thus, every one of those factors should work to our advantage as we head into the coming year. Those are precisely what make me feel greater confidence regarding how we perform in this quarter and on through the following one. Still, let me offer a word of caution: in my view, macroeconomic conditions are going to matter. There also needs to be demand. In any case, that capital spending must be taking place on the commercial side.

Michael Perito

analyst
#10

I'd like to begin with something you said, Vince, regarding putting money into the OpEx area and attempting to capitalize on where the industry stands right now. I was curious whether you folks could perhaps elaborate a bit further on that point. I mean, from the financial statements it seems clear and apparent that you're in a solid spot at this point. So what kinds of investments are you considering? As you think about the coming 12 months, what do you believe might deliver the greatest impact? And clearly there are still some growth possibilities ahead of you, plus plenty of competitors who likely have opportunities too but lack the balance sheet to truly capitalize on them fully.

Vince Delie

executive
#11

Sorry, I didn't catch part of that. You're asking about digital in particular. Is that right?

Michael Perito

analyst
#12

Yes. I mean, I assume the majority of what you're examining is digital, though speaking more generally, are there any efforts or types of spending you're especially targeting that you believe might prove quite productive across the coming 12 months when it comes to sustaining growth and capturing share while the sector sits in a softer spot.

Vince Delie

executive
#13

Yes. Well, to begin with, I'd say that's an excellent question, and this has been a topic of discussion for us internally. As we head into next year, there are 2 directions we could take. Let's be honest, banking as a whole is dealing with margin compression. Certain banks find it hard to expand revenue; competition for deposits is intense; so I definitely get why so much hesitancy exists going into next year. But considering where we stand, our capital is robust — we hold a strong capital position. Our liquidity is tremendous; we've put money into de novo expansion within retail, and those are coming online, which brings added expense. So investment in those projects has already begun on our end. As a result, you'll see depreciation expense arrive alongside them. But now we've reached a stage where they ought to begin producing revenue or adding to what we're doing, correct? We simply — a number of them were launched by us early this year, or toward the end of last year. So solid success should be visible there; and those sit mainly in faster-growing markets that aren't experiencing as much difficulty as certain other more legacy markets when it comes to growth. So our outlook on how they perform is quite positive. We're equally positive regarding our build-out of the common app that I mentioned. Multiple loan products can be purchased on our platform as of today. Before this quarter ends, it will be possible to buy multiple loan products along with multiple depository products through a single application. And training is underway in the field. Training on our systems and our capabilities has been happening for quite a while. I believe you'll begin to witness that paying off. Several years back, we also altered our branch model within the consumer bank. Rather than keeping tellers and platform staff, we began introducing relationship bankers; meaning more thoroughly trained bankers inside branches; the final region is at last being closed out when it comes to transitioning those individuals into this elevated banking role, which ought to assist with cross-sell and generating product sales in branches beyond merely handling transactions. And then we have bankers essentially — plenty of bankers are retreating at other institutions. So chances should arise for us to pursue business that comes our way that we've been — with companies we've been approaching for a long stretch in the commercial space. We have put money into treasury management — to put it more precisely, that's an area we've funded, and my belief is it will help us turn into a go-to provider for mid-market and bigger businesses. . On the digital side, we've also spent on our platform so we can capture a larger share of wallet faster, correct, by giving clients a more streamlined way to come aboard. Considerable amounts have gone into our institutional capabilities from a capital markets angle, taking varied stances with clients. So honestly, there are multiple areas where we've put in work. And my sense is we will absolutely see results that beat our peers as a result. Anyway, those are my thoughts. Incidentally, we've additionally constructed our small business lending platform. That remains a priority for us. Our intention is to fold merchant and treasury management services together into a bundled offering along the lines of the common app; work on that is scheduled for Q1 of the coming year. Roughly 90,000 clients fall into either depository or loan categories within the small business segment. So there's a fair amount — my estimate is we sit at approximately 3% to 5% penetration with merchants in that area; a fair amount of upside exists there when it comes to fee income, and our attention has been on advancing into the next year. Those represent a few of the strategic investments we've undertaken. And my honest view is that right now, it's logical for this company to keep chasing those investments and push revenue growth through 2024, a period when doing so might prove harder for other firms.

Michael Perito

analyst
#14

Yeah. No, that's very clear. Nice analogy. One final thing from me, and after that I'll back off so somebody else can come in. This is more of a big-picture item rather than something about the near term. When you consider the franchise, its scale, and the growth estimates, I'd assume you're having ongoing discussions with the Board and the leadership group about the appropriate amount of capitalization. And clearly, on the asset side, when you're at the upper end of the range, capital gets discussed quite a bit. So I'm just wondering — do you have any fresh perspective on what you'd consider the appropriate capital level for F.N.B.? How does that look in the coming couple of years? Do you figure it's a bigger figure than what we saw across the prior 24 months? Clearly, you don't need to arrive at that answer at this moment, but I'm just somewhat interested in what people inside the company are saying about capital, considering all the current circumstances. And when you consider capturing market share and keeping the balance sheet expanding going forward?

Vince Delie

executive
#15

Yes. Well, at each board meeting we hold, we review the company's capital and liquidity situation. That's why we've got a fairly distinct group that examines the different parts of our financial results. The Board goes over the balance sheet carefully each time we meet, along with ways to get the most out of returns. From there, we look at what investors and the street are anticipating, and how our results stack up against that. Capital has been something we've kept on the agenda for quite a while. Since the AOCI impairment has hurt other firms' capital positions, we see ourselves as holding less capital, and that's because our risk profile is lower in the commercial lending segments we're in, as well as in consumer operations, where we stay quite cautious. When you take a look at our current position — CET1 sitting at 10%, and our TCE ratio at 7.5% and climbing — we're feeling fairly confident about our capital situation. I get it that once you cross the $100 billion threshold, regulators are going to expect more on the capital front. That said, considering where we stand right now, we're in one of the strongest spots we've occupied in years. Our portfolio is quite solid. We've devoted considerable effort to energy. Gary has done an outstanding job bringing risk down in that portfolio — through the Regency sale, the hospitality sale, the sale of adverse credits — and we've really accomplished a great deal. Before the pandemic hit, we had already shifted more than $1 billion off our balance sheet. From a capital standpoint, then, I'd say we're sitting in a really strong spot. Where we stand right now feels comfortable to us, and we bring it up at each board meeting. When you look at how we're doing on returns on tangible common equity, we rank in the upper quartile. So even with capital ratios that are elevated, we're still posting an 18% return on equity — results that are both solid and reliable, and profitable too.

Michael Perito

analyst
#16

Great. All right. Vince, I appreciate you taking my questions today.

Vince Delie

executive
#17

By the way, one additional point regarding capital — through buybacks or dividends, we have paid out more than $1.5 billion, over $1.5 billion in capital deployment to shareholders as well. So I think when you consider the company in capital management, that's part of the discussions that we have with the Board, just to throw that in there; so our shareholders have benefited from that distribution of capital immensely. And obviously, we have retained that capital, we have much higher capital ratios. That's part of the equation. So we feel that we need to evaluate where we are every quarter anyway, sorry.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#18

I'd like to ask something more about the NIM. Where do you think it might reach its lowest point in the coming year? If you could just give an update on that, and then I have another question about deposits.

Vince Delie

executive
#19

Right, I'm not certain that I'd call that an outlook for the coming year. I'll have Vince take that one. Please, Vince. Share a bit of detail on where things stand right now.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#20

Regarding that, we'll share our perspective once we give guidance for the upcoming year in January, though I think, as I noted, the fourth quarter is sort of landing at a level comparable to the third quarter. And perhaps the first half of next year, but once more, we need to do our — we've only just kicked off our budget projects for next year; so I believe there's still some downward movement, and pinning down precisely when it bottoms is tough to predict, no question, but sometime around the middle of '24 would be roughly where it lands given how things stand today, though that could shift by the time we wrap up our budget and release guidance in January; yet the compression I referenced has clearly eased. Should the fourth quarter land similar to the third quarter, net interest income, as I said before, declined by just $3 million. So I believe the sustainability of net interest income matters greatly, correct? And pushing our efficiency ratio into the low 50s. That's an essential piece of it. So expect more in January. I'm unsure regarding what level it might actually bottom out at; but the compression has definitely moderated, as I mentioned.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#21

Thanks for those details. When it comes to deposits, the CV engine really is strong — it's exactly what customers want. Are you able to share some breakdown of what you're observing — is this coming from new customers, or existing ones moving additional funds over? Could you walk us through where you're gaining traction there?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#22

Sure, I'd say...

Vince Delie

executive
#23

Yes, I think it's a — go ahead, Vince, I'm sorry.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#24

No, you go ahead.

Vince Delie

executive
#25

I was just about to say — my view is that it comes down to a mix of every one of those things. Part of what we're doing, I think, is convincing people to move more of their money to us. That was the main focus of certain campaigns. The money market product, a few of the CD products we offer. Bringing in new customers has gone pretty well for us, I'd say. More than 50% of the fresh funds coming through the door come from new customers. So it's above 50 to 50, but it has delivered results. That's one way to put it. Still, the biggest factor behind our success, and behind our ability to handle the betas and the migration somewhat more effectively, is honestly the insight we get into our own customer base — through the tools we've implemented using AI, our data scientists, and the data hub we've built — which lets us devote a great deal of time to studying behavior. That, I believe, has genuinely assisted us on pricing. And we've stayed a bit more disciplined than other players. Perhaps, if you look at our cost of funds and our margins, somewhat better. So that's reflected there. That said, I also think that serving as the primary bank for consumers and businesses, as I mentioned in my remarks, matters enormously, and that demands steady investment in technology, treasury management services, everything I listed earlier; so the two are inseparable.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#26

That's helpful, thank you. Could you give me an approximate percentage — some kind of rough typical rate for the fresh CDs, or alternatively, what's the top deal you're offering right now? And after that, could you quickly touch on how seasonal patterns affect the muni book?

Vince Delie

executive
#27

Sure, Vince, I'm not sure. Those specifics aren't something I can recall offhand. Vince, do you happen to have them?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#28

Yeah, sure. I'd mention a few points. On our promotional CDs and money market accounts, the rates have hovered at roughly 5%, slightly under or slightly over that. So, like Vince mentioned, thanks to the analytics backing everything and the resources we've got, we've pulled in roughly $800 million of fresh deposits from May onward using that approach. That has sort of anchored the entire balance sheet. Then when it comes to muni flows, something I've consistently referenced, the typical incoming range runs from $300 million to $500 million. In the latest quarter, it landed toward the upper part of that span and was fairly evenly distributed across the different categories. Only a modest portion sits in DDA — the bulk goes into money market and sweep accounts, which is where those funds move; that rises and falls over the course of the year, tending to grow through October and November, while Q1 is consistently the low point.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#29

Okay, thank you for that. Now let me shift to a different subject for a moment. What's your latest thinking regarding buybacks? Your growth was so strong this quarter. Is that the primary constraint? And clearly, organic growth likely takes priority; but could you explain how buybacks fit into the picture, since CET1 exceeds your target?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#30

Absolutely, I can address that. Regarding the 10.2%, we're slightly above what we aim for. In my view, during Q2, while we were active, excellent chances existed to deploy some capital there. Then in Q3, given the expansion we experienced, along with when the special assessment landed, there was a possibility it would occur in Q3, and because of that ambiguity, we chose to stay inactive through Q3. As usual, our dedication to handling capital in a way that's completely in line with shareholders remains. So we're watching it carefully. We might become active in Q4, though we truly want to observe how the broader situation unfolds; yet obviously, capacity exists for that; and considering the dividend payout ratio that all of us have strived hard to bring down to 30%. We currently possess flexibility along with the robust earnings production that we have, meaning this figure will grow, and we'll deploy it. If loan growth remains robust, we'll direct it toward supporting loan growth; that's consistently our primary and optimal use of capital.

Vince Delie

executive
#31

Another item I should bring up, Vince, concerns the tax credit deal we completed during this quarter. A few people have wondered whether that was just a one-off. It isn't; in fact, we run a business focused on tax credit transactions, especially within energy, so we've completed quite a few of them across the past several years. Within that group, there's a pipeline of tax credit deals we go after. As a result, it can be uneven, since constructing a solar field takes time, or getting certified and bringing that infrastructure online takes time, given that they must actually be producing power before the entire financial process can even begin; even so, it is a business we operate. It sits within our corporate finance area, and over the past several years they've performed extremely well; therefore, I'd anticipate that continuing into next year too, since we've built up that expertise, and we're confident that the people handling it — Tim and his team, who have executed many of these successfully — are well positioned to keep chasing opportunities. . I'd factor that into the picture too, because from a profitability standpoint it doesn't appear in the same manner, since we record an asset carrying a very thin margin, correct? That ultimately affects margin, and afterward we receive a tax benefit. Then all of you say, well, you're simply benefiting on taxes, yet that genuinely forms part of the profitability tied to the credit's extension, just so everyone is clear. So a number of people have raised this with us. And I wanted to ensure we made it clear that this is something we pursue continuously and that it will also contribute incrementally next year.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#32

And it gives funding as well, correct?

Vince Delie

executive
#33

Yeah, that's right.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#34

Regarding the NII guidance, you said there would be no more rate increases. If a rate hike does occur in November or December, I'm just curious whether that still matters much in terms of what it contributes to NII on an annualized basis. And perhaps you could discuss briefly how you're handling the balance sheet's sensitivity given the prospect of rates staying higher for longer.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#35

Yes, I'd say...

Vince Delie

executive
#36

Sure. Vince can take that one.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#37

Yeah. Frank, any kind of rate shift this late in the quarter, right, it doesn't have much of an effect on Q4; so we don't really gain a lot from that. And given the level of rates, honestly, even for next year the impact isn't all that large. If we look at where our IRR position sits, we've sort of been steadily drifting toward neutral quarter after quarter, just naturally arriving there. When you look at — once our IRR status comes out in the Q, the plus 100 ramp versus a minus 100 ramp is roughly 1%, 2%. So actually there's an advantage in either direction, since the yields on loans and investment securities we're adding remain above the portfolio rate. So you do pick up some benefit from that; however, 25 basis points in the bigger picture, it doesn't — it won't accomplish all that much; and we'll incorporate it into the guidance in January when we put it out, but it truly won't move the dial.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#38

All right. So turning to the guidance for expenses in the fourth quarter — how should we frame that? You spent a good deal of time discussing the investments you're making. Would it be more accurate to view that as a step-up in investment spending, which could mean a possible decline in expenses ahead, or, considering all the initiatives underway, is it simply cleaner to treat that as the current run rate?

Vince Delie

executive
#39

Vince, I'm not sure whether you'd like to...

Vince Calabrese

executive
#40

Absolutely, I can address that. As Vince mentioned, we've kept putting money back into the business — you're well aware of that, Frank, given how long you've tracked us. That's simply how we operate: spending to bring in revenue down the road. And we've managed to pull that off while keeping a really solid efficiency ratio in the low 50s. So that's just the nature of running this business. The discussions we have among ourselves always center on directing our CapEx toward places where future revenue can be generated, and on putting money into markets, correct? Through the de novo approach we've brought in new markets, and by growing our ATM strategy, <<inaudible>> Virginia, Charleston, plus markets that are extremely appealing; so putting money into those new markets is another piece of the investment, and those markets then produce future revenue for us. Regarding the expenses in the fourth quarter, it's always a — toward the close of the year, things can get a bit lumpy, or you're wrapping up incentive plan accruals and that sort of item as it lands. So when we issue guidance in January for the coming year, we'll include a cost savings target just as we do annually. I mean, we've removed roughly $60 million in costs while growing and building out scale; so that's consistently a piece of how we operate. And the initiatives Vince brought up — the de novo digital investments, the infrastructure needed to support that growth — we concentrate on producing that positive operating leverage and keeping a low 50% efficiency ratio; so it isn't simple, but it's something we focus on inside the company. And I believe those investments have worked out well for us. So it'll remain a piece of it; so there isn't really a step function involved, Frank, it's a fair question, but it's genuinely just a piece of how we operate.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#41

All right, that's helpful. Then, to wrap up, regarding the tax rate and that renewable energy deal — I completely understand it's simply a component of the arrangement, just inherent to the economics of those tax credits you receive. Would you agree that, if I examine the 4Q '23 guidance, it comes in somewhat lower, I'd say, compared with your rate across the prior several quarters, aside from this 3Q? Is that — would you characterize that as lumpy as well? Should we anticipate additional activity in 4Q? Or is it simply — has that business scaled up to a point where one might view it as potentially sustainable?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#42

Yeah, Frank, the fourth quarter figure is genuinely linked to that same solar deal we closed during the third quarter. Most of the tax credit is booked in the third quarter, and afterward there's carryover that sort of evens out the effective tax rate across the year, which additionally helps the fourth quarter. And that essentially wraps it up for this transaction; however, as Vince mentioned, there's a pipeline of transactions we keep pursuing. The team is already actively engaged on others that might occur next year and into '25. So — but 4Q is genuinely just connected to this transaction and sort of the smoothing of it into the fourth quarter.

Brian Martin

analyst
#43

I've got a single question, and it's about margin for a moment, Vince. I suppose — I'm grateful for the details regarding how the funding pressure has eased here — yet I suppose when it comes to the DDAs, what I mean is, I suppose the shrinking decelerated somewhat once more during this quarter. I'm simply sort of curious whether you believe a bottom is close by, how you're viewing that overall, and perhaps just a refresh on roughly where newly originated loans are landing?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#44

Yeah, I'd say, I suppose, allow me to address...

Vince Delie

executive
#45

I'm not sure — please, Vince, continue. Brian wanted to know which Vince that was. Go on.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#46

Okay, regarding the loans, I can address that. After that, Vince, if you'd like to discuss the approach for noninterest-bearing, that would likely be worthwhile. The fresh loans we originated in Q3 came in at 6.85%, an increase from 6.37% during Q2. Commercial loans therefore came on in the 7s, while mortgages arrived in the mid- to high 6s across the third quarter, and as of right now those sit around the mid-7s, simply because of where mortgage rates stand; so 6.85% represents a solid level and exceeds total portfolio yields, meaning that advantage flows through. On a spot basis, the overall portfolio rate rose 15 basis points thanks to those elevated rates on the new originations relative to the existing portfolio. There's also a slide in the deck, Brian, that you know well. Noninterest-bearing deposits have remained a priority for as long as I've been at this company, and Vince was doing so before me. We've expanded from 16% to — I believe our peak was 34%; we stood at 26% roughly before COVID, correct? And we'll put in serious effort to hold that figure as elevated as possible, and it's merely one element of all our activities, weekly during pricing, at every ALCO meeting, at every board meeting, so...

Vince Delie

executive
#47

Right, so that's really covered on Page 13 of the investor deck. We get asked about this a lot, but the way I see it, it ties directly into the strategy I've been laying out — we wanted to push noninterest-bearing deposits higher. Obviously, back when rates were low, folks didn't place much value on them. I brought them up constantly, talked about how we were doing on that front, and nobody really focused on it at the time, because the STP advantage just wasn't significant. These days, though, it gives us a fairly meaningful cushion on the margin side. If you look back at 2019, we sat at 26%. Demand deposits, 31% and 20%. You can see the stimulus-driven spike that followed. So we feel quite good about our position; we put client primacy first — he's got a trademark on that phrase. That's what he calls client primacy. Internally, our strategy is making certain we serve as the main depository bank and disbursement bank for consumers and businesses. And once again, we keep putting money into de novo branch locations to bring in new households where we can act as the disbursement bank on the consumer side. We've put money into digital; we've put money into TM products and services, such as the payment hub we implemented, plus some of the other offerings we recently launched that help us cement our role as the principal depository bank. That's the reason these demand deposits stay fairly stable. Compared with others, then. They aren't — it's not simply cash sitting here. In a lot of cases, those balances are there to cover services, the balances must stay in place for disbursements occurring across a month or a week; so they're largely embedded; so we feel quite confident in our deposit mix. That isn't to claim there was no pressure, since when rates dropped, naturally, companies and individuals, myself included, got a bit careless about parking their money in demand deposits; so that's different now. I believe consumers and businesses alike expect to put those balances to work given the returns available today. So I think we've shown over a fairly extended stretch that we're a very strong depository institution with a big focus on low-cost funding sources. Anyway, that's — I hope that's useful to you.

Brian Martin

analyst
#48

Yeah. No, that helps; seems like there might be room for it to drop somewhat further, though it's still stronger than what peers are showing and is maintaining well; alright then. And after that perhaps — please continue.

Vince Delie

executive
#49

Right. My belief is — my belief is that we are going to beat the competition. I cannot say what lies ahead for us down the road since nobody can — if I had the ability to forecast rates, I would not be sitting here trading bonds. However, my belief is my belief is that beating others will happen thanks to how our business model works. So that's...

Brian Martin

analyst
#50

Brian, thanks for that. On the reserve — it did come down slightly this quarter, though it's still at a pretty solid level, marks included.

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#51

We're always watching that closely. With unamortized discounts, we're at 1.25% and 139%, which puts us in the upper quartile and strong versus peers. We're comfortable with where things stand and with how the portfolio is positioned going into the end of the year. So my expectation is that it keeps tracking along similar lines from here.

Brian Martin

analyst
#52

Okay, Gary — just to refresh my memory, I believe there was a credit this quarter involving some other banks that hold an SNC portfolio. What's the size of your SNC portfolio as of today?

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#53

As of today, our SNC portfolio stands at $3 billion. More than 40% of it carries an investment grade rating, and basically the remainder sits essentially right at investment grade. As a result, that portfolio has done extremely well — it's very strong. Our approach: we don't purchase paper. We concentrate on customers we're familiar with and customers within our market. So that approach has truly demonstrated its value in that portfolio over an extended period; we've brought in substantial deposits that Vince mentioned in connection with that portfolio as well, and it keeps delivering outstanding results. So it's a very strong portfolio.

Vince Delie

executive
#54

I don't really want to give an answer here, since comparing syndicated loan books across banks just isn't possible. Take the buy side specifically — we aren't a leveraged finance participant. When we join a deal, we're purchasing participations, and we do that because we expect to gain ancillary business and because we're taking part in bond economics. One of our rules regarding their customers is that our bankers must hold a relationship with the company; they cannot simply depend on Bank of America or P&C to bring us into a deal. That kind of book differs from a less-in portfolio where you merely go out, purchase leveraged transactions, and chase yield. So, as Gary mentioned, a sizable portion of that syndication book consists of investment grade credits. Beyond that, we lead quite a few credits, since we built out a syndication effort. That would be captured within that figure where we're left the — so all of that has to be factored in.

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#55

Correct. Like Vince said, leveraged finance isn't a business we're in. A private equity business isn't something we have either. What it really comes down to is customers in the markets we serve, the ones we call on and have relationships with. So for us, that's been a really strong book of business.

Brian Martin

analyst
#56

Understood. Thanks for all those details. Then perhaps my final question concerns the commercial and consumer pipelines. I realize you aren't providing any outlook for '24, but considering the expansion we saw this quarter, I'd simply like to know how the pipelines stand now compared with the prior quarter. How would you describe it?

Vince Delie

executive
#57

Sure — we've just finished a quarter of funding activity. What usually occurs is that we establish the pipelines. My sense is that across most markets, we're lower by 5% to 10%. I recently reviewed the figures market by market and monitor them quite closely. So I'd describe it as a 5% to 10% decrease, though they are still growing. Considering the portfolio as a whole and how our commercial loan portfolio behaves, first, the runoff has slowed considerably owing to rate conditions. That should assist in steadying the balances. That's point one. Second, appetite for capital appears to have eased as we head into the coming year. That partly explains why the pipeline has decelerated — fallen somewhat, and in particular, I pay closer attention to the 90-day pipeline, which is lower by roughly 4% or 5%. That's the one I watch most since we examine it in two ways, correct? Total against close in the near term; and I believe it will grow once more as we move into next year, clearly contingent on interest rate movements and the broader economy. Even so, I'm fairly confident there will be some buildup. Then the third item I wanted to raise is that utilization rates have edged down a bit, which signals a retreat; specifically, within the commercial book, we're observing a 1% to 2% drop in utilization rates. For me, that indicates borrowers are somewhat stepping back.

Brian Martin

analyst
#58

Understood. And regarding those pipelines — you mean a decline of 4% to 5% for both consumer and commercial? Or was it mainly on the commercial side?

Vince Delie

executive
#59

No, my apologies, I was referring just to commercial. On the consumer side — what the pipeline looks like there hinges on the specific segment. Take mortgage, for instance: we're carrying more mortgage volume than we actually need. Essentially, we're getting more aggressive in order to move it off the balance sheet, correct? That means we're competing harder in the conformance space, which dents margin somewhat; it moves it off the balance sheet. So growing our consumer and mortgage business has gone quite well for us; that doesn't concern me much. Small business has done reasonably well. Pipelines have risen. That physician's first program and the focus on health care has really delivered for that group, we have some tremendous momentum that we brought on — the head of our small business lending area possesses specialized knowledge in health care, which explains why we're building those products I brought up earlier during this call. The pipeline there appears quite strong. And I believe there's an opportunity for us as we head into '24, as I mentioned, within the small business segment, which sits inside consumer, to expand that book of business. After all, we have a huge number of small business customers spanning 7 states. I referenced 90,000 to 100,000 customers; so our small business pipeline during the latest quarter hit record levels, and I'd anticipate we keep building on that. I realize it doesn't add all that much to the overall total, but it ought to be a good sign for the retail consumer bank. That's the situation. I don't — honestly, we aren't expecting problems with mortgage or — mortgage is harder, sure, given the higher interest rate environment, since most loans we originate across a fairly wide footprint are purchased money loans, and we've put substantial investment into the platform lately. So we're quite confident we can deliver better than peer results in mortgage, just as we have been. And that opens up home equity possibilities and other chances within the consumer segment. Plus, with the application we launched, we believe that will also assist us in '24; so having the ability to open a depository account and apply for a home metric loans at the same time will let us originate loans in the consumer space.

Brian Martin

analyst
#60

Understood. Alright, and my final question concerned efficiency. It seems, based on what was said regarding expense management and this quarter's results, that we ought to view the low 50% efficiency ratio as roughly a level that can be maintained moving forward?

Vince Delie

executive
#61

Our target — we have consistently stated our target is 50% to 55%. That's what we aim to reach. Naturally, we want to remain as low as we can, correct, since all of us have incentives to keep expenses well controlled here as part of our incentive program. So I believe we will be extremely diligent; yet I also believe that considering our capital liquidity, our digital investment, and what we have underway here, we must remain focused on expanding revenue as we navigate this challenging period. We can handle risk quite effectively. And I think we sit in a very strong position to grow as we enter '24. So regarding revenue, I believe we'll get a chance to manage — at minimum contribute to positive operating leverage compared with peers; thus there is expense build, but revenue growth accompanies it as well; so that's roughly the strategy. It has been the strategy for quite a while. I know there are times when it's lumpy and people ask <<inaudible>> into issue. You can observe the outcomes across a long stretch when we've outperformed peers for a decade, I don't believe. So in any case, that's where we stand.

Vince Delie

executive
#62

Alright, once more, I want to express my appreciation to everyone for those inquiries — they were quite thorough and really solid. So, thanks for taking part. And I'd also like to give thanks to our team members once more; I mention this each time, yet achieving this is impossible absent outstanding individuals. So I'm involved and passionate about our staff. Regardless of the situation, we ultimately succeed since we function jointly as one unit. But gratitude goes out to the employees, and thanks to the investors for their ongoing trust in what we do. We'll keep on producing results as we navigate through these turbulent stretches ahead; so, thank you. Everyone, take care.

Operator

operator
#63

That brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate everyone joining us for today's presentation. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.