F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 19, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 78 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Lisa Hajdu

executive
#1

Thanks. Good morning, everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call. During this F.N.B. Corporation conference call and in the documents we file with the Securities and Exchange Commission, forward-looking statements and non-GAAP financial measures frequently appear. Non-GAAP financial measures are typically considered alongside, rather than as a substitute for, the results we report under GAAP. You can find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP reporting measures, compared with the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures, within our presentation materials and our earnings release. Kindly review those non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures found in our related materials, reports and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available on our corporate website. Until Friday, January 26, a replay of this call will be accessible, and the webcast link will be posted to the webcast link will be posted to the about Us, Investor Relations section of our corporate website. Now I'll hand the call over to Vince Delie, Chairman, President and CEO.

Vince Delie

executive
#2

Thanks for joining us on this call about our fourth quarter results. With me are Vince Calabrese, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer, and Gary Guerrieri, our Chief Credit Officer. On a reported basis, net income available to common shareholders at F.N.B for Q4 came to $49 million, and on an operating basis it was $139 million. For the full year 2023, our operating results featured record revenue totaling $1.6 billion, record net income available to common shareholders of $569 million, and record earnings per diluted common share of $1.57. Tangible book value per share rose 15% compared with a year earlier, reaching an all-time high of $9.47 per share and moving steadily toward the $10 mark. Since 2009, internal capital generation at F.N.B — meaning tangible book value plus dividends — has been robust, posting 10% compounded annual growth; given that strong profitability, positive operating leverage for the full year came to 1.5% and should stay in the upper quartile relative to peers. Our outstanding financial results in 2023 stemmed directly from steady execution of our strategic initiatives. The banking turmoil early in the year shone a light on how much balance sheet resilience matters, including our deposit base, solid capital and liquidity, and disciplined underwriting; it also reaffirmed the worth of our quality customer relationships and our comprehensive delivery teams. Such attributes have long been woven into F.N.B's long-term strategy, which has been tested across numerous cycles during the past decade and is embedded in the very foundation of how F.N.B functions. Our dedication to keeping a stable deposit base shows up in total deposits, which finished the year at $34.7 billion, flat versus the prior year, despite heightened competition for customer deposits. The mix of noninterest-bearing deposits relative to total deposits closed the year at 29.4%. Although customers have been shifting away from noninterest-bearing deposits, we keep outperforming peers in the industry by a wide margin on total deposit cost and overall cost of funds. Our spot deposit costs finished the year under 2% and beat peers by more than 50 basis points in the third quarter. Lower funding costs than peers, along with strong liquidity, give us balance sheet optionality. Our tangible common equity to tangible assets stands at 7.8%, the highest in company history, and above peer medians. F.N.B stays dedicated to deploying capital optimally in a way that is fully aligned with shareholder interests and best positions F.N.B; for future success. In line with that dedication, F.N.B. recently wrapped up the sale of roughly $650 million of available for sale securities, announced redemption of $110 million of preferred stock, and moved $355 million of indirect auto loans to held for sale, with that sale anticipated to close in the first quarter. Taken together, these moves produced a capital neutral transaction that enhances forward returns and earnings, with expected EPS accretion in the low single digits. Our ongoing capacity to serve client needs is essential to our performance. F.N.B. We've kept making purposeful investments in our delivery team to strengthen ties with customers, capture more market share, and stay ahead of rivals; back in June 2023, we rolled out the eStore common application across most of our consumer lending offerings, and more recently in December we added deposit products, which lets customers submit applications for as many as 18 consumer deposit and loan products at the same time. For 2024, our aim is to welcome small businesses in, with business loans, deposits, and payments all part of the common application within the eStore; these added capabilities improve the customer experience even more and drive deeper product penetration, since customers can request several loan and deposit products at once in a highly streamlined way, cutting out keystrokes, offering a portal for uploading supporting documents, and automating account funding; we also rolled out meaningful upgrades to our physical delivery channel during 2023. Beyond growing our footprint with 4 de novo locations, we formed a partnership with the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit that makes F.N.B the only ATM provider for the third largest heavy rail system in the United States. With ATM banking services available at every metro station, this partnership will bring over 120 machines into the F.N.B. network during 2024. Our physical delivery channel is nearing 2,000 combined branches, ATM and interactive television. Alongside our digital Easter, F.N.B. has substantially advanced access for our current and future customers while boosting brand awareness across our foot. Thanks to the success of our eStore and our outstanding bankers, total loans and leases finished the year at a record $32.3 billion, up $2.4 billion from year-end 2022; we're starting the year in a strong position and will keep watching the macroeconomic environment, or market-specific trends closely so we can manage risk proactively as part of our core credit philosophy; we'll stay firm in our approach to consistent underwriting and risk management so we maintain a balanced, well-positioned portfolio through economic sites. I'll now hand the call to Gary for more detail on the fourth quarter's credit performance. Gary?

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#3

Thanks, Vince, and good morning to all of you. We closed out both the quarter and the fiscal year with our asset quality measurements holding at strong levels. Delinquency on a total basis ended the year at 70 basis points, which reflects a seasonal increase of 7 basis points versus the close of September, and a decline of 1 basis point measured against the same point one year earlier. NPLs and OREO came down by 2 basis points relative to the preceding quarter and by 5 bps versus the comparable period 1 year ago, finishing at a very healthy 34 bps. Criticized loans dropped 13 basis points when set against both the previous quarter and the prior year-end, while net charge-offs for the quarter and for the full year landed at 10 and 22 basis points, respectively. I'll wrap up my comments by giving you an update on how we approach credit risk management along with our CRE portfolio. Total provision expense during the quarter came to $13.2 million, covering loan growth as well as charge-offs. On top of that, provision expense received a favorable boost from declines in criticized loans and NPLs. Our funded reserve at period end grew by $4.9 million over the quarter, now sitting at $406 million, equivalent to a robust 1.25% of loans, which speaks to our strong standing versus peers. Once acquired unamortized loan discounts are factored in, that reserve reaches 1.39%, and our NPL coverage stayed robust at 418% when those unamortized loan discounts are included. We stay dedicated to steady underwriting and credit risk management so that a balanced, well-positioned portfolio is maintained through all phases of the economic cycle. Every quarter, beyond our continuous full portfolio stress test, we carry out targeted deep-dive reviews of our portfolios. The stress testing output for this quarter revealed reduced forecasted net charge-offs along with a stable provision relative to what the previous quarter produced, once again affirming that the diversified nature of our loan portfolio lets us endure a range of economic downturn scenarios. Turning to the nonowner-occupied CRE portfolio, during 2023 we effectively handled maturities and the effects of the rising rate environment on that portfolio. Come 2024, that same approach will continue, as we track the rate environment and get ahead of maturities on the horizon. At year-end, delinquency and NPLs within the nonowner-occupied CRE portfolio stayed quite low, at 32 and 18 basis points respectively, which validates our steady underwriting and strong sponsorship. To sum up, asset quality metrics closed the year at very healthy levels, and we enter 2024 from a position of strength. We keep producing diversified loan growth across appealing markets amid a competitive landscape for high-quality borrowers, all while upholding our steady underwriting standards; we watch macroeconomic trends and the individual markets within our footprint closely, and we will keep managing risk aggressively while preserving a consistent credit profile across every one of our portfolios. At this point I'll hand the call to Vince Calabrese, our Chief Financial Officer, for his remarks.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#4

Gary, thanks, and good morning to everyone. Today I'll walk through our Q4 financial results, share additional information about recent moves we made to further strengthen the balance sheet, and offer our 2024 guidance. After setting aside $114 million in significant items that impacted earnings, operating net income available to common shareholders for the quarter totaled $139 million, equating to $0.38 per share. Operating earnings for the entire year set a record at $1.57 per share. Tangible book value stood at $9.47, a 15% increase over December 2022. Consistent with our continuing proactive approach to managing the balance sheet, we implemented multiple measures aimed at improving future profitability and our capital position. During the final part of Q4, we liquidated roughly $650 million in available-for-sale investment securities, moved $355 million of indirect auto loans into held for sale, and disclosed plans to redeem $110 million of Series T preferred stock, which had been issued a decade earlier. Taken together, these balance sheet moves produce additional earnings with a tangible book value earn-back period under 1 year, compared with a 5-year earn-back for repurchasing shares, all while preserving capital flexibility in 2024. During Q4, selling investment securities generated a realized loss of $67.4 million; those securities were yielding 108 on average, and we put the proceeds back to work in securities yielding roughly 350 basis points more, with duration and convexity profiles that were similar. On the indirect auto loans that were classified as held for sale at December 31, we took a $16.7 million negative fair value mark along with other noninterest expense, which reflected interest rate movements since origination. We expect that loan sale to close in Q1, and the money received will go toward paying down borrowings so the yield ends up similar to that of the loans we sold. Roughly 100 basis points of benefit came to our year-end loan-to-deposit ratio. If you set aside the $355 million in indirect auto loans that were classified as held for sale, our period-end loan growth came to 8% compared with year-end 2022. Looking at the fourth quarter, production consisted of high-quality loans throughout our diverse footprint, with commercial loans rising $351 million and consumer loans up $178 million during the quarter. Our investment portfolio was basically unchanged from the prior quarter, sitting at $7.2 billion, which includes the restructuring of the securities portfolio. The mix between AFS and HTM is still roughly balanced, with 45% held in available for sale as of year-end. As of December 31, the duration on our securities portfolio stands at 4.2 years, which is in line with last quarter. Deposits finished the year at $34.7 billion, up modestly by $96 million from the previous quarter. By the end of the year on December 31, noninterest-bearing deposits made up 29.4% of total deposits, whereas on September 30 that figure was 30.9%. Because our deposit base is stable and granular, we expect to keep beating the industry, with a good ratio of noninterest-bearing deposits to total deposits and reduced deposit costs, and we significantly surpassed peers on that front since our team stays hard at work managing the deposit mix. We ended the year with spot deposit costs at 193, and cumulative deposit beta was 34.3%, right in line with the guidance we gave you last quarter. Net interest margin for the fourth quarter was 3.21%, a decline of only 5 basis points, which is an improvement over what we projected last quarter. Earning asset yields rose 14 basis points to 5.25%, driven by stronger yields on loans as well as investment securities. Total cost of funds climbed 21 basis points to 2.14%, while the cost of interest-bearing deposits was up 29 basis points at 2.65%. Net interest income came in at $324 million, off slightly by $2.6 million versus the previous quarter. Now on to noninterest income and expense. Operating noninterest income reached $80.4 million, and once you adjust for the $67.4 million realized loss tied to the investment securities restructuring. Income from mortgage banking operations was up $3.1 million quarter over quarter, helped by better gain on sale margins and supported by the drop in mortgage rates during the fourth quarter. Beyond that, we saw a $2.4 million drop in other noninterest income, while small business investment company funds declined, which mirrors the typical fluctuations tied to the performance of the companies in the underlying portfolio. In addition, we split the service charge fee income line on the income statement into service charges and a new line item for interchange and card transaction foods, which previously was included within the service charge line. That provides clearer visibility into the separate revenue streams that make up noninterest income. Noninterest expense came in at $218.9 million, which was essentially flat quarter over quarter after you back out two items: a $16.7 million fair value mark on direct auto loans held for sale, and a $29.9 million FDIC special assessment related to refilling the deposit insurance fund following the bank failures. Outside services increased $2.4 million from the linked quarter, driven by higher third-party costs. Bank shares and franchise taxes accounted for $2.3 million, tied to charitable contributions that qualify for the Pennsylvania bank shares tax credits, while marketing expenses fell $1.2 million due to how digital marketing campaigns were timed in the third quarter. Our efficiency ratio for the fourth quarter was 52.5%, which keeps us in the top quartile among our peers. For the entire year, we kept costs in check while expanding the many different revenue sources we have, and that shows up in an efficiency ratio of 51.2%; we ended the year with capital ratios among the strongest we've seen in recent memory. Even after factoring in both the balance sheet management items we went over earlier and the FDIC special assessment, our CET1 ratio stands at 10.1%, which remains above the operating target we've set. Tangible common equity was 7.8%, and if you back out the 54 basis point hit from AOCI, you'd get 8.3%. As of December 31, tangible book value per common share reached $9.47, which is a $0.45 per share increase over September 30. AOCI lowered tangible book value per common share by $0.65 at year-end, versus $1.06 last quarter, mainly because of how interest rates affected the fair value of available-for-sale securities. Since the investment securities sold in December were classified as available for sale, that realized loss didn't have any incremental effect on TCE or tangible book value, because the market value was already captured in AOCI. Now let's move on to the 2024 guidance for the first quarter as well as the full year, beginning with the balance sheet; on a full year spot basis, we anticipate mid-single digit loan growth as we keep growing our market share throughout our diverse geographic footprint. Looking at spot balances compared with the same period last year, we anticipate growth in overall deposit balances within the low single-digit range. For net interest income across the entire year, our expectation falls somewhere between $1.295 billion and $1.345 billion, and when we look at the opening quarter of 2024 specifically, that figure lands in the $318 million to $328 million range. Built into this outlook is an assumption of 325 basis points worth of rate reductions, consistent with the <<inaudible>> , and our projection places those cuts in May, July and November of 2024. Turning to noninterest income, our diversified fee-based income strategy ought to continue delivering gains, producing full year results somewhere in the $325 million to $345 million span, while the first quarter comes in at $80 million to $85 million. Looking at the entire year, we expect noninterest expense to fall somewhere in the range of $895 million to $915 million. That figure accounts for about $6 million in rent costs tied to the construction period for our new headquarters, during which we'll continue using our existing office space. Once you strip out that effect, the midpoint of our guidance for expenses works out to a 3.7% rise compared with 2023 operating expense levels. For the first quarter, noninterest expense ought to land somewhere between $225 million and $230 million, driven mainly by the fact that compensation costs tend to be elevated early in the year due to typical seasonal long-term stock compensation as well as higher payroll taxes as the new year gets underway. For the entire year, we're guiding to a provision of between $80 million and $100 million, with the final figure tied to how much net loan growth and charge-off activity we see. Last, our effective tax rate for the full year ought to land in the 21% to 22% range, and that projection leaves out any investment tax credit activity that could still happen. Vince, I'll turn it back over to you now.

Vince Delie

executive
#5

In 2023, F.N.B. carried out several efforts consistent with our strategic goals, among them the launch of eStore common applications for consumer loans and deposit products, broadening our physical delivery channel, and putting money into systems and processes that let us make operations more efficient. Our work to grow data analytics capabilities and apply AI for better performance keeps moving forward. Amid disruption in the banking industry, these strategic efforts fed straight into our outperformance relative to peers during 2023, with the company producing record operating EPS of $1.57 alongside robust organic loan growth of $2.4 billion. Deposit balances held steady, with noninterest-bearing deposits making up 29% to 34% of total deposits and a cost of products in the top quartile. Excluding acquisition synergies, we have achieved more than $75 million in cost savings across the last 5 years, which produced positive operating leverage and an efficiency ratio of 51.2%, placing us in the top quartile versus peers. Operating return on average tangible common equity came to 18%, while intangible book value rose 15% to a record $9.37. Asset quality remains a strength for us, as we finished the year at or near historically low levels. Our employees made this year's exceptional performance possible. Their dedication to F.N.B's mission and values fuels success for every one of our stakeholders; in 2023, that dedication showed clearly, as F.N.B. earned more than 30 prestigious awards. A number of independent organizations honored F.N.B's financial performance, outstanding culture, and innovative technology, including eStore earnings international. In our view, these honors and our results stem directly from a workplace environment that engages and rewards people. I take pride in what we've built together. Thank you.

Daniel Tamayo

analyst
#6

Perhaps we could begin with how the balance sheet or restructuring affects the margin. I'm grateful for the 2024 guidance. But when considering what happens in — during the first quarter, I'm wondering whether you could explain your thinking on how the restructuring plays in, viewing it as an effect of 5 or 6 basis points versus simply ongoing pressure on deposits, and then how the margin's trajectory develops across the year under your assumptions?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#7

Sure, a few points come to mind. To begin with, looking at the fourth quarter and moving ahead, net interest income fell by just $2.6 million from one quarter to the next, matching what happened the quarter before. For that quarter, NIM compression amounted to merely 5 basis points. The preceding quarter saw 11. In fact, during November and December, we stood at <<inaudible>>. So things largely leveled off there, for those 2 months at least. Our guidance already incorporates the restructuring completely. Regarding what lies ahead for the margin, I'd repeat what we stated three months ago: it likely reached its low point at some stage during the first half of the year, followed by modest gains afterward once you move into the latter half. Still, much could unfold, correct, given the Fed cutting. Our own forecast includes 3 Fed cuts, while others suggest 3, 4 or 5. To us, 3 seemed the most sensible; that is what our guidance reflects, together with the restructuring's benefit. And as we've done previously, we will keep vigorously pursuing demand deposits, which is where our focus will be. I believe our share of overall deposits has held up quite strongly compared with peers, and shifts within that category have likewise compared quite favorably; so the NII guide essentially incorporates everything, Dan.

Daniel Tamayo

analyst
#8

No, I get it, and thanks for that. Let me try putting it a different way — is it fair to say you believe the deposit pressure we saw in Q1 cancels out the — basically, what I'm hearing is that there may still be additional compression overall once Q1 comes around. So your view is that this does more than cancel out the balance sheet restructuring, and that simply carries on through the first half, into Q1?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#9

Well, we won't get into specifics about quarterly margins, correct? Net interest income has every bit of that factored in. Regarding the mix shift that took place over the quarter, we keep watching customers chase higher rate products, which is only natural. Folks out there are thinking, okay, the Fed has peaked, and given where the average rate has sat since July, when will cuts begin. So some of that mix shift is certainly still going on; when it comes to Q1, our demand deposit is typically at its seasonal weakest because municipal deposits tend to hit bottom and then rebuild. So everything there does create a bit of pressure on the margin, and the restructuring then helps cancel out a portion of those effects in Q1 — that's probably one angle I can give you on it.

Daniel Tamayo

analyst
#10

Understood. All right, so for my final question, I want to probe the sensitivity side of the balance sheet. I'm just wondering what the right framework is, given that you brought up a bottom occurring halfway through the year. Previously, I believe we discussed potentially being liability sensitive over the medium term, yet perhaps asset sensitive near term when cuts happen. Should we still view it that way, with possibly some negative effect initially? Then after several quarters pass, that's presumably when the advantages of rate reductions kick in?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#11

Yeah. That is absolutely the correct framework. Regarding sensitivity, whether further reductions come our way past the 3, as you're aware, many variables factor into this matter. Plus there are steps we might pursue based on what the economy does; so but as you put it, the time frame matters most, correct? Near term, you get a detrimental effect especially from the cluster plus another cut, and afterward I believe deposit delays will eventually close the gap. What I mean is, looking back, when you examine our beta at present, correct, it sits near 34%. During the previous upgrade cycle, we essentially peaked at 35%. Assuming that appears sensible. However, reaching that would require, say, the medium term, longer term to recover, likely the medium term, for deposit rate delays to close the gap and deliver that advantage. And as you're aware, we've undertaken numerous steps. What I mean is the CD book has expanded over the shorter term in the 7- and 13-month type range. The CD portfolio's total average maturity at this moment is 10 months. Thus there's a chance to reprice that going forward. Consider the timing of when the Fed might act, but yeah, I believe that's — we remain somewhat asset sensitive and essentially steering toward neutral, and then we believe that — when you look at our margin trajectory across the year, it's rather more neutral given the anticipated 3 cuts we've incorporated.

Daniel Tamayo

analyst
#12

All right. That's great. Thanks for that.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#13

I was hoping you could spend a bit of time discussing how loan growth and deposit growth are interacting. You clearly have a target, and over time you're moving nearer to a 100% loan-to-deposit ratio. I'm just attempting to work out what the primary constraint on loan growth might be, and how you are pulling deposit dollars in through the door, given what remains a fairly competitive backdrop.

Vince Delie

executive
#14

Sure. Let me kick things off, and after that I can hand it over to Vince Calabrese. To begin with, a few of the items we brought up during the prepared comments regarding acquiring appliance represent a method for us to push deposit balances higher. What I mean is adding the capacity to open a deposit account at the same time as a loan application, with no extra key strokes. For us, that's enormous. So once the field begins using these tools and customers begin engaging online and figure out that this is possible, I believe it will assist, and it will raise our likelihood of capturing a larger share of the client relationship, especially on the deposit side; so when a loan request arrives, we'll be able to move a bit faster when opening the deposit accounts. So that's one item we planned for, and we believe it will benefit us going forward. If you consider engagement with the eStore, we examined — we rolled that out around midyear. So if you consider the 6 months in '22 against the 6 months in '23 during that same period. When you compare how many applications we managed to get online, they doubled — we doubled the volume of consumer loan applications. That's without the deposit account opening capability, incidentally. And 30% of those clients — 30% of those applications involved non-F.N.B customers; so that's one element of it. The improvement of the digital strategy. The second opportunity for us really sits in small business and middle market banking on the TM side. We've put a substantial amount into our treasury management capabilities; we have certain product capabilities about to come online. We noted that we intend to bundle products in the small business space in '24, likely in the back half of the year, and we'll be rolling that out. That too will help us expand deposit balances. And if you consider what we've done in the past, historically we've grown deposit balances somewhere in the 10% — 8% to 10% range organically. So I believe we've kept pace with the organic loan growth we've delivered, which is comparable, correct, across a long stretch of time. Also, I believe a few of the strategic moves we've made, along with moving into additional markets that offer greater potential thanks to increases in population and the creation of businesses, will let us stay on track with our goal — namely, supporting our loan growth using deposit balances belonging to new customers. Vince, I'm not sure — would you like to provide any figures?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#15

Right. Frank, the only thing I'd tack on is that our guidance doesn't assume we reach 100% — it's more like that 95%, 96%, 97% zone once you project it out. That said, the way we've handled it before, looking back historically, when we hit 97% several years ago, we made a move this quarter by selling the indirect auto loans, which frees up additional shelf space for us. What that did, actually, was give us 1% on the loan deposit ratio. So we'll keep that level in check. Reaching 100% isn't the plan; the mid-90s is what's baked into the guidance, and as I said, we'll begin managing from there. Once we get to 95%, we'll ask: what does the environment look like? How quickly are loans growing, and what moves do we make, same as we've always done — just manage it.

Vince Delie

executive
#16

In our case, this isn't just some routine task, and it's not about whether deposit growth can provide the funding for our balance sheet. That's something we're able to do. We've got the ability to pull it off — the only issue would be margin, or more than that, correct? So we're attempting to get everything into proper balance, right; we're quite confident about growing while raising prices. We're eager to go head-to-head with all the other players in the market, push up rates on our CDs and money market accounts, and we could pull in a substantial amount of funds; we did bring in $1.3 billion of new money. I mean, we — during the back half of the year, it comes down to managing everything so that we keep our profitability at a relatively solid level. Outperforming is what we're aiming for. So we're — we're not looking to hand over everything just to inflate our balance sheet. We recognize what potential limits we might face on funding. And margin is what gets traded off. So on the other side, we need to be achieving that through the loans we originate to make it worthwhile. That's the way we see it.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#17

Absolutely. No, I get it — that's helpful context. And then, I suppose, just to piggyback on that, Vince, you brought up creating some capacity through that modest loan sale. Clearly, balance sheet optimization is always on your mind, but even so, I'm just curious whether — do you anticipate additional chances in the near term to do exactly that, perhaps with Jed taking on some smaller chunks that, for one reason or another, don't deliver the total returns? Could that be a near-term route to keeping the loan-to-deposit ratio right where it stands? Or would you characterize this more as a one-and-done situation for the near term?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#18

Yeah. During the fourth quarter, we devoted considerable time to determining the size of what we intended to pursue regarding both the volume of securities and the volume of loans we had in mind; so as things stand today, we have no intention of conducting further sales. I believe we fine-tune it, as Vince mentioned — we possess the capacity to fund and expand the deposits, and we've been doing that forever. So at this juncture, I wouldn't call it one and done permanently, correct, since we continually examine the balance sheet. And should opportunities arise, we'll evaluate them, but at present there are no plans. As I said, we put substantial time into sizing it and arrived at what we ultimately executed.

Vince Delie

executive
#19

Assuming the rate backdrop allows us to shed assets that generate loan income, and that produces a gain, and we can redeploy that into something different. Absolutely; that's something we've done before. Across the years, we've divested more than $1 billion. So we'll evaluate things on a selective basis, Frank. And the balance sheet gets reviewed by us all the time. Generating the greatest possible returns is what we're aiming for. And we'll examine chances to exit, especially when it comes to indirect auto, that limited relationship, correct? What I mean is, we'll take a look at that and either trade our way out of it or trim it down, right? Pricing tools have been used by us to shift the portfolio around, right? And we'll find out. Everything depends on what the interest rate environment happens to be, how demand appears in higher-yielding categories. What the risk profile of the balance sheet happens to look like. All those things get weighed by us, and decisions get made accordingly. But managing within the loan-to-deposit range that we've had historically is our plan. Moving beyond that isn't something we're seeking.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#20

Yeah, and one more thing, Frank — we aren't feeling boxed in when it comes to the loan growth we'd want to pursue. Those mid-to-high single-digit figures we've posted? That's achievable — we've pulled off moves like the ones Vince is talking about. And in mortgage, we tweaked our pricing somewhat so we'd have more products that can be sold. That means we're trimming how much growth lands on the balance sheet, which fits into how we steer that balance sheet. So plenty of different levers exist there.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#21

Great.

Timur Braziler

analyst
#22

Maybe I'll start with Vince Delie. You'd said something about positive operating leverage in '23 and that you expected to be in the top quartile for operating leverage going forward. Does that mean positive operating leverage is possible in '24? Or is the revenue environment difficult enough that it's more likely that won't happen next year?

Vince Delie

executive
#23

Yes. I believe that as we go through this interest rate cycle, it gets more difficult, clearly, right, since you're looking at revenue that's declining while your expense base is essentially fixed. So we've removed expense, but that's not easy to do. In the second half of the year, I definitely would anticipate that we'd generate positive operating leverage. So as we get past that inflection point Vince mentioned earlier, right, the margin compression that comes with rate cuts, we ought to be able to get through it and, in the second half of the year, see positive operating leverage. If you look at F.N.B. for the full year in 2023, we did better than others, right, since we delivered full year operating leverage. There was negative operating leverage everywhere, at least from what I observed. So I think I'd expect us to do all we can to be in a comparable position in '24.

Timur Braziler

analyst
#24

Yes, that helps. Then I've got one for Gary. If I look at the office maturities in '24, roughly 20% of that book appears to be maturing, and I'm curious what portion of that maturing debt consists of loans from vintage 2019 and earlier. Also, when you examine your CRE portfolio, again focusing on vintages 2019 and earlier, how much do those loans differ in credit quality, simply because today's environment is so unlike the pre-pandemic one?

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#25

Yes. Broadly, we underwrite those at origination in a range from the low 60s to the high 60s. So alongside that LTV level, which has served us very well through this cycle up to now, those maturities are also structured with very short terms. Maturities fall within 5 years, or a bit under that in certain instances. Consequently, a lot of those deals have been refinanced during the past year or several years, and many of those borrowers adjusted those deals to the right size. Keeping those maturities quite short has been our aim, and we will keep doing so in these conditions. Having said all that, we are as focused on that office space as anybody, and we feel pretty good regarding the portfolio right now. Since this space has faced a difficult stretch because of all the pandemic-related problems we have witnessed, we have had only a handful of credits over the past several years, and only a couple of credits that we needed to address from a loss perspective. So we feel good about where it stands. There is a 20% roll rate over the next year, and we anticipate working through that alongside our sponsors, who have demonstrated the capacity to rightsize, add to reserves, pay down debt, and return it to a 120 type of debt service coverage. So in '24, we will keep doing what we did in '23.

Vince Delie

executive
#26

To build on Gary's remarks, from a conservative underwriting standpoint, the majority of deals we would have written back in 2019 carried long-term leases extending past the maturity Gary referenced, which had an earlier maturity date. The implication is that even if cap rates move and valuations shift, with a lower LTV and a longer remaining lease term, the debt service coverage stays whole. That makes it far simpler to absorb a write-down caused by cap rate expansion when you hold significant liquidity and a tenant committed for the long haul. So in nearly every instance, that's the lens we'd apply while underwriting those deals, and it gives us a strong sense of confidence. I'd also note that the bulk of the portfolio — the overwhelming majority of it — is located outside the urban office picture. As a result, we believe we're well protected, since suburban office in faster-growing markets doesn't face vacancy the way you'd see in major metros. Another point on the size of the annulars: 40% of the portfolio is under $5 million when it comes to loan size. Bump that threshold to $5 million to $10 million, and that's an additional $17 million; so you're approaching 60% of the portfolio being under — almost 60%. It's below $10 million, and if you raise it one more notch to $15 million, you're at 70% of the book of business. Altogether, the top 25 credits average, as of now, slightly more than $30 million — I believe it's exactly $31 million — so the portfolio is highly granular. I think we've exercised strong prudence by holding granular positions throughout that space. And that's really been demonstrated in how performance has grown during what's been a tough stretch. It's geographically diversified as well. It spans 7 states rather than being concentrated in a single city or one particular area; that's obviously something we monitor. There's no question urban office shows real weakness. So it's a fair question. Does that answer it?

Casey Haire

analyst
#27

I'd like to ask a follow-up about the net interest income guidance. Vince, it seems like deposit beta will top out at roughly 35% for human deposit beta. When would that occur in relation to your first Fed cut? Also, what does your guidance imply for deposit beta during the descent in 2024?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#28

Yeah. What I'd say is we'd move up somewhat — we finished the year at 34.3%, as I believe the slide indicates. We're anticipating just somewhat greater here, perhaps another point or 2. And after that, for the second quarter, in line with the margin sort of reaching its low point during the first half of the year. Then what we had in mind — I brought up the update, it's now been 35% twice to the upside. I believe when we get to the moment the Fed pivots and begins lowering rates, applying a comparable approach over the medium term, correct, 35% seems reasonable to us. However, during 2024, based on when the Fed cuts happen, right, and we capture some share of that — likely more than half — yet you wouldn't realize 35% off within calendar 2024. So, as we've done, we'll be actively overseeing our deposit book regarding pricing and in our weekly pricing committee meetings, we've already begun discussing, all right, when to move to lower rates. A number of our rivals already have. So we'll track it very carefully, talk about it continuously, and we'll do the right thing at the right moment; but roughly half or so of that 35% may come through this year.

Casey Haire

analyst
#29

Got it. Got it. Moving over to credit now. Gary, assuming I'm reading what you said the right way, it sounds as though you're expecting net charge-offs to fall during this year. What I'd like to know is the sort of loss rate that's baked into your provision guidance.

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#30

Yeah. When it comes to that provision guide, at $80 million to $100 million, obviously it backs loan growth along with charge-offs, that particular charge-off level we have built into our plans. That figure isn't one we make public, though I'd set it against what you're thinking. We do anticipate performance that holds steady or gets somewhat better across every priority.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#31

However, Casey, I believe that turning to Page 9 of the presentation we've provided, you'll be able to observe net charge-offs relative to average loans; during the third quarter of 2023, we have that single occurrence taking place. So, what I'm saying is we are.

Casey Haire

analyst
#32

Yeah, that's reasonable. You had it correct.

Vince Delie

executive
#33

It's what shows up in your charge-off.

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#34

Absolutely. Casey, if you take the past 3 years, that span comes out to 6 basis points — 6 basis points — and for '23, excluding that single item, it would be 10 basis points. So what you have there is genuinely consistent, dependable results across a fairly large, drawn-out, and rather turbulent stretch; and as I mentioned, we're pleased with where the portfolio stands. Heading into 2024, our feeling was quite positive. Of course, every one of us has some worry about the direction this economy is headed and what all of that will ultimately mean, and as we're all aware, that still has to unfold; even so, we've had solid, reliable performance and the portfolio has remained stable.

Casey Haire

analyst
#35

All right, that's everything from me. Vince Delie, you pointed out that your TC sits at its peak. From what I recall, your CET1 has never been above 10% before. With capital ratios where they are now, how is the team weighing the appetite for share repurchases?

Vince Delie

executive
#36

The Board has given us authorization to buy back stock, and that remains in place. Our intention is to assess it continuously going forward. Should opportunities arise to repurchase shares, we will definitely act on them, provided the earnback makes sense. Since we're also focused on keeping tangible book value at certain levels, I believe we'll keep reviewing this, assess it, and act on deals when they're worthwhile. As for putting capital to work going forward, we're really watching how the economy might shift along with loan growth, since we want that capital to go where it has the greatest impact. However, if things slow down, we won't simply stay put and keep accumulating capital and do whatever's needed to ensure the returns are — I'm not sure whether that addresses what you asked. To put it differently, that remains an open item, and we'll continue to weigh it going forward.

Michael Perito

analyst
#37

There's really only one final item I have. For Gary, I'd like to focus on the credit aspect. Discover released its results just yesterday, and there was a bit of an increase on the consumer side, in their prime book of lines of credit, autos, and similar areas. I'm just wondering what you're observing among consumers and regarding credit health — most of those portfolios, apart from the mortgage book, shrank this year, as I understand it. So what amount of growth is assumed for 2024? And what might be the main factors that could produce improved growth results among consumers? Is it simply the broader economic conditions? Is it pricing, or competitive forces? I'd appreciate some detail on all of that, which would be wonderful.

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#38

Yes, overall delinquency for that entire portfolio, totaling roughly $12 billion, stands at 89 basis points. That covers all consumer lending. During the fourth quarter, it typically rises somewhat due to seasonality at year-end with the holidays and so forth. However, looking at a rolling 13-month period, the range has been 70 basis points to the <<inaudible>>; thus, performance has been extremely steady throughout that portfolio. Regarding the underwriting we perform there, I have strong confidence. I believe it is quite disciplined and quite consistent. We can achieve solid loan growth within those portfolios. And considering the investment we've made and the teams in place, it represents a significant portion of our business. So going forward, we keep anticipating strong, steady growth in that mid to slightly higher range under current conditions, in the high single-digit range under current conditions, and we expect that portfolio to keep performing well throughout the cycle that we.

Michael Perito

analyst
#39

That helps. So within the mid-single-digit growth guidance, it sounds like a portion of consumer growth for '24 is included. As things stand today, that's what you expect.

Vince Delie

executive
#40

Correct, mortgage included. Yet if you removed more, growth remains our expectation, and once more, I believe certain investments we've made in the digital tool — the reality that we're spread across the <<inaudible>> 60 million consumers in our footprint — plus some of the build-out with the ATM delivery channel, which heightens consumers' accessibility to cash and our brand, all of that, I think, gives us a bit of confidence, even though I'd say the consumer, with inflation and some of the economic changes going on, is going to be somewhat challenged. I think we're in a pretty good spot to keep growing the book, not as robustly as in the past. I know it's been — last year was tough, but things are going to stabilize, and in a lower rate environment, we should see some opportunities to grow that portfolio. But that's baked into the guide.

Michael Perito

analyst
#41

Great. Very helpful.

Russell Gunther

analyst
#42

I wanted to ask a follow-up about the balance sheet repositioning and the tangible book value earn-back math; I understand the securities repositioning. Could you confirm whether the savings from the preferred stock dividend are part of that calculation? Then I'd like more detail on the indirect auto piece. Which rate borrowings would get paid down, and does that math include any reserve release tied to those loans? I'm just trying to understand the puts and takes.

Vince Delie

executive
#43

Yes. Russell, as you're aware, the securities repositioning took place in the available-for-sale portfolio. That was already reflected in tangible book value. So no incremental hit comes from it. The loan sale produces a very slight hit. But because the combined transaction delivers such strong overall earnings accretion, that earn-back comes in under a year. Once you include the preferred dividend, it obviously still remains under a year, since that is accretive. So a pretty strong earn-back metric. Anything — sorry, did I cover all your questions there?

Russell Gunther

analyst
#44

Regarding the auto segment and the puts and takes on the savings from that discount, I just wanted to ask about the rate on borrowings you'd anticipate paying down, and whether any reserve release tied to those loans is baked into that calculation.

Vince Delie

executive
#45

Understood. Yes. No. So on the borrowings, we discussed paying them off at a rate comparable to the yield on the loans. So we're talking about a yield of roughly 5% to 5.5% on those loans. So net pay down borrowings at a similar rate. And just as a reminder, that loan sale hasn't closed yet. So we actually haven't seen the capital benefits from that full transaction; so just on a pro forma basis, when the loans do go off the balance sheet, we'd expect CET1 to increase unestimated 10 basis points and <<inaudible>> increase roughly 6 basis points as well on top of that.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#46

Russell, on the tax line there isn't any extra income statement impact during Q1, since marking it to market means everything gets captured in Q4. So honestly, what remains is simply carrying out the sale.

Russell Gunther

analyst
#47

And so I suppose the final question after that would return to what we discussed regarding CET1, with the pro forma amount still exceeding 10%. You all talked about buybacks, yet there's also the earn-back sensitivity; so are you unwilling to consider letting capital grow or doing more securities repositioning? Or what's your thinking there?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#48

No. I believe we devoted considerable time during Q4 to determining the size of what we executed; therefore we have no intention of conducting further security sales, which changes direction. Keep in mind, over the past several years, we maintained a short demo investment portfolio and remained cautious in our management approach; thus the overall dollar figure we handled there represents roughly the entire amount we aim to complete. We have nothing else in the works; and from the standpoint of the capital ratio, it falls within our guidance, plus our capital ratios will gradually rise throughout the year, which matters. And as Vince mentioned before, should conditions allow, that opens the possibility for share repurchases when it's sensible.

Vince Delie

executive
#49

Absolutely. It would be great to see tangible book value exceed $10 — that's something everyone could cheer about. In the end, I believe that leads to a better valuation for us, considering how profitable we are; but — so all of that is going to be managed by us. All of it will be monitored, and we'll make wise choices in response to return pressure.

Timur Braziler

analyst
#50

Got it.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#51

I'd like to dig into what economic assumptions sit beneath your guidance for loan growth. And also beneath the guidance on provisioning.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#52

Regarding the economic environment, well, it's essentially what economists in the consensus camp are putting out there. What I mean is that growth decelerates during the back half of the year. We aren't coming up with that on our own; instead, we're examining what economists across the nation expect. And that is roughly what gets incorporated into GDP, Scott, and our plan declines to something like 0 point, though it remains growth.

Vince Delie

executive
#53

The average comes to 2%.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#54

Yes, that's 2% on average across the year.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#55

So if that expectation were to get worse, would the provision end up exceeding that range?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#56

With the range we've got, I'd say we feel quite comfortable.

Vince Delie

executive
#57

Yeah. No, at this point, given where the economy stands and how the portfolio appears to be positioned, we feel quite at ease with that range.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#58

Then turning to loan growth — the pace to wrap up the year has been really strong. Is it somewhat more weighted to the front end, with things slowing down over the back half? Or do you feel fairly good that mid-single digits will hold steady throughout the year?

Vince Delie

executive
#59

Yes. I'd say seasonality exists in originations, and it depends on which portfolio you're looking at. Take the commercial book — it usually grows more as you go from the second into the third quarter. Take mortgage banking — we moved that up a bit, maybe by a quarter, really the first and second quarter, and then it starts to take off. Alright, so each portfolio is different — I only used those two to illustrate a point. When we build our plan and set what we present as consensus, we take into account both the macro picture and conditions on the ground. Basically, we started from scratch in assembling that plan. We went around to each of our business units and gathered input. We looked at what our production capacity has historically looked like in the markets we serve. After that, we turned to the broader economy and asked if the numbers made sense and what was actually going on. That's really the approach — which is why Vince mentioned that we rely on economists' consensus estimates. We aren't taking someone else's projection and running it through our own model to generate a forecast. Everything we've provided already incorporates all of that. We develop these figures internally, and then we factor in the broader economic conditions that could affect them. That applies across provision expense, loan growth, and the commercial, consumer, and mortgage categories — we separate each segment and construct the estimate from the bottom up. Given the point we're at in the cycle and current conditions, forecasting is difficult, but compared with three months ago, we're somewhat more positive about the year ahead. I believe the loan growth guidance captures that sentiment. My hope is that we can outperform it. When you take a look at what's in our pipelines, the past quarter was quite strong on the commercial side, and you can see that in the loan growth and the big jump we had in Q4. Commercial results can swing year to year, but last quarter went well for us. As we look at the pipelines going forward, they're roughly flat. So there isn't a large pipeline sitting there telling us, hey, we're definitely going to hit 3% or 4% or 5%, or whatever that mid-single digit figure is for that portfolio. Given everything we currently know about the economy, I'd say I feel fairly confident in what we're putting forward. I'm not sure — that's really helpful.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#60

May I also ask whether there are any sorts of regional insights you can draw from how the eStore has performed? There's a great deal of activity, and plenty of non-account holders are using the eStore. Could you split that out by region in any way? Or is it simply strong trends overall?

Vince Delie

executive
#61

Sure, that's a fascinating thing to ask. I posed that very question to our team. So I raise the identical question within the company. It remains fairly new, and we're attempting to work out how to build something that gives us the same level of detail. Gets us to the level of detail we require from an origination standpoint. But when they first examined it, it's largely uniform, which is noteworthy. It wasn't concentrated in a single geography. It was distributed over a fairly wide geography. So I believe wherever we enjoy name recognition, branch locations, correct? We generally see more activity. As soon as you go beyond that, we don't do much advertising, so you don't observe as much activity, which is partly why we chose branded ATMs and proceeded with the ATM deployment, since our hypothesis was that the more often consumers encounter us, the more inclined they are to go digital. That formed part of the strategy; so it appears to be succeeding. If you examine where our geographic locations sit, where we have signage and some recognition, there's greater digital activity.

Manuel Navas

analyst
#62

That's excellent. Thanks for that.

Vince Delie

executive
#63

And clearly, since the deposit products got added back in December, we're now going to begin promoting them. So through some advertising, we'll attempt to expand that, raising consumer awareness about what we can do. I'm aware that locally, I noticed it during the Super Bowl — we manage <<inaudible>> not the Super Bowl, rather the national championship for college football <<inaudible>> dealers have already gone out and lost. But we do receive some backing, to phrase it that way. We appeared in the playoff game; our ads ran during the Steeler Buffalo Bills matchup. Probably locally, we ran during the national championship, correct, since we have customers who follow those events closely. So we put out some advertising, and a few people mentioned it. After that, branding on buildings in certain markets has given us a visibility boost — especially, I believe we've noticed greater prospecting activity thanks to the signage on our headquarters building, and that has drawn some people in. Then there are the sponsorships with the penguins, Wade Jersey, the patch — you get plenty of exposure from that too. In any case, that's our approach to building awareness.

Brian Martin

analyst
#64

Well, the majority of what I wanted to ask has already been covered. There's just one item, Vince — you addressed it, I believe, when you took the final question about how the commercial pipeline's growth is paced? Based on how the fourth quarter came in, it seems like things get off to a somewhat slower start, though it likely picks up after that; that's broadly what I took away. Would you say that's accurate?

Vince Delie

executive
#65

Yes. What I'd say is the third quarter was very strong for us, which essentially emptied out the 90-day bucket in the pipeline, and now that needs to be rebuilt. Fairly flat. Production in the Carolinas came through well for us. A few of the Carolina portfolios are showing double-digit growth, and that's quite encouraging. And that's without CRE, with no significant boost coming from CRE. So that has us fairly enthusiastic. Beyond that, I believe we'll see chances in both the Midwest and the Northeast too, from a C&I standpoint, as we get deeper into next year — specifically the back half of next year.

Brian Martin

analyst
#66

Understood. Alright, and then this next one is for Gary. Gary, the credit picture just — it comes across as really robust. I suppose if you had to identify a single spot right now where you might be somewhat more cautious, the criticized figures seem to have declined during this quarter; but broadly speaking, is there any particular pocket you're monitoring a bit more closely as we move toward '24, considering how solid the portfolio is?

Gary Guerrieri

executive
#67

Sure, I'd say the CRE book overall, honestly. What I mean is, we've been deeply engaged with that. And the team has performed quite well in developing risk management protocols surrounding it. Tom Fisher and his group are thoroughly engaged with those business books just as they are with the remainder of the portfolio. But office space, obviously, and we've mentioned this for years, that segment was destined to be a longer-term holding within the industry. It's something that will need to be worked through gradually. That shift, I'd characterize as not short-lived. A lasting transformation has occurred in that market. Thankfully, I believe we selected wisely there over the years with strong, dependable sponsors possessing liquidity, and I think that explains why that portfolio has kept delivering the way it has up to now. But that CRE segment and that office portfolio. I believe there's quite a distance still to cover on that, Brian. So we'll keep staying deeply engaged with it.

Brian Martin

analyst
#68

All right. That's great. Yeah. So perhaps just a final couple of points, and it's regarding the fee income line — simply sort of examining how mortgage has improved, and you mentioned a bit about a slight shift in approach in that area. Just the pluses and minuses regarding what mortgage could look like going forward, and then also the capital markets revenue. It stayed fairly steady, perhaps somewhat beneath the level seen in earlier years, so I'm just curious about how we should view that, or what the pipeline appears like at this point.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#69

Yeah. What I'd say is that noninterest income once more demonstrates the upside of having a revenue base that's converged, correct? I mean, we've delivered yet another solid quarter exceeding 80%. We've stayed over 80%. 6 of the last 7 quarters, achieved through various means, but once again, that's the advantage of diversification. So for us, capital markets had a strong quarter. I mean, it's higher than the quarter before, lower than a year ago. It had a 10 handle on it, yet plenty of opportunity remains in that area. And I believe as the rate environment begins to move, opportunity will keep being there for us. But truly, we get contributions from every element within it — from swaps, from international syndication, within capital markets. So even inside that business, there are numerous components. And then mortgage came back strongly. I mean, we enjoyed a very robust '23 — I mean, at a time when the market declined in terms of originations, with the entire industry contracting, we grew, and in terms of originations, we're projecting. An increase near double digits for originations in '24 compared with '23. And what I said about pricing related more to saleable against portfolio, not truly influencing how many originations there are, but rather what we make on the balance sheet versus what gets sold.

Vince Delie

executive
#70

Another point I'd make is this: should rates move lower, assuming those cuts materialize, we ought to witness heightened derivatives activity, plus greater debt capital markets engagement as our sizable corporate clients come to market seeking to raise capital, and syndication ought to strengthen during the year's back half. Beyond that, within the mortgage operation, gain on sale ought to speed up. Thus, as Vince mentioned, having a portfolio. Also, we've enjoyed solid, consistent expansion — worth noting that our asset management along with the wealth and trust operations have performed remarkably well; consequently revenue is higher, net income is rising, and net assets are expanding. What I mean is, we're sitting at record levels; therefore we're operating in favorable markets where that book should keep growing. So we possess a nicely diversified collection of fee drivers that, I believe, over the next twelve months, provided rates unfold as some predict, ought to leave us fine on the noninterest income front.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#71

And then initiatives on the small business and PM side will be additive.

Brian Martin

analyst
#72

Yeah. No, what you all have developed really is generating strong returns now, and as you mentioned, that diversification. And I suppose regarding the mortgage, I was simply attempting to get clarity, Vince, on whether a portion of the rise in this quarter was essentially just you selling a greater volume and, if that's the case, you do have growth in originations in the coming year and you keep selling at an elevated pace, perhaps that likewise adds to an improved forecast for '24.

Vince Delie

executive
#73

Yeah. The gain on sale margin is reduced, however. It's dependent on the rate environment. But if you examine it, we might have sold yet we aren't earning as much per unit. We're simply getting it off the balance sheet when the rate environment gives us the chance to do so. And keep in mind, we concentrate mainly on purchase money. That activity has been diminished, correct? I mean we don't — we're not — under a falling rate environment, we would observe additional refinance activity, despite the fact that we focus more on purchase money, we would receive some advantage from the refinance market. So there are trade-offs. But I believe it's a fairly balanced approach and I think that's how we've managed to maintain our fee income levels throughout this period. Even with consumer fees declining, right, we've performed quite well.

Vince Calabrese

executive
#74

Brian, one more thing from my side: during Q4, mortgage income also got a lift as rates declined. That gain was helped along by the fair value mark on the pipeline in Q4.

Brian Martin

analyst
#75

Understood. Alright, that's great. Then the final item concerned the margin. Vince, Vince C., just this single question. Please remind me — from the standpoint of variable rates, what share of loans are variable rate, and then assuming a 25 basis point reduction on that portion, how much does each 25 basis point reduction shift the margin?

Vince Calabrese

executive
#76

We have to examine the legacy balance sheet, correct? The proportion remains roughly 47% of loans that are heavily marked down, which I mentioned before, and there are all the various moving components, since these carry a 10-month average maturity. So gains and losses exist there. That is essentially all incorporated into the market sort of reaching its low during the first half of the year, Brian, and after that.

Brian Martin

analyst
#77

Yes. All right, that's a 47% help; okay then.

Vince Delie

executive
#78

Yes. I want to express gratitude to everyone for the questions, which were excellent. Thanks for your interest. And considering everything that happened this year, F.N.B. has done quite well; and a lot of the key strategies that we've put in place and discussed across the years truly came through amid the liquidity crisis earlier this year. You were able to witness directly what we've been saying regarding client primacy, the strength of our deposit portfolio and our credit underwriting. So I believe it truly demonstrated itself this year and I'm quite excited about transitioning into next year, ideally, into a stronger economy, but we head into '24, especially the latter half of '24 and once more, we want to thank our employees since they rise to the occasion and get things done and did a commendable job last year. So thank you. Thanks to all of you. Take care.

Operator

operator
#79

Alright everyone, that brings today’s conference call and presentation to a close. We appreciate your participation. At this point, you’re free to disconnect your lines.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.