F.N.B. Corporation (FNB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 18, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lisa Hajdu
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for joining our earnings call today. This F.N.B. Corporation conference call, along with the documents we submit to the Securities and Exchange Commission, frequently includes forward-looking statements as well as non-GAAP financial measures. Those non-GAAP financial measures ought to be considered alongside, rather than as a substitute for, the results we report that are prepared under GAAP. You can find reconciliations from GAAP to non-GAAP operating measures, and to the closest comparable GAAP financial measures, within our presentation materials and our earnings release. We encourage you to review those non-GAAP and forward-looking statement disclosures that appear in our related materials, reports, and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are accessible on our corporate website. A replay of today's call will remain available through Friday, October 25, and a webcast link will be shared in the About Us, Investor Relations portion of our corporate website. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Vince Delie, our Chairman, President and CEO.
Vince Delie
executiveHello, everyone, and thank you for joining the call about our third-quarter results. Joining me are Vince Calabrese, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer, along with Gary Guerrieri, our Chief Credit Officer. For the third quarter, F.N.B. reported operating net income available to common shareholders of $123 million, which works out to $0.34 per diluted common share, once we made adjustments for $15.3 million in significant items that impacted earnings. The third-quarter results demonstrate our ability to originate quality loans and significant deposits throughout our footprint, all while maintaining noninterest-bearing deposit balances at a steady level of roughly $10 billion. Our performance this quarter showed sequential revenue expansion, and we strengthened the balance sheet, achieving a CET1 ratio of 10.4%, which is a record for us. Shareholder value was driven higher as tangible book value rose 15% compared with a year earlier, while operating return on average tangible common equity came in at 14%. Another point of particular pride is that across many MSAs in our footprint, we've been picking up market share, and in Pittsburgh we secured the #2 position in traditional retail deposit share despite facing competition from some of the nation's biggest banks; given these conditions, continuing to prudently steer our capital and liquidity is essential. F.N.B. during the quarter We wrapped up an indirect auto loan transaction worth $431 million. That move allowed us to remove assets with lower yields from our balance sheet, with only a small effect on future earnings, while also strengthening capital and improving the loan-to-deposit ratio. Vince Calabrese will walk through the specifics of that sale when he speaks. We ended the quarter with total loans of approximately $33.7 billion, representing a 4.6% annualized increase on a linked-quarter basis once you exclude the loan sale. Yet again, F.N.B's lending growth exceeded the published H8 figures, as we continue capturing additional market share. Credit for that goes to our business model, which stresses a varied and appealing footprint, along with sufficient capital and liquidity to serve our clients. We closed the quarter with $36.8 billion in total deposits. That's a 5.1% increase, or $1.8 billion, compared with the second quarter. The gain came from new production driven by successful deposit initiatives, along with seasonal deposit inflows. This strong sequential growth in deposits shows how well our commercial and business bankers have done at building and deepening client relationships. We've also put our digital and data analytics capabilities to work, using data-driven lead generation to market and capture deposits effectively from new and existing retail households. In consumer and small business deposits, we made progress through our omnichannel Clicks-to-Bricks environment, drawing on our diversified geographic branch footprint and our award-winning eStore common app. Our ratio of loans to deposits got a lot better, landing at 91.7%, which is down almost 5 percentage points versus the prior quarter. That sequential move shows we can carry out plans to keep the loan-to-deposit ratio in check whenever it's necessary. During the third quarter by itself, F.N.B. brought in close to $1.8 billion in deposits, finished a loan sale, and backed $391 million in loan expansion. We'll keep steering the loan-to-deposit ratio using our long-term approach of serving as our customers' main operating bank in both the consumer and commercial books, helped along by our sophisticated digital tools, the Clicks-to-Bricks strategy, and our ability to bundle products. Overall revenue for the quarter climbed 2.3%, driven by noninterest income hitting a record $90 million together with stronger net interest income. Our plan is to keep pushing the strategy of broadening where our revenue comes from and making the most of what we've already invested, which includes growing the business lines inside our Capital Markets segment. Noninterest expense from operations came to $234 million, lifted by greater salaries and benefits—partly tied to the strategic hiring we need in order to capture more market share—plus our sustained spending on risk management infrastructure. We deliberately raised marketing costs by $2 million to back deposit programs, and that produced our strong deposit growth. Keeping expenses in check is still a top priority, and we anticipate fourth quarter expenses will decline on a sequential basis. Because we keep managing expenses and because our revenue streams keep getting more diverse, we achieved an efficiency ratio of 55.2% in the third quarter, which leads our peers. Staying disciplined about conservative, consistent underwriting is another thing we focus on constantly, and it lets us keep serving our customers. Across the last ten years, our credit team has developed a thorough framework for handling credit risk concentration proactively and effectively through a range of economic cycles; this enduring method of managing credit risk keeps working in our favor; so now I'll hand things over to Gary for a look at overall credit performance. Gary?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveThanks, Vince, and good morning to all of you; we closed out the quarter with our asset quality metrics holding steady. Total delinquency ended the period a bit higher, at 79 basis points, or 16 bps versus the previous quarter, while NPLs and OREO came in at 39 basis points, an increase of 6 bps. Net charge-offs were 25 basis points, and on a year-to-date basis they were 17 basis points, which speaks to solid performance given the current economic environment. Criticized loans declined 22 basis points on a linked-quarter basis, which reflects improvement throughout the portfolio. Funded provision expense for the quarter totaled $22.9 million and covered charge-offs. At the close of the period, our funded reserve stood at $420 million, an increase of $1.4 million, ending at 1.25% — that's 1 basis point above what we reported the previous quarter. When acquired unamortized loan discounts are factored in, that reserve figure reaches 1.34%, and including those discounts, our NPL coverage position remains solid at 353.7%. Within the nonowner CRE portfolio, credit metrics are still at levels we consider satisfactory, with delinquency and NPLs increasing slightly to 69 and 31 basis points, respectively. The rise in early-stage delinquency was largely connected to a handful of performing credits that had reached maturity and were going through documentation; several of these were renewed through the ordinary course of business following quarter-end and are current as of now. That rise in nonperforming loans traced back to a single credit that we moved onto nonaccrual status. Our dedication to the strategy of getting ahead of and lowering our nonowner CRE exposure — the figures for which appear on Page 11 in the earnings slide deck — has not changed. Each month, we go through maturities coming due as well as those already handled, our biggest exposures, and the market climate for each property type in our footprint, which is what we've told you before. Vince noted, and we agree, that because we take this proactive stance on credit risk management, we can move fast to bring in our seasoned special assets team whenever it's needed, partnering with our customers to hold any possible losses to a minimum. Every quarter, we run focused examinations of a range of portfolios, plus a stress test covering the entire portfolio. For this quarter, the stress tests we ran once more indicated reduced net charge-offs and a provision that held steady relative to what we saw in the previous quarter, with our existing ACL now covering about 90% of the charge-offs we project under a severe economic downturn — which again confirms that because our loan portfolio is well balanced, we're able to hold up across a range of stressed economic scenarios. To wrap up, our credit metrics finished the quarter at solid levels, and stability in our loan portfolio remains intact. We keep putting money into credit risk management systems and personnel, which is consistent with our steady underwriting approach and core credit philosophy. At this company, our seasoned executives work to keep banking groups staffed with people who have deep experience. That way, we can achieve sensible expansion of our loan book and, at the same time, stay ahead of credit risk no matter what phase the economy enters. At this point, I'll hand things over to Vince Calabrese, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer, so he can share his comments.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThanks, Gary, and good morning, everyone. In my comments today, I'll go over the third quarter's financial results, including details on the indirect auto loan sale, and then walk you through the guidance we're giving for the fourth quarter. On an operating basis, net income for the third quarter was $123 million, or $0.34 per share, after adjusting out the $11.6 million loss connected to the indirect auto loan sale and a $3.7 million software impairment. As part of our ongoing efforts to manage the balance sheet, we sold $431 million in performing indirect auto loans that carry lower yields. That transaction lifted the loan-to-deposit ratio by roughly 120 basis points and added about 10 basis points to the CET1 capital ratio. Setting aside that loan sale, total loans and leases rose $391.4 million, a 1.2% increase from the prior quarter, taking the period-end balance to $33.7 billion. Consumer loan growth, which came to $299 million excluding the loan sale, was mainly driven by residential mortgage originations, as volumes stayed elevated while mortgage rates fell during the third quarter. Commercial loans and leases were up $93 million from the linked quarter, matching what we expected, thanks to the sizable amount of commercial loan closings in the second quarter and a lower revolver balance. Total deposits ended September at $36.8 billion, a solid linked-quarter increase of $1.8 billion, or 5%, aided by our successful deposit initiatives that demonstrate the value of our granular deposit base across an attractive geographic footprint. Third quarter deposit growth was led by a $1.3 billion increase in interest-bearing demand deposits and a $783 million increase in time deposits. At quarter-end, noninterest-bearing deposits represented 27% of total deposits, compared with 29% in the prior quarter, reflecting the strong growth in interest-bearing deposits and noninterest-bearing deposit balances that held roughly flat at about $10 billion. On last quarter's call, I discussed our goal of reducing the loan-to-deposit ratio organically through slower loan growth and deposit seasonality, along with several loan and deposit initiatives our team has implemented. The success of our ongoing balance sheet management and deposit gathering initiatives brought the loan-to-deposit ratio to 91.7% as of September 30, an improvement of almost 5 percentage points from 96.5% at June 30; we expect the loan-to-deposit ratio to remain relatively stable in the fourth quarter, since deposit growth continues to be a strategic priority. Net interest income for the quarter was $323.3 million. That's up $7.4 million, or 2.4%, from the previous quarter. Several factors drove that: earning asset yields improved by 8 basis points to 5.51%; loan balances grew; and we benefited from a favorable shift in the mix of interest-bearing liabilities, as total borrowings fell by $1.6 billion, or 28%, on a linked-quarter basis. Total income increased $3.1 million reflecting higher life insurance claims. Last quarter we were $54.4 million, which we were the third best among our 21 bank peer group this quarter is $55.2 million. Offsetting those positive factors, interest-bearing deposit costs rose 15 basis points, reaching 3.08%, and we continued to see balances grow in deposit products offering higher yields. Net interest margin for Q3 came in at 3.08%, unchanged from Q2. Between March 2022, when the Fed started hiking, and August 31, 2024, our cumulative spot deposit beta hit 40%, which is better than what our peers achieved over that same tightening cycle. As rates come down, we'll keep moving the balance sheet toward a more neutral position. After the Fed cut the federal funds rate by 50 basis points in September, we've been gradual in reducing what we pay on deposits across a number of products, including the promotional CD and money market offers we currently have in market. At quarter-end, roughly $7 billion in non-maturity deposits carry rates of 4.25% or above, and our CD portfolio stands at $7.7 billion with a nine-month duration. Within that, $2.9 billion matures in Q4 2024 at a weighted average rate of 4.75%. On top of that, we hold $2.8 billion in short-term or floating rate borrowings priced at an average of 5.15%, plus about $1 billion in swaps that start maturing in January 2025, with rates ranging from 75 to 100 basis points. Now shifting to noninterest income and expense: noninterest income hit a record $89.7 million, rising 2% quarter over quarter. In capital markets, we added $1.1 million more, spread fairly evenly across syndications, debt capital markets, customer swap activity and international banking. Mortgage banking income grew $1.6 million versus the strong level from the prior quarter. That was mainly driven by $2.8 million of net MSR impairment in Q3 2024, which resulted from faster prepayment speed assumptions after the recent decline in mortgage rates — a headwind despite higher saleable production volumes. BOLI income climbed $3.2 million, reflecting more life insurance claims. Total income increased $3.1 million, also due to higher life insurance claims. Last quarter we were at $54.4 million, which ranked third among our 21 bank peer group; this quarter it's $55.2 million. Turning to operating noninterest expense, it came to $234.2 million, which after adjusting for significant items is $8.4 million higher than the prior quarter. Salaries and benefits made up the biggest portion of the operating expense increase, up $5.1 million. That's due to variable pay linked to production, plus reduced salary deferrals from less mortgage production retained on the balance sheet, along with deliberate hires supporting our market share push and continued investment in risk management capabilities. Marketing expenses increased $2 million, driven by the timing of promotional campaigns backing our strong deposit efforts. We keep managing our expense base tightly, and as we build the 2025 budget, we're looking at a number of efforts focused on cost savings so that growth in revenue and growth in expenses line up more closely; because some additional costs arrive alongside greater revenue, our efficiency ratio for Q3 is still 55.2%, the best among our peers, even if it is slightly above the 54.4% recorded in the quarter before. At F.N.B, capital reached all-time highs, with tangible common equity at 8.2% and CET1 at 10.4%, giving us capacity to deploy capital and increase shareholder value. Versus the same period last year, tangible book value per common share climbed $1.31, or 15%, to $10.33, demonstrating our commitment to building capital organically. Total income increased $3.1 million reflecting higher life insurance claims. On the peer comparison, last quarter we were $54.4 million, which we were the third best among our 21 bank peer group this quarter is $55.2 million. Now let's shift to what we expect for Q4 2024. For the full year, loans ought to grow by a mid-single-digit percentage, and the loan sale is included in that number. We now expect total deposit balances to climb mid-single digits compared with a year ago, above our prior guidance of low single digits. In Q4, net interest income should come in at $310 million to $320 million, presuming the Fed cuts rates 25 basis points in November and another 25 basis points in December. Noninterest income has stayed strong, so our Q4 estimate is in the $85 million to $90 million range. Turning to costs, we anticipate noninterest expense in Q4 will be lower than Q3, with guidance of $225 million to $235 million. Provision in Q4 should be between $20 million and $30 million, based on net loan growth and charge-off activity. Lastly, our effective tax rate for the entire year should be in the 21% to 22% range, and no investment tax credit activity that might occur is included in that number. As we've noted previously, renewable energy financing transactions are part of how our leasing company business operates, and we have deals of varying sizes at different stages in the pipeline, although when the investment tax credit will be recognized remains uncertain. With that, I'll turn the call back to Vince.
Vince Delie
executiveThank you, Vince. The accomplishments at F.N.B. stem from the strong ties we establish in the neighborhoods we serve. Speaking for everyone at F.N.B., we extend our assistance to all who have been affected by Hurricanes Helene and Milton, and that includes our own colleagues, clients, and those living nearby. In the days, weeks, and months ahead, F.N.B. will keep collaborating with organizations in the impacted region to aid recovery and healing; any of our customers feeling the direct effects of these storms should contact us if they need help. The excellent standing of F.N.B. shows clearly through the leading deposit share we possess in markets across our footprint. During the last year, we increased our penetration by expanding or holding steady on deposits in close to 90% of our MSAs, and F.N.B. currently sits within the top 5 in almost 50% of the MSAs where we do business throughout 7 states. Once more, our results earned us honors, with further national and regional accolades this quarter recognizing our workplace culture, our diversity and inclusion efforts, and our client experience. In particular, we were recognized globally as one of Time's World's Best Companies, named by Newsweek as one of America's most Admired Workplaces, and selected by Global Finance Magazine as the Best Bank for small- and medium-sized enterprises in the Mid-Atlantic. The strength of our results also reflects how good our people are. We put our energy into recruiting and keeping the most skilled and seasoned professionals. Because we invest in our staff, we are able to grow efficiently. As a matter of fact, 90% of our senior management team brings experience from larger institutions and/or public accounting, delivering a great deal of expertise to our risk management, operations, and revenue-generating functions. As I've frequently said during these calls, the exceptional quality of our staff leads straight to value for stakeholders. The way F.N.B. has successfully steered through numerous economic cycles is directly <<inaudible>> our varied and seasoned team. Their capacity to grow revenue efficiently, reduce risk, fine-tune our balance sheet, and carry out our established strategies produces our continued success. I express my gratitude to our teams for their commitment and to our shareholders for their backing. Thank you, and at this point we'll begin taking questions.
Frank Schiraldi
analystBringing in core deposits is clearly favorable right now, I'd imagine. That said, can you share what average rate these inflows are coming in at? And Vince, you brought up shifting toward a neutral — more neutral — interest rate stance. At least over the near term, wouldn't that deposit-side expansion push against that somewhat?
Vince Calabrese
executiveSure, a few points come to mind. During the prior quarter, as we noted, short-term borrowings rose considerably in order to support the exceptionally robust loan growth seen in Q2. Bringing in substantial deposits was therefore the objective, and that's what we accomplished. Specifically, $1 billion of new money came in. The overall figure reached $1.8 billion, yet $1 billion represented new money at roughly 4.25%, that level. These deposits are structured to be quite short term — a mix of money market accounts plus very short-dated CDs, namely 5-month CDs. That leaves us considerable room to maneuver going forward when it comes to lowering rates. Regarding the liabilities we added, I believe our loan-to-deposit ratio stands in a better place. Previously we sat in the 96s. Reducing it is our aim, and we achieved a meaningful drop to 91.7%. Looking broadly at the balance sheet, at quarter's end we hold $11 billion of liabilities that can reprice immediately, subject to market forces of course — roughly $11 billion. Beyond that, another $5.4 billion sits in CDs maturing within the next 6 months, with $2.9 billion of that maturing in the next 3 months carrying a 4.75% rate. We also have $1 billion of cash flows from the investment portfolio, rolling off at approximately 2.91%, which we reinvest at somewhere between 4.25% and 4.50%. Obviously plenty of levers exist there to assist with repricing. Given the Fed's 50 basis point move in September — larger than perhaps anticipated — our loan portfolio feels that effect across a 3-month span; so some catch-up will be necessary, though the levers available to us can help counterbalance it. Our team is positioned quite well, and we've already begun lowering interest rates. We cut rates by 50 basis points on our CD offer along with several other deposit categories; the process of reducing rates has started and we're prepared to keep doing so. That was quite a bit from me, but we have — I feel the levers are well placed for us to move forward and adjust as rates decline.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAlright, that sounds good. Now, F.N.B., from what I recall, was a bank that adopted a pretty careful approach when it came to your assumptions on deposit beta as rates declined, at minimum through those first couple of cuts. Since we've now seen that 50 basis points, and you mentioned that you've already brought some deposit rates down, I'm wondering if you have any updated view on how an early deposit beta could develop across these initial few reductions through year-end?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYeah. Clearly, built into our guidance are those 50 plus 2 more 25 basis point reductions. Our guidance implies a beta of roughly 15% by the time we reach the end of this year. My hope is that we can do better than that. So everybody is prepared to adjust pricing. A lot of our competitors have been lowering rates, which means there's room to do so. Our NPL coverage position remains strong at 352% inclusive of the discounts. Therefore, 15% is what's baked in, and by year-end, we'd be looking to beat that.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAll right. And finally, regarding the indirect auto sale — what are your thoughts on further opportunities here on the balance sheet? Did any of this involve loosening credit standards somewhat? Or at this point, given the yield, are you simply aiming to get out of this line of business?
Vince Delie
executiveGetting out of this business is not what we're after. We identified a chance to remove some assets with low yields from the balance sheet; this wasn't about credit. It was more a matter of overseeing the balance sheet as a whole and especially our ratio of loans to deposits. We essentially examined it alongside our deposit — alongside our capacity to bring in deposits, and when combined with selling those loans, we managed to lower it quite a bit. Also, during the prior earnings call, there were some inquiries regarding whether we could accomplish that and whether we could expand deposits in such a competitive climate. I believe we demonstrated that we can handle those 2 things. In the ordinary course of business within that indirect auto portfolio, loan sales will occur occasionally; we've consistently treated it as a means of overseeing the balance sheet and overseeing our loan-to-deposit ratio; we've done this on multiple occasions; however, we keep the servicing. As a result, we still hold onto the clients. We utilize the data about those clients to attempt cross-selling of other services to them. So that serves us quite well. However, it isn't — this wasn't about credit.
Vince Calabrese
executiveThis thing doesn't stick around long, you know—it's got a 2-year lifespan. So when you look at it from the income statement angle, since we've already paid off those borrowings, going forward there's essentially nothing hitting earnings. On top of that, it boosted our capital. On CET1 ratio, we gained 10 basis points. And that by itself contributed 100—or rather, brought the loan-to-deposit ratio down by 120 basis points. So it's been an appealing...
Vince Delie
executiveIt's a deal that makes sense, and it supports our capital position and basically leaves us far better equipped to serve our clients. My expectation is that demand for loans will rise. Just going by the earnings calls I've heard and read, credit looks more benign than people would have expected, and the economy appears somewhat stronger. Right now, I sense a great deal of wait and see. After the election is behind us, I really do believe that regardless of the winner, there will be demand, especially in the C&I book. So we want to be ready to capitalize on that. And Frank, I think another thing this shows is that, across the last year and through this most recent quarter, strong financial institutions can fund themselves and can build deposit balances. We've discussed our business model, we've discussed using data analytics, and how we're positioned in our markets, the prominence we hold there, our share there. There's been a great deal of — many of the larger bank CEOs have talked a lot about how midsized and regional banks can't gain share; we've shown that's not true; so our business model works. Our share has grown. If you look at Pittsburgh, as I mentioned, we surpassed the legacy Mellon Bank franchise there in deposit share. That happened just in the last turn. And those are — those represent real customer deposits; so we're performing very well when it comes to acquiring names. We're succeeding at becoming the primary client, which explains why our demand deposit balances have held at roughly $10 billion. At other institutions, migration has occurred at a much quicker rate. Everything we've said is embedded in our business model has been validated this quarter. So I want to stress that, and I know we've repeated it many times, I believe the results provide the proof.
Russell Gunther
analystI wanted to begin with expenses. Could you go back over the 3Q numbers briefly and explain what drove them to the upper end of the earlier guidance? Then give us some detail on the 4Q range. Does it just track fees, or is there something else that might push you to the top of that bracket?
Vince Calabrese
executiveAbsolutely. Operating expenses this quarter, as you're aware, reached $234 million. Our July forecast was $220 million to $230 million. Several factors caused that. Marketing rose by $2 million, a choice we made to expand the $1.8 billion in deposits — clearly a deliberate move to invest additional funds in marketing, attract those deposits, and it paid off nicely. Comp benefits also climbed by $5 million, for a few reasons. Production-linked incentives were higher thanks to our noninterest income success. Commissions tie into that, along with deposit gathering and fee income. As noted in the release, we seized chances to bring on producers in important markets and put money into risk management personnel to back our ongoing expansion. Also, just because, 3Q had one more workday — worth another $1 million. Those are roughly the factors that lifted us slightly past the range. Still, looking at the efficiency ratio, we keep delivering top quartile performance. Last quarter we hit 54.4, ranking third among our 21-bank peer group; this quarter stands at 55.2, and I believe we'll stack up well once more. Turning to the fourth quarter, we're working with $225 million to $235 million, which is $5 million above the earlier guidance. That reflects several items: ongoing variable compensation tied to robust noninterest income, loan production slowing with the season, which lowers FAS 91 cost deferrals, FDIC insurance premiums holding at elevated levels, plus the effect of new hires. Yet stepping back, we anticipate the absolute fourth-quarter figure will decline versus the third quarter, and that matters most.
Russell Gunther
analystYes, all right. That's helpful detail, Vince, and I appreciate it. Then perhaps, just when we think ahead or carry that discussion further, you both mentioned aligning the growth of revenue with that of expenses. So when we consider 2025, is positive operating leverage something you expect to be in a position to produce, or do we truly have to witness an easing cycle from the Fed come to an end and deposit costs catch up so that efficiency drops more significantly and positive operating leverage is delivered for 2025?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo, I'd say, clearly reaching a yield curve with a more positive slope later in the next year would create a difference; thus I believe having it during a portion of 2025 as opposed to 2024 is certainly attainable. Yet I think possessing that yield curve will be, in a sense, the essential factor in getting us to that point.
Vince Delie
executiveYeah, when the curve has the right kind of slope, that really powers our — I mean, take a look at our balance sheet and where we sit; we did exceptionally well in those conditions. So clearly, that's central to how we succeed; we're just like any other bank, obviously, but if you check, that's the ideal situation for us when it comes to profit. So with any luck, we'll get some moves at the short end of the curve that put its slope where we need it so we can gain.
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect. And once you reach that stage, it will push both net interest income and net interest margin considerably higher going forward.
Russell Gunther
analystGot it. Okay. Understood. And then just one final item from my side. You folks restated a mid-single-digit growth target for this year. Looking ahead, do you hold any optimism about speeding up that rate, or should we instead be considering headwinds such as paydowns or possible further portfolio exits that would hold you at a mid-single-digit pace?
Vince Delie
executiveI don't believe we're in a position to say that at this moment. Guidance for next year hasn't been provided by us. But looking back at history, I'd say this: I think we've performed very well across a long stretch. Almost 14 years in this seat, 19 years in total, I've been here. Loans and deposits have grown nearly every single year during my time here — perhaps the pandemic, perhaps one quarter when loans didn't grow. Even so, we've delivered fairly steady organic loan growth. That lands in the mid- to high single digits, no matter what size the balance sheet was at any point; and as the balance sheet expanded, our strategy shifted toward entering markets that would hand us opportunities, correct, so our growth trajectory could be maintained no matter the balance sheet's size. So that has, I think, worked out over the years. Therefore I can't claim to be optimistic, given how much uncertainty surrounds next year right now. Yet I genuinely believe nobody is better positioned than we are to produce that loan growth once the market returns. So demand rises in a manner consistent with a growth scenario, let's phrase it that way.
Timur Braziler
analystGoing back to how we're bringing in deposits. If you look at what fresh funds cost us during this period, it came to 4.25%, and honestly, that figure still pulls the blended rate upward. So I'm curious, when we think about the fourth quarter and beyond, considering what makes up that deposit expansion and the 50 basis point cut on CDs, does that come down from the 4.25% mark, or are we still paying above 4% to bring in new money?
Vince Delie
executiveYeah. I doubt we'll dive into the exact tactics for setting our prices, since we don't want our rivals overhearing. That said, I can share this: you have to view the whole picture, and even though that represents the rate on newly acquired funds, it's essentially tied to the money market.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, it's the money market in 5-month CDs, so it's...
Vince Delie
executiveMoney market certificates of deposit are what's fueling that. A piece of it comes from demand deposits. Mix is shifting, or there's runoff happening right now, but primary clients are being brought in; operating accounts with free balances are part of what we hold, so as things progress, my expectation is that we stand to gain. And one more thing I'd point out, given what you said about it not being accretive — in fact, short-term borrowings carrying a far higher rate got replaced by us.
Vince Calabrese
executive5%...
Vince Delie
executiveThe figure stood at 5%. That ended up working in our favor. The way I see it — Scott and I tend to debate this, and it shifts with where rates are — Scott holds the Treasurer role here. My position is basically this: "Look, bringing in customers, right, fresh customers, beats leaning on wholesale funding or another institutional-style source of money." So for our shareholders, this particular trade turned out to be a really solid one.
Vince Calabrese
executiveRight, the fact that the loan-to-deposit ratio dropped by that much means we now have room to go ahead and actively reprice the remaining portfolio. So there's...
Vince Delie
executiveLet me repeat that point, since given how competitive things are right now, our pricing isn't out of line compared with what rivals charge. That tells you the model we run is delivering results, and we're gaining market share in a manner that lifts both our margin and our profitability. So — as time goes on, with new clients coming in, we can adjust prices in response to market shifts; ultimately that means greater profitability per client too. In any case, that's the thinking behind what we pulled off.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAbsolutely. One more point I'd tack on as well: there's a sizable pipeline on the commercial side involving extra deposit accounts that we're actively chasing and working to land. This past quarter treated us really well on that front, and a still very substantial amount remains that we're pursuing in order to bring in relationships.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, that's really helpful context. Then, perhaps to revisit the auto sale, or the indirect auto loan sale — what underlying features did those loans have? How did you decide which pieces of that portfolio to sell off during this quarter?
Vince Delie
executiveI'll hand that one over to Gary, since that area actually reports up through him.
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAbsolutely, Timur — what we looked at was simply a representative slice of deals presently sitting in the portfolio. None of the accounts included in that sale had fallen behind on payments, so what changed hands was top-tier FICO, premium-quality receivables carrying an average life of 2 years.
Timur Braziler
analystAll right, that's great. And then, finally from my side, there's been increasing chatter about M&A in the Mid-Atlantic, and your name has sort of been pulled into that conversation. I'd just really like an update on how you're thinking about deploying capital down the road and where M&A could slot into that?
Vince Delie
executiveOur stance is unchanged; we've said before that we aren't seeking to materially dilute tangible book value. I don't believe that — commenting on particular transactions isn't something I want to do, but our focus remains on in-market deals, on the smaller side, assuming anything like that were even available to us, and we're taking an opportunistic approach to whatever opportunities exist. So acquisitions within our markets that carry cost savings are among the options. As I've mentioned, any deal would need to be immediately accretive to earnings with only limited dilution of tangible book value. Beyond that, the return must be well above our cost of capital. So I don't think we've moved off that at all. And while there's plenty of noise out there, we'll remain true to our strategy. I think it's — we've performed well over the last few years, keeping our attention on tangible book value accretion and returns, and that will continue to be our focus going forward.
Daniel Tamayo
analystPerhaps I'll begin with the fourth-quarter guidance regarding NII, or net interest income. I just want a bit of clarification, and I'm attempting to gauge how much margin compression might occur in order to align with what you've guided? On the balance sheet aspect, was there anything during the third quarter related to how quickly things grew that might affect average balances in the fourth quarter? Could that figure potentially decline? I'm simply trying to figure out the right way to arrive at the margin number?
Vince Calabrese
executiveIf I may — I believe this connects to my earlier comment, Danny, regarding the implied beta contained in that figure, correct? The Fed made a 50 move in September, and you only experienced a partial month's effect from it. Consequently, you'll get the complete quarter's effect from it. After that, there are 2 additional 25 moves. So I'd say our NII guide carries a degree of conservatism, yet we're applying a 15% beta as the year concludes. Should we outperform that, then there's potential upside. As things stand today, we haven't lined up any further portfolio exits or similar actions. Thus it would simply be routine business. However, as Vince mentioned previously, the fourth quarter brings some seasonality with somewhat slower business, plus you've got election-related uncertainty and all that; so no, a certain amount remains. Our mid-single-digit forecast for loans continues to be the same one we've consistently provided. So nothing out of the ordinary exists; it's merely us handling the rate reductions occurring between now and year-end.
Daniel Tamayo
analystAll right, got it. So average earning assets are probably going to rise in Q4, and during that quarter it's really a matter of margin, before things begin to level off at some point next year. Would that be a fair way to put it?
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect. And what I'd add is that I'd describe the margin as roughly flat. What I mean is, should it decline, we're talking a few basis points lower, nothing significant — that's just my opening remark.
Daniel Tamayo
analystOkay. All right. That helps. Then perhaps one for Gary regarding the credit backdrop, and more specifically the net charge-off backdrop. Clearly, you saw somewhat greater volatility during Q3, but I'd just like to hear your present thinking on what could serve as a solid run rate for the bank's net charge-offs as you consider the near term?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveDaniel, from a risk management angle we're extremely proactive, keeping ahead of our clients through information flow and by grasping their position along with the risks across the portfolio. From both a risk management and charge-off standpoint, we've kept performing exceptionally well, and every credit metric has sat at or close to record lows for a good while now; this quarter we came in at 25 bps; year-to-date, 17 basis points, which is a truly, truly strong outcome given this environment, which remains somewhat uncertain. And as everyone knows, the CRE environment certainly keeps showing some stress at this point. So I'd anticipate continued performance like what we've delivered over the last several years; and could it tick up slightly? I mean, it might normalize, but I feel quite good about our position, and looking forward, about continuing to outperform relative to the industry.
Vince Delie
executiveGary and the group working under him have accomplished something great when it comes to keeping those risk ratings up to date. That's why he brought up collecting the data. My view is that our position now will remain our position going forward, more or less, unless something huge happens in the worldwide economy. So we won't be caught off guard down the road, to phrase it differently; we're quite rigorous when it comes to underwriting and reviewing risk ratings often, running stress tests and assessing exposure; therefore what's in front of you reflects reality. And I believe that has held for a really long stretch in our case, and Gary has accomplished something great. So that keeps us where we are.
Kelly Motta
analystI realize I'm repeating a point that's already been made, but I'd like to tie up a few remaining items regarding the margin. Concerning the prepared commentary on that 15% beta by year-end, I just want something clarified: is that figure for interest-bearing deposits or for total deposit beta — that's my first question? Second, I understand the budget for next year hasn't been completed; still, speaking at a high level, I'm curious how you expect deposit betas to behave on the way down more generally as we look beyond the upcoming quarter?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes. Kelly, that 15% represents total deposit beta at year-end. Historically, we've discussed something in the mid-30s range during a down cycle — I believe we have certain statistics from the prior cycle that we examine. So that's roughly what we have in mind. Consequently, I'm not certain, but by the conclusion of next year it might land around 30-ish, I'd say, as a total level — once more, total deposit beta at the end of next year is approximately what we're thinking at this point.
Kelly Motta
analystUnderstood. That's quite useful. Then, regarding lending, I'm curious about what you're observing in your regions when it comes to how spreads are holding up on commercial loans? Also, are you noticing any variation in how that's performing in the Carolina markets compared with some of your older Mid-Atlantic markets?
Vince Delie
executiveYeah. It's actually pretty uniform everywhere, which is unexpected. Your question suggests you'd think there would be regional differences. Yet it's been quite uniform. With capital leaving the CRE space, I believe there's somewhat greater pricing flexibility in that category. When you come across a high-quality CRE opportunity, you can capture a bit more margin from it these days. That stems from banks retreating and financial nonbanks retreating too; so I'd say demand isn't strong from a C&I standpoint, more or less everywhere at the moment. Everything is paused. I'd anticipate that shifting as we head into next year. I lack a crystal ball, yet my instinct and 30 years of experience tell me a considerable amount is being withheld. So I'd guess that as we head into next year, we'll see demand at a higher level, especially for the C&I. I anticipate that will occur; and then on the Consumer side, consumer home equity and direct installment has been quite benign. I'd anticipate that picking up somewhat too. And our mortgage company has achieved an outstanding job of gaining share more or less everywhere. So we would keep — I hope, keep succeeding there. I'm not sure whether that addresses your question, but it's more or less the same. The margins are identical based upon the risk profile, more or less everywhere.
Kelly Motta
analystThat’s interesting and really useful. Moving to the cost side, I realize it’s still early to discuss next year, but you’ve previously mentioned the double rent carry tied to the new headquarters build-out. I’m curious about the timing and whether it’s still expected that roughly $7 million will come off next year once you transition into the new space?
Vince Delie
executiveYes. I’m not certain the actual figure is $7 million, but the project itself remains on schedule; our move-in date is November 25, I believe. It seems we picked the most difficult possible week, Thanksgiving. I’m not sure why, but that’s when everyone will relocate there; close to 800 employees are moving into a single site. Right now we occupy 7 buildings here on Pittsburgh’s north side, spread all over the area. I think simply being together will produce efficiency and productivity gains. Our staff are largely in the office already. So that should be a big help; the rent we referenced stems from having had one year of free rent, correct? Under GAAP accounting, that gets spread across the full lease term, and we still carry rent expense for this building. So that explains why it’s happening, in case that slipped your mind. I’d expect a portion of that $7 million to return. It isn’t the full amount, but part of it should come back next year. There could also be demand for additional space. That’s difficult to predict. I can’t give you a perfect apples-to-apples comparison, but in principle, yes, we should see a benefit from a GAAP accounting standpoint. The remaining rent is noncash.
Brian Martin
analystOne question, and let's return to deposits briefly, Vince, and how well things went this quarter. The DDA did dip somewhat. And I realize you folks have discussed being the main bank for your clients, and then the new commercial as well, Vince, where you mentioned seeing chances. So does that — I suppose, do you still expect that flattening at that level to be a reasonable way to view the DDA over the next few quarters, holding near 27%, or do you think it will slide further from the current point?
Vince Delie
executiveThe mix did decline. Clearly, we're in a stretch when demand deposit balances are seeing some runoff, and we've also added many new models, so there's been a change, yet we've stayed near $10 billion quite steadily. As rates climbed, we managed to hold that, as you saw. I think when rates decline, we ought to hold it and expand it in time. So about the whole picture, I can't really say. When you consider total deposits and demand deposits as a share of that total, certainly it will be reduced. Still, that $10 billion of noninterest-bearing deposits has been quite helpful for us; and if you compare our overall cost of funds with peers, we stack up quite favorably. That's the key factor. So I'd say we have chances to expand the noninterest-bearing category, since as clients grow and we've added new ones, and we can provide all the treasury management offerings and the balances used to cover services for their disbursed funds from operating accounts that we hold, we'll see demand deposits rise eventually; however, there remains — keeping demand deposits is very tough in this climate, because anyone holding extra balances wants a better yield, correct, given what's available now compared with the pandemic period when rates were near 0, right? There was nowhere to put it. So — even so, I think we've performed well, and I'd anticipate we keep performing well in that category. Also, we've added many — okay...
Gary Guerrieri
executiveTo add on to that, Brian, we noticed revolver balances come down by roughly 1%, and that is going to have an effect on DDA balances too, since money shifts out of DDA to pay down some debt, as customers, being cautious during these times with everything that's going on and the election on top of us, did make some decisions to pay down some revolver balances; so there's a slight impact there as well.
Vince Delie
executiveThat's a fair observation, Gary.
Vince Calabrese
executiveLet me also mention, Brian, that we've brought in quite a few new names as well, both on the retail side through additional households and through new commercial clients, and once those clients are with us, we have a chance to expand those relationships, which has been a priority for a while — truly becoming the complete bank for the people we serve.
Brian Martin
analystYeah, I hear you. Alright, that's clear. So then regarding — Vince, you appear fairly upbeat, at least about loan growth in the coming year. I suppose there's just nothing yet from that initial rate reduction, which, as you mentioned, was somewhat larger than what folks might have anticipated. Is there any increase in conversations with your clients, where you get a feeling that this optimism about loan growth for next year exists? I realize you all will provide further detail next quarter, but it sounds like several others, other banks, have mentioned that the first rate cut genuinely sparked some fresh interest among their customers. And it didn't seem like you were experiencing that yet, perhaps due to the election and needing to move past a few matters?
Vince Delie
executiveRight, I'm not as hands-on with clients as I once was, though I do engage with the bankers and speak with certain customers. Honestly, I haven't observed that so far. I believe it's still somewhat of a wait-and-see approach, and they anticipate more cuts. So there could be conversations, yet they're thinking, "Hey, I'll have a far better chance later on since everyone is indicating that further rate cuts are coming," correct? So I don't see everyone rushing ahead and declaring, "I'm going to seize this 50 basis point decrease." I think they're sort of holding back and saying, "Hey, let's watch how the election turns out." Many things could occur. After the election, corporate taxes are up for discussion, and all sorts of matters affecting our clients are up for discussion. So they'll hold back and say, "Hey, I want to wait and see what happens." And that's roughly what I'm hearing and observing. And once more, I lack as much understanding as perhaps — I don't know, Gary, would you like to add something?
Gary Guerrieri
executiveAbsolutely, Vince — I'm on the same page as you regarding all of that. It's more or less how things seem right now. Given where we stand in this stretch ahead of the election, my expectation is that as we move into 2025 and reach the middle part of the year, when activity picks up considerably, we'll see demand become somewhat stronger.
Vince Delie
executiveAnd, Brian, I’ve been away for the last few months. I mean, I’ve been in Winston-Salem, and I’ve been in a lot of different places. Winston-Salem, I’ve been in Ohio, and around Pennsylvania. So what I’m hearing is the same. Nothing I’m hearing is different. But then again, I don’t have the complete picture. I mean, maybe what I’m getting is biased information on.
Brian Martin
analystRight, and maybe just one thing on the margin. It sounds like Vince might be able to remind us what the near-term — I think you went over some of the repricing items, but on the loan side, what reprices right away? And then it sounds like, secondly, maybe the expectation is to see a little bit of pressure on the margin in Q4. And then if you're neutral, I guess the expectation is you can kind of keep the margin pretty stable; and then as you get into next year and if the yield curve steepens, you get some improvement later in the year. Is that roughly the way to think about it?
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, I think you said it exactly right, Brian; that would just help with it. But on your first question, Slide 15 lays out the components really well. Just as a reminder to everyone, the 47.5% shown there in the chart of the $33.7 billion that reprices on the loan side over a 3-month period; and like I said before, when you look at the levers we have, there's $11 billion of liabilities that can reprice today. There's another $5.4 billion in CDs maturing in the next 6 months, $2.9 billion in the next 3 months at a 4.75% rate, and then $1 billion in cash flows from the investment portfolio rolling off at 2.91% and being reinvested today, at a minimum between 4.25% and 4.5% — figures that could climb toward $4.25 billion, $4.50 billion, or $4.75 billion; so that basically gives you the main components there.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. All right. Yes. Then I believe you brought up, Vince, or perhaps someone else on this call did, some recruiting that your team has completed on the — possibly related to fee income. If you could perhaps just show us what's happening in that area. And then only one modeling question. From what I gather, the fee income for this quarter, the BOLIs might be somewhat, I don't want to label it, nonrecurring, and additionally there was a negative item you referenced regarding impairment on the mortgage that...
Vince Delie
executiveWhich basically offsets it.
Vince Calabrese
executiveYes, there was an MSR impairment of $2.8 million.
Vince Delie
executiveSo they offset each other. If you look at the fee income, Brian...
Brian Martin
analystRight. Okay, that's logical. Alright, so regarding the staffing you've brought on, I suppose, is there a particular segment you're targeting? Was it capital markets, Vince, that you mentioned in terms of — I believe there was a remark regarding recruitment, and I'm merely attempting to figure out where there...
Vince Delie
executiveRight. We've brought in individuals. We've swapped out personnel. In particular markets, we've upgraded through those substitutions. We had — that's a single domain that's fueling somewhat of the rise in salary costs. Thus we've managed to attract some genuinely skilled individuals. And subsequently, we've been constructing our risk management structure, and we established an operating efficiency team for our operations division since we believed that given the shifts happening with AI and our spending on our data hub, we'll be capable of generating efficiency in operations; so we've recruited — we implemented some modifications. A press release was issued, but we attracted some exceptionally skilled individuals, some process engineers to assist us in generating efficiency and enhancing customer satisfaction and managing risk in the back office. So although that isn't a front-end recruitment, that ought to benefit us over the long term. I mean that's genuinely what's contained within the rise in the run rate of expenses, salary expenses. It isn't as big as the overall sum that we're disclosing because there are all sorts of components in there. A portion of it's directly tied to production, correct, greater production in those fee income sectors. We're disbursing commission. But I believe we're placing ourselves in a fairly solid position going into next year, both with funding, correct? So should there be an uptick in demand, maintaining that funding short, short duration in our approach so we can reprice downward, capitalize on the shifts in interest rates that happen and subsequently investing in sectors that yield revenue and create efficiencies. So those are the elements that propelled all of our choices.
Brian Martin
analystUnderstood. Alright, I think that covers everything on my end. And I suppose you could just refresh my memory — when it comes to sensitivity, you folks are fairly neutral, correct? Is that what I picked up? I assume there's been no shift regarding where you stand on sensitivity right now?
Vince Calabrese
executiveNo, I'd put it this way — what I mean is, we remain asset sensitive, though it's obvious we're heading in the direction of neutral. What I mean is, considering every lever I've mentioned, Brian. Should you review our 10-Q, asset sensitivity is still what appears, yet in my view we sit closer to neutral than the rate calculation would suggest, and we're trending that way. Yes.
Manuel Navas
analystIs everyone able to hear me at this point?
Manuel Navas
analystA good number of the things I wanted to ask have already been covered; even so, could you go a bit deeper on the places where deposit market share gains are showing up? Which geographies are producing the strongest results, and where do you anticipate that momentum carrying on?
Vince Delie
executiveSure. We recorded some rather <<inaudible>> the Carolinas came in at double digits, and I believe that's a region where things have gone really well for us. In Pittsburgh, we keep enjoying success. Given how enormous our share of that market is, it tends to build on its own momentum, I'd say. What I mean is, we've reached the scale needed to compete strongly in this area, attract new customers, and develop larger relationships, and that process is ongoing; so that's a place where we're gaining. Across the central portion of Pennsylvania, our performance has been remarkable. We therefore added a substantial amount there. Then, when you look toward the Mid-Atlantic region, we've achieved some wins in the markets we're pushing into. On top of that, Charleston, South Carolina along with the South Carolina market we're entering quite rapidly have delivered solid outcomes for us. Those areas are — it's essentially — my sense is it's essentially all over the place, isn't it? I'd say we've performed well across quite a few markets. Still, my take is that the Carolinas plus the central portion of Pennsylvania are likely out in front, correct, and after that Pittsburgh.
Vince Calabrese
executiveCorrect. Out of the 57 MSAs where we do business, 35 posted growth, and when you combine the ones where share went up with those that held steady, that comes to 91% of our markets, so I'd call that a really solid outcome. Then in the Carolinas, 6 of the markets we serve there saw gains, so...
Vince Delie
executiveWhat I meant was the sequential gain, not the improvement shown in the market share figures. Even so, the two line up quite closely and tell much the same tale.
Manuel Navas
analystSwitching topics for a moment — suppose we see meaningful rate reductions by the midpoint of next year, what sort of fee upside do you anticipate? You're bringing on new relationships across the Carolinas; might that turn into stronger mortgage activity fairly quickly? Could you just address that fee opportunity tied to lower rates?
Vince Delie
executiveSure. For us, mortgage really comes down to demand, since we're heavily focused on purchase money lending. So ideally, we'll see additional housing inventory available, and more individuals choosing to list their homes. Still, I believe that would be positive. Regarding swap income derived from commercial clients — someone else raised this question, I believe it was Brian, asking what we're observing in the market? The key point I can share is that clients considering a fixed rate swap are monitoring developments, and they haven't acted yet, since they keep hearing through media coverage that further cuts are on the way. So when you speak with them, they tell you, "I'm going to hold off for now." That said, I believe that segment has room to expand. I believe our Syndications operation, as time goes on, will present opportunities, since there will be additional M&A, especially within the middle market and the lower portion of the middle market, which works to our advantage. We've also — we're also growing in a number of areas; we're entering the advisory space. We're developing our public finance capacity. So certain initiatives will drive fee generation in '25 that aren't even in place currently. So I believe — and they won't be — it won't be enormous, but it will make a difference. In any case, those are the items we're considering as we plan ahead.
Vince Calabrese
executiveAnd the debt capital markets had a record year this year.
Vince Delie
executiveYeah, the debt capital markets have clearly performed well, and there's no reason that shouldn't keep going, correct? Since, as Gary noted when discussing online utilization figures, we examined our bigger clients and found almost no capital markets activity that would push down revolver balances — that's the reason he commented, "Hey, this is going to hit your demand deposits. Our clients are drawing on their cash balances to reduce debt as we head into the coming quarter." So that's the pattern we've observed. And there's likely some degree of recalibration happening among the customer base and on their balance sheets, as they get ready as well for whatever lies ahead.
Vince Delie
executiveAll right, thanks to each of you. I'm grateful for the inquiries. I value how much time you've spent with us, and we genuinely can't wait for the upcoming quarter and for what we'll deliver. I'm also thankful for all that the employees have accomplished and keep on doing to push us the right way. So, my thanks. Thanks to all of you. Stay well.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate everyone joining us for today's presentation. You're welcome to leave the line now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete F.N.B. Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to F.N.B. Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in F.N.B. Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.