First American Financial Corporation (FAF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 22, 2026
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Craig Barberio
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for joining First American's conference call covering third-quarter 2026 results. Joining us today are our Chief Executive Officer, Mark Seaton, and Matt Wajner, our Chief Financial Officer. Some of what we say today may include forward-looking statements, which are not strictly tied to historical or current facts. Any forward-looking statements we make speak only as of today's date, and the company does not commit to revising them for circumstances or events that arise afterward. There are risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from what those forward-looking statements set forth. To learn more about these risks and uncertainties, we encourage you to review yesterday's earnings release along with the risk factors outlined in our Form 10-K and later SEC filings. In today's presentation, we include some non-GAAP financial measures, which we think offer extra insight into how efficiently the company is operating and how it is performing compared with prior periods and with competitors. For further information about these non-GAAP financial measures, including how they are presented and reconciled to the most directly comparable GAAP financials, please see yesterday's earnings release, which you can find on our website at www.firstam.com. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Mark Seaton.
Mark Seaton
executiveThanks, Craig. Adjusted earnings per share came in at $1.78 for the quarter, up 5% versus the prior year. National Commercial Services posted its highest third-quarter revenue ever, capping another excellent quarter for our commercial business. Growth was broad-based — eight of our 11 asset classes rose year-over-year — and average revenue per order hit a record for the fifth quarter in a row. We closed 22 transactions that produced more than $1 million of premium in the quarter, versus $12 million a year earlier. Just six of those transactions were data centers, which shows the market's strength is wider than that, spanning energy, industrial, and multifamily. Commercial refinance contributed significantly as well, with premium revenue up 49% from the prior year. Residential remains the more challenged side of the business. Purchase revenue fell 3% as affordability constraints kept weighing on existing home sales. Refinance revenue was down 1%. Over the past six months, the 30-year fixed mortgage rate has risen roughly 100 basis points, to 7.5%, the highest level since the second quarter of 2024. Higher mortgage rates reinforce what we expect: a lower-for-longer residential origination environment. Ours is a cyclical business, and while elevated rates prolong the difficult conditions we're operating in, they also give us a chance to make transformational changes to the business. We're using this period to deepen customer relationships and speed up the rollout of our new AI-native title and settlement platforms. I'll begin with Endpoint. In the third quarter, we launched wave two of the Washington pilot, extending the platform to more users across the Seattle metro area. Each day brings valuable learnings about the product and about how we train our team to work effectively on the new platform; we keep making meaningful progress automating the tasks needed to close a transaction. Our automation rate rose from 30% in the first quarter to 34% in the second quarter, then hit 42% in the third quarter. That's a fundamental shift in how title and settlement work gets done. As workflows grow more standardized and automated, our people's role increasingly moves away from executing routine tasks toward managing exceptions and focusing on higher-value customer interactions. The result should be less time processing a file and more time with customers, while also delivering a more consistent and efficient experience. We're applying what we learned from the Washington pilot as we prepare for an accelerated national rollout next year, and by the end of 2027 we intend to have the majority of our direct division revenue running through Endpoint. Sequoia, our instant title decisioning platform, is also advancing significantly. In the third quarter, we launched Sequoia for purchase transactions in three more Southern California counties. We're now successfully completing 17% of California purchase transactions processed through Endpoint, up from 11% last quarter. Beyond that, we extended Sequoia’s use for refinance deals into 33 more counties throughout Northern California, and at this point 34% of California refinance transactions handled on the platform are being completed. Human review time is another key metric we monitor. As Sequoia scales, every order it produces still gets reviewed by a person. Yet the time each review takes keeps going down. For purchase transactions, average review time dropped to 74 minutes in the second quarter from 83 minutes in the first quarter, then to 56 minutes in the third quarter. We anticipate additional gains, especially since we’re rolling out new tools in the fourth quarter aimed at making the review process more efficient. Compared with our traditional process, Sequoia already cuts processing time by 2/3, and we anticipate it will grow even more efficient as time goes on. Title plant data stands among First American’s most significant competitive advantages. We obtain source documents straight from counties, pull out and structure the pertinent data, and then bring our underwriting expertise and advanced technology to bear to generate fully insurable title commitments. We believe that as Sequoia matures, we can generate those commitments more quickly and at a lower cost than any other industry player by drawing on this distinctive end-to-end capability. Importantly, First American’s balance sheet stands behind these commitments, pairing speed and efficiency with the financial strength and underwriting certainty our customers expect. Looking to the fourth quarter, we intend to introduce Sequoia for purchase transactions across Northern California and to move into Florida in both our direct and agency operations. Much like Endpoint, we anticipate that by the end of 2027 a majority of our orders will be processed on the Sequoia platform. We believe that once fully mature, Sequoia will give us the industry’s most modern title production platform, with a goal of automating roughly 80% of refinance transactions and 70% of purchase transactions in markets where we maintain title plants. Our bank, First American Trust, is another significant driver of our earnings, providing a growing and increasingly diversified source of investment income. In Q3, investment income in the title segment rose 11%, powered by a 39% increase at First American Trust, which is benefiting from growth outside our captive title business, including ServiceMac and our 1031 Exchange business. On our outlook, we expect the recent pattern of a strong commercial market and a sluggish residential market to persist; through the first three weeks of October, our open purchase orders are down 8%, refinance is down 35%, and commercial is down 7%. Judging by our order pipeline, we still believe commercial will finish the year strongly. Given elevated mortgage rates, however, we will be in a lower for longer residential origination environment. Looking ahead, we anticipate those trends carrying forward into 2027, and against that backdrop our attention will stay sharply fixed on bringing our core title business capabilities up to date while expanding the adjacent operations that hold up better through cycles — among them First American Trust, ServiceMac, Home Warranty, and our data business; at this point I'll hand the call to Matt, who will walk everyone through our financial results in more detail.
Matt Wajner
executiveThanks, Mark. For this quarter, GAAP earnings came to $1.72 per diluted share. Adjusted earnings — which strip out net investment losses and amortization tied to purchased intangibles — reached $1.78 per diluted share. Within the title segment, total revenue hit $2 billion, a 7% gain versus the same quarter of 2025. Commercial revenue landed at $297 million, up 21% over last year, powered by a 13% rise in average revenue per order alongside a 7% lift in closed orders. Purchase revenue fell 3% in the quarter, the result of a 5% drop in closed orders that was partly offset by a 2% gain in average revenue per order. Refinance revenue slipped 1% from last year, as a 4% decrease in average revenue per order was partly offset by a 3% rise in closed orders. Refinance made up only 5% of direct revenue this quarter, which shows how subdued refinance activity still is compared with historical norms. Over in the agency business, revenue reached $868 million, up 9% from a year ago. Because agent revenues carry a reporting lag of roughly one quarter, what these results mainly capture is remittances tied to economic activity in the second quarter. Information and other revenues totaled $292 million for the quarter, 6% higher than last year, largely on the back of a 31% jump in fee revenue at ServiceMac stemming from expansion of its loan portfolio. Investment income came in at $169 million in the third quarter, an 11% increase from last year, mostly driven by growth in our investment portfolio linked to higher deposit balances at First American Trust. Personnel costs were $574 million in the third quarter, up 6% versus the same quarter of 2025. That rise stemmed chiefly from greater salary and incentive compensation expense. Other operating expenses totaled $306 million this quarter, 11% above last year, mainly due to higher software expense and increased production expense. Our success ratio reached 87% for the quarter, exceeding our 60% target. We booked $8 million in one-time expenses this quarter connected to an operational restructuring and an indirect tax matter. We also kept investing in certain businesses beyond our domestic title operations, including ServiceMac. The investments at ServiceMac are underpinning substantial growth in its loan portfolio. The provision for policy losses and other claims stood at $45 million in the third quarter, equal to 3.0% of title premiums and escrow fees, the same as the prior year. The third quarter rate mirrors an ultimate loss ratio of 3.75% for the current policy year plus a net decrease of $11 million in the loss reserve estimate for prior policy years. Interest expense was $31 million this quarter, up 27% from last year, reflecting higher interest expense tied to growth in deposit balances at First American Trust. Pre-tax margin in the title segment came to 12.4%, or 12.7% adjusted. Turning to the Home Warranty segment: total revenue was $115 million this quarter, unchanged from last year. For the quarter, pre-tax income came in at $11 million, a 30% decline versus last year, mainly because we spent more on marketing to keep fueling growth in our direct-to-consumer sales channel. Our loss provision stood at 47%, basically flat against the third quarter of 2025. In the Home Warranty segment, the pre-tax margin was 9.9%, or 9.7% adjusted. The effective tax rate for the quarter was 22.4%, a touch under the company's normalized rate of 24%. Debt-to-capital came to 30.3%. If you exclude secured financings payable, that ratio was 22.2%. On dividends, our target payout ratio across the cycle is 40%. With this year's results and our outlook ahead, we lifted the common stock dividend by 11% during the quarter, taking it to an annual rate of $2.44 per share, which moves the payout ratio closer to our target. In the quarter, 23,000 shares were repurchased for $1 million in total, at an average price of $64.24; and in October so far, we've bought back 143,000 shares for $9 million total, averaging $62.40. At this point, I'd like to hand the call to the operator for your questions.
Bose George
analystMorning, everyone. Let me start with costs. You brought up what I take to be a one-off $8 million charge, but I'd like a wider picture: what margin level do you anticipate in 2027 assuming residential volumes hold near $2 trillion — or, as I understand it, the MBA projects something even lower — and commercial stays roughly flat, given the comparisons are set to become quite tough?
Matt Wajner
executiveHello, Bose, and thanks for asking. Sure — I'll walk through every one of our main markets. Looking at where we are now, taking into account the points you raised and what Mark covered in his prepared remarks, our current view is basically no change in revenue year over year—that's 2027 measured against all of 2026. As you pointed out, we anticipate commercial will be robust in the coming year. We've said we're expecting a record year this year, and we believe modest growth is achievable next year since we think that strength will persist and might even pick up. So commercial should see some modest growth next year, and that would give us a record year in 2027. On residential, clearly, we hold a more negative view regarding both purchase and refi. For the coming year, we anticipate a decline in revenue relative to the current one. A favorable factor we foresee for next year is income from investments. That figure has been climbing—specifically, investment income net of interest expense has risen roughly 8% year-to-date versus the prior year. We anticipate it will remain robust next year, since rates are expected to be elevated, encompassing both short-term rates and US Treasury rates. We believe that should be beneficial for our investment portfolio—both the portfolio itself and the yields we earn on deposits—so we anticipate some growth in investment income. Turning to expenses, we expect the usual inflationary pressures on personnel and other operating costs, mainly salaries and technology spending. Another item: it's too early to say, but regarding the loss ratio, we've been at 3% this year and 3% last year, and that consists of 3.75% for the current policy year with a release of prior years of 75 basis points. Looking at our business, through a typical cycle we usually see losses in the range of 4% to 5%, and for the past several years we've actually come in under that. The main reason is that during the pandemic, when everything felt uncertain, our loss rate ran a bit higher, but those claims ultimately never materialized, so we've been giving back a portion of that cushion. My expectation is that sometime soon we will either reduce the pace of those releases or stop them altogether. Naturally, any adjustments we make will depend on the claims that actually come in. If that plays out, $27 would be our strongest year on record.
Bose George
analystAll right, that's really useful. So to pull it all together, do you think the margin will end up roughly flat, or might there be some upside?
Matt Wajner
executiveAt this point, I'd say I don't really see much room for the margin to expand. It all comes down to how the commercial market performs next year. Should commercial do better than we expect, we might be able to expand it. As things stand, though, I don't anticipate margin expansion next year.
Bose George
analystAlright, thank you for those details. I have one question about Sequoia and Endpoint, looking at it from the cost angle. As that deployment keeps moving forward, do the initial expense savings actually materialize only once you've completely switched off the other platforms? Would that land potentially in 2028, or does it take a bit longer since some things are still running on the older platforms?
Mark Seaton
executiveThat hinges on which platform you mean — Endpoint or Sequoia. With Sequoia, the savings come as we deploy it. Strategically, the coming year will be a major one for us as we deploy both of these platforms. We'll begin to capture incremental gains—take Sequoia, for instance—as it rolls out, as our fulfillment rates rise, and as more orders move through Sequoia, we achieve savings on each order processed there. There's no real need to hold off on realizing those savings until the legacy platform is retired. With Endpoint, I'd describe it as somewhat different yet comparable. Strategically, next year is a significant one, and assuming we execute successfully during it, we should truly start seeing the benefits in 2028.
Bose George
analystOh, okay. Great. Thanks.
Mark Seaton
executiveThanks, Bose.
Mark Hughes
analystYeah, thank you. Good morning.
Mark Seaton
executiveGood morning, Mark.
Mark Hughes
analystRegarding the title pre-tax margin, I believe you indicated that you aren't expecting margin expansion next year. If you factor in somewhat more investment income and somewhat higher expense, does that imply pre-tax margin would be stable?
Matt Wajner
executiveYes, I'd say I think we could be stable to. Stable is roughly what I would expect at present. There could be a bit of pressure, so it might contract somewhat, but as things stand today, I don't see a significant deviation.
Mark Hughes
analystWhat's the outlook for investment income in the fourth quarter? How does that look like it's coming together?
Matt Wajner
executiveMy expectation is that investment income will track the same rate of growth as in the first three quarters. On the subject of investment income, I believe I mentioned this last quarter, but the way we look at it is investment income net of interest expense, because much of the increase in investment income has come from deposit growth at the bank, correct? So you have interest expense offsetting that. Looking at it year-to-date, investment income has risen 11% year-over-year. Interest expense has climbed 31%, and net was up 8%. That 8% net increase strikes me as a solid figure for Q4.
Mark Hughes
analystThanks for that. Regarding the commercial side, it sounds as though you have solid confidence for next year. From what you’ve seen, how much does that depend on interest rates if rates stay higher for longer? What would that mean for refi, and then for purchase — and maybe, as part of that, it sounds like refi was pretty strong in commercial this quarter. Are people rushing to get in before a deadline, or is that simply healthy underlying activity?
Mark Seaton
executiveFor us, fortunately, Mark, it just isn’t as sensitive to interest rates. There’s surely some sensitivity, I’m sure, but I think particularly for these large deals such as data centers and the big energy deals we’re doing, they just aren’t rate-sensitive. We’re seeing those deals close. Another point too on the commercial side is that you don’t have 30-year mortgages, right? Like you do on the residential side. Many of these commercial loans now have shorter duration as well; typically they’re five years, and I’ve spoken with several clients who are coming in with even less than that, simply because they think, hey, rates are high, and why should we take out a 10-year loan? We can do a three-year loan. That just generates more transaction activity, more refinance activity in our pipeline over the next couple of years. Commercial is simply a more stable business when it comes to refinance volume than the residential side, which is obviously good for us.
Mark Hughes
analystVery good. Thank you.
Mark Seaton
executiveThanks, Mark.
Terry Ma
analystHi there, thanks. Morning, everyone. I'd like to pick up where we left off regarding the 2027 margin outlook. If residential deteriorates further and some of the commercial momentum eases off, how do you view the capacity to hold title margins near the current level? And what extra levers could you pull on costs should that scenario play out?
Mark Seaton
executiveTerry, I'll take that one. Looking ahead to next year, my view is simple: we're already operating in a difficult market. For the past couple of years, refinancing has felt like a one out of 10; and as I noted, our open refinance orders are down 30% + in October. Still, that comes off a very low base. Much the same can be said for purchase activity. Purchase has basically been at rock bottom for four years now. This October, our open orders are down 8%; we do have levers available. That said, our attention really sits on next year in this hard market, and conditions will become a little tougher still. What matters is staying very close to our customers. We aim to take share while the market contracts. We intend to put money into the business and launch these new platforms next year; that will be our priority so we're properly positioned for the next cycle. That effort is paying off. Over the last 12 months, market share has grown 60 basis points, and we've made zero acquisitions. We simply want to sustain that momentum; there are always levers at our disposal. Even so, we're thinking three to five years out rather than about next quarter. That's how we're approaching it at the moment.
Terry Ma
analystUnderstood. That tracks; regarding commercial, do you have any insight into how the pipeline is shaping up as we head toward the fourth quarter? ARPA growth slowed down quite a bit this quarter. Is there anything worth flagging? Was that mostly a mix issue, or did certain deals end up pushing into the following quarter? Any detail on that would be useful. Thanks.
Mark Seaton
executiveOn the first part of your question, we're extremely optimistic about commercial in Q4. Extremely optimistic; we've already signed three premium deals each above $1 million. Our pipeline going into Q4 is genuinely solid. You can never be certain, can you? It's during the final two weeks of December that you really learn how Q4 turned out. Still, that pipeline is truly robust. We've said so throughout the year, and there's simply a great deal of momentum behind us. A great deal of momentum. It's genuinely wide-ranging. It spans many geographies. As Matt mentioned, our belief is that it will continue into next year as well. So commercial in Q4 is something we're extremely optimistic about; as for ARPA, perhaps Matt could address that.
Matt Wajner
executiveYes, thank you. You mentioned that ARPA slowed down versus Q2. To clarify, ARPA did grow compared with a year ago. It did slow from Q2—we've discussed this previously—but if we look at commercial, roughly 70% of commercial revenue is generated by our National Commercial Services business, which Mark covered in his prepared remarks, and about 30% comes from our local business. In fact, within NCS, our National Commercial Services business, ARPA rose both year-over-year and sequentially. What that tells us is that certain large deals occurred last quarter in Q2 outside centralized commercial, and those really boosted that ARPA. That ARPA was a record ARPA. So ARPA remains quite healthy. It simply lacked the benefit of perhaps some large deals flowing through the non-centralized channel.
Terry Ma
analystOkay. Got it. Thank you.
Mark Seaton
executiveThank you.
Oscar Nieves
analystMorning. Earlier you had a few remarks regarding the Endpoint and Sequoia rollouts, and I'd like to follow up on those. Once Endpoint goes national next year, which execution risks loom largest, and would you anticipate that shift weighing on costs before any benefits appear, possibly in 2028?
Mark Seaton
executiveThanks a lot for that question, Oscar. When we first launched Endpoint, the greatest risk, I'd say, was simply executing on the technology. We were attempting something nobody had done before, and there were genuine technological hurdles we had to clear; that risk has largely disappeared at this point. We feel very confident in our capacity to build products, and at Endpoint we have an excellent product design engineering team. Technology-wise, the flywheel is truly spinning, so our confidence in where our product stands is high, and that was the risk. What I see as the risk today sits more on the change management front. For 25 years, our team has used FAST, our system, and judged by today's standards it is inefficient. Even so, they are accustomed to it, correct? They are used to logging on, and they are productive within an inefficient system; now we are bringing out a new system, and a great deal of change management must go into that. You are instructing someone who has spent, again, 25 years on one system to work with an AI-native platform, and right now that is the major risk—just change management; among the things we are testing in these Washington pilots is not only refining the product but also, all right, how do we train our people? Are we providing sufficient training? Are we taking the right steps? Heading into next year, that, in my view, will be the largest risk. As for costs alone, I don't anticipate materially more cost. It is more or less already baked into our run rate. There may be some, but getting it right next year is worth the investment. Compared with that initiative, I don't expect a material cost increase next year.
Oscar Nieves
analystThat's quite useful. Now I'd like to ask about the bank and its growth. For several quarters you've noted how First American Trust keeps expanding. Could you say how large you believe that segment could get compared with the whole company, and how you view its rate sensitivity and the deposit mix?
Mark Seaton
executiveOkay, I'll take that first, and then Matt can address rate sensitivity and the deposit mix. Let me just say our bank gives us a major strategic edge for two reasons. First, it makes our operations much more efficient. As a settlement company we're handling escrow funds constantly, and because we have a bank tightly integrated with our operations, we can open accounts, close accounts, and move money faster than anyone else; so there's an operational benefit. Second, there's a substantial financial benefit as well, since we can direct certain deposits into our own bank and earn a spread on them; it has grown just about every year. I believe we've nearly maxed out — not entirely, but I'd say 95% of our own internal deposits that we're able to push into First American Trust, we do. Really, the growth prospects going forward come from what I'd call these non-title deposits. We are going to. There are 20,000 different title agents out there banking with their own institutions. We approach them and say, "Hey, why not bank with First American Trust?" We're seeing some success with that; also, when we acquired ServiceMac, they have deposits too that we can direct into First American Trust. We discussed this last quarter, but our 1031 Exchange balances were never held at First American Trust, yet we built a product, and now we have roughly $1 billion in deposits at First American Trust. We're growing these non-title deposits, I believe, very successfully. How big can it get? I don't really have an answer to that. What I do know is every single month, we're signing up new agents and growing our deposit base. I'll turn it over to Matt to discuss the sensitivity.
Matt Wajner
executiveYeah. So on the bank's sensitivity — the bulk of the bank's assets sit in the bond portfolio. You can think of that portfolio as having a duration of five years, and every month roughly $50 million to $60 million comes off in cash that we reinvest. That's one way to frame it: look at the forward curve, then think about that amount being reinvested at those rates. Then just one point on growth. On a year-over-year basis, comparing average deposits in Q3 2026 with Q3 2025, deposits were up almost 38%, and nearly all of that, as Mark said, came from ServiceMac, our sub-servicing business, and from our 1031 Exchange business. I wouldn't expect that pace to keep up. There are still opportunities to keep expanding, but I just don't think it would keep expanding at that rate.
Oscar Nieves
analystAll right, that's useful. For my final question, let's shift to reserves. You said title losses usually come in around 4%-5% across the cycle, and that you've stayed under that for a number of years since COVID. If those releases—since you've freed up some reserves—were to slow down or halt, how should we view the provision going forward? What portion of today's rate reflects the release, and where does the rate for the current year land?
Matt Wajner
executiveRight now, our reserving level is 3%. Our thinking there is that 3.75% applies to what we term the current policy year; on new policies we're writing, the reserve is set at 3.75%. When we release reserves no longer needed from earlier years, that accounts for the 75 basis points of reduction bringing us to 3%. In today's environment, for new policies, we'd regard 3.75% as roughly the appropriate loss reserve at present.
Oscar Nieves
analystAll right, that’s really useful. Thank you very much.
Mark Seaton
executiveThank you, Oscar.
Operator
operatorThank you. That brings us to the end of the time available for questions today. That wraps up this morning's call. We'd like to remind everyone listening that a replay of today's call can be accessed on the company's website, or by dialing 877 to 660 to 6853 or 201 to 612 to 7415 and entering the conference ID 1376 3251. The company thanks you for joining us. That concludes today's conference call.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete First American Financial Corporation transcript — plus 133,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to First American Financial Corporation earnings transcripts and 133,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in First American Financial Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.