flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 2, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for joining us on today's analyst call about our half-year figures for 2021 — and not the strategy day. That was a misspelling fact. Great to have you with us. I hope all of you are doing well. We'd like to use the next 60 minutes to give you more insight into our press release and the preliminaries we published this morning. Following the presentation, the analysts will get the chance to ask questions, and we're more than happy to answer them. Let's jump into the presentation and into the results for the first half-year. It has been the best half-year in our history. We are perfectly on track to deliver what we promised for this year. We had record numbers for new customers, reaching 1.75 million customers at the end of June. If you keep in mind, our guidance for this year was 2 to 2.2 million clients at the end of the year. We are very well on track to meet this target. The transactions settled were close to 63 million, which is also absolutely within the range of the guidance that we as a management gave to the market, reaching 90 to 110 million transactions.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe saw a substantial rise in revenues and in the adjusted EBITDA margin alike, posting revenues of EUR 226 million alongside an adjusted EBITDA margin of 48%. We'll get into the financials shortly as well. During the first half we kept outperforming all of our major peers. As we had already done in the first quarter, we outperformed the three biggest peers in Europe: Avanza, Nordnet, and Fineco. Across the entire first half, and therefore in the second quarter too, we once again delivered a great performance. Our client growth matched what those three peers achieved combined, and that really is evidence for our strategy, which is driven mainly, obviously, by our great European footprint. Keep in mind that the first half was marked by plenty of corporate actions at group level: the merger of DEGIRO, the arrival of a new management team at DEGIRO, and the implementation of additional synergies. We are entirely satisfied and grateful to our people for this great work, which produced these record figures overall. As for the major events we had, as I mentioned, there was not only the completion of the merger of DEGIRO and flatex Bank into flatexDEGIRO Bank AG, but also the launch of a variety of products and services, including first and foremost the ETF and savings plans at zero fees.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWhen it comes to ESG, we've made enormous strides and we keep getting better all the time. We were only recently put through analysis and rating, and we've ended up rated within the top 10 of our peers where our ESG setup is concerned. On the subject of additional products and services, one key thing to flag is of course the launch of early and late trading across all of Europe that we've announced, which, by the way, goes live next Monday for all our 1.7 million clients, along with the launch of the European ETP partnerships, which we expect to go live in the third quarter. One more item we'd like to raise is the AGM we held successfully, which also helped us in the vote on the stock split, and that should likewise take place during this quarter. That's the introduction. Let's move to the facts and figures. I spoke about a structure and strategy that is growing very fast. In the first half year, we succeeded in expanding our client base by more than 40% to 1.75 million clients. We've always said that, when it comes to our long-term vision and long-term mission, this is the first and most important metric for us. It is customer growth, and it is transaction settled.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe recognize that along the way some quarters are going to be great and others could come in softer, particularly because of the business model all of us operate, which relies heavily on seasonality. In a moment we'll also walk you through the seasonal patterns. We genuinely believe that as our client base grows and trading activity holds up sustainably across the coming 5 years, we'll be able to achieve our long-term vision, or midterm vision, Vision 2026. We'll succeed in turning that commercial success into even stronger financial KPIs in the years ahead. Looking at our outgrowth across the past 18 months, you can see that in every single one of those 18 months, we outperformed our peers. Once again, for us this is clear proof that we're heading in precisely the right direction, that we've put in place and continue to put in place precisely the right measures to keep on this growth path. We also see that, clearly, certain market movements will give us durable support in outgrowing our peers. Worth highlighting in particular is that this outperformance has nothing to do with luck. Nor does it have anything to do with us doing things better or being smarter.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThis ties directly to our clear strategy of being a Pan-European player — one with a genuinely unique European footprint. That's what drives our success. And rest assured, we're investing right now in future growth as well. Investing in our growth going forward is something we'll keep doing continuously. I've said all along that we won't evaluate this business on a quarterly financial basis. Our growth story comes with a very clear ambition, and that's exactly what we're absolutely pursuing. The seasonal patterns I referred to, of course, affect near-term development — both in trade volumes and in customer growth. Q2 has consistently been the weakest quarter. I was rather surprised in recent weeks when competitors and peers came out with their figures. There was so much talk about a weak Q2, and I have to say, this is a seasonal pattern we've observed for decades. We just gave you the 2016 to 2019 numbers, and they show very impressively just how markedly weak Q2 typically is. That's precisely why the fact that Q2 came in weaker than Q1 doesn't surprise us at all. Q1 is typically the strongest quarter, along with Q4 — particularly, or also, because in Q2, especially in Europe, there are plenty of bank holidays and vacations, which lead to slower growth in both clients and transactions.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveOnce again, the fact and the results were absolutely no surprise to us. If anything, we were positively surprised by the H1 results, given how fast growth has been recently and the extra expenses we carried over the past months and quarters. As I said, the crucial point is turning commercial success and commercial KPIs into financial success and financial KPIs as well. In H1 2021 we hit our all-time record EBITDA margin at almost 48%, coming from recent quarters somewhere around the high 40s, but we never made it to 48%. Yes, here too we were expecting a slightly higher margin, but we're very well aware that one-offs and one-off expenses exist. As I said, we had a lot of corporate structural changes in the company during the first six months of the year that we have digested. We were discussing making an adjustment to EBITDA, but we always promised that the adjustment to EBITDA would be very straightforward, always only related to the long-term incentive plan and any one-time, one-off personnel expenses. That is why we have not adjusted any other items. I'm happy to explain in detail what other costs were involved during H1 that we don't expect in the future.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThe first item, and one with among the biggest impact, is that our employee base has expanded by approximately 100 people in total across the past six months. That is clearly tied to the growth — the enormous growth we've delivered. As you'll recall, I consistently make the point that for every 10,000 clients, we require about one or two additional people. All told, we added over 500,000. Multiplying 50 by two people gives you 100 extra employees. That's what we anticipated and what we encountered. So these kinds of costs weren't adjusted for, since they are sustainable and will keep going, yet they'll deliver a large effect — a strongly positive one — on profitability as economies of scale come through. We also keep bringing in the right clients. You're all familiar with this debate about, okay, winning a big number of clients matters. What matters more is winning the right quality. If you look at which clients we've brought on during the last six months, you'll see we are confronting exactly, and aiming at exactly, what we preach. The first and most interesting point is that we succeeded in winning increasingly more female savers and investors.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThat share moved up from 13% to 17%, a solid number for us, particularly since it concerns one of the most underserved groups in the European market: female savers and investors. Considering that 50% of the population — actually more — is female, this is an area the market has been lacking, and it's where we'll keep concentrating our efforts on attracting these young professional ladies, young professional women with a mature profile, who are also growing increasingly financially independent and increasingly find themselves having to choose where to put their money for the long term, ultimately landing with us. You can see the same thing in assets under custody. At EUR 40 billion in assets under custody, each client holds roughly EUR 25,000 with us, in cash and in securities. Compare that with many other brokers, especially amid all the big talk about neo brokers, and you'll notice we carry 3x, 4x, 5x what those players carry. That's a really important metric when it comes to sustainability. The larger the account sizes, the stickier the clients. I've often said that neo brokers are great for us, since they build awareness in the market and tend to serve as incumbents — sorry, as incubators for the more, shall we say, affluent brokerage clients.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveYou've witnessed this pattern with a lot of brokers too. I believe it was also mentioned in the Robinhood IPO filings that the majority of clients, and most of the churn, comes from accounts being churned with high accounts, with large accounts. That's precisely the way it works. People often begin perhaps with these neo brokers, wind up developing themselves, their accounts grow larger and larger, and then they discover they're in a constrained setting, so they must take this extra step, moving to additional products, additional services, and ultimately they land with brokers such as flatexDEGIRO. We're glad to keep pursuing our course to win clients in the correct segment with the correct demographic average. That's what you can see on the right-hand side. As I mentioned, AUCs of roughly EUR 23,000, annualized trades of 71. 70% of the population we won fell within the sweet spot we set for ourselves, 25 to 55. Nearly 60% with prior brokerage experience as well as higher education. That's also what you see, what we have among the most commonly named professions. I addressed this point. Which expenses did we incur that we didn't adjust for, but that we've actually absorbed through the P&L?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveI'll begin with the operational personnel costs. Right, those are largely a result of the consolidation. Beyond that, we added slightly more than 100 to the FTE count, reflecting the strong growth we've seen and that we anticipate going forward. We also brought in additional senior hires to keep building out stability, compliance, and fast execution across our systems and our growth. This also means we expanded in areas such as marketing, where we'll keep focusing, since we're targeting four, five, six core markets on top of our domestic ones, which we must and will pursue very significantly over the next six months. That growth was highly cost sensitive, so average personnel expenses stayed flat. Overall, it remains quite moderate at under EUR 40,000 per FTE on average. You can see we're expanding, but not by bringing in highly expensive people. As I've consistently noted, particularly when it comes to service and customer support levels, where costs are typically lower than at the high end with IT staff or risk staff, we've seen only very moderate growth there, which isn't really reflected in the figures themselves.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveBeyond the personnel costs, there were also some one-off other admin expenses, stemming not just from consolidation but particularly from the corporate structural changes we went through in the first half. Overall, other administrative expenses came to roughly around EUR 3 million, mainly from consulting tied to the merger process between DEGIRO and flatex Bank. Plus, to some extent, provisions for potential claims arising from the federal court decision regarding historic pricing changes, et cetera, which is relatively low. Taken together, these one-offs totaled roughly EUR 3 million. Beyond that, we spent almost EUR 10 million more on marketing, with massive client acquisition cost. We got it down to under EUR 35, which I'd say shows how great our marketing team is operating and that the marketing strategy is absolutely the right way to continue with, and that will support us in the massive growth during future quarters and half years. Coming down from more than EUR 100 client acquisition, so savings of more than 60%-70% down to EUR 35 is exactly where we want to go to.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveOur internal target has consistently been under EUR 50. Delivering below EUR 35 in the first half demonstrates the outstanding work our colleagues are doing and points to where we're headed. Yes, we'll keep up this growth, as I mentioned, particularly by rolling out extra services and products over the coming months, and by ramping up marketing campaigns while maintaining a low CAC approach across all European countries, especially now with the Tradegate launch. We'll kick off a major European campaign in support of that growth through the second half. Even with all these heavy growth investments, we still managed to raise profitability. I think that's something we should all bear in mind together. We are, without question, a growth company. If we sat back and said, "Okay, hey, we don't want to spend any more of that big marketing," saving EUR 17 million on marketing would produce a EUR 0.70 EPS increase, which is absurd, because we're a growth case, not a value case. That's why, once again, we won't keep focusing on quarter-by-quarter financials. We have a very clear long-term vision. That long-term vision is driven by customer growth and customer activity, both based on very moderate and very reasonable expectations.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSo in certain quarters, marketing spend will be higher, and in others, it will be lower. Again, the long-term vision for the EBITDA margin is 50% plus at the shorter end. At the longer end, the expectation is a 60% plus EBITDA margin. Last but not least, between EBITDA and EBT, we also had rising depreciation and amortization. This comes from, again, one-off write-offs on intangibles we no longer use, along with other adjustments we adjusted through the P&L, totaling EUR 2.5 million, which sit in the D&A and which we will not see going forward anymore. As such, the D&A increased. Obviously, it went up because we had the first-time application of amortization on identified intangibles from the flatexDEGIRO Purchase Price Allocation. That took effect now for the first time for a full six months, and so it also had an impact on the P&L results. Regarding the LTI, the long-term incentive provisions are mainly what determines the EBITDA adjustment. The LTIP, which is based on a stock appreciation rights program, as you know, is based 50% on stock price development and 50% on the EPS guidance and EPS growth, the expected one that we apply in our valuation models.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThe increase in this line item clearly stems from the rise in the share price—from EUR 62 at year-end, which was used to value the model, up to EUR 117 as of June 30th or June 29th. That share price increase is reflected in the higher provisions, obviously, and also in the revised consensus for 2023, when the plan begins to become exercisable. Because the plan depends 50% on EPS growth, you can see that we hold provisions and build the model on a fairly high EPS expectation, since we are convinced that we are heading in exactly that direction with respect to EPS. Overall, approximately two-third of the provisions have already been built on the fair value as of June 30th, as I said, on a share price of roughly EUR 117 and consensus EPS for 2023 of more than EUR 6. We remain highly convinced that we will reach our full year guidance. If we simply continued linearly as we did in the 1st half, we would end up, with respect to number of clients, at the upper top of the guidance even, and we are very convinced that we will carry on the strong growth that will ensure we meet both the guidance on number of clients and the guidance on number of transactions.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThere's really no justification we can see for altering that. In fact, it's the reverse, because — as I mentioned at the outset — Q2 is the softest quarter, if we assume growth in Q3 and Q4 on a quarter-by-quarter basis. Our conviction is strong, very strong, that we'll keep performing very successfully through the next half year and also hit all management guidances. As I noted, the P&L always comes down to which one-offs we had, what we adjusted for, what we left unadjusted, and what we absorbed through the P&L. To us, one of the key figures is that within half a year we produced over EUR 80 million in operating cash flow — 2x what we achieved in the first half of 2020. Our net cash position rose to EUR 180 million. I think plenty of people also overlook this: we carry no operational debt. We have no debts, no long-term debts, and no liabilities to banks stemming from operational debt — sorry, from non-operational debt. We're also strongly convinced we'll sustain this operating cash flow growth over the coming years and coming half years. Once more, on this point, doubling it would leave us at roughly EUR 170 million.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe generated EUR 170 million of operating cash flow in a single year. Multiply that by five — assuming zero growth at all — and across the following five years you'd accumulate roughly EUR 850 million, EUR 900 million in operating cash flow. Our ambition for the coming five years is something you know very clearly, and with the growth we anticipate, once again, we feel highly convicted about hitting the accumulated operating cash flow target we set for five years of EUR 1.5 billion plus. Seeing that this is heading absolutely in the right direction gives us high confidence in the steps we entered during the last quarters. Important milestones — we touched on that. The early and late trading, the introduction and rollout of the European ETP partnerships, and new marketing campaigns with DEGIRO and flatex. These things will kick in now in Q3 and will generate, obviously, also profitability and growth in the second half and going forward. Keep in mind that we are starting now in the second half with two major synergies. The order flow synergy, from which we expect a high profitability contribution, will only kick in in Q3.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveIt ended up taking somewhat more time. That was because of the DEGIRO merger, which we preferred to complete ahead of implementation. Tradegate is going live four weeks behind schedule. The ETP partnerships will also begin somewhat later than planned. Both are due to launch very shortly and will begin adding extra profitability as well as further growth. That is one more reason we remain entirely certain Q2 was more of an exception than a rule. In H2, so during the second half, more toward Q4, we will launch the next trading app, flatexNext 3.0. As we have said, being market leader and an online broker, we clearly carry not just the responsibility but likewise the task of educating ever more people across Europe. So we will have a very high-class documentary spanning Europe that we will also use, naturally, for marketing purposes to prepare people, to give them a clearer grasp of the financial markets and financial investment, and to educate less experienced potential customers. We discussed Tradegate, the early and late trading. You can see what effect it may have. That is what appears here, the share of early and late trading and flatex equity trades.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveLooking at just the flatex brand, since we haven't had this with DEGIRO before. You can see what volume of trades, particularly during late trading and early trading, we might expect going forward. Applied across more than 1 point-ish million DEGIRO clients, that gives us quite a strong upside potential on the transaction base, which we expect to kick in starting in the second half and then swing to a full year as of 2022. The marketing push has also been talked about. Starting now, with the football season again from mid-August, featuring Borussia Mönchengladbach and shoots and commercial ads, et cetera. We anticipate a growing client count here relative to Q2, along with increasing interaction between clients and broker, meaning higher trades. Overall, once again, we feel very, very comfortable about the coming quarters, so that we can keep going with the product as well. FlatexNext 3.0, moving from push to pull, should fit exactly into this marketing campaign and marketing strategy of winning more and clients, of educating more and more clients. We know our platform up to now is very robust, very stable, very good. We still see potential to lower the complexity of these apps, and to let clients go much faster, much more directly into long-term savings and long-term investments.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAlongside the zero fee ETF schemes and Tradegate, we are definitely headed in the right direction. The High Class documentary — the real-life investing stories brought to you by DEGIRO — is set to launch at the close of Q3, or the start of Q4. As I mentioned, it will be shown across Europe, primarily in our growth markets and the underdeveloped G7. We'll run a 360 campaign in every major country, to keep helping us secure market leadership after having achieved it in France, and to carry on with Spain, Portugal, and Italy. The 2026 outlook remains entirely unchanged. 7 to 8 million customers, 250 to 350 million transactions. Revenue reaching up to EUR 1.5 billion, plus accumulated operating cash flow exceeding EUR 1.5 billion, with adjusted EBITDA margins of 60%+. Once again, there's no change there. The short-term guidance for this year is also unchanged: 2 to 2.2 million clients at 90 to 110 million transactions. That covers my part, walking you through the latest results. I'd like to use the coming 30 minutes for questions and perhaps to dig deeper into one question or another.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, we’re going to start the question-and-answer portion at this point. Should you wish to ask our speaker something, dial zero and one on your phone’s keypad right now to join the queue. After your name is called, you’ll be able to pose your question. Should it turn out that your question was already answered before your opportunity to speak arrives, you may dial zero and two in order to withdraw it. In the event that speaker equipment is in use on your end today, kindly pick up the handset prior to connecting. Please hold for a moment while we get to our first question. Our first question has come in. It is from Roberta Luca at Goldman Sachs. Your line is open now.
Roberta Luca
analystHello there, good morning. Thanks for the presentation. I’ve got a couple of questions. The first one concerns a figure you don’t disclose — revenue per transaction. Could you give us some overview of how that figure is trending? If we work the numbers backwards from what you reported today, it comes in under the EUR 4 target. We’d like to understand how it’s progressing and when you believe you can get to that level. My second question: I take your point that the second quarter is a slower quarter each year. Can you give us some sense of your expectations? First, historically, how large that gap has been on a quarterly basis, and whether this second quarter differs significantly from prior years, given, I suppose, the high volatility in the first quarter. Sort of a bit of a reiteration of what you expect for the second quarter — sorry, the third quarter, obviously with the summer months — and whether you anticipate any further slowdown there. Thank you.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThanks, Roberta. On the first point, revenue per transaction — yes, we came in a bit under that, at roughly EUR 3.50 to EUR 3.60 per trade, I believe. Broadly speaking, we're looking for as much as EUR 4 per trade over the long term. That's our long-term view. Of course, some products haven't been introduced yet that would help lift those per-trade revenues. Obviously, first and foremost, take Tradegate trades as an example. Clients will be able to get Tradegate trades at a flat price of EUR 3.90. That, above all, will feed into the growth. On top of that, as you're aware, we operate a highly successful ETP partnership across Europe. That same partnership is one we'll also put in place with DEGIRO, and it will likewise raise revenue per trade, bringing existing and future models together with our product partners. We'll continue to target an average of EUR 4 per trade. Also, something else to bear in mind: in certain European countries, we compete in markets with extremely low fees, and that likewise supports our growth and the pace of it. As we've consistently said, that doesn't mean those fees will stay at this level indefinitely.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveTurning to growth now. We constantly need to strike a balance between expanding and being profitable, and we're absolutely 100% pleased and extremely satisfied with where that balance sits today. At the same time, we're able to raise both as our client count grows. That's the primary short-term priority within our Vision. As for the later part of that Vision, things could shift toward somewhat less growth and more profitability. On the second quarter, I'm not certain I fully caught your question 100%, but it was somewhat about placing Q2 2021 in a historical context. How much better or worse did it look relative to other quarters? Let me frame it this way. In my view, the mistaken assumption would be to measure it against Q1 2021, since Q1 2021 wasn't a typical quarter, wasn't a typical Q1. We had, in itself, a very strong Q1 and this year had a far stronger Q1. Then comes Q2, which is very average. In terms of trading activity, for us it was absolutely consistent with what we'd seen before and what we'd experienced previously.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveBear in mind, Q2 was, in my view, just about as strong as Q2 2020, when COVID was in full swing and everybody kept telling us, "Oh, you're only landing all these clients because of COVID." We still managed to match that powerful quarter we posted back in 2020. Once again, Q1 was very strong for us. Q2 has been a perfectly decent, average quarter. Since Q1 came in so high, it looks as though Q2 fell apart. Q2 landed completely in line with the historical data, the historical evidence, and the historical expectations we always hold. I want to be very clear about this: we are absolutely not taken aback by what happened in Q2. It was exactly what we expected for Q2. In fact, we came in slightly above our expectations for Q2. As for Q3 and Q4, let me be very clear here as well. Q3 and Q4 don't matter to me. What matters to me is next year, the year after, and the year after that. We intend to grow. We're a growth story, and we will grow. If people want to challenge that quarter by quarter, I'm more than happy to take it on. We aren't sitting around thinking about Q3 or whether this happens to be the summer break, to be fair.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveOur long-term vision is to win 6, 7, 8 million clients over the next five years, and we see ourselves perfectly on track to reach that goal. Again, our guidance for this year was 2 million clients. We're already at 1.75, so there are 250,000 clients that we have to win in six months, which is super absurd for us. Again, we will not end up in this quarter by quarter game because we have the longer term vision in front of us. Yes, I expect Q3 to become, as I said earlier, better than Q2, and I expect that Q4, most probably, if everything goes right in the markets and markets don't go totally crazy, will outperform Q3. This is what we know from historical data and statistical analysis and expectations. Would I put my hand for this on fire? No, I would not because markets are totally going wild every now and then. Again, nothing that surprises us as of now. We were rather surprised by a very good Q1, to be fair, than by an average Q2.
Roberta Luca
analystAll right, thanks.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveNo problem at all.
Operator
operatorWe'll take our next question from Marius Fuhrberg at Warburg Research. Your line is open as well.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystHi, Mo. I have a couple of questions. First, you keep emphasizing the Q3 situation, even though — as you noted — you're not focused on Q3 and Q4. Could you still give us some sense of how Q3 has begun so far? Second, the adjustments you made seemed quite significant — more than EUR 54 million, I believe. Clearly, most of that stems from the stock-based incentive program, which is outside your control. My question is: do you plan to put another stock-based compensation program in place over the next two to three years? Or do you wait, given that the current stock-based incentive program pays out over three to four years?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveStarting with what you asked about Q3: I can't provide any update on how Q3 has begun, and the reason again is that we're only four weeks into 12, and I don't want to kick off this monthly-update game about how a quarter went — sorry, or even how a month went. The next data release we'll do is the quarterly one. Again, it will be good and it will be strong — hopefully in line with what we expect. If we broke it down to July alone, it's what we expected. Up till now, no surprises at all for us. On the adjustments: yes, indeed, it is a significant adjustment. No, as of today, we don't plan any new long-term incentive plans. The plan has not fully distributed out. There are still shares that we can give out to employees, although the vast majority has been given out, so we don't expect any plans as of now for the next, I would say two, three years.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystAlright, thanks. One more follow-up, if I can. The margin in Q2 came in fairly low, though I assume that reflects the weaker top line. Would it be right to say you're expecting EBITDA margins to be significantly better across Q3 and Q4?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveRemember that Q2 was definitely the quarter in which we completed our merger. Everything I mentioned — the digestion we went through during Q2 via the P&L — won't appear anymore in Q3.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorCharlie Mayne from Goldman Sachs has the next question. Your line is open now.
Charlie Mayne
analystGood morning, Mo. I appreciate you giving me the chance to ask a question.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveHey there, Charlie.
Charlie Mayne
analystI just have one question about the rationale behind Vision 2026. My understanding is that you initially stated the assumption was 3,000 additional clients per calendar day. Now you're targeting 2,000 to 2,500 per calendar day for the full year 2021. Could you just help us understand what accounts for the gap between those two figures? Thanks.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveCharlie here — that figure of 3,000 clients per day relates to the long-term vision. The pace we’re seeing will certainly rise as well over the coming years. I doubt we’ll add on a daily average this year at the rate we will in three years. My belief is that three years from now, our daily growth will be quicker than it is currently. Once more, that guidance came at the start of, or during, the first half, and it has no connection to our long-term growth. What we’ve consistently stated is that to reach Vision 2026, we need average growth of 3,000 clients per day. What the first half has shown us is that we’ve actually already satisfied that requirement now — not in 2, not in 3, not in 4 years. As client numbers rise, our growth rate will rise too. I’m 100% certain of this, because awareness is greater and you have stronger structural targeting of markets. Once we turn market leader in additional countries, awareness goes up, and so on and so forth. For this year, we aren’t targeting 2,000 clients, or 2,200, or 2,500. We simply have the clear guidance, and that would imply saying that to hit that guidance, we need, whatever, 250,000 clients in give or take 100, 120 days.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveTo hit our guidance, we’d need at least 2,000 clients on average each day across the next six months. Once again, we feel very, very strongly that we will get there.
Charlie Mayne
analystAlright, thanks.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveNo problem at all.
Operator
operatorWe move on to Christoph Greulich from Berenberg for the following question. Your line is open now.
Christoph Greulich
analystMorning to you, Mo.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveHello, everyone.
Christoph Greulich
analystThanks a lot for taking my questions. I have a couple of questions from my side, if I may. I'd like to start by coming back to the stock appreciation rights plan. Could you let us know what the total fair value is as of June? Based on your current numbers, how large will the charge be in the H2 P&L?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSorry, what's the size of that charge?
Christoph Greulich
analystRegarding the P&L during the year's second half, and what does total fair value come to at the close of H1?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThe total fair value—if I recall correctly—came in at a preliminary EUR 105 million. That's the plan's overall fair value, calculated using a stock price of EUR 180 and EPS within the consensus range somewhere. On that basis, EUR 64 million to EUR 65 million has been provisioned. Provisioning now covers two-thirds of the plan. Should things keep going the way they are—meaning the share price ends the year at the same level with no change in consensus—I'd expect roughly 20% to be provisioned across the second half. That's another EUR 20 million, give or take.
Christoph Greulich
analystSo this also means that if the share price ends up below where it stood at the end of June, or if EPS declines, that too would translate into a lower fair value.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveSure, definitely. It's a really simple and clear option plan, tied to the EPS and the share price. Should the share price drop relative to June 30th on the 31st of December, that would mean we end up with smaller provisions — or perhaps even release provisions once more.
Christoph Greulich
analystAll right, that's clear. On the customer growth side, looking at the drop from Q1 to Q2, I was just wondering whether any regions stood out positively. In other words, are there any countries where customer growth actually sped up during the second quarter?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveRelative to what, exactly? Relative to Q1?
Christoph Greulich
analystThat's right, yes.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThat's a good question. Let me pull that up. France is a place where we performed quite strongly — we've now taken the top spot in the market there by count of new clients as well, not just in trade. Things are moving along nicely for us there. We'll check on it, and Achim may follow up with some details. That said, we won't be breaking out numbers country by country.
Christoph Greulich
analystThat's clear. Page four shows the customer growth delta versus some of your main peers. I was just wondering why it fluctuated so much — seasonal patterns should be the same for all the players in the market. Do you see any clear reasons why the delta has been so big, let's say around Q4 last year and Q1 this year, compared to where it stood at the end of Q2?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveThat is a good question, and unfortunately, looking at the figures, I cannot answer it. What we observe is that the amplitude is very much dependent on how strong the quarter itself is, right? Or the month itself. The stronger that month is, the more we outperform our peers. Most probably this has to do with the European footprint: when we are strong in a given month, per se, if markets turn positive in a certain month with respect to growth, to customer growth, we manage to outgrow our peers. In normal months and in weaker months, our development is rather relatively stable.
Christoph Greulich
analystThat makes sense. On the EBITDA margin: we posted 54% in Q1, and if my memory serves me, 50% was sort of taken as the new floor, with the path heading toward 60%. Then in Q2 we dropped back under the 40% mark. So I'm curious — how should we view the margin floor going forward, and what sort of trend are you seeing for the full year?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveNothing has changed—absolutely nothing. We'll stick with the same figures we gave last Friday, before today's numbers came out. There's been no shift whatsoever in our expectations, since Q2 came in exactly as we anticipated. Again, I'm basically repeating myself here. When my expectations are met so precisely, there's simply no cause to revise what I expect going forward. The projections for the half year, and particularly Q2, lined up almost perfectly with what we had guided internally. That's once more why we see no justification for tweaking our full-year guidance or our full-year expectation. We'll keep holding the view that in 2021 we'll land somewhere in the high 40s, around 50%, for sure. And that over the coming years, we'll target 60% step by step. Again, given certain one-off effects we absorbed through the P&L in H1 2021, particularly in Q2 2021—to be fair, since we didn't have these figures in Q1—this appears lower than what others may have anticipated. But aware of these costs, aware of these structural expenses that occurred in Q2, it's fully consistent with our full-year expectation as well.
Christoph Greulich
analystAll right, just so we can model this, can you tell us roughly how large the D&A charge was in H1 and what portion of it came from acquisitions?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWhich charge was that? My apologies.
Christoph Greulich
analystRegarding that D&A line — the depreciation and amortization item.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe haven’t made that public yet, since the annual report hasn’t been released. Let’s hold off until that report comes out, because again this involves a couple of matters tied to intangible asset depreciation and amortization following the Purchase Price Allocation for DEGIRO. I’d rather not provide any numbers right now that could turn out different in four weeks. They shouldn’t. But overall, the one-off within D&A was roughly EUR 2.5 million.
Christoph Greulich
analystYou also said every synergy has now been fully put in place. In terms of extra cost savings during the second half that weren't yet present in the first half, what does that mean?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe’ve moved another step forward. With IT, I’ve consistently described this as a process. It isn’t something that will be finished today or tomorrow. Once Tradegate is introduced and ETP is implemented soon, along with product partnerships, we think we’ll then have 85%-90% of the synergies in place. On the cost side, that means we’ll keep releasing the low-hanging fruit—or harvesting it. Naturally, this begins with admin costs. It also relates to personnel costs. We’ve had many changes in personnel costs. That’s also why we adjusted for this one-off cost tied to the merger, the management change, and the change at the second level of people as well. You’re aware of this. Very often it ends up involving costs—releasing contracts and releasing responsibility. This has been done for the vast majority. We don’t expect this anymore in the second half either. It definitely won’t be worse than in the first half. The customer.
Christoph Greulich
analystOne final question from me. You said development work on the upcoming trading apps will begin in this year's second half. What development costs should we anticipate for those?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveTo be fair, as of today, I don't have a value.
Christoph Greulich
analystCould you give us a rough figure — what sort of range are we talking about?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe weren't discussing an amount in the double-digit millions — definitely not.
Christoph Greulich
analystAlright, that's everything I had. Thanks very much for the responses.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveHappy to take your questions.
Operator
operatorFrederik Jarchow from Hauck & Aufhäuser is up next with a question. Your line is open now.
Frederik Jarchow
analystHello, Mo, and thanks for the question. I have just one thing I'd like to ask, and it also concerns the number of trades in Q2. If we compare year-on-year, you were flat — flatexDEGIRO was flat — whereas a peer like Avanza, for instance, posted a year-on-year gain of 46%, even though you clearly outgrow Avanza when it comes to new customers. Could you perhaps explain this weakness relative to the peers? Thank you.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveHonestly, I can’t really give you a proper answer on that, since I haven’t dug deep enough into Avanza to understand why the comparison of their trade count with last Q2 came out better or worse. You might also frame it as Avanza having had a weaker Q2 than flatexDEGIRO, which would mean they raised their trade count relative to Q2 while ours stayed flat. Honestly, I have no idea. For our part, though, this was what we expected. Based on our data and the rate we anticipated, this is what we projected for ourselves, and we hit it. Perhaps it relates to Avanza having steadier trading activity thanks to a large number of savings profiles that we don’t have in that situation, and certainly not in Europe, but also because as of today we don’t focus on that kind of investment either, and instead aim to grow as a broker across all of Europe. That might explain why they retain a higher level of trades, or why Q2 2020 was weaker for Avanza than it was for everyone else.
Frederik Jarchow
analystMm-hmm. Yeah, that tracks. Thanks.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveNo problem at all.
Operator
operatorMoving on to the next question, which comes from Benjamin Kohnke at KBW. Your line is open now.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystMorning, Mo. This is KBW, actually. Yeah, thanks for taking my questions. Well, a few small items, please. The first one has to do with your credit book. I know you probably aren't willing to provide any detailed numbers, but maybe just some high-level comments on how that developed, let's say, both on the retail side and also perhaps the non-brokerage loan book. Any kinds of anomalies that we should factor in here, or just a sort of normal development? Along those lines, just with regard to your IT segment, any kinds of things we should consider there, or just a very normal development as well?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveOn IT services, frankly, it isn't adding anything to any P&L line anymore. It's of minor importance. Nothing unusual took place. As for the credit book, we're continuing with our strategy, which is super successful. There are no anomalies whatsoever. We've had no significant write-offs on any of our structural credit books. Openings are coming back on schedule. We succeeded in growing the credit book. You'll also notice this in the detailed figures within the reported accounts — we've raised the interest income on the credit book, obviously also because of consolidating the DEGIRO margin book. Yeah, as the number of clients grows, that also leads to more clients using margin loans. Overall, we're absolutely pleased with how the credit book has developed.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystOkay, thanks. Just a fast follow-up question. Can you confirm what was mentioned on the strategy day — that you remain on track to roll out a crypto offering sometime during the second half of this year?
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveWe didn't claim we're going to launch it. What we said is that right now we're in a deep-dive due diligence process to implement cryptocurrencies. We've pointed out a few times that custody of cryptocurrencies has been the biggest problem. As of today, we haven't found any solution that gives us the confidence — the full confidence — to offer cryptos to our clients. That could shift from one month to the next, since all of us know the momentum in cryptos is extremely high. Things shift weekly, things shift monthly. Should we find a solid solution, a proper one that places no risk on us as a company when it comes to custody of client assets, we'd be glad to launch it. Technically and commercially, everything is ready. The sole remaining item is that we must identify the regulatory solution for custody of our clients' cryptos.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystOkay, so thanks. And just to flip that around — the guidance you gave for 2021, both on the customer side and on the trade side, doesn't really include.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveNo.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystKind of crypto.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveNo, not at all. Cryptocurrency was never part of the guidance we provided. When we issued that guidance, we didn't talk about any crypto at all.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystThanks, Mo.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveHappy to have you with us.
Operator
operatorJust a quick reminder — if you'd like to ask a question, hit zero and then one. That's all the questions we have. I'll turn it back over to Mr. Chahrour.
Muhamad Chahrour
executiveAlright, thanks once more for being on this call. Appreciate your questions. I hope what we shared gave you a fuller picture of the results. We're looking ahead to the coming months and quarters just as much as you are. So, let me wrap up this call with a few words. We're genuinely pleased and satisfied with what our people have done and with what we achieved in H1. Once again, that's a record first half in the company's history. We're very confident about hitting all our guidance and expectations, both near term and further out. Looking forward to talking with you soon and seeing you soon. Take good care of yourselves, have a great week, and thank you for being on the call.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.