flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 1, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Frank Niehage
executiveGood morning, everyone, and a warm welcome to our preliminary earnings call 2021. Today I'm very proud to show you very impressive KPIs. Revenues weren't just up 60% last year — both EBITDA and client growth rose 55%. The standout KPI last year was the increase in revenues per trade, especially in Q4, which amounted to EUR 5.22. Why is that so important to highlight? I think it proves that DEGIRO goes zero. Our very massive initiative, which we started last quarter last year, proved to be right. For those of you who might not recall exactly what we did, we lowered the fee in 18 markets to zero, and we increased at the same time the FX margin by 15%, and that proves now that profitability per trade is gonna increase. I don't wanna talk too much about the KPIs because I leave this to Mo, and he will show you much more details in the following presentation. Today we try to increase a bit the possible transparency. However, I wanna take the opportunity to talk about two very important strategic projects. Before I do that, please allow me to just mention the situation and the impact of the war in Ukraine to our company.
Frank Niehage
executiveTo start with, our workforce includes people of 40 different nationalities, and of course, individuals from Ukraine. We're really pleased that only a small number of Ukrainians connected to us have been affected in an indirect way. No member of our staff has been directly affected. Still, given their families and roots in Ukraine, we've launched a number of initiatives to assist our employees. We've made financial donations. We've allocated a budget to the employee committee that's helping at the border. We're trying to back refugees and provide shelter and assistance wherever we can. It goes without saying that we condemn this war and, of course, hope it ends as soon as possible. On the business side, we're fortunate that our operations haven't been seriously affected. Why is that? We have very few Russian customers. There are only a very small number of trades and products, relatively speaking. Complying with the sanctions and carrying them out, obviously, doesn't have a serious effect on our business. That's the good news. But as you all know, the war creates volatility, and volatility, of course, works in favor of our business model. Even so, we hope this war concludes as soon as possible. So far, there's been no negative impact on our business.
Frank Niehage
executiveOnce more, we will be watching that situation carefully, and our hope is that it wraps up before long. Let me now turn for a moment to the strategic projects that matter a great deal. As you'd expect, our focus last year was on the DEGIRO merger, and the positive news is that 80% of the low-hanging fruits have already been harvested. That said, 20% remains, and that will occupy us over the coming couple of quarters within this year, and we consider that appropriate. At the same time, we are also progressing on two fresh strategic projects. The first is robo-advice, and the second is cryptocurrency. In this area, there is always a make-or-buy debate. Clearly, our emphasis is on forming partnerships so that we don't lose time to market, can speed things up, and ensure we don't raise the risk level. I have strong confidence that we will release news on those two projects during the next quarter. Please keep your fingers crossed that all goes well, and that we can share further details with you. Beyond organic growth and the 20% of remaining low-hanging fruits related to the DEGIRO merger, robo-advice and cryptocurrencies are the two new projects. That's all from my side for now. I'm happy to hand things over to Mo.
Frank Niehage
executiveHe's going to switch gears and take you through a really thorough, detailed, and transparent presentation. So please enjoy it. Mo, over to you.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThanks, Frank, and good morning to all of you. It's great to have everyone joining this conference call about our preliminary results for 2021. Yes, your feedback has been taken seriously. At the outset, the main thing I want to emphasize is that we have now tried to add more transparency around a great many KPIs. I believe some of you will be quite pleased to read additional detail on certain items, and that begins as of now. I also think this reflects what I and we have consistently promised you — that we will keep working on these matters, and that it takes a while, particularly following the reorganization and transformation tied to the DEGIRO merger. My suggestion is that we jump into the KPIs, into the numbers and into the slides so we can provide the explanation for 2021 here. It's very important to stress that 2021 was a difficult year, mainly because of COVID during the first 12 months — or really the entire year. Even though there was occasionally some light at the end of the tunnel, it very quickly turned back into lockdowns and further problems. Still, despite a year of transformation, we succeeded in outperforming on all key metrics. Customer accounts growth has been published, and transaction growth has been published as well.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThe metric we're publishing today that matters is assets under custody, which rose nearly 38% to EUR 44 billion. Two factors clearly drove that. First, customer growth itself brought in and added more assets under custody. Second, we also observed that throughout 2021, along with the pickup in trading, additional money inflow was recorded during the year. Higher trading activity and more assets under custody also translate into greater revenues for 2021. Total revenues came in at EUR 417.6 million, up 60% versus 2021. I think we need to keep in mind that 2020 was already a year of high volatility and a very profitable one for us. We're extremely grateful and proud of the effort our colleagues put into the business throughout 2021 to take the next step and lift our revenues by 60%. Marketing expenses came in at EUR 46.1 million. I noted on the call when we published the commercial KPIs that we had spent over EUR 45 million in 2021, and the final figure was EUR 46.1 million.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThe marketing increase is clearly driven by client growth—by growth in customer accounts. That's one aspect of the marketing story. The other aspect is—and this effect mainly kicked in during Q4 2021—the costs we incurred producing the documentary that we broadcast across Europe with Discovery and that we are now also streaming through discovery+. It has been a very, very significant project for us, and we will also benefit from this documentary's footage in all future marketing campaigns. Altogether, the documentary costs plus the ad space we booked primarily in December 2021, also for Q1 2022, came to EUR 5 million. There is a special effect that kicked in during Q4, so in the second half of the year, regarding marketing expenses. Still, if you were to take that entire EUR 46.1 million and divide it by the customer account growth, which was 750,000 clients gross, you will see that we succeeded in keeping client acquisition cost at an average of slightly above EUR 60. As we have always stated, the long-term benchmark is EUR 50 ±20%, depending on how we spend the money and where we spend it.
Mo Chahrour
executiveAnother thing to keep in mind regarding marketing expenses is that, during the second half, we spent more on gaining clients in Germany and Austria under the flatex brand than we did in the first half. In the first half, flatex growth accounted for 14.8% of total growth, while in the second half that figure reached 22%. Bringing in more clients in Germany and Austria also entails higher costs for acquiring those clients. You're all aware that these two markets are comparatively pricey versus every other European market, yet at the same time they consistently deliver the highest ARPU. Greater investment spending in Q4 for Germany and Austria — Q3, Q4 — which ought to translate into higher ARPU down the road as well. Taken together, this produces Adjusted EBITDA pre-marketing of EUR 200 million-EUR 223 million, and Adjusted EBITDA of slightly EUR 177 million, both of which are notable figures, with Adjusted EBITDA pre-marketing rising by more than 60%. Overall, we can say that 2023 was a highly successful year, notwithstanding the transformations we went through, given the DEGIRO merger. We succeeded in getting our commercial side right and our financials right. Once again, we kept our profitable growth trajectory going, which fills us with real pride, and we are truly grateful to every one of our employees who gave so much during difficult times — a great deal of effort and a great deal of support, given the circumstances.
Mo Chahrour
executiveTurning to growth — the significant growth — I think one KPI that surprised us too, once all our competitors had reported their numbers. I think it's also worth flagging these points. With flatexDEGIRO, we grew faster than numbers three, four, five, and six in Europe combined. Quite often we ourselves don't truly grasp the speed and the velocity we're putting into all our growth. That's a fabulous outcome from the measures implemented and the products and projects implemented over the last 1.5 years that we've owned DEGIRO. It shows this growth path is the right one to continue on. We look forward to being not only Europe's largest broker, but also to remaining the fastest growing broker in Europe. One new slide that most of you haven't seen in this form shows that, for the first time, we've split up our super-capitalized business and the margin generation on our assets. Our total assets under custody, which at year-end, as I said, came to almost EUR 44 billion, are divided into two parts. 93% of the assets are securities, amounting to EUR 41 billion, and 7%, EUR 2.8 billion, are deposits.
Mo Chahrour
executiveWe introduced this into a context for the first time to demonstrate what margin generation looks like on both of these assets under custody. In commission, we succeeded in producing EUR 340 million of commission income, equivalent to 96 basis points on each individual euro held in securities. The 7% deposit — the EUR 2.8 billion — breaks down into two components. Of that, EUR 1.5 billion sits in a liquidity portfolio, held primarily via the ECB and Deutsche Bundesbank. No need for me to explain what that produces. It creates enormous future potential for us. Should interest rates rise going forward, should we witness a 100 basis point upward shift in ECB rates, that would translate into EUR 15 million of additional EBT. That gives you a solid sense of the elasticity here today. Yeah, a liquidity portfolio yielding more or less zero, or even negative. EUR 1.3 billion is placed in a credit portfolio, the vast majority of which is literally in margin lending products provided to our clients. We keep upholding a highly conservative stance regarding margin lending. The average loan-to-value stands at roughly 33%-34%. We extend a maximum of 60% against blue chip stocks. Very restricted and heavily collateralized.
Mo Chahrour
executiveEarning 300 to 500 basis points on this portfolio hinges on which country and which brands. 16% sits in secured — almost fully secured — alternative investments yielding 200 to 300 basis points, and that adds up to interest income of EUR 59 million, or 242 basis points on our deposits. To give you a closer look, it's exactly what I've now told you. Again, shown a bit in a clear split. Between 2020 and 2021, you see that the credit portfolio beautifully increased, and mainly the margin loans that increased. Actually, the secured alternative investments decreased. This is a clear strategy by the management that we have entered last year and the second half to say we will decrease the so-called by-product of investments and will focus mainly on the margin loans. Having this by-product, mainly in fully secured real estate assets. That is the strategy going forward. The key focus is to continue to grow the margin loan product, which is a beautiful product, highly collateralized. If you look into the credit losses, you will see why we love this product so much. In 2021, the total losses were at 7 basis points. So EUR 1 million of credit losses generating EUR 60 million of interest income.
Mo Chahrour
executiveWe've also put in a few efficiency metrics to show, once more, revenue broken out by income type, assets under custody split by product, and revenue margins for each product. Again, this is the more granular level, so you can see how successfully we've grown our revenues. Yes, that is completely clear. What we achieved was growth mainly in our business within the very asset-light area of commissions. Even on the interest side, which you can see here quite clearly, we grew interest income primarily through asset-light credits and loans, particularly margin loans, which require a far lower equity reserve build than classic mortgages, consumer loans, or any other type of high-solvency asset. That supports continued profitable growth with substantial margins, without needing millions and tons of millions in capital reserves. We also see that revenue margin by product rose very nicely across the last four years. There was a pickup, obviously, in 2020. That reflects the fact that growth didn't kick in as much as it did in 2021, while revenues stayed relatively high given the elevated volatility in 2020. As you'll recall, that year holds the record in our history for the highest trading activity we've ever had.
Mo Chahrour
executiveSo, when I talk about trading activity, as you're aware, it contributes to long-term growth but isn't the deciding factor. And once more, we're trying to bring some clarity to the conversation we keep having over and over regarding our expectations for where trading activity will land. Naturally, nobody can truly predict what trading activity we'll see across the coming five years, because that KPI is tightly tied to macroeconomic developments — be it the geopolitical situation, the interest-rate situation, or the inflation situation. I'd like to be very explicit about this. We expect, and we benchmark, and we forecast a highly conservative level of trading activity from our client base. That orange line you're looking at represents 40 trades per customer account per year. That's the assumption behind our planning. Under our Vision 2026, the figure actually points to trading activity even at the low end of under 35 trades. The blue area is what I'd call windfall profits. That's the hidden reserve our business model produces when volatility runs above expectations. What comes through very clearly here is that, with the high volatility in 2020 and 2021, we also observed a shift upward beyond our benchmark curve.
Mo Chahrour
executiveRegarding 2022, we pretty much take it as a given that it will exceed that. Clearly, the present market conditions and the surrounding situation also add to volatility as well as trading activity. Revenue per trade — I recall when we held that call together during the first half, and we talked at length about revenue per trade and the decline in revenue per trade at that point. The cause behind that decline is something we attempted to make clear across numerous meetings and numerous calls. It was tied heavily, obviously, to how you acquire clients. If you recall correctly, one main factor was that in Germany we provided new clients in Germany and Austria — sorry — for their initial six months, zero commission trading. I began with this when I explained the marketing expenses. Clients in Germany and Austria, yes, cost more and are pricier to acquire, yet they also produce higher ARPUs. When you let those clients trade at no cost, you are clearly handing over an enormous amount of revenues and particularly on the trade. What we have presented here is beautiful growth and steady growth across the last four quarters. The benchmark has always been, for us, in the Vision 2026, and we restated that repeatedly: four euros.
Mo Chahrour
executiveWhen we examine the previous 4 quarters, we clearly exceeded the target we had set ourselves at that time of EUR 4, climbing substantially to EUR 5.22 in Q4 2021. The primary driver is clearly that every client we brought on board in Q4 2020, Q1 2021, and Q2 2021 began paying for trades in Q4. Since flatex, the flatex brand, typically produces larger revenues per trade than the zero brand, this naturally feeds through into the average revenue per trade for the entire group. What further upside do we see? Frank mentioned this. The zero offering from DEGIRO that we launched only in December 2021 has not yet fully flowed through into FY 2022. It will, however, affect Q1 revenues per trade. Secondly, the ETP partnerships we brought in only in December likewise had no opportunity in 2021 to contribute, but they will contribute in 2022. We launched early and late trading only in August 2021. It already made an impact in Q4 2021, which is evident not just in these headline figures but also, if you dig into the details, in how it lifted and bolstered revenue per trade, and it will keep bolstering revenue per trade as well.
Mo Chahrour
executiveTo put it briefly, we're assuming revenue per trade over the medium term stays around the levels we saw in the last two quarters, Q3 and Q4, so to speak. Depending on how successful DEGIRO goes zero turns out to be — and we think that success will be very clear and very significant — we may even see a pickup in revenue per trade here or there. All of this growth, along with the pickup in revenue per trade, is mainly explained and characterized by — and the success of this business is characterized by — its savers and investors, by its clients and client base. We've seen plenty of brokerage companies around the globe that began with a brokerage idea and ended up being whatever they are, whatever business they conduct. Our strategy and focus is clear: to be the place in Europe where savers and investors shape their own financial future and get access to classic capital markets. That's what you see here. AUC share by product: 92% of all our AUCs are cash products, stocks and ETFs. That's what we feel good with, and that's what our clients feel good with.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThat's what produces revenue that can be sustained in the business. If you examine revenue share for stocks, the AUC split, or AUC share, it's nearly equal to the revenue share. Also, 68% of our revenues come from equity cash transactions. 23% originate from ETPs. When you look at the other category, which covers items such as options, futures, CFDs — all of these things that have been or are under heavy scrutiny in recent quarters and years — they make up a smaller and smaller portion of our revenues, and our clients hold less and less of them. That's a very sustainable setup for our clients, for our savers and investors, which should also deliver very sustainable returns going forward. Yeah. Moving more into the quality of our customer base — and I think these are also slides that are, yeah, for most of you, or actually for all of you, rather new. Let's say we start with the cohort analysis that you know from our previous decks. What we see here is the revenues contributed by the different cohorts. We always had this big question, especially about the 2020 cohort. How sustainable is that cohort? Will this cohort not drop away because 2020 included so many clients that only jumped on because they had time, and they wanted to trade maybe around, but they will go away after a year or two?
Mo Chahrour
executiveI'm genuinely pleased that these figures have confirmed our confidence in our client base, in how we attract clients, and in the caliber of clients we bring in. The 2020 cohort added a great deal to 2021 revenues and demonstrates how durable the cohorts are that we've been winning over all the years gone by. We observed the same thing with the 2021 cohort, which made a solid contribution to 2021 revenues. Once again, here, let's watch how they contribute to 2022 revenues. What we're seeing is that our clients trade with us and generate revenues in a stable, significant, and sustainable way. Looking at client activity, we see that across the last three years, so even with a lot of clients won, activity rates have gone up. When we examine the share of medium active clients, meaning clients doing between 10 and 100 transactions, that share rose from 40% in 2018 to 45% in 2021. That shows once more that the clients we're winning are the right ones. The clients we bring in aren't doing just one trade or two trades or three trades per year and then quitting, or trying it out, or perhaps betting on the wrong horse, losing all their money, and jumping away.
Mo Chahrour
executiveNo. Although the proportion of low-trading clients from 1 to 10 has fallen by 5.4 percentage points, the medium active client base increased by 5 percentage points. In the end, that is also the focus going forward — to try to win and steal market share in continental Europe from incumbents, and to grow with clients who have a certain brokerage experience but are looking for the best possible product and pricing structure all over Europe. That is exactly the medium active customer base we are focusing on. When we look into the revenue generation across AUC cohorts, we've also been discussing here around especially smaller accounts, and the discussion always went into a point where we talked about that almost 1/2 of our clients has EUR 2,500 and less on their accounts. By the way, which is 10x more than what we see with most of the neo-brokers in the industry. The median there is usually around EUR 200-EUR 300. Our median is around EUR 2,000. What we see is, and more important than where the median is, that also the smaller accounts are contributing to the profitability of the flatexDEGIRO business. To give you a reading example, 7% of our customer base has EUR 200-EUR 500 AUCs in securities and cash.
Mo Chahrour
executiveFor this group with EUR 200 to EUR 500 sitting in their accounts, ARPU still comes out at EUR 44. When you set that against the average cost we incurred to acquire a client, the conclusion is that accounts holding under EUR 2,500 in assets essentially reach break-even one year out. That again demonstrates that even when we bring in clients with smaller accounts, we are steering them to trade through us and to hold their ETF saving schemes with us. Quite often that is exactly why ARPU ends up lower, since these clients are not especially active in trading through stock picking; instead they hold ETF saving schemes that cost them more or less next to nothing, or even nothing at all, which is what dilutes the ARPU. For us it matters to confirm that these clients do stay active with us. This chart is a new one we have added, and its purpose is to help you grasp which kinds of clients we are bringing on board versus how AUC splits across age brackets. What emerges is that as age rises, AUC development rises as well. Clients remain with us. Our churn rate is remarkably low, which accounts for the strong loyalty and stickiness our clients show over the course of many years.
Mo Chahrour
executiveWe observe that these clients' portfolio sizes are growing as the years go by, on one hand. On the other hand, what we're seeing is that the proportion of new customers in 2020 and 2021 closely, closely resembles the share of total customers within each age group. We aren't seeing any major deviation from the average here relative to the last two years, which were, let's say, very much, very much shaped and defined by a substantial influx of very young trading clients. Once again, that kind of movement hasn't appeared with us. Yes, we notice a slight tick and an uptick, a tilt toward a younger client base when you look at the peak of the yellow line, which sits at roughly 26 to 27 years, versus the average, where the peak lands more around 29 to 30 years. We see it shifted one, two years, but the peak wasn't at 18 years, the way it was for other competitors and peers in the market. Given that we will keep doing so going forward and have done so in the past, we've always concentrated on winning clients, as I mentioned, who possess a certain level of brokerage experience, and who are more or less accretive to our business from day one.
Mo Chahrour
executiveIf we examine how revenue is distributed by age, we observe the same pattern here: as clients grow older, their revenue contribution rises. That is precisely why we keep concentrating consistently on clients aged 25 to 65 rather than those 18 to 25, since revenue generation, as this chart literally shows, begins at roughly 30 years. At that point, ARPU averages EUR 100 per client. By contrast, at 18 years old you sit at approximately EUR 20. Simply moving your age focus by 10 years adds up to roughly EUR 80. That is the clear strategy going forward: to win clients who quickly become trading active and contribute revenue to our business. Looking now at the share of new customers, you can see that we manage to hold the curve at exactly the point where it should be, around 28 to 30 years, where the revenue contribution, the ARPU, has a payback period of literally under eight months. That covers growth. As for the overall portfolio for our client base, we have added some charts and some information to the customer activity.
Mo Chahrour
executiveOne key thing to point out is that activity — meaning the proportion of active customers over the past three years, from Q1 2019 through Q4 2021 — has risen steadily. Back in Q1 2019, approximately 35% of the client base was active in Q1 2019. By Q4 2021, that figure stood at roughly 40%. If you examine the percentage of customer accounts with at least one trade per annum — in other words, how active our client base was — you'll notice it rose by 10 percentage points from 2019 to 2021. That also shows you frequently encounter cases where clients aren't active at all in a given year but come back the following year. In short, activity ratios generally above 60% represent a huge benchmark, and once again it captures the quality of our asset base very well. The count of trading customer accounts has climbed from 250,000 to nearly 800,000 clients — literally. That's in absolute terms. Trades per active customer account each quarter is quite significant. Across the last three years it has consistently been about 20 trades per customer. Whenever clients are trading, whenever they're active, they typically make more than 80 trades per year.
Mo Chahrour
executiveWhen you look solely at active traders' activity rates rather than the entire base — and we layered the U.S. volume share on top of that as well — what stands out quite clearly is an upward shift, one that keeps climbing. Remove the Q1 2021 outlier — that was the GameStop meme stock craze from last year — and a pleasant growth curve emerges, now reaching 20% of overall volume flowing into U.S. volume. As you're aware, we've consistently guided to trading volume of approximately EUR 250 billion to EUR 300 billion. At 20%, that puts us at EUR 50+ billion. That's the figure we referenced at the time we disclosed DEGIRO goes zero, where we do and estimate EUR 50 billion in U.S. equity flow. I mentioned this earlier during my remarks. Keeping the right clients while losing the right clients. During 2021, churn was low on literally every metric. On customer accounts, we shed 2.5% of our client base. Regarding churned trades — which matters more than merely examining what client, or how many clients, you lose — the key is looking into which types of clients you are losing.
Mo Chahrour
executiveDuring the past 12 months, trades representing 1.3% of our total churned — that's just half the figure for accounts. What's happening is we're losing clients who trade very little. If you look at the annualized revenues on an LTM basis for those churned clients and trades, it comes to merely 1.1% of overall revenues. So to sum up again: the clients we lose are literally the right ones to lose — not the highly trading-active ones, and not those that are super profitable for our business, which could otherwise harm our structural development and growth. Yeah, that's literally what the information, data points, and KPIs show. Before we move to Q&A, I touched on our marketing efforts, particularly in Q4. The documentary has been a big success. We broadcasted it across Europe with great success. That success was so big that Discovery has decided to bring this documentary onto their discovery+ streaming service. For us, it's a very important project — it contributes to educating the retail markets in continental Europe and attracts more and more clients into the capital markets. Especially given the situation around the discussions about inflation.
Mo Chahrour
executiveTo dodge or lessen inflation, one clear route is putting money into assets and the capital markets. That has worked out very well. I'm genuinely grateful to the entire team, which has added enormously to getting this documentary made. Obviously, we'll use the documentary in every market campaign we run from here on. Yes, it was a one-off investment on our part, but we'll get plenty of value from it down the road across 2022 and 2023 on the marketing side. We genuinely hold the view that, as a market leader, we must also give back to education and to growing this market, rather than just sitting back and waiting for the waves to deliver clients to us. Anyone who hasn't watched it yet, take your time. It's a four times 12 minutes documentary. You'll find it on discovery+, and it's also up on our website — on flatex.de and on every DEGIRO website, in six or seven languages if I'm not mistaken. That means Spanish, French, Italian, German, English and Dutch, and a couple more. Portuguese, a couple more. So go ahead and enjoy a short, nice documentary about the true stories of investing. Yeah, that's literally all from our side.
Mo Chahrour
executiveYou've got the financial calendar in front of you, it's on this slide as well, and it's also posted on the website. At the end of March, the complete annual report will be released. At the end of April, we'll report the Q1 results for 2022, and it continues from there.
Frank Niehage
executiveYes. Thanks, Mo. Before we open things up for Q&A, perhaps one more piece of important information. We really like this documentary a lot, and we're proud that more than a million people across Europe have already taken the time to watch it. If you take some time to watch it, you'll be in good company, and we're happy to get any feedback. Let's open up for Q&A now.
Operator
operatorMarius Fuhrberg from Warburg has the first question.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystHi, Mo. To start, I appreciate the depth of transparency and the detail you've given us regarding customers and activities. My first question is: what do you expect revenue per trade to be for 2022? I ask because we've observed various effects over recent years, some accelerating and others diluting. Would I be mistaken to think you anticipate revenue per trade for 2022 to be roughly at the same level as what we saw in Q4? My second question concerns trading activity thus far in 2022. The terrible war, naturally, drove volatility in the capital markets. Yet we also saw capital market volatility in Q4 of last year, though customers were not as active as we would have anticipated. How has that trended in Q1 so far? One final question: regarding the 38% of accounts with no activity in 2021, how many assets under custody are allocated to those accounts? At what point would you treat such a low-activity account as a dead account and perhaps terminate the customer relationship?
Mo Chahrour
executiveYes. Thank you, Marius, and thanks for those questions. I'm glad to respond. Regarding the first one — what to expect for revenue per trade in 2022 — I believe Q4 already demonstrated a meaningful rise in revenues per trade. Beyond that, we've put several product and pricing measures in place, as you're aware, so as I noted during the presentation, we can expect revenues per trade to land around the level seen in Q3 and Q4. Once structures such as the U.S. equity FX exchanges take effect, you might even see that revenue per trade base rise further. How it evolves across the full year depends heavily, again, on the mix of trading products and on which clients trade in which countries and in what assets. The EUR 5, I think, marks a watermark that is quite sustainable. I hope that covers the first question. On the second one — trading activity in Q1 2022 — as you know, we don't comment on numbers before we publish them. I think everybody is watching the capital markets at the moment. Volatility in the capital markets is a given. It's clearly not the same as what we saw in Q1 2021.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThat is, I believe, quite clear and quite evident. The progress achieved up to now is something we feel fairly pleased about. I think that is what I can say regarding trading activity in Q1, 2022. Clearly the present circumstances are, sadly, I must say, adding to the level of activity. Having that activity is good. Where this activity comes from is deeply unfortunate. Your third question concerns the activity level of the 38% non-active clients in 2021. Once more here, allow me to restate that for a moment. 68% of our clients were active. That is a huge figure for a financial services company — that more than 2/3 of all your clients have acted and have done business with you. The 32% is nonetheless an asset base that is extremely important to us. Frank mentioned it in the introduction. One reason we think an asset management product slash robo-advisory product could also be accretive to our business is to give these kinds of clients some access to the capital markets, and access that is perhaps different from what you generally see with classic brokers. Ultimately, to revitalize this client base as well, and to invite this client base for whatever reason they are not trading.
Mo Chahrour
executiveIt could be that they lack a trading idea, or perhaps they don’t have funds since their situation prevents them from investing, or they purchased a home and required the money for another purpose. Many reasons could explain why this is the case. With this extra product, particularly on the asset management side and the robo-advisory side, we aim to reactivate a substantial portion of that client base as well. Sorry, I said 68%. The correct figure is 62%, not 68%. That is nearly 2/3.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystThanks a lot. I have one more follow-up on this. That is exactly the point I was getting at. Could you tell me how many assets under custody sit within those accounts that are less active or not active? I’m trying to gauge whether there’s a chance to bring those clients back to the level of activity they had before, or whether these are essentially EUR 0 accounts where nothing ever happened?
Mo Chahrour
executiveLet me return to that slide, which we displayed quite clearly. There we go. I trust it's fully visible to everyone. According to that slide, clients whose accounts held under EUR 200 still produced EUR 44 in ARPU. Once more, the notion that customers with small or extremely small balances bring in no ARPU is incorrect — literally incorrect. This is precisely the point where we say it's something we should, or can, push even higher through additional products. We can generate extra ARPU on top of that EUR 44, perhaps by introducing further products that these clients aren't using today. It makes no difference to us whether someone has EUR 100, EUR 50, or EUR 10 sitting in their account, since we observe that such clients are active in a particular way. We think we can raise the activity rate through additional products that we will roll out and offer over the course of this year.
Marius Fuhrberg
analystAll right, that's clear. Thanks.
Mo Chahrour
executiveGlad to have you with us.
Operator
operatorChristoph Greulich from Berenberg has the next question. Your line is open now.
Christoph Greulich
analystYeah. Morning, Frank. Morning, Mo. Appreciate you taking my questions. I'd like to begin by asking about those two new projects you mentioned, the ones involving crypto and robo-advisory. Did I get it right that whether these get built in-house or come through an acquisition is a call that hasn't been made yet?
Frank Niehage
executiveSure, I can probably take that one.
Christoph Greulich
analystFrank, go ahead.
Frank Niehage
executiveOur approach has been to partner with companies that already exist rather than building something from scratch on our own. Rather than making an acquisition, we'll form a partnership. Particularly in crypto asset trading, we'll ensure that our risk profile does not go up. You're probably all aware of the situation surrounding MiCA, Markets in Crypto-Assets. A draft version of a directive is available at the European Commission level, and in that draft version, unlimited liability is still provided for for those offering such services. That still causes us some concern. We believe we've found a way to cooperate with a partner in which the partner retains the liability and the risk while we give our clients access to that partner. It's a very reputable, strong partner. As our clients can always expect from us whenever we introduce new products or partners, they rank among the best, with a track record and high quality and so on. That covers the crypto asset trading project. As for the assets under management-robo-advice project, once again, we feel we've screened the market very prudently and that we're coming forward with a partner that has a long track record and a very established portfolio strategy.
Frank Niehage
executiveTo repeat, this business won’t hurt or contaminate what we do, given that our focus is on self-directed clients — and from a regulatory standpoint, self-directed clients are handled quite differently from clients to whom you give advice or for whom you give advice. We don’t want a scenario where the entire regulatory framework that applies to advising clients gets layered onto us. To repeat, what we’re seeking here is a partnership in which we provide access to a partner who is then accountable for the advice and who is the one giving that advice, and it isn’t us. That is satisfied. I hope that’s clear and goes some way toward answering the question.
Christoph Greulich
analystThat makes sense, thanks. I had a question about the revenue per trade check that showed up in Q4. Could you clarify something for me: when we discuss the pricing overhaul—whether we mean this year or November last year—the main accretive piece, let's say, was the bump in the FX conversion fee. When exactly did that take effect?
Mo Chahrour
executiveNo. The euro’s FX change had no effect on the EUR 5.22. It took effect — the FX change took effect on December 20th. Over those last 10 days, six of which were bank holidays, there literally wasn’t enough time for it to take effect. On the revenue-per-trade basis. During Q4, the revenue-per-trade basis was mainly influenced, and significantly influenced, as I mentioned, mainly also by clients we won in Q1 and Q2, in Germany and Austria, who began paying for their transactions. You know that with flatex, average revenue per trade is actually usually EUR 7+, especially on equities and ETPs, which clients could trade, as I said, for free during the first six months of their lifetime with us. That contributed massively to the revenue-per-trade basis. It’s not the AutoFX. That only took effect on December 20th. We introduced it literally in November. Absolutely right. Clients were actually allowed, for four weeks, to trade U.S. equities literally for zero, because the AutoFX increase only applied after December 20th.
Christoph Greulich
analystRight, that's clear—thanks. Then I've just got one final question from me. Perhaps you could comment briefly on how you view your cost base, leaving aside marketing spending. I mean, you've covered that already, but just the remaining portion of the cost base—how do you expect that to develop going forward?
Mo Chahrour
executiveYes, thank you, Chris, for raising that. Outside of marketing, personnel costs came in pretty much where we had anticipated. There wasn't a significant jump, even though we've clearly added to headcount too, in light of the enormous growth — mostly on the customer service and customer risk sides. Our admin expenses rose at more than a linear rate, compared with what straightforward linear growth would produce. There were two causes for that. Cause number one: we recorded a gross booking on one item that pushed up both our admin costs and our other operating income, each by nearly EUR 3.5 million to EUR 4 million. It nets to zero at the P&L or EBITDA level, but it did inflate the P&L, so to speak, since accounting rules required us to book it gross. The second factor we also observed was a rise in our banking license fees. That came about for two reasons. First, we're expanding. Higher deposits mean BaFin and Bundesbank charge you larger fees, on one hand. On the other hand, there was a one-off payment that unfortunately every bank had to make following the collapse of a German bank — not Wirecard in this instance, but Greensill.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThose also stacked up as unexpected costs, and that's more or less a one-off item related to the depositary scheme. Beyond these one-off items, which totaled, let's say, EUR 5 million in total — EUR 5.5 million — we expect the personnel expense side, as well as the operational personnel expense side, so excluding the long-term incentive plans, along with general admin expenses, to be and to remain at the level we've seen now in 2021, despite the growth.
Christoph Greulich
analystAll right. That's perfectly clear. Thanks.
Mo Chahrour
executiveGlad to have you with us.
Operator
operatorJust a quick reminder—if you'd like to ask our speakers something, dial 01 at this point to get into the queue. Our next question comes from Benjamin Kohnke at KBW.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystMorning, everyone. I hope my voice is coming through clearly.
Mo Chahrour
executiveYes, hello Ben.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystHey, Mo. Morning, Frank. Morning. Got a couple of questions, if you don't mind. Starting with the strategic projects — really simple one. Does this sit within the initial 2022 guidance you gave, in terms of new customers and the number of trades?
Mo Chahrour
executiveWe consistently steer with caution and provide a specific projection regarding the projects we’ll have in the business. Yes. Even so, should circumstances shift, we’ll let the market know that this could change.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystThanks. On the second one, I suppose it's related to that same subject. I mean, everyone is aware that you're holding, you know, a fairly substantial amount of surplus cash on the balance sheet. Frank, you were quite explicit that you're, you know, pursuing partnerships instead of any kind of M&A. Let's suppose that surplus cash stays put and will actually keep growing. Mo, is there any kind of update on, say, where your thinking stands right now regarding the use of cash? I mean, you keep generating money at a crazy pace, assuming your guidance holds, and so therefore, I think that question is becoming more and more pressing.
Frank Niehage
executiveSure, I can begin, and then Mo can wrap things up.
Mo Chahrour
executiveYes, go ahead.
Frank Niehage
executiveTo start with, if we get an opportunity to form a really smart partnership in which we don’t need to contribute equity, we’d prefer that over putting in investment. Next, we continue to think it’s beneficial to keep that surplus cash and capital on hand for situations down the road. Picture Payment for Order Flow coming into effect, and then many neo-brokers run into difficulties. At that point, we figure it could be the right moment to pursue an acquisition and take over some of them wherever that makes sense, yeah. Conversely, when it comes to our growth and how quickly we move, having sufficient regulatory capital to fund that growth is a good thing.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystThat's somewhat of a strategic perspective on it, but perhaps what you'd rather round out is the financial side.
Mo Chahrour
executiveNo, absolutely. I mean, with all due respect and humility, regarding how we generate cash, Frank said that when it comes to AUM and crypto, we don't consider acquisitions. That doesn't mean we don't consider acquisitions at all. It means we don't consider them for those two products, given the risk profile, the risk situation, and the regulatory situation surrounding those products. If opportunities exist in the market that make sense for our development, we will always take a second look at them. You also know I'm a big fan of cash. I remember when we acquired DEGIRO, we had this wonderful situation where we didn't have to ask anyone out there for a single penny to finance that transaction. That's why here I'm very classic and very conservative. I love to have one time EBITDA and cash in my accounts, which lets me, at any opportunistic moment, make decisions together with Frank and the supervisory board and not rely then on capital access that, as you know, might take a lot of time. Given that situation, and perhaps also in a capital market situation where prices are low, I'm really reluctant to give away our shares at low prices.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThat's basically the reason we think it makes sense to keep that cushion in place. And then, thinking about the years ahead: if it turns out that 2 or 3 years from now we're sitting on all this cash and still haven't found opportunities, well, there are certain plans, clearly, and a few strategic ideas that we talk about on either side of that decision.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystOkay, that's quite straightforward. Thanks. My final question is about the costs of acquiring customers. If I heard you correctly, Mo, Q4 had a particular effect tied to the TV campaign amounting to roughly EUR 5 million, correct? Even so, that's still, I mean, still well above the longer-run objective of about EUR 50 for each new customer. Perhaps you could give a little outlook for 2022. I mean, the TV campaign carries on through the first half and will incur expenses. Would it be reasonable to expect customer acquisition costs during 2022 to land somewhere from EUR 50 to EUR 100?
Mo Chahrour
executiveLet me clear this up, since that hypothesis isn't correct. Client marketing costs came to EUR 46 million, and roughly EUR 5 million of that was spent on producing the documentary and the advertisement. Once you strip that out, you land at EUR 41 million, if I'm not mistaken. Divide EUR 41 million by the 800,000 gross clients — we actually had 798,000, so let's round up to 800,000 — and you get EUR 51.25 in client acquisition costs. As I've said, we've consistently guided to EUR 50 ±10%, depending on the market environment and depending on where you're growing. We're going to stick with that. I don't see CACs heading toward EUR 100. Absolutely not. Sure, maybe it won't remain at EUR 50 — maybe it lands at EUR 60 — but definitely not at EUR 100, which takes us back to the same point: EUR 50 ± a certain variance, depending on which markets you're growing faster in. As I said, take Germany as an example — CACs there are more like EUR 150-EUR 200, whereas in Italy, for instance, CACs sit below EUR 30. How quickly you grow in different markets also shapes your client acquisition costs.
Mo Chahrour
executiveTaken as a whole, across the entire group, our ongoing emphasis will remain on the EUR 50 to EUR 60 range for client acquisition costs.
Benjamin Kohnke
analystAppreciate it — thanks a lot.
Mo Chahrour
executiveNo problem at all.
Operator
operatorUp next, we have a question from Christoph Blieffert of Exane BNP Paribas. Your line is open now.
Christoph Blieffert
analystGood morning. I’ve got a few questions, and I’d like to take them one at a time. To start, how would you characterize how Trade Republic is competing right now, especially since DEGIRO and Trade Republic are moving into similar markets? And on that point, what do you see as your main competitive advantage?
Mo Chahrour
executiveHi, Chris. Let me clear that up. We aren't moving into any new markets. What I'd say instead is that Trade Republic is coming into markets where we've already been active for more than five years. That's the first point. Second, we're expanding in those markets very successfully, whether that's France, Spain, or Italy. The Netherlands is a home market for DEGIRO, which I think also lets us keep feeling very good. On top of that, we've launched DEGIRO goes zero precisely in these core markets and core growth markets. As for how Trade Republic is moving competitively, I don't know. I know just as much as you do, and all of us know they don't reveal much about what they do or how they do it. All we've read is the press release saying they want to go into these countries, but I have no numbers, and I don't know what they do, how many, or how successful they are. Our competitive edge hasn't changed over the past years. It's still the Triple P strategy. It's still price. It's still product. It's still the platform. Starting with price, as I mentioned, we offer zero commission trading on all regulated exchanges, charging only EUR 0.50 handling fee.
Mo Chahrour
executiveRegarding Trade Republic, as I recall, they offer trading at zero commission with a EUR 1 handling fee, and the only venue you can trade through is the market maker Lang & Schwarz — unlike us, where trading happens across every exchange worldwide. Our presentation demonstrated quite clearly how crucial it is to also provide a product portfolio, an exchange portfolio. That's the distinction between us and neo-brokers broadly. Our target isn't 18-, 19-, 20-year-old clients who simply want to experiment a little with buying and selling Tesla, even though, judging by assets under custody and the average versus the Tesla stock price, most of them probably can't afford the Tesla stock anyway. All of these considerations matter to us. Looking ahead, as I've mentioned a few times, this market shouldn't view us as a neo-broker. The way we should be viewed is as the best regionalized version of Interactive Brokers, serving the European markets, attracting the right clients, attracting active clients, attracting clients who contribute from day one and contribute to profitability. On top of that — Frank raised this too — there's the PFOF discussion: we'll most likely finish this year with, I'd say, on the exchange side, definitely zero PFOF.
Mo Chahrour
executiveThat PFOF conversation with other brokers is likewise constraining their expansion in those countries. In short, I believe we remain on course. We aren't fixating on whatever happens around us so long as we can't break it down. What we observe is that, up to now, we've been handling things properly. Competition exists, and make no mistake, we're assessing those rivals very, very carefully and with prudence. As of now, we find ourselves positioned in a way that should let us keep up that growth regardless of any additional market entries from peers or competitors.
Christoph Blieffert
analystUnderstood. Moving to my second question: what would you say the perfect trading climate looks like for the clients you serve? Is it more a market that climbs with little volatility, or the volatile market we have right now? What would the ideal world be for you?
Mo Chahrour
executiveIn a perfect scenario, you'd have volatility on one side combined with people being aware of the market. Because, I mean, ultimately, what counts as ideal for us? What we'd consider ideal is when the number of clients—the first KPI in our success formula—goes up. What's the main driver behind that increase in clients? Clearly it comes from brand awareness and marketing, but more broadly, it's awareness of capital markets. The greater the awareness of capital markets across society—which typically occurs when markets are highly volatile, since at those times every newspaper runs 20 articles a day on capital markets—the more attractive capital markets become to clients. On one hand, that's an interesting environment in itself. As for trading activity, volatile markets are consistently appealing and, as we showed on our slide with the hidden reserve, so to speak—here we go—those markets contribute extra windfall profits to our business. That would be the perfect dream: volatility days every day with plenty of capital market awareness. Unfortunately, Chris, as you know as well as we do, life isn't a place where wishes come true.
Mo Chahrour
executiveWe need to work with the conditions we've got and aim to get the most from them. What we're seeing, though — and for us this matters above all — is that no matter what the market is doing right now, our clients stay loyal, they stick with us, and they remain active in a sustainable way. That's the key part.
Christoph Blieffert
analystAlright. On page 16, that chart displaying the percentage of U.S. volume — does it cover flatexDEGIRO, or is it just for DEGIRO?
Mo Chahrour
executiveThat's at the group level. Group numbers are what we always present. We don't do it otherwise. If just a single brand were involved — something we would never do — then we would disclose that it applies to only one brand.
Christoph Blieffert
analystWould it be reasonable to think that DEGIRO's share is likely larger, considering that flatex-
Mo Chahrour
executiveYes.
Christoph Blieffert
analystFor clients in Germany, could they trade U.S. stocks on Tradegate in euros? In euro currency.
Mo Chahrour
executiveetc.
Christoph Blieffert
analystMm-hmm.
Mo Chahrour
executiveYeah, they are.
Christoph Blieffert
analystMm-hmm.
Mo Chahrour
executiveRight.
Christoph Blieffert
analystAlright.
Mo Chahrour
executiveAbsolutely.
Christoph Blieffert
analystWe’ll take one final question.
Mo Chahrour
executiveGermans, right. Germans have a tendency to trade U.S. stocks in euro terms on local exchanges, and that's an abnormality in the European environment. I believe it's literally only Xetra that permits that, plus obviously Tradegate, to trade stocks denominated in euros. Exactly.
Christoph Blieffert
analystOne final question, if you don't mind: could you share what your CET1 ratio stood at when 2021 came to a close?
Mo Chahrour
executiveChris, we’ll be glad to go through this once the final numbers are out, since the key factor is clearly net profit rather than EBITDA. Both of them matter. At the bank, it is extremely profitable — very high — so 20%+. At the group level, after the audited accounts, we expect it to be at least 15%+.
Christoph Blieffert
analystAll right, many thanks.
Mo Chahrour
executiveGlad to help.
Operator
operatorAt this point, we aren't seeing any further questions come through. So for the closing remarks, I'll hand things back to the speakers.
Mo Chahrour
executiveOkay, many thanks for joining us on today's call. We appreciate your support a lot. I hope we've managed to give you greater clarity on some of the data and facts, and that this also meets what you were hoping for. We wish all of you peaceful days, and hopefully the geopolitical situation settles down again as soon as it can. Take care, keep well, and we hope to talk with you again before long. If there's anything you need, just get in touch.
Frank Niehage
executiveSame here from my end. Many thanks to everyone, and best of luck — please stay healthy. Let’s keep our fingers crossed that this war ends as soon as possible and that peace returns to Europe. Have a nice day. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.