flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 28, 2024

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Financials Capital Markets earnings 54 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Hi, and welcome to the flatexDEGIRO Preliminary Results 2023 Analyst Call. I'm Laura, and I'll be coordinating today's event. Just a note that this call is being recorded. And throughout the call, your lines will stay in listen-only mode. <<operator_script>> With us today are Frank Niehage, CEO, and Dr. Benon Janos, CFO, as our presenters. I'll now turn things over to your host, Frank Niehage, to get today's conference started. Thank you.

Frank Niehage

executive
#2

Good morning, everyone, and a warm welcome from Frankfurt. With me are my colleague Dr. Benon Janos, our CFO; Achim Schreck, our Head of IR; and Dr. Thomas Lindner, our Head of Finance. I'm Frank Niehage, and I'm glad to present and begin with the commercial highlights from last year, before handing over to Benon, who will shift gears and provide a bit more detail and color on the financial results. It goes without saying that last year was a challenging one, not just for us but for the entire industry, given the geopolitical situation in both Europe and the Middle East. On top of that, interest hikes and high inflation created irritation and challenges for the whole industry and, obviously, for our clients. Still, in such a challenging environment, we were pleased to deliver further commercial growth, resulting in the second best financial result in our firm's history — something we take some pride in sharing with you today. As I mentioned, Benon will later provide a bit more detail on that. But 2023 wasn't only a strong year — we also got off to a very strong start in the first two months of this year, with over 10 million trades in the first two months and over 80,000 new clients joining our platform, along with over €1 billion in fresh money, which gives us a good level of comfort.

Frank Niehage

executive
#3

And with luck, this year will deliver our strongest numbers on record. Turning back to the regulatory side: we take real pride in the fact that, working closely alongside BaFin and our special auditor, we got almost 70% of the relevant issues over the line. And on a very positive note, I'd like to point out that there is a shared understanding with both the regulator and Mazars that the key findings — the most serious ones — will, we hope, be settled by summer this year, and better still, should that happen, no further after audit will be required. That is genuinely good news, and my thanks go to every one of our employees who helped make it happen. And once more, many thanks for the tremendously helpful support from both the regulator and our special auditor Mazars, who helped us get the homework done. So all in all, this is a wonderful foundation. Once our figures — which as of today are only preliminary — have been fully audited, we can show you a CET1 ratio exceeding 30%. And clearly, that will then let us carry on with the announced capital allocation strategy, which we published at the end of last year, asking this year's Annual General Meeting to approve two things: a minimum dividend and a share buyback program of 10% of our capital over the next years.

Frank Niehage

executive
#4

Overall, then, the outlook is positive, and we're glad to keep it that way. Now I'll turn to commercial growth with a little more detail. Looking back from 2020 through 2021 and 2022 and on into 2023, we've seen new clients increase without interruption, which confirms for us that both platforms, DEGIRO and flatex, hold strong appeal. Set against our peers, we're proud to report client growth of more than two times, and clearly that isn't a normal level. We achieved that client growth even while cutting marketing spend. To underline the point again for 2022, we spent nearly €50 million on marketing. We handled that well and brought it down to €34 million last year, and we'll keep trimming it gradually, hopefully reaching €30 million this year, and we'll go on managing our costs in general very, very carefully. Beyond commercial growth, I'd like to point out that we brought in over €4.5 billion of fresh money last year, and that's despite paying no interest. That again demonstrates both the client growth and the fresh money: clients come to us because they want to invest, not because they want to save.

Frank Niehage

executive
#5

We're not the savings platform—we're the investment platform. And what's even better is that more than 91% of the new money was immediately reinvested, which shows we're attracting the right clients, and we're grateful that they use the platform for investing. That even resulted in clients growing their wealth with us, with a figure just under €40 billion back in 2022 and more than €51 billion—nearly €52 billion—in 2023, and the trend remains positive. It's good that our clients are building their wealth with us, and it demonstrates that investing in capital markets does make sense in these times. As I said earlier, 2023 was challenging across the industry. So it's no surprise that trades per client per annum came in lower than in prior years. And comparing us once more with our listed peers, I'd say we sit in the middle, averaging roughly 22 trades per client per annum. Obviously, that produced a decline in trades: where they stood at €67 million in 2022, we booked only €57 million, so €10 million less in 2023. Still, our strategy of monetizing income per transaction continues, and we succeeded in raising average commission per trade from €4.06 in 2022 to €4.13 in 2023, and we'll keep improving it this year.

Frank Niehage

executive
#6

Because of our balanced, mitigated business model and the fact that we run a full-fledged banking setup, we managed to raise interest income from €71.5 million in 2022 to €136.3 million in 2023. That demonstrates a great deal and offsets the weaker trading activities. Particularly in times like these, operating that kind of business model helps. Let me turn to how clients see us and to the topic of awards. I can't say whether it's a coincidence, but last year we were able to present seven awards in the German-speaking countries, and at the same time we received seven awards in the international countries. Quite respectable awards, showing that clients are happy with the platform. That doesn't mean we can't improve and do better. We work on that constantly and want to raise quality. But we'd also like to take this moment to think of all the clients who trust us and who took part in those awards, and thank you all for that. Moving on now to further details, let me thank you all and hand over to my colleague, the CFO, Dr. Benon Janos. Benon, the floor is yours. Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#7

Thank you so much, Frank, and good morning to everyone from me too. As Frank said, 2023 turned out to be the second-best year in our company's history, and I'm glad to now walk you through more detailed financials and share our outlook for 2024. The past year brought some remarkable developments. Interest levels kept climbing steeply for the first time in many years. Most indices, though, rose despite the wall of worry. For most investors, 2023 represented a much-needed comeback in both stock and bond market performance following a brutal 2022. BigTech and the artificial intelligence bandwagon especially drove much of the S&P 500's positive performance in 2023. Still, retail investor activity fell last year relative to 2022, which is mostly down to two factors: low volatility and high interest rates. First, general volatility in the stock market dropped all year long — taking the CBOE volatility index VIX as a yardstick, the year opened at a vol level of around 20 and fell through the year to roughly 15. Second, let's quickly look at one of the most important financial ratios, the price to earnings ratio; general overnight banks deposits, or overnight federal debt, to put it another way, in the Eurozone trade at 4% to 4.5%.

Benon Janos

executive
#8

That corresponds to an inverse PE ratio of 20 to 25 times for the US market, and a US deposits/debt PE ratio of 18 to 19. Tech firms, in an isolated manner, were easily able to clear that hurdle, but for the broader stock market it was much harder to rise. Our adjusted revenue for 2023 grew 6% to €391 million. On a fourth quarter stand-alone basis, we were able to show revenue growth of 14% year-on-year, up to €100 million. There were no adjustments in the 2023 revenue number. In 2022, however, adjustments of €34 million were non-operationally added to the revenue line from releasing provision for the long-term incentive plan. I will come back to the point of adjustments later in the presentation. Commission income declined by 14% in 2023 to €235 million. However, we were able to grow commissions in the fourth quarter of 2023 by 5% to €55 million compared to Q4 of 2022. As mentioned in my introductory statements, the full year decline was driven by lower trading activity of retail investors, which was 25% below last year's level. That also means that a good 10 percentage point of the decline we've been able to compensate for by growing our customer base and improving the average commission per trade.

Benon Janos

executive
#9

The rest of the decline in commission income was more than offset by interest income, and that rose 91% to €136 million versus a year earlier, and in the fourth quarter of 2023 it was up 77% to €55 million compared with the fourth quarter of 2022. As it has done before, flatexDEGIRO has stuck with its approach of paying no interest on cash deposits. The fact that we have brought in more than €10 billion of net cash inflows to our platform across the last two years, even as interest levels climbed, demonstrates our strength as an execution only online broker focused on trading active clients. Now let's turn to earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, EBITDA. EBITDA fell 23% year-on-year to €140 million. For the fourth quarter, the comparable figure shows an 8% decline, which stems largely from the release of provision for the long-term incentive plan in 2022 that I referred to earlier; if we adjust for the long-term incentive plan, adjusted EBITDA increased 7% to €154 million for the full year and was up 27% in the fourth quarter of 2023 versus the fourth quarter of 2022. All of those EBITDA figures fully include non-cash markdowns and real estate investments, on which I gave more detail in the Q3 2023 earnings call.

Benon Janos

executive
#10

Those figures also take in the special effect tied to the generous one-time salary increases driven by broad inflation pressures across the last few years, plus penalties paid to the regulator, and also to the Italian Competition Authority, AGCOM — which, as you're aware, we are contesting in court. Now, an update from me on the real estate investments. Across the full year, non-cash markdowns on those investments came to €11 million in total, and the bulk of that was booked in the third quarter. In Q4 of 2023 there were only marginal changes, and assuming the general level of interest rates doesn't move up unexpectedly, we don't anticipate any meaningful effects in 2024 either. Our 2023 adjusted revenue guidance of €38 million was beaten, with €39 million in revenues generated. Both our adjusted EBITDA margin and our adjusted EBIT margin grew slightly versus the prior year, and against the guidance we issued early in 2023 we were effectively on target. On the adjusted EBITDA line, technically we came in 50 basis points short of 40%. Absent the non-cash real estate markdowns mentioned earlier, along with the fines and the inflation compensation, the respective margins would have been several percentage points higher. In recent years, our annual statement has shown the IFRS segments Fin and Tech.

Benon Janos

executive
#11

With the annual report now out, you'll see a new segment reporting structure that we're bringing in to make things more transparent. The Fin and Tech segments basically mirrored the B2C and B2B business the Group historically concentrated on, as our business model has shifted and evolved toward being an online broker. So the old segments are being replaced by the new ones, flatex and DEGIRO <<inaudible>>. One thing worth flagging, though: even though the names imply these segments correspond exactly to the flatex and DEGIRO brands, that really can only be a rough approximation. The flatex segment covers, for instance, flatex and DEGIROoperations, all credit and treasury operations that don't fall explicitly under the halo brand, and outsourcing solutions. IT services get allocated to the segments on the basis of revenues. In any case, the new segments give a more accurate picture of how we run and manage the business and let you see our core business better and more clearly. The first transparency initiative came, by the way, at the start of 2023, when we introduced monthly KPI figures. These new segments are now the second step. And the third and fourth measures will be introduced shortly when we get to the outlook for 2024.

Benon Janos

executive
#12

Our goal for 2024 is the strongest year in the company's financial history. Now, a quick remark about adjusted earnings. So far in this presentation of the 2023 financial results, I have used the term adjusted, or adjustments, 11 times. Adjustments introduce complexity into financial statements, and where possible we would prefer to avoid that going forward. Should more than 50% of the long-term incentive plan be executed, we will absorb those costs as normal operating personnel costs in the future. We anticipate the future yearly effect on the profit and loss statement. That effect will be smaller than it was previously. We will keep presenting the details of the adjustments on a like-for-like basis so that '24 can be compared with '23. The adjustments will, however, receive less emphasis, allowing for simpler and more transparent headline key figures. No adjustments is the first of the transparency improvements. The fourth one concerns the financial KPIs we have focused on. Over the past years we have used the EBITDA metric. Historically, that metric originates from a period 10 years back, when flatexDEGIRO's earnings power was substantially lower. At that time the group had no integrated IT departments and no banking license.

Benon Janos

executive
#13

Back then, it was just a different company. And that metric has worked well for us. Depreciation sits below EBITDA. For a company as highly vertically integrated as ours, depreciation is the line item that matters. We're glad to have this degree of internalization and glad to keep investing in it. It gives us freedom and lets us move fast. Getting the regulatory reapplication of credit mitigation techniques for automation done within 10 months would have been impossible without full control over our IT. We're also aware that, at present, outside IT would cost us more than developing IT in-house. Of course, past growth also pushed up the depreciation line, largely because of the DEGIRO acquisitions. We'll now move ahead and put less emphasis on EBITDA in favor of net income, accompanied as needed by financial metrics below the EBITDA line, such as operating income, pretax income or earnings per share. So we're also giving our outlook for 2024, with a clear focus on top and bottom line, as follows. We're targeting revenue growth of 5% to 15%, that is, a revenue range of four €10 million to approximately for €50 million for full year 2024. The aim is also for net income to grow between 25% and 50%, for a range of €90 million close to €110 million.

Benon Janos

executive
#14

Here's our top line and bottom line outlook for 2024. So to say it again, the net income line takes in every cost and depreciation effect from all long-term incentive plans, any markups or markdowns coming from investment activities, and no adjustments whatsoever are made in the guidance numbers we're presenting. And in planning for 2024, we're also not counting on any tailwinds from the markets — trading activity at the start of the year has been okay so far, as one would expect in the seasonally good first quarter, but it's way too early to project a sustainable uptick in retail investors' trading activity already. It might happen once interest rates come down. But as we said, it might. We don't want to get ahead of ourselves. So at present we plan with a similar retail trading activity in 2024 compared to 2023. With regard to such potentially low interest rates, that would of course also have a countering effect on our interest income, which we're mindful of. We plan in general with very similar average weighted interest levels in 2024 compared to 2023, while 2023 started low. And at the time, we expect to reverse for 2024.

Benon Janos

executive
#15

You're welcome to contact our team and Investor Relations if you'd like to talk through some of your assumptions. But as Frank already said, yes, January and February have both come in favorably and above our assumptions. Still, the year is long and there are another 10 months to go. Even so, we're confident that we can keep growing our customer base and growing our brokerage franchise in general. I'd now like to hand things back to Frank for a quick update on the successful resolution of Boston Scientific.

Frank Niehage

executive
#16

Yes. Like I said before, we already succeeded in releasing our regulatory capital during the previous year. That is improving the credit risk mitigations. Our attention is now even more on the most serious and relevant F4 findings, which, as I mentioned earlier, are due to be settled in summer. We read was both BaFin and the special audit of <<inaudible>> that once that has been resolved I know after audit is necessary. And again that's a very good result. So that is where we are focused, and concerning the risk, the other findings are 70% resolved. So overall, this is quite positive. May I permit myself one further remark, since as we already stated, we began strongly in January and February, but generally we prefer to stay under-promise and over-deliver, as none of us knows how quickly the geopolitical situation in both the Middle East and in Europe might be resolved, and we all keep cross fingers and pray for this. And we obviously believe there is going to be a decrease in interest rates this year, but none of us knows when this is going to happen. I would say rather in the second half of the year, but we do know and we do see a decrease in inflation rate, which is positive, but we don't know whether it is going to stay low and how low it is going to stay.

Frank Niehage

executive
#17

So taking everything together, that brings us to the assumption that we'd rather stay the full course and be cautious, and to under-promise and over-deliver, and we hope you understand that with regard to our guidance as well.

Benon Janos

executive
#18

Two quick final slides from me. At the end of September, BaFin approved the reapplication of the credit risk mitigation techniques. Once again, we've given you an update on our capital structure and requirements. Since then, thankfully, not much has changed, but the outlook has become clearer. We'd like to take this opportunity to quickly confirm and reiterate that we are on track to expect the common equity Tier 1 ratio to rise well above 30% once the full year 2023 net income has been recognized in our regulatory capital base. This comfortable position allows us to follow through with our capital allocation strategy as announced in December. We intend to ask the next Annual General Meeting in June for the authorization to buy back up to 10% of our share capital. This authorization will be valid for technically five years. Initial signs and timing of the share buyback program, once approved by the Annual General Meeting and by the regulator as well, will then depend on inorganic growth opportunities, market conditions and ultimately, of course, on our share price levels. However, from today's perspective, there is a clear management view to make it a sizable element of the capital allocation, much more of course than the minimum dividend that we will additionally ask the general meeting to approve.

Benon Janos

executive
#19

We appreciate everyone listening, and at this point we're glad to take whatever questions you may have.

Operator

operator
#20

Thanks. <<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Andrew Lowe at Citi. Your line is open. Go right ahead.

Andrew Lowe

analyst
#21

Yes. Hi, guys. Thanks for taking my question. My first one is just on the assumptions behind the NII guide. If you helpfully gave us the detail, it seems to imply to me that you're looking for about €135 million. And with your assumptions of flat rates and the balances that you've given, if you assume €50 million of other income then that implies €260 million to €300 million of commission income. So, just checking those numbers are sort of broadly consistent with your thinking, and if you then take that commission income at the midpoint of that say 280, then as per your guidance on the activities and customer numbers that implies for the year is €0.35 per trade versus €0.14 in 2023. Is that sort of correct in your thinking and what gives you confidence that you can drive increase in the commission per trade in the next year? The second question is do you think it's fair to assume that your cash balances are likely to be stickier than some of your other peers given you've got smaller average balances and heavier trading, which perhaps means that they've got a greater liquidity one. Thank you so much.

Frank Niehage

executive
#22

Perhaps I could begin with a broad remark about why we think monetization per income per trade can improve. We're pursuing product and service initiatives — things like US option trading late and early US trading at the zero securities lending, plus further services — and those hopefully will contribute in the second half of this year. And that isn't yet reflected in the numbers. So that will definitely have a positive impact. But with respect to your details, I hand over to Benon, who will help you to understand how the figures work.

Benon Janos

executive
#23

Andrew, a quick question first, or a quick answer on your second point: do we believe the cash balances are stickier? We believe they are stickier, and we feel okay about them. We have never gone wild. We have never used an interest rate fee or an interest rate as a mechanism for attracting new clients. So clients are used to getting no interest on their deposits. And that number has been rising slowly but steadily. We think the problem will also be smaller once the ECB starts cutting rates, if it does. We feel quite okay with our strategy of basically hanging on and focusing on the trading element of the equation. On your first question about the precise mathematics, I think I would add that probably, overall, the interest line is a bit on the low side — you mentioned the €135 million — whereas the average commission per trade is maybe a bit on the high side. So those are a slightly different view, or a slightly adjusted view, that we might have. But as always, it depends on so many things over the next 10 months. Ultimately, the total number of client deposits in our bank is one of the leading factors, and they are just extremely difficult to predict.

Andrew Lowe

analyst
#24

I really appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#25

Appreciate it. Next up, we have a question from Panos Ellinas at Morgan Stanley. Your line is open now, so please go ahead.

Panos Ellinas

analyst
#26

Yes. Hello. Thanks for taking my questions. So, my question concerns the average trades per customer that you've guided to be similar to 2023. I'm just wondering what the base is there? What mix are you assuming in terms of markets, and how should we think about the 12% customer growth and any potential dilution in the average days per customer, given that your customers take time to pick up versus the reactivation of existing clients. So, how should we think about the mix? That's my first question. And then my second one is on the gross profit margin. It has been fluctuating a bit quarter-on-quarter. So, I'm just wondering what a more sustainable level going forward would be? So, these are my two questions. Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#27

Starting with the first question about transaction per customer: as we look at the year, our initial assumption is that average trades per customer stay constant. Then, naturally, we factor in the average growth expected from new customers. So — that's not a bad way to capture our thinking: effectively take the 22, then add a small increment on top from new clients. You mentioned 12% — whether it's 9% or 12% or 10%, that's of course a bit too much precision. But the overall logic is precisely the one we hold. And on gross profit margin: that margin is driven effectively by three elements. It's driven by the costs that trade task for the high — high-cost place than the trades which are less expensive have two elements. And actually there are also a few one-off items. So some of the markdowns we've had in investments are reflected in that line as well — not all of them, but some — which generally makes the line a tad more volatile than you might perhaps infer when you look at our normal operating business.

Benon Janos

executive
#28

Also, how commission and interest income are balanced matters a great deal—one final key point: the greater your interest earnings, the lower your cost of goods sold tends to be, since that's usually a business with very high margins. And for this year, looking at the rate we saw in 2022, or a bit under that, is probably not a bad idea—or a bad assumption.

Operator

operator
#29

Thanks. Now we’ll take the question from Mengxian at Deutsche Bank. Your line is open — please go ahead.

Mengxian Sun

analyst
#30

Thanks a lot for taking my questions. I have several questions of my own as well. The first concerns customer deposits. You're anticipating an average of €3 billion in customer deposits for 2024, and that figure is significantly below your year-end balance. So I'm simply trying to grasp the reasoning behind that conservatism. If you can, could you also let us know where customer deposits stood at the end of February? My second question relates to the monetization rate. Looking at the Q4 figures, commission income per trade fell to just above €4, and that was the cause this quarter. What assumption do you have for commission per trade next year? And the final question: can you take us through the cost projection once more — how much of an increase do you expect for personnel and marketing? On the last conference call you said it should be around €35 million again. And what do you expect for other expenses? Thank you very much.

Frank Niehage

executive
#31

All right. Should I kick things off with marketing?

Benon Janos

executive
#32

Thank you.

Frank Niehage

executive
#33

We actually set a combined range of €25 million to €35 million for marketing this year, targeting €30 million, and that would mean a €4 million decrease compared with last year. Then, when it comes to the financial questions, I'll pass things over to Benon.

Benon Janos

executive
#34

On your first question about customer deposits — yes, we're above what we issued. That is indeed the situation, and we're definitely being careful here. As of the end of February, we're at roughly €3.5 billion. We'll be communicating that in our monthly statements, and we've now had 2 months with a base meaningfully higher than anticipated. But during last year's stretch — the 18 months when interest rates were rising — we saw the deposit base fluctuate a little, and we just didn't want to extrapolate too far into the future. So far it looks very healthy, and we have some comfort that the figure is probably too low, but only 2 months are done so far. So yes, you can certainly put that down to conservative planning. On the marketing projections, as Frank already explained: the range was set some time ago when we did our financial planning, and now that the first-quarter activities have been spent and marketed and planned, there's — as Frank alluded to — already a certain element of conservatism, since we're likely to spend closer to all 30 than last year's number.

Benon Janos

executive
#35

Now, about monetization. Looking at monthly figures for trades per customer, or even quarterly ones, is genuinely difficult. A number of the invoices we get are annual, and although certain ones can be broken down to a monthly level, doing that for all of them isn't easy. So I'd say the proper way to represent this is through half-year or annual figures. Our intention is to raise the monetization rate. We've observed price increases at the heel that took effect in the middle of last year, so on a full-year basis that will have an impact. But when it comes to those numbers, I'd probably recommend looking at longer timeframes rather than shorter ones. We feel okay, and we're seeing no surprises in our business.

Mengxian Sun

analyst
#36

Thanks a lot. And on costs, what kind of personnel cost increase are you expecting for 2024, and what about the other operating expenses? Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#37

Our plan is for those costs to stay flat, and — give me a moment to address that question. Over the past three years, revenues have climbed sharply, obviously, and so have the client base and revenues, but costs have risen too. A few points deserve mention. First, inflation naturally comes into play, and since we wanted to keep our staff content, we were perhaps more generous than the typical bank, lifting salary levels through a one-off adjustment to the salary base early this year. Specifically, salaries went up by 8%. We also brought on many people as a result of the BaFin findings and regulatory positions from. Still, it's fairly evident that we intend to end calendar year 24 with a smaller headcount than we started the year with. That alone ought to more than offset any modest salary increases coming. So our focus on managing the operating cost line this year will be considerably sharper than it was last year.

Benon Janos

executive
#38

A year ago, we weren't able to do that as much as we would have liked, because of the requirements mainly imposed on us by the regulator. As we gradually shift gears — I talk too much about regulation and hopefully more again about commercial focus — that will also let us be somewhat more disciplined when it comes to costs.

Frank Niehage

executive
#39

You also brought up the cost-income ratio.

Benon Janos

executive
#40

Absolutely, Frank, I'm glad to cover that. For the full year, our cost-income ratio comes in at roughly 51% to 52%. We expect that figure to decline considerably over fiscal year 2024, and using the projections we provided, you can work it out — there will be a significant reduction, taking it well under 50%.

Mengxian Sun

analyst
#41

Thanks a lot. That makes perfect sense.

Operator

operator
#42

Thanks. Now we’ll go to the following question, which comes from Simon Keller at Hauck & Aufhaeuser. Your line is open, so please proceed.

Simon Keller

analyst
#43

Morning, and thanks for taking my questions. First, why did reported EBITDA come in above adjusted EBITDA during Q4? Second, what would need to happen for you to land at just the low end of the net income guidance? I ask because 2023 included several one-offs, and absent those, my own calculation says you should already be showing at least 30% growth year over year. Third and last, regarding CapEx plans for 2024, could you shed some color on that? Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#44

Regarding your first question, reported EBITDA was — hold on one moment, please. During Q4, because of how the share price moved as well as EPS projections, we essentially recorded a modest release of provisions back into the EBITDA line. That falls under those well-known adjustments, something I personally dislike. As I mentioned earlier, going forward we would essentially prefer to stop discussing adjustments altogether so that questions like this one don't come up. So that's one of the transparency steps we had planned. Turning to your second question, I understand your point. And yes, naturally the bottom end of the guidance is conservative, plainly so. But we also can't know if the ECB might catch us off guard in some way down the road. My colleague Frank has already pointed out that the geopolitical situation remains strained, and that's simply a cautious lower bound we included there just to stay on the safe side. So please view that as reflecting an outlook we aren't planning for, since it is the low end. And one moment on the CapEx. Just a second, please. So, for 2023, our CapEx approval, or our CapEx budget, came in at roughly €17 million to €18 million in new fresh CapEx.

Benon Janos

executive
#45

That figure will likely come in quite close to that same level this year.

Simon Keller

analyst
#46

All right, thank you. And a quick follow-up about provisions being released down the road — I realize you won't be adjusting for those, but will they show up in revenue, or do they also land straight in what I'd assume are personnel expenses? Thanks.

Benon Janos

executive
#47

When it comes to costs, those will sit within operating expenses and within personnel costs. Should we make adjustments and release additional provisions, there would be a modest contribution on the revenue line — we'll make that visible — but it shouldn't move the needle.

Simon Keller

analyst
#48

Okay, thanks.

Operator

operator
#49

Thanks, and we’ll go ahead and take the next question from Ian White at Autonomous Research. Your line is open—please go ahead.

Ian White

analyst
#50

Appreciate you taking the question. I've got a few things from my end, please. First off, on how net cash inflow has been progressing — it seems like during Q4, net cash inflows slowed down pretty considerably. I'm curious if you could give us some color there, please. Would I be correct in thinking that, in aggregate, you had outflows from existing customers in Q4, but that this was more than offset by the new customers you brought on board? That's my first question. Then maybe, again, on the guidance — could you help me understand the range of outcomes you've considered in your net profit guidance? Basically, what would we need to believe for you to get to 25% and 50% respectively? Could 50% be reached with cash balances at €3 billion, for example? Or is the sensitivity largely the customer trading rates and cash balances — those sort of three unknowns? And then finally, on the cost guidance, could you help a bit with depreciation and amortization for 2024? Are we going to see some amortization of the higher development expenditure that's been accrued on the balance sheet since 2021, or is that going to be broadly unchanged, please?

Ian White

analyst
#51

Appreciate it.

Benon Janos

executive
#52

Thanks, Ian, for that question. Regarding your first point about the net cash outflow — good catch. And that's right: in December, we had one special situation in our core market, the Netherlands, where we saw client outflows tied to a local tax rule, really for the first time in two years. Put simply, clients gained an advantage by taking cash off our platform. So we did see that. That said, it fully reversed at the start of the year. So it's a trend we viewed as an isolated event at year-end, particularly in December, and haven't seen since. So that's something we feel fine about at the moment and basically wouldn't read too much into. As for the guidance range — clearly, when you do financial planning and consider various outcomes, it's always a mix of many different input variables, with how much clients trade ultimately being the most important one. But if client activity remained at precisely 22, and if deposits stayed at exactly €3 billion, then reaching the 50% would probably be a bit harder.

Benon Janos

executive
#53

But new client additions, plus a modest uptick in trading activity that we've genuinely observed at the start of the year — and the start of the year was in fact quite strong in February as well — so this isn't merely the January effect. That said, we believe we're positioned much closer to the upper end of the range we provided. We're completely aware that the range sits at roughly €10 million to €12 million at the midpoint, below your assumptions; another way of seeing it is that there are two analysts, I believe, who publish — or who account for source — on the net income line, with adjustments in the order of €8 million to €10 million, and that may be a reasonably good figure to use when making projections for the year. So that accounts for perhaps two-thirds of the gap between our midpoint and yours, with the remainder reflecting maybe a conservative stance simply on the deposit base. Also on the interest rate — our weighted average interest rate observed on our deposits. So it isn't the average ECB interest rates, but the average weight we observed was approximately 3.5% last year.

Benon Janos

executive
#54

And that's pretty much the identical figure we're planning for this year, though thankfully we're holding somewhat higher balances. And your final question concerned the cost guidance and depreciation line — we don't anticipate any major changes this year versus last year. We're in the last phases of the growth wave that the absolute depreciation line captures. We'll share more details on that a bit later, probably around the year's time when we present the exact mechanics and give a sense of when we reach a peak, so to speak, and when perhaps the total assets to be depreciated decline a little. But that isn't happening. This year — that's most likely to happen in 2025.

Ian White

analyst
#55

Alright, understood. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#56

Thanks. <<operator_script>> Our next question comes from Benjamin Kohnke at KBW. Your line is open, so please go ahead.

Benjamin Kohnke

analyst
#57

Morning, gentlemen, and thanks for taking my question too. Benon, perhaps I could begin by drawing on your perspective a bit regarding the turn margin loan business. I mean, you've implemented considerable price rises. Can you now make it available to the whole zero customer base, or are you merely signaling a margin loan book of roughly €1 billion, which would be largely flat? So I'm curious whether you might offer some thoughts on that reasoning — is it perhaps price sensitivity, with you factoring in reduced volumes against increased prices and higher interest rates? Then another question, maybe somewhat tied to that one. I mean, I realize commenting on competition is always tricky, but I mean we saw Trade Republic arrive with, I think, rather impressive figures. Some press reports have suggested they're now weighing a margin loan launch too. So the competitive landscape may also feed into how you think about the margin loan guidance. And maybe one final question returning to gross margins — I was honestly somewhat taken aback by the figure we saw in Q4, and heading into Q4, given that, at least if my math is right, and I believe you confirmed this in Q3, making the adjustments, it stood at roughly 90%, and the mix in Q4 at least ought not to have been any worse.

Benjamin Kohnke

analyst
#58

You mentioned that for the full year '24 it ought to come in somewhat above the 82% recorded for the full year. So you're not merely returning to that level. Could you perhaps revisit the makeup of that gross margin once more and explain why it isn't larger going forward? Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#59

Alright, let's begin with the margin loan business. That business consists of two parts: volume and interest rate. Where volume is concerned, the figure has stayed fairly sticky. Across many, many prior quarters it moved around between €900 million and €1 billion. Right now we're near the lower end of that. Bringing the products to a wider base has — has effectively let us grow it slightly, and even while lifting rates substantially and in part doubling rates, the book hasn't declined. So that's a favorable factor that will again produce a meaningful contribution from the interest line that we'll see thanks to the margin loan, though it isn't growing 30% annually. So although we expect the book to grow, it isn't growing quickly. Still, the economic benefits of the loan do of course increase. On the Trade Republic margin loans, everything I know is what appears in the newspapers and the banking license. They said they will do that. So I'm confident they will. I have no details on it. I think a general remark is that we see them in Germany. In the other 15 countries where we operate, we see them less.

Benon Janos

executive
#60

There's one remark I'd potentially like to offer. And regarding gross margin — apologies if I wasn't clear when I responded to that question a bit earlier — but our expectation is that it will come in somewhat below 80% rather than above it.

Ian White

analyst
#61

All right. And yeah, that 92% — I think it's roughly 80%, or something like that — going from 90% in Q3 down to 80% in Q4. Honestly, I still don't really get why it dropped that much.

Benon Janos

executive
#62

We'd like to follow up with you on that. We want to move to answering it precisely.

Ian White

analyst
#63

Thank you, Benon.

Operator

operator
#64

Thanks. We have no more questions lined up. At this point, I'll turn things back to Frank Niehage for his closing remarks. Thank you.

Frank Niehage

executive
#65

Yes, thank you so much for spending some time with us. On behalf of everyone here, we hope the remainder of your day is wonderful, and we appreciate your support—all the best.

Operator

operator
#66

Thanks, everyone. That brings us to the end of today's call. We appreciate your participation. Stay safe. You can disconnect now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.