flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 26, 2024

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Financials Capital Markets earnings 52 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the flatexDEGIRO Analy Call for Q1 2024. I want to let you know that this call is being recorded, and throughout the call your lines will remain in listen-only mode. That said, there will be a chance for you to ask questions toward the end of the call. To register your question, simply press star one on your telephone keypad. Should you need assistance at any point, just press star zero and an operator will connect you. At this time, I'll turn things over to your host, Mr. Achim Schreck, who will bring in today's conference. Thank you.

Achim Schreck

executive
#2

Morning, everyone. I'm Achim Schreck, and I lead Investor Relations at flatexDEGIRO. We're glad to welcome all of you to the analyst call about the Q1 figures that came out yesterday evening. As always, we'll walk you briefly through the numbers before we take questions. It's a real pleasure to have the entire management board with us today, and to kick things off, I'd like to pass the floor to our CEO, Frank Niehage. Frank, over to you.

Frank Niehage

executive
#3

Okay. Thank you, Achim. Morning, everyone. Welcome to our firm's Q1 earnings call — which is also my final one. As usual, before I begin with the quarter's highlights and then pass things over to the CFO, let me take a few personal moments, with mixed feelings. By stepping down, I am hoping to prevent any further harm to our firm's reputation and to settle the friction with the founder ahead of the upcoming annual general meeting. Having served 10 years as CEO of our firm, the moment has come to say farewell. First, I want to thank you — the analysts and shareholders — for your trust and your support; working with you has been a pleasure. You also pushed me, and that helped a great deal. So please keep giving the firm and its new management that same support. Obviously I will remain a key shareholder of the firm, and I will take pleasure in watching this firm's amazing, profitable growth story going forward, and I hope we stay in touch now and then, since the school of life has taught us that we always meet twice. Second, I want once more to thank all our employees.

Frank Niehage

executive
#4

I already covered that in an internal email, but once more, thank you everyone for the tremendous backing, accomplishments, and dedication — and let me single out one individual in particular for thanks. That's our Chairman, Martin Korbmacher, with whom I began this journey together and who ranks among the most professional bankers I've ever had the privilege to work alongside, and a wonderful person as well. Back in the day, some referred to him as God's gift of investment banking. Absent the professional relationship between chairman and CEO, our firm's success story could never have come about. Should you doubt me, you can read about it in a study published by the Reinhard Mohn Institute — one I always enjoy citing — which examined the performance of listed companies and underscored just how crucial the professional relationship between those two roles of chairman and CEO is in shaping company performance and, last but not least, the stock price. If you don't remember how our stock price has performed over recent years, I'm glad to give you the figure, which comes to more than 550% to date. And incidentally, that beat the DAX across the same stretch. Or, viewed from a different angle, market cap appreciation over that same period works out to 11x.

Frank Niehage

executive
#5

Let me take a few seconds here to bring you back in time. About 10 years ago, another shareholder named Christian Angermayer persuaded us to rescue the distressed Fintech Group, and at that point flatex was a niche broker focused only on Germany, based in Kulmbach, losing money, with approximately 120,000 clients. The founder, along with the supervisory board member at the time, kicked off a conflict with the key partners and steered the company into a dead end, with EUR 8 million in EBITDA losses. Together we settled on a fresh strategy of independence from the founder, requested that he resign his supervisory board seat, moved the head office from Kulmbach to Frankfurt, agreed to dilution via capital increases, and set about improving corporate governance. Two major acquisitions — the XCOM BIW Group deal in 2014 and, clearly, the DEGIRO acquisition in 2019 — were, among other things, a game changer. I could continue on and on, but given the timing, I would rather turn to where things stand today. We have built Europe's largest online broker, listed in the SDAX, with headquarters in Frankfurt. This year we are moving toward serving 3 million clients, with 1,300 employees drawn from 30 nationalities, operating in 16 countries throughout Europe.

Frank Niehage

executive
#6

We created a genuine European champion. Having occupied the CEO role for such a long stretch makes me extremely proud. This company is run extremely well, stands on very solid footing, and earns high profits. Yet isn't it odd that right now the very same founder attempts a return as a supervisory board member via the back door, asserting he knows better what benefits the company? I'll let all of you answer that. My trust is that the incoming management team will keep pursuing the strategy of profitable growth. And let me make one final request. Kindly sign up for the approaching annual meeting and use your voting rights. It works as in democracies: should you not vote, you back minorities. Regarding the agenda for the approaching annual general meeting, what matters most — and clearly everything matters — but allow me to spotlight the share buyback and the fresh long-term incentive plan for employees. And finally, please back our Chairman, Martin Korbmacher, who will ensure professionalism, good corporate governance, and the sustainable, profitable growth strategy. That returns me to why we are on today's call. Let's discuss how profitable the first quarter turned out to be now. These are the highlights. We kept managing our costs very effectively, and we did bring in over 120,000 new clients during the first quarter.

Frank Niehage

executive
#7

And we accomplished that by lowering CAC from above 100 EUR down to 95 EUR — a fantastic effort from the marketing team. We pushed monetization further as well and lifted revenues per trade once more. Now let's dig into the specifics. Revenues rose 25%. EBITDA climbed 177%. And on top of that, income was up 341%. Those are what I'd call strong figures. And finally, net cash inflows came to EUR 1.8 billion. And as I've said repeatedly on the last couple of calls, that's without earning any interest — which shows we attract the right clients, people who come to us to trade rather than to save. It comes as no surprise that we anticipate the guidance landing at the upper end of the range we gave. And of course, should interest rates fall in summer and trading activity strengthen, you all know where the guidance will go. But naturally, I'll now leave that decision to the new management going forward. Lastly, as always, I'll pass things to the CFO. He'll shift gears and walk you through the details. And thanks once more to all of you — please take care.

Frank Niehage

executive
#8

Benon, you have the floor.

Benon Janos

executive
#9

I really appreciate that, Frank, and a good morning to everyone. In my role as CFO of flatexDEGIRO, I'm glad to welcome all of you to this Q1 2024 financial call as well. But before I turn to the financial figures, which really shouldn't contain any genuine surprises for you, I want to give my deepest thanks to Frank. Frank and I first met back in 2013, over eleven years ago, and I wouldn't be standing where I am today without his vision and his backing. Nobody I've ever come across has been more inspiring or more passionate than Frank. I've also picked up a great deal from him over the past decade. Thank you for your great leadership and your vision. You will be missed. Best of luck in everything ahead of you, Frank, and many thanks — you really should feel proud. Representing the management board today are Frank Niehage, Stefan Simmank, Christiane Strubel, and myself, and I'd also like to take this chance to welcome Stefan and Christiane, who are seated beside me right now. Following Frank's departure, Stefan and I will move forward to jointly lead the business under an interim mandate. The supervisory board has been running a structured process and has stayed in close contact with us in recent weeks, and we feel very well informed regarding the search for a suitable successor.

Benon Janos

executive
#10

We're glad to back the new candidate as soon as he's made known to us. And again, we want to thank Frank personally for steering the flatexDEGIRO ship across a decade. Stefan and I, though, have collaborated on a professional basis and in a constructive manner, including at our prior employer in our roles since 2001. Rest assured that will carry on. One further item before we move to the figures. We take particular pride in having recently been given a substantially higher ESG rating by MSCI. During April, MSCI lifted our rating by 2 notches, moving us from double B to single A... For some perspective on those ratings, among the peer group of investment banking and brokerage, inside the MSCI All Country World Index, a mere 15% of companies sit higher than flatexDEGIRO. Morningstar Sustainalytics reaffirmed our ESG rating within the low-risk category. Still, we've bettered our score and now stand in the risk rating, ranked as number 4 out of a total of 147 in the investment banking and brokerage category, where a lower rank is preferable and signals reduced risk. Now turning to commercial performance. Gross customer additions came to 121,000, up 8% year-on-year and 57% sequentially.

Benon Janos

executive
#11

Roughly 25% of those newly opened customer accounts — around 30,000 — were acquired under the flatex brand in Germany and Austria. Assets under custody hit a record EUR 58 billion, rising 29% year-on-year and 12% quarter-on-quarter. We processed 16.1 million transactions, essentially unchanged year-on-year despite fewer trading days, and up 19% sequentially. Over recent quarters, client trading activity has stayed fairly steady, with a slight increase in Q1 of 2024 versus Q4 of 2023. That places us around the middle of the pack among competitors. Still, Q1 of 2023 showed higher trading activity. On assets under custody, the story is fairly simple. Client cash deposits of roughly EUR 3.6 billion in the fourth quarter were basically flat sequentially and have risen about 10% across the past five quarters. Securities under custody climbed to EUR 54.4 billion, helped by higher index levels and new client purchases. Being able to build the cash position over recent quarters is a very encouraging sign, even with the aggressive and costly scramble for client deposits seen elsewhere in the market. Cash inflows of EUR 3.8 billion against cash outflows of EUR -2 billion left us with a net inflow of EUR 1.8 billion.

Benon Janos

executive
#12

Our margin loan book grew a bit, which brought net investments on our platform to EUR 1.9 billion in the first quarter of 2024. Cash held under custody is essentially flat. Commission income came in at EUR 75 million and interest income at EUR 44 million, with other income of roughly EUR 4 million, for a total of EUR 123 million. As a result, revenues rose 25% year-on-year and 23% sequentially. Commission income increased 10% year-on-year and 36% sequentially. Interest income reached a record EUR 44 million in the first quarter, 65% higher than the first quarter of 2023 and 13% higher than the last quarter of 2023. Now on to trade monetization. On average, we generated 4.64 EUR per transaction in the first quarter of 2024. That figure is up 12% year-on-year and 13% sequentially. We usually see an uplift each year in the first quarter thanks to selected fees that are mostly paid during that quarter, but a few additional points may help. We stepped away from some low-earning trades, while at the same time reaping the full benefits of price increases implemented in mid-May 2023 on the DEGIRO platform.

Benon Janos

executive
#13

We've also observed strong U.S. trading volumes overall, and that works to our advantage for FX conversion. On top of that, the trade mix in Q1 leaned somewhat toward transactions carrying a higher commission per trade. EBITDA — which we keep emphasizing for comparison purposes — rose 177% to EUR 54 million versus a year earlier, and gained 4% quarter over quarter. Net income came in at EUR 30 million, basically unchanged sequentially and roughly 340% higher than in Q1 of 2023. A few points on how costs moved in the first quarter relative to the same quarter a year ago. Current personnel expenses increased by EUR 3.4 million, reaching EUR 24.9 million, driven by an 8% salary increase tied to inflation implemented in early 2023, along with new hires connected to the BaFin audit. We anticipate both of those effects will be considerably milder across the final three quarters of 2024 thanks to base effects. We managed to cut marketing expenses by 33%, from EUR 17.2 million down to EUR 11.5 million, and therefore lowered client acquisition costs from EUR 153 to EUR 95. Other operating expenses are basically unchanged. We'll now walk you through the financial topics connected to our annual general meeting on June 4, 2024.

Benon Janos

executive
#14

Today, the agenda and related documents are going up on our website. The share buyback is being divided into 2 votes so that the rights of all shareholders are properly reflected and protected. One vote covers the share buyback without any possibility of excluding subscription or tender rights, and that item needs a 50% quorum to be approved. There is also a vote on the share buyback where exclusion of subscription and tender rights is possible. That vote calls for a 75% quorum for approval and provides the company with more flexibility. So effectively, with a 50%-plus but under-75% vote, the company can still repurchase shares, though it faces more limitations than under a 75%-plus vote. Either way, the share buyback's individual and combined size is capped at 10% over 5 years. We are also putting to a vote a new long-term incentive program running across a time span of 6 years. It is a stock option plan made up of approximately 5.5 million shares. That equals 5% of the shares outstanding, with a 4-year vesting period and a 2-year execution period. It features a share price-related factor with a 30% hurdle rate, plus risk-adjusting factors.

Benon Janos

executive
#15

To reiterate what was said earlier, at this point the documents have not yet been posted on our website. That will take place over the course of today, so we won't be in a position to answer detailed questions regarding the AGM on today's call, and we would kindly ask that any inquiries be directed from Monday onward, in the usual way, to our investor relations department and to Achim Schreck. One last slide concerns our pillar three transparency report, which we also released last night. Risk-weighted assets fell from EUR 1.3 billion at the close of 2022 to EUR 908 million at year end, 2023. The main driver is the reapplication of credit risk mitigation techniques, as we communicated to the market in September of 2023. At group level, our common equity tier one ratio came in at approximately 27% at year end, 2023, compared with about 20% at the close of 2022. Once again, the biggest contributor to this substantial improvement is the reapplication of credit risk mitigation techniques. With respect to using our 2023 annual profits for our core tier one capital, no application was submitted under Article 26, Section 2 of the Capital Requirements Regulation, or CRR for short, to count those profits as regulatory own funds within our group.

Benon Janos

executive
#16

Theoretically speaking, the CET1 ratio might have climbed to a level considerably higher than 32% had we sought this treatment, or a corresponding future decision, at the AGM with no additional plans in place. Once more, that was purely a theoretical observation. At the close of 2023, our CET1 ratio is 27%. The decision not to apply came in light of the AGM proposal covering dividend and share buyback, since a significant share of 2023 profits is earmarked for those. Right now we are working out the precise figure. We are likewise wrapping up our calculations regarding the effect of introducing the third iteration of the capital requirements regulation, CRR3, which takes effect for every EU bank at the start of 2025. Broadly, CRR3 may result in elevated capital requirements and more intricate processes. After all the work is finished, we will update the markets as appropriate. So we would politely request that you remain patient and refrain from posing detailed questions regarding the 2024 share buyback amount at this moment. We appreciate your understanding. With that, we wish to bring the financial presentation to a close, and it is my pleasure to return the floor to Achim.

Achim Schreck

executive
#17

Thanks, Benon, for walking us through the figures. At this point we're glad to take your questions about the Q1 financials.

Operator

operator
#18

Everyone, just a quick reminder — if you'd like to pose a question or share something on today's call, hit star one at this point, and if you want to take your question back, press star two. Our initial question is from Benjamin Conklin at KBW. Go right ahead.

Benjamin Conklin

analyst
#19

Morning, gentlemen. I trust you can hear me clearly. I have a few questions of my own, if I may. Could I begin with marketing, perhaps? Unless I'm mistaken, on the previous call you provided a budget of EUR 30 to 35 million for the year. Now, given what appears to be a pickup in retail trading activity, are you beginning to see more and better opportunities, I suppose, for winning customers in this kind of new environment? And would you think about stepping up marketing efforts? And then, secondly, perhaps staying on the trading environment. This morning there were a few reports regarding trading volumes from some of your new broker peers, arguably indirect in nature only. If accurate, they look very strong for the first quarter, correct? The question here, I guess, is twofold. Why do you believe flatex is not growing as much, or, you know, in an inferior way, a significantly inferior way here? Do you have any concern that the likes of Trade Republic are increasingly eating into your target customer base? That would be all for me, yeah.

Benon Janos

executive
#20

Thanks a lot, and good morning. I’ll begin with the marketing question. So yes, the range is roughly EUR 30 million to EUR 35 million, and at present we don’t really have plans to alter that. What we are seeing is that as we began moving somewhat away from brand marketing toward targeted marketing, we can keep bringing in new clients while our client acquisition costs are substantially lower. If we should need to raise the marketing budget because client inflow rises meaningfully, we will respond and probably do that. At the moment, everything is aligned and on track, and we’re comfortable with the plans we have now. That’s what I’d say about the first question. As for the second question, I’ll hand things over to Achim Schreck.

Achim Schreck

executive
#21

Thanks, Ben, and hello, Ben. Yeah, so regarding that… I believe the article concerned trading volumes at a single exchange — the indirect picture, so to speak, of what is going on in the market. First of all, as we have said a few times already, the customer group in question is a different one. So naturally we know nothing about their trading activity, the size, the profitability, et cetera, and on that basis we would also prefer not to comment further or speculate. As you are all aware, there are certainly several additional players in Germany, also when compared with our international business. But I think the figures in the first quarter have now demonstrated that of the 122,000 new customers we gained, roughly a quarter came from the flatex brand in Germany — sorry, for Germany and Austria. So we are quite pleased with our performance and our development. So I think that is everything we would like to say at this point in time.

Benjamin Conklin

analyst
#22

Okay, thanks so much. And perhaps just one brief follow-up question, if I could, regarding personnel cost. I was somewhat taken aback to see such a sharp year-over-year rise, particularly since you recorded roughly EUR 3 million of inflation bonus during the first quarter of last year. And just to verify, Ben, I believe what you mentioned on the previous call was a roughly flat development in personnel cost compared with a year earlier. I simply wanted to check whether that figure included or excluded the sales component. Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#23

To start, our goal is to end 2024 with a smaller workforce than we had when the year began. We went through the usual Q1 round of salary increases, and it was considerably more benign than the one last year. That said, our personnel cost base clearly went up because of the hires we made, mostly during last year, and some of those people who joined our platform near the end of the year. We'll watch how the year unfolds, but our plan is definitely not to expand our employment base, period. And if we find we need to make salary adjustments at any point during the year for whatever reasons, to keep our people happy, then we'd choose to do that. So personal costs could rise mildly, but headcount will not.

Benjamin Conklin

analyst
#24

Alright, but does that figure include sales on both, or does it exclude them — for both of those metrics?

Benon Janos

executive
#25

When it comes to 2024, every figure we're giving includes any SARS expenses.

Benjamin Conklin

analyst
#26

All right, thanks.

Benon Janos

executive
#27

In 2023, we obviously had figures both adjusted and non-adjusted.

Benjamin Conklin

analyst
#28

Absolutely, absolutely, and thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#29

Marius Fuhrberg from Warburg Research has the next question. The line is yours.

Marius Fuhrberg

analyst
#30

Thanks for taking my questions. I have a few from my side too. First, on revenues per trade, which rose quite a lot, including quarter-over-quarter — did you make any price increases at DEGIRO in Q1, or what specifically drove that? Second, regarding the competition fine you got in Italy, which you received last year in Q2 — any progress on that, and on your fight against it, and any visible timeline for court dates or for when to expect any sort of repayment or confirmation of the fine? And my last question: last year in some calls, you mentioned that you plan to enlarge the credit book at the Zero — any comments on that? What actions are you taking in order to do so, and how are you looking at it right now?

Achim Schreck

executive
#31

Thanks for those questions, Mario. I'll begin with the first one, about revenues per trade. As is always the case in financial markets, there's that good old rule: never extrapolate January, and never extrapolate Q1. We've witnessed a favorable combination of effects, and that produced this really nice commercial per trade figure, and very clearly, we expect that figure to decline in Q2, and the full 2024 figure to be, of course, below the Q1 figure. There were a few effects at play. So indeed, we raised prices on the DEGIRO platform around May of last year, which therefore contributed only partially to 2023 figures, but fully into 2024 figures. But we've also seen a trading mix that was pretty highly skewed towards US trades, where we do benefit through the FX conversion, and we have also seen a mix slightly positively skewed towards more ETP trades. And that is something that produced the figure we posted for Q1. Please expect that figure to decline in Q2. On the competition fine in Italy, there's no news we can report. There is no real timeline, and once we receive any formal updates, we will certainly mention it on one of the upcoming calls.

Achim Schreck

executive
#32

Regarding the credit book at DEGIRO, it did indeed expand. It is rising. It is not doubling, clearly. We made the product offering available to all DEGIRO clients, but that is a process in which most clients who wanted it previously already had the option to obtain it by changing their client status. The impact we have observed is mild, but it still contributes to the expansion of the Margin Loan book.

Marius Fuhrberg

analyst
#33

Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#34

Panos Ellinas from Morgan Stanley has the next question. The line is yours — go ahead.

Panos Ellinas

analyst
#35

Hi there, thanks for taking my questions, and best of luck to Frank. For the first one, could you perhaps share how much U.S. trading you saw during the quarter as a share of total trades? And also, if you could share the level of FX commissions in the quarter and how that compares with the same quarter last year, Q1 of last year. That's my first question.

Achim Schreck

executive
#36

Hi Panos, this is Achim. Hello. These are details we'd rather not disclose at this point, but just so you get a sense of, let's say, how big the effect is. If you compare quarter-over-quarter, we had essentially an identical count of trades — actually 200,000 fewer than in the first quarter last year. That difference is mostly a decline in CFD trades, so trades that aren't very profitable and aren't part of our core business. So then, if you look at essentially the same trade count, the change in provision income, which is roughly EUR 7 million, mostly comes from the price changes we've implemented on the DEGIRO side. And the remaining portion comes from more U.S. trading. When we say more U.S. trading, it isn't the count of trades — it's the larger volume of trades that we've seen. Of course, our FX benefit depends on volume, since it's 25 basis points when customers ask us to handle the FX conversion for them. When it comes to the U.S., it's a volume effect rather than a trade-count effect.

Panos Ellinas

analyst
#37

Sure. My next question concerns the fact that flatex trading activity rose year-on-year, while DEGIRO remains lower year-on-year even with stronger customer growth. Could you provide additional detail on activity and the signs you have observed so far at DEGIRO? And to finish, regarding guidance, you are now aiming toward the upper end. Could you share more of the drivers and what gives you greater confidence about reaching that upper end? Do you see potential upside to previously guided customer growth or trades per customer, or is it mostly driven by better monetization for the rest of the year, and likely higher NII than you initially expected due to the cash balances? And then one more, if I may. Clearly, net profit growth has developed positively, but the margin remains low at about 24% versus the other listed European platforms. So, considering that interest income likely becomes a headwind as we approach the rate cuts, do you see scope for further improvement in the net profit margin over the next couple of years?

Panos Ellinas

analyst
#38

That's everything I had to share. Thanks very much.

Achim Schreck

executive
#39

Thanks, Panos. Perhaps I'll begin with what you asked regarding how much trading DEGIRO did compared with Flatex. When you take into account that we had fewer trading days, I believe trading, or the count of trades at DEGIRO, would likewise have come in flat or a touch higher. Germany has in fact done better, and Austria too. What we've observed, then, is more of an outperformance, and I think that ties back somewhat to the question Ben raised at the outset regarding what we are presently seeing in the German market — namely that development there has been rather positive. Still, there are no genuine specifics at this point about particular DEGIRO markets where trading activity would differ materially. On your second question, about what might be somewhat different compared with the start of the year, I'd probably point to two things. The first is something you can see in the presentation, namely the commission per transaction, which we would not have anticipated at these levels, and we covered the details a few minutes ago. So that is a positive for us. And moreover, given the circumstances — the battle for deposits, so to speak — we don't take part, and yet in spite of that, we managed to grow our base of cash deposits, and that figure now sits at a level that is in fact somewhat above what we would have imagined.

Achim Schreck

executive
#40

I'd say those are likely the impacts that caught us off guard the most, if you will. Regarding net profit margin, I think we're in a year where profitability is genuinely shifting in a meaningful way compared with last year. There's also a rationale behind our providing a range for consolidated net income. I think once 2024 is behind us, we'll have a fairly solid benchmark for what our general net profit margin, or the range for net profit margin, might be going forward. Panos, does that address your question?

Panos Ellinas

analyst
#41

Yes, that's quite clear. Thanks a lot, and once more, best of luck to Frank. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#42

Our next question is from Ian White at Autonomous Research. Ian, you have the floor.

Ian White

analyst
#43

Hello there. Thank you for taking my questions. I have a few follow-ups from my end, please. Regarding costs, could you walk us through how sensitive they are to revenues? Essentially, are costs likely to move with revenue? Is it only transaction-related costs, or are there other components within staff, or even investments you might make if revenues came in, say, above your guidance, or, or, or would that mostly just flow through to EBITDA, please? That is question one. Second, I was interested to understand, is there anything else notable to call out or understand regarding client trading activity, aside from just the trades per client? Do you see more clients being active, for example, in the first quarter, more clients logging into their accounts? I am just wondering if there are any broader indicators of client trading interest in the first quarter. And maybe just a slight follow-up on the previous comments. What have you specifically tweaked in your thinking regarding the guidance for 2024? Is the base case now for cash to be, you know, somewhere higher than EUR 3 billion on average for the year? Is it commission per trade at, I don't know, EUR 4.40 or something like that?

Ian White

analyst
#44

What adjustments have you made to your model that lead you to say things will land at the upper end of that range? Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#45

Thanks, Ian. I'll begin with your first question. Most of the expenses tied to trades sit clearly within the COGS line. So once you factor that in, from that point there's a fairly direct fall-through into EBITDA. There aren't any special effects we'd have to apply in order to bring in more revenues through trades, apart from paying the usual market data providers, exchanges, custodians, and everyone else who receives a fraction of the trade revenue when we settle a single trade. When it comes to interest income, the costs — the COGS line — are obviously even lower, and it drops through more directly, but that's also why the entire line is lower than it was in the past, and we don't expect effectively any major changes. If trades rise meaningfully in the second half, so to speak, then the cost of goods sold line will rise a little, because interest income will be part of the mix, smaller relative to commission income. On client activity trends, I'll hand it over to Achim.

Achim Schreck

executive
#46

Okay, thanks, Benno. Regarding client activity — meaning the count of customers who’ve completed at least one trade, which is our definition of an active client — yes, we did see growth during the first quarter. What we observed is that a larger number of people were active. On one hand, there’s the normal seasonal lift, since the first quarter always tends to be strong. It may be a touch better than that, though we’re still talking about roughly 30 to 31% of clients having placed a trade on a quarterly basis. So yes, it’s up somewhat, but clearly nowhere near what we saw during the hype periods or anything like that. It’s a solid 2 to 3 percentage points above the prior three quarters.

Benon Janos

executive
#47

Regarding the reasons behind the revised guidance, the biggest factor, I believe, is genuinely the cash positions that we hold at our bank on behalf of clients, since we definitely anticipated a lower figure when the year began. Yet the mix also appears to be shifting quite favorably for us, and I hope that at some point during this call, or on a future one, I'll be able to speak about a more substantial uptick in client activity — but as of today, that's where things stand... On a sequential basis, there's a pleasant trend that looks consistent with what some competitors reporting numbers are showing. Still, let's be clear, we remain down year on year, and that is something we would like to tackle going forward.

Ian White

analyst
#48

Great, thank you.

Operator

operator
#49

Our following question is from Christoph Greulich at Berenberg. The line is yours — please proceed.

Christoph Greulich

analyst
#50

Good morning, and thank you very much for taking my questions. I have two, please. The first concerns the buyback. I completely understand that you’re unable to provide detailed figures here, but could you give us a somewhat broader view of the execution plan—what your thinking is on that? Will it proceed in, say, a roughly linear fashion, or are you aiming to do it more opportunistically? And really, depending on where the shares stand at the moment, essentially buying back more or fewer shares. Then the second one: could you give us a brief update on the situation involving the special commissioner of BaFin—whether there is anything to report regarding the timeline, or any update? And thirdly, perhaps also a bit of an update on what the pipeline looks like with respect to commercial initiatives. What are the things you’re working on, and what can we expect over the coming months and quarters? Thank you.

Benon Janos

executive
#51

Regarding the buyback, as mentioned in my remarks, we can't give you an exact figure at this point. There are some considerations I raised in my speech that we still need to complete. What we can share, though, is that this isn't a matter of spreading 10% of the shares outstanding across five years, which is what the German Securities Act permits. That's not what this is about. Once we've wrapped it up, you'll hear from us. As for the special commissioner, fortunately there's nothing new to report — no developments, nothing changed, and no news is good news. We remain on schedule to complete the remaining tasks so that the special commissioner can conduct his review and conclude his mandate. Our current expectation, consistent with what we've said over recent quarters, is that this will take place in the summer. So happily, there's nothing further to update on that front. When it comes to the pipelines of potential commercial products, Stefan, myself, and the management team will need some time to get a full handle on what the potential timelines look like. That's why we're somewhat reluctant today to present figures on it. We'll return to this with you at some point in the months ahead, but 2024 is clearly a transition year for us, in the sense that the regulatory matters have thankfully been largely resolved.

Benon Janos

executive
#52

Most of them, though not every single one—and that commercial side can gradually work its way into our company, something we're very much looking forward to.

Christoph Greulich

analyst
#53

Okay, that's all quite clear. Thank you. Could I just ask one quick follow-up about the marketing budget? So from what you've said about the budget for the year, it sounds like, yes, it'll be more or less flat versus 2023. If I look at the Q1 figure, that was down quite significantly. So am I right in understanding that marketing spending will have somewhat different seasonality than we've seen in prior years, with this strong skew toward Q1?

Benon Janos

executive
#54

Not really. The main shift, I'd say, is that starting last year we began moving away from brand marketing. Brand marketing had been a key part of our corporate strategy that we kicked off 5 years ago, back when our name wasn't widely known among the general population in the countries where we operate. We got to a point where we decided to pull back from that, and those efforts were very expensive. We've exited our sponsorship in Spain with the soccer club Sevilla FC, and we announced that we'll end the main sponsorship with the German soccer club in the middle of the year. That's marketing euros that will become available for other purposes, if needed. So for 2024, compared with last year, we'll lean more on targeted marketing, affiliate marketing, and other approaches. So I think there may be two elements here. First, we can lower our clients' acquisition costs, a trend that's clearly visible in Q1. And either that trend continues, or we'll simply be able to find more clients that we're willing to pay EUR 100 for, and then the number of clients coming onto our platform will be higher. So what we won't do is this: if client growth comes, we won't restrict ourselves to, you know, a fixed marketing budget.

Benon Janos

executive
#55

Still, at this point, I'd say your description matches pretty closely with what we're anticipating.

Christoph Greulich

analyst
#56

Great. Yeah. Thanks, Benno, and best of luck to Frank.

Benon Janos

executive
#57

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#58

One last reminder — if you want to ask a question, hit star one at this time. Our next question is from Andrew Lowe. Go ahead, please.

Analyst

analyst
#59

Hey, everyone. Appreciate you taking my question. Hopefully the connection's fine. I've got two quick things. First, would you be open to sharing what you're assuming for deposit balances through the remainder of the year? Second, back in February you pulled the guidance you'd been discussing — something like commissions per trade of EUR 435 — but on the conference call it sounded like you thought that number was somewhat too high. Does that still hold for the rest of the year? Should we expect commissions per trade to land under that EUR 435 level? Thanks.

Achim Schreck

executive
#60

Thanks, Andy. Actually, after I answer the second question, I'd like you to ask the first one again, since it didn't come through clearly. So regarding the revenues per trade, or the commissions per trade, that we saw in the first quarter — they've clearly been quite positive. One factor, as mentioned, is of course the higher share of US volume within. So if you were to assume that we'd continue to see similar-ish volume increases in US trading in the following quarters, then I think a number like EUR 435 might be reasonable. But of course, it still depends on that variable as well. Then please, could you repeat your first question, please?

Analyst

analyst
#61

All right, my apologies for that. I hope this version works better. I was just wondering whether you'd be open to sharing the assumptions behind your deposit balances for the remainder of the year. You clearly had earlier guidance of EUR 3 billion, which looked rather low, and it's now coming in much higher. So any guidance on what your guidance assumes would be great.

Achim Schreck

executive
#62

Right. We began the year assuming roughly EUR 3 billion, and now we're at the end of April, and that figure is still holding firm at EUR 3.5 billion, EUR 3.6 billion. So we obviously need to face facts and raise that somewhat. And that's also the primary reason we shifted our guidance range from the lower half to the upper half.

Analyst

analyst
#63

All right, thank you.

Operator

operator
#64

That brings us to the end of the Q&A, so I'll return the call to your host for closing remarks. Thanks, everyone.

Achim Schreck

executive
#65

Thanks a lot, and I appreciate everyone joining us. And of course, should you have any additional questions, I'd be glad to assist, and thanks as well on behalf of the management team here. So once more, thank you, and enjoy your Friday. Talk soon. Goodbye.

Benon Janos

executive
#66

Take care.

Achim Schreck

executive
#67

Thank you, everyone. That’s all from us.

Operator

operator
#68

Appreciate everyone being on the call today. At this point, you’re welcome to hang up.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.