flatexDEGIRO SE (FTK) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 25, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Achim Schreck
executiveGood afternoon, and welcome, everyone. Thanks for joining us for the presentation of our Preliminary Results 2024 and for our update on the Strategic Priorities. I'm Achim Schreck, and I head up the IR function at flatexDEGIRO. Before we go straight into the presentation, let me take care of a little housekeeping first. First of all, I'd like to welcome today's speakers. Joining me are Oliver Behrens, our CEO since October, and Benon Janos, our CFO, who has now been with us for 10 years. On the agenda: as usual, our setup is that we'd like to walk you through the preliminary single items worth highlighting in the P&L before we move into the outlook, and both of those will be presented by Benon. Oliver will then follow up with the strategic priorities, which we communicated yesterday evening as well as this morning, and with our roadmap for achieving our mid-term guidance in 2024 to 2027. Since today's presentation is open to all analysts and investors, we've decided to take questions through the Q&A tool you see here in the webcast, and we strongly encourage all of you to make active use of it already during the presentation.
Achim Schreck
executiveAfter the presentation wraps up, we’ll pause briefly for 15 minutes, and then we’ll move into Q&A. Once the Q&A gets going, we’ll also take it upon ourselves to bundle comparable questions together so that we can get through as many of them as possible within the time we have. Because of that, please understand that we won’t be reading out the names of individuals associated with the questions. I’ll go over the Q&A housekeeping again when we reach that point. But at this stage, without further delay, I’d like to pass things to Oliver for a few opening comments, please.
Oliver Behrens
executiveMuch appreciated, Achim, and a very warm welcome from me as well. I'm grateful you could be with us today. I'm Oliver Behrens. As Achim said, I came on board at flatexDEGIRO as CEO last October. It's clearly a real pleasure to be here in front of you today and to begin my first appearance by highlighting a record year for revenues and earnings — though it goes without saying that above all this reflects the success of my fellow Management Board members and over 1,200 colleagues throughout the company, who performed tremendously during times that weren't always easy. In some ways we made things harder for ourselves by falling behind on regulatory requirements previously, yet we've now largely put that right. With the special commissioner's mandate finishing in September and BaFin cutting our SREP by 150 basis points in December, we're plainly heading in the right direction. And as we continue along that path, we now have the capacity to concentrate more again on commercial matters, on what our customers need, and on serving them better. Crypto trading's launch was an initial step, but just one among others still to come.
Oliver Behrens
executiveThat's the reason — and following quite an intense first month here, I'm really eager to also outline our strategic priorities and vision for flatexDEGIRO as we look toward 2027. Those priorities are going to steer us across the coming three years, letting us keep delivering value, particularly for our customers. And when you do right by your customers, or when we do right by ours, I'm convinced you're simultaneously doing right by your shareholders and your employees too. Our aspiration is to become Europe's leading investment platform for building wealth, and the strategy for reaching that goal rests on three core pillars. We'll grow the business we already have, broaden what we offer in products and services, and boost operational efficiency. So please bear with me a little. I'll go deeper into those three pillars further on. The opportunity sitting in front of us at flatexDEGIRO is extremely attractive, and I'm a very realistic guy. After 40 years in the financial industry, I know this won't be a walk in the park. Making it happen will take hard work, and there may be some bumps along the way. Still, the ambition we've set for ourselves for 2027 — growing revenue by more than a third and in doing so nearly doubling our net income — is what the entire management team is committed to delivering, on the basis of the individual initiatives I'll detail more later.
Oliver Behrens
executiveThat said, I'll stop my opening comments at this point and pass things over to Benon to start with, so he can walk through the preliminary 2024 results. Thank you.
Benon Janos
executiveThanks, Oliver. Good afternoon, everyone, from me as well. Thank you very much for joining today's presentation, and a very warm welcome to you too. Over the next few minutes, I'm delighted to walk you through our strong preliminary results for fiscal year 2024. Please keep in mind that these numbers remain preliminary. The complete, audited Annual Report 2024 is scheduled for publication on March 26. We've organized the presentation of our 2024 preliminary results into six buckets, namely: customer growth, commission income, interest income, revenues, costs and earnings, and the outcome of our 2024 guidance and, of course, what to expect for 2025. Please be aware that, given time constraints and to stay focused, we won't go through every slide uploaded in this morning's presentation in full depth. That applies in particular to the Q4 performance slides, which are in the appendix and won't feature in my presentation today. We'll return to the usual financial results format with our Q1 2025 quarterly figures. This time, though, the emphasis is on our three-year outlook alongside a record fiscal year 2024. First, let's take a closer look at our customer growth metrics for 2024 on Slide 8 and Slide 9.
Benon Janos
executiveI'm happy to share that throughout 2024, our month-over-month customer gains consistently beat what we saw in 2023, and we saw a notable pickup in the fourth quarter. The Q4 peak was certainly helped by greater market activity surrounding the U.S. election, but the broader trend clearly highlights how well our strategies are working and the rising demand for what we offer across Europe. For the full year, we added a remarkable 421,000 new customers, which works out to a 24% increase over 2024 — sorry, over 2023. On top of that, we've made considerable headway in optimizing what it costs us to acquire customers. During 2024, our acquisition cost per customer came in at €75, a 24% reduction versus 2023. That gain reflects our continued push to improve efficiency and get the most out of the money we put into marketing. As you may have seen earlier, we've hit an important milestone, with our customer base now above 3 million. Over the last three years, that base has risen by 1 million. This steady expansion reflects annual rates between 13% and 16%, demonstrating our reliable capacity to draw in and keep customers year-over-year even with a tougher base effect. And with these results, we managed to sustain our industry-leading customer growth, posting a compound annual growth rate of 14% across the past three years.
Benon Janos
executiveIt's worth pointing out that during this period, likely just one peer that isn't listed has shown stronger growth. That peer's growth, though, is largely powered by its shift from neo brokerage into neo banking. As you can see on this chart, despite all the challenges across the last three years, we have consistently ranked at the top of the industry in relative terms, and given that we have meanwhile built the largest customer base, even more so when you look at absolute numbers. Among the peers shown on this graph, we are the only player that isn't confined to one country or a small set of countries — instead we are taking on Europe as a whole. Let's now turn our attention to our active customer base. In Q4 of 2024, we reached the largest active customer base in our history, with close to 1 million customers actively trading. Please note that here we define an active customer as one performing at least one trade per quarter. The share of active customers per quarter has also shown a positive trend, rising slightly to 31% in Q4 of 2024. And while that share has been fairly stable at around 30% over the last two-and-a-half years, we clearly do see some room for improvement, which we will also come back to later in our strategic priorities.
Benon Janos
executiveTurning now to how our commission income has been developing. To start, on Slide 13 you'll see that we've kept a steady average range of 20 to 25 trades per customer per year across the past 2.5 years. Why do I mention two-and-a-half years, just as with the customer activity chart earlier? The reason is that the first quarter of 2022, and to a far smaller extent the second quarter of 2022, was still untouched by adverse external factors like the sharp rise in inflation and the Central Bank's response of raising interest rates. As you'd expect, trading activity has run higher at flatex, although we see quite similar patterns for both of our brands. Our flatex customer base is somewhat older and hence generally wealthier and more trading-savvy, which accounts for the gap versus DEGIRO. Let's turn next to growth and the count of settled transactions across our brands. A key driver behind our 11% rise in settled transactions has been our expanding customer base. In particular, our performance in 2024 has exceeded 2023, with faster growth especially visible during the second half of the year. Transaction growth also received support from external factors, such as the pickup in volatility and financial markets around the U.S., for instance.
Benon Janos
executiveThe election is in November of 2024. Let's turn to the next slide. Our average commission per transaction rose noticeably, and several key factors drove that. First, the price adjustments made in May of 2023 at DEGIRO have had a positive effect on our revenue starting in the third quarter of 2023. On top of that, a favorable product mix and a bigger share of U.S. trades added to this growth, with the latter especially evident in our strong Q4 figures. It's also worth noting that the first quarter typically comes with a higher commission per transaction because of seasonal effects. That comes from booking certain annual fees, which are usually charged in January or February of each year. To sum up, all of these factors together produced substantial growth of 20% year-over-year, which reinforces our strong financial performance and puts us in a good position for future success. Let's now move on and focus on interest income, our second most important revenue stream after commission income. In 2024, once again, we saw impressive net cash inflows onto our platform, totaling €6.6 billion, which is a 47% increase compared to 2023. We recorded positive net cash inflows of more than €500 million per month on average in 2024.
Benon Janos
executive95% of those inflows went into securities, compared with 91% in 2023. On top of that, we saw more cash per customer during 2024, which lined up with interest rates coming down. That development produced a 17% rise in cash under custody at year-end. So we now hold more than €4 billion in cash assets that our customers place with us and on which we pay no interest ourselves — a strategy we have followed consistently since flatex was founded almost 20 years ago. Let me briefly walk everyone through how those €4 billion of cash under custody are used to earn interest income. At present, roughly a quarter of the cash volumes is put back onto our platforms so that we can offer fully collateralized margin loans to our customers. Our margin loan book stood at €1.2 billion in volume at the end of 2024 and has gained considerably from our growing customer base and from the extra access that DEGIRO customers have been given. The average interest rate on these loans also rose in 2024. As for the rest of the cash under custody, we hold most of those funds overnight at the German Bundesbank. Even though interest rates declined over the year, on average they were still 9% higher than in 2023.
Benon Janos
executiveIn summary, we've observed rising volumes in interest income and rates across all the relevant segments, which produced a 32% lift in interest income, taking it to €180 million for fiscal year 2024. Clearly, rates will bring some genuine headwind in 2025. However, I'll address that in greater detail later, when I present the outlook for the current year. Before we get into costs and earnings for 2024, let's complete the overall revenue picture. All told, in 2024 we delivered the highest revenues in flatexDEGIRO's history. At €480 million, revenues beat the prior year's figures by 23% and stand a good 15% above even the earlier record set in 2021, the COVID meme stock hype year, when we reported €415 million in revenues. Interest income's share of revenues has climbed steadily over recent years, yet that trend probably won't carry on this year. Other operating income is largely tied to IT services and is usually a smaller line for us. In 2022, it was artificially inflated by the non-operating reversal of provisions for long-term variable compensation. Even though the underlying business captured in other operating income has mattered little across recent years, that ought to shift going forward.
Benon Janos
executiveOliver will go into more detail on that when he walks through our strategic priorities. Having taken a close look at our top-line, let's turn to costs and then to earnings. This slide shows our various cost items and how they have developed over recent years. I'll go a bit deeper into what is driving each of those cost items. You can clearly see that our operating expenses rose fairly substantially over the year, particularly personnel expenses and admin expenses — a trend we intend to reverse in 2025. Personnel expenses were up 19% year-on-year, reaching €116 million. Salary increases, along with hiring additional employees during the course of 2023 — actually in the context of remedying regulatory findings — drove that rise in personnel expenses. Please note that our personnel expenses already include €5 million of provisions for measures planned in 2025. We also capitalized roughly €2 million less of development costs this year. In 2024, we delivered on our commitment to hold the number of employees at year-end below the level we began with in January. We finished the year with 1,253 employees, roughly 4% fewer than the 1,301 we had on December 31 in 2023.
Benon Janos
executiveLooking ahead to 2025, we're now committing to push a little harder and hold the personnel expense line on the P&L at or under the prior year's figure. Those provisions are a key piece of getting us there. Turning to marketing, we've spent roughly 7% less even though customer growth has accelerated. With total marketing spend of €32 million, our average cost per customer acquisition dropped considerably, to €75 from €100 in 2023. Other administrative expenses rose to €61 million in 2024, versus €49 million in 2023. That climb stems largely from higher IT costs plus greater spending on professional services, legal, and consulting. Those costs were partly tied to projects related to regulatory requirements, and they helped us successfully close out the last severe BaFin findings, which is what led to the special commissioners mandate ending at the end of September last year. All told — and I mentioned this on our Q3 call back in October — our admin expenses came in up to €10 million higher. We intend to bring them down, concentrating on cutting what we spend on professional services, legal, and consultancy fees. As a side note, operating as a regulated bank means paying various fees that are levied based on the bank's actual size, whether that's on the balance sheet or in customer deposits.
Benon Janos
executiveNaturally, as we grow successfully, there's a tendency for admin costs to run higher. That means we must put in double the effort to get those costs down. Turning to the quarters: EBITDA margins came in at 40% to 45%. Beyond the one-off items already noted in personnel expenses—namely, the €5 million provision for personnel measures in 2025 and the €2 million reduction in capitalized development costs—we also recorded an extra €2.5 million in depreciation stemming from streamlining IT developments this year. Taken together, that amounts to a €9.5 million pre-tax impact, or roughly €6.5 million after tax. Put differently, our record net income of €112 million might have been markedly higher. Still, this more cautious, long-term-oriented approach has served us well and will keep doing so. Before we wrap up the discussion of our preliminary 2024 results, let's review how we did against our 2024 guidance. We entered the year guiding to revenue growth of 5% to 15% and net income growth of 25% to 50%. Following a good, solid first quarter, we lifted both to the upper end of those ranges. After the Q3 figures, we raised revenue guidance once more, to slightly above the upper end.
Benon Janos
executiveLooking at the figures we've just shown, we topped both of them, and that was powered by a fourth quarter that came in noticeably stronger than we had expected, thanks to the lingering impact from the U.S. elections. Revenue was up 23% versus a year earlier, and net income rose a robust 55% compared with the same period last year. On the back of those results, the top-line came in a bit above the latest market expectations, whereas net income landed slightly under. I think that's largely attributable to the one-off items I walked you through in detail a moment ago. So with that, I'll wrap up our review of the business year just ended and briefly turn to what we anticipate for 2025. Our expectation is a mixed overall picture, with growth in commissions' income offsetting a drop in interest income. At the same time, we'll be concentrating on reducing costs, as I already mentioned earlier. What that means is we see the top-line in a range of plus/minus 5%, with somewhat more optimism on the bottom line, where the range extends to plus 10%. Although our guidance rests on revenues and net income alone, this chart also lays out some key assumptions we've made to arrive at those numbers. A few of those assumptions could strike some as conservative — for instance, holding trading activity and levels of cash under custody merely stable despite the recent figures.
Benon Janos
executiveLike I said earlier, being careful and conservative has worked well for us, and we want to continue in that vein. Markets are capable of shifting fast, and circumstances can evolve. There's a meaningful amount of interest income headwind we need to offset. At this point I'm very glad to return the floor to Oliver, who is going to take you through our strategic priorities for the coming three years. The floor is yours, Oliver.
Oliver Behrens
executiveThank you, Benon. Before we get into more detail on the strategic priorities ahead, let me take a minute to frame where we are right now. The past three years have been pretty tough for us — partly because of a fairly sluggish trading environment, which at least was offset by our capacity to grow interest income, and partly because of the internal work we needed to do, and have now done. So today we're in a far stronger position. A few items remain outstanding — for instance, the last, less serious findings from the BaFin audit. And we'll address those thoroughly. So the deck may not be 100% clean yet, but it certainly isn't slippery anymore, which means we can start running on it again rather than tiptoeing around. And running is plainly the quicker route to our next milestones. So what is it we're running toward? Interest rates should decline further in 2025 and then stabilize in 2026. That will cost us some interest income, which we need to offset this year, as Benon noted in the 2025 outlook. At the same time, lower rates are broadly positive news for equity markets.
Oliver Behrens
executiveThat said, relying on this isn't our goal. We intend to take the driver's seat so we can speed up growth. To make that happen, we'll sharpen our commercial focus, improve the organizational setup, and reduce costs in areas where they have become bloated. Let me be very clear about this as well. Yes, revenues will benefit. Yes, earnings will benefit. And yes, our shareholders will benefit as well. But fundamentally, what this is really about is becoming Europe's leading investment platform for building wealth. That is the positioning we will claim for flatexDEGIRO. Everything else will follow from that. Not the reverse. In a fast-paced industry, you constantly need to deliver for existing and future customers and never rest on historic laurels. If you look at the strategic opportunity, there are three categories. The first category is focused on making sure we, as an organization, are fit for growth and create the high financial leverage that one would expect from a growing online platform business. Ensuring that we are running in one harmonized IT platform is key here. Second, there is an already existing huge potential, which are not fully — we are not fully utilizing.
Oliver Behrens
executiveOur customer base exceeds 3 million, yet the proportion who actively trade in any given year is actually under half of that figure. And the proportion of highly active customers producing 80%, 90% of our revenues is comparably small. That may be normal in our industry, but we want to put this, the business on a wider, more stable basis. Geographically, we have already started to diversify the business operating in 16 countries instead of just the Netherlands and Germany. And some markets are doing really well and have grown to quite some size. Especially in those key countries, we need to increase our local presence to ensure we properly understand market differences and serve special local customer needs. And finally, in this category, there are certainly opportunities in our treasury activities when I look at the €4 billion of cash we can work with. In the third category, you have products and services we don't have, but will launch over the next three years to enhance our offering. That's purely brokerage related on the one hand side, but it also includes revitalizing one of our legacy businesses, which is currently kind of hidden in the other operating income, namely business process outsourcing, where we basically can offer non-retail banks a solution to collect retail deposits.
Oliver Behrens
executiveWe refer to this as Deposits as a Service, so to speak. And although it's a business that we in assets already have. It falls into this second category of new products, as we're discussing leveraging the unique strength of a legacy site business to develop it into a relevant business line. We're simply witnessing a great deal of rising demand for this service, and we can meet that demand with a bit of extra effort. Launches of products and services are clearly driven by customer needs. At the same time, finding ways to boost our share of recurring revenues is also something we constantly keep in mind. For the next few minutes, I'd like to now go a little deeper into these three categories and add some more detail to the outline I've just given you. Increase efficiency — let me begin by establishing the foundation for what forms the basis of every successfully growing business, an efficient organization, and what we will focus on to get the most out of this future growth. As Benon mentioned in his comments on our cost base, it currently is a bit too high. There are good and valid reasons for it.
Oliver Behrens
executiveWith DEGIRO now acquired, our robust expansion, and the BaFin conclusions — which, frankly, were homemade — we've reached a stage where reversing this pattern is simply necessary. Certain cost cuts are already underway, and you can see that reflected in our cost base, which fell between Q3 and Q4. That effort absolutely has to carry on. Much of it concerns administrative items like legal and consultancy fees. Beyond that, we must also question the broader ratio linking headcount, revenues, and profits. A quick comparison of revenue per employee or net income per employee against a broader peer set shows we don't come out looking too good. In certain areas, the growth initiatives I just outlined will help us expand into the organizational structure that has already been built. In other areas, more cost work will be required, and Benon already noted that our 2024 accounts include roughly €5 million in provisions for those measures. Will that be sufficient to fully close the peer gap on revenues per employee? In most respects, probably yes. On net income, no — our business model inherently carries somewhat higher marketing costs, for which, in return, we should also expect industry-leading growth to keep coming.
Oliver Behrens
executiveOn the ballpark figures side, we'd anticipate keeping operating costs firmly under control across the coming three years, even with the top-line growth we expect. Lowering complexity — lowering complexity is likewise the key phrase for my final slide on this strategic category. We've already said publicly that we're in the middle of converting from a German Aktiengesellschaft into a European SE. That gives us added flexibility, yet above all it is simply a far better reflection of our DNA as a European leader. Our goal is to make the move to the SE as early as some point in the second half of 2025. Finally, we're also making good progress shedding certain legacy alternative credit and investment engagements that bear no relation whatsoever to our core business. Most of them were taken on during the period of negative interest rates, yet looking back, they weren't worth the effort and have essentially delivered zero yield across the last three years. Put differently, no money has been lost on them, but we can certainly put that capital to far better use going forward. Grow and strengthen the existing business. In online brokerage, with a cost-efficient organization, you can generate considerable operational leverage, especially in a setup led by fixed costs such as ours.
Oliver Behrens
executiveYet that's really only enjoyable if top-line growth comes along with it. So in what way do we intend to get there? Let's begin with what's available within the business we already run. With a solid customer base to build on, across the past 3 years — none of which benefited from extraordinary market circumstances like COVID or meme stock hype — we've delivered customer growth of 13% to 16% each and every year. Naturally, we'd like that trajectory to keep going in the future. And if we merely add another 10% per annum, we'll pass the 4 million client mark before the end of 2027. Now, you could simply look at history and trust it will carry on that way on its own, or you could set out concrete measures that back up your assumptions. Launching new products will, of course, make us more appealing to both new and existing customers. But it's equally about enhancing what's already in place. As an example, in January we brought on another Platinum ETP partner in Germany. We'll refine the search functionalities, the market data we offer, and strengthen portfolio analytics and charting tools — none of that is rocket science, yet every bit of it matters. So does the overall customer experience in the app, appealing offerings for different audiences, and targeting those audiences appropriately in our marketing efforts.
Oliver Behrens
executiveWhat these initiatives do goes beyond helping us bring in new customers. They also matter a great deal when it comes to activating, or reactivating, customers who are currently inactive. So the metric in question here is the proportion of active customers. During 2024, a bit under 50% of our customers completed at least one trade, one transaction. And you can see a clear gap between the individual cohorts, as shown on the slides — that is, the years in which we onboarded new customers. It probably comes as no surprise that in the COVID years we gained a large number of additional customers, whom we never targeted through our marketing and who, as a result, essentially arrived for free on top of the customers we would ordinarily have won during those years. Obviously, those three customers are of lower quality from our perspective, in the sense that they are less active and therefore dilute the group-wide activity rate. What is quite encouraging to see is that the last two cohorts already — meaning the new customers we won in 2023 and 2024 — show an above-average level among those customers who may not have completed a transaction but still hold meaningful assets on our platform. On the one hand — on the other hand, we will also refine our communication processes so as to engage with customers on a more personal level, so that a higher share will not even become inactive in the first place.
Oliver Behrens
executiveTo get more specific, if you look country by country, the top six nations make up approximately 80% of our customer base. We have half of that base in our home markets of the Netherlands and Germany, but also in growing markets like Spain, Austria, France, and Italy. We've built a presence that justifies taking a more localized approach in those countries. That begins with adapting our offering and communication to local needs, but it also extends to establishing local relationships with partners and regulators. As a first step, we're talking about a fairly limited local staff presence. Beyond our current customer base and market footprint, my 40 years of experience tell me there's additional potential in our treasury strategy as well. Of the roughly €4 billion in customer cash at flatexDEGIRO on which we pay no interest, a good €1 billion is deployed for fully collateralized margin loan business overnight at the German Federal Bank. That's excellent for avoiding risks, and you even earn some interest on it, but it's likely not the most efficient approach. We're examining somewhat more active strategies without giving up our sentimentally risk-averse stance.
Oliver Behrens
executiveYet given how large these deposit balances are, a mere single basis point of improvement on average would already translate into €0.25 million in additional pre-tax profits. We'd also like to expand those funds further by offering term deposits to customers down the road, which would once again broaden the product range we provide to customers without cannibalizing existing business, while at the same time reinforcing our maturity profile. That wraps up the category of growing and strengthening the existing business, so I'll move on to new product ideas and how we can diversify our offering further. Launching a new product was essential very late last year and very early after my arrival, and the rollout of crypto, which was the first product, began in mid-December. The pickup so far has matched our initial expectations. Our offering does stand out in the German market, since we give full transparency on the total cost of a crypto trade. With most customers — most peers, you'll find marketing claims like no commission, just the spread. But that so-called spread is significantly bigger than most people would expect.
Oliver Behrens
executiveWhen working with us, customers can count on a figure ranging from 0.6 to 0.7 of the volume. And having said that, the pricing here is considerably more appealing than what a customer would pay elsewhere. On the — apologies, there's a lot going on with this slide. Regarding the operational setup, we opted for a partnership structure, working alongside experts in the relevant fields, which speeds up our time to market while also reducing operational and liability risk on our side. Since launching crypto, our customers can now trade in nearly every major asset class on our platform. Down the road, we might explore products that are still missing, like foreign exchange. As for our international rollout, we have already filed our MiCAR license application with the BaFin and anticipate a response from them by the close of this quarter. Our dialogue with them is going very well as we work toward that. As the roadmap shows, our initial focus will be the geographical rollout, and only afterward will we broaden the product offering. The upcoming go-lives are scheduled for flatex Austria and DEGIRO in the Netherlands, France, and Spain, with additional DEGIRO markets still to come later this year.
Oliver Behrens
executiveOn the new product side — another one we've already mentioned is securities lending, which would let our clients loan out a portion of the stocks and ETFs they hold so those holdings can produce extra income. Right now the emphasis is on DEGIRO, since Dutch law makes the process considerably simpler. As we see it today, roughly 20% to 30% of DEGIRO's assets would be especially appealing to specialized security lending desks at global investment banks. That works out to somewhere around €7 billion to €10 billion currently, with the basis point returns generated split among customers, us, and the partners needed to facilitate the process. Savings plans are a more basic-looking product — frankly, we need to do some catch-up there to make sure we're giving customers a state-of-the-art offering, including the ability to add single stocks into our savings plan, which requires handling fractional shares. In Germany, there's an ongoing political discussion about introducing capital market-based elements into the pension system. At the end of 2024, the former government put forward some promising proposals in that direction, and we believe the new government — however it ends up being formed after last Sunday's election — will take up this topic again with some priority.
Oliver Behrens
executiveSo having a robust savings-plan product available in the market once those pension accounts actually exist is therefore really essential. For an online brokerage like flatex, the appeal will mainly come from growing customers over the long term and from how sticky those customers are, along with their assets. The product itself will probably carry fairly low commissions, and trading activity in these accounts will likely be rather modest as well. Still, we shouldn't underestimate the underlying effect of getting millions of Germans more in touch with capital-market investing. Even more important, the government will very likely shift its tone toward capital-market investing, and that will help our business overall. That said, we're optimistic, but let's wait and see until the new government has finally taken shape and what specific proposals they put forward. And this isn't a discussion happening only in Germany. Across Europe there's a growing need to tackle the pension gap, or unfunded pensions. We're also planning to potentially add products tailored to clients in a lower risk category or with less appetite for risk, such as structured deposits.
Oliver Behrens
executiveStrictly speaking, these aren’t saving plan products, but we’ve included them here too, since they serve a very similar target audience. Deposits as a Service — the final item regarding new products — is Business Process Outsourcing, which I referred to as Deposits as a Service earlier in my opening remarks. For over 10 years now, we’ve been providing our banking capabilities to non-retail banks that wish to draw in term deposits yet lack the infrastructure needed to handle thousands of clients. It’s a white label solution, integrated seamlessly into how the partner bank presents itself in the market. It’s a fairly small business at present, sitting within our other operating income, and in a negative interest rate environment, frankly, trying to grow in this area hasn’t been attractive. Still, the market environment has shifted, which makes it far more appealing now — and not only because of the positive interest rate environment. Demand generally for sources of retail funding is expanding quickly across the European financial market, propelled by changes to the European capital requirements directive, yet not every bank has retail presence in Europe. Our service offering will likely prove quite useful for many players seeking to meet these new requirements quickly and efficiently.
Oliver Behrens
executiveHaving laid out all those measures, I still need to give you a summary of what happens when we add up all the individual pieces. We've deliberately chosen to do this using 2027 figures. By that point, we anticipate the measures we've presented will be running at full speed, which lets us look at a full-year impact. So to sum up, our ambition is to speed up top-line growth in our core banking business unit, and also in non-brokerage where Business Process Outsourcing is concerned, helping third-party banks bring in term deposits from retail customers. Alongside that growth, we'll watch costs carefully, cut complexity and bring our IT landscape into further harmonization. Although we're concentrating on organic growth measures, lower complexity and harmonization will clearly also pay off handsomely if any M&A opportunities come along. If we deliver on these measures, combined with the improvements already achieved during the past two years, we'd expect to win back the capital markets' full trust as well, and to keep narrowing the valuation gap versus our peers. In financial terms, these measures should, we expect, let us produce revenues of roughly €650 million in 2027 and net income of roughly €200 million.
Oliver Behrens
executiveIf we measure that goal against the record results we posted in 2024, it works out to about a 10% CAGR on the top line and 20% on earnings. With that, let me pass things back to Benon right away so he can offer a few comments on how we're thinking about capital allocation. Thanks.
Benon Janos
executiveThank you, Oliver. 2024 was another robust year, with net income comfortably above €100 million. I realize that given how solid our capital structure is, many of you are quite keen to get a clearer picture of how we will allocate capital from here on. As you're aware, during 2024 we set aside €55 million—roughly 75% of 2023 profits—to fund a modest dividend along with a share buyback program, which will keep running for approximately another two months. To date, we have repurchased slightly more than 2% of outstanding shares, and the approval from our AGM covers as much as 10%. That leaves considerable headroom. That said, during the past month, ever since Oliver came on board, our attention has been entirely on strategic priorities and on building a solid grasp of what is possible across the coming three years, which is what we laid out for you today. Prior to communicating details to shareholders about the timing and scale of future capital allocation, we will now complete our annual financial statements and, using these additional measures, refresh our mid-term financial plan—covering capital planning and risk modeling as well—so that we do not constrain our options in any respect. After this work and any follow-on talks with the regulator are finished, we will be in a position to discuss a mid-term policy on a firm factual footing.
Benon Janos
executiveWe appreciate your understanding. And many, many thanks as well for being with us today. I hope Oliver, Achim, and I have managed to provide a solid overview of how flatexDEGIRO developed over the last business year and of our strategic roadmap going forward. Of course, though, we also want to offer you the chance to raise any further questions you may have on these matters. Achim, perhaps back to you again, and could you take us once more through how the Q&A session will work?
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks, Benon. And thank you, Oliver, for that informative presentation. As we said at the start, we'll now take a 15-minute break. Quite a few questions have already come in, but please keep sending them through the Q&A tool. As mentioned earlier, we'll group them and respond to as many as we can. If we can't get to all of them, don't worry — the IR team, meaning myself and Laura, will follow up with each of you individually. Thanks for your attention so far. We'll return at 3:15 German Time. Thanks again, and see you in 15 minutes.
Oliver Behrens
executiveWe'll be with you shortly. Thanks.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks, everybody. Good to have you back for the Q&A portion, which is happening now. Sure enough, a good number of questions have come in already. Our initial plan was to allot roughly 45 minutes to Q&A. We're glad to add 15 more minutes, though after that we really do need to head off and catch our flight to London. Still, we'll do our best to get through as many of your questions as possible, just as we mentioned at the outset. Let me kick things off with one for Oliver. You said regulatory shortfalls are now mostly fixed — what remains to be done?
Oliver Behrens
executiveWell, thanks, Achim. Obviously, we've zeroed in on what came out of F3 and F4, though a few findings from F2 and F1 exist as well. So we're tracking well when it comes to fixing those and putting steps in place that get us past them. My sense is that a majority of these matters are now essentially folded into the BAU routine, which is what keeps us, you could say, from drifting off course where our risk and control framework is concerned.
Achim Schreck
executiveBenon, I have one question about the 2025 guidance for net profits — why is that target growth rate not based on adjusted net profit, excluding one-offs?
Benon Janos
executiveRight. That's a practice we actually ceased over a year back. We no longer make adjustments to figures. Our emphasis tends to be on the top line — revenues — and after that we look at reported net income. And as we did today, we walked through certain one-offs that sit within the net income line. Still, that isn't something we'd formally present as an adjusted net income line. In my view, it's for each investor or analyst to run their own calculations off those one-offs. But we don't adjust the numbers we report.
Achim Schreck
executiveOliver, I’d like to ask about crypto trading and how development stands now in January. Could you expand a bit on where we are, what we’ve accomplished up to this point, and what the initial numbers currently look like?
Oliver Behrens
executiveYes. I think adoption, as I said during my presentation, has tracked pretty closely with what we had planned for. Right now, our clients are doing roughly 500 transactions daily. The encouraging part is that we've set up a desk in our Berlin office, which works well for people who already have jobs. Keep in mind we've only launched in one market so far — an organization where we're able to make a real difference by bringing out new products. Additional markets will come into the picture <<inaudible>>.
Achim Schreck
executiveAnd broadly speaking, a shift toward the SE figure for trade.
Benon Janos
executiveBroadly speaking, the way our system operates is that at present we aren't anticipating any non-linearity or step function down the road; we keep expanding our IT systems further. We still capitalize personnel costs, though at a somewhat lower pace this year than the prior one. And ongoing investment in the platform ensures we're able to handle those transactions. One good illustration is the crypto offering we now have in Germany. That marks the first offering of ours requiring 24X7 trading. So it's typically a major deviation from trading that runs between the exchange opening in the morning and closing in the evening. We managed to accomplish that with no significant impact. So on the whole, we believe we can handle it internally with our own software code and without unusual non-linearities.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks. On that other income line — do you see it getting to 10% of revenues over the long run, or is it going to stay more of a single-digit thing?
Benon Janos
executiveWell, that would come to €48 million versus what was reported a year ago. I'd certainly like to see that figure materialize, but we shouldn't get ahead of ourselves. Our aim is to ensure we complete the shift in the business model, and that's actually a really key point Oliver already raised. And I want to stress this: when you're treated as a services supplier and get paid per product, you typically earn a 20% margin on the business. That has always been the case. If, though, you suddenly can serve a specific business need and help a bank or another party provide part of their funding, you can suddenly receive basis point charges. So the question here is — and no contract has been signed yet — how many basis point charges can we obtain, on which projections; that's what it all comes down to. At this point, I mean, this is the first time we've communicated this strategy, and we want it in swing in 2027, which might be a bit ambitious.
Oliver Behrens
executiveAnd perhaps to build on that annuity income — I believe it's really overall revenues driven by volume rather than by transactions. In Deposit as a Service, we figure there's a solid opportunity to shift from, say, a ticket fee per account over to basis-point fees. But beyond that, there are the other initiatives — let's see what we can pull off with savings plans, particularly using equities, where alliance <<inaudible>> essentially you're able to take your five stocks and begin with five shares, for instance, and set up a savings plan. We can offer reshuffling and rebalancing. So there are lots and lots of methods for generating annuity income. The initial move in that direction is securities lending, which likewise charges fees tied to volume. Our proprietary deposit offering will similarly carry fees based on volume. We simply need to demonstrate that we can get ourselves there, and that is precisely why we're concentrating on these handful of topics — and we won't alter course; we'll execute on them.
Benon Janos
executiveThank you, Oliver. Turning to how costs developed in Q4, there are four questions about individual cost items, and I'm glad to walk through them. The first one concerns what the €5 million provision booked in the fourth quarter of 2024 actually is. And frankly, put very simply, that's a cost we have taken of approximately 5%, all other things being equal. So when you do that in certain geographies, Germany in particular, you clearly have to enter into negotiations with our employees. So this amount has been earmarked for that purpose, in order to reduce our overall headcount further. Could you give more color on the €2 million capitalized expense in the fourth quarter? What is the nature of those expenses? If the question is about the €2 million or €2.5 million of additional depreciation we have taken, that relates to minor products within the DEGIRO software code where we simply stopped development and simply cleaned up the depreciation asset base. If it's about less capitalization on personnel-related costs, it's simply the fact that we simply needed fewer man hours to spend on developing new code over this past year. The next question: if we exclude the €5 million one-off expense in Q4, we still see a substantial increase in personnel expenses of roughly €4 million quarter-on-quarter.
Benon Janos
executiveWhat’s driving that? And should we view it as a lever that can be sustained in 2025 too? That is, naturally, an excellent question. I’ll go into a little more detail on it. Oliver brought with him 40 years of experience across a range of banks in Germany. He has made it clear that, broadly speaking, as a bank we have paid our employees somewhat less. If you compare monthly salaries and additional salaries with the industry standard, then if you run the numbers, on average we have handed our employees roughly 50% of a month’s salary. The norm in Germany is considerably higher. Since we had a record year and since we had fantastic earnings, we chose to return some of that money to our broad employee base by way of a higher short-term incentive bonus, which was booked in December/in the fourth quarter. What is your current CET1 ratio and what is the regulatory requirement? Could you share your thinking on capital return to shareholders, please? Okay. So the regulatory requirements are communicated mainly via the known SREPs, and they are unchanged. Everything that has been communicated still holds as of today. We have reached a point at which we no longer put future CET1 ratios on any slides.
Benon Janos
executiveWe know it’ll rise once our books are fully audited and published, and we either seek the regulator’s approval or wait for our AGM so shareholders can approve it. If we did the math, we’d likely land at CET1 ratio levels above 30%. That said, as I mentioned earlier, we previously included them in charts because they were a very sensitive topic. Thankfully, that’s no longer the case. But let’s first complete the annual audit, get the figure formally approved, and then we can communicate a new CET number, which will be presented at that point. Overall, though, our capital base and our regulatory capital base remain very well covered.
Achim Schreck
executiveThere's one more thing I wanted to ask about the rise in personnel expense, and I think you've already addressed the bulk of it. Perhaps just to add one point — part of the question is also that, if I'm not mistaken, you said headcount was lower than a year ago, which makes such a sizable increase a bit counterintuitive. Could you shed some light on that? That would be much appreciated.
Benon Janos
executiveTo be completely honest, this is counterintuitive to me as well, and I—along with the rest of the team—obviously had to dig into it the same way to get a full picture. A few factors are involved in grasping it completely. To begin with, many people joined the platform toward the close of 2023. Hiring during 2023 was therefore weighted to the back half. So if you begin and finish the year with a set headcount, you nonetheless get a year-on-year effect that looks entirely different. It's just the mathematics of it: the 2023 figures come out substantially lower since a large share of those people arrived only late in the year. That effect is one of the causes. We also have general salary increases, which represent a significant and sizable line. There are still legacy consequences from the enormous inflation witnessed across recent years. And in the general salary line, we saw a 4% to 5% increase last year. There has also been an increase—which I just mentioned—that we booked during the fourth quarter against our variable compensation on the short-term incentive line. That reflects a situation where we simply wanted to give some of that money back to our employees, given a record year.
Benon Janos
executiveAnd honestly, there was also a Christmas bonus item of roughly 2 million that got recorded in Q4 as well. So it's clear to us that this personnel line represents a peak in 2024, and now we need to put in the work to ensure that in the year ahead it is — as I said earlier — flat or lower.
Achim Schreck
executiveThank you, Benon. flatex has always positioned itself as an alternative for investors who use traditional banks. That said, fixed income or bond trading — which many investors consider essential — is not offered by flatex. What is the reason flatex doesn't provide this, or are there any plans to change that?
Benon Janos
executiveWell, generally speaking, bonds are something we do offer, so we might not be recognized as a bond trading house, but anything that carries an ISIN can typically be traded — though as always, exceptions exist in certain countries that come with certain limitations. Italy is among those markets where we observe a degree of protectionism from Italian banks regarding full access to the Milan Stock Exchange for those products. Still, by and large, our intention is to keep going and grow the bond product line. That line wasn't significant during the zero interest rate environment, but clearly it's not at the levels it was before now, though it continues to hold relevance.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks. Over the course of our plans through 2027, could you give us an indicative CapEx budget, compared with the roughly €40 million or so that we spent annually in 2020 and 2023?
Benon Janos
executiveWe’re still a company that’s growing, so in the past we continued adding staff. So we’ll keep working on our software code, and as we go forward we’ll keep replacing and potentially expanding our data centers. For the crypto offering, for instance, we needed to purchase servers with special technical requirements that we hadn’t had before. So it’s actually quite similar to the regulatory reporting — sorry, the regulatory capital question, because now that we’ve communicated what we’ve planned to deliver on products, we’ll go back, finish our annual numbers, and then do proper capital and cost planning, which today we have, however, not at the scale and granularity that would be needed to, for example, talk to the regulator.
Achim Schreck
executiveThose targets incorporate customer growth of no less than 10% each year, and that's under the roughly 14% we saw in the prior year — so what's behind that conservative assumption compared with the historical growth? Are you anticipating increased competition, and how do you view customer growth by market and by segment? And the crypto offering ought to give customer growth a lift as well, shouldn't it?
Benon Janos
executiveYes. On that 10% figure — I get why some might see it as low, especially since January was already pretty decent for us. Could you repeat the question?
Achim Schreck
executiveNo, I can’t agree with that.
Benon Janos
executiveAll right, apologies — the question disappeared off my display, so I’ve, uh, lost the thread.
Achim Schreck
executiveCustomer growth accounted for 10% of the 14% we’ve seen historically, and that holds across markets and segments.
Benon Janos
executiveYeah. On the customer growth line, we might be a little conservative—that’s clearly true. Still, we did well by being a notch cautious. And keep in mind that our general customer line has grown over recent years, and as we go forward the base effect keeps getting bigger. Crypto trading is a product that helps, though it remains small. We operate in 16 countries. Right now we’ve been live for two months in one country. So we are seeing expectations clearly in line when it comes to trade count, notional traded, client activity, and frankly assets under custody as well. But it’s too early to say whether we’re really attracting new clients just because of this offering. We haven’t yet truly rolled out our marketing initiative for that product in Germany. We’ll do that over the course of the year. So once we roll this product out, that will be a question for 2026. But given the reasonably attractive spread we’re going out with, we probably should get some attention from clients who prefer trading with better spreads than elsewhere. There was a third question embedded in there.
Achim Schreck
executiveWhen it comes to markets and segments.
Benon Janos
executiveOur business has been divided into three groups: core countries, growth markets, and the rest. That structure isn't going to change. Naturally, we put more marketing dollars into the core markets and the growth markets. As of today, we don't anticipate altering that. We don't currently have — we don't have any marketing campaigns devoted to individual research countries at this point. That could shift down the road, but at the moment our focus stays on the countries Oliver displayed in his chart during his presentation.
Oliver Behrens
executiveYeah. I believe there’s plenty of work ahead of us in these core markets, and the opportunity there is substantial. So let’s stay focused.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks. And Oliver, I’ve got one question for you about how you generally see M&A. Would you view flatex as a natural consolidator in the European online brokerage market? And are there any interesting opportunities you’re seeing?
Oliver Behrens
executiveAs I said earlier, I believe we've narrowed a good deal of the gap between our value and where we ought to be over the last few months. We stayed level with the other publicly traded peers. A great amount of our time will go toward merging our platforms, making that platform more scalable still and capable of taking in other entities. So right now, I'd put it this way: we'll be quite occupied with our own affairs, so to speak. That said, we'll keep an eye open and, yes, remain open to talks, should the occasion to examine that arise. But right now what matters to us is combining the two companies—at least on the platform side—into one, and after that differentiating what we offer across the various countries with the different flavors that are needed and required.
Achim Schreck
executiveI appreciate that.
Benon Janos
executiveThe next one concerns guidance, and it has disappeared again. A quick remark for the IT folks at the back: could you please avoid clicking questions away before they get answered?
Achim Schreck
executiveYes. I believe I’m feeling — no, it’s returned.
Benon Janos
executiveLet me address that. There are a few points here. First, the ETF train keeps moving, and further ETF penetration will always be a broad trend. We haven't observed anything departing from that. Our stable commission income per trade has been strong — very strong — thanks to a heavy emphasis on the U.S. market and U.S. stocks. The top seven U.S. stocks, from NVIDIA to Alphabet, have been traded very actively. We believe those trends can hold, though a decline is always possible, especially if the general ticket size comes down when markets fall. Crypto in Germany has so far been accretive, for whatever that's worth. But since we haven't fully settled the pricing of the crypto product in other countries, it's difficult to judge whether that can continue. What I can say is that today, over the two months of crypto trading in Germany, looked at in isolation, it would have slightly raised the average commissions per trade, given that the notional volume traded appears higher than we may have expected.
Benon Janos
executiveAfter we shift over to DEGIRO, that figure could shrink somewhat, or it could end up matching the volume of transactions that happen on the DEGIRO platform.
Oliver Behrens
executiveTo build on that point, it's quite clear that clients across different age brackets gravitate toward different financial instruments. So you've got plenty of younger clients — or, let's say, first-timers, people coming into contact with financial instruments for the first time — and they tend to go for the ETF savings plan, right? But as they advance in their wealth positioning and their savings, they branch out into other products. And there's a natural progression, particularly among the younger generation, toward trying crypto as the next step, because among their peers it's used as a financial instrument that gets added to the broader understanding that they need to do something for retirement, and that ETF savings plans are the best step — the first step into saving. And that's clearly visible: as Benon described in his remarks, with us, most clients still use shares as the primary instrument for their diversification — especially, the deeper they get into it, the more they want to see the individual instruments. And there's an advantage to seeing the shares in the portfolio rather than, in the extreme case, just seeing one asset as one ETF in the portfolio. That's why we want the product in the middle to hopefully be popular as well — where you can pick the stocks your friends hold, your family holds, your peers hold, or even the people in your country hold, to have a savings plan based on shares.
Oliver Behrens
executiveLooking at individual shares inside the portfolio hits you differently on an emotional level than simply holding a single asset as a wrapper, whether that's a fund or an ETF.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks. And perhaps just to touch a bit on commission income for each trade — are there any pricing changes you're planning for transactions across the next 3 years?
Benon Janos
executiveRight now we don't have any broad plan to introduce additional pricing structures. We might make minor tweaks in specific markets, but set against the work we've completed at DEGIRO across the past three years, nothing is currently under consideration.
Oliver Behrens
executiveNaturally, we go over our pricing tables once a year to check whether we’re competitive and whether there are areas for improvement. But as things stand right now, as has been set out, there’s no meaningful change in course. There will be small actions where some areas involve currency exchanges and — but that’s minor — minor points that won’t have a significant impact on earnings.
Achim Schreck
executiveOn the capital side, there are a couple of questions. One of them, I believe, has already been addressed — that's the currency Tier 1 ratio with 2024 net income included. The other one is about how much capital would be on hand for distributions to shareholders and for potential M&A.
Benon Janos
executiveYes. So to begin with, we've already set aside €50 million for the share buyback. Those funds are also deducted from regulatory capital. As a group, we brought in roughly €89 million of free cash flow during 2024, and we're pleased to have a solid foundation. There's one particular item, and that's the third iteration of European banking regulation coming into force. Where capital requirements are concerned, it represents a step change. We're very well prepared for it. However, the complete picture will only become clear once the books are audited and we have, so to speak, the initial report containing fully audited figures. So it's a figure substantially higher than €100 million. Still, let's work through the calculation when we reach that point, and we'll address it on one of the upcoming quarterly calls. That's likely the best approach to it. And on top of that, the €50 million already earmarked is deducted. On this, much like the M&A opportunity, the same math applies — whether we deploy the money toward M&As, which as of today aren't on the table, or return it to shareholders, from a financial standpoint that's a very comparable calculation.
Achim Schreck
executiveAnother thing that's come up is that earlier in 2024 we obviously announced and kicked off the share buyback program, but since December no shares have actually been repurchased. And in the guidance and the report, there's currently no mention of capital allocation to shareholders. But does M&A mean any kind of shift in that?
Benon Janos
executiveNo, it doesn’t mean anything. So please don’t read too much into that. We brought in a third bank to handle the share buyback on our behalf. We’ve set targets for how much we intend to repurchase, and we’ve agreed on the timeframe; that plan is now fully in motion. I’m also somewhat surprised that for an extended period there have been no purchases. But ultimately, it comes down to their discretion. We still expect €50 million to be repurchased over the coming period, or including the €28 million we have today. So the remaining €22 million will be repurchased over the next weeks, and we will complete the full €50 million by the start of the second quarter, so there are no real changes there.
Achim Schreck
executiveOliver, could you put some numbers on what we should expect from securities lending through 2027, and how the margin would break down between customers and ourselves?
Oliver Behrens
executiveSo, naturally, how clients will ultimately embrace this is an open question, but as I believe I noted during my presentation, the figures regarding assets eligible for sec lending and the initial focus market—which is DEGIRO's market in the Netherlands—come to roughly €10 billion in volume out of the €31.5 billion in assets under custody and equities. Once fully rolled out, we anticipate revenues landing in the neighborhood of the €20 million mark plus. So when you combine that with the existing B2B Deposit as a Service business and add a bit of growth, we're not too far off from the numbers that have been floated for 2027.
Achim Schreck
executiveDoes flatexDEGIRO aspire to add a social trading component to its platform, the way some rivals have done?
Oliver Behrens
executiveRight now, there aren’t any plans for that on our side.
Achim Schreck
executiveAlso, do you have any plans to introduce an asset management product over the next few years? For example, your own ETFs through partnerships with current issuers? Or do you see room to charge platform fees on customer investments in third-party funds?
Oliver Behrens
executiveWe keep a close eye on what competitors are up to. Obviously, there's some jitteriness regarding payment for order flow and possible regulatory shifts across Europe. That is precisely why I came up with the concept of share-based savings plans, which let an individual, or groups of individuals, choose the shares themselves, or basically let people follow others and replicate their investment approach. To my mind, that offers a bit of social assistance, so to speak, from professional investors toward those seeking guidance, and we're able to charge fees for that. I'd say it's hardly a strong argument to muddy accountability and roles in this area. What we do is build a platform carrying every product on offer, where clients can then pick whatever suits them. Should we combine that with — pardon me, our own offering and go head-to-head with asset managers? Probably not.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks. So returning to the M&A subject, I have a couple of questions. First, I believe this has already been addressed pretty thoroughly regarding what sorts of M&A opportunities you'd consider. But in addition, when it comes to the 2027 targets, do those factor in M&A, or are they calculated on an organic basis?
Benon Janos
executiveI’ll go ahead and take those questions. So that is an organic basis — it covers the clients we already have, along with new products we deliver and bring onto the platform — and it’s spiced up with possible improvements coming from our treasury activities.
Oliver Behrens
executiveOur discussion stays focused on what we understand, rather than on what we don’t.
Achim Schreck
executiveRegarding the things we're familiar with, perhaps you could go into more detail on the business opportunity for Business Process Outsourcing or Deposit as a Service.
Oliver Behrens
executiveYes.
Achim Schreck
executiveCould you clarify exactly what it is, how much revenue this business might potentially bring in, and what type of fee structure we should expect?
Oliver Behrens
executiveFollowing what happened with Silicon Valley Bank and with instant payments arriving, most bank CEOs—and the regulators too—got nervous, and let's remember why: clients could move funds with a single mouse click, away from a bank that had landed in the headlines and toward what they saw as a safer place. From the regulators' standpoint, and likewise from the standpoint of the chiefs of a great many banks, funding sources have to be diversified. That, in my view, is the reason the net stable funding ratio came about. This ratio essentially examines the various sources, how long those sources run, and the binding terms attached to them. Certain banks lean entirely on capital markets funding, particularly where they run a monoliner business. So there are multiple parties with whom we will be speaking. What do we offer? Essentially, what we offer is that we build, so to speak, the Internet branch, the online branch—one that is essentially a slave to our own offering, though solely for deposits—on our platform, which can serve different mandates. In a way, then, it stays invisible to the clients. They therefore see the deposit offering of X, Y, Z bank, and it will be administered on our platform.
Oliver Behrens
executiveWe handle the whole range — KYC account opening, call center services, monitoring — and we'll provide the cash as well, and from the client's perspective that's completely transparent, since that client will be a client of X, Y, Z bank. But essentially, we'll be delivering the service platform for it. That helps them diversify where their funding comes from, and it's a very valuable proposition. We think there are at least a handful or more clients, potential clients, out there who are willing to consider our services, because in this field they don't view us as a competitor. So I'm firmly convinced an opportunity exists. There's also a CR requirement that foreign banks essentially must not rely entirely on funding from their parent company. Let's not forget that foreign banks in Germany right now have roughly €2 trillion of balance sheet, and they also lend to large players in the market. And those loans, along with the capital and most of the funding, are mostly sent by the parent. And within the EU and the regulation there's also a need for — or, let's say, it's called Klumpenrisiko if your concentration risk all comes from your parent — and they will also seek diversification of funding.
Oliver Behrens
executiveThere are lots of ways you can diversify where your funding comes from. Repos are one route; issuing bonds is another. Still, collecting retail funding brings a meaningful advantage, since it's regarded as extremely, extremely sticky. To us, that looks like an opportunity. We intend to look into it. For 2027 we have modest figures in the plan, though we'll have to see if we can clear that hurdle. I hope that addresses your question.
Achim Schreck
executiveBenon, I have one more question for you. As you said, there's the divesting of non-core financial engagements that currently earn zero interest. How much capital would be unlocked once those divestments happen?
Benon Janos
executiveSo, well, looking at 2025, that's likely to bring a modest uptick, though across the years they haven't done so. When we consider pure capital and cash, the figure comes to roughly €100 million in total, and of that, €30 million is what we intend to complete this year. As I said earlier, the contracts are signed, yet the deal hasn't closed, and the remaining 60% to 70% is what we'll be examining across the coming two years.
Achim Schreck
executiveThank you. One question asks whether it isn't typical for new customers to be more active when they onboard and then steadily decline as cohorts get older—which I think ties to the cohort chart we showed earlier.
Benon Janos
executiveI can take that one. If you’re talking cohort analysis, that’s arguably one of the holy grails of online brokerage, and examining cohorts in detail gives you a great deal of information. You see plenty of trends. It isn’t necessarily a universal pattern that activity always declines as clients age. What matters more is how sticky a client is from the moment they’re onboarded. So when someone joins and becomes familiar with stocks during a period of fairly high volatility, those clients tend to keep showing above-average volatility. Yes, above-average activity. Activity may fluctuate along with how attractive the market is. But it’s baked into the DNA of the cohort that a client learned stocks, or trading stocks, can be interesting or beneficial. So we don’t necessarily see a tendency for dramatic change. Even now, flatex is approaching 20 years old. We still have clients from old cohorts who remain very active and active well above average. As people get older, they tend on average to be wealthier and to have on average more time for trading. That’s a good thing for us.
Achim Schreck
executiveStill on the subject of customers who are less active or inactive — as the chart shows, roughly 250,000 clients currently hold over €1,000 in their accounts. Are these people logging into the platform on a regular basis? How are we communicating with them and keeping them engaged? Or is it simply a backup account, with their primary relationship elsewhere?
Oliver Behrens
executiveThat is a really great question. Essentially, we're building tools so we can interact with these clients—sending messages and offering guidance. As I said regarding the questionnaires we conduct with clients on a regular basis, we continue to hear feedback that 36% of our clients are unsure what steps to take, or at minimum they require assistance. So for us, dedicating ourselves to financial education is absolutely vital to help them get past, shall we say, that resistance. What action should I take? How do I avoid making an error? And how can I succeed at investing? That's why we're seeing substantial demand for investment seminars, particularly with our partners—many of whom are mutual fund companies—but also in the certificate area, where people examine the various instruments available to them. Another very interesting point is that in the future, clients will essentially be able to access something like a library offering education customized to their needs, and they'll receive support from, let's say, individuals in a comparable situation, which we hope will encourage them to engage. And I'd add that anyone who has become a client had a reason for doing so.
Oliver Behrens
executivePerhaps they lost track of it along the way, but we're able to assist them in essentially recalling it and moving up to the next level.
Benon Janos
executiveThat is obviously one of the spots where some catching up is needed on our side. This is definitely a result of the emphasis we placed during recent years on the regulatory findings, which we have mostly resolved. And as we look ahead, releasing that potential and reinforcing the Autobahn in clients' minds is going to matter a great deal going forward. And let's keep in mind, when a client trades, that is one thing. If a client keeps cash in our account, we earn money from that. Generally speaking, that is a positive. As soon as we roll out the securities lending product, a third pillar gets unlocked, which is that if a client holds no cash with us and does not trade, but still has appealing stocks in his portfolio that he is happy to lend out, he will produce a pickup and so will we. So it is quite literally a whole new expansion in the percentage of clients from whom we generate revenues. But naturally there will always be a small fraction of clients whom it will likely be very difficult to activate.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks. flatex has roughly two times the staff that some Nordic competitors do. What accounts for that gap, and does it stem from flatexDEGIRO covering so many different language regions too? How do you view the potential for AI to make your customer relations more efficient?
Oliver Behrens
executiveOkay, I think that's a fair question. At first glance, it does appear there's a meaningful gap — or it seems like twice as many employees. But the business model differs substantially too. To start with, we're running in 16 countries, and that demands a different level of effort. Second, we have an in-house IT team of roughly 450 people among those 1,300 employees. We also currently run our own data centers and similar infrastructure. So the setup isn't the same. That said, none of this excuses us from examining whether we've got the right, lean configuration we want going forward. Right now, we still have two — at minimum two platforms that need to be unified. So we'll watch this carefully. As Benon and I said very plainly, we're focused on cost and we apply very strict cost discipline. We'll keep monitoring this and see what actions we can take. We will — you can see it in the provisions for 2020 — in the 2024 accounts for 2025, there were plenty of questions about that. We'll cut headcount by a decent number, and that's the reason we set up the provisions.
Oliver Behrens
executiveWe’re definitely watching that closely. Sure, we had already held headcount in check compared with how things stood around the start of 2024, but this is <<inaudible>> while, naturally, if we move into additional markets and so forth, there could be a few growth opportunities in certain places. Still, right now our attention is squarely on what’s directly in front of us.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks. I’ve got one question about the pension opportunity, and perhaps you could say a bit more about it. This seems like it could reach a customer base that’s less active but possibly more sticky. Do you expect the new coalition government in Germany to bring in the relevant vehicles soon?
Oliver Behrens
executiveLooking at this quite positively, setting aside the danger that Friedrich Merz puts together a coalition with those voter percentages behind it, I feel fairly confident we'll see a result regarding the pension system. If you consider it, roughly 83 million people live in Germany, and of those, let's say 65 million are employed. Right now there are only 20 million, 25 million custody accounts; my estimate is that no less than 40% to 50% of everyone with a job falls within the scope for retirement savings built on securities, which would imply the market could add a substantial number of new custody accounts, particularly with a tax incentive on the way. That's exactly right. These assets are long-term and they are sticky. However, clients must be educated so they don't halt their savings plans whenever the market sours for a spell. They ought to view it as an opportunity and apply the cost average effect to essentially capture more performance. How soon will this arrive? We kept it somewhat vague in our planning, yet it's evident that a great deal of investment need lies ahead for Germany. Infrastructure, digitalization, rebuilding the economy along with the car manufacturing sector, Autobahns and so forth.
Oliver Behrens
executiveOur constitution includes a 3% deficit ban. The only route available is getting ordinary people out there to put money into certain areas and back the country’s transformation. I’m hopeful things will improve. We’ll see how realistically the new government can carry out this plan. Still, that would come on top of what we have already planned. Thank you.
Achim Schreck
executiveBuilding on that, could you help us gauge how significant the extra potential revenue from pension accounts and crypto would be for the 2027 mid-term guidance? Would the impact be major or minor, or how much would stem from the momentum we already have and continued growth?
Oliver Behrens
executiveI'd describe it as the cherry on top, really. How fast the government actually gets its act together is what matters. Our view is that this becomes a topic starting in 2026. That is precisely why we included all the figures for 2027 as a full-year impact. Personally, I believe the count of custody accounts in Germany might rise by 40% or 50% if they truly get it right, and that's the optimistic scenario you'd want to see. The same question comes up in other nations with unfunded pension systems, and European capital markets depend so heavily on foreign capital that the EU Commission, the ECB, the regulators and, naturally, the governments all have a strong stake in boosting local ownership of markets. And that ought to help, since they also observe what's happening with the UK ISA accounts, with the NISA accounts in Japan and, above all of course, with the 401(k) accounts in the U.S. The ability to invest and hold local percentages in capital markets matters fundamentally for transforming the economy too. So my sense is the impact will be significant if they really get it right. The catch, though, is that this story has a long beard, and they have never — truly never — been good at execution.
Oliver Behrens
executiveLike I said, that paper sits in Mr. Lindner's drawer — he's essentially departed from the government. Still, the matter hasn't changed, and that's exactly why, staying on an upbeat note, I feel optimistic that we'll have something to work with.
Benon Janos
executiveTo wrap up on that and return to the heart of your question, we've set goals that are both realistic and ambitious, and reaching them will require some new revenues. I'd likely put securities lending—a very common existing product in the Dutch market—into that category too. That said, yes, new revenue from new products will be necessary for us to get there, though we're confident we will.
Achim Schreck
executiveThanks, Benon. As far as I can see, there aren’t any more questions in my queue at the moment, so I’ll turn things back to Oliver for some closing remarks.
Oliver Behrens
executiveYeah. I think that was, how should I put it, a genuinely exciting day and, first of all, yes, a strategy session with all of you. I wanted to express my thanks for the confidence you've placed in the management team and in the people of flatexDEGIRO. It was a pleasure being here alongside you today, and we're looking forward to working together and collaborating with you as investors and as supporters of our business. And we'll be there for you. Thank you for joining us today.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete flatexDEGIRO SE transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to flatexDEGIRO SE earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in flatexDEGIRO SE or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.