Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 27, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Robert Macleod
executiveAlright, thanks a lot. Good morning to all of you, and good afternoon as well. We really appreciate you joining Frontline's call for the fourth quarter earnings. Our strong results this quarter came about because tanker demand rose, thanks to expanding trade between the Atlantic and Asia, a tighter supply of available fleet capacity, and the implementation of IMO 2020. Only a few weeks into 2020, that market strength began to reverse — sorry, reversing — because of problems in Libya, Venezuela, and Nigeria, plus attacks in the Middle East; after that, sanctions on the Cosco fleet were removed. Then, making things far worse, the coronavirus showed up right away, hitting global trade, oil demand, and the freight market. The VLCC segment is soft since ton miles demand has fallen, while our Suezmaxes and Aframaxes, 2 segments where Frontline holds substantial exposure, are getting improved earnings on a relative basis. This year's beginning has been remarkable; honestly, at moments it has felt somewhat like a horror movie. Yet the key point is that we are earning money in the freight environment of today, and having a modern, well-run fleet matters most. Let's please go to Slide 3 and review the Q4 highlights. Net income came to $108.8 million, or $0.55 per share. That is definitely a solid quarter, and the $8.7 million in profits tied to the Trafigura deal is not counted as net income. We declared a $0.40 dividend. The prior dividend was $0.10, paid for Q3 of '19. VLCCs earned $58,000 in Q4, and for Q1 we have booked 83% at $90,000. Suezmax earned $38,000 in Q4, and for Q1 we have booked 75% around $72,000. LR2s earned roughly $30,000 in Q4, and for Q1 we have booked 72% at $36,000. The 54 — $554 million ICBCL sale-and-leaseback is in the last stage of being signed and will help facilitate closing the 10 Suezmaxes we are buying from Trafigura. Before I go into greater detail on the tanker market, I want to hand you over — hand the call to Inger. Inger, please, could you walk us through the financials?
Inger Klemp
executiveAbsolutely. Thank you, Robert, and good morning — and good afternoon to all of you as well. So let's now move on to Slide 4 and take a look at the income statement. For the fourth quarter of 2019, Frontline recorded total operating revenues net of voyage expenses of $224 million, along with EBITDA adjusted for certain noncash items of $163 million. Net income reported by Frontline came to $108.8 million, which works out to $0.55 per share, while net income adjusted for certain noncash items was $106.9 million, or $0.54 per share, in that same fourth quarter. Excluded from the fourth quarter's net income is $8.7 million in net cash received and accrued profit share tied to the 5 charter-in and charter-out agreements with Trafigura, which instead have been accounted for as a reduction of the acquisition cost of the vessels. The noncash items this quarter were made up of a $0.8 million unrealized gain on marketable securities, a $1.1 million loss connected to our interest in FMSI, and a $2.2 million gain on derivatives as well. Compared with adjusted EBITDA of $43 million and an adjusted net loss of $10 million in the third quarter of 2019, the fourth quarter reflects an increase of $120 million and an increase of $106.9 million, respectively. The reason net income came in higher for Q4 is that time charter basis <<inaudible>> went up, and that was fueled by TCE rates being greater in the fourth quarter than they were in the third. Moving on, let's look at the balance sheet on Slide 5. When you compare the balance sheet at the close of December 2019 against September 30, 2019, the key shifts are as follows: first, cash and cash equivalents rose by $68 million, reflecting the combined impact of CapEx payments, debt repayments, debt drawdowns, operating cash flow, and money raised through share issuance under the ATM program. Other current assets went up by $62 million, which came from higher receivables and inventories. Short-term debt rose by $310 million, tied to the December 2020 maturity of the $500.1 million facility, which we expect to refinance. Equity grew by $130 million, driven mostly by net income for the quarter and share issuance under the ATM program, partly offset by cash dividends. At December 31, Frontline holds $343 million in cash and cash equivalents, which includes undrawn amounts under our unsecured loan facility, marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. As of December 31, the newbuilding CapEx we still have left to cover comes to $302 million. That covers 1 Suezmax tanker and 1 VLCC, both due to be delivered in May 2020, plus 4 LR2 tankers, scheduled for delivery in January, March and October 2021 and January '22, respectively. For these newbuildings, we figure debt capacity of roughly $234 million. As Robert mentioned, we're in the final stages of signing the $554 million sale-and-leaseback deal with ICBCL, which will fund the cash amount due when the 10 Suezmax tankers close on March 16, 2020. This lease financing runs for a tenor of 7 years and comes with an interest rate equal to LIBOR plus a margin of 230 basis points. Its amortization profile sits at 17.8 years, and it gives Frontline purchase options across the whole period, along with a purchase obligation when the term wraps up. Back in November 2019, the company entered into a senior secured term loan facility with Crédit Suisse, sized at as much as $42.9 million, to partially fund the Suezmax tanker resale being built at Hyundai. That facility comes due 5 years after delivery, bears an interest rate of LIBOR plus a margin of 190 basis points, and its amortization profile is 18 years. Next, in February 2020, Crédit Agricole committed to providing a senior secured term loan facility worth $62.5 million, intended to cover part of the VLCC resale cost. Subject to final paperwork, this facility comes due five years following the delivery date, bears interest at LIBOR plus a 190 basis point margin, and follows an 18-year amortization schedule. As of December 31, the year-end date, the average margin on bank debt is LIBOR plus 185 basis points, and following the new $659.4 million borrowing I mentioned, it will rise to LIBOR plus 195 basis points. Now let's turn to Slide 6 and take a closer look at cash breakeven rates and OpEx. Looking ahead to 2020, our projection for the average cash cost breakeven rate is approximately $22,700 each day for VLCCs, $19,700 per day for Suezmax tankers, and $15,600 daily for LR2 tankers. When we average that across the fleet, the estimate lands at roughly $19,400 per day. These figures reflect the all-in daily rates that our other vessels must generate to pay for budgeted operating costs along with dry dock, estimated interest expenses, TC and bareboat hires, loan installments, and G&A expenses. For every $1,000 per day in rates actually achieved beyond our cash breakeven, that translates to about $22.8 million in additional cash flow after debt service annually, equivalent to $0.11 per share — which shows just how critical it is to maintain low cash breakeven rates. The chart on the right side of this slide displays yearly incremental cash flow after debt service on a per-share basis, under scenarios where achieved rates exceed our cash breakeven by $10,000, $20,000, $30,000, or $40,000 per day, respectively. To illustrate: with a fleet average cash cost breakeven rate near $19,400 per day and an average fleet TCE rate of $49,400 per day, Frontline's cash flow per share after service would come to $0.0339. Robert, back to you.
Robert Macleod
executiveThanks a lot, Inger; it's wonderful to see the profit potential before us, and the financing completed recently really highlights where Frontline stands; that's quite heartening. So, let's turn to Slide 7 now, if we may. I want to clarify why our perspective on the market over the long haul hasn't shifted; however, let's address the virus initially. The adverse market impact brought about by the coronavirus is definitely powerful and has struck oil demand directly. How demand is affected will unfold gradually and projections differ widely. Our view is that demand will come back and rise in 2020 compared with the prior year, since we regard the present circumstances as short-lived instead of lasting. Yet clearly we cannot forecast the timing of a turnaround, though we hold cautious optimism that containment of the virus will arrive sooner rather than later. When that occurs, we hope to see a market again where oil demand is robust, volumes from the U.S. Gulf to Asia keep growing, IMO 2020 plays a significant part, and fleet expansion keeps decelerating. Sentiment, as everyone knows, is a potent force; right now it is deeply negative, but that will change. Next slide, please. Capacity growth for the worldwide fleet is decelerating. Expansion of the fleet serves as a key driver of long-term profits in the tanker business. And investors have often been let down previously, since excessive ordering rapidly wipes out upcycles. At present, practically no tanker orders are being made. And although that could shift rapidly, the most recent occasion we witnessed the order book at today's levels was 1997; we anticipate vessel off-hire will significantly affect fleet capacity during this year, just as it did in 2019. There are 137 VLCCs, or 17% of the fleet, scheduled for dry dock in 2020; regarding Suezmaxes, that figure is 109, or over 20% of the fleet. Crucially, any off-hire tied to scrubber installations is excluded from this count. Dry-dockings cannot be delayed, and worldwide shipyards began 2020 with the busiest schedule since 2007. Shipyards are stretched even further at present because of the coronavirus, <<inaudible>> workers and suppliers. This is certain to produce a strongly favorable impact on supply across 2020 and likely into 2021 as well. Let's check the following one, Slide 9. And whether you believe it or not, IMO 2020 in fact took place. All through last year, the shipping and investment communities concentrated on IMO 2020, and justifiably so. In our view, the consequences of IMO 2020 have been eclipsed by other developments lately, yet the effects are genuine and will stay a factor for a considerable while. IMO 2020 has generated an enormous gap in owners' costs tied to fuel. For instance, a modern VLCC equipped with a scrubber will be making $30,000 a day while simultaneously a big share of the VLCC fleet will be making roughly their daily operating expenses. Frontline, as you're aware, operates a highly up-to-date fleet averaging roughly 4 years of age, which hands us an enormous edge given where fuel prices stand right now. And, as I said near the beginning of this call during the introduction, at present rates we continue to generate a profit; to wrap up, let's look at Slide 10. The fourth quarter results, along with first quarter guidance, have shown what this company can achieve when markets are strong. There's no debating Frontline's standing in the market, and this fleet is the finest one we've ever possessed. Our breakeven levels, too, sit at historically low points. Yet at this moment, the market's headwinds stay powerful; nor do we expect any meaningful upturn before the virus is contained. Still, once containment of the virus happens and negative headlines fade away, the tanker market may very well return to the robust earnings setting that we came into during the fall of 2019. With that, operator, please open the line for questions.
Jon Chappell
analystRobert, I'll start with my first question. During the presentation, and also in the earnings release, you noted that because of present-day uncertainty, and even with the favorable long-term picture, you're taking a cautious approach. So my assumption is that being cautious means no purchases of new vessels, even if the market lifts asset values somewhat; but what does that mean for the dividend policy? For 4Q it appears to be roughly a 75% payout ratio, the 1Q rates so far are actually stronger, though I understand there will be a tail off for what's left. Do you believe the Board gets far more conservative about the payout until the demand side has a bit more clarity? Or would you anticipate a comparable type of payout for the first quarter results?
Robert Macleod
executiveOnce more, regarding taking a cautious stance, I'll address that first. I believe cautious also means we are extremely prudent about whatever we do when it comes to chartering. We are extremely focused on operating the company as well as we possibly can. Clearly, our day-to-day fixing work matters enormously. So on that front — we are laser-focused. You can observe how we began in 2020. And sadly, even with the very high-quality fleet, we continue to run in the black. As for the dividend, you did see that we paid the $0.10 in Q3 even with the loss that quarter, and today we followed that with a $0.40 for Q4. So for the second half of 2019, when you look at the payout ratio, it looks — of course it looks very, very good. So as we enter Q1, we've gotten off to a much stronger start in Q1 than what we earned in Q4. So I think the Board would now watch how the — well, how it develops between now and the Q1 release and our board meeting in May. So I think everything hinges on how things turn out. If this kind of crisis, regarding the virus, if it keeps going throughout, then I'm sure the Board will have a very good thing. But if it's temporary, and the world heads to a better place and returns to normality, then I think the payout will be decent. And Q1, thus far, is looking very good.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right, that's great. My follow-up is for Inger. It appears the short-term debt rose quite a bit on the December 31 balance sheet. I believe a bullet point went unaddressed during the presentation, indicating this belongs to the larger facility and that you anticipate refinancing it. How quickly could that refinancing happen, so we can watch that debt level come down from current liabilities and return to long term?
Inger Klemp
executiveWe've purposely not truly examined that as of yet. So we hold no worries regarding it whatsoever, in a sense; yet I believe the plan is to start digging into it now, during the upcoming quarter, I suppose. So when we next gather here to talk, I'd guess we likely will have something arranged.
Randy Giveans
analystI have two things to ask. First, regarding your share count and the shares you've issued — clearly, during 3Q and 4Q, when those shares were trading at significant premiums to NAV, that was logical; in 1Q, with the shares from the most recent Trafigura acquisition still outstanding. But looking ahead, given that your shares have now fallen back below NAV, and quite substantially in our opinion, what's your thinking on buybacks right now — whether as a kind of supplement to the dividend, or in place of it?
Inger Klemp
executiveApologies, we didn't quite hear the question. Are you asking about repurchases or issuances?
Randy Giveans
analystYeah, the second one. Since the shares are now trading at a pretty steep discount to NAV, would buybacks come into play alongside the dividend, or instead of it?
Robert Macleod
executiveThat's a matter we're monitoring very closely, naturally, as far as how the situation evolves, since that genuinely represents the other option.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right. Could you also provide an update regarding your scrubber installations? What number has been finished? What number is still to come? And do you have any sort of plans for additional scrubbers given that the spread has tightened somewhat, though it seems a bit more steady now.
Robert Macleod
executiveRight now, 26 vessels are sailing with scrubbers in operation; another 6 are due to be installed over the coming period — mostly in the next quarter, but partly Q3 as well, likely, based on how we see various yard delays, it could be Q3; that gets us to 50% of the fleet; and just to be clear, within that 50%, there's an overweight on Suezmaxes and VLCCs and an underweight on LR2s. So our view on this is simple: the larger the vessel, the more it makes sense. No decisions have been made about installing scrubbers on ships outside of their docking schedule. That is something we consider, and we're monitoring. Because of our ownership stake in Clean Marine, we have superior access in both timing and price for scrubbers; but the answer is 26 at the moment, 6 scheduled and monitoring further.
Randy Giveans
analystGreat. Then just one fast thing, and you only need to give me 5 seconds for it. On LR2s, has any of them moved to dirty, or already made that move to dirty, during the last month or 2, given how wide the gap is between crude tanker rates and products?
Robert Macleod
executive11 clean, 7 dirty, 1 that went dirty in the past 8 weeks.
Greg Lewis
analystYeah. Rob, would you mind giving us some insight into how things look right now in the rate market for Vs? Obviously, it's been a rough month, no question. Yet it appears as though during the past week or so, there's been a bit of stabilization plus a slight uptick in the V market. So, whatever detail you can give us on that would be great. Did sentiment simply change? More volumes coming through? Anything along those lines would really help.
Robert Macleod
executiveWell, the V market, as everyone witnessed, was absolutely torn apart, correct? Then roughly 2 weeks back, it began to recover gradually. My sense is it hit its lowest point. Globally, you're looking at 40,000, versus the high 20,000s or 30,000s for our top vessels, while OpEx runs at 2/3 of the worldwide fleet. This week, a fair amount of quiet activity has been happening. When the market's weak, the first vessels pulled out are the weakest ones plus the oldest ones. So those have been getting picked off; then all at once, we're actually seeing today and yesterday that the list isn't looking too bad in the Middle East. So at this point the modern vessels are beginning to snip, but globally you're at 50. Then it becomes — your top vessels could be — it likely begins with a 4, though I'm not claiming it's merely sort of — conditions are so fragile out there; we could easily lose 5 points before this call wraps up. Still, on the whole, I view the V market as regaining its footing and gradually improving. We're seeing a good number of light swing jobs, which absorb some capacity in the Far East; however, regarding the Aframaxes and the Suezmaxes, those held up considerably better. That explains why our figures remain — if every one of our vessels were fixed today, we'd still be profitable. It's down to our Suezmaxes and Afras. Since on their own, the Vs aren't doing well. With luck, though, the worst is behind us and things improve going forward. The FFA, or futures market, points to the same thing, though only time will tell. It feels like the world keeps getting 1 shock after another. Still, good news has to arrive at some point.
Greg Lewis
analystAll right, that's great. And that's it from me, just one final item. A rival of yours picked up a pair of VLCCs in the newbuild segment. Frontline, as I understand it, is always looking to make acquisitions when the opportunity arises. I suppose there are 2 parts here. First, obviously, the disruption we've witnessed during the past month, or I should say, starting in early to mid-January. Has that reduced the willingness of buyers and sellers to get together and complete sales? And what I'm really after is this: are there still tankers — be they Suezmaxes or Vs, or perhaps even LR2s — that Frontline is actively reviewing as possible acquisitions? Or, going back to what you said about adopting a cautious stance, would you say we're now into March and you truly don't anticipate being out in the market seeking to buy tonnage until some greater stability appears later in the year?
Robert Macleod
executiveWe keep watching at all times. And like I mentioned before, in the near term we are extremely cautious; as a result, we're placing more into the silo right now than was the case a month or 2 back, or rather we are more on the silo than we were then. Still, should the right deal present itself, then we remain ready. Our long-term perspective, I believe, is quite obvious. We think this is — yet we don't view it as a lasting, it's a short-lived state of affairs. And regarding that transaction you brought up, the 3 vessels we saw. You may feel that it now appears to be an awful deal, but in my view that transaction still holds up as a reasonable one. If you — it's for delivery and — at this point we are still here; we have definitely not switched off the lights when it comes to additional deals.
Mike Webber
analystRobert, I just wanted to circle back to what we were saying about demand in the current climate, and clearly there isn't much you're able to influence at the moment; but when you think about emerging from this and demand eventually recovering or bouncing back, how are you approaching getting your fleet ready for that? It may be premature, but I'm simply wondering where you're deciding to — could there be floating storage chances that emerge while production is sort of climbing, sort of exceeding what's actually being consumed? How are you thinking about placing your fleet optimally so it can seize an eventual rebound in demand?
Robert Macleod
executiveRegarding that, clearly, across the different segments. But turning to the 1 — the Aframaxes and Suezmaxes, we typically maintain a strong footprint in the Atlantic basin, and luckily that's true at present. The Atlantic along with the Mediterranean Black Sea and the Baltic have suffered much less. So our positioning there is correct; we aren't receiving many inquiries heading east. So we're staying put. So I believe we're in the proper spot, where we currently are. As for the Vs, they're distributed the way they usually are. There's a fair amount of fixing coming out of the Middle East; and at current rates, if I could pick between a 40-day voyage or an 80-day voyage, I'd choose the shorter one based on our market outlook. Once we begin witnessing genuine, genuine shifts here and the virus contained and so on, we'll be sending more vessels ballasting westward on speculation. Because that should line up with Chinese demand returning. And with the U.S.-China deal, we subsequently expect that U.S. Gulf exports on Vs will rise enormously; so we want to be positioned for that. And on the floating storage matter. We observed the market shift into contango 2, 3 weeks ago, then Australian backwardation. Now we're back in a contango or slight contango once more. But regarding floating storage, I don't think it justifies the economics, though this could happen all at once, naturally, considering how cheap oil is; so it's something we're watching. At the same time, we're far less involved in floating storage today than we were several years back. We've disposed of 19 old ships across the last 3 years, thankfully. And with our fleet today, we're far more concentrated on trading, but if we have short-term, the stuff we've been doing that at better rates than what the market offers us on an AG-East, then we'll take it.
Mike Webber
analystYeah, that was sort of what I wanted to ask next, particularly because of the swing we've witnessed in that curve during the last month. I'm simply wondering about the connections with Trafi that provide you some advantage or something like an early view, should somebody act fast regarding floating storage, considering how many — how extreme the movement in that curve has been lately, whether that's something you would consider or whether that's — whether you're noticing any sort of growing interest there?
Robert Macleod
executiveInterest has grown. And setting aside Frontline's fleet, the reality is that most vessels sit near the OpEx threshold; so once you reach that kind of bracket, some buyers will step in; and what we understand will follow is that you tighten availability for that vessel type, which benefits everyone else. So naturally, I'm quite optimistic that it occurs. And it very well could, considering how weak the market is.
Robert Macleod
executiveAll right. I appreciate all of you joining the call. I'd also like to use this moment to express gratitude to the entire Frontline team for how hard they've worked and how much they've put in. We're going to emerge from this in a strong position; and with any luck, it won't take too long. Thanks so much, everybody.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's conference to a close. I appreciate everyone for joining in. You're free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.