Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 27, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Robert Macleod
executiveMuch appreciated. Good morning to everyone, and good afternoon too. It means a lot to me that all of you are on this call for our second-quarter earnings discussion. First off, I'd like to express my gratitude toward the people working ashore and the crews aboard our vessels for the incredible effort and dedication they've shown — clearly, those are the main drivers behind the great numbers we posted. Conditions in our markets can be very choppy. Still, the ups and downs we've seen across the past year have been unusually severe, serving as a reminder of how quickly things can turn favorable for tankers. During the first six months of 2020, Frontline delivered results better than any period going back to 2008, and on top of that, we've locked in healthy fixtures for Q3. Even with rates having dropped lately, Frontline is set for a strong 2020. Turning to Slide 3, here's a brief review of what stood out in Q2. We posted $200 million in net income, a bit above $1 per share — clearly a robust quarter. Once you strip out noncash items, net income came to $206 million. Our declared dividend was $0.50, compared with $0.70 paid out for Q1 2020. During the quarter we chose to pay down $60 million on the Hemen facility, and that decision largely explains why the dividend is smaller. Inger has handled some excellent financing work, and she'll walk everyone through it later in this call. During the quarter, we took delivery of two newly built vessels — one Suezmax and one VLCC. That leaves just four ice class LR2s still on order, all scheduled for delivery next year. For VLCCs, Q2 earnings came in at $75,800, and we've already locked in 76% of Q3 at roughly $61,000. Suezmax vessels earned $51,100 in Q2, with 77% of Q3 booked at $29,500. LR2s brought in just under $37,000, and two-thirds of Q3 is booked at $14,500 — those Q3 figures exclude the long-term time charters. Before we turn to the market, I'll pass the call to Inger, who will walk us through the financials.
Inger Klemp
executiveAppreciate that, Robert, and hello everyone, good morning and good afternoon. If we move to Slide 4, we can review the income statement highlights. For the second quarter of 2020, Frontline's total operating revenues net of voyage expenses came to $301 million, while adjusted EBITDA was $259 million. Net income came in at roughly $200 million, or $1.01 per share, and adjusted net income for the quarter was $206 million, or $1.04 per share. Altogether, the adjustment for this quarter was $6.4 million net. Those adjustments comprised a $5.9 million loss on derivatives, a $0.9 million unrealized gain on marketable securities, a $2.7 million share of losses on associated companies, and a $1.3 million amortization of acquired time charters. Adjusted net income rose $27 million during this quarter, primarily because our time charter equivalent earnings increased on the back of higher reported TCE rates for our VLCC and LR2 tankers in the second quarter, together with a $12.4 million gain from selling 1 VLCC that had previously been recorded as an investment in finance lease. Now let's review the balance sheet highlights. The key events in the second quarter affecting the balance sheet were that we took delivery of the Suezmax tanker Front Cruiser and also took delivery of Front Dynamic, and we drew down debts on these vessels; as Robert noted, we repaid our senior unsecured facility by $60 million; we signed 2 new loan facilities — financing arrangements with total balloon payments of $349 million that had been due in December 2020 and in March 2021, on terms consistent with Frontline's other loan facilities; we also paid $138 million in dividends and earned adjusted net income — pardon me, net income of about $199.7 million. As the quarter closed, Frontline held $462 million in cash and cash equivalents, including undrawn amounts under our senior unsecured loan facility, multiple securities and minimum cash requirements. The current portion of long-term debt includes $240 million of debt maturity on the $466.5 million facility due in April 2021, plus $80.3 million of debt maturity on the $109.2 million facility in June 2021, and we expect to refinance both. Our remaining newbuilding CapEx requirements at quarter-end stood at $161.1 million tied to the 4 LR2 tankers, with 2 of them expected for delivery in January 2021 and in February 2021, and 2 expected for delivery in August 2021. In that regard, Frontline has secured a financing commitment for a loan facility of up to $133.7 million from CEXIM and Sinosure to partially finance these 4 LR2 tankers. This facility carries a tenor of 12 years, an interest rate of LIBOR plus the margin consistent with Frontline's other loan facilities, and an amortization profile of 17 years. Also, the facility still needs to be finalized through paperwork. So let's move on and examine more closely Slide 6, which covers cash breakeven base along with OpEx; we project that for the rest of 2020, the average cash cost breakeven base will come to $22,600 each day for VLCC, $18,900 each day for the Suezmax tankers, and $15,700 each day for the LR2 tankers. The fleet average estimate comes to roughly $19,100 each day; those are the rates. These represent all-in daily rates our vessels need to earn in order to cover budgeted operating cost on dry docks, estimated interest expense, TCEs and bareboat hire, installments on loans and G&A expenses. On the right-hand graph of the slide, we've displayed, as we typically do, the incremental cash flow after debt service per year and per share, assuming $10,000, $20,000, $30,000 or $40,000 each day achieved above our cash breakeven rate, respectively. Those figures include vessels on time charter-out, and we're considering the 365-day period starting July 1, 2020. To illustrate, with a fleet average cash cost breakeven rate of $19,100 each day and assuming $30,000 on top of the average fleet TCE rate, that would total $49,100; Frontline would then produce cash flow per share after debt service of $3.49. With that, I'll hand things back over to Robert.
Robert Macleod
executiveThanks so much, Inger. Turning to Slide 7, we'll examine the tanker market in Q2. During the opening half of 2020, crude demand underwent an unprecedented and severe adjustment. Because the demand hit from COVID-19 proved both massive and abrupt, worldwide commercial stockpiles rapidly climbed to unprecedented heights, essentially filling every bit of land storage that was available. Simultaneously, contango emerged in the crude market, which prompted traders to keep oil aboard tankers, boosting interest in near-term charters for our vessels. That consequently produced remarkably robust tanker rates, and those show up in what we delivered for Q2 2020. Since then, the freight market has softened to reduced levels, and while recovery indicators are clear as economies keep reopening, demand improvement probably won't follow a straight line, and how far and how long COVID-19's effects will reach is hard to forecast. Difficulties tied to COVID-19 have been widespread across the sector. They take in logistics for swapping crews, discharge delays, and reduced yard availability for dry docks and surveys. Every one of these items works in favor of effective fleet supply. Demand projections swing considerably from one month to the next, as the chart near the bottom of this slide illustrates. Let's go to Slide 8 now and review how global fleet capacity growth is decelerating. The supply aspect of the balance keeps getting better, and that's quite encouraging. Measured against the entire fleet, the order book sits at its smallest share since 1997. Meanwhile, the typical age of the VLCC fleet at the close of Q2 2020 stands at its peak since September 2002. Come the end of next year, 65 ships will exceed 20 years of age, with another 85 surpassing 17.5. Robust fleet supply expansion won't fully register until 2021 or 2022, yet it ought to be substantial and usher in a prolonged stretch of elevated rates. We're pleased with how things stand now: newbuildings are joining the market in a disciplined manner, the order book keeps contracting, and scrapping of ships is unavoidable. Current markets plus a touch of forward view. The demand shock most likely sits in the past, though swings should be anticipated. Today's freight market is still strained. Crude output has fallen nearly 10% from January, and that missing volume shrinks what typically gets shipped. That means cargo counts have dropped by somewhere between 20% and 25%. On the brighter side, inventories are being pulled down — near-term discomfort, yet perhaps a longer-term benefit. Projections indicate a meaningful share of the OPEC reduction might come back over the next several months, and paired with the Northern Hemisphere heading into winter, that provides reason to expect a firmer freight market. To wrap up, the significant swings we saw in tanker rates over the past 12 months show how tightly balanced the market is and demonstrate that only a small shift is needed for the tanker market to surge. As we look toward 2021 and afterward, rebounding demand for moving crude oil will line up with fleet growth that is shrinking quickly, and that underpins our highly positive long-term view of the market; therefore, as Frontline, we benefit from the youngest fleet and the lowest breakeven levels ever in our company's history. Frontline's earnings could be considerable, $23 million annualized for each $1,000 above $18.7 million; so our position is very strong. With that, let's open it up to questions, please.
Randy Giveans
analystOkay, so, first thing I wanted to ask about is the dividend, correct? During Q4 of 2019 and Q1 of 2020, your payout was more than 70% of net income, if I'm not mistaken. Then in Q2, that got cut to 50%. I believe you said one factor was the $60 million that was repaid in April on the Hemen facility. So is that the whole story? Or are you setting things up for a smaller dividend in the coming quarter? And going forward, should we count on no less than 50% of net income?
Inger Klemp
executiveNo, that's the only factor behind it. If you include that amount, I think the dividend comes to $0.80, which is likely the figure you had in mind.
Randy Giveans
analystAnd when you mention that $60 million from Hemen, is that what you mean?
Inger Klemp
executiveCorrect. That fully explains it — the dividend comes to 50%.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right. And moving ahead, should we take the 50% of net income as a reasonable assumption?
Inger Klemp
executiveLooking forward, that's the usual baseline we work with, in a sense. Nothing about it has shifted, really; we simply — during this quarter chose to pay down the facility using $30 million — that works out to $60 million, I mean, which comes to $0.30 per share. That applies, potentially, to this quarter.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right. Regarding the Hemen facility, my understanding is that it closed in April, correct? Should we anticipate that the rest of it gets repaid during Q3?
Inger Klemp
executiveNot necessarily — that hasn't been determined. How we'll handle the portion that's left is still something we're weighing. Extending the facility is one possibility, and paying it off is another, so we'll just have to wait and find out.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right. Then for my final question, I'd like to ask about the scrubbers. Where do things stand with those installations? From what I understand, you pushed back a handful of them — 4, if I recall correctly. Do you have any sense of when they might get installed, or what your approach will be for the scrubbers that are left?
Robert Macleod
executiveRandy, that work is complete on our end. A couple are currently being fitted right now. As for those 4 we delayed, nothing more has been done on them. Our plan is this: once those vessels that were meant to receive scrubbers go into dry dock during the quarters ahead, we'll get them ready. That means all the subsea work gets handled, and it's only a minor expense. After that, the scrubbers themselves can be mounted, or retrofitted; at present they're sitting in storage at our manufacturing sites in Indonesia; so we'll take it from there. The spread has been getting somewhat better, though we retain that flexibility; and for now, they'll stay where they are in storage.
Jon Chappell
analystLet me start with a few quick questions for clarification. My sense is that we're in a situation where bookings for the quarter to date appear quite high, largely due to how load to discharge accounting works. I realize you all make a real effort to clarify these gaps. So perhaps the way to put it is this: when you consider what's left of the quarter — the remaining 24%, say, for the VLCCs — are there any unusual or exceptional vessels, whether uncontracted or contracted, where that remaining stub portion of the quarter might come in above or below what the market averages?
Robert Macleod
executiveObviously it all hinges on whether we lock in the loading dates at the end of September or in early October — that's the determining factor. So it's — but nothing — to address the second half of what you asked, nothing stands out, nothing unusual. What I would add regarding the earnings, though, is that looking at earnings across multiple quarters matters here. So if I were to simply respond to how Frontline is doing on VLCCs so far this year, my take would be that Q1 was very strong; we beat our peers. As the numbers show, we're giving some of that back in Q2; and my guess is that we're at a pretty solid rate level and a good percentage here for Q3. So I'd put it this way: outperform in Q1, as we know, a bit under in Q2. And then Q3, I think, is looking quite good for us.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right. Then one more point of clarification, Robert. My understanding is you mentioned that the long-term contracts aren't part of the quarter-to-date rates. The press release states that short-term charters are in the forecast, so what falls between the long-term and the short term? I believe you've got 2 at 9.5 months and 1 at 12 months, plus 4 that are just under 6 months. So to be clear, are the ones just under 6 months the ones in the quarter-to-date, while the longer ones are not?
Robert Macleod
executiveYes, that's right. Essentially, our — the 6-month charters, which are about 6 months plus or minus 1. So the minimum period is 5 months. Those deals are what we treat as spot in the numbers. And anything beyond that, which begins with the 8-month deals, and it's — we have a couple of 1-year deals, and we've got the 5 Suezmax on the 3-year deals. So anything over the 6 months is treated as longer-term and is not included.
Jon Chappell
analystUnderstood. Also, I saw in the disclosures that 7 vessels are chartered to Hemen affiliates. My assumption is that those are the 7 you completed during the second quarter. I'm just wondering, do any options come with them? Or are they fairly fixed on timing?
Robert Macleod
executiveNo options are attached.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right. For my last question, Robert, I believe you've described a quite well-balanced outlook for the market across the second half of the year. And obviously, with how the third quarter has begun, you're going to be cash flow positive, and Inger has essentially outlined the dividend approach. As you consider the cash ahead, do you view this stretch of what we might term choppiness or uncertainty as a chance to bring in more tonnage? Or do you expect to devote the coming 6 months to further delevering the balance sheet so you're positioned for that favorable 2021, '22 outlook you mentioned?
Robert Macleod
executiveThe size suits us quite well. The age suits us very well. Like I mentioned in the intro, the company is in a very good shape. But — so nothing needs to be done, in my view. It's — should an opportunity arise, say, along the lines of the Trafigura deal we did, which we quite liked, then perhaps. But the base case is to take pleasure in what we have and then harvest from that by having, hopefully, what is the best operation.
Chris Tsung
analystI wanted to revisit the cash breakeven levels once more; regarding Slide 6, I realize Jon raised this point before, but I'm coming at it from a somewhat different perspective. So looking at Slide 6, those cash breakeven levels of roughly $19,000 on a fleet average. According to the press release, charter coverage is not part of the breakeven level. So I was curious, does that imply the breakeven levels, once time charters are excluded, would indicate a somewhat higher breakeven for the fleet?
Inger Klemp
executiveNo. What I mean is, the cash breakeven rates we've shared represent the total cost our fleet incurs divided by the various number of days for each segment, and then presented on a gross basis. Should you have contract coverage, above the breakeven rate, that would clearly bring down the cash breakeven rate for the spot vessels; so it won't go up then.
Chris Tsung
analystYeah, yeah, yeah. So, say the charter — suppose we took the contract coverage out, that would lower it, and you're telling me the response is negative?
Inger Klemp
executiveIs that so? I actually said I don't even know. No, no.
Chris Tsung
analystAll right, understood. I simply wanted to get some clarity there. And really, what I was hoping to do was ask about the Clean Marine investment you made. As I recall, when that deal happened in October of '19, it looked like a clever hedge tied to IMO 2020 and scrubbers more broadly; and now, 10, 11 months later, with COVID, OPEC and all the market volatility, how do you intend to handle that investment from here?
Robert Macleod
executiveHow this plays out remains to be seen. At present — our stake sits at roughly 17%, and the business operates a production site owned in Indonesia, plus it holds its stocks and similar assets. And as for us — we — at this point our investment is — the loan we've extended to the company is really quite small. So there's essentially no exposure for us. Putting additional capital into the company doesn't strike us as necessary. And my sense is that at some stage down the line, there'll be something positive to report. Naturally, it hasn't proven to be as detached from this — from what we'd been anticipating, but on the downside — the danger involved there was, all along, kept in check and bounded.
Chris Tsung
analystAll right, got it. That clears things up. One final item, then. With those voluntary reductions announced by a number of major OPEC producers, plus the bottlenecks building near ports in China and Hurricane Laura hitting the U.S. Gulf, I'd like to know how your company plans to deploy its vessels over the coming period.
Robert Macleod
executiveAt the moment, forecasting this market is incredibly tough. That's a fairly plain statement, since I've spent a few years in this business. My instinct tells me we're heading toward conditions that look more typical. As everyone knows, our volumes are very, very weak. Based on the most recent stretch we've observed, global output sits between 3 million and 4 million barrels beneath what's being consumed. That clearly weighs on freight, yet it might strengthen the argument as we approach winter, and Q4 tends to be a solid quarter. So my <<inaudible>> without much firm conviction, I sense improvement will come as we get closer to the year's end. Regarding this fleet, our effort is to shift positions into the Suezmax segment within the Atlantic Basin. When faced with picking either a lengthy voyage at today's rates or a briefer one, we go with the briefer one. A few possible catalysts exist out there. So we're monitoring everything intently. And we sense that conditions could improve. Meanwhile, volumes stay weak. So everything hinges on the cargo side. What we witnessed in the Middle East during the summer, when essentially 1 of every 3 cargoes vanished, has clearly damaged the earnings. Hopefully, though, demand will gradually return, and better periods might lie ahead. Still, I remain quite guarded. I won't don the bullish cap at this point.
J. Mintzmyer
analystTo start, nice work on the quarter. With rates moving around like they are, I remember you've previously arranged several swaps and hedges tied to certain debt profiles. I'm also aware a fresh debt structure is on the way alongside the new builds. Do you intend to grow or lengthen those rate swaps? Is anything like that being considered? Or will you keep some floating exposure?
Inger Klemp
executiveRecently we've actually put quite a number of rate hedges in place. So right now, I'd say we have no additional plans to add still more rate hedging; but we also had on — currently we hold $550 million of hedges. And then there's a smaller piece of roughly $100 million that will mature very soon. Still, as things stand, I think we're satisfied with it.
J. Mintzmyer
analystAll right, that tracks. Yeah. From what I recall, roughly a third of your position was hedged. Has that strategy shifted at all? Jon brought up your cash plans earlier — whether you'd consider growing the fleet, ordering new vessels, or picking up secondhand tonnage, that sort of thing. On a similar note, Frontline enjoys a solid premium relative to several tanker competitors. Honestly, Frontline might be the one — or among the very few — tanker outfits that could be described as carrying a decent valuation in this market. Could Frontline step in as a consolidator via equity? I'm aware some counterparts listed in Norway — no need to call them out today — are changing hands at a meaningful discount to NAV. Does a consolidation play exist there? Or has that idea been shelved?
Robert Macleod
executiveNo, opportunities do exist. And like you mentioned, we've got the pricing. We're sitting well beneath the premium level we'd typically command, and that premium exists for clear reasons. Our main shareholder continues to be enormously supportive, and that won't change. As for consolidation, sure, we could be a consolidator, though we're content with our current setup. We'll keep watching for chances. So we'll see what emerges and what's logical. Given the scale we already possess, our earning potential is already in place — something the Q2 figures make plainly evident.
J. Mintzmyer
analystGreat, great. Robert, you'll need to excuse me for asking this as our final question, but when we spoke during April, you made what was sort of an amusing wager that if interest rates dropped again, you would — no surprise — be trekking across Norway. So I simply wanted to follow up on that and ask when those travels are scheduled. And perhaps once COVID is behind us, we could assemble a group.
Robert Macleod
executiveI would say to you, you'd likely get pleasure from that hike. Naturally, it's a gorgeous hike. Provided you begin on the East side and head in the direction of the town where I grew up, and that's the correct — you're headed the proper direction; however, J, the wager has in fact been resolved. It wound up being a dinner. And — though I have to say, given how sure I felt, the stakes were significant, and things got extremely, extremely near. Still, luckily for me, I escaped without paying up.
Analyst
analystQuestioner from Pittsburgh here — that's where steelmaking began, the sector that a certain Scotsman, Andrew Carnegie, turned into a household name. So I got to wondering: how do prices for scrap steel influence when ships get retired?
Robert Macleod
executiveScrap — are you referring to the rate for scrap steel?
Analyst
analystSo, regarding the choice to take ships out of service, I realize it relates to those 5-year intervals and such in the marketplace — but does the level of scrap pricing, high or low, influence what the industry does about retiring vessels? I was simply curious whether an increase in the scrap steel rate would lead to additional retirements, and whether that would help your industry?
Robert Macleod
executiveThat's a good question. And the truth is yes, it certainly does; to illustrate, take our bigger vessel. Incidentally, the oldest one we have right now dates from 2009. So really, we have no candidates at all. Yet if you examine that market, as I noted during the introduction, the number of older ships keeps growing. And over the past 18 months, the value — the steel value moved up and down between $11 million and $18 million. At present, it sits at the bottom end of that range. So this plays into the decision-making process. The question of whether to scrap is clearly tied to that price, since it represents a solid share of the contract's value.
Analyst
analystPerhaps you might persuade certain shipyards to provide incentives for those doing the scrapping, linking the purchase of a fresh boat with the dismantling of an existing one.
Robert Macleod
executiveIndeed. That might serve as one approach, or alternatively putting together a collection of every aging vessel and recovering the remaining value faster through that route.
Robert Macleod
executiveAlright. No, I believe — I believe we'll wrap things up. So I just want to express my gratitude to each of you for joining the call; and to my coworkers and all the people at Frontline, many thanks for everything you've done.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings today’s conference call to a close. We appreciate your participation. You’re all free to disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.