Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 25, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lars Barstad
executiveHello, and welcome to the earnings call for Frontline's third quarter. Being in the hot seat for this call is a first for me. It's a privilege and a thrill to support our companies in this role. The board has firmly established Frontline's long-term plans, and we operate a highly professional company that has smoothly adjusted to this change in leadership. This quarter has been unpredictable, and the year so far has been remarkable. I'm inclined to mention back zones, yet those appear to have become typical for the shipping sector. All of us have been impacted by the worldwide COVID-19 pandemic. And while we must continue to bear with the circumstances for some time yet, the horizon shows no sign of hope. Let's turn to the highlights on Slide 3. Frontline entered Q3 2020 on a strong footing, yet freight rates began to rise as the quarter went on. We still concluded the quarter with solid returns on a load-to-discharge basis, making $49,200 per day on our VLCCs, $25,100 per day on our Suezmaxes, and $12,800 per day on our LR2/Aframaxes. That produced a net income of $57.1 million, or $0.29 per diluted share. Our adjusted net income was $56.4 million, which rounds to $0.29 per diluted share. We're delighted to announce that Frontline has signed three term loan facilities worth as much as $485.2 million. Inger, who is here with me today, will go into greater detail about our financing activities later on in this presentation. Thus far in the fourth quarter, we have roughly 74% of our available VLCC days at $22,600 per day, 61% of our available Suezmax days at $12,600 per day and 65% of our LR2/Aframax days at $13,800 per day. These booked earnings reflect the difficulties this market is facing. And while we'd like to feel positive about what lies ahead, uncertainties remain going forward. Frontline has thus chosen to hold off on paying dividends this quarter in order to safeguard the company's cash position. I'll now hand things over to Inger, who will walk you through Frontline's financial highlights.
Inger Klemp
executiveAppreciate that, Lars. Good morning, good afternoon, everyone. Moving on to Slide 4, let's examine the income statement. During the third quarter, Frontline posted total operating revenues net of voyage expenses amounting to $178 million, along with adjusted EBITDA of $108 million for the same quarter. Net income came in at $57 million, equal to $0.29 per share, while adjusted net income stood at $56.4 million, also $0.29 per share, for Q3. Compared with the prior quarter, adjusted net income fell by roughly $160 million. The main reason was a drop in our time charter equivalent earnings stemming from lower reported TCE rates, which Lars covered earlier for the third quarter, plus roughly five additional days this quarter because of dry docks on four vessels. We additionally booked a $13.9 million rise in ship operating expenses, largely attributable to a $4.3 million increase in dry docking costs, a $2.1 million increase in repairs and maintenance, and $4.8 million in extra crew costs related to COVID-19. Furthermore, we had a $12.4 million reduction stemming from what we <<inaudible>> during the second quarter <<inaudible>>. Now let's move to Slide 5; throughout 2020 we closed loan facilities totaling approximately $920 million, of which $725 million went toward refinancing four existing loan facilities that were maturing in December 2020 and the first half of 2021; beyond that, we closed two financings worth over $196 million for the purpose of financing new vessels. Every one of these loan facilities carried attractive terms at LIBOR plus 190 basis points or better, which keeps our cost structure competitive; in November 2020, the company signed three new term loan facilities totaling $485 million. Two of those facilities served to refinance two existing term loan facilities coming due in the second quarter of 2021. Facility number three came in at $133 million and its purpose was to provide part of the funding for the four LR2 tankers that are still being built. Now for the specifics of how those two facilities were refinanced: to start, we put together a senior secured term loan facility alongside a solid syndicate of banks — the biggest shipping lenders worldwide — in the amount of $250.7 million, and the goal was to refinance the $466.5 million facility that was set to mature in April 2021. The replacement facility reaches maturity in May 2025 and comes with an 18-year amortization schedule. We drew it down in full during November 2020, and as of September 30, 2020, $256.8 million of that refinance facility was booked as long-term debt. After that, we signed a senior secured term loan facility with ING and Credit Suisse for as much as $108 million. The purpose was to refinance the $109.2 million facility that came due in June 2021. Under the new arrangement, maturity is now November 2025, and amortization is spread across 17 years. That facility was also fully drawn in November 2020, and by September 30, 2020, $78.6 million of the refinance facility had been classified as long-term debt. On the slide, the grey column displays debt maturities prior to refinancing, whereas the blue column displays them following refinancing. As shown, once refinancing was complete, no material debt maturities occurred until 2023. Also, starting in 2025, the amount of debt coming due has climbed a lot. On top of that, we signed a senior secured term loan facility together with CEXIM and Sinosure, totaling $133.7 million, which covers part of the remaining $142.3 million needed for the four LR2 tankers currently being built. This facility carries a 12-year tenure along with a 17-year amortization profile, and with that in place, the newbuilding program is completely funded. Now let's move on to the balance sheets, which you'll find on Slide 6. During Q3, the key events that impacted our balance sheet included signing the two new loan facilities I just discussed, which replaced the two term loan facilities carrying balloon payments totaling $324.4 million that came due in April 2021 and June 2021. As a result, short-term debt along with the current portion of long-term debt dropped by $311 million, while long-term debt rose by $283 million. On top of that, dividends totaling $97 million were paid, and adjusted net income came in at $56.4 million. As of December 30, 2020, Frontline holds $423 million in cash and cash equivalents, which includes the undrawn portion of its unsecured loan facility, marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. Now, let's examine cash breakeven rates along with OpEx on Slide 7 more closely. For the fourth quarter of 2020, we project the average cash cost breakeven rate to come in at roughly $21,900 per day for VLCCs, $20,400 per day for Suezmax tankers, and $15,700 per day for LR2 tankers. Across the fleet, the estimate averages approximately $19,500 per day. When we talk about these rates, we mean the total daily amount our ships need to bring in to pay for scheduled dry dock work in the budget, expected interest costs, time charter equivalent and bareboat rental, loan repayments, and general and administrative costs. During the fourth quarter of 2020, the cash cost breakeven figures for Suezmax tankers are affected by dry docking scheduled for those vessels in Q4, plus one LR2 tanker also going into dry dock during that same quarter. As mentioned earlier, operating expenses in the third quarter took a hit from higher dry docking expenses, greater spending on repairs and maintenance, and extra costs for crew related to COVID-19. As we always do, we'd like to focus your attention on how much cash Frontline is capable of generating. On the right side of this slide, the graph displays yearly incremental cash flow per share, after debt service, based on achieved rates that exceed our cash breakeven rates by $10,000, $20,000, $30,000, or $40,000 per day. These numbers apply to vessels under time charter-out agreements, and we're looking at a 365-day period beginning October 1, 2020. As an example, suppose the fleet's average cash cost breakeven rate is $19,500 per day, and we add $30,000 above the average fleet TCE — then the fleet TCE reaches $49,500 per day, meaning Frontline would generate cash flow per share after debt service of $3.42. With that, I'll turn it back to Robert.
Robert Macleod
executiveThanks, Inger. Now we’ll turn to Slide 8 for a review of the third quarter in the tanker sector. Worldwide oil consumption hit its lowest point during May, and by June we were already seeing a rebound, with demand exceeding supply as OPEC and other major producers made deep reductions. The oil market shifted away from building inventories and toward drawing them down. You can observe this in the lower left portion of this slide, where the yellow bars appear. After that, OPEC+ raised output a little, which meant the reduction stayed well under the levels of Jan 20, and the drawdown pattern is still ongoing. During a draw phase, the costly barrel tends to be drawn down first, and that is usually floating storage. Most of the OPEC reductions have been concentrated geographically in the Middle East Gulf; as a result, recovering economies, especially in Asia, are obtaining their oil from more distant sources. That results in longer-term miles. Ultimately, this benefited VLCC markets, since those vessels provided the greatest economies of scale. We also observed sustained demand for product storage throughout the quarter, and in particular for jet fuel storage, which kept LR2 markets relatively far. This trend is clearly mirrored in our quarterly results. Let’s go to the next slide, Slide 9, and examine the fleet and order books. Tankers kept joining the market over the quarter, with many having been committed straight from the yard into product storage. That limited the effect on crude spot markets; there were reports, or there have been reports, of a substantial delivery backlog caused by COVID-19 related disruption, but that backlog appears to have been resolved. There has been recent speculation about enormous orders in clips of five and 10 vessels being placed in Asia. Those have not yet been confirmed and are not included in this dataset. Still, as a brief indication, there is potential for fleet expansion in both 2022 and even more so in 2023, assuming 20-year-old ships exit the competitive spot markets and oil demand evolves in line with the trend over that time horizon. One of the major x-factors for shipping ahead is clearly propulsion technology. Frontline monitors these developments closely, drawing on our extensive business platform, but there is also — there is still some distance to go before reaching any conclusions. Let’s go to Slide 10, where we’ll attempt to clarify one of this market’s mysteries. We have a record number of vessels, quite literally across all asset classes, reaching or exceeding the 20-year mark. The average recycling age for a tanker is very near that age, at times depending on the underlying freight rates. We are currently in markets with comparatively higher volumes of inventory still, along with a greater amount of sanctioned oil volume. This appears to have underpinned demand for tankers in the final part of their effective lifespan. In the chart below, we’ve shown this by comparing the average price obtained on tonnage transacted at an age close to 20 years, and the reported price obtained for recycling. That gap is quite stark, and it probably accounts for why recycling has been so quiet. Right now, selling vessels for alternative use is the option of choice for the illness. One thing worth pointing out: in the competitive spot markets where we do business, vetting policies subject us to strict scrutiny, so these vessels make up a negligible portion of those balances. Let's turn to how Frontline handles ESG. For years, Frontline's core values have been operations that are efficient, safe, and transparent. Efficient so we can save on costs, including fuel costs; safe so we can protect our seafarers, the environment, and our physical assets; transparent so the investing community, people like yourself, can readily grasp our business model. What we've discovered over the last couple of years, as we've gotten familiar with the relevant ESG framework for our industry, is that for us it's less about enforcing entirely new routines or changing how we conduct ourselves, and more about how we structure our communication around policies and routines that are already in place. A central piece of our business model is having technical management clustered, or shared if you prefer, with other listed companies we know well. Through this we achieve economies of scale, since we share knowledge and practices across more than 230 vessels. This collaboration hands us impressive leverage to shape and influence the standards we expect to be mapped, on social aspects as well as on governance. But we also share synergies when it comes to applying technology to optimize performance, both in the traditional sense, like speed and consumption, and also with respect to our environmental footprint. Frontline, though it may be a bit under communicated, is very well positioned to comply with the stricter environmental, social and governance framework. The shipping industry has to get comfortable with going forward. So let's move to Slide 12, the tanker market outlook. Greater oil supply is now essential for the tanker market to balance. For a while we were shielded. Our tankers were employed by storage; now we depend on volumes reaching the markets and normal trading patterns returning. Demand for tankers is still sustained by the OPEC+, and we find it extremely encouraging to see oil prices perform strongly as the volumes offered rose significantly, particularly from the Libyan exports that resumed in October. This in isolation, so oil demand might actually be firmer than the market in general expects. Looking at the benchmark Brent oil curve, we see the same pipeline expressed in a dramatic move from contango, or carry if you like, to a near flattening of the curve; this signals inventory draws to accelerate and oil markets potentially finding a balance at an earlier stage; it's obviously a bit early to call, but just to explain how these mechanisms work. Suppose we're currently pulling 3 million to 4 million barrels per day out of inventories. Once stockpiles get back to normal, that's the amount producers will need to supply, and that in turn should mean more tankers showing up during the month. Let me wrap things up now with Slide 13. Frontline, then, sits in a strong financial position. Nothing of substance comes due on our debt before 2023. Across these three connected expectations, the company is placed very favorably. Even with lockdowns dragging on in various regions, oil demand keeps climbing back. What crude prices are doing points to a shift in how the oil market feels, and looking ahead we anticipate greater volatility in the freight market. Thanks; with that, we can turn to the Q&A.
Randy Giveans
analystHello there, Frontline crew, and once more, congratulations on moving up, Lars.
Lars Barstad
executiveI really appreciate that, Randy.
Randy Giveans
analystTo start with, on the dividend — you reinstated it a year ago with a $0.10 payout, even though there was a loss after the 3Q 2019 results. Then you raised it to 40 or — my mistake, 70% of net income after the first quarter dropped in the second quarter, and now you've reduced it to zero even with a $0.29 gain. So I suppose my question is why has the dividend been so erratic over the past year? And what would prompt you to bring the dividend back, since it's obviously not merely positive net income.
Lars Barstad
executiveYes, positive net income alone isn't what drives this. We operate in a highly volatile market, and typically we do have fairly good visibility into our future earnings. For Q3, earnings were solid, but the — our visibility, or looking ahead to Q4, it doesn't appear too strong; and we're in the midst of a global pandemic, with plenty of uncertainty ahead. So we chose to hold onto the cash and the low — naturally, resuming dividend payments the moment we see the market has settled and is potentially set to come back to levels we consider appropriate.
Randy Giveans
analystUnderstood, alright. So it's more of just a subjective view of the market when it comes to the…
Lars Barstad
executiveWhen it comes to our dividend policy, we're positioned so that we prefer to exercise our judgment whenever we consider it necessary. And in this specific instance, we determined that doing so was the prudent choice.
Randy Giveans
analystUnderstood, okay. Then I suppose I have another item regarding your rates so far this quarter. For the fourth quarter, the VLCC and Suezmax figures have fallen compared with the third quarter, which is logical. Your LR2 rates, though, are moving upward. So what might explain that, and what number of your LR2 product tankers are currently engaged in the crude trade?
Lars Barstad
executiveSo, eight of our LR2s are deployed in crude. We have 10 running in the clean trade, and one of those is on a shorter time charter. The anticipated time charter return for Q4 is likely somewhat influenced by the returns we have observed on the clean side.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right. So for crude compared with products, do you have a view covering the upcoming 6 to 12 months? Which sector looks most attractive, or more attractive — I believe you said neither was especially attractive?
Lars Barstad
executiveThat's a really good question. The situation is that we've gone through seven quarters in which, in a sense, the crude side of things shaped the clean trade. Only during the last quarter and a half have clean product tankers truly performed much better. So calling the dirty Aframax market is genuinely hard — clearly it's now being hurt because Russia stayed fairly firmly together without that, and that damaged the North Sea barrel, or the Baltic barrels leaving Russia. My inclination would be to hold off on making that call until trade flows have returned to normal.
Randy Giveans
analystUnderstood. Fine, then. I'll let you get on your way. Many thanks.
Chris Tsung
analystHello, Lars. Hello, Inger. How are things with you both?
Lars Barstad
executiveHey there. All is well, thanks.
Chris Tsung
analystExcellent. That's good news. I'd like to hear more about why you chose to offload SeaTeam — can you go into a bit more detail on that? And are you also pursuing divestments of other joint ventures, such as the stake in Clean Marine?
Lars Barstad
executiveOkay, let me start by addressing SeaTeam. For a stretch of time, that company served us quite well as something we ran essentially in-house. Clearly, it isn't a core part of what we do. Our approach relies on contracting out services of the type SeaTeam provided; even so, it clearly delivered valuable insight to us and helped us gain a solid grasp of the markets, including those for technical management. The choice to exit that holding stemmed largely from an opportunity that presented itself, not from any strategic plan to move fast on it. An opportunity came along, and we arrived at an arrangement under which OSM will keep operating SeaTeam pretty much as it was originally set up, and will look after our vessels that fall under management, applying the very same approach that already existed within SeaTeam. So in essence, it amounts to staying true to our strategies — staying true to the strategy we began with. As for Clean Marine, that's an investment we continue to hold; we aren't what you'd call an active owner there; our role was closer to that of a listening post. So I'll set that aside — the scrubber market, or ETFC market, is somewhat inactive, as I'm sure you're aware, yet the company remains operational; and fundamentally, we've simply been viewing it as a passive investment.
Chris Tsung
analystAll right, thank you. Yeah, that's clear. And if we look at — not really the guidance, but the fixtures we've had so far in Q4, the other twos are somewhat difficult, and two as masses hasn't usually concluded in this manner. I suppose how much of that comes from the count of clean tankers relative to dirty ones, or which elements are letting Suezmax vessels trade beneath LR2s, or LR2s trade above Suezmax for Q4?
Lars Barstad
executiveWell, as I mentioned when I wrapped up Q3. Q3 turned out to be somewhat unusual as far as the way freight rates moved. Since in a typical market, Suezmax will do slightly below VLCCs, and then many of your efforts will trail somewhat beneath that. Yet this year, or this quarter, Suezmax has in fact lagged VLCCs by over 50%. And that's a market-wide view, not specific to us; given the OPEC cut, we've observed that longer-term miles have been given priority or grown. That has placed VLCCs in a far stronger spot thanks to their economies of scale. And Suezmax especially has felt this. So I believe the rate mirrors how extreme things have been in the Suezmax market, with few chances to trade across the quarter and a market quite severely battered. The LR2s have, over the whole quarter, beaten essentially every other segment except the VLCCs; and that's clearly because of their capacity to store clean products and especially for that.
Chris Tsung
analystAlright. So that's it on the storage clean trade. Alright, and then just a final quick thing about dry docking. In your prepared remarks, you mentioned the dry dock timing for Suez and one for LR2 in Q4. Could you give me how many Suezmax are in dry dock in Q4?
Lars Barstad
executiveHow many in Q4.
Inger Klemp
executiveFour for Suezmax.
Lars Barstad
executiveYes, four.
Chris Tsung
analystAll right, that's 4 Suez vessels plus a single LR2 during the fourth quarter. Appreciate it, everyone. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Jon Chappell
analystThanks a lot. Good afternoon to you, Lars and Inger.
Lars Barstad
executiveGood afternoon, Jon.
Jon Chappell
analystInger, let me start with a quick one about the dividends. Given where your fourth quarter rates stand so far, it's entirely sensible, but you've also managed to refinance quite a bit of debt on very favorable terms during a really tough market. Do the new facilities carry any limits on dividend payments or payout ratios that might have factored into choosing to suspend it this quarter?
Inger Klemp
executiveNo. Our new facilities include no such reductions, so that had no bearing on it.
Jon Chappell
analystAlright, and Lars comes aboard at a fascinating moment. Frontline also has a history of pushing hard precisely when rivals aren't able to. So through the dividend you're holding onto cash. Inger has performed excellently at strengthening the balance sheet. Yet you brought up the ambiguity and pandemic-era asset prices falling quite sharply. How would you sort of see 2021 in your position and in Frontline's position within the industry, when it comes to buying assets, chartering in vessels, simply piling on more leverage while others are merely anxious about staying alive.
Lars Barstad
executiveWell, like you mentioned, being aggressive against other comps is already part of our DNA. We additionally have a really solid shareholder supporting us; so clearly — we're examining — clearly this is something that has us quite thrilled about what's ahead. At this moment I'd say the uncertainties are somewhat too large, to be completely frank. Even though we're optimistic. Certain risks sort of appear when you look at the coming couple of quarters; we believe chances will likely emerge as we churn and we see these levels especially on the freight side. And I believe we — folks will discover that Frontline's DNA hasn't truly altered, even if I'm occupying hot seats to complete it.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right, that's helpful. Many thanks, Lars. And thank you as well, Inger.
Lars Barstad
executiveMuch appreciated.
Analyst
analystHello, and thank you for taking my question. There are two items I'd like to raise. First, you brought up the unwinding of the contango storage circumstance. Could you share your estimate of what proportion of that has already taken place? Second, Libya went from essentially shipping hardly anything at all — I saw a report the other day saying it's now above 1 million barrels a day. Does that give the Suezmax market in the Eastern Mediterranean some support on the rate side?
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks. Those are two truly excellent questions. Starting with floating storage: on Slide 8 of our presentation, we include some figures sourced from ClipperData, or Clipper Data. The approach I take, or that we take, toward storage is to examine holdings kept over a lengthy span. That's why we set the threshold at 21 days; those volumes topped out above 100 million barrels; at present they've fallen to 60 million barrels; that works out to a 40% reduction. How much oil — once that process wraps up is hard to say, since there's also the matter of the shape of not just the crude curve, but the market as a whole. As I believe I noted as well, we're seeing what amounts to a record level of sanctioned barrels, or sanctioned production, globally, which likely means a somewhat larger volume of floating oil inventory is needed than we'd typically see; even so, it's trending lower. And in my view, we've removed at minimum 42%, perhaps as much as 50%, of that floating storage; turning to Libya, the situation there has been genuinely thrilling and rather unexpected. They've succeeded in scaling up, and based on the most recent figures I came across, it reached — they got to 1.2 million barrels per day. That has certainly made things much more compelling than they were over the previous couple of months. So we're noticing considerably more issues cropping up in the markets. We're also noticing chances opening up. Many of those barrels are, or for some time now actually have been, heading East. And that suits the Suezmax vessel size perfectly. So yes, it has given the Mediterranean market meaningful support.
Analyst
analystOkay, many thanks.
Greg Lewis
analystYes, thank you, and good afternoon, then Lars, congratulations on the position. I suppose I just had a somewhat wide-ranging question. I mean, it was kind of discussed that people are focused on the dividend, justifiably; so I guess I'll put it another way as I look at Frontline and the company appears to trade on — depending on which valuation metric and I know you don't wish to talk about NAV, but we can look at something like more Wall Street like EBITDA and the companies that are premium, and the company's been able to leverage that premium to grow and be opportunistic over time. So just kind of curious, what do you think drives that premium?
Lars Barstad
executiveSo what drives our relative pricing to our product is about…
Greg Lewis
analystRight. So, yeah, if you were looking to acquire a business, I suppose being at a premium is helpful when you want to pull that off. And so I'm just sort of wondering how you approach that, since it clearly creates opportunities for you? So I'm just sort of wondering how you approach that?
Lars Barstad
executiveWell, I'd say — to start with, plenty of elements go into determining what we charge. A few of them are perhaps outside our control — we're a preferred stock with significant liquidity and so on; on top of that, our cash breakeven thresholds are exceptionally low. Our leverage is comparatively high, which means you get a fairly fast payoff whenever the market shifts. And looking back, we've shown ourselves to be pretty generous to our shareholders. I realize we likely mention this each quarter, at minimum from the time I came to Frontline in 2015. but putting money into Frontline means you're investing alongside our biggest shareholder. You aren't exactly a lone investor in some huge company, and his record of caring about getting value for every dollar is widely recognized; so, I'd say that's a given, I'd imagine, and it's a tough figure to dissect.
Greg Lewis
analystAll right, that’s great. And when I consider that, as you look at the businesses in this space, you clearly described how to proceed and noted that although conditions are weak at present, there are grounds for optimism in later years. Given that you currently have a fairly appealing fleet — good ages, large vessels — should we expect chances to arise? Do you believe any M&A possibilities might emerge within the coming six to 12 months, or has it largely been the same set of participants for more than five years, with no real prospect for consolidation that you can see?
Robert Macleod
executiveConsolidation opportunities will always exist, yet once again, price and opportunity remain the key questions, naturally. The markets have in fact consolidated, though perhaps not in the manner investors might prefer — rather, larger pools are being formed as trading entities expand and so on. As a result, the number of individual owners operating three or four ships may not have declined, but their tonnage has at least been brought together in some fashion. As for M&A, you and I both know there are always the typical possibilities, or names you might call the usual suspects; we keep watching them at all times and are continually present in the markets seeking opportunities. That said, perhaps not right now, given how the market is currently behaving.
Greg Lewis
analystAll right, many thanks. Have a good day.
Randy Giveans
analystHey, returning with two brief modeling questions. First, regarding the loan facilities, we’ve got LIBOR plus 190 basis points, so that’s quite impressive, Inger. But after those recent refis, is the intention now to perhaps repay the outstanding $60 million on the Hemen facility? And with the new refis recently completed, what are your weighted average interest expense and debt amort schedule through 2021, in terms of quarterly payments?
Inger Klemp
executiveYes. We expect to be — were you asking about the ordinary instalments, is that what you meant?
Randy Giveans
analystYes.
Inger Klemp
executiveYes. All right. During 2021, the regular payment under the loan arrangements currently in place comes to roughly $160 million per year, split equally across each quarter. And there will be a modest step-up in those regular payments during 2021, since we will be taking delivery of the four LR2 tankers and drawing down on the new facility for the 16 Suezmax tankers, which we went through earlier in this presentation.
Randy Giveans
analystYes.
Inger Klemp
executiveYour remaining question concerned the Hemen facility, correct? Was that what you were asking about?
Randy Giveans
analystAll right, so about that Hemen facility — the $60 million still outstanding.
Inger Klemp
executiveThere's an agreement we've got in place that sets May 2021 as the maturity date. So our intention is to stick with what that agreement says, and repayment will happen in May.
Randy Giveans
analystUnderstood. Fine. Then regarding that overall weighted average interest expense, I notice your interest expense dropped quite a bit compared with Q2. I'm just attempting to figure out where that heads in Q3 or Q4.
Inger Klemp
executiveAll right. As of the close of Q3, I believe the average cost stood at roughly 2.3%. And I believe in Q4, a bit less, approximately that same amount.
Randy Giveans
analystUnderstood. Alright, and then a final modeling query before everyone can head off to Thanksgiving, I suppose, here in the States. Regarding operating expenses, there was a massive jump during the third quarter. I realize you mentioned the bulk of that stemmed from certain dry docking and some one-time crewing expense, just attempting to gauge an appropriate run rate for that in Q4 of 2021.
Inger Klemp
executiveApart from SFL, it would deliver payer during Q3. Nevertheless, we've got 22 within the press release that they'd likewise experience a sort of one-off in Q4 concerning this crew cost tied to COVID-19, or $1.5 million.
Randy Giveans
analystYes.
Inger Klemp
executiveOf course, our decrease is lower compared to what we saw this quarter, at $4.8 million. We've also mentioned that our vessels would be going into dry dock during Q4. So my sense is you shouldn't anticipate costs dropping further in Q3 when it comes to dry docking happening in Q4 — likely they'll be somewhat greater; apart from that, I don't believe we'd see any unusual items in Q4; as for 2021, I don't expect anything out of the ordinary in that sense. The sole thing Frontline must account for is, naturally, how the COVID-19 pandemic unfolds, and I'd feel confident about it, yet it appears to be active, it's falling into place, and things ought to be fairly normal after some time there too; so there shouldn't be any expenses tied to crude changes and those kinds of matters as we move into 2021.
Randy Giveans
analystAlright, hopefully that turns out to be the case. That sounds great. Well, thank you very much. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks.
George Burmann
analystMorning, everyone. Actually, good afternoon. I appreciate you fitting me in. There are a few things I want to ask about. First off, your fleet used to be mostly VLCC and Suezmax tonnage. Then over the past 2 years, you shifted toward the LR2 Aframax segment. Could you explain what drove that decision? That's my first point.
Lars Barstad
executiveSure. Through the years, Frontline's fleet has branched out across what amounts to 3 main or core categories. When it comes to the LR2 Aframax sector — or more precisely the LR2 sector — it functions as the VLCC equivalent within the clean trade; for quite a while that reflected a worldwide trend in which refining capacity expanded quickly across the Middle East as well as Asia, alongside the expense of refining capacity in North America and afterward Northwest Europe. Naturally, that situation got somewhat derailed by the fracking revolution, which meant U.S. refineries wound up with fairly inexpensive feedstock. And we could sustain run rates and margins across an extended stretch. Yet the original investment came about from the imbalance between supply and demand on the products side; this is once again becoming more and more relevant as India aims to double its refining capacity in a comparatively brief period. Plus we observe enormous expansion of refining capacity in China, which means China might turn into a major petroleum products exporter. Meanwhile, we currently see European refineries having a hard time and to a significant degree closing down. So that was — that was essentially the central strategy driving it. What we clearly ran into was that clean markets underperformed versus expectations. The LR2 ended up participating in the dirty trade, so pulling somewhat under half the fleet into that dirty trade; however these vessels are able to be cleaned up and can return to the LR2 markets, yes.
George Burmann
analystAll right, excellent. Moving on to the next one — I think you completed a fairly significant transaction in the prior year involving Trafigura, if I'm not mistaken, covering 10 Suezmax tankers, quite modern vessels built in 2019. Do a number of those remain on time charter — meaning chartered back to Trafigura — and if so, what are the rates?
Lars Barstad
executiveFive vessels are still on time charter back to Trafigura, structured with a profit-sharing arrangement; so — the rate stands at $28,400 per day.
George Burmann
analystSo right now they bring in solid money for you, correct, even if we aren't splitting profits with them?
Lars Barstad
executiveDefinitely.
George Burmann
analystAll right. So, turning to scrapping, you said during your opening comments that given how rates stand at present, plenty of businesses would incur enormous losses if they kept transporting. Have you noticed any recent opportunities at the scrap yards that have let companies scrap? And you also noted, apart from scrapping, what options would a company have when purchasing a VLCC or Suezmax tanker that is 20 or 25 years old?
Lars Barstad
executiveWell, starting with scrapping. From what I gather, I think we prefer the term recycling. To begin with, understand the recycling facilities; they too have been severely impacted by the global pandemic, which means they've had to close. Right now there's growing activity in the recycling markets; and we're seeing an increasing number of vessels sold for recycling, though not necessarily in <<inaudible>>. A few Aframax units have gone, but only very few deals involving a Suezmax have been reported. And as I said during my presentation, a disconnect exists between the price these vintage vessels can fetch for not necessarily trading, but for storage and other activities, versus what the recycling companies are prepared to pay you for this deal. So, regarding what these tankers are used for, I think I'd be somewhat inclined to speculate, but clearly there is oil being transported somewhat outside the normal stock market; and there are, as I mentioned, quite a large amount of sanctioned barrels in the world right now and these needs somewhere to be stored.
George Burmann
analystAll right. Then for a final point, perhaps you could address this once more — I saw that the ship management division is being divested, and you expect to record a gain of roughly $7 million in Q4 from that sale. Why did you decide to divest this division, basically moving your in-house ship management toward an outsourced model? Does that save you money — is it more cost efficient?
Lars Barstad
executiveLet me give a bit of detail about our mobile. We have technical managers internally, but crewing is outsourced — effectively the daily operation of the vessels. That means we keep an internal organization, technical management departments, actually a fairly big one, which supervises third-party technical managers; and SeaTeam was regarded as a third-party technical manager. So in a way, we held a company that we would ordinarily contract out to for that role. This may clarify what I said about it not really being a core business, and the divestment happened mainly because OSM approached us with a chance to keep operating the company. That company will go on being operated in much the same way and to the same standards we held when we owned it directly. And clearly we will purchase that company's services moving forward, exactly as we do with the other third-party technical managers we use.
George Burmann
analystAll right, excellent. If I could squeeze in one final item; at this moment, what rate of interest do you typically pay on the debt you're taking on? You said you had an extremely favorable debt facility, with a really attractive rate, and with weights essentially at zero across the globe, so I'm curious how big a benefit that gives your business right now, and for what period are those rates fixed?
Lars Barstad
executiveI'll have Inger respond to that, she'll handle that question.
Inger Klemp
executiveRegarding the fresh credit arrangements we've now established, during this call we walked through the term loan side of things, and the margin on those got fixed for a period of 5 years; beyond that, our presentation includes the debt maturity schedule, so it's clear how each facility will come due down the road; the blended rate we're announcing as of today comes to a margin of 190 basis points plus LIBOR, and LIBOR right now sits at quite a depressed level. Three-month LIBOR stands near 30 basis points, or roughly 25 basis points, something in that vicinity — that's the figure we're working with. On top of that, naturally, there's the turn out facility mentioned a little earlier in the presentation, carrying a 6.25% rate that we pay on the $60 million involved, though it represents only a tiny slice of the overall loan book. So in a sense it barely moves the average.
George Burmann
analystSo, in the event that LIBOR rates were to rise, your interest rates — would the costs tied to your interest rate also increase somewhat?
Inger Klemp
executiveYes, that would happen. On top of that, we currently hold interest rate swaps covering $550 million at a level somewhat above 25 basis points or 30 basis points, despite those being quite competitive. So, one could say there's overall exposure to an increase in LIBOR rates, but does that simply make sense? Yes.
George Burmann
analystYes. And perhaps just one final quick item, regarding scrubbers — does every vessel you operate now have scrubbers installed in cases where they're needed?
Lars Barstad
executiveNo. Roughly 66% of the ships in our fleet currently have scrubbers on them; we sort of eased off how quickly we were putting scrubbers in, given the shrinking scrubber margin tied partly to how the gap has narrowed between high-sulfur and low-sulfur fuel. That's how I'd phrase it — we wouldn't be able to simply restart that initiative down the road.
George Burmann
analystI've been hearing some recent reports concerning slow steaming. Might that have a beneficial impact on day weights and on demand for tankers?
Lars Barstad
executiveThat's possible. It — I'm not certain what sort of context you mean by that. Yet to start with, on the label leg, whenever we are empowered, quite often we get to choose our own speeds. And given this earning environment, to be quite honest, we'll slow down as much as we possibly can. However, there's also a broader discussion about how, when our carbon footprint is measured, slow speeding might have a part to play so that tanker fleets can meet the goals of IMO going forward; so — but this is still, kind of, somewhat up in the air. I have to admit, as of yet we haven't really examined that deeply.
George Burmann
analystAll right, that's excellent. I really appreciate you taking the time today.
Lars Barstad
executiveYou're welcome.
Inger Klemp
executiveThanks.
Lars Barstad
executiveAll right. In that case, I simply want to express my appreciation for this call and for your attention. To those of you with us from the States, have a wonderful Thanksgiving, and please stay safe. Thanks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.