Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 19, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 32 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Lars Barstad

executive
#1

Hello everyone, and welcome — whether you're joining in the morning or later in the day — to the call covering Frontline's results for the fourth quarter and the entire year. This past year brought plenty of ups and downs, and unexpected shocks have turned into something we now see regularly in the markets where we operate. Our operations have felt the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic in numerous ways, yet the thing that matters most is that every one of our seafarers has stayed safe, and no serious harm has come to anyone within our organization. Conditions in the tanker sector were difficult during the year, but taken overall it proved to be a strong year from a business standpoint, and our full-year performance in 2020 came in as the strongest we've posted since 2008. Now please turn with me to Slide 3, where we'll review the key points. Frontline came into the fourth quarter of 2020 on a soft note, expecting some degree of normal seasonality to kick in, as the northern hemisphere usually stock up for winter. This time around the fourth quarter proved to be softer than Q3, actually, for the first time in 10 years. When you look at it on a low-to-discharge basis, our VLCCs earned $17,200 each day, Suezmaxes brought in $9,800 daily, and LR2s generated $12,500 per day. For the third quarter up to now, roughly 78% of the VLCC days we had available went for $22,600, 68% of available Suezmax days came in at $17,800, and 65% of LR2/Aframax days were booked at $12,200 per day. Describing the market during the fourth quarter as tough would be accurate. I'll get into that subject more later in my comments. Right now, I'll hand it over to Inger, who will take you through Frontline's main financial results.

Inger Klemp

executive
#2

Thanks, Lars. Good morning, everyone, and good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. If you’ll turn with me to Slide 4, we’ll review the income statement. In the fourth quarter, total operating revenues less overage expenses came to $101 million. Adjusted EBITDA was $31 million; our net loss came in at $9.2 million, or $0.05 per share. Adjusted net loss for the fourth quarter was $20 million, or $0.10 per share. During the quarter, we recorded several adjustments: a $6.9 million gain from selling SeaTeam, a $2.5 million gain on derivatives, a $1.9 million unrealized gain on marketable securities, $1.3 million in amortization of acquired time charters, and $1.6 million from our share of losses at associated companies. Compared with the third quarter, adjusted net income in Q4 fell by $76 million. The main reason was a $75 million drop in time charter equivalents earnings, reflecting the lower reported TCE rates in the fourth quarter that Lars discussed. For full year 2020, Frontline reports net income of $413 million, or $2.09 per share, and adjusted net income of $421 million, or $2.13 per share. That makes it the strongest annual result since 2008. Now let’s move to the balance sheet on Slide 5. As of December 31, 2020, Frontline held $413 million in cash and cash equivalents, including the undrawn amount under our senior unsecured loan facility, the marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. In November 2020, we signed two terminal facilities totaling $361.5 million to refinance two existing terminal facilities that matured in the second quarter of 2021 and had total balloon payments of $324.4 million. We also signed a loan facility of $133.7 million to partially finance the CapEx requirements, which stood at $142.4 million at the end of 2020, for the four LR2 tankers we had under construction. Additionally, in February 2021, we extended the terms of our senior unsecured revolving credit facility of up to $275 million by 12 months, to May 2022. As of December 31, 2022, $60 million of this extended facility has been recorded as long-term debt. $216 million remains available and undrawn under this facility. With the refinancing and financing concluded, we have no material debt maturities until 2023. And the newbuilding program is fully funded. Now let’s examine the cash breakeven rates and OpEx more closely on Slide 6; for 2021, we estimate an average cash cost breakeven rate of approximately $21,600 per day for the VLCCs, $17,800 per day for the Suezmax tankers, and $15,600 per day for the LR2 tankers. The fleet average estimate is about $18,200 per day. These rates represent the all-in daily rates our vessels must earn to cover the budgeted operating costs and dry dock the estimated interest expenses, TC and bareboat hire, installments on loans and G&A expenses. During Q4 2020, our OpEx came in at $7,800 each day for VLCCs, $9,700 daily for Suezmax, and $8,300 per day for LR2 tankers. Dry docking of 4 Suezmax vessels plus 1 LR2 tanker during that quarter affected these OpEx figures; in Q1 2021, we'll dry dock 1 Suezmax tanker. On the slide's right-hand graph, we've illustrated yearly incremental cash flow following debt service — on a per-share basis, assuming achieved rates of $10,000, $20,000, $30,000, or $40,000 per day above our cash breakeven base, respectively. And then, apologies, these figures account for time-chartered-out ships. Newbuilding deliveries have been factored in, and they cover a 365-day span starting January 1, 2021. For instance, given a fleet average cash cost breakeven of $18,200 daily, and adding $30,000, the fleet's average TCE rate would reach $48,200 per day. Frontline would then produce $3.46 in cash flow per share after debt service; with that, I'll pass it back to Lars.

Lars Barstad

executive
#3

Thanks, Inger. Now we’ll turn to Slide 7 and go back over the tank markets in the fourth quarter. During Q2, crude stockpiles climbed at an unprecedented rate — 2.6 million barrels per day, based on EIA data. With oil consumption continuing to increase, reaching roughly 10 million barrels above Q2 levels, crude prices kept getting stronger, and the market’s structure gave participants an incentive to drain tanks, whether afloat or ashore, because forward prices were increasingly below prompt prices, which made keeping inventory uneconomical. A large number of tankers were used for storage in the latter half of last year, especially beyond China. That destocking cycle put additional strain on a market that was already oversupplied, since those ships are now back competing in the spot trade. Asia, and China in particular, has driven most of the recovery so far; for a time this propped up the VLCC market as it brought oil demand back from the Atlantic basin. Later last year, we observed China also pulling from inventories, which dampened its need for tankers. By December 2020, Chinese oil use hit a record high of 16.6 million barrels, per the EIA. Let’s go to Slide 8 and examine the crude fleet and order books. The claim that vessels over 20 years old have difficulty trading in the conventional oil market is beyond dispute. Oil majors, traders, and national oil companies all enforce a hard cutoff at 20 years; as a result, once a ship has passed its 20-year class, our options are very few. And with freight rates at zero to negative for non-eco tonnage, it’s hard to see any prospects for that part of the fleet in alternative use. Right now the conversion market for FFOs and SSOs isn’t very active, and storage demand is limited because all the curves are in steep <<inaudible>>. We also think the coming regulatory changes on GHG emissions will pose a challenge to the fleet ahead; that points to a limited lifespan even for a vessel aged 17.5 years. Ordering activity is subdued and doesn’t line up with the fleet’s current age profile; we did see a few orders late last year, and that gave the order book a slight lift. About 30% of the total tanker fleet is roughly 15 years old. And once energy efficiency rules — the now-famous EESI — take effect in 2023, the possibility of a carbon tax regime — and the potential work for a carbon tax regime gets underway. That entire segment of the fleet will either have to invest heavily or much higher. Let’s move to Slide 9; we want to discuss our clean product tankers; ordinarily we don’t bring up our clean trading capabilities in these presentations, but we do have 18 modern LR2s, with four more to come, which makes us a significant owner in this space. When travel got curtailed in 2020, the drop in jet fuel demand dealt a heavy blow to refinery margins. For years now, margins at European and U.S. refineries have been squeezed. And because of large prospects, very little money went into upgrading and modernizing those facilities. The weak margins of last year sped up choices to shut refineries for good or turn them into storage facilities or, in a handful of cases, floating plants. Asia overall, and the Middle East and China specifically, have grown refining capacity a lot over the past three years. Today's refineries handle a broader mix of crudes with greater efficiency, and I could walk you through a whole presentation on that subject. What matters is that they beat local refineries on cost, especially in Europe, and to some extent in the U.S. as well. On the slide here, you can see that permanently shuttered refining capacity in Europe amounts to around 500,000 barrels per day, while in the U.S. it's near 700,000 barrels per day. Asia has seen some shutdowns totaling 705,000 barrels per day, yet fresh capacity there reaches 1.4 million barrels per day. On a net basis, we observe that, or rather we anticipate that, trade flows will shift because of this. With product demand returning to normal after the COVID-19 pandemic in Europe and the U.S., and we must presume some degree of normality comes back across the next several years. Jet fuel and other products will much more probably be sourced from Asia, and that brings longer-term miles. For the developments we expect in the product trade loss, our LR2s deliver excellent economies of scale. Turning to Slide 10, let's talk about the market outlook from our perspective. In this presentation I'm concentrating on the near-term drivers, since that's likely the engaging portion given where markets stand. Saudi Arabia has indicated it will reverse its voluntary one million-barrel per day reduction starting April 2021. That's on top of anything else they agreed to. The typical cold weather across the Northern Hemisphere threw off normal demand patterns. Gas, LNG in Asia switched on capabilities to — apologies, the gas and LNG surge in Asia, plus the unclear capabilities regarding our oil for heating dynamics, since we haven't truly seen oil for heating in ten years, generates plenty of uncertainty about how much oil has been — how much incremental oil got consumed over this stretch. The jump in LNG prices implied oil prices at $260 per day, creating strong incentives to burn oil for heating. We've had episodes of a comparable situation, like when skiing abruptly became popular in Madrid, and most recently in Texas, we've witnessed how cold weather impacted production. Goldman Sachs puts that production loss at roughly 700,000 barrels per day for February. Oil demand keeps recovering even with prolonged lockouts. Oil prices point to markets tightening. As we see it, floating storage no longer acts as a major factor pressing down on the tanker market. Also, during the month of April by itself, the EIA anticipates a rise of 3 million barrels in oil supply; therefore, let's turn to Slide 11 and bring all of this together. So, after a major pullback in worldwide growth, the global tanker markets corrected dramatically in the second half of 2020. A robust rebound in 2021 is being priced in by every major commodity market, and worldwide GDP should expand 5.5% over the course of this year. Oil demand is coming back, and exactly how quickly remains somewhat unclear; we are all aware that the analyst agencies respond slowly both when demand falls away and when demand is on the mend to the upside. During 2021, worldwide oil output is projected to rise by 5.3 million barrels. Once this recovery begins for tanker Suezmax, yet we sit quite low in the cycle, as the chart in the bottom right corner shows. OPEC+ is anticipated to soften its cuts starting in Q2 2021. And given all of that, we think Frontline is nicely positioned to benefit from a tanker market recovery thanks to our modern OPEC exposed fleet. With that, I would like to invite questions from the audience.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#4

Thanks. Good afternoon. Lars, while I was going through your press release and presentation, it hit me that Frontline has long had a reputation for being agile and curious when others sort of can't be. And at this point, with you having been quite prudent on the dividend side, and Inger having done a great job pushing up the maturities, it looks like you're sitting in a position of financial strength at a moment when the markets are still really kind of struggling; so how are you thinking about the coming six months and Frontline's willingness and ability to acquire ships before the optimistic upturn starts, maybe later in the year or early next year? Or do you sit back and wait until you see the whites of the eyes on a recovery before getting more aggressive?

Lars Barstad

executive
#5

Well, that's a good question and it's an expected one. I think I'd like to emphasize our capabilities — as you mentioned there. Whether we sit back, whether we're looking at something right now, or whether we'll do something in Q2 or later, I'm not going to comment on, to be quite honest; but the solid answer, I believe, is we're always looking. And our financial show, where we're also ready to move when we see the opportunity.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#6

All right; my second one is more about the sector, something else that's been on my mind. I'd say scrapping matters somewhat at the margin. In this market, it isn't the biggest piece of the recovery. Demand is what will drive that. Still, plenty of companies keep bringing up the new emission rules, the awful state of the market, and the way older vessels get penalized, and how that should push scrapping — you even devoted an entire slide to it. Yet it appears scrapping has barely happened over the past 12 months, a stretch when rates have been about as poor as they can get, certainly across the last six to nine months. And at this point there's a shared optimism that OPEC will resume output, the world is bouncing back, and conditions will improve. So given the belief that things can only improve from here, why should scrapping speed up, when at the absolute bottom there was really little being done?

Lars Barstad

executive
#7

Well, I have to say — and I believe I said this, or at least hinted at it, during my presentation — that the absence of scrapping in this market puzzles me somewhat. I think I made the point that by every economic logic — and we shouldn't be doing much scrapping this month or last month, and we haven't seen it happen yet. Still, I expect scrapping to pick up as the year goes on. As for the difficult, if somewhat unclear, picture when it comes to regulatory shifts and similar matters, I believe that will be a very significant driver for our market ahead. But I won't be — I'm not going to side with those predicting doom, claiming every ship older than 10 years must be scrapped and so on. There's plenty that can be done so tankers genuinely cut their GHG Emissions using the kits they already have. And — but certainly, it will shape our market ahead, and I think one has to be somewhat skeptical of all the different forecasts analysts make about the tanker fleet's prospects.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#8

All right, that's clear. Thanks, Lars.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#9

Hi there. How are you doing, Lars and Inger?

Lars Barstad

executive
#10

Hello.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#11

So, I suppose I'd like to kick things off, sort of continuing from what Jon mentioned about your robust balance sheet and the points you both brought up. And rather than inquiring about takeovers within the fleet scope, how about — do you have any inclination to perhaps ramp up your operational side, maybe even moving into charters? What might the power of this market be, and what kinds of durations <<inaudible>>?

Lars Barstad

executive
#12

My apologies. Your audio isn't coming through clearly enough for us. Sorry about that.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#13

Is this better?

Lars Barstad

executive
#14

Yes, this is better.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#15

My apologies. I suppose I was simply building on Jon's point and noting that you folks possess a remarkably robust balance sheet. Inger has performed excellently in extending the debt maturities all the way to 2023. And rather than just <<inaudible>> when it comes to growing the fleet, how do you feel about boosting your operational leverage by securing additional charters of whatever length?

Lars Barstad

executive
#16

Yeah; so, assuming I understood you properly, essentially to expand our — our willingness to raise our operational leverage. The issue is that — allow me to respond in another way. As things stand, we're genuinely pleased with where we are, since our fleet is spot exposed to an extremely high degree, except for the five Suezmax vessels we've got tied up on long-term time charter out. We're at almost 100% spot exposure; so essentially, we find ourselves able to capture the upside should we wish to enhance our capacity to earn more. That, I believe, is likely some months away. And returning to what was said earlier, we are examining options, though I'm not in a position to verify anything.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#17

Yeah. No, that's reasonable. And I suppose, if you happen to be examining — can you kind of shed light on whether what you're reviewing is those particular propulsion technologies, or possibly within the broader < >?

Lars Barstad

executive
#18

Apologies, I'm genuinely having a hard time catching what you said, though was propulsion what you brought up?

Chris Tsung

analyst
#19

Yeah, yeah. My apologies — does this come through any clearer?

Lars Barstad

executive
#20

Yeah, we're getting you in fits and starts.

Inger Klemp

executive
#21

That's where you're stopping.

Lars Barstad

executive
#22

If we're considering different kinds of propulsion, though? Yeah, that's true. Still, we aren't prepared to put money into it at this point. In our view, the jury hasn't fully decided. Like I said during our Q3 presentation, when it comes to modern fleets, we're in fairly solid shape, at least regarding emissions out to 2030. Naturally, for us to commit capital to propulsion — and by that I mean retrofits or placing orders for vessels with a share that differs from the conventional one — we truly have to witness — it resembles the scrubber debate somewhat; we always began putting money into scrubbers once the economic rationale was clear; with propulsion, that moment hasn't arrived. We don't know — well, we're quite certain a common tax will come. What amount it will be, we don't know. How it will be implemented, we don't know. So essentially, the propulsion question remains something we're still weighing. I could readily state that LPG and LNG, and later ammonia, appear likely to be the path forward, or one of the paths forward. My guess is we'll land in a scenario with multiple propulsion options, depending on the sort of trade you operate in. Still, I believe it's crucial to remember that we ship owners cannot be footing the bill for this sort of thing. So essentially, the market has to signal what it's prepared to pay. If that was a…

Chris Tsung

analyst
#23

All right, sounds good. Yes. That's part of it, though — what I mean is, I'll simply attempt to get back on and rejoin the line. So I apologize for the issue with my connection. Thanks, everyone.

Lars Barstad

executive
#24

All right.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#25

Hello there. Lars and Ingo, how are you doing?

Lars Barstad

executive
#26

How are you? Doing very well.

Inger Klemp

executive
#27

Okay.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#28

Great, great. Alright, so I just want to ask regarding the dividend — clearly, you repurchased it during the prior year, and no dividend has been distributed across the past 2 quarters. Therefore, assuming profits come back as anticipated, I suppose in the upcoming quarters, does some kind of formula exist for bringing the dividend back? Or would you say it's entirely at management's discretion? And if that's the case, what would prompt you to bring the dividend back?

Inger Klemp

executive
#29

Randy, my view is it matches what we said in the earnings release. We remain committed to giving dividends back to our shareholders together with the board, yet we would need to examine both positive results <<inaudible>> initially, we must see a positive result. And after that, clearly, we also need to consider the market in the presentation; so in a sense that's the same burden we carry in our press release.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#30

Understood, all right. So given that you’re active in the crude side and also the products side of the tanker business, where do you see the most upside over the next few months — whether that’s by asset type like VLCCs, Suezmax, or LR2?

Lars Barstad

executive
#31

Honestly, that question has come up more than once already today. The way I think about our company is that it runs like an engine with four cylinders: we’ve got VLCCs, Suezmax, and the LR2s, which trade in both clean and dirty. Lately there’s been at least a bit of a spark in the Suezmax cylinder — nothing to get thrilled about, but it is at least climbing out of negative returns. At the moment, it’s the Aframax space that has some excitement, driven by weather and disruptions around the U.S. Gulf. To be completely frank, I’m not certain which segment gets hit first when the recovery narrative potentially begins to play out — maybe the VLCC markets, since ultimately you need refinery runs to rise for products to move. Still, the beginning of any volume comeback would likely originate in the Middle East, and that would benefit the VLCCs first, I’d say.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#32

Understood. Fine, that makes sense. Then, moving quickly to asset values — what sort of effect has this recent market softness had on them? At the same time, though, there's a positive view for the second half of 2025, correct? So it appears as though the share price rally might have run ahead of the gains in asset values. Is that right? Or what are you observing there?

Lars Barstad

executive
#33

Your read matches mine. In my view, the equity market is putting recovery at a somewhat later point. So clearly, it's skipping past the near-term uncertainty. That said, a handful of deals have provided some support for values, at least when you consider the five-year-old market; I also think we're set to receive a bit of price transparency on resales, on a new build. Still, I wouldn't call it an increase, though I would say this — at a minimum, we're solidly at what could be the bottom.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#34

Alright, sounds good. That's all I've got. Appreciate it once more.

Lars Barstad

executive
#35

Thanks.

Inger Klemp

executive
#36

Thanks.

Lars Barstad

executive
#37

All right. I want to express my appreciation to everyone for tuning in. We're enthusiastic about what lies ahead in the tanker segment and hope each of you has a wonderful weekend. Thanks.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.