Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 27, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks a lot. I appreciate it, and greetings to everybody on this morning and afternoon. It's great to have you join Frontline's earnings call for the first quarter of 2021. We are clearly rather pleased that we can present figures in the black, which might come as a surprise to a number of you. Corporate activity during Q1 2021 was relatively subdued, since our financial standing is solid and nothing significant was closed in that period. We remain highly committed to looking after the welfare of the people sailing our ships, given that they are out there facing the worldwide ups and downs of COVID-19 contamination. The teams handling our technical matters and operations are performing tremendously in softening the difficulties that come up; and it gives me great pleasure to say that our sales vaccination effort is progressing well. Let's turn to Slide 3 and review the key points. What we achieved in Q1 2021 really demonstrates the value of sticking with our approach, staying largely exposed to the spot market and not counting on a near-term market rebound, our chartering desk stayed committed to employing the ships on a monthly basis where we permit our vessels to take on lengthy voyages, locking in revenue while possibly foregoing further gains. Our contemporary, fuel-saving fleet was designed for exactly this and likewise provides us with such flexibility. This turned out to be the correct decision; during the first quarter of 2021, we earned $19,000 per day with our VLCC fleet, $15,200 per day with our Suezmax fleet, and $12,000 per day with our LR2/Aframax fleet; thus far in Q1, we have secured 70% of our VLCC days at $18,100 per day; 63% of our Suezmax days at $13,600 per day and; 59% of our LR2/Aframax days at $14,200 per day. Every figure shown in the table follows the load to chart basis. Before Inger walks you through the financial highlights, allow me to briefly address fleet development too. We accepted delivery of two out of our four LR2s arriving this year from Fusion and from Future in March and April, respectively, which brings the count of LR2s we have on the water to 20. Additionally, after that, we verified the purchase via resale of six high-spec ECO scrubber-fitted VLCCs scheduled for delivery from Hyundai Heavy Industries in Korea, with five in 2022 and one early in 2023. I'll now hand things over to Inger for the financial highlights.
Inger Klemp
executiveThanks, Lars, and hello everyone, good morning or good afternoon depending on where you're joining from. Moving on to Slide 4, let's review the income statement. As Lars mentioned, we're pleased to deliver results in the black. Frontline's total operating revenues net voyage expenses came to $107 million for the first quarter. Adjusted EBITDA stood at $59 million, and we posted net income of $28.9 million, which equals $0.15 per share. In addition, adjusted net income was $8.8 million, or $0.04 per share. Those adjustments include a $15.7 million gain on derivatives, a $3.1 million unrealized gain on marketable securities, $1.2 million amortization of acquired time charters, and a $0.1 million share of results of associated companies. Adjusted net income for the first quarter rose $21 million versus the prior quarter. That improvement came from an $11 million drop in ship operating expenses, largely driven by $6.4 million lower drydocking costs. We also saw time charter equivalent earnings rise $6.8 million, attributed to stronger TCE rates, along with an $11.2 million reduction in other costs. Now let's examine the balance sheet on Slide 5. Total balance sheet figures grew by $10 million during the first quarter. The quarter's balance sheet changes mainly stemmed from taking delivery of the LR2 tanker Front Fusion, plus routine debt repayments and depreciation. As of March 31, 2021, Frontline held $380 million in cash and cash equivalents, including undrawn amounts under our senior unsecured loan facility, marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. Next, let's look more closely at Slide 6, covering cash break-even rates and OpEx. We project cash cost break-even rates for the rest of 2021 at roughly $21,500 per day for VLCCs, $17,700 per day for Suezmax tankers, and $15,900 per day for LR2 tankers. This gave a fleet average estimate of about $18,000 per day. These rates are the all-in day rates that our vessels mature to cover budgeted operating costs and drydock, estimated interest expenses, TC and bareboat hire and installments and on loans and G&A expenses; during the quarter, we recorded OpEx expenses of $7,300 per day for the VLCCs, $7,100 per day for the Suezmax tankers, and $7,200 per day for the LR2 tankers. We drydocked just one Suezmax tanker in the first quarter, and we anticipate drydocking two Suezmax tankers and four LR2 tankers in the second quarter. Now let's check the graph on the right side of this slide. As always, we present incremental cash flow after debt service per year and per share, assuming $10,000, $20,000, $30,000 or $40,000 per day achieved rates above our cash break-even rates. These figures take into account time charter equivalent vessels, which have been modified based on newbuilding deliveries, and we are examining a span of 365 days starting April 1, 2021. So, to illustrate with this chart, if the fleet's average cash cost break-even rate stands at $18,100 per day and we add $30,000 to the average fleet earnings, the TCE rate would come to $48,100 per day. In that scenario, Frontline would produce a cash flow per share after the service of $3.45; at this point, I hand things back over to Lars.
Lars Barstad
executiveI appreciate that, Inger. Turning to Slide 7, let's take a look at a recap of the tanker market in Q1 2021. Obviously, conditions have been rather challenging. From January through March, total oil consumption increased by 4.3 million barrels, hitting 96.5 million barrels per day. Conversely, supply dropped by 0.5 million barrels. The main driver behind this was what Saudi Arabia did with their voluntary cuts, which brought things to 93.5 million barrels per day by quarter's end. With inventories continuing to be drawn down, tanker demand stayed essentially flat. During this quarter, we did witness Libyan volumes coming back. We also saw, near the close of the quarter, the U.S. cold snap, which generated considerable volatility. As a result, tanker rates strengthened toward the quarter's end, and that's actually quite encouraging because it signals a tighter balance than people might assume. So to sum up Q1, consumption is outpacing supply, and the inventory drawdown is somewhat offsetting that volume. Looking at the chart on the right, what you see is what I'd call a ripple instead of a really robust market, but rates responded quickly — first the Aframax segment shifted as Libya reopened, and then the Suezmax segment followed, driven largely by the U.S. Gulf cold snap, or the U.S. cold snap, impacting the volume side in the U.S. Now let's proceed to Slide 8 and examine tanker orderbooks. Across every asset class, we're seeing delayed recycling. There's minimal incentive to retain older tonnage in this market, yet those vessels stay on the fleet list. Recycling prices have climbed 30% year-to-date and are currently being negotiated at roughly $550 per long ton, or $23 million for a VLCC. To some degree, this is being outcompeted by the fact that demand persists for vintage tonnage from undisclosed price buyers at relatively firm prices. The total tanker order book has contracted by about 4% year-to-date. This asset vessels deliver and new ordering has been quite subdued. On VLCCs, we've seen 20 new — 28 new orders placed. But with 25 vessels delivered over the same period, the order book remains fairly flat. The VLCC order book sits at approximately 9% of the existing fleet, while the overall tanker order book is up or around 7% of the existing fleet. Let's go to Slide 9 and see what's happening with asset prices. Prices are indeed moving. Over the past 6 months, we've seen more than 170 new orders for containerships. We've also observed quite firm ordering on LPG, along with confirmation of LNG orders, which has added further momentum to the activity. Also, similar to what's happening across commodities generally, steel costs have dropped significantly. The underlying conditions in the tanker sector point toward capacity getting tighter in the years ahead, and stricter rules on greenhouse gas emissions make the argument even stronger for putting money into newer vessels that burn less fuel. That said, propulsion isn't what's driving things at this point. At present, what's pushing prices, along with this transaction, is yard capacity — or more accurately, the shortage of it. Let's turn to Slide 10 and examine the near-term picture. We're right now in the midst of OPEC plus raising output; the increases are happening at a somewhat slow pace, yet they are contributing to transportation demand. At the moment, Asia — China especially — is exiting refinery maintenance. Meanwhile, oil demand keeps bouncing back; the focus has now shifted to the U.S. and Europe as lockdowns come to an end. Inventories, whether on land or floating, have returned to normal and sit at pre-COVID-19 levels. Starting from where things stand today and based on EIA figures, oil supply should rise by 6 million barrels by year-end. If you check the chart on the lower left-hand side, it shows that the bulk of those gains are anticipated to occur essentially from the current point through the summer. The crux of the demand balances in 2021 appears on the right-hand side. As we know, gasoline demand dropped by 3.3 million barrels per day in 2020 and is now projected to rise by 1.8 million barrels per day in 2021. For jet, it hit the crude oil balances by 3.2 million barrels per day negative in 2020, and roughly 1.3 million barrels per day should come back this year. For diesel, we're actually putting back more than we took out, 1.2 million barrels per day. And for fuel oil, we're holding steady. Other uses of oil are contributing as well, at 0.7 million barrels per day. Let's go to Slide 11 and my summary; so in essence, to close this out, every key macro indicator signals a solid recovery; and global GDP should be up 6% this year. Prices are moving as capacity tightens and steel costs climb. As I just said, Global Oil surprise should increase by 6 million barrels by the close of 2021. The pace of COVID-19 vaccination in developed nations is quite encouraging, and countries are reopening. The chart below, which shows activity across the various key segments of the shipping sector, tells us the cyclical recovery run has begun. Every key shipping sector is solid, with tankers trailing. Frontline is perfectly placed to seize the expected recovery in tanker markets with our modern spot exposed fuel-efficient fleet. With that, I'd like to open the floor for questions and answers, please.
Jon Chappell
analystThank you. Good afternoon.
Lars Barstad
executiveHi, Jon.
Jon Chappell
analystI'd call that a fairly even-handed take on the market — perhaps more even-handed than the optimism you'll hear from some others. Still, it's clear that last week's press release about the 6 new VLCCs signals, in my view, plenty of confidence regarding where the market is headed. I believe I raised this 3 months back, but at this point in the cycle, given what you foresee over roughly the next 12 months, would you describe yourselves as a more aggressive buyer of assets? And if that's the case, how heavily does this fuel propulsion issue factor into whether you pursue more new builds, as announced last week, rather than the traditional Frontline approach of buying in the secondhand market?
Lars Barstad
executiveWell, that all comes down to — well, to start with, I'd say we are aggressive at all times, but the right opportunity needs to sort of present itself to us. That said, our broad read on the market has sort of hardened across the last couple of months; and we now hold greater conviction that we're heading in the right direction. On the matter of resale against modern kind of ships already trading, we clearly must consider the present kind of spot markets when we weigh taking a vessel that's currently sailing in this market versus taking one that gets delivered at a moment when we anticipate being at full throttle once more. So that's clearly one piece of the calculus. And second, there really aren't that many ships up for sale that kind of fit within the areas where we'd like to put money; so you might say that while dry bulk activity has been enormous and the ordering activity for containerships and LPG has been so spectacular and so on, the VLCC kind of asset market has stayed rather muted year-to-date.
Jon Chappell
analystAlright, that's totally clear. Building on that, regarding how this gets funded — I realize you'll almost surely secure financing for those vessels that were ordered or announced last week. What struck me as a little odd was that, for the down payment, even with the cash sitting on your balance sheet, you still pulled $50 million under the Hemen facility. So what's the reasoning behind how much liquidity you want to hold, using debt to cover down payments, and not bringing back the dividend even after a profitable quarter? I get that Q2 is soft and the near-term outlook is kind of choppy. But should we expect debt drawdowns to fund newbuilds moving forward, and perhaps keep the cash for a stronger market before revisiting capital returns?
Inger Klemp
executiveI'd say this facility we're drawing on gives us flexibility. We'll put in place the, shall we say, debt financing; our plan is to do that, I believe, likely in the back half of 2021, at minimum, for the first vessel. And possibly for every one of them too, depending on what opportunities come up when we look at — or begin working on — that. So when it comes to equity and repaying this facility we're drawing on, we'll have flexibility down the road to determine how to handle that and when to do it — or whether we'd want to use the ATM. That hinges on the share price and on when we'd want to raise equity, so it depends on that as well. So I think we'll keep that somewhat open, somewhat open.
Jon Chappell
analystOkay, got it. Thanks, Inger. Appreciate it, Lars.
Lars Barstad
executiveYou're welcome.
Randy Giveans
analystFrontline crew, how are things?
Lars Barstad
executiveDoing well, Randy. And how about yourself?
Randy Giveans
analystOkay. So, my question — you spent quite a bit of time on the crude side. If we also take a look at product tankers, what's your read on those two, and when do you think an inflection point arrives where rates genuinely begin improving? And alongside that, are you taking advantage of this softer stretch to clean up certain LR2s that had been operating in the dirty trade so they can move into the clean trade down the road?
Lars Barstad
executiveLet me handle the first part. Clearly, we're in a phase of recovery. My sense is we've more or less just wrapped up working down inventories. That's part of what I'm observing, and it's fairly dynamic, which tells me — on top of that, we're in the middle of refinery maintenance, and it's a fairly substantial round of it. Honestly, I had fairly high hopes that the product market would begin gaining momentum as early as March; and — instead it lost steam. For the product market to truly get going, a larger share of the jet demand that's been missing needs to return; and — even so, there's always some product market activity to be found when arbs start to open. For that to happen, refineries need to finish their turnarounds. So you could call it a chicken and egg situation. And frankly, I'm still not entirely certain which one comes first. It could be a pull or a push, or maybe crude oil demand rises first, driving the VLCC market, which then spills over into LR2s as product gets moved — or perhaps it happens in reverse. So honestly, it's hard to call. On the cleanup side, one vessel has been cleaned, and we took advantage of this window in the market. It isn't truly a window, since there's always some level of cost attached. And we have to keep in mind that we were earning a great deal of extra income while doing that. Still, I'd say you should expect that we'll progressively examine deploying our ships as LR2s, since that's their actual designation, instead of IFRS.
Randy Giveans
analystYeah, that's clear. OK, and now for my follow-up question. You've demonstrated pretty strong cost discipline during the market slump, especially lately, with a notable reduction in vessel OpEx and G&A. So looking ahead, what would be a reasonable run rate for those two items?
Inger Klemp
executiveLike I said, in the quarter we're currently in, we'll incur a drydocking expense that's greater than what we saw in Q1. In the first quarter, drydocking costs came to just under $600,000; and for Q2, my estimate is roughly 7% or maybe slightly above that too. So from that perspective, operating expenses will of course go up next quarter. However, it will fluctuate significantly quarter to quarter based on how many vessels undergo dry dock; in Q3, our plan is to drydock 3 vessels rather than 6, which means it'll be about half of what I mentioned for Q2 in terms of cost. Regarding the admin expense, I'd say that G&A — the level we have right now in Q1 isn't the sustainable rate. My guess is that an additional couple of million dollars would represent the ongoing rate from here.
Randy Giveans
analystSo a few million beyond that $6 million figure, all right — would $9 million be a solid run rate to expect moving ahead?
Inger Klemp
executiveI'd say that's likely on the high side, though you could add a couple of dollars beyond the number shown in the report. Once that's factored in, you're looking at $8.3 million or $8.5 million, or thereabouts, something along those lines.
Magnus Fyhr
analystYeah. All my questions have pretty much been addressed already. Still, circling back to what Jon asked about your view on placing orders or purchasing additional vessels — do you see an opening there? A lot of operators seem somewhat reluctant to acquire ships or place orders at today's prices, because of the ambiguity around propulsion technology. I'm just interested whether you believe more chances exist in that space, newbuildings as opposed to picking up resales.
Lars Barstad
executiveRight, we — I believe we'll stay faithful to what we've said and attempt not to grow the order book; and honestly, it's pretty hard to judge where that order book stands today. Since I suspect you'd find it extremely tough to secure a VLCCs order for handover during Q4 2023. And if you managed to find such a slot, my guess is the pricing sits above 100. That might mean we'd choose to concentrate instead on picking up resales or modern ECO vessels already trading. So — though I should point out that yards have seen frenzied activity. And Inger and I would draw a comparison between part of the forward outlook and what we saw during 2002, 2003; back then, far more yard capacity was on its way. Today, that isn't the case. We even see yards beginning to examine 2025, just to give you a sense of the situation out there.
Magnus Fyhr
analystYou have a very up-to-date fleet, and you brought up that scrapping rates are climbing. When it comes to some of those aging vessels at last making their way to the breakers, what are you seeing out there? I mean, today's market rates — I mean, today's spot rates are quite tough for those aging vessels; and I was simply wondering whether you anticipate that scrapping will at last begin rising here over the summer?
Lars Barstad
executiveI believe it will, sort of — our tally is at 8 VLCCs disposed of for demolition so far this year. And I believe it's 3 Suezmaxes. Still, we must keep in mind that COVID caused interruptions in the ability of the recycling yards to actually take in tonnage; so the pandemic has impacted, sort of, the efficiency there too. I think given where recycling steel prices sit right now, we ought to definitely witness some activity. That said, we still face this rivalry in the market for older secondhand tonnage originating from unnamed, sort of, parties, which in all likelihood are engaged in what I prefer to call the dark web of oil — essentially shipping either Venezuelan or Iranian sanctioned crudes.
Magnus Fyhr
analystSo I suppose, given the — yeah. For those discussions that are happening right now — I suppose, with the talks currently underway involving the Iranians and the possibility that those sanctions get lifted. How do you think about those ships at last, perhaps finding themselves unable to compete in a market that's open?
Lars Barstad
executiveMy view is that this might be an enormous boost for the tanker market that follows the rules. And essentially — all of us discuss the Costco moment for tankers, and I believe that scenario could arrive. Since all at once, at minimum under the nuclear deal involving the U.S. and Iran, there will be a substantial amount of cargo that requires compliant vessels in order to trade, in a sense, inside the compliant market.
Magnus Fyhr
analystIf I could squeeze in one last item, for either Inger or yourself, about the drydocking plan. Are you aiming to get every drydocking finished before Q4 arrives? Or do you expect a few vessels to still be in the fourth quarter, sort of setting yourselves up for an improving market?
Inger Klemp
executiveNo dry dockings will take place during the fourth quarter for us. They fall solely in Q2 and Q3.
Chris Tsung
analystI’d like to press a bit further on something that came up before about OpEx. I noticed it dropped quite a lot versus Q2 — compared with Q4, by about 20%; and when I look at your earlier deck on OpEx. For the Suezmaxes, daily OpEx was roughly $9,700 a day. And in the current presentation, it’s lower, at about $7,100. So perhaps you could walk through why that happened.
Inger Klemp
executiveOpEx is going to move quarter to quarter, as I mentioned, because of vessel dry dock, depending on whether or not we’re in drydock. And in that specific quarter you’re pointing to, when Suezmaxes had elevated OpEx, that came from having Suezmax dry dockings during that period. By contrast, at present there’s only a modest drydock expense, and that doesn’t really have an impact on OpEx.
Lars Barstad
executiveStill, to make this clearer, what we do is record the real dry docking expenses during that quarter.
Inger Klemp
executiveWe expense the dock. We don't capitalize as many of our peers do.
Lars Barstad
executiveSo that's why we get that volatility in that.
Inger Klemp
executiveYes.
Chris Tsung
analystRight, got it. Okay, that makes sense. I suppose, just to piggyback with a different inquiry — regarding those 6 VLCC resales set to begin handover during 2022. Might you elaborate a bit on how those deliveries will be spaced out? Does more of it land early on, or does more of it land later? I'm aware that 1 unit is being handed over during 2023. I merely was curious whether the schedule will be evened out — any detail at all would be welcome.
Lars Barstad
executiveHonestly, it should be pretty even. The initial ship gets handed over quite early during 2022. Naturally, at this point we do possess a small amount of leeway regarding when those handovers occur; so — and after that they arrive steadily, one following another. And the final ship arrives extremely early during 2023.
Chris Tsung
analystFor my final question — I saw in the slides or the release that a choice was made to buy stock in Golden Ocean. If I recall, it's roughly $400,000, so nothing significant. It isn't large, but I was hoping you might share more specifics about why that decision to acquire Golden Ocean shares was taken.
Inger Klemp
executiveSure. That ties back to a forward contract we hold — one covering Golden Ocean shares — and by effectively closing out that contract, we gained the chance to participate in the rights issue that Golden Ocean carried out. So the size wasn't large; only a handful of shares; regardless, we went ahead since it was in the money.
Lars Barstad
executiveYeah, I really appreciate you having us on. And I'm also grateful to all of you for tuning in. Thanks as well to everybody on the Frontline team for an amazing job during Q1 — and please, everyone, stay safe.
Operator
operatorThat does conclude our conference for today. Thank you all for participating.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.