Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 26, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks, everybody. Hello in the morning, and hello in the afternoon as well. You're all welcome to Frontline's call about our second quarter results. The first quarter of this year was one thing, but Q2 ended up being pretty packed. A lot of you have repeatedly wondered whether Frontline would try to capitalize on softness in the market to expand even more. I think Q2 has given you our answer. In certain respects, we operate a shipping platform with three legs: VLCC, Suezmax and LR2s. The VLCC leg of ours has been a bit shorter compared with the others. At this point, we're correcting that somewhat. This quarter, one difficulty we faced in the marketplace involved repeated outbreaks of COVID infections across multiple regions globally. In Western areas, vaccination progress has been substantial, though other nations aren't as lucky. We continue to prioritize the safety and health of our seafarers, and it's encouraging to report that our initiatives to secure vaccines for them are progressing nicely. I also want to note our deep appreciation for those port states generously providing vaccines to seafarers at no cost whatsoever. Now, let's proceed to review the key points on slide three. The results for the second quarter of 2021 show how tough the market was during those three months. Even so, they offer more evidence that our business model, our efficient operations, our modern fleet, and a chartering team that works extremely hard are able to beat the main benchmarks. For some context, a weighted average earnings index I looked at not long ago for tankers across the board stood at a little above $6,000 per day in Q2 2021 — the weakest figure seen in over two decades. To do better than that, an owner — and especially that owner's charterers — has to scrap for each and every cent and understand their situation thoroughly so they can play their cards as well as possible. Unfortunately, based on what we can see, that isn't always what happens. During the second quarter of this year, Frontline put in the effort and came away with $15,000 per day across our VLCC fleet, $11,000 per day for our Suezmax vessels, and $10,600 per day from our LR2/Aframax ships. Looking at Q3 so far, we've locked in 70% of VLCC days at a rate of $14,000 per day, 64% of Suezmax days at $9,800 per day, and 63% of LR2/Aframax days at $11,800 per day. Every figure shown in this table reflects a load to discharge basis. Before Inger walks you through the financial highlights, I'd like to briefly touch on the acquisitions made during the quarter. In the second quarter, we picked up six of the newest Eco-design VLCCs via resale; those vessels are still being built at Hyundai's yard in Korea. We also bought two modern Eco-type VLCCs from 2019 that came out of that same shipyard. For quite a while, we'd been watching the VLCC asset market intently, hunting for chances to act. Since we weren't counting on any near-term rebound in tanker markets, the delivery timeline became a major point of leverage for us. Steel prices are holding up strongly, and with so much activity in non-tanker assets pushing possible delivery slots much farther into the future, we felt more assured about moving forward with these investments. With that, I'll turn it over to Inger, who'll take you through the financial highlights.
Inger Klemp
executiveAlright. Thank you, Lars. Good morning, and good afternoon to everyone. As Lars noted, after the VLCC acquisition, we've made headway on the loan financing. This August, we secured financing commitments — contingent on final documentation — for three senior secured term loan facilities. Those facilities total up to $247 million, and they'll cover part of the purchase of the two VLCCs constructed in 2019 plus two of the six VLCC newbuilding contracts. Each facility will fund 65% of market value. The interest rate will be LIBOR plus a margin of 170 basis points, and amortization will run over 20 years starting from the yard delivery date. For the four remaining resale VLCC newbuilding contracts, we plan to arrange long-term financing nearer to when those vessels are delivered. Let's turn to slide four and review the income statement. Frontline recorded total operating revenues net of various expenses of $80 million and adjusted EBITDA of $28 million during this quarter. We're reporting a net loss of $26.76 million, or $0.13 per share, along with an adjusted net loss of $23.2 million, or $0.12 per share. This quarter's adjustment comprises a $4.7 million loss on derivatives, a $0.8 million gain on marketable securities, a $1.3 million amortization of acquired time charters, and finally, a $0.8 million share of losses of associated companies. Compared with the first quarter, the adjusted net loss in the second quarter fell by $32 million. That decline stemmed from lower time charter equivalent earnings caused by reduced TCE rates, as Lars referenced, plus a $9.3 million rise in ship operating expenses — largely from higher dry docking costs — partly offset by a $4 million gain on marketable securities sold during the quarter. Now let's examine the balance sheet on slide five. Total balance sheet figures grew by $64 million this quarter. The quarter's balance sheet changes mainly reflect taking delivery of the LR2 tanker Frontline Future and acquiring six VLCC newbuilding contracts, alongside routine debt repayments and depreciation. As of June 30th, Frontline holds $257 million in cash and cash equivalents, which includes undrawn amounts under our senior unsecured loan facility, marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. Let's look more closely at cash break-even rates on slide six. For the rest of 2021, we project an average cash cost break-even rate of roughly $21,800 per day for the VLCCs, $7,500 per day for the Suezmax tankers, and $15,400 per day for the LR2 tankers. The fleet average estimate comes to about $18,000 per day. These figures represent the all-in daily rates our vessels need to earn in order to cover budgeted operating cost and drydock, estimated interest expenses, TCE and bareboat hire, installments on loans, and G&A expenses. Those very favorable conditions we secured for financing commitments covering four of the VLCCs we picked up, the ones I brought up before, bring our daily cash break-even rates down by roughly $1,400 per vessel per day relative to the financing terms already in place for comparable ships. During this quarter, our OpEx expenses came in at $7,600 per day for VLCCs, $8,500 per day for Suezmax, and $9,000 per day for LR2; we had three Suezmax tankers in drydock this quarter, pardon me, plus four LR2 tankers. Looking ahead, one VLCC and two LR2 tankers are expected to enter drydock during the third quarter, with zero in the fourth quarter. As the graph on the right-hand side of this slide indicates, assuming $30,000 above the fleet's average daily cash cost break-even rate of $18,000, Frontline would produce cash flow per share amounting to $3.51 per year. Once the eight VLCCs are acquired, this cash generation potential will grow. That said, I'll hand things back over to Lars.
Lars Barstad
executiveAppreciate that, Inger. If we turn to slide seven, I'll walk through what happened in the tanker market during the second quarter. In Q2 2021, worldwide oil use came in at 96.7 million barrels per day on average. Compared with Q1 2021, that's a gain of 2.1 million barrels per day. Output came in at 94.9 million barrels per day on average, so the world kept pulling roughly 1.8 million barrels out of inventories. To give you a sense of why that matters, drawing down inventories doesn't require much shipping. As a rough guideline for tanker utilization, moving 1 million barrels of oil per day calls for roughly 30 VLCC equivalents. A draw of this sort translates into 30 to 35 VLCC equivalents of lost demand. Across the quarter, tanker rates drifted lower and volatility diminished. During Q2 2021, OPEC+ did add over 1 million barrels per day of supply, yet major OPEC producers also entered stretches of stronger demand, usually in the Middle East, where summer arrives and you essentially start burning oil or fuel to generate electricity. The U.S. and Brazil contributed an additional 900,000 barrels per day. Brazilian volumes mostly showed up as exports, whereas in the U.S., demand is also growing very strongly, so fewer barrels left the U.S. Gulf. North America and Greater Europe saw demand climb sharply, while Asia, which had driven the recovery, experienced a much more subdued trend in that second quarter. As the two charts below show, where I've essentially separated out North America, Europe and Eurasia, demand in those regions climbed sharply during Q2, while the rest of the world, especially Asia, which as I said had driven the recovery into 2021, has done less well in this year's first half. Now let's go to slide eight and examine tanker order books. Not surprisingly, new ordering was subdued through the second quarter of 2021. We've been seeing that when someone tries to book a sizable batch of VLCCs or Suezmaxes, the earliest handover slot you can get is basically somewhere in 2024. The reason is obvious — so much ordering is going on right now in vessel categories other than tankers. Since the start of this year, the order book across VLCC, Suezmax and LR2 combined has shrunk by 10%. When you look at ships above 10,000 deadweight tons, the overall order book is equivalent to 8% of the fleet currently trading. Interestingly, that figure lines up with what we observed during the first quarter of 1997. If you measure it in absolute deadweight terms, this is the lowest point in 20 years; let me put that into some perspective. Back then, two decades ago, the world was consuming roughly 76 million barrels per day of oil. If you look at a normalized market right now, it's nearer to 100 — maybe even above that. What that tells you is the oil market has grown roughly 30% compared with early 2000. The order book, though, is about the same size. At present, VLCCs on order total somewhere around 81 vessels. At the same time, 124 VLCCs are going to hit 20 years old or go past that during this period. On the Suezmax side, the figure is 41 units. Using the same criteria, 123 of them are crossing the two-decade mark. Let's move to slide nine now and look at oil in transit. For us, this indicator matters a great deal. We monitor it pretty much each month to figure out where we stand. Oil in transit basically refers to oil that's moving — so anything sitting in storage is effectively excluded. Here, I've put a red box around 2020. That year turned out to be wildly unstable for the business of moving oil. It opened with a price war between Saudi Arabia and Russia, which threw off the first and second quarters, and we saw output climb enormously, with shipping rising alongside it. Then COVID-19 hit, and the demand shock we saw wiped out a huge amount of production very suddenly, and with it the need for transportation. By the third and fourth quarters, shipping demand had dropped nearly to where it stood in 2017. At that point, floating storage was what kept tanker utilization afloat. In the tanker markets during the first six months of 2021, volumes basically went up and transportation grew. We've been dealing with more vessels coming out of storage and newbuilds entering the fleet, and we've also seen significant inventory draws. Where we are at this moment — clearly this is July and August of 2023 — we've gone back to Q4 2019 levels. Commercial inventories in the OECD have dropped to 2019 levels now, and we consider that a fair proxy for inventories globally. There's another point to mention. When inventories stop being drawn down, oil that's being transported will factor in. To illustrate, EIA currently projects a build of 1 million barrels of oil per day for September, but then for October, a draw of 0.5 million barrels per day from inventories is expected. So what you end up with is a gap of 1.5 million barrels, and that volume still needs to be moved. In terms of very large crude carriers, you'd need somewhere between 45 and 48 of them to handle it. That should give you a feel for just how quickly the situation can shift. Now let's move on to slide 10. I gave this a fair amount of attention in our press release, and I call it the VLCC fleet paradox. The picture is almost the same when you look at Suezmaxes, but I decided to focus on the VLCCs; all of us can only guess what's happening with the older generation of VLCCs. Everyone accepts that a ship at the 20-year mark is going to have a hard time, because only a small pool of charterers will take them on, and that's based strictly on how old they are; given the tough trading conditions in the first six months of this year, the money made by non-Eco, high-consuming ships has been either nothing or in the red. Keep in mind that right now, 51 ships have passed the 20-year threshold. So far this year, eight VLCCs have been reported as sold for recycling. Over that same stretch, the typical recycling price in Asia has climbed 70%, and for a VLCC it now sits near $25.5 million. Crude oil storage is one of the usual ways an older tanker gets phased out. During Q4 of last year, crude oil curves shifted into backwardation, and that provides zero support for floating storage. So far this year, out of the 660 VLCC fixtures we recorded, three spot fixtures have been reported that involve a vessel 20 years old or older. I want to emphasize this again because it's significant — and it's especially significant when you consider the earlier slide showing our position in the cycle for oil being moved. If effective tonnage genuinely hasn't grown over the last couple of years, then balance may be closer than we think. As I stated in the press release, this skews the picture so badly that it essentially has to be dealt with. Let me wrap up on slide 11. Both demand and supply for oil keep climbing. We must acknowledge that Delta variant infections cast a shadow over the outlook, especially across Asia; asset prices are holding steady, steel prices keep going up, and activity at the yards is quite strong, though for assets outside the tanker segment. Meanwhile, the tanker fleet keeps getting older, the total order book keeps contracting, and the possible delivery window shifts even later if tanker demand strengthens. OPEC+ intends to add roughly 400,000 barrels per day on a monthly basis through the close of the year; that adds up to 2 million barrels per day of extra supply. Returning to the math, by year-end we would require 60 to 65 VLCC equivalents. Oil in transit keeps increasing, and the major unknown is clearly the timing of the inflection point. I'd ask you to look at the chart beneath or at the bottom of the slide. I presented this to you in the prior quarter too, and as the orange dot shows, that marked our position in March of this year; we are essentially steadily pulling ourselves out of negative year-on-year growth in worldwide oil trade and into positive ground. Since that time, Frontline has grown its position considerably. We have obtained appealing financing and stand prepared to capitalize as we move toward the anticipated recovery. Many thanks. I'd now like to begin taking questions. How are you doing, Randy?
Magnus Fyhr
analystYeah. Good afternoon. When we look at how the fleet did in Q3, versus a few of the competitors, it seemed like your results were somewhat stronger. I realize comparing one quarter to the next is difficult, but you've kept beating the peers on a consistent basis. Was there something else going on in the quarter, or can you offer any additional color about how things went in Q3?
Lars Barstad
executiveThat's a good question. This is among the things we clearly attempt to study. Clearly, whenever you put two peers side by side, fleet makeup and vessel age are factors, and those do matter; they don't explain the whole of the outperformance. It also comes down to remaining faithful to the reality that we're ship owners. We possess assets that must be safeguarded, and we have to push as hard as possible to make our customers grasp that and refuse to yield. It's also tied to having a modern fleet, which, beyond the economics, hands you additional chances to trade around. Essentially, every option is available to you. That's a significant element too, as you work to position your vessels so you can reach greater utilization and improved returns. I trust that answers your question well.
Magnus Fyhr
analystYeah. Thanks for those details. And we're also looking straight into the abyss at this point. Rates are extremely weak. This is the softest stretch of the year. You said fleet expansion might not be so large once you account for how old the fleet is. But can you see anything at all about the winter market? It's still August. I realize it's somewhat early, but I was just wondering what your view is on a fourth-quarter rebound.
Lars Barstad
executiveThe volatility in the freight market's share tells you how little we actually know, frankly. That said, we book so far in advance that we truly do get an early read on demand; from that angle, what we're seeing is that right now we're working September dates in the Middle East and West Africa, and volumes look pretty strong. We've watched Suezmax rates actually attempt to tick up slightly. We're also booking early October dates out of U.S. Gulf, and that appears fairly active at the start too. I can't promise you anything, but things look at least improved compared with two weeks ago.
Magnus Fyhr
analystAll right, that sounds positive. So, only one more item from me. When it comes to the S&P space, you folks have been pretty busy picking up certain resales. I'm just wondering whether you're spotting any chances in the used-vessel segment. A ship — a 2012-built unit without Eco, as I understand it — was reportedly sold last week at quite a substantial markdown. Whether that represents an isolated deal or a signal of possible softness in the secondhand arena, I can't tell. Maybe you're able to shed some light on it.
Lars Barstad
executiveIf a value curve exists, my view is that the weakest point sits with the middle-aged generation, and especially when a scrubber isn't fitted. Take the really old tonnage — such ships have found support from artificial demand originating with undisclosed accounts seeking to employ the vessel for whatever purpose. As for modern units, those clearly are what everybody desires to hold as we move toward a tighter regulatory regime and confront every kind of efficiency requirement down the road. That leaves ships in the middle somewhat out of favor. That particular deal doesn't trouble me much, since from my vantage point, one could make the case that a highly modern ship, a resale, or a newbuild tracks more closely with asset prices in general and ultimately with steel values. So long as that remains firm, the modern portion of this fleet doesn't concern me much.
Magnus Fyhr
analystAll right. I really appreciate you taking my questions.
Lars Barstad
executiveYou're welcome.
Jon Chappell
analystThank you. Good afternoon.
Lars Barstad
executiveHi.
Inger Klemp
executiveHello.
Jon Chappell
analystInger, for two of the six VLCC newbuilds, you've secured $130 million. By my calculations, that works out to roughly 70% financing — should we expect comparable percentages, meaning an additional $260 million drawn down for the other four?
Inger Klemp
executiveYes, Jon, that's what I'll be aiming for.
Inger Klemp
executiveOkay, so if we add that $390 million together with what gets drawn under the Hemen facility, that covers most of what has to be paid here. That would leave, I believe, only about $74 million of cash outlay tied to the six new builds. Is that the overall financing structure you're aiming for? Or, once the bank facilities come through for the remaining four ships, would that amount need to be repaid to the Hemen facility right away? We're treating this Hemen facility as bridge financing for now; we'll keep going, or rather, at a somewhat later point we'll weigh our alternatives regarding long-term financing for the equity share of these vessels.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right. So besides that Hemen facility reaching its end in May 2022 — which you've clearly delayed on multiple occasions, and it's likely reasonable to figure you might delay it once more should you choose to — is there anything else in the way of sizable bullet payments or amortization schedules on the horizon over what we might call the coming 12 to 18 months, as we work toward that recovery Lars mentioned?
Inger Klemp
executiveNo, nothing comes due before 2023.
Jon Chappell
analystAlright, that's excellent. On the whole, you're feeling positive regarding how liquid things stand. At this point it's simply a matter of closing out the financing for the most recent 4 newly constructed vessels and, in a sense, waiting things out until the market comes back. Would you say that's right?
Inger Klemp
executiveYes, exactly right. Yes.
Jon Chappell
analystOkay, that covers everything I wanted to ask. Getting you to that point depends a lot on liquidity, in my view, and Inger, I appreciate you spelling that out.
Inger Klemp
executiveYes. Thank you.
Randy Giveans
analystHello there, Lars and Inger. Are you able to hear me at this point?
Lars Barstad
executiveYes, that works.
Inger Klemp
executiveYes, we can.
Lars Barstad
executiveHowdy.
Randy Giveans
analystGreat. I was able to pick up your audio before. The problem was on your end — no worries. Lars, congratulations, clearly, on being formally named CEO. That's an exciting moment.
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks a lot.
Randy Giveans
analystI have a couple of things to ask. Frontline has obviously been quite busy picking up vessels. Does this plan keep going so the fleet expands that way, or might you instead consider divesting some of the older ships?
Lars Barstad
executiveHonestly, nearly each time we have one of these conversations, it's hard to lay out the playbook for you while we're live, if it's even possible at all. Of course, we're keeping every option on the table. I won't rule it out, and I won't say it's happening either. Fleet composition is something we'll always review, and newer vessels are what we prefer. Sure, that may be one piece of what we do moving forward.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right, that makes sense. When we look at the rates you've achieved so far this quarter, they're quite strong on a relative basis, aren't they? Are any freshly inked time charters baked into those figures? Have you entered into any such agreements over this summer? We're beginning to observe some rates moving higher on the product side. Could that perhaps signal the beginning of a recovery, or is it still too soon to say?
Lars Barstad
executiveLet me take that first question first; no time charters have been concluded by us; that's a really good thing to ask, since short-term time charters get booked by us as spot, and none of those have been done.
Lars Barstad
executiveOkay. Next, regarding that LR2 market you mentioned — sure, it's tightening up over in Asia, and honestly it's pretty robust. We'd like to believe there's staying power here, though we've found ourselves let down on a handful of occasions when things took off. There was one of those runs back in April too.
Randy Giveans
analystYeah.
Lars Barstad
executiveI'd say the verdict hasn't come in yet. What we've been doing during this period is really getting one of our LR2s cleaned up. The mix now leans more heavily toward the clean side, since 7 out of the 20 ships are in the dirty trade, and then clearly 13 are clean and set to go in that market.
Randy Giveans
analystGreat. 13 clean and dirty. All right, well, hey, I apologize for the problems before, but I appreciate you coming back on.
Lars Barstad
executiveOh, thanks.
Inger Klemp
executiveThank you.
Lars Barstad
executiveOkay.
Lars Barstad
executiveYeah, absolutely.
Magnus Fyhr
analystRegarding getting the LR2 cleaned up.
Magnus Fyhr
analystYeah, hi, thanks. A quick follow-up on cleaning up that LR2. Could you walk me through the process a bit, how long it takes, and when it'll be ready to clean? Just what's involved in getting it set up to carry cleaner products.
Lars Barstad
executiveWell, there are a few different paths. In this instance, clearly, we came across a chance to wash the tanks at a decent price, and a subsequent voyage was already arranged. I have to say that's down to luck more than skill. Typically, what you'd do is, to trade properly as a clean ship, your last three cargoes need to be clean. The initial cleaning cargo might be condensate, after that you could shift to a different product, and then at last you're genuinely able to carry something like a gas oil or perhaps even a gasoline. Through that, you essentially get the vessel cleaned up. That sort of situation means you occasionally have to give a discount on freight to reach that stage. Essentially, what we examine is whether a spread of $750,000 to $1 million exists between the two markets, and if we can arrange something, we'll essentially kick off a process of cleaning a dirty LR2. Of course, going the opposite direction can be done right away; here, we chose to put some money into performing the physical clean. That allowed us to — depending, naturally, on the charter and what he requires — but we were able to become a properly clean vessel within a fairly brief period and a single voyage.
Magnus Fyhr
analystHow long does it take, from washing the tanks to actually carrying gasoline?
Lars Barstad
executiveIn this case, that’s probably around 25 to 30 days.
Magnus Fyhr
analystSo those three cargoes were excluded for the reason that you'd cleaned out the tanks, is that right?
Lars Barstad
executiveNope. Correct.
Magnus Fyhr
analystOkay.
Lars Barstad
executiveOtherwise it would have taken long. Yeah.
Magnus Fyhr
analystThanks for that color.
Lars Barstad
executiveYou're welcome.
Lars Barstad
executiveAll right. That covers everything, so I really appreciate you taking the time to tune in on what's been a hectic day for earnings releases. At Frontline, we'll keep pushing forward, and with any luck, when we come back with next quarter's results, we'll be able to share a market picture that looks entirely different. Thanks.
Operator
operatorToday's call is now finished. Everyone is free to hang up at this point. We appreciate each of you for joining in.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.