Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 29, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lars Barstad
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome to Frontline's call regarding our results for the third quarter. We are in truly turbulent times, though freight markets have not been as turbulent as anticipated. The third quarter of 2021 represented the lowest point for tankers after COVID-19; normally this is a weak period for the markets, yet it appears that everything has been intensified under present conditions. As the quarter drew to a close, we began to observe demand for freight picking up because export volumes were rising, and that trend has carried over into the fourth quarter. At this moment, like the rest of the world, we are worried about what the Omicron variant of the COVID-19 virus might mean, what action OPEC+ will take regarding it, and whether the continuing Iranian nuclear negotiations in Vienna will yield anything. Let's begin by examining the facts about Frontline's third quarter and reviewing the highlights on slide 3. The performance in Q3 2021 mirrors the difficulties the tanker market encountered during this period. Nevertheless, it demonstrates that our business model, our efficient operations, our modern fleet, and an extremely diligent team succeeded in beating most of our competitors. During the third quarter, Frontline earned $10,500 per day with our VLCC fleet, $7,900 per day with our Suezmax fleet, and $10,700 per day with our LR2/Aframax fleet; thus far in the fourth quarter, we have booked 79% of our VLCC days at $21,600 per day, 72% of our Suezmax days at $17,900 per day, and 64% of our LR2/Aframax days at $16,000 per day. Every figure in this table is calculated on a load to discharge basis, but I believe they demonstrate that the markets have genuinely rebounded from the third quarter even though rates have not yet hit elevated levels. I will now pass things to Inger for a review of the financial highlights.
Inger Klemp
executiveThanks, Lars. Good morning or good afternoon, everyone, wherever you're joining from. Once we'd acquired eight VLCCs in the first six months of this year, we stayed busy with the financing side. Across Q3 and Q4, we entered into term loan facilities and locked in financing commitments amounting to $507 million in total, which goes part of the way toward funding the acquisition of the two VLCCs constructed in 2019 along with the six VLCC newbuilding contracts. Those facilities cover 65% of market value; pricing comes in at LIBOR plus a 170 basis point margin; and amortization runs mostly over 20 years, with 18 years in some cases, beginning on the date the yard delivers the vessel. Adding the $33.4 million we can draw under the term loan facility from November 2020, which partially funds delivery of the final LR2 tanker, our bank debts reach as much as $540.4 million. The company additionally brought in gross proceeds of $51.2 million via the equity distribution agreement, along with net cash proceeds of roughly $67 million from selling 4 LR2 tankers. As a result, the outstanding commitments as of September 30th tied to Frontline's newbuilding program — 1 LR2 tanker plus the 6 VLCCs — and to buying the two VLCCs built in 2019, are completely funded. With these new financings, we're able to bring down what we pay to borrow and reduce even further our cash break-even rates, which already lead the industry. That hands us substantial operating leverage and solid returns during a strong market, and it also helps protect our cash flows when the market turns weak. On top of that, Frontline has extended the terms on its senior unsecured revolving credit facility, worth up to $275 million, by another 12 months, pushing it to May 2023, which means Frontline has no loan maturities coming due before 2023. Let's now turn to slide four and go through the income statement. For Q3 2021, Frontline's operating revenues after subtracting voyage costs came to $69 million, while adjusted EBITDA stood at $17 million. We reported a net loss of $33.2 million, equal to $0.17 per share, along with an adjusted net loss of $35.9 million, or $0.18 per share, for the quarter. The adjustment items include a $1.2 million derivative gain, a $0.2 million gain on marketable securities, and $1.3 million from amortization of acquired time charters. The adjusted net loss for the third quarter rose by $12.7 million versus the second quarter; that larger loss came from a decline in our time charter equivalent earnings caused by lower TCE rates, together with recognition of a $4 million gain on the marketable securities sold during the second quarter. Partly offsetting this was a $3.2 million drop in ship operating expenses, mainly because dry docking costs were lower. Let's now examine the balance sheet on slide five. During Q3, our total balance sheet figures went up by $6 million. The quarter's balance sheet changes mostly stem from receiving the LR2 tanker from Front Favou r, along with routine debt repayments and depreciation. By the end of the third quarter of 2021, specifically on September 30, Frontline had $190 million in cash and cash equivalents. That figure takes into account undrawn amounts available through our senior unsecured loan facility, along with marketable securities and the minimum cash we are required to hold. When it comes to the remaining capital expenditures for new buildings and vessel acquisitions, Frontline faced $659.4 million as of that same date. That entire amount is covered, thanks to an estimated $540.4 million in debt capacity plus $118.2 million in cash generated via the ATM and through selling the four LR2 tankers I referenced earlier. Additionally, as I noted before, the company does not face any debt maturities until 2023. Now, let's take a closer look at cash breakeven rates and OpEx, which appear on slide six. For the remainder of 2021, our projected average cash cost breakeven figures work out to approximately $21,400 each day for VLCCs, $17,800 daily for Suezmax tankers, and $14,100 per day for LR2 tankers. Across the whole fleet, that estimate comes to roughly $17,600 per day. These represent the all-in daily amounts our ships need to bring in to handle budgeted operating costs along with dry dock, anticipated interest charges, TC and bareboat hire payments, loan installments, and G&A expenses. During the third quarter, OpEx expenses we recorded stood at $8,200 per day for VLCCs, $77,200 per day for Suezmax tankers, and $8,800 per day for LR2 tankers. During Q3, we put 2 LR2 tankers into dry dock, and during Q4 we anticipate sending 1 VLCC plus 1 Suezmax tanker to dry dock. On the slide's right-hand side, the chart presents free cash flow per share alongside free cash flow yield, calculated using the current fleet and the share price as of November 26 under different TCE rate assumptions. Here's an illustration: suppose we use historic Clarksons TCE rates for non-eco vessels covering 2000 through 2021, November 2021, then make adjustments for Frontline's scrubber and eco vessels — Frontline would show a free cash flow yield of 38%. As assumed TCE rates rise, the potential free cash flow yield rises too, and it also rises on a fully delivered basis. Having said that, I'll hand things back over to Lars.
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks a lot, Inger. We’ll turn to slide 7 now and examine how the tanker market performed in the third quarter. During Q3, tanker rates hit their lowest point, and seasonally speaking, that stretch tends to be the softest time of the year. It’s probably fair to say this has not been a typical year. In fact, we haven’t seen a typical year at all since 2019. Worldwide oil use came in at an average of 98.6 million barrels per day, which is 1.9 million barrels above what it was in the second quarter. Supply averaged 96.8 million, rising by nearly 2 million barrels per day as well; we kept building inventories at a pace quite close to 1.8 million barrels per day. OPEC+ supply increased by an average of 1.4 million barrels per day. I think it matters to point out here that many of the major OPEC producers had just exited their period of peak demand, which is when they consume fuel to generate electricity and essentially to cool things down. That usually takes place in September, so near the close of the quarter. We observed robust demand growth across North America and Europe, whereas Asia’s demand rebound was subdued in the third quarter, just as it had been in the second quarter. What made the quarter we just went through unusual was the extreme volatility in oil and energy prices. We saw natural gas prices, coal prices, and other commodities tied to energy prices climb sharply over the quarter. All those markets ended up performing strongly as the quarter drew to a close. I think it’s worth noting here, if you look at the graph on the lower left side of the slide. Total global consumption is at present actually not all that far from where we began, in January 2020 before the pandemic struck us. In December, we actually are. Some market commentators are in fact making the case that we’ll finish at or reach 100 million barrels per day. What we’ve observed, which appears on the chart on the lower right side of the slide, is that oil in transit has moved quite favorably over the past couple of months. We saw that in Q3, we stayed around those depressed levels where oil in transit would rise and then fall again and rise, producing this sort of choppy pattern. Then as we entered November, we began to see that this oil on water, which essentially reflects demand or utilization across the tanker fleet, climbed swiftly to the point where it stands now. Let’s go to slide 8 and take a look at the order books. Tanker ordering was clearly subdued in the third quarter. We saw 1 Suezmax order and 8 LR2 Aframax orders. As far as we could tell, no VLCC orders were reported during the quarter. What did occur, however, was that the delivery window for ordering any kind of meaningful number of tankers is now beginning to become constrained for 2024 as well. 2023 is set to see hardly any deliveries of VLCCs and Suezmaxes. Prices for newbuildings are quoted at extremely elevated levels. There hasn't been a great deal of price discovery in this market, especially when it comes to VLCCs, since no newbuildings of any kind have really been ordered over the past 4 to 5 months. Obviously, that's driven by a mix of high steel prices and limited availability. Essentially, the calculation shipowners have to make right now, if you're going to enter the market and order a VLCC, let's say at $110 million, $115 million, or $120 million, depending on whom you talk to, is that you're really placing a wager on where steel prices stand in 2023. That's clearly a wager many people are reluctant to make at this stage of the curve. The VLCC order book currently stands at 71 units; that's slightly more than 8% of the fleet in existence. We still face this situation where 113 VLCCs will be at or beyond the 20-year mark across that span as the present order book gets delivered; for Suezmax, 41 units sit in the order book, and 116 will be crossing 20 years under the same measures. One thing that shifted somewhat in the third quarter is that recycling has begun to look more promising. Let's turn to slide nine. With recycled steel prices at record highs, activity is at last picking up. As the chart at the top shows, 2017 and 2018 were the last major stretches for vessel retirement. Now, in Q3 by itself, we saw nearly 0.76% of the worldwide tanker fleet sold for recycling. We're now in a position where alternative uses for tankers are very limited. As most of you probably know, in earlier markets you had the chance to either convert a ship for storage or even turn it into an FSO, so essentially an oil-producing unit. Those markets are clearly shut at the moment. We also observe that through the pandemic, it has become clear that recycling capacity was severely reduced. Essentially, there has been, you know, a COVID pandemic in nations such as India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh. Year-to-date, we've seen 15 VLCCs, 11 Suezmaxes, 18 Aframaxes, and 8 LR2s reported as sold for demolition. Broadly, this comes to nearly 2% of the fleet in existence. Basically, we think this could speed up going forward since recycling values remain very strong. Let's turn to slide 10. There's plenty of noise in the market right now, and portions of this presentation could concern the potential impact from the Omicron virus. I think we'll need a few weeks to learn more about this variant just to know where things are heading. What we do know is that in recent weeks, we've had something of a message of the U.S. releasing oil from their Strategic Petroleum Reserve. Naturally, there are other outside forces influencing things too, yet let's zero in on this particular one. Over the past 18 months, the U.S. has drawn down its SPR on several occasions. Even though American stockpiles sit beneath the five-year average, this nation isn't really facing any crude shortage. Following those recent drawdowns, we've in fact seen exports tick somewhat higher, with a large chunk of that volume headed toward Asia, especially during October and November of this year; clearly it isn't the SPR barrels themselves that travel straight to the Gulf Coast and get shipped abroad. Essentially, the U.S. simply holds plenty of oil. What a release from the SPR does is push down crude prices locally, which in turn makes that crude appealing to buyers in China or Asia. China, India, South Korea, and Japan have all committed to backing the U.S. push by tapping their own reserves. Other than India, none of them have given much detail regarding amounts. We must keep in mind that these Asian nations are much more exposed to serious supply interruptions, since their own production capability at home is quite constrained. As winter approaches, Northern Asia confronts record-high energy costs. Whether any further oil will be released from the SPR at all, now that prices have fallen by $10, is clearly an open question. Should that occur, it might well set off a rise in ton-miles. Let's turn to the summary, and let's walk through a few of the elements currently in play. Oil demand alongside supply keeps climbing, though the newest variant of the virus is clearly casting uncertainty over the picture. Since Q3 2021, tanker markets have bounced back, yet they remain pressured because oil supply hasn't returned entirely to pre-pandemic levels. Tanker recycling — I believe this deserves real attention — has at last begun affecting vessel supply. We've got all these outside forces about which we truly know little at this stage. The U.S. SPR release, OPEC's path ahead. They just pushed their meeting back by a couple of days so they could learn more regarding the virus outbreak. Iranian nuclear negotiations restarted in Vienna. Plenty of developments are set to unfold across the coming couple of weeks. Oil in transit keeps increasing, and energy prices sit at record highs as the Northern Hemisphere moves toward winter. What matters most here, I think, is that Frontline's financial commitments are now completely funded, with lower total funding costs, and we truly are well-positioned as this market's story plays out. Last, I've shown this graph below previously, and it displays year-on-year how different segments and their trades are doing; for tankers, we actually see growth of 3.8% year-on-year in October versus October 2020. For quite some time, tankers had been trailing every other asset class within shipping, yet at this point we are genuinely beginning to see results from them. Having said that, I would now like to begin the Q&A portion.
Chris Tsung
analystHello there, and good afternoon to both Lars and Inger. How are you doing?
Lars Barstad
executiveAnd how are you? I'm doing well, thanks.
Inger Klemp
executiveAll right, thank you.
Chris Tsung
analystAppreciate it. I just wanted to inquire regarding those 4 LR2s which got sold. Before the transaction, had they been cleaned up, or did they remain fairly dirty?
Lars Barstad
executiveNo, they were being traded on a clean basis.
Chris Tsung
analystAll right. My recollection is that during the prior quarter, the split was 7 dirty versus 13 clean. How does your fleet break down at present?
Lars Barstad
executiveAs a matter of fact, it comes in at precisely 35% engaged in dirty trading and 65% in clean trading.
Chris Tsung
analystAll right, I appreciate that. Regarding drydocking, Inger, I believe you mentioned roughly one VLCC and two Suezmax vessels for Q4. What's your estimate for the number of days on those two?
Inger Klemp
executiveThe number of days? Oh, roughly 20 days — that tends to be the usual figure. Yeah.
Chris Tsung
analystSo that works out to 20 days apiece, right? All right, that adds up to 40 altogether.
Inger Klemp
executiveMm-hmm.
Chris Tsung
analystOkay, thank you. One last quick item from my side: what amount is still available under the equity distribution agreement?
Inger Klemp
executiveThat agreement provides for a total of $100 million. Since we have raised $41.2 million so far, the amount left comes to $48.8 million.
Chris Tsung
analystOkay, that's all I had. I'll hand things back. Appreciate it, everyone.
Inger Klemp
executiveThanks.
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks.
Greg Lewis
analystYeah. Hey, thanks, and good afternoon, everyone. I suppose I'd like to go a bit deeper into why you chose to sell the LR2s. What was it about those ships that perhaps made them more appealing than certain other vessels we have? Is it more about, you know, capturing the acquisition, what was that? A year ago, with the Suezmaxes; it came down to those vessels being part of the sale and leaseback deal, really the fact that they were product carriers rather than crude, or really what I'm getting at is, I think all of us are hopeful that we'll see tanker rates recover in 2022, hopefully. What I'm wondering is whether we might see additional deals of that similar kind, perhaps involving some of your crude vessels?
Lars Barstad
executiveYeah, thanks. No, that's a reasonable question. Throughout the past year, we've clearly expanded enormously in our exposure to the VLCC market. This is something we've communicated for quite a while, that this has been our goal. Historically, we've observed that the sort of return we can deliver to our shareholders is, kind of the best return we're capable of delivering comes from the bigger vessels. Kind of in that process, we've obviously gone far to grow that fleet substantially. Then, over the year, and this is kind of an odd one, the asset class that has gone up the most is, in fact, LR2s. While all asset prices have climbed, the LR2s have been incredibly strong. Basically we viewed this as a chance to seize value at that point in the curve. It could be that we'll kind of dispose of other vessels too. It's kind of our focus is to grow and maintain our VLCC position, since that's where we think we get the best kind of value for our money. As the LR2 segment is a very interesting one. we have faith in that market, but we judged it kind of wise to seize this value as we felt kind of the price we could get on these four units, the oldest four in our fleet, Chinese built, our ability to capture value there. We basically did it.
Greg Lewis
analystAll right, that's helpful. Thanks for walking us through that, and regarding the VLCC sector, when you brought up past pricing. What I'm really attempting to get at is this: when I examine the VLCC fleet right now, take those 100 ships, the ones that are 20 years old, you mentioned 115 or something like that, so let's say more than 100. Is there any indication of what portion of what you'd call the current VLCC fleet has scrubbers installed?
Lars Barstad
executiveTo be honest, when it comes to the modern ones, that figure isn't available to me right now, but from what I've observed, roughly half of the VLCC fleet currently has scrubbers installed. My presumption would be that the newest ships essentially arrive that way from the shipyard. However, the bulk of scrubber spending has likely gone toward the non-eco, less efficient vessels, since that's where it makes the most financial sense. That said, I don't have that breakdown available to me right now, but roughly 50% of the fleet operates with a scrubber.
Greg Lewis
analystAlright. That's all from me, then. You know what, if it comes back to me, I'll jump in. It's just slipped my mind. Thanks, everyone, for your time.
Lars Barstad
executiveAlright. Thanks.
Jon Chappell
analystThank you. Good afternoon, everybody.
Lars Barstad
executiveAfternoon.
Jon Chappell
analystInger, I'll pose Greg's question on his behalf. You accomplished quite a bit regarding financing during Q3, and it appears everything is now in order, which satisfies a major requirement when it comes to the new build commitments. I'm simply wondering about the equity distribution — why did you consider it necessary to issue equity of that size, considering all the financing you had arranged, and the fact that you're essentially covered now even without the pricier equity?
Inger Klemp
executiveWell, the action we took there benefited the company in a sense, since the NAV of the Frontline share sat well under the share price at the moment we printed those shares.
Jon Chappell
analystMm.
Inger Klemp
executiveFor the company, doing that refi turned out to be a smart, sound decision.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right. Looking at the bigger picture, Lars, there are obviously plenty of factors we simply can't pin down at this moment, and honestly this line of questioning would have made more sense a couple of weeks back, before additional developments came into play. Still, everybody — and that includes us — has laid out a pretty hopeful take on the reasons conditions ought to improve. The way it looks, the spring is winding up, stockpiles are sitting at very low levels, output is climbing, consumption is climbing, and the fleet keeps getting smaller. And yet here we are, stuck around these depressed numbers where occasionally you see a small uptick and you start thinking, "All right, this is it. The cycle is finally kicking off." And then it drops right back down. Setting aside OPEC simply being somewhat tightfisted when it comes to releasing supply, what would you say has been the main thing holding back this rebound from the Q3 bottom from really picking up steam? Beyond the items you've already touched on, do you have any additional worries regarding whether this can hold up as we move into early 2022?
Lars Barstad
executiveMy sense is that obviously there isn't — and probably can't be — a single right answer to what you're asking; however, what we've observed is that in certain segments you suddenly find yourself able to push, so you can sort of drive rates upward. But then other portions of the pie, or of the spectrum, are dealing with their own problems. Essentially, what we've seen over the past few weeks is genuinely strong demand in the VLCC space. We're finally seeing the Middle East export in a way that roughly follows the OPEC plan. Before that, we had suspicions that OPEC nations were in fact using up or holding onto a great deal of that oil at home. Then you get West Africa dealing with output problems. All at once, that volume sort of dwindles. There's also been, across the past few months, a circumstance in which, for the long-haul oil, you require the Arbs to be open. Essentially, Atlantic Basin oil needs to be priced in a way that makes it appealing to refiners in Asia. That hasn't really been happening; this is essentially because demand recovery has taken place fairly quickly over this period, or at least during the latter half of this year, in Europe and the U.S. at minimum. Essentially the local crudes in and around the Atlantic Basin have been priced fairly attractively, which basically means that refiners in Asia can't really compete. You've had a handful of these elements at play during this fall. We remain roughly a couple of million barrels of production short of where we'd be at pre-COVID levels. Naturally, there are new vessels that have been delivered over the course of the year. I'd say it's a combination of those three factors. As for pricing and the way crude gets priced, whether it heads to Asia or remains local, that could shift very quickly. As for the production boost, I'd argue that's riskier at this point, whether OPEC will actually add volumes into Q1.
Jon Chappell
analystMm.
Lars Barstad
executiveThere’s one point I can state with confidence: we’re quite near equilibrium. That said, we’re not there yet, so to speak. As I believe I’ve said previously, the market resembles an engine with 3 or 4 cylinders, and for it to gain any momentum, every one of those cylinders has to fire. Unfortunately, a single cylinder gave out just as the rest were running.
Jon Chappell
analystAlright. That's all clear to me. Let me just add one more question on that. I'd say everybody will be watching OPEC in the coming days. Clearly, at the moment they're usually the ones really setting the mood in the tanker markets. Based on what you mentioned regarding the Arbs, and if the SPR release over in the U.S. pushes domestic prices down here, which might mean more exports, and those are longer haul. Does OPEC still hold as much influence over the tanker markets as it did before? Or would you say it's more of a mood setter rather than something that actually moves the fundamentals?
Lars Barstad
executiveTo be quite honest, I'd say it's more of a mood setter rather than something that actually moves the fundamentals.
Jon Chappell
analystMm.
Lars Barstad
executiveWhat demonstrates this is that over the course of this year, OPEC has been involved — first raising output, then abruptly halting those increases, and afterward postponing gatherings. On top of that, only a fairly modest share of the added output has ended up showing in what they ship abroad. Among OPEC members, some are in fact exceeding their required cuts, essentially as a result of troubles on the production side.
Jon Chappell
analystMm-hmm.
Lars Barstad
executiveMy sense is that the headline matters most here. Within the narrow slice of worldwide crude oil shipping that we track, what we're seeing is a steady rise in volumes. Of course, should OPEC abruptly determine in January that they have no wish to raise output, I'd expect movement in prices, and all at once Atlantic cargoes would be drawn toward, or shifted back over to, Asia; from our vantage point in tankers, that counts for much more than whatever OPEC might settle on for a single month.
Jon Chappell
analystUnderstood. OK, that's quite useful, Lars. Appreciate it. And thank you, Inger.
Inger Klemp
executiveThanks.
Chris Robertson
analystMorning, all. Chris Robertson here, sitting in for Randy Giveans, who is sitting in for Randy. Appreciate you having us on the call. Hello.
Inger Klemp
executiveHello.
Chris Robertson
analystTo build on what we discussed regarding the ATM program, could you explain the reasoning behind the size of what you issued in October? And if, hypothetically, rates remain soft throughout 2022, might you tap it once more with an additional issuance?
Inger Klemp
executiveGiven where our share price sits right now, using the ATM again is not something we would contemplate.
Chris Robertson
analystAll right.
Lars Barstad
executiveLet me build on that point. Frontline has run ATM programs in the past, you know, and we've stayed very strict about it — we only move when it adds value and when the right circumstances exist. That, I think, also helps address what you were asking.
Chris Robertson
analystAbsolutely, that helps a lot. We're all set now. Thanks so much.
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks.
Inger Klemp
executiveThanks.
Lars Barstad
executiveAbsolutely, we really appreciate you joining the call. Thanks for making the time. And of course, a big thank you to everyone on the Frontline team, who has once again delivered outstanding work this quarter. Please stay safe.
Inger Klemp
executiveYeah.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.