Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 17, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 49 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Lars Barstad

executive
#1

Thanks, and a warm hello to everybody joining us, whether it's morning or afternoon where you are. It's a pleasure to have you on Frontline's call for the fourth quarter results. We kept pushing ahead through a market that turned out to be a bit less thrilling than we'd anticipated. As the third quarter was winding down, we began to notice freight demand picking back up thanks to rising export volumes, and that trend carried over into Q4. Unfortunately, that wasn't sufficient to shift the needle on the vessel supply and demand balance enough to cause any meaningful movement in rates in absolute terms. Let's go right to the highlights on slide three. During Q4, Frontline earned $16,500 per day across our VLCC fleet. Our Suezmax fleet came in at $14,200 per day, while our LR2/Aframax fleet posted $13,900 per day. Looking at Q1 2022 so far, we've fixed 58% of VLCC days at $21,300 per day, 65% of Suezmax days at $19,600 per day, and 56% of LR2/Aframax days at $18,800 per day. Every figure in this table is calculated on a load-to-discharge basis. To make sure everyone listening understands how we get to these figures when the benchmark indices are being reported as negative, let's turn quickly to slide four. We've repeated this many times: Frontline operates a big, varied fleet of contemporary tankers; a call earlier today made it clear we ought to explain this in more depth. The issue is that these indices meant to reflect market performance rely on a methodology that's rather outdated, since a modern tanker trades quite differently from an older one. A modern tanker's economics, particularly once you factor in a scrubber, are vastly different today given the record-wide gap between high sulfur fuel oil and low sulfur fuel oil. At Frontline, our fleet's average age is five years. Eco vessels make up 79% of the fleet, and 54% of the fleet has scrubbers fitted. Looking at the diagrams on the right side of this slide, what we've essentially done is take some benchmark indices categorized for non-ECO vessels, non-ECO with scrubbers, ECO vessels, pure ECO with no scrubber — these are typically ships built after 2015 — and then ECO with scrubber. Using the Q4 2021 average, on the VLCC side you can see that a non-ECO, non-scrubber, no nothing vessel will earn $5,400 per day according to the index. An ECO vessel with a scrubber will earn a premium of $12,500 per day, which essentially comes from lower fuel cost; the same pattern holds for Suezmax and LR2s; that's what you need to remember when you view Frontline as a share. We have both a very modern fleet and very low cash break-even levels. With that, I'll hand things over to our CFO, Inger Klemp.

Inger Klemp

executive
#2

Thank you, Lars. Good morning and good afternoon, everyone. I believe we ought to begin by turning to slide five, where we'll examine the income statement. Frontline brought in total operating revenues, net of voyage expenses, amounting to $101 million during the fourth quarter, along with an adjusted EBITDA of $51 million; net income comes in at roughly $20 million, or $0.10 per share, while the adjusted net loss stands at approximately $5 million, or $0.02 per share. The adjustments recorded this quarter involve various items. We see a $5.3 million gain on derivatives; a $0.5 million loss on marketable securities; a $5.1 million gain from vessel sales; recognition of the DNV distribution amounting to $13.4 million after tax; plus $1.3 million in amortization of acquired time charters. The adjusted net loss for the fourth quarter, then, fell by $31.1 million relative to the third quarter. That decline stemmed from higher time charter equivalent earnings, which came about because of stronger TC rates, as well as a drop in ship operating expenses. Partially countering this were rises in interest expense and depreciation tied to three vessels delivered during the fourth quarter. Let's now examine the balance sheet on slide six. Total balance sheet figures grew by roughly $130 million during the fourth quarter. Movements on the balance sheet for the quarter mainly stem from taking delivery of the LR2 tanker Front Feature along with VLCCs FRONT DRIVA and FRONT NAUSTA, plus regular debt repayments and depreciation. As of December 21st, Frontline holds $181 million in cash and cash equivalents, which includes undrawn amounts available under our senior unsecured loan facility, marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. The remaining CapEx — newbuilding CapEx of $437.4 million as per December 31st — is entirely covered by the $390 million in committed debt, together with a portion of the $68.6 million in net cash proceeds from selling four LR2 tankers. The company faces no debt maturities before 2023. Please turn to slide seven, covering cash breakeven and cash generation potential. We project average cash cost breakeven rates for 2022 at approximately $22,700 per day for VLCCs, $18,900 per day for Suezmax tankers, and $16,000 per day for LR2 tankers. The fleet-wide average estimate sits near $19,300 per day and accounts for dry dock of 16 vessels during 2022, carrying an impact of $740 per day. Among those 16 vessels are five VLCCs, five Suezmax tankers, and six LR2 tankers. Such rates represent the all-in daily amounts our vessels need to generate in order to cover budgeted operating costs plus dry dock, estimated interest expense, TC and bareboat hire installments on loans, and G&A expenses. We logged OpEx expenses in the fourth quarter at $7,600 per day for VLCCs, $6,900 per day for Suezmax, and $6,100 per day for LR2. One VLCC and one Suezmax tanker underwent dry docking during the fourth quarter. On the right side of this slide, that chart displays free cash flow for each share once debt service is covered, plus the free cash flow yield, using the existing fleet and a share price of $16 as of February 16 across different TCE rates. If we look back at that slide Lars walked everyone through, slide four, I believe that was

Lars Barstad

executive
#3

Mm-hmm.

Inger Klemp

executive
#4

When it comes to our fleet, thanks to the ECO and scrubber modifications, we're showing some very strong premium TCE rates. That's what's reflected on this slide as well. Taking Clarksons' historical TCE rates for non-ECO ships from 2000 through 2021, and then applying the adjustments for scrubber and ECO premiums, Frontline comes out with free cash flow per share of $2.44 and a free cash flow yield of 32%. Naturally, that free cash flow yield could go higher if you assume better TCE rates, and it also rises on a fully delivered basis. Having said that, I'll hand things back over to Lars.

Lars Barstad

executive
#5

Thanks, Inger. Now we'll turn to slide eight for a review of how the tanker market performed in the fourth quarter of 2021. We'll begin with that headline you can see there. The amount of oil moving by sea is getting close to the peaks seen in 2018 and across 2010 through 2019. Take a look at the chart at the bottom, especially that dark blue line marked with a red circle — you can essentially watch how the dots representing volumes of oil in transit kept climbing steadily through Q4. One quick thing to note: the yellow line over on the left side of the chart reflects January and the early February figures, which is where we stand right now. Global oil demand was estimated to average 99.7 million barrels per day in Q4, which is an increase of 1.5 million barrels per day versus the third quarter. We kept pulling down inventories, to the tune of 1.4 million barrels per day over the fourth quarter, since demand keeps exceeding supply. Let me add something here, because going back 12 months, when I sat here on this same call, I felt quite optimistic, largely because we had expected inventory draws to end in August, which really set up an interesting second half of the year. That didn't materialize; the draws have kept going well past what anyone predicted. If you trust EIA's figures, demand growth projected for 2022 will mostly come from outside the OECD, and by year-end we're going to get very close to 103 million barrels per day. Today's oil price points to tightness in the market. There have been production problems in Libya, Nigeria, and Angola, and on the whole OPEC+ is overcomplying. What that means is, you know, when they have these sort of pre-decided output levels, they simply can't hit them. Essentially, the unwinding of OPEC+ cuts is happening far more slowly than anticipated. Even so, oil in transit has climbed steadily since October 2021 and now sits 20% above the lows. You could fairly directly equate that to tanker demand. In essence, tanker utilization is getting better. Even with higher activity and these rising volumes, we still haven't hit the turning point for it. Let's turn to slide nine and examine the tanker order books; this one is clear enough. Since vessels keep being delivered while no new orders come in, the order book keeps getting smaller. There's also this quite unusual situation in which 6% of the worldwide VLCC fleet now exceeds 20 years of age. 2022 is in fact a big delivery year, yet by the close of 2022, over 80 VLCCs will be due for recycling within that same period. There's a major question mark over net fleet growth once all this plays out. For Suezmax, the picture is the same, with 12% of the fleet, or 72 vessels, either already past or reaching 20 years during 2022. The LR2 order book has more in it, but again, 15% of the fleet will go past 15 years. When it comes to LR2s, their useful life is clearly much longer than 15 years. In the clean trade, charterers don't want a ship over 15 years old hauling a clean cargo, mainly because they worry about contamination. That means an LR2 past 15 years will typically switch over and become a Suezmax. Order books for VLCCs, Suezmaxes, and LR2s are at 8%, 7%, and 13%, in that order. Even more significant, real room for new tanker orders has now been pushed out to 2025. Let's turn to slide 10 and go a bit deeper into how the fleet looks today. Here I've focused on the tankers we're exposed to, the asset classes we hold. As everyone knows, by 2023, IMO will bring in new rules. We call them tickets to trade; every vessel worldwide is going to receive CII ratings. If you've seen those, it's A, B, C, D, E, that's essentially the scale. You have to be C or above to earn the ticket to trade. Frontline's own fleet, on an overall weighted basis, has a carbon intensity rating of A. That reflects 2021 data. Looking at the chart on the left, you can see how many ships in the tanker fleet — first, those beyond 20 years are already challenged, and that's 6% of the fleet. Add those that will be efficiency challenged, meaning they face an EEXI rating below C, and you add another 17%. Then look at the non-ECOs that struggle to trade economically given where oil prices are now, and that takes you up another 29%. CII comes up a few times on this chart, and CII measures a vessel's carbon intensity and its average emissions per volume transported. A ship's carbon intensity matters to charterers if you're going to charter that vessel, if they have carbon footprint policies or when they have. It's also a relevant measure when we discuss carbon tax and the possibility of shipping joining the EU ETS trading program. Basically, I think we can all agree the worldwide fleet of VLCCs, Suezmaxes, and LR2s faces some challenges over the coming years. The only, or the most efficient, step you can take to lower your CII, meaning carbon intensity, is speed. Simply slowing down will cut your carbon footprint. But to handle EEXI, you'd actually have to do physical work on the vessel. You'd essentially have to limit its ability to generate power, which also ends up lowering speed; it's worth noting that for the Frontline fleet, we don't see any challenges when it comes to staying on the IMO trajectory until at least 2025. Now let's go to slide 11. Tanker demolition — that's an area that's essentially been absent from our market for some time now. Thanks to all-time high scrap steel pricing, things are at last appearing set to speed up. The two most recent significant dismantling years were 2017 and 2018. Then in 2021, we have in fact witnessed 2.3% of the entire tanker fleet exceeding 10,000 deadweight — which is essentially a gauge of the tanker fleet's carrying capacity — having been cut by 2.3%, and we think this pattern must keep going. The elderly fleet faces serious difficulties in the compliant spot market, and alternative uses or chances for older tankers — normally for storage or conversion — are practically nil. Looking at the bottom graph right there, scrap steel prices, I actually attempted to locate a longer record to check whether we'd ever been at such levels, and I just couldn't locate it, at minimum within the records I was able to get to. We think this mix of the regulatory pressures I outlined on the earlier slide, the extremely difficult market for non-ECO ships and the scrap steel price ought to generate a favorable result for a tanker owner. Let's proceed to slide 12 and examine Frontline and the way we are tackling the ESG.

Lars Barstad

executive
#6

Like I believe I said during a few earlier quarters, Frontline launched what we term our decarbonization journey, aimed at IMO 2030 and 2050. That got underway back in 2019. The initial step, which we called the Veracity platform, was essentially about determining our current position. Digitalization is part of this. It also involves enabling us to capture live data from each vessel under our control and route it into a database, letting us examine not just carbon but speed, consumption, and incidents across the entire fleet — essentially to establish where we stand. Once that was in place during 2020, we began planning how to make improvements. To start with, our fleet ranks among the youngest and most fuel-efficient in the sector, we always remain compliant with tightening regulations, and we're pursuing strategic moves toward decarbonization. Among other efforts, we've completed successful tests with low carbon marine biofuel. Frontline aims to cut carbon emissions by 3% annually, roughly equal to 55,000 metric tons. The reason this genuinely pays off is that it simultaneously boosts our earning potential. I don't believe I must explain at length that we do align with the UN Sustainable Development Goals concerning the sea and seafarer wellbeing. Naturally we release our ESG report each year, and I'd urge every listener to take a look. We also naturally practice what we call sustainability accounting, in line with SASB principles. Turning to slide 13, let me try to wrap this up. Oil demand alongside supply keeps climbing. The Omicron variant appears to have had a much smaller effect than we might have dreaded. Since Q3 2021, tanker markets have indeed bounced back, though only modestly — far too modest for our taste. We remain hampered by oil supply that hasn't returned fully to pre-pandemic levels. As noted earlier in this presentation, tanker recycling is at last beginning to influence vessel supply. Beyond that, plenty of variables are in play. U.S. SPR releases have occurred. Discussion now surrounds the future OPEC strategy, plus we have the Iranian nuclear talks. Many moving pieces exist. Oil in transit keeps increasing. Energy prices sit at record highs, and oil is currently nearing $100 per barrel. How that will influence what I just mentioned regarding the SPR releases, regarding OPEC strategy, and regarding the Iranian nuclear talks is generating some quite intriguing dynamics. Finally, Frontline's financial commitments are completely funded, and we achieved that while lowering overall financing costs. We believe we're well-positioned as this market's story develops. With that, I think we'll begin taking questions on this call.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#7

Thanks. Good afternoon, Lars and Inger. Lars, the first subject I'd like to raise with you — you mentioned it during the presentation and in the press release — is that OPEC is clearly struggling to reach its production quotas. Not Saudi Arabia, not U.A.E., yet a number of other nations likely face deeper structural problems. When you consider the supply the tanker market requires to keep pace with this recovery and demand, and given that countries in West Africa and elsewhere can't truly hit their quotas, where do you expect that supply to originate, particularly while U.S. companies aim to be more disciplined? And might this become a problem in which inventory draws persist far longer than expected, since we're unable to answer that rise in demand with global supply?

Lars Barstad

executive
#8

Well, yes, I understand it was framed as a question, but you've sort of partly answered it on your own. So the clear response is that the place where supply could really be ramped up fairly fast — and really what's required is more exports — is, as you know, obviously America. But so far, the restraint shown by U.S. producers has been, well, not a positive for us, though it has been a positive for crude prices. And if that pattern holds, then we've got a problem on our hands. Naturally, there are still barrels available in the Middle East and in various nations, I'd presume. If not, then the trouble we're in is far worse than we'd care to imagine. My sense is that would probably be the first stage if things stay the way they are right now, or if crude prices climb even higher. My view is that OPEC would essentially need to fully open the taps. Even though OPEC would prefer crude to be priced very high, I also believe they deeply fear demand destruction. You know, a crude price well above $100 would land us in exactly that scenario. That's roughly my take on it. I also believe that, you know, if we end up in a scenario where America doesn't boost output further — I think EIA has roughly 800,000 bpd for U.S. production. Unfortunately, American demand is climbing pretty quickly as well, so it's unclear how much will remain available for exports. I think, in a way, there's a massive incentive to reach some kind of agreement regarding Iran.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#9

Okay.

Lars Barstad

executive
#10

Yeah.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#11

Okay, so that situation with Iran basically brought me to my second point, which is also my second question. I mean, you haven't exactly been quiet when it comes to pointing a finger at that illicit fleet, that illicit trading fleet. There's a pretty fascinating chart in here, you know, that illustrates the gap between the non-ECO vessels, the ECO ones, the ECOs fitted with scrubbers, and then the entire IMO 2023 matter too. It really seems as though there's just so much bullishness out there in the market, you know, folks are hesitant to send older ships to the breakers since those vessels are completely paid off and they're able to earn a solid return on the recovery. So when do either the rules, the economics, or perhaps even more crucially, just the vetting and the charterers — I'd imagine you talk with the largest ones — truly dig in their heels and compel additional scrapping of, you know, ships that are 15+ years old?

Lars Barstad

executive
#12

Okay, so I believe there are really two separate markets at play here. When it comes to the compliant market, the major charterers have already been engaged in this practice; within the compliant tanker sector, which we operate in, we face daily examination, and clearly we're making every effort to shield ourselves from any involvement in activities that breach sanctions. There's a parallel marketplace out there earning substantial profits. The reason those earnings happen is that sanctioned crude comes at a reduced price. So long as that price gap persists, there's motivation to deal in sanctioned crude, so to speak. That, in my rather straightforward view, is the way we can tackle this matter. If, for instance, sanctions on Iran were to be removed, every bit of that volume would have to be carried on compliant ships. That's because Iran's usual buyers — and remember, historically that has meant places like India, Northwest Europe, Korea, and similar — are simply unable to accept that oil aboard a vessel whose compliance isn't properly arranged. That would serve as an enormous catalyst for demand when it comes to compliant tankers. Put another way, I'd say it would deliver the fatal strike to this shadow market.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#13

Okay. Thanks for the thoughts, Lars.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#14

Hello there, Lars and Inger, how are you both doing?

Lars Barstad

executive
#15

We're doing well. Hello to you, Randy.

Inger Klemp

executive
#16

Hello there.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#17

Let's begin by examining your fleet. So, you reached an agreement to divest those 4 LR2 vessels, and every one of them has now been handed over to the buyers. Given that asset prices keep beating spot rates, what are your thoughts regarding additional divestments?

Lars Barstad

executive
#18

Yeah. No, this is, as you know, clearly something we keep discussing. As all of you are aware, we've made certain investments on the VLCC side during the last year. For that, we need to explore different ways of, well, bringing in equity. We went ahead with these LR2 disposals since at that moment we viewed it as a really strong chance, and we'll keep examining different possibilities. I'd characterize this as possibly a highly advantageous moment and arrangement for us to act; it ought not to be seen as, you know, a total shift in our view of the market; ideally we'd prefer to retain as much profit potential as possible, yet we think, or have seen historically, that the greatest return comes from the VLCC segment. However, at present we hold no immediate intentions to divest additional LR2 or Suezmax vessels, for that matter.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#19

Understood. All right. So far this quarter, your Suezmax and LR2 rates have cleared break even, while VLCC remains under it. Do you see any catalysts that could genuinely push those numbers up? And in the interim, as we hold out for the spot market to strengthen, might you consider locking in some time charters of six months or 12 months to guarantee a bit of cash flow?

Lars Barstad

executive
#20

Sure, I'll address your second question first. Our view is that freight markets tend to mean revert, and that's what the historical record tells us.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#21

Okay.

Lars Barstad

executive
#22

Naturally, every peak and every trough lasts for a different amount of time, so obviously we sit somewhere between those two points. This doesn't strike us as a moment when you lock in cash flow through lengthy time charters. We'd prefer to take that route. Should we choose to do so, it would happen at another spot along the curve. We don't sense any obligation to pursue it, given that our financial standing is solid. On top of that, our fleet genuinely offers us a degree of reassurance amid these truly awful markets. Regarding the varying earnings across asset classes, as you're well aware, that ties back essentially to which trades are functioning in the oil market. What the Suezmax flow reveals is that oil has largely been moving over fairly short distances. I won't dive too far into the specifics, but one consequence of Europe's energy crisis affecting natural gas is that refinery margins have faced pressure when processing high sulfur crude; consequently, the natural destination for U.S. barrels has become Europe, which is mainly a Suezmax trade, and that has subsequently damaged the VLCC trade; additionally, the VLCC market gets hit by the reality that most recent OPEC output hikes originate in the Middle East, and clearly the Middle East sits nearer to the key market of Asia, so ton miles have essentially taken a hit because of that.

Randy Giveans

analyst
#23

Understood. Alright, hey, I appreciate that thorough response. That's all from my side.

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#24

Yeah, thanks. Good afternoon, Lars and Inger.

Lars Barstad

executive
#25

Hi, Magnus.

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#26

First off, a question about those dry dockings. I believe you said 16 vessels are scheduled for dry docking during 2022. Should we figure on those being spread out uniformly across the year, or, given your upbeat view of the market, are you attempting to accelerate the dry docking?

Inger Klemp

executive
#27

As things stand, the schedule is four during the first quarter, five during the second and the third quarter, and then two during the fourth quarter. That's what we're planning; however, we can clearly seek to make adjustments depending on the market, based on whatever takes place in the market, in a sense.

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#28

Alright. I believe you brought up roughly $740 a day for dry docking. Does that work out to approximately $20 million across those 16 vessels?

Inger Klemp

executive
#29

Yes, it comes in somewhat lower. The figure is right around slightly under $18 million.

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#30

All right, that's great. So this one's probably for Lars. When it comes to rates, I think you recorded some pretty impressive ones this quarter, and part of that came from what I understand was revenue recognition. Looking ahead, regarding rates — and thanks for breaking down how the premiums stack up against non-ECO — are the rates you're booking right now similar to what you had in Q1? The market's been softer in January and February, so I'm just trying to get a sense of whether that premium is still holding up.

Lars Barstad

executive
#31

Not for the VLCCs, unfortunately. I think that's something you have to accept. With the Suezmaxes, though, yes. The LR2 is honestly a somewhat more mixed picture, I'd say. The Suezmaxes

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#32

Oh, right.

Lars Barstad

executive
#33

Over the past 10 or 11 days, it has in fact demonstrated a certain amount of potential.

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#34

All right, good. Given that the market looks somewhat different this year, do you anticipate any seasonal pattern emerging — with the second quarter and third quarter usually being the weakest? Should we expect a fairly steady path heading into Q4 this year?

Lars Barstad

executive
#35

That is genuinely a great question, since in our sector, as you're aware, we typically track those seasonal patterns, and it's quite unusual, or rarely happens, that we break away from them. I'd say much of the difficulty we're facing in the tanker market really mirrors just how extremely tight the supply side of the oil market has become. In theory, we might get a very — we could swiftly find ourselves in a highly atypical market, essentially because, let's say, OPEC raised output beyond what was planned, or something develops on the Iranian front. As I said earlier, we're still drawing down from inventory. If you examine an oil curve, the reason is fairly clear, since crude right now is as costly as it has ever been relative to crude delivered, let's say, in May. The backwardation is incredibly steep. If anything were to shift with that curve, you'd begin to see inventories start building once more. Essentially, a swift shift in the oil curve would set off a great deal of activity. It's nearly frightening, considering the political friction between, for example, Ukraine and Russia, that the rest of the world is willing to operate on such depleted inventories when you face the danger of possible action targeting one of the largest oil producers on the planet.

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#36

Okay. So you brought up that the majority of those barrels out of the U.S. have been heading to Europe, since OPEC has been providing crude to Asia. Should OPEC run into trouble raising output even more, could you picture a situation in which shale output actually begins climbing more, and that extra barrel heads toward the Far East?

Lars Barstad

executive
#37

For sure. I believe I'm aware of where you're calling from, and this is something that strikes us as, at least in our view, somewhat ironic. What we've seen is a link between releases from the U.S. SPR and exports from the U.S., and those cargoes generally wind up in Asia; so essentially, clearly it isn't the identical molecules, but when you put out supply from an SPR, you make a crude accessible in nearby U.S. markets and then clearly let participants in the U.S. market ship out more. So in a way that's an indirect flow into a strategic sort of stockpile in Japan or China, or perhaps even Korea. That is essentially what served as the foundation of the VLCC trade during Q4, and to some degree into January, which was in fact this rise in shipments from the U.S. Gulf that were arriving in Asia.

Magnus Fyhr

analyst
#38

Excellent. So, Inger, I appreciate that. Lars, thanks to you as well, and I also want to say thank you for a presentation that was really full of useful detail.

Lars Barstad

executive
#39

I appreciate it.

Inger Klemp

executive
#40

Thanks.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#41

Hello there. Good afternoon to both Lars and Inger. How are you doing?

Lars Barstad

executive
#42

Oh, we're doing well.

Inger Klemp

executive
#43

We're good, yeah. Thanks.

Lars Barstad

executive
#44

Thank you.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#45

Thanks. The first thing I'd like to ask about is what you showed on slide four — your fleet includes 3 vessels that aren't ECO — and the chart on the right side that you presented indicates a sizable premium for non-ECO ships fitted with scrubbers. So my question is whether there's any intention to put scrubbers on those 3 ships, or would you instead consider selling them, given that the average TCE in Q4 for non-ECOs with scrubbers appears to still be under cash break-even levels.

Lars Barstad

executive
#46

This is something we keep talking about, and clearly when you have a non-ECO, non-scrubber vessel, the choice is essentially whether to sell it or to fit scrubbers so it moves up the chain. I'm not able to give you an answer on this call, but I would say the question is a fair one and it is being discussed. We tend to refer to it as the scrubber spread, correct? The gap between high-sulfur fuel and low-sulfur fuel has clearly grown enormously over the past 5 to 6 months, which makes fitting a scrubber very economical. There are practical matters to consider — you take a ship out to the market, which doesn't really matter that much in this market, but then you have to locate a yard, schedule the timing, and all of that. I can tell you this is very much at the top of our list, especially for those vessels.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#47

Excellent, thank you. I have just one additional follow-up question. Regarding those six VLCC newbuildings, could you provide a revised timeline or delivery schedule? I'm simply looking to understand the pace at which those vessels will arrive.

Lars Barstad

executive
#48

Yes. Delivery of the initial vessel is set for Q2.

Inger Klemp

executive
#49

Q1.

Lars Barstad

executive
#50

Mm-hmm.

Inger Klemp

executive
#51

End of Q1.

Lars Barstad

executive
#52

Yeah.

Inger Klemp

executive
#53

That brings us to the close of Q1.

Lars Barstad

executive
#54

Yes, Q1 has wrapped up, though we're only in April — the beginning of April. As for the remaining ones, clearly they won't follow that same timing. We aren't rushing to get them out as fast as possible at this point. Instead, they'll arrive one after another, like pearls on a string, during the back half of the year.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#55

Alright, excellent. I appreciate the information. I have nothing further.

Inger Klemp

executive
#56

Thanks.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#57

Thank you, guys.

Lars Barstad

executive
#58

Thank you.

Greg Lewis

analyst
#59

Yes. Hello there. Thank you, and good afternoon. I appreciate you taking my question. My apologies if somebody already raised this. I had difficulty connecting. Given Frontline's exposure to and ownership of scrubbers, obviously the gap between high sulfur and low sulfur is getting wider. Are you hearing or seeing or at all worried about availability of either grades or, as oil demand has risen, any kind of detail you could provide around that and how you're thinking about that for the remainder of the year?

Lars Barstad

executive
#60

Well, we haven't. Availability hasn't typically been a big issue, though occasionally at some ports, you know, they've had to reserve things further in advance. What's driving this is mostly that bunker market participants don't want to keep stock on hand when backwardation is steep. Essentially, they'll, you know, try to cap how much they're holding and wait until basically somebody has ordered a given quantity of bunkers; that's causing some problems. You're correct. At certain locations, high sulfur is genuinely difficult to source. My expectation is that this situation should improve once we get past winter up north, since part of what's made this market so tight is that straight-run fuel has been diverted into power generation because gas prices have been extremely elevated. I'm not sure that addresses what you were asking. To this point, we haven't really encountered situations where securing fuel becomes impossible, if you want to put it that way.

Greg Lewis

analyst
#61

Alright, excellent. Hi there, so I appreciate you letting me ask. Have a wonderful day.

Lars Barstad

executive
#62

Thanks.

Robert Silvera

analyst
#63

Thanks for letting me ask. Here's what I want to know: how high do rates need to climb before you'd start paying a cash dividend again, or bring one back?

Lars Barstad

executive
#64

Honestly, that's a tough one to respond to. Looking back, we've never really had a set dividend policy, you know? That said, we do have,

Robert Silvera

analyst
#65

Right.

Lars Barstad

executive
#66

The board has more say in that. Based on what we've seen, any time Frontline posts a solid positive net income, dividends get paid out. I think you mostly have to check where our cash break-even sits — all of it is cash break-even — and that might offer some sense of the levels to watch for. And that figure is $19,300 on average across the fleet; but the moment the VLCCs begin earning something meaningful above $22,000-$23,000 per day, and let's say $19,000 for the Suezmax and $16,000 for the LR2s, Aframaxes, that's the point where we're in a position to start handing out money.

Robert Silvera

analyst
#67

Would it be around 10% higher than those levels at the point when you might start the dividend up again? Or would it just be 5%? Could you give us some sense of that, how far above?

Lars Barstad

executive
#68

Yeah, no, honestly, I wish I were able to. I think my response to this would be somewhat different. You know, Frontline is always going to do everything possible to distribute dividends. There have even been cases where we paid dividends in a quarter during which we didn't truly earn money, since we can see the earnings coming in the next quarter. I wouldn't question how aggressive Frontline is about paying dividends to shareholders, but I'd rather not have a discussion about percentages, if that's alright.

Robert Silvera

analyst
#69

No problem. I really miss how things were back in 2003 and 2004.

Lars Barstad

executive
#70

So do we.

Robert Silvera

analyst
#71

All right, then. I really appreciate the thorough responses to our questions and the presentation itself — that was very helpful.

Lars Barstad

executive
#72

You're welcome.

Robert Silvera

analyst
#73

That's it from me. Thank you.

Lars Barstad

executive
#74

Thank you.

Lars Barstad

executive
#75

Okay. I think we'll wrap it up.

Inger Klemp

executive
#76

Yes.

Lars Barstad

executive
#77

We appreciate everyone tuning in. Enjoy your evening, and a good day to all of you. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#78

That concludes the conference for today. Thank you for participating. You may all disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.