Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 25, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 36 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Lars Barstad

executive
#1

Good morning, and good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for joining Frontline's Second Quarter Earnings Call. As we noted in the release, the LR2s were the standout during this quarter. It's easy to overlook that nearly one-third of our vessel days are generated by that asset class; during Q2 we began to observe how the displacement of Russian crude and products was also impacting the Suezmaxes; and lastly, the VLCC showed signs of life as the second quarter drew to a close. Before we move into the Q2 financials and the outlook, let's review the highlights on Slide 3 of the deck. In the second quarter, Frontline earned $16,400 per day on our VLCC <<inaudible>> $6,500 per day on our Suezmax fleet and a very impressive $38,600 per day on our LR2/Aframax fleet. Thus far in the first quarter of 2022, we have booked 73% of our VLCC days at $28,100 per day, 73% of our Suezmax days at a solid $45,000 per day and 62% of our LR2/Aframax days at an even more impressive $46,200 per day. Every figure in this table is calculated on a load to discharge basis and may be impacted by how many ballast days we ultimately have at the end of Q3. That matters more for the VLCCs, which typically undertake the longer voyages. It sometimes impacts Suezmaxes and, to a lesser extent, LR2s. With that, I'll now hand things over to Inger for the financial highlights.

Inger Klemp

executive
#2

Thanks, Lars, and good morning, everyone — good afternoon as well, ladies and gentlemen. If we move to Slide 5, we'll review the income statement. During this quarter, Frontline brought in total operating revenues of $159 million along with adjusted EBITDA of $98 million; net income came in at $47.1 million, or $0.23 per share, while adjusted net income was $42.5 million, or $0.21 per share, for the quarter. Over on the right side of that slide, we lay out the adjustments booked this quarter: a $8.9 million gain on derivatives, $6.1 million from share results of associated companies, $1.3 million of amortization on acquired time charters, a $0.8 million gain on an insurance claim, a $12 million loss on marketable securities, and a $0.4 million loss on lease terminations. Adjusted net income for the second quarter rose $44.1 million versus the first quarter; that rise in interested net income came from higher time charter equivalent earnings thanks to stronger TCE rates during the quarter, though it was partly offset by ship operating expenses climbing $7.5 million, mostly from higher drydocking costs plus other income and expense movements. Next, let's review the balance sheet on Slide 6. Overall balance sheet figures grew by $304 million in the second quarter relative to the first quarter. Those movements during the quarter mainly stem from taking delivery of the 2 newbuilding VLCCs, Front Alta and Front Tweed, along with acquiring the Euronav shares in exchange for Frontline shares, plus ordinary debt repayments and depreciation. At June 30, Frontline held $351 million in cash and cash equivalents, including the undrawn amount under our senior unsecured loan facility, marketable securities and minimum cash requirements. Now let's look more closely at Slide 7. Keeping costs down has always been part of Frontline's DNA, and the core values of the Frontline platform are staying simple and focused while maintaining lean, efficient management teams. This slide shows Frontline <<inaudible>> on OpEx, G&A and interest expense. That, combined with outperforming peers on revenues for at least two out of three segments this quarter, explains Frontline's superior operational performance in the second quarter of 2022. Then I think we should turn to Slide 8; that covers cash breakeven and cash generation potential. For the remainder of 2022, we estimate average cash cost breakeven rates of roughly $24,900 per day for the VLCCs, $20,000 per day for the Suezmax tankers and $17,200 per day for the LR2 tankers. That works out to a fleet average estimate of about $20,700 per day. The fleet average estimate incorporates drydock of 6 vessels in the remainder of 2022, with an impact of roughly $530 per day. These 6 vessels break down as 2 VLCCs, 1 Suezmax tanker, and 3 LR2 tankers. During the second quarter, our OpEx expenses, drydock included, came to $8,100 per day for the VLCCs, $10,400 per day for the Suezmax tankers, and $8,400 per day for the LR2 tankers. Also in Q2, 6 vessels underwent drydocking — 4 Suezmax tankers and 2 LR2 tankers. The chart over on the right-hand side of this slide presents free cash flow per share following debt service, along with free cash flow yield, both calculated on the basis of the current fleet and share price using August 24 alternative TCE rates. Drawing on historic Clarkson TCE rates for non-eco vessels across the 2021 period, with adjustments made for scrubber and eco vessel premiums, Frontline shows free cash flow per share of $2.34 and a free cash flow yield of 20%. That free cash flow yield potential rises when higher assumed TCE rates are applied and on a fully delivered basis; with that, I'll hand things back to Lars.

Lars Barstad

executive
#3

Thanks, Inger. Let's continue and take a look at Slide 9, where we recap the second quarter. I've given this slide a title: "a pivotal point for tankers." Q2 is typically a somewhat soft quarter, also called a shoulder quarter. But as the graph in the bottom left shows, something shifted as we entered Q2 this year. Global oil demand was 700,000 barrels per day lower in Q2 than in Q1, averaging 98.4 million barrels. Supply averaged 99.1 million barrels per day, a modest increase of 0.2 million barrels per day during the quarter. What we're essentially seeing is the volatility in the market during Q2, and first and foremost, on the LR2s, it's a ton-mile story. We're currently reaping the benefits of that story, which began in the second quarter; highly inefficient trading patterns are developing, and that benefits oil in transit and utilization, as the graph in the bottom right shows. Toward the end of Q2, all Frontline asset classes, including the VLCC, began to move up. Asian demand, and Chinese demand in particular, remained subdued, but the current activity level paints an interesting picture for future starts to come. Let's then turn to Slide 10. Here we have global exports, and what you're looking at is two charts showing basically the tracked output of oil and products, split by essentially every producing country in the world and every region in the world that produces oil or products. We've seen a dramatic shift in demand and trading patterns for refined products develop during Q2 this year. I think people tend to forget — it's somewhat overshadowed by the situation in Ukraine — that most of the Western world has actually fully come out of COVID, out of the COVID-19 pandemic, with the effects that has had on demand; and at the same time, refining capacity, particularly in Europe and to some extent in the U.S., was reduced quite dramatically during the pandemic, when these regions experienced horrific refining margins. On top of that, we've had the situation with sanctions on Russia, which makes Russian oil and products more difficult to move. So essentially, what we see is that global clean product exports are actually approaching the highest levels we've seen; and this takes us back to 2017. Going further back, AIS tracking isn't as efficient as it has been in this period. But we are reaching an all-time high on clean products exports globally. Global crude oil exports are improving. It's lagging, though, on the product side. This is — but the appreciation in global crude oil exports is primarily caused by U.S. SPR releases, and U.S. production and its export capabilities are growing. U.S. production has increased by 1.4 million barrels year-to-date according to EIA. And as most of you would know, the U.S. They're releasing nearly 1 million barrels per day from their SPR — or equivalent to that from the SPR. In writing, I'd say — but speaking, right now we're seeing very strong demand for tonnage, in both the Middle East and the U.S. Gulf, which suggests this favorable freight trend should keep going. Let's go to Slide 11 then. The order book keeps shrinking, especially on the crude side. Not a single VLCC or Suezmax order has been placed over the past 12 months. Actually, I need to correct that slightly, since this morning I saw reports of VLCCs ordered — or rumored to be ordered — in Japan, but we'll come back to that. To really change this picture, we'd need far more; on the VLCC side, 27 vessels have been delivered year-to-date, with 21 still to come. Some of those will obviously slip into '23; but the order book totals 41 vessels. Our fleet is 861 vessels, and 81 of them will be over 20 years old during this year. When that order book is fully delivered, 114 VLCCs will be above 20 years old; with the Suezmaxes it's even more pronounced; 25 Suezmaxes have been delivered this year. Eight more are coming, six next year and two in 2024. That makes 16 total in the order book, and 65 Suezmaxes will pass the 20-year threshold this year. And by the time the order book delivers, a total of 111 Suezmaxes would effectively be disqualified from the commercial trading oil market. On the LR2s, we have in fact seen some orders placed this year. The broker varies of course, but we've landed on identifying 13 orders placed. And — still, I'd argue that's not an alarming development. There are 20 LR2s, or at least vessels registered as LR2s, that are going to be over 20 years this year; but if you raise the threshold a bit and put it at 15 years, which for anyone trading clean products is a more relevant yardstick, you have more than 70 LR2s built prior to 2008. So basically, by the time this order book has — when this order book has delivered, this will come to age; so we're not really that alarmed about the development on LR2s either. I think if we look at the chart at the top left here, and this has become quite repetitive over the quarterly presentations we've done. The blue line is the absolute deadweight size of the tanker order book, and the yellow one is as a percentage of the fleet. And as we can see in absolute deadweight, we're back to the 2000 to 2001 period, and we all know the oil market is much larger now than it was in 2000. When you look at the share of the fleet, the picture is even starker — you have to go all the way back to 1996, and actually earlier than that. The truth is, I don't have records going back before 1996 on this. That makes it hard for me to judge whether we're in early-'90s, mid-'90s, or '80s territory. Still, I'd call this an alarming trend, and we're beginning to see the first indications that tankers may turn into a chokepoint in the energy logistics chain. I'd also like to point out, for those of you who aren't very familiar with freight and tankers, that oil isn't something every nation on earth is fortunate enough to have. On top of that, there's an uneven link between how populations grow and where oil resources sit; so this need for transportation is genuinely real. So we'll watch how this plays out. Let's turn now to Slide 12. I think this one is quite exciting. Over the past month, the time charter market has essentially exploded. The period market's time charter is a classic old-school bellwether for what large oil transporters expect.

Lars Barstad

executive
#4

These are what we call the big guys — Shell, Equinor, BP, Chevron, the major players in this business that hold equity crude and have considerable transportation requirements — and they are all in the market, every one of them, seeking commitments of as much as three years on time charters. And for them — even for them — a three-year commitment is a meaningful thing. We saw earlier, during the reporting season, even five-year charters being signed. That is very interesting and very encouraging. This is clearly consistent with the spot market, but it isn't all that frequently that you — following a comparatively brief stretch of firm spot markets — see this kind of activity in the long-term time charter market. So what this essentially tells us is that our analysis may align with the analysis of some of these players. Frontline will stay a spot-focused owner whose aim is to deliver stock-market returns to our investors. That said, some degree of secured revenue and margin does form part of our long-term vision. And as we have reported, we are actively examining the time charter market for certain of our asset classes. So let's turn to Slide 13. We are — even though things have been fairly quiet on this front from Frontline over the past couple of months, or actually not months — last month, I should say. The Frontline and Euronav combination is on rails. We are progressing, and essentially the stage of the process we are in right now is led by legal and is more of a regulatory task directed at the regulators, and we are working toward a Frontline relocation filing to — for the relocation of — from the platform in Bermuda to Cyprus. A tender offer will follow that. We expect it to take place in Q4 this year. There have always also been discussions about the various outcomes of this tender offer. I've left out the scenario of achieving less than 50% acceptance; but obviously, should that occur, we don't believe it will. We think this is an industrial solution the market wants, but I just left that out. If we get above 75% acceptance among the Euronav shareholders, we will proceed directly to a merger with Euronav. Should we, in that case, end up between 50.1% and 75%, the outcome is more or less the same. Frontline gains control of Euronav and a combination of the two complementary platforms will be created that will perform basically as one company, although Euronav will veridically be a subsidiary of Frontline; so let's — with that, move to Slide 14 and a summary; so Q2 '22 was a shoulder quarter in terms of oil demand. And in fact, Q3 should have been the same. That's if you follow normal seasonal patterns; this is currently a turmoil story with sanctions on Russia acting as a catalyst, but we may face a structural catalyst when it comes to products. I mentioned earlier in the presentation the dislocation between refining capacity and demand. Worldwide crude shipments by sea are nearing where they stood before COVID, and the volume already on the water has reached that mark. Order books keep shrinking, and right now nothing is pushing anyone to put money into fresh capacity; on top of that, there's the matter of how soon such capacity could actually reach the market if ordering began today. A further question is whether we are beginning to sense the structural constraints in oil transport that could lie ahead. Frontline has a modern, efficient fleet exposed to the spot market, and conditions appear to be lining up — plus, I might add, winter is coming. I'd like to point you to the chart at the bottom, which differs from the previous three quarters, and it's essentially a seasonal chart showing the average weighted earnings across all tankers. It isn't Frontline's tankers — it's every tanker, basically all the tanker indices. As you may notice, a very unseasonal pattern is taking shape. With that, I'll open the floor for questions.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#5

Thanks. Good afternoon. Lars, I have two brief questions about capital allocation. First, it's encouraging to see the dividend restored for the first time. Running the numbers, it appears the payout ratio might be around 70%, which hasn't happened in quite a while. Could you confirm a rough range? And the second part of that question: as we work through the last steps of completing the Euronav transaction, are there any limits on dividend amounts or other corporate actions we can take before that process finishes?

Lars Barstad

executive
#6

First off, Inger has just passed me a note here. I think it's up 79%...

Inger Klemp

executive
#7

Right, since we have to figure out the dividend basis using 222.6 million shares outstanding at the close of the quarter — the second quarter, that is — you'll then arrive at 79%.

Lars Barstad

executive
#8

Yes. And returning to your other question, the combination agreement was published in July, the exchange ratio has been fixed, and the dividend has been — is being — paid within that exchange ratio. As for dividends going forward, that basically has to be adjusted either through the exchange ratio, which is highly unlikely, or else through the number of shareholders Frontline will have after the merger.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#9

My second question is for you, Lars. During the presentation you said China really hasn't returned to the market yet. It seems Russia is still quite dependent on — sorry, Europe is still quite dependent on Russian crude, and the sanctions clearly haven't taken effect yet. Is there a way to quantify, or even qualify, what has driven this VLCC spike before you actually see the impact of these two potentially big catalysts on the market?

Lars Barstad

executive
#10

Well, first I'd like to note that the European and U.S. sanctions on Russian crude haven't affected Russian flows as such, but they have changed the trading pattern. So basically, what we're seeing now is that Russian crude oil and Russian products are sailing past Europe on their way to Asia; and at the same time, Europe has had to alter its purchasing patterns and is importing feedstock and products to a much larger degree from the Middle East, West Africa and the U.S. So — and that's what has created this highly inefficient trading pattern. So it has — as far as we can see, the sanctions have basically stopped Russian crude from entering Europe; as for the VLCC, that's a very recent development. And I think it's more tied to U.S. production and the U.S. SPR release and their export capacities; so — and as you know, and as I've described before on earlier calls, the oil market is a bit like a toothpaste tube. If you squeeze it, the toothpaste will pop out somewhere. And basically, U.S. crude oil has then priced itself to go far east, basically through the share price itself going far east, basically through the share volume being offered. So that, I think, is the game changer here. I also think — not to get too technical — with the flattening of the oil curves in a very, very steep backwardated market, holding large volumes of crude oil over a long voyage is quite expensive and basically unhedgeable; but obviously, with the flat structure in the crude oil market, it's easy to hedge your exposure over the 60 days you need in order to transport crude from, say, the U.S. Gulf to China.

Jon Chappell

analyst
#11

All right. That’s quite useful. Thanks, Lars, and thank you, Inger.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#12

Hello. Good afternoon. How are you doing?

Lars Barstad

executive
#13

Thanks. Doing very well.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#14

Thank you. Right. I just want to follow up on that previous question — so what you're saying is that for the near term, we'll keep seeing VLCCs and Suezmaxes, correct?

Lars Barstad

executive
#15

Essentially, what we observe is that at least for VLCCs — once these big trade routes become active, like the U.S. Gulf to Asia or to North Asia that we've witnessed. You end up employing those vessels across a very, very extended stretch of time. So capacity gets tied up for a long stretch. And — we're also seeing that activity persist. When we book VLCCs at this point, we're booking them for late-September; so essentially, the oil gets lifted in September and delivered to China around late-October or early November. And we see this carrying on, since October dates are already being worked on. That said, this does leave something of a gap in the Suezmax program, given that those get fixed nearer to their loading dates; yet at the same time, the Suezmax enjoys considerable support from crude flows out of both the Middle East, but mainly West Africa into Europe. So essentially we see — this appears to be holding steady or perhaps even strengthening.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#16

Okay, great, yes, appreciate that detail—very useful. Now, regarding the makeup of your fleet, I understand from the presentation that you're not considering additional shipping capacity, but given these vessels arriving early next year and the possible tie-up with Euronav's fleet, which leans heavily toward be-weighted tonnage, I just wanted to clarify: do you want to rebalance the fleet composition, or how should we view that?

Lars Barstad

executive
#17

You're exactly right—rebalancing our fleet mix is what it's about. Frontline has traditionally leaned toward VLCCs as its main vessel type, with Suezmaxes playing a supporting role. The LR2 vessels we've brought into the fleet are, over the longer horizon, relatively recent additions, and we clearly regard them as highly efficient trading assets. This quarter, I think, illustrates that point. That said, it's a straightforward analysis—one we've walked through several times before—but I'm glad to go over it once more. When you examine what Frontline's typical cash breakeven is for each vessel class, and then factor in the economies of scale in oil transportation, you'll see that the ceiling—or really where the VLCC tops out—sits far above what you'd see for a Suezmax, for instance, or an LR2. What that means is you can place a bit into variable and get considerably more return per dollar from owning VLCCs when the market is strong. That's essentially been our clients' philosophy from the start; we're also pretty skilled at operating VLCCs and have a solid client base in that segment. So that's essentially been the core source of Frontline's earnings over the years, and the Euronav deal is one piece of carrying that narrative forward.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#18

Understood. Excellent. Thanks. And if I could just fit in one final modeling question — I noticed your administrative costs have crept up somewhat this quarter. Is that a one-off tied to the merger with Euronav, or is it something else?

Inger Klemp

executive
#19

Yes. And you're correct. This quarter we do carry higher expenses for professional fees and legal costs than is typical for us, and those relate to this merger.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#20

All right, so it wouldn’t be the case that the run rate moving forward is merely a bit higher this quarter and perhaps into the next one?

Inger Klemp

executive
#21

Apologies, I didn’t hear your question?

Chris Tsung

analyst
#22

I was saying this really shouldn’t be viewed as a new run rate for admin expenses — it’s only this quarter and next, so will it just be somewhat elevated?

Inger Klemp

executive
#23

Well, as long as we’re in the process of, let’s say, combining the companies, I guess you can assume we’ll also have higher professional fees and legal expenses in the quarters still ahead.

Chris Tsung

analyst
#24

All right, that makes sense. Thanks, Inger. Thanks, Lars.

Lars Barstad

executive
#25

Thanks.

Analyst

analyst
#26

Hello there. Hey everyone. I’ve got a few questions for you regarding the Euronav transaction. Clearly, during the second quarter, you completed several share deals that raised your stake to roughly 20% in Euronav. Assuming the chance exists to increase your position before the tender offer, is there anything that prevents you from doing more?

Lars Barstad

executive
#27

It actually is — and this results in what you might call transactions, which were bilateral, and they were sort of driven by incoming, to phrase it that way. There’s a regulatory mechanism known as the creeping tender offer. If you keep doing this, at least U.S. legislators will sort of stop you — not physically, but you will — they don’t consider it the proper way to proceed; so that’s why we sort of halted at that point. There are also limits to — when you become a related party and so on; that isn’t necessarily a major concern for us since we are already very much related via the combination agreement. But there’s no sort of significant incentive for us to keep on that path, or it is partly to continue those — or to carry out more of those transactions.

Analyst

analyst
#28

Yes. Understood. That's clear. Thanks for that; and I suppose this might be a delicate matter—I get it if you can't answer—but have there been any talks with that Euronav shareholder who has spoken out against the deal, perhaps to find an amicable resolution, or does it all just depend on how the tender offer plays out later this year?

Lars Barstad

executive
#29

Ultimately it all depends on the tender offer—on what happens when we tally the shares at the close of the tender offer.

Analyst

analyst
#30

Understood. Okay. Alright. Thanks Lars.

Lars Barstad

executive
#31

Thank you.

Lars Barstad

executive
#32

All right. Thanks a lot for joining the call. Once again, these are thrilling times. We're quite enthusiastic about both the market developments and our ambitions concerning the combination with Euronav; so with that, thank you, and have a good day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.