Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 30, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 39 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Lars Barstad

executive
#1

Thank you very much. Good morning, and good afternoon to everybody. It's a joy to have all of you join Frontline's earnings call for Q3; getting to provide an update from a segment of the market that is currently enjoying such outstanding results feels genuinely great. I've joked before that tankers act as a safe harbor when markets descend into chaos, and the last 6 months have demonstrated precisely that; throughout Q3, each asset class Frontline trades started gaining strength. I say started since quite a bit has occurred after September ended. Three principal headlines merit our attention, and I'll address them more thoroughly afterward. They are the realignment of crude and product flows brought about by sanctions on Russia, Chinese imports starting to recover ground surrendered to COVID 19 lockdowns, and where U.S. exports stand. Before we move to the third-quarter financials and the outlook, let's go over the highlights on Slide 3 of the deck. In Q3, Frontline made $25,000 per day across our VLCC fleet, $4,100 per day with our Suezmax fleet, and $4,200 per day on our LR2/Aframax fleet. — so far in the first quarter of 2020 — apologies, in the third quarter of 2022, we have locked in 75% of our VLCC days at a solid $77,200 per day, 76% of our Suezmax days at 65,400 per day, and 70% of our LR2/Aframax days at a cool $58,000 per day. Again, each figure in this table is computed on a low-to-discharge basis and will hinge on how much balance date is left when the quarter ends, yet it still indicates a decent Q4 regardless. Shifting quickly to Slide 4 in the deck, I'll repeat some key points regarding how the Frontline fleet is put together. We — and I just want to remind every listener that we continue to hold one of the youngest and most is industry — we've taken delivery of a few newbuildings this year, with 2 more coming in January on the VLCC side. After delivery and after scrubbers are installed in Q4 and Q1, 21 of our 23 VLCCs will have a scrubber fitted. On the Suezmax side, 21 of our 29 Suezmaxes carry scrubbers, and among the LR2s, 4 out of 18. As shown on the right-hand side there, the average or the gap between the eco scrubber segments and the non-ECOs appears to have narrowed, but in reality it hasn't; it's simply that absolute rates have risen. So it now looks less pronounced. We also see an EcoVLCC fitted with a scrubber earning $24,200 per day versus a non-acre non-scrubber. That same relationship stands at $13,500 per day for the Suezmaxes and $12,300 per day on the LR2s — while on our LR2/Aframax fleet we're seeing $40,200 per day and on our Suezmax fleet $41,100 per day. Now I'll hand things over to Inger, who will walk you through the financial highlights.

Inger Klemp

executive
#2

I appreciate the introduction, Lars, and greetings to everyone joining us this morning and this afternoon. Let's proceed to Slide 5, where we examine the eco statement. During the third quarter of 2022, Frontline recorded total operating revenues net of voyage expenses amounting to $209 million, along with adjusted EBITDA of $148 million; net income came in at $154 million, equivalent to $0.69 per share, while adjusted net income stood at $82.9 million, or $0.37 per share, for this quarter. Over on the right side of this slide, we've laid out the adjustments for this quarter, comprising a $15.8 million gain on derivatives, a 5.7 million share of results from associated companies, $0.3 million amortization of the acquired time charters, a $2.8 million gain on insurance and other claims, plus a $47.1 million gain on marketable securities. Adjusted net income for the third quarter rose by $40.7 million versus the second quarter. This rise in adjusted net income stemmed from higher time charter equivalent earnings, thanks to increased TCE rates during the quarter, which was partly counterbalanced by greater interest expense from elevated interest rates and higher administrative expense as we began incurring costs tied to the proposed business combination with Euro now. The Board of Directors has announced its plan to declare and pay a cash dividend for the third quarter of 2022, but only once the tender offer is finished. That dividend is anticipated to equal 80% of adjusted net income for Q3 '22, distributed to record holders following the tender offer's completion in 2023. So now let's shift to Slide 6 and examine the balance sheet. This quarter, total balance sheet figures grew by $184 million. The balance sheet changes in Q3 mainly stem from taking delivery of one new building, the western Tama, — along with a higher carrying value of shares held in Euronav, a rise in current assets from increased voyage siting progress, and trade accounts receivable, as well as the quarter's net income. As of September 30, Frontline held $406 million in cash and cash equivalents. — this includes undrawn amounts under our senior unsecured loan facility, marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. Now let's look more closely at Slide 7, covering the peer comparison. Keeping costs down has always been in Frontline's DNA and the core values of the frontline platform is to keep it simple and focused and maintain a lean and efficient management team. This slide demonstrates that we beat our peers when it comes to lower OpEx and interest expense in the third quarter; regarding G&A, on a per basis it is lower than frontline this quarter because of increased administrative expenses stemming from costs related to the proposed business combination with Eurona. So I believe we should proceed to Slide 8. Cash breakeven and cash generation potential. For the rest of 2022, we’re projecting average cash cost breakeven rates of roughly $25,000 each day for VLCCs, $20,200 each day for Suezmax tankers, and $17,200 each day for LR2 tankers — that gives a fleet average estimate of about $20,900 each day. That fleet average estimate takes into account dry dock for 2 vessels, 1 VLCC and 1 LR2 tanker during what’s left of 2022, and the effect is around $380 each day. We reported OpEx expenses, which include dry dock, for the third quarter at $8,800 each day for VLCCs, $7,500 each day for Suezmax tankers and $8,900 each day for LR2 tankers. During the third quarter, we dry-docked 4 vessels: 1 VLCC, 1 Suezmax tanker and 2 LR2 tankers. The graph over on the right-hand side of the slide displays free cash flow per share after debt service, along with free cash flow yield basis, which are fleet and share price on November 29 at alternative TCE rates. This is based on historic argon TCE rates for non-income vessels from 2000 to year-to-date 2022 — the adjusted premiums on scrubbers and eco vessels. Frontline’s free cash flow per share comes to $2.37, with a free cash flow yield of 18%. The potential for free cash flow yield rises as assumed TCE rates go higher, and it also rises on a fully delivered basis. With that, I’ll hand things over to Lars Barstad.

Lars Barstad

executive
#3

Thanks, Inger, and let's begin by examining the tanker market. On Slide 9, the title I picked for this time is whether we're seeing the beginning of a fresh bull market. Global oil supply has returned to where it stood in 2019, at roughly 100 million barrels per day. In September, the EIA reported production of 101 million barrels per day, with consumption at 100 million barrels per day. During the third quarter, worldwide crude oil exports hit 40 million barrels per day. That represents roughly 40% of worldwide production that then shifts out onto the oceans. For tankers, this is a normal state of affairs. Oil in transit has risen considerably, hitting the peak from '20. You can observe this in the chart at the lower left, where worldwide crude oil exports sit at around or approximately 40 million barrels per day. However, the yellow line — worldwide oil in transit — is in fact flattening at the levels witnessed in Q1 2020, when Saudi Arabia and Russia were caught up in a crude oil price war. The reason for this is tied largely to the circumstances surrounding sanctions on Russia. I'll return to that point. Still, I want to point out that laden days have risen only 10% year-on-year, while the load-to-load business — that is, the distance between when a ship loads a cargo and when it reaches its next cargo or engagement — has risen 20%. If you turn to the chart on the right-hand side, this matters greatly at the moment, especially since we've been flooded with OPEC news, news about Russian sanctions, news about virtually everything. People often overlook the fact that China is genuinely beginning to move. Chinese oil imports are climbing. In Q3 by itself, they rose to 1 million barrels per day, and this is a deep trajectory. Preliminary figures for November indicate that Chinese crude oil imports have in fact climbed 3 million barrels per day from the bottom reached in July. As I'll get to a bit later in the presentation, both the time charter market and asset prices are shifting. Let's turn to Slide 10 and examine the new trading patterns. Looking at the somewhat puzzling graph at the lower left-hand side, you'll notice that European imports of oil and products from Russia have fallen 1.4 million barrels per day year-on-year. That's November last year measured against this November. To a great degree, this shortfall has been replaced by imports from the U.S., Latin America and Asia. If you look at the 2 blue columns under the European import figures on the right, together they come to 1.3 million barrels per day. The products and oil arriving from Asia travel a distance 3x as long as the route from Russia. And what originates from America, the Americas, or Latin America lies at minimum twice as distant compared to Russia. Plus we have observed exports out of Russia to an equal degree, the identical previous movement from Europe toward Asia. And you will notice that the orange bar beneath the Russian heading stands at 1.3 million or 1.4 million barrels per day, which equals what Europe is substituting. And bear in mind, Europe keeps bringing in 3.2 million barrels per day from Russia, and right now we confront the sort of heightened sanctions embodied by the price cap. So following fiscal December, the verdict remains unknown regarding how this unfolds, yet these flows could shift even more. Should you examine the chart on the right, the U.S. has occupied a significant role during the final 6 months of the year by supplying additional volumes into the market via their SDR releases. And it is unjust within the market that when this SPR release concludes, how much volume we forfeit, port capacity will we forfeit from the U.S. In the lower chart on the right-hand side, I have attempted to do this somewhat simplistically. And I realize plenty of people would be able to challenge me on this. However the grey region is U.S. net export. It is essentially U.S. exports and I essentially subtract the SBR release. We all understand that the FBR is not linked to the ocean. Thus the SPR supplies the U.S. refining system, which, conversely, possesses the ability to export additional barrels. But what we have witnessed is that in spite of the SBR release, the outright or the net exports from U.S. has in fact risen, and especially so recently. So I would likewise say that the verdict remains unknown concerning how substantial the decline in U.S. exports will be once the SPR ceases releasing barrels. If we then proceed to Slide 11 and examine the assets and the TC markets. As the spot markets shift, so too will the time charter rates and the asset prices. And there has been and there still exists a frenetic level of activity in the time charter market for tankers. And this occurs as charters attempt to find coverage. And given the present order book and the fundamentals for oil, there is growing interest for tonnage. I did not write it, but it is nearly as though there is a fair for lacking the capacity to freight oil going into the future. Resales are presently priced above contracting, and this stems from the timing of available yard space. Should you look at the chart at the bottom left here, this represents resale values as quoted. The dark blue one concerns VLCC sales. It is in fact slightly beneath where it is — the actual market is. The final kind of Whisper number on the VLCC resale is $130 million for a scrubber-fitted prompt delivery. A new order will be delivered in 3 years at the earliest. What this essentially does is create a gap across the entire freight capacity supply chain, and that's what worries folks holding short positions. And when you have confidence in the present rate climate, growth in rates tends to ensue. I had a fascinating conversation with some investors recently, and we went over today's fundamentals — and it hit him all at once that this situation might genuinely persist, and then what? A somewhat amusing aspect is that when you examine the long-term historical data, and honestly this caught me off guard too, weighted tanker sector earnings have reached levels we hadn't witnessed since 2005. The explanation for that is clearly that Aframax and LR2 segments are generating significantly greater profits than at any point before. So for VLCCs, this isn't a particularly out-of-the-ordinary market. For Suezmaxes it's a strong market, for Aframax and LR2 it's an extraordinary market — and regarding present retail prices, we truly haven't observed these levels in 14 years. Let's turn to Slide 12 and examine the tanker order books. And that accounts for at minimum half of the reason we find ourselves here. In the chart at the upper left, I've attempted to group together the asset classes that Frontline has exposure to, specifically the VLCC, the Suezmax and LR2s.

Lars Barstad

executive
#4

If you simply tally up the vessels that are over 20 years old today — ships whose trading efficiency, in our view, is not merely constrained but essentially unworkable within a compliant tanker market — that collection comes to 163 vessels. For that same segment, the order book sits at 92, and those orders are scheduled for delivery across the coming 2 to 3 years. That pairing of figures defies logic. To push the absurdity further, throw in the 303 vessels in these asset classes that are presently above 15 years of age, and nearly half of them will cross the 20-year mark while that order book is still being delivered. As for this recycled pool versus order book ratio, I'm not sure I've actually answered that one myself. Regardless, it's a fascinating one. So let's shift from Slide 12 to Slide 13 and offer a handful of remarks regarding the Frontline Euronav combination. As all of you are aware, essentially every aspect of this combination is clearly rather delicate. I'd simply like to walk through the sequence — the front relocation comes first, and that is underway. Once that's done, we'll kick off the tender offer. Plenty of analysts and market participants have raised questions with us regarding these delays. They are regulatory cost delays. The move from plant to Bermudafm Varmdo Cypress has turned out to be intricate. Numerous regulatory bodies are part of this, and they consume time. Even so, we remain — we stay dedicated to seeing this process through. That said, the tender offer's launch has been pushed back into Q1 of next year. The end result stays unchanged, contingent on the level of support we receive in the tender offer. Should we secure more than 75%, we'll proceed with a merger or move toward one; should we land between 15.1% and 75%, we'll establish a group; and in either case, Frontline will come away with a controlling interest. Let's now turn to Slide 14 and attempt to recap everything we've covered. The salmon story carries on, and additional efficiency inefficiencies are anticipated as we approach the 5th of December. Worldwide crude oil exports have reached recovered levels, and oil in transit remains quite robust. The ratio of order book to recycle pool is at unprecedented levels. The order book represents roughly 5% of the existing fleet — and here I'm referring only to the segments we're exposed to — against 9% in what's termed the recycling pool. As a matter of fact, the markets are pricing in constrained feed supply, whether in the stock market, the TC market, or on assets. And through all of this, Frontline holds a modern, efficient spot export fleet, and as we unfold, winter is in fact a promos now. With that, I'll offer my thanks and open the floor for questions.

Omar Nokta

analyst
#5

Clearly, these are really thrilling days throughout the tanker sector. I'd like to inquire, clearly, regarding the most recent subject you brought up during the presentation, which concerns the merger. And after that, perhaps just about moving the domicile away from Bermuda over to Cypress. I realize, clearly, that regulatory matters exist in that area; yet does that ultimately call for a shareholder vote in order to happen? Or is it possible to handle that as part of normal business operations?

Lars Barstad

executive
#6

No, a shareholder vote will be necessary.

Omar Nokta

analyst
#7

Okay, that works. So, without putting you in an awkward spot, I'd like to ask about the tender offer's timing in Q1, given the conversations you're having with the various authorities. Could it land in January, or does it look more like March? Can you give us any sense of the odds?

Lars Barstad

executive
#8

Giving a real answer on that is next to impossible. We've shown that the relocation filing timeline has, clearly, run much longer than anticipated. Still, our outlook stays positive and optimistic. The paperwork is actually being handled at the same time. That's why our expectation is this process will end up being much more streamlined, and in fact we're able to submit the documentation for a tender offer ahead of the relocation taking effect.

Omar Nokta

analyst
#9

All right. Perhaps a bit more on the market side. Clearly, you mentioned Aframax and LR2 sitting at unusually elevated levels, with rates that historically we've never witnessed. What's your current thinking on that segment? You have those 18 vessels, and I can see 2 of them are tied to those appealing longer-dated contracts, but what about the other 16 or so — how are you employing them? Do they operate in the clean trades, or have some moved into 30?

Lars Barstad

executive
#10

Well, the — the bulk of them are still in the clean space. I believe during the prior quarter, I noted that 6 of 18 were trading in Dee. That figure now stands temporarily at 7, essentially because a single vessel was frequently offered the cargo, and it couldn't turn it down. But on the whole, I think you should view this along 2 dimensions. First, there's the broad macro — or macro, whichever term — shift in which refining capacity has moved further from key demand centers; and the COVID pandemic proved a fatal blow to a substantial amount of European refining capacity, plus some in the U.S; so that's the — that supports a structural transformation in trading patterns, and it's not going away. And then of course, this got turbocharged by the inefficiencies tied to sanctions on Russia. Europe relies on, or has relied on, fairly sizable product imports from Russia, especially diesel. And now that must be obtained from other sources; and it's producing a refinery margin climate unlike anything we've truly experienced before, or at minimum not for a very long stretch. So I think in the near term, that will persist. So we can genuinely anticipate these super-inflated clean rates carrying on. Yet over the longer horizon, we have this structural shift in the dynamics that will assist this market down the road, though perhaps not to the same elevated sales levels we're witnessing at present.

Chris Robertson

analyst
#11

Chris here, covering for Amit. I want to focus briefly on the dividend — less on where it stands today, and more on what it might look like further out; and Lars, you brought up the chance of a stronger-for-longer environment where rates stay elevated; so with adjusted net income and the 3Q dividend in mind, I'm wondering how we ought to think about this going forward as we get closer to, say, 2030, when technology around future fuels and things like that may become clearer. Could there be a change where you'd keep more cash as dry powder, either to pursue extra growth opportunities or to carry out a fleet renewal down the line?

Lars Barstad

executive
#12

Good question. If you look at the way we've run things, the finance side has typically favored paying dividends, whereas things such as new vessel investments have been funded through other means. The few times we didn't hand back a generous dividend were situations where it was clear the market had fundamentally changed. So I'm not certain that fully answers what you're after. Even so, I'd note that distributing 80% of net income is consistent with what Frontline has always done when we're profitable. Essentially, our aim is to hand investors the cash we bring in. And in that context, 50.1% stands as the share we point to. So I'd say that's simply how we usually go about it.

Chris Robertson

analyst
#13

Yeah, that makes sense. So, just to build on that — I suppose the real million-dollar question, like you said, is how much will the market look fundamentally different by the time we get to 2030 versus where it stands now? Since it looks like there's a good number of years of runway remaining given the existing order book and all the other things happening. Yet as we move nearer to the decade's close, that's sort of what I was trying to ask — how much will that market have changed...

Lars Barstad

executive
#14

No, I apologize, Chris, but that's an excellent question, and you're right to call it a million-dollar question. I only wish I had an answer. At Frontline, when it comes to things like new technology and new fuels, we usually tend to be late adopters; we'll always aim to orient ourselves toward regulatory shifts and similar developments, and to carry out best practice to the extent we're able. The jury is still out — the bulk of our tonnage consists of deep ocean, long-haul vessels. And the way things look at present, there genuinely isn't an alternative energy source available for those ships. It's possible that should gas prices or LNG prices fall substantially, the economics of LNG propulsion might return and be competitive; however, it's rather hard to picture that. Still, I think when you take the long view, you need to remember that at minimum the vessels are going to cost more as time goes on — essentially, since you have to invest in order to lower your carbon footprint. So — but I wouldn't even venture to attach figures to that, beyond the broad trajectory that — though to be fair, we've actually cut a fair amount of — and each year now we're committed to complying with regulatory requirements aimed at lowering our emissions. And that's what we'll do; although clearly, at some stage, the ships simply cannot go any further.

Greg Lewis

analyst
#15

You all have clearly put in a great deal of effort. I appreciate the presentation. I had a few questions regarding how Russia is affecting things at this point. I suppose what I'm really asking is a couple of things: since these cargoes have been redirected away from Europe, they now need to travel to more distant locations. What kinds of limitations or constraints apply in those export regions? And what I'm genuinely curious about is whether, in an area such as the Gulf of Mexico, there's potential for a lot of ship-to-ship transfers, where smaller ships then head out to put the oil onto bigger ships for their ultimate destination. Should we be factoring that into our thinking from a logistics standpoint, which would likely make the market even tighter?

Lars Barstad

executive
#16

Yes. It's — to start with, that's a solid question; and this situation keeps developing as time goes on. In the past I've spoken quite a bit about the dark web of oil and the markets involving Iran and Venezuela. For the Russian trade, I would say I usually call it a gray market, since these are all solid vessels that are sailing in compliance with Klaus and insured possibly in markets other than where shipping typically operates, and so on. But what you're pointing to here is that this highly inefficient trade that's taking place right now will likely expand, and that you'd deploy larger tonnage to capture the advantages of economies of scale and so on, at least assuming Asia keeps taking Russian crude. And indeed, we are already witnessing this, not within EU territory as such; but we are seeing other locations where STS operations are taking place. The extremely troubling aspect of that is that not every one of these locations is appropriate for it, and the safety and pollution risk goes up. So — but we've also observed very strong activity in the sale and purchase market, or the asset market, for older tonnage, which we anticipate will be entering this market. I'm referring to the 17% to 17.5% or even 15-year-olds up to max MVs that have recently been bought and that might show up in order to make this trade somewhat more efficient and to scale it up ahead of the price cap taking effect.

Greg Lewis

analyst
#17

All right, that's helpful. My next item was really about — you mentioned a bit about insurance, and insurers coming to terms with the fact that each trade — we've seen this before in certain parts of the Middle East and other regions. When I think about cargo seeking coverage, say, on the gray and black market, is that cargo, broadly speaking, something those partners can get insured — and honestly, is it typically arranged by the purchaser or the vendor when it comes to shipping?

Lars Barstad

executive
#18

So — the environmental exposure, once cargo is loaded onto a vessel, is handled by the shipowner; however, you're raising a very good point. Russia, for instance, has a substantial insurance sector, an internal insurance market. Whether that market is capable of properly handling this category of risk is clearly a major question; and — then again, with this price cap, we don't know how things will unfold. We've gotten certain signals from OFAC regarding how they envision structuring the price cap, though we don't truly know the specifics of how that cap will be enforced. And — I mention this because a scenario could emerge in which oil is actually sold in line with the price cap, and then the sanctions wouldn't actually apply. In that case the insurance market would be in a position to — or the Western insurance market would be in a position to cover it. So — but to say it again, there's an open question. If this oil keeps trading in a way where insurance remains uncertain, that is clearly a significant worry and issue.

Lars Barstad

executive
#19

All right. Thanks, and I really appreciate you tuning in. These are certainly pricing times, and have a truly wonderful Christmas once it arrives. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#20

Thanks. That brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate everyone for joining in. You're free to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.