Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 31, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Lars Barstad
executiveThanks so much, Dero. And thanks for joining us on Frontline's Q1 earnings call. We're running a little behind. But better — good than sooner, or however that saying goes. The year's first quarter came in unusually strong for us. Russia continues to weigh on the market, and sanctions against Russia remain in place; yet in my view, the main driver of what happened in Q1 had to do with China. That robust Q1 has also let us lock in fairly solid figures for Q2, following the Frontline team's nonstop efforts to build shareholder value. Before I hand things over to Inger, a few key figures from Slide 3 of the deck. In the third quarter — pardon me, in the first quarter Frontline earned $52,500 per day across our VLCC fleet. $64,000 per day across our Suezmax fleet, and $56,300 per day across our LR2/Aframax feet. And we've essentially returned to a somewhat reverted earnings relationship among our segments, with the Suezmaxes beating the VLCCs and the same holding for LR2s; we've locked in rather firm figures as we moved into Q2, with 78% of our VLCC days booked at $75,000 per day. 71% of our Suezmax days booked at $65,000 per day, and 63% of our LR2/Aframax days at a very respectable $65,700 per day. Once again, every figure in that table is calculated on the load to discharge basis, and they'll be shaped by how many balance days we ultimately have when Q2 ends. And keep in mind, this is Q2, which is meant to be the soft spot in the market. With that, I'll hand it to Inger, and she'll walk you through the financial highlights.
Inger Klemp
executiveThank you, Lars. Good morning, and good afternoon, everyone. Let's move on to Slide 4, which covers the profit statement, and go over a few highlights. As Lars mentioned, the first quarter of 2023 delivered the strongest first-quarter profit we've seen since 2008. It also marks the first time the company presents interim financial information under IFRS. With this shift to IFRS, one key point is that dry-docking costs are now capitalized and then depreciated across the period until the next scheduled dry-docking, which runs anywhere from 2 to 5 years, or 2.5 to 5 years. In Q1 '23, dry-docking costs of $3.6 million were capitalized, and 3 vessels underwent dry-docking during that quarter. I should also note that the company changed its estimate for the useful life of its vessels, moving from 25 years down to 20 years, effective January 1, 2023, and this pushed depreciation expense up by $12.7 million in Q3 relative to Q4 '22. Now let's go to Slide 5 for some balance sheet highlights. As of Q1 '23, the company carries no remaining newbuilding commitments, since it took delivery of its final 2 VLCC newbuildings, Front Orkla and Front Tyne, in January 2023. Liquidity stands at a solid $584 million in cash and cash equivalents, which includes the undrawn portion of the unsecured facility, marketable securities, and minimum cash requirements. Finally, the company's leverage ratio is a healthy 52.9%. Now please turn to the next slide. Lastly, let's examine the company's cash flow potential; we calculate industry-leading cash break even rates <<inaudible>> 300 fleet average, which factors in dry-docking costs for 8 Suezmax tankers during 2023. Of those, 4 are expected to be dry-docked in the third quarter, while 4 should be dry-docked in the fourth quarter. Average OpEx for Q1 '23, excluding dry-dock, came to $7,300 per day. As the table on the right-hand side shows, free cash flow points to strong return potential for the company. Taking just the scenario where VLCC rates are assumed at $75,000 per day, using the 5-year historic spread to VLCC for Suezmax and LR2 tankers, annual free cash flow potential comes to roughly $1.4 billion, or $6.29 per share, which equals a free cash flow yield of 42%. With that, I'll hand things back to you, Lars.
Lars Barstad
executiveI appreciate that, Inger. Let's take a brief moment to review how the tanker market performed during the first quarter of 2023; as I noted earlier, this period is usually one of seasonal strength. Typically during Q1, we shake off the excitement from Q4 and conditions tend to soften fairly rapidly as we head into February. This year, however, the market reached a second peak during March. Every segment that plan Frontline operates in was doing extremely well. Looking at the chart in the lower left corner, you can see just how high the average weighted market earnings have climbed. The explanation is, of course, that not just VLCC and Suezmax, but also Aframax and LR2 are all performing extremely strongly. When you set that against the era we prefer to reference, the stretch spanning 2003 through 2009 in the most recent times, we sit quite high on the earnings side, and the markets are doing extremely well. Chinese imports reached an all-time high, as shown in the chart in the lower right. We additionally observed the largest count of VLCC shipments headed to China. As I mentioned before, Russian sanctions keep producing inefficient trading patterns, though the focus is more on China, since that situation appears to have settled into some sort of plateau. That said, we experienced a very mild winter across the Northern Hemisphere, in both Q4 and Q1, which dampened oil demand somewhat. Moving on now to Slide 8 or Page 8, we did get an OPEC cut, or rather a voluntary cut. Volumes are indeed lower for May. But what about ton miles? Well, Russia kept exporting under the current oil price scenario — the oil price scenario we find ourselves in — the G7-Cap is not blocking Russian oil exports; and we observe Russia pumping without pause. This is quite interesting now, ahead of the OPEC meeting on June 4. Volumes from both OPEC+ plus and non-OPEC were lower in May. And — but this is — and we must keep in mind this is the seasonal slow point of the year, with heavy refinery turnarounds. Global oil demand is anticipated to increase by roughly 2 million barrels per day during the second half of 2023. And if we consider the whole picture, global exports overall have indeed returned to pre-COVID levels, though somewhat slow in May. It will be very interesting to watch what the U.S., Brazil and West Africa can accomplish post summer, and those are the 3 candidates capable of exporting more volume as we move into winter. Let's then proceed to Slide 9. Vessel utilization remains elevated, though it does fluctuate, as you can see in the bottom left-hand chart, and the figures come from Signal Ocean, which essentially tracks each fixture across the different asset classes and calculates how many days the ships spend laden. Looking at that bottom left chart, for the VLCC, we're at fairly high levels versus what history shows. Yes, it has come down. It may be somewhat subdued at the moment. Still, the VLCC is likely feeling the effects of the Q1 rally plus the small rally from just a couple of weeks back. Turning to the Suezmaxes, they're also elevated compared with prior years, yet they've likewise come off over the past couple of months. LR2s have returned to trend, I would say, even if they sit high within that trend. The main thing to take from these 3 charts, though, is the general trajectory of utilization as well as ton-mile demand across the year. Clearly, first, we're at a low point in the cycle, and second, the direction going into the end of the year, based on history, ought to be very interesting. Now let's go to Slide 10 and briefly talk about the orderbook, and I won't walk through every one of these charts in detail. I think they speak for themselves. It's rather remarkable that by this year's close, 111 VLCCs will still be trading that are older than 20 years. That equals 12.6% of the current trading fleet. The orderbook has 16 vessels left to be delivered, which is 1.8% of the fleet. For the Suezmaxes, roughly 14% of the fleet will be past 20 years by the end of this year, and the orderbook sits at 18% after expanding quite a lot in Q1 and Q2; that works out to 3% of the existing fleet. On LR2/Aframax, the global fleet numbers just 415 vessels, and 25 of them are beyond 20 years. Here, looking at 15 years is actually more relevant, but to stay conservative, let's just use the 20 years; that comes to 6% of the existing fleet. The orderbook in that segment is expanding and it's substantial. So right now it equals 12.8% of the existing fleet. Across all the segments Frontline is exposed to and the asset classes we're involved in, roughly — well, nearly 12% of those fleets are older than 20 years, while the orderbook sits at 4.6%; it's extremely, extremely hard to imagine a supply-side scenario that would shake the tanker story, at least not until well into 2026. And then, to wrap up. Frontline just posted its best first-quarter earnings since 2008 — $193 million — plus a cash dividend of $0.70 per share, and we're still capturing value on time charter and assets at a high point in the cycle. New orders are showing up for Suezmax and LR2. 2025 is now completely sold out, and you can pencil in 2026 in China. In Korea, you likely have to look at 2027. For VLCC, only 2 orders have been rumored year-to-date, though more are under discussion. And 12% of the tanker fleet that we're exposed to will be above 20 years old by the end of this year. OPEC+ transactions have had a limited impact so far in May, and it appears that's being offset by ton-miles. And once again, China will be the x-factor as we grind through the summer lull. Finally, I'd like to walk through the chart below a little. I just gave a presentation to a group of students from Denmark, basically laying out the long-term picture in oil and tankers. What you see in the blue line is oil demand, which tends to grow alongside population growth. And on the right-hand side, the yellow graph is annual fleet growth as we get into 2025. And while that's a bit of apples and pears, it simply doesn't add up; and with that, I'd like to open it up for questions.
Jon Chappell
analystI want to start with strategy. There have been some notable moves since the quarter closed — the sale of the vessel and the 2 time charters on the LR2s. Are we now at that stage in the cycle where you're considering cashing in on some of the older tonnage that might not be core? I believe there are 10 ships older than 8 years; and beyond that, are you now at a stage where you might pursue additional time charters on the LR2s while leaving the larger crude vessels open for spot?
Lars Barstad
executiveYeah, sort of — first off, when we review the fleet and identify which vessels might be possible sale candidates, efficiency is the main thing we examine. And we're getting ready for the regulatory framework around CII and ETFs and so on. So essentially with that in mind, we evaluate it; and clearly, the values that can be realized. As things have stood so far, on the time charter side, we've observed elevated values for the Aframax/LR2. And we've witnessed quite a bit of price movement on the secondhand Suezmax side. So I'd say that's simply natural. But yes, we will sort of engage with the market when we see values that are essentially what we refer to internally as the point where you can hit unicorn numbers on particular asset classes over a sustained period, we pretty much just have to seize it. The average cost — the average cash breakeven for our Aframaxes/LR2s, we've sort of got to bear that in mind, when you can get $46,500 per day versus a cash breakeven of $16,800, it's essentially something you cannot let go. On the asset side, we aren't publicly offering all our vessels; that's seldom a good strategy. But yes, for the less efficient vessels, we'll be inclined to seize the advantage if the opportunity presents itself.
Jon Chappell
analystTo build on those two subjects, here's a somewhat fresher update. Folks appear far more jittery regarding the OPEC reduction, a worldwide downturn, softer crude prices, and so on. Even so, you've described a structure in which the coming 2 years ought to stay fairly strong. Have you noticed any pullback in deal-making involving older ships, which have looked almost parabolic across the past 12 months? And likewise, has there been any decline in charterers' readiness to commit across that 2 to 3-year stretch?
Lars Barstad
executiveIt would be dishonest of me to claim otherwise; and as you're aware, having spent many years in this business, our attention tends to lean toward large transactions when equity markets are performing well, not the reverse; and at present, we've experienced turbulence. We've also seen softness across some segments. Fundamentally, that shifts the mood to some degree. So — though I wouldn't go so far as to say — my read is that this amounts to a short-term sort of ebb and flow. I don't anticipate, barring a scenario in which worldwide crude consumption collapses entirely, I can't picture that persisting; so frankly, it's a very ordinary projection for Q2.
Chris Robertson
analystThis is Chris Robertson, filling in for Amit. Lars, I'd like to briefly discuss the LR2 fleet. At the Frontline level, what number of those are presently involved in dirty trading? And beyond that, do you perhaps have a broad idea, across the entire fleet, of how many LR2s are right now taking part in a dirty trade?
Lars Barstad
executiveThank you, Chris. That's an excellent question, since switching from clean to dirty has grown more and more efficient during the past half year. So in fact it's quite hard to keep track. Not — clearly, not regarding our own fleet, there I feel quite at ease, but concerning what's going on, in a sense, throughout the world. To give you some explanation, a dirty vessel can be converted to clean in the Middle East rather fast by making a few brief voyages carrying condensate; and at least until this point, the market has shown willingness to pay — to offer a substantial premium for that capability, essentially encouraging owners to do precisely that; but at least among our own vessels that we continue to control, those not chartered out on time, meaning that would be 14. There are 4.
Chris Robertson
analystAll right, understood. Let's shift topics. Regarding shipyard capability, you brought up the constraints — Chinese facilities possibly for 2025, whereas Korean ones in 2026. However, I suppose, do you have any idea how much inactive capacity might be reactivated within the coming several years? Also, is today's bottleneck primarily tied to workforce? Or does it stem more from the shipyards as such, the property dimension?
Lars Barstad
executiveI believe we've observed newcomers entering the scene, so to speak. I wouldn't describe them as inactive, yet Chinese yards operating at drastically diminished output that are somewhat being revived and open to accepting orders. Naturally, this is a gamble. Yet should an owner choose to employ such facilities, there are a handful. Quantifying this is tough, I'd say; however, examining certain of these newcomers, securing a vessel before '25 is impossible, or you can't even obtain one ahead of '26, and that's largely since bringing those yards to operational status requires time. Concerning workforce, I don't — China appears to lack significant difficulties; regarding Japan and Korea, that's certainly an element. Additionally in Korea, what we observe is that, even though a tanker is a relatively sophisticated vessel, they lean toward concentrating on more labor-heavy or more engineering — technology-heavy vessel categories. Thus they aren't truly — well, they do make offers, yet they're pricing themselves beyond contention for <<inaudible>>. And that's '27. As for the broader possible volume in that area, gauging it is extremely hard, and no possible volume exists until — well, it begins in 2026.
Chris Robertson
analystAlright. Yeah, that's useful context. One last thing from me; it has to do with what you're anticipating regarding the OPEC gathering taking place in just a few days. Brent crude is trading at levels notably under $80 per barrel, which we tend to view as a line in the sand. There's some market chatter regarding speculators when it comes to oil pricing. Are you worried that further reductions might be proposed as we head into that meeting? Or what's your take on it?
Lars Barstad
executiveHonestly, there isn't much I can do beyond simply reading what all of you are reading in the media. That said, I have to point out that if you implement a cut effective in May, and then all at once introduce extra cuts in June, it comes across as — it seems odd. Since you require this — and demand is also at a cyclical trough at that moment, so I suppose a person needs a bit of patience while making such a significant move — if you're acting as an OPEC strategist. What I find troubling about the current state of affairs is that Russia, even while asserting that it complies with the voluntary reduction approach, in actual physical terms, they clearly aren't; so it's — yeah, it will be an interesting one. It's — I mean, it's nearly unfeasible to — yes, to offer any sort of well-founded projection. What I must — what I will add, though, is that whatever rise in demand, given that this is a voluntary cut, will be undone quite rapidly once demand starts to show its peak.
Chris Robertson
analystYeah. That seems reasonable to me. In the near term, it comes across more as a matter of enforcing compliance, and afterward, as you put it, they can gradually build back up over time.
Omar Nokta
analystI simply wanted to revisit the conversation about newbuildings. Obviously, Slide 11 is a very straightforward chart, yet it likely captures everything regarding growth in oil consumption and growth in the fleet. Lars, I recall that on the previous call, you had said — I believe it was that most recent one — that newbuildings were not particularly appealing to Frontline. I just wanted to check whether you have any update on that. Of course, you just pointed out in your remarks that we are looking firmly into '26, maybe '27, for taking delivery. But regarding how you view the chance to enter the newbuilding market, I suppose, first, is this something you might be reexamining? And second, how might you compare the opportunities involved in possibly ordering VLCCs as opposed to Suezmaxes and LR2s?
Lars Barstad
executiveYes. Omar, that's a good question, but unfortunately — not unfortunately, I believe my answer remains the same. There are 3 factors we must take into account when examining the newbuilding market. To start with, there's obviously the question of which technology we'll go with. But let's say you were looking at a standard vessel — in that case, what matters is how long it takes before that investment actually starts generating cash flow for us. And then, last of all, there's the price of the asset itself. So basically, what we're seeing is this: I keep hearing people say inflation hasn't really touched asset prices yet. Because when you look at asset prices adjusted for inflation across a long stretch of time, a VLCC from 2008 to 2009 would be worth $70 million in today's dollars. But for that comparison to hold up, inflation also has to be reflected in the rates, and so forth. Beyond that, for Frontline to find it attractive, the long-term time charter market would have to sit at levels well above the brief spikes we witnessed here and there over the past two quarters or so. With all that in view, it just doesn't look like a compelling proposition for us. I'd add that a portion of the orders crossing our desk come with long-term charter obligations attached, and that runs counter to our strategy — what we've promised shareholders is exposure to the spot market. Then there are the orders with no such charter commitment behind them, and to my eye those look like fairly opportunistic plays. Essentially, you're putting down 20% or 25% as a down payment on a call option for a market. Down the road, maybe in 2026, that might turn out to be pretty compelling. Also worth noting: that space isn't where we operate. Which explains why we keep an eye on it and pay attention, yet hitting the button isn't our role.
Omar Nokta
analystThat's clear, Lars. So when we consider this, you obviously need inflation affecting charter rates to actually spark some new ordering. Then how do you view — I mean, Frontline has clearly been quite aggressive on acquisitions over the years; but broadly speaking, regarding capital deployment, you obviously follow a capital allocation strategy that involves paying a substantial dividend; but when it comes to where an opportunity might exist or how value is set and so on. Are newbuildings definitely ruled out, and how do you evaluate whether to do things in the sale and purchase market? Could there be chances with younger tonnage? Might there be chances with older tonnage that people have perhaps overlooked given the shift toward a greener future? Any thoughts on where an opportunity might exist to add some assets cheaply, whether by age range or maybe vessel class type?
Lars Barstad
executiveYes. No, I think on the vessel class side, we would be looking closely at any LR2, Afra, Suezmax or VLCC that is under 5 years, but — or at 5 or under. But if you examine the visibility on what's offered in that segment of the market, it is essentially zero. So it's — many of them have done VLCCs, you could say that have been delivered in the last few years are actually on time charters and even relet again to operators or traders or oil majors. So these guys aren't really sale candidates; and so there is essentially a vacuum for vessels in that age bracket that would interest us. So I think that's essentially the answer. And with that in mind, we'd rather sit tight and churn out the best return we can from the assets we hold until we make an investment decision.
Omar Nokta
analystAbsolutely. Yeah, that's logical. That essential scale is already in place for you. Perhaps only one thing, if I may, clearly quite delicate. But I simply wanted to ask and find out, given that you're — given that this call is happening. Is there anything publicly you'd say — anything you feel able to share regarding what's going on at Euronav, with the changes in management and on the Board; and then too, I realize this is likely more delicate and not really tied directly to Frontline, but anything you'd say about the exchanges with International Seaways that took place yesterday?
Lars Barstad
executiveYeah. Well, I get the question, but honestly it isn't really my place to offer a comment. On the Euronav matter, I'm just watching, the same as you, though we do hold shares, yet that's pretty much where it ends. International Seaways is no different. It's — I see the same things you see, and my visibility is quite limited.
Omar Nokta
analystFine; that works.
Chris Tsung
analystI just wanted to ask — in your deck, you pointed out that sanctions on Russia created inefficient trading patterns, and that's clearly been a benefit for many tanker owners. Do you think those inefficiencies can be resolved? Or do they run deeper, structurally speaking, until the conflict ends and until the sanctions get lifted?
Lars Barstad
executiveWell, here's what I'd say — and I was thinking about putting this into the deck, but I wanted to verify it further. But with essentially all the — whatever you'd call it. Essentially, what I see, or what we see, is this: if you examine the Suezmax and Aframax fleet, and you examine how many vessels are calling on Russia, if you run that analysis over the past 3 months, you'll discover that roughly 30% of the Afra and 30% of the Suezmax fleet is still, at some point, calling on Russia. So that indicates the linkage between what you might call the grey fleet and the white fleet, to use that term, is in fact extremely high; so it means there are obviously inefficiencies, but perhaps not as significant as one might anticipate. Because it isn't the case that we've lost 30% of the vessels in the — well, the non-Russian trading market. So I'd say the picture is somewhat more balanced. What is accurate, however, is that a ship of lower quality and sort of beyond the age limits and so on, or possibly run by a business that has a red flag associated with it, obviously won't be able to reach the compliant market. But it appears the interconnectivity is in fact fairly efficient, as you'd anticipate in the tanker market; yet this actually carries some positives, since it really means the risk on — well, calling it the risk isn't right. But when this situation eventually flips, perhaps the negative effect on ton miles won't be all that severe.
Chris Tsung
analystGot it. And perhaps just a single additional question regarding the arbitration. I was simply wondering, is there anything significant coming up that we ought to keep an eye on between now and January 2024?
Lars Barstad
executiveNot right now.
Sherif Elmaghrabi
analystTo start, I'd like to ask a brief follow-up regarding something raised earlier about LR2s in clean and dirty service. What's the timeframe needed to return an LR2 to the clean trade? And what costs come with that?
Lars Barstad
executiveNaturally, it varies somewhat based on your approach. However, should you run 3 condensate voyages of very short duration throughout AG-East, partial cleaning can be achieved inside 21 days. After that, a manual clean would be performed to handle whatever remains, meaning a handful of extra days. So indeed, it lands somewhere around — let's say 25 days.
Sherif Elmaghrabi
analystSo, with the fleet growth being as limited as you pointed out on Slide 10, assuming demand stays strong, might vessels older than 20 years get retrofitted so they can keep operating, or perhaps move into the Russian trade? Or do other considerations end up sending them to the scrapyard instead?
Lars Barstad
executiveNo, I'd say you've put your finger on it there. Clearly, within the OPEC tanker segment especially, there's a lifespan that's basically finished once you're past 20 years of age. That said, I should mention that what's emerged during the past month or so is that certain — in China, for instance, you've got Shandong province, where a great number of the country's independent refiners are based. It's therefore a massive discharge port handling crude of every quality; and the fact that they've begun cracking down on some of the older, less well-maintained ships is genuinely a good signal that folks are starting to examine this properly. Also, you may well have come across this, Pablo, something I believe was an Aframax that was sitting off Malaysia or Singapore and exploded. I'd say that's sort of drawing regulators' attention toward the dangers present in this market. So — yet for a tanker that's well approved, and there are likely plenty of those, and properly maintained, there's no reason it shouldn't get an extension; but once again, that would involve the usual scrutiny through vetting of the different kinds of — vetting departments on the charter — on the chartering side. What we essentially begin to assume in our fleet modeling is this: once a vessel goes past 17.5 years, roughly 25% of its efficiency disappears. And should it exceed 20 years, half of its efficiency is gone. So in terms of utilization, or your capacity to serve the oil market, that's a drop of 25% and 50%.
Lars Barstad
executiveAlright, I appreciate you all joining the call. Reporting another solid quarter has truly been a pleasure. With luck, we'll keep that up, and we're eager about what lies ahead. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's call to a close. We appreciate everyone joining in. You're free to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.