Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 30, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 40 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Lars Barstad

executive
#1

Hello, everyone. Thanks for joining Frontline’s First Quarter Earnings Call. During the first quarter of 2024, the security situation for transit between the Red Sea and the Gulf of Yemen—sorry, the Gulf of Aden—was, to a significant extent, a blot on the period. There remain charters that insist, and owners who are willing, to operate in the region while disregarding seafarer safety, but at Frontline, we do not. A key point from Q1 of 2024 was that every Euronav vessel now operates under the Frontline flag. As 2024 moves forward, we will fully capitalize on possessing a fleet of 41 modern, low-consuming VLCCs, alongside our efficient Suezmax and LR2 fleets. Utilization appears to be rising across all asset classes, yet once more, the LR2s are the standout performers. Before I hand things over to Inger, please look at the figures on Slide 3 in the deck. In the first quarter of 2024, Frontline earned $41,100 per day with our VLCC fleet, $45,800 per day with our Suezmax fleet, and $54,300 per day with our LR2/Aframax fleet. LR2s delivered VLCC-level figures during the quarter, since this segment was hit hardest by disruptions in the Suez Canal passages. The Suezmax is specifically mentioned for a reason. Consequently, shifts in flows forced those effects into new trading patterns over the quarter. Thus far in the second quarter of 2024, 78% of our VLCC days are booked at $60,400 per day; 73% of our Suezmax days are booked at $46,400 per day; and 72% of our LR2/Aframax days are booked at a very solid $64,700 per day. Once again, every figure in the table is calculated on a low-to-discharge basis, and they will be influenced by how many balance days remain at the close of Q2. I will now turn it over to Inger for the financial highlights.

Inger Klemp

executive
#2

Thanks, Lars, and greetings everyone, whether it's morning or afternoon where you are. Moving on to Slide 4, we can review the profit statement. For Q1, our reported profit stands at $180.8 million, translating to $0.81 per share. On an adjusted basis, we're showing a profit of $137.9 million, which works out to $0.62 per share. Compared with the previous quarter, adjusted profit increased by $35.8 million, largely because of better TCE earnings. Once again, that improvement stemmed from the 24 VLCCs delivered by Euronav last quarter as well as in the current quarter, along with higher TCE rates. Again, this is partially counterbalanced by increased costs for ship operations, along with depreciation and finance expenses tied to the handover of the 24 VLCCs from Euronav. Let's now examine some balance sheet highlights on Slide 5. The changes in the balance sheet this quarter are connected to receiving the last 13 of the 24 VLCCs that were purchased from Euronav in the prior year. Frontline holds robust liquidity of $404 million in cash and cash equivalents, which includes the undrawn portions of the senior unsecured revolving credit facility, plus marketable securities and the minimum cash requirements owed to the bank as of March 31, 2024. There are no remaining newbuilding commitments, and no significant debt maturities are due until 2027. Now, turning to Slide 6, we'll go ahead with that one. Once we had taken delivery of every one of the 24 VLCCs bought from Euronav, and following the disposal of the seven older ships during the first and second quarters of 2024, the composition of our fleet stands at 41 VLCCs, 23 Suezmaxes, and 18 LR2 tankers. The average age across the fleet comes to 5.9 years, and 99% of the vessels are ECO, with 56% having scrubbers installed. For the remainder of 2024, we project the average cash cost tied to breakeven rates at approximately $31,200 each day for VLCCs, $23,500 each day for Suezmax tankers, and $22,200 each day for LR2 tankers. The estimate for the fleet as a whole comes to about $27,100 each day. The amount is somewhat greater than what we saw in the previous quarter, and that's attributable to the financing and refinancing transactions we completed. When we look at the fleet average estimate, it accounts for dry dock work on two Suezmax tankers along with five VLCCs during 2024. More than two Suezmaxes plus two VLCCs will be docked in the second quarter, followed by one VLCC in the third quarter, and then two VLCCs in the fourth quarter. Our recorded OpEx expenses, dry dock included, for the first quarter came to $8,100 per day for VLCCs, $8,800 per day for Suezmax tankers, and $7,400 per day for LR2 tankers; the startup of two Suezmax tankers is factored into that figure as well. Excluding dry dock, the first quarter fleet average for OpEx stood at $7,700; with that, we can proceed to Slide 7. Frontline has around 30,000 earnings days annually, where about 28,000 are spot base. Looking at what we can generate in cash and what's possible right now, based on the fleet we have and the spot market rates Clarkson Research reported as of May 29 — that's $55,900 a day for VLCCs, $50,000 a day for Suezmax tankers, and $65,500 for LR2 tankers — you get to $835 million a year, which works out to $3.75 per share. Over on the right-hand side of this slide, it shows that a 10% bump from where the spot market sits today would push that cash generation potential up by roughly 19%; and with that, I'll hand things back over to Lars.

Lars Barstad

executive
#3

I appreciate that, Inger. Turning to Slide 8, let's examine what's happening in the market right now. The circumstances involving Israel and Hamas, and also between Israel and Iran, remain what they are. Political risk keeps building around us. On top of that, there's tighter scrutiny of sanctions avoidance coming from both the U.S. and the EU. What this does is push what I formally call a grey fleet even deeper into the <<inaudible>> space, and that space keeps expanding as time goes on. On a much brighter note, worldwide oil demand, based on EIA figures, is projected to hit a record high during June, reaching 103.76 million barrels per day. Let's be clear about one thing: sure, we're moving toward greener fuels and taking part in the green transition, but worldwide energy demand as a whole keeps climbing, which means oil and hydrocarbons remain important and continue to grow. One thing really stands out about Q1 and the start of Q2 — that's when the markets truly started showing some muscle. If you look at the chart on the right, we basically leaned on the Clarksons Indices to <<inaudible>>. Right now, a three-year time charter for an ECO's over VLCC is getting close to $55,000 per day. What that does, in effect, is push the time charter market into something resembling a contango, because VLCC time charters at one year, two years and three years really do sit at those different levels. You should also observe that the LR2 and the Suezmax markets are priced roughly the same. One more exciting development: the TMX pipeline expansion is now becoming a reality, and we're beginning to see, or will soon start learning, how that oil will behave. We're discussing 650,000 barrels per day once the expansion is complete into the Pacific Basin. That will impact utilization in that area. They report that where the TMX pipeline terminates can only accommodate Aframaxes. It cannot accommodate STS operations, and there is essentially no storage at that location. We're going to watch how the trading flows develop. It depends on where that crude is headed — you might have Aframaxes absorbing the freight expense to bring it to an appropriate ship-to-ship transfer point, or it could go into refineries in the United States. And last thing on that subject: the Dangote refinery — the market has clearly been guessing about what kind of impact it will make. This isn't something in the future; it's a large-scale refinery that has finally started up in Nigeria after <<inaudible>>, and it's pretty remarkable that they're bringing in feedstocks from the U.S. Gulf, something nobody expected since they're located right next to Nigerian crude supplies. Their order books continue to grow, and as that happens, they handed over additional interruption time, which I'll come back to later. Looking at the bottom chart on this slide, the VLCC — as I've mentioned repeatedly — appears to be stuck in a sort of positive grind, with each cycle producing higher lows. As we go <<inaudible>>, that pattern still appears to be holding. The Suezmax, which I brought up during the introduction, is tied to the Suez Canal. The Suezmax has therefore looked very range-bound near the $40,000 per mark, and it doesn't appear to have legs to move anywhere. The LR2s, though, are the standout performers. Disruptions to passage through the Suez Canal hit them hardest, and volatility, we observe, is on the rise. There are also cases we've observed — and Frontline has been involved in these — where Suezmax vessels get cleaned up in order to go head-to-head in <<inaudible>>, particularly gasoline shipments running from the Middle East Gulf toward the Western region. So let's move on to Slide 9 and look at what's been happening with flows. I touched on some of this a bit earlier. OPEC is keeping its production cuts, and those reductions are concentrated mostly in the Middle East Gulf area. This has given non-OPEC supply something of a chance to grow, and that growth keeps going. In the upper left section, you can see the ton miles generated by oil exports from the Americas. When we say the Americas, we basically mean the whole continent, and we can see that number staying at a very high level. We're also seeing that VLCCs are starting to be preferred, particularly in May. What that tells us is that a large share of this cargo is traveling over long distances. Looking at the chart in the bottom left, we can also see that Europe continues to pull oil from farther away, so the ton miles Europe generates while steering clear of Russian crude keep accumulating. Then lastly — and this is rather intriguing — I believe what's emerging is that in a better outcome for the short, it might be located in the Middle East, and its movement toward course growth is picking up speed and is considerably bigger in the <<inaudible>>. Now let's move on to Slide 10. The order books <<inaudible>> are set to keep expanding. At this point <<inaudible>> is prepared to perform <<inaudible>>. So I think this is going to grow. Over the past two years or so, these have been coated tankers, and that figure has now climbed to 26.6% of the LR2 fleet as it stands. Still, you have to take into account that after LR2s get beyond 15 years of age, they usually turn into Aframaxes, so if you want a true picture within the Aframax size class, I'd argue you should bring in the total Aframax count, which would bring that percentage down sharply. Even so, this growth in the order book keeps going, although it's diminishing more and more when you get to 2027, and in fact we're now discussing 2028; so let's turn to Slide 11. If one slide from this quarter's deck deserves attention, it's this one. Look down at the chart in the lower left. Beginning in 2024, we're hitting a wall of replacement demand. When you look at tonnage that has to be retired once it reaches 20 to 25 years old—it varies by asset class—there's an enormous group of deadweight tons constructed from 2004 through 2011 that are now reaching that age. Newbuilding activity hit its absolute high point in 2011, and again, that covers every asset class. Back then, the world had 519 shipyards. At present, the global count of shipyards stands at 247. That means a 52% decrease has occurred in the total number of yards worldwide. When it comes to tonnage capacity, the drop isn't quite as steep—40%—since certain yards are larger in scale. In both South Korea and Japan, we observe real difficulty in growing what capacity already exists, largely because of demographic pressures and challenges in drawing in labor. During several presentations, I've pointed out that South Korea has to bring in workers from the Philippines just to meet its capacity requirements. As for Japan, people there note that welders are 56 years old on average. What we're dealing with here is really a population issue. In places like South Korea and Japan, there simply aren't a lot of young people who have a strong desire to take up work at a shipyard.

Lars Barstad

executive
#4

China could have a great deal of capacity. What we're looking at here is a structural tale about supply. To swap out all that tonnage requiring replacement across the coming 10 years, we've got a problem on our hands. If you focus just on tankers needing replacement, we are in fact — should you take a long view, put the big glasses on, between now and the '30s, more than close to 400 VLCCs must be constructed, 300 Suezmaxes must be constructed, 187 LR2s must be constructed, plus close to 400 Aframaxes. So this is fairly enormous, and it amounts to a structural issue. That means it can't simply be sold off. And whereas every bit of market intelligence shares the view that oil demand keeps rising, even though ton miles might shrink in the short to medium term should Ukraine and Russia find a resolution and should the Red Sea passage reopen, there's no getting around the reality that growth in shipping supply appears difficult. Having said that, let's turn to Slide 12 and walk through the summary. So once more, the Q1 highlights at Frontline include a fully delivered VLCC fleet being sold under the Frontline flag. We have wrapped up the sale of <<inaudible>>, and that has handed Frontline one of the most fuel-efficient fleets available in the market. We closed and signed the expansion in financing, thereby finishing our strategy of releveraging the fleet we already have. The security situation across the Red Sea, Gulf of Aden and the Middle East broadly persists. Tanker markets keep contracting, with building capacities now in doubt as delivery dates shift into 2028. The oil demand picture for short and medium term stays solid, and the market is also sort of cautioning us about the OPEC+ <<inaudible>> second half of 2024. Liquidity has grown in the period market, with long-term time charter rates climbing, and in all honesty, this represents the intelligent money entering the market. So given all that, I'd like to open things up for questions.

Omar Nokta

analyst
#5

Thanks. Hello, Lars and Inger. Good afternoon, and thanks for walking us through everything. It's consistently thorough and helpful on all the various pieces of the market story. I suppose I have a few questions. Perhaps starting with the financing side. Like you mentioned, you wrapped up and signed the expansion financing. A sizable chunk of cash has just been freed up lately. If I'm reading the figures right, $417 million has been freed up, and that will essentially pay back the Hemen Holding borrowings of $395 million, which was originally used on the Euronav deal. But what about the seven tankers, the seven older ships you just sold? Those freed up $275 million once the debt was repaid. Is that cash? Is it set aside for something specific? Or will it go toward more debt reduction?

Inger Klemp

executive
#6

Keep in mind that we used more to finance the Euronav <<inaudible>> now they still spend $395 million that we drew under the Sterna facility and also the Hemen shareholder loan; we spent some cash from operation until we sold the vessels — the older vessel. So that answers your question.

Omar Nokta

analyst
#7

All right. Yeah. So it's really that straightforward, then. Okay. And I suppose, just to stay on the topic of Lars, you spent a fair amount of time discussing the market and how LR2s are the segment that's performing well, and you also brought up TMX. What's your view on the LR2 fleet and how it's trading right now — or how do you handle, let's say, those LR2s when it comes to dirty versus clean, given how strong things are outside the Suez market, and then also considering the possible pull toward Vancouver?

Lars Barstad

executive
#8

Yeah. No, that's a fair question. Right now is a moment when, frankly, we'd probably have preferred to have a few Aframaxes in our fleet, uncoated ones; but so essentially, to address what you asked about LR2s performing well. Clearly, this ties to the reality that, since the Suez Canal is essentially shut, for products moving East to West, the yards operate intermittently, yet from West to East there's minimal material building up. You have to give an owner an incentive to actually reposition the ship heading East, which means the rates really need to climb. So the utilization of the LR2 fleet is just rising substantially, largely because of this inefficiency. And it's gotten to the stage where significant work has gone into cleaning up Suezmaxes for this trade. Suezmaxes can clearly clean. Suezmaxes clearly cannot serve every cargo. Essentially gas, oil is probably the limit of what they can handle. But that's fundamentally what's pushing this market. Dangote, I don't believe, we've necessarily TMX. I don't think we've witnessed that fully impacting the Aframax market. But at least from what we can observe now, as markets develop or evolve, it appears many of these barrels are in fact going for rest. It's the opposite side of the globe. And so essentially, what we're seeing is trade appearing where Aframaxes will move up and down the coast, you have certain STS locations in — we have some in U.S., we have Mexico, and you have Ecuador. Ecuador, you also have tankage, and we see this as we gather the oil from TMX on Afras. So utilization is in fact rising on Afras to some degree, though not necessarily to the degree as if the Aframaxes were heading all the way west to China; and then STS activity and then placed into VLCCs that carries it over to our clients there. So I think we still need to examine this trade for several more months until we grasp how it will function; but you could say that the worst case scenario, which is clearly the best case scenario for a ship owner, is that all this — you need to load an Aframax every day; so <<inaudible>> and if they must travel for 40 days before the discharge, you have eight days until they're back. A significant number of ships will be required for this. Yet from our current vantage point, at the outset, it doesn’t — the full span of days isn’t necessary since you’re essentially traveling along the coastline toward a potential ship-to-ship transfer point, after which a bigger ship comes into play; and up to now, it appears the direction is toward very large crude carriers.

Omar Nokta

analyst
#9

All right. Thank you, Lars. That is useful. One last item from my side, regarding how the VLCCs performed during Q1 — clearly there is a significant gap between what the original fleet brought in and what the Euronav vessels achieved after being repositioned. Should we expect additional repositioning moves during Q2? And is Q3 genuinely the first quarter where things reflect steady operations under the deal?

Lars Barstad

executive
#10

Yes. I believe there are several things worth noting. First, keep in mind that scrubber coverage across the Euronav fleet is smaller than what the Frontline fleet had before the transaction. Naturally, that shapes the earnings achievable. Second, at the start, practically every ship came in near Singapore. So we face the possibility that introductory trade won't deliver what we hoped for; timing of entry into the market also matters, since they arrived in a very tight cluster. That caused us to land in an extremely slim window in the Middle East, which happened to be Q1's weakest area; regardless, I think your observation is spot on. Going forward, we'll distribute the fleet more uniformly worldwide; and the Euronav ships are going to simply merge in. We likely won't address separating the two fleets when reporting from here on. Also, you raise a valid point — these vessels completed lengthy voyages; therefore some time is needed before everything is fully settled, or whatever term fits, within the overall fleet. So Q2 may partly reflect that. In Q3, operations ought to be normal.

Lars Barstad

executive
#11

Alright, that's clear. Though naturally, it showed up less strongly during the second quarter compared with the first, of course.

Omar Nokta

analyst
#12

Alright. Understood; so the second quarter is going to improve, and once we hit Q3, it's really in full swing. Got it. That's great. Appreciate it, Lars, and thank you, Inger.

Greg Lewis

analyst
#13

Hi there. Thanks, and good afternoon, everyone. I appreciate you letting me ask a few things. Lars, it seems the time charter market is getting deeper. I mean, clearly, you guys are making the most of it. When we think about the second half of this year and where rates are headed, plus that gap between, I suppose, the forward curve and the spot market, I'm just kind of wondering what you're observing and how you're weighing the chances to keep placing a few ships on period charters.

Lars Barstad

executive
#14

We do this all the time <<inaudible>>. That said, I think it's worth remembering our stance is that this one lasts a while. I don't love admitting this, since we coined the phrase stronger for longer back in 2020, and that turned out to be completely wrong. In that instance, though, we were being fairly aggressive in going after charter coverage. These days, however, we're keeping an eye on it, and we'd like to — it stands to reason; we'd like to push into this market, though we won't — at Frontline we've got sort of a guideline where we aim to hedge 30% of our biggest exposure, which means revenues, interest rates and the bunkers. That's roughly the guideline. On interest rate swaps, we're right about there, or quite near it, with superb timing; when it comes to bunkers, we're somewhat under that. As for revenues, we have essentially, except for the LR2s, essentially no revenue locked in as we move ahead. Still, we intend to push into this, yet we're certainly in no rush, since we think this market will strengthen bit by bit. Going back to the — I brought up that structural problem that exists on the supply side, along with oil demand that appears extremely, extremely resilient. It's going to require a bit of time for us. So — but we do want to — at whatever point — well, it also depends on when we exit the cycle. We'd like to hold some adequate coverage. Right now, though, we aren't chasing this hard.

Greg Lewis

analyst
#15

All right, that's great. Then I just wanted to touch a bit on — you had those asset sales, and I suppose, if we look at it, perhaps there are two additional Suezmaxes sitting in that 2010, 2011 bracket. We sort of share the market view that in past cycles, ships that are older have tended to do better, the gap has narrowed for aging tonnage compared with newer vessels, and owning the older ships during bull markets has usually been logical. I'm just wondering — I mean, I suppose, ever since the Frontline acquisition was made public, 16 vessels have been sold. So my question, I guess, is whether you think this cycle will unfold in a different way, with so much more bias against older ships that maybe that spread, which normally narrows across these multiyear up cycles, won't behave the way it always has?

Lars Barstad

executive
#16

That's quite a question. In our analysis and in examining this market, I believe — as I've mentioned many times, we lean toward this idea regarding what's happening in the old economy; the way this will ultimately unfold is — clearly it hasn't happened yet, but oil prices and all of that will sort of move — with commodities being what we'll be confronting ahead. Given that, we'd prefer to have the most efficient equipment. We're noticing some selectivity from customers favoring more efficient tonnage. We can't overlook the regulatory environment we're up against <<inaudible>> the benefit sort of faded somewhat from the discussion over the past year, 1.5 years. There's still the matter of CII, and there's still the matter of energy efficiency and similar things. And fundamentally, we lean into that heavily, and it's part of our approach; so I think perhaps, looking back two or three years from now, what you ought to have done is concentrate on 12 to 15-year-old ships, where you get more value for your money. But we keep building for the long term to <<inaudible>> it'll be within the 20 to 30 years, and that's essentially the plan we're pursuing.

Greg Lewis

analyst
#17

All right, that's really useful. Thanks a lot.

Lars Barstad

executive
#18

Thanks.

Petter Haugen

analyst
#19

Yes. Good afternoon, everyone. Thanks for letting me ask. Regarding that last line in the summary, Lars, where you mention the longer-term time charter markets — I suppose my question has two parts. First, when it comes to the requirements, is it the traders? Or is it more the underlying cargo owners who are requesting a longer period? And the second part: as of right now, have we observed interest in charters of five to seven years for new builds with deliveries in 2027/2028?

Lars Barstad

executive
#20

Thank you, Petter. On the first one, absolutely, yes. Sorry — this is the oil majors, the parties who have transportation needs. So basically this is the big players coming into the market: oil majors, national oil companies and so on. Second, yes, there is interest in longer-term business in the market. So perhaps not 10 years, but five to seven years, definitively, and seven years charters, absolutely; so but this is a somewhat different market than — just to remind everybody, our proposition to our investors is to give you spot exposure; these kind of deals, we might — we're very likely to pass on. We don't have an order book either. So — but it is absolutely starting to merge market around its longer-term use as well.

Petter Haugen

analyst
#21

Let me add one more thing to that. Suppose someone has a vessel being newly constructed, handed over during 2027 — what level of rates do you figure they could secure on a charter agreement running 5 years, starting at that point?

Lars Barstad

executive
#22

That is quite a broad question. Honestly, it's tough to give an answer; however, the forward curve appears rather level, and it's <<inaudible>> the kind of level that provides a shipowner with a reasonable return on equity; so we're looking at roughly $50,000 each day in any case, how much of the transaction we observe that is but that doesn't truly provide you with — that — apologies, $50,000 each day doesn't truly create — it gets certain people enthusiastic, while others perhaps not; it's the 2027 handover, based on the timing of your order, costing you $110 million, $215 million, $220 million. So that's a substantial figure. Still, I believe for the time being, those are the levels where such pricing sits.

Petter Haugen

analyst
#23

All right, thanks. I've got one last thing, and it's about dividends from here on out. I realize your approach is discretionary, yet on this occasion you're distributing the full amount, which I believe most people are happy to see. So how do we frame the payout ratio looking ahead? I'm wondering specifically about the upcoming quarter, since that period and possibly Q3, given a summer market, might bring something smaller, I'd guess.

Lars Barstad

executive
#24

Right. What I'd say is that as a general guideline — though again, it isn't an official policy — you're looking at 80% of adjusted net income; keep that figure in mind. That's essentially how it plays out. Yet the reason we went with 100% right now is that visibility is strong; our liquidity situation is solid; and giving shareholders the money we generate is what we're here to do. Naturally, as markets move ahead, one can wonder whether we'll choose 100% once more or land at 80%. My sense is it ties back to the overall market mood. That's what we've aimed for from the start: when the market takes a steep dive, we won't empty the company's cash reserves. On the other hand, should the market hold steady or perhaps strengthen, we've got flexibility — unless some structural move means we'd prefer to put that cash back to work for our shareholders <<inaudible>> you ought to be generously compensated.

Petter Haugen

analyst
#25

Thanks for that, Lars. That's everything I had.

Lars Barstad

executive
#26

Many thanks, and I appreciate everyone tuning in. We're still in thrilling times, even though a bit of the volatility we'd hoped for hasn't shown up yet. Still, we'll just keep watching how these markets move. And thanks so much.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.