Golar LNG Limited (GLNG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 20, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Karl Staubo
executiveAppreciate that, speaker, and thanks for joining Golar LNG's Q1 earnings release. We're grateful you could spend some time dialing in. I'm Karl Fredrik Staubo, and I've just stepped into the role of CEO here at Golar LNG. Prior to diving into the quarterly figures, kindly take note of the forward-looking statements shown on slide 2. With me today is Mr. Eduardo Maranhão, who has moved into the CFO position at Golar that I previously held. Eduardo previously served as CFO of Hygo, and most of Golar's stakeholders already know him well. Together, we look forward to helping Golar keep succeeding. Moving to slide 3 for the Q1 highlights. Adjusted EBITDA came in at $78 million for the quarter, with net income of $25 million, and both figures beat consensus estimates. Our shipping portfolio posted a TCE of $61,700 per day during the quarter, and at quarter end our shipping revenue backlog sits at $187 million. Hilli keeps achieving 100% uptime, and the 56th LNG cargo is being offloaded right now. Gimi is still on schedule and stands at 69% technically complete. In Q1, we announced the sale of Hygo low and GMLP to New Fortress Energy, and that deal closed on April 15th. Those transactions will show up in our Q2 numbers, but they're anticipated to produce an accounting book profit above $650 million and to boost liquidity and liquid assets by roughly $900 million; we've kicked off the previously announced buyback program of as much as $50 million, with 1.2 million shares repurchased so far. As of Q1, our cash balance is $245 million, and that figure excludes the sales proceeds from the NFE transactions. I'll now hand the call to Eduardo, who will walk us through the first quarter numbers.
Eduardo Maranhão
executiveAppreciate that, Karl, and good morning, everybody. I'm pleased to share an update regarding our financial results for Q1 of 2021; so if we move to slide 5; you'll note the group delivered a very strong performance during the first quarter. Total operating revenues came to $126 million for Q1, a figure that was 7% higher than what we recorded in Q4 of the prior year. Adjusted EBITDA reached $78 million, matching the level of the preceding quarter. A major factor behind this result was elevated utilization along with increased charter rates across our carrier fleet, and that drove total revenues of $63 million. We successfully carried out our shipping strategy and pushed TCE rates as high as $10,000 per day compared with the prior quarter. FLNG revenues generated by the Hilli met our expectations, landing at $54 million. Even though that's below the prior quarter, when overproduction revenues from earlier years boosted the figure, these results demonstrate the outstanding operational execution by our team, who once again achieved 100% commercial uptime. Starting up operations under our long-term O&M agreement with LNG Croatia brought in greater management fees, which also helped lift our other operating revenues, which totaled $9 million for the quarter. Net income stood at $25 million, an amount $17 million above the prior quarter; the primary reason for that was better noncash mark-to-market gains on our interest rate swaps, which followed favorable rate movements; regarding financing, our net debt position when Q1 ended was just about $2.1 billion, a touch above Q4. That was largely the result of the $45 billion drawdown under the gaming facility. We'll share more updates about that later in the presentation. So, when Q1 wrapped up, our total cash position, as Karl mentioned earlier, came to $245 million; and that figure excluded the sales proceeds tied to the NFE transaction. So, turning to slide 6, the closing of the Hygo and GMLP transactions last month has further boosted our liquidity position. With $150 million of unrestricted cash available when the quarter closed, plus $131 million of cash proceeds received on April 15th, our balance sheet has been substantially strengthened. Using yesterday's closing price, our NFE stake is now valued at close to $800 million. And that opens up substantial optionality for any funding strategy. Given all that, we now hold more than $1 billion in liquid assets, as the left hand side of this slide shows. We are now well-positioned to satisfy our current CapEx commitments and to finance future appealing investment opportunities. I'd like to emphasize that our priority for 2021 will revolve around optimizing our debt structure, and that covers refinancing our April ‘22 convertible bonds. We'll keep working to simplify our group structure even further, and we'll also aim to concentrate on FLNG and upstream business developments. Alright, so at this point, I'll hand things back to Karl.
Karl Staubo
executiveAppreciate that, Eduardo. Moving on to slide 8, where we look at how our shipping has performed. As I noted earlier, for the quarter our shipping TCE was $61,700 per day, and for 2021 we've locked in 90% of the vessel days that remain. Of those 90% contracted days, 19% carry index linkage while 71% sit on fixed rate charters. We entered 2021 taking a careful stance on shipping exposure, since we anticipated roughly 50 newbuild deliveries arriving during the year — about two-thirds of those deliveries hold charter parties, while one-third of the newbuilds are still open. That said, the current strength in LNG freight rates has surprised us on the positive side, even with the usual seasonal softness we see in spring and summer. This gives further backing to our favorable view of the shipping segment ahead. Consistent with our outlook on shipping rates growing more optimistic, our exposure to LNG freight rates keeps rising via floating rate charters and the off fixed charters that will follow them. Spot exposure sits at 3% for Q2, 11% for Q3 and 40% for Q4, timed to align with the typical seasonal firming of LNG freight rates as winter approaches. For Q2, we anticipate TFDE TCE rates near $47,000 per day alongside 98% fleet utilization, reflecting the strong contract coverage we hold for the quarter. Now to slide 9 — our optimism regarding the future outlook for LNG carriers keeps growing. Right now the total LNG fleet on-the-water numbers 597 ships. That fleet breaks down into 254 steam carriers, 183 TFDE carriers, 44 Q-Flex and Q-Max, and 116 mega ships, with a further 130 on order. On supply, our view is that the order book gets offset by less efficient steam carriers exiting their long-term charters and confronting new, stricter emission standards, which pushes those vessels to slow steam or become uneconomical for international trading. Measured by vessel count, the 22% order book stands against 42% of vessels currently on the water being steam ships. So in our view that more than offsets the order book. Demand keeps growing, with 361 million tons of LNG moved last year. Per Clarksons, each ton of LNG transported uses 1.4 LNG carrier per year on average. Given expected growth of almost 100 million tons across the coming three to four years, that implies 140 incremental ships required. On top of that, growing distances — since most incremental volume moves from the U.S. to the Far East — consume 2 times, or two LNG carriers per ton, which would mean needing almost 200 ships. Finally, the three Korean shipyards able to build high-quality LNG carriers are filling up with container orders, so no meaningful additions to the order book are possible, with delivery no earlier than 2024. This leaves us very optimistic about the medium and longer-term outlook for LNG carriers, and we're positively surprised by the current seasonal strength in a year with 50 newbuild deliveries while demand remains negatively affected by COVID. Moving to slide 10, let me expand on a few of the environmental rules that are starting to take effect. The first one to note is EEXI, or the Energy Efficiency Existing Ship Index, which kicks in starting in 2023. Under EEXI, the IMO has committed to cutting CO2 emissions by 50% by 2050. That date is still a long way off, but given how long assets in the LNG business stay in service, in many respects this is already a problem today. On top of that, the IMO's first target beyond 2030 calls for a 40% reduction in carbon intensity. The IMO will mandate that every vessel in every segment meet a commonly agreed index prior to January 1, 2023; to satisfy those requirements, every ship engaged in international trades must act, whether by slowing down, switching to cleaner fuels like LNG, ammonia or hydrogen, or performing other retrofits to vessel design that raise energy efficiency. For LNG shipping, the likely outcome is slow steaming or idling of a substantial portion of the steam carriers. As noted on the prior slide, that amounts to 42% of the worldwide LNG carrier fleet. Moving to FLNG and beginning with Hilli on slide 12. Hilli keeps running at 100% commercial uptime, and its 56th cargo is being offloaded right now. We've made steady headway when it comes to raising Hilli's utilization. All documentation needed to lift any production caps on gas reserves, and to allow output beyond the present contract capacity, has been executed. We're in advanced talks regarding extra production that should start up in the first quarter of next year. We'd also like to remind everyone that we are now at a point where Brent linked earnings will be recognized beginning in the second quarter of this year. For each dollar the Brent curve sits above $60, Golar earns $2.7 million in annual EBITDA. Given today's Brent forward curves, we anticipate continued Brent contribution for Hilli over the years ahead. Moving to page 13 for an update on Gimi. The conversion project stands at 69% technically complete, on track and on budget. We've gone past 9 million man-hours, with roughly 2,400 yard workers assigned to the conversion each day. During the vessel's fifth and final drydock, all remaining sponson blocks have been attached, and it remains on schedule for completion during this quarter. Gimi should sail away from Singapore in the first quarter of 2023. Commissioning revenues are set to begin in the second quarter of 2023, and its 20-year contract with BP starts in the fourth quarter of 2023, carrying a total EBITDA backlog of $4.3 billion; we also note that Kosmos, BP's partner on the Tortue field, said in their Q1 report that they are working to maximize the FLNG capacity that fits their current infrastructure. By infrastructure, they're referring to the FPSO and the breakwater the project is putting in place. That works out to 5 million tons on an annual basis. As a reminder, Gimi's capacity stands at 2.5 million tons. So to reach 5 million tons per year of liquefaction capacity, you'd need either an additional Mark I design FLNG or, alternatively, a Mark redesign FLNG to cover the entire 5 million tons. Moving on to slide 14. We're now at a point where the gas price indicates LNG economics are strongest upstream; on the left-hand side we put together an illustrative example of FLNG economics. Assuming gas reserve and lifting costs of $1 per MMBTU, plus a $2 tolling fee that includes a 10% unlevered return to the FLNG owner, FLNG technology lets us deliver FOB gas at $3 per MMBTU. Given today's healthy shipping rates, sending cargo to the Far East would tack on another $1.5 per MMBTU, giving a delivered LNG price of $4.5 per MMBTU. On the right hand side, as you can see, that translates into a very attractive downside compared with historic JKM pricing, along with very healthy upside potential; so, to illustrate, any time the dark blue line sits above the green line, the FLNG provider makes money.
Karl Staubo
executiveAt a JKM price of $10 per MMBTU right now, the gas producer is left with a solid margin of roughly $1.4 billion annually. It's this risk-reward picture, together with gas forward prices, that is fueling two things: growing interest from the majors in our FLNG tolling arrangements, and Golar's own wish to shift our focus back to an integrated upstream model, where we can capture more of the gas upside. We go into more detail on what the potential economics of that gas upside might look like on page 15, based on a Mark III or a 5 million ton per annum FLNG. 5 million tons of liquefaction capacity works out to 250 million MMBTUs per year. So a $2 margin works out to $500 million in annual EBITDA. Once again, current and forward LNG prices would indicate that economics for projects like these will land between 2 to 4 times EV EBITDA. Acquiring and producing integrated gas isn't a new idea for Golar, but we believe the fundamentals for this potential upside in Golar's business model are stronger than they've ever been — thanks to supportive gas forward prices, thanks to our proven track record of 100% utilization on Hilli, and finally, because we now have a balance sheet capable of lifting such a project and executing on this strategy; we're currently chasing stranded gas and associated gas reserves that may allow the rollout of our integrated upstream strategy, and we'll update the market as soon as there are further developments on this front. Moving to corporate and strategic focus. We announced today our 2020 ESG report, which can be found on our website. Even though ESG has been an integral part of Golar's operations since the Company was formed, we are increasing our transparency to the market on our performance. Some of the highlights from this year's report are on slide 17. The carbon footprint of our FLNG technology is competitive with shore-based liquefaction mega projects. We've cut fleet-wide carbon emissions from an AER of 9.95 to 8.71. And on Hilli, we have — we're now up to 35.4 local employees and have spent more than $10 million on local purchases. We've also published our ESG targets through 2030; these either align with or exceed any regulatory requirements for our fleet and operations. Moving to slide 18 and the earnings power from our existing asset portfolio. After the sale of Hygo and GMLP to New Fortress Energy, Golar is significantly simplified, and our asset portfolio and financial performance should be easier to predict and follow. Our shipping segment is made up of 10 vessels, of which 8 are TFDE carriers, 1 steam carrier and 1 FSRU currently operating as a carrier. The fleet is fully delivered and generated an EBITDA over the last 12 months of $121 million. A $10,000 change in rates works out to $32 million in change in EBITDA. We're optimistic that this segment will see improved performance on the back of the strengthened LNG carrier market outlook. Regarding Hilli, utilization remains at 100%, and given a pro rata EBITDA output of $93 million for the trailing 12 months, we anticipate additional upside in her performance too. That upside will come from building potential overproduction, earnings on oil derivatives, and carrying out the advanced talks regarding greater capacity utilization beginning in the first quarter of 2022. As noted, Gimi is set to commence its 20-year contract with BP on schedule during Q4 2023, which brings another $151 million of contracted EBITDA to Golar. We also hold additional EBITDA potential through an uptime bonus on Gimi. Therefore, once Gimi delivers, we anticipate a run rate EBITDA from the current asset portfolio of no less than $352 million, compared with $201 million of EBITDA over the trailing 12 months. As discussed before, considerable additional upside exists in FLNG tolling and integrated projects, which could contribute substantial further EBITDA potential. So, wrapping up on slide 19, we feel optimistic about greater earnings power in our shipping business, since rates are stronger than we had anticipated, the market outlook is positive, and our exposure to shipping freight rates is growing via our charter portfolio. In FLNG, we expect higher earnings from Hilli thanks to oil derivative earnings and headway in the talks on increased capacity utilization, and Gimi stays on time and within budget. Gas prices support FLNG growth, and we have seen heightened interest in the tolling business and are quite enthusiastic about the chance to develop integrated gas and FLNG upstream opportunities. On corporate and investments, our liquidity position is strong after the sale of Hygo and GMLP; this will allow us to finance growth projects and optimize debt. Finally, we will keep pursuing further group simplification, probably separating our midstream shipping business and upstream FLNG business into two distinct vehicles eventually. That wraps up Golar’s Q1 earnings presentation; we thank you all for dialing in; and I’ll hand things to the operator for any questions.
Randy Giveans
analystTo start, of course, congratulations to you, Karl, for stepping into the CEO position; Eduardo, for taking on the CFO role; this looks like a wonderful moment to start those new jobs. Now, regarding the LNG side of things first, a number of folks view the Qatar expansion as almost impossible to compete with, correct, given its roughly $5 landed costs. Your slide 14 demonstrates that, initially, your FLNG projects are able to outperform that. So, I suppose this is a two-part question. Is there any appetite to take part in that tender offer for the 100 to 150 LNG carriers from Qatar? And then, even more significantly, for Golar, since trains 3 and 4 have improved economics, what obstacles exist and perhaps what timeline is expected for getting Perenco to ramp up trains 3 and 4? You did mention 1Q ‘22, but could there be any possibility of starting sooner?
Karl Staubo
executiveThank you, Randy; so, as far as the Qatar tender goes, we are certainly aware of it; even so, we think our advantage lies in upstream and FLNG development. And any extra dollar we have is more apt to go toward that rather than shipping. Therefore, we currently have no plans to take part in that tender. As for Hilli and potential production upside, I believe, nearly all the agreements that could be reached between us and the local government and between us and Perenco, are very close to being finalized, if not already finalized. Still, there are existing off-takers and other parties that must have agreements in place with Perenco, and those agreements lie beyond our control. Yet given this gas price, the economics work well enough for everyone involved; and each day without production represents a lost opportunity dollar; so, we remain encouraged and optimistic that a solid shared solution can be found for all parties; we do not anticipate any additional significant incremental production ramp-up. Certain volumes we may be able to bill under the current overproduction arrangements, but no meaningful increase before Q1 next year.
Randy Giveans
analystAlright, that covers all of it. Good — so now, regarding your balance sheet. Clearly, it's in fantastic condition after the New Fortress shares. So then, what do you intend to do with that $1 billion in liquidity? That's significantly higher than the $500 million you still have left in CapEx, which you demonstrated on that slide. There are some costly sale leasebacks that could be paid off. Meanwhile, your stock is severely undervalued. So, do you anticipate finishing the rest — the remaining portion of the $50 million buyback during Q2? Also, could you share any fresh information about the convert refinancing, including timing and possibilities, plus the NFE for GLNG share exchange?
Karl Staubo
executiveAlright. That's several questions. I'll begin, and then Eduardo, please jump in as we proceed. So, regarding the buyback program, you observed that we bought back 1.2 million shares, which we essentially had to halt once we reached the blackout period ahead of Q1 results. The original framework approved at the Board level is $50 million; and I believe it's reasonable to expect that provided the share price continues trading at a discount to both book and underlying values, we intend to keep the buyback program going. The next question concerns the CB. I think what we've indicated there is that a number of different alternatives are available to us. In no specific order, we might pursue an exchangeable offering at exchangeable internal fee shares. We might issue a CB or unsecured bond at the GLNG level, or we might settle in cash using either cash available from the balance sheet or a sell-down of derisked assets like Gimi. So we have multiple avenues for handling that maturity. As for precisely which path we plan to take, that hinges on the relative share price between NFE and GLNG. To some degree, it hinges on the absolute share price of GLNG; but what I mean by that is, if you were to do a CB on GLNG, you obviously wouldn't do it around current levels. And finally, it hinges on near-term growth projects. We plan to address it during the second half of this year; and the main reason for addressing it at that point is that then we are — we have no restrictions on any of our liquid assets and therefore, are in a position to better weigh the alternatives; in the interim, we are maintaining close dialogue with constructive investment banks and other investors proposing different alternatives, and we are keeping them on file and comparing where we think we can achieve the best solution.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right, we’ll jot that down. And then, moving along fairly fast, regarding the NFE GLNG share swap — is there anything further you can share, or any extra insight on what might happen there?
Karl Staubo
executiveWhich item do you mean — the exchange offer, or the distribution of NFE shares?
Randy Giveans
analystIn the press release, you brought up the possibility of swapping NFE shares for Golar common stock as part of a...
Karl Staubo
executiveRight; that comes down to how NFE's share price stacks up against Golar's. And that's a decision we'll look at after the lockup period ends — 90 days following closing, which happened on the 15th of April.
James Yoon
analystMorning, everyone. This is James, filling in for Chris. I'd like to dig a bit deeper into what you said regarding priorities. Specifically, looking at the end markets — LNG carriers on one side, FLNG on the other — which do you view as, basically, the one where you might be able to deploy capital work at an earlier point? And then, continuing that same thread, is there anything still needing to be cleaned up before we might see something resembling a transaction in one of those two areas?
Karl Staubo
executiveAll right. Let me take that one again. So, regarding — right, our incremental dollar, I'd say the place where we at Golar hold a more distinctive advantage is upstream and FLNG. Like we mentioned during the presentation, we've by now delivered cargo number 56 of LNG from the Hilli, along with an operating utilization of 100% in delivery, which is unprecedented. Therefore, we think our advantage lies in FLNG and upstream, and our incremental dollar is going to go toward growth in FLNG and upstream rather than toward shipping. That said, as stated during the presentation, we hold 10 ships; we have meaningful exposure; we're pleased with the outlook, but adding ships to our portfolio is not something we intend to do. And as for what comes next regarding when either could happen, we've just wrapped up the $5 billion EV transaction involving the sale of GMLP and NFE. That closed on the 15th of April, on one hand, but speaking for us, we feel essentially no immediate pressure to settle the two. At the same time, we think one factor behind our trading at a discount to underlying value is that investors want cleaner exposures to either upstream or shipping. So we'll stay opportunistic and aim to carry out further simplification as soon as we find an attractive way to do it; and on that front, we're looking into various alternatives, both for spinning out shipping and for establishing an upstream company; so either option works for us.
James Yoon
analystUnderstood. Then when it comes to the shipping side of things, getting it ready in case it might be spun off or something like that, is there any kind of element you're bringing into how you charter, maybe attempting to boost coverage or do things along those lines so it becomes more appealing to the market? Is there some kind of effort that needs to happen, or does that fall into the category where — if a bid shows up for it, do you believe you could essentially have it separated sooner instead of later?
Karl Staubo
executiveYes, absolutely. So essentially, a short time ago, 12 months — or 12 to 18 months ago, we adjusted our approach to shipping a bit so we'd carry more coverage. Two factors really drove that decision. First, we observed many newbuilds coming into the market during '21, and we didn't want to carry excessive exposure, considering that we have 50 new builds arriving in the market in addition to COVID. So, we attempted to secure a fair amount of coverage. And to a degree, the strength of the rates has caught us favorably off guard. And you could argue we ended up being somewhat overly cautious. The second factor, or reason, behind us securing this much cover this early was that all of it happened before the NFE transaction, when our balance sheet position wasn't the same as it stands now; so, we aimed to stay cautious, avoiding any sort of unexpected rate situations. That said, as we attempted to make very clear on page 8, our exposure to the market keeps growing since we're quite optimistic about what the outlook holds; and at present, I anticipate we'll become more and more exposed to the spot market, whether via floating rate arrangements or simply because vessels roll off fixed rate charters on their own.
James Yoon
analystUnderstood. What I’m really asking, I suppose, is whether you believe that to bring in a strategic — another deal, you’d only need one or three conditions. First, enhancing asset quality somehow. Second, in that middle category, perhaps you’d say market timing simply isn’t favorable. Or third, you might just feel you need a bit more time, since you recently completed a major transaction. And it sounds as though the assets are roughly where you’d like them. Market timing isn’t something you’re forming a view on, and it’s mainly about creating some separation from the last big deal you closed. Is that roughly the correct way to see it, or am I getting that wrong?
Karl Staubo
executiveIf an appealing deal comes along that we could execute tomorrow, I don’t believe we’d have any issue executing it tomorrow. It’s widely recognized in the market that we’ve been actively reviewing options for our shipping fleet, including pursuing a consolidation play. We don’t think any high grading of our fleet is necessary. TFDE carriers are, so to speak, the work horse of the industry. And we observe that the pressure falls more on the steam vessels; therefore, for us, a high grading isn’t something we anticipate. I don’t — I believe we’ve finished and are done with the NFE deals. So we definitely possess sufficient energy and opportunism within the Company that, should we identify the right transaction tomorrow, we’re glad to pursue it. Thus, for us, it comes down to locating the right home for the shipping fleet; we’re happy with it as it stands today. We believe it will improve. Yet, simultaneously, we do think we’re somewhat penalized by retaining it within the same company as the upstream; so, we’re willing to settle this as soon as we locate the right home.
Mike Webber
analystSo, if it's alright with you, I'd like to focus on slide 23, since I believe that would be useful. And I simply want to confirm that my understanding is correct. Your previous question concerned — or rather, your previous response dealt with what should be done regarding the carrier fleet; and it really appears that the appropriate comparison here relates to the value of Golar in its entirety; it resembles TK 2015 in that, if a home can be located for the carriers, suddenly the value proposition at Golar appears far more straightforward and much cleaner. However, I did — I'm aware you've addressed this topic, yet I'm also aware that distributing the carriers or sending them away was not included among the strategic initiatives on slide 23. Considering how challenging that is — first, locating a purchaser for a fleet of that size, or presumably injecting some equity into it, meaning there's value available to distribute — is it reasonable to state that at present, this appears somewhat harder than the items you've shown on slide 23 regarding distributing NFE shares and the other strategic initiatives?
Karl Staubo
executiveYes. I'm not certain precisely what you were referencing on slide 23 within the appendix. However, I believe what we — when we refer to further group simplification, our meaning is essentially locating a home for shipping or achieving the same simplification by possibly spinning out the upstream. So, I think both options are acceptable to us. Regarding debt optimization on the shipping fleet, we noted in today's earnings release that, as part of following the NFE transaction, we have committed to lowering the debt on four of our ships, whereby we essentially put $60 million of cash into four of the ships, thereby cutting debt by $15 million per ship in exchange for an overall debt reduction of $102 million. So, we disburse 60, which will occur in the early portion of Q3; and in exchange, we receive $102 million of debt reduction. So, in effect, that amounts to a $42 million debt saving for Golar, and to some degree, this ought to be viewed as further enabling the shipping fleet to the response; conversely, when examining the implied values of listed peers, that indicates our shipping fleet is worth somewhere in the range of $250 million to $350 million of equity. That naturally moves around with share prices, but that's where we trace it; and broker…
Mike Webber
analystYeah. I mean, if it truly carried that sort of worth, spinning it off would be the obvious move, correct? But I suppose what we're really asking is, when it comes to assessing — that's a tough puzzle to crack, isn't it? You're not even the first group running Golar to take a swing at it, right? So it remains an open question mark; regarding what strategic paths exist for the carriers versus — I think it's even there on the slide — unlocking the hidden value inside FLNG, the possible structural transaction, and I believe you're referring to the strategic deal on the FLNG side. The way things stand right now, how does that sequence shape up? Is it more probable that you locate something to do with the FLNG assets prior to being able to act on the carriers, or do you figure it's more probable that you discover a route to move the carriers off the books first?
Karl Staubo
executiveTo address where things stand as of right now, I'd say it would be shipping out, followed by GLNG — FLNG — and an upstream company.
Mike Webber
analystSure, okay, that tracks. About FLNG — I wonder if you could give us a few more details on the Mark III in the deck. At 5 million tons, that's clearly larger than the Hilli and the original technology you were considering. I'm trying to line that up against fast LNG, which New Fortress launched not long ago, and clearly you two share a distinctive relationship. How much should we treat those as technologies going head-to-head, or have you shifted somewhat toward a slightly bigger slice of the market? If the goal is a facility turning out 5 million tons of LNG, are you simply circling a different set of projects than FAST LNG would?
Karl Staubo
executiveI'd say we're also enthusiastic about the NFE deck. The way it looks to us, the two are strongly complementary. So, FAST LNG rests on liquefaction capacity that's somewhat smaller. It sits on the seabed rather than floating, obviously. That makes it, to a degree, better suited to shallower waters. A jackup, though, has no storage. So whatever cost edge you get from the liquefaction kit itself is partly eaten away by needing an FSU parked beside it. So our view — and NFE has stated this plainly in public on their calls multiple times — is that Golar's engineering team is helping NFE develop the FAST LNG solution. So we see the two technologies as strongly complementary. In our view, FAST LNG holds one really notable edge: being FAST. It fits certain geographies in shallow water very well, but for bigger stranded or associated gas projects in deeper waters, a floating unit becomes necessary purely because of water depth. In those cases, we can use our current Mark I; our Mark III design, which derives from a Mark I; and we're also examining our earlier Mark II design, if you recall it, which was essentially welded in midstream — or mid section. So we're fans of the FAST LNG. We're fans of our FLNG too. We don't view them as direct rivals. We view them as complementary, so to speak, working the same very appealing opportunity of producing cheap upstream gas.
Mike Webber
analystAnd does that $2.5 million represent roughly the CapEx needed for Mark III — how much — does it cover a meaningful quantity of equipment for separation and treatment, or would you still — would you still have to locate 5 million tons of fairly dry and clean gas in order to make use of that technology?
Karl Staubo
executiveThat's largely premised on, you could say, a gas pack comparable to a Mark I. Simply because Mark III is a newbuild, you get considerably greater deck space. So there is room to accommodate additional gas treatment, if that's what you'd like; yet one of the appealing aspects of our FLNG technology is that we aren't, you could say, tailored to a single particular gas field. We're reusable and redeployable. So we don't wish to make it, you could say, overly specific, though we can definitely add gas treatment. Clearly we are examining that given the both, associated and stranded gas fields we are evaluating at present; and from that analysis, I believe, the technology plus the stripping opportunities we have on board ought to be adequate to produce some of those fields.
Mike Webber
analystSure. Let me ask one more, then I'll hand it back. Once again, looking at slide 23, you brought up the intended allocation of NFE shares to Golar's stockholders. And pardon me if this has already been stated in public, but can you give us a rough estimate of how much of that stake you'd realistically expect to hand out to Golar's stockholders?
Karl Staubo
executiveAs we note in the press release, it depends on how GLNG and NFE compare in share price terms. It depends on growth projects coming up soon and, to a degree, it depends on GLNG's absolute share price. What that means is that if our shares keep trading at heavily depressed levels, then you more or less have to give away a larger portion of those NFE shares to your investors so the value can be unlocked; yet if you're able to put that capital to work in appealing near-term growth opportunities, which might run around 2 to 4 times EV EBITDA, as we pointed out during the presentation regarding integrated upstream opportunities. To a certain degree, we believe that could actually be superior to whatever investors might achieve if we simply distributed the cash. So from our standpoint, we'll balance those two options, though we won't hold onto the NFE shares merely for the sake of holding onto the NFE shares. And we won't pursue that if we believe there's a growth project five years away, since that wouldn't be the correct approach. In that case, we'd have to move much faster than that.
Omar Nokta
analystI’d like to focus on Hilli a little further, just to get a better handle on what the opportunity looks like. Regarding the ramp-up you anticipate, or the talks you’re holding for ramp-up in Q1 ‘22 — is that essentially about bringing train 3 up, or does it involve train 3 and 4 together, or is it really just maximizing trains 1 and 2? Any detail you can offer?
Karl Staubo
executiveAll right. We’ll do our best to provide as much detail as possible. Right now, we’re running train 1 and 2 at full capacity; however, since we have spare capacity and train 3 and 4 exist and are functioning well, occasionally we use train 3 and 4 for some overproduction. We also alternate which trains we produce from to ensure the ship remains at a very high level of capability. The main reason for the gradual deployment of incremental capacity on Hilli is the need to connect additional gas fields to produce the gas. Our assumption is that we’ll see partial utilization of increased capacity. So, to put it in terms of your question, Omar, we’re at full capacity on train 1 and 2, and we’re discussing partial utilization of train 3. But in practice, we’re shifting among all 4 trains to keep the vessel truly operational, though that’s our view.
Omar Nokta
analystAll right. Thank you, Karl. That's clear to me. And in that scenario, if you began putting 3 to partial use, would there be any additional CapEx you'd have to take on?
Karl Staubo
executiveNo. There's no CapEx, and only a very slight rise in OpEx.
Omar Nokta
analystOkay. All right. Then just one more thing — a final question on this. The Hilli's contract runs through 2026. I realize we're still five years away from that, but considering the situation across the commodity markets and the push for more upstream investment, has there been any discussion about an extension, or is that still premature?
Karl Staubo
executiveThe way we see it, we have no interest in prolonging that agreement unless we're compensated for the entire CapEx. As you know, we put money into 4 trains. Right now, only 2 are in use. So any conversation about expanding on the current side would have to involve the full capacity — or at minimum, we'd need to be paid for the unit's full capacity. At the same time, the integrated upstream model is looking more and more appealing to us, and having the vessel return in '26 might line up nicely if we could secure a gas field where we'd be able to put the ship to work. Another plus with Hilli is that she clearly has a demonstrated history; we know the vessel performs. That makes her appealing to parties who'd like to keep using her for tolling operations, and it's definitely appealing to us if we could generate our own gas reserve.
Sean Morgan
analystThe idea of shifting away from the pure tolling arrangement you've historically used with the FLNGs toward a more integrated upstream approach is something I find pretty interesting. So would you look to team up with an E&P, or would you perhaps venture beyond your comfort zone and aim to take on the production yourself along with all the operations that your partner traditionally handled off the vessel?
Karl Staubo
executiveWell, we certainly recognize the benefit of joining forces with a party that brings upstream capabilities; we also recognize that a number of oil producers out there are currently flaring or reinjecting associated gas, which represents lost opportunity for them and an opportunity for us to capture. Yet if that gas could be produced, it wouldn't just substantially enhance the carbon footprint of such oil production, it would also create very substantial incremental earnings for the field's owner, quite comparable to what Perenco has in Cameroon. So, in all likelihood we would aim for a region where an upstream partner is present. That said, we are currently examining a handful of different options.
Sean Morgan
analystAll right. Then turning to the ESG report you put out, I found it interesting that you cite carbon intensity 25% lower than, I suppose, your peers on land. So how exactly do you arrive at that figure? Also, does that basically reflect only current operations, leaving aside any possibility for producers of terrestrial LNG to reinject liquefied carbon? And could that be done offshore too?
Karl Staubo
executiveYes. So, assuming you mean the AER figure, now brought down from 9.95 to 8.71, that is essentially CO2 per ton mile. What gets us there is specific installations on border ships that raised efficiency; and regarding the FLNG, it is likewise greater utilization of the vessels that cut the carbon footprint on each MMBTU produced. So those are basically the main improvement areas. We keep examining other engineering tweaks, so to speak, that we can apply to our current asset portfolio to make things better. We have an internal group, which we call the green team, that works continuously on enhancements throughout the fleet. And we keep drawing on Golar’s innovative engineering capability to make improvements. And as you may have noticed in some of our earlier reports, we have, among other things, enhanced the cooling of our FSRU portfolio, now sold to NFE, where we managed to lower pure consumption by 15% to 20% through better cooling.
Sean Morgan
analystAll right. That largely concerns the fleet, then. Regarding FLNG versus something on land — what you called a mega project, I believe — what sort of savings show up in that case?
Karl Staubo
executiveThe primary reason is the liquefaction technology we use, which is efficient, plus the absence of any physical footprint for the vessels we put into service, since they float.
Ben Nolan
analystI'd like to revisit the situation involving Hilli and Perenco for a moment. From what I remember, during the prior quarter you mentioned — or at least it came up — that you had essentially delivered something like an ultimatum to them: unless a restructured contract was in place, I believe by the close of this year, you wouldn't be extending your agreement once the current term ran out. Is there anything new on that front? Specifically, how much confidence do you have that they've now been pushed to the negotiating table, and that this will actually result in greater duration and volume?
Karl Staubo
executiveOur confidence is quite high that a solution will be reached. The main reason is that there's money available for every party involved. That covers us, it covers Perenco, it covers the gas off-taker, and it definitely covers the local government. Given where gas prices stand today, the economics work well enough for everyone at the table. Because of that, we ought to see capacity go up. There were some regulatory hurdles that have now been worked through regarding production gaps. On top of that, there's growing confidence around adequate gas flow and gas tie-in to support higher production. We're confident we can deliver that added capacity starting essentially at the beginning of next year; though, as experience has taught us, nothing is finalized until it's finalized, yet we stay quite optimistic. And you could argue we believe we're nearer than we've ever been to reaching a resolution in the relatively near future.
Ben Nolan
analystAll right. And they would — as a piece of that, I guess, it would have to look at Q1 of the coming year, since the schedule has slid quite a bit across the past several years. Do you expect that first quarter of next year to be when volumes start rising and things get going in earnest?
Karl Staubo
executiveIt's reasonable to say that hasn't been sufficient. Naturally, we've been very eager to raise utilization for Hilli ever since she arrived on site. For a stretch, we had a gas price that wouldn't cooperate. After that came some regulatory difficulties regarding a cap on gas production that had to be worked out; and finally, there's a commercial agreement among the different parties. Where things stand at present, I'd say, is that everything except the commercial agreement is finished. Some of us at the table, I believe, are already in agreement; so it comes down to obtaining, I suppose, one or two more signatures on that agreement, and then it's complete. So I believe it makes a great deal of sense, as I mentioned, in economic terms for everybody involved. It makes every bit of sense. We're confident in that timing; and beyond that, we think gas flow as well as gas reserves back it up. And we've gained some visibility into that, which came after we pressed hard for quite a while. So, that's the time line we believe we're able to hit.
Ben Nolan
analystThen, finally, one more from me. You and Mike discussed FAST LNG a bit — how you're assisting the New Fortress team, and the notion that it's complementary. I get that it's complementary. It isn't identical, exactly, though certain parallels exist. What I wonder is why you didn't simply handle it on your own and keep them as an off-taker, or why that wasn't included in the structure, the way it would be with an FLNG unit. They're complementary, yet I'd imagine doing it falls well within what you're capable of.
Karl Staubo
executiveFor sure. To begin with, we hold a 9% stake in NFE. That story makes us quite optimistic; our view is that, taking in Hygo and GMLP, they've got a rather compelling future ahead. The advantage of that approach — locking in long-term, guaranteed supply of gas at a fixed price — is clear to us. That partly drives our desire to make sure our NFE investment keeps — or at minimum shows — positive momentum. Across upstream as a whole, I'd say we're weighing various options. On one call tied to the merger announcement, Mr. Wes Edens noted that we could, as time goes on, consider forming some kind of shared upstream entity or shared holding company. When we evaluate upstream investment, particularly the integrated model, a major draw is this: you secure enough off-take to cover every project cost, then you're exposed on the open capacity, which effectively gives you a cash breakeven of zero. Everything beyond that becomes profit. So a party like NFE would clearly be an appealing off-taker. Following the Hygo acquisition, they definitely have enough demand to serve as a substantial off-taker. That ought to make it a win-win for us. In that respect, absolutely nothing is set in stone. Still, it's plainly a group we like collaborating with. Our sense is they've done a great deal of — sort of clearing the path for downstream growth and downstream adoption of FLNG. And on the upstream side, we do notice certain synergies.
Greg Lewis
analystHey Karl, it's the top of the hour now. So I'll keep it to a single question. I'm just hoping for a bit more detail about where things stand today with New Fortress Energy, since you're collaborating with them. Are you being compensated as a consultant — do you receive a service fee, or do you hold something like a right of first refusal on the project, or the option to put money into it? Or is it truly just that you're working alongside them, and should something come together, you'd then work out how to gain from it? Is there any sort of formal agreement in writing?
Karl Staubo
executiveOkay. So, in connection with the merger — and this has largely become public. But, regarding how the assets they bought from us are operated, we carry on operating them from a technical standpoint, and there are also specific transition services that we keep providing from Golar to NFE; for those services, we receive the fee that was agreed in advance. For anything beyond those fees, we are essentially compensated on a consultancy basis. But, for some development projects, we view it as an investment, for both our side and NFE, and as a way to boost the value of NFE. So, I believe it depends on precisely which parts of the services you're asking about; but, generally speaking, we are paid for the hours put into such projects; and then, regarding cooperation past that, I've mentioned that we enjoy a very strong relationship at essentially every level of the two organizations. And it's somewhat more of a play-it-by-ear approach; and then, should we identify an appealing solution, we'll determine how we might potentially build it out jointly, or, if it's more logical, pursue it independently; so, some things we do jointly, and some things we do on our own; and I believe we share a reasonably solid grasp of the different objectives of the two groups.
Greg Lewis
analystAll right, excellent; and then only one — all right, yes, that works well. I appreciate everyone giving us your time.
Karl Staubo
executiveI appreciate it.
Liam Burke
analystThanks. Hello, Karl. Karl, you brought up the fresh Mark design and the shift away from tolling. Returns for both Hilli and Gimi are extremely robust. How does the return profile look for that new design, and then for stepping back from tolling?
Karl Staubo
executiveOne way to frame this: if a party is ready to hire a unit from you, they have to turn a profit by hiring it from you. So the way we approached it is, sure, we earn solid returns on tolling; sure, we'll keep pursuing tolling deals whenever we judge the returns attractive enough; however, if you simply consider today's gas price and the earnings of those essentially leasing FLNG capacity from us, what we receive is nearly trivial next to theirs. And given the cash breakeven cushion you hold relative to past gas prices, we believe it could be highly compelling if we could generate gas on our own behalf or at minimum participate in that arbitrage. So, in our view, you shouldn't assume we'd abandon tolling fees completely, yet we've kind of taken a second or somewhat closer examination and recognized that the genuine economics sit upstream, provided you can also gain exposure to the gas sales price.
Liam Burke
analystGreat. Moving on to the FLNG designs, you have FAST LNG as well as the Mark series. Do any rival designs exist in the market, or are you innovating ahead by offering something quicker and less expensive?
Karl Staubo
executivePetronas operates the floating FLNG unit. Shell owns the Prelude, and Exmar owns the Tango. So other companies definitely are engaged in floating liquefaction of some kind. I believe nobody has — well, we have delivered more cargos than anyone else. And second, I doubt any competitor offers a lower cost per ton liquefied; combining our cost points, our performance track record, and the rather fast speed to market, I believe we stack up very well against peers. And BP having embraced our FLNG technology, I think, is additional proof that they don't perceive a superior option in the market.
Karl Staubo
executiveAppreciate everyone joining the call. We’re grateful for the attention on Golar. The future has us genuinely enthusiastic. At long last, it appears we’ve got some momentum at our backs in each of our business areas. And we’re eager to talk with all of you before long. Thanks.
Operator
operatorSo, that does conclude our conference for today. You may all disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Golar LNG Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Golar LNG Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Golar LNG Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.