HDFC Asset Management Company Limited (HDFCAMC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 9, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and welcome to the HDFC Asset Management Company Q4 and full-year FY '20 earnings conference call, which ICICI Securities Limited is hosting. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll turn the conference over to Mr. Jaideep Goswami, Head of Equities at ICICI Securities. Thank you, and over to you, sir.
Jaideep Goswami
unknownThanks, Raymond. Good afternoon to our investors and everyone else joining us. It's a real pleasure and an honor for us to have the chance to host this quarterly and annual conference call for HDFC Asset Management Company, and we're joined by Mr. Milind Barve, our Managing Director; Mr. Piyush Surana, our Chief Financial Officer; and Mr. Simal Kanuga, our Chief Investor Relations Officer. With that said, I'll turn things over to Simal for his opening remarks. Simal, the floor is yours.
Simal Kanuga
executiveYes. Thank you, Jaideep, and thank you to the team at ICICI Securities for hosting this call. We had to push this call back, so please accept our apologies for that. So, good evening, everyone. We hope that each of you and your loved ones are safe in these very unusual times. I'll begin with a brief overview of the industry, and then I'll cover the key aspects of our performance for the year and the quarter ended March 2020. Milind and Piyush are on the call to take questions after that. On the industry, the quarterly average AUM for the industry was INR 27 trillion for the quarter ended March '20, which is a growth of 10% over March 2019. The QA AUM in equity-oriented funds came in at INR 10.4 trillion, a growth of 7% year-on-year. Against INR 10.4 trillion of QA AUM in equities, the closing AUM as of March 31, '20 for equity-oriented assets was INR 8.3 trillion. The corresponding closing AUM as of March '19 stood at INR 10.2 trillion. That decline is due to nothing other than the fall in markets. The systematic investment plan flows for the month of March '20 held up resiliently at INR 86 billion. We'll now move to us.
Simal Kanuga
executiveFor the March '20 quarter, our assets under management came to INR 3,698 billion, compared with INR 3,423 billion in March of 2019 — that's growth of 8%. In QA AUM, we hold a 13.7% market share. As of March 31, 2020, closing AUM stands at INR 3,191 billion, with market share of 14.3%. To be more specific, QA AUM for actively managed equity-oriented assets in the quarter ended March '20 was INR 1,574 billion, whereas closing AUM as of March '20 was INR 1,200 billion. The decline in closing AUM relative to QA AUM is attributable to the sharp market correction, as shown by a 23% fall in the NIFTY 50 during March 2020. April's market gains have pushed AUM higher, and how our equity asset revenues develop from here will hinge on market conditions over the coming few months. At present, we run 221 branches. Live accounts number 9.4 million, and we employ 1,194 people. Equity's share of total AUM stood at 48% in March '19 and has declined to 38% in March '20 — again, chiefly because equity markets fell.
Simal Kanuga
executiveFor March '20, our individual monthly average AUM came in at 57.2% of total AUM, compared with 52.2% for the industry. Individual investors keep favoring us above all others, and we hold a 15% share of individual AUM. Our count of unique investors is 5.6 million, versus 20.8 million for the industry overall. Systematic transaction flows in March '20 totaled INR 11.3 billion, spread across 3.29 million transactions. In the B30 market we remain the #2 player, with an 11.9% share. We'd like to point out that the business is fully functional and has carried on as before in spite of the lockdown. As an illustration: during February 2020, we processed 650,000 transactions. In March, even with the extensive steps taken to limit workforce and the eventual full lockdown, we processed 1.03 million transactions. Slide #15 of the presentation, which has been uploaded to our website and to the exchanges' websites, gives you a snapshot of how we have dealt with the situation so far and the steps we continue to take on this matter. I'll now turn to financials. Before diving into the numbers, it's worth noting that the results for the year ended March 2020 carry a significant onetime impact from an unrealized loss that was recognized.
Simal Kanuga
executiveRegarding our holdings and securities in SL Group: the total unrealized loss booked for the financial year that closed in March 2020 comes to INR 1,203.6 million, which is INR 120 crores. As of March 31, 2020, the carrying value of those NCDs stood at INR 294.21 million. That leaves a residual figure of INR 29.4 crores now. The collateral was valued at INR 358.78 million as of March 31, 2020. Nonrecurring expenses came to INR 400 million in the prior financial year. With that in mind, we are also disclosing our PBT and PAT adjusted for these one-off and nonrecurring expenses. Let me turn to the annual figures. For the full financial year, operating profit for the year ended March 2020 came in at INR 15,129 million, versus INR 11,931 million for March of '19 — a rise of 27%. PBT before nonrecurring items for the financial year ended March '20 was INR 17,734 million, compared with INR 14,147 million for March '19, up 25%. Because of nonrecurring items, though, PBT for the financial year ended March '20 rose 20% to INR 16,531 million, against INR 13,747 million for March '19.
Simal Kanuga
executivePAT, once more, before nonrecurring items, for the financial year that ended in March 2020 stood at INR 13,526 million, versus INR 9,613 million for March '19 — a rise of 41%. But because of nonrecurring items, PAT for the financial year ended March '20 came in at INR 12,625 million, compared with INR 9,306 million, which works out to an increase of 36%. Turning to the quarterly figures, the final quarter of the financial year was marked by mounting uncertainty as the COVID-19 pandemic emerged and affected markets around the world. That caused AUMs to decline throughout our industry, which hurt revenues. Operating profit for the quarter ended March 2020 was INR 3,562 million, against INR 3,534 million for March of 2019 — up 1%. PBT nonrecurring -- before nonrecurring items, for the quarter ended March '20 was INR 4,250 million, versus INR 4,244 million for March '19, an increase of 0.13%. Due to nonrecurring items, though, PBT for the quarter ended March '20 fell by 20% to INR 3,297 million, compared with INR 4,146 million as of March '19. PAT before nonrecurring items for the quarter ended March '20 was INR 3,213 million, against INR 2,837 million for March '19 — an increase of 13%.
Simal Kanuga
executiveBut then again, because of nonrecurring items, profit after tax for the quarter that ended in March '20 came in at INR 2,500 million, versus INR 2,762 million for March '19 — a decline of 9%. For the financial year ended March '20, our operating profit margin, expressed as a percentage of average AUM, stands at 41 basis points. The figure for the prior financial year was 37 basis points. A dividend of INR 28 per share has been proposed by the Board of Directors, and it remains subject to approval by shareholders. Thank you for listening so patiently. Stay safe, everyone. We'll now open the floor for questions. Milind and Piyush are very much here to take questions, if any. Raymond, if you can start taking questions, please?
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question comes from Parthiv Shah, who is calling in from Tracom Stock Broking.
Parthiv Shah
analystSir, my question concerns the whole of this year, which looks extremely tough, particularly for profitable equity AUM, especially given that equity portfolios are on average down by 20% and the outlook for the remainder of the year also does not seem very great. So a ballpark figure of at least a 20% hit on your equity AUM in terms of the income. So I was just trying to get a sense of how you are planning to recoup this particular loss for this year? Any sort of increase in the direct plans expense ratio? Or any sort of measures which can help you give levers for lower OpEx and thereby increasing your margins? So just want to get a sense of that.
Milind Barve
executiveYes. Thanks for asking that. You're correct in how you're viewing it — this year, yes, what we're seeing is that we began the year with equity AUM, or actively managed equity AUM, that is materially below both the average for the last year and the quarterly average. It's also just as important that roughly 73% to 75% of the revenue we generate comes from equity-oriented funds. So the drop in equity AUM levels is going to affect the company's revenues. I do believe — we do believe — that since the working environment has shifted and now, predominantly, business — at least during the first month of April and in the last quarter of March — has largely been conducted through digital platforms, this will actually result in some meaningful reduction in operating expenses. So making a very accurate estimate of how much of the revenue loss can be recouped would be difficult. That said, we remain cautiously optimistic regarding recovery in the markets from where they stood on 31st of March, when we earlier reported our numbers.
Milind Barve
executiveDuring April, the markets gained roughly 6 or 7 points. As a result, our equity AUM has risen above where it stood on March 31, though what lies ahead depends heavily on how dispersed and how long-lasting the COVID pandemic and the lockdown prove to be, as well as on how the lockdown affects markets over the near term. That said, I should note that investor appetite for equity — or for equity products — is still quite healthy. Even during March, flows into equity mutual fund products were reasonably strong, totaling almost INR 11,000 crores in March alone. In fact, the industry posted its highest quarterly close of INR 29,000 crores in the fourth quarter of March '20. So we stay cautiously optimistic on two fronts: a, regarding the market's recovery; and b, we will be quite prudent, and we will — we will spare no effort when it comes to cutting operating costs in these difficult times.
Parthiv Shah
analystAnd sir, I’d also like to get a clearer picture here. You said that during March, equity AUM grew across the whole industry. Measured as a percentage, how did HDFC AMC do when it comes to gaining market share in equity AUM?
Milind Barve
executiveAs my colleague already pointed out regarding market share, we did see some decline compared with a year earlier. Still, it's worth keeping in mind that we continue to be the biggest manager of actively managed equity funds. Our product mix therefore stays quite robust relative to competitors. That gives us a reasonably solid mix on the product side, and on top of that, our liability franchise is very strong when you look at our portion of the industry's retail AUM.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Parag with White Oak Capital.
Parag Jariwala
analystYes, sir. I have two questions. The first concerns equity AUM, where we have TER. Suppose the AUM actually drops and the TER falls into a lower bucket that lets us charge customers a somewhat higher TER. In that case, does the payout to distributors stay at the earlier TER, or does it rise? So what I mean — what I'm really asking is whether there's any room for us to raise our net yield. That's the first one. Second, on SIP, if you could share some color on the people who are dropping out or canceling their SIPs — a bit of their profile, whether self-employed, salaried, et cetera — that would be very helpful.
Milind Barve
executiveRegarding your first question about the TER change — yes, it's true that as AUM decreases, the applicable TER rises slightly, marginally. So starting in April, if there's a decline in the product's total AUM — and I'm referring to equity funds here — we'll be able to charge a marginally higher TER under the SEBI guidelines. That said, distributor commission isn't tied to the TER, and it will stay the same as before for basic plans. To that extent, we don't think it will be very material. But yes, margins will improve marginally due to the lower AUM and the resulting rise in the chargeable TER. So there will probably be a small margin improvement. I don't know — it's very hard to predict whether it will be material or not. But to answer your question, distributor commissions are all basis points of AUM, and they will remain constant.
Parag Jariwala
analystAnd then, sir, regarding SIPs?
Milind Barve
executiveRegarding SIP, yes, I believe we're still seeing fresh SIP inflows and new SIP registrations. There are stretches when investors choose to stop their SIPs, and they also tend to — some SIPs simply reach the end of the term they were originally signed for, while in other cases SIPs get cancelled early. That said, I should point out — I think this is covered in our presentation — that a very high percentage of our SIPs carry a 5-year commitment, and a very high percentage of our SIPs are signed for more than 10 years. So from that standpoint, the people signing up for SIPs are making a genuinely meaningful commitment. It isn't the case that a SIP runs for just a few months or a few — 1 year or 2 year; people are still signing SIPs for 5 years and 10 years.
Parag Jariwala
analystTurning to cancellations, though—what I'm getting at is whether that figure is tied to something else, or are you seeing more cancellations now than in earlier quarters or months? Or has it stayed flat?
Milind Barve
executiveCancellations don't really follow any set pattern. A certain level of cancellation occurs regardless of whether markets are performing well or performing poorly. So SIP remains a fairly substantial component of the flow into our total AUM, as we've illustrated on the slide. That's essentially the order book sitting in our hands. For instance, as of March we still had INR 1,100 crores coming purely from SIP flow. So we rank among the major players in the SIP segment, and that provides us with assured flows into our equity funds going forward.
Operator
operatorWe’ll take the next question from Yashodhan Nerurkar at PPFAS Mutual Fund.
Yash Nerurkar
analystOkay, so I’ve got about 3 questions, and I think one of them has been partly addressed already, so I’ll move on to the remaining 2. First, at present, as we all know — and I mean this is an entirely different scenario, a sort of black swan event — going forward, after this entire crisis is behind us, what is your strategy going to be? Would it look like working from home, with perhaps half the team doing so? And in what way would transactions be preferred and accepted — through the digital medium, or some other preferred channel? Second, at the moment, since nearly everyone finds themselves in the same boat, do you feel there’s a need to give IFAs somewhat more incentive? Or do you see competition emerging from other players who are attempting to offer IFAs more incentives, even though many of them are actually going through a genuinely tough period? So simply to capture more sales or build more AUM — I mean, is that what you people are intending to do?
Milind Barve
executiveAt this point, making a highly precise forecast about how the pandemic and the lockdown will play out strikes me as very difficult. Still, one can observe that in the near term, the style and method of working that involves having so many people in offices, with people walking into offices, at least in the near future, does not appear to be the business model, at least over the coming 1 or 2 quarters, given the need — rightly so — for social distancing. There will be a requirement — and only a limited amount of travel and commuting is being permitted. For a considerable period of time, I believe — and I hope I'm wrong about this — we will be seeing business that comes through on digital platforms, both via distributors and via the HDFC MF online platforms. As you know, multiple digital platforms are available. A number of distribution houses have their own digital platform. Stock exchanges have digital platforms. There is NSE, and then there is HDFC MF online. So people are choosing various types of digital platforms to access mutual funds, to carry out their transactions for buying and selling.
Milind Barve
executiveI do agree with you that this could mark the start of a shift in what may develop as a way of working. As a company and as a policy, we would encourage more working from home if that helps reduce the possibility of risks to the riders, and that would be the approach. And I must tell you that since the lockdown was announced in the last week of March, almost all of our operations, as far as client-facing goes, are fully operational. We are working from home and everyone has been digitally empowered, so to speak, and connected to the office. Even sales people are making their calls over the phone without having to meet in person. So yes, there is a redefining of the business method, or the method of doing business and the style of doing business, at least in the near term. I think the hardship from this is felt equally, whether it is a fund house, whether it's the distributor, and most importantly, the retail investor as well. And I think we are not, at least right now, looking at repricing anything on our products — of our products.
Yash Nerurkar
analystAlright, that answered what I asked. I just had one more question, if that's okay?
Milind Barve
executiveCorrect.
Yash Nerurkar
analystSo what trends are you seeing right now? In other words, is there a shift among those investors who previously put money into debt funds or balance funds? And after everything that happened with Franklin Templeton, are they moving more toward equity?
Milind Barve
executiveHonestly, we don't have data that backs this up industry-wide. And I think, as to whether — sure, when people are — if they're pulling money out of certain debt funds, they're — a lot of them are doing what's known as a switch out into another fund. Either they're switching into other debt funds that they feel comfortable with. Even inside the same fund house, the requests are to switch into another debt fund of that same fund house. So it's not necessarily the case that people are withdrawing money from mutual funds and leaving debt altogether. But it's very hard right now, and also very premature, to establish and to think about whether there's a very particular, distinct pattern regarding where that money is going. There is definitely some trend of moving, within debt funds themselves, toward whatever the investor perceives as a safer debt fund.
Operator
operatorMoving on, our next question comes from Saurabh Kumar at JPMorgan.
Saurabh Kumar
analystI’ve just got a single question about that market share loss, looking at it both on a December basis and on a March basis from last year. Sir, if you had to split it between essentially the front book and the existing AUM — I mean, the back book — would the loss be larger on the back book side, meaning this is the performance? Or is it that you would have lost on the flows as well?
Milind Barve
executiveTo be clear, we aren't sharing flow figures since they tend to be rather uneven from one month to the next. That said, I'd note our AUM has dropped a bit more sharply, due in part to how certain of our funds—or one of the larger ones—have performed. It's also fair to point out that while the industry holds roughly 10% of its AUM in small and mid-cap, our equity AUM sits nearer 20% in small-cap and mid-cap funds. Ours is the biggest mid-cap fund—well, one of the biggest; in fact, it is the biggest. We also run a fairly sizable small-cap fund. And I believe the hit, or the effect, that markets have had on this set of shares by market cap has been heavier. In that sense, beyond the marginal state on performance, our fund house would have felt an impact.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAll right. And regarding this front book — really, when it comes to the flows, based on what you understand, it's obviously hard for us to obtain that. But from your perspective, would you be keeping your market share where it is now? Or...
Milind Barve
executiveMaking projections is really tough. Take the flows, for instance — in the industry, we saw INR 67,000 crores of flows over the last year. What's interesting is that the last quarter turned out to be the strongest, at almost INR 30,000 crores, so nearly half of the flows came in that final quarter. So I think the markets — flows respond to how people are feeling about the markets, whether they're reasonably priced, and so on. But I think the good thing — and I can mention that NSE announced the April number yesterday, I think, in the evening. I think it's been published at about INR 5,500 crores or something, which is INR 5,000 crores-plus, so that's a fairly good number. It's a fairly resilient number, showing that flows and interest in equity are still there. Making projections on market share and projections on flows themselves is very difficult.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAlright, sir. Sir, only one further question from me. What I mean is, if — well, there are a few funds that parent companies have placed up for sale. So would you be — I mean, since you've got the balance sheet and the market capitalization, would inorganic be something you'd at least be open to?
Milind Barve
executiveYeah, strategy-wise, we’re always willing to examine what could be tactically synergetic to acquire and to use our listed shares as currency. That said, it’s just as true that we have — there’s nothing under active consideration right now.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Roshan Chutkey, who is calling in from ICICI Prudential Asset Management.
Roshan Chutkey
analystI want to state something first, and then I'd like you to tell me whether you agree with it. Over the next 4 years, as the old book churns and new flows arrive, the management fee as a share of AUM will probably decline gradually. Basically, the trail payouts on the incremental source are high. Do you agree with that?
Milind Barve
executiveThe trail is already steady. At this point, there won’t be any additional rise in the trail. The trail is a fixed figure, and it will not go up. It will rise proportionally with the growth in AUM. But you’re correct, if you mean the trail on the book as well as — or relative to the trail on the flows, then the trail on the flow is somewhat greater than the trail on the book. That’s accurate.
Roshan Chutkey
analystSo as the legacy book turns over and fresh inflows arrive, the ratio of your asset management fee to MF AUM ought to worsen, correct? The yield on revenue, right?
Milind Barve
executiveIn theory, you're correct. But the actual situation is that the book doesn't churn all that quickly. Many investors are long-standing ones who remain invested for a long period. So no data indicates that a given X percentage of the book must necessarily churn. Actually, we see plenty of investors who are genuinely long term — long term meaning, say, 5- or 10-year investors. Those people don't churn. Someone who joined 1 year ago, if unhappy, will churn. That makes it very hard to estimate with real accuracy how much the margin will drop from flows affecting the book. Conceptually, though, you're right that due to cost, the trail on flows exceeds the trail on the book. As more flows enter the book, the book's margin will decline. To elaborate, this year, on an industry AUM of INR 10,00,000 crores, industry flows were INR 67,000 crores into the book. So new flows are roughly 6%, 6.5% of the book now. Basically, that's not a very material number.
Milind Barve
executiveI'm referring to the industry figure here, simply to illustrate the point. As a share of the book, industry flow has reached a level this year as low as 6%.
Operator
operatorUmang Shah from Arohi Asset Management has the next question.
Umang Shah
analystFirst quick question: quarter over quarter, we noticed a modest increase in other operating expenses. Could you explain what's behind that?
Milind Barve
executivePiyush, would you like to handle this one?
Piyush Surana
executiveYeah, so there's a one-time item of roughly INR 9 crores in there, tied to the settlement — you may have seen the settlement order. That's basically what drove the uptick. Just to expand on that a bit. So that, and you'd also have picked up on the MTM loans. With those 2 things, this whole SL matter we were up against last year appears to have wrapped up — just wanted to make sure of that.
Umang Shah
analystBut Piyush, sir, wouldn't that show up in other income, right? Not in the other effects?
Piyush Surana
executiveUnderstood.
Milind Barve
executiveNo, no, no. That's not right—you're...
Piyush Surana
executiveMPF, that could show up in other income, but there was a regulatory matter that had been pending tied to it, and that has also now been closed. And we paid certain interest to the FMP investors and the FMPs involved, along with some settlement fees. So that is now closed.
Umang Shah
analystUnderstood. Understood. So, yes. Sir, my other question was that I was simply examining the regular and direct TERs across a number of funds within the same category. So I was looking at the HDFC multi-cap scheme, and I was looking at the other multi-cap scheme. Now let me just read out a few numbers that I had. For April '20, the regular TER of your multi-cap fund stood at 1.5, and the direct one was roughly 0.9. That therefore left a trail of 0.6. Now, for the other funds, I will cite some names such as Axis, which has 1.7 for regular and 0.4 for direct, leaving a trail of 1.3. And there is Kotak at 1.5 and 0.6, leaving a trail of 0.9. So when you look at the trail that you have, yours appears to be the lowest, and that too by a sizable margin. So here I just wanted to get a sense of how you think about this with respect to IFAs recommending your schemes, et cetera?
Milind Barve
executiveLet me address that. I'll point out that certain schemes of ours — HDFC Equity Fund, for instance, which is a multi-cap fund; Top 200, a fund with a very long history; and Balance Advantage, formerly known as Prudence Fund — these are quite old funds, and we have many investors and distributors who have stayed loyal to us as investors. They also receive the commission that has been paid since earlier times, and over time that commission has gone up and come down. So there is a substantial amount of old AUM, as I was explaining a moment ago when answering another question. The trail fees paid on the book are quite low. Meanwhile, the trail fees paid on the flow are somewhat higher than those on the book. So as things stand today, we think we are fairly competitive when it comes to our trail commissions. Regarding the example you cited in the multi-cap space concerning this Equity Fund — we are competitive, and we retain the option at all times to revisit our trail commission with distributors should we judge there is a need to raise it or lower it.
Milind Barve
executiveStill, the reality is that you perhaps—there's no way to be viewed as, say, comparing one fund house's trail to another's and attempting to treat them as equal. Trail commissions, I'd say, are typically prohibited. And provided we remain within an acceptable ban, that tends to be regarded as a decent amount. Yet preserving overall business margin becomes very hard if you wish to be seen as the top payer. Whoever pays the most ends up with the smallest margin. So from a stakeholder's perspective, that's an additional consequence.
Umang Shah
analystUnderstood, sir. My final question is this: when you examine how HDFC AMC performed between 2008 and 2012, the period when the GFC took place, your overall AUM swung very sharply. Even so, you succeeded in holding on to your revenues and in raising your PAT. So could you walk us through how, in spite of those AUM swings during that stretch, you were able to keep that growth and keep those revenue figures?
Milind Barve
executiveI'd say there are 2 things here, and I'll answer at a high level. First, we place a very strong emphasis on the high-margin equity business, and that continues to be the core. As I noted, nearly 75% of our revenue last year came from equity AUM, mostly mutual fund revenues. So one point is a very strong focus on the profitable part of the market segment, which is equity business or actively managed equity. That's one thing that has helped. And the second is that we keep extremely strong control over operating costs and expenses. And as we understand it, the key to managing this business lies in optimizing the high-margin business as much as possible and keeping a very prudent level of cost control so as to maintain operating costs. So I think that's the key, which is not only followed in those years, we -- but we keep following year after year. As we've shown in our presentation deck, our operating profit margin has been maintained at 41 basis points. And when you look at some of the key cost elements in it, we've been able to contain both employee cost and other operating expenses at a significantly low basis points of the industry -- of our AUM.
Milind Barve
executiveI'd say we're probably near the bottom on that measure, given these cost levels. Take employee cost, for instance — it's only about 5.5 basis points of AUM, and operating expenses add roughly another 6.5 or 7 basis points. So in my view, keeping an eye on cost matters just as much as working to improve margins by going after the higher-margin equity business.
Operator
operatorMoving on, our following question comes from Haresh Kapoor, who is calling in on behalf of IIFL Asset Management.
Haresh Kapoor
analystI'm just trying to get a handle on what actually went on this quarter. On a quarterly average AUM basis, your AUM fell 3.3%, with equity down 5.3%. Those are probably the main indicators on average AUM, and they're down — yet your revenues are down around 10% quarter on quarter. So is there some yield movement happening on the debt funds, or any other particular line items like that, which is why your revenue line item is down about 10% on a Q-on-Q basis?
Milind Barve
executiveLook, on a broad basis, when the mix of products includes less equity — and clearly, during the last quarter, we witnessed something unusual, a 23% drop in the market within just 1 month — that damaged the averages for the year. It likewise shifted the product mix. The mix changed from having more equity within total AUM to having less equity AUM. But it lowers the overall productivity of the AUM. So essentially, what's happened is there's no material change in margins. As a matter of fact, margins during the quarter stayed fairly stable. It's mainly the composition of total AUM, which had a bigger equity component in the December quarter and now carries a smaller equity component in the March quarter. That's the answer.
Piyush Surana
executiveOn top of that, just to add, you'll recall that during the December quarter we also had some additional performance fee on our advisory mandate. That's the reason revenue for that quarter came in a bit higher. So it wouldn't be — you're not making an apples-to-apples comparison when you look at those 2 revenue figures.
Haresh Kapoor
analystAlright, and the second point, just regarding this SIP transaction and so on. So for March, the figures you provided on Slide 11, and clearly, that was lower. But how has momentum been on your side? Since December through March, obviously that's a decline, but looking forward at market share losses on the SIP book specifically, if you could speak to that and how that trend is developing?
Milind Barve
executiveI think, yes, we'd want to reverse the trend of — sorry, reverse what we hope isn't a trend of somewhat lower SIP, because as you can see year over year, it isn't a material fall. And clearly, what happens is there's a bit of an incumbency disadvantage, since we've been running this SIP for the last 10, 12 years. We were the ones talking about SIPs when everyone else was discussing which product, while we were talking about doing SIP. So what's also happened is that we have a lot of SIPs compared with the industry that are going through their normal expiry process. Someone signed up for an SIP for 3 year or 5 year or 7 year, and that period is also coming to an end. It's true that some SIPs are being cancelled. So we'll try to focus attention on trying to reverse this trend as much as we can. And SIP still remains a reasonably meaningful part of our flows. Having said that, I — we believe we're a reasonably good player in terms of our SIP book as well as the flow we get per month.
Milind Barve
executiveOn our presentation deck, I believe we show a March SIP figure of nearly INR 1,100 crores, which I would call a fairly material amount. And so, if I can count on INR 1,100 crores of SIP flows each month, that is a fairly good number. Of course, we do acknowledge that it has declined from the level seen in the prior quarter.
Haresh Kapoor
analystNow, regarding market share on the debt side—clearly, something has happened in the market involving one of the AMCs. Earlier, during one of the other market shocks a couple of years ago, you picked up market share on the debt side. So are you already seeing that trend in April, with market share gains occurring on the debt side? Or is it more or less status quo right now, where some trends could emerge later? Or have you already seen that trend?
Milind Barve
executiveMy sense is that a shift is occurring—to some degree, money is moving out of debt funds and into liquid and overnight funds. And as we've likely said before, our portion of the liquid fund has grown substantially, both in averages and in closing AUM. What we're seeing in April is that the liquid and overnight business has grown considerably in size. So some safe-haven investing is taking place. And since we are fortunately the strong brand, we are the obvious beneficiaries of that trend.
Operator
operatorNischint from Kotak has the next question.
Nischint Chawathe
analystMilind, I'm sure you've been in constant contact with distributors. In your most recent conversations, what do they actually expect from you? What sort of support are they truly looking for from you? What should you be doing for them so they can perform at their best? I suppose there isn't much you can do about market movements, or for that matter, appetite or the wallet that can flow into equity mutual funds. But when it comes to support, what is it that they are really hoping to get from you?
Milind Barve
executiveI mean, when you're asking this during such challenging times — unusual and difficult in so many ways — the distributors are doing a fantastic job of remaining connected with their constituents and, in turn, with their clients, as those clients come to them with questions, whether that's regarding the market, equity, or debt. And I think the key thing that we, and especially our investment team, have been concentrating on almost daily is that we're running 3 to 4 conference calls and webinars. A lot of these involve distributors, and sometimes, at the distributors' request, they're held directly with investors. Such an elevated volume of investor calls, of information sharing, of news sharing and handholding across the whole industry — I've never witnessed anything like it. We are very much at the leading edge, engaging with anyone who wishes to speak with a fund manager, anyone who wants a call — arranging calls with these investors, and we support that. I think what clients and distributors most want is a view — at minimum a considered view — on what we believe the possibilities are in the market, especially in equity, and on what the right actions for customers are at this moment.
Milind Barve
executiveAnd I believe that’s exactly where we’re strongly committed, and our investment team, together with support from the sales team, is doing plenty of that kind of engagement. Any time I try to call or talk with a fund manager, I’m always told that he’s on a call, or he’s on a webinar, or he’s in some conference meeting with other distributors, groups of distributors, or sometimes a group of clients. Second, this is essential — because the present situation truly demands some extraordinary handholding for distributors, who in turn remain connected with investors. And that’s how — that’s what we’re involved in.
Operator
operatorMadhukar Ladha from HDFC Securities has the next question.
Madhukar Ladha
analystTo start, I want to follow up on what Roshan raised a bit earlier. Milind, I believe you said something about 6% of the flow. I didn't quite catch that portion. Could you go over it again?
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So I think, you see, quite often when people attempt to model growth in AUM — particularly in the equity book, the equity book, as you know, is affected by flows. It's affected by market movement. Those are the 2 primary drivers of AUM in equity. So the point I was making is that on opening assets under management, the industry had roughly INR 10,00,000 crores of assets under management in the equity book at an industry level, which is approximately INR 10,00,000 crores. And the net flow, that is the net purchases or net inflow into equity mutual funds during the financial year '19-'20, came to about INR 67,000 crores. So I was trying to — so the point I was making, that the flow as a percentage of the book, the book at the start of the year and the flow during the year, the flow was around 6.5% or 6.7%. That is the point I was making.
Madhukar Ladha
analystRight. But sir, wouldn't it matter to examine gross outflow first and then gross inflow? Because if outflows run higher from a back-book standpoint, that could genuinely hit our commission trails. Our commission trails could grow more. So perhaps that 6% figure might not actually give us the clearest picture. And I believe churn has been pretty high too when you look at the gross numbers.
Milind Barve
executiveI don't see any reason to think churn is inevitable. Actually, when I answered an earlier question, I noted that many long-standing investors would rather keep their money in place. Occasionally a newer investor, if their experience over a short stretch hasn't been good, will try to exit. So we have no specific data indicating that a large number of old investors are leaving and that gross flows are therefore necessarily being added to the book. In theory, you're correct that gross flow is what you have to examine. On a net basis, though, it also matters to know who is leaving. And making a really precise prediction of whether the person exiting is a high-commission client or a low-commission client is very difficult.
Madhukar Ladha
analystGot it, sir. Just a few more questions from me. First, our investment book stands at roughly INR 3,944 crores on the balance sheet, correct? So, what share of that is equity?
Milind Barve
executiveOur equity exposure is essentially nonexistent. There's just a very minor position, and that's the mandatory requirement to invest...
Madhukar Ladha
analystJust the sponsor commitments.
Milind Barve
executiveEquity is the sole area where we put money. Beyond that, we hold a really tiny position in a few AIFs — pardon me, venture funds — which could themselves contain some equity and unlisted holdings. You should...
Madhukar Ladha
analystCould you provide that overall percentage—just a rough total percentage figure if possible?
Milind Barve
executiveOn the equity side, that figure is quite small. Piyush, could you say what portion of our AUM is in equity?
Piyush Surana
executiveYeah, that comes to somewhere in the range of INR 100 crores to INR 125 crores, and that figure takes in the mandatory investments Milind mentioned a moment ago.
Madhukar Ladha
analystAll right, understood. Your tax rate looks somewhat low to me. My guess is that part of the reason relates to the way this M2M is actually taxed. Could you provide us with...
Piyush Surana
executiveAnd that's why it's low as well, since we continue putting money in and holding those investments for 3 years before we sort of redeem.
Madhukar Ladha
analystRight, so that's the reason they get taxed as long-term capital gains.
Piyush Surana
executiveYeah, that's right, that's right, that's right.
Madhukar Ladha
analystAll right, all right, good. And, Piyush, I believe you said there was that international mandate last quarter — I guess some advisory fee stemming from it. And that was deposited during the last quarter. Doesn't it accrue each quarter? Or why does it show up in December? And...
Piyush Surana
executiveThere are also a couple of pieces to these kinds of mandates. The first is the standard fee, and that tends to be fairly small. Then there's the performance fee, which makes up a bigger portion, when it clears the performance thresholds. That's the situation we saw in December, and it explains the increase we recorded that month.
Madhukar Ladha
analystThat was driven by performance fees, then. Okay. And last, could you speak a bit about which cost levers you have as we head into FY '21? I think we've performed really well when it comes to costs. What more is possible? And since we're going to encounter some pressure, have we kind of considered a plan for how we might cut costs even further?
Piyush Surana
executiveRegarding expenses, Madhukar — apologies, I meant Milind?
Milind Barve
executiveYes, I’ll keep this brief, and Piyush, feel free to jump in. I think what we’ll need to do is take a fairly hard look at every discretionary cost item within our operating costs and determine how much we can save from that. We believe some spending is discretionary—for auditors, on holding events, and similar things—which, in any case, cannot now take place. So we think some of these discretionary expenses can be saved. We will also examine rationalizing employee cost, which to some extent we have done this year. As you can see, despite having roughly 70, 80 new employees during the year, our employee cost has risen by, if I’m not mistaken, a low single digit. Piyush, is it 4%, 4.5%?
Piyush Surana
executiveYes.
Milind Barve
executiveYes, 4%. So some rationalization of employee cost is already underway. We’ll pull all these levers. And I think the new way of working that’s evolving—although for a different reason—we hope that shifts for the better too, and that will produce some operating-cost savings that we foresee.
Operator
operatorShubhranshu Mishra from BOB Capital Markets has the next question.
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystOn the closing AUM, we split that by approximately INR 50,000 crores. Is all of it MTM? Or does some of that also come from redemptions? If we could get the breakup, that would be helpful.
Milind Barve
executiveNo, I’d say it’s fair to describe almost all of it as—well, I’d say nearly entirely, if you’re talking about last quarter, there was a fair amount. I mean, look, market trends during the quarter dropped by almost 30%. So within that, as I said earlier, there was a somewhat larger book—one that’s a much larger book than the industry’s—in the small-cap fund and the mid-cap fund. We have the industry’s biggest mid-cap fund. So naturally, in conditions like these, over the last 12—sorry, during the last quarter, the mid-cap fund declined by 31%, and the small-cap declined by 38%. So because of that, the MTM impact on the book has been somewhat higher given the nature of the equity composition.
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystSo the INR 50,000 crores figure is mark-to-market, not redemption — is that right?
Milind Barve
executiveAlright.
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystRight, sure. On top of that, we currently hold close to INR 1,00,000 crores in liquid funds, and my sense is that we're adding further there, and in effect essentially the whole TER drops straight through to PAT. So how should we think about PBT from here on? Our average has been roughly 39 to 40 bps of core PBT. Would it be reasonable to assume that this stays in a comparable band?
Milind Barve
executiveI'm not — you mean PBT...
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystRegarding PBT, since the liquid fund — my impression is that we'll pick up a bit more in the liquid fund moving forward too. Is that a fair assumption?
Milind Barve
executiveNo. When it comes to liquid funds — which make up roughly 6% or 7% of total revenue — we'll see higher earnings since the liquid fund's size is growing. But the bigger point is that we have to grapple with the reality that there's a fairly reasonable degree of decline in the equity AUM book, where margins run much higher than they do on liquid funds.
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystAll right, then how should we view core PBT in that scenario? Would it stay in that same band—roughly 39 to 40 bps—or drop a bit, by 5 to 6 bps?
Milind Barve
executiveHonestly, no, I really don’t believe we’re in a position to provide guidance on the PBT figure, because our business is quite tightly tied to equity markets overall — as you’ll note, I said earlier that nearly 75% of last year’s revenue was generated by equity-oriented funds. So the state of the equity markets, and how much actively managed equity AUM we hold, becomes the main force driving our revenues and, in turn, our profit before tax and after tax.
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystOkay, and then one final item. What's your view on the dividend payout? Will we be holding on to cash in case something comes up during FY '21, so that the payout ratio ends up lower than it was for FY '20? Is that the right way to think about it?
Milind Barve
executiveYeah. I believe the board weighed the different choices around the payout ratio. There was a sense that it mattered to be perhaps somewhat more conservative and to raise the dividend. We've raised the dividend from INR 24 per share to INR 28 per share, which represents an increase. And in the current environment, one needs to be somewhat more cautious and prudent instead of adopting a very high dividend payout, and to conserve additional cash.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Nikhil, who is calling on behalf of ICICI Prudential Life Insurance.
Nikhil Joseph
analystI just want one clarification. Could you walk us through why other income came in negative this quarter? For quite a few quarters now, we hadn't seen other income turn negative. If you could shed a bit more light on that, please.
Milind Barve
executivePiyush?
Piyush Surana
executiveRight, so regarding the MTM on the NCDs we mentioned earlier, there's a footnote about it underneath. At the close of the third quarter, that figure stood at INR 25 crores. As of year-end, it now sits at INR 120 crores. So the remaining MTM that has come through is what produced that negative other income.
Nikhil Joseph
analystOkay, absolutely. And one more thing, sir — regarding equity AUM, could you share how much has come in on the current book after, let's say, September 2018? The AUM, yes?
Simal Kanuga
executiveApologies, this is Simal. So you're asking for the September '18 AUM, and you're also asking for the AUM as it stands now. Is that what you need?
Nikhil Joseph
analystNo, sir. So essentially, how much of the AUM currently on the books would have incurred after that date, once the TER regulation change took effect?
Simal Kanuga
executiveSo that's roughly how the split worked out. The thing is, we don’t break out how much of the AUM came from before versus what it is today, since there can be — well, it may even have gone through some churn or similar. But I will — if you check September 2018, our equity AUM, let me just give you that figure. September ’18, it was — yes, INR 1,47,000 crores.
Operator
operatorWe have time for just one final question. That last question comes from Piran Engineer at Motilal Oswal Financial Services.
Piran Engineer
analystI’ve got a few questions about distributors and commissions, and one is a follow-up to what Parag asked. So once the TER drops because you’ve moved into the higher slab, do you absorb the entire impact? Or at what point do you pass that along to the distributor? Because in the other situation, you said you keep all the benefits when you move into the lower slab—so what happens when you move into the upper slab?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, no. Look, once you move into the upper slab, the distributor commission stays unchanged as well. As you probably know, distributor commission is a fixed number of basis points applied to AUM. So suppose I'm a distributor and I hold INR 100 crores of AUM with us. Now say I'm being paid a set number of basis points, X basis points. If that 100 grows to 110 in that product, your revenue also rises by 10% thanks to the larger AUM, yet the basis point stays exactly where it was. So for instance, should the TER rise because of a fall, optically it looks like the margin has gone up. But in the same way, when AUM increases, the TER declines, and we don't cut his commission. His commission stays the same.
Piran Engineer
analystSo how frequently do broker commissions get renegotiated? Is it kind of an annual process, or does it happen whenever needed? How does that actually work?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, we don’t renegotiate. There’s no timeline on our side for renegotiating it. If you ask me, we never renegotiate it. I don’t believe there’s a system where we discuss it each quarter or annually. No, commission resets do not happen. Once — will they — look, typically the commission and its basis-point level get triggered by some event, whether regulatory or something that has materially altered the commissions and margins landscape. For minor events, we never return to renegotiate either upward or downward according to AUM movements, at all. There is no time frame whatsoever in that regard.
Piran Engineer
analystThen, sir, to address one of those other questions — I believe it was Madhukar's — you mentioned that commissions have a bigger impact on incremental flows, though it really hinges on which customer is leaving. So...
Milind Barve
executiveSure thing.
Piran Engineer
analystSo take one customer and one distributor, same sales scheme, and so on. Suppose NJ Invest sold your HDFC Top 100 to a customer in 2010, and then did the same, say, for another customer in 2012. Is it possible that you'd be paying different commission rates across those 2 different timelines?
Milind Barve
executiveYes. Yes. Without a doubt, yes.
Piran Engineer
analystSo there's no harmonization whatsoever?
Milind Barve
executiveThe reason it isn't harmonized is that anything that applied and was promised to him in 2010 will keep being paid on the 2010 asset. And anything promised for payment to him in 2019 will keep being paid for as long as that asset stays in place. So really, the way our registrars can — and this is the industry's own method — the commission amount is attached to an individual transaction. So it isn't given to a distributor. Inside one distributor, there could be different prices for different buckets of transactions that were given to us across different periods of time in different products.
Piran Engineer
analystFair enough. Okay. And sir, if you could just give me a rough estimate, what's the largest gap paid to different groups of customers for the identical product? So let's say, okay, the HDFC Top 100 scheme is distributed by distributor A and distributor Z — what might the biggest variance in commission be?
Simal Kanuga
executivePiran, that's something we aren't disclosing at this point.
Piran Engineer
analystAlright, fair enough. And then just one final thing — what share of your equity gets distributed through individual RIAs? And will this new regulation, or the proposed one, have any effect on that?
Simal Kanuga
executivePiran, as you’ll notice, there’s a pie chart in our presentation, and it shows that if you consider IFAs — which these days go by the name MFDs — they account for roughly 40% of our overall equity business.
Milind Barve
executiveLet's wrap it up there. There aren't any more questions, correct?
Simal Kanuga
executiveYeah, Milind. That's right.
Operator
operatorThat will be our final question. At this point, I'd like to return the conference to Mr. Jaideep Goswami for his closing remarks.
Jaideep Goswami
unknownThank you. I want to use this moment to express genuine appreciation to Milind and the whole senior leadership group at HDFC AMC for making the time and responding to every question with such patience. Milind, is there anything you'd like to add in closing before we wrap up?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, I believe there are a few questions, and I think we'd stick with what we've laid out in our presentation pack, along with the responses we've provided to the different questions. We want to thank everyone who submitted questions. We want to thank everyone who's on the call, and thank you to ICICI for hosting us. And once again, on my own behalf and on behalf of my entire team, hope everyone stays safe and healthy. Thank you.
Jaideep Goswami
unknownThanks.
Operator
operatorMuch appreciated. ICICI Securities is bringing this conference to a close. Thanks for being with us, ladies and gentlemen. Lines can be disconnected at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HDFC Asset Management Company Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to HDFC Asset Management Company Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in HDFC Asset Management Company Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.