HDFC Asset Management Company Limited (HDFCAMC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 23, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and welcome to the HDFC Asset Management Company Limited Q1 FY '21 earnings conference call, hosted by IIFL Securities Limited. <<operator_script>> Kindly be aware that this conference is being recorded. I'll now turn the conference over to Mr. Devesh Agarwal of IIFL Securities. Thank you, and over to you, sir.
Devesh Agarwal
analystThanks, Nirav. Good evening, all, and welcome to the 1Q FY '21 earnings call for HDFC Asset Management Company Limited. Joining us from management today are Mr. Milind Barve, Managing Director; Mr. Piyush Surana, Chief Financial Officer; and Mr. Simal Kanuga, Chief Investment -- Investor Relations Officer. I'll now pass things to Simal for opening remarks. After that, we'll open the floor for Q&A. Simal, over to you.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThanks, Devesh, and to everyone at IIFL Securities for hosting us today—we truly appreciate it. Good evening, all, and we hope each of you is doing well. As always, I'll begin with a look at the industry and then our company specifically. After that, we'll be glad to take your questions. The industry entered the quarter with a lower base AUM of INR 22.3 trillion, mainly because equity markets fell in March 2020. Even with that lower base, quarterly average AUM came in at INR 24.6 trillion, a marginal decline of 3% compared with June 2019. During the quarter just ended, we saw healthy inflows amounting to INR 1.24 trillion across asset classes. Equity-oriented QA AUM was INR 9 trillion for the June quarter, and the quarter closed with AUM of INR 9.8 trillion. Equity-oriented AUM has declined 7% year-on-year, even though net new flows were positive in every quarter. What's important to note here is that the industry began this quarter with AUM of INR 8.3 trillion and finished it at INR 9.8 trillion, with flows of only INR 63 billion—net new flows of just INR 63 billion during the quarter.
Simal Kanuga
executiveFor the quarter we're in now — July through September — we're beginning from a base of INR 9.8 trillion, compared with INR 8.3 trillion during the quarter just completed. SIP flows in June 2020 totaled INR 79 billion, versus INR 86 billion in March 2020. Turning now to our own figures: our share of quarterly average AUM came in at 14.5% last quarter, compared with 14.2% for June 2019 and 13.7% as of March 2020. QA AUM for the quarter ending June 2020 was INR 3,562 billion, compared with INR 3,624 billion, while closing AUM was roughly flat across the past 12 months, at INR 3,575 billion. On actively managed equity-oriented AUM, our QA AUM market share is 14.5%. QA AUM for June 2020 comes to INR 1,293 billion, against INR 1,645 billion for the quarter ended June 2019. That decline is mainly due to the market drop in March 2020, which was partly offset by the rally in the April-to-June quarter and even afterward. Closing AUM as of June 2020 stands at INR 1,378 billion, versus closing AUM of INR 1,200 billion for March 2020.
Simal Kanuga
executiveLet me restate that between 70% and 75% of the fees we earn hinges on our equity AUM. Equity AUM accounted for 39% of total AUM as of June 2020, versus 48% in June 2019. Two factors explain this: big inflows into our liquid fund — liquid and debt funds — plus mark-to-market losses on equity AUM. Individual AUM makes up 51.7% of total AUM, compared with 50.5% for the industry. We remain the top pick among individual investors, holding a 14.6% market share of individual AUM. Our unique investor count stands at 5.6 million, out of 21.1 million industry-wide. Systematic transaction flows in June 2020 totaled INR 9.6 billion across 3.11 million transactions. The figure I'm citing reflects actual cash flows received. We remain the #2 player in the B30 market with an 11.7% share. Our B30 footprint covers 145 branches. Through these lockdown periods, we shifted seamlessly onto our digital infrastructure. Over the quarter just ended, more than 90% of transactions were handled digitally. Worth noting as well: we've further strengthened our digital capabilities, adding WhatsApp transaction services along with e-KYC and video KYC.
Simal Kanuga
executiveSomeone putting money into a mutual fund for the very first time can now complete a transaction in our fund with zero paperwork. During the quarter, we reached over 10,000 partners via webinars and other formats, and more than 90,000 participants attended the various programs we run. We remain in operation at 221 branches, serve upwards of 9.4 million live accounts, and our workforce stands at 1,192. Now on to the financials. The same quarter a year earlier was marked by mounting uncertainty as the COVID-19 pandemic emerged and hit markets around the world. Equity markets dropped, and the resulting decline in equity AUM hurt revenues, because equity schemes generate a large share of the investment management fee the company earns. Operating profit for the quarter ended June 30, 2020, came to INR 3,006 million, versus INR 3,815 million for the quarter ended June 30, 2019 — a decrease of 21%. Profit before tax for the quarter ended June 30, 2020, fell by 12% to INR 3,804 million, compared with INR 4,299 million for the quarter ended June 30, 2019. Profit after tax for the quarter ended June 30, 2020, was INR 3,024 million, against INR 2,917 million for the quarter ended June 30, 2019, an increase of 4%.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThe PAT for the quarter that closed on June 30, 2019, was calculated using a higher tax rate, because the lower-tax-rate option under Section 115BAA of the Income Tax Act only came in during the quarter that ended September 30, 2019. Our operating profit margin as a percentage of average AUM stood at 34 basis points for the quarter ending June 30, 2020, versus 41 basis points for the year ending March 31, 2020. We also showed that slide in the presentation laying out the breakup of our investment book. As we announced last quarter, the Board of Directors had proposed a dividend of INR 28 per share for the financial year that ended March 31, 2020, and shareholders approved it at today's AGM. Thank you for listening patiently. Stay safe, everyone. We'll now open the floor to questions. Milind and Piyush would take -- would be glad to take any questions, if there are any. Nirav, please go ahead and open the line for questions now.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Nitin Jain at SK Capital.
Analyst
analystActually, I’ve got 3 questions...
Operator
operatorNitin, my apologies for cutting in. Could you boost your volume a bit for us, please?
Analyst
analystIs this line working — are you able to hear me at this point?
Operator
operatorCorrect.
Analyst
analystYeah. So the equity share of your AUM has dropped significantly — from roughly 50% nearly 2 years back to only 37% at present. On top of that, in the equity segment the company has given up almost 1.5% of market share over the past 1 year alone. Since management fee is driven mainly by equity AUM, what corrective steps have you considered to tackle this issue? And then my second question: your annual report discusses the investment style used in equity-oriented schemes. You noted there that you're aware long stretches can occur in the market where alternative investing approaches deliver better results, and that you're developing capabilities in other styles by bringing in the right people. So could you please expand on that further.
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So to address the first question, yes, it's accurate that equity AUM, which roughly 1 year ago stood at about 46%, 47%, has declined to 37%. But you'll understand that a big chunk of this is really the mark-to-market decline, and most of that took place in March, when the market saw a very, very sharp fall. You'll be glad to hear that our equity AUM, which was around INR 1,20,000 crores in March, has been recovering steadily and has climbed to nearly INR 1,45,000 crores as per the latest figure. As of 30th June, it might be somewhat below that. It could be nearer to -- Simal, is it INR 1,39,000 crores or INR 1,40,000 crores?
Simal Kanuga
executiveCorrect, yes.
Milind Barve
executiveCorrect — but it keeps expanding. We're clearly in the middle of an AUM rebound as markets have bounced back, as you're aware, during April, May and June, and our equity AUM has participated in that rebound. While we accept that market share has slipped somewhat, and I believe I'll address the second question. So the first thing is that, we think that given the medium-term view on equity and the rebound we're expecting to see in markets, broadly, and we're watching where we'll ultimately land, and we don't know precisely when or with great accuracy, but we're looking at a market scenario, which is post-COVID and so forth. And we think equity AUM is highly sensitive to how markets perform, besides being sensitive to flows. Whereas if you look, historically, those have contributed roughly 5% or 6% to the book, judging by last year. The bulk of the growth in the book size for the year actually stems from mark-to-market movement. So we stay optimistic that we would — we're positioned fairly well to participate in this market recovery, which we've already witnessed from April through June and some of it even continuing afterward.
Milind Barve
executiveThat said, yes, it's true — we've been quite candid about this in our management discussion on investment performance — and it's fair to say that in some of our large equity funds, our investment performance has fallen short of what people expect from us. There are a couple of things we believe. First, we do believe that, like market cycles, investment performance also goes through cycles where, for some stretch of time, some of your key calls won't pan out, or it will take longer for them to actually show up as positive performance. That said, what we've recognized more broadly is that in our equity book of about INR 1,40,000 or thereabouts, what we need to bring about is effective diversification of investment styles. So while some of our funds have followed our particular style, which hasn't delivered performance — as we've said in our note — we do believe, and we're very careful and very mindful of the fact, that we need to build a diversified style eventually. We're in the midst of that. So what have we done in that direction? Number 2 — number 1, we've actually hired 2 new fund managers, 3 actually in the team, and 1 of them is in the PMS; they're already on board, and we believe — and we're happy to say — that we've gotten good feedback from the market about these 2 hires.
Milind Barve
executiveThese are resources of really high quality. They bring perspectives to the market that differ from what we’ve been following so far in some of our large funds. And we do believe that as they manage money over a period of time and bring a differentiated approach to investing compared with what we have been following, it will lead to improved performance in some of the funds we are managing. The other thing, of course, is that even in our existing funds, where there is no change in fund manager, we will be working toward effective diversification. Right now, we seem to have reasonable overlap in our equity holdings across a number of our funds. And what we will do progressively over a period of the next 2 or 3 quarters is reduce the overlap so that each of these funds has a more distinct style and positioning in the marketplace and in our portfolio construct, so that the idea — so what are we trying to achieve? We are really trying to achieve this in a large fund book that we have in equity, which is about INR 1,40,000 crores: you must clearly have at least 4 or 5 distinct strategies, with reasonably low overlap in stock holdings.
Milind Barve
executiveSo I believe we're heading that way, and I think we stay confident that over the coming few quarters, you'll see proof of the different construct in the portfolios. New fund managers have already been brought on board, adding their expertise to the team, and that will produce a more differentiated call. So we're mindful about performance. We are — while we do believe that a portion of it will come back through the holdings we currently hold, we're also getting the portfolio ready on an overall basis. And I look at it as the more CEO and how the Board views it and how the INR 1,40,000 book, we will have differentiated efforts, which will deliver better investment outcomes. Markets go through different phases. At times certain kinds of stocks or certain sectors are incredibly highly valued, and certain stock sectors, they can go back deep into value. So we'll take a differentiated approach, which we think will help us over the long run or even in the medium term.
Analyst
analystI just want to follow up on that point, sir. Could we also get a look at new project launches from the company?
Milind Barve
executiveLook, when it comes to product launches, it's easy to say we'll roll out new products, but the reality is that SEBI has now categorized different strategies under different names. For instance, you can only have 1 value fund or 1 multicap fund. So we've more or less filled most of the available buckets with our existing product range. If I'm not wrong, the only one we're missing is something like a dividend yield fund. That's something we'll consider if we feel dividend yields are strong. That said, as a team we're examining whether we should do more thematic funds, which we haven't done much of. The thematic fund segment is more open since we don't have existing thematic funds, and we could explore thematic or sector-biased thematic funds going forward. But apart from that, for most equity product types that SEBI permits, we already have a product in each of those markets.
Operator
operatorManish from Nippon has the next question.
Manish Poddar
analystManish Poddar here, from Nippon AIF. I just wanted to hear your thoughts on whether operating structure will shift after COVID, because if you look at it, our AUM mobilization in the channel hasn't really changed much. So I'd just like to get your sense of — let's say you mentioned the research piece or the investment piece of the business in the first question. On the sales structure specifically, the branch network, let's say over a 3 to 5 year horizon, will anything change? Or is there any thinking around that?
Milind Barve
executiveAlright, so to start with, the branch network stands at 221 locations. And as you're aware, once COVID struck and the lockdown came into force, protecting the health and safety of both our staff and our clients became our number one concern. Because of that, only a very small number of branches stayed open. Instead, we kept things running through electronic channels. That means we lean on strong platforms such as HDFC MF online, plus a separate one for HDFC Partners that serves our distributors. Over time, as you know, we built up those 221 branches. Right now, as we near the end of June and reach the middle of July, roughly 140-plus branches are operating, each staffed with only a handful of employees, covering just the critical functions, and we're following whatever the local regulations permit and prohibit. If you look at this quarter, nothing has really changed in a structural sense, apart from one thing: transactions on HDFC MF online, which used to run at 12%, 13%, have now climbed past 20%. And if you look at new registrations on that same platform, again HDFC MF online, the number of users signing up on our HDFC MF platform has doubled relative to the prior quarter.
Milind Barve
executiveWhat we're seeing is a clear shift: folks who previously might have been somewhat hesitant—back when you could still head to the office or send someone there with a form and a check—are now, to a degree, being pushed by circumstances toward online channels, and that's what they're doing. And I'm glad to report that with the properties we hold and the facilities we've got for transacting online, we're putting more resources and time behind that, and it's helping us and will likely keep helping. But going forward... <<inaudible>>
Operator
operatorSir, are you able to hear us? Mr. Barve, can you hear us? Participants, kindly remain on the line while we bring Mr. Barve back onto the call. Ladies and gentlemen, we appreciate your patience. Mr. Barve's line is now reconnected to the call. Sir, please proceed.
Milind Barve
executiveRight. So, as you can observe, there isn't any structural shift in the distribution channel as such, apart from the fact that people are turning to electronic methods for investing in funds, whether that's a redemption or a purchase. I believe that covers my response. You may move on to the next question.
Manish Poddar
analystLet me ask one more, if I can — a pretty fundamental one. You mentioned unique visitors of roughly 5.6 million, so what exactly is your definition of "unique" in that context?
Milind Barve
executiveUniqueness gets determined through the unique permanent account number. So at times, when someone holds 2 or 3 folios — take our case, for instance, we have 9.5 million — 9.4 million or 9.5 million customer accounts, though some duplication may exist within that. So if you de-duplicate those accounts and count one PAN number just a single time, then that gives the 50 lakhs, 52 lakhs customers that we have.
Manish Poddar
analystSir, but this 5.6 million — is that still also a live number? So it's a live number. It won't include any individual — let's say an individual opened that portfolio in, say, 2010, and redeemed his portfolio in 2012. That wouldn't be part of this number at all?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, no — this is happening right now. These folks are… these are the very people who buy from us at present.
Manish Poddar
analystAnd as a quick follow-up on that, do you have any sense at all — say, within that universe of roughly 21 million — of what the lapse rate might be, or of how many consumers would have used an HDFC product, among the MF products, over the past 3 years or thereabouts? Any kind of indication of the sort of number you could reach?
Milind Barve
executiveNo. No. No. So the way we do it — we continue to count unique customers, and that unique customer figure is net of the folks who are leaving. So in the end, what matters to me is, say, 5,000 or 10,000 people coming in and perhaps 2,000 people going out. But then I'd say my net number is 8,000. That means the unique investor count is a net figure. So additions minus deletions aren't being tallied separately by us. I mean, we do have that data, and maybe we can address that offline. But what you're effectively seeing and aiming at is that there is a real gain in new customers, net of the people who are going out.
Operator
operatorHaresh Kapoor from IIFL Asset Management has the next question.
Haresh Kapoor
analystTo follow up on the previous question, I’d like to get some perspective on these unique investors and also the SIP pool — whether you address them together or separately, whichever you prefer. If I look at the details you provide on unique investors for your company, the industry figure is clearly rising. But looking at March — perhaps that’s a shorter window — even so, there isn’t really any change on your side, in terms of units relative to the industry. So the industry has expanded, yet you haven’t really expanded there. If you could walk us through that, please. And on the SIP figure, I understand — and I believe Mr. Simal, early in his remarks on SIP, also stressed the cash flow aspect of SIP. We know some money doesn’t come through and that some rationalization is needed there. Still, if you look at how the SIP data flowed from March to June, the industry is down perhaps 10%, while you are down roughly 15% or so.
Haresh Kapoor
analystSo clearly, on the SIP side you're losing market share. I understand the figures you provided cover the whole transaction pool on the SIP side, which can include both STP and SIP. So perhaps you could walk us through what's actually going on there, since that's a key customer aspect I'd like to grasp, both on unique customers and on the SIP side. Second, could you talk a bit about the cost side? Obviously, in Q4 you rationalized some employee costs. So maybe some normalization on the bonus front, et cetera, given how the year had played out, and in Q1 you're seeing some of those numbers normalizing on the employee expense front. There's also been some rationalization on other expenses, maybe the discretionary part, et cetera, travel expenses, et cetera, that you're undertaking. So if you could just talk through what levers you have, because your AUM on a closing AUM basis really looks better. Even on the average for the quarter, per se, it's more or less similar, but the mix has changed meaningfully versus what we had seen previously, which will have some implications on the revenue line, though the closing number is similar.
Haresh Kapoor
analystSo it's possible that for a while you'll need some kind of cost lever to help speed up that profitability. So maybe you could just walk us through that part. And I'll just get to one part maybe a bit later.
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So, to begin with the SIP, there's no denying at all that we belong to an industry that has experienced a decline in SIP flows, and we are very much a part of that. I think the plain reason is that right now we are in the middle of — or at, hopefully, I can say, the peak, or hopefully past the peak, of the pandemic. So there's a certain amount of — we're seeing — if you look at 3-year returns, even for the benchmarks, they're fairly low single-digit returns. And what's happened with SIP is that while the merits of SIP as a method of investing for small or new investors haven't changed, the reality has also been that investor returns, right, when we're assessing them in the middle of a pandemic, are actually negative or low single-digit even after 3 years. So essentially, what investors are saying is that — and look, this isn't the right way to view it — this year is actually the moment to sign up a new SIP or raise your SIP contribution. But people actually react based on the more recent experience they've had.
Milind Barve
executiveSo because of that, we've seen more SIP cancellations and fewer new SIPs being registered — that's an industry-wide pattern. Within that context, it's quite possible that when your market share is very dominant, and if there's a bit of pushback on investment performance for a few quarters or occasionally for somewhat longer, you'll see a modest decline in market share. So that's accurate, and I agree with what you said, and I addressed it in the earlier question — on a year-on-year basis, the drop in market share is somewhat larger. But looking quarter on quarter, the market share decline is, if I'm not mistaken, 14.8% to 14.4% on closing AUM. So I think we've now put in place a number of measures aimed at correcting the fundamentals of what we do, which means fixing investment performance, while also simply being patient — we're not being complacent about it. The investment team, the CIO and the investment team, along with the Board, had a very constructive discussion on performance this morning, as they did in the earlier meetings.
Milind Barve
executiveWe think we’re going to repair investment performance, since some of these market-share slippages will be addressed at least over the medium term—perhaps not right away, but over the medium term, they will be corrected. Because once the issue is diagnosed and the remedy is put in place, we believe the results will be visible for people to see. Still, predicting those outcomes over very brief windows, such as 1 or 2 quarters, will be hard. The second question concerned operating cost logics.
Haresh Kapoor
analystSir, prior to that, the question also touched on unique investors. Perhaps it's a shorter time period, but that isn't improving while the market improves? So is it just that — we should simply look through it because of a shorter time period, or is there something to comment on regarding that?
Milind Barve
executiveOur market share hasn't really shifted in any meaningful way. We continue to hold 26%, 27% of the unique investors. In any given quarter, the number of new investors added could be a bit higher or a bit lower. But as a book, and if you look at the industry figures we've provided, there are 2.06 crore unique investors. We have roughly 5.6 million unique investors, which works out to about 26%, 27%. Now, I don't believe there's a trend of 27% turning into 26% or 25.5%. That's not a trend I see. As I mentioned, once investment performance is fixed, we'll see much of this reverse, but I don't view it as a major trend of losing share in new investor additions in any meaningful way. Obviously, though, it's a variable worth monitoring, and we'll do everything it takes to fix that. And that will happen over the next 2 or 3 quarters as we go forward. On the second question, operating leverage remains reasonably good, as we've demonstrated. If you look at our total cost, there is a saving. One of the savings is, of course, more regulatory driven, which is savings in commission, but you are seeing a drop in our employee cost.
Milind Barve
executiveIn the prior year, we had budgeted for a specific amount of employee cost and a specific amount of variable payer bonus, which was rationalized during the last quarter. A 25% reduction has been applied to senior employees, junior employees have absorbed certain other reductions, and a substantial number of very junior employees received no reduction at all in performance pay. But in effect, we generated savings of roughly INR 8.5 crores to INR 9 crores in the last year on performance-related pay. That is reflected. That figure has now been assumed to stay consistent, which is why you observe a saving in employee cost. The third element is that even at the operating level, in what appears as other expenses, this quarter we had a somewhat disproportionate spend on CSR. The reason is that we spent -- I won't say spent, we donated INR 7.5 crores to the PM CARES Fund in the very first week of April, right when the lockdown was announced. So our pro rata CSR cost should really be around INR 6.5 crores, whereas the figure you see, which is already in the P&L, is approximately INR 9.5 crores. So there is a -- so if you had -- if CSR cost runs somewhat above pro rata, CSR cost will not be present in the other quarters -- the subsequent quarters.
Milind Barve
executiveYou're going to see some savings from this. But what we're really trying to do is bring operating expenses down over a 12-month period by somewhere in the range of INR 35 crores to INR 40 crores. That's the target we've set, and that's what we'll deliver. So if you look at the presentation deck, you'll notice that our operating expenses to AUM have in fact come down by 1 basis points. Revenue from AUM at the top line has declined, and I think that's due to the product mix, which has deteriorated. But here's what I'd tell you. When you talk about AUM, or equity AUM, declining as a percentage of AUM, that's happening across the entire industry. It isn't just us. Given that we had a big book and a big market share, the drop in equity AUM shows up more clearly for us, along with the revenue loss that follows from it. But just as it recovers for the industry, it will recover for us as well. So I think -- so we'll work to keep our operating expenses among the lowest in the industry measured as a percentage of AUM. They're only about 6 basis points. And as you can see, there's some saving there, even in this quarter, when you compare quarter to quarter.
Milind Barve
executiveWe will keep a hawk's eye on operating cost, and as you can see, that delivered INR 10 crores of savings in this single quarter. Between INR 35 crores and INR 40 crores is the savings range we would like to achieve on a 12-month basis.
Haresh Kapoor
analystSir, and finally, from my side, it was mostly about the CEO side of things. So anybody can take that one, whoever feels comfortable. So regarding — of course, you're retiring. So when it comes to that transition process and bringing someone in, where do we stand on that? And have you looked at candidates? And if you could just give us some color so we get a bit of clarity, that would help. By what timeline might we expect something?
Milind Barve
executiveAt this point, it would only be fair to note that the Board has — so we have a Nomination and Remuneration Committee, known as the NRC. Finding my successor is now the task that committee is occupied with. Work on that has already started. A search firm has been brought on, and that firm has already made significant — has made progress on that front. For me to say precisely what stage we are at would be premature and inappropriate. But that search is very much underway, and it is the committee, the Board together with the external search firm is also collaborating closely with the NRC and reviewing prospective candidates, both internal and external, and will then in due course bring forward the recommendation for the final candidate or a final few candidates, which the Board will approve. It would not be appropriate for me to comment on when we can make an announcement, because I don't think we have got far enough along in that process to be able to say that in this month or by this date we will have an announcement. But I think my tenure ends at the end of January, and I think within a reasonable time before that we should have an announcement on that.
Operator
operatorNext up, we have Nischint Chawathe calling in from Kotak.
Nischint Chawathe
analystSure. There are two things I want to ask about. First, a smaller one: what actually happened with that other income line item, since it grew a lot this quarter? Second, a bigger-picture question about what's really going on with retail investors, because this was a quarter where the market did pretty well, yet from an inflow standpoint it was very weak. So what are you watching over the next 9 months?
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So, to address your first question about other income: looking at the March year-end, we posted a net profit of INR 1,262 crore. The dividend payout was somewhat lower percentage-wise, though in absolute terms it's higher than the prior year. We're paying out roughly INR 590 crores — INR 595 crores in dividend, with the remainder added back. So essentially, what will happen, and will keep happening, is that out of the profits we generate, even as we aim to maintain a reasonably higher or solid payout ratio, there will always be surplus money that gets added to the AMC's AUM, added into the mutual fund AUM. For instance, comparing year over year, the total surplus sitting on the AMC balance sheet has risen by nearly INR 900 crores, or 33%, while much of it — all or nearly all — sits in debt mutual funds within our own direct mutual funds and in tax-free bonds. So I think effectively 3 things have happened. First, there's an increase in other income because the total AUM we manage is 33% higher.
Milind Barve
executiveSecond, we benefited from mark-to-market gains stemming from interest rates coming down along the yield curve on the debt products in which we've invested. And the third item, as we noted, is that regarding our exposure to the SL promoters, the collateral's value rose from INR 36 crores to INR 77 crores, yet on a conservative basis we have revalued our exposure by just INR 9 crores, moving from INR 29 crores to INR 38 crores. So that INR 9 crores has likewise flowed into other income on a pretax basis. Those are the 3 factors behind the rise in other income. As for your wider question on what's going on with retail investors, well, we certainly must keep in mind that this conversation is taking place during a pandemic. So people are looking at returns over the last 1, 2 or 3 years that are either negative or in low single digit. And therefore -- and they've also seen that flows were good in the month of April, but those flows started tapering in May and turned negative in June. And so I believe people would prefer to wait for some visibility on the market and the economy after the COVID.
Milind Barve
executiveWhat the market is pricing in is a world where COVID is absent or behind us, and the timing of that is hard to call. Right now retail investors aren't putting fresh money to work, even though we at this fund house think they ought to be examining the returns available on debt, on bank deposits, or on any other asset class. Gold is the sole exception where you've earned enormous gains. So I believe it will take a while longer before retail investors recover -- that is, before they reposition their confidence in equity funds specifically. Still, money keeps flowing into mutual funds and debt products from institutions and retail investors alike, and that benefits the industry. Yet we must get through this stretch in which equity as an asset class is undergoing a bit of a redefinition, during which confidence among retail investors in this product category will need to be rebuilt, and the flows will indeed return. We've witnessed this before as well: owing to market conditions, fresh purchases of equity funds decline, stay flat, or even turn negative, but that builds back in time as markets normalize and investors return to embracing equity as an asset class they must invest in, or as a share of their wallet.
Nischint Chawathe
analystTo carry this further, when I set this against what a few of the brokerages are saying — they seem to be posting record volumes, or among their strongest quarters in many years, I mean the retail brokerages — so it appears folks are at home and placing bets directly on equities. So do you figure that between the 2...
Milind Barve
executiveThat's a good question. It's true that retail involvement in the market, in terms of turnover, has gone up quite a bit. But when you examine delivery volumes in the market very closely, they've actually declined, which suggests retail investors are likely trading in a more speculative way — buying, selling, trading. They aren't necessarily committing medium- or long-term money to equities by going long on equity, necessarily. That's my read based on some of the data points I've collected. Delivery volume, as a percentage, has fallen, which tells us people are engaging in more short-term or more speculative investing. But yes — I agree. I mean, there is data showing that retail investor transaction volumes have been very, very high. I also think they're able to do that from home, from the comfort of the house, when it comes to daily trading or things like that. But I think this is a period when market momentum has been upward. So this typically happens when you get a one-way upward move in the market, where people tend to do this daily trading.
Milind Barve
executiveDown the road, folks are going to return to medium- and long-term investing by way of funds. So we, as a fund house — and I personally hold this view — must get through this stretch. And in the end, people will come back to purchasing equities via mutual funds.
Operator
operatorWe’ll take our next question from Akash Singhania at Motilal Oswal.
Akash Singhania
analystI have a question about the surplus funds we've put into our mutual fund schemes — I'd like to get a sense of what the amount was, say, in March versus June. So what's the change there? And as you said, most of it sits in debt funds or the tax-free bonds. Is any portion in equity as well? And what sort of yield are we expecting on the debt funds?
Milind Barve
executivePiyush, would you like to handle that one?
Piyush Surana
executiveYes. So the gap between the March and June figures would come to roughly somewhere around INR 300 crores and INR 350 crores, as far as book size goes, Akash. The other item you raised was — sorry, could you say that again?
Akash Singhania
analystCould you tell us the size of the book and the yield we're anticipating? And is there an equity piece as well?
Piyush Surana
executiveRight now, the book size stands at roughly INR 4,200 crores. Over the quarter, it went up by somewhere around INR 300 crores, INR 350 crores. As for equity exposure, that's quite minimal. What we hold is mostly the mandatory investments we're required to make in our own equity mutual funds, plus a bit of marginal equity exposure in things such as the industry platform that AMFI has launched, MFU and the like. All told, that comes to about 1.6%, everything combined, roughly INR 60 crores, INR 70 crores.
Akash Singhania
analystAnd what type of yields have we earned over the last 1 year on our debt investments?
Piyush Surana
executiveSo across the past 12 months, we'd have made somewhere around 6% — 6% or a bit more, 6% to 6.5%. And in this quarter, our yield would have been somewhat higher, largely owing to the factor that Milind brought up earlier.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Sameer Bhise at JM Financial.
Sameer Bhise
analystI just wanted to get a feel for credit funds as a product, since that particular piece of the puzzle has recently emerged from a bit of turmoil. So how are you seeing customers respond, how are distributors responding, and what's your view on that side going forward?
Milind Barve
executiveRegarding the credit funds, it's accurate that there were industry events you're fully aware of that took place around the last week of April. That did set off a bit of a panic generally in debt funds, but more specifically in credit risk funds. So it's true that credit risk funds across the industry, ours included — and we had one of the larger credit risk funds at about INR 13,500 crores — all of us in the industry saw a reasonably high degree of redemptions through the first few weeks of May. But after the first week of May, just after one of the fund houses announced an event, redemptions started to taper quite significantly. So there were periods when redemptions were as large as INR 400 crores, INR 500 crores in size, or even higher than that in a week. They've now tapered very significantly. I mean, at this point our outflow or redemptions are almost as low as INR 120 crores to INR 150 crores a month. So we're down to hardly INR 7 crores or INR 8 crores of redemptions per day. So I think the environment for credit risk funds has improved significantly.
Milind Barve
executiveThe key point is that our credit risk fund did experience a redemption, and that redemption took the AUM from INR 13,500 crores down to roughly INR 6,300 crores at the end of June. That said, while those redemptions were happening, we took a very conservative stance. In our credit risk funds, we raised our AAA exposure from 24%, 25% up to 34%, 35%. So when you count cash and net current assets, our credit risk fund now carries 38%, 39%, or close to 40% in AAA, cash, and net current assets. The profile of our credit risk fund has therefore improved a great deal, but I'm glad to report that the panic has mostly died down almost entirely, and redemptions in these funds are now very, very low and reasonably comfortable to handle.
Sameer Bhise
analystBut what's your sense of how this product is being received? Or how are customers responding as time goes on?
Milind Barve
executiveConfidence will return to credit risk funds — it's just a question of when, in my view. The reason I say that is that nobody can dispute how safe AAA funds are. Those AAA funds currently carry YTMs of 5.5%, or at times below that, when you consider the medium term — and I'm talking strictly AAA funds. Compare that with a credit risk fund — ours, for instance — where the portfolio's YTM, or yield to maturity, stands at roughly 9.5%. So you're being paid for bearing some kind of process — and it's not as though non-AAA credit is inherently poor. In our view, that credit is of reasonably sound quality. It's very, very diversified, and so forth. So it's simply a fact that investors will begin to feel the pinch from the yields they're currently getting on AAA portfolios. As a result, they will, in a gradual, measured fashion, rebuild some confidence in credit risk funds — at least those funds run by houses they trust, or where they trust the underlying portfolios, whether that's the portfolio quality or its liquidity.
Milind Barve
executiveWhat catches me off guard — I mean, in some sense it's startling that the spread between a AAA fund and a credit risk fund holding 40% AAA comes to nearly 400 basis points. My feeling is that this differential is going to shrink, and investors are going to return. But this is our line of work, and we're at a stage where trust has to be rebuilt in these product categories, and we'll simply have to endure those products and play a role in that rebuilding effort.
Operator
operatorUp next, we have Saurabh Kumar with JPMorgan.
Saurabh Kumar
analystOnly two questions for you. First, regarding the market share loss — whether it involves fees, incentives, or possibly M&A, could you speak to any of those factors? And second, on the dividend payout, do you have any thoughts about raising it, given the cash that just keeps accumulating on the balance sheet?
Milind Barve
executiveI apologize — what was that initial question again?
Saurabh Kumar
analystSir, would you consider either lowering the expense ratio on some of your bigger schemes, or raising what distributors get paid, to tackle the market share issue — or perhaps exploring some M&A, a merger or acquisition? And the second question was about the payout, sir.
Milind Barve
executiveAt this point, we aren’t really considering repricing anything in our equity book. Practically speaking, if you’re promoting certain schemes that are fairly small in size, you might take a look at it. That’s something we review periodically. We don’t have any active strategy under consideration to lower the TER or raise the payout, because obviously that has an impact. Both of those actions would reduce share margins and the product’s profitability for the company. So you’d be careful about cutting TER below what you’re permitted to charge. We also believe that investors who specifically come into direct plans are no longer sensitive to TER, because investment performance significantly overrides TER considerations. And I think as long as we focus on investment performance and get that right, there isn’t much sensitivity to TER. And I’d say also, there isn’t as much sensitivity to payout, since your payout has to be competitive, but it doesn’t necessarily have to be the highest among competitors. So I don’t think there’s any active strategy under consideration on repricing that TER or the commission payout.
Milind Barve
executiveSecond, we'd examine any strategic opportunity that comes up from an M&A standpoint. That said, at present there's no specific target that we have under active review. But yes, since we're a listed company, that gives us a currency we can actually deploy in an M&A situation, which does enhance our capacity to pursue M&A. Still, we need to be cautious, because ours is a fairly efficient, low-cost operation with a high operating profit margin. We'll take great care not to water down those criteria merely for the sake of building size. If, however, you can add size together with economies of scale, we would consider it. I'm simply offering a bit of color for your thinking. That said, the short answer is that nothing is actively under consideration. On cash, look, I agree that cash will keep accumulating on the AMC's balance sheet. That said, cash also provides — for instance, right now we have, in fact, if you ask me about one of the questions we addressed, our yield on our book reaches as high as 7.7% net of tax this quarter.
Milind Barve
executiveSo when it's used efficiently, that surplus actually gives you very efficient returns without carrying too much risk. That said, it does dilute return on equity. So I'm sure the Board will keep that fact in mind when it looks at a more normalized market environment and decides on the payout going forward.
Operator
operatorNishant Chandra from Temasek has the next question.
Nishant Chandra
analystI've got two questions. Sorry—can you hear me?
Milind Barve
executiveThat's correct — you are.
Nishant Chandra
analystAll right, regarding Page 14 in the deck — I’m not sure whether you touched on this during your opening comments, but physical investments by customers, or physical transactions, have dropped sharply. So should we read that as pent-up potential still to be captured over the remainder of the year? Or has a significant amount already been captured thanks to your electronic — thanks to your digital initiatives?
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So I have to say that — look, people conduct transactions in 2 ways. One is online and the other is physical. And over these past 3 months of the lockdown, clearly, even after the quarter ended, we have only just over 140 branches, which are operating with skeleton staff out of 221. So clearly, people's capacity to leave their houses, with an application form and a check to carry out a physical transaction, is seriously limited. So it is correct — you're right to assume that basically these physical transactions will rise and return to more normal levels once the lockdown environment eases in different parts of the geographies we deal in. At present, we are actually operating where physical transactions are severely limited because of the lockdown, and I think it is not at all at the normal level that we should normally see. Overall, as you see, as I did mention, we are at about 65% to 70% transaction volumes, overall. And the percentage of online has gone up because the physical has gone down. So I would think that the physical has really gone down because of the lockdown situation and should normalize as and when the lockdowns are lifted across the country.
Milind Barve
executiveHello? Can you hear me OK?
Operator
operatorNishant, anything else you'd like to ask? Our next question comes from Dhaval Gada at DSP Investment Managers.
Dhaval Gada
analystI have just a couple of questions. First, could you give a bit of commentary on the net yield right now in equity, debt and liquids compared with last year, and could you tie that to the decline in yield? Apologies if I missed this earlier, but could you repeat it and add some context across these 3 product segments? Then the second part: earlier on you mentioned some shift in thinking regarding diversifying your investment style. Conceptually, I just want to understand what benefit we might give up by diversifying, given that this approach has worked so far over the last 15-odd years, when earnings volatility was quite low at a pretax level? So any thoughts on that? And the last question concerns 2 product segments. One is the dividend yield product and the second is overseas feeder funds. Any thoughts on these 2 products?
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So regarding your first question about whether margins had seen any meaningful change: there really hasn't been much. There's been a very slight shift, a downward movement in equity margins, but nothing significant. As a result, margins across product groups are broadly unchanged. Some decline has occurred in the margin on debt, since the credit risk fund we mentioned earlier carried a very high margin, and that has now been reduced by almost INR 7,500 crores this quarter. So overall margins — and also because money is flowing into somewhat lower-margin liquid or liquid plus funds — mean margins on debt have also softened a little, though this stems from reduced flows into high-margin products. That said, the bigger driver of the revenue decline is product mix volume rather than much margin loss. Because debt was anyway 25% — if you look at our presentation from last year in March, equity accounted for 76% of revenue. So even with some margin decline in debt, debt and liquid combined represent 25% of revenue.
Milind Barve
executiveThat doesn't affect total revenue. But a decline in the equity product mix hits total revenue harder, and that's what's taking place. And we think it will fix itself in the coming quarters. I'll keep this short since, as I said, I gave a lengthy answer to your other question, and this is covered in the management discussion section of our annual report. We've stated that we're a large equity fund house. As we speak, we manage INR 1,45,000 crores of actively managed equity, less a modest sum of index funds. What we're observing now is that when strategies overlap heavily across different funds, there can be a stretch of time when a number of your funds aren't delivering good performance. So as a fund house, as a company, as a business, we suffer during that part of the cycle. So what we're doing is actually quite simple. Out of the INR 1,40,000 crores, INR 1,45,000 crores we had, we want a reasonable amount to follow a particular strategy.
Milind Barve
executiveSo whenever we’ve got 5 or 6 strategies running, it’s possible that 1 or 2 aren’t performing well, 1 or 2 are just average, while 1 or 2 are doing really well. And at least for that reason, the flows coming into the business, or the AUM gain from mark-to-market gains, will normalize. One thing we’ve diagnosed as needing to be tackled is that we hold reasonably large amounts in similar strategies, and that’s the current situation we’re trying to correct. And as I mentioned in my earlier answer, here’s what we’re doing about it. That’s the broad approach a large fund house like ours should take, and that’s what we’re doing. That’s what we’ve understood as a challenge that, over time, the Board, our investment team, Prashant and all of us are seized with. Sorry, did I miss some other part of your question?
Dhaval Gada
analystYes. Yes. The third question concerned the dividend yield and the feeder fund tied to the overseas products. So that's the third one. And sir, one follow-up regarding the first answer. On the debt side, so I get the product mix impact. On the debt side, starting from a 40 basis point net yield, roughly how much of a decline would you have seen — like a ballpark figure there?
Milind Barve
executiveRegarding the debt yield this quarter — and Piyush, jump in if I get this wrong — isn't it roughly 28 or 29 basis points, versus 37 or 38, Piyush?
Piyush Surana
executiveRight. We’d have taken a hit of roughly 4 or 5 basis points on...
Milind Barve
executiveRight. So, as I said, we would have taken a hit of 4 or 5 basis points on debt, but debt and liquid together account for just 29% of our revenue. So a decline in margin has no effect on total revenue. If, however, the equity portion were to drop, then I would have flagged that separately.
Piyush Surana
executiveJust to add on that point: when you look at the revenue decline and try to attribute it, roughly 80% to 85% comes from the drop in AUM, with only a small portion from margin decline. And that margin decline is sometimes a bit seasonal, since certain expenses get debited — sometimes less, sometimes more. For that reason, you really need to look at the full year. So, as Milind said, I wouldn't read too much into the margin decline.
Dhaval Gada
analystGot it. Yes. And if you could address that final item, regarding the products section. Yes, that covers it.
Milind Barve
executiveYes. Look, on the products side, as I mentioned, the dividend yield — I’m not sure; we need to talk with our investment team about whether we think this is a — naturally, there are areas of the market with extremely high dividend yields. At present, we hold some fairly high dividend yield stocks in our portfolio. Should we launch a very specific dividend yield fund — a number of utilities, for instance, carry high dividend yields — we will discuss with our investment team whether a separate fund is needed for that. As for investing abroad through feeder funds, again, as I said, we have to be clear on this. Currently we lack the expertise to select stocks. We may need to do a feeder fund with another global fund manager, with whom we might tie up. That could be Standard Life. It could be another fund — another fund house. We will speak with our sponsors, Standard Life, first, of course. So we’ll pursue that. Right now, if you ask me whether there is something we are about to do in the near future, the answer is no. But yes, this is an option we will look at.
Milind Barve
executiveThere's a single fund we're filing with SEBI — a multi-asset fund; actually, not filing, it's an existing fund that we're repositioning as a multi-asset fund. Within that fund, we've included an enabling provision allowing investment in international securities.
Operator
operatorThanks so much. Ladies and gentlemen, because of time limits, that’s going to be the final question for today. I’ll now turn the conference over to Mr. Devesh Agarwal for his closing remarks.
Devesh Agarwal
analystThanks a lot, everybody. Speaking for IIFL Securities, I'd like to use this chance to express our appreciation to the HDFC AMC team for letting us host today's call. As we wrap things up, sir, is there anything you'd care to say in the way of closing remarks?
Milind Barve
executiveI'll keep this brief as a closing note. Thank you again for your time and for your patience in joining this first quarter post-results call. As I mentioned at the start, and as my colleague noted, we're navigating unusual times as a fund house. Personally, I believe we need to focus on the point when conditions normalize. When that happens, we can't say, yet our confidence holds that markets and the economy will eventually return to a more normalized environment. And I think, as long-term investors, we stay quite reasonably optimistic. I'm fairly optimistic about our business's positioning, the operating leverage within it, the strong level of profitability we enjoy, and our cost control, given that we continue to be reasonably more profitable than any other fund house. And I think that will remain at the core of our strategy. We have work ahead of us on fixing investment performance, which we are very focused on, and I'm confident that will come about as we move forward. Once more, on behalf of my team and myself, many thanks for joining the call.
Milind Barve
executiveI also wish each of you good health and safety. Thanks.
Devesh Agarwal
analystThanks, sir.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. That brings this conference to a close on behalf of IIFL Securities Limited. We appreciate your participation. You can go ahead and disconnect your lines now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HDFC Asset Management Company Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to HDFC Asset Management Company Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in HDFC Asset Management Company Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.