HDFC Asset Management Company Limited (HDFCAMC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 27, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Q4 FY '21 and Full Financial Year '21 Earnings Conference Call of HDFC Asset Management Company Limited. <<operator_script>> Kindly be aware that this call is being recorded. Joining us from the management team are Mr. Navneet Munot, MD and CEO; Mr. Piyush Surana, Chief Financial Officer; and Mr. Simal Kanuga, Chief Investor Relations Officer. I'll now turn the call over to Mr. Simal Kanuga, who will give a brief, after which we will proceed to a Q&A session. Thank you, and over to you, sir.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThanks, Margaret. Good evening, everyone, and thank you for joining this call. The presentation is available for download on our website and also on the exchanges' sites. As always, I'll give a quick industry update first, and after that we'll go through some company-specific details. Navneet, Piyush and I will be here afterward to take your questions. Starting with equity-oriented flows: during the quarter just ended, the industry recorded net outflows of INR 84 billion. Let us split that figure across January, February and March. In January the industry had outflows of INR 149 billion, and February followed with INR 59 billion, which adds up to INR 208 billion of outflows across the first 2 months. March brought a change in direction, with the industry posting a net inflow of INR 124 billion. Debt funds recorded an outflow of INR 410 billion in the quarter ended March '21. Liquid funds posted outflows of INR 422 billion. Across the full financial year, debt funds took in INR 2,199 billion, whereas liquid funds had outflows of INR 240 billion. Individual folios in the industry keep climbing and now stand at INR 97.3 million. B30 AUM remains unchanged at 16% of industry AUM.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThere's one figure we want to flag for you when it comes to B30 AUM: equity AUM within B30 makes up 66% of the B30 total. Out of a total of INR 5.2 trillion, that works out to INR 3.4 trillion. SIP flows reached a high of INR 91.82 billion. We'd ask that you examine the flows month by month across the 3 months of the quarter: INR 80.23 billion in January, INR 75.28 billion in February, and INR 91.82 billion in March. Summing those gives INR 247.33 billion, roughly INR 82.44 billion a month. Some spillovers may have occurred, and looking at any single month's data could therefore present a different picture. Let's turn now to AUM. For the quarter that ended in March '21, our quarterly average assets under management came to INR 4,156 billion, distributed among 5.3 million unique customers and 9 million live accounts, served via 227 branches. Even with the conditions we experienced during financial year 2021, we added 6 new branches, and our headcount grew by 60. Total employee strength is now 1,254.
Simal Kanuga
executiveWe finished the year with AUM at INR 3,955 billion, which is 24% growth compared with March 2020. Looking at QA AUM, we recorded 12% growth for the quarter ended March '21 versus March '20. For overall AUM, our market share came in at 12.9% on a QA AUM basis and 12.6% on a closing AUM basis. When ETFs are excluded, our market share is 14.1% in QA AUM and 13.8% on closing AUM. Our reason for showing market share without ETF is, as you know, that more than 80% of ETF AUM comes from 2 asset management companies plus the government disinvestment program stroke, PSU debt ETF. For actively managed equity oriented AUM, our market share is 13.3% on a QA AUM basis and 12.9% on a closing AUM basis. We have had questions in the past about our performance. Though it is too short a period to call, we have observed a material improvement in performance over the past few months, in fact from October of 2020. Our share in debt stands at 14.4%, both in QA AUM and closing AUM, while in liquid it is at 16.7% and 15.7% in QA AUM and closing AUM, respectively.
Simal Kanuga
executiveOur asset mix remains favorable relative to the industry, with a larger share in equity assets. Individual investors account for 57.6% of our AUM. The comparable industry figure is 53.7%. We still hold the top market share in individual AUM, which is 13.7%. In March of 2021, we processed systematic transactions totaling INR 10.4 billion. As mentioned before, the figure we report is on an actual cash flow basis. In B30 AUM, we are a clear #2, with a market share of 11.7%. We keep advancing our work in building state-of-the-art digital infrastructure and using it to improve customer experience. Now we'll turn to financials. The company's financial performance in the early part of this financial year was hurt by the effects of COVID-19 on the markets. After that, conditions began to improve as markets recovered, and the situation had started to look quite upbeat in January, February 2021. But with the second wave of the pandemic setting in across large parts of the country, things have worsened rapidly since then. Across the 4 quarters of this financial year, we saw a improving trend in operating revenue.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThroughout the year, we focused on conserving costs, and we managed to hold expenses in check, delivering savings of roughly 8% versus the prior year's total expenses. Those savings came mainly from cutting back on business development, travel, other overheads, et cetera. As we emerge from the second wave, we will need to raise spending on growing our business. In February 2021, a grant of ESOPs was made to certain employees, and the expenses had -- employee benefit expenses include the pro rata amortization of the fair value of ESOPs as required under the Ind AS accounting framework applicable to the company. A note on this has been provided in the presentation. This is a noncash charge and a book value neutral thing. Our operating margin had gone down to 34 basis points in quarter ended June 30, improved to 37 basis points in September 30, 2020, and to 38 basis points for the quarter ended December 31, 2020. It now stands at 37 basis points for the quarter ended March '21. In terms of financial highlights for the financial year ended March 31, 2021. Operating profit for the financial year, March 31, 2021, was INR 13,996 million as compared to INR 15,129 million for the financial year ended March 31, 2020.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThat represents a decline of 7%. For the financial year that closed on March 31, 2021, profit before tax rose 6%, reaching INR 17,488 million, versus INR 16,531 million in the financial year that closed on March 31, 2020. Profit after tax for the financial year that ended March 31, 2021, came in at INR 13,256 million, compared with INR 12,625 million in the financial year that ended March 31, 2020 — an increase of 5%. Now, financial highlights for the quarter that ended March 31, 2021. Normally we would compare against the same quarters of the prior year, but with the COVID-19 reset, we feel sequential comparisons matter just as much, so we have included both in our investor presentation. The quarter's figures are as follows: operating profit for the quarter that ended March '21 stood at INR 3,802 million. That is 7% above the operating profit of INR 3,562 million for the quarter that ended March 31, 2020. Profit before tax for the quarter that ended March 31, 2021, was INR 4,228 million. It rose by 28% compared with INR 3,297 million for the quarter that ended March '20. Profit after tax for the quarter that ended March '21 was INR 3,159 million.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThat represented a 26% increase over the INR 2,500 million recorded for the quarter that ended in March '20. Since this marks Navneet's first time engaging with all of you, I've asked him to offer a few remarks prior to opening the floor for questions. So, Navneet, please go ahead and take it from here.
Navneet Munot
executiveThank you, Simal. Good evening, and thanks to all of you for joining this call. Our country is currently confronting the second wave of COVID, and I hope each of you and those close to you are staying safe. Within our company, we are making every effort to ensure that all our employees and their families can get through this challenging period. I came on board at HDFCAMC on 16th of February this year, which means it has been just over 2 months. Coming from outside, I had long held this company and everything it represents in high regard. So leading this team and serving this organization is a tremendous honor for me. Milind, my predecessor, transformed this company from an ideation stage into a leading asset manager — the position it holds today. Our leadership team is highly experienced. As a matter of fact, a good number of them have spent many years with the organization. Indeed, several have been here since inception. A strong set of values, which are the hallmark of the HDFC Group, binds this team together. Prashant, a veteran of the industry for almost 3 decades now, heads a highly talented investment team.
Navneet Munot
executiveAcross the past 2 decades, this company has established a truly exceptional franchise. It possesses size, scale, and efficiency, which show up in one of the biggest assets under management and profitability that leads the industry. Yet we are clearly eager to accomplish more. And every ingredient we need is already available. The pedigree, the brand we stand for, HDFC, which is synonymous with trust and confidence, our people, our footprint — and by footprint I mean our reach and our distribution capability — products with a long-term track record, and all the resources required. The sector we operate in has grown phenomenally, particularly over the last 6, 7 years. So when we consider long-term growth potential, it appears we have only scratched the surface. That makes me very optimistic about our industry. I look forward to engaging with all of you in the times ahead, and we are open to taking your questions.
Simal Kanuga
executiveMargaret, could you go ahead and begin taking questions now, please?
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question comes from Saurabh at JPMorgan.
Saurabh Kumar
analystSir, I have two questions. First, you said performance in actively managed equity has improved since September. But on Slide 9, the December '20 market share compared with March '21 is still lower. It's not a big drop, but it's still 30 basis points. So I just wanted to understand what's going on there. And the second one — I'll follow up on that.
Simal Kanuga
executiveHold on for a moment, Saurabh.
Navneet Munot
executiveThat might stem partly from money moving into NFOs, sector and thematic funds, and so on, where we may lack a presence. Still, broadly speaking, now that performance has begun to improve, we're hopeful that prospective investors, our partners, everyone has started to take notice, and that this should begin showing up in flows.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAlright, sir, the second thing is that around 6 months ago there was some discussion about you wanting to roll out quite a few funds and look into new strategies within the fund. Could you give us an update on where that stands?
Navneet Munot
executiveSure. I mean, after the SEBI classification in our industry, we're in nearly every one of the main categories. Now, there are a number of them where we might have given up some market share. So we were once the leader in large cap, flexi cap, equity hybrid, ELSS, and we remain very large in those. But there's room for us to win back market share there. So when it comes to the core products, we've been present, though gaps could exist in the passive strategy that Simal mentioned, while a big chunk of the AUM comes from government mandates. And then there are those divestment related ETFs, on both the equity and the bond side. Even so, there could be opportunity on the passive front. Some opportunity could exist in thematic and sector funds. Lately, over the last couple of quarters, we've seen Indian investors seeking global diversification, and international funds have drawn investor interest. There could be opportunity for us in that area. So over time, we'll gradually fill in all our booking. In fact, as we speak, our NFO on the asset allocation product is underway.
Navneet Munot
executiveIn this quarter, most likely, we'll launch a sector fund focused on banking and financial services. A few other funds are also queued up across some of these categories for the coming quarters. So when it comes to thematic and sector offerings, and on the passive side too, as well as internationally, there are certain gaps we'd like to address over the next several quarters. One thing I should point out, though: people have consistently complimented HDFC MF from the outside for steering clear of launching a product out of fear of the seasons. That tradition will continue. So we do have a fairly sizeable NFO lineup, but each will come with strategies we see as genuinely appropriate for investors, or for a segment of them, where we have conviction about that product's scalability and sustainability over a long period. We won't roll out a product merely for the sake of it, or simply because it happens to be collecting money right now — that we won't do. Also, I firmly believe many of our existing products carry substantial growth potential, especially the solutions-oriented funds. Still, wherever product gaps exist, I think those have been identified well.
Navneet Munot
executiveAs you know, we launched the dividend yield fund in December, and it was very well received. We currently have an NFO running for the asset allocation product. Then, for the couple of categories I mentioned, I believe you'll be seeing us in the market over the coming several quarters.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Aditya Jain at Citi Group.
Aditya Jain
analystI guess you kind of got at this already, but beyond rolling out those new products you brought up — basically rounding out the product lineup — are there any other strategic priorities on your mind, Navneet, now that you've taken the reins? Anything you think needs changing or improving, or how do you see it?
Navneet Munot
executiveOkay. So, as I said, during the past two quarters, we’ve lost market share in a few of our key categories. When it comes to equity, I think we want to hold up against that decline and begin to rebuild that share. On the fixed income side, our market share has increased, but even so, we believe that, given our brand, our long-term track record, and the quality of our people, there’s still room for us to grow there. Of course, I mean, the industry is evolving. There’s plenty of growth potential, but the operating environment is still shifting, and customer preferences are shifting. So we would focus on whether it’s technology, whether it’s giving our customers a state-of-art experience and service. The product gaps I’ve already mentioned, so I think all of that will keep us occupied to make sure we raise our market share in individual AUM, where we’ve been a leader. But again, given our pedigree, our product range, our people, our presence, our distribution reach, I think there’s a lot of room for us to grow. On SIPs, where we’ve been a leader, I think we were a pioneer in spreading the idea of SIP in India.
Navneet Munot
executiveWe think the share of the market we hold right now has room to rise a lot across the coming several years. B30 is a further segment. Since our footprint there is really big — I mean, if you consider all our branches, 150 out of 227 sit in that area, whether you measure it by our reach with distributors in those markets — we see plenty of opportunity for growth there. So that's the picture on all of those fronts, Aditya.
Aditya Jain
analystUnderstood, sir. Then just one point to clarify regarding the ESOP. Could you share the scheme's overall size, and also explain how the expense will be amortized across the years ahead?
Simal Kanuga
executiveAs you're aware, we noted that the ESOPs are structured uniquely, essentially spreading them across the vesting period. So basically you value the ESOP using the Black-Scholes model and then spread that value over the ESOP's vesting period. These ESOPs, as we specified, vest in 3 tranches over 3 years. Each tranche therefore vests over the period applicable to it. So one portion is 1 year, another portion is 2 years, and a third portion is 3 years. The ESOP's value will thus be spread across that period. Some of it has come in this year because the grant was made only on February 22nd. The coming year will show a larger portion of the charge since it will include a piece of all 3 tranches; then it will decline in the subsequent year, and in the final year it will be the lowest.
Aditya Jain
analystUnderstood. So roughly speaking, that works out to INR 28 crores annually, though in year one, because it includes, as you mentioned, all 3 tranches, the figure would be INR 30 crores or INR 40 crores.
Simal Kanuga
executiveAs I mentioned, during the coming year—that is, the financial year currently underway—a charge relating to the first tranche will arise, and since that tranche vests in 1 year, it will be completed. Next, for the second tranche, which vests across 2 years, half of its charge lands in this year. As for the third tranche, spanning 3 years, 1/3 of its charge falls in this year. What you'll therefore observe is a charge weighted toward the front end. This year brings a bigger charge; the following year it drops; and by the third year it drops further still. More detail on all this should be available once our annual report comes out, which will likely be in roughly 1.5 months.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Sameer Bhise at JM Financial.
Sameer Bhise
analystI just wanted to — so clearly, as you pointed out, one of the main strategic priorities is product launches, and I wanted to get your sense of how the industry is likely to develop, particularly regarding profitability — how sustainable are the current levels? And what are your thoughts on that?
Navneet Munot
executiveLook, over the past several years, we've clearly seen across the world that this industry's margins have been squeezed. A great deal of capital has flowed into passive, and that has driven consolidation within the industry. That said, I believe there's an enormous growth runway in front of us where India is concerned. As I said at the outset, we've barely scratched the surface. There's a long way to go in terms of the market's overall growth. And of course, when you consider the investor's wallet as a whole — whether we're talking about households' total financial assets or total assets, or the incremental flow — the share our industry captures remains quite small, and compared with the rest of the world, there's a long way for us to go. But as I noted, globally we've observed margins coming under pressure. Still, I think in India, at the point where we are now, if you look at our margins and equity — which sit more in the ET — handling ETs — and fixed income, which runs at roughly anywhere from 27, 28 to perhaps 32, 33 basis points on the money market.
Navneet Munot
executiveThere are potentially — these constitute our 3 main segments, perhaps roughly 12 to 13 basis points. At least for the near term, it appears that this could be sustainable. But naturally, across a longer stretch, as passives grow bigger, there might be thinner margins on the equity side. And naturally, if the passive begins expanding within other segments, then it would carry its overall effect.
Sameer Bhise
analystAlright. Alright, that's useful. And it may be early days yet, but have you noticed any effect on flows — we're probably near the end of April now — and how have things played out with this whole COVID situation? Any thoughts on that.
Navneet Munot
executiveSo, again, as I said at the outset, the country has been struck by COVID's second wave. But the interesting thing is that at this same time last year, when COVID hit — and I think all of us have traveled a long distance since then, every industry, or nearly everyone, has figured out how to live with it. And I think digital has become a way of life. In fact, as I noted a few minutes ago, our NFO is underway, and the last couple of days have been fairly encouraging, and that's even though a large number of branches would be shut, a large number of — I think — salespeople or client services, everyone would be working from home. But I think digital is the way of life. And I think we've managed to make solid progress on that front. So of course, COVID is having an impact. But yes, I mean, we are seeing everyone getting accustomed to the new environment.
Sameer Bhise
analystSo April has held up well despite what's happening around — is that what you'd say?
Navneet Munot
executiveI can't speak to the industry figures, and maybe a couple of other products as well. I was merely noting that the NFO that's currently open, and the industry has managed to function in this environment. Regarding flows thus far, where the April month is concerned, one of the intriguing patterns we've observed, Sameer, over the last several quarters — counterintuitively — is that whenever the market has risen a lot, I mean, we're seeing some redemptions across the industry. But in the month of March, when markets fell, many people who had been waiting on the sidelines, they put money into — I mean they put money to work, and then we saw some flows into the equity funds. I think — and it sounds a little counterintuitive — but perhaps that trend might persist. I think if markets stabilize at these levels, we may see domestic investors returning. Following 9 months of outflows, March was a good month, and maybe we'll have to keep our fingers crossed for the next several months.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Nischint Chawathe, who is on the line from Kotak Securities.
Nischint Chawathe
analystCan you hear me at this point?
Operator
operatorYes.
Nischint Chawathe
analystYes. I’d like to ask about the ESOPs you’ve announced—roughly INR 300-odd crores, INR 350-odd crores. I’m just trying to get a sense of the overall expense tied to those ESOPs that would hit the P&L across a 3-year span. In fact, I think it’s a 3.5-year span.
Simal Kanuga
executiveNischint, once the annual report is released, I believe you'll have a much clearer picture of that. That said, you might be able to sort of extrapolate figures based on what our current results show. Still, I'd hold off until the annual report is available before getting a clearer sense of the total cost.
Nischint Chawathe
analystThat's a fair point. And the current figure would be — I know you walked through the reasoning. But the current figure would land somewhere around 5% to 10% of all the vesting that took place this quarter.
Simal Kanuga
executiveIn that area, roughly.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Malhar Hemal Manek, who is an individual investor.
Speaker
unknownI'd like to ask about the core way our business is structured, since I believe a conflict of interest may exist there. The reason is that, frequently, the count of attractive investment opportunities goes down when the fund size goes up, owing to the law of large numbers. As a result, it's frequently in the unitholder's interest for the maximum fund size to be capped, for lower quality investments to be avoided, and for the returns of the funds to be higher. Shareholders, though, would prefer the fund size to be as large as it can possibly be. So how do you think about this conflict of interest?
Navneet Munot
executiveGiven how big the equity fund is — and I take it that when you mentioned mutual funds, you meant the equity funds, as far as size goes — I'm honestly not certain there's a correlation between how large a fund is and how it performs over a longer horizon. Even so, if you consider the industry's overall size, the total equity AUM that all mutual funds manage combined, against the overall market cap, we remain quite small relative to most other developed markets. I also believe there's still plenty of capacity, especially in strategies such as large cap, multi cap, flexicap — several of them. There's a long way for us to go. Sometimes, when you sense that a strategy has less capacity or that incremental flows could hurt your ability to deliver returns in line with expectations, fund houses have clearly taken that step and moderated those flows, or may even have halted them. But on the whole, if the question is whether the mutual fund industry ought to have stopped flows because it has grown very large, I don't think we're anywhere near that.
Navneet Munot
executiveWe’re a very long way from those.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Hiral Desai at Anived Portfolio Managers.
Hiral Desai
analystCan you hear me? Is the audio coming through?
Operator
operatorYes, sir, you are.
Hiral Desai
analystMy question is this: you've talked about passive funds, and about the fact that EPFO money sitting in there accounts for a large part of that. But looking at the past couple of quarters, a lot of these index funds have been launched outside the headline indexes. So the NEXT 50, Midcap 150 — a lot of these small cap funds are being launched. Now, generally, HDFC has been fairly strong in the smaller cap and the mid cap domain. Now my worry is, you know, in an index fund, since there is not too much of a differentiation available, the first-mover advantage could actually be used. So I just wanted to get your thoughts on that.
Navneet Munot
executiveSo Hiral, if you add up every index fund out there, the total is roughly INR 15,000 crores, give or take. And inside that space, we've clearly been the leader. Our market share would be near 30%, I believe — isn't that right, Simal?
Simal Kanuga
executiveYeah. Yeah, 30%.
Navneet Munot
executiveRight, our market share sits at roughly 30%. Actually, when I first talked through the product lineup — or the roadmap for launches across the coming quarters — that covers a number of the offerings on the index fund side as well.
Simal Kanuga
executiveSo, if I can just jump in here — we've already filed for a NIFTY NEXT 50 fund with the regulator. And we're in the process of perhaps adding 1 or 2 other indices as part of our index fund offering.
Hiral Desai
analystUnderstood, understood. No, sir, that's actually the point I was hoping to verify — whether a few of these products really sit in the pipeline across the coming couple of quarters. That's why I raised the question. The second thing, Navneet, is that given how much time you've put into this industry, I just wanted to get a sense of some of the fintechs currently operating out there — so players such as Paytm or ETMONEY expanding, plus plenty of these other fintechs in the market — are they genuinely assisting when it comes to lifting penetration past, say, the big cities? So are you witnessing substantial flows through these platforms arriving from beyond, say, the top 20 cities?
Navneet Munot
executiveYes, Hiral. Actually, the fintechs have performed really strongly. A number of them — if I may mention the names, companies such as Zerodha, Paytm, ETMONEY, and Groww, all of these players — are getting, I'd say, fairly substantial in terms of investors who use them as platforms for transactions. As a matter of fact, over the past 1 year, close to more than 1/3 of the new brands — that is, the new investors the industry has brought in — have originated from these fintechs. And one more point that's quite interesting: many of these new investors are in fact under 30 years of age. So on the whole, if my recollection of the figure is right, it's 29-odd lakhs of new SIPs that these fintechs have generated, which works out to roughly 29% of all industry SIPs too. And their AUM has already gone past INR 20,000 crores. So they're becoming, I'd say, fairly meaningful. And they are genuinely assisting in broadening the market toward a newer set of investors.
Hiral Desai
analystWould our share of the fintech market be comparable to the share we hold overall?
Simal Kanuga
executiveHiral, reaching those figures wouldn't be very optimal for us.
Hiral Desai
analystSure, no problem at all, Simal. My final question concerns the operating cash flow figure you reported alongside the FY '21 results. Within that number there are a couple of line items — one being the loss on sale, sorry, the INR 91 crores loss on sale of investment. Then there's an MTM on investments of roughly INR 217 crores. Could you split these out between whatever relates to the SL NCDs and the remainder of the investment book? My understanding is that in the P&L we had already booked an impact for the SL NCDs in Q4 of last year. So if you could just break that down for me, please.
Simal Kanuga
executiveAlright, so let me walk you through what has taken place regarding the SL NCDs. You're correct that during the previous year, we did absorb a loss on the SL NCDs. And in the current year, across the first 3 quarters, you would have observed that we recorded MTM gains on those entities, since the underlying collateral — namely the shares of Zee's group company — had risen in value. Now, during this quarter, as stated in a note, the majority of those shares have been divested, so on a net basis, we have a gain of approximately INR 85 crores, which is also the reason you will notice other income for this year coming in higher.
Hiral Desai
analystRight, right. No, no. What I wanted to do was look at it from a full-year standpoint, because there are a couple of line items sitting in operating cash flow. One of them is the loss on sale of investment, which is INR 91 crores, and the other, I believe, is the MTM on the investment book, roughly INR 217 crores. All of that ties to the rest of the investment book.
Simal Kanuga
executiveLook, that isn’t a cash flow item. It’s an adjustment made to cash flow right from the outset. When you look at the cash flow statement, you begin with PBT, correct? So essentially, you’re — and you’re attempting to work out cash flow from operating activities. Since this isn’t an operating activity, you’ve removed it. So your — the figure you’re seeing as a negative, if you check the heading, that indicates profit. Can you spot that line, the one where the INR 91 crores appears? That is the profit.
Hiral Desai
analystRight, but then that INR 1,478 crores figure won't reconcile, will it?
Simal Kanuga
executiveIt will, since when you begin at INR 1,478 crores and follow that path, then strip out the additions and subtractions, you arrive at INR 1,478 crores.
Hiral Desai
analystNo, no. Understood, understood, understood. I get that it isn’t tied to operating cash flow. I simply wanted to confirm that this effect comes entirely from the investment book and has no bearing on the SL NCDs.
Navneet Munot
executiveNo. So look, the SL NCDs sit inside the investment book, correct? A great deal of this does tie back to the SL NCDs — so those shares we offloaded that I just mentioned.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Anush Kumar at B&K Securities.
Anush Kumar
analystCan you hear me?
Operator
operatorYes, sir.
Anush Kumar
analystNavneet, nice work on delivering a fairly solid set of results given a more difficult environment. My question is this: we've observed the mix moving toward equity and income on a sequential basis, yet yields appear to have been held down. Could you shed some light on that for us?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo in the past year, with the conditions we saw, I believe additional money flowed into debt as system liquidity grew, and there was a shift toward higher-quality names. And as a fund house, we benefited from that, thanks to our product performance and the quality of our products. On the debt side, we saw increased flows. On the equity side, as we mentioned earlier, the industry has had outflows. Naturally, we were affected by that as well. So the mix has certainly changed this year. That said, if you look at us overall in terms of asset mix, we still have a higher equity asset than the rest of the industry.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Madhukar Ladha, who is on the line from Elara Capital.
Madhukar Ladha
analystLooking at what happened with the numbers this quarter, equity's share and debt's share both actually went up in the quarterly AUM mix quarter over quarter, and yet blended yields appear lower. So I'm trying to understand what might explain that.
Simal Kanuga
executiveMadhukar, are you able to take that one?
Madhukar Ladha
analystYeah, I can hear you. Yes.
Simal Kanuga
executiveMadhukar, equity has ticked up slightly and operating revenue has risen too, so what's behind that comment of yours?
Madhukar Ladha
analystNo. But on a yield basis, right? Last quarter, revenue came in at roughly 49.5 bps against your quarterly average AUM. This quarter, it's 48.8 bps, so that's a drop of around 0.7 bps, and then your equity share has actually risen by — by roughly 80 bps Q-o-Q, while the debt share is up by about 120 bps.
Simal Kanuga
executiveLiquid would have increased as well.
Navneet Munot
executiveYes.
Simal Kanuga
executiveI believe it also...
Madhukar Ladha
analystNo. Liquid is — no, what I mean is the share of AUM.
Navneet Munot
executiveMadhukar, let me jump in on that if I may. So what you're doing is taking the total mix of equity, debt and liquid and running it on a straight-line basis. But even inside equity, it's possible that cash flowing into 1 product rather than another, and debt capital going to one product rather than another, could also play some role. 0.7 isn't especially high. So I'd say it likely has to do with what's going on internally within the asset class.
Madhukar Ladha
analystOkay. It has more to do with things inside…
Navneet Munot
executiveThe mark-to-market gain present in a fund, along with flows relative to the book, can affect the overall margin. So, I mean, on a quarter-on-quarter basis, you can't simply draw a straight line, put it on the model, and extrapolate from that.
Madhukar Ladha
analystRight. No, I get that — I was just trying to find out whether anything over there is shifting in a material way.
Navneet Munot
executiveThe situation looks nearly identical.
Operator
operatorShubhranshu Mishra from Systematics has the next question.
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystTwo questions here, both for Navneet. First, considering how the strategic value of sales has shifted upward for passive funds previously, are there particular passive strategies of ours that stretch further into larger AUMs and a rising ETF? We also brought in a little — actually a lot of passive funds, probably through the launches. That's question one. Second, again on performance: one — my understanding is this is an industry-wide phenomenon, and we operate more as a distribution-led industry rather than a product-led one, aside from a few AMCs? So any views on, again, returning to the forefront and turning into a product champion instead of a distribution champion? Those are my 2 questions.
Navneet Munot
executiveOn the passive side, to address that first question—I believe in India a substantial number of investors have still not entered the market, and naturally we must always be thinking about how we outperform the market. So my view is there will be opportunities on both the active and passive sides. And when you look within passive at the overall market right now, roughly 80% plus of AUM comes from about 2 AMCs plus the government disinvestment program. And naturally, the PSU debt ETF we mentioned earlier. The remainder of the passive business from individual investors or from our other channel partners—which is essentially our core strength—remains quite small, and these are early days. As we said earlier, the index fund total size is 15%, and there we hold a dominant market share. A few additional products are either going to be launched within the next few months or sit in the pipeline across the coming several quarters. Over time, I'm confident there will be room to grow on the passive side too, and we would take part. And the distribution strength we possess—we would want to leverage it fully the way we have on the active side, on the passive side as well.
Navneet Munot
executiveEven so, profitability will always be something we keep firmly in mind. In other words, our profitability leads the industry, and we would never lose sight of that either. As for your second question, Shubhranshu, I missed it.
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystSure. So my second question is this: most AMCs have turned into distribution-led franchisees rather than product-led, apart from a few. Now, will we step up to the front and become a product champion, where we make the case with a lot of performance in our equity funds rather than the strength of distribution?
Navneet Munot
executiveIf I've understood correctly—if you're talking about product versus solutions—then yes, I'd use that term, delivering the appropriate kind of solution both to your partners and to investors, which covers all of your hybrid funds designed to meet particular objectives, such as your children's benefit fund or within the retirement category. Those, I think, are probably going to expand. And once more, considering our reach, the strength of our distribution, and the pedigree of the brand, I'm confident there's considerable opportunity in that area too. That was your question, I believe—correct?
Shubhranshu Mishra
analystNo — what I'm really getting at is this: when we examine our larger schemes, the performance doesn't measure up against the various peers. So what steps or measures are we taking, or have we already taken, that will get us back into that game?
Navneet Munot
executiveYes. So I think we said earlier that we've been through a performance cycle over the past couple of years. But I think we've seen a material reversal in how we're performing over the last 6 months, which Simal mentioned earlier. Are we doing anything differently? Honestly, my answer is no. In fact, the same strategy that generated alpha over a long period of time, and which didn't do well in the last couple of years, that very same thing has started to do well recently. And, but at the same time, I mean, we said earlier that we recognize the fact that for an organization of our size and scale and aspiration, having style diversity would be optimal for us. And with that in mind, as all of you are aware, we've added 2 new portfolio managers. Their orientation is very similar to how we think, that is fundamentals focused and also having a long-term orientation. But they think somewhat differently when it comes to valuation. So this was, like, the first step we've taken when it comes to style diversity. In fact, the 2 new managers who joined us last year, they now manage almost 15% or so of our active equity AUM.
Navneet Munot
executiveActually, I can share that. Some of those products have been drawing incremental flows on our side. Of course, we don't disclose the flow numbers for each product, but we are clearly seeing those products gain traction with our partners as well as investors. And of course, the product lineup that we have already discussed about to have a more diversified product base, particularly in the thematic and sectoral as well as in the fund of funds and the other categories.
Operator
operatorSakshi Goenka from Alchemy Capital has the next question.
Sakshi Goenka
analystCan everyone hear me?
Operator
operatorYes, ma'am, that's correct — you are.
Sakshi Goenka
analystYeah, I just wanted to get a handle on how the cost overhead will trend from here. Given the sizable savings you achieved this year, what portion of that do you see as lasting, and how much might return as business momentum improves?
Navneet Munot
executiveSakshi, when you look at employees and the other cost line, we saw a decrease of roughly 8% or so in FY '21 compared with FY '20. And the main way that was accomplished was through cuts in business development, travel, other overheads, et cetera, and the COVID period provided a chance to examine every cost item. A portion of that, or I would say a substantial portion of it, this cost will certainly return. And we would not want to preserve that simply because in any case, we will not scale back the growth prospects. But there could be some cost savings that we could realize, perhaps a modest amount, but let's say, in rent and all which may persist for a while, those sorts of reductions will be sustained. But yes, the bigger portion of the cost that we had cut will come back in times to come. I must stress at the same time that as an organization, we have been very, very cost conscious. In fact, in my first 2 months, I've witnessed the frugality, which is like part of the culture of the organization. And I think that will always persist. And that's why we have been able to have, apart from several other reasons, our better quality asset mix or better quality distribution, et cetera, is also that given the cost consciousness, we have an industry-leading profitability.
Navneet Munot
executiveThat will always remain our focus. Still, a significant amount of cost rationalization was possible last year, and I think I would assume much of it will surface, and we would not want to hold that back.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Utkarsh Solapurwala, who is on the line from Damos Capital.
Utkarsh Solapurwala
analystCan you hear me, sir?
Navneet Munot
executiveRight, Utkarsh.
Utkarsh Solapurwala
analystMy question follows up on fintech. What I mean is that millennials these days are choosing apps like Zerodha and Groww more often instead of visiting traditional brokers or the traditional distribution channels for financial services products. So if fintechs such as Zerodha obtain a license, wouldn't they disrupt the traditional financial services industry and reduce our market share and profitability going forward?
Navneet Munot
executiveOf course, I'd say I've long been a follower of Andy Grove — Only The Paranoid Survive — so we should stay paranoid at all times. But at the same time, we're aware of where our strength lies: our platform, I'd say our product range, our people, our presence, and the partnerships we've built over the years. And naturally, when it comes to the overall digital infrastructure, I'd say our digital assets rank right up there. We'll keep building on that, be it the user interface or the user experience we offer. Just as you mentioned the names of some of the fintechs, we'll definitely stay focused on that as well. So there's no reason we'd lose out just because newer players are coming into the industry. In fact, I firmly believe there's so much growth ahead of us when it comes to capturing a higher share of the overall wallet — I mean, the households' wallet — and the newer players will actually benefit everyone. And I think the growth opportunity is so large that the more the merrier. I'm sure everyone will bring some innovation that will truly help the industry.
Navneet Munot
executiveSo I think our real focus should stay on what we do best, and at the same time we should keep strengthening how customer-centric we are on our side.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Shailaja Dongrel with CONCEPT Investwell.
Analyst
analystWhat exactly are we doing differently that makes us so cost efficient? People regard HDFCAMC as among the most cost-efficient AMCs anywhere in the world. So what is it that we do differently? And why do others find it so hard to match?
Navneet Munot
executiveI'd like to bring others in on this too, perhaps. But my take is that it's embedded in how we operate. Every dollar spent on anything at all matters, I believe. The procedures put in place to extract maximum value across every function — that's deeply ingrained, I'd say. Beyond that, it comes down to how people work; it's a culture built up over time. And naturally, it's also baked into the business model: right from day 1, since this company was founded, the emphasis has been on size, scale, and the quality and profitability of the business. Those things are all essential. We never really traded profitability away for scale, or for any other motive, I'd say. So the constant focus has been on making the business sustainable. And that, I think, has served us well through the cycles. Anything you'd like to add, Simal?
Simal Kanuga
executiveYes. I’d like to add one point here: I think a big share of the credit for this focus on costs belongs to Milind, who built this business. So it was something he instilled. We — the whole management team — are always saying that you have to watch this, because in the end this is what feeds into the company’s profitability, so you need to be very careful about it. And honestly, when I joined this company, which was about 7, 8 years ago, I had worked at other mutual funds. And when I arrived here, I saw that even the sales guys — and usually, sales guys are people you have to hold back — but even the sales guys here were so cost-conscious that it came as a bit of a surprise.
Navneet Munot
executiveThat’s a positive surprise.
Operator
operatorUp next, we have a question from Dipanjan Ghosh at Kotak.
Dipanjan Ghosh
analystSir, just one quick question. I think this follows up on what another participant asked about net yields, that revenue line item. So I just wanted to get clarity: you said part of the product mix inflows — maybe those inflows were there to fund MTM gains where the funds — where yields are low. I'm trying to work out whether there's been any shift in the distributor commissions you charge at the scheme level. During the quarter, was there less passthrough from the scheme accounts to the fund accounts?
Navneet Munot
executiveI don’t believe there’s any material change. No, not really. As we’ve consistently said, I think that comes down to book versus flows, yes.
Operator
operatorThe next question comes from Kunal Thanvi at Banyan Tree Advisors.
Kunal Thanvi
analystWelcome, Navneet, to your new role, and congratulations to you. My question is something we've raised for a while now, so pardon me for repeating it. When we speak with IFAs and the distribution folks about channels, one piece of feedback that's come up commonly for a few years or so is that the PRs pass on, and weak performance had created a degree of discontent within the chain here, and they weren't very happy with HDFC Mutual Fund. I wanted to understand what color you can give on that. How are things moving now that performance is coming back? And also the fact that we're trying to transition some portion of our AUM with different strategies — what flavor are we seeing on the distribution side of the business?
Navneet Munot
executiveOur partners matter a great deal to us. I mean, they're the reason we exist. I mean, our customers and partners are the ones who have — who've done it for us, and that's why we're where we are. And they mean a lot to us. And when it comes to making sure we deliver the performance they'd expect from a brand like ours, we compensate them well for the assets they bring in. As part of that, the connectivity, the service we'd give them, that is very, very critical. And we've always been very, very innovative on that front in terms of how we can serve them better. Of course, the performance you mentioned or maybe some of the other reasons you brought up over the last few years may have had some impact. But we have corrected, I mean last 2 months or so. A lot of these people have been very, very good friends for a very long time. I think they're all — they've always been very supportive of us, and I have no doubt in my mind that they'd be very, very supportive of us in terms of growing the business to the next level.
Kunal Thanvi
analystSure. My second area concerned the passive side of the business, and it's largely industry-specific. For instance, looking at global markets, when sustained underperformance occurs and a particular category's size exceeds what flexibility can handle in that market, the shift from active to passive happens at a much quicker pace. What's your sense on large cap as a category in India — do you feel we're getting close to the point where a large part of the yield would sit on the passive side in the next 3 to 5 years?
Navneet Munot
executiveOver the past several years, we've witnessed significant polarization in the market. My recollection is that during 2018, '19, and '20 — those 3 years — roughly 80% or so of NIFTY's returns came from the top 5 stocks. If my memory serves me right, that figure in 2018 exceeded 100%. And every one of the remaining stocks, well, they subtracted from the total return. As the rally broadens out, my assumption is that the alpha opportunity will return. In fact, it's fairly evident when you examine fund performance across the last couple of months or quarters. Actually, you raised this on a global basis, and I fully agree that over an extended period — the last several years worldwide — capital has shifted from active to passive. But considering how ETFs have grown and where they stand today, along with the emergence of Robinhood investors, these 2 trends will in fact generate greater alpha opportunity for active investors. I mean, you'd have observed what actually unfolded when Tesla joined the S&P, or certain other events, if you've been tracking them. So my view is that — provided active managers execute properly, concentrating perhaps on time arbitrage, with a long-term orientation in our money management compared with many other participants who are affected by market noise, and on research arbitrage, meaning you bring in the right kinds of research sources, robust research, and portfolio construction.
Navneet Munot
executiveWhat we've observed in India across many years is that alpha has been produced in every market cap segment. And looking ahead several years, opportunity remains, considering the size we're at now. By size, I mean the amount of money run by all the large cap — or, say, mid and small cap fund managers relative to the total market cap. So opportunity is still there. Naturally, will it get harder and harder? Naturally. The democratization of information, the institutionalization of markets, all of that is causing alpha to shrink. That's why each fund manager — or each fund house — must work harder and harder on building a solid alpha engine. We take pride in our team and the capacity we've built, the processes we've established. Looking at our fund management, our analyst team and the support team, we believe substantial alpha opportunity exists over a long period of time.
Kunal Thanvi
analystSure. My next question relates to both the industry and HDFCAMC. If you look at the industry, it's a business that generates very high free cash flow, where CFO to PAT stands at more than 90%, which is something we've also observed at FMCG companies. Yet dividend payouts are lower, and that's specifically true for HDFCAMC as well. Do you have any thoughts on that aspect? How should we think about dividend payouts? And is there a specific policy that we follow?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo I think this is something that our Board and our team have talked about as well, and that's why this year you'd have noticed the dividend has increased. I mean, even the payout ratio has risen. And I mean, there's always a debate about the appropriate level of cash you'd want to carry on the balance sheet. But of course, you're right, because cash past a certain level would begin pulling your ROE down. So that's a fine balance you have to strike. But I agree with you, and I think the Board is aware of that, and it's something that keeps being discussed within the Board — what the ideal payout ratio should be.
Kunal Thanvi
analystAbsolutely. And if I could fit in one final question, it's on a wider level. Looking at the AMC business, it has 4 major pillars: brand, distribution, risk management and performance. Coming in now as CEO, which areas would you focus on if you were drawing parallels from those 4 pillars? What is something you're looking to pursue with greater vigor?
Navneet Munot
executiveYou're right, and during roughly the last hour we'd have talked about the pedigree behind our brand. We'd have talked about our presence, meaning our reach. We've talked about our people, our partnerships, our platform, our profitability — all of it. And to be very honest with you, if you ask me, for us to reach the next level, what's that other P? I think all of these are simply attempts at creating an equilibrium. I mean, all begin with P. Which P matters even more? That would be purpose. And I think that deep sense of purpose we share across the team at HDFC Mutual Fund — that we want to be the wealth creator for every Indian. After 20 years of -- since our inception, I mean, today we have, like roughly, as Simal mentioned, 9 million accounts. If you look at unique investors, they'd be a little over 5 million. If you look at the overall industry, that is less than 25 million. In a country of our size over the next 5 or 10, 20 years as the economy goes to a much higher level.
Navneet Munot
executiveSo with that said, household savings are going to stay extremely high. For this industry to advance to the next stage, I believe a deep sense of purpose matters more. And that's exactly where our focus will go. This mission will drive us — the goal of being the wealth creator for every Indian. So essentially, building on each of these elements: the pedigree you mentioned, our brand being synonymous with trust and confidence, the people and the experience within the team — whether that's the investment team or all the other teams — the partnerships we've built over the years, the presence we have, 227 branches, whether you look at our presence in B30, the digital presence or the digital assets we've created, all of it. And I think if you keep building on that, a deep sense of purpose, that customer centricity — how do we reach more and more investors and create wealth for them over a long period — I think that will — that's something that will take us to a different level, and that's what motivates the management team here every single day.
Operator
operatorWe have time for a final question, and it comes from Abhishek Saraf at Jefferies.
Abhishek Saraf
analystLet me just ask about one area, if you could elaborate, regarding the other asset management structure. What's our strategy when it comes to PMS and the alternative EIF type of structure? Since we're sensing some shift toward passives as well on the mutual fund side. So if that leads to some dilution in margins at the MF level, do you think that means we'll be focusing on the PMS and EIF side, where we could probably earn equity kind of TERs? And probably at the AMC level, we have margin utilization, meaning a positive impact on margin. So just your thoughts on how HDFCAMC views the alternative structures?
Navneet Munot
executiveI think, looking back through our history, we were among the early participants on the PMS side. And given the platform we have, there's clearly substantial potential, or opportunity, for us when it comes to building the PMS business. Plus, with certain other regulatory shifts — especially the draft paper on accredited investors — that could genuinely unlock opportunities both on the PMS side and on the alternative side. We'll always stay open to that. Again, looking back through history, as I mentioned, we once had a sizable base of clients who were with us in PMS products. This year, we're looking at possibly expanding that platform. That said, I should note that even within our core products there's plenty of opportunity for us — I mean in our core production plus the new product launches I spoke about in the mutual fund space. So while we keep an eye on opportunities outside the mutual fund space, whether through PMS or the AIF route, I think our bigger focus, at least in the near term, will continue to stay on the mutual fund side.
Abhishek Saraf
analystIf I could just squeeze in one final question. Over the past 6, 7 months, our schemes have been outperforming. Is that mainly because of the mean reversion we've seen toward value stocks, or are there other factors also driving the outperformance our schemes have managed to deliver?
Navneet Munot
executiveLike I said before, has there been any shift in how investors are thinking about time? Not really. I believe it's the same approach that generated alpha over an extended stretch historically, and that approach definitely struggled across the last 2 years. That exact same approach has begun performing well lately. And at the same time, as I noted earlier, we've brought on newer fund managers who run a couple of strategies. And although the general orientation might be similar, they do think somewhat differently, especially regarding valuation.
Operator
operatorThank you. Given the time we have left, that was the final question. I'll now pass the conference back to management for their closing remarks.
Navneet Munot
executiveThanks to everyone for joining this call. As I said before, the country has been struck by the COVID wave. I hope you and the people close to you stay safe. Wishing each of you all the best.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings us to the end of this conference on behalf of HDFC Asset Management Company Limited. We appreciate your participation, and you can now disconnect your lines.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HDFC Asset Management Company Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to HDFC Asset Management Company Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in HDFC Asset Management Company Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.