HDFC Asset Management Company Limited (HDFCAMC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 16, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Simal Kanuga
executiveThanks a lot. Good evening, everyone, and many thanks for joining this call. Our presentation can be found on our website and on the exchanges' sites too. We'll begin, as we always do, with a look at the industry, then move on to our company. After that, we'll take your questions. During the first quarter of this financial year, equity-oriented funds drew healthy inflows, compared with an outflow of INR 84 billion in the quarter ending March '21. Net inflow for this quarter will be INR 251 billion. A reversal in trends has been visible since March 2021, and it is still continuing as we speak. The interesting thing we have observed is gross equity flows. For the financial year that ended in March '21, average monthly gross flows came to INR 237 billion, whereas in the first quarter of the current financial year, that average monthly gross figure was INR 337 billion. Average monthly reductions, which stood at INR 290 billion last financial year, came to INR 253 billion in this quarter. Net funds recorded outflows of INR 20 billion, while liquid funds saw inflows of INR 95 billion. The "other" category, which includes ETFs, arbitrage funds and hedge funds investing overseas, continued to attract healthy inflows. Individual folios crossed the 100 million mark for the first time, finishing at 102 million as of June end. On the individual side, AUM stands at INR 18.3 billion, and equity-oriented funds make up 70% of that. B-30 remains at 16% of total industry AUM and accounts for 27% of equity-oriented AUM. As you're all aware, SIP flows for June 2021 came in at INR 92 billion. Turning now to our company: we ended the quarter with AUM of INR 4,187 billion and a market share of 12.4%. Quarterly average AUM was INR 4,169 billion, with a market share of 12.6%. For the reasons discussed on earlier calls, we also report market share and AUM data. Our market share on a quarterly average AUM basis, as shown here, is 13.7%, while on a closing basis it is 13.6%. When you look at actively managed equity-oriented AUM, our share comes to 12.9% measured on a QA AUM basis, and 12.6% on a closing AUM basis. It's worth noting here that we wrapped up a sectoral NFO — the banking and financial services fund — not long ago. We also brought out an asset allocation fund of funds during the quarter, and the response has been healthy. On the debt side, our market share is 14.5% in QA AUM and 14.7% in closing AUM; for liquid, the figures are 15.5% and 15.9% in QA AUM and closing AUM respectively. Our asset mix remains favorable relative to the industry, given the larger share of equity assets we carry. Individual investors account for 57.9% of our AUM, versus 53.7% for the industry. Our market share in individual AUM remains the highest, at 13.5%. In June 2021, systematic transactions we processed came to INR 9.8 billion, and what we report is actual cash flow. For the whole quarter, inflows from systematic transactions reached INR 28.3 billion. On the subject of systematic transactions, we want to highlight an interesting campaign we ran for a month or two. We called it NurtureNature and committed to planting one tree for every new SIP registered digitally in an equity-oriented strategy. We scheduled it around World Environment Day and ran it for a couple of things. The response was genuinely heartening, with strong interest shown across the country. With an 11.5% share in B-30 markets, we hold a distant #2 position. On the digital side, we are making some substantial changes. Our mobile app was recently refreshed — simple and powerful. And the feedback coming in on it is truly encouraging. I think instead of listing everything we're doing, it would serve us better to update all of you whenever we complete something. You will certainly be hearing a lot more from us on this. We keep progressing on building a state-of-the-art digital infrastructure and using it to improve customer experience. We now turn to financials. For the quarter that closed on June 30, 2021, the company turned in stronger results than it did in the same quarter of 2020. Operating revenue increased, driven by a larger AUM and by a mix that paid better, with equity AUM making up a bigger share; at the same time, the company spent more on business promotion during the quarter. Since those accumulated costs are recorded in the schemes' books, they result in reduced management fees for the company. The company has also seen some margin dilution caused by a lower total expense ratio in equity schemes, which stems from growth in size. Other income was higher this quarter, thanks to a bigger book size and mark-to-market gains on investments. Back in February 2021, we granted ESOPs to a number of employees, and our employee benefit expense line carries pro rata amortization of the ESOP fair value, as the Indian accounting framework that applies to the company requires. That's a noncash charge — it isn't deductible in the same way and it's book value neutral. For quarter 1 of FY '22, that noncash charge amounted to INR 176 million. Beyond that, employee benefit expense was also higher because we went back to our practice of annual increments in employee remuneration, having paused it last year in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. This allowance of certain expenses along with higher tax on the company's investment income has added to the rise in the company tax rate. We now move to the financial highlights for the quarter. Here's how the quarter breaks down: operating profit for the company came in at INR 3,652 million for the quarter that closed June 30, 2021, versus INR 3,006 million in the quarter ending June 30, 2020 — that's a 21% rise. Profit before tax for the quarter ended June 30, 2021, climbed 23% to INR 4,661 million, compared with INR 3,804 million in the quarter ended 2020. For the quarter that closed on June 30, 2021, profit after tax came in at INR 3,454 million, compared with INR 3,024 million for the quarter that closed on June 30, 2020 — a rise of 14%. Operating margin for the quarter that closed on June 30, 2021 now stands at 35 basis points, versus 34 basis points for the quarter that closed on June 30, 2020. With that, we'd like to move into the Q&A. As Neera said, Navneet and Piyush are both here with us. If you have any questions, we're happy to take them. Neera, please go ahead and open the line for questions.
Analyst
analystFirst off, I'd like to ask: for the coming 2 to 3 years, what mix of equity and non-equity are you aiming for?
Navneet Munot
executiveShalijah, we don't really set a target like that, though you've probably noticed our share outpaces the industry's overall share. Within total assets, our equity portion runs above the rest of the industry, and we'd be glad to see that continue going forward.
Analyst
analystAll right. My next question: we've now watched our market share fall steadily for more than a year. What do you believe accounts for this goal? And what steps are we taking at this point on this matter?
Navneet Munot
executiveAs Simal said earlier, I think, first of all, when it comes to market share, the more relevant figure to look at is mainly the data on Slide 8 — that's market share excluding ETF. Because, as you know, ETF AUM here has over 80% of the AUM coming from 2 AMCs and also from the government disinvestment program in PSU and ETFs. Of course, we have seen a slight dip in ETF AUM market share as well. But we wouldn't read too much into that. Are we worried? No, but we are definitely taking action to change it. No doubt about that, of course, here. We carry on with our efforts and focus, which we are hopeful and confident will deliver a healthy market share. We believe all the necessary ingredients are in place; these things, whether we like it or not, don't move in a straight line. We do go through gyrations. As you are aware, there has been a period when some of our equity funds haven't performed as well. There has been a significant improvement in the government, some of the funds rank in top quartile or even top decile in the last '21 performance. Even performance over 3 and 5 years has started looking good and being recognized by our distribution partners as well as clients. We have been making efforts on all fronts, including better connectivity with our partners to spread this message. You would have seen some of the other marketing campaigns recently. Simal talked about the NurtureNature campaign that we did as an ESG initiative, but it also has — digital adoption of our digital assets as well as an increase in flows into SIPs, bringing new investors and then new partners into our fold and a variety of other initiatives that are underway, which gives us confidence that over a period of time, you would see improvement in market share.
Analyst
analystAll right, and just to ask — do we expect our market share to return to 23%, the level it held before?
Navneet Munot
executiveAs Simal mentioned, consider the product gaps — certain categories where our presence wasn't complete. As you're aware, starting in 2018, under the SEBI classification, there are 4 categories in equity where we've ranked as the biggest player in fixed income. We offer something in nearly every category spanning duration and credit products. And naturally, on the money markets side, we hold the top position. However, a handful of categories exist — sector and thematic funds, passive products, meaning both ETF and index funds, international funds, and additionally certain fund of funds. In some of those categories, our product lineup wasn't complete; yet across the last couple of quarters, we've introduced a few products. More products will come over the next several quarters; actually, Simal can correct me — last quarter we had 2 NFOs, and I can't recall when HDFC AMC last had 2 NFOs within 1 quarter; both drew a very strong response from our partners and investors. We believe the market will take note of all these efforts, including the performance improvement. And a gradual improvement in market share is what we should be able to see.
Aditya Jain
analystRegarding equity AUM growth from one quarter to the next, those 2 have been fairly good. Could you speak to — give us a qualitative sense of the kind of market share you're seeing in flows? Is it getting better? And roughly which region is that in?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo Aditya, for competitive reasons we don't disclose the flows number. I think across the quarters or years, we've said this, and we've kept making that same point. But broadly, as you're aware, flows in the industry have turned around; for 9-odd months, the industry was experiencing outflows. During the last 3 or 4 months, the industry has begun to see positive flow. We think that — I believe over the coming several quarters, equity flow ought to stay healthy.
Aditya Jain
analystUnderstood; regarding the income...
Navneet Munot
executiveTo be specific, if your question concerns our funds, I believe several funds run by the newer managers who came on board during the past 1 or 2 years have drawn solid interest, while the new fund launched in the December quarter, the dividend yield fund, the large and mid-cap fund, focused equity fund, multi-strategy, multi-asset fund — I think a number of these funds have attracted solid interest over the last few months. And naturally, we have been emphasizing that the fund has gotten better across the board. And as the product matures, we ought to see flows returning across all categories.
Aditya Jain
analystUnderstood. Regarding the ESOP cost, would you be able to provide the expected figures for the full year FY '22 and then for '23? I'm assuming those will be clear numbers, but is that what they are from a modeling standpoint?
Piyush Surana
executiveI'll handle this one. On the last call, we discussed the ESOP and its structure, which involves vesting over 3 years, correct, with 1/3 vesting this year. So — the second vesting occurs after 2 years, and the third one after 3 years. As a result, the costs you observe are front-loaded in the first year, since the first year carries the full cost of the first tranche, half the cost of the second tranche, and 1/3 of the cost of the third tranche. And because these were granted in February, a full year concludes in Feb. So this cost that you've seen this quarter, logically speaking, you would see the same cost in the next 2 quarters. And in the last quarter, it would dip. And then the following 2 years would carry a lower cost based on the vesting schedule I just described. So you could, based on this information, do some calculation and figure out what the likely cost would be.
Aditya Jain
analystUnderstood. Alright, and one final point — you touched briefly on your own digital investments. Could you elaborate on how substantial those are, or how they stack up against newer digital channels such as apps like Groww, Paytm Money, and INDwealth? So how crucial is your own acquisition compared with the third-party apps, which are gaining solid traction nowadays?
Navneet Munot
executiveWell, I believe Simal discussed the refresh — because of — using the app and getting a feel for it yourself, being able to do voice search on our corporate website, being able — a DPI gateway so third parties can integrate with some distributors. We have an R&D with access on a mobile solution for partners. I could keep listing things, but as — I think what I'd say is it isn't so much about culture, it's about mindset; it's about people participating and making this a way of life for your people. It isn't just about technology, applications, a portal or the app. Rather, it's about embedding a culture of automation, a culture of customer centricity, eliminating every friction possible in their journey, shifting from, I'd say, a KYC to UIC — know your customer to understand your customer. Letting our partners scale their business up. In what ways do we apply data and analytics across every part of our business? In what ways can we automate our processes? So all I'd say is that — I mean, digital will be the backbone of everything we do, the entire ecosystem. Even at the risk of repeating a few things I've mentioned. In what ways do we serve our customers? In what ways do we make their journey as frictionless as possible? In what ways do we onboard a new distributor? In what ways do we serve those distributors? How can analytics assist them with upselling? In what ways do we deliver our content better? We make it more contextual and more consumable. So it comes down to a range of things and then making the organization future ready. We have solid digital assets built over the years, we've been investing. We'll invest a great deal more in that as we speak.
Kunal Thanvi
analystWell done to the team on a solid set of numbers. I also hope everyone at HDFC is well and keeping safe. I have 2 questions. My first one concerns SIP market share. We're seeing the SIP market share trend downward. I just wanted a comment on what drove that fall in market share. Is it fewer new SIPs coming in, or more cancellations? Because in the overall industry figures, what we've observed is a meaningful increase in usage, while cancellations have somewhat flattened out. So how is HDFC AMC viewing this same trend from the company's perspective?
Navneet Munot
executiveWell, of course, Kunal, you would know this — over the years, I think we have clearly been a leader in SIPs. In fact, more than a decade ago, when SIPs weren't as widespread, I think we were among the biggest players in the SIP market. As an organization, we have worked very hard to promote the idea of SIPs within the mutual fund industry. In fact, over the years, when you get a cycle that isn't going your way, when performance dipped, we also saw a bit of cancellation and fewer additions of new SIPs. As we discussed here when we spoke about flows returning to equities, we expect the same thing to happen with the SIP book as well. A few other initiatives we've launched lately also address how we retain our leadership on the SIP side. That is a very, very critical part of our business growth strategy; it always has been and always will be.
Kunal Thanvi
analystSure. I understand. The reason I posed this question this way — and perhaps a related follow-up too. Something we keep hearing throughout the industry is that the digital players, whether it's the Groww, the ETMONEYs of the world, the PhonePes of the world, they're bringing in fresh additions to the SIP. On the last call, we had also brought this up — we discussed it. So how are they set up with these third-party apps when it comes to acquiring, like, new customers coming into the market?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo in every way possible, I mean, collaborating with all our partners who have historically assisted us in building the SIP book, whether those are the banks or the national distributors or the MFDs, large or small, and the fintechs are another group of partners for us. So we will be — we have been a partner alongside all of them. As I said, as noted, I mean, we step up our efforts toward better partnership with them as we enhance our overall capabilities. I don't see any reason why, even within the fintech space, our market share shouldn't be greater than where it stands today. And a couple of other points, I think Simal spoke about at the NurtureNature campaign, and we were very pleased by investors' and our partners' response. We will be launching more initiatives to make sure we secure our fair share of the SIPs. Beyond that, I would also add that a lot of it is about market making. One part is capturing the market share we deserve, HDFC AMC, but also the — one can talk about the INR 9,200 crores of SIP flow. Yet considering the overall savings pool, that figure ought to be far bigger over the coming several years. And I think as a leading industry player, we will do whatever it takes to ensure that we not only work on gaining market share from the current book, but also act as a collaborator with other industry players on how we grow that substantially. So working with millennials, I mean offering the best possible investment education and offering the best possible transaction tool to millennials. Quite a few of them over the last 1 year or 15 months, we have observed have become a lot more drawn toward direct investing. We believe that for long-term value creation, it's important that they don't shift their focus away from mutual fund products, particularly via the SIP route. And whether it's our marketing strategy, whether it's our digital strategy, whether whatever initiatives we are taking on being more pricing centered, being more customer-centered, I think, and moving from client services to a client delight or a customer delight, I think all of those should assist us in helping the industry and expanding that market.
Prakash Kapadia
analystThere are 2 things I'd like to ask. Obviously, taking the last 1 year, starting with the lockdown period, the proportion held by <<inaudible>> and by individual investors in cash volume has kept climbing steadily. It has consistently stood at around 2/3 of total cash share volumes. Ordinarily, what tends to happen when that shifts? Because at some point this direct route into the investing market has to rationalize. And once this correction takes place, will we see flows into mutual funds right away, or do they arrive with a lag? What usually happens? Since we've witnessed so many cycles across markets. What usually happens? Do such investors return to mutual funds, and do they end up playing a bigger role in mutual funds because some of them get their fingers burned and come back, though with a lag? That's my first question. And second, could you quantify how much was raised in the last quarter through NFO?
Navneet Munot
executiveSorry to interrupt, but is your question about direct equity versus mutual fund participation by HNI?
Prakash Kapadia
analystYeah. Since right now what we're witnessing is euphoria. So when these shifts happen, what's the outcome? Once things normalize, do we see greater participation in mutual funds, once they've burned their fingers? Will they return? Will they return with a vengeance? Will they return with a lag? If you could give some…
Navneet Munot
executiveWe've witnessed that, Prakash. I mean, this isn't the market's first time. We saw it before too — 2007 or '99, 2000, or in '91, '92. The industry has been through such phases. I mean, there are always — and making money becomes far simpler. The way things have been over the last 12, 14 months, plenty of people get drawn toward direct investing; over a period of time, they come to realize the advantage of professional management and of handing money to mutual funds. Our belief is that I think over a period of time, we ought to be able to start capturing that share. I'm speaking about the industry overall and, naturally, for us too; and I think the — one message that for the industry as well as for us we would be working very hard on is that value creation isn't about like attempting to make money daily or weekly. Rather, value creation, if you've seen some of our recent campaigns, is about what we're calling STP — a sound investment, plus time, plus patience. And it clearly demonstrated that as an industry, I mean if I look at some of our products that carry a 20, 25 years of track record and the compounding that has taken place — that people who put in INR 1 lakh 25 years back, they now have like INR 80 lakh, INR 85 lakh or INR 90 lakh, or a INR 10,000 SIP across a 25-year period has turned into INR 8 or INR 9 crores. As we travel around and spread that message more forcefully and make our UI, UX — which they see while trading in the secondary market or investing in IPO — when they see using our transaction as easy as that or as, I would say, user-friendly as that, hopefully, I think we ought to be able to get that back. But globally, I mean, we're witnessing the same thing. There are a large number of newer investors coming into the equity market or rather, I would say, capital markets. And yes, I mean, one of the savings options — as long as we can provide a better experience and tell our story better, that at the lower end, it's better, you compound your money by handing it to professional fund managers like us. I think we ought to be able to benefit from that trend. I think the trend is very welcome. Honestly, if you ask me, I will — more than 10 million accounts have got opened in demand. In my view, that demonstrates the appeal of the capital market's interest, just as our industry renders our product attractive to — what I mean is, the proposition holds appeal for these investors. And with any luck, we ought to gain from that as well.
Prakash Kapadia
analystAll right. And could you put a number on how much was raised via the NFO in the quarter just ended?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo in our asset allocator fund, I believe it comes to roughly INR 1,100 crores. For our BFSI fund, the figure was INR 1,877 crores, if my memory serves me right. Yes.
Prakash Kapadia
analystAnd finally, you brought up this cycle. So during that cycle—assuming it has to turn around and settle down eventually—then money flows return right away. People figure, okay, I'm better off earning 15%, 18% instead of chasing that quick profit and then losing it all; so does that occur with a delay when it comes to these individual investors returning to mutual funds? Or does it usually take its own time and effort once the market settles?
Navneet Munot
executiveI believe part of what we're seeing this time is structural. Perhaps some people think they're capable of managing and can put money directly into stocks. I mean, they've had a good experience, maybe they wish to keep going. Many investors who came in recently over some period, as they earn money, they might hand that money over to professional fund managers and begin refocusing on their own profession or their own business. I think that would be a quicker use of time, speaking lightly. I think it's — we'll have to wait and watch, I mean, what that tipping point is where new mutual fund folios exceed new demat accounts. I mean, I'll just give you one data point. Between 2017 and 2020, if I recall correctly, our peak investor grew at roughly 70% or so in absolute numbers. And over that period, demat accounts rose by somewhere near 40%, 50%, so those are adding more unique investors than demat accounts, where people are entering the secondary market. Now over the last 1 year, that — maybe 15 months or so, yes, that has flipped. I mean, we've seen about a 15% rise in unique investors, while demat accounts, I mean, are growing at roughly 50% or so. But we've witnessed these cycles previously. And as I said, as long as our industry works together and the message we've been delivering, which is that funds are here, as long as we can spread that message — the market is very large. I mean, the underpenetration is so great that there would be ample scope for us to grow.
Prashant Kothari
analystI’d just like to get a quick handle on what we’re actually seeing here. From the 13 2.8 completion with the regulations, I get that part. But why haven’t yields really risen, given that the equity mix looked favorable for us last quarter?
Navneet Munot
executiveDo you mean margin dilution?
Prashant Kothari
analystNo, what I mean is the yield — operating revenue, which sits at 49 basis points. Why isn't it, say, returning to FY '20 levels, given that the equity mix has clearly improved?
Navneet Munot
executiveLet me address the margin compression a bit. So I think it's — I think over the years, we've said that margins depend on the asset mix we hold: equity, money market. It's also about flow versus stock; and when I say asset mix, I mean within the asset class too. So when you talk about debt, credit funds versus money market funds, margins there are distinctly different. In equity as well, some products carry lower margins. Some products carry higher margins. With some of the newer funds, the money was raised recently, payouts may have been higher. I mean, the overall commission would have been higher versus the stock we hold. Payouts would be lower. It's a combination of a variety of things. Also, I think some competitive pressure has been there. You might have heard about some of the NFOs that happened, and the money has come at a higher cost for the industry. I'm talking overall. And we have to be cognizant of that fact. And it's a fine balancing act for us to look at growth versus margins when we play in our game.
Prashant Kothari
analystDo you have a longer-term perspective on what margins might look like after, say, 5 or 10 years?
Navneet Munot
executiveWell, Piyush has said several times before that we view equities at roughly 80 basis points or thereabouts. As for fixed income, it used to be around the mid-30s, but that has declined since the mix has shifted. People now hold, shall I say, a different opinion on interest rates as well as on the credit environment. And money has sat at the front end of the curve, where margins are thinner. And naturally, there is some interest flowing into passive funds, where margins are also thinner. I think over the coming few years, in India, we continue to believe active funds will keep growing. And on a relative basis, we have healthier margins than the industry, even in fixed income — with the bouquet that we have, we believe our margins can hold at where we are today. In fact, they were higher at one point, but we hope that at minimum we ought to be able to stay at where we are today. And we are examining every option. I mean, looking at certain categories where we sit at present, I mentioned some of those products at the outset. And we give domestic investors exposure to invest internationally, et cetera, into international funds. Over time, we expect margins could remain where they are. But I think globally, if we look at how margins have come under pressure in this industry, with the shift from active to passive and markets growing ever more efficient, obviously there would be some pressure, and I think that cannot be denied. How will we respond? We will respond through, as I said earlier, a range of initiatives on the digital and automation side, how we build better operating leverage there, and also by exploring some additional revenue streams. Right now, nearly all of our revenue and profits come from our old product. There has been a very strong conviction, which I share, that there is so much runway for growth in that space, given the massive underpenetration in India. At the same time, considering the global play and also the changing tastes of various investors, I think we would be open to looking at what else we can do on the non-mutual fund side, which includes PMS and AIF, where margins would be better. It is on the drawing board. Hopefully, we should be able to share over the next couple of quarters what we are thinking on that front. So on the core products, as the margins I gave you, that has been the case over the last few years. We hope we should be able to sustain despite the competitive pressure that is emerging. However, when you consider the worldwide pattern across a stretch of time, then without question, India does sit toward the higher end.
Prayesh Jain
analystFirst off, regarding the — when I compare AUM on a sequential basis, it's gone from roughly INR 1.66 trillion up to INR 1.72 trillion; that works out to only about 3% growth quarter over quarter, while market returns have remained quite robust within the mutual funds and at times delivered 6%, 7% or even better returns. So does that imply we would have seen certain outflows on the equity side?
Simal Kanuga
executivePrayesh, here's the thing — I believe what you're looking at are those figures you cited, our quarterly average AUM; if you check the closing AUM, it has risen from INR 1,654 billion million to INR 1,805 billion during the quarter. So if you turn to Page 9 of the presentation, on the right-hand side, we've provided the closing AUM figure. And that alone should make it clear. So essentially — in terms of — if you look at 15,000-odd during the quarter, that has been the AUM. When you're examining point-to-point market figures, that's what you need to compare against.
Prayesh Jain
analystSo even taking that into account, Simal, it still looks like — given how sharply flows into the market have risen, there appears to be a bit of a disconnect over whether we're actually seeing smaller additions.
Simal Kanuga
executiveYes. We are seeing that — obviously, we have been — and that shows up in the market share, right? So if you look at the figure for our market share, the market share is — what you're saying is absolutely correct.
Prayesh Jain
analystAll right. And Simal, looking at the liquid side, our market share is also slipping quarter over quarter. Do you have any thoughts on that?
Simal Kanuga
executiveI believe we saw a substantial gain in our market share within liquid. I mean, when the crisis hit around March and April, obviously, money flowed to safe havens, and we captured higher flows in the liquid fund. But as corporates' need for money has risen across the quarters, I mean, the liquid fund category overall has declined for us. And at this point market share is more reasonable, whereas — I mean, last year it was exceptionally on the higher side.
Prayesh Jain
analystYeah. I was actually referring more to some of — even a few from Q4 onward, Q4 through Q1, our market share also declined. Are there any particular reasons behind that?
Navneet Munot
executiveLiquid is really hard to forecast. I mean, there's a possibility of growth among corporate treasuries, institutions, and some other investors — I mean, they keep shifting according to what's happening in the money market, and it might be specific instances of a few investors coming in, then moving out on those exact days, yes.
Prayesh Jain
analystAll right. All right. Then finally, regarding the other income, there was a very sharp jump—but is that mainly due to NPM on the equity side? Or what caused it?
Navneet Munot
executiveA couple of factors have driven other income higher. We recorded some mark-to-market gains on certain portfolio holdings. Beyond that, there's the entire matter of the Essel Group NCD we discussed, and that is being set today; I believe we also talked about it on the previous call. So we generated some gains from selling off that debenture..
Prayesh Jain
analystCan you put a number on the Essel piece?
Navneet Munot
executiveI don't believe we'd like to start putting a figure on that.
Prayesh Jain
analystAll right. Sir, I was merely attempting to understand whether the trend in other income is sustainable — the other income line.
Navneet Munot
executiveOn that point, if — I wouldn't really treat this quarter as something one could extrapolate; there's certainly a portion that is likely to hold up given how interest rates stand at this juncture. So there is a fair amount in there. But past that, I don't think we'd want to offer any guidance.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThat said, though, you’re able to look at our portfolios. What I mean is that 88.5% of our assets are invested in mutual funds, mostly in liquid products. Then again, 0.5% sits in an arbitrage fund, which, again — you’d be aware of where current yields stand — and the rest is in debentures and tax rebonds. So you can check prevailing yields and consider your own projection; also take into account that the dividend payment is scheduled in the next few days, which would remove some money from the book.
Piran Engineer
analystCongratulations on the quarter. I've got a few questions. First, about incremental margins coming in below the back book margin. That's been a theme unfolding since October 2018. Where do we stand in that cycle now? Has most of the back book already been repriced downward? And will you perhaps see only a couple of quarters of downward repricing? Or will this continue as a trend for at least a couple of years?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo, Piran, we've discussed this previously. And so this is going to persist for some time. And as I've consistently said, projecting the pace and the duration over which this happens is going to be difficult. The back book, as we've said in the past, was built up under a different dispensation, and the flows are arriving at a different price; so until they converge at some point in time, this is likely to keep occurring.
Piran Engineer
analystAll right, but would it be fair to say that over half of today's AUM has arrived — let's put it this way — during the era of the new pricing dispensation, meaning across the last 2.5?
Navneet Munot
executivePiran, I don't believe we can really offer you anything beyond what we've already provided on that.
Piran Engineer
analystAlright, absolutely. And then the second thing — you brought up some additional costs tied to the scheme during this quarter. Would you be able to put a number on that?
Navneet Munot
executiveNo, honestly not, though there are certain business development costs we've begun to incur, such as SIPs and similar items, so some extra expense has come up there; even so, I don't believe we'll be quantifying it. Viewed competitively, it wouldn't be sensible on our part to do so.
Piran Engineer
analystAll right. All right. Understood; and then finally, regarding what you said about teaming up with fintechs and getting — securing your fair portion of share in that distribution channel, could you just explain what commission rates are like there compared with a traditional distribution channel?
Simal Kanuga
executiveSo a number of those that have been picking up a substantial volume of new SIPs, every one of them channels the money into the direct plan. As a matter of fact, whether they hold the RIA or not within the RNS fund distributors, a few of them might work with fund distributors, so it would be a combination of those.
Piran Engineer
analystAll right. But when you include regular plans, do your offerings come in at par on commissions, or below, or above?
Simal Kanuga
executiveAt par, as far as I can tell. Yeah.
Anshu Dayani
analystThat answers what I asked.
Saurabh Kumar
analystSir, regarding the launches, how many additional points do you expect to do this year, the NFOs?
Simal Kanuga
executiveSo we've discussed the categories in which we'd be looking at product launches. Within the core categories, a multi-cap fund is one we would be launching at some point among sector. We would be expecting an MSC fund from us; on the whole passive side, a couple of products are lined up. The first we started would be an equal weight fund, and a few more are in the pipeline at various stages. One international fund, I mean, that's in the pipeline; so yes, we would — our hands are full for the next couple of quarters.
Saurabh Kumar
analystBut sir, I mean, across the whole year, I mean, what figure are we looking at — 4, 5, or something else?
Simal Kanuga
executiveWhether that's 5 or 1, I can't say. You've witnessed what we're able to collect compared with perhaps plenty of others; that hinges on the — my sense is it's less about what amount of money can be gathered here and more about which product category. Those figures don't carry much meaning, I'd say.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAll right, that's a reasonable point. And sir, regarding this direct piece, first, could you quantify what HDFC AMC's IT budget is? And second, is there any sourcing you obtain from these platforms as part of that direct sourcing, or a relative part of that from national distributors?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo whatever platform emerges from that into the direct plan counts as direct only.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAlright, going straight to the point. So what portion will be HDFC direct, meaning from your own branches of that <<inaudible>>?
Navneet Munot
executiveWell, Saurabh, we haven't disclosed those figures since it operates as a multichannel setup. A portion arrives via our website. Another portion comes in through our physical branches, and beyond that through the RIAs along with the fintech platforms.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAll right, but the fintechs are going to be like — I mean, could you give a — I mean, roughly what range will that number fall in? Is it the dominant portion of this part?
Simal Kanuga
executiveFor our current book, definitely not the dominant portion. That's because SIP creation is a more recent phenomenon rather than an older one. And our book is, like, much...
Saurabh Kumar
analystNo, no, sir — regarding the incremental, the incremental?
Simal Kanuga
executiveAs for the incremental part, no, I don't believe so. Not in terms of value on it. Numbers, possibly.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAll right, and regarding the technology IT, how much would that be, sir?
Simal Kanuga
executiveThe exact figure isn't something I can provide. And as I said earlier, some of it falls under CapEx, while some is revenue expenditure. A portion involves partnerships. Another portion is our in-house development; really, it's a mix of several elements. So within the total expenditures, I don't think I can isolate an IT project as such for you.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAll right. So one last thing, sir. We're noticing some rivals becoming quite aggressive in passive ETFs right now — Zerodha has just come out with a passive ETF, and you've witnessed their track record in the booking space. So what do you make of this business at this point? Would you want to grow it more aggressively? Or — how should we think about this passive ETF piece?
Simal Kanuga
executiveIf you consider the industry's total size, it remains modest. And you brought up one participant. As I believe we noted on the previous call, the boundary is — more players, I think, can only help in expanding the market. This market is quite small. When all is said and done, India still counts about 2.5 crore unique investors out of 1.35 billion people. We've set ourselves what I'd call a very audacious mission — to become the wealth creator for every Indian; so we have a bit more than 5 million unique accounts. We believe there's a very, very long road ahead. A portion of them will arrive through active funds. A portion will arrive through passive funds. A portion will arrive through solutions-oriented products. In India, I believe, needs will differ from household to household. From where we sit, the way we view the business isn't the lens — I mean the one asset managers would apply, right, active against passive, or equity against fixed income, or mutual fund against AIF, PMS; or inside distribution, direct against distributors; inside distributors, banks against NDs against MFDs or RIAs, or T-30 against B-30, and so on. From where we sit, our thinking is that tens of millions of savers across India are here seeking the right kind of product that they can use to meet their financial goals. Provided we can deliver the right kind of solutions to these people by understanding them better, working alongside our partners or working alongside digital platforms, over a period of time, we ought to be able to grow. Certainly, assets have expanded tremendously worldwide. There's plenty of room for that product to grow in India too. In fact, we said earlier that we'd also be launching a couple of products to complete our product bouquet. But as to whether this will significantly dent the growth potential of the business's other segments, the answer is no. Will it genuinely expand the market? The answer is clearly yes. And I think I said last time that a large number of people in India have yet to meet this case; they don't wake up in the morning wondering how do I beat the market today or over the next 6 months and 1 year. So I think it's quite clear that our focus will be on putting customers at the center — on how we can help them meet their financial goals and their life goals. And as long as we're able to do that, the question of which product to use and how we build the solution is something the whole industry will figure out together, I think. And newer players who bring fresh innovation — whether in product, in delivery, or in giving investors a different experience — they're all welcome as part of the industry. We'll all work together. On our side, I think our mission is absolutely clear. We want to be the wealth creator for every Indian, and we believe this product has a lot more potential to grow; and we need to reach out to a lot many more investors than what we have reached out to in the last 25, 30 years as an industry.
Analyst
analystCan you hear me?
Simal Kanuga
executiveYes, okay.
Analyst
analystYeah, so based on what the company disclosed in the previous pre-annual reports, it looks like — we keep shedding distributors. Take FY '19, for example: you had <<inaudible>> distributors on your panel, and by FY '20 that number had dropped to 70,000. Now we're at 65,000. So, as I've put the question before as well, all I've received back is that the company values its distributors. So I'd just like to hear your perspective on why people are leaving us, when peers are reporting a growing trend in panel distributors?
Simal Kanuga
executiveI believe we've largely returned to the previous figure for those distributors. Along the way, there was a phase—if my memory serves—when a number of these distributors shifted toward platforms such as Prudent and NG and others, since I think the aggregation technology plus the remaining IT backbone is on offer, giving you improved service. So some of them sort of danced with these platforms. The count might therefore have dipped, yet new distributors keep emerging. And our numbers are right there. Actually, I'm glad to say that within our sector, for the BFSI fund, over 10,000 MFDs took part in it. From my perspective, that group of distributors has clearly embraced it—that’s how I’d put it.
Analyst
analystAll right. No — the reason I raised this question is that ever since SEBI prohibited upfront commissions, HDFC has experienced a steady drop. So could that be connected, given that the company immediately shifted the cost onto distributors?
Simal Kanuga
executiveNo; so I think — look, you can view this in 2 ways. First, the 70,000 figure we're citing represents the whole universe. The roster of active distributors is clearly far shorter; and as Navneet mentioned, in our most recent BFSI NFO we had over 10,000 distributors take part, which is a very, very big number. So along those lines, in terms of — if you examine it — and that's a point Navneet raised. A number of the smaller distributors have in fact migrated to platform, for reasons of efficiency and cost benefit analysis.
Analyst
analystAll right. And another major trend that appears to have unfolded over the past 2 years is the growth of passive investing; so if you look, they've climbed from roughly 8,000 crores to 9,000 crores; by 2010, they're near 2 lakh crores, 2.5 lakh crores, that's the whole passive AUM; so I tried to get the company's view on this before as well, but it was sort of — the sole answer was that, no, it remains a very small portion of the overall industry. But if you look over the last 3 years, it's also the fastest-expanding segment of the industry. And a few of our peers hold something like 35%, 40% market share there. So what does our plan look like? In other words, are we — is our intention to hold off longer? And after that, make forceful corrective moves? What's the company's thinking here?
Simal Kanuga
executiveNo, let me do one thing first. I'll walk you through some numbers, and after that Navneet can handle the strategy portion; so the figure, if you check as of June end for the passive ETF, stands at 3 lakh 20,000 crores; now out of that 3 lakh 20,000 crores, the 2 government — quasi-government owned entities, they come to roughly 2 lakh crores in total, correct? In fact, more than 2 lakh crores. So basically, this is largely Government of India and EPFO funds, along with a few other provident funds that generally track the EPFO. Of that total—INR 3 lakh 20,000 crores—the remaining share, about INR 2 lakh crores, is directed to those two asset management companies. Right now, the full amount has been split between them at a 3:1 ratio—that's the first point. Second, the other roughly INR 40,000 crores consists of liquid debt and the Bharat Bond ETF. Of that INR 40,000 crores, roughly INR 34,000 crores comes from the Bharat bond ETFs — again, government-owned entities, PSU fixed income capital raising, all done through one asset management company. For economic reasons, we stayed out of that bid. Then there's some money in the CPSE and Bharat 22 ETF, right? That was a government disinvestment program, and about INR 22,000 crores has come from it. The government has now made a statement — the divestment secretary said this would no longer be the preferred route for further disinvestments. Next, the gold ETF category sits at approximately INR 16,000 crores, and we maintain a pretty solid position in it—ranking number two in that segment. So when you take in all those numbers together, sure, the total appears quite big. But once you unpack those figures and factor in the addressable market segment, the picture really doesn't match the way we see it. Now, on the retail side of passive investing—which usually flows through index funds rather than ETFs—AUM there is about INR 25,000 crores in index funds. Within that INR 25,000 crores, our own AUM comes to INR 5,600 crores. That means we hold over one-fifth of that market—literally. As Navneet mentioned before, we’ve just gotten the green light from the regulator for an equal weight index fund, and we’ll likely bring it to market at some stage in the current quarter. On the strategy front, though, Navneet is better placed to give you more detail.
Navneet Munot
executiveWe've discussed this before, and as I said earlier, growth will occur in both active and passive as India continues to evolve. On a global level too — I noted earlier that passives have performed quite strongly when it comes to incremental growth. That said, my feeling is that in the coming few years, even worldwide, this may be a somewhat contrarian view, but I believe active is set to make a robust comeback; in India, I see substantial growth potential on both fronts, passive and active alike. At the risk of saying this for perhaps the second or third time, I'd put it this way: we don't view ourselves through an active-versus-passive lens, or in those terms at all — rather, we place the customer at the center and then apply our capability as an investment manager, correct? That is, we can deliver active, we can deliver passive, we can do — whatever falls under investment management, combine that with our risk management and our overall product capability; and then harness the power of data and analytics to provide the right kind of contextual and consumable content, whether it arrives through any channel — the traditional channel or the digital platform — the aim being how we reach a greater number of savers and give them the right kind of solution with the help of our partners or the digital platforms. That's the aim. If that means perhaps investing somewhat more in passives than we have historically, we will certainly do so.
Madhu Gupta
analystSo really, what I'm trying to find out is whether there's still room for HDFC AMC to cut costs further — or to push more operating leverage benefits down the road. And if that's the case, where exactly do you expect those savings to come from? Then my second question is about the newest regulation — I mean, per the new rule, when it comes to compensation of key management employees, a minimum of 20% of it has to go into the mutual funds that we manage. So will that have any effect on your employee costs? Any thoughts on that?
Navneet Munot
executiveOn the first point, I mean, regarding operating leverage, I mean, this business — asset management globally is inherently one that's famous for strong operating leverage, correct? I mean, take a new fund manager on our side who is, say, running INR 5,000 or INR 10,000 crores of assets. Suppose that AUM doubles over the next 2 years, given our franchise. Would we need to bring in another fund manager for it? No, I mean, that same manager handles it, with the same set of branches, the same set of overall costs that we already carry. Naturally, one portion of it would be variable. Say, the money that comes in from the distributor carries a cost with it. But our margins, obviously, there is a — I mean, if you look at the margin overall, clearly there's positive operating leverage. That said, I think Piyush has been pointing this out across the last couple of quarters — some of the cost cuts that took place, especially, I think the organization made sure that through the difficult stretch of the last 1 year, plenty of cost rationalization took place. A portion of those costs will return once we begin exploring newer growth avenues and expanding the market and rolling out new products, putting money into marketing and business development, putting money into IT and technology — I mean, into technology and digital, and so on. So a bit of costs will return. That said, structurally, I mean, if the question concerns operating leverage, yes, inherently, this is a business carrying very high operating leverage.
Madhu Gupta
analystI'm asking because, when you look at HDFC AMC, the cost relative to this year is already pretty low. So can it be reduced even more? Or have you hit the best level possible — meaning, past this point, will it start climbing?
Piyush Surana
executiveWhat I'd say carries more weight, Madhu, is the way these flows return and generate market activity on the revenue side, rather than on the operating side, on cost. During the last call, we noted that part of the cost savings witnessed last year in FY 2021 stemmed from reduced travel, business development, a few other overheads, and so on. Some of those expenses will come back, and we wouldn't want to suppress that, since investing in business growth is something we favor—so a portion may stick around. The cost efficiencies achieved through better use of technology—part of which couldn't be incurred last year, travel being one example—will likely return at some stage. Yet structurally—and to reiterate the same idea, if you're inquiring about operating leverage, then yes, it exists as scale continues to expand; consequently, for us the more significant question is how we increase revenues and how we increase the AUM.
Madhu Gupta
analystUnderstood. Understood. And on the regulatory shift whereby compensation now — essentially 20% of compensation being mutual funds, meaning — well, management is managing; so would that have some kind of effect on your employee cost? Do you foresee any kind of...
Simal Kanuga
executiveAt the AGM as well, I believe our Chairman spoke about this. He applauded — well, praised the regulators for introducing it. And he said, I mean, that we would be glad to put it into practice. Naturally, he spoke of a bit of flexibility that could be granted to asset managers regarding how to implement it. But apart from that, I think even otherwise, most of our employees would anyway have their money invested in the fund now, so in their own funds. So I don't think it will dramatically alter how people view their investments and our employee cost, not necessarily. All I think the Chairman requested was that some bit of flexibility be given. A younger employee may have a different sort of risk/return expectations or a risk profile or, let's say, different employees would have their own differing financial needs. But apart from that, generally speaking, I think it's a welcome move and he applauded it.
Navneet Munot
executiveAnd to your pointed question, will it affect our employee cost? No, it won't.
Venkatesh Sanjeevi
analystI'd like to make one gentle point about domestic mutual funds in this industry: many products are sold by distributors on the basis of 10-year term performance — or maybe 1 year, or at most 2 years or so. Whatever performed well recently is what needs to be sold and does get sold — even looking at how international funds are receiving flows now, segments have been getting flows, and that seems to be the case. So the question is, how can this kind of thing change? Could other parameters — like risk, or turnover, or other aspects of a fund — be highlighted? Are AMCs taking steps to sort of sell products on things apart from just near-term performance? And do you think it's feasible to get that sort of maturity across the industry as well?
Navneet Munot
executiveNo, that's a great point, Venkatesh — you made it that people focus so much on, I would say, fund alpha on the short-term side rather than looking at investor alpha. What matters more is how you meet the investor's goal, how you create alpha for investors over a long period rather than keep chasing last 1 year or 3 years' performance. And there are a number of studies — I'm sure you know that better — where I think turning money based on recent performance doesn't lead to a better outcome for the end investor. I think over the years, we are seeing a good number of our partners understanding that aspect. I think fund houses selling with the distributor and selling with all the other stakeholders — there have been a lot of efforts on that front to highlight the importance of staying invested for the long term. Initially, I talked about our newer marketing campaign about the STP — it's sound investment plus time plus patience, and not trying to chase the side of the season, which really creates value for you over the long period. And we hope that as markets become more mature, investors as well as distributors pay a lot more attention to long-term performance and long-term value creation rather than keep chasing short-term performance.
Venkatesh Sanjeevi
analystBut when it comes to AMFI as a body — the regulated mutual funds for the year campaign has come out, so should something be done on that front to build awareness and such, with just 1 or 2 funds attempting this?
Navneet Munot
executiveNo, I believe everyone across the industry — and I have to compliment every player over the last several years — has worked extremely hard to emphasize why long-term investing matters, why staying disciplined matters, the whole SIP campaign, how remaining disciplined and investing monthly across a longer period beats chasing short-term market movement. I think that has been happening. The whole industry is doing this jointly. Can we do more? I mean, of course, everything — I mean, that holds true for everything the industry can do regarding whatever we are doing; and your point is absolutely correct that all the stakeholders must work together to make sure investors focus on creating value over a much longer period rather than chasing short-term performance.
Analyst
analystRoughly 90% of what I hold in retail funds sits with HDFC AMC, and 90% of my portfolio share is at the AMC as well. So I'm watching this quite closely. What I've noticed is that next to other AMCs, HDFC AMC shows less aggressiveness in its portfolio. Take the SBI focused fund, take the Axis fund — they carry meaningful weight in Avenue Supermart, meaningful weight in Alphabet, companies growing very rapidly, while when I look at HDFC AMC's portfolio, some funds are holding Jagran Prakashan and stocks of that kind. So my question: if HDFC wants to continue with value-based investing, that's completely fine; but why doesn't the current HDFC AMC offer anything aggressive — because I, as an investor, as a customer, if I want to put part of my money into aggressive funds, then I must go to other AMCs, since HDFC AMC offers me no portfolio of that kind. And what's your thinking on this? Because that's my first point.
Navneet Munot
executiveSo if you look at — I think I said this at the start. If you look at the longer-term track record of several of our funds, funds that have existed for a very, very long time, I think the performance speaks for itself. Short-term ups and downs can happen. What counts more, though, is how capital has grown many times over across the years. We mentioned our Flexi Cap Fund — formerly HDFC Equity Fund — along with HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund, which carried another name yet is the very same offering. Through the years, results of that sort have come through. You can always find one or two names at any given moment — I won't weigh in on specific stocks — but those picks don't say anything about whether a manager is aggressive or conservative. What counts far more, in my view, is staying faithful to your label, faithful to the philosophy your fund follows, faithful to your mandate, and faithful to whatever you've told investors. That's exactly what we've shown across the past twenty-odd years. And we don't see any reason why the bulk of our funds shouldn't be able to produce the sort of results investors look for from us over the long run. Our attention, I'd say, has never shifted away from adjusted returns. Investors eyeing something like a small cap fund have several routes—they can put money into one of those, or instead consider a concentrated portfolio or just a couple of high conviction ideas. A focused equity fund may be the pick for some, whereas others lean toward spreading bets across market capitalizations through a flexi cap; should they want some fixed income within the portfolio, balanced advantage or the hybrid equity fund might come into play. Within any of these, every fund manager comes with an investment style of their own. Now, regarding this value versus growth versus quality discussion — and I should note — I'm not sure who first made the observation that every form of investing is really value investing, since you'd never say "I do wet in swimming." After all, any swimming gets you wet. In the same way, with investing you're seeking value that goes beyond the price we're paying right now. That means each manager views stocks through a different lens and brings a distinct style. What I can tell you is this: our investing approach, our investing beliefs, and our investing method — along with the team that has delivered what I'd call strong results across a really extended stretch — have all been clearly validated by the historical record. Many thanks, and I truly value the trust you place in the AMC. Thank you very much.
Analyst
analystMy second question concerns how we give a manager incentives. Because if I look — I hold funds across small cap, mid-cap, whatever you name, my money sits in all of these funds. Yet when I examine their portfolios, there is — a considerable overlap exists among all these funds; so I'd like to understand how you incentivize fund managers, since if the AMU is rising, that rise may come from inflation or perhaps a new fund that is arriving into that particular new fund. So what weight do you assign to the automatic increase in the AMC driven by inflation? What importance do you give to fresh money that an investor is committing or channeling into that specific mutual fund? Since that shows the confidence I have in it — say I think that focused fund will perform really well, that focused funds will perform really well, then I'll put more money into it. So how do you — what's my share of wallet? How much of that is flowing into the incentive-based system? How is that being tracked?
Simal Kanuga
executiveI believe the question is — does it concern fund manager incentives? Mr. Mukerji, if you don't mind, perhaps this wouldn't be the best platform for discussing this. That said, feel free to drop us an email or share your contact details, and we'll get in touch by phone to resolve whatever question you have.
Analyst
analystAll right. My final question: I notice on YouTube — and we do have plenty of trust in the HDFC brand, everyone speaks positively about it — but there are quite a few YouTube videos speaking negatively about HDFC AMC, its fund managers, and its performance. Now, if someone from a small town is watching those YouTube videos and also watching videos from competing AMCs, he could become biased. How do we counter that?
Navneet Munot
executiveWell, you can't respond to millions of tweets and millions of comments on social media — no company could manage that. But I think the proof is in the pudding. We can plainly see from the recent — our NurtureNature campaign, or some of the other flows — that the response coming from smaller towns is rising sharply. Our brand, I'd say, is highly respected throughout the country, in large towns and small towns alike. People, I think, regard us as a highly trustworthy brand. And I don't believe a few comments here and there genuinely sway investors' decisions. After all, 90% of your money sits with us. I'm sure many other investors are like you, and I hope more and more investors like you keep that faith in an AMC that has placed purpose at the center of everything we do — being the value creator for every Indian.
Utkarsh Solapurwala
analystWe launched an index fund not long ago that carries a very low TR ratio. Down the road, if plenty of other digital-only AMCs bring out lower TR, price competition would follow. So how do you see that sort of price-driven competition here in India?
Navneet Munot
executiveRivalry within our industry has been around the whole time, you know. It isn't anything novel, I mean. That said, of course, I believe innovations and products exist. There are innovations in the way those products are delivered, and so on. As I mentioned before, considering the opportunity India presents in this industry, the more the merrier. A growing number of these participants will assist in expanding the market. You've got just 2.5 crore investors. For an AMC, I think that means lower fees. If they can bring in only a modest number of additional investors, as an industry participant, I'd welcome it. That said, as I've said a few times, for us the question is how we deliver the right solution to every investor and each of our partners as they work toward their financial goals. We wouldn't focus on one particular product that comes at a much lower cost. Every investor would need a range of things. And it isn't just about — I mean, looking at history and what every investor has gone through makes it obvious that shaving a handful of basis points off here or there isn't what truly moves the needle toward someone's life or financial goals. What matters, I think, is the whole offering that an asset manager or AMC puts together. Our long-held view is that partners — the mutual fund along with the other stakeholders — ought to join forces to grow investor alpha, even as we as the manufacturer keep pushing to produce stronger fund alpha; that, I'd say, is the bigger piece of it, and as we've said many times before, for us that's what counts. Our business over the last 20 years has got built on this premise that we have a scale. We are one of the largest players. We aspire to have quality, which is reflecting in our asset mix and the way we source our business, the way we have built our business; and of course, we want industry-leading profitability and wouldn't really sacrifice one for the other; and all of this with purpose at the center, which is to be the wealth creator for every Indian.
Hiral Desai
analystSo I actually had a question about the cost side, Navneet, but you kind of answered that in one of the earlier questions, and I think you covered it pretty thoroughly. But I just wanted to understand, out of this total 10 basis points of cost that we had last year, what proportion of this would be variable in nature? Just a ballpark number.
Navneet Munot
executiveIn the past, we've talked about it at roughly out of our cost between 20%, 25% are variable.
Hiral Desai
analyst20% to 25%.
Navneet Munot
executiveYes.
Hiral Desai
analystUnderstood; and finally, Piyush, is there any other collateral still outstanding tied to the Essel NCD, or is that finished?
Piyush Surana
executiveNo, I mean, financially speaking, there is nothing more. It's essentially complete.
Kunal Thanvi
analystMy question is about — we've witnessed quite a bit of traction in the business since PFRDA altered the realization there. And with HDFC being the biggest private player in that space, could you shed some light on that business? And over the long term — from a really long-term view — we are — if I'm not mistaken, at INR 18,000 crores of AUM right now. How should we think about that market? Because a big portion of that market is held by PSUs. How do we see it over 5 to 10 years?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo I mean that's part of one of our group companies. I'm sure you'd get a chance to ask them about — specifically about that company and that business; but broadly, I mean, of course, in India, if you look at the overall savings pool, if you look at the demographics, if you look at the need for investment products, I think all investment products will coexist. I think mutual funds have a role, pension products have a role, some of the other products have a role. And everybody can coexist and there's enough opportunity for all the players; but specifically, on that business and how it's evolving, I think I may have a view, but it's better if you ask HDFC Life.
Kapil Agrawal
analystMy question concerns — yes. Your flagship equity fund, I mean, has grown a lot over the past 1.5 years. That's offset some weak results from 2015 to '19; but on the capital-raising side, a few of your competitors have been pretty aggressive, and they did much better there. So how do you plan to grow your AUM, both through inflows and new fund offerings? Could you also give us some color on where you're targeting?
Navneet Munot
executiveWell, first, on performance — as you said, there was a period when some of the key schemes had issues on that front, and you've seen a material reversal there. As I said earlier, a few of those schemes now sit in the top decile. Some are actually in the top quartile over 1 year. And even 3 and 5 years have started looking good, of course. Our distribution partners and clients are recognizing it too. Sure, it takes them a little time to recognize the reversion, but we're hopeful about what we're doing and the message we're giving, and people have been noticing it. Have we done anything differently? Honestly, no, not really. What wasn't working over the last couple of years is working now. Our investment team has been through a few such cycles before, and that keeps them committed to their convictions, because they've seen some of these cycles already, and this has been like another one. We're very happy to say the interest in those positions, or in those convictions, has been vindicated. The market does take time to fully recognize this, but today we can say with confidence that things are improving on the ground. I think I also mentioned at the beginning — we talked about style diversity, which we've discussed on some earlier calls too, this whole idea of achieving style diversity; it's working out reasonably well. Some of the newer fund managers now run almost 15% of our AUM, and a few of those funds have seen traction. We also have a good product pipeline in place, and we expect those to start increasing in the core flagship products, which have one of the best-in-class long-term performance track records, though they went through a cycle of underperformance and are now coming back.
Kapil Agrawal
analystCould you give us some detail on the new fund launches? Which markets or particular types are you zeroing in on? Would you mind expanding on that a little?
Navneet Munot
executiveYou may have missed it earlier, but we went over the segments where our footprint has been on the smaller side. I believe, in line with the SEBI classification, that for the core categories spanning equity, fixed income, and gold, our lineup of products is just about complete. At some stage we'd roll out a multi-cap fund, as soon as the approvals and other pieces are sorted out. We'd be bringing out a handful of passive funds, possibly a few on the index side as well as some on the ETF side. There are plans to introduce certain overseas funds, along with offerings focused on sectors and themes. During the previous quarter, we rolled out the NFO for banking and financial services, and additional thematic and sector-oriented products are currently in the works. As I believe I noted on the previous call—which was my first one—I've consistently commended HDFC AMC for a particular quality: this AMC would never bring out a product simply because it happens to be trendy at the moment. The investment team has to hold a strong conviction in it; we have to believe that some group of investors, at any given point, will require that product within their broader portfolio; and we have to perceive both sustainability and longevity in it. Otherwise we wouldn't launch something merely for the sake of doing an NFO. That is something we have never done, and we never will. That said, anyplace our lineup has holes, we'd close them across the coming quarters or years.
Kapil Agrawal
analystAll right. One final question from me. You mentioned this earlier during the call as well, about some of the newer players entering the market and investing directly. What's your approach to going after these people? Could you point to something — any specific steps you've already taken or plan to take in order to target these markets?
Navneet Munot
executiveOur view has consistently been that partners matter a great deal. This country is huge. In India, there are, I mean, hundreds of towns along with 600,000 villages. The country has 1.35 billion people. If we consider how many advisers exist today, the ratio is roughly 1 for every 18,000 people. Investing isn't just about ease of transaction or getting it done; the behavioral side matters a lot. That's precisely why a good adviser or a good distributor is so critical — to provide that handholding at the right moment, so that in the month of March 2020, you don't exit equities, or perhaps do the opposite. So we firmly believe partners have a major role to play. That said, I mean, some investors will kind of do it themselves, just as they do for many other things in their life. They'd like to handle even investing on their own, and for them we would offer a best-in-class platform as well. But our core belief is that partners matter to us; and there's no reason to think they won't keep mattering for our business to keep growing.
Analyst
analystSo at this moment, one of the primary concerns on our minds is the change taking place between growth in demat account numbers and mutual fund accounts. So I mean, we've touched on this a bit during the call too — when the market rises, you really do witness a significant jump in those demat accounts. So my question is really grounded in your experience and in the past: what percentage of — when the market reverses direction, or even stays subdued, or even turns negative, what share of these incremental new additions being made to demat accounts actually flow toward the mutual fund category?
Simal Kanuga
executiveI believe we cited that figure earlier — between 2017 and '20, if you examine the share of new accounts added by the mutual fund industry compared with demat accounts, I think it was roughly that the mutual fund industry was bringing in far more unique investors than new demat accounts were. That pattern has now flipped during the last 15 months, for a range of reasons. Naturally, markets have been favourable for people. I mean, work from home may have played a part. Perhaps certain platforms have made investing in the secondary market much simpler, and I'm sure that may have played a part. And naturally, some millennials and some of the — I mean, younger investors are enjoying that experience. And this isn't just happening in India. I think it's been a trend globally. I mean, the so-called domino effect. Now, how does the — and how do we respond? I'm referring to the whole industry and to us as well. So I mean, if — I wouldn't view it as a challenge. I mean, I'd view it both ways. I mean, naturally, if everyone believes that making money is so simple and that they can trade and can build wealth over a longer stretch, I mean, that's worrying. Another way to see it is that it's a substantial opportunity. It simply demonstrates the interest in the capital market. It simply demonstrates that investing habits are shifting. I think compared with some of the earlier methods of investing, perhaps people now believe capital markets are a better place to put money. So seen that way, it's an opportunity. So how should we respond, both as an AMC and as an industry? What I'd say is this — if you set aside the short-term market swings and so on, and ask why this trend is taking place, then as an industry we need to move faster on digital adoption and offer a stronger user interface and a stronger user experience when people put money into mutual funds — for instance, when they invest on their own via some of these platforms. We also need to put much more effort, I'd say, into a deeper focus on investor education. How do we bring home the value of creating wealth over the long term that comes from compounding when you stay disciplined? I mean, setting the right goals, getting your asset allocation right, staying disciplined through market cycles — that is how wealth gets built — and we should carry that message in the language these people, I'd say, take in more easily. We also need to redesign product and marketing strategy around how we deliver that message. As I said a while ago, in the language they would prefer, we made that content much more, I'd say, easy to consume and better contextualized. And of course, the right sort of partnership with some of these platforms that have managed to draw in a great many of these investors — they themselves have said that a big share of their investors don't earn as much as they could simply by putting money in fixed deposits, correct? I'm sure you've heard or read their remarks, since they know from experience what their investors are doing by trading in the market. So then, on our side — from a mutual fund industry standpoint or as HDFC AMC — we must partner with them and make sure our products are visible to investors with the right messaging and the right packaging. I think if all of us do this together, I have no doubt that in the next few years we would also succeed in bringing a great many of these investors into the mutual fund fold.
Analyst
analystAlright. Moving on, my next question concerns equity AUM shares — for your firm and for the industry as a whole. If you look at the trend over the longer term, equity AUM's share has kept climbing steadily, and that's probably largely because interest rates have been declining on a structural basis. So maybe 5, 10 years from now, it's quite possible interest rates won't reach a peak, which actually makes investing far more appealing than putting money in debt. So taking a slightly longer-term view, could our equity share rise to somewhere around 65% — 60%, 65% kind of a level?
Simal Kanuga
executiveWe'd certainly love to see that happen. I mean, if you look at the profitability, sure — but that isn't how the world works. Take other countries where interest rates are very low: is it the case that people put money only into equity? I mean, even at negative yields, trillions of dollars sit in bond funds and money market funds. Different investors have different income needs, different investing needs, and I think we need products for all investors. And I mean, if you look at the total size of the fixed deposit market plus some other fixed income products like bonds and post office and all of that, I mean, that's a large market; and there too, I think mutual funds have a good proposition for attracting those investors. So I think, yes, both will grow. I don't see any reason that only equity will grow, and there's not much scope for us to grow on the fixed income side. I think on the retail side, particularly, there's tremendous hope for us to grow in individual investors' book.
Analyst
analystRight, just one more question on that. Once you strip out the higher ESOP costs, where would operating margins have landed, in basis points?
Piyush Surana
executive36%, 37%? I believe it's 37% — 36.5%?
Analyst
analystAll right. So 37. Okay; and Navneet said a while back that the funds run by the newer fund managers are gaining more traction. So could you possibly spell out which funds those are?
Simal Kanuga
executiveSure, yes. So it is — there's a gentleman named Amit Ganatra, and he manages the HDFC capital builder fund. He manages the HDFC multi-asset fund. He manages HDFC asset allocator, fund of funds. He also now manages the HDFC tax saver fund. Gopal Agarwal, who is one of the other managers, he manages the HDFC Focused 30 Fund. He manages a fund called HDFC large and mid-cap fund. He manages HDFC dividend yield. Those are the funds.
Navneet Munot
executiveAnd at this point Anand Laddha will be the one running the banking and financial services fund. That's a different fund manager, and of course that fund hasn't grown, though I think perhaps once the investment cycle turns — then there's Rakesh Vyas, who runs our infrastructure and housing opportunity funds.
Navneet Munot
executiveI really appreciate everyone joining us, and I hope you and the people close to you are doing well. Please stay safe. Keep healthy. Thanks.
Operator
operatorMuch appreciated. On behalf of HDFC Asset Management Company Limited, that brings this conference to a close. We thank you for being with us. Your lines may be disconnected at this point. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HDFC Asset Management Company Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to HDFC Asset Management Company Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in HDFC Asset Management Company Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.