HDFC Asset Management Company Limited (HDFCAMC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 25, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Simal Kanuga
executiveAll right, thank you Nirav, and good evening to everybody. I'll begin by sharing some industry data. QA AUM for the quarter that closed in March 23 came in at INR 40.5 trillion, which represents 6% growth Y-o-Y. Net flows in equity-oriented funds across the year totaled INR 1,801 billion, and out of that INR 1,618 billion went into actively managed equity-oriented funds while the remaining INR 184 billion was in equity-oriented index funds. So when you look at net flows, index funds made up roughly 10%. For gross flows, however, that figure would be significantly lower. Another data point on actively managed equity-oriented funds that may be of interest is flows through NFOs. Over the year, the industry gathered approximately INR 342 billion through actively managed equity-oriented NFOs, which is almost 21% of net flows into actively managed equity-oriented funds for the year. The equivalent figure for FY '22 stood at INR 748 billion, nearly 34% of net flows into actively managed equity-oriented funds in the prior financial year. SIP flows kept up their growth path, reaching INR 143 billion in March of 2023 against INR 123 billion in March of 2022. SIP flows for FY '23 totaled INR 1.56 trillion, almost 35% of the industry's gross active equity flows. The comparable figure in FY '22 was INR 1.25 trillion, nearly 23% of the industry's gross equity close. On QA AUM, actively managed equity-oriented funds were at INR 19.38 trillion, while equity-oriented index funds were at INR 0.52 trillion; let's now turn to debt. Over the year, debt funds, which include debt index funds and debt ETF, saw an outflow of INR 582 billion. If flows into debt index funds and ETF are excluded, the figure is considerably larger — an outflow of INR 1,569 billion. Liquid fund QA AUM rose 8% Y-o-Y, adding INR 0.42 trillion. Net outflows from liquid funds for the year amounted to INR 510 billion. Others, covering ETFs, arbitrage and FOF investing overseas, grew 13% Y-o-Y. The industry recorded 37.7 million unique customers at the close of the fiscal year. Retail investors made up 58% of monthly average AUM for March 2023, and the individual investor folio count climbed to INR 145 million from INR 129 million the year before; let's turn now to our own figures. Quarterly average AUM for the quarter closed at INR 4,498 billion, a 4% increase Y-o-Y. In quarterly average AUM our market share was 11.1%, or 12.5% when ETF is excluded. On a quarterly average AUM basis, our share of actively managed equity-oriented AUM is now 12%, and 11.9% on a closing basis. We have seen a modest uptick of late. Including debt index fund, our quarterly average debt AUM market share was 13.3%. For quarterly average liquid fund AUM, market share reached 13.1%. On the asset mix side, we continued to move more toward equity, which is now 54.4% of our QA AUM, a bit better than the industry's level. At the close of the quarter ending March 2023, we had 6.6 million unique investors. During that quarter, January through March 2023, we processed 13.14 million systematic transactions worth INR 50.4 billion, versus 12.02 million transactions worth INR 45.2 billion in the quarter ending December 2022; looking at quarterly figures matters here because February has fewer days and we usually see some spillover from Feb into March. In March '23, we processed 4.53 million transactions amounting to INR 17.1 billion. For March '22, the figure stood at INR 12.3 billion, meaning that in March '23 we processed systematic transactions worth INR 17.1 billion. March '22's comparable number was INR 12.3 billion. We kept working to widen the product lineup, introducing two equity-oriented thematic to sectoral funds, a long duration debt fund that attracted healthy interest, especially late in March, and a variety of passive strategies spanning equity and fixed income over the past year. On March 31, we announced the first close of our HDFC AMC Select AIF FOF, with commitments reaching INR 400 crores in total. That figure is certainly encouraging, particularly considering today's market conditions. We'll continue to bring in more capital for this fund, and we have a solid pipeline ready. Turning now to the financials. We finished the quarter with a profit after tax of INR 3,761 million, which is up 9% year over year. Total revenue rose 10% to INR 6,378 million, and operating revenue was up 5%. We closed FY '23 with a profit after tax of INR 14,239 million, a 2% increase year over year. Total revenues were up 2%, and operating revenues also rose 2% year over year. As for employee costs, they stayed flat at INR 3,127 million, compared with INR 3,122 million the year before. When you look at that figure without the non-cash ESOP charge, it comes to INR 2,726 million, compared with INR 2,489 million a year earlier — a 9.5% rise Y-o-Y. On other expenses, we recorded an 18% increase, which in absolute terms is INR 348 million; the main drivers were spending on business promotion, travel, digital assets, IT infrastructure, among other things. For the year ended March 31, 2023, our operating profit margin as a basis point of AUM was 35 basis points, while the operating revenue margin came in at 49 basis points. Earlier today, the Board recommended a dividend of INR 48 per share versus INR 42 per share, which works out to a payout ratio of 72% compared with 64% last year. That is, naturally, pending shareholder approval. We'd like to flag something you might have spotted in our exchange release: the Board's Nomination and Remuneration Committee has approved an ESOP plan involving 1.05 million shares to be offered to eligible employees at yesterday's closing price. Thank you very much for your patience in listening. At this point, Navneet, Naozad and I are all fully available for questions. So, Nirav, please go ahead and start assembling the question queue.
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystI've got three questions. First, regarding the yield this quarter — the yield has dipped a bit on a sequencing <<inaudible>>.
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystYes. Is it better at this point?
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystYeah. So sir, my first question concerns the yield. For the first 9 months, we were at roughly 50 basis points plus on yield. This time around, we're seeing a modest compression there. So I just wanted to understand whether this is purely a product mix effect, or whether there's some impact from the debt mutual fund related taxes and the change that occurred, or anything else worth reading into — perhaps more incremental flows into the balance advantage fund, and whether that could have any effect? That's question one; on trade receivables, the trade receivable figures stayed at about INR 80 crores in the first half and also in the balance sheet just released. This number was roughly half of — close to half of that a year earlier. So how — what am I to make of this? Why has it gone up? And thirdly, on the ESOP plan you mentioned, sir, could you provide some guidance on what the charge to P&L might be across the next couple of years?
Navneet Munot
executiveThe first question on the — this quarter's margin. So first, this quarter had 90 days versus 92 days in the December quarter. Revenue per day in the December quarter was INR 6.08 crores, so two fewer days this quarter would mean a revenue loss of slightly more than INR 12 crores. And we had some year-end adjustments relating to unabsorbed cost of B30, which was debited during the quarter at the fund level. I think that broadly explains the difference. And as you rightly said, I mean, we also maybe, I mean, product mix, etcetera. But by and large, that's the explanation.
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystSir, could I just ask something more about those costs, sir, if you wouldn't mind giving a bit more detail on that when you reach the B30 you referred to.
Navneet Munot
executiveApologies, are you referring to the cost or the margin?
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystSo on the margins, you mentioned there's some effect coming from the B30 related assets, correct? Could you just shed some light on that?
Navneet Munot
executiveThat's 1 basis point overall, right.
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystSo I just wanted to get clarity on whether that's the case?
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveSwarnab, this comes down to accounting. Essentially, all that we've spent on B30 has to be absorbed inside the year. So it's somewhat of a year-end adjustment, in a way. And on top of that, the INR 12 crores that Navneet referred to, I believe, addresses the — addresses your question.
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystAll right, understood. So is it fair to assume that in the next year, once things stabilize, we can really return to what we saw during the first 9 months?
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveYes. Guidance is something we have avoided, I think. So I don't want to speculate on precisely what the next year would look like. That said, perhaps Navneet, you would like to add something.
Navneet Munot
executiveRegarding the overall margin, we’ve talked about this before: the commission we pay on the book is less than the commission on flows, so new flows will create some dilution. Then the dilution base was quite rapid in the financial year of March ’22, since gross flows as a percentage of beginning-of-year AUM were approximately 55%. In the current year, that same figure is somewhere in the early 20s. It also depends on the AUM of each individual strategy. So growth in AUM also produces some dilution; but in the end, the way I see it is that growth in AUM and shifts in asset mix over a period of time will determine the profits of our business. And that is where we are focused.
Swarnabha Mukherjee
analystRight, sir, understood, understood. Could you also address the trade receivables and the cost side of things?
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveYes, I'll handle that. On trade receivables, what we have is simply a shift in how often payment is made, since the mutual fund pays us — the fees the AMC collects — right after the month closes. So there's nothing — that was a one-time adjustment that will now carry on going forward, but it's absolutely money we will receive, so no concern there. As for your question about the cost of the new stock options, under the Black-Sholes Model the estimated expense, a noncash charge that gets debited to the P&L account across the next three years because of this new ESOP program, would come to roughly INR 55 crores to INR 60 crores. Out of that INR 55 crores to INR 60 crores, about 55% would be booked in this financial year, around 30% in the following financial year, and the remainder in the year after that. On top of this, we'll have a debit of approximately INR 18 crores from the existing ESOPs already issued, which are running through our P&L. I trust that answers the question.
Kunal Thanvi
analystThere are a couple of things I'd like to ask. The first concerns <<inaudible>>, which held a press conference not long ago and more or less laid out how it sees the regulatory thinking around <<inaudible>>. The gist of it is that the intent is to shift from, let's say, a scheme-based TER to one based on asset class. So I'd like to hear your view on this, and on how it affects AMCs, particularly the large ones whose equity books are already very substantial, with NV among the top 3. That's my first question.
Navneet Munot
executiveKunal, to begin with, the regulator has of course set out its thinking. That said, we are engaged through the industry forum and are examining every implication; as an organization, we have chosen to start putting our minds to it once the regulations are formally issued. Whoever gave that outline of their thinking at the post-SEBI Board meeting press conference you would have heard, <<inaudible>> said they will do what is necessary in consultation with the industry. I'm sure you'd agree that SEBI's overarching aim is investor protection and market regulation, together with market development; so I'd say regulation is a given. As an organization, we have to make sure we do what is fair for our stakeholders.
Kunal Thanvi
analystYeah, of course. So really, if that regulation does end up coming into force, that's when we'll start working out how things are likely to play out. The reason I'm raising this is that, looking at it from a value chain angle, how would everything move through if regulations of that kind were introduced? Because in a sense it would shake up the whole value chain, wouldn't it?
Navneet Munot
executiveAt this stage, I think there's nothing more I can add beyond what I've already said. And I hope you can understand that.
Kunal Thanvi
analystSure. That makes sense. The second question concerned the LTCG introduction for long-term debt mutual funds. Could you help us understand how that affects the industry and HDFC AMC, and what our exposure was to that specific peer and beyond that point?
Navneet Munot
executiveYeah. The finance ministry has put forward a change to tax rules taking effect April 1, '23. Under it, investments and specified debt mutual funds whose equity exposure doesn't exceed 35% of total corpus in domestic equity shares will be classified as short-term capital assets. The proposed change means fresh investments made on or after April 1, '23 will lose the benefit of cost indexation and concessional long-term capital gain tax rates. By default, gains will be treated as short-term capital gains and taxed at the flat rate regardless of holding period. Investments made up to March 31, '23 will be unaffected. We would obviously have preferred that the tax benefit remained in place, considering how policymakers see the debt market evolving, especially the corporate bond segment. There are still certain built-in advantages to debt mutual funds that, in my view, will keep them a favored option. First, with debt mutual funds, tax is only triggered when you redeem. Second, there is no prepayment penalty or issues around liquidity. In my view, debt funds provide solid liquidity. Third, you get flexibility to redeem and shift across the rate or credit curve, and I think there is transparency around all of that, along with the flexibility that debt funds give you. Also, a varied collection of securities that has demonstrated strong performance over many years across the industry — so despite all the reports about securities, the aggregate equivalent of NPAs from the debt mutual fund sector has remained minimal. We therefore continue to believe growth opportunities exist. Still, I have to reiterate my earlier point: as an industry, we would have preferred that the tax benefit remain in place, since I believe we were making a contribution and hold enormous capacity to help build the debt market, especially the corporate bond market.
Kunal Thanvi
analystSure, absolutely. And regarding how corporate and retail split out for the three years and above, what would that mix look like for the industry, or for us, if you're able to share it?
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveKunal, there isn't a figure that exists in that particular form, right? In our presentation, we do show the split between corporate and retail investors, or individual investors as we describe them throughout. But I think plenty of corporates stay with us along the way. Plenty of individuals may use it over a shorter horizon; and similarly, we have corporates who tend to remain for very long periods, even in ultra-short and those sorts of funds.
Devesh Agarwal
analystSir, first of all, I’d like to ask: we’re seeing solid market share gains on the equity side and also on the SIP side, but it seems like those are being partly offset by the market share we’re losing in the debt segment. So could you give me a sense of why we’re losing market share on the debt side? What challenges do we face there?
Navneet Munot
executiveOur debt market share in the QA AUM business for March '23 was 13.3%. If we look at market share excluding debt index funds, that comes to about 14.6%. I should say we were somewhat late in launching debt index funds, since we were waiting for some regulatory clarity, and we got going once that became clear. So the delay in launching debt index funds did hurt us, although we managed to catch up to some extent. Apart from debt index funds, in most other categories, market share would have been stable or better.
Devesh Agarwal
analystGot it. All right. And sir, looking at the full year, would you be able to share what the AMC yields were along with gross tiers for the three main asset classes, namely equity, debt and liquid.
Simal Kanuga
executiveI'm not sure he only wants it for equity, debt and — 70 basis Devesh is on the equity side. Just over 7 basis on debt and roughly 12, 13 basis on liquid.
Devesh Agarwal
analystSorry, I missed for debt.
Simal Kanuga
executive27 basis.
Devesh Agarwal
analystOkay. And Simal, could you share the TR figures for those same segments?
Simal Kanuga
executiveI don't have TER on hand. I'll get that to you; we'll send it over.
Devesh Agarwal
analystRight, got it. Last thing, then: when we look at OpEx for FY '23, it lands at about 14 basis points. Given that — and bearing in mind the ESOP expense will take a hit of nearly INR 25 crores, INR 30 crores in FY '24 — do you see any scope to improve on the cost side? Also, on the growth in other expenses we had in FY '23, do you expect that to keep going, or will there be some easing? And on the whole, might those 14 basis points come down to 13 basis points, something along those lines?
Simal Kanuga
executiveDevesh, Naozad will go into more detail on this, I think, but let me make just one point here. You won't see another 25 basis point step-up, since—as Naozad pointed out—the overall expense for that initial year lands around 50-something, more like 55-odd percent, plus what carried over from the earlier arrangement. Still, during the present year, back in March of '23, a noncash outlay of INR 40 crores was already recorded in the books regardless. The difference would end up significantly smaller than what you're citing; Naozad, though, can go into more detail on costs. So on the employee cost side, Devesh, I think if we work through the costs and strip out noncash items — the ESOP expense — employee costs across the last three years show a CAGR of roughly 8%, with year-over-year at 9.5%. Turning to other expenses, the three-year CAGR there comes to about 6%. Now, looking at absolute figures: other expenses stood at INR 1,954 million in March '20, and for the current year they reached INR 2326 million. That works out to a total rise of INR 372 million across three years. Over the period ending March '20, we spent INR 37 crores for those three years. Out of that INR 37 crores I just mentioned, INR 10 crores resulted from CSR costs. Strip out CSR, and the additional amount we spent across those three years comes to INR 27 crores — a CAGR below 5%. Looking year over year, the cost increase was <<inaudible>> toward business development, NFO spend, IT and digital infra spend and marketing. It goes without saying that we have stayed prudent on expenses and will continue to be. That said, our spending on future business investment wasn’t efficient. Regarding your question about the 14 basis points, I believe a good deal of the heavy work we’ve completed on IT and digital has run its course this year. Not only do we provide guidance on that, but we would expect to be able to at minimum hold the 14 basis points for ’24.
Analyst
analystHello, is my voice coming through? Let me start with this: if you take a year-over-year view, the industry as a whole is up 6%. Our total revenue is at 1% or 2%. And given that we now reach every pincode, we've essentially covered all of India. So what strategic initiatives are we pursuing to improve our trajectory in the coming years at HDFC AMC — to drive better revenue growth going forward?
Navneet Munot
executiveI'd say that growth is on the lower side. On the debt side, thanks to the debt index fund, our equity market share, I believe, has been gradually rising, which is an encouraging sign. The share we hold in the SIP market, along with all the systematic transactions we reported—SIP and STP included—has been creeping upward. As you correctly pointed out, we have a substantial platform footprint spanning 228 branches of our own plus a wide distribution network, and we're working to capitalize on that. Results have gotten better, product approvals from the various distributors and advisers have been on the rise, and we're attempting to—well, we've been putting money into our digital assets, into marketing, into a range of other efforts, and those have begun to bear fruit.
Lalit Deo
analystI have a couple of questions, then. First, on the better results from the major equity schemes — you're saying that in the major schemes we're back to quartile 1 and quartile 2; so on flows, how has market share moved across the different channels, whether direct or distributor-led? Could you give a qualitative view on that?
Navneet Munot
executiveYou're absolutely right there. Our performance in most categories, I'd say, is top tier. And I think our investment approach has been complemented by clients holding to their conviction even while going through stretches of underperformance, and I'm sure you appreciate this — easier said than done. We've been focused on growing our systematic transaction book and have seen results recently, which I mentioned earlier as well. I was asked how it's showing up and in various numbers — if you look at unique investors, that count has risen to INR 6.6 million, up from INR 6.3 million in the prior quarter. Industry-wide, unique investors have climbed to 37.7 million from 36.7 million. So this quarter, close to one-third of new unique investors picked HDFC Mutual Funds. Systematic transactions, which Simal discussed earlier, went from INR 12.3 billion in March '22 to INR 17.1 billion in March '23 — for us systematic may cover both SIP and STP. Naturally, we also launched a couple of new thematic funds during the year, business cycle and M&C fund; but I'd say most of our strategies, which carry a long-term track record and, naturally, have delivered very strong performance lately, are clearly translating into excellent market share. And that holds across channels. I think your question was about channel. So whether you look at direct, at national distributors, at our MFDs, at other banks — almost across all channel partners, we've seen improving trends.
Lalit Deo
analystAnd sir, one additional point: right now, since we're also observing some performance gains, and with the raw material's change of control from HDFC Limited to HDFC Bank, do we expect the share of those coming from HDFC Bank to HDFC AMC to rise over time, given our performance improvement as well? How do you view that asset potential over the <<inaudible>> FY '25?
Navneet Munot
executiveAs I said earlier, we're certainly excited about this opportunity and look forward to collaborating closely with HDFC Bank on distribution. And since we have top-quality products across asset classes, we're confident of gaining further wallet share from HDFC Bank.
Prayesh Jain
analystFirst off, sir, in your view, is there demand for a hybrid structure sitting somewhere between 35% and 65% equity, given that these vehicles still keep the indexation benefits?
Navneet Munot
executiveMy belief is that funds need to be sold based on what they offer. I don't believe that merely due to how it's taxed, some particular category would exist that the industry, I think, would want to promote. As I keep saying — that same line over and over — we have offerings for every investor need. And I'm confident that various investors, shaped by what they require, how long they can stay invested, their preference for liquidity, the returns they expect and their appetite for risk, will pick different products.
Prayesh Jain
analystAlright. Sir, and second, regarding costs, when I compare Q3 with Q4 sequentially, there's a fairly solid reduction in other expenses, or overheads. So how are we meant to interpret that? Is there something particular you'd want to point out there, and is what we saw in Q4 a run rate that can be sustained?
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveMy view is that we shouldn't be looking at it quarter-on-quarter. But in particular, during the last quarter, we had fewer NFOs, so the business expense came in a bit lower. Some CSR spending landed in Q3 rather than Q4. So that's the main cause of the decline from INR 66 crores to INR 58 crores. On a year-on-year basis, more — I mean, no.
Prayesh Jain
analystAll right. All right. Understood; and the remaining piece of what SEBI discussed concerned the broking charges paid by the AMC. Could you point out what the brokerage charges were, as a percentage of bits of equity AUM, that we would have paid during FY '23?
Navneet Munot
executiveNo, I don't believe I'm able to talk about that.
Prayesh Jain
analystAll right. All right. And that would — and whatever commentary has surrounded it, to be included in the TER. In what way do you think that will impact us?
Navneet Munot
executiveSpeaking seriously, brokerage does fall within TER; it will definitely amount to a regime change; and I think every one of us will need to handle it accordingly. What we do will be in the best interest of our unitholders and other stakeholders. So I think being prudent means strategizing on the same ones where we know the exact regulation.
Dipanjan Ghosh
analystI have just a couple of questions. First, returning to the yields: you said there was a factor involving some unabsorbed cost and an accounting impact on B30, and the second was a product mix change, barring the less space. Could you give us some qualitative sense of the B30 impact? And also, what would be — or perhaps you could quantify how much the product mix change affected things during the quarter? Second, on the expense side, again going back, given that you're concentrating on rolling out your non-mutual fund strategy and also spending on the technology side, how do you — how do you plan to keep the current cost ratio where it is? Could you give some color on that?
Simal Kanuga
executiveOn your first point, I think, as you know, right, how the B30 accounting works. Basically, the B30 spend gets accounted for and then it is amortized over a 12-month period. Now, we aren't able to do it as per the SEBI formula — there is a formula that says what percentage of sales is happening from B30 and so on and so forth — the balance needs to be absorbed in the TER; so there was some adjustment in reference to that. So that was the B30 thing that we referred to, the Dipanjan.
Dipanjan Ghosh
analystRight, and what about expenses?
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveOn the expense front, I believe we've said that a certain portion of spending has already occurred during this year, and part of that will keep carrying into future periods; so I'm not entirely sure what you're after, since as a rule we don't provide guidance on forward-looking figures.
Dipanjan Ghosh
analystGot it. What I'm really trying to get at is how much extra spending there will be on the non — on rolling out the non-mutual fund strategy? And whether that's going to be material to our overall P&L.
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveDipanjan, that simply won't count. It'll be very, very minimal. And I think most of it, when it comes to setting up our AIF and the related costs around legal, accounting and tax, all of that has already been taken care of. So we don't expect anything material from — on that, for sure.
Dipanjan Ghosh
analystSure. And maybe just one question, if I could squeeze in something about your product pipeline for FY '24. I mean, I just wanted to get some understanding — will there be any NFO spends, that kind of thing on the equity side, that can come up.
Navneet Munot
executiveSo we will be doing a few NFOs, not many. And I think if you recall right, I just referred to that NFO as a percentage of the net sales number in FY '23 having been at a pace slower than compared to FY '22. Most of the standard categories, we already tick the box, even in terms of sectoral and thematic, we've been able to expand our product portfolio. On the passive side, we have done a slew of products, both on the ETF as well as on the index platform. I don't — we don't expect many more NFOs to see the light of day during the course, in terms of high spending kind of NFOs. We would continue to expand our portfolio on the sectoral thematic side.
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveI think our prudent book is nearly at capacity in terms of core categories. As we mentioned earlier, we had 8 NFOs in FY '22. In FY '23 we had something like 25, among them quite a few passive funds. Sure, a sector-thematic fund will pop up here and there, but I'd say our product portfolio is pretty much complete. On the product side, we are absolutely best-in-class for active, and absolutely best-in-class for passive as well, yeah.
Srinath V.
analystI just wanted to ask, what was the year-on-year equity yield contraction? For the current year the figure was 70 bps, but what sort of equity yield contraction was it?
Simal Kanuga
executive<<inaudible>> Honestly, it's kind of hard to look at it that way, and in any case we won't give you anything on the future. That's all we can say. What happens is that whenever yield contracts because AUM has grown, that tends to carry a follow-on effect over a stretch of time, and so it kind of neutralizes itself.
Srinath V.
analystNo, no, it's not really about the future—mostly we just want to reconcile the current figures. If you look at the yields reported for the year, they haven't moved much, but owing to the mix change, we can't see how yields are trending in order to reconcile the gap between asset growth and revenue growth.
Simal Kanuga
executiveWe'll follow up with you on that number. Do we have it available offline here? I believe the weighted average AUM for the year has gone from the mid-70s to the early 70s.
Srinath V.
analystOkay; this is for equity, right?
Simal Kanuga
executiveThat's right.
Srinath V.
analystYeah. Perfect. And considering the gross flows you guys have seen, particularly with the share gain over the last 12 months, would it be fair to assume that a large part of this repricing, where our back book had significantly lower payouts, is either — we're like halfway through or largely finished. How do you view this book repricing? Because if around 70% of the assets we hold now are assets that are like two, three years old, then the repricing should be largely done, right?
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveSo we mentioned this earlier. It hinges on multiple variables and is hard to predict. It depends on which part of AUM is going out — more recent high-cost AUM or the older AUM. And we also have to factor in the mark-to-market impact, so mark-to-market impact versus flows. So gross sales as a percentage of outstanding AUM also guides how fast dilution happens — so we've seen this many times, but honestly, we ourselves find it difficult to put a precise number. The endeavor is always to have better retention of the existing assets. At the same time, continue to get a higher share of the gross flows.
Srinath V.
analystUnderstood. Understood. Navneet, do you have any thoughts about a stock buyback, considering that equity dilution is now coming in a business such as ours, which really requires no capital? I wanted to get your general view on buybacks, and also, would we need any specific SEBI approval beyond what any other ordinary company would require in order to carry out a buyback?
Navneet Munot
executiveSo, I mean, I said earlier that the overall payout ratio and how capital is used are matters we continue to discuss with the Board. At this point, you would have noticed, I think we have an <<inaudible>> payout ratio. Have we talked specifically about a buyback? Not really; but I mean, every option always remains open.
Srinath V.
analystAll right, all right. Then the final question would be whether you could put a value figure on the brokerage payout, since we're trying to gauge what risk we're likely to be up against. So I'm not asking what the law will be or how you'll handle it, but could you simply disclose the value number, so that at least we can work out what the value at risk is?
Navneet Munot
executiveI think it's prudent to say that we should wait until we know the exact regulation. There's no point in speculating at this point in time.
Kunal Thanvi
analystCould you help me understand what our yield is on the new flow — and did you notice any change in competitive intensity during this quarter? Also, are we seeing any improvement in the new yield on the new flows we're getting? That's my first question. The second one is, from a longer-term view, if you could help us understand the company's remuneration policy, since we've seen ESOP come back — how should one equate variable pay and ESOP now that ESOP is coming in? And at what level will the ESOPs be granted — will it be company-wide? How much will that affect the variable salary we saw in one of the quarters during the financial period — will the ESOP cause that to go down, and how should we think about it?
Navneet Munot
executiveSure. Regarding your first question on the commission payout trend, I believe we've said over the past couple of quarters that the situation is improving. The direct plan TER for the NFO we just completed is much healthier than that of NFOs launched roughly a year ago. And flows outside of NFOs are also arriving with better margins. As a matter of fact, I brought this up before — because of the high commission, there's no direct plan TER, and our distribution partners are with us over the medium to longer term more than anyone else, though customers could choose a direct plan when the gap is materially large. And most distribution partners do understand and appreciate that. On your second question about ESOPs — as Simal said in the opening remarks, our NRC has approved a grant of 10.5 ESOPs to eligible employees. As you know, the HDFC Group has long held a firm conviction in the idea of shared ownership and aligned interests. We believe that when employees are given a stake in the company, they develop a deeper commitment to its success and gain added motivation to pursue our common objectives. Our people are our greatest asset—this business is fundamentally about people. Turning to distribution and the other points you raised: we have brought on a Big Four firm to advise us on this matter. The initiative is broad-based, spanning over 50% of our workforce. Over a three-year vesting schedule, the dilution comes to under 0.5%. Also, I believe Naozad has already covered both the financial and the accounting effects of this site.
Kunal Thanvi
analystRight, the motive behind my question is that our business is fundamentally driven by people, so when we grant shares to 50% or more of staff, does that imply the variable compensation tied to performance will level off, or will it keep outperforming the way it has done historically?
Navneet Munot
executiveWell, all of that gets taken into account by the NRC and, naturally, by the management team, as we review fixed compensation, variable compensation and, naturally, ownership via the soft plans. As I said before, over that three-year stretch the compound annual growth rate has come in at around single digits. So that's my take.
Kunal Thanvi
analystSure, understood. So — and if I can fit in one last question, it's about what Naozad mentioned regarding our effort to hold total costs at 14 bps, correct? Now, looking at our business and how things have been trending, it seems fairly clear that yields would likely decline, right? And given that this is an operating leverage business, one would think the cost per AUM could also decline, and therefore that drop in yields might be offset by it? Could you give us some insight into how you view our cost structure—not over a single year, but across something like five years—relative to growth in AUM? Given that our TER will presumably decline as size increases, it's cost as a percentage that will determine the profit growth we as a company manage to deliver over the next four, five, or perhaps ten years from now.
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveLooking at it across a longer horizon, along with operating leverage—which, as you correctly pointed out, is something everyone is focused on. Therefore, when you look at a span of three, five, or 10 years, what we aim for is for expenses to rise more slowly than AUM — and mathematically, that means basis points ought to decline, correct? So that is clearly what the business is striving toward.
Analyst
analystStarting with a wider industry question. There was, I believe, another guideline issued by SEBI concerning how mutual fund trusts and AMC boards divide responsibility. Is there anything worth reading into that, since it looks as though SEBI likely wants strategic decisions weighted more toward the trust instead of the AMC board; so does that alter things materially in how the business is run, in terms of how performance gets assessed and how fees get charged?
Navneet Munot
executiveNaturally, the Trustee Board and the AMC Board both review all of these matters, performance is monitored closely — I mean fund performance — along with everything else tied to risk management, compliance, and various other areas. Naturally, as I said before, SEBI's overarching aims have been market regulation and investor protection, and they continue doing many things to make sure the industry performs well and looks after unitholders as best we can over time.
Analyst
analystNo, my point was more about, broadly speaking, the ability to, say, take more everyday decisions regarding, say, which fees get charged, how to secure improved performance if that calls for any adjustments somewhere in the business? On all of those points, do you see anything substantially different in how the business is operated at present?
Navneet Munot
executiveHow the business is operated, that has materially changed, no.
Analyst
analystGot it. Got it. On the second one, once more regarding fees, and again this is a general question for the whole industry: does the industry hold a position on whether it is, roughly speaking, making more than what's desirable or what's justified? And of course, I may not have put that question the right way, but is there agreement about what the proper level of profitability is across the various buckets of AUM sizes the industry works in today? And how are you, roughly speaking, getting that across to the regulator?
Navneet Munot
executiveIf my memory serves me right, the industry's total PAT came to roughly INR 8,000 crores, and since we handle INR 40 lakh crores, that works out to 20 basis points. That profit figure, though, would also take in other income. Adjust for that, then, and the operating level for the industry on INR 40 lakh crores would land near INR 6,500 crore, INR 6,700-odd crores, which is about how much <<inaudible>>. That part is up to you — I mean, when you set it against, say, the business we run, is 16 basis points or 17 basis points too much for us? Not really, I think.
Analyst
analystGot it. Sorry — just to follow up, sure, the larger companies, including HDFC, do have the benefit of a profitable back book, but would it be fair to assume the regulator wouldn't really see it as all that bad compared with where the rest of the industry is? Since, I mean, that's only in terms of how the phase would be reached.
Navneet Munot
executiveYou'd appreciate how much effort went into building that book over more than twenty years—getting to this level of profitability isn't easy—for millions of investors, creating a long-term ramp for them, tens of thousands of distribution partners nationwide, I mean across 228 physical locations, serving close to 98%, 99% of imports, delivering the performance we've delivered over two decades plus. I mean, if you look into that, I have all of it. Profit number in that context.
Sahej Mittal
analystFirst, regarding net yields on non-NFO business and non-NFO flows, which you're about to address. Suppose, in this quarter, you're hypothetically earning, let's say, 60 bps on your equity AUM. Then what did that figure stand at for non-NFO equity flows during the prior quarter, compared with year-over-year? That's my first one; and the second one is that since the industry is pressing hard on the asset manager, what's your take on whether they're also offering the sort of commission payouts that are occurring in the industry at present. So — is the regulator even examining these distributors' profitability and the type of back book they hold. Those are my two questions, sir.
Navneet Munot
executiveOn the commissions tied to incremental flows, I believe we've already addressed that. I think conditions in our environment are improving somewhat, whether you look at NFOs or non-NFOs across the industry. The second question was about, I missed that.
Sahej Mittal
analystTurning to distribution — in what way does the regulator view the commissions paid out to distributors?
Simal Kanuga
executiveWell, the Chairperson has basically made it clear that the industry should decide how it wants to handle that. So I don't think — from what we understand, our limited understanding suggests a regulator won't really go down to that level of discussion. At least that is what the Chairperson said during the press conference.
Sahej Mittal
analystAll right. And then, looking at the non-NFO flows within the equity segment, net realizations haven't dropped at all. Would it be reasonable to think that?
Simal Kanuga
executiveCommissions have indeed come down, you see, but net realization is going to tell a different story, because what happens is that when my — what usually happens is that if the AUM cost is that INR 5,000 crore multiplier, then a dip in revenue is what you'll see. But if you look at the commission dip across the last 12 months, as Navneet mentioned, we've seen those numbers improve slightly compared with where they stood before.
Prayesh Jain
analystRegarding the AIF, you said you permitted commitments valued at INR 400 crores. What else is planned for new launches during the coming two years or so?
Navneet Munot
executivePrayesh, this is the first one for us. As things stand, our attention is on this one. Perhaps in time we will broaden our product range further on the AIF side. But right now, I believe we want to concentrate on growing this one to the next level.
Prayesh Jain
analystAll right. All right. This one is also similar to a question from earlier, possibly the last one. But when I look at your ROEs, which have declined from the 35%, 36% range to 25% now. And also, if we consider this from the standpoint of AMC profitability two years, three years out, do we think it might, say, move upward in some manner going forward; yet it doesn't appear to be the direction the regulatory moves are coming across. It doesn't seem that profitability in terms of ROEs could truly trend higher.
Navneet Munot
executiveFor us, the ROE is driven by the base effect, given that we have a large balance sheet; so of course, as we raise our payout, as we have been doing in structure over the last two, three years; but the ROE impact would be there just due to the base effect for us.
Prayesh Jain
analystAnd since margins have declined as well, that would have factored in too. So it was more — more from that angle. So I get that the balance sheet has grown in size. But it was more on the margin side, if you look at how they've kind of come down. So over the longer term, do we see that coming back at any point soon?
Navneet Munot
executiveThat's roughly 35 basis points. So across the last several quarters, it's been 35 basis points, 30 basis points.
Naozad Sirwalla
executiveWell, Prayesh, the reality is that profits have increased. So when you look at ROE, we really do value the question you've raised about margins coming down. That's true, isn't it? And I believe Navneet pointed out that our margins are somewhat dictated by the book carrying a different price while the flows come in at a price above what the book costs. So margins are indeed declining, yet that wouldn't have any sort of direct effect. ROE is simply, well, profit divided by net worth. And on that front, we're holding a modest amount of surplus cash; so from our perspective, in theory we're an infinite ROE business in that sense. At present, aside from what regulators require when it comes to the skin in the game circular and the minimum net worth threshold of INR 50 crores, all the remainder sits on our balance sheet. Were that not the case, then naturally our ROE would appear very, very different; but I do agree with you on the margin front — I think our business has faced some pressure on margins across the last few years; regarding regulation, we genuinely don't know what will actually unfold. That said, if you cast your minds back to 2019, I think we did witness a regulatory shift, and following that, we've managed to handle matters as they stand. So let's see how this develops, and we'll make our decision afterward.
Atul Mehra
analystOnly one question from me. In the mutual fund business, what we generally see is that the regulatory issues discussed on this call are largely piling up around fee pressure and comparable matters. So why — near term it may not contribute much. Yet looking at the medium to long term, would you consider incubating a private equity venture capital operation, where the value we could derive over time is much greater? Near term, of course, it won't move the needle given how large our public markets business is; but the profitability and the scope there might be considerably bigger when you look at it over the long run. Any thoughts on these two businesses?
Navneet Munot
executiveYou shouldn't think of a business as being more regulated or less regulated. As a matter of fact, regulation on alternatives is shifting as well, as you'd know. I mentioned earlier that I wouldn't say much about the regulatory side, but we stay committed that over time, this business holds tremendous opportunities. As I've mentioned a number of times, our mission is to serve as the well creator for every Indian. That spans everything from someone putting in an SIP of INR 100, INR 200, or INR 500 each month, all the way to ultra-HNIs, family offices, and institutions seeking perhaps different types of solutions within the asset management business. We're building capabilities across the board. We've been best-in-class — in terms of our product range on the active side, and we've significantly expanded on the passive side. So as that market grows, we are absolutely ready to capture it. Turning to alternatives, you referenced that the initial offering on the <<inaudible>> is now out. At this point, we're fairly pleased with our progress on both fronts—developing capability within the investment team and extending our reach among investors. More than 200 investors, I believe, took part in our first close. That is genuinely very encouraging, and we'd like to keep growing it over time; we've rolled out two strategies under PMS. Going forward, opportunities should emerge on that side as well. Regarding our Gift City subsidiary, I think in another quarter or two, once it's fully set up, we'll look at launching products — both for global investors who want to invest in India and, at a later stage, even providing opportunities for domestic investors through the LRS Group to invest globally. So I think we want to capture every possible opportunity on the asset management side. And I don't think the timeframe we'll examine is about which areas are more regulated versus less regulated; we genuinely value, I believe, how regulators have fulfilled their role in India, and I think they deserve enormous credit for how the market has developed across the years. I believe — and I'm sure you'd share this view — that Indian Capital Markets rank among the most robust, and I'd add among the most liquid and transparent as well. Over time, transparency genuinely helps foster trust among investors, all kinds of investors. So whatever the regulator undertakes — as I mentioned before, even at the risk of repeating myself — beyond regulating the market and protecting investors, they also hold market development as one of their objectives. And every one of us in the industry is hopeful; we interact with the regulator and with other market participants about how we can grow together — for, I'd say, the betterment of investors and, naturally, for the economy's growth over time.
Gaurav Jani
analystI just wanted to get a sense, from a mix standpoint when it comes to equity, both direct and indirect, how far away are we from the industry?
Navneet Munot
executiveWhen it comes to equity mix, we're ahead of the industry. On closing AUM, I believe equity made up 56% of total assets; on average, that figure stood at 54% of total assets. For the industry, it would be 49%, yeah, 49%. So yeah, we're better than the industry.
Gaurav Jani
analystSo really, the direct split in equities compared with the industry — that works out to roughly 80 to 20, I mean 20 and 80 indirect.
Navneet Munot
executiveThe management fee stays the same under both the direct plan and the distribution plan, yes.
Navneet Munot
executiveThank you.
Operator
operatorMuch appreciated. That brings this conference to a close on behalf of HDFC Asset Management Company Limited. We thank you for being with us. Your lines can be disconnected now. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HDFC Asset Management Company Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to HDFC Asset Management Company Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in HDFC Asset Management Company Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.