Hilltop Holdings Inc. (HTH) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 23, 2026
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Matt Dunn
executiveA range of factors could cause this to come out materially different from what we've said—among them the cautionary language cited at the start of our deck and in the annual and quarterly reports we most recently filed with the SEC. Be aware that some of the information shown here is preliminary and rests on data we have as of now. Other than where the law requires it, we expressly disclaim any duty to revise prior statements when new information emerges. This presentation also contains certain non-GAAP measures, among them tangible common equity and tangible book value per share. You can find a reconciliation of those measures to the closest GAAP measure in the appendix to this presentation, which is posted on our website at ir.hilltop.com. I'll now hand the presentation to Jeremy Ford.
Jeremy Ford
executiveThank you, Matt, and good morning. Hilltop's net income for the third quarter came in at $24.9 million, equivalent to $0.44 per diluted share. Return on average assets during the period stood at 0.67%, while return on average equity reached 4.7%. Turning to a summary of our lines of business: PlainsCapital Bank continued to see core loan and deposit growth, and with net interest margin expanding, the bank produced $44 million in pre-tax income. PrimeLending posted a pre-tax loss of $11 million, reflecting a mortgage market that had to absorb a severe jump in mortgage rates within the quarter. Hilltop Securities posted $7 million in pre-tax income, as significant swings in interest rates during the quarter pressured the firm's trading operations. Over at PlainsCapital Bank, strong expansion of core loans and deposits throughout our markets drove net interest income higher and, in turn, pushed pre-provision net revenue up both quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year. A $10.1 million provision for credit loss offset that pre-provision earnings improvement, bringing the bank's return on average assets down to 1.06% for the quarter. In addition to the bank's continued core loan growth, the loan pipeline grew in a healthy manner during the third quarter, with our markets continuing to execute on banker recruiting and focused growth initiatives. Our net interest margin improved as well, climbing by over 25 basis points compared with a year ago to reach 3.49%, driven by steady deposit costs and loans repricing upward. September's effective fed funds rate hike had an immediate effect on cash yields, though it made only a marginal difference to the bank's quarterly results. We expect deposit costs to face upward pressure going forward, a topic Will will cover later in this presentation. During the quarter, deposit balances at PlainsCapital Bank rose by $500 million, with net growth stemming from both large balance customers and new granular depositors. Looking to the fourth quarter, we anticipate that deposit balances will continue growing on a seasonal basis. One notable item: PlainsCapital Bank increased deposits swept over from HilltopSecurities by $100 million in Q3. Even though the bank did book a $10.1 million provision expense for the quarter, we still feel good about the loan portfolio's overall health. Will will share more credit commentary in his prepared remarks. Texas's economy continues to expand, giving our bank a great operating environment; we think our long-standing, relationship-based model for commercial banking will keep letting us drive long-term growth while maintaining strong credit standards. Turning to PrimeLending, which posted a pre-tax loss of $10.8 million in the third quarter. We saw a big jump in interest rates, and September was especially tough—30-year average mortgage rates went up by almost 70 basis points—and that really cut into purchase activity across the whole market. On top of that, the sudden rate increase lowered the fair market value of loans sitting in PrimeLending's existing pipeline. We do actively run a hedge book against that pipeline, but when a rate move is as large and as fast as what we saw in the third quarter, those hedges don't work as well. And then there are the affordability challenges for homebuyers—homeowners insurance, property taxes, and inventory at entry-level prices—which continue to weigh on volumes. We remain concentrated on the things PrimeLending is able to control — meeting the operating, recruiting, and productivity targets we've set while working hard to right size the business so it fits this market, which has been persistently difficult. Given both the period of seasonal slowness we typically see and long-term rates that remain elevated, we do expect the fourth quarter to stay challenged. During the quarter, HilltopSecurities generated $7 million of pre-tax income against $117 million in net revenue, for a 5.9% pre-tax margin. Looking at HilltopSecurities' business lines, Public Finance Services delivered another quarter of strong top-line results, with net revenue of $37 million, which matches the third quarter of 2025. During last quarter's earnings call, we mentioned that the municipal issuance market remains strong, and that is still the case. As a top player in public entity advisory, we'll continue seeking opportunities to broaden what we offer and serve as a one-stop provider for our valued clients. Elevated volatility created a very difficult environment for both Structured Finance and Fixed Income Services, particularly in September and in long duration bonds. The magnitude and pace of that shift made our hedging programs less effective. In Structured Finance, appetite for prepayment protected collateral declined as rate expectations in the market changed. To wrap up, Wealth Management delivered another solid showing in both retail and clearing, with revenue for the quarter coming in above the same period a year earlier. With the fed funds rate expected to move higher, we think results will stay strong through year-end. HilltopSecurities dealt with a choppy interest rate environment in the third quarter, which put pressure on both revenue and earnings and hurt the firm's pre-tax margin. We do anticipate that Public Finance and Wealth Management will keep performing well in the quarters ahead, since customer activity in those areas remains healthy. As we close out the year, Structured Finance and Fixed Income Services — the segments more sensitive to rates — will continue to operate cautiously. Let's turn to page four. Hilltop's capital position remains robust, reflected in a common equity tier one capital ratio of 18.3%. Tangible book value per share came in at $32.20, a slight dip from the prior quarter. We returned $33 million to stockholders during the quarter — $12.6 million through dividends and $20 million via share repurchases. Thank you. I'll now hand things over to Will, who will walk you through our financials in greater detail.
Will Furr
executiveThanks, Jeremy. I'll begin on page 5. As Jeremy mentioned, Hilltop's consolidated income attributable to common stockholders for Q3 2026 came in at $24.9 million, or $0.44 per diluted share. Results for the quarter show both how the turbulent rate environment affected us and how resilient Hilltop's diversified operating model proved to be. On the rate side, July brought a change in how the market viewed things — moving from expecting possible declines in short-term rates to a market clearly leaning toward higher short-term rates. That change, together with 10-year yields climbing in September to multi-year highs, produced a combination of factors that led to sizable valuation adjustments in Q3; in both the broker-dealer and mortgage segments, we took valuation marks tied mainly to mortgage pipelines and other trading assets. All told, mark-to-market losses reflecting both rate and volume effects recorded in the third quarter totaled roughly $16 million pre-tax. Beyond that, Hilltop's reported negative AOCI effect came to about $21 million, capturing mark-to-market adjustments on the AFS securities portfolio net of hedges. The quarter also brought net valuation gains of $4.6 million from Hilltop's merchant banking portfolio investments. Amid the market swings, Hilltop's diversified model kept generating solid foundational results, with net interest income growing $10 million, or 9%, compared with the same period a year earlier. Commercial loan and deposit growth at the bank drove that. Finally, the quarter felt the effect of a higher provision for credit loss expense, driven by an allowance build that I'll cover when we get to page 6. Hilltop's allowance for credit losses rose $9 million during the quarter, reaching $94 million, which put the ACL-to-loans-HFI coverage ratio at 1.07%. As the graph shows, collective reserves tied to portfolio changes went up by $8 million. That ACL increase reflected both net loan growth of $3.6 million and roughly $4.4 million from the net effect of risk rating adjustments made during the period; on top of the ACL build, the allowance for unfunded reserves also grew by $1.5 million in the period. That change's expense shows up in other non-interest expense. While we know volatility persists in interest rate markets, along with ongoing conflict in the Middle East, midterm elections and other matters that might add credit risk, we keep watching the portfolio closely, concentrating on areas we think could present future risk to the bank. And while an idiosyncratic event involving an existing client is always possible at any moment, we don't expect any meaningful systemic risk across the portfolio right now. Finally, as we have noted repeatedly, the estimate for allowance for credit losses is capable of swinging sharply, since the calculations and evaluation encompass, without being limited to, the following: assumptions about economic activity, inflation, interest rates, employment levels, and particular credit activities inside our portfolio — every one of which may be volatile across periods. I'll move to page seven. Net interest income for the third quarter came to $122 million, which includes roughly $830,000 of purchase accounting accretion. Compared with the third quarter a year earlier, net interest income rose $10 million, or 9%, powered by better deposit cost along with commercial loan growth. In the third quarter, net interest margin rose 12 basis points from the second quarter of 2026, reaching 333 basis points. The NIM gain stemmed mainly from deposit costs that stayed fairly steady between periods and from improving loan yields that reflect the favorable effect of new business booked across the first three quarters of 2026. Our present internal rate outlook assumes one more 25 basis point rate hike in 2026. In that rate scenario, we expect NII levels to keep drifting modestly upward, chiefly because of anticipated loan growth in our banking segment. In addition, we expect interest-bearing deposit betas — which averaged about 74% through the latest rate reduction cycle — to return to our model betas of 55%-60% in any extended rate increase cycle. Moving to page eight. Average total deposits for the third quarter stand at about $10.7 billion, reflecting growth in customer deposits in both interest-bearing and non-interest-bearing deposits; beyond that, we are quite pleased with how our non-interest-bearing deposits were retained over the last year and with the work our treasury services team keeps doing to serve clients and support growth in our commercial deposit base every day. On deposit rates, both the cost of interest-bearing deposits and the cost of total deposits stayed comparatively steady against second quarter of 2026 levels. As mentioned earlier, with our current interest rate outlook, we do expect interest-bearing deposit yields to have hit their trough levels for the cycle and to likely trend upward alongside short-term market interest rates over time. Moving to page nine. Total non-interest income for the third quarter of 2026 came to $187 million. Against the same period a year earlier, mortgage revenues fell $9 million, which includes the effect of mark-to-market losses on the pipeline during the quarter; those market valuation effects came from higher market rates, producing hedge ineffectiveness and lower rate lock volumes, which dropped 18% to $2.2 billion from the prior year period. Beyond that, gain on sale margins for loans sold to third parties fell 26 basis points to 200 basis points, as weaker demand has driven continued margin compression. Mortgage rates are still hovering around 7%, so affording a home continues to be difficult nationwide, and we expect these conditions to weigh on mortgage sales activity through 2027. Against that market backdrop, PrimeLending's leadership team is concentrating on further optimizing cost and productivity in the middle and back office functions, growing our client-facing sales team selectively across the country, and refining our pricing to support sustainable, profitable growth going forward. Principal transactions, commissions, and fees were down, reflecting reduced overall trading activity in municipals, derivatives, and MBS during the quarter, and that figure includes $6.6 million of pre-tax mark-to-market valuation losses in the third quarter tied to our mortgage trading pipeline. Although the trading market was volatile and produced significant value swings throughout the quarter, the hedging program stayed within our risk management framework, and should market conditions improve, we are well-positioned to benefit in future periods. Moving to page 10. Non-interest expenses fell by $7.8 million from the prior-year period to $264 million. The year-over-year third quarter expense decrease came from lower variable compensation, mainly reflecting reduced non-interest revenue production at the broker-dealer and in the mortgage origination segment. Looking ahead, we expect expenses other than variable compensation to stay relatively stable at current levels, as we remain diligently focused on prudent growth of revenue producers while continuing to gain efficiencies across our middle and back office functions. Now on page 11. Third quarter average HFI loans came to $8.7 billion.
Will Furr
executiveMeasured on a period-end basis, HFI loans rose $134 million compared with the second quarter of 2026, mostly because of new origination volume along with funding of earlier commitments in commercial real estate; measured on an ending-balance basis, loans are up $580 million, or 7%, versus third quarter 2025. Although commercial loans have kept a positive growth trend, the market for funded loans is still intense, with competitive pressure arising from both pricing and structure. Taking performance year to date, our current pipeline levels, and expected payoffs in the fourth quarter into account, we anticipate full year average total bank loans will grow 7%-8% over 2025 levels, excluding mortgage warehouse lending and any retained mortgages from PrimeLending. If we turn to page 12. Beginning with the upper right chart, NPA levels are down $2 million from the second quarter of 2026, to $60 million, and continue to reflect generally positive trends in our HFI loan portfolio. Now to the bottom left chart, net charge-offs for the quarter came to $1.2 million, equal to 6 basis points of the overall loan portfolio. As I said earlier, we do not expect any systemic exposure across our portfolio, but we stay vigilant in assessing risk and negative credit migration, and we focus on early detection and aggressive workout when necessary. As the graph at the bottom right of the page shows, allowance for credit loss coverage at the bank in the third quarter was 1.11%, including mortgage warehouse lending. If we turn to page 13. As we head into the fourth quarter of 2026, a lot of uncertainty persists in the market around interest rates, inflation, and the overall health of the economy. With these uncertainties, our teams stay focused on controlling what we can, concentrating on producing quality outcomes for our clients, associates, and the communities we serve. As the table notes, our outlook for 2026 reflects our current assessment of the economy and the markets where we participate. Also, as the market changes and we adjust our business in response, we will provide updates to our outlook on future quarterly calls. Operator, that wraps up our prepared comments, and we'll hand the call back to you for the Q&A portion of the call.
Hannah Wynn
analystHi. Good morning, guys.
Jeremy Ford
executiveGood morning.
Will Furr
executiveGood morning.
Hannah Wynn
analystI'd like to begin with mortgage. I realize your prepared remarks covered quite a bit about the softer activity and pipelines you experienced this quarter tied to the rate environment, and that you anticipate pressure on this business all the way through 2027. I'm just curious how we ought to frame the puts and takes for this business, and whether you could add a bit more detail on how the pipelines look from here. And regarding expenses, should we anticipate continued losses, or is there room to bring that expense base down and get closer to break even?
Will Furr
executiveGood morning, Hannah. Let me take that last part first. From the non-interest expense standpoint, we stay focused on productivity and on aligning the business with the current market environment. Although we do expect the origination market to stay challenged, given where rates sit and where affordability stands nationwide, objectively, our focus will be on managing expenses to a level appropriate for where we believe market conditions are headed. On the pipeline side, once more, as rates moved higher, we saw a fairly pronounced pullback in overall activity, as I mentioned in my comments regarding lock volume, specifically in the later portion of the third quarter; we expect, as we noted, we expect that to persist; that said, the team at PrimeLending remains focused on recruiting top-performing LOs across the country. We intend to grow the business very thoughtfully and profitably as we move forward. Again, it's a challenging environment, and again, we will do everything in our power to drive toward profitability, while also supporting our LOs nationwide so they can generate as much volume as possible.
Hannah Wynn
analystGreat, that really helps. Thanks. Looking at margin, we had a good step up this quarter, which was encouraging to see. Can you discuss how much room is left from loan repricing and where you expect the margin to trend going forward? I know you said deposit competition has picked up and that you anticipate those pressures rising. I'm just wondering where you think overall NIM will land.
Will Furr
executiveYeah. I think this will come down to two separate measures. On the net interest income side, we're observing and we anticipate continuing to observe a favorable path for total revenue there. We reached $122 million this quarter. With the loan growth trends we've had, plus where our commercial pipeline stands at present, we remain at ease and confident about the NII trajectory. But that expansion will come mostly from the asset side when we consider overall loan growth. I did mention that deposit costs have probably reached their low point for this stage of the cycle. We think that's accurate, and as short-term rates start climbing, we do anticipate fierce competition for deposits, and that will probably drive overall interest-bearing deposit costs upward. At the moment, competitively speaking, I believe we're mostly seeing rational behavior, despite some new entrants in the market offering certain special rates. We compete with that daily. Still, from a NIM standpoint, we would anticipate NIM flattening out and possibly drifting somewhat lower from where it stands now, down from the 3.33% level; but once more, we'll accept net interest income in exchange for a slightly reduced NIM as we move ahead.
Hannah Wynn
analystGreat. I appreciate the color there. Thanks for taking my questions. I'll step back.
Jeremy Ford
executiveThank you.
Will Furr
executiveThank you.
Matt Olney
analystHi there, thanks. Morning to all of you. Morning. I was hoping to get a little more detail on the loan growth patterns the bank posted. Those numbers look quite robust. Can you shed any additional light on the forces behind that growth? I understand there's considerable disruption in your markets. I'm wondering if that's translating into some volume gains for you. I believe I heard Will reference expectations for somewhat larger payoffs in Q4. Any further detail on that? I'm simply wondering if the momentum we're seeing this year is sustainable into 2027. Thanks.
Will Furr
executiveWell, I appreciate the question. Yes. Our commercial loans have been trending positively. We've recorded roughly 7% growth overall, as we mentioned. A big part of that comes from our markets throughout Texas and the strong performance of the teams working there. Much of the growth we've seen—around $300 million—has come from our CRE portfolio, with the rest coming from C&I. Looking ahead, the pipelines are still robust, and so is the activity the team is generating. We believe we're gaining from some of the deal activity in the market, thanks to certain transactions that have closed. The team is actively and aggressively bringing new bankers onto the platform, and we're succeeding at that effort. We feel really good about where the bank stands when it comes to bringing producers on board, and about the business our bankers have been able to generate; regarding the payoff side, let me just clarify that. The outlook does factor in what we'd describe as a normal amount of payoffs for the quarter. We're not anticipating anything unusually large in the fourth quarter. Even so, we always keep that in mind when building our outlook. Once again, solid momentum, plenty of good activity. Pipelines are still very strong. Recruiting has given us a positive lift, and so has the productivity of our bankers throughout the footprint. When it comes to lending and deposits at the bank, we're quite confident about where those trends are heading.
Matt Olney
analystAll right, thanks for that thorough rundown, Will. Turning to capital, I noticed buyback activity came in a bit lighter this quarter. Was that because of valuation? Longer blackout periods? Could you give any color on the repurchases we made during the third quarter? I believe you still have a fair amount left under the authorization before it lapses in January. How eager are you to finish that authorization ahead of expiration? Thanks.
Will Furr
executiveYes, the third quarter, I'd say, reflects solid prudence and execution on our part, given that the share price was high. Beyond that, rates were rising and we recognized that would affect AOCI. That explains why we did just $20 million this quarter compared with $50 million in each of the two preceding quarters. We'll revisit this quarter too. We have $85 million of authorization remaining. I doubt we could get through that in a single quarter. Still, we'll be in a position to transact once the window opens.
Matt Olney
analystAll right, I appreciate all that detail. I'll take a step back now.
Will Furr
executiveOkay, thank you, Matt.
Evan Yee
analystHi, good morning, and thanks for taking our questions. I know you touched on expenses a bit already, but could you walk us through in more detail what drove the better non-variable expense outlook for the year, and how should we think about that as we head into next year? I'm just trying to get a handle on the puts and takes there. Thanks.
Will Furr
executiveYeah. Again, as we've been looking at expenses, and we've said this across several quarters, here's what we prioritize. We want to keep expanding our productive sales resources across all of our businesses — that means the broker-dealer, the mortgage business, and the bank as well. I believe every team and its leadership group is concentrated on accomplishing that. Yet at the same time, we are equally concentrated on boosting productivity—partly by making greater use of technology already at our disposal, and partly through refining our processes. Over the past couple of years, the team has done a strong and careful job of handling this. We are quite happy that, apart from variable compensation, our expenses have now held steady across several quarters. Once again, where things stand is that we keep advancing on certain initiatives underway throughout the organization—again, initiatives I won't name, simply the everyday work the team performs. We expect expenses to come in somewhat lower. That's essentially what caused us to adjust the guidance. Once again, pushing down costs and lifting productivity while still putting money into the productive resources this organization needs is a foundational, everyday effort around here.
Evan Yee
analystAlright, thanks. Moving on to the balance sheet — deposit growth was strong this quarter. I appreciate you restating the 2026 outlook, but can you give us some color on how we ought to think about that growth as we head into 2027? Thanks.
Will Furr
executiveYeah, on deposit growth, our focus remains on expanding low-cost, core, granular deposits throughout the business. We're mainly a commercially oriented bank, so it begins with the treasury team and what I mentioned in my remarks about their work to keep delivering quality services to our customers, which drives mostly commercial deposits, along with staying competitive on interest rates. We have a number of initiatives throughout the footprint aimed at growing and engaging more customers and expanding our customer base on the deposit side; but again, I think it will stay competitive, and that's probably been the area where we've seen as much competition as anywhere from the new entrants, in connection with some of the M&A transactions that have happened, with offer rates and teaser rates and so forth. We see deposits on a positive trajectory, I think, as we go into 2027. But again, we'll update that guidance when we get to the January meeting.
Evan Yee
analystAll right, that's great. Thanks. I'll pull back now.
Will Furr
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThat brings the question-and-answer portion to a close, and that's the end of today's call. We appreciate everyone joining us. You're free to disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Hilltop Holdings Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Hilltop Holdings Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Hilltop Holdings Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.