IRIS RegTech Solutions Limited (540735) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 25, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Vinod Agarwala
executive[Foreign Language] I'm Vinod Agarwala, Chairman of this 22nd Annual General Meeting of IRIS Business Services Limited. So many shareholders are present, and I welcome them all to the meeting. The pandemic continues to rage across India and rest of the world causing us to affect unique changes in our lives, many of which are probably reflective of new normal. The fact that we are holding this virtual AGM online is one such. It is hosted on infrastructure provided by NSDL and compliance with the Companies Act 2013 direct with mini circulars issued by Ministry of Corporate Affairs Government of India. Mr. Santosh Sharma, Company Secretary informed me that requisite quorum is present, so let us start proceedings for the meeting. I welcome other directors on the Board of the company through this 22nd Annual General Meeting. Please allow me to introduce them to you. Firstly, Mr. Bhaswar Mukherjee who retired a few years ago as Director of Finance of the PSU Navratna Hindustan Petroleum Corporation, is Chairman of the Audit Committee and Stakeholder Relationship Committee of your company. His contribution to ensuring that your company continues to maintain the highest sustainable corporate governance with IRIS cannot be overstated. Mr. Bhaswar Mukherjee?
Bhaswar Mukherjee
executive[Foreign Language] I am Bhaswar Mukherjee, an Independent Director on the Board of your company joining the AGM today from Navi Mumbai. Thank you.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveThank you, Bhaswar dada. What makes the company great is financial and commercial success it has to show. This comes from how strong the sense organization is. Mr. Ashok Venkatramani is a veteran marketeer, who has served companies like Hindustan Unilever, ABP News Network and ZEE Media Corporation in leadership positions. He is the Chairman of Nomination and Remuneration Committee and Corporate Social Responsibly Committee of your company. Mr. Ashok?
Ashok Venkatramani
executiveGood morning, everyone. I'm Ashok Venkatramani, an Independent Director on the Board of IRIS Business Services. I'm joining this AGM from my office in Mumbai today.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveThank you, Ashok. Over the past year, the company's Board has been greatly strengthened with the induction of Dr. Haseeb Drabu, a former chairman of J&K Bank and former Finance Minister of Jammu and Kashmir. Dr. Drabu is well-known economist, not only just in India but the world over. His contribution as a member of GST council is well known to all. With a keen ability to anticipate the future, he chairs the committee of risk of your company, Dr. Drabu? I think there's some technical problem. He is not able to introduce himself. So I now invite promoter directors to introduce themselves.
Haseeb Drabu
executiveGood morning. This is Haseeb Drabu joining from Srinagar. I'm an Independent Managing Director of your company. Thanks for being here. Thank you.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveI now invite promoter directors to introduce themselves.
Operator
operatorMa'am, please unmute yourselves.
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveApologies. My apologies. Good morning, everyone. I'm Deepta Rangarajan, full-time director of IRIS and joining this AGM from Chennai today.
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveGood morning dear shareholders. I'm Balachandran, whole time Director and CFO of IRIS. I'm joining this AGM from the company's registered office in Vashi, Navi Mumbai. Thank you.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveGood morning. My name is Swaminathan, the CEO of the company. I'm sorry for the latency in the images coming up because in the conference room, there seems to be a 10 to 15 second delay for the image to come up on your screen. So please bear with us. We are sorting this out. I'm joining the AGM from my office, from our office and from your office in Navi Mumbai. Thank you.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveOkay. As I already said, I'm Vinod Agarwala, I'm lawyer by profession. Now apart from other directors, we have Mr. Santosh Sharma, Company Secretary and several members of leadership team joining from their respective locations. Representative of statutory auditors, KKC and Associates LLP and secretarial auditor, Parikh & Associate, too are present. The notice convening this meeting has been -- and the Board report has already been emailed to all shareholders and will be taken as well. The statutory auditors KKC and Associates and secretarial auditor, Parikh & Associate have both expressed unqualified opinion in the respective audit reports for the financial year '21, '22. There are no qualifications, observations or adverse comments on financial statements and matters which have any material bearing on functioning of the company. The statutory auditor's report on standalone financial statement and consolidated financial statement are available on Page #113 and 118 of the Annual Report. Secretarial Auditor Report is enclosed in Annexure 7 to the Board report at Page #83 of the annual report. Corporate Governance Report is enclosed at Annexure 8 to the Board's report on Page # 88 of the Annual Report. To transact the business, as mentioned in the notice, the members are provided with an opportunity to inspect all documents referred to in the notice and [indiscernible] statement by writing to the company on its e-mail ID till the date of AGM. I believe that all people would have taken help of this thing. The instruction for joining the AGM are provided in Notice of AGM under Note 21, link for joining AGM have been provided to all the company -- all by company secretary. We have received the request from members to speak at the AGM today. We will call out their names when the time comes. I request the speakers to introduce themselves and be brief and to the point. Members can also raise their hand by clicking on raise hand option on Zoom platform who have not yet given their name. The management will answer all questions received before the course of proceedings today. As you can appreciate this is an innovation by company to enhance the quality shareholder participation during this virtual AGM. I urge members to please take advantage of it. I would further like to inform you that all that today's meeting is streaming live on companies YouTube channel, IRIS Business Services Limited. Pursuant to provisions of Companies Act 2013 and SEBI's Listing Regulation, the company has provided facilities for voting by electronic means to all members to enable them to cast their votes electronically so that business may be transacted to such voting. For this purpose, the company has tied up with e-voting system of National Securities Depository Limited for felicitating voting through electronic means. The company provided remotely voting facilities to all person and Board members on Friday, August 19, 2022, being the cutoff date for voting on all 5 resolutions set out in the notice of AGM. Members attending the AGM today who have not cast their vote by remotely voting are entitled to exercise their right to vote by e-voting. M/S Priti J. Sheth and Associate company secretary has been appointed by the Board as a scrutinizer e-voting at this AGM. The result of voting will be declared in due course after considering the e-voting done today by members participating in this AGM and the remote e-voting already done by certain members. The result, along with the scrutinizer report shall be submitted to stock exchange that is BSE and NSE and it will also be placed on the website of the company as the meeting conveniently held today. The resolutions have already been put to work remotely voting and the requirement to propose and second is not relevant. The performance of companies included in directors' report and management discussions and analysis. Now allow me to say something to the shareholders. It seems that in this past pandemic world, the virtual AGM has become the new normal for a company with a large number of shareholders back all over the country and some even overseas. The virtual AGM offers great way more shareholders to engage with the company than in-person AGM would allow. Today, your company has over 3,500 shareholders and by holding this AGM through this structural platform, every one of them spread over more than 150 locations has an opportunity to participate. To each one of you who has joined this meeting today, thank you for taking the time, thank you for making the effort. We value the importance of face to face interaction with our shareholders, too. I'm happy to announce that starting this year, company will host a shareholder's meet to coincide with the World Investor Week observed globally from October 3 to 9, 2022. An initiative of the International Organizational Securities Commission. It is a week-long global campaign to raise awareness about importance of the investor's education and protection. I invite you to join in person or virtually. We will share details shortly. COVID refuses to go away. We're looking at what most businesses are doing or how people are behaving. One would think that life is back to normal and that COVID is history. Threat though is that it is not so. Today, I want to dwell on importance of organization and how it may have changed the workplace forever. Most of the organization have made adjustment in this post-COVID world, including IRIS. In this post-COVID world, employees are beginning to define the terms of their engagement with the employers. Today at IRIS, we are re-imagining HR because it is not just about the work from home, it is work from anywhere. It is work from -- on my terms - the employees term. You may have also seen the statement attributed to Google's CEO, Mr. Sundar Pichai, that Google has too many employees who do not work effectively or with focus. He is reported to have said that Google's productivity isn't where it needs to be. You may have also seen the tweet of Wipro's Rishad Premji, who has drawn attention to the increasing cases of moonlighting by industry staff. He calls this cheating. At Apple, reward seems to be going against 3 days in the office directive with employees urging management to view such decision to their line managers. Post-COVID employees behavior has changed and not all for the better. From the statement of which I administered Premji, one could conclude that many employees with freedom to work from anywhere has licensed to do what they please. Here at IRIS, many of our colleagues are simply reluctant to return to office and understandably so. During the pandemic, many of them had moved to their respective meeting places with their families. Their reluctance to return to Vashi is understandable, as a consequence on any given date, less than 20% of the office is occupied. I do not think we will enforce mandatory attendance in office so long as the work is getting done and the managers are satisfied with the work of their subordinates. So for this to work, we propose continuously train our managers to get better at monitoring the work from home, of those who seek the flexibility to work at time of their choosing. In this work at any time world an employee can take a break in the afternoon to watch a series on TV or catch matinee or run an errand. Traditionally, in most companies the metric used by HR to monitor employee was to keep track of our system in the office. This is obviously no longer meaningful. The timesheet culture has to be a way to monitoring if the expected outcome have been delivered. With the concept of work hour becoming redundant, we need to revisit the concept of results. Vacation and work-related parts in labor force disbursed, we are figuring out how to keep employees engaged. We are also asking ourselves fundamental questions about work-life balance in flexi-time world. The old 8-hour rule won't work any longer. Here at IRIS, we have always tried to be ahead of the curve. If employees can work for anywhere at any time of their choice, and we have the system to manage them, it gives us confidence to recruit from anywhere. In the battle for tail end, the world now becomes our catchment area where we recruit from the change, when we recruit will change, how we will recruit will change. We will recruit more women, especially stay-at-home mothers, a work from home, work at your convenience framework is a situation made for educated to stay-at-home mothers. According to a research study of the prestigious The Atlantic Magazine, in U.S.A., where opportunities abound as much as 43% of women and -- with children leave their job. A World Bank study says that between 2010 and 2020, the number of working women in India dropped from 26% to 19%. Following COVID, economist in Mumbai estimate that female employment plummeted to 9% by 2022. Says a Bloomberg Report. We will recruit outside the big towns and cities. What COVID has done is to force large part of a workforce to try and stay close to home where they may have support system. Many of our own [indiscernible] back to towns or even to villages, they [indiscernible], by building a referral system to spot [indiscernible]. Mumbai like compound system, no matter where they may be, we will be able to significantly improve the quality of technology tenant at IRIS. Bear in mind that your company does not need to recruit a large number of -- like the big IT services firm. We have confidence in our approach. Let me turn to year that has gone by during which much has happened. I want to draw your attention to a few of them. Tomorrow evening, I'm happy to say, we our company will receive an award from Union Finance Minister, Smt. Nirmala Sitharaman, recognizing IRIS as India's best fintech, institute by financial experts with award take note of the work we have done for Reserve Bank of India, which has helped transform the Indian banking system rendering it as former ICICI Bank Chairman, K. V. Kamath says, the strongest in 50 years. I wish to place on report your company's gratitude to RBI and the various officials of RBI who interacted with us over the years for the opportunity to serve the country in this manner. The award ceremony will be streamlined on live on the website of Financial Express. Your company made a new beginning in November last year when IRIS migrated from SME platform to the main Board of BSE, while getting listed on NSE as well. From having just under 400 shareholders. When on SME Board, your company now has over 3,500 shareholders after the minimum trading lot condition of 4,000 shares was removed. More than half of our shareholders invested shares -- shares, 100 shares each, which as many assume [indiscernible] earning just one share each. Earlier this year, we received one of our first major public recognition when we were awarded the silver medal in the category of tax technology providers. As you are aware, your company is hugely respected to either of GST compliance software, for the recognition came a couple of months later. This time from GST and itself when we became 1 of the 4 partners authorized to generate e-invoices. Your company has mount for the brand refresh, it may have caught your attention as well. We have very new colors, we have also come up with the tagline which captures the purpose of the company. All this year, we wish to describe IRIS as the place where information meets technology. Now with as many regulatory implementation as we do, we are building transparency and driving growth. It captures the mission of the company. It captures succinctly what we do. As I conclude, I wish to express our profound gratitude to each of our clients who support us with their business, helping us grow. I thank our incredible partners from different parts of the world who are working with us for our mutual benefit. The last must -- word must go to, however, to Rakesh Jhunjhunwala, who passed away recently. He is reported to have said, whatever you can do or dream, you can begin it. Boldness has a genius power and magic in it. He also said in a different context, we do not succeed without obsession. The entrepreneurs who founded this company started their journey with obsession with the dream to make this world better place by getting people to use data better. I thank you all for partnering us on this journey. Now I hand over to Balachandran Krishnan, the whole time Director and CFO, who will speak about the performance of the company during the year. Over to you, Balu.
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveThank you very much, Vinod. Good morning, once again to all shareholders. I intend to give you a very quick operational review update. And this is short standard as well. Is it possible to connect the slide deck.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveAbhijeet, can you just allow him to share the screen?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveWill NSDL, please allow screen sharing.
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveSorry for a small delay. So we have the slide deck on the screen. I hope all of you can see. So let me go to the next slide. The one after this, one more, okay. Here is a quick background about the company. I'm sure all of you know, IRIS well enough, but still a small description of what we do. Your company operates in the reg-tech segment and that too primarily with products in the Software as a Service space. Within this, our footprint is global, and we created to regulators and enterprises. We report our numbers to business segments, which are called Collect, Create and Consume respectively. Tax segment creators regulators, or it may creates the means to both operating solutions to enterprises, through mean to interact with regulators. And in the Consumer segment, which is nascent at this point of time, we do have a couple of industrial products in the making as well. Now on the next slide, please. Okay. Here is a quick review of our presence in multiple countries, about 45% of revenues come from India, by diversity distributed across all the 3 studies you see on the slide. Next slide. Okay. Now let me take a quick look at the company's financial performance for the year '21, '22. So this year was not an easier one for the company with headwinds still coming from the COVID pandemic which hampered the domestic and -- especially revenues from our regulator oriented business. Still, the overall revenues grew at about 8%, while expenses moved up at a higher rate, partly when they employ expense increases. We can assume that there was some impact on the EBITDA and net profit levels. Next slide, please. On the other hand, revenue mix improved significantly with the Create segment putting in a solid performance, growing by nearly 26%. Recurring revenues is a very important metric and now contribute, as good as 78% reported, up from 71% in the previous year. The annual recurring revenues, the other important metric also has moved up. And is in fact at about INR 48.5 crores as in June -- as in June 2022 guidance. Next slide, please. If you take a look at the actual ratios, you find that the profitability has impacted. But interesting thing is our working capital management has improved the debtors in the broad base coming down to 86% from 97%. Next one, please. Now this is a final slide, is all about our first quarter results, which was announced on August 12. Typically you would have seen that the first half of our performance in the past has been the little more subdued compared to the second half. But having said that in this first quarter, we have posted a 20% growth in top line compared to the corresponding period. Expenses also grew at relatively a low pace still fairly substantial, but a lot of it compared to revenues, we have a certain jump at the individual. From business perspective, I should say that we do see some bigger activities on the [indiscernible] regulators, which go -- which all go well for the company. So that's it from my side, quick update as I mentioned. Thank you. Over to the Chairman.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveI now request Mr. Swaminathan to introduce the senior management team to the members. Meanwhile, thank you Balu for presenting.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you. Now I think I'll talk to the senior management a little later. I'm going to say a couple of things I think are very important. I think the last year has been huge in terms of what we call vindication. So when we receive an award tomorrow from Government Finance Minister, it's the culmination -- it's not the end, you don't use to word, culmination as an end. It's a culmination of a journey that we started many years ago with a lot of sense belief or what [indiscernible] called obsession that what we do will change the world. And I think it goes back to what Gandhi ji said point purpose means will follow. We have been obsessed about the use of data standards that we are going to change the world. It shows in the way the Indian banking system has become so strong today. And today, we touch a large number of people across the country, every individual, every household in the country with a bank account. Because ultimately, if the banks in the country are safe or as Mr. Kamath says, the banks have the safest [indiscernible], I think we should be happy about it. This would not have happened without the support of RBI. So we have a huge set of gratitude, [indiscernible] mentioned, which is why as we turn over a new [indiscernible] as we from [indiscernible]. We also started going for a significant amount of rebranding, the basis that let -- let's look at the company afresh and look at wear new clothes. When you come on illness, what's the first thing you do is wash up and go wear new clothes. So we got us new clothes. So what did I'll do is I am going to request Gautam, our colleague who runs the GST business to share with us the thoughts that went into the rebranding. And -- after Gautam, I will request Ashok who was also involved in providing input on the rebranding side and who is a reckoned marketeer to offer his comments on the whole rebranding exercise. Gautam, do you want to go first at the framework project and then Ashok can offer comments. Gautam, over to you. There is a bit of latency in this whole thing. So we bear with us and [indiscernible] latency. Gautam, I don't know [indiscernible], can you please get yourself on screen. I don't know if you are on mute, I can't even see you. There is no video. So while Gautam comes up, maybe you want to take establishing you were helping us a lot to work on greatly in terms of the whole rebranding exercise. So can you please -- by the way, Abhijeet, I have just been told, Gautam is not the panelist. Can you please make Gautam a panelist. In the meanwhile, Ashok so can you please share your inputs on the rebranding exercise, please.
Ashok Venkatramani
executiveCan you hear me now? Yes. Thank you so much, Swami. I think I had the good fortune of being involved with the team on...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveWe had the good fortune. So thank you.
Ashok Venkatramani
executiveOkay. I think -- I would qualify the change of clothes analogy, which you gave saying that it's not just change of clothes, its change of clothes to convey a new purpose. And I think what was said by Vinod ji in his speech and which was also reiterated in all that the marketing team has put together is that, when they go back to their customers, it's not just a set of new look on the brand, but also a new sense of purpose on what the company endeavors to do and more importantly, how the company endeavors to add value to their customers going forward. And to me, somewhere linking the company's own purpose to ensuring that they deliver what the customer wants. I think that linkage has got strengthened. And to my mind, that is, I think the key aspect of this change. And I think the success of this whole change, to my mind, will be really reflected. When we go actually out into the market and start talking to the customer about the new change and what we try to do and what we will try to reiterate in our endeavor to bring value to our customers. So to me, that -- the implementation of this whole change is really the key. So I'm really looking forward to continued engagement with the team in making sure that we not just look new, but also are able to communicate to the customers the value which we bring to them in a more enhanced manner. Swami?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you, Ashok. In fact, with our earliest tagline used to be where information meets technology, which can meet pretty much everything in the world. We can have this moving ground and drowning motion to create honey and even there this could have been applied. I think focusing directly on the business itself, those are the entire businesses about creating software for transparency for energy compliance, which in turn drives growth. I think a sharper missing that's coming with your support, with the support of various teams that are actually involved in it. So until Gautam comes, Gautam, are you there? Gautam?
Gautam Mahanti
executiveYes. I am here, Swami, can you hear me?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveWe can't see you, we can't see you. Yes, much better. So Gautam, share with us the thought that went into rebranding, please.
Gautam Mahanti
executiveSure. So I think continuing from what Mr. Ashok said, we needed -- it was time for us to look at refreshing our 25-year-old brand and needed to build something which is more contemporary and in line with what we do and what we value, in line with the changing times. So we actually -- we're not just looking at changing our brand, changing the color, but something which should be a reflection of what we truly value and what actually drives us to do what we actually build. The journey was actually recuperated in partnership with a leading brand consulting firm, which actually looks at building brands from the perspective of innovation as well as growth. So it was brand-driven growth exercise, and it involved actually -- involved talking to stakeholders, both external as well as internals. External stakeholders, we spoke to a lot of our customers, partners and even consultants who have actually worked with us in the past and present ex-employees. And internally, we spoke with a lot of employees, a lot of people who work with IRIS, actually what does IRIS mean, what are we doing right, what are we not doing right, how can we do. And this all culminated and actually coming down like peeling onions -- what was that one key underlying theme which defines what we do, and everything came down to building trust and transparency and how this trust and transparency. And what we do is using open standards like XBRL, we build reg-tech SaaS products. So that's all the what and the how part of it. But the why is all about -- we all dream about transparent tomorrow, and that's what is the common underlying theme of IRIS. And that's what's reflecting now in our tagline, which is building transparency -- and transparency, sometimes actually lead to growth of our customers, of our partners and their growth is actually eventually leading to the growth of IRIS. And from a brand color and look and feel perspective, we wanted to ensure that the legacy 25-year-old brand, which had built an identity and brought IRIS to where it is today. That familiarity was retained. At the same time, retaining the cross share, which actually is an indication of the sharp focus that we have and the eye is an indication of human figure, which is -- which [indiscernible] human touch, reliability and care and support, which is a very integral part of IRIS DNA. The colors, green and blue. Blue symbolizes technology, green is a color which symbolizes growth. It's also the color of our planet. We are looking at more environment-friendly initiative, we're looking at getting into ESG. So the blend of green and blue is actually bearing technology as well as growth and which is actually relating outwards. So that's what the new brand IRIS stands for, human touch with technology and growth.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveGautam, thank you. In fact, the most satisfying part of the whole exercise was, I was not involved in it. I completely loved what happened finally, I loved the final outcome. And the reason why that it's satisfying impact my not involve -- me not involved in it is because this is due the collective input from the colleagues and the collective input from the clients that we actually work with. So it's not -- while Deepta was involved in it. But I say that largely it was Deepta and Gautam, most Gautam than Deepta in one year, [indiscernible]. Balu was temporarily involved in it, but I think it shows a company coming of age, where there are people in the next level that we're able to not see and articulate what the company stands for. So I think between Deepta and Ashok [indiscernible] facilitating role. [indiscernible] facilitating role and I think huge source of confidence there are people in the company who make things happen. I think it could be a huge source of confidence for our shareholders as well as for youth holders of the company. So Gautam, thank you and to everybody who was involved in the rebranding exercise, thank you very, very much, mostly to you. The second person that I want to introduce you to is my colleague Shilpa. You might have met Shilpa in the past and Shilpa is sitting right next to Gautam there in the same room. So one of the big victories in the last one year is the vindication of our work in the GST front as a tax technology provider. It's one thing to get an award for a [indiscernible] to get the award, it is a due diligence by Supreme Court [indiscernible] and it's one of those really awards with great category. But subsequently, we managed to capture the margination of GSTN who have decided to give us 1 of appointed 4 partners to become the invoice -- invoice registry or [indiscernible] a lot. And I don't know what the language is, when new things happen, new language comes up. So I think Shilpa there probably help us with the new language. So Shilpa, the question is, what is significant about us becoming an IRP. What does it mean for the company?
Unknown Executive
executiveYes. So invoice registration portal, that is the IRP. So just like we -- you mentioned a brief about it so that I can explain the significance of it. So IRP is a registry, which has been appointed by the Government. What this means is every business who is covered under this mandate, they need to send their invoice first to this registry. The registry is going to verify the invoice, validate the invoice and then stamp the invoice with a unique number and only then the business can forward this invoice to the customer. So a new step of validation by an independent authority that is the registry is -- will be now affected for the businesses in India. So the way India has approached invoicing is they are going in a pace manner. So in 2020, it started for larger companies with turnover above INR 500 crores. And from 1st of October this year, it has this -- threshold has come down to INR 10 crores. So what it means is every company who is going to get covered under the invoice from will send to IRP and then it becomes a valid invoice. When we see the way things are moving here, as the threshold keeps on lowering, it is a larger market. The SME market that is fitting in a more digitalized in the whole operations. So they're all invoicing or any data that they're generating is now becoming standard and a digitally available format. So which IRIS becoming an IRP what -- so with IRIS becoming an IRP, all the SME, the larger market that is up out there, we are going to help them digitalize their operation, which in turn for them, it is going to help because the other opportunity is of cash, credit and commerce will open up. We also know that ONDC is also making a big way here. So because of these allied opportunities around it, the core thing that is the data you are becoming is very important. And being an IRP, I think we will be having [indiscernible] you are registered with us, all the data will be there with us and from there the opportunities around the data, the allied opportunities is where we will be seeing growth happening. And of course, MSME is being one of the major contributors to the GDP, we helping them is overall going to a help the economy is what we -- what we see.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveBut Shilpa, the questions that shareholders keep asking me is the generation of [indiscernible] free, you have to give it for free to users of it. How do you make money? If you're going to give it for free to companies to generate the invoice, and [indiscernible] pay a lot of money. How do you get money in this?
Unknown Executive
executiveYes, So there are 2 overall parts to it, if I can say one is compliance part of it that is just invoice get them e-invoice generated. So that is something being -- will be given by 3, 4 by all the IRPs. But the allied opportunities which I was just talking about, so when we are saying about say credit opportunity. So the minute you have an invoice available in digital format invoice discounting or getting funded for the supply chain financing, these things come up. So for these areas, what we are looking at is partnering with the experts or the providers in these particular spaces. And then from -- so the business module will work more on those lines, not targeting the MSMEs to pay us, but more from these allied opportunities, the growth and the financing will come from there. So does that address the question?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executivePartly it does. Because these are the questions we always ask. In fact, the most interesting part of our growth in GST is the application called Peridot which some of you might have actually seen. It has more than million download. But what's more fascinating is that then with just word of mouth, there are 4 lakh active users, which is a huge number by [indiscernible] -- active users as in using at least once a month. And from what Gautam said, these almost 80,000, 90,000 people who use us it on a daily basis. Gautam, is that right?
Gautam Mahanti
executiveYes. On a monthly basis, we have 200,000 users daily depends on the date of the month. At least 20,000 to 30,000 users.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveAnd this is for a product which people don't need to come to daily because it's not like they change the vendor every day. So thank you, Gautam. Thank you Shilpa for the inputs on that. One feedback I got up to last AGM is the opportunity for shareholders to interact with our colleagues working on different products, which is why when Vinod ji announced our initiative during the World Shareholder Week, which is going to be from October 3 to 9, what we're actually going to have is our product teams available for presentations, we can do deep dives in every product and look at understanding every product. So that shareholder will be much better to see from the company. We are in a business which is likely complicated -- it's not very easy to understand. So we hope that we will use the opportunity of the World Shareholder Week, which will be observed in IRIS as well to basically figure out what we do, look at the hood and understand the business much better. We are unique. It's difficult to compete with our business, but I think [indiscernible], I think you will go forth and tell people what we do and why we are so significant for the Indian ecosystem. And that's the reason why we have pushed into World Shareholder Week and I hope we will definitely participate in that. Chairman, over to you.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveThank you Swami, that was a wonderful presentation. Now I take up item #1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 of the business as detailed in Notice convening meeting, the 22nd Annual General Meeting. Item #1, to receive, consider and adopt audited financial statement, stand-alone and consolidated of the company for the year ended 31 March 2022 and the reports of the Board of Directors and auditors report thereof. Item #2, to reappoint Mr. Balachandran Krishnan, who retires by rotation and being eligible has offered as offered himself for reappointment. Item #3, the reappointment of Mr. Bhaswar Mukherjee as an independent director of the company. In accordance with provisions of Companies Act, an independent director shall hold office for a term up to 5 years, on the Board of the company but shall be eligible for reappointment on passing a special resolution by the company. And disclosure of such reappointment is to be made in Board's report. Mr. Bhaswar Mukherjee was appointed as Independent Director of the company for the first term on 31 August 2018 for the tenure of 5 years, which expires on 8 October 2022. The resolution seeks to approval of members in term of provisions of Companies Act raised with schedules and rules of SEBI Listing and Disclosure Regulation, et cetera. For appointment of Mr. Bhaswar Mukherjee for final term of 5 years, Mr. Bhaswar Mukherjee once appointed, will not be liable to retire by rotation. Item #4, reappointments of Mr. Ashok Venkatramani, as an independent director of the company. Again, in accordance with provisions of Companies Act an independent director shall hold office for 5 years. And can be reappointed on reappointment on passing a special resolution by company and disclosure of such reappointments is to be made by Board's report. Mr. Ashok Venkatramani was appointed as Director by company on 31 August 2018 for the tenure of 5 years, and his tenure also expires on 8 October 2022. This resolution seeks his reappointment for the company for the second and final term of 5 years. Mr. Ashok Venkatramani once appointed will not be liable to retire by rotation. Being interested in Agenda Item #5 and with the consent of members present, I would like to step down as Chairman of this meeting, and request Mr. Ashok Venkatramani to take the chair for this session. On Item #5. Ashok, you are on mute.
Ashok Venkatramani
executiveOh, sorry. Thank you, Vinod ji. I now take up Item #5 of the business as detailed in the notice convening the 22nd AGM. It is about reappointment of Mr. Vinod Agarwala as an Independent Director of the company. In accordance with the Companies Act 2013 an independent directors shall hold office for a term of up to 5 years on the Board of the company and is eligible for reappointment on passing of the special resolution by the company and disclosure of such the appointment to be made in the Board's report. Now Mr. Vinod Agarwala was appointed as Independent Director of the company for his first term with the shareholders' approval in the AGM, which was held on 31 August 2018 for a tenure of 5 years. Mr. -- the tenure of Mr. Agarwala expires on November 26, 2022, this resolution seeks the approval of the members in terms of Section 149 and all the other applicable provisions of the Act. For reappointment of Mr. Vinod Agarwala as a Non-Executive Independent Director of the company for a second and final term of 3 years, Mr. Agarwala, once appointed, will not be liable to retire by rotation. Further, pursuant to the Regulation 17(1A) of [ SEBI ] listing regulations, please take note that Mr. Agarwala shall attain the age of 75 years on 30 October 2024, which is during the course of his second term as a non-executive independent director. Now considering the vast experience, expertise and the valuable contribution of Mr. Agarwala on the recommendation made by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, which was held and shared by me on 26 May 2022. As also the Board of Directors at their meeting held on 27 May 2022, it's been approved for the continuation of Mr. Agarwala as non-Executive Independent Director on the Board of the company. So accordingly, pursuant to the regulations of the SEBI Listing Regulations, this special resolution for continuation of his directorship with effect from 30 October 2024, up to 26 November 2025 being the date of expiry of his term of office is proposed to be passed. I would now request Mr. Vinod Agarwala to join back and take the chair of this meeting. I would like to hand over the proceedings to.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveThank you, Ashok. We have list of shareholders who have registered as a speaker shareholder with the company. And also, who would like to speak on the financial statement, ask question. And I now request Mr. Swaminathan, CEO of the company and the whole time Director to take over the further proceedings. Over to you, Swami.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you, Vinod ji. I -- at the end of the day, it's a shareholder who goes through what we do, who keeps us on our toes. We have received extraordinary inputs from shareholders in the past. We are grateful to every one of them for their valuable selection, for the valuable inputs. There are shareholders who ask us questions to probe us and make us look at businesses like we've never done before. There is shareholder who is actually required people to watch for employment. Very good recommendations who we have continued with gain from association from shareholders like that. There are shareholders who've actually reinvolved in testing of products as I think it will be very useful. I mean, I think both on and on about the different ways in which our shareholders have actually added value to us. One special person who keeps us on our toes [indiscernible], who's our shareholder for a long time, who has sent us set of questions already, which we will answer after which he still have the right to ask more questions if he wants to. And I'll request Deepta to take these questions and answer them. I will read out questions and Deepta, since she's technically involved in some of the business will actually take the question.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo, Deepta the first question to you is, what's the average realization per FERC customer, net of partner fees? Assuming 140 customers as an incremental revenue in the U.S. of INR 2.17 crores in FY '22, one gets an average realization of around $2,000, which seems to be on the lower side, your comments. Deepta?
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveI'm audible, right?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveYes.
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveThank you, Swami, and thank you, [ Robert ] for the questions. So I think you're talking about the average realization for per FERC customer. So just a couple of things to keep in mind. Firstly, a bulk of the customers have signed up in the second half of FY '22, and that's one part of it. Secondly, as per India's, the revenue recognition policy. Our FERC revenues are recognized evenly through the course of the year. So if you just seek the revenues and divide by the number of customers, you probably -- you will be getting a lower figure that we have than the actual at this contract value. So that math will be incorrect. Having said that, the realizations, the overall realization for the FERC finance market are definitely lower than those of SEC and [indiscernible] because of the filing requirements on FERC are much more structured. So I hope that answers your question.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveAnd I think with your answer you also answered part of the next question, which is about revenue recognition policy in the case of work. He also wants to know about revenue in policy because [indiscernible] of very similar to work. It also has been done over the course of the year [indiscernible]. And so are all revenues generated for the filings under FY '22 already recognizing the profit and loss account, and even I can answer the question, no, because of the -- we [indiscernible] over a period of time. The third question that he has does the ARR participants include the entire ARR from U.S. and Europe, one by IRIS, what is expected to drive ARR growth going forward?
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveSure. So yes, the ARR of INR 47 crore includes the entire ARR from U.S. and Europe, which is one by IRIS, so that's correct. The second part, which is what is expected to drive ARR growth. See there are like 2, 3 things. One is, whenever there are new mandates where our solutions find an opportunity, there are typically step terms sitting here, right? So that is one. The second is when there are no new mandates, then there are 2 factors. One is switch and replacements. So our ability to switch existing customers from other providers that can contribute to ARR growth to the replacement market. And the second is of course our ability to retain our own customers. And the second is the ability to upsell or cross-sell other solutions, not necessarily related to mandates. So for example, in the case of IRIS CARBON, we are just talking through a lot of disclosure management solution. So that is mandated -- not dependent on mandates. So [indiscernible], when we have new mandates and otherwise incrementally as we attract new customers or offer roll out new offerings, not related to mandates.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThe fourth question where only assumes that we do at [indiscernible], so just give you an update on the rights issue. We have received approval from one exchange, but approval is not considered to be complete until both exchanges give their approval, it is a matter of time before it happens and that's when we made the disclosure. So if you want to propose use of the right issue, which products, which geographies, which expense items would be particularly targeted on our spend on. So that question, I will answer. It's very easy to answer. I think color doesn't require [indiscernible] in a significant way. It's clear [indiscernible] where we are running after customers, where the spend will go. And it will most basically be largely on marketing and sales in terms of putting feet on the street. Deepta, can you just focus a little bit on our recent hiring in America where we recruited somebody for on-the-ground sales and what we're trying to do there and any other markets where we are scaling up our sales and marketing team?
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveSo we have recruited one additional resource in the U.S. markets because we see opportunities not only for CRC and SCC, but we also see upcoming opportunities in newer areas like government reporting, [ AgFirst ] and also in ESG. So having said that, if we have to successfully make a dent or kind of get our maximum returns in each of these -- for each of these opportunities, we need to ramp up our sales staff even higher in the U.S. market. Similarly, in the European market at this point in time, we have one resource who's kind of on the ground over there. And of course, we have resources over here. But again, we see opportunities coming up in the European markets, again ESG being another one, where we need to ramp up our sales presence for sure in that market as well.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThe last question that [ Rohith ] had and he's sitting across to us was our India revenues of INR [ 42.5 ] crores, how much came from GST-related products. That's for Mr. Balachandran. Balu?
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveYes, sure. I can do that.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveHow much came from GST-related products?
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveSo I would say that in the previous year, which is FY '22, maybe as much as 40% of revenues come from the GST compliance products.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you. And the next question, I think -- Gautam, is that -- and Gautam, are you listening there? What is the current competitive intensity in the area of GST? And what's the potential over the next 3 to 5 years? So Gautam, we've come up a blue sky [indiscernible] for me, which is like fairly large. We won't give you the numbers here. But Gautam, in terms where to land in terms of GST, what was actually happening broadly, the competitive landscape, and so probably the most important thing is the revenues won't necessarily come from [indiscernible]. There's a point that came from [indiscernible] a while ago about how [ much ] will come from adjacent offerings. But I think Gautam is maybe best positioned to expound on that. Gautam.
Gautam Mahanti
executiveSure. So actually, if you look at the overall size of the India market and we slice it into various categories, it's actually a pyramid. So we call it as category A, B, C. Category A is the top large corporates, 7,500 number, and category B is about 75 lakhs taxpayers who are currently in the GST -- who are GST registered. The category C is the long tail of MSME, about 7 crores in number, which are currently outside of the GST ambit but would be coming as more and more the economy that's formalized over a period of next 3 to 4 years. We see them moving into the GST ambit. Now our focus as IRIS GST has always been the top segment of customers, the 7,500 corporates we work with. We offer some kind of a solution to close to about 1,000-odd corporates. Now -- and solution offering has always been in the compliance space. So compliance as a book becomes the first thing. But then there's a lot of consolidation that is happening in the space now with the competition coming in and offering -- going upstream, offering AR/AP integration for basically [ cash ] solutions, and going downstream into credit offerings or analytics and related solution offerings. So IRIS, we also have a similar growth plan of going deeper with our existing customers, going upstream as well as downstream as well as reach out to the new customers with the entire thing. And in this whole space, there's consolidation that's happening and is bound to happen as we go in the coming years. And slowly, this actually percolates on because an anchor is always linked to a supplier or a customer or a dealer distributor on -- they buy and they sell to someone. And with the formalization of this entire chain, there's an opportunity to actually integrate right from the source until the last end consumer. And with an IRP license also coming in play, IRIS is well poised to actually look at completely digitizing the entire chain end to end. So that's what our plan is for the next 2 to 3 years.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveI want to add to what Gautam said that new things happen. You can't really anticipate how the world will change.
Gautam Mahanti
executiveDid I answer the question? Or...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveYes, you answered the question. Thank you. Thank you, Gautam. So what I was saying is that when things change, when a dramatic shift happens in the market, you can't always anticipate what new opportunities will actually come, because I have to think a pleasant surprise for us will actually happen. Of course, when the applications are [ sought ], we apply. I think almost about 30, 40 people applied for new [indiscernible] licenses. That's a huge investment on what we've actually done in the GST space. so I think you're going to be surprised by what's going to happen on the GST front not because we are not [ sharing ]. The -- we were a bit surprised with the company in terms of the opportunities coming up. So the idea is to be ready for it. Be ready for the solutions and be ready to be nimble and fast on one's foot to get ahead. Rohith did inform me that we will have -- we might have many more questions to follow up on what he had sent us. So please, Rohith, the floor is yours if you have any more questions. Can somebody take Rohith -- the panelist just in case Rohith wants to ask a question? Can you get the panelist named [ Van Hood ] [indiscernible] actually see? Rohith, are you there if you have still a question? Rohith Potti. Rohith, be the first one. Yes. Rohith, you've been promoted as a panelist from what I can see.
Unknown Executive
executiveRohith, sir, we now unmuted you.
Rohith Potti
attendeeYes. Yes, yes. Thank you so much for the opportunity again. And, I mean, first, it's great to see the energy in the presentation -- in the initial presentation. And the rebranding is also a very interesting exercise. So thank you for sharing all the thought process behind it as well. I have a few more questions on the annual report. So I'll go through them one by one. So before that, first I want to -- some more clarification on Deepta ma'am's response to my written questions. So on one hand, we said that the revenue recognition of U.S. and Europe is over a period of a year because of Ind AS requirements. And then we said that the ARR of INR 47.5 crores includes the entire revenue that we generated from the FERC and the ESMA wins. So I'm not able to reconcile that because that would imply that -- so for example, we saw a 2 point -- so we saw the U.S. revenue go up from INR 1.1-odd crore to INR 3.3 crores. So it's around INR 2 crores, INR 2.1 crores. So it doesn't make sense that in an -- the FERC market of 800 customers, where we have the second largest market share, but the revenue that we generated from that market is roughly around INR 2 crores. So does that mean that there is no more revenue to be recognized from that? So I'm not able to reconcile both of them. I don't know if I'm able to convey my question properly.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveRohith, the point is the way you calculate ARR isn't the way we report on the financial books of accounts. In the books of accounts, you have the [indiscernible] in terms of Ind AS to report it in ARR. You'll report for the whole 12 months. So the two are calculated very differently. The treatment -- accounting treatment of the two are very different. And that's why the frequency is very important to be able to get the right number.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeOkay. So when we -- so we -- would it be right to say that the ARR increase from INR 40-odd crores to INR 47 crores is entirely -- okay, so I'll rephrase the question again in a different way. So in August last year when we had the AGM presentation, we had an ARR of INR 44 crore. And at the end of the year, we had an ARR of INR 47 crore. But we also mentioned in the AGM last year that majority of the growth we expect in the second half, we are going to see a lot of growth coming from FERC and ESMA because that happens in the second half. So does that mean that in the second half -- I mean, after the AGM, we were able to win only INR 3-odd crore of ARR? Because that also doesn't seem to fit what the expectation would be from ESMA and FERC revenue growth that we could expect.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveRohith, you -- but we also mentioned that we lost some U.K. business. Therefore, the revenue has actually dropped on account of client loss in U.K. Therefore, the numbers that we added were more than the numbers you actually mentioned because it's more than -- and the increase happened in spite of the U.K. loss.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeAnd U.K. loss was how much value-wise?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveAbout INR 3-odd crores as I'd call it. About INR 3-odd crores.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeOkay, INR 3-odd crores. And South Africa was pushed, you had also mentioned, right?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSouth Africa was delayed because people need additional time to file. And therefore, the revenue is -- we had incurred costs.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeBut that was included in the ARR, is it?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveNo. I don't have the answer to the question. So I need to get -- I need to get back with an answer to the question. Excellent question.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeOkay. So what is the quantum there? And...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveI don't know offhand. We will get back to you with an answer.
Rohithh Potti
attendeePerfect. Perfect, sir. And then I'll continue with the rest of my questions. If you could -- so the disclosure management suite was interesting to know about. So if you could detail more information on that. So what do you see the market -- geographical as well as the value market potential for the suite, that would be very interesting to hear.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo Deepta, can you take that? Deepta, want to take the question on disclosure management?
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveSorry, I was not able to hear you clearly, Rohith. My apologies.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThe opportunity of disclosure management. The opportunity from the disclosure management suite.
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveSo actually, it's too early to say. We have rolled out our disclosure management model first in the European markets. And like we do with every new offering or every product, Rohith, we ensure that it stabilizes first with customers. The scheme, because we had two partners in Europe who were strongly asking for disclosure management solutions for all the customers, so it's kind of a backward integration from the final filing, one step in, well, which is the actual creation itself. We see kind of the good part of this is it's not being mandate driven. One of our partners is actually saying that once we stabilize this, they can take this to a lot of their unlisted customers as well. So having said that, we've kind of brought our early wins. So we got our first customer in the European market. We will be rolling out. Our partners are beginning to offer it to others as well. I think we'll be able to answer this with a little bit of clarity once the product is out there, once customers actually use it and once we're able to kind of push it down the channel further. Why we are optimistic about this is it's an adjacency we can go through all of the existing customer base and beyond, and it also takes us beyond mandates. So we also see the same requirement in the U.S. market. One of our partners in Canada is kind of asking for the same product and is already engaged with us on this. But a little too soon to kind of quantify it.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveAlso Rohith, you'll understand the disclosure management software can be sold only with feet on the street. It's a more -- it's a much deeper client engagement and sale that we need to do. And so part of the question that you asked, the question that you asked about what the money will be used for is basically getting more feet on the street to be able to move the product either in Europe or other markets -- and U.S. and other markets.
Rohithh Potti
attendeePerfect. So that was helpful.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveBut one second. Deepta, we only have our first approval in disclosure management, right?
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveYes. we signed up our first customer for disclosure management in Europe. So that's -- you're correct, we signed up our first customer.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo we've done about -- with China, one customer. And how many demos have you done already?
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveI [ wouldn't ]...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[ Anuj ], are you out there? [ Anuj ],can you [ basically ] answer the question in terms of how many demos you've done in Europe for the disclosure management [ tool ]?
Unknown Executive
executiveSure. So we've kind of met about 8 to 10 customers who've expressed their interest. And we've done demos, and we've got about around 30 customers who expressed interest post August. So it's usually -- July and August is supposed to be vacation months. So post that, we've got about a substantial number of customers who've expressed interest. But demos would be around 8 to 10 that we've done.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo Rohith, basically [ Anuj ] and her colleagues [indiscernible] have got -- we're driving in Europe. We've met a number of companies. We work with the partners. And therefore, once certain things fall in place, you'll actually see them going back there and doing demos. Once a couple of more people, feet on the ground, feet on the street, have established, they'll all go and do demos because this is a high customer engagement and sale.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeAnd what would be -- the realization would be higher than IRIS CARBON, ESMA realization? Or how would that whole thing look?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveDeepta? Deepta, if you [ don't want to ] do this, [indiscernible], please.
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveSure, Sure, sure. Sure. We are still discovering the unit. We have seen disclosure management solutions. For example, if you take Workiva, right, which is the one that we always look to, our kind of a guidance for it, and then try and think [ below ], their solution start at $30,000 upwards. We have seen certain, et cetera, at like $22,000, $23,000 upwards. So we had -- we are still in the discovery process in terms of understanding what are the [ version ] of disclosure management where we can take it.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[ Anuj ], when you met companies, did they [indiscernible]? [ Anuj ], can you please share with us what are the numbers you think might fly, adding to what Deepta said?
Unknown Executive
executiveYes. So overall, I won't put numbers at this point in time because I think -- like I said, we've got around like 30 companies who expressed interest in the disclosure management. And overall, if you see from a market perspective, the players which exist, their solutions are very, very expensive. So we also hear some news there in like Workiva as an example, who's supposed to be the #1 in the disclosure management space, they've been offering the solution at like EUR 100,000, like EUR 100,000, EUR 150,000. So that seems to be kind of a very, very expensive one. So -- and this number of 30, what we did was we rolled out a survey to our customers. After our filing was over, so we asked a bunch of questions. How happy are you? Are you [ happy ] with the overall product and stuff like that. And since we were rolling out the disclosure management, we also asked a couple of questions. How are we preparing your annual reports? And would you be interested? And the number 30 is derived from there. However, we do intend to reach out to the rest of the customers because a lot of them do not know what a disclosure management means. So we definitely do intend to reach out to the rest of the customers. But like how Deepta said, it's a little too early. But we're really hoping from September onwards, we can start connecting with customers in a more engaging manner.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveAlso, Rohith, you'll understand, in those countries, the first question is never [indiscernible]. Consumer data. Consumer data comes after the need is established. So I think that's the way likely we'll proceed. Rohith, over to you.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeSo thank you for the detailed answers. So coming to Collect. In the last AGM, there was excitement about this business with things opening up. But I think we've not probably closed any major deals so far. So when do you think a traction would come here?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveCan you take that, Gautam?
Gautam Mahanti
executiveYes, Swaminathan.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo without getting into specifics of where we are bidding and whatever, can you broadly overlay what the current status is in terms of opening up of regulators, plans for implementing a Collect platform, [ Gautam ]?
Gautam Mahanti
executiveYes. We've started getting RFPs this year. And markets in [ Asia ] and in Africa are really active. Middle East is slightly active, but we've kind of responded to about four RFPs whose result will be coming out in the next quarter or so. So we are hopeful on that [ lines ].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo we are bidding in Latin America, we bid in Africa, we bid in Asia, right?
Gautam Mahanti
executiveCorrect.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveOkay. Rohith, did that answer your question?
Rohithh Potti
attendeeYes. I look forward to that. So coming back to Europe and U.S., one thought or suggestion I have is that it will be great if you can sort of give -- like give a revenue division -- geographic division among different geographies. If you could do the same for ARR. If it is possible, that would be great because it would help map the growth in each of the geographies. Because otherwise, we're not able to get a sense of what the actual market size in terms of value is for each of the filings. So if that is possible, that would be helpful. And coming to ARR specifically, other than ESG implementation and switch and replace in Europe, are there any other growth opportunities? And in U.S., what's happening with the second half of -- second phase of both filings? That would be great to know. And what is the time line there? And what is the time line potentially for the muni filings as well? That would be great to know.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo let me address the ARR question first, is that personally, and this is my personal view, I'm in [indiscernible] thinking about the ARR numbers for a very simple reason. As earlier said, we got four [indiscernible] the [ strategic planning ]. There are many more that we expect to be able to bid on in the days ahead. Now the nature of our Collect business is such that it's very lumpy. So the moment you win two, say, Collect business opportunities, our percentage of recurring revenues actually come down dramatically, which may lead to misleading inferences by people. So the fact -- so beyond -- so one of the reasons why our overseas business actually went down as a percentage of total business is because RBI actually went up. So I think it will be misleading. I think -- but the more granular we get, the more misleading it could be. But having said that, we recognize what you said. We recognize the value of what you actually said. So let's discuss it internally and talk about whether it makes sense. We've been at hard situation that people have come to us and said, "Oh my God, this is falling." "No, it's not falling. RBI has gone up. The lumpy nature of RBI has actually gone up. So I think as well, to people -- if people understand this breakup, that's why we said it's a complicated business to understand. So -- but your point is well taken. We [indiscernible] to what we can actually do. In terms of municipal business, Balu, you want to take that? Where we stand? We've done a few pilots in a few states. But Balu, you take over and [indiscernible]. So Florida, Illinois are the couple of states where pilots have actually happened. Nothing concrete as to how [ we're doing ]. States at the said they're going to roll it out, but we do not see -- Balu [ is taking cover. ]
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveWell, I think very significant to add on whatever what [ Swaminathan ] spoke, right? It is true that in Florida and in the State of Michigan, they've made some good progress. For example, a couple of tax rulings have come out and...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveDone by us.
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveYes, done by us. Pilots are around the corner. And then collaborating with them by -- with the -- which we are used to participate in. And we are -- there are a [ couple of ] things in terms of [indiscernible] [ getting-to-know ] stage and looking at doing pilots. And our expectation is from a mandate point of view, maybe late next year or -- it's too early to say, but there would be some [ acts ]. But the whole area is [ breathtaking ] because there are thousands of state agencies. And one state comes in, other states should follow. Of course, there are some [ critical ] process involved because the states have the right to [ drive ] the taxonomy while the municipal, well, regulation is managed by the federal government. So they are sorting these things out at this point of time.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveRohith, does that answer the question?
Rohithh Potti
attendeeYes, the muni part, yes. So the [indiscernible]...
Balachandran Krishnan
executivePhase 2 of FERC.
Rohith Potti
attendeeYes.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveAnd [indiscernible] Phase 2 FERC. Deepta, we want to hear Phase 2, FERC.
Deepta Rangarajan
executiveSo FERC Phase 2, at this point in time, there's no news as yet. There's no official announcement from the FERC. We are still waiting for that. [ Anuj ], if you have anything to add.
Unknown Executive
executiveNothing...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[ Anuj ], you want to add to that?
Unknown Executive
executiveYes, nothing specific. We're also trying to see if there is any updates on that, but nothing that we hear at the moment.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveOkay. Thank you. Rohith?
Rohithh Potti
attendeeI'm aware I'm taking a lot of time, so I'll just quickly go through my last few questions on the financials. So one suggestion is probably in the presentation, if you can also indicate what proportion of the shareholding is owned by employees. I think that would be a good indication in general for shareholders, if they are fine having that -- if you guys think it makes sense to have it separately. But I just thought I'd give you that suggestion.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveGood suggestion. Taken -- noted. It will be done.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeYes. On the financials, a few questions. So there is this number of INR 13 crore in contract assets. So what are these contract assets? This number is increasing at a very sharp pace. And the greater than 6 months overdue is almost INR 5.5 crore this year. It's jumped up from INR 1 crore last year. So that was first question on contract assets. And there is -- on liabilities, there is an unearned and deferred revenue that has increased to INR 8.5 crore. If you could speak about this, the accounting, what is this, how will it flow into the P&L, et cetera, it would be great. On financials, my third question is on partner fees. It's gone up to 9% of revenues from 7% of revenues. So it's a 34% year-on-year growth. It's gone up much faster than the growth in revenues in Create, where I believe we use this particularly. So could we share more details on this? And a similar observation on legal profession and consultancy fees as well, which has gone up from INR 3.3 crore to INR 4 crore. So what -- so primarily, partner piece is what I think I'd be more interested in hearing about.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveBalu, I think, agrees.
Balachandran Krishnan
executive[indiscernible].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo my colleague, Vineet, who works closely with Balu and who's Balu's [indiscernible] [ legal ] will actually take the question on partner's fee or what the question you had. Vineet, over to you.
Vineet Kandoi
executiveSo first question you asked, about the contract asset, actually that is regarding the unbilled revenue. And that is basically for the contract which we have with TCS for the RBI CIMS project. So we are recognizing the revenue from that project based on the percentage of completion method as well -- as mandated by the Ind AS accounting standard. As we have already told in many of the earnings call before, that this contract is basically back-ended contract, where the billing is not happening on what efforts we are spending and how much work is being done. So the revenue is being recognized, and that is being passed on the contract asset. So if you -- when you see the contract assets of around INR 13 crore, INR 9.6 crore is basically from that contract, which we are yet to build though we have completed our part of the work. So the contract is such that we will get its back-to-back arrangement between TCS and IRIS. So when TCS gets paid by RBI, we will get paid by TCS. So that's why you see that jump in the contractor side. So deferred revenue, when you asked, deferred revenue is actually the income which is being deferred in case of U.S.A. and Europe as well as a few of the AMC contracts as well, which, in the case of iFile, where the deferred revenue is being recognized over a period of time. So when we get money in advance, the revenue is being recognized over a period of time till the financial reporting end. And after that, the revenue is being deferred, which will be recognized in the subsequent periods.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeSorry, Vineet, this was very, very helpful. So I just wanted to follow up. So in case of contract assets, the revenue has already been recognized, but that cash has to come in, which will come in, hopefully, this year or something. And, in case of the deferred revenue, the revenue number -- the deferred revenue number that you've indicated, that will be recognized through the course of this financial year. Am I right?
Vineet Kandoi
executiveCorrect. Correct.
Balachandran Krishnan
executive[indiscernible].
Vineet Kandoi
executive[indiscernible], you shall see -- you can say.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeOkay. Okay. perfect.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveIt could be more than one financial year.
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveWell, thankfully, they're 3-years contract where the customer paid maybe the whole amount upfront. That's -- but it varies.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo just to interrupt one second for people who may be joining for the first time. We are implementing a partnership with TCS, a compliance platform at RBI. The primary contract is between TCS and RBI. And the payment term between RBI and TCS is 5 %. We work through TCS to deliver what needs to be done, though we have direct [ link ] to RBI and we have people working with RBI in making this happen. The work that we do will get paid by TCS. But at the same time, for this to happen, it's still a personal -- a [ clause ] that TCS has with RBI. So the work that we have done is not [ without revenue ]. There, the revenue is recognized in the manner that we actually mentioned, but the payment will come to us based on RBI paying TCS. And that's why the complication arises. So it's done in accordance with accounting standards, working with the state auditors and the internal auditors in a manner which is completely [ coherent ], one.
Rohithh Potti
attendeeSorry, one follow-up question to Vineet again. So the deferred revenue, which is primarily for Europe, and I'm guessing the FERC revenue is also included, so I'm sorry to harp on this, but is this deferred revenue portion of INR 8 crore, INR 8.5 crore, whatever portion is attributed to ESEF and FERC, has that portion of revenues being included in the ARR calculation?
Vineet Kandoi
executiveYes, Rohith, yes. INR 47 crores includes all the -- all of the actual ARR which we have with [indiscernible].
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveAnnualized.
Vineet Kandoi
executiveAnnualized revenue.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveRohith, [ ARR ] is differently -- revenue is recognized differently. That's the fundamental disconnect that happened here.
Rohith Potti
attendeePerfect. Sure. Yes, please.
Vineet Kandoi
executiveYes. The third question you asked, Rohith, is about the partner fee? Do you want...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveRohith, are you there?
Vineet Kandoi
executiveAre you there?
Rohithh Potti
attendeeYes, I -- yes, I am, I am, I am, yes.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThere's a question on partner fees.
Vineet Kandoi
executiveYes. The partner fees, since -- if you see that we also have a partner who is working with us on the RBI CIMS project as well. So that expense is recognized this year. And also, we have partners in Europe and U.S.A. markets. As the revenue is increasing there, probably the partner fee will also increase. So that's the two components of the partner fee which is leading to the increase in the partner fee.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo the partner fee, Rohith, for your understanding, has two components. One is partners who deliver on the technology front or consulting side, and there are partners who work [ with us ] on the marketing front. And the two together are lumped together? Right, Vineet?
Vineet Kandoi
executiveYes. Yes.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThe two of them are lumped together. And the lumpiness happens because of the lumpiness of the...
Vineet Kandoi
executiveCollect business.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThe primary Collect business. In the Collect business, there is a certain lumpiness, and that lumpiness will be reflected in the partners' fees. There will be [indiscernible] partners for certain components of what we do in the case of the Collect segment of the work.
Rohithh Potti
attendeePerfect. Sir, one more suggestion because you repeatedly mentioned that the ARR and the revenues are [ calculated ] different. But I guess my confusion stem from the fact that we've consistently maintained -- we've continually disclosed how ARR forms so much percentage of revenues. So that seems to indicate that there is a link -- I mean, it's a 1:1 relationship between the 2. So maybe that could be disclosed differently. Just a thought. And I'll just end my questions here and let other shareholders ask, please. Thank you.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo any suggestion you have on how we recognize it, please send it us. We will certainly share with our Board and let the Board take a view. So thank you, Rohith, for your questions. We have a number of other shareholders who actually asked to speak at the conference. So Mr. [ Sakeet Kapoor ] is there. The floor is yours. Is Mr. [ Sakeet Kapoor ] there?
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderYes, sir.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveYes, speak. Go ahead, the floor is yours. We're listening.
Unknown Executive
executive[ Sakeet ], sir, you...
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderYes, yes. Sir, am I audible right now?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveLoud and clear. Very loud and clear. Not to worry.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholder[Foreign Language], sir.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you. [Foreign Language].
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderYes. Indeed, sir, thank you for this opportunity to participate today in this AGM, sir. And a lot of enlightenment for investors to have such a descriptive answer and -- question and answers for -- and this is an example how AGMs should be conducted wherein an equal opportunity to all investors should be given. So thank you, sir, for firstly the opportunity. So while going through the business model and all, there are a couple of points, suggestions, which I would like to put forward, and I have some observations also. So firstly with the observation point, sir, I think. So sir, we have spoken in length about what the opportunity lies in the horizon or in the vicinity, but our scale of operations are still very modest. So I would like to understand when this actual scaling up happens in terms of revenue breaching even the INR 100 crore mark on an annual basis. So what are the factors that would lead to growth in revenues going ahead since the scale of operations are very -- if I could understand the landscape in which we are operating, if you could give some thoughts on more like what kind of market share are we commanding currently in the business -- in the fields where we are operating. And what can we scale up to, say, 2 years, 3 years, 5 years down the line? Since you have spoken about the rights issue, also, sir, I'll just chip in my question about the size of the rights issue which you are contemplating. I missed the part. Sir, for the segment-wise revenue point which you have mentioned about Collect, Create and Consume, if you could throw again the light on how to gauge the size of these segments wherein, I think -- so Collect has -- we have -- in the Collect segment, we have post losses for the June quarter. So is it against the critical mass that we'll attain or the lumpiness or the nature of the segment? If that could be explained. And sir, employee costs, definitely it forms a major cost component. So what type of rationalization, as Ashok, [ I guess ], in the very -- in the introductory remarks did mention about the vulnerabilities arising due to COVID-19. So how is this line item going to shape up going ahead? And what steps are we taking to rationalize the same? Sir, you spoke about, in various geographies, our presence. So if you could throw some more light what the export component has been last year out of the total business pie. And what are we eyeing going ahead with, I think, a lot of work in the geographies of Europe and U.S., as mentioned in your opening remarks? A lot of discussion has already gone through. So if you could give detail on the same. And sir, coming to the point about this tie-up with TCS and RBI for the compliance purpose, if you could throw some more light on which segment or which compliances for which category of -- which category are we going to service through this platform. I think -- so I have -- in particular also, I would like to speak about the NBFC compliances for which I think so the entire thing has moved from a COSMOS base to the XBRL format. So I would like to understand, what is the size of the -- what is the size and the term of the contracts which we have with RBI in terms of the migration that has happened from COSMOS to the XBRL front? And also, sir, what's your feedback? How have the NBFCs complied -- or what's the feedback from the NBFC in terms of this migration? I think it started way back, if I'm not wrong, sometimes in the December month of 2020, when we were given demonstration about how the platform works. And now we are, I think, so -- more than 18, 16, 17 months to it. So how had been the migration? How has the compliance happened? And there is a road map through which RBI would be paying you. How the compliances with the NBFCs happening? What are the troubles they are facing? And what -- how is your [indiscernible] looking up at it? Sir, I've been a client. I am doing compliances for my NBFC and over a period of time did face hardship in the same. And also, I have a suggestion that this can be taken as a business opportunity also wherein small NBFCs where -- who are NBFCs because of the nature -- very small nature of business, somebody like an NBFC only investing in equity in mutual funds, but they have to comply with these compliances on a quarterly and annual basis only because they're falling in the ambit -- since they are falling in the ambit of it. So we can also provide a service portal through which these compliances can be made -- done by IRIS itself via the collection of data from these small NBFCs at a [indiscernible] cost and thereby creating a revenue-generating system on the basis of the same since these small NBFCs have to push around [indiscernible], reviews and things like stuff and may lean continuously to your help then to get the feedback. I know the bandwidth for the compliance and the number of NBFCs and the bandwidth of your staff does not matches completely. So there had been cases which I have spoken to, I think, with Mr. [ Baradi ] about it through mails and also reported to Mr. Sharma day before yesterday also and earlier also. So that I can take forward. But I feel that this -- that, that could be a business opportunity for IRIS going ahead wherein we can look after their compliances where -- in a portal where you are taking data from them. So that could be done in that manner. And also, sir, you should try to collect feedback from NBFCs. You should also try to see the total number of NBFCs registered, how many have complied, what is the data pending, then getting back to them and getting things sorted. Maybe you can construct a fee structure. Maybe you can look at getting them compliant because migrating from a system for all people is not an easy task. And not everybody is tech savvy. Even those -- said people are learning and tech savvy, but the language format, the systems doesn't jell the way that has been. So I have faced issues with the same. This was my understanding. Sir -- also, sir, going ahead, I think, sir, even other opportunities can open up in the form of the income tax filing of returns also. So we have the bandwidth. I don't know whether we are doing any work with the IT department, but that can be another step. With now [ Incyte ] coming into way, the -- every data is now being collated at the income tax [ Incyte ] department through which filing of returns and a reconciliation will become much easier going ahead. So our partnership with the income tax department and helping small business enterprises in being compliant in filing of returns could be another business engine for us going ahead. Since we are in the domain, we are in the foray and we are in constant talks with other regulatory bodies, this proposal can also be taken. And also, sir, realigning things -- income tax, RBI, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, all this can be singly realigned via a CIN number and a PAN number of the entity. So these things can be very easily streamlined, and a single token service can be charged from people like you, wherein we, investors, or we, participants, can join hands and create this as a seamless platform of all sorts of filing, herein submit, filing it at different regulatory bodies for the same data again and again. You file your -- you prepare your P&L balance sheet, file it with the income tax. Then you prepare the same stuff, file it with RBI. Then you prepare the same stuff, file with the corporate affairs. So there's a duplication of work that happens on a continuous basis, and that involves the same manpower to work again and again, paying fees at all stages. So how can these things be coagulated at one end and can be streamlined? That was my thought process which -- and I think that this is a very godsend opportunity for me to speak in front of you, putting forward my point of understanding, sir. And I'm a layman in this aspect. This is only the point which I could -- from what I'm experiencing over a period of time, I just thought if you people can look after these three aspects, income tax, RBI and MCA, and aligning all these three steps. Having the same line of business, same line of data or compiling again and again, things can look very different than what the compliances are happening today. So looking forward for engagement, if my points deliberate any merit, we'll look into it. And I think -- so sir, definitely the work which you have done for the XBRL, there should be a system wherein you should check what are the problems, specific problems, the generalized set of problems, and how can those be addressed by the form of [indiscernible], WhatsApp Bro or YouTube Live or any way in which things can be addressed to the large section at a particular goal since you have all the database of NBFCs. These are my few points, sir. If -- and I would love to hear from you. If I have something else to speak, definitely I will -- and just excuse me for a couple of [indiscernible].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[ Sakeet ], thank you very, very much for your inputs. Shareholders like you who are also customers are extremely valuable to our company. Every input of yours will be taken note of and we'll respond to it. But I will respond to all of them together once we finish with other people who want to speak as well. We have Dnyaneshwal [ Kamlakar ] Bhagwat who's there. So Dnyaneshwal, if you're there, we would love to take your inputs and have your comments. Please keep it brief because ultimately, I don't want to get killed by other shareholders as well in terms of the time taken. Dnyaneshwal, over to you. Dnyaneshwal [ Kamlakar ] Bhagwat? Can we look at his...
Dnyaneshwar K. Bhagwat
shareholderYes, sir. Yes, sir. Can you -- first of all, I want to...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[indiscernible], sir?
Dnyaneshwar K. Bhagwat
shareholderSir, [indiscernible] problem. Still, [indiscernible], sir.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[indiscernible].
Dnyaneshwar K. Bhagwat
shareholderFirst of all, My name is Dnyaneshwar K. Bhagwat. I'm calling from Mumbai [indiscernible]. Secondly, thanks, Company Secretary Mr. Santoshkumar Sharma for sending me the soft copy really in advance, which is full of knowledge. Even thanks for sending -- giving me the hard copy also. So thanks to you. Secondly, about the financial part, opening remarks from you. There are a lot of other people and have given all their details. So in my mind, there is no question because everything is there. So no more asking the question. Thirdly, I support all the resolution. Only, sir -- only my [indiscernible] sense is that I'm sorry. [Foreign Language] No more questions.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[Foreign Language] In the case of Rohith, he sent out the questions in advance, even [indiscernible].
Dnyaneshwar K. Bhagwat
shareholderYes, sir. Yes, sir.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveAnd that's why we answered them one by one immediately.
Dnyaneshwar K. Bhagwat
shareholderOkay, sir.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[Foreign Language] We just take notes. But it was sent in advance and prepared [Foreign Language] So Rohith actually had send those questions in advance, which allowed us to prepare for them. [indiscernible] [Foreign Language].
Dnyaneshwar K. Bhagwat
shareholderSir, [Foreign Language]
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executive[Foreign Language] the company to answer your questions. So please don't take -- please don't get mad. Please don't take things like this. [Foreign Language]. We will be replying to the questions even through a filing with the BSE. This event is also being recorded, also will be available. So don't worry, all questions will be answered. [Foreign Language]. Thank you very much. I now go to [indiscernible]. [indiscernible], you out there? [indiscernible]?
Unknown Executive
executiveSir, the person is not joined.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveHe's not there? Okay. Next, [indiscernible].
Unknown Executive
executive[indiscernible].
Unknown Executive
executiveSir, not joined.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveBut he's not there? Then we have [indiscernible]. Not there.
Unknown Executive
executiveWe come back to [indiscernible].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo we come back to -- so I think he was these questions. I think because of the kind of questions that you had, that we have decided to introduce this week-long program in October where we will do a deep dive into every single product, and we will take feedback from users, clients and everybody else. So I think in some senses, we've anticipated these issues. See, ultimately, when we develop a software for RBI, we do not -- so we have been on a fixed price for RBI. We can't keep charging NBFC more and more and more for whatever we actually do for them. We have an MCA practice where we work with people. We will have the RBI [indiscernible] project. Beyond the income tax thing, I think the solutions are very well taken. What you are talking about is the [indiscernible] filing platform. But let me address the most important question that you asked, in my view, as it's your view as a shareholder. [Foreign Language] We have to scale up. That's the most important question you asked. So what we don't have is marketing money. If we had marketing muscle, we would grow much faster, we'll grow more -- much faster. So the reason we have the rights issue, the reason we're looking at things like that, is basically to raise enough resources to push ahead and grow faster. Secondly, you said until last we were a struggling company, we were in deep crisis. And we've just come out of the crisis. We also have a strong [ wicket ]. Therefore, growth can happen only from a position of strength. Growth cannot happen from a position of weakness. So you'll actually see some of our vision being sorted out going forward. You talked about employee costs. We still underpay our employees compared to the market. I think some fair amount of revision needs to be done. All that you will see happening going forward. As far as NBFC, that is concerned, that is that part that, as you know, comes to our office. When an NBFC needs some filing, if they have a problem, they call us. We respond to them immediately. I'm so happy to give you some really -- one of our smarter people in the company who are closing the RBI. If you have any feedback to offer relating to RBI, when that comes to us, and we endeavor -- we'll respond to it immediately. And we actually see that any transition of any kind that actually happens is not painless. It will always go through a bit of struggle. And it's -- again, it's -- basically, we need to understand your problem, you need to understand our problems. But it's more important that we understand your problems first and solve the problem as far we are concerned. And that's what we're actually trying to do. So I think every one of your points is very well taken. So when we organize the week-long investor week during the [indiscernible] the week, I hope you will come. And we can sit together, go product by product and look at what else can be done. Balu, if you want to add something, you're most welcome to.
Balachandran Krishnan
executiveNo, you mentioned about the TCS partnership that we have. And that is related to something on RBI's CIMS project, Centralised Information and Management System project. This is getting implemented. It has been in the works for the last couple of years where that's replacing the existing system which we built. But even the new system, we are doing a substantial part of the work, which includes the analytics part as well as a [ statistics ] concerned. So that is going to be an integrated system. And that will slowly take over whatever is happening right now, including the XBRL filings that are happening through the existing system, which will mean that the NBFC filings will move into this over a period of time.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveVinod, you want to add something?
Vinod Agarwala
executiveNo.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveOkay. So any others who might want to ask questions, you've got to raise your hand and maybe take it forward. Can we please see the list participants, see if they raise their hands. We need to unmute them. Floor is yours.
Unknown Executive
executive[indiscernible].
Unknown Executive
executive[indiscernible].
Unknown Executive
executive[indiscernible].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveI think [ Sakeet ] is going to follow up. [ Sakeet ], over to you. [ Sakeet ], the floor is yours.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderYes, sir. Just wanted the small data of how the migration has been set currently, from how many NBFCs as per your data...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSir, sir, sir, we don't have visibility from RBI's side. That's a question you should ask RBI. That's one question which we haven't answered. You need to ask RBI because we are only vendors to RBI. So these are all things that we will not even know. We don't even know who had difficulty unless they will actually tell us. So we only -- we work on RBI. We have no visibility on NBFCs except to the extent that you'd call us and say there's a problem.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderSo you don't have no milestones set. But if you -- if the NBFC complied, do you [indiscernible], but they truly complied through...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveWell, the responsibility of compliance is not mine. The responsibility of compliance is between RBI -- my -- I have milestones set up in terms of my software delivery to RBI. That is what I'm accountable for. I'm accountable for solving problems that NBFCs have in the course of migration. If the NBFC reach out to me in the proper manner, I have a responsibility to reach out and solve the problem if RBI [indiscernible] feedback in terms of what needs to be [ used ]. Ultimately, the software belongs to RBI. It will be RBI and you in terms of who's complying, who's not complying. I have no say in that matter.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderSo in that case, I think so your team -- you should look at your strengthening of the team, sir, because that is where you people will be -- the people filing for the NBFCs have issues. And over a period of time, our mails have remained unanswered. It may be because of a number of factors, because of pressure from them. But I think -- so the [ helpdesk ] team from your end needs to stand then up and response -- respond to calls, respond to mails from the customer because that would only strengthen your software vulnerabilities which you people are facing, sir. And so that is what [ we see ].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo that is what we'll do. We will look into it immediately. But I must also tell you that we've been working with RBI from 2008 until '22. We have never received those feedback. But to your credit, we'll take it very, very seriously and look into it immediately. Thank you.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderSir, I have the mails with me. So anyway, [indiscernible].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSir, I believe you. Sir, I believe you.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderYes.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSir, I believe you totally. I believe you totally.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderYes. I can validate those emails, sir.
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveI started -- Sir, I started by saying we will look into it immediately.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderSo we look forward for a better quarterly data...
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you. Thank you.
Unknown Shareholder
shareholderAnd -- so that we can be better compliance [indiscernible].
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you. Chairman, over to you. Chairman, over to you.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveThank you. Thank you. I hope all questions have been answered, and I'm thankful to shareholders for making valuable suggestion. And I can assure you all your suggestions will be seriously considered and it will be deliberated upon. And whatever needs to be corrected or implemented, we will certainly do it. With that, since e-voting mandatory -- is mandatory, the company has already made the facility available to the members for all the resolutions transacted in this AGM. There is no requirement for members to proposing or seconding each resolution. Having replied to the question of shareholder, I request -- shareholders have already asked questions. Now Swami or Balu, if you have to say anything further. No?
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveSo I just want to thank everybody for participating in the meeting. And I'm glad we have an active shareholder population within the company. Every suggestion, shareholder or a customer, is invaluable. In fact, the nature of our business is that every shareholder is a customer and every customer can be a shareholder. So thank you very much for participating. Vinod, the floor is yours.
Vinod Agarwala
executiveOkay. I request the shareholder who have not already voted to exercise their voting rights using e-voting platform of NSDL. The e-voting module of NSDL will be open until 15 minutes after the conclusion of the meeting. [Voting]
Vinod Agarwala
executiveI thank all for attending the meeting for their active support and participation. Thank you. [ See you again. ]
Swaminathan Subramaniam
executiveThank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete IRIS RegTech Solutions Limited transcript — plus 255,000+ transcripts from 12,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to IRIS RegTech Solutions Limited earnings transcripts and 255,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $24.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.