Jana Small Finance Bank Limited (JSFB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 21, 2025

National Stock Exchange of India IN Financials Banks earnings 97 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

And good day, everyone, and welcome to the Q3 and 9 months FY25 earnings conference call of Jana Small Finance Bank, hosted by Investech Capital Services India Private Limited. I'd like to remind everyone that all participant lines will remain in listen-only mode, and after the presentation concludes, you'll have a chance to ask questions. If you require any assistance during this call, please signal an operator by pressing star followed by zero on your touch-tone phone. I'll now hand the conference over to Mr. Nitesh Chan from Investec. Thank you, and over to you, sir.

Nitesh Chan

analyst
#2

Thanks, Steve. Good afternoon, everyone. Welcome to the Q3FY25 earnings conference call for Genai Small Finance bank, where we'll discuss the financial performance of Chennai Small Finance Bank. Joining us to address your questions is the top management team from Jana Small Management. Presenting the management team is Mr. Ajay Kanwat, Managing Director and Chief Executive Officers. I'd now like to hand the call over to Mr. Ajay Kanwal for his opening comment. Over to you, sir.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#3

Thank you so much, and welcome, everyone. As I did previously, my remarks will center on the investor presentation that we have uploaded, and when I speak I will be citing the pages of that investor presentation. Let me begin with slide number three. We enjoyed a very strong quarter three, in which gross NPA and net NPA both declined. I would really appreciate it if you would walk through these particular figures with me, the ones in the box. First, regulatory provision in Q3 has fallen to 81 crores against 149 crores in Q2. And if the investors and analysts on this call recall what I said previously. I did state that Q2 saw the peak of our challenges. And this decline in regulatory provision from 149 to 81 stems from that purpose. Second, we are making an extra provision so that our NET NP stays below 1. That is mainly because of our need to apply for a universal bank in May this year. As we all know, applying for a universal bank requires meeting the conditions of gross NPA below 3 and net NPA below 1 for two consecutive years. We met it last year, and to ensure that we meet it this year we keep providing the accelerate provision.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#4

So during quarter three, we've completed 93 crores of that. But looking at net NPA, it's come down to 0.91% against 0.9% in Q2. Our PBT, after both the regulatory provision and the actual provision, stands at 105 crores, which is of course above Q2's 88. If we add back our deferred tax asset, which is lower in Q3 than it was in Q2, our PAT comes to 111 crores and 97 crores, versus 97 crores in Q2. For anyone who'd like to work out what would have happened to PAT, ROA, or ROE had the bank not made the accelerated provision, I've also provided those figures — our adjusted PAT. Simply adding back the accelerated provision and removing DTA would have given 204 crores. ROA would have been 2.4%, and ROE would have been 20.7. So it's very important that we understand the accelerated provision and why we needed to make it. And of course, both gross NPA and net NPA are declining. I'll walk you through credit cost in detail on the following page. But at a very high level, it's been a fabulous quarter, with a reduction in regulatory provision and a rise in PBT, and if you look down at the balance sheet, we've seen solid growth in secured loans of 36% year on year, and the secured book now stands at 68%, up from 60 at the March ending — the financial year ending.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#5

Our unsecured portfolio is down 7% compared with a year earlier, reflecting pressure in the MFI business. And starting last quarter, we launched CGTMSE for micro enterprises that are operating, and for the remaining MFI book, CGMSU — and I'll tell you how much we've already placed into the guarantee program. Deposits keep rising nicely, and our LCR stands at 279%. Book value has risen 380 per share, which I wanted to mention so we're quite precise about it. So it's really important to note that from the first page, gross NPA and net NPA have both been falling, and if you stripped out the excellent provision the bank took, that figure would be 204 crores. Page number four of the presentation deck covers our credit quality. Credit cost was 196 in Q1, 210 in Q2, then down to 174 in Q3 — 174 — while actual provision itself is 93. So actual credit cost has come down. If I exclude actual provisioning and recoveries, net credit cost is only 44 crores. So once more, I'd like to say this for those who join our analyst calls regularly: we've witnessed a decline in credit cost in Q3, and the toughest challenges are behind us.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#6

Also, since a lot of us are eager to understand how the gross NPA moved during this period and what to expect going forward, here's where we stand: we began with an opening gross figure of 755 crores. We brought in roughly 437 crores, while recoveries and write-up came to 434. The result is that closing gross NPA is flat. Now, regarding how much of the gross NPA and net NPA is secured versus unsecured — we will definitely address that before moving into Q&A. The key takeaway here is that credit cost has declined in absolute terms. And if you set aside the accident provisioning, it comes out even lower. Our PCR remains quite healthy at 66.94. I say quite healthy because 66 — that is, given a secured book of 68%. Two more points I want to touch on, which are Q3 developments, now on slide number five. We have taken approximately CGT MSC, covering 13.3% of our portfolio, and by March 25th we are hoping to get to around 25 to 30% of the portfolio under both guarantee programs. I want to stress that our staking guarantee program exists simply to ensure that anything unexpected in the future does not destabilize us on credit cost.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#7

Our lending approach is cautious—far stricter than what the MFIN criteria require. We genuinely think our book is holding up far better than the industry overall. Still, I wanted to be sure we were being particularly prudent given the conditions out there. The other item I flagged here is the cost-to-income ratio. And for everyone, what I've actually done is take OPEX against total business—meaning my asset book plus deposit book. I divided that by total cost, and there you can see 0.9%, 0.92%, 0.91 per quarter. So honestly, cost isn't rising. It tracks the AEM growth. The problem is that NIM is falling since the unsecured book is shrinking, and that is putting pressure on cost income. So the moment we stabilize our unsecured MFI book—which we expect to do in quarter four, meaning it doesn't fall any further, just holds where it is or turns positive—our cost income will begin improving. So you should expect cost income to begin improving. Nothing out of the ordinary is happening on cost. It's simply a shift in mix between secured and unsecured, and we've witnessed an unexpectedly sharp drop in unsecured.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#8

I simply want to reassure all of you that our attention is squarely on expenses, and this is purely a matter of arithmetic that will line up once the MFI book halts its decline and, naturally, improves further when it begins to expand. Lastly, I want to discuss CASA. On 3rd of October, we took a step of reducing our CASA pricing, since we genuinely felt that a great deal of costly CASA was flowing in which, in our view, was not the ideal CASA to hold onto. Having completed that, I have shared with you our CASA cost as of September end, which stood at 4.8%. That figure has now declined to 4.44% during the quarter by itself, purely because we removed the top end of CASA. As a result, our CASA ratio has fallen to 18.43% since our reduction on 3rd of October. A substantial portion of the costly kacha shifted to other banks. We managed to recoup some from the retail bank, from retail CASA, though not the entirety. We will definitely turn CASA positive as we move into quarter four. Our LCR remains quite robust. We hold ample liquidity. So no difficulties exist on that front.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#9

The main takeaway here is that we're at 68% secured. We're on track to reach 80% secured with 20% unsecured. As a bank, we'd like to place that under guarantee programs so there's no event risk that we'll run once we do so. Second, cost income is up, and that's not due to any extraordinary cost — it's mainly a drop in the mfi. And third, we've aligned our CASA rates. We do think this may be short term, but it's certainly the healthiest move for CASA growth. I'll now go to slide number nine. It's very important to look at our asset book and see how it's really growing in the areas we want it to grow. So affordable housing for nine months, with an average ticket size of 11.9 lakhs, has grown at 25%. Our microlap, which has an average ticket size of 6.4 lakhs, has grown by 14.3%. Our MSME loans have grown 17.4% by 73.9%. Our gold loans are at 104.9%. So all the core businesses are unsecured and are really moving along as a very healthy business at a very healthy rate. We continue to expect strong growth insecured in quarter four too; unsecured, as you can see, in the nine months has degraded by 11%.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#10

And I do expect that in quarter four, at a minimum, we should keep any additional decline from happening. That isn't for any other reason. We do believe that the focus on our business and the criteria we've applied give us comfort in making sure we hold the book at this point and begin growing it. Because the new book obviously is performing very well. I want to now move on very swiftly to slide number 14, which will show you our anchor bank. I just want to make a very important point. We've always said that the future of us is making sure that the aspirational customer, the middle of India gets a home bank. And we want to be the anchor bank for people following our anchor bank slide, which is there in every quarter — you will see that hold on penetration in home loan and lab customers has increased from 1.8 last quarter to 2%. Our TD penetration, which was at 19, has gone to 20. Our pre approved business loan, which is at 15, has gone to 16.5. Doing this is super important for us because this is where we get operating leverage.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#11

Here's where we shift into a competitive mode, and here's where customers genuinely see us as a bank. As we bring in more and more of these customers, our credit quality will keep improving, and that's why we've put up this slide and why we stay focused on it. And I'm happy to share with you that there's genuine positive movement here. Let me now go to the next slide, which covers the deposit side. I want to make two, three points here. First, our CV ratio stands at 102 for two reasons. One is really that we saw FDOD growth in the last week that was unexpected, which has since been paid down — that's why, if you look at the last page on secured assets, there's a big jump in FDOD growth, and that's for this quarter. Otherwise it would have been at 98 or 99%. Second, we always keep it in the 90s because we all know we have a refinanced line from NHB, SIGBI and Nabad. We've taken an additional 730 crores of NHB and SIDB money. That's 10 year and 5 year money at very good pricing.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#12

But the reason we do it is that it genuinely assists ALM in securing long-term rates. So where liquidity is concerned, there are a few points to keep in mind. At 279, our LCR shows we're highly liquid. Doing so isn't a problem for us. We're keeping the CD ratio somewhat elevated purely because we don't want excessive cash sitting on the balance sheet, since that tends to act as a drag. And this situation arises solely because we do receive refinance lines from nfd, Sigbi, Nabad, which we consider quite healthy from the standpoint of tenor mismatch. Next, I'd like to go to slide number 19, and I truly want to restate this. Strip out exit provisioning, strip out DTA, and we land at a 2.3% ROA, which represents the bank's true value, and we would definitely sit in the two plus range once we more or less complete bringing net NPA below 1 and gross NPA below 3. Once that gets resolved, we'll be there. Slide number 20 provides a net NPA breakdown across secured, unsecured and total, where you'll notice that almost 79% of net NPA sits with secured loans. Those secured loans carry property backing with an LTV of 46%.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#13

So there isn’t a great deal to expect on credit cost from here. I really do want to go back to what we said about credit cost in Q2 — that it would decline in Q3. The worst is behind us, and we have definitely put it behind us. I don’t want to create any illusion that this isn’t hard work. It still involves a lot of hard work, and we are very focused on making sure we keep at it, persist with it, and hold credit cost at the lowest level as we move forward. There is a PNL slide, slide number 21. Our PBT of 350 crores. In this difficult environment, that has been the highest we have ever delivered, so 350 crores. 354 crores. PBT is after 208 crores of accident provisioning and, of course, helped by 24 crores of deferred tax asset. And it is very important for all of us to know this, because there was a certain trajectory you may have been expecting from us, and rightly so, in terms of profits. I just want to say that we are maintaining that trajectory. It’s simply that we have to make sure end NET NPS to below 1, which is where we are doing accelerated provisioning.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#14

Management and the board are still aligned and everyone remains on board just as before. With that said, I'd like to offer a couple of highlights before I wrap up and open things for Q and A. First, credit costs have come down. If I strip out accelerate provisioning, which is needed to keep NET NPO under 1%, we're truly at the very low end of provisioning — the worst is behind us in Q2 itself, which is what we had signalled, and now the numbers show it. Our secured group is growing quite strongly, so we should land in the 35% range when the full year finishes. On secured growth, we'd like to grow our unsecured book in Q4, or at the minimum keep it stable. We're very focused on cost, though we think mathematically the better answers will appear any which way in Q4. And LCR remains strong, our deposit growth remains strong, and we're very liquid with that. Thank you so much — happy to take questions.

Operator

operator
#15

Thanks a lot. We’ll now start the question-and-answer portion. If you’d like to ask something, you can press star and one on your touchstone phone. Should you want to take yourself out of the question queue, you can press star and two; participants are asked to use ANSEC while asking a question. Ladies and gentlemen, we’ll pause briefly while the question queue is put together. The first question comes from Manish at Nirmal Bang. Please go ahead.

Manish Ostwal

analyst
#16

Yes, sir. Thank you for the chance and for a steady performance set amid a difficult microenvironment. So congratulations to the team. My question is about the microfinance business. In your view, where does the industry stand in terms of the pain — that's number one — and second, when you say quarter four will bring some growth or a stable and secured book, I mean, are you seeing collection trends in the current book improving, and can you talk about the collection trend from October, November, December? That is my first question, sir.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#17

Thanks, Mani. First, let me share my view: a single industry-wide answer may no longer be achievable. Whether we're talking about SFDS or MFIs, you're going to witness divergent results, and two factors will determine that. First is which entity holds what mix of the book, and that's really important — a secured book, too, can come in various forms. Ours is mostly backed by property, so our answer should differ; and with MFI, we've never pursued much growth, so if you compare our 2018 book with our December 2024 book, our CAGR comes to roughly 1%. So you really shouldn't expect much of a challenge, since the book has expanded at a slow pace. It's not that no challenge exists, but the scale of it would be smaller. So honestly, I don't have a solid answer for you about what the industry should accept. I think you'll have to judge by the books. Now, where do we stand in the MFI industry? I have to say that hitting 99% by the 20th or 22nd of the month at 2022 levels is still quite difficult. We tend to remain at 98.5, 98.6.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#18

The figure I’m referring to is the collection percentage for B0. I’m not including anything beyond what demand is in B0 and what gets collected in B0. And we continue pushing until month end to hit that 98.5, 98.6 — I don’t think so. That is shifting quickly. That said, we are consistently at 98.5, 98.6, and we can see the new book we’ve disbursed over the course of the year is performing well. Anything we might have viewed as challenging, we believe most of it has already worked through. So I do think we now have the comfort at least to hold the book flat, if not grow it, and that’s a step we will take in Q4. I hope that helps, but importantly — I did say in Q2 that you had seen the peak, and we may be among X number of players who would say that in Q2; different players will have different situations depending on, you know, what kind of books they hold.

Manish Ostwal

analyst
#19

Got it, and my second question is for Abhilash. I recall that at the earnings analyst meet at the end of the quarter, you mentioned operating expense growth would be 8 to 10% for the year, but looking at the nine-month figure, it shows growth of 19.5%. So with the pressure on credit cost, how do you view OpEx growth relative to your raised guidance of 8 to 10%?

Abhilash Sandur

executive
#20

On the OpEx growth, I'd say it tracks the AUM growth. What's happened, if you look at the covered slide from earlier, is that OPEX is moving in step with AUM. We had previously guided to 8 to 10%. That scenario didn't factor in any extra connection cost or additional marketing spend that would have been needed over the year. Having said that, that's probably why there's been a slight blip in the current year. I think you want to add.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#21

Okay, thank you, Manish. The math here is quite straightforward. On page 5, we show roughly 8,000 people working in microfinance, yet that book is negative for the year by approximately 11%. Had this book been positive at 5 or 6% — which is what a normal year would look like absent stress — then our cost of income would likely have come in near 55%, and we would have justified this increase in cost. The difficulty now is that our people are focused on collections and are not generating any incremental business. That is why costs are elevated, and rightly so, since we clearly have more collectors than we anticipated, and those collectors are not bringing in new business, so cost income is coming under some pressure. I don't think so. We are no longer adding collection capacity. I believe we already have more than enough for what we need. So you should not see a rise in cost. And as I said, if you stabilize the unsecured book in Q4 — meaning it holds at today's level, or even turns slightly positive — you will see pushback again and cost income will come down.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#22

I gave that very specific box for a reason—I want you to understand that this is something we're watching closely. Our cost income should always be a point of real pride, and we'd like to return it to the 55 level, since our longer-term objective is to reach the 50 to 53%. That said, at the moment collections are the bigger priority for us, and that's where we added the bodies. Second, as you're aware, the industry has seen some attrition, which does push people cost up somewhat and likely makes the competition for collections talent tougher, with pay running above what it usually is in any given year. Put those two together and you have the explanation for our higher cost. I expected this question, though, and it does bother us—that's exactly why we set out that box. And we certainly want to see an improved cost income as we move into Q4.

Manish Ostwal

analyst
#23

One final question about the somewhat longer-term view. So you noted in Elsmith that we're aiming to reach the 80% secured book. Our margins continue to fall as the secured book rises and the MFA book declines. So if I ask you, what should one model for your sustainable ROA, given the cost metrics and the pricing of the credit cost and the NIM profile on a sustainable basis?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#24

Okay, Manish, first off — again, I'd like us to look at this, since there's a bit of extra here. Slide number five. On slide number five you can see earnings at 7.6%. And it shows you that had the MFI book remained at that growth — even had it simply stayed at the March levels — my name would be 8%. Alright. Which means my secured book name is in fact holding up where it needs to hold up. 8% was a NIM in March. 8% would have been my new in December. Forget growth — if I just held the microfinance book flat to match. So that is what I want to give you. Comfort that even though we are turning secured, we have micro lab, we have gold loans, we have two wheelers, we have affordable housing, and means are very handy. So that's rule number one. Another point number one. For three years our model was that our NIMS would drop 30 basis points. Sorry — 50 basis points. As we turn 80% secured, I want to tell you the point to point. So we assume 60% in March 24th will get to 80. So 20% change in secured, 50% drop. 50 basis point drop in min.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#25

CASA is going to get better, moving from 20 to 30. So there's a 20 basis point benefit from CASA; net, the minimum negative would have been 30 basis points across three years. So that 30 basis points isn't what you're seeing today. What you're actually seeing today is CASA, with the microfinance book dropping from 9,800 to 8,800. The secured impact isn't in yet. That's what the secured book has accomplished quite well. And as a matter of fact, it's keeping NIM just where it stood in March. Secured NIMs aren't declining at all. The decline is only in unsecured.

Manish Ostwal

analyst
#26

Alright, thanks a lot. Thanks so much.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#27

Thank you, Manish.

Operator

operator
#28

Our following question comes from Shamil Shah at Paris Investments. The line is yours — please proceed.

Saumil Shah

analyst
#29

Yes, hello sir. So our guidance for this year has been set at 30% growth in pets, which means that for the next quarter we would need to deliver close to 500 crores in profit. So to what extent is that achievable? Naturally, we will be taking some DTA benefits in the next quarter. Even so, it remains a very tall task. So would you like to revise our guidance?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#30

Yes. Well, look, I didn't provide additional guidance since I figure Q4 one can be worked out. But let me take a step back for a moment. If you look at slide number three. Adjusted fact stands at 586. Set DT aside entirely. Just consider that absent the need to make that excellent provision, we would have landed at the number we had guided towards, or perhaps a touch better. And the reason I raised it is precisely to make that point: our business model, had there been no requirement to keep net NPA below 1, would certainly have been at a 5. 500 plus number. It wouldn't be exactly what it is, because we may not want net MP to climb much further. But I certainly would have done better than that. And that's what I'm illustrating when I say step back and consider the franchise's capacity to produce — it's much higher. And I do believe that now the worst is behind us, we had a very strong quarter. We have watched our credit cost come down. I think our acceleration in TBT in quarter four will certainly be higher than what was seen in Q3.

Saumil Shah

analyst
#31

Alright. Alright. Sir, based on last quarter, we had 740 crores of DTA. So could you tell us how we plan to use it? I mean, is there any calculation for the next two years?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#32

So based on our initial math, you know, we would have exhausted most of our DTA — all but the final hundred crores — by the time we close out 27 this year. Naturally, we'll leave a little detail aside. We do want to sit down now, and we're going to do that, as we began in the next year, on how we utilize the bulk of our DTA, since we have 2 additional years in which to use it up. We have certain ideas in mind and we will definitely be working on them. We'll share them with all of you when we come for the next year. So when we open up next year, when we do the full year March 25, we will do 2 things for all of you and, of course, for us. First is to make sure we give you guidance for the next year, which is quite straightforward. Our guidance on asset 20% we meet. Our guidance on deposit growth of 20% we will meet. If you give us the benefit of adding back accelerate provision, then we are meeting the ROAS, ROEs, etc. But we will come back with guidance for the next year. When we do March 25th, we will also share with you how you plan to use up the DTA?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#33

Since there is a slight shortfall that emerged during this year.

Saumil Shah

analyst
#34

This is really just a bookkeeping question about the current year. I was simply trying to work it out based on the PSL certificate. You see, once we become a universal bank, our PSL requirement will drop to 40% from 75%. So how much extra benefit could we gain from selling PSL certificates?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#35

Therefore, the CSL certificate isn’t going to do much for us. Let me explain why. Once you move from 75% to 40%, the bigger PSL book will consist of surplus MSME micro enterprise, which doesn’t fetch you a lot of value when you sell it. Perhaps 10 basis point, 20 basis points, so at best you can use around 30:40 crore. Nothing more significant than that, because the real money in PSLC comes when you sell the SMS — that is, the small and marginal farmer — which we are anyway surplus in, and we make use of that PSL CCL even today as an ssb. So, first, there won’t be a big jump in profit from 75% PSL to 40% PSL. That is what I think. You should. And at least in our heads we are budgeting a 25 basis point minimum drop in cost of deposit when we turn into a universal bank. And we do expect the velocity of growth of both CASA and deposit to be much better. When we drop the word small finance, those are the two things in our mind that we are contemplating. There are other cases like, you know, your capital adequacy may drop etc.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#36

And so on. But you're aware that 25 lakhs — well, 50% of the book needs to sit under 25 lakhs, and that will shift. Still, we don't view those as having much impact, I don't believe. So we're either going to reduce our capital efficacy or, you know, originate a lot of large loans. Everything else, I think, stays as it is, but for us the key shift, I believe, will definitely hand us a substantial edge when it comes to velocity and the cost of deposits.

Saumil Shah

analyst
#37

Alright, alright, I’ll leave it there. Thanks, and best of luck.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#38

I really appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#39

Our next question comes from Rahul Bangaria at Luck Investment Managers. The line is yours.

Rahul Bagaria

analyst
#40

Thank you very much for asking my question. Sir, my first question concerns your slide number four, which you have kind of already addressed earlier. If you could just give us a sense of it. You know, the additions during this period have broadly been in the same range as the prior quarter, but the provisioning required by regulators has come down. So just give us a sense of what this recovery is all about. 430 odd crores, because your recoveries under other income is also not a very big number. So just to give us a sense of what and where do we expect this 400 crore odd number gross NP addition to kind of go in the future.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#41

Okay, so there are two points here. First, the 434 line includes both technical write-offs and recoveries. That's the key first element — regarding recoveries out of 434, that would be roughly 100, and I mentioned around 100 909. 109; the remainder is all recoveries. Yes. And those recoveries show up across two lines: one sits in credit cost, and the second is in other income. So we do expect both to carry on as we move into Q4. We would be able to take technical write-off as we do full provisions, and we will keep getting good recoveries, which we have seen accelerate in Q3. We do think Q4 will sustain that. We are hoping and working towards the addition, which is 437. We should bring that down a bit more in Q4. And we should end up with a closing GNP number that is flattish to lower than where it stands right now.

Rahul Bagaria

analyst
#42

So, given the nature of — sorry, please go on, sir. Go ahead.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#43

I’ll come back to that a bit later.

Rahul Bagaria

analyst
#44

Okay, so as the book keeps shifting toward being an 80% secured book, what do you expect credit cost to look like? Because based on what I— from what we're seeing in the— one of the slides where you gave the gross NP numbers, even for your affordable home and the micro lab book, those have risen quarter on quarter from Q2 to Q3. Broadly, what's your expectation for that book?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#45

Let me go through these one at a time. First, we did state that credit cost for this year would be 1.6 to 1.7%, and based on where we sit in Q3, we'll finish at a 1.6, 1.7% cost, and easier. It's also very important to look at slide number 20, which gives you a sense of where the challenges, if any, might show up. There you can see that 79% of net NP sits in the securities, which tends to be more a matter of timing rather than whether you'll get your money back. And ngds are very low in our three year model, which I explained earlier — we have assumed a secure of 80%. We have modeled a 1.5% credit loss.

Rahul Bagaria

analyst
#46

All right, all right, got it. And sir, one final question before I return to the queue: are there any extraordinary items in the current quarter — whether on interest, write-backs, or anything of that sort?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#47

So I’m turning to Abhilash. No, there’s nothing that ought to be changed. I think the sole unusual item — and I have to say this is something we hadn’t foreseen; we made an attempt, yet it didn’t work out. Our expectation was that the microfinance book would steady itself in Q3, but for some reason our attention on collections stayed elevated. October went well for us, though November and December again meant hard work. As a result, our disbursement fell short of what we believed was achievable. Beyond that, in our working we found nothing else that appeared odd.

Rahul Bagaria

analyst
#48

Understood. Thank you, sir, for taking my questions, and best of luck.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#49

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#50

Kamal from Investec Capital Services is on the line with our next question. Please proceed.

Kamal Mulchandani

analyst
#51

Thanks a lot, sir, and congratulations on a strong set of numbers. First, building on what the previous participant asked, could you walk us through the reasons behind the rise in GNP within the secured segments of micro lab and affordable housing?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#52

Okay, so speaking just for us, there are two states where we're seeing somewhat more difficulty, and I can't say if that's across the whole industry or just specific to Jana — one of them is Odisha. Then second, we've noticed a modest improvement in West Bengal. We've taken steps to deal with those, and we're confident that this DOS NPA should definitely get to a better place than where it stands today. But not — nothing, you know, if the question is whether you're seeing any spillover from microfinance into micro lab, the answer is no. There isn't much overlap between them, and we don't see micro lab reacting in that way either. These are affordable housing. Still, we do believe there are two geographies where we need to tighten up our shop and our act, and that's exactly what we're focused on. Nothing beyond that causes us any discomfort. That's why, if you actually look at quarter-on-quarter advances for the group, which is on page nine, we keep growing affordable housing in micro lab at a very healthy clip — quarterly growth of 7% and 5%, or further 6%. So nothing that would worry us, just a bit of hard work in two geographies.

Kamal Mulchandani

analyst
#53

Alright, I understand. And did I have it right that the write-offs in Q3 came to 109 crore rupees?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#54

That's right. Abhilash brought that up. And look, first off, I'm not going to tell everybody that all this anxiety about what microfinance can do and how the numbers look is now behind us. If we had the choice, we'd definitely want to ensure NPAs stay under 1. Because our aim is to become a universal. So we're giving it our best to reach the right points. And in our view, Q3 was extremely good. Because those numbers we kept discussing in Q2, when we said this is our peak — we've actually delivered them. If you look at credit cost, it's shown including access provision. That's also, you know, a very large number. If you turn to slide number four, trade cost stands at 174 versus 210 in the prior quarter, and that 174 includes 93 of accelerate provision. So yes, you're right. The technical write-off was 109 and the remainder were recoveries.

Kamal Mulchandani

analyst
#55

What did that figure come to in the prior quarter?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#56

A write-off, you say? Let me verify that. Bear with us for a moment while we look into it.

Kamal Mulchandani

analyst
#57

Alright, certainly, sir. And if you wouldn't mind giving me a hand as well.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#58

We didn’t have any technical write-off. It’s only in this quarter that we are technical.

Kamal Mulchandani

analyst
#59

Understood. Sir, could you also help us out by telling us the blended credit cost and ROAS for your secured book as well as your unsecured book?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#60

All right, blended credit cost — while Abhilash works that out quickly, let's move on to the next question, shall we?

Kamal Mulchandani

analyst
#61

Alright, that's everything from my side. Sir, it would be wonderful if you could follow up with us regarding the credit course and the RN numbers. Many thanks.

Operator

operator
#62

Thanks. Our next question comes from Darshal Javeri at Crown Capital. You have the floor.

Darshil Jhaveri

analyst
#63

Hello. Good evening, sir. Thanks a lot for taking my question. First off, congratulations on such a strong set of results. So, I just wanted to ask: with regard to, you know, now that reported growth — since we won't be able to hit 30 — can we expect that next quarter will be similar to what we reported, like 110 crores? 111 crores.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#64

No, it definitely ought to be better, and the reason is straightforward. Whatever assets we brought on this quarter, you know, those will generate additional income for us in the next quarter, and we would certainly want to grow — or at minimum stabilize — our unsecured book. So that too will contribute to profits. We are not anticipating any rise in credit cost, for sure. So I think that should be a positive as well. You're also aware that quarter four is in any case a good one for every bank. It's the strongest quarter each year, which means disbursements pick up considerably and that certainly produces a lot of fee income. So, I mean, if I simply take those three parameters — a larger balance sheet heading into Q4, unsecured hopefully stabilizing, and heavier disbursement in Q4 — I do expect my cost of deposit to decline in Q4, and I can see that happening, because we've repriced our casa and we had repriced our deposits too. So I would anticipate a much bigger EBT impact, and I would certainly want to keep NET NPO under 1 and gross NPA under 3 as I go into — as I close out the quarter. I can say that with a lot of comfort, because today is the 21st of January and we really have a clear view of what we're expecting.

Darshil Jhaveri

analyst
#65

Understood, sir — that's quite useful, sir. So the accelerated provisions, those will perhaps wrap up in FY26, correct? Or will we — how much longer are we going to keep carrying these accelerated provisions, since they dampen the book considerably? I just wanted to ask whether, after we submit the application for the universal banking license, they'll carry on in Q1 as well, or how that would play out? Sir,

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#66

My sense is that this unwinding plays out across the coming three or four quarters. It won't be some sudden matchup, but what you will see is that the amount we add to the actual provision shrinks as we move into next year. So certainly, you know, since right now the total corpus of action is .208 crores, let's say we take another 60, 70, 80 crores in quarter four, that should land closer to something like 275 to 300 crores of accurate provisioning that we're carrying into the next year. So obviously those provisions get used up. But certainly I don't see a wide. We should add more to them. And remember, you know, as your unsecured book stabilizes. Right. The need for provisioning anyway comes down. Secure doesn't take too much provision and like I said, you know, the small blips in secure will get sorted out. So I do see that, you know, the carry of accelerate provision, which means my PAT is reduced this year, it won't happen next year and make sure that what that number is, I put that clearly in slide number one so that there is clarity in everybody's mind that what to expect with our franchise.

Darshil Jhaveri

analyst
#67

Yeah, anything in the way of guidance you'd want to share for FY26 at this point.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#68

Okay, so asset growth came in at 20, and liability growth was 120%. What I mean is that we had said we would hit that target this year. We will definitely provide similar guidance for next year as well. I don't believe that will change things for us. What we want to deliver is around PAT and ROE — we just want to take the time to wrap up this year and observe how the release of asset provision plays out, and so on. Let me be very clear on that, and then we will certainly get back to you when we announce the March results, you know.

Darshil Jhaveri

analyst
#69

Okay. Okay.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#70

At this moment, growth in both assets and liabilities is set to keep going. Expansion of the secured group will also carry on. A decline there is not something we would want to see. So all three of those will take place. We'll push even harder to grow CASA. And as you have observed, we've brought the CASA cost down. That approach is not going to change. So I think those are a few of the givens you ought to assume — that Jannah as a strategy, and that will stay the same.

Darshil Jhaveri

analyst
#71

Right. Fair enough, sir. That’s all. On my end. So everyone, thank you very much.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#72

Thanks. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#73

Shailesh El Kanani from Centrum Booking has the next question. The line is yours, go ahead.

Shailesh Kanani

analyst
#74

Good evening, sir, and thank you for the chance to speak. Sir, aside from the collection efforts, could you identify any strategy that we have put in place in the three third quarters, because where Visa is concerned, our performance looks very strong? Visa.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#75

That's a great question. Sorry—did you get through the whole question? Apologies, you're cutting out a little.

Shailesh Kanani

analyst
#76

So, I mean — sorry, would you rather I just go over the question again?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#77

No, I understand. Yes, I’m saying it again. You want to know why our results came in stronger. Was there some particular strategy we used in Q3?

Shailesh Kanani

analyst
#78

Okay. And are there any states you'd want to highlight where our results have improved dramatically in sequence, or anything you'd like to follow up on? Any states that are doing well.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#79

Okay, I’d like to direct everyone listening on this call to a particular slide — that’s slide 11. To start with, out of a total unsecured book of 8,000–888 to 899 crores, 5,124 is individual loans. I doubt you’ll find many other MFIs or SFDs where individual loans make up such a high share. Individual lending has been our approach because we started in urban micro finance. We shifted to individual loans as far back as 2018. One characteristic of individual loans is that they’re much more urban in character. And you can see we’ve provided a pickup showing where our agri and non-agri sit. But we give individual loans to customers who have completed one withdrawal cycle. And second, only after an underwriter has visited them — that’s a credit underwriter’s visit to establish what the cash flows look like before a loan is extended, since typically uninterrupted loans run higher. So I’d say one reason our book performs better is, first, that it’s individual loans — we had done underwriting — and second, collection behavior on individual loans is much stronger now than on group loans, because with individual loans there’s no ganging up of people saying, okay, let’s all get together and not pay, or let’s put up a barricade outside the village.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#80

There are no MFIs in this. None of that takes place. With individual loans, there’s no ringleader involved. There’s a customer on one side and a bank on the other. Second, this customer has been through a credit cycle and understands what credit means. Third, my underwriter has paid him a visit. We were giving the market this clear signal as far back as Q2, but we lacked the numbers to support it, since Q2 did show an increase. And we kept telling people: listen to what we’re saying — we believe we’ve seen the worst of it — and use that as the starting point for judging us against what will play out across industries. Begin from this page and look at what their book consists of. 5124 is individual loans. 1643 is BC, where we hold service guarantees, meaning that if the money isn’t collected by them and the account turns NPA, they bear responsibility in a financial sense. Right. So when you add those two together, you can see why my credit cost ought to be lower. Both because we had service guarantees from BCS, which is roughly 20% of my book. Individual loans come to 5124 out of 8000 crores, which is a few 55 to 70% of the book — very different from a regular MFI or an SFB, I would think, and that’s why you would expect differential performance.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#81

And we're quite confident that this strategy will keep going. Yes, three bcs gave us some trouble. We now understand what needs to be done in a different way. But keep in mind that 14 of the 17 bcs performed very well. So those three taught us a lesson—we'll correct it, and then we'll move forward. So, just to add, to sum up. Sorry to keep dwelling on this, but even so, what I was after was sequential performance. Look, individual share was elevated for us even during the second quarter, right. Perhaps a few bips up or down, but even in the second quarter we held more than 50% share in individual lending. So I simply wanted to check whether we have done it, because the individual book as such has shown a notable improvement Q on Q, so I was just wondering if something has occurred there. So one point is, you know, some of it would be a technical write-off, because you heard abhilash say that we did not do a technical write off in Q2—we did one in Q3—so part of the GNP drop may relate to that technical write off. So you're right that it looks better than Q2, and I think one reason would certainly be the tech write off.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#82

But taking a step back — even using the Q2 figures, individual loans are sitting at just over 4%, and I believe IL will outperform group loans across MFIs, SABs, and banks alike. And again, barring someone having handled it in a truly strange manner, when the credit call has been made on customers with existing credit experience, my view is you'll see a superior outcome in IL than with group loans, and I do think a larger share of the industry will move toward IL as the solution, since the batteries are broken. There are no ringleaders behind this, and you'll find that customer behavior toward a bank or financial institution in a one-on-one setting ultimately turns out better.

Shailesh Kanani

analyst
#83

Fair enough, sir. Any, any, any, any mention for any state when it comes to performance.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#84

So where are we putting in a lot of effort? I’m looking at Raman right now. We were putting in a lot of effort in Bihar. Yep. We definitely have an issue in certain pockets of UP, but not across the whole state. So I wouldn’t single out the state broadly. There are a few districts there where we certainly are seeing stress in Odisha, and that we can see both in MFI and even our housing book. So there’s a general level of challenge in Odisha. I think apart from three small pockets of West Bengal, nothing significant, but we’ve never had a big part of our exposure there. Yeah, I mean that is what I would call out.

Shailesh Kanani

analyst
#85

Fair enough — that’s useful. My second question, then, was about the PC book. The PC book has again posted a noticeable sequential decline, and GNP is also — sorry.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#86

One major factor, once again, is that the CBC book first keeps getting better—so that's rule number one. Some portion of it, though, might perhaps come from any tech writers taken here, which could be the cause. Still, yes, if you were to set that aside, then when examining the credit cost, the single assumption you should definitely verify is present is that the unsecured achievement incorporated the BC book.

Shailesh Kanani

analyst
#87

All right, so this is my final question. For our individual lending and gag customers, what additional products would overlap besides the unsecured loan? Is there any overlap with affordable housing, or any other product, for our customers?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#88

Let me explain what I mean. You should understand that we have 3005 people in the field working on affordable housing microlabs. Those 3000 individuals report to a business manager who oversees the affordable housing microlab operation, and most of them—actually, I'd say all of them—come from either banks or NBFCs engaged in housing or life lending. There's zero overlap in salesforce between microfinance and affordable housing or microlab. So that's rule number one. Credit underwriting for affordable housing and Micro Lab is handled by a distinct group of underwriters that uses a scorecard and, as you know, follows physical visits, valuation, and legal checks. I'd also like to make clear that our Micro Lab is not a moral obligation by the customer. It is surfaceable property. Even though it's six and a half lakhs, we don't offer a product where someone deposits a power of attorney on this property transaction and then we give a loan on property that a legal lawyer has signed. Yes, and we can do surface reaction on it. So that's my point. I want to clarify this because the question is how much impact microfinance has on this—in our book it should not be high.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#89

Do we have any microfinance clients within affordable housing and Micro Lab? Yes—there are definitely plenty of strong microfinance borrowers. At most, that segment makes up roughly 5 or 6% of the affordable housing Micro Lab group. We've assessed how they perform, and the encouraging part is that our Micro Lab customers with a microfinance background—sorry, affordable housing Micro Lab customers coming from microfinance—perform very well, though they aren't a big portion. And mostly this customer will have just one secured product, only one unsecured product. Right? Whether individual or JLG. So we carry only one product line in the bank. We have no other unsecured business. Our whole bank does microfinance only, where you can obtain a GLD if you're a GLG graduate, you'll receive an individual loan. There's no other unsecured product. Only in the bank.

Shailesh Kanani

analyst
#90

Alright, that’s fair enough, sir. Thank you very much. And I wish you the best of luck, sir.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#91

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#92

Thanks. Attendees, kindly keep it to a maximum of 2 questions each. We now have Sarvesh Gupta from Maximal Capital Private Limited on the line. You may proceed.

Sarvesh Gupta

analyst
#93

Good evening, and thanks for the chance to speak — and congratulations on a solid set of numbers. Most of my questions have already been covered. There's just one thing: if you could give a bit more clarity there. Hello?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#94

Sure, please go ahead.

Sarvesh Gupta

analyst
#95

Okay, so this 2.3% adjusted ROA that we've posted across the first 9M — once those tax benefits disappear, that figure could drop by roughly 25% as well. So. And then you mentioned there might be a 30 basis point hit stemming from the. From our getting to 80%. Kind of a secured book. So all told. Where do we, you know, look maybe 2, 3 years out, where do we look for the ROA and ROE to settle once the tax benefits have also run their course.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#96

Okay, that's a fair question. So three years from now, and you're right to bring up funding—admin will compress by 30bps. It'll be 80% secured. What we hadn't factored into our numbers for three years out is that we'll also have a credit guarantee running alongside. We're going to model that in now. But in the earlier model we'd built, where we'd moved to 80% secured with a NIM decline, our ROA would land in the 1.8 to 2% range and ROE between 16 to 17%. That's the steady-state model we'd envisioned playing out. And I should also mention that CASA had reached 30%. So there were three variables: 80% secured, CASA at 30%, a NIM drop of 30bps—and then ROI would be 1.8 to 2. Cost income would come in around 53%, and ROE would be 16 to 17. The one variable I'd like to add now is that I have a credit guarantee program. It carries a cost, but it also gives us upside if something does go wrong. So we'll just put that model in, and when we see you again after the March results, we'll bring it forward to all of you.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#97

I do believe this is something we should tackle as well, though I have to say we've been too tied up working to restore stability and turn around the credit cost. Now that we've got a little more room to breathe, we'll definitely finish that up and let you folks know when we present the March results.

Sarvesh Gupta

analyst
#98

Alright, regarding the CASA cost — you lowered it in October, and my understanding is that above 5 lakh and 10 lakh we offer a fairly decent savings rate. So as we expand, should we expect to be a top-tier player on savings bank interest rates, or do we intend to bring it down? And since you've cut it this time, our CASA has also fallen. So how should we view this whole picture? If you could shed some light on it.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#99

Right. So what we saw was that at the very high end — when you offer, say, 7.8 or another one of those extreme CASA rates — you end up with very large tickets. And basically we took a look and said, look, that doesn't really help us grow a CASA, but is that the sort of CASA we want to build ourselves on? Because once you head down that road, you just get more and more of it. That's very easy to pull off, right? You're essentially paying money and getting good CASA. So we said, fine, at the upper end, let's cap it at some point. It's not that we'll cut our price and turn uncompetitive, but that extreme end we don't want. There are banks — I mean, we don't. We know where a CASA went, which bank actually took it away, and at what price. But we believe that price is too extreme. And our thinking is, look, there's no hard work here. We'll open branches, RMs. If you look at our presentation, there are plenty of segmental offers. We've started.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#100

The traction we've seen for mit has been quite strong. So at a certain point, you know, our view is that CASA pricing needs to stay highly competitive, but there was some competition we had no desire to engage in, and that's the reason we pulled back from it.

Sarvesh Gupta

analyst
#101

Appreciate it, sir. And best of luck to you.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#102

Yes, and look, I've put this slide up once more to illustrate how costs are coming down, since there is a CASA decline across the industry. So people might assume that, well, CASA is falling just as it is elsewhere in the sector, or partly so, and so on. I simply want to be clear on this: our CASA decline is plainly driven by a drop in price. We've brought back a portion of the money that went out. By "recovered," I mean the wholesale money, or wholesale CASA, has left and retail CASA has come in. But honestly, we haven't yet arrived at the stage where the two are matched up. We're going to work hard and move beyond that. Yes, sorry. Abdul Ash has an update on one of the earlier questions. Kamal, you raised that question. We said we'd come back to you once we'd calculated it.

Abhilash Sandur

executive
#103

Regarding credit cost across segments, for 2 and 3 secured — if I take out the accelerated portion, the regulatory piece came to 23 crore unsecured and 56 crores. That represents our credit cost for the Q. So that particular answer has been covered, and that's what I've provided to you.

Operator

operator
#104

Thanks. We’ll take the next question from Chintan Shah at ICIC Securities. Your line is open — please go ahead.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#105

Yeah, thanks for the chance to ask. So first, on the PCR as well — this quarter we ended up with our secured PCR at 48 percentage, up from 29 percentage in the prior quarter. So what would probably be the reason for that? Is there any change in the PD assumptions or the LVD assumptions, or how does it work?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#106

It’s really straightforward. Yeah, look — I don’t have any other option: whatever I make a provision for in unsecured, I’m taking a technical write-off. Right. After that, what remains is the secured book. So if net NPAs are to stay under 1, there’s no route other than raising TCL there. Okay, so it was probably done just to hold net NPA under 1. Yeah, of course. At the start of the year we were at 18%, and some of us asked why not take it to 20 to 30, since that’s where the industry sits. So last time we set it at 28, but now we don’t have that room — we have to take it to 48. My concern is that when we put the next money in this quarter to get net NPA below 1, it could even become 58 or 68. But yeah, that’s the direction it’s headed now.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#107

Sure. And I’m not sure whether I missed this, but did you mention the microfinance slippages for the quarter, which came to roughly 230 crores in the prior quarter?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#108

No, Abhilash has the figure. Just give me a minute.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#109

Sure. And one more figure as well. So I believe, did we mention the collection figures for the last 3 months — any numbers there, or their work — could you please give those? And also, for January, how has the collection trend looked so far, specifically for the unsecured portfolio, and even on the secured side, are we noticing any spikes or any sharp drop in collection efficiency?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#110

The first area is secured lending. I noted a few regions where an uptick is visible, and in my view that has more to do with our own actions than with the industry overall — there we need to strengthen both collection efforts and certain trade parameters. So that's one thing. Nothing is preventing us from growing. We therefore stay on our growth trajectory. Nothing is raising alarm for us — there's simply some work to be done, and we'll fix it. On the unsecured side, I genuinely believe that in January, February and March, somewhere between the 30th and the 31st of each month, we'll be pushing hard to hit 99%. I don't think so. Nothing has been streamlined to the point where we'll get to 99% or 98.5%, which is what we've managed by the 20th or 22nd. I don't believe that kind of stability exists either — certainly not in how customers are responding and how the industry is viewing things. So I expect that hard work to carry on. The only new thing I can see right now is that people feel more confident about it than they did last quarter, which is why my sense is disbursals will accelerate further and the book will level off.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#111

That said, we do consider ourselves extremely focused on microfinance. Even so, the one bright spot for us is that, because of how our book is structured, the damage people might have expected hasn't materialized. And that's exactly what all of you are able to observe in these Q3 results. But yes, there's nothing on secured, which should. Let me be very clear on this point: there's nothing there that, you know, gets rubbed off and funds that. I think it's really just 2 geographies that are challenging.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#112

Yes, of course. Let me answer that. To date, we have already set aside 208 crores in accelerated provisions, and as mentioned, another 60 or 70 crores will likely be taken in Q4. That gives us roughly 300 crores of baggage. So what would cause us to reverse these accelerated provisions in Q4? What could serve as the trigger for reversing that provisioning?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#113

So that will occur over the coming year instead of in Q1 of next year, and it will be driven by — yeah, sorry. And so, you know, to put it very simply, you know, net NPA needs to stay under 1 and net NP needs to stay under 1. When slippages occur, there is basically only one way to provision for them. So I do think that as slippages become more and more normalized, less and less provisioning will be required. And when some of these customers at some point require 100% provisioning, we won't need to set aside any further provision because it has already been provisioned for, and certainly on the unsecured side, whatever this 208 crores goes to unsecured, it won't be that we have fully used it up either — we'll collect the money or we'll use it 100% provisioning. So obviously our need for provisioning will be lower. But it all depends on. So the Q3 provisioning will probably unwind around Q2 Q3 next year. What we provisioned, about I think around 60 crores in Q1, that is probably what will be available in Q1 next year. So that kind of phasing will happen. But important, you know, Chintan is, you know, we did give a set of numbers that one should expect from the bank.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#114

I really believe that when you factor in the actual provision, much of it is already apparent. So when you're projecting numbers, you ought to note that the bank isn't required to set aside an excellent provision. It already holds a corpus and surplus of 300 crores. How would the figures then appear? That makes things very straightforward for you, and so, being quite upfront about it, I placed it on slide number three, stating that assuming no excess provision is made, how would the bank look? That would give a clearer picture of what next year will resemble. It might even be better if there's a reversal on credit cost as well. Just give me until March. No, I—if I made a remark here that wasn't very clear, when I meet with you alongside the March results, I'll provide a clear sense of when that reversal will occur. We can't go on past that point, but you know, the pace of reversal and which quarters it will arrive in? Just give me the chance to do it properly. One thing you should know for certain is that when we complete this year, we're currently at Pat, around 360-odd crores.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#115

There's just one more quarter remaining. Any sensible increment beyond Q3 that you'd care to add is fine. So you know where Pat will land. On top of that, roughly 300 crores of accurate provision will be carried. So a fair estimate for next year can be made right now. That means we won't be holding accurate provision. And beyond that, a portion of this provision will be released. At minimum, if not the whole thing, so a fair guess can be made of why the number — yeah, sorry, well, I said from our side that proper guidance will be given to you when you meet us, sure sir. Sure sir. And such, lastly, on the credit guarantee scheme, so when does recovery come? Any timelines for the recovery? When might we expect that, and what could the quantum be? Any thoughts there? No, so I'm hoping that since then there's been no recovery, because this year just started guaranteeing — now, if they turn NPA, we'll have to request the institution to give us the money into fresh disbursement. I'm hoping I never go back to them for money, but whatever we'll see will probably happen next year if some of these do turn NPA. I think what you will see, Chilton, is that over the next next few quarters we'll keep adding to our CGT, MSC and CGMSU guarantee programs, so that any event risk on unsecured won't disturb us too much. It will of course disturb us a bit, but very marginal, what we have seen this year — I don't want to see it any other year. So it's more of a kind of insurance taken against the portfolio, right.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#116

And given that no external event has occurred yet, we still observed stress within the book, right? That indicates future stress could arise even without an event. And, you know, what we've been telling all our investors is that we want a persistent, consistent book where we're predictable. We got disturbed; now we've taken our medicine, and we want to ensure we don't get disturbed going forward. There's ample business to do. The books are performing well. We're in 180 cities, we've got 24,000 people, and all our products are seeing Covid in their existence. We're very comfortable with the growth and with what we're doing. So the one takeaway I want to leave you with — I thought BC was one opportunity, and to be fair, BC has worked well; the three haven't. But I also want to add, on top of the cgt, mbc, CG and a few, I also must tell you that even with my BC book, I am also guaranteeing that while I'm doing my own book as well — so we're doing the entire unsecured book, both BC and non-BC — so that even for my BCS there's much more safety in the future if something odd happens, which none of us can.

Sarvesh Gupta

analyst
#117

Sure. And one last thing — do you have that MFI slippages figure on hand?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#118

230. That's right. 230. Yes.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#119

So that's the QOQ website flight, correct?

Abhilash Sandur

executive
#120

Yeah. Yeah.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#121

Absolutely, absolutely. Yeah. I believe that covers everything. That's from my side. Yeah. Thanks.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#122

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#123

Thank you. Our following question comes from Ashlee Sonjay of Kotak Securities. The line is yours.

Ashlesh Sonje

analyst
#124

Hello sir, good evening. I have a couple of data-related questions. First, how can—how would you explain the FLDG treatment on the BC book within MFI?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#125

Very straightforward. It moves to NPA: there’s a deposit accessible under the service guarantee program, and we draw on that deposit and apply it. The result is that my net NPA and my trade cost come down. So, two points. Gross NPA rises — that I cannot alter — while net NPA, because I take the money and apply it, stays steady, meaning it stays lower. And my credit cost likewise does not factor that in. During the year, from the various deposits we had available, we pulled out roughly 110 odd crores. That shows up as a provision reversal. Then provision made. No. So no reversion is needed once you go to NPI and apply a deposit. Okay. And second, could you share the SMA book in MFI as of December and September? So, you know, if you look at what’s sitting in the — so I would use this. We haven’t done the SMA breakup, but we did want to give you a sense of what’s going on. That’s what we’ve done on slide number four, where our closing gross NPI is about 756. Right. And if you take slide number — give me a second here.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#126

Okay, so if you turn to slide 20. Right. Slide 20 shows that of the 758 crore, 382 is secured, 225 is unsecured, and 151 is DC. Mostly unsecured. And the DC book carries a PCR of 86 and 98. So no trouble is coming from there. The secured book has roughly a 46% PCR. So that really is a high PCR, mainly to keep net NPA under 1. But LTV is 46. So this shouldn't worry us. So the real question will be what happens then, and what is the need for provisioning in T? The only flesh that comes in is from unsecured. Because I think on secured we can do enough and more feedback on the action we've taken in Q3. So that should be the only number you put in your model.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#127

Alright sir. And finally, could you tell us the microfinance disbursements for this quarter and for the one before it?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#128

Yes, that's something I can do. I have it here, and Abhilash has it ready as well.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#129

And, if you can, also why. Yeah, thanks. That covers everything I wanted to ask. Thank you.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#130

On a year-over-year basis, I can tell you it's negative, roughly 19 or so percent. But I'll give you the exact figure there. And while he's providing those numbers, you listen in. While we were working on CGT, MSC, and CGMSU, one of the risk mitigation measures was also the PC approach. That's why I mentioned the 110-odd crore we've reduced from our credit cost. You know, it's a result of us, you know, giving higher income to the B.C. over all these years. And in a stress moment, we did think they wouldn't have a challenge. But if they did have a challenge, they would have to account for it themselves, which they have done. 1800 is our microfinance disbursement for this quarter, against 1350 last year. 1338 last quarter.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#131

Abhilash, would you mind repeating that? I wasn't able to catch what you said.

Abhilash Sandur

executive
#132

1800 corresponds to Q3. Q2 is 1338. In Q2 we had 1338 and 1899. 1809. 1809. But what did it come in at during Q3 of last year? Q3 of last year? 1970. 1970, my friend.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#133

Regarding those write-offs of 109 crores this quarter — that entire amount would come from MFI, is that right?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#134

Right. So that's exactly why you should use it to work out the reason we didn't. Why we failed to grow despite having done it at M crore.

Chintan Shah

analyst
#135

Understood, sir. All right, thanks.

Operator

operator
#136

Thanks. Our next question comes from Sagar sir at Spark pwm. Please go ahead.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#137

Good evening, sir. Thank you for the chance to speak, and thanks for the congratulations — at least we saw a stable set of numbers given this kind of environment. Actually, I had a couple of questions. My first one relates to the data-keeping question. What were the interest reversals this quarter, especially in the MFI segment?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#138

About 50 crore of interest reversal. That's occurred year to date. Actually, for the quarter it's roughly 18.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#139

The figure for the quarter came to 18 crores. Hi there.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#140

Yeah, sorry about that. Yeah, 18 crores for the quarter.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#141

All right, 18 crores for the quarter. That's for the MFI segment, correct? Okay, got it. Now, the second thing was tied to this — the slippage ratio. You already called out the figure earlier for this quarter. In fact, our slippage ratio is still somewhat elevated, sitting at roughly 6%. So the 230 crores you flagged was mostly driven by the MFI business. Then, for the other — the second half was entirely tied to the secured segment. So could you point out which of the secured segments are actually — where the secured slippage ratio came in comparatively higher?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#142

So, if you look at our gross NP net entry — this is the slide on page 9 — Micro Lab, as I mentioned, has 2, 3 geographies that are giving us a bit of a challenge. We've seen an increase in Micro Lab and slightly in affordable housing. So there are just two points. MSME loans are very stable, and in fact two wheeler has dropped back; Gold loans, anyways, technical. So a bit of Micro Lab which has seen a slippage, and specifically in the three geographies, not the book in general across the country. Okay, so Microlab — and that is completely secured business, right? The Micro Lab business — yes, I specified it earlier. This is entirely surfaceable. Surface applicable property business with a 33% — with an LTV which we have given, as if you can see on page nine, last column is 32.8%, which is 33%. So it's a matter. Okay, but you know we are not seeing anything which is kind of — we know a few geographies we could do a bit better, which we are now just tightening. That's about it.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#143

All right. So at least on that front, there’s no big cause for concern, or there isn’t much significant overlap with mfi. It doesn’t have too much to do with the MFI business.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#144

Let me be very clear about this. Listen, that's exactly why, with 5.8% quarter on quarter, I would have pulled back or slowed the growth if I found that, listen, I'm getting into an area where I'm uncomfortable. We don't have that discomfort, and I want to be extremely easy with this: if you see any sign of trouble, we would be running away from it, and I would have already announced it to you folks — that, listen, here's where I can see a problem coming. I don't see a problem coming. It's one or two jobs. We'll fix it.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#145

All right, thank you. Thank you, sir. And finally, regarding the PCR — the provision coverage ratio for the secured segments. What is that ratio for the secured segments as of this Q3FY25?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#146

Slide 2048.3% unsecured.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#147

Alright. Alright, yes sir.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#148

You get the 758 gross NPA breakdown. It shows that 79% of net NPA is fully secured, so there's really not much damage there. The only thing to worry about is unsecured slippage in Q4. That's the only piece that could hit a trade cost. If you subtract your recovery, then I think we're in good shape regardless. And we hold a large amount of PCR. But as I said earlier to Chintan, most of this PCR unwinding will take place next year.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#149

And just to follow up briefly on your last remark: you said we’ve hit the bottom where the microfinance business is concerned. So is it fair to expect, by Q4, a sequential rise in disbursements within that specific MFI segment?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#150

100%. Since Q4 is always a strong quarter regardless. You're aware of that, correct? Exactly. That isn't the thing that concerns us. Can I grow sufficiently? Then my book will turn into — become like having no — has no negative growth, or it becomes positive. That's the biggest demand I place on myself. And Sudhir operates a business sitting directly in front of me. You know our work is there. But listen, here is the classic fee issue. If you source group loans, your rejection rate sits at 70 to 80% now, batches. So we don't want to grow and wind up with problems as well. So we are extremely strict about what we're doing. So for instance, my existing customer — if he isn't in a metro city and carries more than 50,000 rupees outstanding balance with any MFI, I am not giving him money. Okay, I say that. I'm only telling you that listen, I can grow much faster. But I don't want to grow when I'm not certain that this is going to turn out right. Credit. So I'm saying this again. Non metro city, more than 50,000 offers exposure. Good customer of Jannah. He will not get a repeat loan. Because we are not ready now, till the industry is pretty much sorted out, which I don't think so we are sorted out right now.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#151

We’ve therefore set strict requirements, and we’ll keep them in place. If growth becomes a bit more of a challenge, I’d prefer to accept that. But I don’t want to build things up until we have real clarity about what’s happening on the front end. And that holds even though a credit guarantee is available. Because in my view, credit guarantees are meant for event risk, not for taking on more risk and saying, fine, whatever extra comes along will be covered. That isn’t how we’re inclined.

Sagar Shah

analyst
#152

All right, many thanks. Really appreciate it, and best wishes for the coming quarter.

Operator

operator
#153

Thanks. Our next question comes from Anand Kundra at My Temple Capital. The line is yours — go ahead.

Anant Mundra

analyst
#154

Good evening, and thanks for taking my question. We're currently running a somewhat elevated LCR, so I just wanted to get a sense of why we're holding more liquidity than usual and when we should expect that to come back to normal levels. I'd imagine this also has some bearing on our NIMs as well — perhaps there could be a bit of an uptick in NIMs. Is that understanding correct?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#155

You're 100% right about that. Our LCR is extremely high—very, very high. We did attempt to lower it. Q2 saw some progress, then Q3 put us back. What we typically do now with bulk deposits is ask every bulk depositor for maybe 5 or 10 bits extra, but structure it as non-volatile, you know? Somehow our sales force is quite comfortable with that approach, and it gives us strength in whatever bulk we take here. We've launched a few products that would include our retail deposit and cut bulk overall. When that happens, LCR will come down too. The way we think about it is, bulk has a reason it's called bulk. So the best thing when you take bulk is to make it non-callable. Once it's non-callable, then you can sleep easy. And we've also given the breakup of how much is one year plus—roughly about 70% of all bulk deposits are more than one year as well. But we are conscious of that. We do know we'll save some money if we get it right, and we'll attempt to do that in waterfall.

Anant Mundra

analyst
#156

Understood, sir. So, what’s the situation? Relative to our peers, we’ve handled this MFI cycle quite effectively. Yet in terms of reaching your long-term guidance — you know, achieving a steady-state ROA of 1.8 to 2% — what’s the real next challenge you see? Is it the mobilization of CASA, where you need to reach 30%? Or is it that there’s been some increase in NP on the secured side? So does that also concern you? Given that this cycle is behind us and you’re past the peak, what is it that’s really troubling you right now?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#157

Now, when it comes to affordable housing, micro lab, and MSME — honestly, on MSME we're performing well. We're gradually seeing sales invoices used for purchase invoice discounting. Our emphasis is on establishing credit frameworks and early-warning mechanisms around that. So that's rule number one, I'd say. On micro lab and affordable housing, we're simply in 180 cities, concentrating on running operations smoothly. As I said earlier, we have 3,000 people. So it's always like this — you must keep your hand on the machine at all times. You can't presume everything is fine. So I think simply ensuring solid execution is all that's needed. It doesn't concern me. And you should — we're among the companies that run a microfinance business. We have a micro lab. We can access the credit bureau. We understand where the overlaps are, who's doing what, not only with us. I know my microfinance customer has taken a microlab from someone else. How they're behaving. You've taken from me, how they're behaving. That isn't our real concern. What I'd truly want is to first get the cost syndrome back, since that has been our strength.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#158

And right now we've run into a bit of a hiccup, so I'll turn to cost income. Right. That improvement will come from unsecured, returning to its 10,000 levels. And if that happens more slowly, then I think you have to push harder on the secured side so that cost income gets better. So I think that's one of my focus areas. Product diversification within MSME is our second area — doing product diversion, product diversification in MSME. I don't think so. We'll take our eye off the ball on collections, whether MFI or non-MFI, because I think that is core in this environment. I think that won't change. On CASA we have segmental offers, and we've even shown those segmental offers in one of the slides. We're just making sure that we really focus on retail growth here. I think there is a bit of hard work, but we'll continue doing that and we expect that to continue. So those would be our real top areas. CASA growth, MSME into sales, invoice, purchase invoice, making sure that we keep our hand on execution, and secure MFI collection doesn't get easy ever. And finally is making sure that we get cost income back on track, because that is something where we think cost is a certainty.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#159

Revenue is what we're hoping for. So costs have to come down. Right.

Anant Mundra

analyst
#160

Understood, understood. Thanks for that thorough response. Just one last thing. Would you mind giving a quick rundown of the economics behind CGT MSC and CGFMU?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#161

Right. So the CGMFU cost comes to 1% of the disbursed amount for one year. After that, it pays on whatever balance is outstanding. Then there's the first 3% of the gross NPA. So let's say 100 rupees, and you guarantee 5 rupees goes into NPA. 3% of 5 rupees, which works out to over 15 paisa, is your cost. Beyond that, 75% of the balance amount gets paid by the CGMFU. They could revise your cost of guarantee depending on your delinquencies, whatever it is. So that's the economics, I think — past a certain point, very early, around 1 to 1.5%, you're fine, and you start getting some money back. On CGT MSC, it's 0.3% of the cost. It applies only to micro enterprise. So you need to provide registration. It has to be a small business, and you get money back once it goes into. The only thing is, I think the current condition they've applied is that you get money back equal to 2x of the premium you pay for that year. So unless you have a genuinely bad year, most of your money on the CBD MSC book will come back. And that would be our bias.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#162

And it isn't based on a poll. It's based on every individual loan that you originated. Right, right. So there's a set format where you fill in all the information, you enter the Aadhaar number, you enter the number, you provide all the particulars, everything must line up, and once that's finished, you upload it into the system, the system accepts it, after that you pay the guarantee fee, and then it becomes guaranteed. So it's a highly formalized and highly automated process, and there are sufficient checks and balances in place to ensure that, you know, these things are done correctly. And you know, I think it's very well organized by the National Gynet Corporation.

Anant Mundra

analyst
#163

Thanks. That’s all I have to say.

Operator

operator
#164

Thanks. Thanks. Because we're short on time, this will be the final question. It comes from Vikram Subramaniam at Marshall Vase. Go ahead, please.

Vikram Subramanian

analyst
#165

Hello, and thank you for the question. It's good to see the ongoing stress environment being handled quite well, and I'm also pleased to note that credit quality peak stresses are behind us. But I have a couple of questions, really following up on what a few other participants asked earlier. Could you give us a sense of how the SMA has moved between September and December, and how collection efficiencies have moved over the past four months? This is mainly to get a gauge of the on-ground realities, because even though you're calling out that peak stress is behind us, slippages still seem to be flat quarter on quarter, and you also note that the overall environment remains challenging. So just to get a sense of, more like, forward flows — if we can get an idea of the SMAs or the collection efficiency, that would give us a better picture.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#166

First, collection efficiency for unsecured was 99 — sorry, 98.6, 98.5, holding steady through October, November, and December. Our effort to reach 99 didn't really succeed, and something or other keeps pushing it back. That's why I keep saying microfinance will remain our focus, because we want to see 99 plus. So that's rule number one. I also mentioned that in microfinance, Vikram, we'd normally hit 99 around the 22nd. 20. Right now we're struggling to get there by the 30th, 31st. I don't expect much change on that front. So my guess is we'll be somewhat more relaxed in Q1 of next year rather than in Q4 of this year. So the hard work will carry on. We're prepared for it. We've placed the collectors. We ought to get there. Our SMA came down in Q3 compared with Q2. You want to add something. So I don't foresee a problem. Recoveries are also considerably better in Q3 versus Q2 and Q1. That means we're gaining better traction than before. It also means the collection source is far more settled now, because once you begin hiring people, by the time they grasp the system and start, you know, reaching out to customers, figuring out where they live, we have to have a backlog for everybody.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#167

We therefore know precisely where to locate our customers. Settlement takes some time. I believe that settling period has ended. That’s why I described the work as behind us, and I said so at the last quarter’s quarterly meeting. Look at the shape of the book here, and as I keep saying, take the secured book. Also, if my book weren’t property backed, I’d have a different version. I would have said, let’s say my book were vehicle finance. Its future would be another one. In mfi, similarly, if I had more group loans, I’d probably have needed another quarter. My feeling is that the group loan isn’t so settled. That’s what I think, from whatever I gathered from our MFI business. Fortunately, Q3 turned out right. As I said, the only thing I was hoping for but couldn’t achieve in Q3 was to really stabilize my unsecured group where it stood at the end of September. I thought we’d make it happen, but somehow our field force hadn’t got the confidence to do more disbursements. So we continue working on that, and once I get.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#168

After we get that right, I think the majority of the issues are pretty much settled. I realize this is somewhat lengthy, but I do go through it with Vikram. It gives you a solid sense of what to expect in Q4 and next year.

Vikram Subramanian

analyst
#169

That's really useful, thank you. Appreciate the thorough walkthrough. To build on that and make sure I've got it straight: our book mix, the recovery work we've done, and the potential those give us are what let us say with confidence that the peak in credit quality is behind us. It has more to do with the way we've been handling things and how our book has developed. Would I be right in assuming that?

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#170

Yes, certainly. That peak isn’t just a hope—it’s real. If you look at actual credit cost, which is what we’ve provided on slide number four, it’s lower in Q3 when you check slide number four, even with a higher accelerated provision assumed; my total credit came to 174 crores. That’s below the 210 crores from last quarter, and it’s exactly 196 going up to 210, then down to 174. The 174 includes 93 of excellent provision, which is above the 61 from last quarter. You should see that on slide number four. So I want to give you not only how I feel, but these are real numbers that show you this. Look, behind us now, if my net NP is 0.91, suppose I had admitted 0.95—you know, that was the path we chose—then yes, PBT would be higher, or PAT would have been higher than another 1520 crores. 1520 crores. You can always, you know, when things are more exuberant, we can show them right now. Let’s be more conservative.

Vikram Subramanian

analyst
#171

Understood? Understood. That's quite clear. Many thanks for walking through it so thoroughly. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#172

Appreciate it, everyone. That wraps up the questions for today's conference call. At this point, I'll turn things back to management for some closing remarks.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#173

Thank you. Listen, as we wrap up, I just want everyone to recognize that leaning toward secured lending and keeping our attention there has served us very well. And it strengthens even more our belief that reaching 80% secured is where we should be. Second, we have concentrated on ensuring MFI isn't treated purely as an operational risk business — it carries credit risk and ought to be handled that way, and that is really where individual loans first came from. I think we also hold it clearly in our minds that this was the correct choice, and we will stay on that course. So that, I believe, won't shift. Third, I think we are deeply dedicated to ensuring we produce a robust cost income, and we are putting in heavy effort toward it, since we genuinely believe that certainty which used to be our strength is still our strength. Last, I have to say we made a tough decision on pricing in casa, because I did feel that as growth continued, there would come a moment when this call had to be made. So sooner is better than later. I know our branch team, under Shrini's leadership, is committed to ensuring CASA gets onto its right path, and we are putting investment behind it.

Ajay Kanwal

executive
#174

We're highly confident that Q4 will deliver a significantly improved CASA figure compared with Q3. Beyond that, we'd definitely like to submit a universal bank application in May. The benefit this brings us — for our employees, our customers, our deposit rates, and our deposit velocity — will be tremendous. So we'd certainly want to hold Net NPA under 1%, gross NPA under 3, and present a strong case to the regulators that we're suitable to receive the license. We'll share more with you folks when the March results come out, and thank you for your support and belief during this tough environment.

Operator

operator
#175

Speaking for Investec Capital Services India Private Limited — that brings this conference to a close. Thanks for being with us. You can go ahead and disconnect your lines now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Jana Small Finance Bank Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Jana Small Finance Bank Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Jana Small Finance Bank Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.