Mercantile Bank Corporation (MBWM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 21, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Mike Houston
executiveThanks, Grant. Hello, everybody, and I appreciate you being on Mercantile Bank Corporation's conference call and webcast this morning as we go over the company's financial results for the fourth — for the first quarter 2020. This is Mike Houston at Lambert IR, Mercantile's Investor Relations firm. With me today are members of their management team, and that includes Bob Kaminski, President and Chief Executive Officer; Chuck Christmas, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; and Ray Reitsma, President of Mercantile Bank Michigan. Management's prepared remarks and presentation reviewing the quarter's results will start us off, and after that we'll open the call up to questions. Before we get started today, though, it is my responsibility to let you know that certain forward-looking statements may be involved in this call, such as projections of revenue, earnings and capital structure, along with statements on the plans and objectives of the company's business. Because of the factors described in the company's latest Securities and Exchange Commission filings, the company's actual results could differ materially from any forward-looking statements made today. No obligation is assumed by the company to update any forward-looking statements made during the call. If a copy of the first quarter 2020 press release and presentation deck issued by Mercantile today isn't already in anyone's hands, it can be accessed at the company's website, www.mercbank.com. Now I'd like to turn the call over to Mercantile's President and Chief Executive Officer, Bob Kaminski. Bob?
Bob Kaminski
executiveThanks, Mike, and good morning to all of you. When we wrapped up our January call and said we looked forward to talking with you again in April, not one of us could have pictured the extent to which the world would transform within only a handful of months. This morning, as we normally do, we'll walk through how we performed during the first quarter, but beyond that, we're going to devote considerable time in our remarks to the matters we think you'll care about given the COVID-19 pandemic. Clearly, COVID-19 has brought about a global crisis that threatens lives. Once February came to a close, it grew increasingly clear that this virus was spreading quickly across the United States, and we needed to act. Above all else, Mercantile moved swiftly to protect the health and safety of both our employees and our customers, and Slide 3 of the presentation lays out our thorough response. As worries about the pandemic mounted in the U.S. and Michigan, Mercantile began limiting in-person interaction with customers on March 18, which ultimately brought us to shutting our lobbies completely — closing our lobbies alongside Governor Whitmer's stay-at-home order on March 25. Customers can still take care of their banking needs through our drive-thru locations, video banking machines and electronic banking. Since this crisis began, for instance, our daily retail online banking logins have nearly doubled. Turning to our staff, as Slide 3 mentions, since March 23, on any given day, typically more than 75% of all employees are working remotely from home. Slide 4 shows some of the kind words our customers have shared. As we've noted in recent years, Mercantile has labored without pause since the Great Recession ended to put itself in a position of strength. The aim is to take advantage of a healthy economy while also giving our company strong financial metrics that let us succeed when economic times get weaker. Though the pandemic definitely brings new hurdles for everyone in financial services, our foundation is still extremely solid as we partner with our clients to help them get through the storm this crisis has caused. On this call, we'll give you details on our loan portfolio, including metrics on certain areas of focus as we navigate the issues our industry faces. We'll cover our historical credit quality leading into the crisis, loan concentrations, including a breakdown by loan type along with nonowner-occupied real estate versus owner-occupied real estate and our C&I portfolio by industry classification; we'll also go over activity with our clients related to our payment relief program for existing loans during the pandemic. We'll also discuss our work to get funds to our clients through the SBA with the payment — Paycheck Protection Plan. We are going to go over the important measurements for us, which include our liquidity and capital standing, plus what Mercantile is doing about the fresh regulations permitting a delay in implementing CECL. We will go through how our noninterest — our net interest margin has been affected by what the FOMC did when the crisis first hit in order to stimulate the economy. Because rates have been lowered, our mortgage banking operation has managed to produce unprecedented pipeline volumes made up mostly of refinances. Right now, the stay-at-home order makes new purchase activity very difficult, though real estate agents and buyers are attempting to find creative ways to keep real estate moving while still following the executive orders. Sadly, Michigan has become a hotspot for COVID cases. Southeast Michigan, which includes the City of Detroit, is a big metropolitan region that has been struck extremely hard, with confirmed cases and deaths rising sharply in early April. In the parts of the state where Mercantile keeps — holds the great majority of its market footprint, such as Kent County and West Michigan, as well as the central region, critical statistics have gone up, but at levels that let health care systems keep up with the spread. Social distancing, together with the state mandate, has led citizens to stay home except for those employed in essential critical industries. Numerous local businesses have turned to federal stimulus relief to help continue paying their employees while the state waits for virus cases to decline so the economy can reopen safely. Prior to this crisis, Michigan's economy was broadly stable all through 2019. Certain manufacturing sectors had a down year, yet unemployment was low, real estate prices kept rising, and the tourism industry kept showing strength. It is surely everyone's wish that as infections from the virus decline and plans for removing restrictions on movement in our communities are carried out, the economy's driving force, which is the consumer, comes back with plenty of energy to jump start businesses that have been put into hibernation. We will keep watching the situations closely and be ready to take further steps if those needs come up. As always, we remain confident in our positioning, which continues to strongly serve our customers as we navigate through and eventually out of this ever-changing environment. Those are my opening remarks. I'll now turn it over to Ray.
Ray Reitsma
executiveAppreciate that, Bob. During 2020's first quarter, our loan portfolio grew by $45 million, and every one of our markets added to that expansion. Our pipeline is also holding up well, with $77 million in commitments for commercial construction and development loans; assuming some degree of normal construction activity returns within that window, we anticipate funding those over the coming 12 to 18 months. Asset quality is still solid: nonperforming assets came to $3.7 million, equal to 1/10 of 1% of total assets, as of March 31. In the fourth quarter we booked $6.5 million of noninterest income, which was $1.8 million, or 38%, above the first quarter a year earlier, once you exclude $1.9 million of nonrecurring items tied to that quarter. Higher mortgage banking income largely powered this better noninterest income figure, mirroring the payoff from strategic efforts already underway to grow market share plus a pickup in refinance activity brought on by the recent drop in rates. Growing mortgage banking income further by capturing additional market share — including more of the purchase market — stays a priority. And whenever we can, we'll keep bringing on proven mortgage loan originators. We also saw further gains this quarter across other fee income lines, such as credit and debit card income, service charges on accounts, and payroll processing fees. Credit and debit card income has moved lower since stay-at-home orders took effect in March, and those orders are set to stay in place until April 30. Staying disciplined on overhead costs while we concentrate on efficient delivery systems across every line of business also remains a priority. The arrival of the COVID-19 virus gave us a chance to show what community banking is worth, pairing high-touch service with robust capabilities. As Bob noted, our electronic banking capability let us shut our lobbies on March 25 and helped make it possible for 3/4 of our employees to work from home starting that day. While plenty of banks struggled with the SBA Paycheck Protection Program, Mercantile funded more than 1,500 applications — over $500 million in loans — which sustained thousands of workers in our communities and helped preserve asset quality as this crisis unfolds. Our communities have consistently given us supportive feedback, commending how committed we were to professionalism throughout the process. As Bob mentioned, Slide 4 of the presentation shows some of that kind feedback from our customers. Beyond the federally funded SBA programs, and as Slide 5 shows, Mercantile set up payment deferral programs, offering interest-only options and full payment deferral options to entities hit directly by the COVID-19 crisis. Moving to Slide 6, although consumer lending makes up only a small slice of our portfolio at roughly $30 million, our customer service team has logged more than 500 hardship inquiries, and in fewer than 50 cases have customers asked us to put them in place. As of March 31, the past due list we show on Slide 7 has kept the same proportions that existed before the crisis, and that also holds true so far in April. Looking at the next slides, the risk rating process captures a portfolio with strong characteristics, which speaks to how solid the economy was before the crisis. Keeping risk ratings accurate is going to stay a major priority over the coming quarters. We'll be watching closely the financial condition and performance of credits in these segments: automotive dealerships, hotels and lodging, assisted living, restaurants, construction, movie theaters and retail. Not one of those segments makes up more than 5% of commercial loans. Moving to Slide 11, we'll walk through some specifics of the recent programs put in place by the CARES Act and the Federal Reserve. Through the Paycheck Protection program, eligible small businesses can get forgivable loans so they can keep people employed through this pandemic. These loans have a 1% interest rate, with payments deferred for the first 6 months and then paid monthly over the following 18 months. Borrowers may have the loans forgiven if they use the funds for payroll, rent and utilities in the specified proportions. The SBA also pays an origination fee ranging from 1% to 5%, which is disbursed within 5 days of closing. Over the life of the loan, that deferred income adds to interest income, and accretion speeds up if the loan gets paid off or forgiven. All of this produced an effective yield enhancement of 2.5%. To fund these loans, the Federal Reserve offers term advances, which are shown on Slide 12. With these advances, we can borrow dollar-for-dollar against the PPP loans at a fixed rate of 35 basis points. Those advances must be repaid as forgiveness occurs, and payments come in either from the SBA or from the borrower repaying over the 24-month term; that wraps up what I wanted to cover. I'll hand the call over to Chuck now.
Chuck Christmas
executiveThanks, Ray, and good morning, everyone. I'll begin on Slide 13. Earlier today, we reported net income of $10.7 million, or $0.65 per diluted share, for the first quarter of 2020, versus net income of $11.8 million, or $0.72 per diluted share, for the first quarter of 2019. In the prior year period, net income was boosted by $1.8 million, or $0.11 per diluted share, from a bank-owned life insurance claim payout and a gain recorded on selling a former branch facility. If you set aside those transactions, diluted earnings per share rose $0.04, or roughly 7%, in this year's first quarter relative to the first quarter a year earlier. Turning to Slide 14. Interest income on loans fell as a result of FOMC rate reductions totaling 225 basis points since the start of the third quarter of 2019, with 150 basis points of that easing taking place in the first quarter of 2020. Interest income on securities got a lift from $1.8 million of accelerated discount accretion tied to called U.S. government agency bonds in the first quarter of 2020. All told, interest income dropped $0.7 million in the first quarter of 2020 versus the first quarter of 2019, or dropped $2.5 million once the accelerated discount accretion is factored out. Interest expense came down across every category in the first quarter of 2020 relative to the first quarter of 2019, mirroring the lower interest rate environment. Net interest income decreased $0.3 million in the first quarter of 2020 compared with the first quarter of 2019, or $2.1 million excluding the accelerated discount accretion. Provision expense came to $750,000 in the first quarter of 2020, roughly in line with the $850,000 we recorded in the first quarter of 2019; we chose to delay CECL adoption as the CARES Act allows. As you're aware, an economic forecast is a critical piece of the CECL methodology; we're heading into an economic environment unlike anything we've seen, in which a large share of the economy has been hit hard by shelter-in-place orders and similar responses from businesses and individuals. Considerable government stimulus has been directed to businesses, individuals, and state and local governments. Financial institutions have extended payment relief options to businesses and individuals. Economic forecasts get revised frequently, and no consensus economic forecast exists. Because uncertainty around economic forecasting is so elevated, we've decided to keep using our incurred loan loss reserve model for now, refreshing loss migration calculations and adjusting the 9 environmental factors as needed at the close of each quarter. Provision expense for the first quarter of 2020 mirrors a mix of loan growth, a change in economic environment allocation, and a decrease in specific allocations on certainly — uncertain fully collected lending relationships. Moving on to Slide 15. Total fee income in the first quarter of 2020 was comparable to fee income reported in the first quarter of 2019. But if you take out that BOLI claim we mentioned and the gain from selling the old branch building, fee income for Q1 still rose $1.8 million, which is 38%. Mortgage banking income grew roughly 150%, which shows more refinancing happened later in the quarter and that several strategic initiatives worked well, among them the fact that we kept bringing on more mortgage lenders. Service charge income also grew 13%, mostly because treasury management income was higher, and payroll processing income grew 14% thanks to a bigger client base. Turning to Page 16, overhead costs were up $1.1 million in the first quarter of 2020 versus the first quarter of 2019. Salary and benefit costs rose $0.5 million, which came from merit raises and bigger commissions for mortgage lenders. Occupancy, furniture and equipment costs together rose $0.4 million, mostly because our main office expansion was finished in the fall of 2019. Slide 17 shows our net interest margin at 3.63% in the first quarter of 2020, the same as the fourth quarter of 2019, and 25 basis points lower than the first quarter of 2019. The accelerated discount accretion on called U.S. government agency bonds that I mentioned earlier gave a 22 basis point boost to our yield on earning assets and to net interest margin in this year's first quarter. Yield on loans fell 32 basis points in the first quarter of 2020 versus the fourth quarter of 2019, and it fell 52 basis points versus the first quarter of 2019, largely because of the FOMC's total 225 basis point cut to the targeted federal funds rate that I referred to before. Cost of funds has likewise been trending down, mainly because of the lower interest rate environment, though in size and scale it hasn't fallen as much as our yield on loans has. If we set aside the effects of the PPP loan and PPPLF programs, we expect a lower net interest margin in the second quarter of 2020, since we'll feel a full quarter of the FOMC's total 150 basis point rate cut from early March, and then a fairly steady net interest margin for the rest of 2020; on Slide 18, our mortgage loan originations came to nearly $133 million in the first quarter of 2020, which is an $88 million, or 195%, rise versus the first quarter of 2019. Roughly 65% of mortgage volume in the first quarter of 2020 was refinance applications, versus just 33% in the first quarter of last year. Around 72% of mortgage loan originations in the first quarter of 2020 have been sold, or will be sold, on the secondary market, and that's up about 48% from a year ago. The net gain from selling mortgage loans came in lower in this year's first quarter compared with our activity level, which reflects a onetime impact from our choice to sell closed loans nearer to the commitment expiration date instead of shortly after the mortgage loan's closing date. Higher refinance activity did lead to increased amortization of mortgage servicing rights. Even so, since we apply a lower of cost or market methodology, we recorded no valuation write-down. As of March 31, the estimated value of our mortgage servicing rights stays well above carrying value. Turning to Slide 19; we continue to be strongly and well capitalized — we continue to hold a strong, well-capitalized regulatory capital position. As of March 31, 2020, the bank's Tier 1 leverage capital ratio stood at 11.3%, while the total risk-based capital ratio was 12.9%. That total risk-based capital ratio exceeded by over $94 million the minimum thresholds for being categorized as well capitalized. Share repurchases in the first quarter of 2020 came to roughly 222,000 shares, costing $6.3 million in total, or an average price of $28.25 per share; in late March, we chose to suspend repurchase activity because of uncertainty surrounding the COVID-19 environment; roughly $10 million is currently available under our existing repurchase plan. Moving to Slide 20 for some asset quality figures. The loan portfolio's overall quality stays very strong, with nonperforming loans and loan charge-offs continuing at low levels.
Chuck Christmas
executiveAt quarter's close, nonperforming loans measured just 12 basis points as a share of average loans. Other real estate owned carried a balance under $300,000 when the quarter ended. During 2020's first quarter, gross loan charge-offs came in below $100,000, whereas recoveries on charge-offs from prior periods exceeded $200,000. That produced a net loan recovery of roughly $200,000, which worked out to 3 basis points of average total loans on an annualized basis. Turning to Slide 21, nonperforming asset additions reached $1.3 million in 2020's first quarter, mostly driven by purchased and peered residential mortgage loans. Because of materiality considerations, loan purchase accounting was largely ended as of January 1, 2020. As a result, these particular stressed residential mortgage loans are now classified as originated. Now on Slide 22. Given how much uncertainty exists right now, we won't give earnings performance guidance the way we did on earlier conference calls. Still, we can share key considerations that belong in any forecast of our company's earnings, including for net interest income, the 30-day LIBOR rate; 50% of floating rate commercial loans, or 25% of total commercial loans, are tied to this index. We've repriced 30-day LIBOR loans — based loans on the first business day of each month equal to the closing rate of the previous month end and then hold that rate constant for the entire month. While historically, the 30-day LIBOR rate has approximated the targeted federal funds rate, a credit risk premium has resulted in an elevated 30-day LIBOR rate. The 30-day LIBOR rate was 99 basis points at March 31, 2020 compared to a federal funds rate of 25 basis points. Interest income of commercial loans will be impacted to the degree the 30-day LIBOR rate fluctuates in future periods. PPP loan and PPPLF volume. PPP loan fundings are in excess of $500 million. SBA loan origination fees totaled in excess of $14 million. Direct loan origination costs aggregate about $1 million. It is likely that PPPLF program will be used to fund a majority of the result in deposit outflows over the next 6 to 10 weeks. Net deferred SBA loan origination fees and direct loan origination costs will be accreted into interest income on loans over the life of the loans on a level yield method. PPP loans are underwritten for a 24-month period. The degree to which PPP loans are forgiven and the loans are effectively paid off by the SBA, net deferred loan fee accretion will be accelerated. Accelerated discount accretion on callable U.S. government agency bonds totaled $1.8 million during the first quarter of 2020. Unaccreted discount aggregated $1.5 million as of March 31. The degree to which discounted agency bonds are called, discount accretion will be accelerated; and finally, in asset quality and margin. The degree to which an increase in nonaccrual loans is experienced, loan interest income may be negatively impacted. When it comes to provision expense, net loan growth calls for a certain amount of reserve building through that expense. The extent to which loans get downgraded under our loan grading paradigm, building reserves through provision expense might be needed. The extent to which loans turn impaired from being put into nonaccrual or TDR status, building reserves through provision expense might be needed. At the close of every quarter, the 9 qualitative environmental reserve allocation factors get a formal review. Any adjustments could affect the required reserve calculation, which could affect — which will affect the provision expense. Turning to fee income, the shelter-at-home declarations in Michigan have substantially affected the home purchase market. How far changes in COVID-19 measures get made by Michigan's Governor is hard to foresee for our mortgage banking operations. The shelter-at-home declarations in Michigan have likewise substantially affected debit and credit card interchange fees, since card uses fell. How far changes in COVID-19 measures get made by the Michigan's Governor is hard to foresee for our debit and credit card operations. And finally, on overhead costs, the shelter-at-home declarations in Michigan have substantially affected various overhead costs, including employee meal and mileage reimbursements, plus foreign ATM fee reimbursements. How far changes in COVID-19 measures get made by Michigan's Governor is hard to foresee for various overhead costs. Any rise in problem loan relationships could bring about a rise in collection costs. To close, though many uncertainties could affect Mercantile's financial condition and earnings performance in future periods, we note that we entered the stressed environment with strong asset quality and capital position. That concludes my prepared remarks. I'll now hand the call back over to Bob.
Bob Kaminski
executiveAppreciate that, Chuck, and thanks as well, Ray. That brings management's prepared comments to a close. At this point, we'd like to turn things over for the question-and-answer portion.
Brendan Nosal
analystTo begin, I want to express gratitude for how much detail you provided in the slide deck. That was certainly quite useful. Turning to my questions, I'll start with the reserve level. I understand that NPVs have been quite steady. Charge-offs came in very mild, and you mentioned pushing back CECL implementation; but even with that, when I look at unemployment claims filed in Michigan, that state appears to be among those suffering most; so please help me reconcile the fairly flat reserve amount against the pressure the Michigan economy is experiencing at present.
Chuck Christmas
executiveYes. Brendan, like we said, as everyone is aware, a reserve calculation involves a great many variables. And naturally at this point we have both the incurred model and the CECL model. And as I stated in my prepared remarks, we determined it was best to simply try to manage this process, and because there is enormous uncertainty surrounding economic forecasting, which all of us recognize has a major effect on the calculations under CECL, we decided it was very fitting to keep using the incurred model. I believe it has worked well for us since we implemented it back in 1997. And yes, it is an incurred model, and it certainly begins with migration. But as everyone else who uses this model does, we have those 9 reserve environmental allocation factors that we will absolutely take into account, and we did take them into account at the end of March, and we made certain adjustments; so clearly we will be depending quite heavily on those. And then honestly, we need to observe how this is unfolding — how this environment will affect our borrowers over the coming — particularly across the next couple of quarters. And indeed, Michigan has certainly been struck hard; Bob already pointed that out. But we also observe that when you consider Michigan's primary footprint, those regions have not been struck as severely, with the majority of cases concentrated in Southeast Michigan. So there is a bit of a divide there; but clearly, it does impact the economy across the whole state. One of the fascinating aspects of CECL is that at adoption, our day 1 calculation actually revealed a decrease in our reserve of $700,000. So by choosing not to adopt CECL, at least initially under a day 1 calculation, we in fact raised our reserve, if you will, by $700,000; so moving forward, we're going to — we recognize that there's — that we are entering and currently find ourselves in a highly stressed environment. And as I said in my comments, we will absolutely be working alongside our borrowers, comprehending the effect this is having on them and certainly making any downgrades that are needed. Management is going to keep monitoring the environmental factors and make adjustments to them when circumstances tied to those allocation factors shift; the economic factor has already been brought down to the worst level our present rating framework allows. Then, one final point: the source of that $700,000 cut to the reserve, as we observed, is that commercial loans make up roughly 85% of our loan portfolio. Because of that, our exposure to the consumer retail segment is fairly small, and whatever exposure exists is mostly mortgage lending. CECL is a duration-based model, as you know. Given our commercial lending footprint, the average duration comes in at just a bit more than 2 years. On its own, that fact pushes the reserve to a lower level. So although I say the $700,000 reduction would have been recorded on day 1, it is in fact a net reduction. If you dig into the calculations, the reserve allocations tied to commercial loans would have dropped by a far larger amount, yet we did see a rise coming out of our mortgage loan allocation calculations, and that produced the $700,000 figure. Honestly, to this management team, that doesn't make much sense. Sadly, it's simply how the rules of CECL work, since we are unable to assume renewals on commercial loans. We enjoy strong relationships with a great many of our commercial borrowers, and we anticipate keeping them across many future periods, regardless of any maturities they might have arriving in the coming few quarters or a couple of years. Then, finally, I believe what truly pushed us away from adopting CECL was the economic forecast piece. The third party we intend to lean on mainly for our CECL modeling was revising its forecast quite often, and some extremely dramatic shifts were occurring. So merely deciding which forecast to use came under question. Another control we maintain while constructing our CECL model was that, even as we chose one third-party provider, we wanted certainty that this provider fell inside the range of the consensus that existed, since, as we all know, plenty of people out there supply economic forecasts. We know for a fact that no consensus exists at all. Thus one of those key controls built into our own model, that is, ensuring the economic forecasts we rely on sit within or extremely near consensus. It isn't because no consensus exists; so we felt very troubled about having to begin using a brand-new model that we think contains some serious shortfalls in the middle of a very dire crisis we find ourselves in. So that's a long-winded response to your question, but I want to be sure everyone grasps why we made that choice. We clearly didn't do it to bring our provisioning costs down. We're aware that the banks reporting thus far have shown very substantial rises in provision expense. That's okay. We also realize that a lot of those banks have extremely big consumer loan and retail loan exposures, and we observed — at least in our own models — what sort of effect that might have on the calculations. And once more, as a commercial bank with this rating paradigm we've always used, plus the 9 environmental factors, those are what we'll keep depending on; and should we notice meaningful stress in our portfolio, or in specific credit I should say, we'll downgrade them appropriately, and we'll run our reserve calculations; but it's extremely, extremely hard to grasp precisely what the effect on asset quality will be going forward, simply because of how much stimulus has been introduced. More than 1,500 of our clients, and others still waiting, are set to receive PPP loans, which clearly gives them as much as 2 months of cash flow for some of their largest expenses. We're additionally giving our mortgage borrowers payment options meant to safeguard their cash flows; and for other commercial borrowers too, we're providing payment deferral options. So we observe considerable stress across our whole economy through our marketplaces, yet we also observe an enormous amount of stress or stimulus and various other programs that will reduce how much that stress affects our borrowers, our consumers, and our commercial borrowers. So the key question becomes: what will the duration of the impact be? Our Governor has taken very aggressive measures, reflecting the major impact it's had, particularly in Southeast Michigan. Nobody disputes that those steps needed to be taken. But how much we begin to see them lifted, if at all, across the coming months, will have, by far, the largest effect on our asset quality. And throughout that period, we'll keep measuring our portfolio, measuring the quality of our loan portfolio, and making provision expense entries as required.
Brendan Nosal
analystI definitely get how challenging it is to implement CECL, particularly given how unprecedented things are right now. To build on what was just said, if we were still using the incurred loss approach and looking at credit migration, which plays such a huge role in determining provision expense for open reserves, I'm wondering — could the steps you and other banks have taken, like forbearance or deferrals, end up slowing migration down so that building reserves gets delayed even more while those credits sit in deferral?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah. One point I wish I'd emphasized in my lengthy response to your earlier question is that our migration — at our bank, and really at many banks, but for us — losses have been extremely minimal over the past 5, 6, 7 years. And when you take that into account and walk through our migration calculations, many of our loan categories show that even a grade 4 or 5 rated loan would receive 0 or an incredibly tiny allocation. What we did quite some time ago was adopt minimum, or de minimis, reserve allocation factors for our 5 main categories of commercial loan — or 5 main segments — together with each grade; that represented a pretty substantial bump in the cost, so to speak, or in the reserve amount we had to hold as part of our migration. So while our migration figures were extremely small, we implemented these de minimis calculations. Honestly, one of the major distinctions between our incurred model and our CECL model was that CECL wouldn't permit these de minimis or minimum reserve allocation factors. And when you look at the decline I referenced, the reserve allocations for commercial loans comparing incurred to CECL, it really came down to removing those de minimis figures. So clearly, we weren't comfortable with that, because we believed it was entirely appropriate to factor in some de minimis amounts in our reserve calculations, given how exceptionally clean our asset quality has been across our loan portfolio over the past 5 to 7 years, which obviously was fueling much of our migration. As for your second question, we'll keep working with our borrowers. Our lenders are in regular communication with them. Depending on how those conversations go, if we conclude that credits need to be downgraded, we'll absolutely do so. But it's simply going to take time for this to play out; so — and each customer will be affected very differently; it's really hard to apply a blanket approach. The idea that this will impact everyone the same way, or that everyone will be treated or affected equally — that's just not true, particularly when it comes to commercial lending. My sense is that for a retail lending portfolio, that approach might deliver somewhat stronger results. When it comes to commercial lending, though, no two borrowing relationships are alike — each one has to be evaluated based on its own unique circumstances. That's the reason we've got the grading system in place. It's also the reason we lean on that grading system to genuinely steer the level of our reserve balance.
Bob Kaminski
executiveYes. Brendan, Bob here. I want to build on Chuck's comments and stress again what he mentioned before: our approach to the loan loss reserve has worked extremely well for us throughout the years, both in strong economic periods and in difficult ones. And we'll observe how everything unfolds with CECL across the next 2 years regarding its adoption and the ultimate adoption of it by every bank. But we have a lot of confidence in our methodology. We have a lot of confidence that our customers are in a very solid position heading into this crisis. They were, across the board. The portfolio was very strong. Customers are doing very well. I believe that will benefit them and benefit us greatly as we navigate this crisis and whatever emerges down the line because of our economy being shut down; so it's quite fortunate that we entered with that strength. But like Chuck mentioned, we'll keep analyzing every customer and examining their circumstances, knowing where their revenues originate, and as the economy ultimately reopens here in Michigan. And I believe the Governor and every legislator are working on that to ensure we don't go too far with the restrictions, while making sure we keep flattening the curve; and I believe the results demonstrate that this is occurring. And I believe once that becomes a sustained pattern, then you'll begin to see some nonessential businesses permitted to reopen, and that will deliver some definite relief to our customers and customers in our communities that have been closed down. And because of that, the unemployment figures are extremely high. There's no doubt about that. When you drive through town, parking lots are empty; so you're going to have unemployment. But I believe the measures will benefit us. The state will come out of the crisis; and the county will reopen, and businesses return to work and employees return to work.
Brendan Nosal
analystOkay, that's great. Then here's my final question before I hand things over. Regarding the PPP initiative, you've approved $500 million in loans up to this point. The typical fee appears to be roughly 2.8%, so let me just confirm my calculation is accurate. That works out to approximately $14 million in origination fees, which you anticipate will accrete into NII across whatever period the loans ultimately last. Did I get that right?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYes, you did. To expand on that a bit, we also have around $1 million — and we also have roughly $1 million in direct origination costs, which we will defer and net against those fees over the loans' lifespan as well.
John Rodis
analystTruthfully, the question I had about the typical fee on the PPP loans was already raised and addressed. But clearly, folks, there's a great deal of uncertainty and such. Still, Chuck, I'm just wondering — and I realize there are many moving pieces and all that — but whenever you run stress tests on the loan book, do you have any sense of what cumulative losses might look like across the coming years?
Chuck Christmas
executiveNo; that's — the thing is, John, we've run quite a few distinct models, so to speak. Back in early 2017, we underwent a formal — we brought in an outside firm to conduct a formal stress test on our loan portfolio, applying the stressed scenario that the Fed had laid out that year for DFAST and CCAR testing; and we came away feeling fairly confident. It wasn't a shock to us. The outcomes weren't a shock when they came back. Since the loan portfolio's composition and its characteristics haven't shifted much, we essentially take those very same inputs, so to speak, and we apply them to the portfolio we have now. Our view is that this serves as an adequate proxy, sparing us the process and the expense of doing it all over again. And once more, we believe it's a solid proxy given the continuing similar characteristics of our portfolio, despite the growth; and as you'd probably anticipate, we clearly foresee across both the 3 scenarios — the base case, the 1 and 2 — obviously, we'd foresee a rise in provision expense. Definitely far beyond an annualization of what we expensed in the first quarter. These are unprecedented times. So it's extremely difficult to put a scenario out there and declare this is what will occur. With luck, this will be a comparatively — the depth of it, of the environment, will be comparatively brief. As Bob said, I won't repeat that. I believe he's exactly right about how long this crisis will have an impact. And once more, it comes back — and I'm not trying to repeat myself in responding to a different question — but we're a commercial bank, and it's going to hit all of our commercial borrowers in varying ways; and frankly, a few of our borrowers are enjoying excellent quarters because they happen to make products that are highly essential during this period. Quite interestingly, 2 of our larger watch list credits are among our best performing credits at present simply because of the line of business they're in; so we can toss numbers at it all day long, and I can provide you numbers all day long. And this is among the reasons we chose not to adopt the CECL methodologies, because we wanted to be as quantitative and logical as we could be given the makeup of our loan portfolio. There's no question that it's a stressed environment. Companies and individuals are going to suffer. We're going to see a rise in past dues and nonaccrual and probably some charge-offs. Yet how big that will be is simply something nobody can know, and we could spend all day sitting around working up scenarios, but that won't change anything. We can't say right now the way CECL said it would. What FASB said was that it would forecast losses down the road. Conditions right now are simply too fast-changing, too without precedent for anyone to truly grasp, on April 21, what the effect will be on our bank or on any other bank.
John Rodis
analystNo, that's true. Looking ahead, it's tough to pin down what normal will look like. Let me shift topics, Chuck. Regarding the margin, you didn't give formal guidance, but I believe you mentioned — I'd like to verify this. You indicated a decline was expected for Q2, followed by relative steadiness across the back half of the year. And to double-check, when you refer to a drop in Q2, should we measure that against the figure once discount accretion is removed? The core margin for Q1 came in at approximately 3.42%, as I recall. So a decrease from that figure during Q2?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYes. I believe — correct, that's precisely what I was communicating, which is that our core stood near 3.40%, 3.42%, and we anticipated additional decline in Q2 because the FOMC's rate reductions took place in early March. That means we'd experience an entire quarter's worth of impact. That said — and we could explore many hypothetical situations — a significant portion of our loans tied to prime, representing 50% of those with floating rates, reached their floor values at the start of March. Consequently, not all loans declined by the 100-plus basis points, or 150 basis points, that the Fed lowered rates by. Additionally, regarding what I mentioned about 30-day LIBOR, which stood at 99 basis points, we're already observing that rate decrease during this month, something I'd anticipated as markets out there began to firm up. Still, there are numerous variables at play. That's why I preferred not to offer precise guidance — given all those variables. That said, yes, our core margin will certainly decline in Q2 relative to Q1, even with the PPP program in the picture. Beyond that, I'd anticipate — again, on a core basis — that it stays fairly constant through the remainder of the year, once we move past any significant shifts in the indices underpinning our loans.
Damon Del Monte
analystSo I've got a quick one for Ray. Regarding the C&I loan growth that showed up this quarter, what portion came from more line utilization? Also, what did the utilization rate look like going from last quarter to this one?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah, Damon, Chuck here. To step back a bit on our loan growth — roughly 50% consisted of residential mortgage loans, essentially the held-for-sale portfolio, and the remaining 50% was net commercial loan growth. I want to be sure we've got that math correct. Toward the end of March, we did observe some growth in line balances, though nothing unusual. I don't — I mean, the magnitude of the shift was nothing unusual. We're a commercial bank, and we hold plenty of credit lines. So on a typical day, we'll watch our line balances swing $5 million, $10 million, $15 million; and I'd say that although we experienced some steady increases as the first quarter wound down, that was nothing unusual compared with what we normally witness daily. And when you look at it overall, our line utilization is still hovering at approximately 50%. I'd also emphasize that borrowing formulas underpin our line balances. So even though customers might need to draw on their credit lines, and we're glad to accommodate them, as long as they stay inside our borrowing formula. And of course, any deceleration they could be experiencing in their business given the present environment might reduce the maximum amount they're able to borrow under lines they already have. So again, apologies for repeating this, but there are many moving pieces there. Still, we haven't — on the whole, we haven't witnessed any significant jump in line utilization. Naturally, $500 million in loan funding to PPP has definitely assisted their cash flow situation.
Damon Del Monte
analystUnderstood. All right, and now returning to the PPP topic. You might have covered this already, and perhaps I didn't catch it, but regarding that $14 million in fees, clearly you mentioned $1 million of expenses tied to it. Is all of that recognized when the loan gets originated? Or does it get recognized across the loan's term? I might have missed what you said about that.
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah, we're supposed to — and I really want to stress "supposed to" — receive the fee within 5 days of funding. That said, in our case, I believed we need to give a tremendous amount of credit to our team for what they've accomplished during the last 3 weeks, essentially coordinating with more than 1,500 borrowers, getting the applications processed, and at this point we're funding those loans. Based on where we stood this morning or last night, our fundings have reached $485 million. So we've nearly finished the first wave that we had, and we're certainly optimistic that Congress will replenish that or allocate additional money into the program, since we have additional customers waiting. Not $500 million — I believe we've definitely moved past the biggest portion — but other borrowers remain who would welcome the assistance, and we'd like to deliver it to them. What we're discovering — as we discover — what we discovered upon entering the PPP program, we're discovering upon entering the Federal Reserve's liquidity program; and at this point we're discovering — while attempting to collect our fees — is that everybody is trying to sort this out as they go; so that's not meant as criticism of anybody. This is entirely new, and everyone is trying to work it out one step at a time; and so we made it through the origination process. Right now we're actually alongside banks, working with the Treasury, on obtaining these origination fees and determining what kind of reporting we must supply to them, since they don't know the extent to which we funded them; they certainly know what we've requested, what our borrowers have requested, and what they've approved. However, since the fees depend on when we fund, they don't have that knowledge. So at this point we're discovering there's a reporting mechanism we need to give them that will then trigger them to pay us the fees; so they're supposed to pay it within 5 days of funding, but that presumes we're supplying that information to them that same day, and there's definitely some catch-up coming on that front. With all of that said, I'd expect that we'll be caught up within roughly the next week on getting those funds in.
Bob Kaminski
executiveBob here, Damon. Let me take a moment to expand on a point Chuck raised. I'd like to extend heartfelt gratitude and congratulations to our entire crew at Mercantile for pushing through the PPP effort and sticking with it; every single person was involved. Folks from every corner of the bank, no matter their usual responsibilities, pitched in on this effort to guarantee those applications got submitted, handled, keyed into the system, and cleared by the SBA; we also wanted to put a few of the remarks into our deck simply to capture some of what we've heard back from clients who voiced their thanks, along with certain things they'd picked up about what was happening at other financial institutions where things hadn't run so well. And like Chuck mentioned, this is a brand-new undertaking. All of us are attempting to navigate it. Still, I give enormous credit to the Mercantile group for what they accomplished, keeping things as easy as possible for our clients during a stretch that's been quite tough for everybody. I just want to spend a few seconds stating that, since they truly have earned it, and my appreciation for all of them knows no bounds.
Damon Del Monte
analystAlright, that's a great point. This really shows why community banks matter so much for keeping our banking system strong. So nice work to your team. Let me just squeeze in one more quick follow-up on that. Chuck, regarding these fees, how many of them have already come through in Q1? Or should we assume most of that $14 million shows up in Q2?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah. I'd say that's the million-dollar question, Damon — we anticipate — clearly we don't have certainty, since this is unprecedented for us — we anticipate that most of our borrowers will seek forgiveness shortly after completing their borrowings to cover salary, mortgage, rent, and utility payments. So once that occurs, we'd anticipate that happening around late May and into June, when they'd reach that point, that milestone, so to speak. So as forgiveness gets processed, we think a large portion will actually land in the third quarter; though we certainly anticipate some of it trailing off across the remainder of the year. It's 1% financing, and I believe some of our borrowers will appreciate that and request forgiveness further down the line. We simply can't predict their behavior. We look at it ourselves and figure, alright, most will seek forgiveness after they've made it through the 2 months of cash flows, but it's difficult to know. Still, my view, based on my internal analysis, is that we anticipate most of that funding to come through in the third quarter and a bit — the bulk of what's left in the fourth quarter.
Brendan Nosal
analystI've got just a single additional question; Slide 10 shows every sector harmed by COVID. Clearly, that amounts to a sizable portion of overall commercial loan balances. Among them, which face the greatest strain right now? And as this pandemic unfolds across the coming months, which areas worry you folks the most?
Ray Reitsma
executiveRay here. One major focus for us, I'd say, is movie theaters. They've shut down entirely and basically bring in nothing, making them a priority. As for restaurants, some are limited to drive-thru service alone, while others are fully shut. That's a second one. Then there's hotels, motels, and lodging, hit hard because people can't get around or travel for work or pleasure; so I'd name those 3 as the main areas.
Chuck Christmas
executiveI do want to emphasize this point, Brendan: like we mentioned before, throughout the years, one element of how we mitigate risk and manage concentration has been seeking partnerships with borrowers we regard as quite strong. And as we noted before heading into this crisis, the vast majority of our borrowers were in a very healthy financial position, and they possessed the capacity to definitely ride out the storm, likely more than lots of other kinds of clients you might have in our communities. That being said, Ray raised several excellent points regarding businesses being dark at the moment. That's the reason I believe folks in our state are putting in a great deal of effort to find a solid equilibrium between flattening the curve and cutting down the virus, while also ensuring we don't excessively damage the economy beyond what's necessary to achieve that. So it's a balancing act, but those are all the — we're reviewing our whole portfolio, since certain segments will probably, the longer this drags on, deliver some surprises and some matters that carry unintended economic and commercial consequences, yet we keep monitoring the entire portfolio. But we wanted to make this known for the risk industry: we identify the industries facing the largest immediate effects from the closures thus far.
Brendan Nosal
analystYes, all of that is clear. That's certainly useful information. One final item from my side. If I look at inquiries about retail payment assistance, it seems they hit their highest point near the close of March and the beginning of April, and after that declined. Is that simply a matter of timing related to which payments were owed? Is that the reason for the decline? And do you think inquiries will rise once more as April comes to an end?
Chuck Christmas
executiveThe way I'd put it, Brendan, is this: many individuals who've been laid off, or partly laid off, or who find themselves in a situation of constrained income, they wish to continue paying on time, and they'll do so for as long as they're able. I believe the early inquiries were essentially people asking, "Hey, what choices do I have if I end up needing to enter a payment relief program?" So I believe that as this stretches on, without question, you'll see a growing number of customers taking part in those payment relief options. So once more, as we've mentioned, there are many moving pieces. Much of it hinges on how deep this crisis goes and how long the crisis lasts; and so our clients' performance has pleased us greatly up to now; but without question, the more it continues, the more pressure they'll face and the more they'll take part in these relief programs.
Bob Kaminski
executiveAbsolutely. Thanks, Grant. And many thanks to each of you for your attention to our business and for joining today's call; we hope that you and your loved ones remain in good health and stay safe; that brings the call to a close.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of this call. We appreciate everyone joining us for today's presentation. You're welcome to leave the line now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Mercantile Bank Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Mercantile Bank Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Mercantile Bank Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.