Mercantile Bank Corporation (MBWM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 19, 2021

NASDAQ US Financials Banks earnings 62 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Tyler Deur

executive
#1

Appreciate that, Grant. Hello everybody, and thanks for being here on this Mercantile Bank Corporation conference call and webcast, where we'll go over the company's financial results for the fourth quarter of 2020. Speaking is Tyler Deur, from Lambert IR, which handles investor relations for Mercantile. With me on the line today are several members of their management team: Bob Kaminski, who serves as President and Chief Executive Officer; Chuck Christmas, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; and Ray Reitsma, President of Mercantile Bank, Michigan. Management will kick things off with prepared remarks and a presentation covering the quarter's results, and after that we'll take questions. But first, ahead of today's call, I need to let you know that forward-looking statements may come up during this call — things like projections of revenue, earnings and capital structure, plus statements about the plans and objectives of the company's business. Actual results for the company might differ materially from any forward-looking statements made today because of the factors laid out in the company's latest Securities and Exchange Commission filings. The company takes on no obligation to update any forward-looking statements made during the call. If you don't yet have a copy of the fourth quarter 2020 press release and presentation deck Mercantile issued today, it's available on the company's website, www.mercbank.com. Now I'd like to hand the call over to Mercantile's President and Chief Executive Officer, Bob Kaminski. Bob?

Bob Kaminski

executive
#2

Thank you, Tyler, and good morning to all of you. During today's call, we'll walk you through specifics regarding how the company performed in Q4 and for the entire year, set against an operating environment unlike anything we've faced before, along with a status report on ongoing initiatives tied directly to the pandemic. Looking back at 2020, I want to once more give tremendous credit to the outstanding work done by our committed Mercantile colleagues, whose remarkable resilience and ability to adjust on every front carried us through the numerous distinct hurdles the pandemic created over the course of the year. Just as we've said repeatedly since the pandemic began, protecting the health and well-being of our staff and clients has remained our priority, and that has demanded adaptability from every team member, all of whom have openly shifted to remote work and unfamiliar settings. Thanks to the dedication of our whole workforce, Mercantile once again posted solid results in Q4 and across 2020, all while successfully adjusting alongside our customers as circumstances required so their banking needs could be met through various channels. That momentum shows up in Mercantile's robust financial results once more in Q4, with earnings per share reaching $0.87. The enduring pillars of financial strength at our company enabled our Board to raise the regular cash dividend for Q1 of 2021 to $0.29 per share; we're glad to offer shareholders a steady and competitive cash return even in this frequently difficult climate. What's more, having chosen to halt stock buybacks in March, we've now brought our repurchase program back into action during Q4, thanks to our disciplined framework and careful attention to keeping capital levels strong. Chuck will share more detail on the numerous shifting components of our financial statements covering the quarter's close and year-to-date 2020. As noted throughout 2020 and in our everyday operations, keeping employees and customers safe stays our number one concern, following the guidance and leading practices of government agencies, the CDC among them. Although our locations reopened in late June, rising worry and a growing number of cases in Michigan caused us to shut our branches once more for in-person meetings in November. Our staff and clients have transitioned without friction to other ways of engaging in banking activity, and we'll keep watching closely for new developments and adjust our plans as needed. Slide 10 of our deck lays out the complete timeline of COVID-related actions. Our lending team's work on the forgiveness stage of the PPP carried on through Q4 as we helped clients collect and submit the necessary details so the SBA could issue a forgiveness determination. In addition, as we moved into the opening weeks of 2021 with the newest government stimulus package, preparations for a fresh round of PPP applications have gotten underway. Our lending group's efficient work has earned recognition throughout the market, which has helped open new loan and deposit customer relationship possibilities with many businesses in our communities that encountered difficulties during the application process at the banks they had previously used. Once we'd helped these new clients through the PPP process, we found ourselves able to build on that groundwork and deepen those connections. The same flexibility our communities have shown has been matched by their determination, and it's a privilege to work alongside such resilient businesses. How dedicated our team is to the markets we serve comes through in the way we engage these companies, pushing our shared efforts forward as we pursue economic recovery and growth. Our team spent considerable time helping both new and existing customers navigate pandemic-related difficulties, yet we stayed committed to finding and bringing in new client relationships while still serving the traditional needs of our current customers. Later in this call, Ray will give you a comprehensive update on how our loan portfolio has performed. Throughout 2020, our asset quality held up very well, and so did our steadfast commitment to disciplined credit underwriting, which has kept past dues and non-performing assets at low levels. Delivering a record-breaking amount of mortgage banking income in 2020 speaks to our robust residential mortgage loan production and the continued success of strategic initiatives we created to grow market share and lift revenue. Our team keeps working to maintain a strong pipeline, and those levels have stayed remarkably solid even with the seasonal slowdown of the winter months. We're still concentrated on setting ourselves up to generate solid mortgage banking income in periods ahead, as shown by opening mortgage lending centers in Midland, Michigan and Cincinnati, Ohio during 2020. In a tough environment, our lenders have performed magnificently, and our teams have taken advantage of opportunities to capture pent-up demand and expand market penetration, boosting revenue and reaching strong residential mortgage loan production levels. In the same way our teams have found efficiencies everywhere, our residential mortgage group made an enormous effort to make sure the whole loan origination process—from receiving an application all the way to closing—gets finished in an organized and prompt fashion; and as I noted earlier in my remarks, our diligence and adaptability over the year have built a significant competitive advantage and opened the door to new and exciting potential relationships. Ray and Chuck will offer more detail on this when they speak. Moving to operations: with our continued strategic emphasis on digital delivery alongside branch optimization, we kept engaging our customers through a holistic, personalized approach to what they need, since the ways they interact with us and their preferences are shifting, particularly given the challenges COVID-19 has brought. Using technology as an alternative delivery channel has been part of Mercantile's strategy for many years. We always seek to analyze and assess our interactions across the board in line with industry best practices, while using data to best capture efficiencies, tailor client engagement, and improve internal systems. You can see our current footprint and a summary of strategic initiatives on Slides 3 and 4 of the deck. Our strategic programs similarly show a continuing dedication to our workforce and strengthen our resolve to follow leading practices in environmental, social, and governance, with special attention paid to the social piece. Our Board of Directors—whose 2020 additions brought on members possessing varied business backgrounds—along with our management team and each of our employees stay devoted to carrying out their ever-changing duties as intentional, committed leaders within the community. During 2020, we broadened our in-house diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts and arranged continuous interaction with outside speakers, whom we have invited in through virtual means to create forums for our staff; we have held persistent mission-driven conversations inside our company, in which personnel can hear and gain knowledge regarding our community plus reflect on who they are, since this has to become a way of living for every one of us. Our Management Group, ESG Committee and our whole team stand resolutely dedicated to improving these solid corporate methods rooted in honesty and confidence, while laboring tirelessly to foster and reinforce our essential ties with our varied communities, our staff, our clients and our investors. Near the close of 2020, our team concluded that bold measures were necessary to assist in tackling the hunger and shelter emergencies in our communities. Thus, we joined forces with nearby nonprofit organizations to put $100,000 in as a direct gift for buying goods that help meet these fundamental human requirements throughout our markets. We pushed ourselves as a company and as people toward unending participation, betterment and advancement. We established a lofty standard as we involve our diverse connections in every aspect of our efforts. We feel tremendous satisfaction regarding our 2020 work at every tier of our operations, since we have constructed remarkable bases to maintain and carry forward the growth of these programs for the shared future prosperity of every one of our stakeholders. That concludes my opening comments. I will now hand the call to Ray.

Ray Reitsma

executive
#3

Thanks, Bob. Across the quarter, our loan book as a whole shrank to $134 million, and that figure includes a $176 million decline in the C&I portfolio. A total of $189 million in PPP forgiveness during the quarter had a direct bearing on both of those declines. Owner occupied CRE came down by $20 million. On the other hand, non-owner occupied CRE rose by $51, while the mortgage and retail portfolios each added $10 million of growth in the quarter. Broadly speaking, C&I lending net of PPP activity is still tracking close to where it sat before the pandemic, since we keep bringing in selected new commercial relationships tied to our PPP work and keep serving the relationships we already have. On top of that, our construction pipeline is still healthy, with $99 million of commitments in commercial construction and development loans that we anticipate funding across the coming 12 to 18 months. Asset quality is still strong: non-performing assets came to only $4.1 million, which equals 0.9% of total assets as of December 31, 2020; you can find that breakdown in the financial section of our presentation on Slides 24 and 25. Also, accruing commercial pass-through loans finished the quarter at a nominal dollar level, $1.1 million in total, spread across 8 borrowers. Slides 16 and 17 hold the full pass-through details. Here's a recap of what we did on provisioning through the COVID-19 affected periods. For the second quarter of 2020, $7.6 million of provision expense came wholly from upward adjustments to environmental factors. In the third quarter of 2020, $3.2 million of provision expense resulted from risk rating changes on 159 specific credits, 8 of which were shifted onto the watch list. The fourth quarter's $2.5 million of provision expense stemmed from a $3.9 million rise in qualitative and environmental factors. As a result of these moves, the allowance for loan losses relative to total loans stands at 1.33% net of PPP loans, which is 49% higher than the 0.84% recorded at December 31, 2019. When the program peaked in mid-July, payment deferrals touched 738 borrowers and accounted for $719 million of exposure. Right now, as of December 31, extensions running past that date cover 18 borrowers and $14 million of exposure, which Slide 11 shows. These fairly small deferral figures, taken together with what we expect to be few future requests and our solid past due results, are encouraging signals. The risk rating process paints a picture of a portfolio with strong traits, showing resilience comparable to the pre-crisis economy, as Slide 15 illustrates. Keeping risk ratings accurate will stay a top priority over the quarters ahead, given that our borrowers keep reporting results shaped by the pandemic. We keep watching the financial condition and performance of credits, especially in these segments: hotels and lodging, assisted living, restaurants and entertainment. Not one of those segments makes up more than 5.1% of commercial loans. Slide 13 shows how those segments are composed. Non-interest income for the fourth quarter came in at $14.3 million, which is $7 million higher, or 96%, than the fourth quarter a year earlier. On Slide 20 you can see that the higher non-interest income figure came mostly from mortgage banking income rising 200% versus the previous quarter. That reflects gains from strategic initiatives we have underway to grow market share, more refinance finance activity because rates are at historic lows, a bigger slice of the purchase market, and a greater percentage of loans sold. Looking at 2020's fourth quarter, purchase mortgage loans originated rose 101% compared with the same quarter a year earlier, and refinance activity climbed 95%, which Slide 23 shows. Based on January applications and backlog, refinance opportunities should continue in the near term, and purchase applications sit at seasonally high levels. Growing mortgage banking income by taking more market share, including more share in the purchase market, is still a priority, and we will keep bringing on proven mortgage loan originators when we can, as with our new mortgage office in the Cincinnati area, which opened during 2020's fourth quarter. Payroll services non-interest income stayed flat even with the quarter's high unemployment relative to the comparable quarter a year earlier, and it rose 7.4% across the year. Service charges on accounts likewise stayed flat for the year, mainly because bigger balances offset charges. Credit and debit card income grew roughly 4.8% quarter over quarter as account activity started recovering from the pandemic slowdown, and the December monthly activity level is 16% higher than January's activity level, which shows the recovery achieved during 2020. Last, we recorded $932,000 of swap income tied to interest rate risk management products introduced and implemented for our clients during the quarter; that wraps up my remarks. I will now hand the call to Chuck.

Chuck Christmas

executive
#4

Thanks, Ray, and good morning, everyone. As we noted on Slide 16 this morning, we reported net income of $14.1 million, or $0.87 per diluted share, for the fourth quarter of 2020, versus net income of $13.3 million, or $0.81 per diluted share, for the fourth quarter of 2019. For the full year 2020, net income came to $44.1 million, or $2.71 per diluted share, compared with $49.5 million, or $3.01 per diluted share, for the full year 2019. If you exclude non-core income and expense transactions, diluted earnings per share rose $0.10, or roughly 12%, in the fourth quarter of 2020 relative to the fourth quarter of 2019, while diluted earnings per share fell $0.07, or about 2.5%, in 2020 relative to the full year 2019. Broadly speaking, a higher level of mortgage banking income offset a lower level of net interest income and larger loan loss provisions during 2023. Now, moving to Slide 19: interest income on loans was lower in the 2020 periods than in the 2019 periods, mainly because of FOMC rate cuts totaling 225 basis points since the start of the third quarter of 2019, with 150 basis points of those reductions taking place in the first quarter of 2020. Interest income on securities in 2020 gained from accelerated discount accretion tied to called U.S. government agency bonds, which amounted to $3.0 million for the year. All told, interest income fell $1.9 million in the fourth quarter of 2020 versus the fourth quarter of 2019, and it was down $10 million for the full year 2020 versus the full year 2019. Interest expense fell across every category in the 2020 periods versus the 2019 periods, which mirrors the declining interest rate environment; overall, interest expense dropped $2.6 million in the fourth quarter of 2020 versus the fourth quarter of 2019, and it was down $7.7 million for the full year 2020 versus the full year 2019. Net interest income rose $0.7 million in the fourth quarter of 2020 versus the fourth quarter of 2019, largely reflecting accelerated PPP net fee income recognition from forgiveness payments made by the federal government during the quarter we just finished. Net interest income fell $2.3 million for the full year 2020 versus the full year 2019. Provision expense rose significantly in the 2020 periods versus the 2019 periods, mostly reflecting the coronavirus pandemic and how it affected the economic environment. Provision expense came to $2.5 million in the fourth quarter of 2020 and $14.1 million for the full year 2020, compared with a negative $0.7 million in the fourth quarter of 2019 and $1.8 million for the full year 2019. Roughly 80% of the provision expense booked during 2020 reflects larger allocations tied to qualitative factors — specifically economic conditions, loan review, and the value of underlying collateral dependent commercial loans — along with the establishment of a COVID-19 pandemic environmental factor. The environmental factor tied to COVID-19 that we established in the second quarter is meant to tackle the special difficulties and financial unpredictability stemming from the pandemic, plus how that might affect how collectible the loan portfolio turns out to be. The provision expense we booked in Q4 of 2020 completely incorporated larger allocations connected to those qualitative factors I just mentioned. As the CARES Act and the Stimulus bill that passed in late December allow, we've chosen to keep delaying our adoption of CECL. That said, we still operate our CECL model alongside the incurred loss model. According to preliminary figures, the loan loss reserve balance that the CECL model produced sits roughly $2.5 million beneath the loan loss reserve balances our incurred loss model produced as of the close of 2020. Moving to Slide 20, fee income rose across the 2020 periods versus the 2019 periods, mostly because mortgage banking income came in significantly larger. Once you strip out specific one-time items, fee income for the whole of 2020 climbed $21.7 million, or 92%, measured against the whole of 2019. With refinancing and purchase activity both picking up, plus the strategic initiatives we'd successfully put in place over the last few years, we turned in mortgage banking income that was substantially greater throughout the 2020 periods than during the 2019 periods. Mortgage banking income for Q4 2020 came in $6.4 million above Q4 of 2019, and for the entire 2020 year it landed almost $21 million above the entire 2019 year. Credit and debit card income got back to where it stood before COVID during the third and fourth quarters, which mirrors transaction volume recovering from the second quarter. Service charge and accounting income didn't quite reach pre-COVID levels, but across the third and fourth quarters it improved a great deal from the second quarter, largely because business customers generated higher transaction levels. Now on Slide 21, overhead costs were higher in the 2020 periods than in the 2019 periods, mainly because of greater compensation costs and the expansion of our main office. Salary and benefit costs climbed $1.6 million in Q4 of 2020 measured against Q4 of 2019. Compensation costs tied to mortgage banking rose $0.9 million, and the bonus accrual went up $0.4 million. For the whole of 2020, salary and benefit costs climbed $6.0 million compared with the whole of 2019. Compensation costs tied to mortgage banking rose $4.5 million, base salary costs rose $0.8 million largely from annual merit increases, and the bonus accrual went up $0.4 million. Occupancy, furniture and equipment costs together rose $0.2 million in Q4 of 2020 measured against Q4 of 2019, and together rose $1.7 million for the whole of 2020 measured against the whole of 2019, largely a reflection of our main office expansion being finished in the fall of 2019. Moving along to Slide 22, net interest margin came in at 3.00% for the fourth quarter of 2020. That represents a rise of 14 basis points versus the third quarter of 2020, though it fell 63 basis points relative to the fourth quarter of 2019. Earning asset yields climbed 10 basis points in the fourth quarter of 2020 compared with the third quarter of 2020, and over that same span the cost of funds dropped 4 basis points. Looking at the fourth quarter of 2020 against the fourth quarter of 2019, earning asset yields were lower by 106 basis points, while the cost of funds came down 43 basis points. Loan yields rose 31 basis points in the fourth quarter of 2020 versus the third quarter of 2020, yet declined 67 basis points compared with the fourth quarter of 2019, largely a reflection of the FOMC's cumulative 175 basis point cut to the targeted federal funds rate across the fourth quarter of 2019 and the first quarter of 2020. For PPP loans, we are recognizing origination fees along with direct origination costs, which produces a $15 million net increase in interest income on commercial loans, applying the level yield method.

Chuck Christmas

executive
#5

Net accretion for the fourth quarter of 2020 came to $5.4 million, which was up $2.4 million compared with what we saw in the third quarter of 2020, driven by faster accretion tied to PPP loan forgiveness payments that came in during Q4. At the close of 2020, unrecognized PPP fee income stood at $3.8 million. Looking at recent patterns, it looks like the great majority of the PPP loans still outstanding will be forgiven across the first three quarters of 2021. That said, we should point out that on none of our PPP loans above $2 million have we gotten any forgiveness payments. For roughly 70% of the segment, applications have been submitted to the SBA. The un-accreted PPP loan fee income tied to that segment works out to roughly 20% of the $3.8 million that remains unrecognized. Securities yield for the full year 2020 got a boost from accelerated discount accretion known as U.S. government agency bonds. During the year, accelerated discount accretion amounted to $3.0 million, which had a positive effect on the period's net interest margin of 8 basis points. Working against our net interest margin across the 2020 period starting around the middle of the second quarter was the sizable amount of excess on balance sheet liquidity, shown by low yielding deposits held with the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago and a correspondent bank. Those excess funds largely result from federal government stimulus programs, along with reduced business and consumer investing and spending. Overnight deposits averaged $560 million in the fourth quarter of 2020 and $357 million for the full year 2020, versus our normal average balance of $50 million to $75 million. We anticipate overnight deposits remaining at elevated levels well into 2021. This excess liquidity reduced our net interest margin in the fourth quarter of 2020 by roughly 40 basis points. The cost of funds has likewise been trending downward, mostly because of the falling interest rate environment, though in terms of magnitude and scale, not as much as what we saw on our yield on loans. As shown on Slide 23, mortgage loan originations rose considerably across the 2020 periods and particularly in the second, third and fourth quarters of the year, largely due to significant refinance activity resulting from the decreased interest rate environment, combined with the continued success of strategic initiatives aimed at expanding market penetration, enhancing gain activities and operating more efficiently. Mortgage loan originations reached $219 million in the fourth quarter of 2020, versus $111 million in the fourth quarter of 2019, a rise of almost 100%. For the full year 2020, mortgage loans originations reached $865 million, versus $369 million for the full year 2019, a rise of about 135%. Roughly 54% of the mortgage volume in the fourth quarter of 2020 was made up of refinance applications, comparable to the level in the fourth quarter of 2019. Approximately 73% of the mortgage loan originations in the fourth quarter of 2020 have been or will be sold on the secondary market, also comparable to the level in the fourth quarter of 2019. Moving on to Slides 24 and 25, the quality metrics we use for our loan portfolio are still quite robust, with non-performing loans and loan charge-offs continuing to run at low levels. At December 31, 2020, non-performing loans came to just 11 basis points when measured against average loans. Other real estate owned stood at $0.7 million when the quarter closed, and it was made up nearly entirely of facilities that used to be branches. During the fourth quarter of 2020, gross loan charge-offs reached $0.3 million, and recoveries tied to loan charge-offs from earlier periods came to $0.2 million. That left us with net loan recoveries — the $0.1 million in charge-offs worked out to 1 basis points of average total loans on an annualized basis. Across all of 2020, we booked $0.8 million in loan charge-off recoveries. Non-performing assets saw additions of $1.0 million in the fourth quarter of 2020, while a net decrease of $0.6 million in non-performing assets was recorded for that quarter. Over the last 12 months, the loan loss reserve balance has grown by $14.1 million, roughly 59%, and the coverage ratio, once PPP loans are excluded, rose from 84 basis points to 1.33%. As Slide 26 shows, our regulatory capital position remains strong and well capitalized. At year end 2020, the Tier 1 leverage capital ratio stood at 9.8%, while the total risk-based capital ratio was 13.8%. The PPP loan portfolio and excess liquidity keep weighing on the Tier 1 leverage capital ratio, with no comparable effect on risk-based capital ratios, since a 0% risk rating is assigned to both of those components. The total risk-based capital ratio exceeded the minimum threshold for well-capitalized categorization by $118 million. During the first quarter of 2020, we bought back roughly 220,000 shares, spending $6.3 million at a weighted average cost of $28.25 per share. In March, because of the uncertainty surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, we chose to pause share repurchase activity for a time so capital could be preserved for lending and other purposes; then, in the fourth quarter, we brought the buyback program back and purchased approximately 14,000 shares for $0.3 million at a weighted average cost of $22.05 per share. Right now, roughly $10 million remains available under our repurchase plan; on Slide 27, to wrap up my prepared remarks, given how much uncertainty there is at present, we will not offer earnings guidance the way we have on prior conference calls. That said, we can point to key considerations that ought to be factored into any earnings forecasts for our company, as the slide notes. It is clear that economic conditions, asset quality, PPP forgiveness activity and mortgage banking operations should have the greatest effect on how we perform in 2021; in closing, although uncertainties remain that could affect Mercantile's financial condition and operating performance in future periods, we know we went into this distressed environment with strong asset quality and a solid capital position. Our fourth quarter and full year 2020 operating results, along with the financial condition as of year end 2020, leave us pleased, and we believe we are well-positioned to keep navigating the unprecedented environment created by the coronavirus pandemic and other events. That concludes my prepared remarks. I will now hand the call back over to Bob.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#6

Thanks, Chuck. That brings an end to what management had ready to say, and at this point we're going to begin the question-and-answer portion of the call.

Brendan Nosal

analyst
#7

Hi there, everyone — morning to you all. How's it going?

Bob Kaminski

executive
#8

Morning, Brendan. And how are things with you?

Brendan Nosal

analyst
#9

Thanks, that's great. To kick things off, I was hoping you could walk us through where things stand right now in a few of the industries that COVID hit hard — specifically hotels, restaurants, and entertainment — and let us know how those borrowers are doing relative to the worst point of the pandemic last year?

Ray Reitsma

executive
#10

Sure, Ray here. Let me speak to hotels for a moment; clearly, versus where things stood before the pandemic, they're still getting hit very hard. From an occupancy perspective, they're operating at a better level than they were during the earlier part of the pandemic, with a big emphasis on cutting expenses and similar measures. Our portfolio has held up pretty nicely; within it we have a very strong group of sponsors, and that's what has helped keep those assets going and gives them the capacity to keep doing so. In terms of the structure, the AMs, and so forth, we believe we've got them positioned well. A number of the operators have stepped up with extra capital to pay down our loans, which we've welcomed, and it demonstrates how committed those operating groups are to those assets. So, to answer you as directly as possible: they've come up a little from where they sat at the pandemic's darkest point.

Brendan Nosal

analyst
#11

Yeah, that's useful detail. Thanks. Then one additional item from my side — when I think about reserve coverage at this point as we enter the new year, it caught my attention that your CECL reserve, in theory, came in below the incurred loss reserve base right now. So I'm just wondering, when you consider the year ahead, do you anticipate a significantly greater need to keep adding to reserves, or given what you currently know, would you say the level is adequate?

Chuck Christmas

executive
#12

Yeah. Brendan, it's Chuck. I'll give that a first try. And like I said during my prepared remarks, 80% of the provision we recorded in 2020 came from the environmentals. And as our metrics showed, asset quality remains very strong, and we've managed to grow the reserve off those environmentals rather than from specific credit deterioration, which, as Ray noted, largely occurred through our extended review in the third quarter. So long as those quality figures remain consistently strong, your capacity to increase the reserve still depends mainly on the environmentals. Therefore, it appears to us that if we stay on the same path, our provision will definitely be far below what it was in 2020, and knock on wood we can keep that up; but once more, we still have our loan review program, all our internal communications. Obviously, we keep very close watch on the credits; on every credit, but especially those sitting in the industries that have — that were hit the hardest, and I doubt anyone would be shocked to hear we maintain regular contact with those borrowers. So on the whole, we feel fairly good. With respect specifically to CECL, I believe we — in my view, we began seeing it last week, toward the end of last week, when the mega banks reported and we spoke with other CFOs — bank CFOs, and I think a shared theme out there regarding CECL models is that the economic forecasts are beginning to get better, and that was one of the — our CECL model all through 2020 was far closer to our incurred model. The $2.5 million or so we see at year end 2020 was quite a bit higher than — the gap was quite a bit higher than what we are seeing; and most of that stemmed from the improvement in the economic forecast. Like most banks, we definitely relied on a third-party as our main source, but we also have another third-party that we put into the model too just as a test to confirm the models we're using are somewhat similar or in consensus with the markets out there, and the reserve allocated for the economic factor dropped quite dramatically. Alright, so that's something we might observe, and likely will observe, across the coming couple of weeks. But — and from a CECL perspective, I believe this is logical — during earlier parts of 2020, a significant amount of build occurred, driven by the way the economic environment was segregated along with the forecast. Yet at present, as economic forecasts are arriving in better shape, with results having improved, those employing the CECL model, or as a consequence of that model, end up with some reserve release. Naturally, the overall outcome hinges on every other factor and calculation feeding into it.

Brendan Nosal

analyst
#13

Perfect.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#14

Yeah, that's Bob here. What I'd say is, like we've discussed on previous calls, the incurred loss model is something we've worked with for many, many years, and we're quite at ease with the reserve levels it calls for across every sort of economic environment — whether that's tough periods like what we went through in 2020, or when the economy is doing well. And we believe, as Chuck mentioned, that this gives us the best path to a strong, solid reserve that captures the risk sitting in the portfolio and keeps us positioned where we ought to be. And just like we've done through other economic cycles historically, we're going to keep evaluating, we're going to keep examining those qualitative factors, and clearly keep looking at our credit relationships, making certain — as we always do — that risk ratings are accurate and sit where they need to be too. And we'll do that, obviously, alongside what we're observing on the parallel CECL model. Because, as Chuck mentioned, some interesting dynamics come into play depending on what that model is built on. And — but all of that gets taken into account, and we'll keep assessing each quarter where the reserve should be, but we feel really good about where it sits right now and about the process we have in place to make sure it stays there.

Brendan Nosal

analyst
#15

Great, and thanks for letting me ask these.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#16

Sure thing.

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#17

Morning, everyone. How's it going today?

Bob Kaminski

executive
#18

Doing well, Damon. And yourself?

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#19

Things are going well. Thanks. So, for my first question, Chuck, I just wanted to spend a bit of time on the margin — I believe you mentioned the dollar figure tied to PPP loan forgiveness. Would you mind saying that again, and do you happen to recall offhand what that amounted to in basis points?

Chuck Christmas

executive
#20

Sure. Give me a second to gather my thoughts here. The improvement came in at roughly 2 to 3 — when you look at the fourth quarter versus the third quarter, what we saw in Q4 was approximately $2.3 million, or $2.4 million, above what we recorded in Q3. And nearly all of it, perhaps entirely, stemmed from the forgiveness payments along with the acceleration in fee income that came with them. Our initial forgiveness payment arrived, I believe, on October 30, or whichever was the final business day in October, and since then they've come in fairly consistently, though across a fairly broad range — we receive anywhere from $2 million to $6 million per day from that, and that's carried through into January. In basis point terms, that $2 million to $3 million — $2.4 million contributed roughly 25 basis points to the margin for the quarter. So we ended up — the way I see it, we received a 25 basis point lift from that, and then, as I noted, roughly a 40 basis point drag on our margin from the excess liquidity, so absent that, it would leave us at around a 3.15%, if you will, core margin, which is fairly consistent with what we've discussed on prior calls.

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#21

Understood, alright. Then you mentioned you anticipate most of the outstanding forgiveness happening across the initial 3 quarters — is that right?

Chuck Christmas

executive
#22

Yeah, I'd likely say the first 2 quarters. I hope that's what I said. I'm aware that's what my script contained, the first 2 quarters. Applications below $2 million keep arriving. Naturally, we must wait on borrowers to assemble their paperwork, we examine it, afterward we file it with the SBA, and then obviously, wait for the SBA to complete its steps prior to sending it to ACH. So regarding the timing of everything, our role is fairly minor. But as I mentioned, things have been quite consistent, steady regarding the volume of forgiveness flowing in. So judging by the previous 2 months and also what we've observed up to now in January across the initial 2 weeks, I'd anticipate most of those getting paid off before the second quarter ends. Once more, I put that out there — regarding the $2 million, we simply don't know what the government is doing with that segment, obviously going back to the second quarter; they signaled that loans exceeding $2 million would receive extra scrutiny. It surely looks that way. The application — the forgiveness application process and the application itself is far, far more lengthy — is far lengthier, far more developed. We have cases where they request extra information on certain ones. So it has unquestionably required a longer stretch of time compared to what we encounter with those loans below $2 million; so it's an estimate that it will be at the close of the second quarter, feel fairly confident regarding those below $2 million and we're hopeful the government will begin accepting or approving the forgiveness applications and paying off those above $2 million too. At year-end, the above $2 million portfolio represented roughly 50% of our outstanding balance. So that segment is approximately $185 million. So it's a fairly sizable segment on the balance sheet. The forgiveness — the net origination fee is roughly 20% of the, I believe, $3.8 million remaining.

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#23

Understood, alright. Then regarding expenses, clearly those branch shutdowns gave you decent savings. What would you consider a sensible baseline ongoing level that we ought to genuinely use for modeling moving ahead into 2021?

Chuck Christmas

executive
#24

Yeah, I suppose I used the term core alongside normal simply attempting to determine our position. A few extra — we never discuss these, yet there were certainly certain expenses tied to PPP, stay-at-home, work-from-home in that figure. Still, I'd argue, once you strip things down to the core, I'd estimate that the rise during 2021 compared with 2020 will land somewhere in the range of 1.5% to 2%.

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#25

All right. And is that calculated from roughly, say, $98 million, or about $98.5 million, or not quite?

Chuck Christmas

executive
#26

Yeah, Damon, I don't have that figure sitting in front of me, but I'd say whatever amount ends up at the core that we included there — that's probably a fairly solid estimate.

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#27

All right. Then only one — actually, two fast questions here, and regarding fee income — the swap fee income you all disclosed for this quarter, is that something that — is this a sort of new emphasis for you all, where we ought to begin factoring in some measure of it every quarter, or is it more of a one-off?

Chuck Christmas

executive
#28

No, it's absolutely a new program, and it's a back-to-back swap program. Obviously, many banks have been engaged in this. What it is, it's a means to manage interest rate risk from, as I'd describe it, our longer term commercial loans. So those are usually 5-year balloons. Sometimes we do 7-year balloons. Before, we relied on the FHLB, plus the broker deposit program to a lesser degree, to roughly match-fund those. Yet clearly, what we've seen — and this explains why we continue booking those 5-year fixed rate balloons along with the occasional 7-year — is that going to the FHLB for advance money simply isn't necessary for us. What we came to realize, starting back in 2019 and definitely throughout 2020, is that from an on-balance sheet standpoint, we genuinely didn't have the capability to hedge those longer term fixed rate commercial loans very effectively. So we started looking into whether we could offer swaps to some of our customers. This isn't something we'd roll out to everyone — typically it would be for the bigger, more sophisticated ones. We're handling this initiative carefully, since a swap is a new instrument for a lot of borrowers, though not all of them. We've also partnered with a well-known third party that serves as an advisor. They assist us directly, and they also engage with our borrowers and provide materials for them. So here's the situation: for borrowers we've specifically identified — and these will tend to be bigger, more sophisticated clients carrying larger balances — we're changing our approach. In the past, every borrower we worked with could choose either a fixed or a floating rate. Going forward, for this particular group, the only option we'll extend is a floating rate. Should they prefer a fixed rate, they'll need to arrange an interest rate swap with the bank directly as the way to lock that in. Naturally, that leaves us holding something we'd rather not have — fixed-rate exposure once more — so at the very same moment, we turn around and go to a correspondent bank, setting up the mirror-image swap on the other side. On the swap side, our exposure is essentially zero. There are just a few leftover pieces of credit exposure, and naturally we underwrite those with our borrowers when we underwrite loans, using adjusted loan-to-collateral values. That lets us — since rates differ, it lets us generate some upfront fee income. I'm sure this happens at a lot of your banks too. Basically, we rolled this out in Q4 and plan to continue it. It'll be transactional by nature. As a result, I'd expect certain quarters to show higher fee income while others come in with less, though I'd put it at roughly — truthfully, our budget has been sitting around $50,000 to $70,000 each month. Once more, naturally, this is fairly recent for us, yet we definitely recognize the chance, and honestly the necessity, of taking this step in order to handle that exposure to longer-term interest rate risk.

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#29

Understood. Alright, that sounds excellent. Then, if I may fit in one additional brief question for Bob — do you have any perspective regarding the latest TCS sale to Deutsche Bank, plus what might come afterward? My sense is that certain branch divestitures could be on the way, and perhaps your view on that, and potentially acquiring some — maybe new lenders? Thank you.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#30

Well, as we've discussed previously, anytime disruption arises — should a bank M&A kind of deal occur in any of the markets we serve, that does create certain possible opportunities, and just as we've done before, with this specific situation you mentioned, we'll keep examining whether there's any path for us to become stronger owing to some of the shifts happening in the marketplace for those banks. So we'll keep taking a hard look at whatever opportunities might emerge and make the wisest choices from a strategic perspective for Mercantile. And it appears that anytime disruptions occur, customers typically wind up dealing with certain frustrations and some problems of that nature, along with some employees too. So we'll maintain our flexibility and keep watching to see what opportunities might present themselves to us as all of us move through the next several quarters.

Damon Del Monte

analyst
#31

Thanks a lot — I really appreciate you fielding everything I've asked today.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#32

Of course. Appreciate it, Damon.

Bryce Rowe

analyst
#33

Thanks. Good morning.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#34

Good morning, Bryce.

Chuck Christmas

executive
#35

Morning, Bryce.

Bryce Rowe

analyst
#36

Thanks for letting me ask a couple things today. I had a question about the mortgage remarks you made — it sounded as though your outlook there is pretty favorable even with some of the elevated 10-year rates over the past month; so could you help us frame how mortgage market share gains might compare against what current market volumes would look like if 10-year rates are higher?

Chuck Christmas

executive
#37

Sure, Chuck here. I'll give it the first try, then Bob and/or Ray can weigh in. Forecasting mortgage banking, I'd say, is definitely extremely difficult, particularly when it comes to refinance activity. Based on market data, what we've heard from third parties, perhaps as much as a third of mortgage borrowers out there can refinance, and naturally that shifts nearly daily as mortgage rates move; but mortgage rates clearly remain fairly low and some opportunities do exist. We certainly expect rates probably won't decline further, and if anything, might tick up a bit, as you pointed out, Bryce. So we certainly don't — we are not expecting refinance activity in 2021 to match what it was in 2020. So on net and refinancings, we're expecting less income from that. This is a constant priority for us, though right now the emphasis is really on something specific: within a mortgage banking operation, you have to be certain you can originate loans tied to home purchases. When rates go down and nearly everyone can refinance, earning plenty of fee income is easy — but sustaining a robust business over the long haul demands a dependable group of loan officers with the right relationships, the kind that secure our piece of the purchase mortgage market, so to speak. When we speak with lenders who might join us, that's a key focus for us. We examine what they've done, what they specialize in, and their track record with the purchase market. So within the strategic initiatives I brought up, and I believe Ray brought up too, we're expanding that through more than just new offices such as Midland and Cincinnati last year — we're also bringing additional lenders into markets where we already operate. We'll keep seeking out opportunities. In the markets we're in now, we will absolutely keep exploring additional markets, nearby ones, or any other chances that arise to strengthen the team. On the purchase side, we think that's definitely going to be a benefit — that's what we'd expect. To wrap up, pinning down exactly where that ends up is honestly close to impossible, but here's how I see the whole net picture: we figure refinancing will come down somewhat, but given where the market stands right now — the economy and rates included — we'd expect purchase activity to pick up. So that was a long answer, and I didn't give you an exact number, but that's our read on it.

Bryce Rowe

analyst
#38

Okay, go ahead.

Ray Reitsma

executive
#39

One more point I'd add is that once we flipped the calendar into 2021, the volume of opportunities we're tracking climbed roughly 20%, and that's not what you'd typically see from a seasonal pattern. The mix between refinance and purchase has held steady too, so both of those drivers remain at work, and they're quite powerful — not just given the time of year but in outright terms. So regardless of what the accurate figure is for the population out there, or the share of folks who stand to gain from a refinance, that group is still there and they're still going after it energetically; and we've certainly observed that pretty steadily from the start of the year through today.

Bryce Rowe

analyst
#40

All right, that helps, Ray. Thanks for that. I had a question — actually, I've got two more questions left. The first one is about PPP: is there any signal from borrowers regarding this newest round of the PPP as far as what level of interest we might see in 2021?

Bob Kaminski

executive
#41

Yes, and it's a curious thing. During the initial phase, we originated more than 2,000 loans totaling $550 million over the life of that program. We're only at the beginning now, and already 300 applications have come in, amounting to roughly $75 million. So right away, the demand was quite robust. It has already cooled somewhat. As for how things will unfold going forward in terms of the trajectory for applications and approvals, that's still unknown. Our feeling is that it will be a bit lower, though how much lower is far too soon to say — but that reflects the data as of yesterday morning.

Bryce Rowe

analyst
#42

All right, that's useful. And the remarks about loan forgiveness for accounts carrying balances of $2 million or more are quite interesting. Folks, I'm wondering how those borrowers are responding, given that perhaps greater scrutiny is now falling on the forgiveness process. I mean, I'm not sure how much you've been involved with those specific customers, but any anecdotal observations you could share would be worth hearing.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#43

To be honest, my discussions on that topic have been quite few. They're simply waiting to see what happens next, consuming whatever material they can locate, and attempting to provide information that backs up the actions they took in the program, which every single one of them is convinced was suitable; and they're eager for the chance to present whatever details are required to make that argument.

Bryce Rowe

analyst
#44

All right, that is useful. And perhaps one final item from my side here — there has been a great deal of discussion regarding loan yields, the effect of the PPP along with forgiveness, and also some remarks about excess liquidity. With the economic outlook perhaps having improved somewhat as we head into ‘21, I was curious what competitors are doing from a loan pricing standpoint at this point compared with how things looked during the worst of the pandemic. I am simply attempting to figure out whether pricing pressure is on the way in ‘21 compared with what we may have observed last year. Thank you.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#45

I have not truly seen, gone through, or sensed any extra pricing pressure occurring during those periods you mentioned. I would say pricing pressure exists, yet it has not actually shifted.

Bryce Rowe

analyst
#46

Alright, that's quite useful. Thanks, everyone.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#47

Thanks, Bryce.

Bob Kaminski

executive
#48

Appreciate that, Grant, and many thanks to everyone for the interest you've shown in Mercantile Bank Corporation. Our wish is that you and your loved ones remain in good health and out of harm's way. We also can't wait to talk with all of you once more when the first quarter wraps up in April; with that, we're bringing this call to a close.

Operator

operator
#49

That brings today's call to a close. We appreciate your participation in this presentation. You're free to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Mercantile Bank Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Mercantile Bank Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Mercantile Bank Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.