Mercantile Bank Corporation (MBWM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 19, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Bob Kaminski
executiveThanks, Anthony. Morning, everybody. Appreciate you all being on the call with us today. The Mercantile team keeps delivering excellent financial performance, which shows how powerful a high-touch, relationship-driven style of banking can be — that approach is what lets us establish lasting ties with the clients we serve. In Q3, we brought in net income of $15.1 million, which works out to $0.95 per share, up almost 41% compared with the third quarter of 2020. Across the first 9 months of this year, net income reached $47.4 million, which is more than 57% above the same stretch a year earlier. Two main pieces are powering those strong bottom-line figures: first, solid organic loan growth in the double digits, which produces healthy expansion in net interest income, and second, very robust generation of noninterest income, which makes up close to 1/3 of all our revenue. What makes both of those revenue pieces work comes down to a single thing — our people. Mercantile has a distinct strategy along with a client-focused culture that reaches every level of the company. Day in and day out, our team carries out that strategy in the markets we serve. We think Mercantile will once again stand out because of our commercial loan production in Q3, which hit a 25% annualized growth rate once you exclude PPP loans. That growth is nicely balanced and spread across the different loan categories. Ray will dig into our loan portfolio in greater depth later on this call, but I want to share a few thoughts on how we got here and why we're confident we can keep it up. Backing our local communities sits at the heart of who we are. Hard as it was, the pandemic handed us a chance to demonstrate that we can serve our clients at the very highest level no matter what happens. When Michigan businesses called, we responded — sometimes at moments when the banks they already used would not — and those companies got to see the Mercantile way for themselves. Business leaders clearly respond well to our local, responsive decision-making and our high-touch style. A lot of them want more from a bank than just somewhere to run transactions; what they're looking for is a genuine financial partner. Our core commercial loan growth in Q3, together with our steady and sustained pipeline, demonstrates that this approach works. I want to point out that even while we've — while we've expanded loans and dealt with the pandemic as it continues, our asset quality has stayed solid. We keep posting low levels of past due loans and nonperforming assets, which reflects our dedication to disciplined underwriting and also the strong performance of our commercial borrowers and the teams managing them. When it comes to mortgages, our agility and our local lenders working in-market also add a great deal to our success. That brings me to a second crucial ingredient of our success that I want to call out. I mean the strength and the diversity of our noninterest income, with mortgage banking being its biggest piece. Mortgage banking income came to a solid $6.6 million in Q3 and $23 million year-to-date, which is up 17% over the first 9 months of last year. What's behind these numbers is our capacity to produce those originations, and that leads directly to our wins — starting with the mortgage bankers we've brought on board who have deep ties where they live and work; given how our team has performed and the encouraging trends we keep seeing in applications and pipeline volume, we feel we're in a strong spot to take additional market share in the quarters ahead. One more strategic choice that has paid off is the interest rate swap program that got underway in late 2020. That added revenue source allows us to stay competitive across a wider group of commercial clients. For the 3 months ended September 30, 2021, swaps brought in $3.9 million in fees, which accounted for 1/4 of noninterest income during the period. Noninterest income on the whole rose more than 17% versus the third quarter a year earlier. We stay dedicated to our strategic emphasis on broadening and expanding our fee and sources; over the last 12 months, noninterest income represented more than 31% of operating revenue, versus 22% at the median $5 billion to $10 billion bank range in the most recent quarter. As I said before, our people are what make these results happen, and we've supported them for a long time by investing in technology. Digital adoption has sped up since 2020, and certain banks are finding they have to catch up. In our own operations, we adopt the best practices of the industry while using the data at hand to gain efficiencies, tailor distinctive client interactions and hone our internal systems. Investment in technology has been a longstanding priority and a key element of how we do business, and it will keep expanding as our customers' needs keep changing. The mix of our people, products, services and technology is plainly producing financial strength and organic growth. Crucially, this underpins our continuing push to build shareholder value within a genuinely sustainable organization. Earlier today, we declared a fourth quarter cash dividend of $0.30 per share. As for our stock buyback program, we were able to repurchase an additional 288,900 shares of Mercantile stock, which brings year-to-date purchases to 635,800 shares. On balance, we think our strategy, talent, culture and business model together underpin the sustained, consistent high performance we deliver for our clients, communities and shareholders. With a solid foundation and momentum as we head into the fourth quarter and 2022, we're ready to take advantage of the continuing M&A-related disruption in our markets, whether by drawing in talent or deepening client relationships. That wraps up my opening comments. I'll hand the call over to Ray now.
Ray Reitsma
executiveThank you, Bob. My remarks this morning will focus on three subjects along with the supporting evidence found in our third quarter results: robust growth in core commercial loans; strategic expansion and recurring noninterest income; and gains in operational efficiency. Let's begin with core commercial loan growth. For Q3, we're reporting an increase in core commercial loans of $162 million, which works out to a 25% annualized growth rate, with 62% of that amount coming from C&I credit. On a year-to-date basis, core commercial loan growth stands at $298 million, equal to a 16% annualized growth rate, 60% of which is C&I credit. I want to emphasize that this expansion is made up mostly of C&I credit, consistent with the strategic goals we've set. Achieving this growth was made possible by our commercial team's efforts and their dedication to building relationships through the business community bank value proposition. The pandemic and the PPP program allowed us to demonstrate in practice what we had pitched in theory — specifically, that Mercantile offers the capacity and technology clients require, combined with prompt local decision-making and outstanding service. We came through when many others did not. Because of our strong growth, we raised our provision expense, mainly to support that expansion; we've also reduced our stock repurchase program, acknowledging that growth at this robust level demands equally robust capital support. Our backlog is holding steady relative to earlier periods as we fund this remarkable pace of core growth. Now turning to strategic growth in sustainable noninterest income. Through the first 9 months of 2021, we posted year-to-date noninterest income of $42.5 million net of gain on a branch sale, versus $30.8 million a year earlier — a rise of 38% and $11.7 million. How do we argue that this performance can be sustained? Swaps accounted for $6.1 million of that growth and reflect fulfilling customer demand for fixed rates without absorbing the balance sheet risk of a traditional fixed rate, which matters greatly to margin sustainability in today's environment. Our term debt funding has remained close to 50% fixed for an extended period, and we don't anticipate the mix shifting in any meaningful way. Our mortgage activity contributed $3.3 million of the year-to-date increase in noninterest income, as our team lifted production from $645 million last year to $742 million this year. The sustainability case for this business rests on the fact that last year's volume was split 30% purchase activity to 70% refinance activity, whereas the current year's mix is an even 50 to 50 split between purchase and refinance activity; and naturally, purchase activity is much more sustainable than refi activity. Smaller yet significant contributors to the noninterest income picture include service charges on accounts and credit and debit card income, which rose by 17% and 19%, respectively, in the third quarter, mirroring growth in the number of relationships we serve as well as higher activity within those accounts as the economy rebounds from the pandemic. To wrap up, noninterest income accounted for 32% of revenue during the first 9 months of 2021, compared with 25% in the earlier period. The last subject I want to address is boosting operational efficiency. On a year-to-date basis, our efficiency ratio comes in at 57.4%, versus 59.9% for the same period a year ago. Steady investment in technology across the years has paid off for us, letting our customers take advantage of many digital channels instead of coming into a branch, and giving us room to shift resources toward additional improvements on a digital platform that is already current. Worth pointing out is that during this stretch of strong loan and noninterest income growth, our FTE rose just 11% over the prior year period, reaching a total of $629, and that year-to-date revenue growth of 11.4% exceeds noninterest expense growth of 6.8%; that wraps up what I have to say. I'll hand the call over to Chuck now.
Chuck Christmas
executiveThanks, Ray, and good morning, everyone. On Slide 22, you'll see that we reported net income this morning of $15.1 million, which works out to $0.95 per diluted share, for the third quarter of 2021. That's an increase of more than 40% compared with the $10.7 million, or $0.66 per diluted share, we recorded in the same period a year earlier. For the first 9 months of 2021, net income came to $47.4 million, or $2.95 per diluted share, which is up more than 57% from $30.1 million, or $1.85 per diluted share, during the first 9 months of 2020. Now let's move to Slide 23. Interest income on loans for the 3-month and 9-month periods of 2021 was fairly consistent with the equivalent periods last year, since growth in core commercial loans and residential mortgage loans has mostly offset the negative impact of the FOMC rate cuts totaling 150 basis points in March of 2020 and the persistently low interest rate environment since then. Interest income on securities for the third quarter of 2021 is 9% higher versus the same period in 2020, largely driven by growth in the securities portfolio over the past 12 months. Securities interest income for the first 9 months of 2021 is essentially flat compared with the corresponding period in 2020, once you exclude accelerated discount accretion on U.S. government agency bonds in 2020. All together, interest income for the most recent quarter rose $0.3 million versus the third quarter of 2020. That said, it fell $4.2 million for the first 9 months of 2021 relative to the comparable prior year period, mainly because the lower interest rate environment cannot be entirely offset by growth in earning assets. Interest expense either decreased or stayed roughly flat across all categories during the 2021 period versus the prior year period, and that reduction reflects the low interest rate environment. In total, interest expense fell $1.3 million in the third quarter of 2021 relative to the third quarter of 2020, and it was down $5.4 million between the comparable year-to-date periods. Net interest income rose $1.6 million in the third quarter of 2021 versus the third quarter of 2020, and it was up $1.1 million during the first 9 months of 2021 compared with the respective prior year period. On the whole, growth in earning assets was essentially able to offset a lower net interest margin. We recorded provision expense of $1.9 million for the third quarter of 2021, versus provision expense of $3.2 million a year earlier. For the first 9 months of 2021, we recorded a negative provision expense of $0.9 million, compared with provision expense of $11.6 million during the respective prior year period. The provision expense we recorded for the third quarter of 2021 mainly reflected growth in core commercial loans, whereas the prior year provision expense was primarily made up of increased allocations tied to the downgrading of certain nonimpaired commercial loan relationships to reflect stressed economic conditions stemming from the COVID-19 environment. The negative provision expense we booked in the first 9 months of 2021 mainly came from higher reserves required for growth in core commercial loans, and that increase was entirely offset by a reduction in the reserve allocation tied to the economic and business conditions environmental factor, which got upgraded in the second quarter because both current and forecasted economic conditions had improved. The fairly sizable provision expense in the 2020 year-to-date period largely stemmed from a bigger reserve allocation connected to the economic and business conditions environmental factor, the addition of the COVID-19 pandemic environmental factor, and the commercial loan downgrades in the third quarter of 2020 mentioned earlier. We chose to delay adopting CECL until January 1, 2022. Even so, we keep running our CECL model alongside our incurred loss model. According to preliminary results, the reserve balance under CECL would come in roughly $7.2 million below our reserve balance as of September 30, 2021, calculated under the incurred loss methodology. That compares with a $6.6 million difference at June 30 and a $2.6 million difference at year-end 2020, so it marks an increase. Over the past few quarters, the main gap between the 2 reserve models has to do with the economic forecast portion of the calculation. With CECL, the economic forecast we use has improved considerably. With the incurred model, our outlook on economic and business conditions is broadly favorable and getting better, though not to the degree reflected in market economic forecasts; at the close of every quarter we will keep evaluating all of the qualitative factors and we'll make adjustments to the loan loss reserve balance through the provision expense line item on the income statement. Moving to Slide 25, overhead costs in the third quarter of 2021 were fairly flat versus the same quarter a year earlier, but they rose $4.9 million in the first 9 months of 2021 relative to the first 9 months of last year. In the third quarter of 2020, we took a large bonus accrual because of a change in estimate tied to the bonus plan metrics, since no bonus accruals had been recorded in the first and second quarters as a result of COVID-19 and the weakened economic environment that came with it. That bonus accrual in the third quarter of 2020 exceeded what we recorded in the third quarter of this year by $1.1 million. The smaller bonus accrual in the third quarter of 2021 offset the effect of higher salary expense from annual employee merit pay increases, higher medical insurance costs and increased FDIC insurance premiums, mostly driven by a larger deposit base. Roughly 60% of the year-to-date rise in overhead cost sits in salary and benefits, and nearly half of that amount consists of higher medical insurance costs. The rest is mostly made up of increased FDIC insurance costs and former facility valuation rate balance. At present, we expect overhead costs in the fourth quarter of 2021 to be close to the third quarter expense. When it comes to 2022 overhead costs, we are in the early stages of putting together our 2022 budget. At this point, I can't offer any particular forecast, but we do anticipate that salary expenses will rise more than they usually do, driven by inflationary conditions in our marketplace and by bringing on additional staff to back the ongoing loan growth and revenue projects we expect. Moving ahead on Slide 26. Our net interest margin came in at 2.71% for the third quarter of 2021, which is 5 basis points lower than both the second quarter and first quarter of 2021, and 15 basis points below the third quarter of 2020. Relative to the same quarter a year earlier, earning asset yields fell 32 basis points, whereas the cost of funds dropped 17 basis points in this latest quarter. The yield we earn on loans has stayed fairly steady across the last 5 quarters, apart from the fourth quarter of 2020, when we booked an unusually large accretion of PPP fee income. Turning to Slide 21, net accretion of PPP fee income reached $2.8 million in the third quarter and has remained highly stable ever since the program began, with the exception of that fourth quarter of 2020 I just mentioned. At the close of the quarter, unrecognized PPP net fee income stood at $3.4 million, the great majority of which ties to fundings under PPP round #2.
Chuck Christmas
executiveIf PPP forgiveness patterns hold steady, then we anticipate that a substantial portion of the PPP net fee income still unrecognized will be reported — recognized as income in this year's fourth quarter. A sizable amount of surplus liquidity held on our balance sheet, shown as low-yielding deposits at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, keeps dragging down our net interest margin. Those surplus funds come from higher local deposits, which largely stem from federal government stimulus programs plus reduced business and consumer investing and spending. Local deposits and sweep balances together rose $538 million, or 15%, across the first 9 months of 2021, and they are up $1.4 billion, or 51%, compared with year-end 2019. Roughly 1/2 of the local deposit growth since year-end 2019 consists of higher noninterest-bearing checking account balances. Overnight deposits averaged $734 million in the third quarter and $649 million across the first 9 months of 2021, far above our normal average balance of approximately $75 million. During the third quarter and first 9 months of 2021, this surplus liquidity reduced our net interest margin by roughly 40 to 45 basis points. We anticipate overnight deposit levels will remain elevated far into the foreseeable future. The cost of funds has trended favorably, mainly because of the declining interest rate environment, and we anticipate that trend will persist through the rest of 2021 and into 2022 as time deposits and FHLB advances that originated during earlier periods of higher interest rates reach maturity. As Slide 30 shows, we continue to hold a strong, well-capitalized regulatory capital position. As of September 30, 2021, the Tier 1 leverage capital ratio stood at 9.3%, while the total risk-weighted capital ratio was 12.5%. The PPP loan portfolio and excess liquidity keep affecting the Tier 1 leverage capital ratio, yet the total risk-based capital ratios face no comparable effect since a 0% risk weighting applies to both components. Solid core commercial loan growth over the past several quarters, along with stock repurchase activity, affects both our Tier 1 leverage capital ratio and the total risk-based capital ratio. To be categorized as well capitalized, our bank's total risk-based capital ratio exceeded the minimum threshold by $94 million. In the third quarter of 2021, we bought back roughly 289,000 shares for $8.9 million, at a weighted average cost of $30.97 per share, which lifted our year-to-date total to 636,000 shares for $19.8 million at a weighted average cost of $31.14 per share. That year-to-date weighted average cost works out to approximately 125% of average tangible book value. In the second quarter of 2021, our Board of Directors approved a new $20 million stock repurchase plan, since we were nearing exhaustion of the plan outstanding at that time. As of September 30, $8.4 million remained available under our repurchase plan. To wrap up, we're happy with how operations performed across the initial 9 months of 2021, along with our financial position at the close of the quarter, and we feel we're in a solid place to keep steering our way through the extraordinary conditions brought about by the coronavirus pandemic as well as other developments. That covers what I had ready to say. At this point I'll hand things back to Bob.
Bob Kaminski
executiveAppreciate that, Chuck. That wraps up what management had ready to say, and at this point we're going to turn things over for questions and answers.
Brendan Nosal
analystPerhaps we could begin with the topic of loan growth. I mean, you folks have somehow found a way to navigate what amounted to a sluggish expansion climate for nearly every other bank really effectively. Even so, the figure for this quarter struck me as remarkably robust. Might you provide a bit more insight into what you're observing among your commercial clientele that permits such powerful credit origination? And after that, perhaps your perspective regarding where the growth rate heads next?
Ray Reitsma
executiveYeah, this is Ray, and I'm glad to speak to that. The outlook for the direction it takes going forward looks quite solid. At present, we have clearly funded at a heavy pace throughout the prior quarter, yet the pipeline we must fund as we enter this quarter is equally robust. So the momentum persists, I would describe it as, without slowing compared with what we logged during the earlier quarter. And it mostly consists of bringing additional relationships onto the roster. Our current clientele is expanding somewhat, though the bulk of the increase stems from onboarding fresh relationships, for the reasons we've laid out across all of our remarks — namely that the relationship banking model and the capacity to provide it despite a difficult climate has simply connected extremely well within the communities we serve. And though that may sound straightforward, it has proven to be the crucial factor, since if you don't receive the service you're after, it feels as though you're searching, and we've been on the receiving end of that repeatedly.
Bob Kaminski
executiveThis genuinely speaks volumes about the people we have here. Even with the difficult circumstances they faced on the job — whether logging in from home under a hybrid arrangement or being on-site — they get how vital it is to answer clients promptly and to keep pushing those fresh relationships across the line, and they put in serious effort toward that; once more, it's something that sets us apart, something clients notice when they stack Mercantile up against competing banks where we operate.
Brendan Nosal
analystOkay, that's really useful context. Perhaps I have one more question. I'm just considering how sensitive your assets are and how the balance sheet is positioned right now for a scenario where rates rise, especially since the makeup of that balance sheet has shifted so much across the last 1.5 years. So given that the Fed and the market appear to be expecting increases in rates possibly sometime in late next year, could you remind us what a single rate increase would do to either NIM or net interest income?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah, this is Chuck. Those particular figures aren't right in front of me, but without a doubt, we would arrange our balance sheet so that it delivers higher net interest income and margin when interest rates are climbing. And regarding those figures — I'm aware they can be found in our Form 10-Q, so would you prefer to pull them up faster yourself, or should I send them your way after the call?
Brendan Nosal
analystYeah. No, that's okay. I was just hoping to get a bit more of your conceptual thinking on it.
Daniel Tamayo
analystI'd like to maybe dig into the allowance a little. You mentioned the COVID factor now baked into that allowance. What portion of it is still there? And if we assume it eventually goes away, where do you see reserves landing over the coming couple of years?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah. As of September 30, the COVID environmental factor makes up roughly 20% to 25% of our reserve balance. And again, this is one of the qualitative items included in the calculation, together with all the others. So we're clearly hopeful we reach a point where we can begin upgrading that environmental and, ideally sooner rather than later, remove it entirely.
Daniel Tamayo
analystAll right. So it's fair to say that, basically — were we to release that figure, it would represent a sensible, I suppose, typical — and that's before factoring in your comment regarding CECL adoption, which could mean a normalized reserve ratio down the road?
Chuck Christmas
executiveCorrect. What I'd say is it definitely lands at a fairly low level, and honestly, that isn't a place where we feel at ease. Yet that's the reality CECL forces upon us. This is partly why we delayed pulling the trigger on adopting it for as long as possible, since the model is duration-based. On top of that, commercial loans make up the bulk of our loan portfolio, and those tend to be short term in nature. The duration on that commercial portfolio likely sits at slightly more than 2 years, which produces a comparatively — it produces a smaller amount of reserves held against our commercial loans than the incurred model would generate. Then, when you combine that with exceptionally clean asset quality, it becomes difficult to maintain reserves at the level you believe they ought to be under CECL.
Daniel Tamayo
analystNo, that's clear. Now shifting topics. What you said about rising overhead tied to bigger salaries because of wage inflation, plus added hiring from your strong loan growth — I get both of those. But how do you see that affecting overall efficiency? Do you still believe revenue growth can outrun it? Or how does it shape your broader view on profitability?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYes. I'll likely have — I know I've got a few more detailed thoughts for you in January, after I get through budget season and can build a longer-term forecast, given where we are right now and what we expect ahead. Near term, what I meant was that we're going to see overhead costs grow more than usual, starting essentially next year, when the pay rates take effect and hiring keeps going. Over the long haul, we certainly expect to benefit from the new employees joining to support that loan growth and fee revenue. As Ray mentioned, we've shown that our revenue is expanding at a quicker pace than our overhead costs. So quarter to quarter, it may be somewhat uneven, but we believe we're set up well to keep growing the way we have and to ensure that revenue expands more quickly than overhead costs do. One more thing I'd mention is technology — and Bob said a few things along these lines in his opening remarks — we've remained, I'd say, state-of-the-art from day 1 of this bank's existence; and we keep doing that — and our platform matches or beats those of the other banks we compete with. More importantly, we keep — we must keep funding that program the whole time, so we're up to date on everything we need; and therefore we have no significant catch-up costs or investments required on the technology front, only the ongoing upgrades and the rollout of new products and services when they come along.
Damon Del Monte
analystSo for my first question, let's talk about fee income. Could you expand a bit on what you're expecting for mortgage banking, and how the pipeline looks to you this early in the fourth quarter?
Ray Reitsma
executiveSure. At this early point in Q4, the pipeline is holding up better than a seasonal pattern would suggest. Normally, volume begins to taper off somewhat around this time of year, yet our trend line hasn't followed that. So the initial signals for the rest of the quarter look fairly good right now. And in the communities we serve, the market is still strong when it comes to purchase activity. We've completed a successful shift away from refi toward purchase activity. I'd say perhaps a bit quicker than our peers. And so I feel fairly good about what this quarter will deliver.
Damon Del Monte
analystAll right, that's great. Now regarding the swap income you recorded during this quarter — clearly extremely robust. Are you expecting some moderation there, with it settling at a somewhat reduced amount? Or would you say expansion in this line of business can be maintained around this roughly $4 million mark?
Ray Reitsma
executiveLike I said in my remarks, I regard that figure as something we can keep up, and there are two reasons why. First, across a really extended stretch, 50% of our term funding has come through fixed rates — that's precisely what the swap delivers for the client, while giving our balance sheet debt that carries floating rate traits; so there's ample room to keep going, though a swap isn't suitable in every case. You require a particular level of size plus customer sophistication and wherewithal to make it all work. That said, our chances in this space don't look like they're shrinking anytime soon; and my expectation is that we stay on a comparable trajectory well into the foreseeable future.
Chuck Christmas
executiveI suppose I'd simply tack on to what Ray said — it's absolutely going to come in unevenly from one quarter to the next, that's just how this program works. Roughly 50% of the revenue we booked in the fourth — sorry, in the third quarter — came from prepayment fees. A few bigger clients refinanced their existing fixed rate debt into floating-rate debt using a swap. Typically, under our program, rather than making the customer pay that prepayment penalty in cash — which we'd book as interest income — we build it into the swap metrics instead, and then the correspondent bank we swap with pays us the fee; what we receive is, I'd call it, an oversight fee, name it whatever you like; so swap income involves 2 separate things. One clearly is activity. The other issue is the extent to which existing fixed rate loans get refinanced — practically all of them carry prepayment penalties that we will collect — and how that all shakes out.
Bob Kaminski
executiveDamon, it's Bob here. I suppose I'll close out on this subject by noting that a swap isn't necessarily a great match for each and every customer. The folks on our lending team have performed quite well at pinpointing those client circumstances where it does work well, where the sophistication exists, and where the characteristics Ray mentioned are in place, so that the customer comes out ahead and can secure what they're seeking in terms of a rate on a term loan, while it also assists us in meeting our balance sheet goals from a banking perspective.
Damon Del Monte
analystUnderstood. That provides useful context. Now I have a single additional inquiry regarding total noninterest income. The remaining noninterest category came in at slightly above $1 million for this quarter, exceeding what we typically see. Chuck, did that include any one-time items?
Chuck Christmas
executiveIndeed, roughly $600,000 of it was one-time. We have at last completed the collection process on a credit we had been pursuing ever since the Great Recession. It ultimately worked its way through the courts, including all appeals, and we received our payment at last. So approximately $600,000 of that amount is non-recurring.
Damon Del Monte
analystAll right, that's helpful. Moving on, I want to touch briefly on how big the securities portfolio has gotten — clearly, it grew a fair amount from one quarter to the next. Should we assume you'll maintain that amount of securities on the balance sheet? Or will loan growth's pace be what determines it? How should we frame that?
Chuck Christmas
executiveSure. The expansion we saw in the third quarter, I'd say, lines up closely with what we experienced across the prior 4 quarters. Around this same point 12 months ago, we began meaningfully building up the portfolio once it became clear to us that the surplus liquidity would remain on the balance sheet for a good while; and even after those securities purchases and the loan growth, we know the excess liquidity has actually grown; so my expectation is that in the fourth quarter, for sure, growth will keep going the way it has through roughly the last 4 quarters. Eventually, that pace will ease off, particularly as commercial loan growth keeps up, and much of that will hinge on how deposits behave, since that is truly what drives the excess liquidity as a whole; the bulk of that money keeps going into government agency bonds, typically in the 3 to 7, 8-year — 3- to 8-year maturity range. Basically, what we've done is stick with the laddered maturity approach and simply extend those ladders; and we absolutely want — down the road, we would very much like to see the securities portfolio build that we've achieved, and nothing would please us more than to take those investments as they come due and direct them into the loan portfolio. From a cash flow perspective, we'll certainly have that chance; loan growth doesn't require it. My sense is rates will likely rise over the coming few years, and at that point we can refinance those funds at better rates. So we view it as a sound way to use that excess liquidity, without getting too aggressive in chasing yield through longer maturities; we haven't purchased any kinds of — any investments different from what we've always built — bought in the past. So we remain disciplined on that front and believe we have a solid program going forward.
Damon Del Monte
analystUnderstood. Alright. Excellent. So, only one last item from me. To return to the topic of the provision and reserve guidance, this quarter's provision came in bigger than we anticipated, exceeding what showed up across the prior several quarters, and it reflected the increase in loans. With the positive sentiment and ongoing growth in loans, ought we to anticipate a provision figure roughly in line with this quarter's?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah. As we mentioned, the bulk of that $1.9 million stemmed from growth in loans, and we didn't adjust any of the environmentals during this quarter, which I believe matters. During the second quarter, we experienced loan growth that required provisioning. The quarter closed with a negative provision, since the shift in the economic environmental outweighed the expansion in our commercial loan portfolio and the resulting provision expense; however, assuming nothing else changes, I'd say that proportionally, future loan growth will necessitate a comparable level of loan provision expense without altering any environmentals.
Bryce Rowe
analystBryce, maybe a quick follow-up on the swap income piece. I was hoping to understand how much prepayment income has hit that line during this year — not only the current quarter, but the full year. Then could you also discuss what additional prepaid-type income might show up in that line going forward? I'm just trying to gauge how much fixed rate activity remains in the portfolio.
Chuck Christmas
executiveYes. Bryce, like I said earlier, budgeting for that was going to be difficult, particularly when looking quarter by quarter, simply because of the nature of what we're handling. Like I mentioned, during Q3 by itself, about 50% of the income was generated by prepayment fees, and that's definitely a bigger proportion than what the $6.1 million figure reflects. So my guess would be that maybe one-third of that $6.1 million on a year-to-date basis relates to collecting prepayment fees, or building them into the swap, and capturing them that way. And I believe Ray mentioned that around half of our portfolio — the commercial loan portfolio by itself — carries a fixed rate; and while our goal isn't to turn all of those into floating rate loans with a swap, there are definitely some chances out there. On this team, I wouldn't say we're sitting around anxious about how elevated rates have climbed, since they remain extremely low. Still, there's no denying we're seeing plenty of inflation pressure, and clearly the current climate — unlike anything we've dealt with before — is driving part of that. Even so, we keep a close eye on the potential hit to our income statement should medium- and longer-term rates move up substantially. That's exactly why we're working through this initiative, along with other efforts, to ensure our balance sheet is set up to hold up well under those conditions. Obviously, there's some discomfort upfront, particularly with refinancing, when we move those higher-rate fixed loans into floating rates. Even so, we believe that kind of safeguard, so to speak, is absolutely the correct move. Bob and Ray both already noted that not everyone can participate in the swap program. Because of that, we don't truly get the chance to convert fixed-rate commercial loans over to floating rates — and honestly, we have no desire to. What we do focus on is the bigger-balance loans, the ones handled by more sophisticated management teams. Obviously, we need to make certain that the people who borrow from us grasp how the swap operates, the mechanics behind it, and then certain restrictions that might be imposed upon them as they go about operating their companies. So there is a great deal of opportunity in that area. That is — up to this point, what we've been discussing relates to loans already on the books. Certainly, when we consider new lending being brought into the bank, along with extra funds borrowed by clients we currently serve, many of those scenarios genuinely satisfy the thresholds we've established concerning deal size and sophistication. Any time a party is seeking an option with a fixed rate, we are most definitely engaging them in a discussion about the swap program. So plenty of chances exist, in the current book of business and through expansion as well. But pinning down what that adds up to across a quarter, or even over a year, that's simply a tough thing to forecast, just because of how the product works.
Bob Kaminski
executiveAs Chuck mentioned, getting a precise read on things is tough. When we consider swaps, that's simply one more instrument available to us in our toolkit as we work to figure out what suits the customer best—what their requirements are—and then build a credit package that is sensible for them and equally sensible on our end. So it's an excellent program. I give the team a lot of credit for getting this program up and running, since it addresses what's needed in the current climate, and it's something that delivers a solid upside for us on the income side. Just as importantly, it places the customer in a position where their needs are met regarding their credit request.
Bryce Rowe
analystGreat. There are a few additional items I'd like to ask about. I'm just wondering what you're observing. Clearly, PPP brings a fair amount of noise and volatility when it comes to yields and NIM. Would you be able to offer some remarks on what you're observing regarding originated yield in the current quarter compared with quarters we've seen recently?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYes, I have the smallest piece of information right here in my mind. What I have is that for us, the PPP program has remained fairly steady this year in terms of how it affects the income statement. And when it comes to overall net interest margin, the fee accretion contributes roughly a 15 basis point beneficial effect. As I said, and I believe I said this during my prepared remarks, I would anticipate the following. Looking at the patterns we're seeing, our expectation is that the bulk of the dollars still remaining will be forgiven, settled here during the fourth quarter; how much control we have over that is very limited, since it depends entirely on our borrowers submitting the applications and the SBA providing the funds, but the patterns appear fairly stable. So I believe we'll see somewhat of a small tail, in my view, as we move into next year; yet largely, we'll wrap up the program here once the year ends.
Bryce Rowe
analystAll right. Then perhaps one final thing for you, Chuck; regarding CECL, does it remain essentially moving ahead with January '22 for that adoption?
Chuck Christmas
executiveYeah. Let me think. Hand me one more extension specifically, though I doubt I'll receive that one. So yeah, January 1, 2022, is when we will switch over to CECL.
Brendan Nosal
analystI’ve got just a single additional question. Regarding the COVID component that remains in the reserve, and also that roughly day-one CECL reserve decrease, I simply want to confirm that presumably there’s a certain amount of overlap between those two figures, correct? In other words, when CECL is adopted, you would be freeing up part of whatever COVID reserve factor is left. Is that the proper way to view it?
Chuck Christmas
executiveI actually regard those as being entirely distinct; the COVID factor does sit inside our CECL model; and moving from incurred to CECL involves a distinct choice about what we truly wish to do regarding that COVID environment. So assuming we held the COVID environmentals constant and had adopted on October 1, we’d have a bit more than $7 million of excess that we would push through capital and complete that CECL adoption. That is how it currently works out. However, adopting CECL and whatever we choose to do with the COVID factor truly are two distinct choices, or two distinct effects.
Bob Kaminski
executiveThanks, Anthony, and I really appreciate everyone taking the time to follow what's happening with our company. We hope that you and your loved ones remain in good health and out of harm's way. We also can't wait to talk with all of you once more when the fourth quarter wraps up, during our conference call in January. That brings this call to a close.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's presentation to a close. We appreciate your participation in this session. You're welcome to leave the call at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Mercantile Bank Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Mercantile Bank Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Mercantile Bank Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.